id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02333v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02333v1 | Why do LLaVA Vision-Language Models Reply to Images in English? | 2024-07-02T15:01:55 | 2024-07-02T15:01:55 | Musashi Hinck, Carolin Holtermann, Matthew Lyle Olson, Florian Schneider, Sungduk Yu, Anahita Bhiwandiwalla, Anne Lauscher, Shaoyen Tseng, Vasudev Lal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | We uncover a surprising multilingual bias occurring in a popular class of
multimodal vision-language models (VLMs). Including an image in the query to a
LLaVA-style VLM significantly increases the likelihood of the model returning
an English response, regardless of the language of the query. This paper
investigates the causes of this loss with a two-pronged approach that combines
extensive ablation of the design space with a mechanistic analysis of the
models' internal representations of image and text inputs. Both approaches
indicate that the issue stems in the language modelling component of the LLaVA
model. Statistically, we find that switching the language backbone for a
bilingual language model has the strongest effect on reducing this error.
Mechanistically, we provide compelling evidence that visual inputs are not
mapped to a similar space as text ones, and that intervening on intermediary
attention layers can reduce this bias. Our findings provide important insights
to researchers and engineers seeking to understand the crossover between
multimodal and multilingual spaces, and contribute to the goal of developing
capable and inclusive VLMs for non-English contexts. | [
-0.421760231256485,
-0.5338862538337708,
0.5078173279762268,
0.253523588180542,
-0.39126214385032654,
-0.005037419963628054,
0.15778599679470062,
-0.8669065833091736,
0.1553330421447754,
0.521774172782898,
-0.6020604372024536,
-0.0335056334733963,
-0.5505983233451843,
0.08576129376888275,
-0.37468957901000977,
0.47149658203125,
-0.39998915791511536,
0.36375895142555237,
-0.5297380089759827,
-0.33561521768569946,
-0.5100175738334656,
-0.5042594075202942,
-0.5128392577171326,
-0.3305155634880066,
0.8519794344902039,
0.10386769473552704,
0.5453348755836487,
0.23554520308971405,
0.5471476316452026,
0.1979980617761612,
0.0774446576833725,
0.29709702730178833,
-0.3627338707447052,
0.11021322757005692,
-0.10787433385848999,
-0.7709643244743347,
-0.06259200721979141,
-0.3695761263370514,
0.5192608833312988,
0.5126502513885498,
0.16204026341438293,
0.21205832064151764,
0.18305212259292603,
0.686215341091156,
-0.741169273853302,
0.20240095257759094,
-0.5268651843070984,
0.022787384688854218,
-0.3903534710407257,
-0.2830630838871002,
-0.642524003982544,
0.4113675057888031,
-0.16046550869941711,
-0.2839958667755127,
-0.12992139160633087,
0.2096329927444458,
1.0624494552612305,
0.22178757190704346,
-0.6476413607597351,
-0.09062205255031586,
-0.6886780858039856,
0.8496073484420776,
-0.38216346502304077,
0.7694401741027832,
0.21862322092056274,
0.2426132708787918,
0.16777527332305908,
-0.119243323802948,
-0.5608106255531311,
-0.1516454964876175,
-0.22638407349586487,
0.24413487315177917,
-0.34918561577796936,
-0.015639927238225937,
-0.025584474205970764,
-0.14159511029720306,
-0.5697671175003052,
0.1478618085384369,
-0.5402713418006897,
-0.25695693492889404,
0.5224924087524414,
0.09070078283548355,
0.3709739148616791,
0.10427328944206238,
-0.23717480897903442,
-0.17489175498485565,
-0.8253390192985535,
0.09730152785778046,
0.41171228885650635,
0.197218120098114,
-0.2305389791727066,
0.8461551666259766,
0.13773152232170105,
0.8313199281692505,
-0.21697062253952026,
-0.3186211585998535,
0.1194644644856453,
-0.2969023287296295,
-0.17831791937351227,
-0.19020868837833405,
0.6092437505722046,
0.9423204660415649,
0.4369010925292969,
0.20631670951843262,
-0.2170792818069458,
0.3230765759944916,
0.05158554017543793,
-0.46028584241867065,
0.11082147806882858,
0.07600251585245132,
-0.3874629735946655,
-0.09864180535078049,
-0.4478079676628113,
-0.5280562043190002,
-0.3929038345813751,
-0.1365865021944046,
0.1558530628681183,
-0.0753365159034729,
-0.22540432214736938,
0.008387677371501923,
-0.09974150359630585,
0.4048228859901428,
0.4317331612110138,
-0.80936598777771,
-0.09004297107458115,
0.05807238817214966,
0.5109003782272339,
-0.13086679577827454,
-0.4750373661518097,
-0.18862472474575043,
0.13072799146175385,
-0.5395383238792419,
1.2050824165344238,
-0.5656302571296692,
-0.3123553395271301,
0.15392301976680756,
0.2313094586133957,
-0.012650624848902225,
-0.398279070854187,
0.10490792989730835,
-0.6088636517524719,
0.3039833903312683,
-0.3224337100982666,
0.10800568014383316,
-0.16420651972293854,
0.2810470759868622,
-0.6130132675170898,
0.7282223701477051,
-0.2911064028739929,
-0.7969836592674255,
0.4410909414291382,
-0.26116272807121277,
-0.3923572897911072,
-0.22375178337097168,
-0.525562047958374,
-0.2241927832365036,
0.43215131759643555,
0.29621434211730957,
0.06090385839343071,
-0.4196377396583557,
-0.03269096836447716,
-0.3196438252925873,
-0.1946815401315689,
0.16178351640701294,
-0.5651234984397888,
0.6974267363548279,
0.20588620007038116,
-0.038465309888124466,
-0.07583434879779816,
-0.5203374624252319,
-0.2232038974761963,
0.5748188495635986,
-0.40317896008491516,
-0.7813100218772888,
0.15646524727344513,
0.355719655752182,
0.3134644031524658,
0.09573475271463394,
-0.5538948178291321,
-0.004414848051965237,
-0.1884482353925705,
0.0269157737493515,
0.6932252049446106,
-0.32682546973228455,
0.6100777983665466,
-0.10538583993911743,
0.5613538026809692,
0.27495935559272766,
0.22502020001411438,
-0.3271048069000244,
-0.5982097387313843,
-0.7521584630012512,
-0.10543911159038544,
-0.1308828741312027,
0.6591672301292419,
-1.127015471458435,
-0.6443662047386169,
-0.08332458883523941,
-0.03375630080699921,
-0.9447466731071472,
0.2595028877258301,
0.48303207755088806,
0.46313172578811646,
0.0399584025144577,
-0.3589133322238922,
-0.5341846346855164,
-1.6313875913619995,
-0.4057430028915405,
-0.32000473141670227,
0.14487381279468536,
0.49684473872184753,
0.28449562191963196,
-0.34906095266342163,
0.5160362124443054,
-0.11745148152112961,
-0.366965651512146,
-0.39404600858688354,
-0.41025909781455994,
0.10916619747877121,
0.00823208037763834,
0.9114412665367126,
-0.8740987181663513,
-0.5238027572631836,
0.28260016441345215,
-0.8333064317703247,
-0.20086044073104858,
-0.2049085944890976,
-0.007048656698316336,
0.4943172335624695,
0.29478415846824646,
-0.5074654221534729,
0.6804957389831543,
0.7503452897071838,
-0.2317335158586502,
0.5095324516296387,
-0.04343090206384659,
0.2965092658996582,
-0.8384729623794556,
-0.32468196749687195,
0.17725197970867157,
-0.09463733434677124,
-0.39164623618125916,
0.3690110743045807,
0.4174223840236664,
0.07554168254137039,
-0.908805251121521,
0.8929060697555542,
-0.7034904956817627,
-0.2963434159755707,
-0.2382020801305771,
0.027475357055664062,
0.5028386116027832,
0.4678739607334137,
-0.017755508422851562,
0.8981397151947021,
0.5601423978805542,
-0.35053926706314087,
0.34947001934051514,
0.262592077255249,
-0.15603967010974884,
0.8034383654594421,
-0.5869264006614685,
-0.06977412849664688,
-0.6087337732315063,
-0.11689624935388565,
-1.3446879386901855,
-0.18607337772846222,
0.2228165715932846,
-0.33707091212272644,
0.5059805512428284,
-0.19474700093269348,
-0.40792226791381836,
-0.4423663318157196,
-0.29857978224754333,
0.6961061954498291,
0.34797266125679016,
-0.6197732090950012,
0.7039713859558105,
0.3318546712398529,
-0.003704115515574813,
-0.6846202611923218,
-1.2896519899368286,
0.31100842356681824,
-0.05679936334490776,
-0.876640260219574,
0.09093428403139114,
0.005216637160629034,
-0.6356344819068909,
0.03608257696032524,
0.04088206589221954,
-0.17797808349132538,
-0.09974870085716248,
-0.11991782486438751,
0.4186849296092987,
-0.2322748452425003,
0.04807901754975319,
0.003806349588558078,
0.25265932083129883,
0.13008436560630798,
-0.1293988972902298,
0.40925857424736023,
0.08894484490156174,
-0.6646724343299866,
-0.3693035840988159,
0.6202355027198792,
0.7775761485099792,
-0.2836436927318573,
0.6807900071144104,
0.08936188369989395,
-0.09340140223503113,
0.02218838594853878,
-0.5040469765663147,
0.022084694355726242,
-0.43076276779174805,
0.7229068279266357,
-0.503602147102356,
-0.48437610268592834,
0.6076313257217407,
0.38226309418678284,
0.20338433980941772,
0.2290053516626358,
0.6577836275100708,
-0.5214272141456604,
1.0202291011810303,
0.7860487699508667,
0.3128361403942108,
0.5218383073806763,
-0.023222796618938446,
0.3114725351333618,
-0.901850163936615,
-0.41014689207077026,
-0.2112351655960083,
-0.25163736939430237,
-0.39501896500587463,
-0.3192690908908844,
0.46157193183898926,
-0.6376627087593079,
0.30189791321754456,
-0.03930855169892311,
-0.22228656709194183,
0.5060765743255615,
0.43682485818862915,
-0.049951814115047455,
0.06652364134788513,
0.5104125738143921,
-0.1927790343761444,
-0.4196150004863739,
-0.6951074600219727,
-0.2202220857143402,
0.9576324224472046,
0.28272825479507446,
1.157152771949768,
0.18885165452957153,
0.370894193649292,
0.006220673210918903,
0.13413134217262268,
-0.7122899889945984,
0.5044841766357422,
-0.17666034400463104,
-0.6358221173286438,
0.05456216260790825,
0.11903499811887741,
-1.0242469310760498,
0.6274778842926025,
-0.1422373503446579,
-0.4331521689891815,
0.1399695724248886,
0.34398576617240906,
0.23575516045093536,
0.36153092980384827,
-0.746076762676239,
0.4741870164871216,
-0.5793617367744446,
-0.9927464723587036,
-0.116961769759655,
-0.28560635447502136,
0.5538288950920105,
-0.13380661606788635,
0.742365837097168,
0.18980157375335693,
0.02378164790570736,
0.2602718472480774,
-0.09952609986066818,
0.9906396269798279,
0.01365105900913477,
-0.4635598659515381,
0.15725767612457275,
0.21141576766967773,
0.3739505410194397,
-0.22850002348423004,
0.2888340950012207,
0.300828754901886,
-0.36486172676086426,
-0.6228268146514893,
-0.3974188566207886,
0.4807996153831482,
-0.6886757016181946,
-0.8264011144638062,
-0.21869252622127533,
-0.5908291339874268,
-0.215224027633667,
0.05014076456427574,
0.37084174156188965,
0.4765114188194275,
0.12106836587190628,
0.050034549087285995,
0.6284195184707642,
-0.529941976070404,
0.5000277161598206,
0.308514803647995,
-0.5731840133666992,
0.014369006268680096,
0.47949546575546265,
0.2209470570087433,
0.39389029145240784,
0.35679399967193604,
-0.17214630544185638,
-0.37995171546936035,
-0.38552263379096985,
-0.7411805391311646,
0.5199629664421082,
-1.0511066913604736,
0.07198234647512436,
-0.4606758654117584,
0.01770799048244953,
-0.3941800594329834,
-0.1601693034172058,
-0.4046967923641205,
-0.1685793101787567,
-0.14890232682228088,
-0.06277428567409515,
0.05245330184698105,
0.7017020583152771,
0.307925820350647,
0.14426977932453156,
-0.49694815278053284,
0.3104766607284546,
0.3416324853897095,
0.314543217420578,
-0.04447634145617485,
-0.7120102643966675,
-0.18408209085464478,
0.05649546906352043,
-0.14599795639514923,
-1.1390074491500854,
0.4634736478328705,
0.26143893599510193,
0.6707860827445984,
0.07084774971008301,
-0.35812824964523315,
0.6291820406913757,
-0.7679979801177979,
0.8044783473014832,
0.20372900366783142,
-0.26721060276031494,
0.528582751750946,
-0.2090756893157959,
0.593073308467865,
-0.0132380910217762,
0.13683289289474487,
-0.49734655022621155,
-0.5653472542762756,
-0.10940824449062347,
-1.0051428079605103,
0.25364020466804504,
-0.10222597420215607,
0.39930832386016846,
-0.08075782656669617,
-0.06544622778892517,
0.07657814025878906,
0.09786088019609451,
-1.1536436080932617,
-0.2240370512008667,
-0.169671431183815,
-0.07616453617811203,
0.0971059650182724,
-0.5633141994476318,
-0.18154309689998627,
0.022694837301969528,
0.4710395634174347,
-0.16557708382606506,
0.24957402050495148,
0.2790313959121704,
-0.5110939145088196,
-0.1281602829694748,
0.1746014952659607,
0.8323741555213928,
0.5641430020332336,
0.23278628289699554,
0.27477601170539856,
0.06616587936878204,
-0.2917650043964386,
0.11840306222438812,
-0.38199615478515625,
-0.39996808767318726,
0.32181546092033386,
0.5519580245018005,
0.9493964910507202,
0.1801825314760208,
-0.6949038505554199,
0.39294275641441345,
-0.16751629114151,
-0.2628841996192932,
-0.2271476686000824,
-0.4836307764053345,
0.08038724958896637,
0.20613107085227966,
0.5883066654205322,
0.25795596837997437,
0.08490537852048874,
-0.4874725639820099,
-0.13699473440647125,
0.746932864189148,
-0.15803128480911255,
-0.41775086522102356,
0.8462710380554199,
0.21186251938343048,
-0.15481425821781158,
0.2514060139656067,
0.21419574320316315,
-0.25896766781806946,
0.624315619468689,
0.5779355764389038,
0.7815834283828735,
-0.05302593111991882,
0.14680369198322296,
0.17310002446174622,
0.7525752782821655,
0.2862384021282196,
0.30757609009742737,
0.2891184091567993,
-0.7400046586990356,
-0.4837122857570648,
-0.4611037075519562,
-0.14116805791854858,
-0.028040654957294464,
-0.3612782061100006,
0.2556631863117218,
-0.21824294328689575,
-0.07608775794506073,
-0.11591875553131104,
-0.7021540999412537,
-0.8995336294174194,
0.20208239555358887,
0.6454623937606812,
0.7515043616294861,
-1.0887526273727417,
0.7283953428268433,
1.1277992725372314,
-0.3678281307220459,
-0.4979652464389801,
-0.2896467447280884,
0.16091084480285645,
-1.2479976415634155,
0.9314001798629761,
0.046657495200634,
-0.20336730778217316,
-0.4136943221092224,
-0.5055092573165894,
-0.9063969254493713,
0.5832792520523071,
0.553979218006134,
-0.5956389904022217,
0.005752164404839277,
0.23276807367801666,
0.45330166816711426,
-0.46376779675483704,
0.16400156915187836,
0.0943247452378273,
0.3922808766365051,
0.09393485635519028,
-1.1439557075500488,
-0.25160446763038635,
-0.4003349840641022,
0.28246915340423584,
0.10570802539587021,
-0.7289015650749207,
0.8445257544517517,
-0.42165011167526245,
-0.17977558076381683,
-0.38402798771858215,
0.41636231541633606,
0.25024858117103577,
0.39081498980522156,
0.2648424506187439,
0.296132355928421,
0.27079537510871887,
0.013472521677613258,
1.4320762157440186,
-0.09240177273750305,
-0.0807022973895073,
0.6462444067001343,
-0.42391958832740784,
0.8064773082733154,
1.251794457435608,
-0.2320575714111328,
0.4449048936367035,
0.6846476197242737,
0.15600401163101196,
0.8096895217895508,
-0.19204191863536835,
-0.022177567705512047,
-0.08158990740776062,
-0.301817387342453,
-0.2062923014163971,
0.4705375134944916,
0.23086017370224,
-0.33037787675857544,
-0.21387845277786255,
0.3637411892414093,
-0.12608782947063446,
0.06551031023263931,
-0.3766762316226959,
0.5118106603622437,
-0.0036872492637485266,
-0.4753701090812683,
0.7568880915641785,
-0.35198864340782166,
0.746928870677948,
-0.42012402415275574,
0.07273556292057037,
-0.5937192440032959,
0.01827235147356987,
-0.20830367505550385,
-0.8509349822998047,
0.36276042461395264,
-0.20531795918941498,
-0.25784003734588623,
-0.3538837134838104,
0.6948381066322327,
-0.5329217314720154,
-0.7305903434753418,
0.6236357688903809,
0.5572943091392517,
0.1650453358888626,
0.33899059891700745,
-0.6445415019989014,
0.4259415864944458,
0.25881510972976685,
-0.3819151818752289,
0.3372299075126648,
0.22365111112594604,
-0.5421733260154724,
0.6857511401176453,
0.3833742141723633,
0.12623876333236694,
0.1827068030834198,
0.1488964706659317,
0.7734920382499695,
-0.3065944314002991,
-0.23789449036121368,
-0.8475234508514404,
0.7751057744026184,
0.04314707592129707,
0.022191349416971207,
0.6483663320541382,
0.36034879088401794,
0.975905179977417,
-0.4030073583126068,
0.9396033883094788,
0.2877974212169647,
-0.053791727870702744,
-0.7038396000862122,
0.46258267760276794,
-1.1960914134979248,
0.35625138878822327,
-0.09285509586334229,
-0.9809026122093201,
-0.34252291917800903,
0.47948241233825684,
-0.056976594030857086,
-0.1324034184217453,
0.6799412965774536,
0.6374064087867737,
-0.025328010320663452,
-0.7529003024101257,
0.7448281049728394,
0.2813762426376343,
0.3651259243488312,
0.6204265356063843,
0.9192051291465759,
-0.4613167643547058,
0.5839739441871643,
-0.003844281192868948,
-0.2349672019481659,
-0.2882978022098541,
-0.8022891879081726,
-0.8542417287826538,
-0.5084275603294373,
-0.14158427715301514,
-0.14628595113754272,
0.15246349573135376,
0.36034446954727173,
0.36406880617141724,
-0.45117270946502686,
-0.28143972158432007,
0.461031436920166,
0.0581883005797863,
0.19981257617473602,
-0.13645122945308685,
-0.1191026046872139,
-0.04844304174184799,
-0.668478786945343,
0.2172989845275879,
0.6203024387359619,
0.3324981927871704,
-0.4528293013572693,
0.09218407422304153,
-0.16017940640449524,
0.20674672722816467,
0.6345303058624268,
0.2804003655910492,
-1.1670401096343994,
-0.12994788587093353,
0.5102919936180115,
-0.2439601570367813,
0.1280238926410675,
0.22497206926345825,
-0.5877799391746521,
0.5707124471664429,
0.31189432740211487,
0.5553063154220581,
0.44820207357406616,
-0.5938897728919983,
0.6650370359420776,
-0.8733364343643188,
0.8854806423187256,
-0.17862950265407562,
0.73613041639328,
0.6320155262947083,
-0.3765334486961365,
0.400592178106308,
0.2849986255168915,
-0.16779009997844696,
-0.8480839133262634,
0.5145456790924072,
-0.6939650177955627,
-0.39241477847099304,
1.1777980327606201,
0.2953683137893677,
-0.737705647945404,
0.13972820341587067,
-0.6131160855293274,
-0.3710121214389801,
-0.018447818234562874,
0.6960693597793579,
1.004037857055664,
-0.029140742495656013,
-0.7117051482200623,
-0.7877712845802307,
0.04738898202776909,
0.6415090560913086,
-0.3950771987438202,
-0.02580813504755497,
0.6934360861778259,
0.10345803946256638,
0.2281651645898819,
0.7408621907234192,
-0.08180098980665207,
0.540536642074585,
-0.07493287324905396,
0.33003196120262146,
0.19467705488204956,
-0.3709777593612671,
-0.26404693722724915,
-0.029782066121697426,
0.2895655333995819,
-0.13562244176864624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02328v1 | Efficient Sparse Attention needs Adaptive Token Release | 2024-07-02T14:58:44 | 2024-07-02T14:58:44 | Chaoran Zhang, Lixin Zou, Dan Luo, Min Tang, Xiangyang Luo, Zihao Li, Chenliang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable
capabilities across a wide array of text-centric tasks. However, their `large'
scale introduces significant computational and storage challenges, particularly
in managing the key-value states of the transformer, which limits their wider
applicability. Therefore, we propose to adaptively release resources from
caches and rebuild the necessary key-value states. Particularly, we accomplish
this by a lightweight controller module to approximate an ideal top-$K$ sparse
attention. This module retains the tokens with the highest top-$K$ attention
weights and simultaneously rebuilds the discarded but necessary tokens, which
may become essential for future decoding. Comprehensive experiments in natural
language generation and modeling reveal that our method is not only competitive
with full attention in terms of performance but also achieves a significant
throughput improvement of up to 221.8%. The code for replication is available
on the https://github.com/WHUIR/ADORE. | [
-0.2063911408185959,
-0.6976151466369629,
0.2887856662273407,
0.4649946093559265,
-0.228359654545784,
-0.03284996375441551,
-0.5846236944198608,
-0.24346183240413666,
0.39536356925964355,
0.43024134635925293,
-0.4779614210128784,
-0.06664946675300598,
-0.7422310709953308,
0.04554126039147377,
-0.557735800743103,
1.0141775608062744,
0.013610977679491043,
-0.3842373788356781,
-0.06280390918254852,
-0.31214919686317444,
-0.669448733329773,
-0.2585909068584442,
-0.8453409671783447,
-0.01386774517595768,
0.7727426886558533,
0.4243616759777069,
0.6973981857299805,
0.8917362093925476,
0.5886073708534241,
0.3713358938694,
-0.4534093141555786,
0.15970493853092194,
-0.8199474215507507,
0.08742954581975937,
-0.23898600041866302,
-0.33709716796875,
-0.7944725155830383,
-0.3033888041973114,
0.667097270488739,
0.7041454315185547,
-0.21370111405849457,
0.28015851974487305,
0.16825290024280548,
0.6629053354263306,
-0.868015468120575,
0.01832863874733448,
-1.0180002450942993,
-0.09297412633895874,
0.07800539582967758,
-0.1768852025270462,
-0.5975478887557983,
-0.10928696393966675,
-0.035478923469781876,
-0.8768253922462463,
0.16185754537582397,
0.041979119181632996,
0.5947305560112,
0.6921266317367554,
-0.24220329523086548,
-0.025680674239993095,
-0.5946414470672607,
0.8850563764572144,
-0.4737204313278198,
0.3804175555706024,
0.2163929045200348,
0.048886340111494064,
-0.2180001139640808,
-0.768111526966095,
-0.31354522705078125,
-0.03625944256782532,
-0.029952844604849815,
0.05641061067581177,
-0.3588322401046753,
0.02433743141591549,
0.16153885424137115,
0.32346034049987793,
-0.20998698472976685,
-0.0754418894648552,
-0.23480866849422455,
-0.315103143453598,
0.2609870433807373,
0.28948068618774414,
0.14920686185359955,
-0.129415363073349,
-0.2179522067308426,
0.06052768602967262,
-0.6476128697395325,
-0.34204235672950745,
0.0908067375421524,
0.36461037397384644,
-0.10091577470302582,
0.5005568265914917,
-0.07808661460876465,
0.5567930936813354,
0.4684261977672577,
0.028445502743124962,
0.11640112102031708,
-0.42312973737716675,
-0.3479059040546417,
0.08792231976985931,
0.4731456935405731,
0.30200785398483276,
0.0817624181509018,
-0.568681538105011,
-0.2981690764427185,
-0.012597019784152508,
0.6913805603981018,
-0.5932812094688416,
-0.04376455768942833,
0.44020336866378784,
-0.3606323301792145,
-0.2157052755355835,
-0.4159788191318512,
-0.8443690538406372,
-0.3056831955909729,
-0.3137454390525818,
0.49552619457244873,
-0.27615097165107727,
-0.20967037975788116,
0.1417548656463623,
0.07460086792707443,
0.09914083778858185,
0.445051908493042,
-1.261728286743164,
0.44449669122695923,
0.5480369329452515,
1.0404741764068604,
-0.4713951647281647,
-0.0825066864490509,
-0.8261256814002991,
0.4184708297252655,
-0.3215123414993286,
0.6638367176055908,
-0.20720943808555603,
-0.09111782163381577,
-0.1436975598335266,
-0.01848718337714672,
-0.24203190207481384,
-0.7212924957275391,
0.47116684913635254,
-0.6604338884353638,
-0.2841584384441376,
-0.32104262709617615,
-0.10912171006202698,
0.3390953242778778,
0.2670474648475647,
-0.858234703540802,
1.066070318222046,
0.2135515660047531,
-0.8369794487953186,
0.1470271199941635,
-0.5987958908081055,
-0.45900675654411316,
-0.01058326568454504,
0.37612074613571167,
-0.3137088716030121,
0.274458110332489,
0.2484806627035141,
0.3533517122268677,
-0.07770059257745743,
0.23672036826610565,
-0.013727140612900257,
-0.5201277732849121,
0.2686166763305664,
-0.5047723650932312,
0.4303233027458191,
0.34554624557495117,
-0.3960106074810028,
0.3833703398704529,
-0.8331059217453003,
-0.243554949760437,
0.10723917931318283,
-0.5487272143363953,
-0.03849242627620697,
-0.04908989742398262,
0.4847430884838104,
-0.23367123305797577,
0.4864532947540283,
-0.44284936785697937,
0.28928065299987793,
-0.6012821197509766,
0.6832956075668335,
0.8976613879203796,
0.0761277824640274,
0.7142003178596497,
-0.17961439490318298,
0.4140440821647644,
0.1296001821756363,
0.17719948291778564,
-0.30402180552482605,
0.043391015380620956,
-1.0907886028289795,
-0.6227260828018188,
0.3456633687019348,
0.2503492832183838,
-0.6263406872749329,
0.4770662486553192,
-0.4060722887516022,
-0.1420847773551941,
-0.7429983019828796,
0.3315054476261139,
0.3492918014526367,
0.2886126637458801,
0.3788256049156189,
-0.09576552361249924,
-0.3106458783149719,
-0.7397006154060364,
-0.1333005279302597,
0.09756609797477722,
0.09040463715791702,
0.4419685900211334,
0.2501744031906128,
-0.31632962822914124,
0.8730769753456116,
-0.6263286471366882,
-0.44591447710990906,
-0.3921442925930023,
-0.014027619734406471,
-0.038295600563287735,
0.5072950720787048,
0.39322546124458313,
-0.631515622138977,
-0.2973470687866211,
0.028993280604481697,
-0.13548551499843597,
-0.0425497330725193,
-0.33200523257255554,
-0.45119190216064453,
0.30736249685287476,
0.45659634470939636,
-0.8190624117851257,
0.14154383540153503,
0.40334033966064453,
-0.12252429872751236,
0.22456856071949005,
-0.3266620337963104,
-0.06078633293509483,
-1.233954668045044,
0.5256677269935608,
-0.1516643464565277,
-0.33246931433677673,
-0.4603295922279358,
0.13451308012008667,
0.09440236538648605,
-0.12823088467121124,
-0.438231498003006,
0.665297269821167,
-0.553071916103363,
-0.16717027127742767,
-0.39007288217544556,
0.3143576979637146,
-0.08205756545066833,
0.7646398544311523,
-0.2904054820537567,
0.7183393836021423,
0.4106263220310211,
-0.5232483744621277,
0.4722839593887329,
0.19213305413722992,
-0.10605118423700333,
0.12128963321447372,
-0.71484375,
0.08906526118516922,
-0.3036171495914459,
0.08619290590286255,
-1.2437666654586792,
-0.5880807042121887,
0.2879889905452728,
-0.34058254957199097,
0.7977056503295898,
-0.005179702304303646,
-0.5252869725227356,
-0.20878225564956665,
-0.3889249563217163,
0.4223211705684662,
0.33442357182502747,
-0.4948713481426239,
0.6341027617454529,
0.5392659306526184,
-0.2753182649612427,
-0.5561185479164124,
-0.8320871591567993,
0.23110809922218323,
-0.029352063313126564,
-0.0827760398387909,
0.06572447717189789,
-0.034272462129592896,
-0.10871966928243637,
0.3203650414943695,
-0.2608097195625305,
-0.014677424915134907,
0.2349892407655716,
-0.10939589887857437,
0.01435709185898304,
-0.09705063700675964,
0.21226195991039276,
0.08610344678163528,
-0.4474548399448395,
-0.18760798871517181,
-0.35990452766418457,
0.37511077523231506,
0.1875392347574234,
-0.21054843068122864,
-0.3628157079219818,
0.37529006600379944,
1.0366568565368652,
-0.27743685245513916,
0.6380776762962341,
0.4493364095687866,
-0.5714198350906372,
-0.26079699397087097,
-0.609137237071991,
-0.1747031956911087,
-0.49255162477493286,
0.6773681044578552,
-0.063033826649189,
-0.9401599764823914,
0.5922240018844604,
0.13218311965465546,
0.1785195767879486,
0.37331411242485046,
0.8193507194519043,
0.23778894543647766,
1.0751322507858276,
0.838485598564148,
-0.4629899561405182,
0.5663559436798096,
-0.18562063574790955,
0.2021796703338623,
-0.8342939615249634,
-0.026205236092209816,
-0.44765833020210266,
-0.5143557786941528,
-0.21539157629013062,
-0.4699772298336029,
0.3018805980682373,
0.006225271616131067,
-0.038101259618997574,
0.29423823952674866,
-0.770310640335083,
0.41055721044540405,
0.25863054394721985,
0.07585656642913818,
0.2306002378463745,
-0.05266938358545303,
-0.025652213022112846,
-0.18983124196529388,
-0.8621904850006104,
-0.2606934905052185,
0.850487232208252,
0.23317520320415497,
0.969547688961029,
0.0822986513376236,
0.3420964479446411,
0.11878201365470886,
0.5199930667877197,
-1.0331635475158691,
0.4200246334075928,
-0.15227827429771423,
-0.35948434472084045,
-0.38649338483810425,
-0.612195611000061,
-0.8598998785018921,
0.17448683083057404,
0.08275937288999557,
-0.8644340634346008,
-0.07724009454250336,
0.4654071629047394,
-0.6955156326293945,
0.1470029354095459,
-0.813140869140625,
1.043239712715149,
0.1099199503660202,
-0.4984586834907532,
-0.3518838584423065,
-0.5661709904670715,
0.3669888973236084,
-0.23575973510742188,
0.02822278067469597,
0.13197772204875946,
-0.4744808077812195,
0.5514721274375916,
-0.2969032824039459,
0.9789940118789673,
-0.055239591747522354,
-0.26736703515052795,
0.3308848440647125,
0.09675848484039307,
0.7423243522644043,
-0.11066509783267975,
0.11588386446237564,
-0.4087395966053009,
-0.25679102540016174,
-0.49687379598617554,
-0.6269332766532898,
0.8997848033905029,
-0.7876282930374146,
-0.4587123990058899,
-0.16778859496116638,
-0.8244494199752808,
-0.17105679214000702,
0.1275348961353302,
0.011748245917260647,
0.6975056529045105,
-0.09217927604913712,
0.22272376716136932,
0.9930269718170166,
-0.20249126851558685,
0.6062358617782593,
0.2583104968070984,
0.19091761112213135,
-0.6589851379394531,
0.994423508644104,
0.24572156369686127,
0.3425232768058777,
0.5750922560691833,
0.013564517721533775,
-0.192744180560112,
-0.5844488739967346,
-0.5808953046798706,
0.16717694699764252,
-0.5100171566009521,
-0.5601414442062378,
-0.9843810200691223,
-0.10333173722028732,
-0.36411505937576294,
-0.3290708065032959,
-0.6030817031860352,
-0.4738306701183319,
-0.4339301288127899,
-0.03259837627410889,
0.6931951642036438,
0.7091898918151855,
0.02814985252916813,
0.5343218445777893,
-0.7685939073562622,
0.5238590240478516,
0.21774692833423615,
0.459753155708313,
0.4725903570652008,
-0.7158323526382446,
-0.5616931915283203,
-0.15850314497947693,
-0.2215910255908966,
-0.5435490608215332,
0.3991870582103729,
0.2010955512523651,
0.45962241291999817,
0.20910285413265228,
-0.027443701401352882,
0.8274708390235901,
-0.625858724117279,
0.6467463374137878,
0.10295496881008148,
-0.9947509765625,
0.4118844270706177,
-0.5145867466926575,
0.7316321134567261,
0.5297074317932129,
0.05115867778658867,
-0.5860920548439026,
-0.8543310165405273,
-0.34434422850608826,
-1.262263298034668,
1.06692636013031,
0.07020779699087143,
0.425031840801239,
-0.2753874361515045,
0.5773601531982422,
-0.26402536034584045,
0.17804738879203796,
-0.5305461883544922,
-0.13230299949645996,
-0.09436427056789398,
-0.6965212225914001,
0.0715079978108406,
-0.5341988801956177,
0.0026262355968356133,
-0.009353533387184143,
0.6473504900932312,
-0.4471573829650879,
0.283640593290329,
0.14709120988845825,
-0.26463383436203003,
-0.5080741047859192,
0.22211351990699768,
0.6289168000221252,
0.5356491804122925,
-0.09023018926382065,
0.290558397769928,
0.24354863166809082,
-0.8189603686332703,
0.10033001750707626,
-0.08002505451440811,
-0.20772816240787506,
-0.376873254776001,
0.2966245114803314,
0.5757969617843628,
0.9545148015022278,
-0.8458289504051208,
0.5839682221412659,
-0.08016334474086761,
-0.03629448637366295,
0.3444235622882843,
-0.07657552510499954,
0.23885184526443481,
0.009943148121237755,
0.48822730779647827,
0.26322025060653687,
-0.019988881424069405,
-0.3092286288738251,
0.4400806128978729,
0.20479805767536163,
-0.43087300658226013,
-0.4508460760116577,
1.0302503108978271,
0.39995113015174866,
0.16861587762832642,
0.24210351705551147,
-0.08120711892843246,
-0.49653518199920654,
0.49623551964759827,
0.5643360614776611,
0.9850898385047913,
0.06150178611278534,
-0.020223289728164673,
0.478760302066803,
0.4266214370727539,
-0.12672363221645355,
0.18109595775604248,
-0.20276421308517456,
-0.5142413377761841,
-0.8546563386917114,
-0.7936962842941284,
-0.10048709809780121,
0.0006446929764933884,
-0.5396361351013184,
-0.03597798943519592,
-0.5778391361236572,
-0.1594482809305191,
-0.24312807619571686,
0.0719643160700798,
-0.19062010943889618,
-0.0265798456966877,
-0.07549287378787994,
0.9679856896400452,
-0.6366776823997498,
0.603156566619873,
0.5994045734405518,
-0.17686888575553894,
-0.586840033531189,
0.06896208971738815,
-0.14736242592334747,
-0.4987451732158661,
0.4700652062892914,
-0.03931548073887825,
-0.09692060947418213,
0.4006322920322418,
-0.4374505281448364,
-1.2291369438171387,
0.9671494364738464,
0.6841146349906921,
-0.6515716314315796,
0.14193350076675415,
-0.22037485241889954,
0.5578508377075195,
-0.017694802954792976,
0.0006061437306925654,
0.4040400981903076,
0.3689650893211365,
0.2515081465244293,
-0.9630820155143738,
0.06411835551261902,
-0.07323163747787476,
0.09427915513515472,
0.4391023814678192,
-1.1747939586639404,
0.45669978857040405,
-0.4439164400100708,
-0.29830437898635864,
0.32341817021369934,
0.8218094706535339,
-0.007915020920336246,
-0.37593019008636475,
0.5000845789909363,
0.8523248434066772,
0.6096436977386475,
0.03975088149309158,
0.8757463097572327,
-0.4429413080215454,
0.34528642892837524,
0.9585384130477905,
-0.2681902050971985,
0.8988553285598755,
0.6452736854553223,
0.08591566979885101,
-0.23895953595638275,
0.3268175423145294,
0.3083004653453827,
0.8203081488609314,
0.15056273341178894,
-0.25059857964515686,
-0.18929454684257507,
-0.3688729703426361,
0.06641183793544769,
0.2878303527832031,
0.17101213335990906,
-0.06423499435186386,
-0.22608429193496704,
0.06796490401029587,
-0.0051661524921655655,
0.034400660544633865,
-0.6955420970916748,
0.9832990169525146,
-0.013760223053395748,
-0.7129161953926086,
0.5958443284034729,
0.06261803209781647,
0.5232919454574585,
-0.5689877271652222,
0.005475585348904133,
-0.2534072995185852,
0.5799046754837036,
-0.05325982719659805,
-0.30533620715141296,
0.41000139713287354,
0.37788593769073486,
-0.3617956340312958,
-0.44911885261535645,
0.7850120663642883,
-0.7058772444725037,
-0.4038969576358795,
0.2579975128173828,
0.2181210219860077,
-0.22776880860328674,
0.1728450357913971,
-0.3982149660587311,
0.6100786328315735,
-0.025886891409754753,
-0.4469209909439087,
0.4378789961338043,
0.4967166781425476,
0.14098361134529114,
0.7071612477302551,
0.4301098585128784,
0.2439030557870865,
0.485649973154068,
0.03820863366127014,
1.2687700986862183,
-0.46177926659584045,
-0.3727392852306366,
-0.6710306406021118,
0.6160284280776978,
0.22450946271419525,
-0.29512032866477966,
0.5823949575424194,
0.5947692394256592,
0.4265247881412506,
-0.03711533173918724,
0.6253880858421326,
-0.05784352868795395,
0.3239244222640991,
-0.4230169653892517,
0.7430877685546875,
-0.6030120253562927,
-0.010052577592432499,
-0.1378200203180313,
-0.8551301956176758,
-0.3619818091392517,
0.38599905371665955,
0.2638835608959198,
-0.19941899180412292,
0.4841850697994232,
0.7675870656967163,
-0.2703913450241089,
-0.39331886172294617,
0.3460697829723358,
0.5566373467445374,
0.033349476754665375,
0.857837438583374,
0.5172231197357178,
-0.5793299078941345,
0.8514695167541504,
0.03364555537700653,
-0.35418999195098877,
-0.2539900839328766,
-0.7596637010574341,
-0.6166607737541199,
-0.2738322615623474,
-0.37055060267448425,
-0.047208186239004135,
0.08018354326486588,
0.9743514060974121,
0.5492262840270996,
-0.9034854173660278,
0.1385890245437622,
-0.004064300563186407,
0.08993683755397797,
-0.2054966241121292,
-0.2517816126346588,
0.47426238656044006,
-0.8593155741691589,
-0.8431236147880554,
0.21833299100399017,
0.6096500754356384,
-0.06965864449739456,
-0.4144551753997803,
0.05011295899748802,
-0.03441913425922394,
0.08296509832143784,
0.5677590370178223,
0.11823511868715286,
-0.6264839768409729,
-0.5301154851913452,
0.16418366134166718,
-0.4951916038990021,
-0.0753309577703476,
0.8991285562515259,
-0.6077564358711243,
0.4147632122039795,
0.4913937449455261,
1.1969672441482544,
0.3559090793132782,
-0.01040130015462637,
0.46989279985427856,
-1.0240600109100342,
0.4093315601348877,
0.19181862473487854,
0.4040284752845764,
0.36307352781295776,
-0.5052975416183472,
0.22700707614421844,
0.29998448491096497,
-0.4368259310722351,
-0.9963245391845703,
-0.01509794220328331,
-1.268378734588623,
0.010283686220645905,
1.2191118001937866,
-0.007671257480978966,
-0.642742931842804,
0.019673582166433334,
-0.4325454831123352,
0.23795126378536224,
-0.45166832208633423,
0.7257671356201172,
0.5958699584007263,
0.385698139667511,
-0.19506683945655823,
-0.41567540168762207,
0.39336803555488586,
0.4044803977012634,
-0.5340400338172913,
0.8493521809577942,
0.46492165327072144,
0.1555798500776291,
0.2563175559043884,
0.8381815552711487,
-0.15010854601860046,
0.3078943192958832,
0.007481071632355452,
0.05730915442109108,
0.12845005095005035,
-0.527388334274292,
-0.43220797181129456,
0.18174605071544647,
0.07283500581979752,
-0.053663454949855804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02320v1 | Exploring the Role of Transliteration in In-Context Learning for Low-resource Languages Written in Non-Latin Scripts | 2024-07-02T14:51:20 | 2024-07-02T14:51:20 | Chunlan Ma, Yihong Liu, Haotian Ye, Hinrich Schütze | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Decoder-only large language models (LLMs) excel in high-resource languages
across various tasks through few-shot or even zero-shot in-context learning
(ICL). However, their performance often does not transfer well to low-resource
languages, especially those written in non-Latin scripts. Inspired by recent
work that leverages transliteration in encoder-only models, we investigate
whether transliteration is also effective in improving LLMs' performance for
low-resource languages written in non-Latin scripts. To this end, we propose
three prompt templates, where the target-language text is represented in (1)
its original script, (2) Latin script, or (3) both. We apply these methods to
several representative LLMs of different sizes on various tasks including text
classification and sequential labeling. Our findings show that the
effectiveness of transliteration varies by task type and model size. For
instance, all models benefit from transliterations for sequential labeling
(with increases of up to 25%). | [
0.2762855887413025,
-0.19843994081020355,
0.5886778235435486,
0.03267146274447441,
-0.31573817133903503,
0.23858855664730072,
-0.5644659996032715,
-0.2603181302547455,
0.0766986533999443,
0.25540977716445923,
-0.39910581707954407,
-0.5556883215904236,
-0.546500027179718,
0.7303720712661743,
-0.1270926296710968,
0.7422485947608948,
-0.15559473633766174,
0.3917316794395447,
-0.13614237308502197,
-0.10966868698596954,
-0.44705304503440857,
-0.27565109729766846,
-0.6439964771270752,
-0.275909960269928,
0.9066925048828125,
0.7824677228927612,
0.2336263358592987,
0.8338014483451843,
0.47002145648002625,
0.2123989760875702,
0.07557129114866257,
0.07622789591550827,
-0.510753870010376,
0.43218523263931274,
-0.19475916028022766,
-0.5821517109870911,
0.21239900588989258,
-0.0872325599193573,
0.9421918392181396,
0.7236009836196899,
0.05209397152066231,
0.36759069561958313,
0.18035447597503662,
0.3991113603115082,
-0.7061439156532288,
0.3180680572986603,
-0.6824588775634766,
0.0021472941152751446,
-0.37689271569252014,
-0.4595800042152405,
-0.8400290608406067,
-0.23876260221004486,
0.03763439133763313,
-0.5663204193115234,
0.06530137360095978,
0.38510823249816895,
0.25314807891845703,
0.2968566119670868,
-0.20937591791152954,
-0.36404022574424744,
-0.7058587074279785,
1.1554808616638184,
-0.435664564371109,
0.26681795716285706,
0.2751331925392151,
0.32255029678344727,
0.04232364147901535,
-0.38430508971214294,
-0.20497798919677734,
-0.08457330614328384,
-0.24461224675178528,
-0.17449434101581573,
-0.2062419205904007,
0.07859776169061661,
0.614767849445343,
0.17011569440364838,
-0.4225371479988098,
0.5315507054328918,
-0.2581973075866699,
-0.32681840658187866,
-0.00787276029586792,
0.12841100990772247,
0.46530553698539734,
-0.3461204171180725,
-0.23531636595726013,
-0.08801241964101791,
-1.2066372632980347,
0.11333708465099335,
0.10992280393838882,
0.9514488577842712,
-0.23224447667598724,
0.41772210597991943,
0.1673145443201065,
0.8420858383178711,
0.2017827332019806,
-0.7170372605323792,
0.051907170563936234,
-0.2808625102043152,
-0.23359891772270203,
0.31446465849876404,
0.5464631915092468,
-0.09059419482946396,
-0.06967992335557938,
-0.4366154074668884,
-0.30973169207572937,
-0.37149256467819214,
-0.035650014877319336,
-0.9286564588546753,
0.2651122808456421,
-0.20622558891773224,
-0.599121630191803,
0.1426764577627182,
-0.23503068089485168,
-0.507136344909668,
-0.5447083115577698,
-0.17216596007347107,
0.42810335755348206,
-0.5555851459503174,
0.09616170078516006,
-0.15442514419555664,
-0.17939625680446625,
0.44158968329429626,
0.5862712860107422,
-0.9092158675193787,
0.058935798704624176,
0.3546537160873413,
1.0032986402511597,
-0.06905177235603333,
-0.14476153254508972,
-1.0784558057785034,
0.03844990208745003,
-0.33479270339012146,
0.7268503904342651,
-0.7675966024398804,
-0.3619503378868103,
0.3603976368904114,
-0.00981205329298973,
-0.2871342897415161,
-0.5863120555877686,
0.5240075588226318,
-0.4792163670063019,
-0.04243657365441322,
-0.7203906178474426,
-0.40701010823249817,
-0.11001384258270264,
0.02622850425541401,
-0.6393014192581177,
0.8436653017997742,
0.3751128911972046,
-0.7340662479400635,
0.3295198380947113,
-0.5246171951293945,
-0.7269696593284607,
0.3087419867515564,
-0.17800410091876984,
0.13778765499591827,
0.3415762484073639,
-0.09784868359565735,
0.3356427848339081,
-0.7189414501190186,
-0.16846920549869537,
0.23008137941360474,
-0.8747955560684204,
0.1480454057455063,
-0.4481492340564728,
0.6337445378303528,
0.28203362226486206,
-0.362349271774292,
-0.007033392786979675,
-0.6333727836608887,
-0.06199898198246956,
-0.03286904841661453,
-0.6449477672576904,
-0.2756039798259735,
-0.23940804600715637,
0.17600397765636444,
0.31308916211128235,
0.18046718835830688,
-0.6599062085151672,
0.2769034206867218,
-0.334272176027298,
0.3337704837322235,
0.6666829586029053,
-0.3084474503993988,
0.9084761142730713,
-0.3722139298915863,
0.8491640090942383,
0.0629098042845726,
-0.4251095652580261,
-0.609209418296814,
-0.11950735002756119,
-0.7957860231399536,
-0.6742658615112305,
0.4138305187225342,
0.3013099431991577,
-1.2694077491760254,
-0.11124905198812485,
-0.34024637937545776,
-0.3469032645225525,
-0.6402619481086731,
0.23240484297275543,
0.6013227105140686,
0.85243821144104,
0.35629743337631226,
-0.12033701688051224,
-0.5531840920448303,
-0.7544429302215576,
-0.3512030243873596,
-0.2999511659145355,
-0.014189829118549824,
0.30312663316726685,
0.3404485881328583,
0.03806579113006592,
0.6308631896972656,
0.08723648637533188,
-0.23802019655704498,
-0.8041499257087708,
0.11775358766317368,
0.24656584858894348,
0.2701263725757599,
0.4798465967178345,
-0.3211020827293396,
-1.0434826612472534,
-0.18400758504867554,
-0.46538886427879333,
-0.2344033271074295,
-0.1623034030199051,
0.1078244000673294,
0.342074453830719,
0.45420318841934204,
-0.4336012899875641,
0.05732179060578346,
0.35095030069351196,
0.15334059298038483,
0.44517725706100464,
-0.30585846304893494,
0.11172367632389069,
-0.9823954105377197,
0.22416789829730988,
0.12826387584209442,
-0.24934546649456024,
-0.7513619065284729,
-0.10787971317768097,
0.26128530502319336,
-0.19949497282505035,
-0.825920820236206,
0.9189562797546387,
-0.6147617697715759,
-0.18947073817253113,
-0.27663883566856384,
0.004100691061466932,
-0.15607671439647675,
0.31833964586257935,
0.24924571812152863,
1.1068683862686157,
0.7713465690612793,
-0.4397432208061218,
-0.06770449876785278,
0.04153482988476753,
-0.729512095451355,
0.5064405202865601,
-0.3062010705471039,
0.03958828002214432,
-0.3867754340171814,
0.5416542291641235,
-0.8995286822319031,
-0.24348010122776031,
0.33350870013237,
-0.13887867331504822,
0.6102754473686218,
-0.49050506949424744,
-1.0092277526855469,
0.13074086606502533,
-0.21453942358493805,
0.6568647027015686,
0.7324736714363098,
-0.7362521886825562,
0.4081173837184906,
-0.12626859545707703,
0.0914638563990593,
-0.5859542489051819,
-0.6006281971931458,
-0.06864038109779358,
-0.3927980363368988,
-0.26767978072166443,
0.3355216681957245,
-0.08469957858324051,
-0.3433743417263031,
-0.43102535605430603,
0.012225586920976639,
0.09599050134420395,
-0.06058911234140396,
0.2152804583311081,
0.15354222059249878,
-0.2901303470134735,
0.19228719174861908,
-0.15179035067558289,
-0.05374046787619591,
-0.4137671887874603,
-0.5405294299125671,
0.4755310118198395,
0.17964136600494385,
-0.2896069586277008,
-0.694319486618042,
0.41820985078811646,
0.5956193804740906,
-0.11963850259780884,
1.0792211294174194,
0.5127484798431396,
-0.24165624380111694,
-0.27090319991111755,
-0.33335888385772705,
-0.13903242349624634,
-0.46862202882766724,
0.06847776472568512,
-0.2582939863204956,
-0.8788203597068787,
0.5367122292518616,
-0.11227548122406006,
0.08625676482915878,
0.3027210235595703,
0.5402522087097168,
-0.27023664116859436,
0.5894628167152405,
0.8172861337661743,
-0.05172860249876976,
0.8406998515129089,
-0.16609328985214233,
0.2707711160182953,
-0.9084327816963196,
-0.027634385973215103,
-0.714611291885376,
-0.4602208733558655,
-0.6462109088897705,
-0.6445012092590332,
0.3690290153026581,
-0.1707766056060791,
-0.22999201714992523,
0.4624923765659332,
-0.04775979742407799,
0.6539920568466187,
0.6039282083511353,
-0.21593518555164337,
0.15626193583011627,
0.40259137749671936,
-0.212153822183609,
-0.2999963164329529,
-0.9313978552818298,
-0.4470136761665344,
0.9335278272628784,
0.1092754602432251,
0.9173192977905273,
0.039568379521369934,
0.9527257680892944,
0.09612922370433807,
0.28905439376831055,
-0.9704096913337708,
0.40271055698394775,
-0.2724042534828186,
-0.4376196265220642,
-0.12464474886655807,
-0.47219210863113403,
-0.9472977519035339,
0.3499707877635956,
0.06997346132993698,
-0.6477231979370117,
0.12486632168292999,
-0.04996344819664955,
-0.5384966731071472,
0.31292885541915894,
-0.4670376777648926,
0.6924295425415039,
0.06236933544278145,
-0.3314971923828125,
0.01825125515460968,
-0.5789884328842163,
-0.04194518178701401,
-0.12870734930038452,
0.18707498908042908,
0.1361876130104065,
-0.0892389789223671,
0.6336045265197754,
-0.11665339022874832,
0.8940362930297852,
-0.1056571826338768,
-0.07584419846534729,
0.45042505860328674,
0.2984524369239807,
0.6702874898910522,
-0.23067325353622437,
-0.3042583465576172,
0.11282408237457275,
-0.2817547619342804,
-0.33950144052505493,
-0.46215978264808655,
0.5703004598617554,
-0.6146315336227417,
-0.6106778383255005,
-0.59539794921875,
-0.642733097076416,
-0.09803906083106995,
0.17284546792507172,
0.4898439645767212,
0.7005434632301331,
0.08385241031646729,
0.27900320291519165,
0.7535820603370667,
-0.47137561440467834,
0.5617660880088806,
0.8807694911956787,
0.2785602807998657,
-0.06396179646253586,
0.8858779072761536,
0.18437260389328003,
0.29877907037734985,
0.7493416666984558,
-0.11138815432786942,
-0.2630336284637451,
-0.4642420709133148,
-0.6650531888008118,
0.5024037957191467,
-0.9982256889343262,
-0.5249437689781189,
-0.39986905455589294,
-0.08748406916856766,
-0.24826554954051971,
-0.46502068638801575,
-0.17101703584194183,
-0.30575430393218994,
-0.5402234196662903,
-0.043005309998989105,
0.10204077512025833,
0.4444870352745056,
-0.0832396149635315,
0.5073146820068359,
-0.6953750252723694,
-0.08697785437107086,
-0.11734281480312347,
0.09398941695690155,
0.14519286155700684,
-0.8858149647712708,
-0.5482808351516724,
-0.17616496980190277,
-0.13370013236999512,
-0.717546284198761,
0.4444277286529541,
0.13612696528434753,
0.39432212710380554,
0.28346532583236694,
0.030119745060801506,
0.6938239932060242,
-0.8741052150726318,
0.6850142478942871,
0.30241167545318604,
-0.7114723920822144,
0.231402188539505,
-0.31099632382392883,
0.560779869556427,
0.5280036330223083,
0.3201964199542999,
-0.8749097585678101,
-0.257342129945755,
-0.15596552193164825,
-0.5628333687782288,
1.2385629415512085,
0.03361784294247627,
0.270711213350296,
-0.30299848318099976,
0.3438904881477356,
0.41441139578819275,
0.10945320874452591,
-0.7099050283432007,
-0.24721193313598633,
0.23805199563503265,
-0.3318444490432739,
-0.1451461762189865,
-0.33457469940185547,
0.10847985744476318,
0.054183200001716614,
0.4928126335144043,
-0.29106295108795166,
0.21321097016334534,
-0.00655117304995656,
-0.579227864742279,
-0.4895721971988678,
0.4949440360069275,
0.4269273579120636,
0.41151484847068787,
-0.0035119005478918552,
0.22523386776447296,
0.06252157688140869,
-0.05800184607505798,
0.35014015436172485,
-0.22920693457126617,
-0.39876529574394226,
0.0908491462469101,
0.6162900328636169,
0.7153953909873962,
0.6889508962631226,
-0.7506715655326843,
0.3952246904373169,
-0.15819762647151947,
0.3625527322292328,
-0.060990218073129654,
-0.019371679052710533,
-0.16107165813446045,
0.17894579470157623,
0.504440188407898,
0.03739344701170921,
-0.023746373131871223,
-0.6674514412879944,
-0.22234082221984863,
0.4424285888671875,
-0.3287922441959381,
-0.47972381114959717,
0.36572858691215515,
0.20579111576080322,
-0.23412492871284485,
0.7491172552108765,
-0.22602330148220062,
-0.275399774312973,
0.5222760438919067,
0.9868689775466919,
0.8446606397628784,
-0.1692371517419815,
0.436139315366745,
0.7295853495597839,
0.2675192058086395,
-0.26290175318717957,
0.05655774474143982,
-0.32727354764938354,
-0.4140178859233856,
-0.4470871388912201,
-0.87356036901474,
-0.44386157393455505,
-0.03584662079811096,
-0.4997163712978363,
0.3704890012741089,
-0.42570507526397705,
0.014899280853569508,
-0.20150822401046753,
-0.06566578894853592,
-0.9196768999099731,
-0.12277819216251373,
0.2647940516471863,
0.955762505531311,
-0.7057939171791077,
0.8424057364463806,
0.6226709485054016,
-0.33830496668815613,
-0.5672481060028076,
0.1925383359193802,
0.028913207352161407,
-0.7179186344146729,
1.2089358568191528,
0.48181894421577454,
-0.29300108551979065,
0.0683336853981018,
-0.31148770451545715,
-1.169569492340088,
1.1077234745025635,
0.8172056674957275,
-0.4216262102127075,
-0.17700323462486267,
0.15368753671646118,
0.5219363570213318,
-0.5471292734146118,
0.3533600866794586,
0.18707622587680817,
0.3350875675678253,
0.2411879599094391,
-0.9757568836212158,
0.014168046414852142,
0.20326583087444305,
0.22470037639141083,
-0.04439037665724754,
-0.6471994519233704,
0.797671377658844,
-0.3497699797153473,
-0.7240104675292969,
0.2477056384086609,
0.6729997992515564,
0.09879748523235321,
-0.11427202820777893,
0.2030874490737915,
0.08407564461231232,
0.6799697279930115,
0.03914373740553856,
1.1782487630844116,
-0.3680941164493561,
-0.01411801390349865,
0.9732251763343811,
-0.3094598054885864,
0.6638146638870239,
0.5349041223526001,
0.10654760152101517,
0.6315958499908447,
0.7338763475418091,
0.2778605818748474,
0.6646215915679932,
0.1201220452785492,
-0.26248857378959656,
-0.3259824216365814,
-0.5332269072532654,
0.02222277969121933,
0.40857160091400146,
0.07710065692663193,
-0.5468197464942932,
-0.4830954670906067,
0.07367824018001556,
0.06688091903924942,
-0.11043013632297516,
-0.4613998234272003,
0.6421307921409607,
0.17776969075202942,
-0.7337692975997925,
0.6709361672401428,
0.3396332859992981,
0.6608445048332214,
-0.6265384554862976,
0.06452656537294388,
-0.2926258146762848,
-0.029859432950615883,
0.03321995213627815,
-0.3014623522758484,
-0.05163009837269783,
0.3794846534729004,
-0.452112078666687,
-0.579742968082428,
0.5245272517204285,
-0.626518189907074,
-0.42290014028549194,
0.22233416140079498,
0.4755077660083771,
0.27574777603149414,
0.259889155626297,
-0.3797157108783722,
0.09610044211149216,
-0.13811467587947845,
0.16183055937290192,
0.7420274615287781,
0.33096522092819214,
0.052108071744441986,
0.5383185744285583,
0.37013885378837585,
0.08724764734506607,
-0.004829870071262121,
0.05223329737782478,
0.568926990032196,
-0.4973486065864563,
-0.27798524498939514,
-0.9060360193252563,
0.37739846110343933,
0.3666805922985077,
0.036199405789375305,
1.0157780647277832,
0.553190290927887,
0.777484655380249,
-0.27370840311050415,
0.7553389668464661,
0.07232976704835892,
0.29157692193984985,
-0.5400587320327759,
0.4004609286785126,
-0.653095006942749,
0.12784698605537415,
-0.028541862964630127,
-0.9759461879730225,
-0.2817695438861847,
0.5799914598464966,
-0.2497072070837021,
-0.08672302961349487,
0.8307480216026306,
0.5446857213973999,
0.02056749165058136,
-0.3253783881664276,
0.5293632745742798,
-0.08181823790073395,
0.10374504327774048,
0.5974149107933044,
0.7032966613769531,
-0.31341034173965454,
0.48788461089134216,
-0.0743599459528923,
-0.09010583162307739,
-0.3408202826976776,
-0.7189317345619202,
-1.0103777647018433,
-0.6205632090568542,
-0.23355460166931152,
-0.24269698560237885,
-0.1818191111087799,
1.2511804103851318,
0.4555492699146271,
-0.5494881272315979,
-0.40294671058654785,
0.4770098626613617,
0.266446053981781,
-0.03818289190530777,
-0.11649151891469955,
0.29790306091308594,
-0.7228527069091797,
-1.015537977218628,
0.7421022057533264,
0.530495285987854,
-0.018381677567958832,
-0.18859374523162842,
-0.07145035266876221,
0.1546531319618225,
0.15587358176708221,
0.5733790993690491,
0.3704437017440796,
-0.7562461495399475,
-0.14730004966259003,
0.17872121930122375,
-0.4391747713088989,
0.2983502447605133,
1.0862334966659546,
-0.7398465871810913,
0.49157536029815674,
0.46978700160980225,
0.47668880224227905,
0.07023759931325912,
-0.134004145860672,
0.4455890953540802,
-0.9266998767852783,
0.23311826586723328,
0.13333791494369507,
0.5312843322753906,
0.7285078167915344,
-0.317861944437027,
0.12577708065509796,
0.013663439080119133,
-0.22582970559597015,
-0.8638297319412231,
0.31900447607040405,
-0.49798548221588135,
0.00793240312486887,
1.56016206741333,
-0.25735384225845337,
-0.39418745040893555,
0.12293470650911331,
-0.07682019472122192,
0.1892218440771103,
-0.5503883361816406,
0.5506212711334229,
0.7570870518684387,
0.01868344657123089,
-0.013268856331706047,
-0.22496981918811798,
0.664280891418457,
0.11819079518318176,
-0.37972137331962585,
0.27865132689476013,
0.5350233316421509,
0.47655579447746277,
0.0654182881116867,
0.8346794843673706,
-0.09101130813360214,
0.25975775718688965,
-0.19670164585113525,
-0.2726474702358246,
0.09087171405553818,
-0.5742741227149963,
-0.598527193069458,
-0.16542868316173553,
0.22983136773109436,
0.16258686780929565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02317v1 | Soft Language Prompts for Language Transfer | 2024-07-02T14:50:03 | 2024-07-02T14:50:03 | Ivan Vykopal, Simon Ostermann, Marián Šimko | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cross-lingual knowledge transfer, especially between high- and low-resource
languages, remains a challenge in natural language processing (NLP). This study
offers insights for improving cross-lingual NLP applications through the
combination of parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods. We systematically
explore strategies for enhancing this cross-lingual transfer through the
incorporation of language-specific and task-specific adapters and soft prompts.
We present a detailed investigation of various combinations of these methods,
exploring their efficiency across six languages, focusing on three low-resource
languages, including the to our knowledge first use of soft language prompts.
Our findings demonstrate that in contrast to claims of previous work, a
combination of language and task adapters does not always work best; instead,
combining a soft language prompt with a task adapter outperforms other
configurations in many cases. | [
-0.46285107731819153,
-0.5716604590415955,
0.3761487901210785,
0.4321978986263275,
-0.08914171904325485,
0.07786639034748077,
-0.7030120491981506,
-0.39472517371177673,
-0.06854967027902603,
0.29219850897789,
-0.5625338554382324,
-0.17967841029167175,
-0.3765610456466675,
0.40588369965553284,
0.13957232236862183,
1.1344648599624634,
-0.06525681912899017,
-0.2797543704509735,
0.23910686373710632,
-0.4154934585094452,
-0.9259343147277832,
-0.1336442232131958,
-0.8152327537536621,
-0.22669149935245514,
0.6884788870811462,
0.7022360563278198,
0.8183807134628296,
0.06460612267255783,
0.274842232465744,
0.276253879070282,
-0.0688076838850975,
0.40075376629829407,
-0.3860360383987427,
0.06378534436225891,
-0.863007664680481,
-0.5013990998268127,
-0.055250126868486404,
-0.381008505821228,
0.5452111959457397,
1.0743484497070312,
0.22140100598335266,
0.05581272393465042,
0.38267937302589417,
0.7353131175041199,
-0.6847780346870422,
0.08688762784004211,
-0.5980320572853088,
0.16126739978790283,
-0.1412404477596283,
-0.4214582145214081,
-0.26236680150032043,
-0.2861807644367218,
0.23718293011188507,
-0.7966523766517639,
0.07182759046554565,
0.03956427052617073,
0.54156494140625,
0.20857059955596924,
-0.33257412910461426,
-0.40874549746513367,
-0.7034606337547302,
1.0354523658752441,
-0.4705342650413513,
0.5215684175491333,
0.190133735537529,
0.2495901882648468,
-0.10818283259868622,
-0.5560770630836487,
-0.38813671469688416,
-0.052792739123106,
-0.31811174750328064,
-0.306476891040802,
-0.26982879638671875,
0.04621761664748192,
0.15257249772548676,
0.02781068906188011,
-0.4804714024066925,
0.27291762828826904,
-0.3212626874446869,
-0.29946181178092957,
0.37735360860824585,
0.07420552521944046,
0.6706523299217224,
-0.0939507856965065,
-0.14166349172592163,
-0.022624598816037178,
-0.6511940956115723,
0.33211851119995117,
0.10130494832992554,
0.9645431041717529,
-0.08274805545806885,
0.3805563449859619,
-0.33498334884643555,
1.0761138200759888,
0.3138982057571411,
-0.19936472177505493,
-0.057608019560575485,
-0.7149164080619812,
0.11176890134811401,
0.11911079287528992,
0.558462381362915,
0.4714635908603668,
0.41912180185317993,
-0.5101208090782166,
-0.20807458460330963,
-0.3106643557548523,
-0.06551691889762878,
-0.6326029300689697,
0.11652031540870667,
-0.151201993227005,
-0.37296488881111145,
0.12020646035671234,
-0.48757147789001465,
-0.8418357968330383,
-0.4709930717945099,
-0.5003421306610107,
0.33307191729545593,
-0.4584605097770691,
-0.24802429974079132,
0.24449674785137177,
-0.31940069794654846,
0.2879977226257324,
0.43626701831817627,
-1.3734683990478516,
0.4026796221733093,
0.6863314509391785,
0.848822832107544,
-0.35404783487319946,
-0.3342219293117523,
-0.9027993083000183,
0.12980571389198303,
-0.21007144451141357,
0.949927031993866,
-0.6185407638549805,
-0.19264358282089233,
0.32967180013656616,
0.22043639421463013,
-0.35911327600479126,
-0.5676919221878052,
0.4784441292285919,
-0.1906781941652298,
0.4211532771587372,
-0.6737291216850281,
-0.06566618382930756,
-0.2126481980085373,
0.11214271187782288,
-0.5967963337898254,
0.9513429403305054,
0.413041353225708,
-0.4487120807170868,
0.4416652321815491,
-0.7117024064064026,
-0.9376625418663025,
0.17610883712768555,
0.08239315450191498,
0.4545312225818634,
0.203423410654068,
0.29756981134414673,
0.4710077941417694,
-0.3340749144554138,
0.031182583421468735,
0.1905195713043213,
-0.39633259177207947,
-0.029829302802681923,
-0.3167131841182709,
0.8272316455841064,
0.1879526823759079,
-0.46241945028305054,
0.003284293692559004,
-0.6685872673988342,
0.04685145989060402,
-0.12743237614631653,
-0.5457946062088013,
-0.6523523330688477,
-0.5486173629760742,
0.313239723443985,
0.3071582317352295,
0.37978366017341614,
-0.14094224572181702,
0.28582069277763367,
-0.4606662690639496,
0.2513939142227173,
0.5005576014518738,
-0.3181796669960022,
0.8157171607017517,
-0.31495946645736694,
0.6272591948509216,
-0.05861452966928482,
-0.08917517960071564,
-0.09870747476816177,
-0.4841693043708801,
-0.5795016884803772,
0.1457800716161728,
0.3076435625553131,
0.8545833826065063,
-1.2875869274139404,
0.08188345283269882,
-0.06830299645662308,
-0.3039228916168213,
-0.6005321741104126,
0.8071244955062866,
0.41489213705062866,
0.4733833968639374,
0.40637776255607605,
-0.14159204065799713,
-0.27668052911758423,
-0.8174273371696472,
-0.740634560585022,
-0.06515617668628693,
-0.025651507079601288,
0.2835412919521332,
-0.0676928237080574,
0.049185436218976974,
0.772545576095581,
-0.1075751781463623,
-0.23405523598194122,
-0.663615345954895,
0.27863848209381104,
0.43985888361930847,
0.49076396226882935,
1.0275650024414062,
-0.7348482012748718,
-0.8035451173782349,
0.20447254180908203,
-0.31806567311286926,
-0.40441498160362244,
-0.29696935415267944,
-0.09950508177280426,
0.3949774205684662,
0.5014727711677551,
-0.37243038415908813,
-0.12595193088054657,
0.6939996480941772,
-0.671329140663147,
0.3676069378852844,
-0.35142454504966736,
0.2788836359977722,
-0.7203788757324219,
0.04789549484848976,
0.0816383808851242,
-0.1983909159898758,
-0.917855441570282,
-0.06932584941387177,
-0.18540945649147034,
0.10504704713821411,
-0.8224208354949951,
0.8975111246109009,
-0.5532498359680176,
0.2278190702199936,
-0.31342369318008423,
0.1902862936258316,
0.08074689656496048,
0.637144923210144,
-0.020090574398636818,
0.9305564165115356,
0.6201553344726562,
-0.6633602380752563,
0.27528008818626404,
0.1300521194934845,
-0.10847819596529007,
0.9304699301719666,
-0.5916522741317749,
0.2599720358848572,
-0.04132666811347008,
-0.24696391820907593,
-0.8994263410568237,
0.2616960108280182,
0.2644338011741638,
0.09936013072729111,
0.439635694026947,
-0.3077791929244995,
-0.4327489137649536,
0.13376384973526,
-0.39933502674102783,
0.5983070135116577,
0.38364410400390625,
-0.5450605154037476,
0.7215918302536011,
0.08069054037332535,
-0.5625869035720825,
-0.35619670152664185,
-0.7514170408248901,
0.18700993061065674,
-0.2224305123090744,
-0.6942387819290161,
0.3633654713630676,
-0.09723037481307983,
-0.2665843963623047,
-0.00989664625376463,
0.12903477251529694,
-0.02382958121597767,
-0.008493168279528618,
-0.13800713419914246,
0.07225413620471954,
-0.5316298007965088,
-0.13896392285823822,
0.2822457551956177,
-0.2595538794994354,
-0.24864202737808228,
-0.3447219133377075,
0.366168737411499,
-0.33521604537963867,
-0.12856824696063995,
-0.3004717230796814,
0.5847721695899963,
0.4216631054878235,
0.07045523077249527,
0.7652863264083862,
0.9689001441001892,
-0.23419468104839325,
-0.2267046719789505,
-0.5039834976196289,
-0.042032159864902496,
-0.5312709212303162,
0.14546306431293488,
-0.5000154376029968,
-0.9683529138565063,
0.49922046065330505,
-0.3883839249610901,
0.2209751009941101,
0.19706369936466217,
0.5184942483901978,
0.3289284408092499,
1.045615315437317,
0.9094619154930115,
-0.07333946228027344,
0.766324520111084,
0.20423901081085205,
0.24966292083263397,
-0.6448694467544556,
0.12237561494112015,
-0.7042633295059204,
-0.4946293830871582,
-0.7117779850959778,
-0.45104774832725525,
0.12690916657447815,
0.15832270681858063,
0.10416294634342194,
0.5421204566955566,
-0.2776390314102173,
0.4378947615623474,
0.8245082497596741,
-0.1762087196111679,
0.32188907265663147,
-0.003292806912213564,
-0.12187203019857407,
-0.13288664817810059,
-1.1573039293289185,
-0.26994436979293823,
0.5373338460922241,
0.06405613571405411,
0.6742759943008423,
0.188690185546875,
0.3864142894744873,
0.025816097855567932,
-0.10790356993675232,
-0.847612738609314,
0.5890074372291565,
-0.7233783602714539,
-0.39614370465278625,
-0.34105607867240906,
-0.24073225259780884,
-1.178601622581482,
0.1847619265317917,
-0.2803943455219269,
-0.8377201557159424,
0.46908271312713623,
0.038317352533340454,
-0.5708587765693665,
0.098884716629982,
-0.9902396202087402,
0.9211891293525696,
-0.25617703795433044,
-0.603140115737915,
-0.15385501086711884,
-0.43191006779670715,
-0.054871805012226105,
-0.024796290323138237,
0.36133816838264465,
-0.09186609089374542,
-0.2618424594402313,
0.7679599523544312,
-0.12882143259048462,
0.8410176634788513,
-0.3057052493095398,
-0.4032992422580719,
0.1532454788684845,
0.22398652136325836,
0.5174581408500671,
-0.040243033319711685,
-0.17377838492393494,
0.00537759019061923,
-0.009652066975831985,
-0.4001002311706543,
-0.8666141629219055,
0.7139064073562622,
-0.47635820508003235,
-0.500312328338623,
-0.058863069862127304,
-0.9234269261360168,
-0.5213806629180908,
0.4221545159816742,
-0.03328896686434746,
0.48176056146621704,
0.09624099731445312,
0.03278251737356186,
0.621992826461792,
-0.520574688911438,
0.5137019753456116,
0.7973968386650085,
0.026056639850139618,
-0.05268729850649834,
1.022402286529541,
0.15054693818092346,
0.33658498525619507,
0.40258485078811646,
0.3897796869277954,
-0.1424850970506668,
-0.5539184212684631,
-0.7694708704948425,
0.19668257236480713,
-0.7104911804199219,
-0.20337344706058502,
-0.3439829349517822,
0.10749954730272293,
-0.5635025501251221,
-0.6073477864265442,
-0.21042616665363312,
-0.6097155213356018,
-0.26829418540000916,
0.19573073089122772,
0.4816943109035492,
0.415532648563385,
-0.19190333783626556,
0.2581659257411957,
-1.0944442749023438,
0.6812483072280884,
0.41672685742378235,
0.44325247406959534,
-0.4050239324569702,
-0.4491199851036072,
-0.2733007073402405,
-0.04395757615566254,
0.3116392195224762,
-0.7079333662986755,
0.18150272965431213,
0.4723563492298126,
0.6917554140090942,
0.1650753617286682,
0.25315457582473755,
0.5994179844856262,
-0.4826456904411316,
0.8695084452629089,
0.24533849954605103,
-0.9022120833396912,
0.5842695236206055,
-0.3797732889652252,
0.60219806432724,
0.9365348219871521,
0.37786373496055603,
-0.7675063610076904,
-0.317384272813797,
-0.16327442228794098,
-1.0403249263763428,
0.9125242233276367,
-0.1211242750287056,
0.3295629024505615,
0.290311723947525,
0.23158793151378632,
0.4099828004837036,
-0.09448140114545822,
-0.35120558738708496,
-0.2186025083065033,
0.0908721461892128,
-0.299029141664505,
0.07002045214176178,
0.057310551404953,
-0.16889487206935883,
-0.34609976410865784,
0.4100757837295532,
-0.6425742506980896,
-0.11977969110012054,
0.011132587678730488,
-0.36405250430107117,
-0.3864465355873108,
0.5336760878562927,
0.42700013518333435,
0.6681413054466248,
0.17536304891109467,
0.2510741949081421,
0.6443459987640381,
-0.4412326216697693,
-0.03271227329969406,
0.20472003519535065,
-0.31081798672676086,
0.1932201087474823,
0.4024141728878021,
0.9122183918952942,
0.715684175491333,
-0.6695789694786072,
0.18858805298805237,
-0.21279439330101013,
0.0024759077932685614,
0.43827322125434875,
0.4115505814552307,
-0.0990573912858963,
0.3279707133769989,
0.22708292305469513,
0.08546298742294312,
0.25308728218078613,
-0.7413448095321655,
-0.09064560383558273,
0.4438748061656952,
-0.3923588991165161,
-0.40555328130722046,
0.369454026222229,
0.4078660011291504,
-0.46570879220962524,
0.2487390786409378,
-0.1414356380701065,
-0.5496212840080261,
0.12199173867702484,
0.6284953951835632,
0.7391955852508545,
-0.19505135715007782,
0.24970780313014984,
0.10544712841510773,
0.2672480046749115,
0.02874436229467392,
0.4484216570854187,
-0.2890832722187042,
-0.556236743927002,
-0.660883367061615,
-0.5180890560150146,
-0.4622836410999298,
-0.18395020067691803,
-0.4676310122013092,
0.47177162766456604,
-0.22545358538627625,
0.0465485118329525,
0.016404375433921814,
0.23671001195907593,
-1.0343306064605713,
-0.1482926607131958,
0.2514294385910034,
1.0786892175674438,
-0.8818369507789612,
0.6114242672920227,
1.044325828552246,
-0.09631311893463135,
-0.8110491633415222,
-0.1652885377407074,
-0.16967028379440308,
-0.9429744482040405,
0.5836827754974365,
-0.1415124088525772,
-0.30694568157196045,
-0.03555622696876526,
-0.15528972446918488,
-0.5607527494430542,
0.624993085861206,
0.5510389804840088,
-0.5735968351364136,
-0.0525984950363636,
0.4844669699668884,
0.44185909628868103,
0.03680039942264557,
0.13131600618362427,
0.8754081130027771,
0.9082822799682617,
-0.099663645029068,
-1.3347288370132446,
0.6027498245239258,
-0.23068156838417053,
-0.005959658417850733,
0.17421329021453857,
-0.47121182084083557,
0.49361616373062134,
-0.2133892923593521,
-0.15207326412200928,
-0.20359958708286285,
0.6662795543670654,
0.059573329985141754,
0.3564744293689728,
0.9377835392951965,
-0.022480566054582596,
0.671572744846344,
0.054583992809057236,
0.712455689907074,
-0.5533195734024048,
-0.16425922513008118,
0.7638462781906128,
-0.20177090167999268,
0.5812482833862305,
0.8711920380592346,
-0.07536771148443222,
0.6142073273658752,
0.09725634008646011,
0.29292431473731995,
0.5547757148742676,
-0.07432108372449875,
-0.24528059363365173,
-0.13481645286083221,
-0.5988541841506958,
-0.2796977460384369,
0.2162751853466034,
0.5712891221046448,
0.001331852632574737,
-0.42977461218833923,
0.2925227880477905,
-0.06164043769240379,
-0.055012427270412445,
-0.39537811279296875,
0.9769551157951355,
0.12545965611934662,
-1.0720757246017456,
0.7124430537223816,
0.004205093719065189,
1.1955909729003906,
-0.6515132784843445,
-0.15241871774196625,
-0.2430730164051056,
0.06117706000804901,
-0.2803383469581604,
-0.9901629090309143,
0.4607810378074646,
0.03251691162586212,
0.008273681625723839,
-0.8381498456001282,
1.192987084388733,
-0.6178232431411743,
-0.26387539505958557,
0.343609094619751,
0.7727555632591248,
-0.04015986993908882,
-0.05619140714406967,
-0.7205452919006348,
-0.23095768690109253,
-0.11555498093366623,
-0.23209166526794434,
0.5783786773681641,
0.9454050660133362,
-0.032368361949920654,
0.3002401292324066,
0.7841677069664001,
0.29021409153938293,
0.07175345718860626,
0.3782420754432678,
0.9023209810256958,
-0.7019128799438477,
-0.49924492835998535,
-0.5591009855270386,
0.45342883467674255,
0.2617405951023102,
-0.4696735739707947,
0.7376649975776672,
0.17828965187072754,
0.6959912180900574,
0.025420965626835823,
0.7479569315910339,
-0.20779356360435486,
0.3243623673915863,
-0.671782910823822,
0.4482000768184662,
-0.6015332937240601,
0.16560512781143188,
-0.2875458002090454,
-0.7531876564025879,
-0.20785261690616608,
0.46140775084495544,
-0.26393991708755493,
-0.10911485552787781,
0.6318381428718567,
0.6646676063537598,
-0.14990197122097015,
0.03610747680068016,
0.20406195521354675,
-0.058323949575424194,
0.14711233973503113,
0.8173817992210388,
0.6424480676651001,
-0.18656668066978455,
0.7266018986701965,
-0.5685586929321289,
-0.18156538903713226,
-0.4036426544189453,
-1.046245813369751,
-0.8525793552398682,
-0.616645097732544,
-0.34522032737731934,
-0.37902936339378357,
0.28251275420188904,
0.9470521807670593,
0.6657204031944275,
-0.9784563779830933,
-0.25731244683265686,
0.11633867770433426,
0.40089669823646545,
-0.4863148331642151,
-0.27537670731544495,
0.17840993404388428,
-0.8241866230964661,
-0.790797770023346,
0.6095287799835205,
0.20620402693748474,
-0.1685921847820282,
-0.2996065020561218,
-0.04662168025970459,
-0.10537515580654144,
-0.07003408670425415,
0.7937132120132446,
0.5396333336830139,
-0.3284050226211548,
-0.308954119682312,
0.18784672021865845,
-0.09209880232810974,
-0.17205409705638885,
1.186484694480896,
-0.9234930276870728,
0.03702254593372345,
0.8911525011062622,
0.6857700347900391,
-0.04987597465515137,
-0.2163483053445816,
0.9711505174636841,
-0.7784080505371094,
0.2924821376800537,
0.12282606214284897,
0.3181775212287903,
0.4731007218360901,
-0.3911202847957611,
0.3288459777832031,
0.08029289543628693,
-0.28319594264030457,
-0.7607218623161316,
-0.0012667370028793812,
-1.0918952226638794,
-0.47657278180122375,
1.3770278692245483,
0.03927885368466377,
-0.30818870663642883,
-0.6316480040550232,
-0.5156760215759277,
0.19816353917121887,
-0.3676708936691284,
0.49474036693573,
0.6414552330970764,
-0.29744046926498413,
-0.09386441111564636,
-0.5668275356292725,
0.6442261338233948,
0.69538813829422,
-0.7740106582641602,
0.01829661801457405,
0.1887892782688141,
0.3290201723575592,
0.3939670920372009,
0.5722532868385315,
0.33281052112579346,
0.3605554401874542,
-0.25681933760643005,
-0.46952736377716064,
0.06288298964500427,
-0.31198689341545105,
-0.4775240421295166,
0.10477957874536514,
0.024393310770392418,
0.20955196022987366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02310v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02310v1 | Evaluating the Ability of LLMs to Solve Semantics-Aware Process Mining Tasks | 2024-07-02T14:44:49 | 2024-07-02T14:44:49 | Adrian Rebmann, Fabian David Schmidt, Goran Glavaš, Han van der Aa | cs.CL | cs.CL | The process mining community has recently recognized the potential of large
language models (LLMs) for tackling various process mining tasks. Initial
studies report the capability of LLMs to support process analysis and even, to
some extent, that they are able to reason about how processes work. This latter
property suggests that LLMs could also be used to tackle process mining tasks
that benefit from an understanding of process behavior. Examples of such tasks
include (semantic) anomaly detection and next activity prediction, which both
involve considerations of the meaning of activities and their inter-relations.
In this paper, we investigate the capabilities of LLMs to tackle such
semantics-aware process mining tasks. Furthermore, whereas most works on the
intersection of LLMs and process mining only focus on testing these models out
of the box, we provide a more principled investigation of the utility of LLMs
for process mining, including their ability to obtain process mining knowledge
post-hoc by means of in-context learning and supervised fine-tuning.
Concretely, we define three process mining tasks that benefit from an
understanding of process semantics and provide extensive benchmarking datasets
for each of them. Our evaluation experiments reveal that (1) LLMs fail to solve
challenging process mining tasks out of the box and when provided only a
handful of in-context examples, (2) but they yield strong performance when
fine-tuned for these tasks, consistently surpassing smaller, encoder-based
language models. | [
-0.2572418451309204,
-0.6573780179023743,
1.162815809249878,
-0.09889989346265793,
-0.21310998499393463,
-0.1794358491897583,
-0.30578482151031494,
-0.5639227628707886,
-0.0654422789812088,
0.7675206065177917,
-0.861794650554657,
-0.675559937953949,
-0.8234177231788635,
0.16367091238498688,
-0.5459856986999512,
0.847643256187439,
-0.3408355116844177,
-0.10481978952884674,
-0.32247528433799744,
0.16615080833435059,
-0.44493770599365234,
-0.6660547256469727,
-0.5611398816108704,
-0.5308453440666199,
0.2017679214477539,
0.3546024262905121,
0.3429791033267975,
0.38222798705101013,
0.4221128523349762,
0.31239989399909973,
-0.15920306742191315,
0.300764799118042,
-0.30181777477264404,
0.4619292616844177,
-0.18563884496688843,
-0.5650756359100342,
-0.5134202837944031,
0.06543224304914474,
0.5305967926979065,
0.9261279106140137,
-0.005524878390133381,
0.2973770797252655,
0.1315412074327469,
0.3117700517177582,
-0.5032325983047485,
0.43191078305244446,
-1.0878705978393555,
0.027988892048597336,
-0.3575054109096527,
-0.36963364481925964,
-0.11678703129291534,
0.16521431505680084,
0.00544216763228178,
-0.4228854775428772,
0.22845184803009033,
0.04955840855836868,
0.5565598607063293,
0.36831948161125183,
-0.08904264122247696,
-0.5644904971122742,
-0.6193352937698364,
0.9039018154144287,
-0.7033991813659668,
0.2732417583465576,
0.6094383001327515,
0.08149769902229309,
-0.5496789813041687,
-0.7843835949897766,
-0.3693762421607971,
-0.13581392168998718,
-0.11217065900564194,
-0.1282651126384735,
-0.018002402037382126,
0.008919155225157738,
0.5226562023162842,
0.44106316566467285,
-0.1727301925420761,
0.2989056706428528,
0.0543428510427475,
-0.1671275645494461,
0.2285318374633789,
0.5891209840774536,
0.11067906767129898,
-0.123668372631073,
-0.2165282815694809,
0.29079097509384155,
-0.5051352381706238,
-0.03364619240164757,
0.29777076840400696,
0.36554816365242004,
0.24910999834537506,
0.6768864393234253,
-0.5122278332710266,
0.5435218811035156,
-0.3630538582801819,
-0.04198641702532768,
0.02852117270231247,
-0.11915699392557144,
-0.39169424772262573,
-0.10676842927932739,
0.4063039720058441,
0.10683469474315643,
0.14583376049995422,
-0.4226933419704437,
-0.42826709151268005,
0.19748662412166595,
0.1464574784040451,
-0.8445921540260315,
-0.0733899250626564,
0.21973282098770142,
-0.35295775532722473,
-0.09563343971967697,
0.02942441776394844,
-0.18995985388755798,
-0.3708110749721527,
-0.4465426206588745,
0.4330514073371887,
-0.37416985630989075,
-0.2834297716617584,
0.16874909400939941,
-0.31351912021636963,
0.15736059844493866,
0.19051924347877502,
-0.7910224199295044,
0.48598524928092957,
1.1843012571334839,
0.8316954374313354,
-0.35319721698760986,
-0.2435225248336792,
-0.9482222199440002,
-0.012001165188848972,
-0.24448339641094208,
0.843912661075592,
-0.7012925744056702,
-0.35975608229637146,
-0.13066908717155457,
0.279889851808548,
0.015576415695250034,
-0.7752510905265808,
0.74711674451828,
-0.5574398040771484,
-0.3705308139324188,
-0.24077416956424713,
-0.8159152269363403,
-0.08618151396512985,
0.4411240518093109,
-0.4529555141925812,
1.1423375606536865,
-0.07834620028734207,
-0.6615774631500244,
0.6150418519973755,
-0.5462086796760559,
-0.25282829999923706,
0.06483098864555359,
-0.09660222381353378,
-0.2513708472251892,
0.43001291155815125,
-0.13875684142112732,
0.9121653437614441,
-0.28971147537231445,
-0.10000216215848923,
-0.48250284790992737,
-0.247983917593956,
0.5009797811508179,
-0.2400999367237091,
0.32673895359039307,
0.36666056513786316,
-0.19888876378536224,
0.17495860159397125,
-0.6040368676185608,
0.00006682576349703595,
-0.0960027426481247,
-0.10570593178272247,
-0.40225809812545776,
0.2965029180049896,
-0.21682941913604736,
0.3312361538410187,
0.11022176593542099,
-0.5000508427619934,
-0.13194195926189423,
-0.48764947056770325,
0.4435538053512573,
0.7703091502189636,
0.06115660443902016,
0.2324133664369583,
-0.14187021553516388,
0.40241268277168274,
0.038460567593574524,
-0.08233049511909485,
-0.373634397983551,
-0.41949403285980225,
-0.6887590885162354,
-0.2727990448474884,
0.06870860606431961,
0.47306883335113525,
-0.36532533168792725,
0.4547351002693176,
-0.16171613335609436,
-0.39276331663131714,
-0.09696286916732788,
0.5615773797035217,
0.02434779517352581,
0.4429442882537842,
0.09685948491096497,
-0.5505331158638,
-0.6252601742744446,
-0.5951612591743469,
-0.4205239415168762,
-0.04588513821363449,
-0.2488507330417633,
0.27442875504493713,
0.4089002311229706,
-0.48540905117988586,
0.9270994663238525,
-0.3113689124584198,
-0.3027260899543762,
-0.0847102627158165,
0.16515403985977173,
0.5093428492546082,
0.1441185027360916,
-0.18020202219486237,
-0.48003438115119934,
-0.13905952870845795,
-0.03560377657413483,
-0.8305726647377014,
-0.2619030177593231,
0.17137028276920319,
0.01891510933637619,
0.45610395073890686,
0.7189071178436279,
-0.5068739652633667,
0.2738412320613861,
0.46788403391838074,
-0.31003013253211975,
0.45718348026275635,
-0.334625780582428,
-0.21517051756381989,
-0.6694108247756958,
-0.03952426463365555,
-0.02673628181219101,
-0.4208850860595703,
-0.6708565354347229,
-0.03427756205201149,
-0.1112990751862526,
-0.07256554812192917,
-0.49956536293029785,
0.36104363203048706,
-0.6277371048927307,
-0.3353758454322815,
-0.7393485903739929,
-0.0910656675696373,
-0.35266417264938354,
0.22050784528255463,
0.2924017608165741,
0.29148730635643005,
0.7926194667816162,
-0.8483012318611145,
0.2776722311973572,
-0.23624424636363983,
-0.6501074433326721,
0.414030522108078,
-0.24253804981708527,
0.008733740076422691,
0.05377567559480667,
-0.07494954764842987,
-0.8666734099388123,
-0.1846134513616562,
0.1191345676779747,
-0.24336057901382446,
0.1404709368944168,
-0.2590964734554291,
-0.8021930456161499,
-0.11123411357402802,
-0.2994648218154907,
0.07349706441164017,
0.5349090695381165,
-0.5161876082420349,
0.631596028804779,
0.48656848073005676,
0.05996985360980034,
-0.22896146774291992,
-0.6692888736724854,
-0.008824369870126247,
-0.6207152605056763,
-0.5039469599723816,
0.25301557779312134,
0.021157460287213326,
-0.2802877426147461,
0.1464858055114746,
-0.5169463753700256,
0.09229281544685364,
0.5399906635284424,
0.5775659084320068,
0.07357725501060486,
0.2291858196258545,
0.08538877964019775,
-0.3972969651222229,
-0.4541373550891876,
0.35263946652412415,
-0.1608736664056778,
0.5696155428886414,
-0.21297432482242584,
-0.540814220905304,
-0.24873623251914978,
0.05927252769470215,
0.3827308416366577,
-0.014184970408678055,
0.6855459809303284,
0.5759872794151306,
-0.7148945331573486,
-0.2229287326335907,
-0.5494473576545715,
-0.2732081711292267,
-0.4761825203895569,
0.30974653363227844,
-0.42035380005836487,
-0.9558054804801941,
0.5910566449165344,
-0.5919673442840576,
0.10182786732912064,
0.29738590121269226,
0.676322340965271,
-0.2016156166791916,
0.8920149207115173,
0.5688430070877075,
-0.013726165518164635,
0.2783421576023102,
-0.17561092972755432,
0.26476186513900757,
-1.0175949335098267,
-0.17332306504249573,
-0.4148315191268921,
-0.17391496896743774,
-0.7762755155563354,
-0.41101500391960144,
0.4035335183143616,
0.15129521489143372,
-0.14241130650043488,
0.1862330287694931,
-0.01364793349057436,
0.33407896757125854,
0.4118189513683319,
-0.09690216928720474,
0.5276285409927368,
0.02000516839325428,
0.18806928396224976,
0.04018513485789299,
-0.6315281391143799,
-0.826289176940918,
0.9924648404121399,
0.35295116901397705,
0.7865045070648193,
-0.1921328455209732,
0.6579589247703552,
0.17232784628868103,
0.2576141059398651,
-0.881230354309082,
0.6765092611312866,
-0.08855699002742767,
-0.3322930335998535,
-0.4064810872077942,
-0.1467280238866806,
-1.1149436235427856,
0.08174063265323639,
-0.3004845380783081,
-0.838860809803009,
-0.15893465280532837,
-0.0031257548835128546,
-0.10216661542654037,
0.4399663507938385,
-0.5435530543327332,
0.8189489841461182,
-0.24323880672454834,
-0.339659184217453,
-0.34157809615135193,
-0.33107343316078186,
0.22395558655261993,
-0.14320141077041626,
0.5307725071907043,
-0.5288364887237549,
-0.19811038672924042,
0.5458554625511169,
-0.5254340171813965,
0.9635016918182373,
-0.06275556981563568,
-0.10347959399223328,
0.13917838037014008,
0.18513935804367065,
0.648833155632019,
0.12231213599443436,
-0.1889956295490265,
0.4160946011543274,
0.14556370675563812,
-0.14004406332969666,
-0.5409444570541382,
0.9697222709655762,
-0.31833168864250183,
-0.8244441151618958,
-0.5238416194915771,
-0.45019686222076416,
-0.29470619559288025,
0.16322581470012665,
-0.05316397175192833,
0.07323221117258072,
-0.13171006739139557,
0.03811263293027878,
0.7831094861030579,
0.10898371040821075,
0.5563410520553589,
0.5262803435325623,
-0.0068315183743834496,
0.38938868045806885,
0.6918050050735474,
0.06715439260005951,
0.027523281052708626,
0.21118971705436707,
0.10822595655918121,
-0.07982496172189713,
-0.7667921185493469,
-0.16335703432559967,
-0.013965261168777943,
-0.7349370121955872,
-0.24112369120121002,
-0.7512592077255249,
-0.07340279221534729,
-0.01639009267091751,
0.08679371327161789,
-0.21605686843395233,
-0.18304166197776794,
-0.24679794907569885,
-0.09488075226545334,
0.4302130937576294,
0.4809938669204712,
0.0652536004781723,
-0.034076910465955734,
-0.7482202053070068,
0.2877187728881836,
0.3009287118911743,
0.7682086229324341,
-0.06868330389261246,
-0.21265022456645966,
-0.2068522572517395,
-0.31168851256370544,
-0.09856263548135757,
-0.7947114109992981,
0.12673898041248322,
0.025917991995811462,
0.8715329766273499,
0.25543299317359924,
-0.11156576871871948,
0.45610475540161133,
-0.45963776111602783,
0.6812491416931152,
-0.36719056963920593,
-0.8907694816589355,
0.6625745296478271,
-0.04660306125879288,
0.029816659167408943,
0.25006598234176636,
0.3815968930721283,
-0.5455230474472046,
-0.5176618695259094,
-0.7208442091941833,
-1.077810287475586,
0.9423967003822327,
0.24697865545749664,
0.027757631614804268,
-0.1731024533510208,
0.5406022667884827,
0.2845103442668915,
0.0979309231042862,
-0.41915610432624817,
-0.11491477489471436,
0.24507670104503632,
-0.00948584359139204,
-0.07898145169019699,
-0.3302041292190552,
-0.038228198885917664,
0.054986849427223206,
0.847052276134491,
0.016930341720581055,
-0.018915480002760887,
0.023163991048932076,
-0.4378742277622223,
-0.016592003405094147,
0.31782254576683044,
-0.019587302580475807,
0.5796076059341431,
-0.10755137354135513,
0.32439252734184265,
0.7389346361160278,
-0.10618841648101807,
-0.17524351179599762,
0.0695371925830841,
0.13518191874027252,
-0.1481320858001709,
0.3720402717590332,
0.7610895037651062,
0.11988148838281631,
-1.0804487466812134,
0.17904488742351532,
0.0654701441526413,
-0.05742359906435013,
-0.4640730917453766,
0.4076741933822632,
0.1947927176952362,
0.3928465247154236,
0.17417551577091217,
-0.14193730056285858,
0.4927481710910797,
-0.908530056476593,
0.04710967838764191,
0.8984215259552002,
-0.30321526527404785,
-0.14896950125694275,
0.3631611168384552,
-0.12818819284439087,
-0.323205828666687,
0.4973336160182953,
-0.20156894624233246,
-0.3839658498764038,
0.4617597162723541,
0.3905050456523895,
0.7819514870643616,
0.04471850395202637,
-0.40892937779426575,
0.027668984606862068,
0.364371657371521,
-0.13203148543834686,
0.19167549908161163,
-0.27311572432518005,
-0.7618502974510193,
-0.5195969939231873,
-0.7548413276672363,
-0.5191898941993713,
0.1884436309337616,
-0.39320167899131775,
0.42321059107780457,
-0.2100939005613327,
-0.13867369294166565,
-0.15774735808372498,
0.0850779190659523,
-0.8240059614181519,
0.10820907354354858,
0.3105067014694214,
0.8074881434440613,
-0.8733686208724976,
0.741067111492157,
0.839958131313324,
0.06763431429862976,
-0.3778294622898102,
-0.09997522085905075,
-0.11961287260055542,
-0.7013731598854065,
0.5566606521606445,
0.32820290327072144,
-0.19207502901554108,
-0.31223219633102417,
-0.08070885390043259,
-0.7998028993606567,
1.0589102506637573,
0.2587103545665741,
-0.3440994918346405,
0.5317273139953613,
0.2517753839492798,
0.5923442244529724,
-0.3097281754016876,
0.18440952897071838,
1.0251388549804688,
0.4145496189594269,
0.022609466686844826,
-0.7941579222679138,
0.24247053265571594,
-0.1478368192911148,
0.12214669585227966,
0.30139654874801636,
-0.1466468870639801,
0.5227924585342407,
0.11328860372304916,
-0.2952142655849457,
-0.13815881311893463,
0.7486410737037659,
0.48795413970947266,
0.5077060461044312,
0.821871280670166,
0.5971062183380127,
0.7393742203712463,
-0.11143599450588226,
1.1034740209579468,
-0.2913295328617096,
0.03330988064408302,
0.9362317323684692,
-0.4063897132873535,
0.713039219379425,
0.42632728815078735,
-0.0002553369558881968,
0.5070748329162598,
0.7527436017990112,
0.39313971996307373,
0.34246811270713806,
0.3521376848220825,
-0.3526870608329773,
-0.5657060146331787,
-0.06906537711620331,
0.000832070130854845,
0.2148468941450119,
0.688709020614624,
-0.19832843542099,
-0.3024871051311493,
-0.2324858456850052,
-0.10913578420877457,
0.056661367416381836,
-0.6032889485359192,
0.8071901202201843,
0.19159400463104248,
-0.6694085597991943,
0.06761151552200317,
0.2919049859046936,
0.7694031000137329,
-0.669757604598999,
-0.018183406442403793,
0.068764828145504,
0.3034336566925049,
-0.36080554127693176,
-0.8986872434616089,
0.7048454284667969,
0.22204738855361938,
-0.1993921995162964,
-0.4173033833503723,
1.0380859375,
-0.08195912837982178,
-0.48828622698783875,
0.3297449052333832,
0.4619869589805603,
0.40132421255111694,
-0.2878865897655487,
-0.36794036626815796,
0.08780946582555771,
-0.5084678530693054,
-0.24185366928577423,
0.6006107926368713,
0.7082492113113403,
-0.38285332918167114,
0.6218644976615906,
0.6484891772270203,
0.18830515444278717,
0.004508253186941147,
0.051407650113105774,
0.7074466347694397,
-0.6457087397575378,
-0.34275639057159424,
-1.186137080192566,
0.2452576756477356,
0.09073370695114136,
0.1834428757429123,
0.803663432598114,
0.6697969436645508,
0.9895108342170715,
0.147460475564003,
0.7404541373252869,
0.09805899858474731,
0.45645102858543396,
-0.7904253602027893,
0.07143959403038025,
-0.3604312241077423,
0.5634528994560242,
-0.09800871461629868,
-0.8122168779373169,
-0.27843576669692993,
0.4862453043460846,
-0.33299359679222107,
-0.08120995759963989,
0.6290863156318665,
0.840194582939148,
-0.13759376108646393,
0.12682853639125824,
0.1801401972770691,
0.055904991924762726,
0.23528538644313812,
0.5347407460212708,
0.9141356945037842,
-0.10494808107614517,
0.3852159082889557,
-0.17412371933460236,
-0.31079214811325073,
-0.06462795287370682,
-1.2749593257904053,
-0.9084973335266113,
-0.47381871938705444,
-0.11778620630502701,
-0.12935315072536469,
-0.15216591954231262,
0.8616591095924377,
0.5488499999046326,
-0.6631675362586975,
-0.3960530459880829,
-0.2787083089351654,
0.15328334271907806,
-0.29736483097076416,
-0.124631367623806,
0.15010474622249603,
-0.7716825604438782,
-0.7477564811706543,
0.4652133882045746,
0.4085848331451416,
-0.2804003357887268,
-0.16095907986164093,
-0.13824810087680817,
0.1055678203701973,
-0.044115327298641205,
0.712786078453064,
0.09354513138532639,
-0.6501857042312622,
-0.1609947830438614,
-0.044430457055568695,
0.35433197021484375,
-0.25201180577278137,
1.0900278091430664,
-0.6955735087394714,
0.25508221983909607,
0.5575095415115356,
0.6985242366790771,
1.0359835624694824,
-0.33772367238998413,
0.2923344373703003,
-0.7072551250457764,
0.03084401786327362,
0.0035550149623304605,
0.6198492050170898,
0.2585478723049164,
-0.3177843689918518,
0.5608742237091064,
0.1516260802745819,
-0.5440348982810974,
-0.71403568983078,
0.24706517159938812,
-0.9372600317001343,
-0.3268073499202728,
1.2200103998184204,
0.013719899579882622,
-0.13220587372779846,
-0.3058149516582489,
0.11229314655065536,
0.29218387603759766,
-0.007185859605669975,
0.6929109692573547,
0.9532548785209656,
-0.5575333833694458,
0.2776818871498108,
-0.8028632402420044,
0.45731866359710693,
0.4322775900363922,
-0.6832771301269531,
0.3416697680950165,
0.3121451437473297,
0.5008677840232849,
-0.1617167592048645,
0.6631221175193787,
-0.13176825642585754,
-0.02890767902135849,
-0.6060491800308228,
-0.09534451365470886,
-0.16723281145095825,
-0.0372249037027359,
-0.35770875215530396,
0.1516248732805252,
0.4307117462158203,
0.06179732829332352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02302v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02302v1 | Towards Human Understanding of Paraphrase Types in ChatGPT | 2024-07-02T14:35:10 | 2024-07-02T14:35:10 | Dominik Meier, Jan Philip Wahle, Terry Ruas, Bela Gipp | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Paraphrases represent a human's intuitive ability to understand expressions
presented in various different ways. Current paraphrase evaluations of language
models primarily use binary approaches, offering limited interpretability of
specific text changes. Atomic paraphrase types (APT) decompose paraphrases into
different linguistic changes and offer a granular view of the flexibility in
linguistic expression (e.g., a shift in syntax or vocabulary used). In this
study, we assess the human preferences towards ChatGPT in generating English
paraphrases with ten APTs and five prompting techniques. We introduce APTY
(Atomic Paraphrase TYpes), a dataset of 500 sentence-level and word-level
annotations by 15 annotators. The dataset also provides a human preference
ranking of paraphrases with different types that can be used to fine-tune
models with RLHF and DPO methods. Our results reveal that ChatGPT can generate
simple APTs, such as additions and deletions, but struggle with complex
structures (e.g., subordination changes). This study contributes to
understanding which aspects of paraphrasing language models have already
succeeded at understanding and what remains elusive. In addition, our curated
datasets can be used to develop language models with specific linguistic
capabilities. | [
-0.2245069146156311,
-0.7131718397140503,
0.5229061245918274,
0.0332784540951252,
-0.5290144681930542,
-0.1278955638408661,
-0.0720934048295021,
-0.1509699821472168,
-0.11465760320425034,
0.48640280961990356,
-0.17292791604995728,
-0.4359292685985565,
-0.3944754898548126,
0.5418646335601807,
-0.33224621415138245,
1.0162655115127563,
-0.00018080438894685358,
-0.18317683041095734,
-0.07441002130508423,
-0.08776525408029556,
-0.3289549946784973,
-0.4999736249446869,
-0.503948450088501,
-0.29700517654418945,
0.4475879669189453,
0.6226640939712524,
1.267043113708496,
0.6629660725593567,
0.4603444039821625,
0.25150036811828613,
-0.25569337606430054,
-0.1877720206975937,
-0.17557691037654877,
0.1321876496076584,
-0.19569134712219238,
-0.501080334186554,
-0.15493133664131165,
-0.18364083766937256,
0.44233042001724243,
0.6207283735275269,
-0.19252535700798035,
0.08340587466955185,
0.06988440454006195,
0.6046711802482605,
-0.40980127453804016,
0.5208867788314819,
-0.7666487097740173,
0.08288426697254181,
-0.18776677548885345,
-0.035443663597106934,
-0.32141542434692383,
-0.3631554841995239,
0.396513432264328,
-0.45417383313179016,
0.3063241243362427,
0.1635534018278122,
0.5163859128952026,
0.12881357967853546,
-0.4306405782699585,
-0.42530399560928345,
-0.339943528175354,
0.4136239290237427,
-0.8352871537208557,
0.2963063418865204,
0.5189850926399231,
0.2945593297481537,
0.1164427325129509,
-0.7117531299591064,
-0.4540119469165802,
-0.5712224245071411,
-0.3033815026283264,
0.025084277614951134,
0.07783487439155579,
0.23624323308467865,
-0.119602270424366,
0.3939876854419708,
-0.6391270756721497,
-0.14847154915332794,
-0.2611033022403717,
-0.13839511573314667,
0.42282533645629883,
0.18957269191741943,
0.5507057309150696,
-0.7305853366851807,
-0.1497376412153244,
-0.11218221485614777,
-0.5372846126556396,
-0.12109705060720444,
0.06567312777042389,
0.1613708883523941,
0.11542504280805588,
0.7191169857978821,
-0.473195344209671,
0.4481368958950043,
-0.2210020273923874,
0.25449422001838684,
-0.06344076246023178,
-0.24968698620796204,
0.06104058772325516,
-0.22908903658390045,
0.7057256698608398,
0.3645157516002655,
0.512093186378479,
-0.4603334367275238,
-0.08822094649076462,
-0.036089975386857986,
-0.03895777836441994,
-0.6261340379714966,
-0.5254057049751282,
0.1517133265733719,
-0.5201534032821655,
-0.27717772126197815,
-0.07681654393672943,
-0.7879599928855896,
-0.3206403851509094,
-0.27416861057281494,
0.2823614180088043,
-0.7840077877044678,
-0.051657579839229584,
0.34373414516448975,
-0.5334760546684265,
0.25543704628944397,
0.19690147042274475,
-0.8735874891281128,
0.11797836422920227,
0.6114227771759033,
0.8038234114646912,
-0.09198536723852158,
-0.7185745239257812,
-0.056668952107429504,
0.08194888383150101,
-0.282989501953125,
1.066432237625122,
-0.6349259614944458,
-0.43186983466148376,
-0.16980202496051788,
-0.46209490299224854,
-0.23909783363342285,
-0.6020804047584534,
0.5918096303939819,
-0.3931131958961487,
0.3135150671005249,
-0.27857092022895813,
-0.5535514950752258,
-0.23978354036808014,
-0.017118249088525772,
-0.4812687635421753,
0.7191047072410583,
0.03145657852292061,
-0.7715414762496948,
0.24456027150154114,
-0.7025943398475647,
-0.3230578601360321,
0.39178889989852905,
-0.15205787122249603,
-0.13138405978679657,
0.31417232751846313,
0.4198693335056305,
0.4295046627521515,
-0.2417146861553192,
0.3559314012527466,
-0.17386962473392487,
-0.08710169047117233,
0.5328564047813416,
-0.5797647833824158,
0.22122184932231903,
0.5313391089439392,
-0.2362692654132843,
-0.14200273156166077,
-0.5065333843231201,
-0.10696538537740707,
0.13008548319339752,
-0.266580730676651,
-0.3102593719959259,
0.16846540570259094,
0.04125096648931503,
0.34362953901290894,
0.39093801379203796,
-0.21696051955223083,
-0.08111613243818283,
-0.1534273475408554,
1.0543196201324463,
0.6474399566650391,
0.5355188846588135,
0.18367420136928558,
-0.5514899492263794,
0.5544862151145935,
-0.11540394276380539,
0.14879544079303741,
0.020266929641366005,
-0.5782386064529419,
-0.35371237993240356,
-0.05912555009126663,
0.04615908861160278,
0.4048891067504883,
-0.688754141330719,
0.11848718672990799,
-0.41231274604797363,
-0.5671411156654358,
-0.4769520163536072,
0.0240436103194952,
0.4736785888671875,
0.467774897813797,
0.3639957904815674,
0.02079581283032894,
-0.03816857188940048,
-0.9511964917182922,
-0.6512899398803711,
-0.3530811667442322,
-0.04849984869360924,
0.36524322628974915,
0.47409170866012573,
-0.09422579407691956,
1.0701723098754883,
-0.4209492802619934,
0.39276933670043945,
-0.5164170861244202,
0.4019133746623993,
-0.25668835639953613,
0.0033041825518012047,
0.25127243995666504,
-1.1266801357269287,
-0.6018809080123901,
0.05513552576303482,
-0.684617280960083,
-0.19799262285232544,
-0.10518793761730194,
-0.21192768216133118,
-0.32709407806396484,
0.3397500514984131,
-1.0191644430160522,
0.19283562898635864,
0.12442975491285324,
-0.4564558267593384,
0.5311838984489441,
-0.06769248843193054,
0.35561224818229675,
-1.1868647336959839,
-0.07669976353645325,
-0.1889626383781433,
-0.1692676693201065,
-0.5072293281555176,
0.290334552526474,
0.08603290468454361,
-0.4577523469924927,
-0.6910414099693298,
0.5469254851341248,
-0.3166249990463257,
-0.08777870237827301,
-0.19678908586502075,
0.3165479302406311,
0.051733482629060745,
0.37971919775009155,
0.27930742502212524,
0.8917964100837708,
0.2756744921207428,
-0.4234068989753723,
0.02399781532585621,
0.6248859167098999,
-0.16825060546398163,
0.16877539455890656,
-0.8583120107650757,
0.17251965403556824,
-0.3183128237724304,
0.2490401715040207,
-1.166630744934082,
-0.4592532813549042,
0.23309914767742157,
-0.4768811762332916,
-0.15401573479175568,
-0.13918572664260864,
-0.41824790835380554,
0.0024906068574637175,
-0.43806716799736023,
0.2366214245557785,
0.6449253559112549,
-0.1536789983510971,
0.25445792078971863,
0.1209784746170044,
-0.4537038803100586,
-0.3176555931568146,
-0.4015967547893524,
0.42796024680137634,
-0.5984840989112854,
-0.3552826941013336,
0.10678815096616745,
-0.0805477648973465,
-0.43040335178375244,
-0.14902858436107635,
-0.1501583456993103,
-0.15682759881019592,
0.0792749896645546,
0.06594175845384598,
-0.01426140870898962,
-0.027922026813030243,
-0.06998977065086365,
0.059206921607255936,
-0.07360368221998215,
-0.10167106240987778,
-0.0023834402672946453,
0.6549175977706909,
-0.23983921110630035,
-0.10138790309429169,
-0.5614451766014099,
0.4218975007534027,
0.7388066649436951,
-0.26939189434051514,
0.4391806125640869,
0.3567720055580139,
-0.04426534101366997,
0.2499946802854538,
-0.2063799351453781,
-0.30635109543800354,
-0.4591359496116638,
0.4218764901161194,
-0.44450002908706665,
-0.6585599780082703,
0.5221508145332336,
0.17744919657707214,
0.1986979991197586,
0.4612707793712616,
0.652195155620575,
0.12967899441719055,
0.850938618183136,
-0.06276676058769226,
0.004828305449336767,
0.5025854110717773,
0.22678636014461517,
-0.16587460041046143,
-0.6342076063156128,
0.161056250333786,
-0.5045507550239563,
-0.07666747272014618,
-0.3960300385951996,
-0.22527407109737396,
0.3300314247608185,
0.24257461726665497,
-0.15382120013237,
0.5114235281944275,
-0.4211495816707611,
0.48921358585357666,
0.5059145092964172,
0.36418941617012024,
0.3212504982948303,
-0.18460822105407715,
0.3485163152217865,
0.10946397483348846,
-0.710351288318634,
-0.7767409086227417,
1.036365032196045,
0.21520283818244934,
0.6770730018615723,
0.10180526971817017,
0.8579238057136536,
0.3941781520843506,
-0.05778674781322479,
-0.5620329976081848,
0.7151708602905273,
-0.0924830287694931,
-0.5977591276168823,
-0.3570076823234558,
-0.4508747458457947,
-1.0419851541519165,
0.25792500376701355,
0.12157279253005981,
-0.6712536215782166,
-0.0797724649310112,
0.24345846474170685,
-0.203637033700943,
-0.15503504872322083,
-0.941482424736023,
1.001381754875183,
0.011755160987377167,
0.19443801045417786,
-0.15162065625190735,
-0.9208569526672363,
0.053584735840559006,
0.139444962143898,
0.19541142880916595,
-0.1713496446609497,
-0.14923109114170074,
0.7375123500823975,
-0.25599437952041626,
0.6741062998771667,
0.10081180930137634,
0.16432246565818787,
0.49749261140823364,
0.44695213437080383,
0.49236664175987244,
0.27769777178764343,
-0.21412628889083862,
0.1302744448184967,
0.04203945770859718,
-0.41037851572036743,
-0.47013285756111145,
0.3077007830142975,
-0.734597384929657,
-0.6578102707862854,
0.004324844107031822,
-0.8203202486038208,
-0.027439527213573456,
0.017456477507948875,
0.5439132452011108,
0.5172157287597656,
0.06603232026100159,
0.2402995228767395,
0.3706952631473541,
0.01168600469827652,
0.40373024344444275,
0.22901368141174316,
0.044596344232559204,
-0.4154808819293976,
0.8468778133392334,
-0.07518996298313141,
0.5641461610794067,
0.7082604765892029,
0.6327980756759644,
-0.3262169659137726,
-0.7400389909744263,
-0.30624911189079285,
0.27115917205810547,
-0.9942777156829834,
0.06021162495017052,
-0.6344699859619141,
0.220139741897583,
-0.6354778409004211,
-0.23329982161521912,
-0.11611613631248474,
-0.6848446726799011,
-0.18419481813907623,
-0.04763398319482803,
0.7156318426132202,
0.5681608319282532,
0.27663561701774597,
0.3453086018562317,
-0.8839170336723328,
0.6146009564399719,
0.5416489243507385,
-0.11681027710437775,
-0.20392633974552155,
-0.5861214399337769,
0.01378562767058611,
0.10708436369895935,
-0.2619327902793884,
-1.0933208465576172,
0.42468026280403137,
0.5709502100944519,
0.3137272000312805,
0.0903516337275505,
0.1819227784872055,
0.5792250633239746,
-0.5907595157623291,
1.1164991855621338,
-0.4244019389152527,
-0.9816986918449402,
0.5865365862846375,
-0.6745251417160034,
0.18244287371635437,
0.610299289226532,
0.4498470425605774,
-0.7053928375244141,
-0.5822879076004028,
-0.6616283059120178,
-0.9122856259346008,
0.5110600590705872,
0.4557126462459564,
0.1929771453142166,
-0.44106701016426086,
0.6448990702629089,
0.29736217856407166,
0.28825604915618896,
-0.8151844143867493,
-0.1348247230052948,
-0.17488843202590942,
-0.3675365746021271,
-0.08601287007331848,
-0.025801638141274452,
0.03307388350367546,
0.20054663717746735,
0.2769111394882202,
0.03960815444588661,
0.18453356623649597,
0.117050401866436,
-0.382388710975647,
0.1936069279909134,
0.6244874596595764,
0.3233097195625305,
0.7715876698493958,
-0.35371074080467224,
0.2279173582792282,
0.1383933424949646,
-0.36087360978126526,
0.07156716287136078,
-0.05294150486588478,
-0.10031168162822723,
0.07479161769151688,
0.524255633354187,
0.7020629644393921,
0.33427906036376953,
-0.8334004878997803,
0.20487914979457855,
-0.0648740604519844,
-0.020407794043421745,
0.18305861949920654,
0.09080539643764496,
-0.00330028566531837,
0.08212082833051682,
0.1661462038755417,
-0.14252331852912903,
0.4172981083393097,
-0.5868410468101501,
0.24394865334033966,
0.25785359740257263,
0.03593407943844795,
-0.4901166558265686,
0.7683226466178894,
-0.004647151567041874,
-0.6098634600639343,
0.5125418901443481,
-0.08488905429840088,
-0.3640827536582947,
0.23748226463794708,
0.4965647757053375,
1.0034620761871338,
-0.019034089520573616,
0.46479812264442444,
-0.20663407444953918,
0.03409377858042717,
-0.2711496949195862,
0.026246406137943268,
-0.29652297496795654,
-0.6880670189857483,
-0.12657961249351501,
-0.48929983377456665,
-0.7941734790802002,
-0.036142267286777496,
-0.7584809064865112,
0.2511849105358124,
-0.043206073343753815,
0.2101837694644928,
0.10616768151521683,
-0.5373061299324036,
-0.4170226454734802,
0.022601952776312828,
-0.030130228027701378,
0.5569265484809875,
-0.9405940771102905,
0.6051507592201233,
0.9196501970291138,
-0.5841442346572876,
-0.7171475291252136,
0.2949755787849426,
-0.3395520746707916,
-0.9633735418319702,
0.45767834782600403,
0.013273420743644238,
0.2856334447860718,
0.29374781250953674,
-0.09454172104597092,
-0.5881201028823853,
0.9899522066116333,
0.4071374833583832,
-0.04619606211781502,
-0.4434550702571869,
0.38609394431114197,
0.4902164936065674,
0.011162425391376019,
0.3330674469470978,
0.6671059727668762,
0.26586923003196716,
-0.1676652878522873,
-0.8877443075180054,
0.012010210193693638,
0.027029527351260185,
0.26941585540771484,
0.3092701733112335,
-0.48083415627479553,
1.1323747634887695,
0.2562257647514343,
0.05117543414235115,
-0.06186986342072487,
0.31625470519065857,
0.23529762029647827,
0.18677182495594025,
0.3015170395374298,
0.38332095742225647,
0.07391609251499176,
0.38059040904045105,
1.0246790647506714,
-0.3986634314060211,
0.5499130487442017,
0.8863832950592041,
0.0012638753978535533,
0.9482199549674988,
0.40391239523887634,
-0.21326303482055664,
0.2902414798736572,
0.6500988602638245,
0.6461638808250427,
0.5786459445953369,
-0.09958340227603912,
-0.2617734968662262,
-0.250471293926239,
0.23551322519779205,
-0.18325841426849365,
0.4904818534851074,
0.3176965117454529,
-0.2411666065454483,
-0.64693284034729,
0.21282216906547546,
0.05061466991901398,
-0.020790839567780495,
-0.22517552971839905,
1.070023775100708,
0.0392884723842144,
-0.8713207244873047,
0.7970000505447388,
-0.16608865559101105,
0.3292944133281708,
-0.4697962999343872,
-0.0645839050412178,
-0.3463731110095978,
-0.15342117846012115,
0.04843207821249962,
-0.9537274837493896,
0.220344677567482,
-0.10946164280176163,
0.09958294779062271,
-0.13351283967494965,
0.573688805103302,
-0.33492007851600647,
-0.10231142491102219,
-0.31398698687553406,
0.4684430956840515,
0.526626706123352,
-0.40124088525772095,
-0.8860248923301697,
-0.3316357731819153,
0.18732519447803497,
-0.46159401535987854,
0.3927236497402191,
0.7881329655647278,
-0.1874103546142578,
0.7439628839492798,
0.3001061975955963,
-0.0009665900724940002,
0.027467194944620132,
-0.2961251735687256,
0.4843622148036957,
-0.7089548707008362,
-0.5487345457077026,
-1.1076536178588867,
0.32619136571884155,
0.21734139323234558,
-0.6146482825279236,
0.9031431078910828,
0.2559727430343628,
0.36090826988220215,
-0.3789386749267578,
0.906737744808197,
-0.11993297934532166,
0.397129088640213,
-0.5514407157897949,
0.4830198287963867,
-0.04295796900987625,
0.046564195305109024,
-0.4283425211906433,
-0.8416672348976135,
-0.08500966429710388,
0.6167217493057251,
-0.36417749524116516,
-0.15698717534542084,
0.6197540163993835,
0.6787707805633545,
0.018324347212910652,
0.09616769850254059,
0.22015725076198578,
-0.12197668850421906,
0.40733543038368225,
0.4720120429992676,
0.9592152833938599,
-0.2571927607059479,
0.7596151828765869,
-0.2192929983139038,
-0.1280810832977295,
-0.28593289852142334,
-0.7432880401611328,
-0.760970950126648,
-0.5935397148132324,
-0.4313579797744751,
-0.07368820160627365,
-0.02535424754023552,
0.9854910373687744,
0.34546586871147156,
-0.5052972435951233,
-0.05850996822118759,
-0.6664388179779053,
0.048172418028116226,
-0.16672199964523315,
-0.2739051282405853,
0.44306114315986633,
-0.612585723400116,
-0.62776118516922,
0.19035957753658295,
0.15317678451538086,
0.011270756833255291,
0.1762176901102066,
0.09978928416967392,
-0.03803040832281113,
0.12540747225284576,
0.515633225440979,
0.2718842029571533,
-0.7683445811271667,
-0.6468820571899414,
-0.007569058798253536,
0.15964668989181519,
0.1644940972328186,
0.7791158556938171,
-0.4474649429321289,
0.13592921197414398,
0.5754759907722473,
0.5130192041397095,
0.06204385310411453,
0.2599073350429535,
0.4859054982662201,
-0.663928210735321,
0.12599241733551025,
0.4473423361778259,
0.3164323568344116,
0.2319282740354538,
-0.24713753163814545,
0.21525947749614716,
0.1868656873703003,
-0.9669271111488342,
-0.6874108910560608,
0.31881681084632874,
-0.7696549892425537,
-0.5004343390464783,
1.401667833328247,
-0.19278642535209656,
-0.05843040347099304,
-0.31658270955085754,
-0.5691466331481934,
0.21257631480693817,
-0.46619248390197754,
0.9463667273521423,
0.7026241421699524,
-0.3867604732513428,
-0.18109607696533203,
-0.4211868643760681,
0.5315341949462891,
0.47013312578201294,
-0.7966906428337097,
0.5817855000495911,
0.3969942629337311,
0.36054375767707825,
-0.12449553608894348,
0.4975917935371399,
-0.13667134940624237,
0.41121217608451843,
-0.009503359906375408,
-0.05301012471318245,
0.08945244550704956,
-0.010372762568295002,
-0.22300390899181366,
0.06283891946077347,
0.575165867805481,
-0.27674606442451477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02301v1 | CFinBench: A Comprehensive Chinese Financial Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T14:34:36 | 2024-07-02T14:34:36 | Ying Nie, Binwei Yan, Tianyu Guo, Hao Liu, Haoyu Wang, Wei He, Binfan Zheng, Weihao Wang, Qiang Li, Weijian Sun, Yunhe Wang, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable performance on various
NLP tasks, yet their potential in more challenging and domain-specific task,
such as finance, has not been fully explored. In this paper, we present
CFinBench: a meticulously crafted, the most comprehensive evaluation benchmark
to date, for assessing the financial knowledge of LLMs under Chinese context.
In practice, to better align with the career trajectory of Chinese financial
practitioners, we build a systematic evaluation from 4 first-level categories:
(1) Financial Subject: whether LLMs can memorize the necessary basic knowledge
of financial subjects, such as economics, statistics and auditing. (2)
Financial Qualification: whether LLMs can obtain the needed financial qualified
certifications, such as certified public accountant, securities qualification
and banking qualification. (3) Financial Practice: whether LLMs can fulfill the
practical financial jobs, such as tax consultant, junior accountant and
securities analyst. (4) Financial Law: whether LLMs can meet the requirement of
financial laws and regulations, such as tax law, insurance law and economic
law. CFinBench comprises 99,100 questions spanning 43 second-level categories
with 3 question types: single-choice, multiple-choice and judgment. We conduct
extensive experiments of 50 representative LLMs with various model size on
CFinBench. The results show that GPT4 and some Chinese-oriented models lead the
benchmark, with the highest average accuracy being 60.16%, highlighting the
challenge presented by CFinBench. The dataset and evaluation code are available
at https://cfinbench.github.io/. | [
-0.20877346396446228,
-0.47318384051322937,
0.2854617238044739,
0.519751250743866,
-0.14644865691661835,
0.2573193311691284,
-0.5573135614395142,
-0.5278818607330322,
-0.3077363073825836,
0.4145090579986572,
-0.3419702351093292,
-0.6703504920005798,
-0.29339900612831116,
-0.16999539732933044,
-0.6340843439102173,
0.8634380102157593,
0.0601559653878212,
0.28832411766052246,
-0.10845397412776947,
0.15313421189785004,
-0.1147124171257019,
-0.35897883772850037,
-1.009492039680481,
-0.4968077540397644,
0.35912472009658813,
-0.09738088399171829,
0.5237544178962708,
0.2813037633895874,
0.7502874135971069,
0.2827240228652954,
-0.18089722096920013,
-0.26471883058547974,
-0.37553727626800537,
-0.4220134913921356,
-0.40536412596702576,
-0.2537793517112732,
-0.397333562374115,
-0.023433301597833633,
0.5300527215003967,
0.8031692504882812,
-0.4672352373600006,
0.27760791778564453,
0.23964662849903107,
0.5725783705711365,
-0.5266711115837097,
0.3774886727333069,
-0.6167376637458801,
0.081685371696949,
-0.41394203901290894,
0.06374143809080124,
-0.29961928725242615,
-0.3597523272037506,
0.23624499142169952,
-0.324646919965744,
0.045413944870233536,
-0.024227069690823555,
0.8412432074546814,
0.06553269922733307,
-0.6556130051612854,
-0.0962853729724884,
-0.2819712162017822,
0.6053633093833923,
-1.0593113899230957,
0.5498791337013245,
0.2064632624387741,
0.6179919838905334,
-0.1684749573469162,
-0.9225128889083862,
-0.3602614104747772,
-0.5003021955490112,
-0.14496305584907532,
0.30737605690956116,
-0.03258070349693298,
0.14931634068489075,
0.31748971343040466,
0.5733214616775513,
-0.5805744528770447,
0.23866945505142212,
-0.22056806087493896,
-0.27674025297164917,
0.7083228826522827,
0.2284279614686966,
0.03364092484116554,
-0.029769424349069595,
-0.5035708546638489,
-0.42667800188064575,
-0.44037649035453796,
0.1933887004852295,
0.27275529503822327,
0.37820225954055786,
-0.22094327211380005,
0.18560108542442322,
-0.17105339467525482,
0.823612630367279,
-0.07711884379386902,
-0.4027921259403229,
0.22755219042301178,
-0.3029918968677521,
-0.32111674547195435,
0.03714744746685028,
0.7571574449539185,
0.32984012365341187,
0.127916619181633,
-0.0798296257853508,
-0.5196275115013123,
-0.38630998134613037,
0.048075683414936066,
-0.6236433386802673,
-0.02855764515697956,
0.3027636408805847,
-0.43683770298957825,
-0.03785812482237816,
0.4009016454219818,
-0.706645667552948,
-0.3937256336212158,
-0.30800244212150574,
-0.06988684833049774,
-0.2310483604669571,
-0.2401595413684845,
0.06035739928483963,
-0.1314549446105957,
0.8248794674873352,
0.2577917277812958,
-0.9222488403320312,
0.46374836564064026,
1.2822175025939941,
0.7960267066955566,
-0.18439359962940216,
-0.21355536580085754,
-0.40803611278533936,
-0.013179436326026917,
-0.5160404443740845,
0.8931299448013306,
-0.2660377323627472,
-0.12744982540607452,
0.10277457535266876,
-0.08387202024459839,
-0.14112970232963562,
-0.7449454069137573,
0.511743426322937,
-0.35855090618133545,
-0.2558761239051819,
-0.3531701862812042,
-0.7502721548080444,
-0.17181019484996796,
0.5575003623962402,
-0.6618667244911194,
0.9320375323295593,
0.30796584486961365,
-0.688139021396637,
0.38749977946281433,
-0.34119734168052673,
-0.31098827719688416,
0.13737884163856506,
-0.28107133507728577,
0.01628894731402397,
-0.19137994945049286,
-0.05829950049519539,
0.5743972659111023,
-1.0060946941375732,
0.7485988140106201,
-0.4552547037601471,
-0.44976332783699036,
0.20761355757713318,
-0.5265424251556396,
0.7669194936752319,
0.04943111166357994,
-0.49870729446411133,
0.051661014556884766,
-0.8330250382423401,
0.12242089211940765,
-0.07796794921159744,
-0.33129021525382996,
-0.22147734463214874,
-0.12582938373088837,
0.38600948452949524,
0.32787567377090454,
0.45593440532684326,
-0.43953871726989746,
-0.1199958547949791,
-0.7256300449371338,
0.35357749462127686,
1.0203728675842285,
-0.23219148814678192,
-0.10573984682559967,
-0.19687128067016602,
0.4703226685523987,
-0.28687646985054016,
0.0004963888204656541,
-0.003423370188102126,
0.04797026515007019,
-0.5702524185180664,
-0.046775590628385544,
0.5186823010444641,
0.6213998198509216,
-0.4503464102745056,
0.5521798133850098,
-0.09565530717372894,
-0.8949546813964844,
-0.04107597470283508,
0.4825151562690735,
0.41193538904190063,
0.3703264594078064,
0.057190604507923126,
-0.1356423795223236,
-0.09512758255004883,
-1.0995969772338867,
-0.4385959506034851,
-0.21236339211463928,
-0.20680496096611023,
0.08771897107362747,
0.5493981838226318,
0.15784284472465515,
0.5414059162139893,
-0.4435860514640808,
-0.2664521038532257,
-0.3248644769191742,
-0.15515774488449097,
0.6449811458587646,
0.36557018756866455,
0.8851016759872437,
-0.660907506942749,
-0.4864429831504822,
0.3926777243614197,
-0.5165134072303772,
-0.015391219407320023,
-0.4608552157878876,
-0.29535651206970215,
0.1010180339217186,
0.6330730319023132,
-0.34086331725120544,
0.07661204040050507,
0.5172351002693176,
-0.3343079686164856,
0.5446819067001343,
-0.030617933720350266,
-0.23331525921821594,
-0.7430302500724792,
0.6123933792114258,
0.16617204248905182,
-0.0875501036643982,
-0.34338706731796265,
0.2779829800128937,
0.311386376619339,
0.1696014553308487,
-0.24923160672187805,
0.9428558945655823,
-0.15837177634239197,
-0.29872578382492065,
-0.139708012342453,
0.43218129873275757,
-0.3210967481136322,
0.5089594125747681,
-0.14322540163993835,
0.5534031391143799,
0.41481447219848633,
-0.2576923966407776,
0.7871668338775635,
-0.046232618391513824,
-0.8109936118125916,
0.5848871469497681,
-0.6849880218505859,
-0.20389920473098755,
0.3753109276294708,
0.3533779978752136,
-0.9254781603813171,
-0.004254566505551338,
-0.053505830466747284,
0.11982769519090652,
0.18273840844631195,
0.3274112045764923,
-0.7920401096343994,
-0.5100215673446655,
-0.15642334520816803,
0.07459449023008347,
0.08237771689891815,
-0.6396394371986389,
0.6450170874595642,
0.037409260869026184,
-0.326743483543396,
-0.7048388719558716,
-0.5853939056396484,
0.03598906099796295,
-0.0587444044649601,
-0.6930426955223083,
0.3803461492061615,
-0.14915381371974945,
-0.4025559425354004,
-0.22154314815998077,
-0.3975597023963928,
0.015483902767300606,
0.2936394512653351,
-0.17710372805595398,
0.4620489180088043,
-0.35588374733924866,
0.07063426077365875,
-0.08212628960609436,
-0.15959246456623077,
0.25918272137641907,
-0.13883785903453827,
0.6259148120880127,
-0.26866960525512695,
-0.4412185251712799,
-0.12893275916576385,
-0.18031291663646698,
0.1866058111190796,
-0.4266654849052429,
0.5978001952171326,
0.462936669588089,
-0.3787921369075775,
-0.3478831946849823,
-0.7956772446632385,
0.18655513226985931,
-0.5021148920059204,
0.4281231164932251,
-0.2566622197628021,
-0.8896158933639526,
0.706728994846344,
-0.11305128037929535,
0.49437111616134644,
0.744907557964325,
0.613686740398407,
0.46492570638656616,
0.41109681129455566,
0.6166486144065857,
-0.5263115763664246,
0.2523936629295349,
-0.10648475587368011,
0.14803998172283173,
-0.30151697993278503,
-0.14619824290275574,
-0.47926509380340576,
-0.1910255253314972,
-0.30715078115463257,
-0.3316403329372406,
0.18236921727657318,
0.032366152852773666,
-0.46105778217315674,
0.32681313157081604,
0.017535613849759102,
0.5230458974838257,
0.28455111384391785,
-0.15109647810459137,
0.24917945265769958,
-0.3214075267314911,
-0.3633803129196167,
0.1630220264196396,
-0.38988593220710754,
-0.30732089281082153,
1.029312252998352,
0.4059765040874481,
0.498784601688385,
-0.050881486386060715,
0.35368531942367554,
0.03503520041704178,
0.6171877384185791,
-0.5984507203102112,
0.45348095893859863,
-0.4498317539691925,
-0.7185881733894348,
-0.22750696539878845,
-0.5894101858139038,
-0.36370858550071716,
0.3459778130054474,
0.008138882927596569,
-0.6609355807304382,
-0.01725459285080433,
-0.1405845582485199,
-0.6128714084625244,
0.3338225185871124,
-0.09932935982942581,
1.0508184432983398,
-0.7527347803115845,
-0.4571416676044464,
-0.1765289306640625,
-0.4805459678173065,
0.8289692401885986,
-0.674767017364502,
0.29002347588539124,
-0.15298794209957123,
-0.09758488088846207,
0.7344661951065063,
-0.4684908092021942,
0.6429153680801392,
-0.16007791459560394,
-0.48118117451667786,
0.1309840828180313,
-0.18631622195243835,
0.330469012260437,
0.0793687030673027,
-0.45789065957069397,
0.2289499193429947,
0.3530585765838623,
-0.3066729009151459,
-0.5058111548423767,
0.772180438041687,
-0.4008930027484894,
-0.5292397737503052,
-0.5878353118896484,
-0.26345396041870117,
-0.43564677238464355,
0.2991018295288086,
-0.07110116630792618,
0.039312805980443954,
-0.6414754390716553,
0.3562263548374176,
0.08480872213840485,
-0.5567765831947327,
0.3380366563796997,
0.6404241323471069,
-0.33669692277908325,
-0.3478269577026367,
0.7194082736968994,
0.04401719942688942,
0.14248959720134735,
0.4009276032447815,
0.14720310270786285,
-0.2594192326068878,
-0.30037933588027954,
-0.19262997806072235,
0.3391650319099426,
-0.9651923179626465,
-0.29300180077552795,
-0.30861184000968933,
-0.5785009264945984,
-0.35285601019859314,
-0.2052793949842453,
-0.5056799054145813,
0.06859192252159119,
0.03781997039914131,
-0.4145975708961487,
0.05431445688009262,
0.39189448952674866,
-0.050061505287885666,
0.142084538936615,
-0.7743698358535767,
0.2441769242286682,
0.2062181830406189,
0.720139741897583,
0.41160184144973755,
-0.41761597990989685,
-0.35254067182540894,
-0.27099692821502686,
-0.2415371686220169,
-0.3003063499927521,
0.25421321392059326,
0.08749470859766006,
0.8958216905593872,
1.0776560306549072,
-0.006800252012908459,
0.9512373208999634,
-0.08875204622745514,
0.6403230428695679,
0.13158805668354034,
-1.0926175117492676,
0.09231185168027878,
-0.2654973566532135,
0.25343915820121765,
0.7626100778579712,
0.1549576371908188,
-0.8508546948432922,
-0.40019482374191284,
-0.44903913140296936,
-1.039094090461731,
0.7230145931243896,
-0.025807252153754234,
0.17852294445037842,
0.14364109933376312,
0.47735175490379333,
0.10527791827917099,
0.3059332072734833,
-0.6442030668258667,
-0.14912617206573486,
0.0030571564566344023,
-0.006500894669443369,
-0.3259228765964508,
-0.10724037885665894,
0.01787484623491764,
-0.22610899806022644,
0.6149694323539734,
-0.2561536729335785,
-0.3887263834476471,
-0.1168670654296875,
0.3434867262840271,
0.05637930706143379,
0.08095240592956543,
0.38912999629974365,
1.0316810607910156,
-0.2754938304424286,
-0.21118785440921783,
0.30721399188041687,
-0.16598348319530487,
-0.20802220702171326,
0.44949930906295776,
0.2223987877368927,
-0.1254548728466034,
0.7657459378242493,
0.395070880651474,
0.561763346195221,
-1.262668490409851,
0.6323778629302979,
0.01163480244576931,
-0.3217322528362274,
-0.858738362789154,
0.10601723939180374,
0.4468074142932892,
0.32859742641448975,
0.488319993019104,
-0.28739047050476074,
0.09782236069440842,
-0.5211628675460815,
0.18685834109783173,
0.4287693202495575,
-0.360430508852005,
0.07468275725841522,
0.5993213057518005,
0.09905148297548294,
0.35184359550476074,
0.7246960401535034,
0.19683682918548584,
-0.3672921061515808,
0.8913769721984863,
0.277790367603302,
0.8273279666900635,
-0.21440759301185608,
0.014982744120061398,
0.539693295955658,
0.41311416029930115,
-0.5125105381011963,
0.2389068752527237,
-0.05599834397435188,
-0.5805528163909912,
-0.1960216611623764,
-0.9261165857315063,
-0.5612027049064636,
0.13293913006782532,
-0.7558748722076416,
0.3540324568748474,
-0.9817150831222534,
-0.07690165191888809,
0.1079290434718132,
0.12967294454574585,
-0.6108891367912292,
0.19181106984615326,
0.3346332311630249,
1.5764403343200684,
-0.3433592617511749,
0.7010063529014587,
0.313110888004303,
-0.04076334461569786,
-0.7417575716972351,
-0.020084824413061142,
0.27807295322418213,
-0.6616954207420349,
0.6308878064155579,
0.2635901868343353,
0.12275069952011108,
-0.3905019164085388,
-0.4703918695449829,
-0.9013861417770386,
1.2683298587799072,
0.5434961318969727,
-1.066881537437439,
-0.08537060767412186,
0.2876681983470917,
0.6900948882102966,
-0.2581934630870819,
0.3611573576927185,
1.0078943967819214,
0.8827596306800842,
0.15735748410224915,
-1.057070255279541,
-0.11264172941446304,
-0.5589500665664673,
-0.018996497616171837,
-0.02822032943367958,
-1.2008440494537354,
0.9252052307128906,
0.19080522656440735,
-0.12246163189411163,
0.21453692018985748,
0.5980441570281982,
0.4156746566295624,
0.36126407980918884,
0.6105515360832214,
0.21314476430416107,
0.7740507125854492,
-0.3188749849796295,
1.1203824281692505,
-0.8065347075462341,
0.2923666536808014,
1.0446213483810425,
-0.5440088510513306,
1.0221710205078125,
0.1069072037935257,
-0.3294270932674408,
0.35988903045654297,
0.8801144957542419,
-0.5520744919776917,
0.018073489889502525,
0.6185592412948608,
-0.00987059436738491,
-0.5799044370651245,
-0.024046538397669792,
-0.3879872262477875,
0.623988926410675,
0.22680629789829254,
-0.3295831084251404,
-0.21865986287593842,
-0.2770656943321228,
0.04904031753540039,
0.04440949857234955,
-0.2829439342021942,
0.5416153073310852,
0.4777654707431793,
-0.5798285007476807,
0.3115600049495697,
0.40514498949050903,
0.6355867981910706,
-1.1731473207473755,
0.20188741385936737,
-0.4562489986419678,
0.38061052560806274,
-0.17244018614292145,
-0.5542181134223938,
0.15439514815807343,
0.1298244744539261,
0.34035977721214294,
0.09669844806194305,
0.4125554859638214,
-0.18329013884067535,
-0.8169830441474915,
0.7865039706230164,
0.3018456697463989,
-0.027703380212187767,
-0.34825143218040466,
-0.8386062383651733,
-0.18401899933815002,
-0.06907587498426437,
-0.4893130958080292,
0.36870312690734863,
0.38686004281044006,
-0.0023394799791276455,
0.7111081480979919,
0.7728116512298584,
0.01544827688485384,
-0.3255205750465393,
0.206608846783638,
0.9142133593559265,
-1.1416120529174805,
-0.626491367816925,
-0.8339584469795227,
0.14522869884967804,
-0.029944226145744324,
-0.47208255529403687,
0.7040064930915833,
0.8962736129760742,
1.115405797958374,
0.16408957540988922,
0.7053830623626709,
0.20519934594631195,
0.19826830923557281,
-0.5518399477005005,
0.8905669450759888,
-0.7532947063446045,
0.44633036851882935,
-0.6387408971786499,
-1.1111352443695068,
-0.30354994535446167,
0.42032256722450256,
-0.32928839325904846,
0.16259248554706573,
0.5696031451225281,
0.5493643879890442,
0.0061525143682956696,
0.19603970646858215,
0.5439644455909729,
0.1628410667181015,
0.19460748136043549,
0.7803253531455994,
0.5186757445335388,
-0.1285104751586914,
0.6572168469429016,
-0.5574503540992737,
-0.07066061347723007,
-0.02722039632499218,
-0.7172430157661438,
-0.9897551536560059,
-0.21373224258422852,
-0.11085987091064453,
0.08522456139326096,
-0.3056087791919708,
0.9626235365867615,
0.3098801374435425,
-0.9004419445991516,
-0.9032717347145081,
0.3916637599468231,
-0.12235359102487564,
-0.5280768275260925,
-0.2088353931903839,
0.6097164154052734,
-0.23444384336471558,
-0.6161770224571228,
0.33214735984802246,
0.36697494983673096,
-0.07077017426490784,
-0.487775057554245,
0.05259223282337189,
0.050136130303144455,
0.028321200981736183,
0.47372183203697205,
0.017781181260943413,
-0.7360705137252808,
0.11467629671096802,
-0.11352521926164627,
-0.25025099515914917,
-0.21267230808734894,
0.9099200963973999,
-0.30755963921546936,
0.17835448682308197,
0.39052504301071167,
0.7525078058242798,
0.29946815967559814,
-0.07194338738918304,
0.671387255191803,
-0.2321169227361679,
0.163671612739563,
-0.10317923873662949,
0.5261876583099365,
0.11684772372245789,
-0.24457471072673798,
0.6744434237480164,
-0.012225992046296597,
-0.22371649742126465,
-0.5888679027557373,
-0.39246684312820435,
-1.0440144538879395,
-0.4561486840248108,
0.7661331295967102,
-0.39717376232147217,
-0.2986769378185272,
0.11830415576696396,
-0.09470969438552856,
-0.09608129411935806,
-0.342871755361557,
0.581212043762207,
0.9670693874359131,
0.2996961772441864,
-0.19957131147384644,
-0.8333677649497986,
0.34253600239753723,
0.41271671652793884,
-0.6942267417907715,
0.4268181622028351,
0.2958256006240845,
0.2516267001628876,
-0.04289685934782028,
0.6366455554962158,
-0.08668647706508636,
0.4313673973083496,
0.06548192352056503,
0.0105828195810318,
0.09389211982488632,
-0.006177778821438551,
-0.191482812166214,
0.26936376094818115,
0.04276331514120102,
0.771259605884552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02284v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02284v1 | Renard: A Modular Pipeline for Extracting Character Networks from Narrative Texts | 2024-07-02T14:14:59 | 2024-07-02T14:14:59 | Arthur Amalvy, Vincent Labatut, Richard Dufour | cs.CL | cs.CL | Renard (Relationships Extraction from NARrative Documents) is a Python
library that allows users to define custom natural language processing (NLP)
pipelines to extract character networks from narrative texts. Contrary to the
few existing tools, Renard can extract dynamic networks, as well as the more
common static networks. Renard pipelines are modular: users can choose the
implementation of each NLP subtask needed to extract a character network. This
allows users to specialize pipelines to particular types of texts and to study
the impact of each subtask on the extracted network. | [
-0.31731683015823364,
-0.5690564513206482,
0.1371578574180603,
-0.16387100517749786,
0.012585241347551346,
0.22625280916690826,
0.22994129359722137,
-0.636268138885498,
0.7533706426620483,
0.8090083599090576,
-1.0374665260314941,
-0.15022411942481995,
-0.5290559530258179,
0.5360313057899475,
-0.5293443202972412,
1.1518714427947998,
0.05755626782774925,
-0.4516681134700775,
0.13741081953048706,
-0.12719140946865082,
-0.4681560695171356,
-0.4200931191444397,
-0.7700793743133545,
-0.4928106963634491,
1.1535545587539673,
0.6698004007339478,
0.6826586723327637,
0.9051026701927185,
0.9453151822090149,
0.4301215708255768,
0.19398362934589386,
0.25664272904396057,
-0.5241289138793945,
1.0352098941802979,
-0.48946794867515564,
-0.5126306414604187,
-0.31736162304878235,
-0.14705902338027954,
0.6659876108169556,
0.25052788853645325,
0.2674938142299652,
0.635141134262085,
-0.2522096633911133,
1.0120313167572021,
-0.6351492404937744,
0.2833251655101776,
-0.3570547103881836,
0.2006361186504364,
-0.3120797276496887,
-0.4614046812057495,
-0.3689382076263428,
-0.4727060794830322,
0.378222793340683,
-0.36079612374305725,
0.29373013973236084,
0.42058220505714417,
1.1962376832962036,
-0.013921943493187428,
-0.2117394208908081,
-0.32860881090164185,
-0.5890741348266602,
0.8667722344398499,
-0.6398504376411438,
-0.009600609540939331,
0.20162412524223328,
0.6533517241477966,
-0.052589692175388336,
-1.6892026662826538,
-0.43278855085372925,
0.30768516659736633,
-0.6812145709991455,
-0.1502774953842163,
-0.1048509031534195,
0.2978001832962036,
0.3339957892894745,
0.5690398812294006,
-0.3804979920387268,
-0.01352677308022976,
-0.5799329876899719,
-0.06709443777799606,
0.892899751663208,
0.5358800292015076,
0.806892991065979,
-0.6491364240646362,
-0.20263653993606567,
-0.18084397912025452,
-0.20742768049240112,
0.09338463842868805,
0.5864970088005066,
0.2570204436779022,
0.28369081020355225,
0.6627120971679688,
-0.012791717424988747,
0.5900365114212036,
-0.16874001920223236,
-0.16007567942142487,
0.23554465174674988,
0.03190969303250313,
-0.5774926543235779,
0.02001918852329254,
1.1252859830856323,
0.12929388880729675,
0.6728194952011108,
-0.08025755733251572,
-0.31758245825767517,
-0.4968249499797821,
0.19622687995433807,
-0.8009300827980042,
-0.7649791836738586,
0.4809834361076355,
-1.1288059949874878,
-0.7525381445884705,
0.21325956284999847,
-0.9360904693603516,
-0.38526949286460876,
-0.07524322718381882,
0.06380432099103928,
-0.15019375085830688,
-0.360246479511261,
-0.23224090039730072,
-0.9154805541038513,
0.08028443902730942,
0.021946558728814125,
-1.1375256776809692,
0.37141838669776917,
0.6438153982162476,
0.9890022873878479,
-0.48999151587486267,
-0.4228755831718445,
-0.6680675148963928,
0.039408352226018906,
0.09218458086252213,
0.9365466237068176,
-0.6517521142959595,
-0.07619660347700119,
-0.06693611294031143,
0.6239178776741028,
-0.040433499962091446,
-0.35503360629081726,
0.6943830251693726,
-0.6287219524383545,
0.17785608768463135,
-0.20565447211265564,
-0.3948046565055847,
-0.6383991241455078,
0.30956727266311646,
-1.1118781566619873,
0.8615574240684509,
0.18982751667499542,
-1.159777283668518,
0.13333983719348907,
-0.40317511558532715,
-0.3689393997192383,
0.32339322566986084,
-0.02841269224882126,
0.03411005809903145,
-0.06881588697433472,
0.19926360249519348,
0.7253620624542236,
-0.48278358578681946,
0.4089241623878479,
-0.09583877772092819,
-0.25845348834991455,
0.31835106015205383,
-0.3310585021972656,
1.0122243165969849,
0.4273909628391266,
0.10048668086528778,
0.27839338779449463,
-0.772456705570221,
0.16352589428424835,
-0.09266922622919083,
-0.2090434581041336,
-0.4395844042301178,
0.3580893278121948,
0.19341981410980225,
0.03475034236907959,
0.10454241931438446,
-0.4534378945827484,
0.4699358642101288,
-0.5122831463813782,
0.6422080397605896,
0.7018046975135803,
0.3763379752635956,
0.2818419337272644,
-0.553985059261322,
0.757045567035675,
-0.4191421568393707,
-0.11822977662086487,
-0.851405143737793,
-0.5690308809280396,
-0.7920240759849548,
-0.560335099697113,
0.3157026171684265,
0.7142624258995056,
-0.9544296264648438,
0.2526172399520874,
-0.06490221619606018,
-0.42990440130233765,
-0.5495697855949402,
-0.062056660652160645,
0.15791206061840057,
0.49151811003685,
0.27267804741859436,
-0.34292513132095337,
-0.7973476648330688,
-1.0779688358306885,
-0.46386340260505676,
-0.4775996804237366,
0.05173391103744507,
0.15820667147636414,
0.4105665385723114,
-0.46112191677093506,
1.1963176727294922,
-0.7227339148521423,
-0.2845456898212433,
-0.5771011710166931,
0.3773336410522461,
0.591002881526947,
0.3702135980129242,
0.1594967544078827,
-0.7182192206382751,
-0.6344799399375916,
0.25668346881866455,
-0.9651557803153992,
-0.3107985556125641,
-0.3129692077636719,
-0.023744257166981697,
-0.27242791652679443,
0.5888180136680603,
-0.051342178136110306,
0.3616010844707489,
0.5370700359344482,
-0.4052066504955292,
1.0509473085403442,
-0.11364413052797318,
0.17358657717704773,
-1.0539588928222656,
0.2558668255805969,
-0.3242034316062927,
-0.47694724798202515,
-0.6382227540016174,
0.3495999872684479,
-0.19324226677417755,
-0.07174499332904816,
-0.2682197391986847,
0.7123820781707764,
-0.6998013854026794,
0.010960648767650127,
0.042948462069034576,
0.03758464381098747,
0.15761327743530273,
0.39583250880241394,
0.23636235296726227,
0.3149261474609375,
0.49982312321662903,
-0.21020442247390747,
0.9335301518440247,
0.19638852775096893,
-0.0535515695810318,
0.3625538647174835,
-0.8669317960739136,
-0.038714248687028885,
-0.16837769746780396,
-0.20303358137607574,
-1.3085784912109375,
-0.37374216318130493,
0.20771855115890503,
-0.19097033143043518,
0.3299328684806824,
-0.5494743585586548,
-0.39383235573768616,
-0.30283400416374207,
-0.29999208450317383,
0.4464591145515442,
0.3506081700325012,
-0.47599825263023376,
0.5838072896003723,
0.5285241603851318,
-0.4567023515701294,
-0.8170375823974609,
-1.0443854331970215,
0.11106257885694504,
-0.24806855618953705,
-0.6881235241889954,
-0.07911378890275955,
0.265850305557251,
-0.42453572154045105,
0.0856194943189621,
0.2687460482120514,
-0.7215880155563354,
-0.21002089977264404,
0.5257631540298462,
0.10786924511194229,
-0.27377405762672424,
0.18265700340270996,
0.1592196226119995,
-0.3254918158054352,
-0.04466699808835983,
0.04700285196304321,
0.3722441792488098,
-0.009716623462736607,
-0.027996430173516273,
-0.7785483598709106,
0.3693879246711731,
0.7606551647186279,
-0.11596719175577164,
0.5440669059753418,
0.6360353231430054,
0.01823117956519127,
-0.4109300673007965,
-0.4975194036960602,
-0.355416864156723,
-0.5632392168045044,
0.2467840611934662,
-0.2418098896741867,
-0.8467658162117004,
0.6289653182029724,
-0.25626441836357117,
0.23840028047561646,
0.6419224143028259,
0.10330391675233841,
-0.20209799706935883,
0.31376564502716064,
0.5667080283164978,
-0.25870752334594727,
0.3321167826652527,
-0.3967958688735962,
0.1504315435886383,
-0.86871337890625,
-0.3865995407104492,
-0.5250875949859619,
-1.0156278610229492,
-0.49883681535720825,
-0.24699628353118896,
-0.2232835441827774,
0.14501233398914337,
-0.13941170275211334,
0.8155539035797119,
-0.7753711938858032,
0.5322420597076416,
0.39018064737319946,
-0.37949642539024353,
0.6802584528923035,
0.2923838794231415,
0.08439099788665771,
-0.3423590660095215,
-0.7071606516838074,
-0.6860190629959106,
0.8137426972389221,
0.4773470163345337,
0.9285597205162048,
-0.04552442952990532,
0.9180001020431519,
0.5867605805397034,
0.23456522822380066,
-1.0329467058181763,
0.4392760694026947,
-0.1716817021369934,
-0.8867778778076172,
-0.4145345985889435,
-0.426315039396286,
-1.1356650590896606,
0.18226155638694763,
-0.4355620741844177,
-1.018328309059143,
0.7426151633262634,
-0.23402369022369385,
-0.02088947221636772,
0.625490128993988,
-0.6665943264961243,
0.7343659400939941,
0.009661581367254257,
-0.07064568251371384,
0.04164215177297592,
-0.7257629632949829,
0.508693516254425,
0.06075545400381088,
-0.026244234293699265,
-0.06979047507047653,
0.026822853833436966,
0.8895306587219238,
-0.3126929700374603,
0.8307459950447083,
0.3209807574748993,
0.22553962469100952,
0.6527494192123413,
0.8192344307899475,
0.5195876359939575,
0.27409934997558594,
-0.36559832096099854,
0.2649129033088684,
0.6019287705421448,
0.013258458115160465,
-0.5072819590568542,
0.6593945622444153,
-0.6155686974525452,
-0.10770268738269806,
-0.7239122986793518,
-0.7705545425415039,
0.3446878492832184,
0.5784940123558044,
0.1096896156668663,
0.7793133854866028,
-0.25842151045799255,
0.12860584259033203,
0.18828758597373962,
-0.2469983845949173,
0.8625395894050598,
0.18257944285869598,
-0.5014878511428833,
-0.46335074305534363,
0.9071524739265442,
0.06281094998121262,
0.22850574553012848,
0.6349650025367737,
0.16629599034786224,
0.07882057130336761,
-0.23357999324798584,
-0.007357860449701548,
0.32149529457092285,
-0.5886933207511902,
-0.24171921610832214,
-0.8958396315574646,
-0.6123002171516418,
0.10512725263834,
-0.2762991189956665,
-0.33984819054603577,
-0.8208132982254028,
-0.4448373317718506,
-0.0010347190545871854,
0.1718217134475708,
1.065032958984375,
-0.05350508168339729,
0.16382089257240295,
-1.1910876035690308,
0.48127269744873047,
0.6638370156288147,
-0.14234468340873718,
0.03503895923495293,
-0.30418962240219116,
0.09266708791255951,
-0.3287350833415985,
-0.14723648130893707,
-0.8846405148506165,
0.9642277956008911,
0.3604177236557007,
0.4093969464302063,
0.6414975523948669,
0.05282555893063545,
0.7927542328834534,
-0.5107882022857666,
0.9215046167373657,
0.24323882162570953,
-0.6145484447479248,
0.44442319869995117,
-0.4156506061553955,
0.1513376384973526,
0.6513427495956421,
0.5527515411376953,
-0.9649166464805603,
-0.09162556380033493,
-0.7280904054641724,
-0.7380138039588928,
0.7433990836143494,
0.15818637609481812,
-0.1626785546541214,
-0.24618284404277802,
0.7431298494338989,
0.11707761883735657,
0.2653607726097107,
-0.7000085711479187,
-0.4250728189945221,
0.23908917605876923,
-0.035571563988924026,
0.26121386885643005,
-0.6779468059539795,
-0.15976953506469727,
-0.3092831075191498,
0.22751399874687195,
0.0431315116584301,
0.3686470687389374,
0.4584871828556061,
0.018567563965916634,
-0.14937035739421844,
-0.15856821835041046,
-0.00362583389505744,
0.6863711476325989,
-0.39551040530204773,
0.26840126514434814,
-0.1681799739599228,
-0.763439953327179,
0.0007728731143288314,
-0.28001171350479126,
0.0610278844833374,
0.1430802196264267,
1.2480288743972778,
0.36567801237106323,
-0.031538087874650955,
-0.6387398838996887,
0.3278108239173889,
-0.30598318576812744,
-0.14118905365467072,
-0.13298282027244568,
0.15579819679260254,
-0.19035473465919495,
0.7201939821243286,
0.40469124913215637,
0.2539435029029846,
0.23265795409679413,
-0.7232149839401245,
0.5767518281936646,
0.04451752081513405,
-0.7539897561073303,
-0.37896353006362915,
0.33684539794921875,
0.22999605536460876,
-0.7584848403930664,
1.0253931283950806,
-0.0147151043638587,
-0.21448935568332672,
0.7217917442321777,
0.5921676754951477,
1.4180866479873657,
0.16206113994121552,
0.5893476605415344,
0.6361850500106812,
0.4708563983440399,
-0.1564553827047348,
0.07524463534355164,
0.23264451324939728,
-0.7128245234489441,
-0.6380405426025391,
-0.7266881465911865,
-0.11257364600896835,
-0.2759084105491638,
-0.7950184345245361,
0.3932225704193115,
-0.4494834840297699,
-0.09031105786561966,
-0.3890513479709625,
-0.06243365257978439,
-0.23937569558620453,
-0.11829280853271484,
-0.27912193536758423,
0.9124364256858826,
-0.7038178443908691,
0.9608196020126343,
0.4795357584953308,
-0.23595410585403442,
-0.9113798141479492,
-0.14024174213409424,
0.045140381902456284,
-0.70182204246521,
1.3611106872558594,
-0.04115875065326691,
-0.02192123420536518,
0.0336192362010479,
-0.35411226749420166,
-0.9161545634269714,
1.2786072492599487,
0.24648915231227875,
-0.7038935422897339,
-0.27081629633903503,
-0.28468888998031616,
0.5900724530220032,
-0.6930955052375793,
0.37705251574516296,
0.46173354983329773,
0.5595490336418152,
-0.040209557861089706,
-0.539458692073822,
0.021746670827269554,
-0.32043546438217163,
-0.2311784029006958,
0.32981789112091064,
-0.34672221541404724,
1.0060389041900635,
0.06141671538352966,
-0.46614763140678406,
0.15264922380447388,
0.5024992823600769,
0.04784894362092018,
-0.050216928124427795,
0.26114514470100403,
0.19771191477775574,
0.8964943885803223,
-0.03828756883740425,
1.135380744934082,
-0.11485733836889267,
0.39141786098480225,
1.1494643688201904,
0.17637868225574493,
0.7599243521690369,
0.5549138188362122,
0.11447795480489731,
1.200174331665039,
0.49855345487594604,
0.07603755593299866,
0.4909566342830658,
0.06718835979700089,
0.05166114866733551,
-0.023471487686038017,
0.16229978203773499,
-0.17217740416526794,
0.2088155448436737,
0.2539367973804474,
-0.6273841857910156,
-0.03688480332493782,
-0.4683845341205597,
-0.11246462911367416,
-0.15864016115665436,
-0.21834570169448853,
0.5635908842086792,
0.22651976346969604,
-0.48239612579345703,
0.29934391379356384,
-0.17774097621440887,
0.42928752303123474,
-0.8579909205436707,
-0.2970094382762909,
-0.050033073872327805,
0.1678737998008728,
-0.7055746912956238,
-0.9739096164703369,
0.5609729290008545,
-0.350871205329895,
-0.3285537660121918,
-0.334483802318573,
1.0957955121994019,
-0.47807133197784424,
-0.46613505482673645,
0.2144080102443695,
0.3272320330142975,
0.2845916152000427,
0.2410433441400528,
-0.9391511678695679,
0.033968061208724976,
0.09593947231769562,
-0.33143582940101624,
0.057585153728723526,
0.6935639977455139,
0.2520519495010376,
0.857425332069397,
0.6902270913124084,
0.45284155011177063,
-0.19589486718177795,
-0.16031475365161896,
0.8229102492332458,
-0.7582301497459412,
-0.25424817204475403,
-1.0979607105255127,
0.8418173789978027,
-0.36711782217025757,
-0.448748916387558,
0.9211544990539551,
0.1872888207435608,
0.07197710126638412,
-0.08744331449270248,
0.622973620891571,
-0.46928295493125916,
0.27360543608665466,
-0.1410154104232788,
0.7876496315002441,
-0.3469257950782776,
0.2616136074066162,
-0.5804612636566162,
-1.1602822542190552,
-0.375383198261261,
0.6800350546836853,
0.14807188510894775,
-0.5778548121452332,
1.3341898918151855,
0.6635048389434814,
-0.15734970569610596,
0.19031572341918945,
0.15419426560401917,
0.04055585339665413,
0.4060020446777344,
0.30064448714256287,
0.5617637038230896,
-0.46921342611312866,
0.30676841735839844,
-0.0116976173594594,
-0.27963826060295105,
0.09054583311080933,
-1.1495482921600342,
-1.4170587062835693,
-0.6904630064964294,
-0.0972682312130928,
-0.25741323828697205,
0.06191527843475342,
0.5581198930740356,
0.7116336822509766,
-0.8824982047080994,
-0.7625735402107239,
-0.028441738337278366,
0.452088862657547,
-0.28876593708992004,
-0.3698112368583679,
0.4333840012550354,
-0.589864194393158,
-0.6092931628227234,
0.402882844209671,
0.581849992275238,
-0.47279229760169983,
-0.48239389061927795,
0.013647128827869892,
-0.6007595062255859,
-0.15537051856517792,
0.4870826005935669,
0.5631289482116699,
-0.19079719483852386,
-0.3995836079120636,
-0.19991256296634674,
0.08277637511491776,
-0.1697828620672226,
1.169305682182312,
-0.7617424726486206,
0.9105902314186096,
1.3054505586624146,
0.546923041343689,
0.6846494078636169,
-0.041990939527750015,
1.0468881130218506,
-0.7042750120162964,
0.36807289719581604,
0.24378111958503723,
0.2693338990211487,
-0.05561419948935509,
-0.4471343457698822,
0.8034942746162415,
0.5857680439949036,
-0.9497070908546448,
-0.80876225233078,
0.4256994128227234,
-0.8563756346702576,
-0.43033915758132935,
1.0745601654052734,
-0.163311168551445,
-0.35988521575927734,
-0.451066792011261,
-0.44663456082344055,
-0.12754221260547638,
-0.23822933435440063,
0.32993850111961365,
0.6476295590400696,
-0.1560986489057541,
-0.2850698232650757,
-0.7110354900360107,
0.6242717504501343,
-0.20456057786941528,
-0.5570091605186462,
0.04992905631661415,
0.14365693926811218,
0.05054480955004692,
0.32923638820648193,
0.608963131904602,
-0.2694232761859894,
-0.24621573090553284,
-0.08916783332824707,
0.16161122918128967,
-0.2952054440975189,
-0.5572444200515747,
0.022708725184202194,
0.5920692682266235,
-0.3080117106437683,
0.19760072231292725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02273v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02273v1 | Multilingual Trolley Problems for Language Models | 2024-07-02T14:02:53 | 2024-07-02T14:02:53 | Zhijing Jin, Sydney Levine, Max Kleiman-Weiner, Giorgio Piatti, Jiarui Liu, Fernando Gonzalez Adauto, Francesco Ortu, András Strausz, Mrinmaya Sachan, Rada Mihalcea, Yejin Choi, Bernhard Schölkopf | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) are deployed in more and more real-world
situations, it is crucial to understand their decision-making when faced with
moral dilemmas. Inspired by a large-scale cross-cultural study of human moral
preferences, "The Moral Machine Experiment", we set up the same set of moral
choices for LLMs. We translate 1K vignettes of moral dilemmas, parametrically
varied across key axes, into 100+ languages, and reveal the preferences of LLMs
in each of these languages. We then compare the responses of LLMs to that of
human speakers of those languages, harnessing a dataset of 40 million human
moral judgments. We discover that LLMs are more aligned with human preferences
in languages such as English, Korean, Hungarian, and Chinese, but less aligned
in languages such as Hindi and Somali (in Africa). Moreover, we characterize
the explanations LLMs give for their moral choices and find that fairness is
the most dominant supporting reason behind GPT-4's decisions and utilitarianism
by GPT-3. We also discover "language inequality" (which we define as the
model's different development levels in different languages) in a series of
meta-properties of moral decision making. | [
-0.456519216299057,
-0.4725695550441742,
0.7022839784622192,
0.39125287532806396,
0.007195464801043272,
0.048944469541311264,
-0.27180665731430054,
-0.5434832572937012,
-0.005257276818156242,
0.5300864577293396,
-0.2726927101612091,
-0.116860032081604,
-0.549249529838562,
0.24338383972644806,
-0.17783401906490326,
1.0278527736663818,
0.01334222499281168,
0.6428675651550293,
-0.16482536494731903,
-0.4987436532974243,
-0.2276591658592224,
-0.830255389213562,
-0.8678836822509766,
-0.49827098846435547,
0.7337350845336914,
0.39583438634872437,
0.7931625247001648,
0.22455529868602753,
0.5712223052978516,
0.37632250785827637,
-0.19075742363929749,
-0.18151147663593292,
-0.22913116216659546,
-0.17542727291584015,
-0.4085691571235657,
-0.4335876703262329,
-0.3929998278617859,
0.11692163348197937,
0.2002822607755661,
0.6442891359329224,
-0.13005080819129944,
0.3080293536186218,
-0.00001486416113039013,
0.771187424659729,
-0.4763074219226837,
0.03022674284875393,
-0.4404619336128235,
0.11314834654331207,
-0.14612746238708496,
0.24923677742481232,
-0.27923285961151123,
-0.6573140621185303,
-0.11053688079118729,
-0.20957176387310028,
0.031933046877384186,
0.057306475937366486,
1.0157121419906616,
0.027426043525338173,
-0.8961845636367798,
-0.49871188402175903,
-0.5803035497665405,
1.061092495918274,
-0.5622522830963135,
0.34438320994377136,
0.4397854506969452,
0.20200783014297485,
-0.008410472422838211,
-0.33088818192481995,
-0.8513402938842773,
-0.14221030473709106,
-0.0772261992096901,
0.1641741245985031,
0.07463845610618591,
-0.045494444668293,
0.1536066234111786,
0.08557365834712982,
-0.5866238474845886,
0.233025461435318,
-0.3768654763698578,
-0.09527133405208588,
0.6475691795349121,
0.20733658969402313,
0.2603541612625122,
-0.4595940411090851,
-0.255776971578598,
-0.1729566603899002,
-0.523180365562439,
0.2091059386730194,
0.8390513062477112,
0.1361023187637329,
-0.1730256825685501,
0.5296039581298828,
0.38505616784095764,
0.69123375415802,
-0.19312834739685059,
-0.2508730888366699,
0.3502384126186371,
-0.4016324281692505,
-0.1782095730304718,
-0.1271546632051468,
0.9277502298355103,
0.7265216708183289,
0.8570929169654846,
0.4381048381328583,
-0.3746338486671448,
-0.04110145941376686,
0.021347304806113243,
-0.4794287085533142,
0.18242575228214264,
0.2382207214832306,
-0.4806751310825348,
-0.2494056224822998,
-0.2054556906223297,
-0.7910588979721069,
-0.4271072447299957,
-0.3631240725517273,
0.056913044303655624,
-0.2401152104139328,
-0.3586882948875427,
0.5680079460144043,
0.0917394608259201,
0.4577440321445465,
0.19323159754276276,
-0.9142588376998901,
-0.18068550527095795,
0.44959723949432373,
0.7691388726234436,
0.059628721326589584,
-0.2455749213695526,
-0.35061413049697876,
0.14584515988826752,
-0.28019285202026367,
0.7520327568054199,
-0.6468993425369263,
-0.5696945190429688,
0.08856198191642761,
0.15674537420272827,
-0.05040900036692619,
-0.33151644468307495,
0.8914065957069397,
-0.22513394057750702,
0.1824081540107727,
-0.5683261156082153,
-0.022093428298830986,
-0.28191056847572327,
0.38057562708854675,
-0.6059002876281738,
0.7421600818634033,
-0.13774451613426208,
-0.6729441285133362,
0.20861274003982544,
-0.5583862662315369,
-0.5166196227073669,
-0.2782363295555115,
-0.25471144914627075,
-0.3391566574573517,
0.22409483790397644,
0.0731864795088768,
0.30880358815193176,
-0.3912675380706787,
0.6738379001617432,
-0.4166939854621887,
-0.003588574705645442,
0.20902730524539948,
-0.5375281572341919,
1.2372121810913086,
0.3233545124530792,
0.03854988142848015,
0.028080157935619354,
-0.43360528349876404,
-0.031250204890966415,
0.41130128502845764,
-0.3909858465194702,
-0.5149564743041992,
0.1543322652578354,
0.20160487294197083,
0.49117720127105713,
0.38276076316833496,
-0.46450379490852356,
0.18642102181911469,
-0.20167545974254608,
0.3988446891307831,
1.0088666677474976,
-0.5735423564910889,
0.28119006752967834,
-0.3095448911190033,
0.6510463953018188,
0.007311579771339893,
0.5245888233184814,
0.2184067815542221,
-0.6252953410148621,
-1.1135855913162231,
0.2597699463367462,
0.02594991773366928,
0.760667085647583,
-0.6515377759933472,
0.0487632118165493,
-0.023923009634017944,
-0.11628285050392151,
-0.4410296082496643,
-0.08797458559274673,
0.47689399123191833,
0.16939085721969604,
0.15400636196136475,
-0.10904117673635483,
-0.508805513381958,
-1.27970552444458,
-0.3445490598678589,
-0.3967522382736206,
0.1021256074309349,
0.37023285031318665,
0.7162501811981201,
-0.21474681794643402,
0.7564623951911926,
-0.3486027121543884,
-0.20548772811889648,
-0.35354650020599365,
-0.11854972690343857,
0.37953805923461914,
0.335970401763916,
0.8054448366165161,
-0.8645023703575134,
-0.3660971522331238,
0.3924049437046051,
-0.6338819861412048,
-0.08091168105602264,
0.02434373088181019,
-0.04228280857205391,
0.22390693426132202,
0.28241023421287537,
-0.37852612137794495,
0.07603789865970612,
0.8343909978866577,
-0.25862255692481995,
0.7173250913619995,
-0.33611345291137695,
0.07507643848657608,
-1.0520403385162354,
-0.265498548746109,
-0.032287996262311935,
-0.06658273190259933,
-0.42104238271713257,
-0.07014014571905136,
0.09864560514688492,
0.03975167125463486,
-0.5485137104988098,
0.6013690233230591,
-0.24979069828987122,
-0.24702171981334686,
0.13328012824058533,
0.42264842987060547,
-0.02654142677783966,
0.48770803213119507,
-0.18385429680347443,
0.8094646334648132,
0.40051957964897156,
-0.5911768674850464,
0.2714988589286804,
0.3188479244709015,
-0.19390347599983215,
0.6988508701324463,
-0.6024507880210876,
0.028283940628170967,
-0.2741655111312866,
0.10815467685461044,
-0.6868919134140015,
-0.11894406378269196,
0.0628931075334549,
-0.28122678399086,
-0.21212980151176453,
-0.22583088278770447,
-0.5196871757507324,
-0.5092377066612244,
-0.11246058344841003,
0.433754563331604,
0.3154027760028839,
-0.430117130279541,
0.6186317205429077,
0.6649313569068909,
-0.18340684473514557,
-0.8999781012535095,
-0.6198484897613525,
0.1286391168832779,
-0.39903777837753296,
-0.6844952702522278,
-0.23690563440322876,
-0.23324252665042877,
-0.5526328086853027,
-0.31446531414985657,
-0.0056960140354931355,
-0.11461913585662842,
0.024501506239175797,
-0.23699422180652618,
0.09746313840150833,
0.032554078847169876,
0.20116077363491058,
0.06284423917531967,
-0.2441297173500061,
0.20804305374622345,
-0.4773321747779846,
0.562023401260376,
-0.650077760219574,
-0.44019562005996704,
0.06790103763341904,
0.4932625889778137,
0.5431789755821228,
-0.45265504717826843,
0.42129096388816833,
0.6686972975730896,
-0.13498859107494354,
0.24377493560314178,
-0.4551403820514679,
0.25867947936058044,
-0.5487250089645386,
0.2329692840576172,
-0.4100542366504669,
-0.933113694190979,
0.7394484281539917,
0.19564568996429443,
0.12600396573543549,
0.2424713671207428,
0.6373316645622253,
-0.15707749128341675,
1.309821367263794,
0.6209014058113098,
0.07086321711540222,
0.4058501422405243,
-0.16710057854652405,
0.384006530046463,
-0.507300078868866,
-0.26560738682746887,
-0.8218514919281006,
-0.2931549549102783,
-0.9829368591308594,
-0.4092917740345001,
0.4906778633594513,
0.1286541223526001,
-0.5311381816864014,
0.135976180434227,
-0.26352256536483765,
0.8038374185562134,
0.3057417571544647,
-0.342540979385376,
0.5623862147331238,
-0.043216731399297714,
-0.6020389795303345,
-0.07229653745889664,
-0.6672742366790771,
-0.9331642389297485,
0.7363983988761902,
-0.011376379989087582,
0.7268386483192444,
0.47818100452423096,
0.40391355752944946,
-0.0585014671087265,
0.2559165060520172,
-0.6749574542045593,
0.6119859218597412,
-0.5677683353424072,
-0.7177072763442993,
-0.03336481750011444,
-0.338226318359375,
-1.1066120862960815,
0.41865143179893494,
0.037648044526576996,
-0.6606351137161255,
0.2877156436443329,
0.03458559885621071,
-0.1465977281332016,
0.5548926591873169,
-0.7452890276908875,
0.7699246406555176,
-0.8333005309104919,
-0.3280184268951416,
-0.22563429176807404,
-0.7236020565032959,
0.6275477409362793,
-0.16786345839500427,
0.7276285886764526,
-0.25989362597465515,
0.0913846418261528,
0.6258453726768494,
-0.2669340968132019,
0.710442066192627,
0.15627847611904144,
-0.5970572233200073,
0.03451215475797653,
0.13971249759197235,
0.4289870262145996,
0.38197198510169983,
-0.18009309470653534,
0.3312557637691498,
-0.05041699483990669,
-0.49698930978775024,
-0.3615393340587616,
0.7427934408187866,
-0.7762147188186646,
-0.9753538966178894,
-0.6049791574478149,
-0.4201364517211914,
-0.16255076229572296,
0.2567319869995117,
0.12651541829109192,
0.21748441457748413,
-0.018055448308587074,
0.026609402149915695,
0.4258812665939331,
-0.8351916670799255,
0.7138052582740784,
0.6000438332557678,
-0.7334216833114624,
-0.2937873303890228,
0.7767518758773804,
-0.11437323689460754,
0.5263053178787231,
0.1269841492176056,
0.38229799270629883,
-0.4082556664943695,
-0.4035695493221283,
-0.5775882005691528,
0.3260931670665741,
-0.7487598061561584,
-0.002854393096640706,
-0.6924952268600464,
0.0681719034910202,
0.05782555043697357,
-0.4594815671443939,
-0.49074649810791016,
-0.23866738379001617,
-0.13583797216415405,
-0.1053086519241333,
0.36133572459220886,
0.9887407422065735,
-0.30167698860168457,
0.25023573637008667,
-0.9159825444221497,
0.12331759184598923,
0.17986273765563965,
0.4492814242839813,
-0.005044056102633476,
-0.28387680649757385,
-0.3010728061199188,
0.10656208544969559,
-0.45942020416259766,
-0.6373119354248047,
0.34641337394714355,
-0.33309808373451233,
0.3794243633747101,
0.4908161759376526,
-0.05832726135849953,
0.8259812593460083,
-0.57030189037323,
0.724307119846344,
0.3200652301311493,
-1.0931049585342407,
0.16766342520713806,
-0.5281043648719788,
-0.0800708457827568,
0.27849823236465454,
0.4498523473739624,
-0.7852009534835815,
-0.484789103269577,
-0.34332969784736633,
-0.7849531173706055,
0.6159092783927917,
0.35961025953292847,
0.46019959449768066,
-0.266377329826355,
0.11321058869361877,
0.03636042773723602,
0.026718685403466225,
-1.1878365278244019,
-0.27327361702919006,
-0.22065682709217072,
-0.05156230553984642,
-0.2274622768163681,
-0.07535573095083237,
-0.04304305836558342,
-0.26371636986732483,
0.32724711298942566,
-0.07738246768712997,
0.027051083743572235,
0.05488022789359093,
-0.08157774806022644,
-0.05298866331577301,
0.4310399889945984,
0.8412966728210449,
0.8215983510017395,
0.10205411911010742,
0.06137744337320328,
0.37151235342025757,
-0.3658932149410248,
0.5576591491699219,
-0.3470010459423065,
0.0616820864379406,
-0.05381544679403305,
0.27749961614608765,
0.7473948001861572,
-0.03355592116713524,
-0.8028636574745178,
0.34472402930259705,
-0.36213403940200806,
-0.08901384472846985,
-0.6348093152046204,
-0.024372976273298264,
0.35686320066452026,
0.3308252990245819,
0.19894295930862427,
0.0081721106544137,
-0.04616212099790573,
-0.40647149085998535,
-0.006686185486614704,
0.5989835858345032,
-0.34424278140068054,
-0.20369504392147064,
0.6818463802337646,
0.4639616012573242,
-0.6480441093444824,
0.5427233576774597,
-0.3789781928062439,
-0.7376629710197449,
0.7515830993652344,
0.2641180157661438,
0.7710029482841492,
-0.2449164092540741,
0.43782779574394226,
0.3422337472438812,
0.5914056897163391,
-0.23819813132286072,
0.34395021200180054,
0.4818267226219177,
-1.0902997255325317,
-0.6257756352424622,
-0.69899582862854,
-0.31747058033943176,
0.0647607296705246,
-0.7370060682296753,
0.3804292678833008,
-0.13029031455516815,
-0.31559979915618896,
-0.47874709963798523,
-0.1360466182231903,
-0.5167869925498962,
-0.10153613984584808,
-0.19824738800525665,
0.35339486598968506,
-0.7243813276290894,
0.837264358997345,
0.5745061039924622,
-0.5202136635780334,
-0.5920950174331665,
0.036095865070819855,
-0.15618835389614105,
-0.7923318147659302,
0.787194013595581,
0.07893657684326172,
-0.33326461911201477,
0.019916027784347534,
-0.41979584097862244,
-0.703803300857544,
0.7070125937461853,
0.6270602941513062,
-0.8510096669197083,
0.011066234670579433,
0.2681746184825897,
0.4993513524532318,
-0.20815351605415344,
0.3162015974521637,
0.602938711643219,
0.8965906500816345,
-0.2780054211616516,
-1.1241179704666138,
-0.38122671842575073,
0.02643786557018757,
-0.022335883229970932,
0.4821411073207855,
-0.9765167832374573,
1.1227970123291016,
-0.5904435515403748,
-0.13877208530902863,
-0.09034755080938339,
0.19373245537281036,
0.33764442801475525,
0.27324169874191284,
0.6282486915588379,
0.32118934392929077,
0.7605317831039429,
-0.1176963746547699,
1.2413278818130493,
-0.22248929738998413,
0.6690530776977539,
0.8159140348434448,
-0.5601019263267517,
0.30273324251174927,
0.5236740112304688,
-0.2024690806865692,
0.37584900856018066,
0.6643339991569519,
0.14166754484176636,
0.025653861463069916,
0.26873764395713806,
-0.08179105818271637,
-0.4538317322731018,
-0.24148115515708923,
-0.292269229888916,
0.5620304942131042,
0.22817738354206085,
-0.019584177061915398,
-0.17876718938350677,
0.10995558649301529,
0.2680104970932007,
0.05210713669657707,
-0.1909712255001068,
0.44206884503364563,
0.24164806306362152,
-0.3941923677921295,
0.6611073017120361,
0.12266410887241364,
0.5262042284011841,
-0.5013846158981323,
0.2929610013961792,
-0.4914065897464752,
0.19706620275974274,
-0.09843556582927704,
-1.0876028537750244,
0.2868455946445465,
0.23376969993114471,
-0.09030786156654358,
-0.39634960889816284,
0.11600018292665482,
-0.4201356768608093,
-0.7575433254241943,
0.8338221311569214,
0.8072104454040527,
0.1995784193277359,
0.49000513553619385,
-0.9108690023422241,
-0.02472926862537861,
0.21236573159694672,
-0.22981251776218414,
0.2761181890964508,
0.6091372966766357,
-0.4719144403934479,
0.9840790629386902,
0.7408811450004578,
-0.11575666069984436,
-0.1641036719083786,
0.28282955288887024,
0.5272459983825684,
-1.0214987993240356,
-0.3697631359100342,
-0.9685126543045044,
0.42825832962989807,
-0.027012314647436142,
-0.379127562046051,
0.6572632193565369,
0.4454905390739441,
1.1360251903533936,
-0.147419735789299,
0.88886559009552,
0.019499901682138443,
-0.05041517689824104,
-0.8000196218490601,
0.6282203793525696,
-0.7943114042282104,
0.4053850471973419,
-0.4011722207069397,
-0.720445454120636,
-0.17060428857803345,
0.9057644009590149,
-0.3157435655593872,
0.37791338562965393,
0.983119547367096,
0.7281920313835144,
0.05407150089740753,
-0.026408489793539047,
0.4058741629123688,
0.22296768426895142,
0.4685611128807068,
0.7768567204475403,
1.1141949892044067,
-0.21197594702243805,
0.8247092962265015,
0.1518055945634842,
0.23031064867973328,
0.0685306116938591,
-0.9646170139312744,
-0.9053089022636414,
-0.5306736826896667,
0.12529809772968292,
-0.29408878087997437,
-0.06967636197805405,
0.800591230392456,
0.35111358761787415,
-0.7525513768196106,
-0.8204776048660278,
0.07312856614589691,
0.814487874507904,
0.04596203565597534,
-0.16771844029426575,
0.13366182148456573,
-0.1810712069272995,
-1.0306013822555542,
-0.06310328841209412,
0.24486464262008667,
0.1633606106042862,
-0.41394805908203125,
-0.2650240957736969,
-0.3577563762664795,
0.15592113137245178,
0.768808126449585,
-0.2560671269893646,
-0.8032216429710388,
-0.48929858207702637,
-0.1088993176817894,
-0.08283344656229019,
0.22409123182296753,
1.1687650680541992,
-0.2596627473831177,
0.19980348646640778,
0.322295606136322,
0.2424853891134262,
0.23933276534080505,
-0.2409764975309372,
0.8013924360275269,
-0.42910847067832947,
0.35702788829803467,
0.2307506948709488,
0.6182363629341125,
0.3446909487247467,
0.004418238531798124,
0.4964946210384369,
0.16423501074314117,
-0.6320245265960693,
-0.7300567030906677,
0.6507830619812012,
-0.6018924713134766,
-0.3561665117740631,
1.2223228216171265,
0.07814037799835205,
0.07114644348621368,
-0.44588589668273926,
-0.26982930302619934,
0.09014138579368591,
-0.4233876168727875,
0.4573928713798523,
0.9626670479774475,
-0.04823983088135719,
-0.04142743721604347,
-0.987602949142456,
0.41002336144447327,
0.45045578479766846,
-0.5998647212982178,
0.06935302168130875,
0.5360295176506042,
0.15547186136245728,
0.09366631507873535,
0.40745651721954346,
-0.0767681896686554,
-0.13728250563144684,
-0.5060551166534424,
0.26154249906539917,
0.3219095766544342,
-0.23631030321121216,
-0.41041189432144165,
0.0009122038609348238,
-0.10896424204111099,
0.283698171377182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02243v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02243v1 | Robust Zero-Shot Text-to-Speech Synthesis with Reverse Inference Optimization | 2024-07-02T13:04:04 | 2024-07-02T13:04:04 | Yuchen Hu, Chen Chen, Siyin Wang, Eng Siong Chng, Chao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | In this paper, we propose reverse inference optimization (RIO), a simple and
effective method designed to enhance the robustness of
autoregressive-model-based zero-shot text-to-speech (TTS) systems using
reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF). To assess the quality of
speech produced by the TTS system without human annotations, RIO introduces a
novel concept termed as reverse inference based on the Bayesian principle,
which suggests that a high-quality generated speech should be able to be used
as a prompt for subsequent generation using the same TTS model. By leveraging
reverse inference as the standard to select exemplars used in RLHF from the
speech samples generated by the TTS system itself, RIO steers the subsequent
optimization towards a direction of enhancing the TTS robustness. The RIO
framework, comprising sampling, automatic annotating, and learning, obviates
the need for a reward model or pairwise preference data, and significantly
improves the stability of zero-shot TTS performance by reducing the
discrepancies between training and inference conditions. Our experimental
results verify that RIO can effectively improve both subjective and objective
metrics, including mean opinion scores, word error rates, and speaker
similarity. Remarkably, RIO can also diminish the incidence of bad outputs to
nearly zero percent, rivalling the robustness when using ground-truth speech as
the prompt. | [
-0.3510698080062866,
-0.8750119805335999,
0.4029688239097595,
0.07735365629196167,
-0.48936647176742554,
0.046847496181726456,
-0.02858917973935604,
-0.1884276568889618,
0.19604909420013428,
0.5247559547424316,
-0.7327878475189209,
-0.6324223875999451,
-0.410601943731308,
0.058115217834711075,
-0.4390604496002197,
1.1664518117904663,
0.38649046421051025,
0.01473951991647482,
0.17527423799037933,
0.013712726533412933,
-0.3124445676803589,
-0.30362698435783386,
-0.8388128280639648,
-0.26020383834838867,
0.5756755471229553,
0.28032147884368896,
0.5666625499725342,
0.6803967952728271,
-0.22609493136405945,
0.14347237348556519,
0.022971905767917633,
-0.059792108833789825,
-0.5016667246818542,
0.5576254725456238,
-0.3398174047470093,
-0.3064189851284027,
-0.20894655585289001,
-0.11000292748212814,
0.6280797719955444,
0.32829269766807556,
-0.10340792685747147,
0.20894058048725128,
-0.018264230340719223,
0.3713405430316925,
-0.9443932771682739,
-0.20661906898021698,
-0.6394786834716797,
0.17024382948875427,
0.31327998638153076,
-0.3384523391723633,
-0.42797204852104187,
-0.5232887864112854,
-0.008320304565131664,
-0.4182758629322052,
0.3483937978744507,
-0.06784671545028687,
0.713165819644928,
0.4769684374332428,
-0.0179921705275774,
0.2872603237628937,
-1.0227333307266235,
1.0402190685272217,
-1.0501943826675415,
0.6990945339202881,
0.2892198860645294,
0.1952638030052185,
-0.23844754695892334,
-0.35831132531166077,
-0.6089850664138794,
-0.42153069376945496,
0.22492843866348267,
0.4335747957229614,
-0.04112323746085167,
0.24750755727291107,
0.0476040244102478,
-0.1812152862548828,
-0.6939912438392639,
0.18883877992630005,
-0.10136767476797104,
-0.3012571632862091,
0.6379479765892029,
-0.015234707854688168,
0.15335436165332794,
-0.01893816702067852,
-0.12875935435295105,
-0.33734622597694397,
-0.9079193472862244,
-0.20375393331050873,
0.5180640816688538,
0.6619685292243958,
0.03353600576519966,
0.4101746678352356,
-0.27887994050979614,
0.7350565791130066,
-0.04195816442370415,
-0.40195658802986145,
0.12311206012964249,
-0.0679812878370285,
-0.4406099319458008,
0.09082101285457611,
0.8857958912849426,
0.11155101656913757,
0.03260944411158562,
-0.408952534198761,
-0.32971081137657166,
0.11615262925624847,
0.31631600856781006,
-0.6802597045898438,
0.2624419331550598,
0.5231828689575195,
-0.11815948784351349,
-0.5397112965583801,
-0.017392434179782867,
-0.981230616569519,
-0.1065087765455246,
-0.16694124042987823,
0.7095257639884949,
-0.18647843599319458,
-0.10184476524591446,
-0.17161288857460022,
-0.24432070553302765,
0.17251457273960114,
0.22216302156448364,
-0.8191215991973877,
-0.04917523264884949,
0.5859487056732178,
0.7011756896972656,
-0.016898395493626595,
-0.47719866037368774,
-0.9504685401916504,
0.28644460439682007,
-0.6648662686347961,
0.8098474740982056,
-0.2035302072763443,
-0.6882719397544861,
-0.18810680508613586,
-0.2937583029270172,
-0.06472866237163544,
-0.2659775912761688,
0.7648751735687256,
-0.27162638306617737,
0.4639517366886139,
0.20304672420024872,
-0.1457986980676651,
0.09994341433048248,
0.15169492363929749,
-0.23661597073078156,
0.8683616518974304,
-0.1076875552535057,
-0.5069038271903992,
0.4386676847934723,
-0.3911541998386383,
-0.5927734971046448,
-0.3369244635105133,
-0.23588481545448303,
-0.6840814352035522,
0.13153968751430511,
0.3896470069885254,
0.09808913618326187,
-0.28612464666366577,
0.425279825925827,
-0.4261894226074219,
-0.5163472294807434,
-0.04047510027885437,
-0.6132888197898865,
0.5103482604026794,
0.47042450308799744,
-0.5399610996246338,
0.2584620714187622,
-0.7460465431213379,
0.10586251318454742,
-0.06281977891921997,
-0.26684629917144775,
-0.036937467753887177,
0.19892965257167816,
-0.18121661245822906,
-0.03474403917789459,
-0.32428592443466187,
-0.6689488291740417,
0.0030999230220913887,
-0.8423065543174744,
0.4187523126602173,
0.4892801344394684,
0.2787635326385498,
0.4012995660305023,
-0.27507543563842773,
0.6767598986625671,
-0.21374134719371796,
0.1898721605539322,
-0.09396602213382721,
-0.3867625296115875,
-0.3910590708255768,
-0.3080376982688904,
0.4458985924720764,
0.8300058841705322,
-0.7915498614311218,
0.5153034329414368,
-0.17636646330356598,
-0.5130345821380615,
-0.6461562514305115,
-0.34317171573638916,
0.5756775140762329,
1.0200090408325195,
0.37492313981056213,
-0.23034147918224335,
-0.5133758187294006,
-0.8621383905410767,
-0.42840805649757385,
-0.5678348541259766,
-0.28868040442466736,
0.035025764256715775,
0.32849806547164917,
0.03311794996261597,
1.0661077499389648,
-0.2964215576648712,
-0.045311763882637024,
-0.2943044900894165,
0.5616323947906494,
0.1463489830493927,
0.5572842955589294,
0.4510299861431122,
-0.4784148633480072,
0.027938487008213997,
-0.3496829867362976,
-0.3447986841201782,
-0.49393680691719055,
-0.3812648355960846,
-0.07841414958238602,
0.4562240242958069,
0.38875338435173035,
-0.25615179538726807,
0.5995854735374451,
0.3270016014575958,
-0.025757141411304474,
0.5451814532279968,
-0.10343772917985916,
0.34382572770118713,
-0.8548786044120789,
0.21087469160556793,
-0.001911501749418676,
-0.17207199335098267,
-0.4838729500770569,
-0.09889451414346695,
-0.3551366925239563,
-0.2643479108810425,
-0.4584547281265259,
0.5509974956512451,
-0.13280145823955536,
-0.27835729718208313,
-0.29644492268562317,
0.3712172210216522,
0.24372638761997223,
0.5788798332214355,
0.34642493724823,
1.0045139789581299,
0.38542354106903076,
-0.45984408259391785,
0.10116687417030334,
0.17745506763458252,
-0.014599950052797794,
0.6183778047561646,
-0.8561668395996094,
0.14270217716693878,
-0.3773905634880066,
0.3212636411190033,
-1.1575713157653809,
0.012077158316969872,
0.38877034187316895,
-0.952593207359314,
0.40200275182724,
-0.36672186851501465,
-0.04066096991300583,
-0.17247682809829712,
-0.5551545023918152,
0.03927163779735565,
0.6101437211036682,
-0.32274478673934937,
0.4934423267841339,
0.3007926940917969,
-0.23825545608997345,
-0.7630516886711121,
-0.9907779693603516,
0.17178697884082794,
-0.3657465875148773,
-0.19828324019908905,
0.316135048866272,
0.32373908162117004,
0.07235126197338104,
-0.18398460745811462,
-0.10437961667776108,
-0.00017064204439520836,
-0.025812435895204544,
0.09520172327756882,
0.17552797496318817,
-0.057433318346738815,
0.08703060448169708,
0.5867871642112732,
-0.2848864197731018,
-0.13264937698841095,
-0.4210870563983917,
0.14147497713565826,
0.2541472911834717,
-0.28320199251174927,
-0.635692834854126,
0.3986715078353882,
0.4971829354763031,
0.05387101694941521,
0.41287532448768616,
0.593396008014679,
-0.09057192504405975,
-0.28618165850639343,
-0.3137645423412323,
-0.5340932607650757,
-0.354985773563385,
0.33896604180336,
-0.2900192141532898,
-0.633102536201477,
0.25419750809669495,
0.10143876820802689,
0.14585699141025543,
0.26357588171958923,
0.452654629945755,
0.02325933426618576,
1.0484071969985962,
0.13749518990516663,
-0.2531517446041107,
0.6631452441215515,
-0.1624734103679657,
0.08111970871686935,
-0.6621890068054199,
0.12049825489521027,
-0.8497902750968933,
-0.07322794944047928,
-0.6291247606277466,
-0.01211653184145689,
0.4495002031326294,
0.012845869176089764,
-0.6306121349334717,
0.5018119215965271,
-0.6799554824829102,
0.17105579376220703,
1.051729440689087,
0.1287791132926941,
0.21301232278347015,
0.06664974987506866,
-0.12682782113552094,
0.04127079248428345,
-0.7885417342185974,
-0.4855581223964691,
0.9177699089050293,
0.16729500889778137,
0.8787418603897095,
-0.030338581651449203,
1.092805027961731,
0.358288437128067,
0.1775016039609909,
-0.7474673390388489,
0.4564450979232788,
0.2366379052400589,
-0.5147972702980042,
-0.579136848449707,
-0.5355995297431946,
-0.9486963748931885,
0.2962770164012909,
-0.5354140996932983,
-0.9414042234420776,
0.034350115805864334,
0.3544592559337616,
-0.6397495269775391,
0.0739721730351448,
-0.7512875199317932,
0.637797474861145,
-0.08604519069194794,
-0.8485726714134216,
-0.08602046966552734,
-1.0096112489700317,
0.0006911168457008898,
0.23494137823581696,
0.17388562858104706,
0.20647579431533813,
0.07498661428689957,
0.8598933219909668,
-0.1327681541442871,
0.7743021845817566,
-0.31612107157707214,
-0.2092859297990799,
0.6303098201751709,
0.191409170627594,
0.4468245804309845,
0.14569374918937683,
-0.12711003422737122,
0.016925135627388954,
0.20367646217346191,
-0.24853305518627167,
-0.8413168787956238,
0.5718073844909668,
-0.8202539682388306,
-0.708764910697937,
-0.17360644042491913,
-0.06119837611913681,
-0.631377100944519,
0.18822139501571655,
0.422133207321167,
0.5033959746360779,
-0.14292562007904053,
-0.02853209711611271,
0.3158476948738098,
-0.502180278301239,
0.5941441655158997,
0.33375826478004456,
-0.1201101690530777,
-1.1465985774993896,
0.9020851850509644,
-0.008538898080587387,
0.312378466129303,
0.6619222164154053,
0.34701868891716003,
-0.696433424949646,
-0.821830153465271,
-0.7962334752082825,
0.28367143869400024,
-0.24554377794265747,
-0.23520267009735107,
-0.2748754024505615,
0.038484856486320496,
-0.721818745136261,
-0.17872847616672516,
-0.45417410135269165,
-0.6998003125190735,
-0.4734078347682953,
-0.1826392114162445,
-0.08746171742677689,
0.28543052077293396,
-0.24555575847625732,
0.5348120331764221,
-0.9742289781570435,
0.5101385712623596,
0.23331734538078308,
0.18914632499217987,
-0.1870003193616867,
-0.9613938331604004,
-0.026682212948799133,
0.2866443991661072,
-0.48531848192214966,
-1.0629863739013672,
0.5311691761016846,
0.042602017521858215,
0.5405243635177612,
0.294705331325531,
0.31056854128837585,
0.5428054928779602,
-0.14300109446048737,
0.9170213937759399,
0.15846878290176392,
-0.9749512672424316,
0.7915992140769958,
-0.5657270550727844,
0.2110576629638672,
0.5479700565338135,
-0.06335613131523132,
-0.334102988243103,
-0.5631091594696045,
-0.6655498743057251,
-0.847919225692749,
0.6957168579101562,
0.3017527163028717,
0.026243003085255623,
0.0687682256102562,
0.327922523021698,
-0.003858000272884965,
0.38488996028900146,
-0.5796642303466797,
0.004271600861102343,
-0.41372352838516235,
-0.16093480587005615,
0.062446486204862595,
-0.11141173541545868,
-0.06899640709161758,
-0.07039951533079147,
1.1352370977401733,
-0.18201056122779846,
0.31642019748687744,
0.5021592974662781,
0.22442030906677246,
-0.21044018864631653,
0.5227277874946594,
0.9317817091941833,
0.4094853699207306,
-0.36108946800231934,
0.0006092478288337588,
0.1936555653810501,
-0.3331272304058075,
0.17982473969459534,
-0.0978442057967186,
-0.49042728543281555,
-0.06497079879045486,
0.32262325286865234,
0.9353742003440857,
-0.10420403629541397,
-0.5547600984573364,
0.28981682658195496,
0.18099577724933624,
-0.20703448355197906,
0.023293770849704742,
0.21422404050827026,
-0.2570699155330658,
0.2488783746957779,
0.37549424171447754,
-0.09279458224773407,
0.13235360383987427,
-0.3426627814769745,
0.2068159431219101,
0.4389364421367645,
-0.3986440598964691,
-0.2739206552505493,
0.974840521812439,
0.23200438916683197,
-0.5443149209022522,
0.21900349855422974,
-0.04940580949187279,
-0.27594900131225586,
0.39609232544898987,
0.5031532645225525,
1.2674742937088013,
-0.19863873720169067,
0.4231097102165222,
0.507819414138794,
0.30317485332489014,
-0.1053944081068039,
0.2562065124511719,
-0.31614089012145996,
-0.6024749279022217,
-0.6245231032371521,
-0.4374292492866516,
-0.7575997114181519,
0.11324065178632736,
-0.5086547136306763,
0.41472792625427246,
-0.31119900941848755,
-0.4285159707069397,
-0.34357428550720215,
-0.2531059682369232,
0.14066213369369507,
0.6575405597686768,
0.04503026232123375,
0.4469837546348572,
-0.7666894793510437,
0.7609376907348633,
0.323818176984787,
-0.4902806878089905,
-0.5624544024467468,
0.0041127391159534454,
-0.14836961030960083,
-0.711940348148346,
0.3050571382045746,
-0.2957465648651123,
-0.6060039401054382,
0.16046909987926483,
-0.6638774871826172,
-0.5100083351135254,
0.8755298852920532,
0.7331815361976624,
-0.5095705986022949,
0.0378950834274292,
0.12586918473243713,
0.6272148489952087,
-0.1722431629896164,
0.43139493465423584,
0.48340722918510437,
0.30572882294654846,
0.4566466808319092,
-0.8118388652801514,
-0.1740802377462387,
0.22523008286952972,
0.14792832732200623,
0.18014726042747498,
-0.40382900834083557,
0.3028002083301544,
-0.4675568640232086,
-0.23153381049633026,
0.14897136390209198,
0.705909788608551,
0.5475644469261169,
0.5270071029663086,
0.34455469250679016,
0.7137483358383179,
0.13128511607646942,
0.02835868112742901,
0.6570497751235962,
-0.1800294667482376,
0.6066561937332153,
1.3700745105743408,
-0.0543019138276577,
0.8346255421638489,
0.7193241119384766,
-0.21364884078502655,
0.2861790060997009,
0.43717771768569946,
0.1875196099281311,
0.7325620651245117,
0.13049238920211792,
-0.15538422763347626,
-0.18722131848335266,
0.01483764685690403,
-0.3194509446620941,
0.397619366645813,
0.08549096435308456,
-0.5676178336143494,
-0.4548285901546478,
-0.12259267270565033,
0.05506274849176407,
0.07358419895172119,
-0.07704608142375946,
0.8546900749206543,
-0.22323550283908844,
-0.9397939443588257,
0.7841284871101379,
-0.13286465406417847,
0.47215425968170166,
-0.4264117181301117,
-0.07361267507076263,
-0.3609048128128052,
-0.1115141287446022,
-0.10835999995470047,
-0.5488637685775757,
0.5740867853164673,
-0.054498340934515,
0.21548867225646973,
-0.23969662189483643,
0.6533356308937073,
-0.3342709541320801,
-0.18594005703926086,
0.050290994346141815,
0.46972090005874634,
0.11012393236160278,
-0.08147957921028137,
-0.6022667288780212,
0.0013719276757910848,
0.04070461541414261,
-0.49040487408638,
0.15321148931980133,
0.18409046530723572,
0.09313922375440598,
0.5419324040412903,
0.5659046173095703,
0.3995015025138855,
-0.2923702299594879,
0.17729105055332184,
0.5030975937843323,
-0.8341732621192932,
-0.5788642168045044,
-0.9380897283554077,
0.3008728325366974,
0.16452272236347198,
-0.31573382019996643,
0.4359578490257263,
0.3612547218799591,
0.6422841548919678,
-0.08553873002529144,
1.0719126462936401,
0.22290416061878204,
0.8189755082130432,
-0.3713155686855316,
0.667697548866272,
-0.4461279809474945,
0.1781390905380249,
-0.6475600004196167,
-0.830791711807251,
-0.4450697600841522,
0.5808848142623901,
-0.49024978280067444,
0.03089972957968712,
0.27819281816482544,
1.1287366151809692,
0.2789565324783325,
0.10348138213157654,
0.7025761604309082,
-0.008932049386203289,
0.37893176078796387,
0.3933022916316986,
0.8071634769439697,
-0.5290167927742004,
0.6798582077026367,
-0.01818997412919998,
-0.20476660132408142,
-0.04576389864087105,
-1.0289740562438965,
-0.492424339056015,
-0.4727560579776764,
-0.4229695200920105,
-0.5083339214324951,
0.2544201910495758,
0.9232021570205688,
0.6828683614730835,
-0.8724161386489868,
-0.1343507170677185,
-0.5245799422264099,
0.356706440448761,
-0.15135127305984497,
-0.28085270524024963,
0.19591602683067322,
-0.2068772315979004,
-0.8746173977851868,
0.4993581771850586,
0.4698478877544403,
0.3124465048313141,
-0.11938653886318207,
0.0519549585878849,
0.036876652389764786,
0.3774518668651581,
0.5530543327331543,
0.7176094651222229,
-0.6740229725837708,
-0.559154748916626,
-0.16707266867160797,
0.12545153498649597,
-0.03231067955493927,
0.6197133660316467,
-1.1490949392318726,
0.39731231331825256,
0.7298286557197571,
0.6091728806495667,
0.5285153985023499,
0.28565311431884766,
0.5582568645477295,
-0.5860636830329895,
0.2695634067058563,
0.45474421977996826,
0.1014394760131836,
0.1883375346660614,
-0.0009720429079607129,
0.4668312966823578,
0.35912948846817017,
-0.5542138814926147,
-0.877463698387146,
0.41670241951942444,
-0.8991969227790833,
-0.2798770070075989,
1.3154754638671875,
-0.07550481706857681,
-0.21493084728717804,
-0.13008300960063934,
-0.4605322778224945,
0.6050758361816406,
-0.7103011608123779,
1.021273136138916,
0.15197014808654785,
-0.47735121846199036,
-0.24926605820655823,
-0.06785055994987488,
0.23536428809165955,
0.5147110819816589,
-0.7166352868080139,
-0.031335536390542984,
0.6086019277572632,
0.14773344993591309,
0.03558924421668053,
0.47303447127342224,
-0.08672691881656647,
0.028956063091754913,
0.09845355153083801,
-0.08079873770475388,
-0.08240377902984619,
-0.31243181228637695,
-0.35255807638168335,
0.28346750140190125,
-0.048687905073165894,
-0.47434738278388977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02235v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02235v1 | Towards a Holistic Framework for Multimodal Large Language Models in Three-dimensional Brain CT Report Generation | 2024-07-02T12:58:35 | 2024-07-02T12:58:35 | Cheng-Yi Li, Kao-Jung Chang, Cheng-Fu Yang, Hsin-Yu Wu, Wenting Chen, Hritik Bansal, Ling Chen, Yi-Ping Yang, Yu-Chun Chen, Shih-Pin Chen, Jiing-Feng Lirng, Kai-Wei Chang, Shih-Hwa Chiou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-modal large language models (MLLMs) have been given free rein to
explore exciting medical applications with a primary focus on radiology report
generation. Nevertheless, the preliminary success in 2D radiology captioning is
incompetent to reflect the real-world diagnostic challenge in the volumetric 3D
anatomy. To mitigate three crucial limitation aspects in the existing
literature, including (1) data complexity, (2) model capacity, and (3)
evaluation metric fidelity, we collected an 18,885 text-scan pairs 3D-BrainCT
dataset and applied clinical visual instruction tuning (CVIT) to train BrainGPT
models to generate radiology-adherent 3D brain CT reports. Statistically, our
BrainGPT scored BLEU-1 = 44.35, BLEU-4 = 20.38, METEOR = 30.13, ROUGE-L = 47.6,
and CIDEr-R = 211.77 during internal testing and demonstrated an accuracy of
0.91 in captioning midline shifts on the external validation CQ500 dataset. By
further inspecting the captioned report, we reported that the traditional
metrics appeared to measure only the surface text similarity and failed to
gauge the information density of the diagnostic purpose. To close this gap, we
proposed a novel Feature-Oriented Radiology Task Evaluation (FORTE) to estimate
the report's clinical relevance (lesion feature and landmarks). Notably, the
BrainGPT model scored an average FORTE F1-score of 0.71 (degree=0.661;
landmark=0.706; feature=0.693; impression=0.779). To demonstrate that BrainGPT
models possess objective readiness to generate human-like radiology reports, we
conducted a Turing test that enrolled 11 physician evaluators, and around 74%
of the BrainGPT-generated captions were indistinguishable from those written by
humans. Our work embodies a holistic framework that showcased the first-hand
experience of curating a 3D brain CT dataset, fine-tuning anatomy-sensible
language models, and proposing robust radiology evaluation metrics. | [
-0.3240407407283783,
-0.5965499877929688,
0.7783862948417664,
0.25425469875335693,
-0.30607086420059204,
-0.3733680844306946,
-0.2500912845134735,
-0.5657588243484497,
-0.2743849754333496,
0.4690968692302704,
-0.25527894496917725,
-0.598007082939148,
-0.5641162395477295,
0.02259165048599243,
0.07944243401288986,
1.048014521598816,
0.08695267140865326,
0.39550071954727173,
-0.3777029812335968,
-0.11584127694368362,
-0.8239970207214355,
-0.2883646786212921,
-0.5800575017929077,
-0.008241266943514347,
0.5584420561790466,
0.12773646414279938,
0.7668547630310059,
0.7694784998893738,
0.6272463798522949,
0.1339375525712967,
0.27064356207847595,
0.21322275698184967,
-0.062310103327035904,
-0.1217895969748497,
0.10213332623243332,
-0.05038592591881752,
-0.7070286273956299,
-0.1650504469871521,
0.31517672538757324,
0.8501102924346924,
0.07033386826515198,
-0.20516015589237213,
0.1265251487493515,
0.4728891849517822,
-0.5971758365631104,
0.49561285972595215,
-0.4482250213623047,
-0.037797845900058746,
-0.04036080837249756,
-0.3846580684185028,
-0.36984655261039734,
-0.05180234834551811,
0.45553529262542725,
-0.5378983020782471,
0.1437743455171585,
-0.038039933890104294,
0.8284785747528076,
0.00878164917230606,
-0.44230103492736816,
-0.26857835054397583,
-0.379021018743515,
0.5830442309379578,
-0.6082216501235962,
0.22729384899139404,
0.3502669036388397,
0.3651024401187897,
0.26366719603538513,
-0.6693839430809021,
-0.3570568263530731,
-0.4288003146648407,
-0.06248649209737778,
0.40294212102890015,
-0.12413043528795242,
0.10942978411912918,
0.2011381834745407,
0.14736266434192657,
-0.923225462436676,
0.07062211632728577,
-0.39559581875801086,
-0.431172639131546,
0.5132747888565063,
0.3885730803012848,
0.34299883246421814,
-0.21913611888885498,
-0.48980987071990967,
-0.10223698616027832,
-0.6916764378547668,
-0.3309587240219116,
-0.10470855981111526,
0.3193482458591461,
-0.2598513662815094,
0.6858121752738953,
-0.08522540330886841,
0.996044397354126,
-0.07940450310707092,
-0.30551877617836,
0.27034270763397217,
-0.16846610605716705,
-0.1135801151394844,
-0.010983890853822231,
0.7813957929611206,
0.6398319602012634,
0.12885843217372894,
-0.17363643646240234,
-0.1520032286643982,
-0.07813242077827454,
0.519162118434906,
-0.8543839454650879,
-0.27863624691963196,
0.2814967632293701,
-0.5360752940177917,
-0.09077119827270508,
0.007718787994235754,
-0.48820599913597107,
-0.6080724596977234,
-0.37694165110588074,
0.5841031670570374,
-0.7598883509635925,
-0.24149709939956665,
0.4398982524871826,
0.27264177799224854,
0.05392889678478241,
0.3996215760707855,
-0.5964256525039673,
-0.13364294171333313,
0.3510218858718872,
0.8000239729881287,
-0.1739453226327896,
-0.4031701683998108,
-0.3735765814781189,
0.2055104374885559,
-0.10655561089515686,
0.7887824773788452,
-0.23236492276191711,
-0.18209707736968994,
-0.20591460168361664,
-0.20362764596939087,
-0.1761825531721115,
-0.25976884365081787,
0.2309744507074356,
-0.33989086747169495,
0.2746855914592743,
-0.1354873776435852,
-0.057166166603565216,
-0.3031197786331177,
0.42041757702827454,
-0.6335191130638123,
0.5236878991127014,
0.30690765380859375,
-0.7516740560531616,
0.49740371108055115,
-0.7792840003967285,
-0.6150848865509033,
0.12452268600463867,
-0.2174505740404129,
-0.3175089657306671,
-0.07419753074645996,
0.3739839494228363,
0.812770426273346,
-0.4981040358543396,
0.4317161440849304,
-0.08210427314043045,
-0.27195170521736145,
0.21947309374809265,
-0.5570034384727478,
0.5942865014076233,
0.08722652494907379,
-0.370706170797348,
0.13155323266983032,
-0.5125933885574341,
0.030875198543071747,
0.11877471208572388,
-0.19194403290748596,
-0.05806512013077736,
-0.18926233053207397,
0.2975211441516876,
0.3611609637737274,
0.17805524170398712,
-0.5828001499176025,
0.014210155233740807,
-0.3636084496974945,
0.4276539385318756,
0.139834925532341,
-0.06333709508180618,
0.07027533650398254,
-0.5844048857688904,
0.4539440870285034,
0.3695153594017029,
0.17665310204029083,
-0.25014030933380127,
-0.5141683220863342,
-0.4679836928844452,
-0.6209970116615295,
0.19223371148109436,
0.47310948371887207,
-0.6042482256889343,
0.2395535111427307,
-0.8156477808952332,
-0.6067477464675903,
-0.4029479920864105,
-0.4301750659942627,
0.45213401317596436,
0.5738086104393005,
0.41195449233055115,
-0.3185264468193054,
-0.33757391571998596,
-1.3418304920196533,
0.024849697947502136,
0.07864096760749817,
-0.232315793633461,
0.27703768014907837,
0.25048553943634033,
-0.09668678045272827,
0.7415620684623718,
-0.5057774186134338,
-0.6193665862083435,
-0.2545647621154785,
0.25006645917892456,
0.01791849173605442,
0.31809163093566895,
0.4756138324737549,
-0.6978916525840759,
-0.436858206987381,
0.38352078199386597,
-0.8452739715576172,
0.19314591586589813,
-0.17393243312835693,
0.22671477496623993,
0.3914901912212372,
0.3184877038002014,
-0.6651350855827332,
0.42756378650665283,
0.35191401839256287,
-0.1287708729505539,
0.24168553948402405,
-0.3843070864677429,
0.3604282736778259,
-0.8995886445045471,
0.3183959424495697,
0.06159796565771103,
-0.18021205067634583,
-0.2553441822528839,
-0.10419324040412903,
0.1379265934228897,
-0.1881018579006195,
-0.36222678422927856,
0.33487722277641296,
-0.6049957871437073,
0.025681110098958015,
-0.11990779638290405,
0.20211991667747498,
0.1625991016626358,
0.6626772880554199,
0.24738679826259613,
0.4003671109676361,
0.6710039377212524,
-0.3826746344566345,
-0.03203806281089783,
0.08645160496234894,
-0.24983228743076324,
0.7277064919471741,
-0.5119275450706482,
0.14046207070350647,
-0.24658413231372833,
0.14467203617095947,
-0.8098245859146118,
-0.3579910099506378,
-0.06828667223453522,
-0.387498140335083,
0.434449702501297,
-0.11346708238124847,
-0.4339049756526947,
-0.2936340272426605,
-0.011258173733949661,
0.4549494981765747,
0.22173593938350677,
0.009007305838167667,
0.695097029209137,
0.5424851179122925,
-0.2471994161605835,
-0.4005093276500702,
-0.7987447381019592,
0.27321290969848633,
-0.0963003858923912,
-0.7046857476234436,
0.37070977687835693,
-0.04636860638856888,
0.14293257892131805,
-0.1359177529811859,
0.07637644559144974,
-0.21977944672107697,
-0.15855206549167633,
0.31885969638824463,
0.29076308012008667,
-0.32946598529815674,
-0.05032278597354889,
-0.007666394114494324,
0.039561107754707336,
0.15198977291584015,
-0.20779632031917572,
0.456314355134964,
-0.5163235068321228,
-0.5173678398132324,
-0.22993415594100952,
0.3935566544532776,
0.8294340968132019,
-0.23014439642429352,
0.24790669977664948,
0.8482959270477295,
-0.6114182472229004,
0.2797735929489136,
-0.5632517337799072,
-0.13958941400051117,
-0.27593180537223816,
0.7862244248390198,
-0.5968183279037476,
-0.9123985171318054,
0.3096187114715576,
0.34662914276123047,
0.032560545951128006,
0.4233415722846985,
0.8319719433784485,
-0.00807697232812643,
1.1781840324401855,
0.3202863037586212,
0.38508492708206177,
-0.27380096912384033,
-0.029020290821790695,
0.27089932560920715,
-1.0280665159225464,
-0.3467220366001129,
-0.10261452943086624,
-0.0631464496254921,
-0.2960226237773895,
-0.2681698203086853,
0.8827559351921082,
-0.23590828478336334,
-0.04201404005289078,
0.13210812211036682,
-0.7736921906471252,
0.30454760789871216,
0.13087226450443268,
0.3626597225666046,
0.13799086213111877,
0.08884590864181519,
-0.15244419872760773,
-0.31843894720077515,
-0.8590170741081238,
-0.4145907461643219,
1.2657151222229004,
0.19286152720451355,
0.2879970669746399,
0.006696758791804314,
0.17201167345046997,
0.1573794186115265,
0.5736802816390991,
-0.8217858672142029,
0.44170457124710083,
-0.11662406474351883,
-0.49925386905670166,
-0.3875235915184021,
-0.09569671005010605,
-1.0983420610427856,
0.34978094696998596,
-0.14294080436229706,
-0.4907218813896179,
-0.16078481078147888,
0.03371058404445648,
-0.7401528358459473,
-0.0004514368483796716,
-0.41779854893684387,
1.075482726097107,
-0.37020137906074524,
-0.5296080112457275,
-0.1265220195055008,
-0.6920344829559326,
0.40897467732429504,
-0.2054482400417328,
0.28755396604537964,
-0.029559796676039696,
-0.046157922595739365,
0.3459131121635437,
-0.04024973511695862,
0.8463067412376404,
-0.1472914069890976,
-0.147696390748024,
0.16646485030651093,
0.39762094616889954,
0.017736244946718216,
0.23623354732990265,
0.1552319973707199,
0.32583510875701904,
0.2172822505235672,
-0.16816754639148712,
-0.43920645117759705,
0.7623172402381897,
-0.5849214792251587,
-0.33781886100769043,
-0.34852665662765503,
-1.0787675380706787,
-0.47605764865875244,
0.3499981760978699,
0.37636396288871765,
0.6008281111717224,
-0.20822280645370483,
0.25085848569869995,
0.5116541981697083,
-0.31844449043273926,
0.2725529968738556,
0.3910868465900421,
-0.06862910091876984,
-0.4985235929489136,
1.0060292482376099,
0.016336485743522644,
0.04125336930155754,
0.5298423171043396,
0.1676616370677948,
-0.24017386138439178,
-0.7997768521308899,
-0.5639846920967102,
0.24299336969852448,
-0.736373245716095,
-0.42122480273246765,
-0.837902307510376,
-0.20689664781093597,
-0.2299947887659073,
-0.1669331192970276,
-0.3811383843421936,
-0.09880160540342331,
-0.021197937428951263,
0.33052924275398254,
0.15807785093784332,
0.6805731654167175,
0.043408408761024475,
0.19749736785888672,
-0.8568857312202454,
0.04737941548228264,
-0.0029549330938607454,
0.21561522781848907,
-0.06941483169794083,
-0.36635181307792664,
-0.553469717502594,
0.28359144926071167,
-0.3924137055873871,
-0.6596635580062866,
0.5119295716285706,
-0.15737059712409973,
0.29667848348617554,
0.03188275545835495,
-0.24192461371421814,
0.7056456804275513,
-0.2747616767883301,
0.7188788056373596,
0.33441323041915894,
-0.7954940795898438,
0.45187029242515564,
-0.7518689632415771,
0.504537045955658,
0.37919148802757263,
0.15740004181861877,
-0.2706751525402069,
-0.28892281651496887,
-0.5019046664237976,
-0.854076623916626,
0.5925150513648987,
0.069816455245018,
-0.02509217895567417,
-0.28433963656425476,
0.15280736982822418,
0.21123415231704712,
0.11419253796339035,
-0.8577542901039124,
0.2743690311908722,
-0.34888756275177,
-0.2955147325992584,
0.09208687394857407,
-0.028897270560264587,
-0.29433372616767883,
-0.26678940653800964,
0.25329557061195374,
-0.5494247078895569,
0.5464808344841003,
0.3876781463623047,
-0.23089376091957092,
0.24074502289295197,
0.09961177408695221,
0.8986906409263611,
0.9100035429000854,
-0.1178753599524498,
0.15688571333885193,
0.12150639295578003,
-0.5654082894325256,
-0.2517702579498291,
0.007954365573823452,
0.22794322669506073,
-0.13089770078659058,
0.4556642770767212,
0.7543211579322815,
0.19043447077274323,
-0.5946293473243713,
1.0076665878295898,
0.051260124891996384,
-0.44912317395210266,
-0.2681642770767212,
-0.24821791052818298,
0.18060840666294098,
-0.06768857687711716,
0.2262476533651352,
0.3308597505092621,
0.24816037714481354,
0.07677816599607468,
0.15485234558582306,
0.48302191495895386,
-0.7178173661231995,
-0.20234182476997375,
0.7153903245925903,
0.10172565281391144,
0.31893256306648254,
0.7108083367347717,
0.06677116453647614,
-0.12703515589237213,
0.48217952251434326,
0.38429582118988037,
0.8021711707115173,
0.14245985448360443,
-0.024922136217355728,
0.5091605186462402,
0.44937264919281006,
-0.15437354147434235,
0.19466640055179596,
0.15319958329200745,
-0.5790079236030579,
-0.5980606079101562,
-0.3779127597808838,
0.05308154970407486,
0.5138547420501709,
-0.8361614942550659,
0.41349852085113525,
-0.3955039381980896,
-0.25639891624450684,
-0.0503029003739357,
-0.4301840662956238,
-0.7445794343948364,
0.46531423926353455,
0.15248329937458038,
0.5665701031684875,
-0.42902570962905884,
0.8162209987640381,
0.7668359875679016,
-0.5226988792419434,
-0.7117906212806702,
-0.00469339219853282,
-0.1398952603340149,
-0.767274796962738,
0.5495412945747375,
0.43094199895858765,
0.0564984567463398,
0.0683721974492073,
-0.2572254240512848,
-0.6253561973571777,
1.1683497428894043,
0.3747411370277405,
-0.37922123074531555,
-0.09455107152462006,
0.37431100010871887,
0.5481218695640564,
-0.677275538444519,
0.4184774160385132,
0.4341055750846863,
0.5805070996284485,
-0.1261782944202423,
-1.080104947090149,
0.3777269124984741,
-0.161960631608963,
0.08530745655298233,
-0.14988276362419128,
-0.43137452006340027,
0.7240424156188965,
-0.37833285331726074,
-0.1384136974811554,
-0.14098992943763733,
0.47019222378730774,
0.3023799955844879,
0.15532286465168,
0.5089112520217896,
0.3503558039665222,
0.31670883297920227,
-0.055699948221445084,
1.2579864263534546,
-0.4344685673713684,
0.047275662422180176,
0.8110693097114563,
-0.3264360725879669,
0.4822823703289032,
0.4861752986907959,
0.15036512911319733,
0.23338870704174042,
0.5291962027549744,
-0.08900302648544312,
0.477827787399292,
0.22293643653392792,
-0.019936859607696533,
-0.47969067096710205,
-0.019116315990686417,
-0.28678953647613525,
0.7872781157493591,
0.3644653260707855,
-0.30142977833747864,
-0.3761879801750183,
0.27296683192253113,
0.022981517016887665,
-0.06692962348461151,
-0.06503095477819443,
0.5813212394714355,
0.02900661714375019,
-0.7825134992599487,
0.7677950859069824,
0.005788269452750683,
0.39468154311180115,
-0.5269696116447449,
-0.07467314600944519,
-0.035094182938337326,
0.06633322685956955,
-0.10277539491653442,
-0.7945573925971985,
0.4930340349674225,
-0.227447509765625,
-0.28728196024894714,
-0.1541869342327118,
0.18555380403995514,
-0.36772188544273376,
-0.3150562345981598,
-0.010320226661860943,
0.5290564298629761,
0.2074475735425949,
-0.3679678440093994,
-0.5618990659713745,
0.1802390217781067,
0.00015628748224116862,
-0.2442733496427536,
0.5038502812385559,
0.4488176703453064,
-0.3849845230579376,
0.5514335036277771,
0.306922048330307,
0.04646032303571701,
-0.44891291856765747,
0.03695427253842354,
0.7124836444854736,
-0.3274453282356262,
-0.31415030360221863,
-0.6906841397285461,
0.8215681314468384,
0.0863189622759819,
-0.5290955901145935,
0.3444769084453583,
0.8658122420310974,
0.5172815918922424,
-0.3146752417087555,
1.047957181930542,
-0.169124573469162,
0.24541300535202026,
-0.6407008767127991,
0.9016245007514954,
-0.5732697248458862,
0.28185784816741943,
0.02817821502685547,
-0.7346634268760681,
-0.692376434803009,
0.5022685527801514,
-0.3073665499687195,
0.31126391887664795,
1.0898035764694214,
0.937393069267273,
-0.18863724172115326,
-0.1331513375043869,
0.5733249187469482,
0.18937012553215027,
0.02987818792462349,
0.9596450328826904,
0.6600468754768372,
-0.37225908041000366,
0.7105506658554077,
-0.06543271988630295,
-0.23365309834480286,
-0.07347642630338669,
-0.8999824523925781,
-0.9266855716705322,
-0.7858350872993469,
-0.4489137828350067,
-0.3991266191005707,
-0.20924261212348938,
0.4330483675003052,
0.7966079711914062,
-0.4025181829929352,
-0.03681022673845291,
0.09144618362188339,
-0.5301687717437744,
-0.32256388664245605,
-0.22552917897701263,
0.7234981656074524,
-0.1633441299200058,
-0.5742571353912354,
0.18149635195732117,
0.6009717583656311,
-0.03789977356791496,
-0.4150947630405426,
0.11562605202198029,
0.19566062092781067,
-0.3243968188762665,
0.858045220375061,
-0.22307343780994415,
-0.9232639670372009,
-0.3639976382255554,
0.15050256252288818,
-0.5430792570114136,
0.12315034866333008,
0.8391153812408447,
-0.694088876247406,
0.4853229820728302,
0.07602984458208084,
0.5232967734336853,
0.5119972229003906,
-0.4448480010032654,
0.5942236185073853,
-0.4549048840999603,
-0.000528333242982626,
0.4615413546562195,
0.21668900549411774,
0.5359916687011719,
-0.4723401665687561,
0.28752902150154114,
0.1055346205830574,
-0.4131213128566742,
-0.63185715675354,
0.08908838033676147,
-1.4794626235961914,
-0.2769036889076233,
1.1687285900115967,
-0.1616973876953125,
-0.08952278643846512,
-0.3323582708835602,
-0.3930510878562927,
0.08936666697263718,
0.045588333159685135,
0.8191962242126465,
0.6095551252365112,
-0.3301559388637543,
-0.3310973048210144,
-0.6524651050567627,
0.374480664730072,
0.24970503151416779,
-0.7167438864707947,
-0.03281877934932709,
0.8099417686462402,
0.3945165276527405,
0.1812542825937271,
0.6498249769210815,
-0.5340062379837036,
0.5879892110824585,
-0.13678978383541107,
0.39559033513069153,
-0.5825582146644592,
-0.23044247925281525,
-0.07086257636547089,
0.47840145230293274,
-0.07594570517539978,
0.05745295062661171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02233v1 | Synthetic Multimodal Question Generation | 2024-07-02T12:57:42 | 2024-07-02T12:57:42 | Ian Wu, Sravan Jayanthi, Vijay Viswanathan, Simon Rosenberg, Sina Pakazad, Tongshuang Wu, Graham Neubig | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multimodal Retrieval Augmented Generation (MMRAG) is a powerful approach to
question-answering over multimodal documents. A key challenge with evaluating
MMRAG is the paucity of high-quality datasets matching the question styles and
modalities of interest. In light of this, we propose SMMQG, a synthetic data
generation framework. SMMQG leverages interplay between a retriever, large
language model (LLM) and large multimodal model (LMM) to generate question and
answer pairs directly from multimodal documents, with the questions conforming
to specified styles and modalities. We use SMMQG to generate an MMRAG dataset
of 1024 questions over Wikipedia documents and evaluate state-of-the-art models
using it, revealing insights into model performance that are attainable only
through style- and modality-specific evaluation data. Next, we measure the
quality of data produced by SMMQG via a human study. We find that the quality
of our synthetic data is on par with the quality of the crowdsourced benchmark
MMQA and that downstream evaluation results using both datasets strongly
concur. | [
-0.7426631450653076,
-0.9966772198677063,
0.40124353766441345,
-0.06617733091115952,
-0.08871529996395111,
0.17435728013515472,
-0.04450554773211479,
-0.13881196081638336,
0.3001057803630829,
0.44081076979637146,
-1.0457346439361572,
-0.07224217802286148,
-0.1440376192331314,
0.3675410747528076,
-0.40562209486961365,
1.0158523321151733,
0.13886551558971405,
0.14405283331871033,
-0.47377830743789673,
-0.1885187029838562,
-0.19527097046375275,
-0.4327673614025116,
-0.37977972626686096,
-0.0014656849671155214,
0.7542276978492737,
0.43445339798927307,
0.7386133670806885,
0.36115264892578125,
0.29458150267601013,
0.36714258790016174,
0.5075684189796448,
0.8895689249038696,
-0.5751091241836548,
0.31336304545402527,
-0.06747063249349594,
-0.275383323431015,
-0.2720330059528351,
0.2319541573524475,
0.755537748336792,
0.34379130601882935,
-0.09826476871967316,
0.5674270987510681,
-0.15427829325199127,
0.44455450773239136,
-0.4472525417804718,
-0.29937687516212463,
-0.7807390689849854,
0.0795893669128418,
-0.3174878656864166,
-0.4690735638141632,
-0.28459033370018005,
-0.2268938422203064,
-0.32953816652297974,
-0.7373245358467102,
0.4574969410896301,
0.26090922951698303,
0.6221185326576233,
0.30879083275794983,
-0.7832887768745422,
-0.3678770065307617,
-0.6302565336227417,
0.6488965749740601,
-0.4297018051147461,
0.5418243408203125,
0.3995700776576996,
0.6340015530586243,
-0.2712280750274658,
-1.0829558372497559,
-1.249316692352295,
-0.2250739336013794,
0.014548659324645996,
0.3513832986354828,
0.0909096896648407,
-0.2571159899234772,
0.3369635343551636,
0.47968190908432007,
-1.0509008169174194,
-0.5222134590148926,
-0.7744381427764893,
-0.23618605732917786,
0.7979540824890137,
0.4639514088630676,
0.3406123220920563,
-0.7743359804153442,
-0.520363986492157,
-0.2230750322341919,
-0.5178903937339783,
-0.018294740468263626,
0.5812243223190308,
-0.03208335116505623,
0.32200926542282104,
1.0397027730941772,
-0.39692071080207825,
0.6038516759872437,
0.24564160406589508,
-0.3498633801937103,
0.30352088809013367,
-0.8042229413986206,
-0.04442333057522774,
-0.2637737989425659,
1.038843035697937,
0.6998223066329956,
-0.10082803666591644,
-0.02846096269786358,
-0.10689307004213333,
0.057995524257421494,
0.5849475264549255,
-0.8516066670417786,
-0.18485599756240845,
0.44575271010398865,
-0.30326423048973083,
-0.29548799991607666,
0.027948059141635895,
-0.7520502805709839,
-0.2563614845275879,
-0.5255745649337769,
0.740636944770813,
-0.39007285237312317,
-0.27936747670173645,
-0.1263352334499359,
-0.4353998601436615,
0.023102760314941406,
0.10871359705924988,
-0.7236138582229614,
-0.16075833141803741,
0.41067421436309814,
0.6048557162284851,
-0.2116091102361679,
-0.2870209813117981,
-0.5642353296279907,
0.372013121843338,
-0.2996244728565216,
0.7792791128158569,
-0.4119783639907837,
-0.4663822054862976,
-0.34685152769088745,
0.22317931056022644,
-0.09890895336866379,
-0.5005447864532471,
0.5474227666854858,
-0.4748532474040985,
0.8202700018882751,
-0.30948132276535034,
-0.3316536843776703,
-0.04528989642858505,
0.5809287428855896,
-0.7061949372291565,
1.1946560144424438,
0.24693985283374786,
-0.7990067005157471,
0.44121304154396057,
-0.546724796295166,
-0.031030792742967606,
0.13642442226409912,
-0.4267912805080414,
-0.14526674151420593,
-0.012437313795089722,
0.30273011326789856,
0.33553260564804077,
-0.4097985625267029,
0.3777317702770233,
-0.21557632088661194,
-0.16580624878406525,
0.5665486454963684,
-0.6075358986854553,
0.46790993213653564,
0.40886321663856506,
-0.00855342112481594,
0.2046547532081604,
-0.9976286292076111,
0.3987467885017395,
0.0034569434355944395,
-0.6116653680801392,
-0.008034739643335342,
-0.1331745982170105,
0.1992817223072052,
0.47199347615242004,
0.13471472263336182,
-0.6535578966140747,
0.026006801053881645,
0.04982848837971687,
0.41213086247444153,
0.6883099675178528,
0.1597069352865219,
0.3084426820278168,
-0.8039715886116028,
0.7695490717887878,
-0.056119244545698166,
0.14872409403324127,
-0.23850099742412567,
-0.45369887351989746,
-0.5897263288497925,
-0.16448651254177094,
0.30524536967277527,
0.24433839321136475,
-1.3645529747009277,
-0.16500741243362427,
-0.17278407514095306,
-0.6525388956069946,
-0.8570239543914795,
0.134364053606987,
0.14422516524791718,
0.544269323348999,
0.350946843624115,
-0.09157595038414001,
-0.5361512899398804,
-0.9904285669326782,
0.031127018854022026,
-0.13775946199893951,
-0.2373289316892624,
0.5913203954696655,
0.3722095787525177,
-0.516713559627533,
0.889423131942749,
-0.4899524748325348,
0.18325290083885193,
-0.014636428095400333,
0.4716285765171051,
-0.09761275351047516,
0.5228909254074097,
0.5612674951553345,
-1.120127558708191,
-0.28252094984054565,
-0.18338021636009216,
-0.6207219958305359,
-0.14751195907592773,
-0.15999086201190948,
-0.4465891122817993,
-0.037515319883823395,
0.4080902934074402,
-0.9472547769546509,
-0.2452666163444519,
0.7628734111785889,
-0.06505706161260605,
0.9905000329017639,
-0.0852033868432045,
0.694970428943634,
-1.5024363994598389,
0.24044610559940338,
-0.36224326491355896,
-0.14946362376213074,
-0.49559563398361206,
0.29481470584869385,
0.13356192409992218,
-0.5180949568748474,
-0.471183717250824,
0.7949392199516296,
-0.1937609165906906,
0.10366497188806534,
-0.023700617253780365,
0.0804302766919136,
0.37845391035079956,
0.4692801833152771,
-0.3680059015750885,
1.0026658773422241,
-0.0298762284219265,
-0.5246211886405945,
0.7734103202819824,
0.1707916408777237,
-0.18270105123519897,
0.7097131013870239,
-0.7465769052505493,
0.33317774534225464,
-0.42089807987213135,
0.2302926629781723,
-1.2456690073013306,
-0.7914183735847473,
0.1316220909357071,
-0.7693498730659485,
0.1855575144290924,
-0.0781586766242981,
-0.732746958732605,
-0.44247329235076904,
-0.4539710581302643,
0.49258697032928467,
0.19759732484817505,
-0.46237415075302124,
0.5217402577400208,
0.37462547421455383,
-0.3245011270046234,
-0.49607279896736145,
-0.37728941440582275,
-0.11419368535280228,
-0.23977817595005035,
-0.953114926815033,
0.34229305386543274,
-0.5142939686775208,
-0.16733728349208832,
-0.15722590684890747,
0.04468946531414986,
-0.0867108553647995,
-0.3441604673862457,
0.32139551639556885,
0.13673913478851318,
-0.3127269148826599,
0.33394649624824524,
0.2900623679161072,
0.18866966664791107,
0.0790015310049057,
0.09317291527986526,
0.652265727519989,
0.26887163519859314,
-0.3879048824310303,
0.12983015179634094,
0.4996294379234314,
0.733182430267334,
-0.4209895431995392,
0.4212244153022766,
1.1765691041946411,
-0.10674505680799484,
-0.24005970358848572,
-0.6154313087463379,
-0.2950981855392456,
-0.5514350533485413,
0.11166462302207947,
-0.5563400983810425,
-0.8445793986320496,
0.12305678427219391,
0.0418606661260128,
0.1640176922082901,
0.36093416810035706,
0.8461724519729614,
-0.3624840974807739,
1.272181749343872,
0.13233719766139984,
0.4761178195476532,
0.21957600116729736,
-0.15657776594161987,
-0.2249402552843094,
-0.6121209859848022,
-0.4042191803455353,
-0.2993384897708893,
-0.4744972884654999,
-0.8534473180770874,
-0.8829894661903381,
0.830987811088562,
0.025499993935227394,
0.01397003885358572,
0.08328697830438614,
-0.33766433596611023,
0.28098616003990173,
0.7301859855651855,
0.24460163712501526,
0.3093916177749634,
0.02507588639855385,
-0.2857450544834137,
-0.10692491382360458,
-0.7178006768226624,
-0.44243744015693665,
1.362648367881775,
-0.1626860350370407,
0.578613817691803,
0.15250514447689056,
0.5446951985359192,
0.40864866971969604,
0.217988982796669,
-0.4729700982570648,
0.5038745999336243,
0.1849084496498108,
-1.0633058547973633,
-0.29351451992988586,
-0.7117491364479065,
-0.9611814618110657,
0.5179576873779297,
-0.5384106636047363,
0.011630444787442684,
-0.13559697568416595,
0.10212725400924683,
-0.33680805563926697,
-0.21299023926258087,
-0.6628893613815308,
0.7753172516822815,
-0.09074340015649796,
-0.5237495303153992,
-0.18108555674552917,
-0.5523593425750732,
0.8430976867675781,
-0.20330360531806946,
0.22727632522583008,
-0.19461719691753387,
0.1029779240489006,
0.5722419619560242,
-0.33232906460762024,
0.14814338088035583,
0.04945661500096321,
0.04744970053434372,
0.6064419746398926,
0.11068095266819,
0.1697019338607788,
0.26934605836868286,
-0.09728098660707474,
-0.3057571351528168,
0.31073927879333496,
-0.40563881397247314,
-0.7789794206619263,
0.8360498547554016,
-0.6318280696868896,
-0.47143301367759705,
-0.10479668527841568,
-0.7971635460853577,
-0.3653838634490967,
0.17903029918670654,
0.29051145911216736,
0.639319121837616,
-0.14720085263252258,
0.26035597920417786,
0.3406513035297394,
-0.42946651577949524,
0.31006819009780884,
0.34835365414619446,
-0.33753952383995056,
-0.6723273396492004,
0.9220651388168335,
0.15450231730937958,
0.26483067870140076,
0.08784174174070358,
0.14155451953411102,
-0.5839336514472961,
0.09633657336235046,
-1.1298439502716064,
0.1513681262731552,
-0.4266236126422882,
-0.20835836231708527,
-0.7729102969169617,
-0.23294076323509216,
-0.35689273476600647,
0.2042512595653534,
-0.07851525396108627,
-0.7237383723258972,
0.013362881727516651,
-0.03405069187283516,
0.18755589425563812,
0.3753695785999298,
-0.11584560573101044,
0.027681998908519745,
-1.0132924318313599,
0.7134324312210083,
0.6877617835998535,
-0.13535399734973907,
-0.30946412682533264,
-0.27928397059440613,
0.013791786506772041,
0.47211432456970215,
-0.6355338096618652,
-0.8388113975524902,
0.4214247465133667,
0.21819144487380981,
0.5288891196250916,
0.2993289530277252,
0.1876288652420044,
0.8344475030899048,
-0.7158097624778748,
0.8360390067100525,
0.09034880995750427,
-0.4041568636894226,
0.44407275319099426,
-0.714745044708252,
0.22243627905845642,
0.4441111385822296,
0.7430719137191772,
-0.496959388256073,
-0.35673657059669495,
-0.6320543885231018,
-0.4963604509830475,
0.3126152753829956,
0.20485703647136688,
0.48780855536460876,
-0.2688775956630707,
0.16368944942951202,
0.20392267405986786,
0.645217776298523,
-0.6302000284194946,
0.09415009617805481,
-0.35883986949920654,
-0.1323128491640091,
-0.05936853960156441,
-0.179361954331398,
-0.263588547706604,
-0.17042408883571625,
0.30499666929244995,
-0.332370787858963,
0.2515464127063751,
0.041259653866291046,
-0.05552346259355545,
-0.22990794479846954,
0.28252747654914856,
0.701849639415741,
0.6993584036827087,
-0.18224738538265228,
0.2983534336090088,
-0.04737837240099907,
-0.34635090827941895,
0.17611990869045258,
-0.016303280368447304,
-0.2817745804786682,
0.22252045571804047,
0.030032705515623093,
0.3201286196708679,
-0.10304256528615952,
-1.0534067153930664,
0.3028843104839325,
-0.08823086321353912,
-0.2140938639640808,
-0.23465043306350708,
0.29066190123558044,
0.07604862004518509,
0.3072424530982971,
0.4440755844116211,
-0.08629937469959259,
0.1968081146478653,
-0.8230030536651611,
0.3997447192668915,
0.5796507000923157,
-0.01475370954722166,
-0.2519218921661377,
0.7804422974586487,
0.020185032859444618,
-0.05913262069225311,
0.5238588452339172,
-0.289033979177475,
-0.2945750057697296,
0.33034130930900574,
0.38963645696640015,
0.2074972689151764,
-0.21681590378284454,
0.4443289339542389,
0.6007498502731323,
0.24232152104377747,
0.20655833184719086,
0.624374270439148,
-0.2144404649734497,
-0.5318827033042908,
-0.41047826409339905,
-0.8519745469093323,
-0.33279845118522644,
0.19922582805156708,
-0.4080442786216736,
0.17462727427482605,
-0.3820379078388214,
-0.42203959822654724,
-0.04977922886610031,
-0.05461231619119644,
-0.490315318107605,
0.4145968556404114,
-0.04011885076761246,
0.429823100566864,
-0.46273699402809143,
0.50621098279953,
0.5417641997337341,
-0.4900277853012085,
-0.6313835978507996,
-0.15604589879512787,
0.00841885432600975,
-0.6649788618087769,
0.5975154638290405,
0.035885054618120193,
0.024365896359086037,
0.08090809732675552,
-0.5600594878196716,
-0.8088507652282715,
1.3536417484283447,
0.29916152358055115,
-0.14681240916252136,
-0.10854262113571167,
0.3410544991493225,
0.44777965545654297,
-0.04689338803291321,
0.2166193574666977,
0.1749163120985031,
0.4615740180015564,
0.2838398516178131,
-0.903509259223938,
-0.14806197583675385,
-0.4954160749912262,
-0.2893684506416321,
0.24237938225269318,
-0.6795839071273804,
1.1314359903335571,
-0.09982284903526306,
-0.37262871861457825,
0.03615321218967438,
0.44617554545402527,
0.6488416194915771,
0.4834516644477844,
0.20706237852573395,
0.5941101312637329,
0.6733423471450806,
-0.029051635414361954,
1.0370978116989136,
-0.20181408524513245,
0.07325064390897751,
0.9819471836090088,
-0.033528782427310944,
0.9285560250282288,
0.5805759429931641,
-0.06425433605909348,
0.19070564210414886,
0.5572885870933533,
0.02464599534869194,
0.3281495273113251,
0.2185044288635254,
-0.3219071328639984,
-0.2110273540019989,
-0.19716386497020721,
-0.40775159001350403,
0.6778441071510315,
0.1732524335384369,
-0.3485844135284424,
-0.11010829359292984,
0.06531283259391785,
-0.14135444164276123,
-0.07169812172651291,
-0.2649850845336914,
0.5768392086029053,
-0.2657955586910248,
-0.7584356069564819,
0.6579445600509644,
0.23821057379245758,
0.4821050763130188,
-0.4505004286766052,
-0.08843418210744858,
-0.41703587770462036,
-0.19993950426578522,
-0.17688529193401337,
-0.5811099410057068,
0.30064666271209717,
-0.0459444560110569,
-0.3776785731315613,
-0.27160632610321045,
0.648785412311554,
-0.7226341962814331,
-0.7870621681213379,
-0.46002137660980225,
0.9189756512641907,
0.08594462275505066,
-0.06214743107557297,
-0.5657559037208557,
-0.17098557949066162,
-0.20240411162376404,
-0.10473275184631348,
0.44900432229042053,
0.6971653699874878,
0.09087967127561569,
0.7045642733573914,
1.1094176769256592,
-0.16943427920341492,
0.5380959510803223,
-0.22411616146564484,
0.9140594601631165,
-0.3450467884540558,
-0.2876521944999695,
-0.641281247138977,
0.6999818086624146,
-0.10285920649766922,
-0.3427859842777252,
0.9725291132926941,
0.7165919542312622,
0.816169023513794,
-0.18499304354190826,
0.5708848834037781,
-0.08613508194684982,
0.6696101427078247,
-0.7125951647758484,
0.8583110570907593,
-0.8226568698883057,
-0.24454887211322784,
-0.248864084482193,
-0.8948999047279358,
0.35076162219047546,
0.4775751531124115,
0.20589002966880798,
-0.029675060883164406,
0.4257292151451111,
1.2141166925430298,
-0.35141506791114807,
-0.05511843413114548,
0.43553683161735535,
-0.18464648723602295,
0.21367202699184418,
0.3148338496685028,
1.2517564296722412,
-0.5215885639190674,
0.5967675447463989,
-0.21561862528324127,
0.1324944794178009,
0.02155289426445961,
-0.4959724247455597,
-0.7447687983512878,
-0.9411944150924683,
-0.04112788289785385,
-0.39265739917755127,
-0.35999569296836853,
0.9305782914161682,
0.7683435678482056,
-0.32024383544921875,
-0.12548187375068665,
0.453447163105011,
-0.158683642745018,
0.3106514513492584,
-0.3230619430541992,
-0.05779106914997101,
-0.17729876935482025,
-0.7168840765953064,
0.5521959662437439,
0.06581635773181915,
0.09479030221700668,
-0.5123236775398254,
-0.06817423552274704,
-0.11505483090877533,
0.2640836834907532,
0.8757798671722412,
-0.0951712429523468,
-0.5191761255264282,
-0.14314106106758118,
0.24757641553878784,
-0.16649535298347473,
-0.14804787933826447,
0.9117301106452942,
-0.7114483118057251,
0.5196527242660522,
0.5570041537284851,
0.6864984631538391,
0.6046105623245239,
0.44965046644210815,
0.6116951704025269,
-1.065346598625183,
-0.050590794533491135,
0.21265047788619995,
0.10349588841199875,
0.30384352803230286,
-0.11230570822954178,
0.37611839175224304,
0.19948585331439972,
-0.5730994343757629,
-0.882666826248169,
0.25915011763572693,
-0.8235366940498352,
-0.19612693786621094,
1.226828694343567,
0.24600203335285187,
-0.045393843203783035,
0.06926090270280838,
-0.5247502326965332,
0.12494947016239166,
-0.07581505179405212,
0.8434177041053772,
0.6502382755279541,
-0.217678964138031,
-0.4518565237522125,
-0.842627763748169,
0.5672115087509155,
0.05719825625419617,
-0.9232255220413208,
-0.2684190571308136,
1.0327174663543701,
0.2424101084470749,
0.303140252828598,
0.5771114230155945,
-0.09887311607599258,
0.46330949664115906,
0.13442416489124298,
-0.21298055350780487,
-0.28303220868110657,
-0.26716992259025574,
0.32574427127838135,
0.5368333458900452,
-0.26013457775115967,
-0.09448070079088211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02211v1 | PromptIntern: Saving Inference Costs by Internalizing Recurrent Prompt during Large Language Model Fine-tuning | 2024-07-02T12:21:14 | 2024-07-02T12:21:14 | Jiaru Zou, Mengyu Zhou, Tao Li, Shi Han, Dongmei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have played a fundamental role in various
natural language processing tasks with powerful prompt techniques. However, in
real-world applications, there are often similar prompt components for repeated
queries, which causes significant computational burdens during inference.
Existing prompt compression and direct fine-tuning methods aim to tackle these
challenges, yet they frequently struggle to strike an optimal balance between
cost-efficiency and performance effectiveness, especially in complex tasks such
as NL2Code. In this paper, we propose a novel method namely PromptIntern to
internalize the prompt knowledge into model parameters via progressive
fine-tuning. Our method enables LLMs to emulate the human learning process for
a new task, where detailed templates and examples in a prompt are gradually
internalized and phased out progressively as the model grows accustomed to the
task. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our method reduces inference
tokens over 90%, speedups inference by 4.2 times, and saves 88.3% monetary
cost. | [
-0.3735496699810028,
-0.752425491809845,
0.4737500548362732,
0.23080186545848846,
-0.34647780656814575,
-0.2768716812133789,
-0.5256490707397461,
-0.19720007479190826,
-0.3616124391555786,
0.5924437642097473,
-0.9314064979553223,
-0.34984254837036133,
-0.23696886003017426,
0.35404908657073975,
0.13032452762126923,
0.6105128526687622,
0.11792101711034775,
0.07915763556957245,
-0.1467275470495224,
0.03913499787449837,
-0.8636916279792786,
-0.16328419744968414,
-1.3515410423278809,
-0.2045968770980835,
0.5065957903862,
0.5768750905990601,
0.23202873766422272,
0.5002108812332153,
0.1115528866648674,
0.2699485719203949,
-0.37147682905197144,
0.5934268236160278,
-0.4769837558269501,
0.6457266211509705,
-0.36557093262672424,
-0.7487537860870361,
0.11374694854021072,
-0.16115030646324158,
0.7955195307731628,
0.7391778826713562,
-0.06362278014421463,
0.17975154519081116,
0.4132121801376343,
0.6890916228294373,
-0.5059282779693604,
0.2225303053855896,
-0.7214935421943665,
-0.07745304703712463,
0.04545430466532707,
-0.27086353302001953,
-0.6089733839035034,
-0.5450524687767029,
-0.029063090682029724,
-0.4675734341144562,
0.44296202063560486,
0.17528097331523895,
0.5954798460006714,
0.6097681522369385,
-0.04311339184641838,
-0.19118189811706543,
-0.4490886926651001,
0.6776158809661865,
-0.9135044813156128,
0.1825670748949051,
0.2868463397026062,
0.21460281312465668,
-0.44125184416770935,
-0.7821134924888611,
-0.44197550415992737,
-0.4321177303791046,
-0.15634849667549133,
-0.22149811685085297,
-0.30879706144332886,
0.14278507232666016,
0.5248451232910156,
-0.011493632569909096,
-0.43143489956855774,
0.3849320113658905,
-0.0656701847910881,
-0.1150735393166542,
0.2773056626319885,
0.3814801871776581,
0.20128311216831207,
0.014284145087003708,
0.006188869941979647,
-0.012223451398313046,
-0.8789486885070801,
0.3374815285205841,
0.1855822056531906,
0.6434300541877747,
0.08730721473693848,
0.3908765912055969,
-0.42311370372772217,
0.6599099040031433,
0.44456014037132263,
-0.07738266885280609,
0.03895493596792221,
-0.24947068095207214,
-0.1591012328863144,
0.05605170130729675,
0.5054599046707153,
0.5206817984580994,
0.48749393224716187,
-0.054250434041023254,
-0.22113187611103058,
0.06845192611217499,
0.05786202475428581,
-1.115950107574463,
-0.08016760647296906,
0.13053031265735626,
-0.48226791620254517,
0.03469057381153107,
-0.2729566991329193,
-0.7693004012107849,
-0.5502041578292847,
-0.701654851436615,
0.09879796952009201,
-0.512481153011322,
0.1722143441438675,
0.12506195902824402,
-0.0976111963391304,
0.019528236240148544,
0.6378372311592102,
-0.673332691192627,
0.06047314032912254,
0.6254602074623108,
0.9572288990020752,
0.03604131564497948,
-0.1640198826789856,
-1.1396937370300293,
-0.21049781143665314,
-0.10837094485759735,
0.8626904487609863,
-0.626667857170105,
-0.4624401032924652,
0.025648953393101692,
0.167286217212677,
0.07750272750854492,
-0.6843719482421875,
0.6277668476104736,
-0.32843154668807983,
0.2318553328514099,
-0.3224002420902252,
-0.7318902611732483,
-0.07416810840368271,
0.21112295985221863,
-0.6099942922592163,
0.9945645332336426,
-0.0560140535235405,
-0.538830578327179,
0.235455721616745,
-0.3569660484790802,
-0.38807517290115356,
0.10149085521697998,
0.1019255742430687,
-0.14787358045578003,
0.3703605830669403,
0.5076707601547241,
0.5228151082992554,
-0.6494202613830566,
0.35507598519325256,
-0.11202461272478104,
-0.3233741223812103,
-0.027853064239025116,
-0.571614682674408,
0.6268277764320374,
0.22204658389091492,
-0.3065612018108368,
0.28998884558677673,
-0.6194692850112915,
-0.20147839188575745,
-0.13495898246765137,
-0.2695349156856537,
-0.5299556255340576,
-0.07942843437194824,
-0.4392135441303253,
0.0034107198007404804,
0.23936976492404938,
-0.5388906002044678,
0.6051726937294006,
-0.6448596119880676,
0.4048577845096588,
0.7300199866294861,
0.30050575733184814,
0.5568123459815979,
-0.2145359367132187,
0.5073002576828003,
-0.08072073757648468,
0.22481976449489594,
-0.5933112502098083,
-0.4733068346977234,
-0.7870259881019592,
-0.235776886343956,
0.11254383623600006,
0.5664439797401428,
-0.7056336402893066,
0.42354148626327515,
-0.08477793633937836,
-0.3449253737926483,
-0.6487079858779907,
0.0640205591917038,
0.3041556775569916,
0.8100284337997437,
0.43123355507850647,
0.24892157316207886,
-0.2643749713897705,
-0.8797748684883118,
-0.4357767105102539,
0.10221907496452332,
-0.39087599515914917,
0.2965647876262665,
0.2075624018907547,
-0.16480261087417603,
0.9164666533470154,
-0.4707323908805847,
-0.08096923679113388,
-0.31276223063468933,
0.46523183584213257,
0.5058250427246094,
0.7217455506324768,
0.3663657605648041,
-0.4065774083137512,
-0.3419856131076813,
-0.3095625638961792,
-0.3220582604408264,
-0.5955192446708679,
-0.5271619558334351,
-0.13009938597679138,
0.15207764506340027,
0.8164246678352356,
-0.7290036678314209,
0.24639585614204407,
0.23306958377361298,
-0.6123325824737549,
0.5590640306472778,
-0.42176511883735657,
0.09582874178886414,
-0.8569105863571167,
0.00607124762609601,
0.07606832683086395,
-0.1491551399230957,
-0.44925254583358765,
0.1647726595401764,
0.357599139213562,
-0.012038861401379108,
-0.24938420951366425,
0.9369679093360901,
-0.6538404226303101,
0.45900285243988037,
-0.34580546617507935,
-0.029108483344316483,
0.1794804036617279,
0.48491936922073364,
-0.3129722774028778,
1.1485754251480103,
0.37678468227386475,
-0.8728691339492798,
0.1318994164466858,
0.13604752719402313,
-0.4883100390434265,
0.4565272927284241,
-0.8137051463127136,
0.0991472452878952,
-0.4219524562358856,
0.3180525600910187,
-0.9626017808914185,
0.060348570346832275,
0.24608851969242096,
-0.15044957399368286,
0.48762595653533936,
-0.3048960268497467,
-0.7009491324424744,
-0.1596985161304474,
-0.2935028076171875,
0.24358364939689636,
0.64757239818573,
-0.8028689622879028,
0.6269860863685608,
-0.07057993113994598,
-0.42008358240127563,
-0.28918546438217163,
-0.470098078250885,
0.1334962546825409,
-0.17834284901618958,
-0.4718920886516571,
0.31583359837532043,
-0.21033288538455963,
-0.1838437020778656,
-0.2492007464170456,
0.02394801750779152,
0.28121912479400635,
0.12047887593507767,
0.2056153416633606,
0.07929188758134842,
-0.17540337145328522,
0.390635222196579,
0.5224407911300659,
-0.14525754749774933,
-0.027806827798485756,
-0.4575206935405731,
0.7293316721916199,
0.15212030708789825,
-0.1340610235929489,
-0.7299001812934875,
0.41208404302597046,
0.36661186814308167,
-0.3385695219039917,
0.8158153891563416,
0.3771096169948578,
-0.30005431175231934,
-0.526662290096283,
-0.7832192778587341,
-0.46869006752967834,
-0.5193085074424744,
0.20041196048259735,
-0.3100636899471283,
-1.0212775468826294,
0.45767611265182495,
-0.5557559132575989,
0.2139330953359604,
0.29255539178848267,
0.38703200221061707,
0.13248685002326965,
0.8901554346084595,
0.3438643217086792,
-0.016172554343938828,
0.588981032371521,
-0.024705884978175163,
-0.12308821827173233,
-0.8529471755027771,
-0.2192457765340805,
-0.8021286725997925,
-0.35747164487838745,
-0.21054841578006744,
-0.5175897479057312,
0.28618621826171875,
0.37428927421569824,
-0.5668494701385498,
0.055901963263750076,
-0.49392974376678467,
0.632861852645874,
0.79075688123703,
0.29339900612831116,
0.21294693648815155,
-0.11352837830781937,
-0.08251108229160309,
-0.08052501082420349,
-0.6296039819717407,
-0.2333567589521408,
0.6948699951171875,
0.2420058250427246,
0.7802701592445374,
-0.0445622093975544,
0.34173330664634705,
0.1855689138174057,
0.10291123390197754,
-0.7483696341514587,
0.5477724671363831,
-0.16065466403961182,
-0.059844523668289185,
-0.3330506682395935,
-0.6132317185401917,
-0.9751195311546326,
0.0808175727725029,
-0.0363144725561142,
-0.7369665503501892,
0.33214548230171204,
0.360059916973114,
-0.44519349932670593,
0.1872948408126831,
-0.7114814519882202,
0.6210897564888,
0.05364011600613594,
-0.5029606223106384,
-0.2854873239994049,
-0.5709722638130188,
0.19007162749767303,
0.049953948706388474,
-0.08317413181066513,
-0.25722256302833557,
-0.15569056570529938,
0.4948273301124573,
-0.3795712888240814,
1.1968293190002441,
-0.4748424291610718,
-0.10679502040147781,
0.15939277410507202,
0.2595888674259186,
1.0522164106369019,
0.31731969118118286,
-0.3475719690322876,
-0.038613442331552505,
-0.4732058346271515,
-0.20476177334785461,
-0.7418214082717896,
0.6878326535224915,
-0.2398231327533722,
-0.5910001397132874,
0.037527523934841156,
-0.5324649810791016,
-0.2687613368034363,
0.20037654042243958,
0.3941132426261902,
0.8209099173545837,
0.09330524504184723,
0.019771361723542213,
0.9285664558410645,
-0.5247023701667786,
0.5061221718788147,
0.501237690448761,
0.07842040061950684,
-0.4300987422466278,
0.38203898072242737,
-0.15154185891151428,
0.18362484872341156,
0.5369584560394287,
0.44525930285453796,
-0.38060179352760315,
-0.6120631098747253,
-0.33308520913124084,
0.3377824127674103,
-0.6544685363769531,
-0.5446458458900452,
-0.6491923332214355,
0.2821758985519409,
-0.38596439361572266,
-0.12439310550689697,
-0.27067744731903076,
-0.12322939187288284,
-0.5682254433631897,
0.08658230304718018,
0.6400435566902161,
0.26387226581573486,
0.12475822120904922,
0.582467257976532,
-0.8587685227394104,
0.25264957547187805,
0.24910353124141693,
0.2990976870059967,
0.12775841355323792,
-0.8044075965881348,
-0.050243329256772995,
-0.00918987113982439,
0.17570017278194427,
-0.5331692099571228,
0.4990691542625427,
0.42103490233421326,
0.4831385016441345,
0.47298726439476013,
0.4720626473426819,
0.794329822063446,
-0.7381057143211365,
0.822567880153656,
0.11890820413827896,
-0.9675754308700562,
0.5794163942337036,
-0.10001399368047714,
0.9729530811309814,
0.8334783315658569,
0.15430571138858795,
-0.6123891472816467,
-0.30816885828971863,
-0.09897208213806152,
-1.0438553094863892,
0.5079321265220642,
-0.07417039573192596,
0.24617323279380798,
-0.2663227915763855,
0.7164813876152039,
0.3168914318084717,
0.09646311402320862,
-0.029897596687078476,
-0.1445935070514679,
0.22939139604568481,
-0.2588133215904236,
-0.048764366656541824,
-0.5746034979820251,
0.10448797047138214,
-0.46433737874031067,
0.5720598697662354,
-0.2585832178592682,
0.13103240728378296,
0.22185833752155304,
-0.11907597631216049,
0.06795661896467209,
0.1661364734172821,
0.6271450519561768,
0.36539652943611145,
-0.05206909775733948,
0.04110640287399292,
0.38444188237190247,
-0.34289154410362244,
0.031125210225582123,
0.1413358449935913,
-0.3228842318058014,
0.13043813407421112,
0.38428792357444763,
1.0479321479797363,
0.519457221031189,
-0.8084656596183777,
0.18905967473983765,
-0.3219730854034424,
0.07594133168458939,
-0.19808365404605865,
0.2112198770046234,
0.029410481452941895,
0.5353668928146362,
0.25889384746551514,
0.11143238097429276,
0.19936253130435944,
-0.2749544084072113,
0.1529937982559204,
0.28445005416870117,
-0.2002989649772644,
-0.13039401173591614,
0.6318482756614685,
0.3525797128677368,
-0.39530491828918457,
0.8332785964012146,
-0.2870540916919708,
-0.3197786211967468,
0.4662801921367645,
0.5566799640655518,
1.0945967435836792,
-0.3212389051914215,
-0.04433167353272438,
0.7738827466964722,
0.17309536039829254,
-0.47601011395454407,
0.1849135160446167,
-0.09866636991500854,
-0.4695873558521271,
-0.6764741539955139,
-0.7057560086250305,
-0.2511137127876282,
0.038385000079870224,
-0.6108769178390503,
0.2647415101528168,
-0.46478745341300964,
-0.06655612587928772,
-0.16893096268177032,
-0.1578783243894577,
-0.6817552447319031,
-0.05904083326458931,
0.09554091840982437,
1.2786896228790283,
-0.28910866379737854,
0.7694879174232483,
0.30362755060195923,
-0.16724956035614014,
-0.796760082244873,
-0.003852886613458395,
-0.12868715822696686,
-0.5251397490501404,
0.74180668592453,
0.46019670367240906,
-0.2160928100347519,
0.2124258577823639,
-0.6807665824890137,
-0.6751731038093567,
0.8034996390342712,
0.5063802003860474,
-1.1400256156921387,
-0.13633108139038086,
-0.38282421231269836,
0.24516287446022034,
-0.30809324979782104,
0.33480963110923767,
0.772815465927124,
0.5477232336997986,
0.02198115736246109,
-0.6976746320724487,
0.35283178091049194,
-0.22393111884593964,
0.12953658401966095,
0.44181880354881287,
-0.27987825870513916,
1.0095678567886353,
-0.28715962171554565,
-0.5263938903808594,
0.30479738116264343,
0.6249863505363464,
0.15221212804317474,
0.0760321244597435,
0.637308657169342,
0.2683023512363434,
1.1040960550308228,
0.03150095418095589,
0.9404293298721313,
-0.44154638051986694,
0.253853440284729,
1.4103771448135376,
-0.22206661105155945,
0.6574177742004395,
0.4076986312866211,
0.06004338711500168,
0.2972744405269623,
0.510739266872406,
-0.04761248454451561,
0.4735868573188782,
0.39449143409729004,
-0.4313739240169525,
-0.36265525221824646,
-0.22185508906841278,
-0.20311015844345093,
0.023116495460271835,
0.35331279039382935,
-0.3050100803375244,
-0.32585063576698303,
0.200358584523201,
0.3126961290836334,
0.09149933606386185,
-0.4602629840373993,
0.9054532647132874,
0.03419375419616699,
-0.951904833316803,
0.6549071073532104,
-0.12072835862636566,
0.8396289348602295,
-0.7212454676628113,
-0.18015091121196747,
-0.5989459753036499,
0.20275652408599854,
0.23826628923416138,
-0.5603463053703308,
0.08932504802942276,
0.0638624057173729,
-0.24278943240642548,
-0.22173668444156647,
0.4072294235229492,
-0.4904053807258606,
-0.40491196513175964,
0.16117225587368011,
0.20950345695018768,
-0.0704185962677002,
-0.5106979012489319,
-0.500199556350708,
-0.152097687125206,
0.11430244147777557,
-0.38866934180259705,
0.15098980069160461,
0.7071686387062073,
0.06489606201648712,
0.8242606520652771,
0.7467510104179382,
0.1179480031132698,
-0.2051810324192047,
0.33722513914108276,
0.9619269967079163,
-0.7647557854652405,
-0.5952014923095703,
-1.0720515251159668,
0.5456221699714661,
-0.18057529628276825,
-0.5620357990264893,
0.5734819173812866,
0.34856459498405457,
0.4963352084159851,
-0.20346659421920776,
0.5735625624656677,
0.34898436069488525,
0.5299881100654602,
-0.8846355676651001,
0.6056733131408691,
-0.47215577960014343,
0.40888482332229614,
0.04625312611460686,
-0.7292923331260681,
-0.37030062079429626,
0.25379469990730286,
-0.08412342518568039,
-0.3567599058151245,
0.547994077205658,
0.9044840335845947,
0.13540522754192352,
-0.0786743313074112,
0.10972979664802551,
0.2405824512243271,
0.3732711970806122,
0.32800203561782837,
0.6910942196846008,
0.08045870065689087,
0.25085851550102234,
-0.33120763301849365,
-0.24647849798202515,
-0.2695391774177551,
-0.9177184104919434,
-1.0904626846313477,
-0.37879636883735657,
-0.26062360405921936,
-0.17755508422851562,
0.1528298705816269,
1.291970133781433,
0.42275139689445496,
-0.8152303695678711,
0.084265798330307,
-0.3224864900112152,
-0.0724504366517067,
-0.2856919765472412,
-0.1959458738565445,
0.33765074610710144,
-0.8461711406707764,
-0.8312508463859558,
0.5854602456092834,
0.0880095362663269,
-0.12853895127773285,
-0.045019786804914474,
0.12042608857154846,
0.05028316378593445,
0.11337189376354218,
0.7010356187820435,
0.19688192009925842,
-0.7337216734886169,
-0.2346300482749939,
-0.11642198264598846,
0.08908788859844208,
-0.12371302396059036,
0.9757919907569885,
-1.0418354272842407,
0.3574238121509552,
0.6766704320907593,
0.6824570894241333,
0.19349299371242523,
0.16537991166114807,
0.8115893006324768,
-0.7933811545372009,
0.3264073133468628,
0.3493489623069763,
0.46331527829170227,
0.23037700355052948,
-0.6039619445800781,
0.40363767743110657,
0.009000410325825214,
-0.5648662447929382,
-0.8375057578086853,
0.3228634297847748,
-0.8657066226005554,
-0.6502938270568848,
1.236510157585144,
-0.0931900143623352,
-0.11515569686889648,
-0.04486554116010666,
-0.6010093092918396,
0.30532339215278625,
-0.8109607696533203,
0.5108501315116882,
0.12068694829940796,
0.060365840792655945,
-0.3832719027996063,
-0.48124921321868896,
0.6078519225120544,
0.30403563380241394,
-0.70368492603302,
0.40445923805236816,
0.5787270069122314,
0.1878911554813385,
-0.25390610098838806,
0.13091209530830383,
0.4571150243282318,
0.07723777741193771,
-0.0005485151195898652,
0.18822667002677917,
-0.3044385612010956,
-0.2760607898235321,
-0.6210377812385559,
0.22393129765987396,
0.002290888922289014,
-0.07446043193340302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02209v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02209v1 | Generative Monoculture in Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T12:17:07 | 2024-07-02T12:17:07 | Fan Wu, Emily Black, Varun Chandrasekaran | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We introduce {\em generative monoculture}, a behavior observed in large
language models (LLMs) characterized by a significant narrowing of model output
diversity relative to available training data for a given task: for example,
generating only positive book reviews for books with a mixed reception. While
in some cases, generative monoculture enhances performance (e.g., LLMs more
often produce efficient code), the dangers are exacerbated in others (e.g.,
LLMs refuse to share diverse opinions). As LLMs are increasingly used in
high-impact settings such as education and web search, careful maintenance of
LLM output diversity is essential to ensure a variety of facts and perspectives
are preserved over time. We experimentally demonstrate the prevalence of
generative monoculture through analysis of book review and code generation
tasks, and find that simple countermeasures such as altering sampling or
prompting strategies are insufficient to mitigate the behavior. Moreover, our
results suggest that the root causes of generative monoculture are likely
embedded within the LLM's alignment processes, suggesting a need for developing
fine-tuning paradigms that preserve or promote diversity. | [
-0.5305415391921997,
-0.6078157424926758,
-0.08541004359722137,
0.17419880628585815,
-0.3159658908843994,
0.14024142920970917,
-0.43764832615852356,
-0.2832966148853302,
0.23914343118667603,
0.5414181351661682,
-0.7315231561660767,
-0.6568489074707031,
-0.5115254521369934,
-0.011800333857536316,
-0.48918232321739197,
1.3624823093414307,
0.0832391008734703,
-0.02892127074301243,
-0.5603967905044556,
-0.3818591833114624,
-0.40252140164375305,
-0.7065510153770447,
-0.6624841094017029,
-0.38989052176475525,
0.6586682200431824,
0.39567050337791443,
0.7167041301727295,
0.6240523457527161,
0.35402679443359375,
0.2292352020740509,
-0.29393085837364197,
0.033368539065122604,
-1.0637543201446533,
0.4332667291164398,
-0.04967111349105835,
-0.4795641601085663,
-0.3076357841491699,
-0.16434894502162933,
0.6997730135917664,
0.8576019406318665,
-0.2631160318851471,
0.24833936989307404,
0.5273082852363586,
0.8537831902503967,
-0.445049524307251,
-0.1902715265750885,
-0.22550517320632935,
0.30906036496162415,
-0.35970810055732727,
-0.17349936068058014,
-0.48599332571029663,
-0.2380804419517517,
-0.06569001078605652,
-0.44157472252845764,
0.3181569576263428,
-0.2213156670331955,
0.592839777469635,
0.09341031312942505,
-0.4856720566749573,
-0.26239290833473206,
-0.9686608910560608,
0.9268115162849426,
-0.44844287633895874,
0.10650947690010071,
-0.03290105238556862,
-0.17658688127994537,
-0.013737944886088371,
-0.036968894302845,
-0.495694637298584,
-0.009197699837386608,
-0.0370163694024086,
0.2559606730937958,
-0.1661766916513443,
0.07507765293121338,
0.27438610792160034,
0.6128326654434204,
-0.5901695489883423,
0.3771359920501709,
-0.4237111806869507,
-0.18290671706199646,
0.4946939945220947,
0.2590402662754059,
0.3529854714870453,
0.03994780033826828,
-0.42157551646232605,
-0.23628735542297363,
-0.8325589299201965,
0.17945216596126556,
0.6313022375106812,
0.13878725469112396,
-0.083064004778862,
0.3368736505508423,
-0.16249395906925201,
0.44171038269996643,
-0.39471015334129333,
-0.04344687610864639,
0.343654602766037,
-0.5868729948997498,
-0.09887365996837616,
-0.23547334969043732,
0.6713526248931885,
0.29442161321640015,
0.35861533880233765,
0.17029380798339844,
-0.19460463523864746,
0.1318122148513794,
0.34300684928894043,
-0.6652501225471497,
0.11997067928314209,
0.05514173209667206,
-0.6424853205680847,
-0.4780813157558441,
0.07586385309696198,
-0.9418796896934509,
-0.41829344630241394,
-0.18610183894634247,
-0.08296669274568558,
-0.10523830354213715,
-0.3960719704627991,
0.17173057794570923,
-0.35823923349380493,
0.11667187511920929,
0.14802129566669464,
-0.931132972240448,
0.10480786859989166,
0.5788294672966003,
0.7061668038368225,
-0.5315744876861572,
-0.410876989364624,
0.009182804264128208,
0.12907056510448456,
-0.43743887543678284,
0.34883996844291687,
-0.3956438899040222,
-0.6839280128479004,
0.18603374063968658,
-0.3589247763156891,
0.23656293749809265,
-0.7768004536628723,
0.38887450098991394,
-0.49654683470726013,
-0.08235305547714233,
-0.3169401288032532,
-0.28156691789627075,
0.07457026839256287,
0.3403646647930145,
-0.6017951369285583,
0.6323122978210449,
0.0496739037334919,
-0.6724399924278259,
0.7068535089492798,
-0.41140538454055786,
-0.6096696257591248,
0.07476461678743362,
-0.23679059743881226,
-0.39568716287612915,
0.1880946010351181,
-0.09253931790590286,
0.002832193858921528,
-0.15719935297966003,
0.10666336864233017,
-0.446543425321579,
-0.2524717152118683,
0.15472087264060974,
-0.5831503868103027,
0.7909557223320007,
0.26904407143592834,
-0.10224569588899612,
0.2286992222070694,
-0.4001714289188385,
-0.18484942615032196,
0.09927935153245926,
-0.6444123983383179,
-0.6942106485366821,
0.13070979714393616,
-0.24796022474765778,
0.12435181438922882,
0.1128879263997078,
-0.3506224453449249,
0.5823296308517456,
-0.18033306300640106,
0.07225817441940308,
0.8889546394348145,
0.11821078509092331,
0.43087098002433777,
-0.7325795888900757,
0.814624547958374,
0.3582083582878113,
0.43114107847213745,
-0.27192023396492004,
-0.3854820728302002,
-1.0580817461013794,
-0.24894046783447266,
-0.05787746235728264,
0.21408982574939728,
-0.7060834169387817,
0.1926388442516327,
-0.33188876509666443,
-0.45441707968711853,
-0.45299646258354187,
0.5355033278465271,
0.37863394618034363,
0.030363604426383972,
0.10591497272253036,
-0.6062923669815063,
-0.45824384689331055,
-0.93707674741745,
-0.08667831867933273,
0.053253162652254105,
0.1696530133485794,
0.04768013209104538,
0.24922293424606323,
-0.4718588888645172,
0.704805314540863,
-0.3233641982078552,
-0.30484169721603394,
-0.3396669328212738,
0.3882078528404236,
0.31885290145874023,
0.5854577422142029,
0.468448668718338,
-0.7806816697120667,
-0.34057992696762085,
-0.10453261435031891,
-0.8370140194892883,
0.028972405940294266,
-0.10465069115161896,
-0.22987866401672363,
0.33300334215164185,
0.5050866007804871,
-0.44303587079048157,
0.2151024043560028,
0.7495394349098206,
-0.1623564064502716,
0.5266728401184082,
0.06151861324906349,
0.034811832010746,
-1.0206257104873657,
-0.34686943888664246,
0.08683326840400696,
0.08644114434719086,
-0.5494421720504761,
0.4542199373245239,
-0.35052958130836487,
-0.03449850529432297,
-0.039106592535972595,
0.1485811471939087,
-0.48217251896858215,
0.3107563853263855,
-0.1549645960330963,
-0.23435857892036438,
-0.07731356471776962,
0.2128337025642395,
-0.05413880944252014,
0.7769089937210083,
0.632662296295166,
-0.7587022185325623,
0.22802986204624176,
0.22899025678634644,
-0.46632009744644165,
0.10404228419065475,
-0.22154812514781952,
-0.02316517010331154,
-0.41327378153800964,
0.10045407712459564,
-0.8881627917289734,
-0.08270011842250824,
-0.05422740802168846,
-0.13243789970874786,
0.3698689639568329,
-0.03136124089360237,
-0.4999696910381317,
-0.4327309727668762,
-0.5147179961204529,
0.6649974584579468,
0.6571956872940063,
-0.5010492205619812,
0.13439613580703735,
0.3217240571975708,
-0.3119526207447052,
-0.6673606634140015,
-0.776538074016571,
-0.1427704393863678,
-0.1524117887020111,
-0.6885582804679871,
-0.10808981955051422,
-0.23789258301258087,
-0.16965165734291077,
-0.20859727263450623,
-0.29238569736480713,
0.28643351793289185,
0.19004248082637787,
0.04399632662534714,
0.19738227128982544,
-0.46726158261299133,
0.281070351600647,
0.21853314340114594,
0.32457029819488525,
-0.038675758987665176,
-0.38275936245918274,
0.7249983549118042,
0.11318878084421158,
-0.5115357041358948,
0.04797109216451645,
0.5643225908279419,
0.7705002427101135,
-0.20496463775634766,
0.9144979119300842,
0.21971707046031952,
0.08455061167478561,
-0.8460248112678528,
-0.37151768803596497,
-0.2732180058956146,
-0.47778892517089844,
0.41073039174079895,
-0.10936247557401657,
-1.1876384019851685,
0.5055961012840271,
0.13341158628463745,
-0.08347254246473312,
0.326493501663208,
0.7056214213371277,
-0.0989641398191452,
0.8977138996124268,
0.8200252056121826,
-0.18140727281570435,
0.588997483253479,
-0.22278933227062225,
0.08210983127355576,
-0.5166940093040466,
-0.11351824551820755,
-0.4051162600517273,
-0.4081387519836426,
-0.9118354320526123,
-0.32484737038612366,
0.565936267375946,
0.04337994381785393,
-0.06853701919317245,
-0.03828055411577225,
-0.5063295960426331,
0.5558544993400574,
0.7441548705101013,
-0.04046553745865822,
0.46232178807258606,
0.1746663600206375,
-0.1790449470281601,
0.10265111178159714,
-0.9882641434669495,
-0.5256481766700745,
1.1427369117736816,
0.3178636431694031,
1.1488958597183228,
0.3169170320034027,
0.994606077671051,
0.398500919342041,
0.7746655344963074,
-0.7375608682632446,
0.5072090029716492,
-0.49745818972587585,
-0.7630763053894043,
-0.42031633853912354,
-0.6215718388557434,
-0.8259286880493164,
0.18361593782901764,
-0.10193280875682831,
-0.4658448398113251,
0.3669394850730896,
0.5019893646240234,
-0.1093946024775505,
0.27678921818733215,
-0.5428194403648376,
1.0487464666366577,
-0.14390051364898682,
-0.5264391899108887,
-0.21635465323925018,
-0.12715351581573486,
0.6146146059036255,
-0.23671981692314148,
0.30146998167037964,
0.20593909919261932,
0.24162741005420685,
0.48188015818595886,
-0.015948964282870293,
1.1089688539505005,
0.0473424531519413,
-0.4076049327850342,
0.24920035898685455,
0.3790993094444275,
0.32057759165763855,
-0.03209279850125313,
-0.09963042289018631,
0.23359639942646027,
-0.06540233641862869,
-0.44360703229904175,
-0.21558186411857605,
0.7455142736434937,
-0.9073455929756165,
-0.9626745581626892,
-0.3486778140068054,
-0.6150947213172913,
-0.14704371988773346,
0.15396951138973236,
0.5732981562614441,
0.23505648970603943,
-0.3275229334831238,
0.4533286988735199,
0.8756519556045532,
-0.3726530373096466,
0.08978305757045746,
0.2171134501695633,
-0.5103940367698669,
-0.008215432986617088,
1.0335708856582642,
0.16520139575004578,
0.6376932263374329,
0.15314260125160217,
0.11028805375099182,
0.15366727113723755,
-0.8074414730072021,
-0.18580998480319977,
-0.1446678787469864,
-0.8623425364494324,
-0.051009293645620346,
-0.36525261402130127,
-0.1637468934059143,
-0.4277239441871643,
0.014442265033721924,
-0.1338815689086914,
-0.12202107161283493,
-0.2507627606391907,
-0.14854402840137482,
-0.20131035149097443,
0.8621079921722412,
0.13767670094966888,
0.19889482855796814,
-0.7677220702171326,
0.1578802466392517,
0.3328544497489929,
0.52907395362854,
0.1385107934474945,
-0.3690783679485321,
-0.3607737123966217,
0.06034942716360092,
-0.5253230333328247,
-0.6552735567092896,
0.17314207553863525,
0.11679285764694214,
0.48190420866012573,
0.699104905128479,
0.012866854667663574,
0.2634182274341583,
-0.22530941665172577,
0.7179346680641174,
0.20504599809646606,
-0.69572913646698,
0.24916939437389374,
-0.6083834171295166,
0.5693778395652771,
0.3960339426994324,
0.47757843136787415,
-0.8765994906425476,
-0.9233854413032532,
-0.10614877939224243,
-0.9509958028793335,
0.6864281892776489,
0.022201158106327057,
0.7419939041137695,
-0.2445041984319687,
-0.08512373268604279,
0.3607158660888672,
0.4781893193721771,
-1.1111644506454468,
-0.3399237096309662,
-0.3847101926803589,
-0.027512796223163605,
-0.20267145335674286,
-0.621193528175354,
-0.38805392384529114,
-0.264054536819458,
0.6595994234085083,
0.0211783517152071,
-0.08335238695144653,
0.012187009677290916,
-0.06629431247711182,
-0.38528338074684143,
0.510084867477417,
0.6967392563819885,
0.5945408344268799,
0.035713862627744675,
0.12392997741699219,
-0.24917763471603394,
-0.20387884974479675,
0.2072003036737442,
-0.2408488541841507,
-0.5675656795501709,
-0.24100889265537262,
0.3986295759677887,
0.716752827167511,
-0.1567370891571045,
-0.4470198154449463,
0.3846164047718048,
0.23437121510505676,
-0.11161676049232483,
-0.230168417096138,
0.31854552030563354,
0.024785274639725685,
-0.02954835072159767,
0.26529157161712646,
0.14602775871753693,
0.02753794565796852,
-0.9179278016090393,
0.2075812667608261,
0.6453229188919067,
-0.12063875049352646,
-0.0358114168047905,
0.41514959931373596,
0.4210239350795746,
0.0088898204267025,
0.6403241157531738,
-0.4705771207809448,
-0.43355241417884827,
0.7716097831726074,
0.5443772673606873,
0.8571407794952393,
-0.053571831434965134,
0.23830361664295197,
0.38164839148521423,
0.7242224216461182,
-0.04703078791499138,
-0.03157741576433182,
0.03531850129365921,
-1.0809130668640137,
-0.39897841215133667,
-0.9554628133773804,
-0.21774519979953766,
0.22641032934188843,
-0.6704907417297363,
0.2527760863304138,
-0.3692231774330139,
-0.14137369394302368,
-0.06324990838766098,
-0.8191447854042053,
-0.28496041893959045,
-0.07041212916374207,
0.5576906800270081,
0.8036673665046692,
-0.9728976488113403,
0.7175417542457581,
0.7088021636009216,
-0.6621757745742798,
-0.3858157992362976,
0.3547719717025757,
0.12869107723236084,
-0.5333684086799622,
0.6784172654151917,
0.12998150289058685,
-0.13828280568122864,
-0.14464059472084045,
-0.5435152053833008,
-0.6880493760108948,
0.6279343962669373,
0.2667142152786255,
-0.7335596680641174,
-0.012616337276995182,
0.3199326992034912,
0.7674770951271057,
-0.3104229271411896,
-0.3333487808704376,
0.2470550686120987,
0.2810424566268921,
-0.08446156978607178,
-0.6121604442596436,
-0.0466848686337471,
-0.28063663840293884,
0.23539306223392487,
0.45816314220428467,
-0.8128857016563416,
0.8549792766571045,
-0.09129919856786728,
-0.3202868103981018,
0.1303136795759201,
0.41221556067466736,
0.11955635249614716,
0.14254915714263916,
0.37767720222473145,
0.5360303521156311,
0.45946571230888367,
-0.1535666286945343,
1.1550266742706299,
-0.22963686287403107,
0.5130484700202942,
0.9564259648323059,
-0.24078187346458435,
0.35974085330963135,
0.5506932139396667,
-0.056394752115011215,
0.45840027928352356,
0.46353429555892944,
-0.23944728076457977,
0.21515591442584991,
0.6115256547927856,
-0.4978140592575073,
-0.4180728793144226,
-0.18484154343605042,
-0.23068352043628693,
0.35681092739105225,
0.17616133391857147,
-0.3927913308143616,
-0.06926891207695007,
0.20242847502231598,
-0.13098104298114777,
0.15644410252571106,
-0.3553602695465088,
0.8517441153526306,
0.04499221593141556,
-1.0292236804962158,
0.65437912940979,
-0.27110224962234497,
0.9632118344306946,
-0.7632274031639099,
0.07495105266571045,
-0.6068188548088074,
0.07163381576538086,
-0.3487575352191925,
-0.5973942279815674,
0.24903954565525055,
-0.08155076205730438,
-0.75227952003479,
-0.5383540391921997,
0.490852952003479,
-0.6309714913368225,
-0.3499308228492737,
0.5941035151481628,
0.5479265451431274,
-0.22914403676986694,
0.30070728063583374,
-0.26951611042022705,
0.14455944299697876,
0.1528296172618866,
-0.33388450741767883,
0.4476145803928375,
0.44311103224754333,
-0.130581796169281,
0.6349953413009644,
0.5893036127090454,
0.23001141846179962,
0.3410402536392212,
0.2010735273361206,
0.9394454956054688,
-0.30391770601272583,
-0.3554338216781616,
-0.9264829754829407,
0.33897075057029724,
-0.025446472689509392,
-0.1817643791437149,
0.7834566235542297,
0.5866906642913818,
1.327565312385559,
-0.3494662046432495,
0.9496079087257385,
0.06096242740750313,
0.0777117982506752,
-0.3729431927204132,
0.8128558993339539,
-0.7213852405548096,
0.43213608860969543,
-0.1237395852804184,
-0.8851485848426819,
-0.043826013803482056,
0.060250263661146164,
-0.06863444298505783,
0.2609897553920746,
0.6245855689048767,
0.8342853784561157,
-0.13050752878189087,
-0.04437963292002678,
0.5452907085418701,
0.3907407224178314,
0.014151508919894695,
0.09567756205797195,
1.0900626182556152,
0.34580671787261963,
0.720341145992279,
-0.2161669135093689,
-0.3115334212779999,
-0.0019726783502846956,
-0.7100247144699097,
-0.6501919031143188,
-0.38979825377464294,
-0.45960378646850586,
-0.3665691018104553,
-0.010416016913950443,
0.7658790946006775,
0.5628284215927124,
-0.9148320555686951,
-0.6530582904815674,
-0.17190054059028625,
0.31939953565597534,
-0.24367289245128632,
-0.2414427548646927,
-0.30381858348846436,
-0.6424441933631897,
-0.6780930757522583,
0.03035121224820614,
0.29532623291015625,
0.05515112727880478,
-0.3884424865245819,
0.027005067095160484,
-0.023962566629052162,
0.05882302671670914,
0.6149551272392273,
0.2417752891778946,
-0.35620108246803284,
-0.12215110659599304,
-0.13539431989192963,
-0.22982217371463776,
0.17770281434059143,
0.9283645153045654,
-0.13060766458511353,
0.8134500980377197,
0.3787257969379425,
0.52426677942276,
0.16152530908584595,
-0.10631665587425232,
0.6257964968681335,
-1.0075119733810425,
0.017394689843058586,
0.296773225069046,
0.3226965367794037,
0.2580632269382477,
-0.15098342299461365,
0.19867032766342163,
0.4559740126132965,
-0.374160498380661,
-0.719871461391449,
0.6255941987037659,
-0.6602743268013,
-0.2987137734889984,
1.289844036102295,
0.06370197981595993,
-0.0547773577272892,
0.160511776804924,
0.024957582354545593,
0.29391777515411377,
-0.32772091031074524,
0.8841743469238281,
1.1504290103912354,
0.09335232526063919,
-0.04769442230463028,
-0.47725188732147217,
0.56292724609375,
0.677002489566803,
-0.7101051211357117,
0.2561023533344269,
0.5591815114021301,
0.31341975927352905,
0.4148896634578705,
0.44512221217155457,
-0.15190823376178741,
0.2776544690132141,
-0.22252686321735382,
0.3608887195587158,
0.1679648458957672,
-0.25914257764816284,
-0.5500621199607849,
0.37760719656944275,
0.4981417655944824,
0.12636587023735046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02208v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02208v1 | How to Learn in a Noisy World? Self-Correcting the Real-World Data Noise on Machine Translation | 2024-07-02T12:15:15 | 2024-07-02T12:15:15 | Yan Meng, Di Wu, Christof Monz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The massive amounts of web-mined parallel data contain large amounts of
noise. Semantic misalignment, as the primary source of the noise, poses a
challenge for training machine translation systems. In this paper, we first
study the impact of real-world hard-to-detect misalignment noise by proposing a
process to simulate the realistic misalignment controlled by semantic
similarity. After quantitatively analyzing the impact of simulated misalignment
on machine translation, we show the limited effectiveness of widely used
pre-filters to improve the translation performance, underscoring the necessity
of more fine-grained ways to handle data noise. By observing the increasing
reliability of the model's self-knowledge for distinguishing misaligned and
clean data at the token-level, we propose a self-correction approach which
leverages the model's prediction distribution to revise the training
supervision from the ground-truth data over training time. Through
comprehensive experiments, we show that our self-correction method not only
improves translation performance in the presence of simulated misalignment
noise but also proves effective for real-world noisy web-mined datasets across
eight translation tasks. | [
-0.14321620762348175,
-0.6385338306427002,
0.31556275486946106,
0.20898498594760895,
-0.23265421390533447,
-0.28683358430862427,
-0.2525451183319092,
-0.5519465804100037,
-0.0025062630884349346,
0.4337281882762909,
-0.8170881867408752,
-0.5107381939888,
-0.6188063025474548,
0.26328760385513306,
-0.5806439518928528,
0.9718400239944458,
0.06635238975286484,
0.2985774576663971,
-0.08469109237194061,
-0.014734591357409954,
-0.41707873344421387,
-0.4816586673259735,
-0.4403858482837677,
-0.18835251033306122,
0.49818533658981323,
0.4255111515522003,
0.8018535375595093,
0.8910737037658691,
0.5327234864234924,
0.32138994336128235,
0.08162933588027954,
0.3109879195690155,
-0.6391942501068115,
0.31301864981651306,
-0.28699225187301636,
-0.5504879951477051,
-0.12247391045093536,
-0.000902851577848196,
0.3828880488872528,
0.4451103210449219,
-0.24233324825763702,
0.06966053694486618,
0.09406953305006027,
0.5923820734024048,
-0.2781967520713806,
0.14795376360416412,
-0.5938403606414795,
0.2479703426361084,
-0.22318348288536072,
-0.011951331980526447,
-0.13515830039978027,
0.07200159132480621,
-0.2161596417427063,
-0.9238377809524536,
0.38837161660194397,
0.1970929056406021,
0.9388527870178223,
0.8812687397003174,
-0.22026611864566803,
-0.1214762032032013,
-1.0589115619659424,
0.8704783320426941,
-0.6315785050392151,
0.7228577136993408,
0.5361303091049194,
0.21858440339565277,
-0.3698444962501526,
-0.5340054631233215,
-0.4702472984790802,
0.27741754055023193,
0.015147305093705654,
0.33759427070617676,
0.03885165974497795,
-0.23000149428844452,
0.25223198533058167,
0.17698538303375244,
-0.47960495948791504,
0.16566181182861328,
-0.5524876713752747,
-0.2849530279636383,
0.47962480783462524,
-0.023503126576542854,
0.20748576521873474,
0.2134292721748352,
-0.1694374531507492,
-0.42172956466674805,
-0.5454888939857483,
-0.2900066375732422,
0.3623170852661133,
0.3997151255607605,
0.02114991284906864,
0.07112160325050354,
-0.3316638469696045,
0.6108919978141785,
0.22234922647476196,
-0.35022568702697754,
0.271925687789917,
-0.30723682045936584,
-0.028845718130469322,
0.2095050811767578,
0.6268265247344971,
0.3598131835460663,
0.2922344207763672,
-0.3931506872177124,
-0.3380570411682129,
-0.08450906723737717,
0.6496397256851196,
-0.6099420189857483,
-0.3607918322086334,
0.05764812231063843,
-0.44757080078125,
-0.34438806772232056,
-0.1331409215927124,
-0.5469745397567749,
-0.1840321570634842,
-0.6385641098022461,
0.6276894807815552,
-0.2997610867023468,
-0.2446385622024536,
0.35624566674232483,
0.2596209943294525,
-0.02127855084836483,
0.4714651107788086,
-0.6523202061653137,
0.2299981266260147,
0.4891831576824188,
0.6954503655433655,
0.04464558884501457,
-0.5324028730392456,
-0.46307727694511414,
0.21202582120895386,
-0.3902200758457184,
0.8402125239372253,
0.02393210679292679,
-0.18325527012348175,
-0.08470569550991058,
-0.0700841099023819,
-0.12220539152622223,
-0.8685619831085205,
0.4988805949687958,
-0.34865710139274597,
0.13608533143997192,
-0.23196148872375488,
-0.4087153971195221,
0.07052638381719589,
0.19721440970897675,
-0.4356381297111511,
0.96183842420578,
-0.018969876691699028,
-0.6429498195648193,
0.3969676196575165,
-0.4235365092754364,
-0.533843457698822,
-0.3775160312652588,
0.05638659745454788,
-0.7732714414596558,
0.026237374171614647,
0.28756383061408997,
0.2375958412885666,
0.18749792873859406,
0.263384073972702,
-0.10688219219446182,
-0.3884437382221222,
0.2334136664867401,
-0.4606209099292755,
0.5373315215110779,
0.5908164978027344,
-0.282511830329895,
-0.158920556306839,
-0.6089694499969482,
-0.22998201847076416,
-0.010540787130594254,
-0.20088987052440643,
-0.35204318165779114,
0.10954544693231583,
-0.2883770167827606,
0.50066077709198,
0.04821445792913437,
-0.4742712676525116,
0.20136229693889618,
-0.5258424878120422,
0.10213205218315125,
0.6801653504371643,
-0.18030454218387604,
0.28029540181159973,
-0.33139362931251526,
0.2583421468734741,
0.6126424074172974,
0.3268231451511383,
0.09453552216291428,
-0.2937766909599304,
-0.8408912420272827,
0.15772852301597595,
0.5503984689712524,
0.4975670576095581,
-0.490665465593338,
0.236498162150383,
-0.3706694543361664,
-0.2107900083065033,
-0.9937430620193481,
0.5854816436767578,
0.32553690671920776,
0.6757063269615173,
0.8200332522392273,
-0.1615719199180603,
-0.6511494517326355,
-0.6071229577064514,
-0.6955308318138123,
-0.08296804875135422,
0.1564463973045349,
-0.2724052965641022,
0.39894428849220276,
-0.4425051212310791,
0.7601054906845093,
-0.36179640889167786,
-0.654909074306488,
0.2662276327610016,
0.3431685268878937,
-0.1658191680908203,
0.7987408638000488,
0.10378167778253555,
-0.7656738758087158,
-0.3453115224838257,
-0.19100922346115112,
-0.7856510281562805,
-0.32256507873535156,
-0.18657219409942627,
-0.24687758088111877,
-0.03991473838686943,
1.0471231937408447,
-0.38739198446273804,
0.33596664667129517,
0.4360784888267517,
-0.03746343031525612,
0.5706630945205688,
-0.4565604627132416,
-0.026584714651107788,
-0.9270723462104797,
-0.1033347100019455,
-0.10236016660928726,
-0.4577188193798065,
-0.4231177568435669,
-0.21031446754932404,
0.07244451344013214,
0.04585923254489899,
-0.3284291625022888,
0.30437755584716797,
-0.4231601357460022,
0.1910897195339203,
-0.39004555344581604,
0.25296929478645325,
-0.18367978930473328,
0.2581525146961212,
-0.20495562255382538,
0.875822126865387,
0.2147129774093628,
-0.9765146374702454,
0.038613367825746536,
0.24331894516944885,
-0.3297002613544464,
0.5330355763435364,
-0.2577507197856903,
-0.1173592135310173,
-0.30406883358955383,
0.21558132767677307,
-0.7342619895935059,
-0.13594189286231995,
0.3435382843017578,
-0.460999459028244,
0.37739402055740356,
-0.25853046774864197,
-0.6151063442230225,
-0.376346617937088,
0.4243634045124054,
0.3210853636264801,
0.42038434743881226,
-0.6063899993896484,
0.11087684333324432,
0.33110862970352173,
0.09327857941389084,
-0.5810126662254333,
-0.780877411365509,
0.044683218002319336,
-0.16092725098133087,
-0.44462093710899353,
0.3340376615524292,
-0.04858272895216942,
-0.1377733051776886,
-0.04027354344725609,
-0.47919777035713196,
-0.180580735206604,
0.24845442175865173,
0.37057048082351685,
-0.21846075356006622,
0.014556601643562317,
0.5671172738075256,
-0.025015821680426598,
-0.4049603044986725,
0.1171175017952919,
-0.65996253490448,
0.27051159739494324,
-0.042710110545158386,
-0.4122065603733063,
-0.4801090657711029,
-0.05419401824474335,
0.34529611468315125,
-0.014844529330730438,
0.5530306100845337,
0.7790945172309875,
-0.3365476429462433,
-0.19627007842063904,
-0.6001359224319458,
-0.3245435357093811,
-0.5033050775527954,
0.4252766966819763,
-0.42887082695961,
-0.41716569662094116,
0.2295430302619934,
-0.5393177270889282,
0.0536331944167614,
0.5366307497024536,
0.19436964392662048,
-0.5753133893013,
1.1669130325317383,
0.6125391125679016,
-0.1554461419582367,
0.5069711804389954,
-0.25064101815223694,
0.37500715255737305,
-0.5172812938690186,
-0.10654586553573608,
-0.5805520415306091,
-0.601071834564209,
-0.4826471507549286,
-0.5951178669929504,
0.25799256563186646,
0.31860917806625366,
-0.16692739725112915,
0.4200037717819214,
-0.3116258978843689,
0.4758172035217285,
0.6437796354293823,
0.05328613519668579,
0.5641366839408875,
0.33011767268180847,
-0.31670308113098145,
-0.4909989833831787,
-0.7908546924591064,
-0.2235216349363327,
0.7933710813522339,
0.10381174087524414,
0.9976573586463928,
-0.059351738542318344,
0.8589638471603394,
0.1080605685710907,
0.19522926211357117,
-0.5167260766029358,
0.11015242338180542,
-0.1381862610578537,
-0.4627678692340851,
-0.3838777244091034,
-0.5755595564842224,
-1.0800807476043701,
0.35457485914230347,
-0.31236860156059265,
-0.17079225182533264,
0.058775898069143295,
0.46546268463134766,
-0.09364472329616547,
0.346746027469635,
-0.47280043363571167,
1.0151530504226685,
-0.3658265471458435,
-0.19132250547409058,
-0.42541801929473877,
-0.8168794512748718,
0.08946040272712708,
-0.1361333727836609,
0.7568486928939819,
-0.02693028375506401,
0.29136955738067627,
0.5780491232872009,
-0.3471148908138275,
1.0445711612701416,
-0.24411481618881226,
-0.20355340838432312,
0.1730838567018509,
0.323050320148468,
0.5785737633705139,
-0.3237580955028534,
0.08168501406908035,
0.2816593647003174,
-0.12226441502571106,
-0.32632559537887573,
-0.6106186509132385,
0.5286569595336914,
-0.9774121046066284,
-0.4742889106273651,
-0.2710173428058624,
-0.5205382108688354,
-0.1431340128183365,
0.31525853276252747,
0.5249195694923401,
0.041318755596876144,
-0.273375004529953,
-0.022502977401018143,
0.7210845947265625,
0.11067895591259003,
0.1644630879163742,
0.7069213390350342,
-0.2781730890274048,
-0.197342649102211,
1.2861030101776123,
0.5267642736434937,
0.059483978897333145,
0.2394590675830841,
0.20003612339496613,
-0.3651480972766876,
-0.3504098057746887,
-0.52583247423172,
0.17888449132442474,
-0.5385118126869202,
-0.3734022378921509,
-0.7357978820800781,
-0.15430574119091034,
-0.5791175365447998,
0.00844026729464531,
-0.7438580393791199,
-0.46234533190727234,
-0.17830955982208252,
-0.0980718731880188,
0.14990822970867157,
0.8408604264259338,
-0.5467037558555603,
0.6847242712974548,
-0.8321065306663513,
0.27183571457862854,
0.1683824062347412,
0.4914317727088928,
-0.2282305508852005,
-0.7276658415794373,
-0.7546631693840027,
0.42334645986557007,
-0.5087347030639648,
-0.5238056182861328,
0.4945600628852844,
0.23899951577186584,
0.44287413358688354,
0.25809037685394287,
0.2637002170085907,
1.1964832544326782,
-0.488840788602829,
0.41041433811187744,
0.05703986808657646,
-0.8296262621879578,
0.5801258683204651,
-0.09931939840316772,
0.23114463686943054,
0.6197218298912048,
0.19889676570892334,
-0.7792965173721313,
-0.6297855377197266,
-0.7566072940826416,
-0.6579009890556335,
0.6997530460357666,
0.26223790645599365,
-0.05505950376391411,
0.10934785008430481,
0.5347516536712646,
-0.05026201158761978,
0.06630377471446991,
-0.7977755665779114,
-0.2782278060913086,
-0.4051854610443115,
-0.43616175651550293,
-0.09376901388168335,
0.18365980684757233,
-0.014419644139707088,
-0.321773499250412,
0.9038158059120178,
-0.05891958251595497,
0.030589347705245018,
0.5093985795974731,
-0.5886939167976379,
-0.4392450451850891,
0.01998748630285263,
0.37895968556404114,
0.1316593587398529,
0.07642296701669693,
0.1749984622001648,
0.23255309462547302,
-0.40497463941574097,
0.1986643373966217,
-0.15176372230052948,
-0.3842194080352783,
0.1137072741985321,
0.07854414731264114,
0.5365980267524719,
0.32575711607933044,
-0.43300938606262207,
0.6116401553153992,
0.01790141686797142,
-0.19873717427253723,
-0.17334024608135223,
0.03243361786007881,
0.10486237704753876,
0.002822732552886009,
-0.004226125776767731,
0.45753055810928345,
0.16363218426704407,
-0.22078895568847656,
0.31177425384521484,
0.038285307586193085,
-0.6052600741386414,
-0.24536237120628357,
0.6405062675476074,
0.13900400698184967,
-0.1594337522983551,
0.7260775566101074,
-0.2678501605987549,
-0.5911251306533813,
0.4873231053352356,
0.8302785754203796,
0.5470708012580872,
-0.4328143298625946,
0.09849118441343307,
0.5579836964607239,
0.4380802810192108,
-0.5572515726089478,
0.037763018161058426,
-0.10295327752828598,
-0.7444167137145996,
-0.4904369115829468,
-0.5853702425956726,
-0.2314799427986145,
-0.13587839901447296,
-0.5361156463623047,
0.21341335773468018,
-0.16620399057865143,
-0.11788470298051834,
-0.37721094489097595,
-0.22880302369594574,
-0.7208383679389954,
0.49913668632507324,
-0.02858121134340763,
0.5159943103790283,
-0.9029655456542969,
0.8699263334274292,
0.5505166053771973,
-0.31888872385025024,
-0.6639261841773987,
0.18842418491840363,
0.07450864464044571,
-0.7874065637588501,
0.6822802424430847,
0.2260168492794037,
-0.30173367261886597,
0.10705544799566269,
-0.807284951210022,
-1.0983928442001343,
0.736804723739624,
0.3189252018928528,
-0.6499201059341431,
0.20442533493041992,
0.3682628571987152,
0.6252581477165222,
0.009131385013461113,
-0.3550557792186737,
0.3339413106441498,
0.5381509065628052,
-0.17323173582553864,
-0.7919822931289673,
-0.26458990573883057,
-0.06246424838900566,
-0.22596199810504913,
0.24413394927978516,
-0.9045835733413696,
0.5469954609870911,
-0.09529547393321991,
-0.3290761411190033,
-0.25136667490005493,
0.6552124619483948,
-0.33497729897499084,
0.07683875411748886,
0.5710780024528503,
0.8504652976989746,
0.9185134172439575,
0.0029504504054784775,
0.5619978308677673,
-0.46738624572753906,
0.4412478506565094,
1.5570470094680786,
-0.08157454431056976,
0.6575919389724731,
0.42644330859184265,
0.06177496910095215,
0.3632757067680359,
0.4800907075405121,
-0.06774415075778961,
0.4444223940372467,
0.254298597574234,
-0.056687720119953156,
-0.6353181600570679,
0.10628923773765564,
-0.3943978548049927,
0.3685580790042877,
0.4482863247394562,
-0.11154364049434662,
-0.44294100999832153,
0.06892391294240952,
-0.19647735357284546,
0.22972197830677032,
-0.0895925909280777,
0.9927552938461304,
0.2134794145822525,
-0.5647658705711365,
0.5051498413085938,
0.16725270450115204,
0.5761081576347351,
-0.3261389136314392,
0.030713515356183052,
-0.19003966450691223,
0.38934972882270813,
-0.18361212313175201,
-0.46107763051986694,
0.6965053081512451,
-0.2131260186433792,
-0.24553219974040985,
-0.505875825881958,
0.6884986162185669,
-0.673434853553772,
-0.38947004079818726,
0.41142597794532776,
0.5593157410621643,
0.46002987027168274,
-0.34473472833633423,
-0.7116445899009705,
-0.06961144506931305,
-0.07741259038448334,
0.15202073752880096,
0.45813748240470886,
0.7141433358192444,
0.1347598135471344,
0.861885130405426,
0.6262131929397583,
0.1057390496134758,
0.3611502945423126,
0.009909217245876789,
0.5441098809242249,
-0.7214431762695312,
-0.5023249387741089,
-0.5992835164070129,
0.13809601962566376,
-0.007192819379270077,
-0.31779295206069946,
0.5989254713058472,
0.5834877490997314,
1.2715719938278198,
-0.13057971000671387,
0.578971266746521,
0.39691951870918274,
0.6700012683868408,
-0.458236426115036,
0.7086343765258789,
-0.5587580800056458,
0.16156578063964844,
-0.08903146535158157,
-0.6363403797149658,
-0.48312118649482727,
0.9537695646286011,
-0.17486572265625,
-0.3231487274169922,
0.5004779696464539,
1.0603042840957642,
-0.2987508773803711,
-0.12977539002895355,
0.5892115235328674,
0.8197447061538696,
0.1450381577014923,
0.04740610346198082,
0.6773024201393127,
-0.9380835294723511,
0.9102224111557007,
-0.501105546951294,
0.2614976167678833,
-0.23605136573314667,
-0.6057029366493225,
-0.34919464588165283,
-0.4611177444458008,
-0.556542158126831,
-0.4607248306274414,
0.293976753950119,
0.9497525691986084,
0.884190559387207,
-0.8546602725982666,
-0.21887539327144623,
-0.24474604427814484,
0.24378690123558044,
-0.4780103266239166,
-0.14073726534843445,
0.004051444120705128,
-0.8919672966003418,
-0.7635400295257568,
0.5342541933059692,
0.043562151491642,
0.3498278856277466,
0.15422546863555908,
-0.2365732192993164,
0.02348865009844303,
-0.2950094938278198,
0.31592634320259094,
0.2773858904838562,
-0.6084127426147461,
-0.11373228579759598,
-0.34970664978027344,
-0.4658207297325134,
0.2565430700778961,
0.6438028812408447,
-0.7144795656204224,
0.7332069277763367,
0.10789275169372559,
0.5411377549171448,
0.5899451971054077,
0.1533726006746292,
0.5431725382804871,
-0.9045959115028381,
0.18760187923908234,
-0.09907449036836624,
0.19074760377407074,
0.28279778361320496,
-0.532797634601593,
0.6175912618637085,
0.4297676682472229,
-0.6377143263816833,
-0.5567051768302917,
0.04635784775018692,
-0.47247591614723206,
-0.36246901750564575,
0.8021471500396729,
-0.09901636093854904,
-0.21709881722927094,
-0.4838322103023529,
-0.28773295879364014,
0.6934598684310913,
-0.21056726574897766,
1.160395622253418,
0.7417985200881958,
0.1603488326072693,
0.21753022074699402,
-0.5446597337722778,
0.6365604996681213,
0.6960943937301636,
-0.3671422004699707,
0.2639397978782654,
0.5081594586372375,
0.5040974020957947,
0.14650821685791016,
0.34298133850097656,
-0.19061492383480072,
0.039211858063936234,
0.033805057406425476,
0.18845003843307495,
0.09324995428323746,
-0.4546176493167877,
-0.4396539032459259,
-0.36015036702156067,
-0.04159029200673103,
-0.12961070239543915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02203v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02203v1 | Automatic Adaptation Rule Optimization via Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T12:06:40 | 2024-07-02T12:06:40 | Yusei Ishimizu, Jialong Li, Jinglue Xu, Jinyu Cai, Hitoshi Iba, Kenji Tei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Rule-based adaptation is a foundational approach to self-adaptation,
characterized by its human readability and rapid response. However, building
high-performance and robust adaptation rules is often a challenge because it
essentially involves searching the optimal design in a complex (variables)
space. In response, this paper attempt to employ large language models (LLMs)
as a optimizer to construct and optimize adaptation rules, leveraging the
common sense and reasoning capabilities inherent in LLMs. Preliminary
experiments conducted in SWIM have validated the effectiveness and limitation
of our method. | [
-0.31436771154403687,
-0.6044095158576965,
0.7163341641426086,
0.4911651015281677,
-0.42143499851226807,
-0.26657694578170776,
-0.3172852098941803,
-0.34923088550567627,
-0.15830537676811218,
0.6587973237037659,
-0.6161633133888245,
-0.3240390121936798,
-0.42087623476982117,
0.27901825308799744,
-0.15452945232391357,
0.5400403141975403,
-0.18088874220848083,
-0.233799010515213,
-0.01725662499666214,
0.026269083842635155,
-0.6973745226860046,
-0.3357217013835907,
-0.656342089176178,
-0.3950580060482025,
0.20656703412532806,
0.6053542494773865,
0.5648922920227051,
0.9086827039718628,
0.6213431358337402,
0.2503473162651062,
-0.0027972159441560507,
0.3731507658958435,
-0.5624562501907349,
0.2777799367904663,
-0.4741990864276886,
-0.45036303997039795,
-0.39537760615348816,
-0.4304771423339844,
0.5268957018852234,
0.37065866589546204,
-0.20505785942077637,
0.12099068611860275,
-0.05490140616893768,
0.7424198985099792,
-0.9925618767738342,
0.4261469841003418,
-0.6480353474617004,
0.1024966612458229,
0.3173704743385315,
-0.49505987763404846,
-0.4665888845920563,
-0.29538214206695557,
0.19613663852214813,
-0.8256117701530457,
-0.26066234707832336,
0.2397247552871704,
0.3142146170139313,
0.465490460395813,
-0.3381783068180084,
-0.6147035956382751,
-0.8206080198287964,
0.8112472891807556,
-1.0541470050811768,
0.5442124009132385,
0.18061333894729614,
0.13469411432743073,
-0.5483479499816895,
-0.3075956702232361,
-0.5374762415885925,
-0.20098234713077545,
0.18974804878234863,
0.018398910760879517,
-0.1636245995759964,
0.06670903414487839,
0.14553490281105042,
-0.05940151587128639,
-0.5818393230438232,
0.3018147647380829,
0.02596851997077465,
0.04524300619959831,
1.0701954364776611,
0.2436036765575409,
0.4317060112953186,
-0.08293699473142624,
-0.14320285618305206,
-0.03863607347011566,
-0.5797039866447449,
-0.060704685747623444,
-0.0837976261973381,
0.5018589496612549,
-0.16768132150173187,
0.3830227255821228,
-0.2026216983795166,
0.7898885607719421,
0.13027514517307281,
-0.5649882555007935,
0.06504778563976288,
-0.09348024427890778,
-0.1078510582447052,
-0.01672893762588501,
0.3575904667377472,
0.5751671195030212,
0.7182087302207947,
-0.1577753871679306,
-0.49649757146835327,
-0.2957887649536133,
0.19068799912929535,
-0.8405607342720032,
-0.011537388898432255,
-0.0928272008895874,
-0.4630127251148224,
-0.12431532889604568,
-0.28220346570014954,
-0.7543816566467285,
-0.49895066022872925,
-0.7686100602149963,
0.8602148294448853,
-0.281657874584198,
-0.1795279085636139,
0.4851171374320984,
-0.05825050547719002,
0.5812963843345642,
0.4976043701171875,
-0.95842444896698,
0.6535230875015259,
0.6090109944343567,
0.8837541937828064,
-0.2724332809448242,
-0.2648770213127136,
-0.4979529082775116,
0.4183259606361389,
-0.4068351089954376,
0.7341006994247437,
-0.3259519338607788,
-0.4096202552318573,
-0.03973022848367691,
-0.00035014579771086574,
-0.4735429584980011,
-0.3946795165538788,
0.5510854721069336,
-0.5692639946937561,
-0.12263452261686325,
-0.05994774028658867,
-0.8159658908843994,
-0.2693029046058655,
-0.14097656309604645,
-0.48771050572395325,
0.5821418166160583,
0.03728533163666725,
-0.40315935015678406,
0.30677881836891174,
-1.1162232160568237,
-0.7666485905647278,
0.012265536934137344,
0.2855529487133026,
-0.26228389143943787,
0.2781525254249573,
0.35786259174346924,
0.6454864144325256,
-0.39400145411491394,
-0.011975463479757309,
-0.46452951431274414,
-0.4204309284687042,
0.22770945727825165,
0.046709515154361725,
0.6306584477424622,
0.43340006470680237,
-0.413999080657959,
0.10525472462177277,
-0.5474624037742615,
0.004346188623458147,
0.35696613788604736,
-0.6533195972442627,
-0.5016137361526489,
0.605033814907074,
-0.0635455921292305,
-0.08134397119283676,
0.12152017652988434,
-0.04251357540488243,
0.3056889474391937,
-0.3131442666053772,
0.5010912418365479,
0.9249963164329529,
0.18455809354782104,
0.5132542848587036,
-0.3431917130947113,
0.4604851305484772,
-0.32952311635017395,
0.19992071390151978,
-0.11742209643125534,
-0.07286132872104645,
-0.7868396639823914,
-0.3833842873573303,
0.06357865035533905,
0.697636604309082,
-0.35651466250419617,
0.815182089805603,
-0.23123317956924438,
-0.33913788199424744,
-0.1801702231168747,
0.5547707080841064,
0.02772151306271553,
0.2500326633453369,
0.29330170154571533,
-0.13019075989723206,
-0.521650493144989,
-0.5684818625450134,
-0.27949556708335876,
-0.01620304398238659,
0.13571594655513763,
0.3478910028934479,
0.6674847602844238,
-0.41522425413131714,
0.7655123472213745,
-0.6880142688751221,
0.08998655527830124,
-0.3204261064529419,
-0.3198879063129425,
0.42260149121284485,
0.16906693577766418,
0.9593945145606995,
-0.6436777710914612,
-0.5071632266044617,
-0.13472190499305725,
-0.7277951240539551,
-0.3260442316532135,
-0.22705987095832825,
-0.17471365630626678,
0.07765529304742813,
0.8292886018753052,
-0.2994832396507263,
0.19742688536643982,
0.7564902901649475,
-0.3692760169506073,
0.5889870524406433,
-0.5246545076370239,
-0.14353036880493164,
-0.9627084136009216,
0.043159157037734985,
0.2981342673301697,
-0.3541490435600281,
-0.5466035604476929,
0.2841606140136719,
0.10806314647197723,
0.0427250936627388,
-0.0913771316409111,
0.801803708076477,
-0.6785388588905334,
-0.10834286361932755,
-0.5261963605880737,
0.03784957900643349,
-0.11682649701833725,
0.3728479743003845,
0.17280609905719757,
0.7714987993240356,
0.6466032862663269,
-1.1529059410095215,
0.48917728662490845,
0.20658846199512482,
-0.3603905439376831,
0.5682440996170044,
-0.6803618669509888,
0.09491583704948425,
-0.2813587486743927,
0.1943909376859665,
-0.8832113742828369,
-0.5085553526878357,
0.1465156376361847,
0.14176097512245178,
0.32607516646385193,
-0.14655669033527374,
-0.3225439488887787,
-0.5020779967308044,
-0.2626379132270813,
0.3163873851299286,
0.5526173710823059,
-0.7856212258338928,
0.7750919461250305,
0.4308915138244629,
-0.25485843420028687,
-0.11355084925889969,
-0.28286638855934143,
0.02722753956913948,
-0.4735705256462097,
-0.6228891611099243,
0.05138859525322914,
-0.5318860411643982,
-0.32893651723861694,
-0.41900986433029175,
0.08170224726200104,
0.028102045878767967,
0.37231191992759705,
0.15225692093372345,
0.04634084179997444,
-0.44932588934898376,
-0.01895797625184059,
-0.02396675944328308,
0.22335293889045715,
0.07296122610569,
-0.2803565263748169,
0.4948846995830536,
-0.21227943897247314,
-0.31834131479263306,
-0.44050824642181396,
0.3054632246494293,
0.9283252954483032,
-0.1841013878583908,
0.6774556636810303,
0.05065218731760979,
-0.1795169860124588,
-0.60126131772995,
-0.5022108554840088,
-0.08993107080459595,
-0.5326669216156006,
0.6528111696243286,
-0.5477846264839172,
-0.5396401882171631,
0.4965072274208069,
-0.34974193572998047,
-0.09441312402486801,
0.3439134657382965,
0.6732610464096069,
0.0029338118620216846,
0.9425447583198547,
0.703159749507904,
-0.23978839814662933,
0.5892475247383118,
0.14236746728420258,
0.13737058639526367,
-0.8057887554168701,
0.021742504090070724,
-0.63343745470047,
-0.10314960777759552,
-0.5251601338386536,
-0.5416870713233948,
0.2705276310443878,
0.04661966487765312,
-0.4454622268676758,
0.42280957102775574,
-0.39720475673675537,
0.5060189366340637,
0.46420371532440186,
0.3524937927722931,
0.20727217197418213,
-0.17239998281002045,
-0.10736702382564545,
0.09874758869409561,
-0.852311909198761,
-0.19437968730926514,
1.146435260772705,
0.5770514011383057,
1.2219398021697998,
0.371233731508255,
0.610856831073761,
0.37560853362083435,
0.11746982485055923,
-1.1375640630722046,
0.5152104496955872,
-0.16789504885673523,
-0.46530717611312866,
-0.5370540618896484,
-0.4005570709705353,
-0.8757193088531494,
0.17677892744541168,
-0.41641929745674133,
-0.6616281270980835,
0.13118097186088562,
0.08929618448019028,
-0.14078359305858612,
0.11890407651662827,
-0.8589611649513245,
0.5991562604904175,
-0.5398153066635132,
-0.06932888925075531,
-0.24133536219596863,
-0.45156559348106384,
0.20930695533752441,
-0.7630764842033386,
0.6290833353996277,
-0.045102816075086594,
-0.09863986074924469,
0.7527079582214355,
-0.2091512531042099,
0.8314860463142395,
-0.12282454967498779,
-0.10058692842721939,
0.22146832942962646,
0.1736534982919693,
0.6334050893783569,
-0.4117635190486908,
-0.13176684081554413,
-0.3158097267150879,
0.05665360763669014,
-0.41982290148735046,
-0.41897130012512207,
0.4851400852203369,
-1.0960986614227295,
-0.5366336107254028,
-0.25700223445892334,
-0.720313310623169,
-0.29732832312583923,
0.40774276852607727,
-0.1707489788532257,
0.14145295321941376,
-0.2906721532344818,
0.1727525144815445,
0.7422621846199036,
-0.26957616209983826,
0.7146584391593933,
0.8277546167373657,
-0.25550270080566406,
-0.36858415603637695,
0.7025968432426453,
-0.09604217857122421,
0.16229096055030823,
0.3629726767539978,
0.6046358346939087,
-0.4916832745075226,
-0.9393317699432373,
-0.21003220975399017,
0.5301132798194885,
-0.7228049635887146,
-0.13123439252376556,
-0.0988178700208664,
-0.24229900538921356,
-0.4473877251148224,
-0.2528685927391052,
-0.053665418177843094,
-0.06262680888175964,
-0.3655318021774292,
0.254694402217865,
0.4328170120716095,
0.7733026742935181,
-0.22634950280189514,
0.38083142042160034,
-0.6659360527992249,
0.4641866087913513,
0.5721020698547363,
0.4050390422344208,
-0.09114208072423935,
-0.9631842970848083,
-0.24452996253967285,
-0.18092481791973114,
0.014608570374548435,
-0.8345587253570557,
0.2701628804206848,
0.646061897277832,
0.9973913431167603,
0.434215784072876,
0.10559190064668655,
0.5284337401390076,
-0.6132916212081909,
0.1043035015463829,
0.2672111690044403,
-1.034830093383789,
0.6182447075843811,
-0.5155922770500183,
0.39066755771636963,
0.23105135560035706,
0.41049477458000183,
-0.5488447546958923,
0.08413571864366531,
-0.12099526822566986,
-0.6484586000442505,
0.44505301117897034,
-0.041111744940280914,
0.345588743686676,
0.23499496281147003,
0.8552626371383667,
-0.11742036789655685,
0.009942896664142609,
-0.567118227481842,
0.19891159236431122,
0.03934193402528763,
-0.3848995864391327,
-0.1445976346731186,
-0.38129401206970215,
0.08881078660488129,
-0.34713396430015564,
0.7338047623634338,
-0.6315723657608032,
0.06595752388238907,
0.08697428554296494,
-0.4105576276779175,
-0.39898133277893066,
0.045345574617385864,
0.8059210181236267,
0.7432749271392822,
-0.1477099061012268,
-0.09417439252138138,
0.5156914591789246,
-0.5023266077041626,
0.1468462496995926,
-0.17915157973766327,
-0.20179243385791779,
-0.4224013388156891,
0.6011348962783813,
0.7230582237243652,
0.3856305480003357,
-0.6150408983230591,
0.4776363968849182,
-0.04155963286757469,
-0.2774580419063568,
-0.14867277443408966,
0.5903234481811523,
0.2604909837245941,
0.570475697517395,
0.3914530873298645,
-0.1800774782896042,
-0.09131557494401932,
-0.6290569305419922,
0.26054176688194275,
0.3932686150074005,
0.25784820318222046,
-0.028705015778541565,
0.4228972792625427,
0.36049216985702515,
-0.4448379874229431,
0.24791300296783447,
0.23306936025619507,
-0.5073137283325195,
0.36360353231430054,
0.8210139274597168,
0.8229237794876099,
-0.5135303735733032,
-0.1119578406214714,
0.3917844593524933,
0.1523168832063675,
-0.3802003264427185,
0.1661786437034607,
0.1974024921655655,
-0.9548987150192261,
-0.7019156813621521,
-0.812751293182373,
-0.42493581771850586,
-0.10916602611541748,
-0.5635449290275574,
0.42830583453178406,
-0.7581564784049988,
-0.03580356389284134,
0.11855705082416534,
0.019619030877947807,
-0.6945648789405823,
0.403323769569397,
0.39531856775283813,
1.26345694065094,
-0.9760712385177612,
0.5640759468078613,
0.5117470622062683,
-0.08913100510835648,
-0.8356472849845886,
-0.027669133618474007,
-0.11656057834625244,
-1.2136626243591309,
0.4433723986148834,
-0.23519808053970337,
-0.32057687640190125,
-0.09930375218391418,
-0.7893936038017273,
-1.0351158380508423,
1.025672197341919,
0.5255565643310547,
-0.7593451738357544,
-0.13085831701755524,
-0.10845664143562317,
0.5330649018287659,
-0.7304434180259705,
-0.08746036887168884,
0.6635290384292603,
0.6257863640785217,
0.27550649642944336,
-1.1545891761779785,
0.16412387788295746,
-0.021773988381028175,
0.10326240956783295,
0.043436434119939804,
-0.6859076619148254,
0.4485557973384857,
-0.4100306034088135,
0.3890770673751831,
0.02361905947327614,
0.5378758907318115,
0.2762347161769867,
0.0827384740114212,
0.7392492294311523,
0.21934159100055695,
0.8419318199157715,
0.3809238076210022,
0.8484671115875244,
-0.3219749331474304,
0.44190970063209534,
1.109089732170105,
-0.33645522594451904,
0.9556194543838501,
0.42820215225219727,
-0.0797312781214714,
0.6136678457260132,
0.5533025860786438,
-0.1305212676525116,
0.6476471424102783,
0.3935825526714325,
-0.21977952122688293,
-0.48259130120277405,
0.20616698265075684,
-0.049250222742557526,
0.702055037021637,
0.4509478509426117,
-0.4200144112110138,
-0.10345808416604996,
-0.31199556589126587,
0.1221046894788742,
0.040284663438797,
-0.6153162717819214,
0.9931499361991882,
0.08878675848245621,
-0.5962813496589661,
0.6382554173469543,
0.19671499729156494,
0.4020044505596161,
-0.3741099536418915,
0.13350898027420044,
-0.03268783167004585,
0.34377527236938477,
-0.1720128059387207,
-0.6751570105552673,
0.01008816622197628,
-0.10089263319969177,
-0.18931318819522858,
0.18439221382141113,
0.9127587080001831,
-0.13004209101200104,
-0.5199517011642456,
0.4594042897224426,
0.5134921669960022,
0.042187489569187164,
0.0034667146392166615,
-0.8519657850265503,
0.12050856649875641,
-0.041446253657341,
-0.2966375946998596,
0.24859483540058136,
0.488784521818161,
-0.040882132947444916,
1.081049919128418,
0.6213585734367371,
0.15669268369674683,
0.050772685557603836,
-0.07580848038196564,
0.764090895652771,
-0.8062529563903809,
-0.6108572483062744,
-0.956671953201294,
0.2685874104499817,
0.14836153388023376,
0.038889843970537186,
0.5594048500061035,
0.46020984649658203,
0.38635143637657166,
-0.2240670770406723,
1.0115433931350708,
0.3716345727443695,
0.3252326250076294,
-0.7957720756530762,
0.5388361811637878,
-0.6475687623023987,
0.02742970548570156,
-0.4916275143623352,
-1.1945370435714722,
-0.543423593044281,
0.96286940574646,
-0.514717161655426,
0.08259391784667969,
0.5401304960250854,
0.7546250224113464,
-0.2669273912906647,
-0.08017561584711075,
0.42880335450172424,
0.21252033114433289,
0.25632739067077637,
0.7548509240150452,
0.5705108642578125,
-0.1204470694065094,
0.2820958197116852,
0.15636226534843445,
-0.435993492603302,
-0.659351110458374,
-1.2516692876815796,
-1.0009641647338867,
-0.39370378851890564,
-0.3924247622489929,
-0.2358807474374771,
0.22311162948608398,
1.184536099433899,
1.0355011224746704,
-0.8565107583999634,
-0.5465899705886841,
-0.12503494322299957,
0.04713328182697296,
0.11213480681180954,
-0.17542827129364014,
0.29702770709991455,
-0.4256100654602051,
-0.408840149641037,
0.5072770714759827,
0.17132622003555298,
0.30247172713279724,
-0.18294425308704376,
-0.6220952868461609,
-0.18745100498199463,
0.558731734752655,
0.6782634258270264,
0.38988983631134033,
-0.3047086000442505,
-0.5559638142585754,
-0.035386353731155396,
-0.01277515385299921,
-0.09640327841043472,
0.695248007774353,
-0.2613636255264282,
0.3922896683216095,
0.3320773243904114,
0.6279070973396301,
0.6404213905334473,
-0.09252766519784927,
0.765309751033783,
-0.1996445655822754,
-0.07662306725978851,
-0.014562506228685379,
0.3893527090549469,
0.20808233320713043,
-0.10718097537755966,
0.5602341890335083,
0.13047772645950317,
-0.6185223460197449,
-0.6881876587867737,
0.13266621530056,
-0.9715418815612793,
-0.479824423789978,
1.5201259851455688,
-0.022753775119781494,
-0.487623929977417,
-0.05496549233794212,
-0.3580714464187622,
0.043558090925216675,
-0.23839706182479858,
0.823788583278656,
0.6052715182304382,
-0.4086301326751709,
-0.25813648104667664,
-0.42259055376052856,
0.4053865075111389,
0.023045614361763,
-0.946559488773346,
0.09850405156612396,
0.38034722208976746,
0.8973082304000854,
-0.11240717768669128,
0.38188642263412476,
0.3978462815284729,
0.2531050145626068,
-0.2560860514640808,
-0.08032416552305222,
0.2593275010585785,
-0.29295313358306885,
-0.4140334129333496,
-0.008755726739764214,
0.6690673232078552,
0.22617290914058685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02147v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02147v1 | LlamAr & GemmAr: Enhancing LLMs Through Arabic Instruction-Tuning | 2024-07-02T10:43:49 | 2024-07-02T10:43:49 | Hasna Chouikhi, Manel Aloui, Cyrine Ben Hammou, Ghaith Chaabane, Haithem Kchaou, Chehir Dhaouadi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have greatly impacted the natural language
processing (NLP) field, particularly for the English language. These models
have demonstrated capabilities in understanding and generating human-like text.
The success of language models largely depends on the availability of
high-quality instruction datasets, which consist of detailed task descriptions
and corresponding responses that are essential for training the models to
accurately address a variety of prompts. However, the availability and quality
of these resources vary by language. While models perform well in English, they
often struggle with languages like Arabic, due to the lack of datasets for
fine-tuning Arabic-specific tasks. To address this issue, we introduce
InstAr-500k, a new Arabic instruction dataset created by generating and
collecting content that covers several domains and instruction types. We then
assess this dataset by fine-tuning two open-source models, Llama-3-8B-Instruct
and Gemma-7B-IT, on several downstream tasks to scale improvements in their
functionality. Based on multiple evaluations, our fine-tuned models achieve
state-of-the-art performance on several Arabic NLP benchmarks. These outcomes
emphasize the effectiveness of our dataset in elevating the capabilities of
language models for Arabic. Our instruction dataset bridges the performance gap
between English and Arabic language models by providing resources that amplify
Arabic NLP development. Building on this foundation, we developed two
state-of-the-art models, LlamAr-8B and GemmAr-7B, which are specifically tuned
to excel at a wide range of Arabic NLP tasks. | [
-0.2757285535335541,
-0.5519686341285706,
0.22883610427379608,
0.25824999809265137,
-0.23433111608028412,
0.4418310225009918,
-0.3109802007675171,
-0.49749937653541565,
-0.1669853925704956,
0.5641785860061646,
-0.3565536141395569,
-0.8494842052459717,
-0.8574241399765015,
0.22151193022727966,
-0.514021098613739,
1.1240911483764648,
-0.16391871869564056,
0.20536644756793976,
-0.0420224666595459,
-0.1218094676733017,
-0.6459197402000427,
-0.3579337000846863,
-0.7309147119522095,
-0.3188929855823517,
0.33472388982772827,
0.8270940184593201,
1.030237078666687,
0.9960479140281677,
0.5968788266181946,
0.19022786617279053,
-0.11100728064775467,
0.5778036713600159,
-0.42760181427001953,
0.1689419150352478,
-0.06785234063863754,
-0.29963764548301697,
-0.4468359053134918,
-0.4844261705875397,
0.7041959762573242,
0.6191412210464478,
-0.31011295318603516,
0.39990365505218506,
0.27808329463005066,
0.8088135719299316,
-0.7385513186454773,
0.13774026930332184,
-0.4740784466266632,
-0.18159912526607513,
-0.29770228266716003,
-0.22431297600269318,
-0.3703502118587494,
-0.39664679765701294,
-0.19368678331375122,
-0.1766989827156067,
0.17642030119895935,
0.020433524623513222,
0.7459738254547119,
0.47599881887435913,
-0.3591308295726776,
-0.6287391781806946,
-0.695888340473175,
0.752260684967041,
-0.8165873289108276,
0.3549860715866089,
0.5361166596412659,
0.16301240026950836,
-0.47559863328933716,
-0.5539497137069702,
-0.2815939784049988,
-0.3794320225715637,
0.07615693658590317,
-0.15456978976726532,
-0.3203636705875397,
0.09632176905870438,
-0.014580008573830128,
0.48755964636802673,
-0.38000932335853577,
0.4665640592575073,
-0.12558622658252716,
0.056824710220098495,
0.5372516512870789,
0.39730313420295715,
0.2803373336791992,
0.27836737036705017,
-0.044813934713602066,
-0.062700055539608,
-1.135356068611145,
0.05123615637421608,
0.39188137650489807,
0.24786370992660522,
-0.21063166856765747,
0.6212691068649292,
-0.2521766722202301,
0.8072339296340942,
0.0950591042637825,
-0.3314128816127777,
-0.2601083219051361,
-0.17389197647571564,
-0.12370733916759491,
0.3700709640979767,
0.38923415541648865,
0.10855665057897568,
0.18792468309402466,
-0.2596331834793091,
-0.44863173365592957,
0.029200466349720955,
0.20258653163909912,
-1.1261391639709473,
-0.20510441064834595,
0.12524032592773438,
-0.18104664981365204,
-0.06422130763530731,
-0.10564347356557846,
-0.33708006143569946,
-0.3598019480705261,
-0.42886239290237427,
0.32513174414634705,
-0.35289105772972107,
0.10953971743583679,
0.49809229373931885,
0.4654618501663208,
0.3154257535934448,
0.19028371572494507,
-1.293070673942566,
0.5004262924194336,
0.7798859477043152,
0.731007993221283,
-0.1683671772480011,
-0.061772000044584274,
-0.4682057201862335,
0.3250783681869507,
-0.5446995496749878,
0.784739077091217,
-0.9862542748451233,
-0.39895281195640564,
0.3221881091594696,
-0.15716567635536194,
0.07083140313625336,
-0.8559997081756592,
0.6235848069190979,
-0.7056281566619873,
-0.09676598012447357,
-0.05862358585000038,
-0.7393972873687744,
-0.3807179033756256,
0.04315377399325371,
-0.6115058660507202,
1.3013938665390015,
0.12210770696401596,
-0.4753739535808563,
0.09762663394212723,
-0.8000392913818359,
-0.44961512088775635,
0.019434278830885887,
0.04120677709579468,
-0.34436899423599243,
0.21134892106056213,
0.6552477478981018,
0.5621078610420227,
-0.6104369163513184,
0.020371144637465477,
0.2692132890224457,
-0.6858632564544678,
0.11720745265483856,
-0.4435773193836212,
0.5224526524543762,
0.07507884502410889,
-0.36705130338668823,
0.1230306550860405,
-0.7781028747558594,
0.021226275712251663,
-0.1873619705438614,
-0.5399311184883118,
0.03020021878182888,
0.060451459139585495,
-0.02944115549325943,
-0.05699995160102844,
0.4455517828464508,
-0.36395445466041565,
0.21344788372516632,
-0.5740684270858765,
0.08083943277597427,
0.5926728844642639,
-0.00016202816914301366,
0.3443600535392761,
-0.42216283082962036,
0.8779423832893372,
-0.09237036108970642,
0.011556490324437618,
-0.3017102777957916,
-0.38427236676216125,
-1.147471308708191,
-0.41536393761634827,
0.2811926603317261,
0.4623435139656067,
-0.4976194500923157,
0.23949702084064484,
-0.18373584747314453,
-0.5238164067268372,
-1.0078845024108887,
0.48633936047554016,
0.4687804877758026,
0.39368027448654175,
0.47964999079704285,
-0.23478399217128754,
-0.49743983149528503,
-0.8244385719299316,
-0.1960112303495407,
0.2177964597940445,
0.03502563759684563,
0.10980495065450668,
0.33620089292526245,
-0.2458408772945404,
0.5387468934059143,
-0.25087258219718933,
-0.21568748354911804,
-0.4483693838119507,
-0.1124923825263977,
0.5632378458976746,
0.24026158452033997,
0.36762335896492004,
-0.33203092217445374,
-0.8085672855377197,
0.17440484464168549,
-0.5226797461509705,
-0.17274640500545502,
0.1428840458393097,
-0.1289951056241989,
0.33961793780326843,
0.3643282353878021,
-0.39392152428627014,
0.5191398859024048,
0.6649152040481567,
-0.2835167944431305,
0.44569969177246094,
-0.19489145278930664,
0.1699472814798355,
-1.1670103073120117,
-0.4351613521575928,
-0.24648942053318024,
-0.09916960448026657,
-0.49443337321281433,
0.22914119064807892,
0.0336141474545002,
0.12390395998954773,
-0.44570860266685486,
0.48620671033859253,
-0.5017191171646118,
0.05163875222206116,
-0.6049253344535828,
-0.25539717078208923,
-0.1299184262752533,
0.2535698413848877,
-0.1744042932987213,
1.3768543004989624,
0.4631827473640442,
-0.664850115776062,
0.1269768625497818,
0.35822758078575134,
-0.783997118473053,
0.1688595414161682,
-0.7850729823112488,
0.4083672761917114,
-0.010588856413960457,
-0.033521734178066254,
-0.7676523923873901,
-0.3797142207622528,
0.2512061893939972,
-0.05927315354347229,
0.42290377616882324,
-0.1599377989768982,
-0.7315853834152222,
0.20712068676948547,
-0.04155368357896805,
0.36038738489151,
0.42141395807266235,
-0.7963915467262268,
0.5605496764183044,
0.23410245776176453,
-0.2532370388507843,
-0.9028511643409729,
-0.22221074998378754,
0.2373700737953186,
-0.13147974014282227,
-0.41959747672080994,
0.48389682173728943,
0.13542313873767853,
-0.2023015171289444,
-0.015816887840628624,
-0.11914441734552383,
-0.13115419447422028,
-0.013043837621808052,
0.4771077632904053,
0.24142597615718842,
-0.4186663329601288,
0.23701614141464233,
0.3727070689201355,
-0.15605045855045319,
0.051098018884658813,
-0.176955446600914,
0.5577335357666016,
-0.08495838940143585,
-0.5088037252426147,
-0.5811962485313416,
0.2965502142906189,
0.2696298062801361,
-0.5508766770362854,
1.1232460737228394,
0.5970418453216553,
-0.1764795184135437,
-0.35152652859687805,
-0.4670884311199188,
-0.11069078743457794,
-0.5236607193946838,
0.6453794836997986,
-0.24066707491874695,
-0.9690336585044861,
0.0965949073433876,
-0.1475706547498703,
0.4199938178062439,
0.1181541383266449,
0.8343506455421448,
-0.12995964288711548,
1.1788371801376343,
0.8596870303153992,
-0.3956359624862671,
0.33635714650154114,
-0.16341012716293335,
0.2072887271642685,
-0.7420694828033447,
-0.17783883213996887,
-0.580446183681488,
-0.3845372200012207,
-0.4804404675960541,
-0.4117611050605774,
0.4365607500076294,
0.023383349180221558,
-0.4442037343978882,
0.09782315045595169,
-0.3556394577026367,
0.8726130723953247,
0.494524210691452,
0.08417116850614548,
0.379424124956131,
0.31366440653800964,
-0.01360299438238144,
-0.101385697722435,
-0.8710705637931824,
-1.105469822883606,
1.3544305562973022,
0.19599910080432892,
0.8249796628952026,
0.40410611033439636,
0.6122717261314392,
0.39491006731987,
0.5261690616607666,
-0.6423131823539734,
0.4046006500720978,
-0.2836841344833374,
-0.30347445607185364,
-0.02436043694615364,
0.03519933670759201,
-1.0013371706008911,
-0.011079765856266022,
-0.11969047039747238,
-0.5177184343338013,
-0.3011654019355774,
0.27293696999549866,
-0.33283621072769165,
0.2712486684322357,
-0.5620796084403992,
0.5257028341293335,
-0.1407328099012375,
-0.4416388273239136,
-0.513267993927002,
-0.23420830070972443,
0.16137252748012543,
0.06092126667499542,
-0.005567438900470734,
-0.2273164689540863,
-0.24408257007598877,
0.6108032464981079,
-0.2724587917327881,
0.7979038953781128,
0.13187961280345917,
-0.3455282747745514,
0.32608747482299805,
0.17355483770370483,
0.5854604244232178,
0.01112778577953577,
-0.24250930547714233,
0.2062804102897644,
-0.1694132685661316,
-0.540151834487915,
-0.5979910492897034,
0.6811990141868591,
-0.9844428300857544,
-0.7689937353134155,
-0.1965649127960205,
-0.8077731132507324,
-0.235152930021286,
-0.26150983572006226,
-0.03290318697690964,
0.44798994064331055,
-0.09287290275096893,
0.20816661417484283,
0.6353629231452942,
-0.18735530972480774,
0.42947039008140564,
0.6712053418159485,
-0.17169250547885895,
-0.2801183760166168,
0.7507286071777344,
-0.08203508704900742,
0.15438030660152435,
0.583248496055603,
-0.14247165620326996,
-0.2751355469226837,
-0.8096543550491333,
-0.5902721881866455,
0.2295241802930832,
-0.7349581122398376,
-0.4703332185745239,
-0.15587742626667023,
-0.3168623447418213,
0.05874354764819145,
-0.1248185932636261,
-0.3085072338581085,
-0.2978658378124237,
-0.5360903739929199,
-0.07922813296318054,
0.5337135195732117,
1.087494969367981,
0.2397482544183731,
0.6583647727966309,
-0.8584650158882141,
0.20679467916488647,
0.03861188143491745,
0.179353266954422,
0.09009620547294617,
-1.149109959602356,
-0.7866777777671814,
0.11863141506910324,
-0.46301764249801636,
-0.692175030708313,
0.44354817271232605,
0.49053770303726196,
0.09087370336055756,
0.4245971441268921,
-0.18167291581630707,
0.7688679695129395,
-0.7999763488769531,
0.4267246425151825,
-0.34584012627601624,
-0.7931855320930481,
0.38291803002357483,
-0.1648000180721283,
0.4433198571205139,
0.36723220348358154,
0.5760987401008606,
-0.36251938343048096,
-0.3623616397380829,
-0.07480297982692719,
-0.7772654891014099,
0.6082553267478943,
0.12501724064350128,
0.4078299403190613,
-0.002570874523371458,
0.5430972576141357,
0.33640652894973755,
0.12368156760931015,
-0.2456870824098587,
-0.2573586404323578,
0.035303182899951935,
-0.6136211156845093,
-0.10212758183479309,
-0.5217244029045105,
0.0009777945233508945,
-0.28594735264778137,
0.8761911392211914,
-0.01006739865988493,
0.02940763719379902,
-0.3803454637527466,
-0.2582319974899292,
-0.12685814499855042,
0.31886565685272217,
0.46294382214546204,
0.8527271747589111,
-0.15505735576152802,
-0.0006242500967346132,
0.2967250943183899,
-0.7772442698478699,
0.4204578697681427,
0.07129044830799103,
-0.12806753814220428,
-0.05858956649899483,
0.6197982430458069,
0.692632794380188,
0.4567034840583801,
-0.8192352056503296,
0.05707893893122673,
0.06772550940513611,
0.19963911175727844,
-0.38829147815704346,
0.5343636274337769,
0.2571784555912018,
0.33036336302757263,
0.3137577772140503,
-0.12253919243812561,
-0.10323769599199295,
-0.14169880747795105,
0.04008811339735985,
0.36355888843536377,
-0.25098106265068054,
-0.336333692073822,
0.5838165283203125,
0.009611574932932854,
-0.5331099033355713,
0.7699743509292603,
-0.0030817254446446896,
-0.15410810708999634,
0.6248218417167664,
0.8905242681503296,
0.6213288307189941,
-0.3318810760974884,
0.1835775226354599,
0.3166010081768036,
0.35782942175865173,
0.10683942586183548,
0.3708909749984741,
0.024637961760163307,
-0.8255493640899658,
-0.6160691380500793,
-0.7623206377029419,
-0.6225112080574036,
0.18386077880859375,
-0.7572354674339294,
0.12956075370311737,
-0.5076479911804199,
-0.058154039084911346,
-0.23988182842731476,
0.15409401059150696,
-0.8273480534553528,
0.13009607791900635,
-0.08905297517776489,
0.854911744594574,
-0.6263615489006042,
0.9568216800689697,
0.7671944499015808,
-0.15058788657188416,
-0.7724006175994873,
-0.18619665503501892,
-0.22138762474060059,
-1.0104385614395142,
0.6474322080612183,
0.20036038756370544,
-0.45726048946380615,
0.2795429229736328,
-0.5768177509307861,
-1.015132188796997,
0.9922455549240112,
0.72037273645401,
-0.7830955982208252,
0.2236199826002121,
0.5327916145324707,
0.4344858229160309,
-0.5184850692749023,
0.25390440225601196,
0.7784243822097778,
0.1959216445684433,
-0.13736219704151154,
-0.5902625918388367,
-0.16431541740894318,
-0.04762217774987221,
-0.07867796719074249,
0.3301766514778137,
-0.5390253067016602,
0.5859645009040833,
-0.3456626534461975,
-0.1765344738960266,
0.2705132067203522,
0.9629412293434143,
0.27478787302970886,
-0.03876522555947304,
0.055387046188116074,
0.5884407162666321,
0.6816115379333496,
0.042607296258211136,
1.035509705543518,
-0.6496938467025757,
-0.17800217866897583,
1.2266091108322144,
-0.20627078413963318,
1.1395914554595947,
0.43156105279922485,
-0.26977184414863586,
0.6943254470825195,
0.6233372092247009,
0.1834275722503662,
0.34506678581237793,
0.044754840433597565,
-0.7956996560096741,
-0.22346432507038116,
-0.47545966506004333,
-0.23782646656036377,
0.753598153591156,
0.5149267911911011,
-0.33189624547958374,
-0.19586081802845,
-0.2922452688217163,
0.2763184607028961,
0.3112722337245941,
-0.3786739706993103,
0.6361851692199707,
0.009799818508327007,
-0.429643452167511,
0.8314509987831116,
0.37544938921928406,
0.39479848742485046,
-0.6506335735321045,
-0.4062395393848419,
-0.48677751421928406,
0.16110053658485413,
-0.23823203146457672,
-0.4366712272167206,
0.06782979518175125,
0.4837351143360138,
-0.16072088479995728,
-0.042116452008485794,
0.32272636890411377,
-0.47273775935173035,
-0.8108665943145752,
0.031396735459566116,
0.33758413791656494,
0.18966154754161835,
0.2115917056798935,
-0.41748347878456116,
0.17945413291454315,
0.0694342851638794,
-0.030057480558753014,
0.40788596868515015,
0.27066493034362793,
0.0027170588728040457,
0.8434144854545593,
0.5628346800804138,
0.2473476231098175,
0.09960392862558365,
0.1857665628194809,
0.757938802242279,
-0.5216516256332397,
-0.017653247341513634,
-1.0296775102615356,
0.3352619707584381,
0.3167170584201813,
-0.4987192451953888,
0.8762881755828857,
0.6176614761352539,
0.8779240250587463,
-0.08622753620147705,
0.43685382604599,
0.44172239303588867,
0.4782017469406128,
-0.7517564296722412,
0.628907322883606,
-0.30475541949272156,
0.5131312608718872,
0.18015983700752258,
-1.0286070108413696,
-0.22430521249771118,
0.5236880779266357,
-0.1380578577518463,
0.03899246081709862,
0.49974575638771057,
1.2813819646835327,
-0.06243669241666794,
-0.02048097737133503,
0.22934943437576294,
0.11078425496816635,
0.18341676890850067,
0.6147307753562927,
0.9686481356620789,
-0.3094211220741272,
0.37988904118537903,
-0.23914866149425507,
-0.03923492506146431,
-0.10184741020202637,
-0.7807122468948364,
-1.0632193088531494,
-0.31054073572158813,
-0.1831430196762085,
0.0277402363717556,
0.3625628352165222,
1.2422213554382324,
0.4483596682548523,
-0.9941902160644531,
-0.654575765132904,
0.03493166342377663,
0.0805363655090332,
-0.20405101776123047,
-0.10400412976741791,
0.688381552696228,
-0.5663414597511292,
-0.7924160957336426,
0.6644445061683655,
0.36324772238731384,
-0.05271858721971512,
-0.10521332174539566,
-0.18956270813941956,
-0.025043781846761703,
0.18994136154651642,
0.5429918766021729,
0.12626607716083527,
-0.7047955989837646,
-0.11634141951799393,
-0.06902140378952026,
-0.0021693690214306116,
0.21208329498767853,
0.4734991788864136,
-0.7141811847686768,
0.25010448694229126,
-0.2731113135814667,
1.0904110670089722,
0.33269572257995605,
-0.121238112449646,
0.5473756790161133,
-0.7934050559997559,
0.238870307803154,
0.2002941220998764,
0.18325816094875336,
0.5524410605430603,
-0.2703028619289398,
0.5429068803787231,
-0.6253476738929749,
-0.6419031620025635,
-0.5958952307701111,
0.17076735198497772,
-0.3702123463153839,
0.13769018650054932,
0.9671717286109924,
-0.08657588064670563,
0.07733958214521408,
-0.1076684296131134,
-0.35921451449394226,
0.24407581984996796,
-0.3977912366390228,
1.182064175605774,
0.7890374660491943,
-0.16508103907108307,
-0.12659558653831482,
-0.7615159153938293,
0.5587449669837952,
0.692873477935791,
-0.8168812394142151,
-0.2618786692619324,
0.30424433946609497,
-0.00636304309591651,
-0.528526246547699,
0.12836436927318573,
0.19318868219852448,
0.37322232127189636,
-0.2082429826259613,
0.05383233353495598,
-0.2516951858997345,
-0.4467223584651947,
-0.32152098417282104,
0.041852567344903946,
0.5757140517234802,
-0.2511879801750183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02138v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02138v1 | Efficient Nearest Neighbor based Uncertainty Estimation for Natural Language Processing Tasks | 2024-07-02T10:33:31 | 2024-07-02T10:33:31 | Wataru Hashimoto, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Trustworthy prediction in Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), including Pre-trained
Language Models (PLMs) is important for safety-critical applications in the
real world. However, DNNs often suffer from uncertainty estimation, such as
miscalibration. In particular, approaches that require multiple stochastic
inference can mitigate this problem, but the expensive cost of inference makes
them impractical. In this study, we propose $k$-Nearest Neighbor Uncertainty
Estimation ($k$NN-UE), which is an uncertainty estimation method that uses the
distances from the neighbors and label-existence ratio of neighbors.
Experiments on sentiment analysis, natural language inference, and named entity
recognition show that our proposed method outperforms the baselines or recent
density-based methods in confidence calibration, selective prediction, and
out-of-distribution detection. Moreover, our analyses indicate that introducing
dimension reduction or approximate nearest neighbor search inspired by recent
$k$NN-LM studies reduces the inference overhead without significantly degrading
estimation performance when combined them appropriately. | [
-0.42590245604515076,
-0.6021703481674194,
0.8458247184753418,
-0.06507933884859085,
-0.168038472533226,
-0.007607470732182264,
-0.3617585599422455,
-0.5097398161888123,
0.11192977428436279,
0.3284018337726593,
-0.43287748098373413,
-0.5168431401252747,
-0.7227166295051575,
0.06738647818565369,
0.26012173295021057,
0.3088414967060089,
0.2686108350753784,
0.01756717823445797,
-0.16154752671718597,
-0.000665455125272274,
-0.05050424858927727,
-0.3449113667011261,
-0.6547682285308838,
-0.1343867927789688,
0.47144463658332825,
0.3281761705875397,
1.026631236076355,
0.3775250017642975,
0.4834444224834442,
0.3125571608543396,
-0.355058491230011,
0.31417620182037354,
0.05733564868569374,
0.08107766509056091,
0.15262216329574585,
-0.4951222836971283,
-0.27347302436828613,
0.0019885858055204153,
0.7681384086608887,
0.8163639307022095,
-0.001692676916718483,
-0.07589376717805862,
-0.19315828382968903,
0.9741237163543701,
-0.8646580576896667,
-0.0832102969288826,
-0.37864965200424194,
0.3866860866546631,
-0.05407710000872612,
0.36996757984161377,
-0.24330393970012665,
-0.7421360015869141,
0.521065890789032,
-0.476749449968338,
-0.09044263511896133,
0.01268049981445074,
0.8447739481925964,
0.577843964099884,
0.02979366108775139,
-0.17268961668014526,
-0.6113491058349609,
1.0998749732971191,
-1.0897589921951294,
0.7667563557624817,
0.9813389778137207,
0.30364564061164856,
-0.5385825037956238,
-0.6725932359695435,
-0.6487074494361877,
-0.421835333108902,
-0.0437685027718544,
0.10706181079149246,
-0.004372425377368927,
0.41273659467697144,
0.011025425046682358,
0.43513283133506775,
-0.2686169743537903,
0.30426540970802307,
0.11461694538593292,
-0.4565940499305725,
0.3581261932849884,
-0.2582698166370392,
-0.1291765570640564,
-0.3924449682235718,
-0.346737265586853,
-0.10233653336763382,
-0.2398374378681183,
0.07244104146957397,
0.6383640766143799,
0.2504623532295227,
0.022742589935660362,
0.18022242188453674,
-0.34302088618278503,
0.6924891471862793,
-0.09986750781536102,
-0.401183158159256,
0.1488834023475647,
-0.3615097105503082,
-0.4355570077896118,
-0.010519076138734818,
1.1306344270706177,
0.3512079417705536,
0.26664313673973083,
-0.258206844329834,
0.03670062497258186,
-0.19436025619506836,
0.09543631970882416,
-0.7038655281066895,
-0.5204671621322632,
0.1904963254928589,
-0.45905572175979614,
-0.5309279561042786,
0.005031332839280367,
-1.2246391773223877,
-0.35376253724098206,
-0.16116639971733093,
0.18007905781269073,
-0.47999274730682373,
-0.35473915934562683,
-0.14511311054229736,
0.18346279859542847,
-0.33430591225624084,
-0.020269567146897316,
-0.35046571493148804,
0.1298767626285553,
0.2724428176879883,
0.8960813283920288,
0.05780763179063797,
-0.10364606976509094,
-0.45769187808036804,
-0.243756964802742,
-0.42421841621398926,
0.39363566040992737,
-0.6540394425392151,
-0.1259368360042572,
-0.3092622756958008,
-0.4474705159664154,
-0.05682193860411644,
-0.491473525762558,
0.6318012475967407,
-0.6729499697685242,
-0.027873070910573006,
-0.05548502877354622,
-0.689696192741394,
-0.18849043548107147,
0.1884079873561859,
-0.8584778308868408,
1.4137722253799438,
-0.021998979151248932,
-1.025897741317749,
0.35960930585861206,
-0.3830172121524811,
-0.1082364022731781,
-0.40001189708709717,
0.07022013515233994,
-0.6706794500350952,
0.43725064396858215,
0.5357139110565186,
0.4475375711917877,
-0.11024969816207886,
0.2357194423675537,
-0.5711634755134583,
-0.15914426743984222,
0.23952196538448334,
-0.727070152759552,
0.5556173324584961,
0.37009647488594055,
0.017166754230856895,
-0.0804300457239151,
-0.7984984517097473,
0.23287305235862732,
-0.2203005850315094,
-0.16152095794677734,
-0.49016058444976807,
-0.09281356632709503,
-0.5542373061180115,
0.11075510084629059,
0.26334768533706665,
-0.5858736038208008,
-0.19967147707939148,
-0.8350341320037842,
0.2346583753824234,
0.5908132195472717,
0.11843577027320862,
0.874747097492218,
0.017422229051589966,
0.36982184648513794,
0.09624196588993073,
0.1958325058221817,
0.4108890891075134,
-0.6064133048057556,
-0.3473643660545349,
-0.26932424306869507,
0.7542701959609985,
0.3581269681453705,
-0.85378098487854,
0.4899691343307495,
-0.29767438769340515,
-0.5421845316886902,
-0.6429933905601501,
0.10024170577526093,
0.4000425338745117,
0.6090932488441467,
0.2948504090309143,
0.08070579916238785,
-0.5497172474861145,
-0.7321149706840515,
-0.2526348829269409,
-0.2478662133216858,
-0.2243483066558838,
0.09179674834012985,
0.2512623965740204,
-0.09873639792203903,
1.1794331073760986,
-0.35081687569618225,
-0.14221954345703125,
0.0775197297334671,
0.30692610144615173,
0.060272686183452606,
0.3193521201610565,
0.2910943627357483,
-0.7095985412597656,
-0.6891435980796814,
-0.1820240467786789,
-0.37568098306655884,
0.03339841216802597,
0.023007579147815704,
-0.07665399461984634,
0.27676036953926086,
0.34365689754486084,
-0.49455171823501587,
0.601698100566864,
0.792253315448761,
0.2939339876174927,
0.475529283285141,
-0.35415247082710266,
-0.04721824824810028,
-1.131340503692627,
-0.37712836265563965,
0.31383323669433594,
-0.2822364270687103,
-0.6920382380485535,
-0.15029653906822205,
-0.012054278515279293,
0.3758012056350708,
-0.1545490175485611,
0.2839706242084503,
-0.4962218403816223,
-0.1978238970041275,
-0.19273830950260162,
0.35189247131347656,
0.11846526712179184,
0.23853699862957,
0.3908272683620453,
0.8073621988296509,
0.6668620705604553,
-0.5940808653831482,
0.15406082570552826,
-0.17583240568637848,
-0.5219040513038635,
0.61595618724823,
-0.16509902477264404,
0.31422001123428345,
-0.05379727482795715,
0.11210054904222488,
-0.6368449330329895,
0.03532810136675835,
0.26425886154174805,
-0.5835184454917908,
0.4238097369670868,
-0.27519211173057556,
-0.5874843001365662,
-0.4762318730354309,
-0.3003685772418976,
0.22558024525642395,
0.2054232954978943,
-0.5833212733268738,
0.4789029061794281,
0.3504669964313507,
-0.02706628292798996,
-0.6144917011260986,
-0.9048079252243042,
0.1856030374765396,
-0.23268568515777588,
-0.4973819851875305,
0.2169562727212906,
0.05489005893468857,
-0.27422019839286804,
-0.05200553312897682,
-0.4936738908290863,
-0.642149806022644,
0.054611239582300186,
0.17738042771816254,
-0.06777719408273697,
-0.20330481231212616,
0.22694948315620422,
0.0234695952385664,
-0.32972437143325806,
-0.03548375144600868,
-0.33333125710487366,
0.11925096809864044,
-0.18754667043685913,
-0.24165013432502747,
-0.6344097852706909,
0.08702699095010757,
0.3649566173553467,
-0.010475464165210724,
0.8630689978599548,
0.7879402041435242,
-0.6255617737770081,
-0.20861339569091797,
-0.7160537242889404,
-0.26345568895339966,
-0.4941955506801605,
0.3546428680419922,
-0.3846351206302643,
-0.7962501645088196,
0.40981441736221313,
-0.1455623209476471,
-0.44999995827674866,
0.016744339838624,
-0.010821256786584854,
-0.3626023530960083,
0.5837032198905945,
0.2735864520072937,
-0.3825070559978485,
0.2339596450328827,
0.11938197165727615,
0.6790673136711121,
-0.6993157267570496,
0.05228809639811516,
-0.561077356338501,
-0.2583008110523224,
-0.5831632018089294,
-0.7876238226890564,
0.21837088465690613,
0.303928017616272,
-0.02415492758154869,
0.22971034049987793,
-0.4358678460121155,
0.5247178077697754,
0.9804966449737549,
0.2129821628332138,
0.3433104157447815,
0.21689175069332123,
-0.3039708733558655,
-0.5397443771362305,
-0.643865168094635,
-0.46359026432037354,
0.8645631074905396,
0.5408492684364319,
0.42024752497673035,
0.03356622904539108,
0.7891902923583984,
-0.039569880813360214,
0.15608620643615723,
-0.6424292922019958,
0.3379339575767517,
-0.07637502253055573,
-0.3014427721500397,
-0.5469779968261719,
-0.9596789479255676,
-0.5516731142997742,
0.06869848072528839,
0.045126695185899734,
-0.9864122271537781,
0.1597953736782074,
-0.0011240210151299834,
-0.6742213368415833,
0.790258526802063,
-0.623090386390686,
0.557093620300293,
0.009147990494966507,
0.013632523827254772,
0.08903516829013824,
-0.8025117516517639,
0.11920667439699173,
-0.07417359948158264,
0.26948282122612,
-0.23874959349632263,
0.07377588748931885,
0.513504147529602,
-0.5398993492126465,
0.7130530476570129,
-0.34218573570251465,
0.047055136412382126,
0.5115551352500916,
0.2557355463504791,
0.7915685176849365,
0.2852233052253723,
-0.5543285608291626,
0.4168357253074646,
-0.10743626952171326,
-0.10688483715057373,
-0.5354906320571899,
0.7657567262649536,
-0.4681559205055237,
-0.047197792679071426,
-0.34632864594459534,
-0.7192356586456299,
-0.503633439540863,
0.16944538056850433,
0.47644612193107605,
0.09094306081533432,
0.13194791972637177,
0.05969482660293579,
0.5431608557701111,
-0.15346378087997437,
0.7927863001823425,
0.04006655514240265,
0.24972108006477356,
-0.6776496767997742,
0.9276992082595825,
0.19432562589645386,
0.4395042061805725,
0.5811295509338379,
0.4250531792640686,
-0.6002406477928162,
-0.871313750743866,
-0.2952321171760559,
-0.1349061131477356,
-0.47578951716423035,
-0.3014635741710663,
-0.46419304609298706,
-0.05585747957229614,
-0.22646838426589966,
-0.06062629818916321,
-0.8075847029685974,
-0.1560301035642624,
-0.3613312840461731,
-0.27391985058784485,
0.4875790476799011,
0.4833995997905731,
-0.19588744640350342,
0.5204489231109619,
-0.8453709483146667,
0.23159539699554443,
0.29295262694358826,
0.8523446321487427,
-0.11001761257648468,
-0.4400034248828888,
-0.06484537571668625,
0.5402742624282837,
0.20523282885551453,
-0.9480612874031067,
0.38473761081695557,
0.29857581853866577,
0.48023802042007446,
0.2907222509384155,
0.47382017970085144,
0.670292854309082,
-0.014871660619974136,
0.6366339921951294,
0.11988310515880585,
-0.6892321109771729,
0.37696805596351624,
-0.04167795553803444,
0.2606821060180664,
0.9968162178993225,
0.24022948741912842,
-0.0781167522072792,
-0.33365848660469055,
-0.4798606038093567,
-0.5552449822425842,
0.5480207204818726,
0.588620126247406,
-0.180728018283844,
-0.02968496084213257,
0.24462030827999115,
-0.21275179088115692,
0.3172835111618042,
-0.6156938672065735,
-0.5508975982666016,
0.02244952693581581,
-0.38877445459365845,
0.19847264885902405,
-0.3783325254917145,
0.391694039106369,
-0.20750363171100616,
0.6527870297431946,
-0.13107900321483612,
0.2047862559556961,
0.3617672324180603,
-0.10991821438074112,
-0.015794651582837105,
0.17328782379627228,
0.3232540786266327,
0.17159029841423035,
-0.5077345967292786,
0.33769869804382324,
0.5951451659202576,
-0.644464910030365,
-0.02427009679377079,
0.13679802417755127,
-0.11539400368928909,
0.31627175211906433,
-0.020541751757264137,
0.4673108160495758,
0.3403889238834381,
-0.31360694766044617,
0.5049918293952942,
-0.17618238925933838,
-0.20981624722480774,
-0.34203460812568665,
-0.40711885690689087,
0.20643983781337738,
0.2073950171470642,
0.03432886302471161,
0.3531004786491394,
0.13572679460048676,
0.17350535094738007,
0.2768327295780182,
0.24519601464271545,
-0.8299735188484192,
-0.1715766042470932,
0.2958579659461975,
-0.19455486536026,
-0.19072048366069794,
0.4943256080150604,
-0.6591315865516663,
-0.44183629751205444,
0.5614007115364075,
0.13083231449127197,
0.8810715079307556,
-0.369291752576828,
0.39804181456565857,
0.4376761019229889,
0.49611327052116394,
-0.2802254855632782,
0.12502451241016388,
0.12625524401664734,
-0.8476651906967163,
-0.5592077374458313,
-0.951309084892273,
-0.29411938786506653,
0.12605281174182892,
-0.5149281024932861,
-0.3317309021949768,
-0.42361417412757874,
-0.4090443253517151,
-0.3066900968551636,
0.1560511738061905,
-0.4978914260864258,
0.276069700717926,
0.14883311092853546,
0.6837581992149353,
-0.5637024641036987,
0.8203111290931702,
0.5609885454177856,
-0.10431073606014252,
-0.7631664276123047,
0.16111572086811066,
-0.12175463885068893,
-0.2098286896944046,
0.44388559460639954,
0.18190594017505646,
-0.25055044889450073,
-0.14415384829044342,
-0.10677462816238403,
-1.0683064460754395,
0.8322740197181702,
0.39512163400650024,
-0.563891589641571,
0.1675957292318344,
0.32316717505455017,
0.5182229280471802,
-0.06009162589907646,
0.23608317971229553,
0.6639423966407776,
0.6756870746612549,
-0.06870049238204956,
-0.947350800037384,
-0.1849515736103058,
0.18597543239593506,
0.25883999466896057,
0.4105602204799652,
-0.22905409336090088,
0.5269123911857605,
-0.20534870028495789,
-0.16594021022319794,
0.10826783627271652,
0.967522144317627,
0.17933060228824615,
0.41775208711624146,
0.667023777961731,
0.9014638066291809,
1.1592705249786377,
0.01662159524857998,
0.8436834216117859,
-0.15738996863365173,
0.3045462369918823,
1.5406407117843628,
0.023870429024100304,
0.8450139164924622,
0.5880085825920105,
-0.5115222334861755,
0.307839572429657,
0.6155762076377869,
0.29753950238227844,
0.5323246717453003,
0.046405039727687836,
-0.40988773107528687,
-0.31638282537460327,
-0.09316352754831314,
-0.16314555704593658,
0.26215213537216187,
0.39011621475219727,
-0.47619396448135376,
-0.12202084809541702,
-0.28895965218544006,
0.05796448886394501,
0.25781723856925964,
-0.10792391747236252,
0.5748811364173889,
0.3534119129180908,
-0.3682129383087158,
0.10177798569202423,
-0.1260140985250473,
0.7412389516830444,
-0.2332342565059662,
0.1965727061033249,
-0.054768797010183334,
0.018734421581029892,
-0.007231862284243107,
-0.5438998341560364,
0.3459172248840332,
-0.31020817160606384,
-0.14439034461975098,
0.07396215200424194,
0.9597493410110474,
-0.3064081370830536,
-0.7149358987808228,
0.29350918531417847,
0.39083242416381836,
0.09388802200555801,
-0.635741114616394,
-0.5845941305160522,
-0.3138989210128784,
-0.0674210861325264,
-0.3449130356311798,
0.380195677280426,
0.4671643078327179,
0.2798522710800171,
0.723193347454071,
0.6558187007904053,
0.30677616596221924,
0.35190561413764954,
-0.018493644893169403,
0.3492885231971741,
-0.1770562380552292,
-0.4759039580821991,
-0.781123161315918,
0.3180081248283386,
-0.22937223315238953,
-0.19796858727931976,
0.6947179436683655,
0.11106827855110168,
0.7589516043663025,
0.0752226859331131,
0.5571286678314209,
0.20905426144599915,
0.5133194327354431,
-0.4296281039714813,
0.6043817400932312,
-0.19701945781707764,
0.2140280306339264,
-0.3785512149333954,
-1.1092519760131836,
-0.4711613655090332,
0.9572795629501343,
-0.42667898535728455,
0.2165777087211609,
0.6276713609695435,
0.9321794509887695,
-0.00872925203293562,
0.34497272968292236,
0.41655534505844116,
0.037602756172418594,
-0.03248037397861481,
0.31019142270088196,
0.5489314794540405,
-0.5482421517372131,
0.5273948907852173,
-1.2418262958526611,
0.15551413595676422,
0.08994432538747787,
-1.319024682044983,
-0.7501857876777649,
-0.181701198220253,
-0.3323616683483124,
-0.08937131613492966,
-0.14914898574352264,
0.8491438627243042,
0.8367273211479187,
-0.9396864771842957,
0.3510203957557678,
-0.42331135272979736,
0.2821085751056671,
-0.280062735080719,
-0.22186002135276794,
0.495779424905777,
-0.22984719276428223,
-0.7623906135559082,
0.6225739121437073,
0.14287588000297546,
0.05507880821824074,
-0.0568503737449646,
-0.18999646604061127,
-0.24844148755073547,
-0.1195753738284111,
0.22457921504974365,
0.0804768055677414,
-0.7994115948677063,
-0.5642907023429871,
-0.11713114380836487,
-0.17023435235023499,
0.08196699619293213,
0.11634939163923264,
-0.5361661911010742,
0.728921115398407,
0.5804882645606995,
0.7809605598449707,
0.11408115923404694,
0.04263214021921158,
0.5437107682228088,
-1.2383852005004883,
0.16117705404758453,
0.4136224389076233,
0.29319608211517334,
0.3767367899417877,
-0.3346226215362549,
0.4461193382740021,
0.05256883054971695,
-0.6929752230644226,
-0.8130906820297241,
0.21424105763435364,
-0.5621916651725769,
-0.04703110456466675,
0.8701358437538147,
-0.2664046585559845,
-0.11366526037454605,
-0.31003233790397644,
0.2058056890964508,
0.2569023370742798,
-0.5698254108428955,
0.5215435028076172,
0.7255114316940308,
0.1747656613588333,
-0.2542026937007904,
-0.9023568034172058,
0.6572115421295166,
0.6077368855476379,
-0.47965502738952637,
-0.18778246641159058,
0.39202144742012024,
-0.07664816826581955,
0.3137088716030121,
0.2699733376502991,
0.23070020973682404,
-0.10919211059808731,
0.07601368427276611,
-0.027137000113725662,
-0.1243949607014656,
-0.4456503987312317,
-0.1471555083990097,
0.14866961538791656,
0.15758396685123444,
-0.3522112965583801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02136v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02136v1 | Black Big Boxes: Do Language Models Hide a Theory of Adjective Order? | 2024-07-02T10:29:09 | 2024-07-02T10:29:09 | Jaap Jumelet, Lisa Bylinina, Willem Zuidema, Jakub Szymanik | cs.CL | cs.CL | In English and other languages, multiple adjectives in a complex noun phrase
show intricate ordering patterns that have been a target of much linguistic
theory. These patterns offer an opportunity to assess the ability of language
models (LMs) to learn subtle rules of language involving factors that cross the
traditional divisions of syntax, semantics, and pragmatics. We review existing
hypotheses designed to explain Adjective Order Preferences (AOPs) in humans and
develop a setup to study AOPs in LMs: we present a reusable corpus of adjective
pairs and define AOP measures for LMs. With these tools, we study a series of
LMs across intermediate checkpoints during training. We find that all models'
predictions are much closer to human AOPs than predictions generated by factors
identified in theoretical linguistics. At the same time, we demonstrate that
the observed AOPs in LMs are strongly correlated with the frequency of the
adjective pairs in the training data and report limited generalization to
unseen combinations. This highlights the difficulty in establishing the link
between LM performance and linguistic theory. We therefore conclude with a road
map for future studies our results set the stage for, and a discussion of key
questions about the nature of knowledge in LMs and their ability to generalize
beyond the training sets. | [
-0.5538182258605957,
-0.8625293970108032,
0.6438359022140503,
-0.058168038725852966,
0.10133817791938782,
-0.03760123997926712,
-0.21177108585834503,
-0.7194774150848389,
0.1947447955608368,
0.47409313917160034,
-0.20413079857826233,
-0.2882307469844818,
-0.657122015953064,
-0.052649468183517456,
-0.26749518513679504,
0.7563885450363159,
0.17299890518188477,
0.16693395376205444,
-0.08265244215726852,
-0.18680192530155182,
-0.04182347282767296,
-0.6674751043319702,
-0.6197660565376282,
-0.5349249839782715,
0.6942940354347229,
0.103243887424469,
1.2201650142669678,
0.9546478390693665,
0.37485411763191223,
0.30071863532066345,
-0.28812849521636963,
0.07592661678791046,
-0.24467583000659943,
0.023559043183922768,
-0.31978851556777954,
-0.8010915517807007,
-0.5988737940788269,
0.21048009395599365,
0.5206297039985657,
1.112993597984314,
0.0380205474793911,
0.02664151042699814,
-0.18094411492347717,
0.7420966625213623,
-0.6799459457397461,
0.21436092257499695,
-0.4513316750526428,
0.18178264796733856,
0.1423685997724533,
-0.2905004024505615,
-0.4309980869293213,
0.004818604327738285,
0.3423071503639221,
-0.1483381986618042,
0.3020709455013275,
0.4239419400691986,
1.143296718597412,
-0.08788257092237473,
-0.7654715776443481,
-0.18610316514968872,
-0.8810839653015137,
0.7342005372047424,
-0.6413624286651611,
0.4536542594432831,
0.6138817667961121,
0.10475888848304749,
-0.2753119468688965,
-0.24888527393341064,
-0.5557713508605957,
-0.45531708002090454,
-0.28430813550949097,
-0.17818321287631989,
-0.1742602288722992,
0.48421144485473633,
0.24259766936302185,
0.5943779349327087,
-0.4986925423145294,
0.4124669134616852,
-0.2978266179561615,
0.13736297190189362,
0.646102786064148,
0.21209338307380676,
0.35054174065589905,
-0.0807875394821167,
-0.21238817274570465,
0.0784483402967453,
-0.5779003500938416,
0.25325024127960205,
0.32630354166030884,
0.17464499175548553,
-0.007597628980875015,
0.679019570350647,
-0.28285712003707886,
0.7075783014297485,
0.038798458874225616,
-0.07624882459640503,
0.3245338499546051,
-0.12758943438529968,
-0.07587868720293045,
-0.38912564516067505,
0.8898017406463623,
0.3187381327152252,
0.20312438905239105,
-0.32725009322166443,
-0.404299795627594,
0.4746037423610687,
0.3859097957611084,
-0.4637824594974518,
-0.18994951248168945,
0.05306313931941986,
-0.3310181200504303,
-0.4454994797706604,
0.024338189512491226,
-0.6161520481109619,
-0.3777025640010834,
-0.4498053789138794,
0.5346418619155884,
-0.11951111257076263,
-0.3367559313774109,
0.2758832573890686,
0.05730864033102989,
0.23949192464351654,
0.043499693274497986,
-1.060219168663025,
0.5761814713478088,
0.8226842880249023,
0.39134135842323303,
-0.1769331693649292,
-0.4710276424884796,
-0.07649674266576767,
-0.08767671138048172,
-0.784005343914032,
0.7632545232772827,
-0.6338504552841187,
-0.21290746331214905,
0.18893012404441833,
0.0885109007358551,
0.09635498374700546,
-0.45320242643356323,
0.29063931107521057,
-0.510904848575592,
0.3652653992176056,
-0.004422142170369625,
-0.5759318470954895,
-0.3793114125728607,
0.017486557364463806,
-0.47868168354034424,
0.7475646138191223,
-0.3712143003940582,
-0.4771880507469177,
0.3392474055290222,
-0.2758447229862213,
-0.3995244801044464,
-0.16399529576301575,
-0.2876397967338562,
-0.273420512676239,
0.5341899991035461,
-0.20330993831157684,
0.6861917972564697,
-0.14205236732959747,
0.20709167420864105,
-0.5438039302825928,
-0.12928108870983124,
0.44342729449272156,
-0.1703367829322815,
0.5585257411003113,
0.02157779037952423,
-0.4631577432155609,
-0.08563272655010223,
-0.6489743590354919,
0.1286277025938034,
0.22017446160316467,
-0.34796983003616333,
-0.5718064904212952,
0.14924956858158112,
-0.4942796230316162,
0.3558913469314575,
0.10367576777935028,
-0.2542863190174103,
0.14505256712436676,
-0.49523261189460754,
0.23501276969909668,
0.7307959198951721,
-0.17573466897010803,
0.7480081915855408,
-0.2628766894340515,
0.6718396544456482,
-0.04194699972867966,
0.1382129192352295,
0.044994112104177475,
-0.5333092212677002,
-1.127899169921875,
0.04383401572704315,
0.3034028112888336,
0.3502088785171509,
-0.3134402930736542,
0.5051893591880798,
-0.13915227353572845,
-0.3181467652320862,
-0.662027895450592,
0.26295459270477295,
0.8049461245536804,
-0.16014179587364197,
0.06961452215909958,
-0.663826584815979,
-0.12352024763822556,
-1.2807698249816895,
-0.35485973954200745,
-0.21594902873039246,
0.04605864733457565,
0.3789556324481964,
0.5046641826629639,
-0.12365841120481491,
0.6996040940284729,
-0.7640242576599121,
0.0158709529787302,
-0.22357177734375,
0.2777057886123657,
0.07156243175268173,
0.060522351413965225,
0.7759531736373901,
-0.8254361748695374,
0.10347842425107956,
-0.09909497946500778,
-0.4530975818634033,
0.14886468648910522,
0.43694978952407837,
-0.1913076788187027,
0.16186736524105072,
0.5941583514213562,
-0.5416450500488281,
0.35362157225608826,
0.5847602486610413,
-0.6059879064559937,
0.6328991055488586,
-0.3574654757976532,
-0.23955446481704712,
-0.8812615871429443,
-0.21961508691310883,
0.1999921053647995,
-0.10070623457431793,
-0.9563415050506592,
0.30343616008758545,
-0.048589203506708145,
0.09548009932041168,
-0.08594883978366852,
0.6094324588775635,
-0.5990840792655945,
-0.16836364567279816,
-0.28013503551483154,
-0.08883922547101974,
0.15461549162864685,
0.8468191027641296,
0.15680503845214844,
0.0789463147521019,
0.6949481964111328,
-0.9075039029121399,
0.07285718619823456,
-0.20247802138328552,
-0.3484266400337219,
0.4042496085166931,
-0.47060129046440125,
0.04615141451358795,
-0.5127370953559875,
-0.11744635552167892,
-1.1741642951965332,
-0.1565844565629959,
-0.04105213284492493,
-0.3060432970523834,
0.6974591016769409,
-0.2078673541545868,
-0.4512910544872284,
-0.27763882279396057,
-0.06671806424856186,
0.2399178296327591,
0.5697036981582642,
-0.1704075187444687,
0.3296681046485901,
0.6397520899772644,
-0.23466522991657257,
-0.7084618210792542,
-0.4418177008628845,
-0.16030511260032654,
-0.22199125587940216,
-0.09397542476654053,
-0.024777809157967567,
-0.16448678076267242,
-0.834025502204895,
-0.1381550431251526,
-0.08275007456541061,
-0.3355308175086975,
0.3378329277038574,
0.31293171644210815,
0.26605841517448425,
-0.37972983717918396,
0.36674612760543823,
-0.34129971265792847,
0.11037694662809372,
0.25825369358062744,
-0.29042717814445496,
0.3430430591106415,
-0.23002921044826508,
0.1534712314605713,
-0.002357343677431345,
0.01848626136779785,
0.5868771076202393,
-0.2532570958137512,
0.8470034599304199,
0.25834599137306213,
-0.15653440356254578,
-0.49163976311683655,
-0.4497908651828766,
-0.0835423618555069,
-0.43567511439323425,
0.4549689292907715,
-0.3238925635814667,
-0.5738109350204468,
0.18926376104354858,
0.18537801504135132,
0.20109842717647552,
0.1443602293729782,
0.41550925374031067,
-0.1333162933588028,
1.3904098272323608,
0.9439958930015564,
0.06801491975784302,
0.782555341720581,
-0.4295383393764496,
0.3161030113697052,
-0.48292961716651917,
0.05740521848201752,
-0.4644469916820526,
-0.386735200881958,
-0.6849192976951599,
-0.190617173910141,
0.17084355652332306,
0.18532875180244446,
-0.11429566890001297,
0.004053568001836538,
-0.21494832634925842,
0.804855227470398,
0.32903599739074707,
0.23703701794147491,
0.28863197565078735,
-0.04813804477453232,
-0.09667089581489563,
0.2905033230781555,
-0.684183657169342,
-0.4799623489379883,
1.0090197324752808,
0.46815890073776245,
0.5567057132720947,
0.16928081214427948,
0.335607647895813,
0.06859026104211807,
-0.03286731615662575,
-1.07683527469635,
0.787542998790741,
-0.17264138162136078,
-0.7702149748802185,
-0.2331809103488922,
-0.3037951588630676,
-1.286548376083374,
0.5224980711936951,
-0.357098251581192,
-0.5583954453468323,
0.3143305480480194,
0.3356756865978241,
-0.19558654725551605,
0.17405860126018524,
-0.8887888789176941,
0.7476997971534729,
-0.3696810305118561,
-0.3870451748371124,
-0.22830750048160553,
-0.7016902565956116,
0.49015137553215027,
0.23859676718711853,
0.5323920249938965,
-0.18928523361682892,
-0.07863147556781769,
0.7849478125572205,
-0.24040202796459198,
0.6651543378829956,
0.2059566080570221,
-0.3144182562828064,
-0.1036851555109024,
0.5943794250488281,
0.1429034322500229,
-0.4445071518421173,
0.16886283457279205,
0.12849581241607666,
-0.2877490818500519,
-0.5879506468772888,
-0.5147310495376587,
0.8873938322067261,
-0.8930884003639221,
-0.7695940136909485,
-0.33603599667549133,
-0.467058002948761,
-0.2289418876171112,
0.28309348225593567,
0.12312513589859009,
0.6940961480140686,
0.055760666728019714,
-0.09576337039470673,
0.6815059185028076,
-0.09707818925380707,
0.21458858251571655,
0.673271656036377,
-0.3301645517349243,
0.07546494156122208,
0.9877415299415588,
0.36826375126838684,
0.6517707705497742,
0.5136443972587585,
0.3782790005207062,
-0.09728259593248367,
-0.6943937540054321,
-0.018735093995928764,
0.5919605493545532,
-0.7235886454582214,
0.35435745120048523,
-0.6250033974647522,
0.07178304344415665,
-0.37447914481163025,
-0.08002418279647827,
-0.2511577010154724,
-0.6565763354301453,
-0.042425259947776794,
-0.2831917107105255,
0.1596352905035019,
1.2487677335739136,
0.3222232162952423,
-0.04523558169603348,
-0.12937769293785095,
0.5746134519577026,
0.5006096959114075,
0.5231289267539978,
0.052384402602910995,
-0.5274259448051453,
-0.26224252581596375,
0.06931471079587936,
-0.3486413061618805,
-0.72391277551651,
0.5485408306121826,
0.09476003050804138,
0.4218399226665497,
0.6338679790496826,
-0.09887590259313583,
0.5447281002998352,
-0.5595868825912476,
0.6856533885002136,
0.035683147609233856,
-0.5448458194732666,
0.2632017731666565,
-0.41240188479423523,
-0.006457176525145769,
0.1520162969827652,
0.5320606231689453,
-0.25163963437080383,
-0.6031875610351562,
-0.8877427577972412,
-0.837419331073761,
0.6790516376495361,
-0.04261277616024017,
-0.09037522226572037,
-0.014904128387570381,
0.3021141290664673,
0.06767356395721436,
0.4877372980117798,
-0.8086486458778381,
-0.6434265375137329,
0.05735494941473007,
-0.0006755197537131608,
-0.7130840420722961,
-0.2879995107650757,
-0.171739399433136,
-0.15502813458442688,
0.5227575302124023,
0.05086585879325867,
0.13981546461582184,
-0.13741321861743927,
-0.009452629834413528,
-0.1889752447605133,
0.6620802283287048,
0.5126129388809204,
0.7890370488166809,
-0.18095846474170685,
0.5416370034217834,
-0.21252167224884033,
-0.21967928111553192,
0.16122505068778992,
-0.24814561009407043,
-0.05168135091662407,
0.04689709097146988,
0.3128837049007416,
0.8320713043212891,
0.45360812544822693,
-0.44422850012779236,
0.4410474896430969,
0.1275167167186737,
-0.04270792007446289,
-0.33584630489349365,
0.16128093004226685,
-0.05215724557638168,
0.12169510126113892,
-0.031926315277814865,
0.05320342257618904,
0.10432547330856323,
-1.1769837141036987,
-0.1667148470878601,
0.6685382127761841,
-0.3266127109527588,
-0.6402372121810913,
0.4187623858451843,
-0.014247165061533451,
-0.6496739387512207,
0.022229382768273354,
-0.19824856519699097,
-0.4944649636745453,
0.48029017448425293,
0.11506450921297073,
0.8011524081230164,
-0.258879691362381,
0.13940800726413727,
-0.10296277701854706,
0.2450464814901352,
-0.36450937390327454,
0.14341947436332703,
0.053516753017902374,
-0.9326782822608948,
-0.10730624943971634,
-0.712785005569458,
-0.2628228962421417,
0.2550981640815735,
-0.7523423433303833,
0.32750260829925537,
-0.5419858694076538,
-0.1903080940246582,
0.4432010352611542,
-0.13750363886356354,
-0.6478492617607117,
0.09468478709459305,
0.34742680191993713,
0.45911821722984314,
-0.922985315322876,
0.5263113975524902,
0.9657815098762512,
-0.33014732599258423,
-0.673011064529419,
-0.06350541114807129,
0.014942198991775513,
-0.8163764476776123,
0.6022699475288391,
-0.04558110982179642,
-0.04319626837968826,
-0.161738321185112,
-0.6079688668251038,
-0.7419259548187256,
0.596380352973938,
0.10927770286798477,
-0.1817147582769394,
-0.44192075729370117,
-0.07294905930757523,
0.8706016540527344,
-0.33294135332107544,
0.3933403789997101,
0.5334598422050476,
0.22295936942100525,
-0.2553465962409973,
-0.9932759404182434,
-0.245202898979187,
-0.3390491306781769,
0.0025947215035557747,
0.4991130828857422,
-0.6694002151489258,
0.8325217366218567,
-0.4069414734840393,
-0.06302426010370255,
0.041019536554813385,
0.26670682430267334,
-0.16576384007930756,
0.18567396700382233,
0.4568605124950409,
0.5179036855697632,
0.2879512310028076,
0.012690983712673187,
1.3220421075820923,
-0.23391711711883545,
0.2154257744550705,
0.7733427286148071,
-0.06352060288190842,
0.8958162069320679,
0.34788942337036133,
-0.1686672866344452,
0.6668689250946045,
0.4019150137901306,
0.23140579462051392,
0.3670431971549988,
0.30723389983177185,
0.10684770345687866,
-0.3321266174316406,
-0.21059860289096832,
-0.06145252287387848,
0.4379716217517853,
0.475756973028183,
-0.5623353719711304,
0.21164652705192566,
-0.1505700796842575,
0.2829376459121704,
0.03826688975095749,
-0.5312902927398682,
0.9656186699867249,
0.2055027186870575,
-0.8165499567985535,
0.8665472865104675,
-0.1973264366388321,
0.5223389267921448,
-0.6569259762763977,
0.019157148897647858,
-0.08579239249229431,
0.33648478984832764,
-0.18122602999210358,
-0.7796673774719238,
-0.3828929364681244,
-0.4716587960720062,
-0.3128817677497864,
-0.19981680810451508,
0.29476210474967957,
-0.6375961303710938,
-0.4090975522994995,
0.3241944909095764,
0.41724708676338196,
0.2349041998386383,
0.3988819718360901,
-0.5256089568138123,
-0.44251519441604614,
-0.2894894778728485,
-0.5021212697029114,
0.6433628797531128,
0.5480294823646545,
-0.01873725652694702,
0.7694721817970276,
0.36580151319503784,
0.5475717186927795,
0.2366524189710617,
-0.15651150047779083,
0.4725196361541748,
-0.7134867310523987,
-0.5550205707550049,
-0.6526780724525452,
0.1441103219985962,
0.17796166241168976,
-0.320031076669693,
0.7592779994010925,
0.19481399655342102,
1.0276883840560913,
-0.13192178308963776,
0.5225158333778381,
0.23780730366706848,
0.34095704555511475,
-0.47071319818496704,
0.4467115104198456,
-0.7074093818664551,
0.28018417954444885,
-0.38808223605155945,
-0.724443256855011,
-0.2567386031150818,
0.39747604727745056,
-0.5263585448265076,
0.032095059752464294,
0.78904789686203,
0.879045844078064,
-0.036111075431108475,
-0.10419425368309021,
0.5155978202819824,
0.803840696811676,
0.07984554022550583,
0.35644376277923584,
0.8244930505752563,
-0.14491979777812958,
0.3664071559906006,
-0.5213121175765991,
-0.27097252011299133,
-0.333082377910614,
-0.32707449793815613,
-1.089748501777649,
-0.5653274655342102,
-0.23560748994350433,
-0.3542040288448334,
0.05972250923514366,
0.9856687188148499,
0.6823617815971375,
-0.5811377763748169,
-0.5848831534385681,
0.030347753316164017,
0.2712004482746124,
-0.3904362618923187,
-0.24989022314548492,
0.2608892321586609,
-0.17728754878044128,
-0.7510587573051453,
0.28535282611846924,
0.1009589210152626,
0.2912556231021881,
-0.3746229112148285,
-0.03125001862645149,
-0.2121797651052475,
0.19113865494728088,
0.6599509119987488,
0.4007427394390106,
-0.9775345921516418,
-0.23224598169326782,
-0.20403927564620972,
-0.11783874034881592,
0.007553237024694681,
0.8642088174819946,
-0.6254099607467651,
0.4666438698768616,
0.6439321041107178,
0.002589241601526737,
-0.1304030567407608,
-0.14813339710235596,
0.8217288851737976,
-0.7043274641036987,
0.29130983352661133,
0.13735102117061615,
0.5761790871620178,
0.03388123959302902,
-0.12148021906614304,
0.2785349190235138,
0.21376509964466095,
-0.5361435413360596,
-1.1064091920852661,
0.6132341027259827,
-0.716168999671936,
-0.5521894693374634,
1.3677626848220825,
0.0480363592505455,
-0.3018265664577484,
-0.283576101064682,
-0.04403810203075409,
-0.147989884018898,
-0.4043262004852295,
1.0437324047088623,
0.6517614126205444,
-0.171768456697464,
-0.13784973323345184,
-0.6914724707603455,
0.7027814388275146,
0.515238881111145,
-0.3767876625061035,
0.12483412027359009,
0.46631747484207153,
0.2313586175441742,
0.4465329647064209,
0.23987652361392975,
-0.01405475102365017,
0.24664810299873352,
-0.27766039967536926,
0.0416383370757103,
0.15925145149230957,
-0.5284547209739685,
-0.5792761445045471,
0.23434054851531982,
0.4523301124572754,
-0.034186843782663345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02122v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02122v1 | Fake News Detection: It's All in the Data! | 2024-07-02T10:12:06 | 2024-07-02T10:12:06 | Soveatin Kuntur, Anna Wróblewska, Marcin Paprzycki, Maria Ganzha | cs.CL | cs.CL | This comprehensive survey serves as an indispensable resource for researchers
embarking on the journey of fake news detection. By highlighting the pivotal
role of dataset quality and diversity, it underscores the significance of these
elements in the effectiveness and robustness of detection models. The survey
meticulously outlines the key features of datasets, various labeling systems
employed, and prevalent biases that can impact model performance. Additionally,
it addresses critical ethical issues and best practices, offering a thorough
overview of the current state of available datasets. Our contribution to this
field is further enriched by the provision of GitHub repository, which
consolidates publicly accessible datasets into a single, user-friendly portal.
This repository is designed to facilitate and stimulate further research and
development efforts aimed at combating the pervasive issue of fake news. | [
-0.25733157992362976,
-0.835680365562439,
0.4828890562057495,
0.05835797265172005,
-0.2995285987854004,
0.5100962519645691,
0.27470818161964417,
-0.29443323612213135,
0.3263530731201172,
0.4652303159236908,
-0.2186809629201889,
-0.5657485723495483,
-0.5220136642456055,
-0.02024344727396965,
-0.8047792911529541,
1.2074944972991943,
0.07700327783823013,
0.24024811387062073,
-0.22992035746574402,
-0.11839940398931503,
-0.12351114302873611,
-0.394925981760025,
0.06763571500778198,
0.02623109146952629,
0.6040754318237305,
0.4428817331790924,
0.5548202991485596,
0.6898923516273499,
0.2344021052122116,
0.09322940558195114,
0.11752783507108688,
0.24201300740242004,
-0.6326053142547607,
0.015120701864361763,
-0.22740349173545837,
-0.29235509037971497,
-0.15079857409000397,
0.4243757724761963,
0.5089734792709351,
0.39542827010154724,
-0.06785622239112854,
0.5449100136756897,
-0.27410200238227844,
0.6024783849716187,
-0.7577819228172302,
-0.20780953764915466,
-0.5064848065376282,
-0.23655198514461517,
-0.6919764280319214,
0.07851820439100266,
-0.12682940065860748,
-0.7079121470451355,
-0.20676332712173462,
-0.544349193572998,
0.4424015283584595,
-0.04182834178209305,
0.8401604294776917,
-0.14659221470355988,
-0.7805616855621338,
-0.4213949739933014,
-0.6433570981025696,
0.38021987676620483,
-0.44894909858703613,
0.29601824283599854,
0.19643139839172363,
0.45247387886047363,
-0.01792432740330696,
-0.6191350221633911,
-0.6662539839744568,
0.04357345402240753,
0.23086683452129364,
0.10091425478458405,
-0.38988474011421204,
-0.24226266145706177,
0.15719498693943024,
0.6161913275718689,
-0.7775270938873291,
-0.012744479812681675,
-0.6277147531509399,
-0.31244760751724243,
0.46114102005958557,
0.004138574004173279,
0.3297576308250427,
-0.26238879561424255,
-0.10287413001060486,
-0.2278735488653183,
-0.5667675733566284,
-0.11943637579679489,
0.9747264981269836,
0.2838233709335327,
-0.09415249526500702,
0.4356563687324524,
-0.47639432549476624,
0.7644726634025574,
-0.09082289785146713,
-0.04406706988811493,
0.34516021609306335,
-0.6942837238311768,
-0.26901379227638245,
-0.06636494398117065,
0.4306648075580597,
0.22465942800045013,
0.05209991708397865,
0.19736142456531525,
-0.3879072964191437,
0.284057080745697,
0.4738883674144745,
-0.3823666572570801,
-0.5143445730209351,
0.11475548148155212,
-0.6978509426116943,
-0.7184999585151672,
0.48010438680648804,
-0.7985132932662964,
-0.6042315363883972,
-0.3117062747478485,
0.20791859924793243,
-0.003659222275018692,
-0.6656108498573303,
-0.04395913705229759,
-0.44974976778030396,
-0.08361735194921494,
0.3033490478992462,
-0.012460033409297466,
0.12732034921646118,
0.49096783995628357,
0.6103500723838806,
0.04066363722085953,
0.1466137021780014,
-0.4184601902961731,
-0.18285417556762695,
-0.5951831340789795,
0.9670760631561279,
-0.48114535212516785,
-0.2763098478317261,
-0.024309199303388596,
0.1521463543176651,
0.29865869879722595,
-0.6626050472259521,
0.8285399079322815,
-0.5543561577796936,
0.4673040807247162,
-0.4617355465888977,
-0.6380777955055237,
-0.3256087005138397,
0.4900485873222351,
-0.9730808138847351,
0.9362978935241699,
0.4387929141521454,
-0.6081324219703674,
0.4728999733924866,
-0.560815155506134,
-0.366243839263916,
-0.022390957921743393,
0.04262196645140648,
-0.6876433491706848,
0.264250785112381,
0.3213321566581726,
0.15364079177379608,
-0.045303355902433395,
0.43318310379981995,
-0.40145015716552734,
-0.2679828405380249,
0.3472190499305725,
-0.4711553454399109,
0.9455239772796631,
0.3523697853088379,
-0.11044765263795853,
-0.09669386595487595,
-0.6482192277908325,
-0.2093328833580017,
0.3013346195220947,
-0.1481960564851761,
-0.3375769853591919,
-0.4532580077648163,
0.3825984299182892,
0.1221286877989769,
-0.0543801411986351,
-0.60561203956604,
0.29821062088012695,
0.11018627882003784,
0.06067962944507599,
0.6514390110969543,
0.1205485388636589,
0.5007940530776978,
-0.5445737838745117,
0.648137092590332,
0.3945022225379944,
0.5639588832855225,
-0.14297589659690857,
-0.430666446685791,
-0.39975467324256897,
-0.0991300642490387,
0.7074979543685913,
0.4509659707546234,
-0.6611557006835938,
0.4003196656703949,
-0.1690622717142105,
-0.6251968145370483,
-0.5309638977050781,
-0.06256550550460815,
0.2648942470550537,
0.4615831673145294,
0.22020798921585083,
0.031131358817219734,
-0.5614718198776245,
-0.863422155380249,
-0.5993425250053406,
-0.11792781949043274,
-0.024547988548874855,
-0.06039513275027275,
1.0478142499923706,
0.04557539150118828,
0.967715322971344,
-0.30788350105285645,
-0.12451377511024475,
-0.15235210955142975,
-0.05007476359605789,
0.44639962911605835,
0.4795486032962799,
0.7637973427772522,
-1.2761809825897217,
-0.41383686661720276,
-0.5221296548843384,
-0.6385728716850281,
-0.08072800189256668,
0.05726904422044754,
-0.08264324814081192,
0.2044687718153,
0.05504486709833145,
-0.5186811089515686,
0.6324132084846497,
0.5643648505210876,
-0.37770146131515503,
0.6053046584129333,
0.4158814549446106,
0.5968334674835205,
-0.922835648059845,
0.0027506130281835794,
0.05455505847930908,
-0.4036869704723358,
-0.7987843751907349,
0.03755369782447815,
0.2872750461101532,
-0.06550679355859756,
-0.403231680393219,
0.4076356291770935,
-0.24276545643806458,
-0.10426006466150284,
-0.15080665051937103,
-0.14834201335906982,
0.4823952317237854,
-0.31618937849998474,
-0.4412964880466461,
0.5696051120758057,
0.6812978982925415,
-0.1896851509809494,
0.7207435369491577,
0.11203442513942719,
-0.4796942174434662,
0.6698075532913208,
-0.5573540925979614,
-0.08787941187620163,
-0.19582784175872803,
0.857393205165863,
-0.8486365079879761,
-0.6776856184005737,
0.9355081915855408,
-1.0240479707717896,
-0.01193363405764103,
-0.3190949559211731,
-0.8732113242149353,
-0.3247040808200836,
-0.338140070438385,
0.1946486383676529,
0.36479800939559937,
-0.5803369283676147,
0.3287868797779083,
0.7120116353034973,
0.37879815697669983,
-0.43413230776786804,
-0.6756418943405151,
0.21354830265045166,
-0.24844099581241608,
-0.3128962814807892,
-0.030417554080486298,
0.1598508208990097,
-0.4932215213775635,
0.13278557360172272,
-0.26888978481292725,
-0.2693184018135071,
-0.17453795671463013,
-0.018890034407377243,
0.17082194983959198,
-0.12907084822654724,
0.20710523426532745,
-0.14183169603347778,
0.18794308602809906,
-0.1216193437576294,
-0.24854886531829834,
0.09128889441490173,
0.17564934492111206,
-0.452048122882843,
-0.5605950355529785,
0.47758999466896057,
0.6680065989494324,
0.05123518779873848,
0.6301535367965698,
0.452099084854126,
-0.5949044823646545,
-0.21739676594734192,
-0.5954409241676331,
-0.27871453762054443,
-0.3797566592693329,
0.018589777871966362,
0.05524805188179016,
-0.4795008599758148,
0.5458722710609436,
0.1200350895524025,
-0.06800225377082825,
0.18144501745700836,
0.1147361621260643,
-0.1182909682393074,
0.8186043500900269,
0.3896220028400421,
-0.43697506189346313,
0.2277454137802124,
-0.10323906689882278,
0.39794284105300903,
-0.3069036602973938,
-0.2693341076374054,
-0.6391117572784424,
-0.12657956779003143,
-0.5140589475631714,
-0.4485431909561157,
0.06872930377721786,
-0.08961839973926544,
-0.06178952381014824,
0.10981106013059616,
-0.8494189977645874,
0.59119713306427,
0.5878074765205383,
0.27580344676971436,
0.4052339196205139,
0.13532891869544983,
0.5508418679237366,
0.018142251297831535,
-0.47978460788726807,
-0.5995846390724182,
1.2901287078857422,
0.27864956855773926,
0.5729731321334839,
-0.0034216337371617556,
0.3175962567329407,
0.6886931657791138,
0.31316983699798584,
-0.47463688254356384,
0.1753360778093338,
-0.06034044176340103,
-1.2123792171478271,
-0.09497407078742981,
-0.4195820689201355,
-0.7464644908905029,
0.23298445343971252,
0.1542147696018219,
-0.12163164466619492,
0.3589022755622864,
0.036870136857032776,
-0.061602890491485596,
0.6988519430160522,
-0.4382007420063019,
0.590686559677124,
-0.10315603017807007,
-0.01022182498127222,
-0.15708154439926147,
-0.4434604048728943,
0.7271924614906311,
-0.21809649467468262,
0.33187511563301086,
-0.3461964428424835,
0.07091724872589111,
0.460576593875885,
0.09431638568639755,
0.6379333138465881,
-0.2710835337638855,
0.11716914921998978,
0.23402100801467896,
-0.130323126912117,
0.4573855698108673,
0.1383066326379776,
0.17098496854305267,
0.43145573139190674,
-0.2215164303779602,
-0.6138714551925659,
-0.17407917976379395,
0.6526730060577393,
-0.4403254985809326,
0.04417257010936737,
-0.8275675177574158,
-0.4287269413471222,
0.0294498223811388,
0.009846536442637444,
0.2148405760526657,
0.36875373125076294,
-0.4379259943962097,
0.24232926964759827,
0.8501379489898682,
-0.3895677328109741,
-0.0302121601998806,
0.6365887522697449,
-0.29145440459251404,
-0.3365538418292999,
0.8448275923728943,
0.6084389090538025,
-0.16744548082351685,
-0.23476707935333252,
-0.08924141526222229,
-0.5272725224494934,
-0.45308417081832886,
-0.4807893633842468,
0.11220847815275192,
-0.7365204095840454,
-0.2774113416671753,
-0.6155875325202942,
-0.1236698180437088,
-0.5786486864089966,
-0.006526544224470854,
-0.4587334394454956,
-0.31793707609176636,
-0.5664556622505188,
-0.24028287827968597,
0.3934498429298401,
0.8618366122245789,
-0.22448024153709412,
0.3997217118740082,
-0.6515158414840698,
0.797976553440094,
0.08460663259029388,
0.3460403382778168,
-0.4826985001564026,
-0.6354991793632507,
-0.2596091032028198,
0.35630911588668823,
-0.33549317717552185,
-0.8845940232276917,
0.44261887669563293,
-0.2609906792640686,
0.6617539525032043,
0.4587654173374176,
0.3464093804359436,
0.3977539539337158,
0.2111005038022995,
0.9583727717399597,
-0.1312485635280609,
-0.6854012608528137,
0.6087130904197693,
-0.8335934281349182,
-0.017760353162884712,
0.6727388501167297,
0.7583505511283875,
-0.354730486869812,
-0.30789798498153687,
-0.8352614641189575,
-0.5768473744392395,
0.48579612374305725,
0.401886522769928,
0.03920632600784302,
0.297750324010849,
0.03947814926505089,
0.27395257353782654,
0.4356656074523926,
-0.8408944606781006,
-0.2032119482755661,
-0.29282647371292114,
-0.09301219135522842,
0.26611003279685974,
0.06132131069898605,
-0.5377908945083618,
-0.4099430739879608,
0.6171302795410156,
0.06819137930870056,
0.08060337603092194,
-0.09304129332304001,
-0.23647813498973846,
-0.11519932001829147,
-0.11674050241708755,
0.4806750416755676,
1.146480917930603,
0.007966462522745132,
-0.1915181279182434,
-0.2656339108943939,
-0.515571653842926,
0.053416669368743896,
-0.04028930142521858,
-0.3241331875324249,
0.5477416515350342,
0.17101489007472992,
0.3820202946662903,
-0.17136795818805695,
-0.43271803855895996,
0.757798433303833,
-0.04194299876689911,
-0.2911536991596222,
-0.4474185109138489,
-0.15889491140842438,
-0.03407838195562363,
0.04502982273697853,
0.9105448722839355,
0.27462896704673767,
0.3724139332771301,
-0.5871009230613708,
0.217717245221138,
0.11880837380886078,
-0.22989153861999512,
-0.37071698904037476,
0.5077115893363953,
0.20952464640140533,
-0.04664664342999458,
0.8514741063117981,
-0.0741335079073906,
-0.40275368094444275,
0.8481082320213318,
0.16338615119457245,
0.40962138772010803,
-0.08425984531641006,
0.6817722916603088,
0.09066887199878693,
0.5308146476745605,
-0.4697250723838806,
0.08413290977478027,
0.2187005579471588,
-0.7805776000022888,
0.033389121294021606,
-0.505976140499115,
-0.4499710202217102,
0.547957181930542,
-0.6958819031715393,
0.1790875643491745,
-0.20654714107513428,
-0.07527631521224976,
-0.07366784662008286,
-0.06227268651127815,
-0.4010571241378784,
0.391082227230072,
0.32206353545188904,
0.9652883410453796,
-1.2201687097549438,
0.573318362236023,
0.5341283082962036,
-0.5223912596702576,
-0.28180623054504395,
0.2603060305118561,
0.7045003771781921,
-0.35553210973739624,
0.19342449307441711,
0.18127769231796265,
0.27326837182044983,
-0.06321649998426437,
-1.040553331375122,
-0.569065272808075,
0.6240537762641907,
0.4390314221382141,
-0.40342098474502563,
0.17429551482200623,
0.2822474241256714,
0.18965330719947815,
-0.18026947975158691,
0.1317521035671234,
0.6534223556518555,
0.7569280862808228,
-0.2320934534072876,
-0.5119565725326538,
-0.28687456250190735,
-0.2825736105442047,
-0.115811288356781,
0.07114841043949127,
-0.6363947987556458,
0.8427226543426514,
0.3623768985271454,
-0.2675201892852783,
-0.2948734164237976,
0.4536292552947998,
0.4670182168483734,
0.7093442678451538,
0.3076290190219879,
0.5855242609977722,
0.7463358044624329,
-0.42863860726356506,
0.9031374454498291,
-0.09915868937969208,
0.2643721103668213,
0.673531174659729,
0.002609043847769499,
0.06182796135544777,
0.14025208353996277,
-0.19373244047164917,
0.31822219491004944,
1.010724425315857,
-0.5218388438224792,
0.3682835102081299,
0.2523331642150879,
-0.2411537617444992,
-0.1618478149175644,
-0.37357988953590393,
-0.5379698872566223,
0.5059090256690979,
0.48396167159080505,
-0.37400785088539124,
-0.3445284366607666,
0.3925461173057556,
0.21971678733825684,
0.12687744200229645,
-0.37720799446105957,
0.24684946238994598,
-0.2694855034351349,
-0.09807007014751434,
0.1535765677690506,
-0.27038705348968506,
0.7930132746696472,
-0.5796979665756226,
-0.18800772726535797,
-0.4222739338874817,
-0.14170923829078674,
-0.28320592641830444,
-1.049182653427124,
0.3803234398365021,
-0.07430833578109741,
-0.39461609721183777,
-0.3992394208908081,
0.9886265397071838,
-0.10670787841081619,
-0.3634977638721466,
0.15620365738868713,
0.6869847774505615,
0.3266496956348419,
-0.5435312986373901,
-0.7247493863105774,
0.34268805384635925,
-0.15305078029632568,
-0.3680940270423889,
0.2706160545349121,
0.2491423338651657,
-0.1731925755739212,
0.6202535629272461,
1.0238701105117798,
0.18400970101356506,
-0.007523815613240004,
0.14567849040031433,
1.0890440940856934,
-0.47624847292900085,
-0.5732234716415405,
-0.3959396481513977,
0.5878844261169434,
-0.6356730461120605,
-0.459921658039093,
0.9195671677589417,
0.8768538236618042,
1.1221522092819214,
-0.23590515553951263,
1.0510551929473877,
-0.12943844497203827,
0.9475160837173462,
-0.11614946275949478,
0.9663199186325073,
-0.3782082200050354,
-0.012577248737215996,
-0.08531957864761353,
-0.7820926308631897,
-0.22605785727500916,
0.3499480187892914,
0.11290217936038971,
0.03817237168550491,
0.2841795086860657,
0.7122231721878052,
-0.33615413308143616,
0.0458340160548687,
0.21781198680400848,
0.051723647862672806,
0.22303853929042816,
-0.08978615701198578,
1.023363709449768,
-0.6109985709190369,
0.7282595038414001,
-0.010239691473543644,
-0.06272342801094055,
-0.43922194838523865,
-0.42833927273750305,
-0.5500808954238892,
-0.49986621737480164,
-0.4293847382068634,
-0.3969537615776062,
0.2807968556880951,
0.288449227809906,
0.8633596897125244,
-0.9578119516372681,
0.11646633595228195,
0.10512243956327438,
0.16326254606246948,
0.023011013865470886,
-0.34149396419525146,
0.03010742738842964,
0.16850030422210693,
-0.6657623648643494,
0.48332321643829346,
-0.058770280331373215,
0.09046617895364761,
-0.41533809900283813,
0.16508544981479645,
-0.29666051268577576,
0.16986407339572906,
0.29877835512161255,
0.4197644889354706,
-0.4715162515640259,
0.009693614207208157,
0.011127188801765442,
-0.3723222017288208,
-0.061657484620809555,
0.7764968276023865,
-0.8767369985580444,
0.3129700720310211,
0.7705481052398682,
0.4014362692832947,
0.28404662013053894,
0.29321977496147156,
0.4099363386631012,
-0.7003517150878906,
-0.0040744212456047535,
0.357522189617157,
-0.04258887842297554,
0.4539256989955902,
-0.6514667272567749,
0.6053884625434875,
0.5778564810752869,
-0.6756449341773987,
-1.3581124544143677,
0.1453908234834671,
-0.7712464332580566,
-0.553572416305542,
0.9098328948020935,
0.2603175938129425,
-0.10066001862287521,
-0.7386974096298218,
0.010894784703850746,
0.33855223655700684,
-0.7064580917358398,
0.8010271191596985,
0.7140375375747681,
-0.07834901660680771,
-0.18339061737060547,
-0.825609564781189,
0.358731210231781,
-0.34058862924575806,
-0.9787367582321167,
-0.16785837709903717,
0.872576117515564,
0.5312688946723938,
-0.06312713027000427,
0.6008397340774536,
-0.21599668264389038,
0.35393837094306946,
0.031749624758958817,
0.011427274905145168,
0.014546124264597893,
-0.4306879937648773,
-0.31441161036491394,
0.1338401585817337,
-0.7903850078582764,
-0.3961939215660095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02119v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02119v1 | Cost-Effective Proxy Reward Model Construction with On-Policy and Active Learning | 2024-07-02T10:09:19 | 2024-07-02T10:09:19 | Yifang Chen, Shuohang Wang, Ziyi Yang, Hiteshi Sharma, Nikos Karampatziakis, Donghan Yu, Kevin Jamieson, Simon Shaolei Du, Yelong Shen | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF), as a widely adopted
approach in current large language model pipelines, is \textit{bottlenecked by
the size of human preference data}. While traditional methods rely on offline
preference dataset constructions, recent approaches have shifted towards online
settings, where a learner uses a small amount of labeled seed data and a large
pool of unlabeled prompts to iteratively construct new preference data through
self-generated responses and high-quality reward/preference feedback. However,
most current online algorithms still focus on preference labeling during policy
model updating with given feedback oracles, which incurs significant expert
query costs. \textit{We are the first to explore cost-effective proxy reward
oracles construction strategies for further labeling preferences or rewards
with extremely limited labeled data and expert query budgets}. Our approach
introduces two key innovations: (1) on-policy query to avoid OOD and imbalance
issues in seed data, and (2) active learning to select the most informative
data for preference queries. Using these methods, we train a evaluation model
with minimal expert-labeled data, which then effectively labels nine times more
preference pairs for further RLHF training. For instance, our model using
Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) gains around over 1% average improvement
on AlpacaEval2, MMLU-5shot and MMLU-0shot, with only 1.7K query cost. Our
methodology is orthogonal to other direct expert query-based strategies and
therefore might be integrated with them to further reduce query costs. | [
-0.37018072605133057,
-0.5543727874755859,
0.3897806406021118,
0.06914308667182922,
0.02934860810637474,
0.019936051219701767,
-0.15483182668685913,
-0.4928978383541107,
0.44489148259162903,
0.7778257727622986,
-0.6001574397087097,
-0.19273456931114197,
-0.21763885021209717,
-0.17127764225006104,
0.3417108952999115,
0.871724545955658,
0.03240522742271423,
-0.1283339262008667,
0.025441069155931473,
-0.22388871014118195,
-0.08813146501779556,
-0.6018259525299072,
-1.1139764785766602,
-0.35052695870399475,
0.827571451663971,
0.5026489496231079,
0.6298115253448486,
1.088985562324524,
0.2588193118572235,
0.1578988879919052,
-0.11612120270729065,
0.5676802396774292,
-0.5357412695884705,
0.13196054100990295,
-0.18841348588466644,
-0.43263477087020874,
-0.5322219133377075,
0.26993700861930847,
0.3728889226913452,
0.6590880155563354,
-0.5100299119949341,
0.02797534130513668,
-0.2265929877758026,
0.9275472164154053,
-0.9917986989021301,
0.35053780674934387,
-0.7504043579101562,
0.21089406311511993,
-0.11894068866968155,
-0.11120595037937164,
-0.49841248989105225,
-0.43697163462638855,
0.23953621089458466,
-0.676932692527771,
0.11537399142980576,
0.1525457203388214,
0.861089825630188,
0.3291248679161072,
-0.5119170546531677,
-0.35199615359306335,
-0.3981821537017822,
0.7690264582633972,
-0.5304325222969055,
0.4143218398094177,
0.6958069801330566,
0.3270683288574219,
-0.19615839421749115,
-0.7527762651443481,
-0.27972179651260376,
-0.3862096071243286,
0.15064099431037903,
0.3012341260910034,
0.1744319200515747,
0.2489650696516037,
0.05710986629128456,
0.2281164675951004,
-0.20426256954669952,
0.2535979449748993,
-0.16055180132389069,
-0.2281658798456192,
0.7238288521766663,
0.08248507231473923,
-0.2919797897338867,
-0.12323873490095139,
-0.5144230723381042,
-0.4909032881259918,
-0.9089730381965637,
0.3811149001121521,
0.7114623188972473,
0.5567450523376465,
0.19916516542434692,
0.32972732186317444,
-0.49140045046806335,
0.7464199662208557,
0.3625168800354004,
-0.1777203232049942,
0.0870448425412178,
-0.13277903199195862,
0.1203291192650795,
0.14869660139083862,
0.5500768423080444,
0.15763013064861298,
0.14115998148918152,
-0.18099555373191833,
-0.40943658351898193,
-0.12009873241186142,
0.4258534908294678,
-0.6435734629631042,
-0.31078848242759705,
0.17053227126598358,
-0.4782924950122833,
-0.44471049308776855,
-0.053600531071424484,
-0.6855998039245605,
-0.45012807846069336,
-0.11882728338241577,
0.35795703530311584,
0.24882592260837555,
-0.30181288719177246,
0.12756463885307312,
0.054759204387664795,
-0.014457938261330128,
0.331264853477478,
-0.9993705153465271,
0.27600252628326416,
0.4323698580265045,
0.6662338972091675,
-0.43545863032341003,
-0.15953834354877472,
-0.9266080856323242,
0.05151285231113434,
-0.2564217150211334,
0.8094890117645264,
-0.4365215003490448,
-0.3300672769546509,
0.34257495403289795,
0.014101361855864525,
0.07537662982940674,
-0.6366954445838928,
0.5465294122695923,
-0.8012587428092957,
0.06889666616916656,
-0.3478371500968933,
-0.5513806939125061,
0.11210241913795471,
0.19080954790115356,
-0.979232907295227,
1.1000394821166992,
-0.0022209559101611376,
-0.5202991366386414,
0.4978679120540619,
-0.7451855540275574,
-0.20364005863666534,
0.023833412677049637,
0.09123578667640686,
-0.4735923707485199,
-0.25987982749938965,
0.21838490664958954,
0.3895852863788605,
-0.16873881220817566,
0.353495329618454,
-0.4001832902431488,
-0.16504552960395813,
0.18990451097488403,
-0.27158355712890625,
0.5583551526069641,
0.4316370487213135,
-0.5950417518615723,
0.274281769990921,
-0.8300371766090393,
0.0018295905319973826,
0.17265507578849792,
-0.7552126049995422,
-0.38685280084609985,
0.24890543520450592,
-0.22085392475128174,
0.0970601812005043,
0.08028024435043335,
-0.5348441004753113,
0.4327051639556885,
-0.5122893452644348,
0.2810009717941284,
0.8973234295845032,
-0.06437545269727707,
0.5661913752555847,
-0.01576986536383629,
0.4764365255832672,
-0.4326086938381195,
0.4347381591796875,
0.044174663722515106,
-0.4586455523967743,
-0.8113206624984741,
-0.15001080930233002,
0.3671956956386566,
0.3484511971473694,
-0.8654382824897766,
0.12276063859462738,
0.07319615036249161,
-0.35661792755126953,
-0.7021099925041199,
0.060979075729846954,
0.6656635403633118,
0.5970544219017029,
0.4609943926334381,
-0.2351677417755127,
-0.1629662811756134,
-0.886735200881958,
-0.15946322679519653,
-0.431522011756897,
0.19247938692569733,
0.5946158170700073,
0.18190476298332214,
0.18781505525112152,
0.9868245124816895,
-0.8782371282577515,
-0.16172662377357483,
-0.13254183530807495,
0.2770332992076874,
0.20267818868160248,
0.2309112846851349,
0.3383905589580536,
-0.7797949314117432,
-0.5938630700111389,
-0.2609526515007019,
-0.15998432040214539,
-0.13068972527980804,
0.05768093839287758,
-0.08385954797267914,
0.4216388165950775,
0.1517912745475769,
-0.36976489424705505,
0.26999250054359436,
0.4224775731563568,
-0.48370927572250366,
0.29784056544303894,
-0.2906437814235687,
0.09707270562648773,
-0.4358460307121277,
0.011184461414813995,
-0.008451472967863083,
-0.23723408579826355,
-0.43165937066078186,
0.21705444157123566,
0.25584876537323,
-0.0032961058896034956,
-0.8572961091995239,
0.848572313785553,
-0.3425024151802063,
0.08298666030168533,
-0.443612664937973,
-0.13407710194587708,
-0.20757678151130676,
1.1209989786148071,
0.401675283908844,
0.6350832581520081,
0.14449883997440338,
-0.7550945281982422,
0.5077490210533142,
-0.04427693411707878,
-0.11466345191001892,
0.25660938024520874,
-0.6573210954666138,
0.1892349272966385,
0.051151905208826065,
0.5078862905502319,
-0.8117592930793762,
-0.24881930649280548,
0.47061043977737427,
-0.23856115341186523,
0.13378673791885376,
-0.20152567327022552,
-0.22585821151733398,
-0.16693781316280365,
-0.4973844289779663,
0.2603508532047272,
0.45171213150024414,
-1.0886385440826416,
0.31657901406288147,
0.7074299454689026,
0.08067731559276581,
-0.811360776424408,
-0.33962422609329224,
-0.20651638507843018,
-0.11361754685640335,
-0.2317991405725479,
0.47515931725502014,
0.05745493993163109,
-0.03421580791473389,
0.10863770544528961,
-0.09214512258768082,
-0.08143356442451477,
0.07889905571937561,
0.12381241470575333,
0.267835795879364,
0.26002997159957886,
0.25958818197250366,
0.080461785197258,
-0.26708143949508667,
0.11372426897287369,
-0.2846863567829132,
0.41114920377731323,
-0.008289920166134834,
-0.3814643323421478,
-0.09438754618167877,
0.11749251931905746,
0.2518136501312256,
-0.1849808245897293,
0.8077541589736938,
0.4773685336112976,
-0.11267677694559097,
-0.4440000653266907,
-0.6316238045692444,
-0.476621150970459,
-0.4151262938976288,
0.2407224029302597,
-0.3305623233318329,
-0.9468216896057129,
0.2976442575454712,
-0.08005830645561218,
0.3510483205318451,
0.27068251371383667,
0.48329660296440125,
0.17330867052078247,
1.3399313688278198,
0.2752831280231476,
0.03510609641671181,
0.4385276734828949,
-0.11819573491811752,
-0.14424888789653778,
-0.34434664249420166,
-0.4964101314544678,
-0.4213210940361023,
-0.13040000200271606,
-0.5246870517730713,
-0.3385119140148163,
0.373277872800827,
-0.08770609647035599,
-0.48080122470855713,
0.028286917135119438,
-0.6266726851463318,
0.24732935428619385,
0.9261611700057983,
0.3486333191394806,
0.11250533908605576,
0.06206993758678436,
-0.07556527853012085,
0.12678353488445282,
-0.996827244758606,
-0.08008042722940445,
1.2715600728988647,
0.5104590654373169,
0.8605735301971436,
0.09500031173229218,
0.4633091688156128,
0.4923454821109772,
0.09782473742961884,
-0.8856894373893738,
0.4514370560646057,
0.08944626152515411,
-0.5179080963134766,
-0.5039845108985901,
-0.5497766137123108,
-1.1051961183547974,
0.257088840007782,
-0.46665263175964355,
-0.21157172322273254,
0.3448186218738556,
0.6235178112983704,
-0.3221980035305023,
0.4236583411693573,
-0.5468276739120483,
0.6898022890090942,
-0.43630218505859375,
-0.8743201494216919,
-0.18562431633472443,
-0.767476499080658,
0.1864953637123108,
0.15553529560565948,
-0.06563962250947952,
0.04097412899136543,
-0.2373751699924469,
0.8931251764297485,
-0.6209035515785217,
0.8622623085975647,
-0.4691460132598877,
0.02455839328467846,
0.26291245222091675,
-0.1912870705127716,
0.9645039439201355,
0.0881740152835846,
-0.11403155326843262,
-0.20949505269527435,
-0.34465673565864563,
-0.5365988612174988,
-0.5404647588729858,
0.7047234177589417,
-0.9777576923370361,
-0.4770534336566925,
-0.5789856910705566,
-0.33262360095977783,
-0.4102364182472229,
-0.13253842294216156,
-0.08967235684394836,
0.2861800789833069,
0.09717223048210144,
0.05574317276477814,
1.028015375137329,
-0.3386286795139313,
0.35286349058151245,
0.7502757906913757,
-0.10963348299264908,
-0.7538791298866272,
0.9225935339927673,
0.04685863479971886,
0.33324599266052246,
0.33373215794563293,
0.40301939845085144,
-0.6557525396347046,
-0.18899163603782654,
-0.6217862963676453,
0.3646613657474518,
-0.5101973414421082,
-0.1757427603006363,
-0.5994120240211487,
-0.04580466449260712,
-0.4675004482269287,
0.021686965599656105,
-0.8510993719100952,
-0.5804594159126282,
-0.020025014877319336,
-0.15558871626853943,
0.4573839008808136,
0.5643203258514404,
-0.164350226521492,
0.2702564597129822,
-0.5080195069313049,
0.08462140709161758,
0.6653885841369629,
0.4935217499732971,
0.308661550283432,
-0.27895209193229675,
-0.39600691199302673,
-0.0754764974117279,
-0.28367382287979126,
-0.7620148658752441,
0.4667401611804962,
0.10170289129018784,
0.851624071598053,
0.6698718667030334,
0.4652171730995178,
0.48490026593208313,
-0.26089003682136536,
0.7525104284286499,
0.15494224429130554,
-0.5995199084281921,
0.5389899611473083,
-0.21184705197811127,
0.10098601877689362,
0.5548374652862549,
0.5194301009178162,
-0.3202682137489319,
0.04160912334918976,
-0.6951521039009094,
-1.1380842924118042,
1.039913535118103,
-0.06425318121910095,
-0.15393032133579254,
-0.02473251149058342,
0.7173076272010803,
0.1449156105518341,
0.27215948700904846,
-0.8401100635528564,
-0.4957226812839508,
-0.2468639314174652,
0.22296158969402313,
0.17106002569198608,
-0.27496689558029175,
-0.15369519591331482,
-0.1270032823085785,
0.885407567024231,
-0.252341091632843,
0.2065115123987198,
-0.04908880218863487,
0.23664499819278717,
-0.12210395187139511,
0.15979549288749695,
0.3186408579349518,
0.4638955891132355,
-0.5712866187095642,
0.2257392257452011,
0.046991318464279175,
-0.2503758370876312,
0.13439269363880157,
-0.13026073575019836,
-0.27830183506011963,
-0.3327760696411133,
0.08395825326442719,
1.3162710666656494,
0.20782232284545898,
-0.7533127069473267,
0.42438453435897827,
-0.010283589363098145,
-0.4344150424003601,
-0.22729837894439697,
0.21252770721912384,
-0.004218208137899637,
0.07690040022134781,
0.3292098045349121,
-0.3061322271823883,
0.13397036492824554,
-0.5161294937133789,
0.02238388918340206,
0.39021381735801697,
-0.7432870268821716,
-0.028653636574745178,
0.6212090849876404,
0.5026423335075378,
-0.19386962056159973,
0.658724844455719,
-0.24000966548919678,
-0.45457854866981506,
0.531040608882904,
0.5739346742630005,
0.561284601688385,
-0.24541224539279938,
0.5768535137176514,
0.4908323287963867,
-0.012081407010555267,
-0.5455635786056519,
0.17505821585655212,
-0.24193711578845978,
-0.690825343132019,
-0.2631974518299103,
-0.5393919348716736,
-0.8805550932884216,
0.16314983367919922,
-0.8527612090110779,
0.15813225507736206,
-0.3452204465866089,
-0.24648654460906982,
-0.3568153381347656,
0.13303425908088684,
-0.4219464361667633,
0.19180217385292053,
-0.18783317506313324,
0.725574791431427,
-0.866556704044342,
0.8392569422721863,
0.9572629928588867,
-0.5899344086647034,
-0.9246682524681091,
-0.42427897453308105,
-0.08242199569940567,
-0.8824865818023682,
0.7596701979637146,
-0.14718158543109894,
-0.0880136713385582,
-0.028339354321360588,
-0.4811764061450958,
-0.8188485503196716,
0.9160174131393433,
0.21918630599975586,
-0.2601868510246277,
-0.03478739783167839,
-0.11625790596008301,
0.39247265458106995,
-0.31607958674430847,
0.5032946467399597,
0.40341246128082275,
0.5543684363365173,
0.3763781487941742,
-0.7181385159492493,
-0.03137823939323425,
-0.14789533615112305,
-0.27751240134239197,
0.39722299575805664,
-0.8265928626060486,
0.8943740129470825,
-0.0055940039455890656,
-0.12417959421873093,
-0.32963263988494873,
0.591407299041748,
0.4450552463531494,
0.39112186431884766,
0.8246617317199707,
0.5736071467399597,
0.5810246467590332,
0.11372040212154388,
1.0745335817337036,
-0.2317725419998169,
0.3215104937553406,
0.8889438509941101,
-0.31906160712242126,
0.9867224097251892,
0.55472731590271,
-0.2851558327674866,
0.21837757527828217,
1.0026143789291382,
0.08183249086141586,
1.022323727607727,
0.3180345296859741,
-0.18232636153697968,
-0.5572454333305359,
-0.49700021743774414,
-0.2803249657154083,
0.1184929758310318,
0.08024884760379791,
-0.07350903004407883,
-0.11819041520357132,
-0.03414633125066757,
0.1516856849193573,
0.12242881208658218,
-0.4375983774662018,
0.8352629542350769,
-0.19185173511505127,
-1.167188048362732,
0.45280033349990845,
0.14437653124332428,
0.7304497957229614,
-0.8249754905700684,
-0.19955986738204956,
-0.38285163044929504,
0.22810164093971252,
-0.1353064626455307,
-0.5616925954818726,
-0.11001896858215332,
-0.17539362609386444,
-0.08474831283092499,
-0.37472400069236755,
0.7006271481513977,
-0.5137353539466858,
-0.12010876089334488,
0.339210569858551,
0.505868136882782,
0.07933373004198074,
0.005120204295963049,
-0.8980379104614258,
-0.19851839542388916,
0.05301631614565849,
-0.49092385172843933,
0.5983468294143677,
-0.059478770941495895,
-0.2400340586900711,
0.6808500289916992,
0.8012098670005798,
0.519803524017334,
-0.010983167216181755,
0.04955203831195831,
0.8494713306427002,
-0.4791262447834015,
-0.7604401707649231,
-0.3785019516944885,
0.36002275347709656,
-0.2284233123064041,
-0.31603914499282837,
0.5241581201553345,
0.37541663646698,
0.915151059627533,
-0.08971043676137924,
0.610643744468689,
0.1932123303413391,
0.6403815746307373,
-0.5452391505241394,
0.5505816340446472,
-0.7579519748687744,
0.30340442061424255,
-0.0716308206319809,
-0.8917570114135742,
-0.1379600465297699,
0.6725841164588928,
-0.14218397438526154,
-0.12453942000865936,
0.5808883905410767,
0.8901861906051636,
0.05132259055972099,
-0.2287716120481491,
0.03374888375401497,
-0.2941460907459259,
0.3074801564216614,
0.5008527636528015,
0.7844570279121399,
-0.08533373475074768,
0.6137131452560425,
-0.3865155279636383,
-0.5087493658065796,
-0.29521891474723816,
-0.9367190003395081,
-0.893089771270752,
-0.4709881842136383,
-0.36139634251594543,
-0.41927823424339294,
0.42948117852211,
1.369931697845459,
0.7471592426300049,
-0.8641038537025452,
-0.465011328458786,
-0.025154417380690575,
0.1890077292919159,
-0.5072519779205322,
-0.22929319739341736,
0.748181164264679,
-0.408609002828598,
-0.7681525945663452,
0.4578353762626648,
0.08926482498645782,
-0.2925087511539459,
-0.4188701808452606,
-0.487233430147171,
-0.40870335698127747,
0.19613102078437805,
0.4648532271385193,
0.6338889002799988,
-0.7306870222091675,
-0.1604156792163849,
0.07261406630277634,
-0.11038454622030258,
-0.11820828169584274,
0.8483927249908447,
-0.9215375781059265,
0.6286312341690063,
0.5572043061256409,
0.9255722761154175,
0.7544689178466797,
0.13534919917583466,
0.46424299478530884,
-0.3920023441314697,
0.021598950028419495,
0.009260845370590687,
0.04567216709256172,
0.004449781030416489,
-0.40341898798942566,
0.8412521481513977,
0.37444210052490234,
-0.6104846000671387,
-0.9344766139984131,
0.23437973856925964,
-0.9152144193649292,
-0.3705199360847473,
1.1644272804260254,
-0.3448794484138489,
-0.0949806421995163,
-0.19173595309257507,
-0.14319148659706116,
0.21229419112205505,
-0.8525248765945435,
1.0350528955459595,
0.3555409908294678,
-0.579237163066864,
-0.009017614647746086,
-0.3866540491580963,
0.7418891191482544,
0.49980586767196655,
-0.6596164107322693,
-0.05915972590446472,
0.5863080620765686,
-0.05459802225232124,
-0.1082780510187149,
0.6508061289787292,
0.1738370954990387,
0.1927911937236786,
-0.001808598404750228,
0.28136777877807617,
-0.5511770844459534,
-0.46346426010131836,
-0.04975332319736481,
0.6209728717803955,
0.26984018087387085,
-0.29069146513938904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02118v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02118v1 | Breaking Language Barriers: Cross-Lingual Continual Pre-Training at Scale | 2024-07-02T10:06:41 | 2024-07-02T10:06:41 | Wenzhen Zheng, Wenbo Pan, Xu Xu, Libo Qin, Li Yue, Ming Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant strides
towards Artificial General Intelligence. However, training these models from
scratch requires substantial computational resources and vast amounts of text
data. In this paper, we explore an alternative approach to constructing an LLM
for a new language by continually pretraining (CPT) from existing pretrained
LLMs, instead of using randomly initialized parameters. Based on parallel
experiments on 40 model sizes ranging from 40M to 5B parameters, we find that
1) CPT converges faster and saves significant resources in a scalable manner;
2) CPT adheres to an extended scaling law derived from Hoffmann et al. (2022)
with a joint data-parameter scaling term; 3) The compute-optimal data-parameter
allocation for CPT markedly differs based on our estimated scaling factors; 4)
The effectiveness of transfer at scale is influenced by training duration and
linguistic properties, while robust to data replaying, a method that
effectively mitigates catastrophic forgetting in CPT. We hope our findings
provide deeper insights into the transferability of LLMs at scale for the
research community. | [
-0.4064359962940216,
-0.5224467515945435,
0.5087668895721436,
0.3365005552768707,
-0.26451414823532104,
0.2153896540403366,
-0.5718576312065125,
-0.28465116024017334,
0.08406424522399902,
0.4511389136314392,
-0.46707212924957275,
0.02705794759094715,
-0.6985040903091431,
0.03170592710375786,
-0.23053623735904694,
0.9309396147727966,
-0.29736414551734924,
0.01741618849337101,
-0.2106543928384781,
-0.14736835658550262,
-0.35338330268859863,
-0.7183783650398254,
-0.8032014966011047,
-0.31441429257392883,
0.7001430988311768,
0.26072779297828674,
0.5745148658752441,
0.7508312463760376,
0.24782051146030426,
0.3122061491012573,
0.30536267161369324,
-0.19240321218967438,
-0.6511985063552856,
-0.20727190375328064,
-0.2506084740161896,
-0.5756730437278748,
-0.21101485192775726,
0.09946148842573166,
1.0131373405456543,
1.0161123275756836,
-0.021047059446573257,
-0.0065045650117099285,
0.2907146215438843,
0.7032902240753174,
-0.42362508177757263,
0.08045949786901474,
-0.6579450368881226,
0.032971158623695374,
-0.44614315032958984,
0.04349598288536072,
-0.371486097574234,
-0.24287135899066925,
0.172574982047081,
-0.6636756062507629,
0.032338060438632965,
-0.015146239660680294,
0.8224271535873413,
0.17072926461696625,
-0.10946016758680344,
-0.22396661341190338,
-0.8092817664146423,
0.9148759245872498,
-0.42883357405662537,
0.7374803423881531,
0.24683009088039398,
0.10147135704755783,
0.20500926673412323,
-0.8980066180229187,
-0.413532555103302,
-0.583563506603241,
0.09518645703792572,
-0.22280389070510864,
-0.0325411781668663,
-0.15403957664966583,
0.09196671098470688,
0.05781944841146469,
-0.5715740323066711,
0.2675442695617676,
-0.36075636744499207,
-0.1346542239189148,
0.4633273780345917,
-0.06527089327573776,
0.4501834511756897,
0.4461013972759247,
-0.19587178528308868,
-0.018734320998191833,
-1.0901768207550049,
-0.09141132235527039,
0.07669593393802643,
0.4066320061683655,
-0.07872603088617325,
0.10476065427064896,
0.1346462070941925,
0.4363826513290405,
0.15234753489494324,
-0.12796568870544434,
0.21354292333126068,
-0.5051864385604858,
0.2411002814769745,
-0.05502598360180855,
0.8102644085884094,
-0.14713171124458313,
0.6612352728843689,
-0.4594765603542328,
-0.005299402866512537,
-0.1448763757944107,
0.23609375953674316,
-0.8210576176643372,
-0.3589068651199341,
-0.2752048969268799,
-0.1953185498714447,
0.14952684938907623,
-0.3494107723236084,
-0.49867314100265503,
0.02650529146194458,
-0.5699676275253296,
0.4172084629535675,
-0.3963777422904968,
-0.29010170698165894,
-0.08408396691083908,
0.5337124466896057,
0.042729880660772324,
0.14101503789424896,
-1.096112847328186,
0.280145525932312,
0.4268675446510315,
0.9463066458702087,
-0.2816009521484375,
-0.6726348400115967,
-0.5538420677185059,
0.032335855066776276,
-0.530280590057373,
0.5523427724838257,
-0.5012362599372864,
-0.4072600305080414,
-0.11055631190538406,
0.07963716238737106,
-0.19996173679828644,
-0.5738278031349182,
-0.02224234864115715,
-0.5660730004310608,
0.04299632087349892,
-0.22871850430965424,
-0.3700248599052429,
0.23030568659305573,
0.3759949803352356,
-0.5830147862434387,
0.7700092196464539,
0.18827863037586212,
-0.553219735622406,
0.4268469214439392,
-0.3878909945487976,
-0.5884655714035034,
0.24025988578796387,
-0.14047493040561676,
-0.2623313069343567,
-0.055767130106687546,
0.24491164088249207,
0.17976872622966766,
-0.4769164025783539,
0.2317563146352768,
-0.3592963218688965,
-0.19535373151302338,
-0.11713220924139023,
-0.39730095863342285,
0.6785305142402649,
0.06997323781251907,
-0.2797430753707886,
-0.19577647745609283,
-0.6060473322868347,
0.04700917750597,
0.09483616054058075,
-0.5083180069923401,
-0.35860276222229004,
-0.1157410591840744,
-0.25507140159606934,
0.21031802892684937,
0.5185368657112122,
-0.5471042394638062,
0.117707759141922,
-0.27240902185440063,
0.31577634811401367,
0.6527620553970337,
-0.24189460277557373,
0.6353550553321838,
-0.39776962995529175,
0.6822981834411621,
-0.14826567471027374,
0.04715350270271301,
-0.08374365419149399,
-0.06698418408632278,
-0.7830838561058044,
-0.25395217537879944,
0.3281696140766144,
0.5847351551055908,
-0.7182705402374268,
0.3244442641735077,
-0.49313050508499146,
-0.5114388465881348,
-0.3116450309753418,
0.49977463483810425,
0.3122585117816925,
0.23080529272556305,
0.3396003842353821,
-0.4263900816440582,
-0.5817191004753113,
-0.6144806742668152,
-0.2813394069671631,
-0.19056276977062225,
-0.2815646529197693,
0.12722189724445343,
0.275752454996109,
-0.21187160909175873,
0.8745737671852112,
-0.06204743683338165,
-0.020404033362865448,
-0.4223276376724243,
0.1253921538591385,
0.049939580261707306,
0.6350950002670288,
0.5092971324920654,
-0.4395299553871155,
-0.7662531137466431,
0.060001153498888016,
-0.6370221972465515,
-0.15918917953968048,
-0.348113089799881,
-0.041836850345134735,
0.1088409423828125,
0.8906643986701965,
-0.40164485573768616,
0.04996264725923538,
0.5852987766265869,
0.036998502910137177,
0.5909424424171448,
-0.4411975145339966,
-0.09857651591300964,
-0.8797134757041931,
-0.021825596690177917,
-0.25969192385673523,
-0.08500482887029648,
-0.7016991376876831,
-0.19425782561302185,
0.027398686856031418,
-0.10797915607690811,
-0.5202004909515381,
0.725953221321106,
-0.6749011874198914,
0.1469118893146515,
-0.23235176503658295,
0.08917991071939468,
-0.2987411320209503,
0.5119642019271851,
0.1159702017903328,
0.6290801763534546,
0.6804718375205994,
-0.6819661259651184,
0.17876166105270386,
-0.012642275542020798,
-0.12537115812301636,
0.6225341558456421,
-0.5890125036239624,
0.29881492257118225,
0.024845829233527184,
0.2779540419578552,
-0.5897969603538513,
0.17347614467144012,
-0.005335772875696421,
-0.18090173602104187,
0.40271347761154175,
-0.05724969133734703,
-0.44990020990371704,
-0.1977221965789795,
-0.009587360545992851,
0.7989300489425659,
0.6059916019439697,
-0.6818081736564636,
0.6208361387252808,
0.34832435846328735,
-0.5442073345184326,
-0.17585621774196625,
-0.702522873878479,
0.21603059768676758,
-0.25096946954727173,
-0.4742129445075989,
0.23931147158145905,
-0.19728516042232513,
-0.12029311805963516,
-0.05310959741473198,
0.12161488085985184,
-0.09644267708063126,
-0.055814843624830246,
0.014228086918592453,
0.08452602475881577,
-0.349285751581192,
0.13620421290397644,
-0.23926828801631927,
-0.05032716691493988,
0.16242893040180206,
-0.6842310428619385,
0.7107890844345093,
-0.23385024070739746,
-0.24729853868484497,
-0.2981565296649933,
0.2695976793766022,
0.5687773823738098,
-0.3177737593650818,
0.7600986361503601,
0.41288453340530396,
-0.17153657972812653,
-0.31898051500320435,
-0.3422476649284363,
0.0033550946973264217,
-0.47821053862571716,
0.49787697196006775,
-0.3761923313140869,
-1.0781468152999878,
0.38869884610176086,
-0.23504464328289032,
0.05023907497525215,
0.2666564881801605,
0.5953149199485779,
0.20982161164283752,
0.708793580532074,
0.9567780494689941,
-0.39649343490600586,
0.5972272157669067,
0.16227546334266663,
0.3021279275417328,
-0.5094900727272034,
-0.09242235124111176,
-0.41357794404029846,
-0.16771499812602997,
-0.5056704878807068,
-0.5963433980941772,
0.31970033049583435,
0.21457064151763916,
-0.5955492854118347,
0.35953572392463684,
-0.08254622668027878,
0.5399971008300781,
0.33775612711906433,
-0.0696425586938858,
0.1292470246553421,
-0.08981822431087494,
-0.11751488596200943,
-0.00836570281535387,
-0.9435595870018005,
-0.13956031203269958,
1.287820816040039,
0.29655924439430237,
0.738290548324585,
-0.14464402198791504,
0.73165363073349,
-0.0767761692404747,
0.7395370602607727,
-0.4112846255302429,
0.5493316054344177,
-0.2964407205581665,
-0.46875208616256714,
-0.6454638242721558,
-0.6364880204200745,
-1.015336036682129,
0.16694776713848114,
-0.021914871409535408,
-0.662814199924469,
-0.13381776213645935,
0.1143769696354866,
-0.18933211266994476,
0.4830871820449829,
-0.433036208152771,
0.6163806915283203,
-0.5529401302337646,
-0.4078916013240814,
-0.2741682827472687,
-0.5505361557006836,
0.17032746970653534,
-0.6738461852073669,
0.3623926341533661,
0.057229503989219666,
-0.08228049427270889,
0.8206178545951843,
-0.5285349488258362,
0.8754765391349792,
-0.08971234411001205,
-0.23447285592556,
0.26286986470222473,
-0.03253941982984543,
0.48373574018478394,
-0.0002719507901929319,
0.12732739746570587,
0.24213115870952606,
-0.1909666210412979,
-0.6686094403266907,
-0.47509151697158813,
0.5832321643829346,
-0.7639451622962952,
-0.636864185333252,
-0.10461611300706863,
-0.7976120114326477,
-0.4907251298427582,
0.3866512179374695,
0.25647222995758057,
0.19601106643676758,
-0.26782405376434326,
0.25186970829963684,
0.5671576857566833,
-0.2787329852581024,
0.3602125346660614,
0.5145416855812073,
-0.16156139969825745,
-0.30610764026641846,
1.0183167457580566,
0.4182698130607605,
0.5529114603996277,
0.33976495265960693,
0.27785438299179077,
-0.23302610218524933,
-0.5928080081939697,
-0.3091001808643341,
0.412168025970459,
-0.376399427652359,
0.23050765693187714,
-0.5469954013824463,
-0.3937826454639435,
-0.42171362042427063,
-0.43872642517089844,
-0.7219224572181702,
-0.07248949259519577,
-0.05104532092809677,
0.09202452003955841,
0.15686209499835968,
0.5359248518943787,
-0.4658944606781006,
0.29842841625213623,
-0.9176061749458313,
0.15389995276927948,
0.46076831221580505,
0.31703367829322815,
0.00967568438500166,
-0.6630590558052063,
-0.49995729327201843,
0.036499883979558945,
0.06769806891679764,
-0.36163824796676636,
0.31104469299316406,
0.3338169753551483,
0.6432167291641235,
0.28532639145851135,
-0.05887458100914955,
0.6068011522293091,
-0.8277847766876221,
0.7212468385696411,
0.4727383852005005,
-0.9598100781440735,
0.2355044186115265,
-0.2942928373813629,
0.7477635741233826,
0.6549294590950012,
0.6758405566215515,
-0.5160220265388489,
-0.43278181552886963,
-0.4929873049259186,
-0.9433789253234863,
0.46155232191085815,
-0.11271786689758301,
0.3264109790325165,
0.06654788553714752,
0.39121532440185547,
0.10128138214349747,
-0.12127318978309631,
-0.7954384684562683,
0.1196017637848854,
-0.10563115775585175,
-0.011244581080973148,
-0.4430047273635864,
-0.05253194645047188,
-0.04263756424188614,
-0.39313626289367676,
0.5266794562339783,
-0.020272893831133842,
-0.13528195023536682,
-0.12255789339542389,
-0.3467775881290436,
0.18304988741874695,
0.05155050382018089,
0.3247969150543213,
0.7358604669570923,
0.1475592851638794,
0.23066383600234985,
0.5968821048736572,
-0.6328557729721069,
0.45844876766204834,
0.052152328193187714,
0.04871293157339096,
-0.16599898040294647,
0.6260969042778015,
0.63121497631073,
0.24143044650554657,
-0.6709391474723816,
0.3029373288154602,
0.09983991831541061,
-0.4680041968822479,
-0.2418825477361679,
-0.14266695082187653,
0.21234919130802155,
0.20014871656894684,
0.028359856456518173,
-0.27962908148765564,
-0.6433613300323486,
-0.6212615370750427,
0.5884034037590027,
0.15569941699504852,
-0.3190170228481293,
-0.44628918170928955,
0.7159213423728943,
0.23591263592243195,
-0.2144218534231186,
0.8401675224304199,
-0.09220702946186066,
-0.4304400086402893,
0.43521225452423096,
0.587624728679657,
0.63105309009552,
-0.48326846957206726,
0.07685533165931702,
0.274657666683197,
0.4874293804168701,
-0.4248204529285431,
-0.17153996229171753,
-0.15218192338943481,
-0.8088563084602356,
-0.5278419256210327,
-0.6825317144393921,
-0.3520970046520233,
0.17595890164375305,
-0.36698970198631287,
0.03857996314764023,
-0.7987361550331116,
0.1777372807264328,
-0.29026979207992554,
0.007711260579526424,
-0.7022360563278198,
0.25487834215164185,
0.2693976163864136,
0.6759273409843445,
-0.7774820327758789,
1.1301127672195435,
0.37162917852401733,
-0.23797707259655,
-0.8904955983161926,
0.03071863390505314,
-0.10014410316944122,
-0.8296270966529846,
0.6295748353004456,
0.06121362745761871,
-0.19651760160923004,
-0.022726651281118393,
-0.44478824734687805,
-1.0360325574874878,
0.8475629687309265,
0.5505120158195496,
-0.8402663469314575,
-0.13912087678909302,
0.47710004448890686,
0.5090200304985046,
-0.47276443243026733,
-0.14191803336143494,
0.8993561863899231,
0.39279884099960327,
0.03171590715646744,
-1.0181381702423096,
0.140149787068367,
-0.16781601309776306,
-0.04803411662578583,
0.2391171008348465,
-0.5875914096832275,
1.10123872756958,
-0.17747017741203308,
-0.1868513971567154,
0.06280795484781265,
0.6832385063171387,
0.24569354951381683,
-0.06270843744277954,
0.7741472721099854,
0.606274425983429,
0.7284623384475708,
0.18926453590393066,
0.7937566637992859,
-0.46071580052375793,
0.10777769982814789,
1.1467207670211792,
-0.3897487223148346,
0.7049586772918701,
0.38775497674942017,
-0.3052791655063629,
0.39747849106788635,
0.5195751786231995,
0.07414190471172333,
0.3481350839138031,
0.6343251466751099,
-0.3933459222316742,
-0.2771579623222351,
-0.029355419799685478,
-0.423265665769577,
0.15599294006824493,
0.1411885768175125,
-0.0303460955619812,
-0.3350927233695984,
0.3422248065471649,
0.3659774363040924,
0.0603424608707428,
-0.42971378564834595,
0.41066133975982666,
0.27689236402511597,
-0.6007006168365479,
0.8528024554252625,
-0.38160455226898193,
0.7369610667228699,
-0.7863128781318665,
0.4114476144313812,
-0.4243415892124176,
0.2648133933544159,
0.17784088850021362,
-0.3069651126861572,
0.32352185249328613,
0.17059116065502167,
0.0081156175583601,
-0.5531200170516968,
0.23545165359973907,
-0.6628010869026184,
-0.5446284413337708,
0.4455079734325409,
0.4423755705356598,
0.3338070511817932,
-0.0953710675239563,
-0.5081154108047485,
-0.013026615604758263,
-0.033615920692682266,
-0.28641170263290405,
0.6558555364608765,
0.5869902968406677,
-0.248292475938797,
0.6854203343391418,
0.6580585837364197,
0.34804046154022217,
0.2101203203201294,
0.08558265119791031,
0.9194464087486267,
-0.5137704610824585,
-0.6088496446609497,
-0.654693603515625,
0.19496309757232666,
0.34127017855644226,
-0.3516206443309784,
0.5701417922973633,
0.38495445251464844,
0.986638605594635,
0.16765327751636505,
0.9016950130462646,
-0.035382673144340515,
0.3271302580833435,
-0.4913710951805115,
0.8396670818328857,
-0.5291476845741272,
0.2579542398452759,
0.02440352365374565,
-0.8061483502388,
-0.2963142693042755,
0.19020366668701172,
-0.3885519802570343,
0.09159819036722183,
0.8131136894226074,
0.7023667693138123,
0.0755561962723732,
-0.38049617409706116,
0.37808430194854736,
0.2377411425113678,
0.40473759174346924,
0.8393481373786926,
0.6829298138618469,
0.1771722137928009,
0.7370615601539612,
0.025206591933965683,
-0.33028143644332886,
0.2112097591161728,
-0.665324330329895,
-0.9327480792999268,
-0.4530494213104248,
-0.20162484049797058,
-0.06479780375957489,
0.20267263054847717,
0.6526612043380737,
0.7587577104568481,
-0.5929200649261475,
-0.44333723187446594,
-0.3129679262638092,
-0.22520706057548523,
-0.039845481514930725,
-0.07834059745073318,
0.2574739158153534,
-0.7033083438873291,
-0.6294116973876953,
0.46523723006248474,
0.1944081336259842,
-0.05080705136060715,
-0.38163918256759644,
-0.3436511158943176,
-0.26080578565597534,
0.277474969625473,
0.5066712498664856,
0.6898091435432434,
-0.2831615209579468,
-0.5003589987754822,
-0.23960387706756592,
0.00050789286615327,
0.04228230565786362,
0.8294709920883179,
-0.6668183207511902,
0.303178071975708,
0.32669416069984436,
1.0751490592956543,
0.5842159986495972,
-0.3535696268081665,
0.911862850189209,
-0.5429595112800598,
0.3762739896774292,
0.2548873722553253,
0.10500181466341019,
0.2613440752029419,
-0.11045462638139725,
0.3107205927371979,
0.3429192304611206,
-0.559363842010498,
-0.683552622795105,
0.3576723337173462,
-0.5841890573501587,
-0.4321554899215698,
0.9414159655570984,
-0.3831980228424072,
-0.13747398555278778,
-0.08602038770914078,
0.18702463805675507,
0.20891073346138,
0.20898687839508057,
0.6187755465507507,
0.7452175617218018,
-0.18126526474952698,
-0.3426297605037689,
-0.39284735918045044,
0.38073527812957764,
0.6463256478309631,
-0.9358820915222168,
0.06284798681735992,
0.08453010022640228,
0.49108532071113586,
0.07032277435064316,
0.8912132978439331,
-0.18142084777355194,
0.01879141479730606,
0.324834942817688,
0.049726057797670364,
0.14066997170448303,
-0.6894694566726685,
-0.2708108723163605,
0.17208890616893768,
0.11111240088939667,
-0.02312828041613102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02099v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02099v1 | Helpful assistant or fruitful facilitator? Investigating how personas affect language model behavior | 2024-07-02T09:36:54 | 2024-07-02T09:36:54 | Pedro Henrique Luz de Araujo, Benjamin Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL | One way to personalize and steer generations from large language models (LLM)
is to assign a persona: a role that describes how the user expects the LLM to
behave (e.g., a helpful assistant, a teacher, a woman). This paper investigates
how personas affect diverse aspects of model behavior. We assign to seven LLMs
162 personas from 12 categories spanning variables like gender, sexual
orientation, and occupation. We prompt them to answer questions from five
datasets covering objective (e.g., questions about math and history) and
subjective tasks (e.g., questions about beliefs and values). We also compare
persona's generations to two baseline settings: a control persona setting with
30 paraphrases of "a helpful assistant" to control for models' prompt
sensitivity, and an empty persona setting where no persona is assigned. We find
that for all models and datasets, personas show greater variability than the
control setting and that some measures of persona behavior generalize across
models. | [
-0.20441055297851562,
-0.7839561104774475,
0.6468050479888916,
0.42889273166656494,
0.14708857238292694,
-0.20422621071338654,
-0.0037676214706152678,
-0.33496662974357605,
0.02460736222565174,
0.54558265209198,
-0.5698422193527222,
0.11060141026973724,
-0.5469495058059692,
0.22236783802509308,
-0.24397271871566772,
1.0963002443313599,
0.3447137773036957,
0.2519024610519409,
-0.4544833302497864,
-0.1387467384338379,
-0.6827722191810608,
-0.46868839859962463,
-0.9477657079696655,
-0.3624683916568756,
0.7847891449928284,
0.4366167187690735,
1.009535551071167,
0.3169080317020416,
0.19474732875823975,
0.44206979870796204,
-0.05228188633918762,
-0.18610543012619019,
-0.2237052470445633,
0.5324324369430542,
-0.3151550889015198,
-0.7113572955131531,
-0.5563947558403015,
-0.00462086359038949,
0.23666217923164368,
1.0350642204284668,
0.08985979855060577,
0.152231365442276,
0.4108494818210602,
0.39533674716949463,
-0.40695613622665405,
0.2710273861885071,
-0.31004562973976135,
-0.21855521202087402,
-0.2771774232387543,
-0.11268093436956406,
-0.3872200548648834,
-0.4411538541316986,
0.25803428888320923,
-0.7280266880989075,
0.2689642906188965,
-0.0650336742401123,
0.27903488278388977,
0.13716712594032288,
-0.8435916900634766,
-0.41581934690475464,
-0.9697169661521912,
0.9014283418655396,
-0.3727719783782959,
0.14860087633132935,
0.6429738998413086,
0.1231851875782013,
-0.34163039922714233,
-0.20775458216667175,
-0.30780544877052307,
-0.19502155482769012,
-0.18362075090408325,
-0.21304479241371155,
-0.36402133107185364,
-0.012898064218461514,
0.2952914237976074,
0.31473198533058167,
-0.32311326265335083,
0.127149298787117,
-0.08955348283052444,
-0.20161184668540955,
0.4572124183177948,
0.29654380679130554,
0.4341734051704407,
-0.24389375746250153,
0.10462967306375504,
0.12755076587200165,
-0.45361170172691345,
0.2207949161529541,
0.692281186580658,
0.2399684190750122,
-0.05071442946791649,
0.5272321701049805,
-0.10675670951604843,
0.7805861830711365,
0.32151341438293457,
-0.32143089175224304,
0.09061090648174286,
-0.28656044602394104,
-0.08015011250972748,
-0.38292208313941956,
0.4951208233833313,
0.2880012094974518,
0.7134220004081726,
-0.1548754870891571,
-0.15231828391551971,
-0.3090456426143646,
0.27973970770835876,
-0.4133302569389343,
-0.3986729383468628,
-0.05721096694469452,
-0.46686699986457825,
-0.02871927246451378,
-0.11439167708158493,
-0.741561770439148,
-0.8750740885734558,
-0.429643452167511,
0.28481894731521606,
-0.27912256121635437,
-0.1372646987438202,
-0.3301106095314026,
-0.056311365216970444,
0.45389753580093384,
0.582722008228302,
-1.2771865129470825,
0.4704705476760864,
0.41487917304039,
0.44803765416145325,
-0.06440987437963486,
-0.33852577209472656,
-0.8712970614433289,
0.044266872107982635,
0.032652467489242554,
0.6185587644577026,
-0.9383318424224854,
-0.7351943850517273,
-0.057337477803230286,
0.04178827628493309,
-0.2903035581111908,
-0.6284533739089966,
0.3043094873428345,
-0.17617520689964294,
0.5224844217300415,
-0.6937977075576782,
-0.21382544934749603,
0.08943530917167664,
-0.13676536083221436,
-0.4992004930973053,
0.6156646013259888,
0.4162936210632324,
-0.728418231010437,
0.2851351797580719,
-0.477539986371994,
-0.3960813283920288,
0.07377473264932632,
-0.3592507243156433,
0.009026164188981056,
0.37456345558166504,
0.17713399231433868,
0.5730865597724915,
-0.22035060822963715,
0.11064855754375458,
-0.23845645785331726,
-0.15992967784404755,
0.7723649144172668,
-0.3821117579936981,
1.0123661756515503,
0.04114801436662674,
-0.2222462296485901,
0.2576422095298767,
-0.6228166818618774,
-0.5051357746124268,
0.2108224630355835,
-0.3221999704837799,
-0.6387527585029602,
-0.1643577367067337,
0.0029055573977530003,
0.2983255088329315,
0.16238322854042053,
-0.2495923936367035,
0.4221095144748688,
-0.0221073217689991,
-0.15570034086704254,
0.959222674369812,
0.31730473041534424,
0.5718795657157898,
-0.4995998442173004,
0.9475045800209045,
-0.29468315839767456,
0.22531941533088684,
-0.30180788040161133,
-0.8209165334701538,
-0.8091450929641724,
-0.11890976876020432,
0.032407552003860474,
0.4790270924568176,
-0.7354907393455505,
0.1715536266565323,
0.07551862299442291,
-0.2813020348548889,
-0.5778132081031799,
0.4307732582092285,
0.28273269534111023,
0.471370667219162,
0.051047515124082565,
-0.16962438821792603,
-0.09274960309267044,
-1.135329246520996,
-0.32477372884750366,
-0.24428245425224304,
-0.2934880554676056,
0.5581112504005432,
0.28660231828689575,
0.04173460230231285,
0.7808542251586914,
-0.4717189073562622,
-0.18469978868961334,
-0.39453625679016113,
-0.14472635090351105,
-0.16353508830070496,
0.3108241856098175,
1.0053876638412476,
-0.7543368935585022,
-0.5749666094779968,
-0.3333263695240021,
-0.3358041048049927,
-0.5271092653274536,
-0.27957484126091003,
0.1094542071223259,
0.006058066617697477,
0.14807580411434174,
-0.3366718292236328,
0.20885734260082245,
0.44306430220603943,
-0.6755708456039429,
0.49888715147972107,
-0.2786628305912018,
0.16830697655677795,
-1.069749116897583,
0.13565225899219513,
0.3226264715194702,
-0.05963870882987976,
-0.9898101687431335,
-0.024080194532871246,
-0.3148859143257141,
0.15398943424224854,
-0.24105864763259888,
0.62804114818573,
-0.4416815936565399,
-0.1462581902742386,
-0.3836256265640259,
0.03938392177224159,
-0.22002358734607697,
0.43139880895614624,
-0.04785875231027603,
1.0164982080459595,
0.5307331085205078,
-0.814351499080658,
0.08523815870285034,
0.4411071836948395,
0.11982043832540512,
0.8754810690879822,
-0.5843693614006042,
0.4210781753063202,
-0.06774832308292389,
0.003023650962859392,
-1.1686581373214722,
-0.3701179325580597,
0.3775939643383026,
-0.37395668029785156,
0.11271688342094421,
0.10798721015453339,
-0.4784527122974396,
0.05928565189242363,
-0.2392895668745041,
0.09915753453969955,
0.2573123276233673,
-0.26289987564086914,
0.7869278192520142,
0.36657896637916565,
-0.5752423405647278,
-0.16283456981182098,
-0.7228049039840698,
-0.0379200279712677,
-0.5025045871734619,
-0.3659277558326721,
0.1138094887137413,
-0.46284401416778564,
-0.6051172614097595,
-0.41022148728370667,
-0.0743752270936966,
-0.20174279808998108,
0.4819147288799286,
0.3144995868206024,
0.23515143990516663,
0.050983600318431854,
-0.11086441576480865,
-0.034908097237348557,
-0.005286365281790495,
0.26424720883369446,
0.3357662856578827,
0.5959550142288208,
-0.021595614030957222,
-0.22000926733016968,
-0.2492000311613083,
0.40828582644462585,
0.6012667417526245,
-0.1686498522758484,
0.8308364152908325,
0.3587169647216797,
-0.06046753004193306,
0.21787576377391815,
-0.5143162608146667,
-0.12096217274665833,
-0.5125473141670227,
0.11368168145418167,
-0.3953891098499298,
-0.8233603239059448,
0.8117937445640564,
0.4419654607772827,
0.09275487810373306,
0.13729190826416016,
0.4732573330402374,
0.12179677188396454,
0.9769662022590637,
0.6896150708198547,
-0.12649443745613098,
0.6561576724052429,
0.07231535017490387,
0.12857654690742493,
-0.8669028282165527,
-0.45146235823631287,
-0.8101904392242432,
-0.29490938782691956,
-0.5508708953857422,
-0.16448694467544556,
-0.001408664626069367,
-0.30014529824256897,
0.0005602857563644648,
0.11474066972732544,
-0.20429196953773499,
0.05251174420118332,
0.5892154574394226,
-0.1503705233335495,
0.21588005125522614,
-0.19519908726215363,
0.14498591423034668,
-0.24525213241577148,
-0.6321755647659302,
-0.7152332067489624,
0.882763147354126,
0.4304913878440857,
0.8465937972068787,
0.5484699010848999,
0.4957369863986969,
0.15230460464954376,
0.3017547130584717,
-0.755112886428833,
0.8549494743347168,
-0.18015024065971375,
-0.5999787449836731,
0.06810873001813889,
-0.30209097266197205,
-1.023354172706604,
0.0184139646589756,
-0.050469327718019485,
-1.0428465604782104,
0.4487808644771576,
0.5172363519668579,
-0.4372381567955017,
-0.11676498502492905,
-0.7719956636428833,
0.7414541244506836,
-0.3014402687549591,
-0.5145607590675354,
0.11077943444252014,
-0.6714975237846375,
0.26791077852249146,
-0.06341148167848587,
0.19525381922721863,
0.10022298246622086,
-0.1912456899881363,
0.7291817665100098,
-0.009850738570094109,
1.0840988159179688,
-0.4454802870750427,
-0.19943690299987793,
-0.0819304957985878,
0.4304364025592804,
0.2994372248649597,
-0.24994124472141266,
-0.27535879611968994,
-0.5101404786109924,
-0.1272769719362259,
-0.4377184808254242,
-0.5932769775390625,
0.9257432222366333,
-0.7747005224227905,
-1.0623505115509033,
-0.37739479541778564,
-0.8082821369171143,
-0.5351350903511047,
0.06964751332998276,
0.04543708264827728,
0.2729373276233673,
-0.1622537076473236,
0.5268217921257019,
0.7212597727775574,
-0.4415203332901001,
0.3038364052772522,
0.5047295093536377,
-0.21172501146793365,
0.02384882979094982,
0.6072337031364441,
-0.006338230799883604,
0.5631491541862488,
0.17688217759132385,
0.41530781984329224,
-0.18012310564517975,
-0.1630924940109253,
-0.1548728346824646,
0.16596190631389618,
-0.8287116289138794,
0.08823343366384506,
-0.6955608129501343,
0.2467399537563324,
-0.6224128603935242,
-0.09935380518436432,
0.22795981168746948,
-0.3265829086303711,
-0.6508516669273376,
0.02880551852285862,
0.3391582667827606,
0.7677497863769531,
0.4958139657974243,
0.6435745358467102,
-0.4252707362174988,
0.1707371324300766,
0.65375816822052,
-0.0706811398267746,
0.025929851457476616,
-0.6263365745544434,
0.15356895327568054,
-0.21066422760486603,
-0.3288606107234955,
-1.135396122932434,
0.06566111743450165,
0.24475619196891785,
0.9376516342163086,
0.5669906139373779,
-0.1696586310863495,
0.5393128991127014,
-0.17998343706130981,
1.1767984628677368,
-0.12757200002670288,
-0.7850170135498047,
0.47787705063819885,
-0.5549265146255493,
0.530535876750946,
0.5294817686080933,
0.30520355701446533,
-0.5391486883163452,
-0.658300518989563,
-0.5877249240875244,
-0.5725740194320679,
0.9249715209007263,
0.19406479597091675,
0.6318515539169312,
0.015447967685759068,
0.5025444626808167,
0.298203706741333,
0.3652074337005615,
-0.869651734828949,
-0.7069297432899475,
-0.18739484250545502,
0.055262308567762375,
0.07682716101408005,
-0.39278534054756165,
0.24254156649112701,
-0.1435137540102005,
0.49923884868621826,
-0.06500930339097977,
0.3308054506778717,
-0.10694830864667892,
0.17563338577747345,
-0.23711708188056946,
0.5756139159202576,
0.5043872594833374,
0.5903730392456055,
0.16408075392246246,
-0.0025694379583001137,
0.12923254072666168,
-0.26140618324279785,
0.0980079397559166,
0.11132977902889252,
-0.27286332845687866,
-0.2115415334701538,
0.39055100083351135,
0.911179780960083,
0.35368016362190247,
-0.23378178477287292,
0.4061090350151062,
-0.17330989241600037,
0.06667584180831909,
-0.051292870193719864,
0.7992814183235168,
-0.004522426053881645,
0.038967303931713104,
0.5217236280441284,
-0.05300996080040932,
0.21501366794109344,
-0.7895991802215576,
-0.12659500539302826,
0.48204952478408813,
0.06244654580950737,
-0.5502929091453552,
0.7338495254516602,
0.33684587478637695,
-0.7893765568733215,
0.46406108140945435,
0.019432881847023964,
-0.3683384954929352,
0.4055449962615967,
0.6672163009643555,
0.8614674806594849,
-0.904610276222229,
0.3358577787876129,
-0.14483022689819336,
0.11233890056610107,
0.2612629532814026,
0.039814867079257965,
-0.15633438527584076,
-0.6583069562911987,
-0.08500073850154877,
-0.32338935136795044,
-0.42047208547592163,
0.5325079560279846,
-0.6957002878189087,
-0.0029179733246564865,
-0.27698856592178345,
-0.08165287971496582,
0.18022534251213074,
0.09048029035329819,
-0.856467604637146,
0.20965775847434998,
-0.09712092578411102,
0.7505321502685547,
-1.158402442932129,
0.8325549364089966,
1.0337525606155396,
-0.4504151940345764,
-0.7570284008979797,
0.5535762310028076,
0.1501290500164032,
-0.3650743365287781,
0.3664107620716095,
-0.17640379071235657,
-0.1047116294503212,
-0.13357800245285034,
-0.1527152806520462,
-0.6341226696968079,
0.9032531380653381,
0.7437558770179749,
-0.26572710275650024,
-0.17914633452892303,
0.11439116299152374,
0.7588953971862793,
-0.45048701763153076,
0.03386898711323738,
0.5360448360443115,
0.5078904032707214,
-0.012344160117208958,
-1.069637656211853,
-0.11763912439346313,
-0.3444386124610901,
-0.004271551035344601,
-0.20726339519023895,
-0.7033633589744568,
0.7470504641532898,
-0.12082156538963318,
0.28125205636024475,
0.3588448762893677,
0.5556340217590332,
0.31013911962509155,
0.3096637427806854,
0.7708696126937866,
-0.3801387846469879,
0.7433485388755798,
0.12437722831964493,
1.2873965501785278,
-0.08158764243125916,
-0.23084458708763123,
1.2164523601531982,
-0.3069456219673157,
0.3308444917201996,
0.8173025846481323,
-0.06075224280357361,
0.4619710445404053,
0.43305835127830505,
0.10361891984939575,
0.3534167408943176,
-0.11231893301010132,
-0.37085095047950745,
-0.09253672510385513,
-0.3000967502593994,
0.011757398024201393,
0.3973459303379059,
0.2949753403663635,
-0.541111171245575,
-0.08204575628042221,
0.3988967835903168,
0.07649350166320801,
0.3438216745853424,
-0.18192024528980255,
0.6220767498016357,
0.058385495096445084,
-0.9458944201469421,
-0.22784218192100525,
0.04925098270177841,
0.38139820098876953,
-0.7426090836524963,
0.12843453884124756,
-0.46876952052116394,
0.14088326692581177,
-0.29048269987106323,
-0.7501739263534546,
0.2584351599216461,
0.13464494049549103,
-0.1119004637002945,
-0.3507739305496216,
0.8161907196044922,
-0.15143807232379913,
-0.3235290050506592,
0.12423654645681381,
0.7186357975006104,
0.12546297907829285,
0.17456470429897308,
-0.7312555313110352,
-0.09784718602895737,
0.23573514819145203,
-0.4582078456878662,
0.43634337186813354,
0.2931082248687744,
-0.26196742057800293,
0.8293100595474243,
0.31773486733436584,
-0.04311077669262886,
-0.0008712636190466583,
0.1439346820116043,
0.799591600894928,
-0.32867857813835144,
-0.33846938610076904,
-0.6829070448875427,
0.6585121154785156,
0.1431410312652588,
-0.6007741689682007,
1.2936866283416748,
0.33740365505218506,
0.5048583149909973,
-0.35100865364074707,
0.5309585928916931,
-0.17405888438224792,
0.3024689853191376,
-0.21705277264118195,
0.25445786118507385,
-0.38797488808631897,
0.46103599667549133,
-0.5697442889213562,
-0.9309007525444031,
-0.1541001945734024,
0.7748090028762817,
-0.6043148636817932,
0.6247178912162781,
0.24628207087516785,
0.6747394800186157,
-0.10594645142555237,
0.01072201132774353,
0.26207342743873596,
0.0715290904045105,
0.5369330048561096,
0.16429966688156128,
0.7081896662712097,
0.20723693072795868,
0.21733365952968597,
-0.34403878450393677,
-0.1663869172334671,
-0.07954724878072739,
-0.5877875685691833,
-0.9552222490310669,
-0.7216272950172424,
-0.4859936535358429,
-0.10529407113790512,
-0.17047502100467682,
1.0099835395812988,
0.34936556220054626,
-0.7233657240867615,
-0.26966360211372375,
0.06495481729507446,
0.013309785164892673,
0.01926858350634575,
-0.27096277475357056,
0.007553614675998688,
-0.03313947096467018,
-1.1025447845458984,
0.34484314918518066,
-0.006942447274923325,
0.09072650223970413,
-0.6715202331542969,
0.019146457314491272,
-0.1610139012336731,
0.15282106399536133,
0.39769500494003296,
0.1292562633752823,
-0.7928072810173035,
-0.5025534629821777,
0.39756330847740173,
-0.011490539647638798,
-0.1043102964758873,
1.0001046657562256,
-0.5512793064117432,
0.38699671626091003,
0.14221720397472382,
0.2848726511001587,
-0.04070267826318741,
0.07404448091983795,
0.7975322604179382,
-1.071053385734558,
0.1314830183982849,
0.1707545518875122,
0.40232715010643005,
0.6779978275299072,
-0.8084772229194641,
0.17286549508571625,
0.017784351482987404,
-0.6602988243103027,
-0.5307804346084595,
0.13597026467323303,
-0.8620813488960266,
-0.1902497410774231,
1.3530101776123047,
-0.12181268632411957,
-0.033236101269721985,
-0.3689389228820801,
-0.5808621644973755,
0.009581531397998333,
-0.5377869009971619,
0.6425373554229736,
0.9659994840621948,
-0.5636214017868042,
-0.4904090464115143,
-0.6641880869865417,
0.5036325454711914,
0.5399751663208008,
-0.7601966261863708,
0.14498867094516754,
0.7811418771743774,
0.6041699051856995,
0.13944971561431885,
0.7460946440696716,
0.28909605741500854,
0.26360756158828735,
-0.4794178903102875,
-0.3646088242530823,
-0.08628412336111069,
-0.356804221868515,
-0.7151827216148376,
0.12158448249101639,
0.6038823127746582,
-0.07731430977582932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02067v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02067v1 | Crossroads of Continents: Automated Artifact Extraction for Cultural Adaptation with Large Multimodal Models | 2024-07-02T08:55:41 | 2024-07-02T08:55:41 | Anjishnu Mukherjee, Ziwei Zhu, Antonios Anastasopoulos | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we present a comprehensive three-phase study to examine (1) the
effectiveness of large multimodal models (LMMs) in recognizing cultural
contexts; (2) the accuracy of their representations of diverse cultures; and
(3) their ability to adapt content across cultural boundaries. We first
introduce Dalle Street, a large-scale dataset generated by DALL-E 3 and
validated by humans, containing 9,935 images of 67 countries and 10 concept
classes. We reveal disparities in cultural understanding at the sub-region
level with both open-weight (LLaVA) and closed-source (GPT-4V) models on Dalle
Street and other existing benchmarks. Next, we assess models' deeper culture
understanding by an artifact extraction task and identify over 18,000 artifacts
associated with different countries. Finally, we propose a highly composable
pipeline, CultureAdapt, to adapt images from culture to culture. Our findings
reveal a nuanced picture of the cultural competence of LMMs, highlighting the
need to develop culture-aware systems. Dataset and code are available at
https://github.com/iamshnoo/crossroads | [
-0.6819191575050354,
-0.23476086556911469,
0.6407598257064819,
0.35180455446243286,
-0.30781319737434387,
0.30039331316947937,
-0.25668463110923767,
-0.9539195895195007,
0.03127335384488106,
0.3981853127479553,
-0.5616372227668762,
-0.6420760750770569,
-0.6716224551200867,
0.38997378945350647,
-0.3826400935649872,
0.44377121329307556,
-0.32411596179008484,
-0.035036973655223846,
-0.15067456662654877,
-0.46646422147750854,
-0.5013449788093567,
-0.11895013600587845,
-0.13794930279254913,
-0.1936141401529312,
0.09867923706769943,
0.6606076955795288,
0.6086367964744568,
0.5737047791481018,
0.5229950547218323,
0.32230594754219055,
0.29484161734580994,
0.18141776323318481,
-0.4783753454685211,
0.07005959749221802,
-0.3654806613922119,
-0.06060193106532097,
-0.46498993039131165,
0.07721713930368423,
0.3341889977455139,
0.5917603969573975,
0.18846537172794342,
0.43436288833618164,
0.18116548657417297,
0.4425490200519562,
-0.6128041744232178,
0.16927392780780792,
-0.6666869521141052,
-0.055865634232759476,
-0.15754717588424683,
-0.25815078616142273,
-0.36053627729415894,
-0.17802484333515167,
0.30867815017700195,
-0.8388844132423401,
0.008874408900737762,
-0.08506763726472855,
0.47029849886894226,
0.35108256340026855,
-0.9699061512947083,
-0.48500967025756836,
-0.921323835849762,
0.781518280506134,
-0.14510488510131836,
0.5388180613517761,
0.23663678765296936,
0.45025748014450073,
-0.1733386516571045,
-0.9141985177993774,
-0.44545361399650574,
0.49042782187461853,
0.24755285680294037,
0.5119693279266357,
0.14668715000152588,
-0.31128963828086853,
0.17269623279571533,
0.4395659565925598,
-0.5056853294372559,
-0.05420803278684616,
-0.450545072555542,
-0.3063669800758362,
0.8676629662513733,
0.40981027483940125,
0.35626015067100525,
-0.3124396502971649,
-0.6623572707176208,
-0.13878248631954193,
-0.5741482973098755,
0.11401376873254776,
-0.11577831953763962,
0.1725042313337326,
-0.47547659277915955,
0.0520557276904583,
-0.34387630224227905,
0.7021052241325378,
-0.014410557225346565,
-0.4317128360271454,
0.23274344205856323,
-0.2958296239376068,
0.09408201277256012,
-0.15056252479553223,
0.41346845030784607,
0.9028197526931763,
0.11030928045511246,
0.0464349240064621,
0.04624202847480774,
-0.19328054785728455,
0.19493147730827332,
-0.556106448173523,
-0.35875916481018066,
0.31738266348838806,
-0.7998424768447876,
0.09417078644037247,
-0.1436426192522049,
-0.8382478356361389,
-0.9552834630012512,
-0.502193033695221,
0.3807547688484192,
-0.3249918520450592,
-0.3682692050933838,
0.09844893962144852,
-0.15222086012363434,
0.4461512267589569,
0.6046456694602966,
-0.5570816397666931,
0.09075655788183212,
0.3682527542114258,
1.0089292526245117,
-0.4467780292034149,
-0.38057076930999756,
-0.001016072928905487,
0.09741108864545822,
-0.24420355260372162,
0.7542962431907654,
-0.38190191984176636,
-0.6205558180809021,
0.10429742932319641,
0.6450027227401733,
0.10609254240989685,
-0.4377731382846832,
0.7937533855438232,
-0.5543943047523499,
-0.22967562079429626,
-0.6625865697860718,
0.16561660170555115,
-0.63251793384552,
0.41668617725372314,
-0.9731864333152771,
0.7022483348846436,
0.021505605429410934,
-0.36061176657676697,
0.5525146722793579,
-0.30866748094558716,
-0.38258588314056396,
0.036767132580280304,
-0.1034957617521286,
0.045534249395132065,
-0.06614694744348526,
0.45171058177948,
0.23963694274425507,
-0.3568851947784424,
-0.16683858633041382,
-0.37117740511894226,
-0.3192811906337738,
-0.09709878265857697,
-0.3750104010105133,
1.079296350479126,
0.3506072461605072,
-0.2901768386363983,
-0.13237953186035156,
-0.9250097274780273,
-0.35288098454475403,
0.19365867972373962,
-0.26324698328971863,
-0.5386757850646973,
-0.01459767110645771,
0.44409897923469543,
0.5994435548782349,
0.21205240488052368,
-0.48898106813430786,
0.18337176740169525,
0.43043428659439087,
0.3349393606185913,
0.8168469071388245,
-0.056028299033641815,
0.5318474769592285,
-0.27607303857803345,
0.4593961536884308,
0.296588659286499,
0.3779789209365845,
-0.2417898029088974,
-0.37458181381225586,
-0.5702651739120483,
-0.23187166452407837,
0.35356053709983826,
0.42479389905929565,
-1.3156055212020874,
-0.03153441473841667,
-0.46860936284065247,
-0.5528310537338257,
-0.3618631958961487,
-0.20734211802482605,
-0.3327908515930176,
0.23931282758712769,
0.1952292025089264,
-0.9787611365318298,
-0.7106127142906189,
-0.6112346053123474,
0.11597062647342682,
-0.12073705345392227,
0.015430496074259281,
0.1493653953075409,
0.5981459617614746,
0.029811860993504524,
0.9600383639335632,
-0.2811847925186157,
-0.15306203067302704,
0.05348300561308861,
0.10474666953086853,
-0.02200279012322426,
0.5247663259506226,
0.500533938407898,
-0.9596176147460938,
-0.5283596515655518,
0.05054207146167755,
-0.9915172457695007,
-0.009255110286176205,
-0.23118910193443298,
-0.3189494013786316,
0.034630417823791504,
0.29704007506370544,
-0.14345218241214752,
0.26918432116508484,
0.8253344297409058,
-0.17238523066043854,
0.40060701966285706,
-0.09364581108093262,
0.4989587366580963,
-1.0489025115966797,
-0.06569208204746246,
0.06628600507974625,
-0.2345268875360489,
-0.6336007714271545,
0.036454182118177414,
0.24700358510017395,
-0.21169671416282654,
-0.4586063623428345,
0.38923653960227966,
-0.618174135684967,
-0.33777353167533875,
-0.12235644459724426,
0.272083044052124,
0.20300626754760742,
0.2557433843612671,
0.40088117122650146,
0.43006423115730286,
0.39275848865509033,
-0.370567262172699,
0.2864668369293213,
0.3943527638912201,
-0.6585710048675537,
1.1298805475234985,
-0.11437353491783142,
0.22074131667613983,
0.1153435930609703,
0.7610312700271606,
-0.9584149122238159,
-0.3058635890483856,
0.34559816122055054,
0.032258376479148865,
-0.26096025109291077,
-0.4356645345687866,
-0.26415327191352844,
-0.3374005854129791,
-0.06134799122810364,
0.8604336977005005,
0.4644976854324341,
-0.657106876373291,
0.9055220484733582,
0.5077393054962158,
-0.3061152696609497,
-0.25134673714637756,
-0.39095425605773926,
0.2587815523147583,
-0.4633418917655945,
-0.7204631567001343,
0.12882575392723083,
-0.23701852560043335,
-0.32002273201942444,
-0.47303473949432373,
0.018077228218317032,
-0.2131720930337906,
0.2946842908859253,
0.3755444884300232,
0.17349009215831757,
-0.06561524420976639,
-0.008868589997291565,
-0.2925183176994324,
0.0592968575656414,
-0.12776166200637817,
-0.4536912143230438,
0.4363957643508911,
-0.012478339485824108,
-0.5477219820022583,
-0.16634470224380493,
0.2140372395515442,
0.9909442663192749,
-0.47954562306404114,
0.12631544470787048,
0.9700697064399719,
-0.38485610485076904,
0.1496320515871048,
-0.5188667178153992,
0.07264621555805206,
-0.39999380707740784,
0.26234790682792664,
-0.5202652812004089,
-0.31034401059150696,
0.902528703212738,
-0.46626272797584534,
0.1081521213054657,
0.3615969121456146,
0.5535835027694702,
0.2151734083890915,
0.8498478531837463,
0.6897149682044983,
0.051942646503448486,
0.0957694724202156,
-0.30300626158714294,
-0.05772867426276207,
-0.9117233157157898,
-0.3260989785194397,
-0.3444088399410248,
-0.5045825839042664,
-0.824112057685852,
-0.6555722951889038,
0.7298808693885803,
-0.3828735947608948,
0.09950051456689835,
-0.06911962479352951,
-0.22776314616203308,
0.5214424729347229,
0.31211939454078674,
0.24918174743652344,
0.7328388094902039,
-0.11287995427846909,
0.2929275333881378,
-0.017660638317465782,
-0.6199982166290283,
-0.43209415674209595,
1.0337668657302856,
0.3753259479999542,
0.58153235912323,
0.07415562123060226,
0.5606774091720581,
0.3806634545326233,
0.2308342456817627,
-0.6782009601593018,
0.30984464287757874,
-0.33935457468032837,
-0.6583835482597351,
-0.08937298506498337,
0.20944669842720032,
-0.7055730819702148,
0.5086844563484192,
-0.40874236822128296,
-0.4233861267566681,
0.8744237422943115,
-0.229178786277771,
-0.6164695620536804,
0.37938743829727173,
-0.4594566524028778,
0.637408971786499,
-0.23903615772724152,
-0.3927842676639557,
-0.055421750992536545,
-0.819388747215271,
0.398833692073822,
-0.34105876088142395,
0.8639758229255676,
-0.23178081214427948,
0.10073476284742355,
0.47979670763015747,
0.25758475065231323,
0.8310501575469971,
-0.21524402499198914,
-0.3765486478805542,
0.2895398437976837,
0.4026026129722595,
0.2685942053794861,
-0.09317833185195923,
-0.12132056057453156,
0.6111089587211609,
0.20701876282691956,
-0.5549957752227783,
-0.19336307048797607,
0.586123526096344,
-0.7818856835365295,
-0.46825888752937317,
-0.15651442110538483,
-1.0479742288589478,
-0.03445928171277046,
0.02742619253695011,
0.010699408128857613,
0.6868108510971069,
-0.27404212951660156,
0.06644941866397858,
0.18603572249412537,
-0.2513582408428192,
0.45388612151145935,
0.32741013169288635,
-0.007610217668116093,
-0.4027649164199829,
0.7844672203063965,
0.17263393104076385,
0.24693329632282257,
-0.3914881646633148,
-0.24420325458049774,
0.05395222827792168,
-0.5437660813331604,
-0.8456793427467346,
-0.1016080304980278,
-1.1788238286972046,
0.07906419783830643,
-0.31541821360588074,
0.19827936589717865,
-0.18102777004241943,
-0.3347429931163788,
-0.10707787424325943,
-0.417791485786438,
0.11810996383428574,
0.23818489909172058,
0.176076278090477,
1.016715168952942,
-0.5051164627075195,
0.14134399592876434,
-0.8363994359970093,
0.0715712234377861,
0.23423896729946136,
0.06099314242601395,
0.05075651407241821,
-0.3475498557090759,
-0.5349321365356445,
-0.009829027578234673,
-0.32184165716171265,
-0.6326621174812317,
0.21460574865341187,
-0.02497544139623642,
0.30520665645599365,
0.352973073720932,
0.32567915320396423,
0.894195020198822,
-0.5136452913284302,
1.0926508903503418,
-0.012584485113620758,
-0.8536800742149353,
-0.005527284927666187,
-0.31610769033432007,
0.6437851190567017,
0.5532142519950867,
0.6128069162368774,
-0.8252074122428894,
-0.18127387762069702,
-0.3635043799877167,
-0.8734468817710876,
0.5940704941749573,
-0.21643343567848206,
-0.14859835803508759,
0.08942291140556335,
-0.058000046759843826,
0.5867692828178406,
-0.17218288779258728,
-0.686491072177887,
0.1621583253145218,
-0.2343721240758896,
-0.2615041732788086,
-0.060300253331661224,
0.0640297681093216,
-0.4849042296409607,
-0.06313512474298477,
0.408648282289505,
-0.2101362645626068,
-0.24717041850090027,
0.4122121334075928,
-0.6829599142074585,
-0.19327010214328766,
-0.07774004340171814,
0.47615596652030945,
1.1106717586517334,
-0.03755231201648712,
0.12017707526683807,
0.4740394055843353,
-0.6363199949264526,
0.21164435148239136,
-0.011722655966877937,
0.07216940075159073,
-0.11483360081911087,
0.5264070630073547,
0.4446428716182709,
-0.09048131853342056,
-0.34863635897636414,
0.22424298524856567,
-0.2292245328426361,
-0.07200410962104797,
-0.5351943969726562,
-0.4806332290172577,
-0.18239520490169525,
0.7871739864349365,
0.6427594423294067,
-0.06478402018547058,
0.300600528717041,
-0.5848186612129211,
0.03795429691672325,
0.14909343421459198,
-0.4342217743396759,
-0.40212059020996094,
0.4908694922924042,
0.6720239520072937,
0.16232182085514069,
0.6528788805007935,
0.042140793055295944,
-0.5431721210479736,
0.6576001644134521,
0.16149844229221344,
0.6610415577888489,
-0.24551501870155334,
0.26678529381752014,
0.3693300783634186,
0.4067094326019287,
-0.07588809728622437,
0.02714579552412033,
0.046951018273830414,
-0.7101253271102905,
-0.4030260145664215,
-0.38993197679519653,
-0.32966962456703186,
-0.18877370655536652,
-0.5711350440979004,
0.2901135981082916,
-0.12232640385627747,
-0.11234775930643082,
-0.45609214901924133,
-0.1537531465291977,
-0.8547260761260986,
0.293697714805603,
0.48023971915245056,
0.9956849813461304,
-1.4173486232757568,
0.5149098038673401,
0.6328100562095642,
-0.2354615032672882,
-0.3832758069038391,
0.23775264620780945,
0.3762020468711853,
-0.6755838394165039,
0.6380093097686768,
-0.06459200382232666,
-0.029276441782712936,
-0.063819520175457,
-0.3841262459754944,
-1.0086482763290405,
1.58731210231781,
-0.21035762131214142,
-0.41551458835601807,
0.21252577006816864,
0.2199777066707611,
0.29827427864074707,
-0.652596116065979,
0.29817909002304077,
0.8741450905799866,
0.5259260535240173,
0.08791545778512955,
-1.1264268159866333,
0.10145476460456848,
0.021879376843571663,
-0.07650235295295715,
0.04533136263489723,
-0.6342594623565674,
0.946897566318512,
-0.0037185121327638626,
-0.23554107546806335,
0.2545798122882843,
0.31087321043014526,
0.1966489851474762,
0.47045910358428955,
1.0820287466049194,
0.17934884130954742,
0.6409748792648315,
-0.41012290120124817,
0.7829317450523376,
-0.5638571381568909,
0.1787782460451126,
0.7082952260971069,
-0.4502933621406555,
0.502941906452179,
0.4361220896244049,
0.026115870103240013,
0.841231107711792,
1.2305989265441895,
0.20216412842273712,
0.5997859239578247,
-0.12061849236488342,
-0.20557330548763275,
-0.4729357659816742,
-0.31706365942955017,
-0.4300299286842346,
0.9332935810089111,
0.4000698924064636,
-0.06839672476053238,
-0.27506035566329956,
0.2594762444496155,
-0.25486016273498535,
-0.27602261304855347,
-0.4157322943210602,
0.6751793026924133,
0.02647755667567253,
-0.43174463510513306,
0.7974549531936646,
-0.36238276958465576,
0.26644912362098694,
-0.37303221225738525,
-0.17293131351470947,
-0.2770211398601532,
0.03410889953374863,
-0.21981148421764374,
-0.5873013734817505,
-0.005600446835160255,
-0.4259958565235138,
-0.02665743976831436,
0.0365922786295414,
0.7282236814498901,
-0.3983171582221985,
-0.3562336564064026,
0.27156543731689453,
0.5520616173744202,
0.16911517083644867,
0.18084776401519775,
-0.5068599581718445,
0.5319405794143677,
-0.00586702860891819,
0.10666239261627197,
0.21079562604427338,
0.6739577651023865,
-0.4565744996070862,
0.33743706345558167,
0.4968688189983368,
-0.09123269468545914,
-0.21301324665546417,
-0.08195962011814117,
0.4248034954071045,
-0.48194757103919983,
-0.38608652353286743,
-0.5632182955741882,
0.894708514213562,
-0.29258912801742554,
-0.04323606193065643,
0.5736425518989563,
0.28205960988998413,
1.0744190216064453,
-0.24701730906963348,
1.0987690687179565,
-0.25686541199684143,
-0.058808036148548126,
-0.5390192270278931,
0.5185602307319641,
-0.7515917420387268,
-0.0838145837187767,
-0.395041286945343,
-0.9449180364608765,
-0.18582502007484436,
0.23553302884101868,
-0.4125189483165741,
-0.2793886065483093,
0.7641198039054871,
0.49567484855651855,
-0.3411642611026764,
0.17496362328529358,
0.18588031828403473,
0.2642926871776581,
0.14738710224628448,
0.47425147891044617,
0.9255654215812683,
-0.3125814199447632,
0.5560470819473267,
-0.35055026412010193,
-0.37867438793182373,
-0.13492463529109955,
-0.9426340460777283,
-0.354408323764801,
-0.9975638389587402,
-0.14860579371452332,
-0.235031396150589,
-0.0952964499592781,
0.8694732189178467,
0.7618892192840576,
-0.680539608001709,
-0.6640580892562866,
0.8640827536582947,
0.030083583667874336,
-0.3055102825164795,
-0.07505667954683304,
0.357881098985672,
0.1144719049334526,
-0.9843906760215759,
0.2705208659172058,
0.368500292301178,
-0.10337241739034653,
-0.44870737195014954,
0.04684387519955635,
-0.1644574999809265,
-0.20227302610874176,
0.948011040687561,
0.17501476407051086,
-0.615570068359375,
-0.612017810344696,
-0.23932036757469177,
0.2393101304769516,
0.09222761541604996,
0.8250450491905212,
-0.4639579951763153,
0.7291121482849121,
0.4193117320537567,
0.43081697821617126,
0.32243114709854126,
0.14827774465084076,
0.7808739542961121,
-0.48480314016342163,
0.4837881922721863,
-0.2159213125705719,
0.6016762852668762,
0.6485596895217896,
0.02969502843916416,
0.7376571893692017,
0.29645392298698425,
-0.762775719165802,
-0.5134029984474182,
0.46013638377189636,
-0.8626246452331543,
-0.3900817930698395,
1.0299770832061768,
-0.12512946128845215,
-0.25630393624305725,
-0.6264355778694153,
-0.21992595493793488,
0.33374813199043274,
0.06233704835176468,
1.0561414957046509,
0.9124077558517456,
0.12882232666015625,
0.07681770622730255,
-0.8040947318077087,
0.3038724958896637,
0.051122214645147324,
-0.6594140529632568,
-0.0052879066206514835,
0.7755675315856934,
0.30162858963012695,
0.5109301209449768,
0.4121372103691101,
-0.18686550855636597,
0.3336141109466553,
-0.1828300803899765,
0.44594019651412964,
0.3597705066204071,
-0.3152991831302643,
-0.4035066068172455,
0.03171718865633011,
0.1801944226026535,
-0.13921765983104706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02066v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02066v1 | BiasDora: Exploring Hidden Biased Associations in Vision-Language Models | 2024-07-02T08:55:40 | 2024-07-02T08:55:40 | Chahat Raj, Anjishnu Mukherjee, Aylin Caliskan, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Ziwei Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing works examining Vision Language Models (VLMs) for social biases
predominantly focus on a limited set of documented bias associations, such as
gender:profession or race:crime. This narrow scope often overlooks a vast range
of unexamined implicit associations, restricting the identification and, hence,
mitigation of such biases. We address this gap by probing VLMs to (1) uncover
hidden, implicit associations across 9 bias dimensions. We systematically
explore diverse input and output modalities and (2) demonstrate how biased
associations vary in their negativity, toxicity, and extremity. Our work (3)
identifies subtle and extreme biases that are typically not recognized by
existing methodologies. We make the Dataset of retrieved associations, (Dora),
publicly available here https://github.com/chahatraj/BiasDora. | [
-0.40332773327827454,
-0.6632190942764282,
0.6655756235122681,
0.14236530661582947,
0.038597628474235535,
-0.061880506575107574,
0.03651003539562225,
-0.8599519729614258,
0.49456727504730225,
0.6869894862174988,
-0.7002728581428528,
-0.6886025667190552,
-0.8462125062942505,
-0.20100371539592743,
-0.7403801083564758,
1.1322460174560547,
0.15016399323940277,
0.4600053131580353,
-0.13450995087623596,
-0.4460737109184265,
-0.512036919593811,
-0.4361954629421234,
-0.30931356549263,
-0.03219249099493027,
0.5099882483482361,
0.12930361926555634,
0.45733511447906494,
0.40371185541152954,
0.607843816280365,
0.14106608927249908,
-0.3146962523460388,
-0.04093262180685997,
-0.6611655950546265,
0.03694824129343033,
-0.3869767487049103,
-0.4360829293727875,
-0.41651198267936707,
0.32676854729652405,
0.3616620600223541,
0.7409210205078125,
0.22429387271404266,
0.7704330086708069,
0.06888475269079208,
0.8346984386444092,
-1.2027286291122437,
0.2256198525428772,
-0.6754665970802307,
0.3856198787689209,
-0.5318032503128052,
0.1115540936589241,
-0.10822446644306183,
-0.45634886622428894,
0.47102200984954834,
-0.35057416558265686,
0.5647327899932861,
-0.018980640918016434,
0.8140774369239807,
0.38602927327156067,
-0.5109532475471497,
-0.404513418674469,
-0.8057259917259216,
0.8389700651168823,
-0.2125067412853241,
0.14208005368709564,
0.3810379207134247,
0.415059357881546,
0.4203246831893921,
-0.5648542642593384,
-0.40712887048721313,
-0.036416810005903244,
-0.16629129648208618,
0.06259237229824066,
-0.5017192363739014,
-0.20288144052028656,
0.4876331388950348,
0.28307804465293884,
-0.34572914242744446,
-0.25510072708129883,
-0.7129430174827576,
-0.3509742319583893,
0.44785040616989136,
0.3600798547267914,
0.2432011365890503,
0.03207636997103691,
-0.2292950451374054,
0.02790200151503086,
-0.8693059682846069,
0.007179861422628164,
0.7011685967445374,
-0.006846777629107237,
-0.22104313969612122,
0.6118743419647217,
-0.12045572698116302,
0.686000645160675,
-0.01588778756558895,
0.20505963265895844,
0.45332157611846924,
-0.49451830983161926,
-0.24995820224285126,
0.016478540375828743,
0.7679492831230164,
0.4449743628501892,
0.20828808844089508,
0.16973860561847687,
-0.0755944550037384,
0.5659012198448181,
0.2828969359397888,
-0.33469969034194946,
-0.12172728776931763,
-0.047380946576595306,
-0.6776564121246338,
-0.9555051922798157,
-0.15481151640415192,
-1.2358088493347168,
-0.8954057097434998,
-0.12470711022615433,
0.41689369082450867,
-0.013727141544222832,
-0.3458974063396454,
-0.02252628654241562,
-0.41381996870040894,
0.4994162619113922,
0.27410587668418884,
-0.7190640568733215,
0.501117467880249,
0.3906635344028473,
0.6590052843093872,
0.09935804456472397,
-0.2680540978908539,
-0.6913069486618042,
-0.05663038045167923,
-0.5138278007507324,
0.35384348034858704,
-1.006160855293274,
-0.27555033564567566,
0.31503233313560486,
-0.1167198121547699,
0.15496303141117096,
-0.669617772102356,
0.7695287466049194,
-0.3273591101169586,
0.3126145005226135,
-0.6577019691467285,
0.022264672443270683,
-0.12678535282611847,
0.1095481589436531,
-0.6890057325363159,
1.185434341430664,
-0.06283461302518845,
-0.960784912109375,
0.6481112837791443,
-0.46688371896743774,
-0.20767194032669067,
-0.3857089877128601,
-0.386559396982193,
-0.3225753605365753,
0.3993370831012726,
0.3506435751914978,
0.29089733958244324,
-0.21623745560646057,
0.3096086084842682,
-0.6736900210380554,
-0.24761204421520233,
0.07876387983560562,
-0.41568130254745483,
1.0829071998596191,
-0.02709110453724861,
-0.5750129818916321,
0.3966817259788513,
-0.8117908835411072,
-0.6278822422027588,
0.21049155294895172,
0.11491695791482925,
-0.783009946346283,
0.020218025892972946,
0.17622728645801544,
0.18874506652355194,
0.3358762264251709,
-0.5272999405860901,
0.14060896635055542,
0.040382545441389084,
0.034215983003377914,
0.9896461367607117,
-0.4810941219329834,
0.543491542339325,
0.08736647665500641,
0.45368874073028564,
0.3494470715522766,
0.7133938670158386,
0.13954736292362213,
-0.49952661991119385,
-1.1533560752868652,
-0.1268591284751892,
0.02598092518746853,
0.28007978200912476,
-0.5391595363616943,
-0.24331189692020416,
0.06394538283348083,
-0.36390119791030884,
-0.963526725769043,
0.17748306691646576,
0.7328894138336182,
0.6630315780639648,
0.30963173508644104,
-0.6411649584770203,
-0.7124847173690796,
-1.3008278608322144,
-0.3320215344429016,
0.06456471234560013,
0.06087420880794525,
0.5104530453681946,
0.607860803604126,
-0.4834313988685608,
0.8333137035369873,
-0.5485230684280396,
-0.9496610760688782,
-0.1080276221036911,
-0.015984492376446724,
0.2089393138885498,
-0.02310137264430523,
1.0007768869400024,
-0.7287279963493347,
-0.4308163821697235,
-0.34870463609695435,
-0.8082712292671204,
-0.3386436104774475,
0.350327730178833,
-0.3083871006965637,
-0.045199524611234665,
0.35810524225234985,
-0.2722114622592926,
0.7342721819877625,
0.7954116463661194,
-0.5498376488685608,
0.5226043462753296,
0.0700683742761612,
-0.2658035457134247,
-0.6380472779273987,
0.034519538283348083,
0.32640478014945984,
-0.1290520280599594,
-0.7067909240722656,
0.012884481810033321,
0.1591375172138214,
0.14159637689590454,
-0.5467362999916077,
0.4362064301967621,
-0.7600476145744324,
-0.4672779142856598,
0.007242049090564251,
0.1276979148387909,
-0.0730043351650238,
0.434434175491333,
0.28899991512298584,
0.644473671913147,
1.1134597063064575,
-0.5192288756370544,
0.014252843335270882,
0.09464941173791885,
-0.2218046933412552,
0.5072409510612488,
-0.6628826260566711,
0.03788723796606064,
-0.3814941644668579,
-0.11250461637973785,
-0.4832979738712311,
0.00041605415754020214,
0.5130268335342407,
-0.2382686287164688,
0.025105081498622894,
-0.3772561848163605,
-0.011119143106043339,
-0.23093678057193756,
-0.6477408409118652,
0.5049241781234741,
0.45066165924072266,
-0.4669109284877777,
0.707892119884491,
0.9281390905380249,
0.2982213497161865,
-1.0224462747573853,
-0.3692011833190918,
0.020544622093439102,
-0.32418355345726013,
-0.3536331355571747,
0.06483250856399536,
-0.0031665207352489233,
-0.7492287755012512,
-0.12099505960941315,
0.047174662351608276,
0.02964762970805168,
-0.10056320577859879,
0.4970865249633789,
0.27943384647369385,
-0.1890648454427719,
-0.2128838300704956,
-0.07257848232984543,
0.14881572127342224,
0.13819701969623566,
-0.042086780071258545,
0.6646541953086853,
-0.21270060539245605,
-0.18868958950042725,
0.12919136881828308,
0.35735395550727844,
0.8139641880989075,
-0.6339846253395081,
0.7785601615905762,
0.8501551747322083,
-0.2923077940940857,
-0.133400559425354,
-0.49912428855895996,
-0.016080010682344437,
-0.4302491843700409,
0.3166925609111786,
-0.17036248743534088,
-0.7327275276184082,
0.7131664156913757,
0.4234676957130432,
-0.15275193750858307,
0.2688305377960205,
0.6592292189598083,
0.3075535297393799,
1.0234453678131104,
1.058566689491272,
-0.4999890923500061,
0.6101124286651611,
-0.2701176404953003,
0.06256161630153656,
-1.1270495653152466,
-0.22115787863731384,
-0.4130275845527649,
0.056561361998319626,
-0.5942205786705017,
-0.5852624177932739,
0.5110849738121033,
-0.3989187777042389,
0.12756046652793884,
-0.08699639141559601,
-0.4384661316871643,
0.4727615714073181,
0.8544240593910217,
0.08268054574728012,
0.06807082146406174,
-0.2539616823196411,
0.08003009855747223,
-0.1020338162779808,
-0.47240784764289856,
-0.5394373536109924,
1.516945242881775,
0.581614077091217,
0.6643167734146118,
0.23388038575649261,
0.6092161536216736,
0.40795260667800903,
0.46233639121055603,
-0.6184018850326538,
0.5085399150848389,
0.1172664687037468,
-0.9586555361747742,
-0.1490415781736374,
-0.08606860041618347,
-0.7235802412033081,
0.3692373037338257,
-0.3110906481742859,
-0.7791219353675842,
0.4864285886287689,
0.427607923746109,
-0.03274201974272728,
0.036822013556957245,
-0.5656192898750305,
0.7814239263534546,
-0.02025594189763069,
-0.9186363816261292,
0.017598537728190422,
-0.6329115033149719,
0.8285152316093445,
-0.04318326711654663,
0.40496423840522766,
-0.18751245737075806,
0.19350896775722504,
0.8016819357872009,
-0.1932017207145691,
1.1742141246795654,
-0.0929083600640297,
-0.11488749086856842,
0.08218808472156525,
0.1622459441423416,
0.525797963142395,
-0.047065649181604385,
0.3542678654193878,
0.41233235597610474,
-0.10111435502767563,
-0.46476006507873535,
-0.23961174488067627,
0.7149885296821594,
-0.7842535972595215,
-0.5029819011688232,
-0.7156492471694946,
-0.4569990932941437,
-0.22819311916828156,
0.2984221577644348,
-0.011816813610494137,
0.5965133309364319,
-0.4186590611934662,
-0.2573179006576538,
1.0278934240341187,
-0.34391629695892334,
0.2673158347606659,
0.8139338493347168,
-0.5308440923690796,
0.034505538642406464,
0.7559546828269958,
-0.056273866444826126,
0.032748281955718994,
0.21146950125694275,
0.15226632356643677,
-0.09393783658742905,
-0.4580616056919098,
-0.22691437602043152,
0.26196619868278503,
-0.5860084295272827,
0.2852325737476349,
-0.7336997985839844,
0.07136639952659607,
-0.6698875427246094,
0.12646809220314026,
-0.3509494364261627,
-0.1400182843208313,
-0.3718728721141815,
-0.17064543068408966,
0.14553411304950714,
1.1273008584976196,
-0.01159991417080164,
-0.02821948751807213,
-0.34673312306404114,
0.36079126596450806,
0.47486141324043274,
0.2596389949321747,
-0.012226732447743416,
-0.1086592823266983,
-0.013349775224924088,
-0.12905004620552063,
-0.16503974795341492,
-1.2586545944213867,
0.7039260268211365,
-0.1504739671945572,
0.45321518182754517,
0.7845457196235657,
-0.16488343477249146,
0.5417726039886475,
-0.6337540745735168,
0.805306077003479,
0.18952296674251556,
-1.0298244953155518,
0.6864739656448364,
-0.5201608538627625,
-0.19723597168922424,
0.3199480473995209,
0.3643414080142975,
-0.3113533854484558,
-0.4856114685535431,
-0.46496474742889404,
-0.8049653768539429,
0.5308391451835632,
0.258694052696228,
0.17571991682052612,
0.10378409177064896,
-0.14844316244125366,
0.06847807765007019,
0.3517562448978424,
-0.8784452676773071,
-0.5759609341621399,
-0.10668875277042389,
-0.22054654359817505,
-0.11871114373207092,
-0.7192710638046265,
-0.45424461364746094,
-0.2196040153503418,
0.45719122886657715,
-0.17100942134857178,
0.13777953386306763,
0.0937785804271698,
-0.3292866051197052,
-0.15191709995269775,
0.025349028408527374,
0.8325366973876953,
0.7264692783355713,
-0.36392244696617126,
0.45606863498687744,
0.05668547749519348,
-0.9227662682533264,
-0.23441322147846222,
-0.19360235333442688,
-0.4015488028526306,
0.15592776238918304,
0.5024217963218689,
0.840130090713501,
-0.0728515237569809,
-0.6676093935966492,
0.7844024300575256,
-0.24865734577178955,
0.03391033783555031,
-0.6994461417198181,
0.13626113533973694,
-0.2502237558364868,
0.4163420498371124,
0.36583173274993896,
0.22480382025241852,
0.578518271446228,
-0.7954664826393127,
-0.15845166146755219,
0.70984947681427,
-1.1809844970703125,
-0.36227697134017944,
0.8213223218917847,
0.20018649101257324,
-0.02537345699965954,
0.21930602192878723,
0.14749030768871307,
-0.5826333165168762,
0.541989266872406,
0.005007042083889246,
0.7868844270706177,
0.18071776628494263,
0.3739302456378937,
0.10345225036144257,
0.7995540499687195,
0.26774582266807556,
0.2063160240650177,
-0.04301175847649574,
-0.8854701519012451,
0.06990104913711548,
-0.7720252275466919,
-0.18840749561786652,
0.37677451968193054,
-0.947521448135376,
0.19785138964653015,
-0.2092912346124649,
-0.2225104570388794,
0.04329770803451538,
-0.20740871131420135,
-0.9332089424133301,
0.013050508685410023,
0.1896185725927353,
0.9066591262817383,
-1.3542838096618652,
0.6914992332458496,
0.46877777576446533,
-0.6799414753913879,
-0.3768406808376312,
0.05614994838833809,
0.36072754859924316,
-1.0317937135696411,
1.0209113359451294,
-0.05617431178689003,
-0.23373806476593018,
-0.4113394021987915,
-0.6511015295982361,
-0.9595917463302612,
0.9140274524688721,
0.060319557785987854,
-0.5849809050559998,
-0.006940979044884443,
0.05496617406606674,
0.6662717461585999,
-0.3967302441596985,
0.3692534565925598,
0.640291690826416,
0.3040096163749695,
-0.2900548279285431,
-0.9171963930130005,
-0.019539594650268555,
-0.3318791389465332,
0.092873215675354,
0.054460249841213226,
-0.554314136505127,
0.8449679613113403,
-0.2509901225566864,
0.05643617734313011,
-0.31736883521080017,
0.483553946018219,
0.1592518538236618,
0.5391289591789246,
0.11773759871721268,
0.4746018648147583,
0.7293077111244202,
0.059260912239551544,
1.092613697052002,
-0.1378961205482483,
0.30776718258857727,
1.118492603302002,
-0.5351284146308899,
0.3987205922603607,
0.8225361108779907,
-0.1354094296693802,
0.328325480222702,
0.4273776710033417,
0.2086278647184372,
0.6596885323524475,
-0.0003471602394711226,
-0.2584170699119568,
-0.01097849290817976,
-0.38457828760147095,
-0.33399471640586853,
0.37336787581443787,
0.35505950450897217,
-0.8795444965362549,
0.012312107719480991,
-0.11791054159402847,
0.0041861883364617825,
-0.18729323148727417,
-0.5746964812278748,
0.5376381874084473,
-0.07454023510217667,
-0.34586459398269653,
0.10612161457538605,
-0.31826603412628174,
0.8710927367210388,
-0.49507802724838257,
-0.19822774827480316,
-0.31649816036224365,
0.2667013704776764,
-0.07951990514993668,
-0.7240729331970215,
0.17109374701976776,
0.07668204605579376,
-0.45680123567581177,
-0.21169611811637878,
1.0065836906433105,
-0.2522358000278473,
-0.5826540589332581,
0.5152767896652222,
0.5145057439804077,
0.018674753606319427,
0.1033414974808693,
-0.4698817729949951,
0.28109848499298096,
0.08975016325712204,
-0.08972824364900589,
0.4581567347049713,
0.2069820761680603,
-0.290571928024292,
0.7173279523849487,
0.5691763758659363,
0.40105175971984863,
0.5391916632652283,
0.254665344953537,
0.8823131918907166,
-0.41572725772857666,
-0.1226494088768959,
-0.770374059677124,
0.32369130849838257,
-0.314513623714447,
-0.5367986559867859,
1.1018189191818237,
0.5863412022590637,
0.9776079058647156,
-0.3782854378223419,
0.8051546216011047,
0.1645035743713379,
0.44135403633117676,
-0.495286226272583,
0.6506481766700745,
-0.4889470040798187,
0.30344417691230774,
-0.8127323389053345,
-0.7472952008247375,
-0.1531708836555481,
0.6530724763870239,
-0.6039458513259888,
-0.16456998884677887,
0.34162941575050354,
0.991158127784729,
-0.26027393341064453,
-0.25187963247299194,
0.4910902678966522,
0.2516438364982605,
0.1171518862247467,
0.37084686756134033,
1.0730209350585938,
-0.28176337480545044,
0.27240198850631714,
-0.16017794609069824,
-0.3757146894931793,
-0.38844823837280273,
-0.7096189260482788,
-1.1770250797271729,
-0.5698091387748718,
-0.18978852033615112,
-0.41264328360557556,
0.04835473373532295,
0.449894517660141,
0.6029324531555176,
-0.6768019199371338,
-0.2169114351272583,
0.11776715517044067,
0.3279912769794464,
-0.050358012318611145,
-0.2730100452899933,
0.1447361707687378,
0.09199012815952301,
-0.7678287625312805,
-0.07454866915941238,
0.2591165006160736,
-0.024783140048384666,
-0.9536219239234924,
-0.01192383375018835,
0.1016886755824089,
0.34355250000953674,
0.7643071413040161,
-0.012327874079346657,
-0.6139687895774841,
-0.15204168856143951,
0.022462021559476852,
-0.008061116561293602,
-0.18014678359031677,
0.8815054297447205,
-0.9109417200088501,
0.46410343050956726,
0.4519719183444977,
-0.10236754268407822,
0.6230900287628174,
-0.6053465008735657,
0.5651441812515259,
-0.6974625587463379,
0.23053231835365295,
0.1327507197856903,
0.5813084244728088,
0.21767573058605194,
-0.2196265608072281,
0.560854971408844,
0.2869522273540497,
-0.0029444119427353144,
-0.9995253682136536,
0.5018854737281799,
-0.7690423130989075,
-0.1796254813671112,
1.279984951019287,
0.30881398916244507,
-0.49949708580970764,
-0.08116506040096283,
-0.5124266743659973,
-0.013541935943067074,
-0.24710063636302948,
0.9189389944076538,
0.3928598463535309,
0.041317619383335114,
-0.18308605253696442,
-0.8187441825866699,
0.8556511402130127,
0.16018196940422058,
-0.4956153333187103,
-0.04060928151011467,
0.8185632228851318,
0.5354160666465759,
0.3905436396598816,
0.8210681080818176,
-0.3233143389225006,
0.19285807013511658,
-0.04221917316317558,
-0.04110344126820564,
0.16667121648788452,
-0.611806333065033,
-0.38666659593582153,
0.23018036782741547,
-0.17296701669692993,
-0.2124188393354416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02062v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02062v1 | Are Data Augmentation Methods in Named Entity Recognition Applicable for Uncertainty Estimation? | 2024-07-02T08:49:43 | 2024-07-02T08:49:43 | Wataru Hashimoto, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This work investigates the impact of data augmentation on confidence
calibration and uncertainty estimation in Named Entity Recognition (NER) tasks.
For the future advance of NER in safety-critical fields like healthcare and
finance, it is essential to achieve accurate predictions with calibrated
confidence when applying Deep Neural Networks (DNNs), including Pre-trained
Language Models (PLMs), as a real-world application. However, DNNs are prone to
miscalibration, which limits their applicability. Moreover, existing methods
for calibration and uncertainty estimation are computational expensive. Our
investigation in NER found that data augmentation improves calibration and
uncertainty in cross-genre and cross-lingual setting, especially in-domain
setting. Furthermore, we showed that the calibration for NER tends to be more
effective when the perplexity of the sentences generated by data augmentation
is lower, and that increasing the size of the augmentation further improves
calibration and uncertainty. | [
-0.16869230568408966,
-0.32466888427734375,
0.583202064037323,
-0.034898120909929276,
-0.14899468421936035,
0.24343284964561462,
-0.21593573689460754,
-0.737493097782135,
0.12471188604831696,
0.36191853880882263,
-0.3372529149055481,
-0.2850474417209625,
-0.6097437739372253,
0.3134308159351349,
-0.2016819417476654,
0.617466926574707,
-0.06755497306585312,
0.4022802710533142,
-0.2813483774662018,
0.2143697440624237,
-0.4531978368759155,
-0.5419754981994629,
-0.6618527770042419,
-0.2466629296541214,
0.510402262210846,
0.15881282091140747,
0.7205157279968262,
0.4042104482650757,
0.7211658954620361,
0.3009953498840332,
0.06241508200764656,
0.3509370684623718,
-0.12497081607580185,
0.14227862656116486,
-0.11666542291641235,
-0.5708267092704773,
-0.338670939207077,
-0.14949391782283783,
0.874045193195343,
0.8900765180587769,
-0.034356750547885895,
-0.24203450977802277,
-0.016309985890984535,
0.6715131998062134,
-0.6422679424285889,
0.14054997265338898,
-0.6245453953742981,
0.08088909089565277,
-0.052660223096609116,
-0.25201210379600525,
-0.05957126244902611,
-0.42467495799064636,
0.5368634462356567,
-0.8955411911010742,
-0.09840231388807297,
0.1643974781036377,
0.920384407043457,
0.6510011553764343,
-0.29708290100097656,
-0.3742784857749939,
-0.9514434337615967,
0.8171588778495789,
-0.8095638155937195,
0.5834696292877197,
0.42539340257644653,
0.28327009081840515,
-0.3837224543094635,
-0.6810969114303589,
-0.7804549932479858,
0.05206766352057457,
-0.0342080183327198,
-0.02078310213983059,
-0.11510855704545975,
0.36337462067604065,
0.46187618374824524,
0.5912126302719116,
-0.04276050627231598,
0.3378129005432129,
-0.24246126413345337,
-0.4263189733028412,
0.8116872310638428,
-0.07966705411672592,
0.15771432220935822,
-0.1002536416053772,
-0.38875800371170044,
-0.20616422593593597,
-0.6115583181381226,
0.11247818171977997,
0.5856912732124329,
0.24749064445495605,
0.04327792674303055,
0.3982278108596802,
-0.3168516159057617,
0.7195752859115601,
0.18186143040657043,
-0.44382140040397644,
0.5282160043716431,
-0.2635692059993744,
-0.40110746026039124,
0.3760513365268707,
0.5265668034553528,
0.23626676201820374,
0.39198037981987,
-0.2564631700515747,
-0.205867201089859,
-0.22123119235038757,
0.16706296801567078,
-0.5932725071907043,
-0.32114943861961365,
0.19171342253684998,
0.16646449267864227,
-0.2660141885280609,
0.24465955793857574,
-0.7574059367179871,
-0.5968554615974426,
-0.47096115350723267,
0.4865499436855316,
-0.5126045942306519,
-0.10380419343709946,
0.09947604686021805,
0.12314791977405548,
0.21794363856315613,
0.5149391889572144,
-0.4157833755016327,
0.19384299218654633,
0.6683202981948853,
0.27181413769721985,
0.048138491809368134,
-0.011278526857495308,
-0.47046366333961487,
-0.026390908285975456,
-0.44246941804885864,
0.35878708958625793,
-0.53362637758255,
-0.23782309889793396,
-0.368547260761261,
-0.02836894802749157,
-0.3259144425392151,
-0.37894025444984436,
0.5941592454910278,
-0.7237219214439392,
-0.00915143359452486,
0.011394187808036804,
-0.8609457015991211,
-0.3388630747795105,
0.1658269762992859,
-0.9085755944252014,
0.8424960374832153,
-0.004937076475471258,
-0.8744155764579773,
0.7990570068359375,
-0.21470840275287628,
-0.45042404532432556,
0.19073539972305298,
-0.3299539387226105,
-0.5288002490997314,
0.17014151811599731,
0.44650521874427795,
0.37283948063850403,
-0.1837984323501587,
0.41189178824424744,
-0.20664793252944946,
-0.4171432852745056,
0.7777646780014038,
-0.7743380665779114,
0.3140122592449188,
-0.07754158228635788,
-0.2021894007921219,
-0.35512977838516235,
-0.8311086297035217,
0.31046631932258606,
-0.3566785454750061,
-0.2225334197282791,
-0.48743435740470886,
-0.12784886360168457,
-0.16791266202926636,
0.05670108646154404,
0.1452217400074005,
-0.6404641270637512,
-0.20159688591957092,
-0.8065956830978394,
0.04077521339058876,
0.43822237849235535,
0.24241068959236145,
0.49975907802581787,
-0.12875275313854218,
0.5177468061447144,
0.1724015772342682,
-0.23088273406028748,
0.12317945808172226,
-0.4380769431591034,
-0.6365879774093628,
-0.11742918938398361,
1.164038896560669,
0.7206124663352966,
-0.8645656108856201,
0.46947893500328064,
-0.5199602246284485,
-0.4730580449104309,
-0.5321364402770996,
-0.21030360460281372,
0.11439844965934753,
0.7735140919685364,
0.297920823097229,
-0.05431876704096794,
-0.8709569573402405,
-0.6700164079666138,
-0.20413535833358765,
-0.17079536616802216,
-0.058661531656980515,
0.511100709438324,
0.36139556765556335,
-0.11179014295339584,
0.9177091717720032,
-0.2307656705379486,
-0.05648098513484001,
0.14341962337493896,
0.1231388971209526,
0.02034466341137886,
0.6741337776184082,
0.21945911645889282,
-1.1644446849822998,
-0.2719380855560303,
-0.16432538628578186,
-0.4247330129146576,
0.2957376539707184,
-0.3432704210281372,
0.19967542588710785,
0.01752519980072975,
0.02338043414056301,
-0.328998863697052,
0.7513619065284729,
0.39113420248031616,
0.2682182192802429,
0.32126036286354065,
-0.3747633099555969,
0.3266609311103821,
-1.2240718603134155,
-0.2340058833360672,
0.2000674605369568,
-0.3134717047214508,
-0.779323399066925,
-0.2680988907814026,
0.24217016994953156,
0.25894737243652344,
-0.3033265173435211,
0.35191088914871216,
-0.7396544814109802,
-0.06413830071687698,
-0.1589849293231964,
0.05344042181968689,
0.21688403189182281,
-0.2458060085773468,
0.3765692114830017,
0.9174726009368896,
0.954310953617096,
-0.7447174787521362,
0.3152207136154175,
0.035192783921957016,
-0.657377302646637,
0.5786214470863342,
-0.3622704744338989,
-0.06921213865280151,
-0.10420769453048706,
0.1645825356245041,
-0.6378628015518188,
-0.3928453028202057,
0.33873024582862854,
-0.5471251010894775,
0.7881168723106384,
0.004579512868076563,
-0.2272714227437973,
-0.3485395610332489,
0.03276176378130913,
0.5124838352203369,
0.24098263680934906,
-0.3583211600780487,
0.6054508686065674,
0.5813885927200317,
-0.05949815362691879,
-0.8375259041786194,
-1.1799898147583008,
0.29946473240852356,
-0.3456668555736542,
-0.2868613004684448,
0.617340087890625,
0.04099397733807564,
-0.16113317012786865,
-0.2316678762435913,
-0.3870919346809387,
-0.37520772218704224,
0.07265268266201019,
0.48085764050483704,
0.3396017849445343,
-0.055766478180885315,
0.49087637662887573,
0.15181276202201843,
-0.07151632755994797,
0.04093560948967934,
-0.05119726434350014,
0.05879942700266838,
0.06499787420034409,
-0.4148580729961395,
-0.5154709815979004,
-0.08334407210350037,
0.08722233772277832,
-0.06338874995708466,
0.6810529232025146,
0.6214761137962341,
-0.8780415058135986,
0.07597742974758148,
-0.798374354839325,
-0.14277173578739166,
-0.42868557572364807,
0.20869246125221252,
-0.4568430483341217,
-0.889888346195221,
0.482844740152359,
-0.18756501376628876,
-0.5205239653587341,
0.48106649518013,
-0.0008565604221075773,
-0.10102658718824387,
0.6866831183433533,
0.48154279589653015,
-0.08249232172966003,
0.2574160397052765,
-0.06826506555080414,
0.4683659076690674,
-1.1510509252548218,
-0.2619427740573883,
-0.23329903185367584,
-0.4447115659713745,
-0.7653831839561462,
-0.6081321239471436,
0.211030974984169,
-0.04324870929121971,
0.20596346259117126,
0.3000069260597229,
-0.43246859312057495,
0.2029135674238205,
0.3927146792411804,
0.2662324905395508,
0.16213729977607727,
0.10850284993648529,
0.09981244057416916,
-0.4917186200618744,
-0.37828704714775085,
-0.36211615800857544,
1.1227654218673706,
0.5146359801292419,
0.8016585111618042,
-0.22590334713459015,
0.8998611569404602,
0.015636354684829712,
0.0849493071436882,
-0.7975737452507019,
0.290357381105423,
0.108240507543087,
-0.45364582538604736,
-0.42367011308670044,
-0.7506418228149414,
-0.7764735817909241,
-0.2694990634918213,
-0.3150797188282013,
-0.9233047366142273,
0.9293384552001953,
-0.02469828724861145,
-0.9230773448944092,
0.24320551753044128,
-0.4440368413925171,
0.3298402428627014,
-0.3109055161476135,
0.12811879813671112,
0.2436225414276123,
-0.6670202612876892,
0.02830863930284977,
-0.37776145339012146,
0.057351209223270416,
-0.06789267808198929,
-0.3467053771018982,
0.666229784488678,
-0.360730916261673,
0.590502917766571,
-0.04903177171945572,
-0.06949856877326965,
0.2936396300792694,
-0.3554355502128601,
0.7023895978927612,
0.456382691860199,
-0.6190354824066162,
0.3457123339176178,
-0.20146209001541138,
0.1898721158504486,
-0.7226461172103882,
0.8641760349273682,
-0.3910468816757202,
-0.5180121064186096,
-0.6355413794517517,
-0.9077205657958984,
-0.3405645787715912,
0.043855056166648865,
0.20482657849788666,
0.3975010812282562,
0.04369811713695526,
0.25493112206459045,
0.7280184626579285,
-0.07641716301441193,
0.472343385219574,
0.29730480909347534,
0.2975820302963257,
-0.6443564295768738,
0.7895843386650085,
0.4902002215385437,
0.109980508685112,
0.6454110145568848,
-0.21960477530956268,
-0.3474928140640259,
-0.8178719282150269,
-0.5356154441833496,
-0.13812609016895294,
-0.4367605149745941,
-0.448032408952713,
-0.6564777493476868,
-0.4267783463001251,
-0.5665601491928101,
0.1222836822271347,
-0.1191343441605568,
-0.6876283288002014,
-0.5656483769416809,
-0.3096001148223877,
0.6137767434120178,
0.2936367988586426,
-0.07162365317344666,
0.3490874469280243,
-0.6299483776092529,
-0.03160921856760979,
0.08888353407382965,
0.4822883903980255,
-0.5117541551589966,
-0.45718416571617126,
-0.20045244693756104,
0.5481020212173462,
0.3928089737892151,
-1.028212070465088,
0.4432292580604553,
0.4128396213054657,
0.6165568232536316,
0.14559628069400787,
0.2805837392807007,
1.0107098817825317,
-0.17359748482704163,
0.4760165214538574,
-0.06501870602369308,
-0.7151005864143372,
0.32262012362480164,
0.21380259096622467,
0.021591508761048317,
0.9632015824317932,
0.3058622181415558,
-0.1120678186416626,
0.1566656529903412,
-0.5305882096290588,
-0.9232580661773682,
0.6067920327186584,
0.22409850358963013,
0.2605103850364685,
0.19035696983337402,
0.6309385299682617,
-0.13371603190898895,
0.5753411650657654,
-0.4481505751609802,
-0.5464810132980347,
0.19068191945552826,
-0.32071951031684875,
0.049281273037195206,
-0.1313440352678299,
0.219255268573761,
-0.2303091585636139,
0.865189790725708,
-0.06746909022331238,
0.06925839930772781,
0.4323210120201111,
-0.05730360746383667,
-0.16222521662712097,
0.31960055232048035,
0.17776326835155487,
0.3699036240577698,
-0.12880609929561615,
-0.10791639238595963,
0.4759519398212433,
-0.6881625056266785,
0.05622672289609909,
0.8022791147232056,
-0.37480154633522034,
0.1360723227262497,
-0.045954056084156036,
1.0118733644485474,
0.4178856611251831,
-0.5151742100715637,
0.3992646038532257,
-0.018696710467338562,
0.05375058576464653,
-0.5503051280975342,
0.017791489139199257,
-0.2398160994052887,
0.2586463689804077,
0.4886099696159363,
0.3055553138256073,
0.43796536326408386,
-0.03448290005326271,
0.33408641815185547,
0.4635535776615143,
-0.6243606805801392,
0.13954707980155945,
0.4337823688983917,
-0.21889013051986694,
-0.0799865648150444,
0.5588271617889404,
-0.22965875267982483,
-0.397550106048584,
0.6741021871566772,
0.3794776499271393,
0.7591099739074707,
-0.4147508442401886,
0.20707747340202332,
0.3157457411289215,
0.3444422483444214,
-0.12943297624588013,
0.3841097056865692,
0.002180565381422639,
-0.9481297731399536,
-0.470366895198822,
-0.7393410205841064,
-0.5249350070953369,
0.04763200506567955,
-0.6040242910385132,
0.14114077389240265,
-0.2911713719367981,
-0.5159192085266113,
0.1495000272989273,
0.15819180011749268,
-0.8523761034011841,
0.8388465046882629,
0.3615439236164093,
0.6264593601226807,
-0.3591539263725281,
0.6049384474754333,
0.9292897582054138,
-0.3353067934513092,
-1.2968049049377441,
0.19270966947078705,
-0.14925728738307953,
-0.416091650724411,
0.5176408290863037,
0.35285142064094543,
0.09065849334001541,
0.19164592027664185,
0.08570178598165512,
-1.2937796115875244,
1.298161506652832,
0.3208649158477783,
-0.6942420601844788,
-0.2996486723423004,
0.5559926629066467,
0.495744526386261,
-0.5594058632850647,
0.386446088552475,
0.41670849919319153,
0.6855509281158447,
0.18595294654369354,
-0.9856382012367249,
-0.06657160073518753,
-0.11656311899423599,
0.11978624761104584,
0.18348482251167297,
-0.03037160634994507,
0.6841395497322083,
-0.31111064553260803,
-0.4282086491584778,
-0.06491313874721527,
0.726986825466156,
0.05912220850586891,
0.4672861099243164,
0.596688985824585,
0.6774736642837524,
1.0593211650848389,
-0.4432235360145569,
0.9581106901168823,
-0.41459187865257263,
0.12184296548366547,
1.325233817100525,
-0.37787681818008423,
0.5791222453117371,
0.5148881077766418,
-0.264549195766449,
0.6376474499702454,
0.8293653726577759,
-0.027446746826171875,
0.2671986520290375,
0.16651961207389832,
-0.354793518781662,
-0.1564580500125885,
-0.24646896123886108,
-0.3999214768409729,
0.34758710861206055,
0.7728056907653809,
-0.5232654213905334,
0.1297898292541504,
0.2142544388771057,
-0.10412683337926865,
-0.2954714000225067,
-0.3335677683353424,
0.7356829643249512,
0.25310471653938293,
-0.469333291053772,
0.11480671167373657,
-0.12902113795280457,
0.5933272838592529,
-0.27354323863983154,
0.04682750999927521,
0.43060800433158875,
0.13452112674713135,
-0.3280254304409027,
-0.776608407497406,
0.08470326662063599,
-0.22382113337516785,
-0.011650488711893559,
0.19604255259037018,
1.126801609992981,
-0.5640086531639099,
-0.8676279783248901,
0.03642183542251587,
0.47661978006362915,
0.17532610893249512,
-0.4263173043727875,
-0.5678053498268127,
-0.3342030644416809,
-0.21075783669948578,
-0.3203408122062683,
0.16446219384670258,
0.36660608649253845,
0.07676566392183304,
0.5908402800559998,
0.5367560982704163,
0.2975771129131317,
0.10925674438476562,
0.18280598521232605,
0.6891347765922546,
-0.2603737413883209,
-0.4363892078399658,
-0.5833259224891663,
0.5594744086265564,
-0.24749957025051117,
-0.0944986417889595,
0.7878050208091736,
0.5703877210617065,
0.8318147659301758,
0.10142990201711655,
0.6694241762161255,
-0.017138682305812836,
0.6268953680992126,
-0.39928293228149414,
0.517650306224823,
-0.3615662157535553,
0.42542701959609985,
-0.4584217071533203,
-0.8265067338943481,
-0.5383344292640686,
0.5009682774543762,
-0.8191249370574951,
0.2427191436290741,
0.3245895504951477,
0.7462427616119385,
0.1472102403640747,
0.18711087107658386,
0.3526826500892639,
-0.10997164249420166,
-0.2657829225063324,
0.3674071133136749,
0.40977486968040466,
-0.8938741087913513,
0.2773188650608063,
-0.8600006699562073,
0.00759549718350172,
-0.0021480873692780733,
-0.9629889726638794,
-0.36117473244667053,
-0.31943976879119873,
-0.6233778595924377,
-0.008136647753417492,
0.16431698203086853,
0.8223395943641663,
0.6334407329559326,
-1.0478079319000244,
0.34924688935279846,
-0.17354077100753784,
0.1425856202840805,
-0.1773374229669571,
-0.26787400245666504,
0.26005661487579346,
0.07752916216850281,
-0.9974409937858582,
0.5698663592338562,
0.26812440156936646,
0.38197386264801025,
-0.09542569518089294,
-0.003434242680668831,
-0.2682434618473053,
0.15339571237564087,
0.0033370712772011757,
0.1631108671426773,
-0.6685140132904053,
-0.4075791835784912,
0.062397077679634094,
-0.08868981897830963,
0.0985444188117981,
0.40234553813934326,
-0.9548474550247192,
0.7326229810714722,
0.4208039343357086,
1.0356775522232056,
0.08772759884595871,
0.3347257971763611,
0.5839696526527405,
-0.8698813915252686,
-0.0992879644036293,
0.39166340231895447,
0.515180230140686,
0.7471718788146973,
-0.9253026247024536,
0.5412188172340393,
-0.015787245705723763,
-0.5553151965141296,
-0.8325879573822021,
-0.06322253495454788,
-0.7321627736091614,
0.4812774062156677,
0.8076571226119995,
-0.32562148571014404,
-0.09706802666187286,
-0.19539274275302887,
0.06034582480788231,
0.45888346433639526,
-0.47867849469184875,
0.4104449152946472,
0.5804110765457153,
-0.12800082564353943,
-0.3214447498321533,
-0.44559961557388306,
0.5568810105323792,
0.3092469871044159,
-0.7839879989624023,
-0.37308716773986816,
0.4385777413845062,
0.12066597491502762,
0.4514182507991791,
0.12580986320972443,
0.026613963767886162,
0.22135087847709656,
-0.13376322388648987,
-0.060277268290519714,
-0.10172264277935028,
-0.2643986642360687,
-0.4370451271533966,
-0.13105031847953796,
-0.11473754793405533,
-0.20440712571144104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02056v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02056v1 | Integrate the Essence and Eliminate the Dross: Fine-Grained Self-Consistency for Free-Form Language Generation | 2024-07-02T08:38:31 | 2024-07-02T08:38:31 | Xinglin Wang, Yiwei Li, Shaoxiong Feng, Peiwen Yuan, Boyuan Pan, Heda Wang, Yao Hu, Kan Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Self-consistency (SC), leveraging multiple samples from LLMs, shows
significant gains on various reasoning tasks but struggles with free-form
generation due to the difficulty of aggregating answers. Its variants, UCS and
USC, rely on sample selection or voting mechanisms to improve output quality.
These methods, however, face limitations due to their inability to fully
utilize the nuanced consensus knowledge present within multiple candidate
samples, often resulting in suboptimal outputs. We propose Fine-Grained
Self-Consistency (FSC) to addresses these limitations by extracting and
integrating segment-level commonalities from candidate samples, enhancing the
performance of LLMs both in open-ended and reasoning tasks. Based on this, we
present two additional strategies: candidate filtering, which enhances overall
quality by identifying highly similar candidate sets, and merging, which
reduces input token requirements by combining similar samples. The
effectiveness of FSC is demonstrated through extensive experiments on various
tasks, including summarization, code generation, and mathematical reasoning,
using GPT-3.5-turbo and GPT-4. The results indicate significant improvements
over baseline methods, showcasing the potential of FSC to optimize output
quality by effectively synthesizing fine-grained consensus knowledge from
multiple samples. | [
-0.4414919912815094,
-0.36601516604423523,
0.6907179951667786,
0.15645883977413177,
-0.19174008071422577,
0.13893666863441467,
-0.481740266084671,
-0.30855268239974976,
0.1716899424791336,
0.47817280888557434,
-0.22723795473575592,
-0.5211536288261414,
-0.4293249547481537,
-0.018792353570461273,
-0.4068659543991089,
0.7866420745849609,
-0.31477418541908264,
-0.31075021624565125,
-0.3358292877674103,
-0.08963925391435623,
-0.303382009267807,
-0.39038416743278503,
-0.3066997826099396,
-0.3388395309448242,
0.256306916475296,
0.6828448176383972,
0.5306365489959717,
0.8810648322105408,
0.26274940371513367,
0.31915050745010376,
0.3091142475605011,
0.5090736150741577,
-0.548790454864502,
0.2799093425273895,
-0.2868974804878235,
-0.1333748698234558,
-0.3905847370624542,
0.20340338349342346,
0.6369976997375488,
0.32792195677757263,
-0.3581526279449463,
0.0014362420188263059,
0.5242648124694824,
0.6963570713996887,
-0.7366323471069336,
0.1644003689289093,
-0.7364806532859802,
-0.19168142974376678,
-0.47528618574142456,
0.0008182457531802356,
-0.23735082149505615,
-0.40326252579689026,
-0.5198305249214172,
-0.3735570013523102,
0.39413782954216003,
-0.4261513948440552,
0.7457368969917297,
0.4337795674800873,
0.037877392023801804,
-0.2684519588947296,
-0.6541793942451477,
0.7618847489356995,
-0.8467006683349609,
0.5283526182174683,
0.22890597581863403,
0.3048284351825714,
-0.38126301765441895,
-0.6219521164894104,
-0.5401816964149475,
0.00013901076454203576,
-0.08429038524627686,
0.193610280752182,
-0.11292764544487,
0.19438086450099945,
-0.2650805115699768,
0.6829531788825989,
-0.3667658865451813,
0.1500294804573059,
-0.24917732179164886,
-0.418552428483963,
0.5698849558830261,
-0.10363391786813736,
-0.017181554809212685,
-0.14694400131702423,
0.05377141013741493,
-0.019177259877324104,
-0.661823034286499,
0.24674826860427856,
0.27816444635391235,
0.6583108305931091,
0.04749166965484619,
0.659315824508667,
-0.6603183150291443,
0.5095974802970886,
0.4093155860900879,
-0.22812804579734802,
0.0014853214379400015,
-0.539709210395813,
-0.33065569400787354,
-0.2068924754858017,
0.9879170060157776,
0.13138826191425323,
0.06076410412788391,
-0.020378418266773224,
-0.4012499451637268,
0.04688866436481476,
0.07441610842943192,
-0.778536319732666,
-0.3291356563568115,
0.3450384736061096,
-0.41846033930778503,
-0.1513061821460724,
0.11567184329032898,
-0.4615665376186371,
0.2095934897661209,
-0.6485126614570618,
0.09396646171808243,
-0.5567509531974792,
-0.10602528601884842,
-0.03749743849039078,
0.04433542117476463,
-0.05715106055140495,
0.4720972776412964,
-1.1103739738464355,
0.31041356921195984,
0.6548431515693665,
0.6412972807884216,
-0.2946532964706421,
-0.3497224450111389,
-0.7218883633613586,
0.19212642312049866,
-0.37950316071510315,
0.9003695249557495,
-0.31364840269088745,
-0.2088930606842041,
-0.3767300546169281,
-0.3898182213306427,
0.09781187027692795,
-0.668743908405304,
0.05516683682799339,
0.08096347004175186,
0.12635605037212372,
-0.13821181654930115,
-0.5099513530731201,
0.3283442556858063,
-0.005970759317278862,
-0.35093334317207336,
1.3084242343902588,
0.38402649760246277,
-0.30690938234329224,
0.44372063875198364,
-0.2660292088985443,
-0.29133737087249756,
-0.01633400470018387,
-0.7578537464141846,
-0.050199415534734726,
0.49947500228881836,
0.1573006808757782,
0.4882589876651764,
0.026792827993631363,
0.45696941018104553,
-0.2894369661808014,
-0.25671330094337463,
-0.26461613178253174,
-0.554201602935791,
0.18469689786434174,
0.5919202566146851,
-0.42627856135368347,
0.16614586114883423,
-0.8716732859611511,
0.4793775975704193,
-0.1198987066745758,
-0.4668327271938324,
-0.15667428076267242,
-0.04892652481794357,
-0.49193131923675537,
0.2938070595264435,
0.4432780146598816,
-0.5481603145599365,
0.19031812250614166,
-0.32554924488067627,
0.25468918681144714,
0.7679300308227539,
-0.16707658767700195,
0.4952009320259094,
-0.3124453127384186,
0.09868602454662323,
0.17353355884552002,
-0.02712666057050228,
-0.11063544452190399,
-0.23674216866493225,
-0.8574366569519043,
-0.299062043428421,
0.22301460802555084,
0.22184385359287262,
-0.5011278390884399,
0.4886130392551422,
0.1119437888264656,
-0.6260195970535278,
-0.5859220623970032,
0.5078117847442627,
0.36632364988327026,
0.27703791856765747,
0.4936464726924896,
-0.41179943084716797,
-0.4714066684246063,
-0.9347073435783386,
-0.1766725331544876,
-0.047004759311676025,
0.007792228367179632,
-0.0046196975745260715,
-0.04480268433690071,
-0.08533817529678345,
1.3593969345092773,
-0.4332807660102844,
-0.22444160282611847,
-0.21000054478645325,
0.24219673871994019,
0.18215394020080566,
0.8315622806549072,
0.4214811623096466,
0.02964727394282818,
-0.4701164960861206,
-0.12385286390781403,
-0.4403895139694214,
-0.3359663188457489,
-0.07104135304689407,
-0.15577422082424164,
0.30157116055488586,
0.5411845445632935,
-0.12657025456428528,
0.2345210760831833,
0.7313684821128845,
0.06848988682031631,
0.39894118905067444,
-0.4107135832309723,
0.15601438283920288,
-1.0245476961135864,
-0.2735185921192169,
0.011696549132466316,
-0.2238103747367859,
-0.48256996273994446,
-0.0345783457159996,
0.07815632969141006,
0.2698828876018524,
-0.32157090306282043,
0.6498651504516602,
-0.4228605031967163,
-0.11921253055334091,
-0.350699782371521,
0.30759772658348083,
0.13762176036834717,
0.2417554408311844,
-0.2063896805047989,
1.119063138961792,
0.2412678450345993,
-0.5594280958175659,
-0.059637993574142456,
-0.1270628124475479,
-0.023392708972096443,
0.40745848417282104,
-0.45846933126449585,
0.07090117037296295,
-0.14278362691402435,
0.07891404628753662,
-0.9728499054908752,
-0.3198612630367279,
0.007996437139809132,
-0.12626075744628906,
0.3322618007659912,
-0.07184316962957382,
-0.30950334668159485,
-0.246849924325943,
-0.21712443232536316,
0.12108021229505539,
0.4027445912361145,
-0.49649062752723694,
0.4321083426475525,
0.08518451452255249,
-0.1470910608768463,
-0.46684569120407104,
-0.6712753176689148,
-0.1819341480731964,
0.28302326798439026,
-0.5615414977073669,
0.1782153695821762,
-0.12034419924020767,
-0.19900581240653992,
-0.1350252628326416,
-0.45801475644111633,
-0.07759431004524231,
0.06400216370820999,
-0.0594470389187336,
-0.03604432940483093,
-0.37687867879867554,
-0.11649814993143082,
0.5248468518257141,
-0.05145924910902977,
-0.5216763615608215,
-0.35621145367622375,
0.5372464060783386,
-0.3226463198661804,
-0.624966561794281,
-0.5065881609916687,
0.5993307828903198,
0.364424467086792,
-0.21893616020679474,
0.08031246066093445,
0.38359692692756653,
-0.15562181174755096,
-0.3278653025627136,
-0.7015731930732727,
-0.11912569403648376,
-0.44958585500717163,
-0.12292160093784332,
-0.6955342292785645,
-1.2956396341323853,
0.5364127159118652,
-0.01697397045791149,
0.3625560402870178,
0.6977717280387878,
0.44075891375541687,
-0.10138940066099167,
0.7612521648406982,
0.46777820587158203,
0.13199275732040405,
0.3832201361656189,
-0.043360136449337006,
0.08975029736757278,
-0.604986310005188,
-0.07958731800317764,
-0.5220304131507874,
-0.05713513866066933,
-0.5725448727607727,
-0.7002049684524536,
-0.09224939346313477,
0.5222917795181274,
-0.14409495890140533,
0.29856494069099426,
-0.8502875566482544,
0.5343930721282959,
0.8374689221382141,
-0.028977179899811745,
0.5266907811164856,
0.07379933446645737,
-0.4529987573623657,
-0.09787207841873169,
-0.5804513096809387,
-0.6756116151809692,
0.7426844239234924,
0.17014789581298828,
0.878530740737915,
0.034261368215084076,
1.471601963043213,
0.13297110795974731,
0.3306160867214203,
-0.48499393463134766,
0.553014874458313,
-0.7117571830749512,
-0.2552855312824249,
-0.3132052719593048,
-0.4693514406681061,
-0.7787471413612366,
0.2807312309741974,
0.07104874402284622,
-0.6005393862724304,
0.14453352987766266,
0.41975486278533936,
-0.42580029368400574,
0.20957998931407928,
-0.5818538665771484,
0.7195295691490173,
-0.12755659222602844,
-0.3335895538330078,
-0.18813665211200714,
-0.31857365369796753,
0.48054423928260803,
-0.06045455485582352,
0.14762380719184875,
-0.4411658048629761,
0.3409043848514557,
0.44941049814224243,
-0.5845779776573181,
0.9056006073951721,
-0.09254024177789688,
-0.3130110502243042,
0.72383052110672,
0.21862271428108215,
0.3606626093387604,
0.00023924159177113324,
-0.03661051020026207,
0.3722410500049591,
-0.005567037966102362,
-0.34908735752105713,
-0.5081906914710999,
0.8722013831138611,
-0.800180971622467,
-0.7128339409828186,
-0.1604066640138626,
-0.5053970217704773,
-0.1455184370279312,
0.4881927967071533,
0.1584647297859192,
0.4060755670070648,
-0.30658406019210815,
0.10836468636989594,
0.3638150990009308,
0.23408915102481842,
0.5627664923667908,
0.16657692193984985,
-0.016465086489915848,
-0.8437032103538513,
0.8988257646560669,
0.1808180809020996,
0.4984651505947113,
-0.00713752955198288,
0.31985047459602356,
-0.269259512424469,
-0.7244400382041931,
-0.6246145367622375,
0.2013295739889145,
-0.5994371175765991,
-0.49495863914489746,
-0.4708994925022125,
-0.3950035572052002,
-0.8786953091621399,
-0.3038790822029114,
-0.728769838809967,
-0.6406983137130737,
-0.36158478260040283,
0.26132896542549133,
-0.029934516176581383,
0.9328881502151489,
-0.49466848373413086,
0.37162333726882935,
-0.9349400997161865,
0.37931060791015625,
0.32256054878234863,
0.6707107424736023,
-0.15512794256210327,
-0.24562227725982666,
-0.030196933075785637,
0.18700751662254333,
-0.5611860156059265,
-0.4583190679550171,
-0.08410046994686127,
0.32113200426101685,
0.8645631074905396,
0.4299788475036621,
-0.035763032734394073,
0.9981554746627808,
-0.5026266574859619,
0.7448882460594177,
0.36371487379074097,
-1.1364156007766724,
0.6838114857673645,
-0.24151144921779633,
0.24328021705150604,
1.0935298204421997,
-0.13515397906303406,
-0.40510353446006775,
-0.966579258441925,
-0.7171630859375,
-0.5849350094795227,
0.5577599406242371,
0.2814890742301941,
-0.19445598125457764,
-0.35308021306991577,
0.3399982154369354,
0.3292904794216156,
0.11270146071910858,
-0.4426560699939728,
-0.06019997596740723,
-0.5362204909324646,
-0.6264554858207703,
0.11845757812261581,
-0.0061896382831037045,
-0.03978254273533821,
-0.10370608419179916,
0.594547688961029,
-0.4446166753768921,
-0.15848411619663239,
0.40082311630249023,
0.23524102568626404,
-0.04541550204157829,
0.5613955855369568,
0.6964486241340637,
0.39909523725509644,
0.011186886578798294,
0.47152894735336304,
-0.13953308761119843,
-0.24344496428966522,
0.27014681696891785,
0.0192450899630785,
-0.3436605632305145,
0.028075098991394043,
-0.026701971888542175,
0.298842191696167,
0.06701360642910004,
-0.21987652778625488,
0.2653745710849762,
0.16858123242855072,
-0.37299925088882446,
0.11187192797660828,
0.4978203773498535,
-0.05895382538437843,
0.13193362951278687,
0.16894719004631042,
0.24325673282146454,
-0.0549282431602478,
-0.5773675441741943,
0.597841203212738,
0.46704062819480896,
-0.09560824185609818,
-0.02998391166329384,
0.583609938621521,
0.22198697924613953,
0.10093271732330322,
0.37125518918037415,
-0.39447033405303955,
-0.018160689622163773,
0.26493504643440247,
0.6369530558586121,
0.7534030079841614,
-0.4297753572463989,
0.0723680928349495,
0.443574994802475,
0.09072581678628922,
-0.5807519555091858,
0.45852595567703247,
-0.19449260830879211,
-0.7236286401748657,
-0.6194727420806885,
-0.7222287058830261,
-0.49082425236701965,
0.00809626467525959,
-0.34056103229522705,
0.24782119691371918,
-0.5278910398483276,
0.07708847522735596,
-0.22904393076896667,
0.0369085818529129,
-0.27731072902679443,
0.19790655374526978,
0.025809403508901596,
0.8572758436203003,
-0.7527119517326355,
0.8674891591072083,
0.24049317836761475,
-0.485946923494339,
-1.2199972867965698,
-0.1353689432144165,
-0.09324780851602554,
-0.7236840724945068,
0.18133772909641266,
0.06295691430568695,
-0.18527725338935852,
-0.15187783539295197,
-0.46355876326560974,
-1.1971255540847778,
1.0193095207214355,
0.3323630392551422,
-0.6462274789810181,
-0.03381359204649925,
0.21922922134399414,
0.2584663927555084,
-0.5962254405021667,
0.02545792981982231,
0.7096502184867859,
0.4567604064941406,
0.4226628243923187,
-1.0092333555221558,
0.10652655363082886,
0.1205485463142395,
-0.10216116905212402,
0.41406112909317017,
-0.7585387229919434,
0.6814137101173401,
-0.13702274858951569,
-0.3249332308769226,
0.2037745714187622,
1.0419509410858154,
0.6846779584884644,
0.34791022539138794,
0.4232998490333557,
0.644476056098938,
1.0062428712844849,
-0.24466392397880554,
0.47270339727401733,
-0.420845091342926,
0.2587960362434387,
1.628041386604309,
-0.22957085072994232,
0.7704214453697205,
0.4489280581474304,
-0.10193750262260437,
0.6009017825126648,
0.3498658835887909,
-0.07052724063396454,
0.3635868728160858,
0.24193602800369263,
-0.16982373595237732,
-0.3762274980545044,
0.11194799840450287,
-0.3009050488471985,
0.6659097075462341,
0.16985231637954712,
-0.054356470704078674,
-0.687828004360199,
-0.356630802154541,
-0.0557500459253788,
0.4391908347606659,
-0.14350290596485138,
0.7803747653961182,
0.004365561064332724,
-0.9651247262954712,
0.5576118230819702,
-0.13792569935321808,
0.7817785739898682,
-0.42272183299064636,
-0.10203994065523148,
-0.39196568727493286,
0.13095365464687347,
-0.3100642263889313,
-0.9215399622917175,
0.5353218913078308,
-0.0860326737165451,
-0.28672417998313904,
-0.3176983594894409,
0.7857611775398254,
-0.6545826196670532,
-0.25399959087371826,
-0.026857372373342514,
0.8150927424430847,
0.36294499039649963,
0.06447690725326538,
-0.3808456361293793,
0.06737174093723297,
0.18616919219493866,
0.12853902578353882,
0.3873453736305237,
0.734696090221405,
0.008192148990929127,
0.26075083017349243,
0.7279423475265503,
0.3061521649360657,
-0.02733592316508293,
0.18692709505558014,
0.8832693696022034,
-0.584925651550293,
-0.3011506199836731,
-0.68363356590271,
0.3523313105106354,
-0.21119241416454315,
-0.2132897675037384,
0.6035850048065186,
0.8712544441223145,
0.9016541242599487,
0.3031178414821625,
0.8196210265159607,
-0.1466762274503708,
0.41499578952789307,
-0.44139784574508667,
0.47573167085647583,
-0.48058995604515076,
0.11167949438095093,
-0.16593477129936218,
-0.8535910248756409,
-0.19151756167411804,
0.5552995800971985,
0.12274328619241714,
-0.024382155388593674,
0.6052694916725159,
0.4877670109272003,
-0.21157391369342804,
-0.1353428065776825,
0.4707363545894623,
-0.06138099730014801,
0.5662094354629517,
0.3872006833553314,
0.45080217719078064,
-0.28716936707496643,
0.5601156949996948,
-0.33735591173171997,
-0.3517354726791382,
-0.0000318651509587653,
-0.9696105718612671,
-0.4612405002117157,
-0.3575594425201416,
-0.20248356461524963,
-0.39568594098091125,
-0.18015682697296143,
0.9307268261909485,
0.7521811723709106,
-0.848508358001709,
-0.23396994173526764,
-0.32299476861953735,
-0.028092490509152412,
-0.1113927811384201,
-0.21821533143520355,
0.09201474487781525,
-0.9808387756347656,
-0.7549176216125488,
0.6503961086273193,
0.4802049994468689,
0.35014548897743225,
-0.23553094267845154,
-0.045219071209430695,
0.2249971628189087,
0.21662655472755432,
0.5589050054550171,
0.33319371938705444,
-1.0227333307266235,
-0.6427227258682251,
0.03294261917471886,
-0.3576759397983551,
0.4042944312095642,
0.847105085849762,
-0.7670670747756958,
0.18667887151241302,
0.4577515125274658,
0.4862411916255951,
0.17000098526477814,
0.2724333107471466,
0.4786457419395447,
-0.8243634104728699,
-0.19374215602874756,
0.05709008127450943,
0.46501442790031433,
0.22914794087409973,
-0.2964537739753723,
0.47528526186943054,
0.05987340956926346,
-0.6945494413375854,
-0.3622293472290039,
0.35497942566871643,
-1.1570318937301636,
-0.3251449763774872,
1.0990650653839111,
-0.1246018186211586,
-0.020815961062908173,
-0.11346003413200378,
-0.0730709433555603,
0.2939412295818329,
-0.7674692869186401,
0.642318069934845,
0.6592780351638794,
-0.5045313835144043,
0.05919468775391579,
-0.14709977805614471,
0.526492714881897,
0.32831600308418274,
-0.8074734210968018,
0.4888976812362671,
0.7543455362319946,
0.46702060103416443,
0.2984134554862976,
1.0961847305297852,
-0.20604601502418518,
0.012752441689372063,
-0.07612729072570801,
0.1117938682436943,
-0.03393750265240669,
-0.35885560512542725,
-0.16360415518283844,
0.41250044107437134,
0.1753220409154892,
0.04002910479903221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02049v1 | Accompanied Singing Voice Synthesis with Fully Text-controlled Melody | 2024-07-02T08:23:38 | 2024-07-02T08:23:38 | Ruiqi Li, Zhiqing Hong, Yongqi Wang, Lichao Zhang, Rongjie Huang, Siqi Zheng, Zhou Zhao | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Text-to-song (TTSong) is a music generation task that synthesizes accompanied
singing voices. Current TTSong methods, inherited from singing voice synthesis
(SVS), require melody-related information that can sometimes be impractical,
such as music scores or MIDI sequences. We present MelodyLM, the first TTSong
model that generates high-quality song pieces with fully text-controlled
melodies, achieving minimal user requirements and maximum control flexibility.
MelodyLM explicitly models MIDI as the intermediate melody-related feature and
sequentially generates vocal tracks in a language model manner, conditioned on
textual and vocal prompts. The accompaniment music is subsequently synthesized
by a latent diffusion model with hybrid conditioning for temporal alignment.
With minimal requirements, users only need to input lyrics and a reference
voice to synthesize a song sample. For full control, just input textual prompts
or even directly input MIDI. Experimental results indicate that MelodyLM
achieves superior performance in terms of both objective and subjective
metrics. Audio samples are available at https://melodylm666.github.io. | [
-0.2173561304807663,
-0.6737293601036072,
0.5007808208465576,
0.8716262578964233,
-0.377541720867157,
0.38163280487060547,
-0.052032820880413055,
-0.1588042825460434,
0.21726302802562714,
0.5643366575241089,
-1.0096369981765747,
-0.9120550155639648,
-0.2818828821182251,
0.14094088971614838,
-0.5727211833000183,
1.1680407524108887,
0.4188433289527893,
-0.1779814064502716,
-0.09212815761566162,
0.31248077750205994,
-0.3368203341960907,
-0.5343146920204163,
-0.7978171110153198,
-0.22419585287570953,
0.7302350997924805,
0.14234110713005066,
0.32649311423301697,
0.2607942223548889,
0.050684891641139984,
0.22047200798988342,
-0.3244675099849701,
0.05587226152420044,
-0.45627155900001526,
0.5591806173324585,
0.11824364960193634,
-0.4337082505226135,
-0.7665891647338867,
0.3052605092525482,
0.5036685466766357,
0.45318493247032166,
-0.13423144817352295,
0.343187540769577,
0.28376471996307373,
0.6034184098243713,
0.08859410136938095,
-0.17250938713550568,
-0.5644826292991638,
0.32728853821754456,
-0.327839195728302,
-0.3095405399799347,
-0.4441266357898712,
-0.5426695942878723,
0.2764093279838562,
-0.8181459307670593,
0.2468748390674591,
0.09384609758853912,
0.5282673239707947,
0.36926981806755066,
-0.25582027435302734,
-0.3798784017562866,
-0.8435534834861755,
0.7519925832748413,
-0.4499586820602417,
0.41509515047073364,
0.42106032371520996,
0.24063099920749664,
-0.1824914664030075,
-0.967079222202301,
-0.131832093000412,
-0.4307931959629059,
0.11039462685585022,
0.5118119120597839,
0.05288043990731239,
0.23144473135471344,
0.2466934323310852,
0.25935304164886475,
-0.6086984276771545,
-0.4587388038635254,
-0.2535591423511505,
-0.07909955829381943,
0.5345978736877441,
0.10946346074342728,
0.31909987330436707,
-0.3778713047504425,
-0.6265468597412109,
0.19617325067520142,
-0.625943660736084,
0.17696891725063324,
0.4860875904560089,
0.5853462219238281,
-0.3666500747203827,
0.6831316351890564,
0.49928417801856995,
0.8937877416610718,
0.5120751261711121,
-0.04264315217733383,
0.10415948182344437,
-0.4854978621006012,
-0.44814667105674744,
0.3227953612804413,
0.9506283402442932,
-0.011511499062180519,
-0.13418960571289062,
-0.31516438722610474,
-0.4676816463470459,
-0.1834130585193634,
0.359214723110199,
-0.38532307744026184,
-0.2534700632095337,
0.3037402629852295,
-0.4516209363937378,
-0.39166754484176636,
-0.0299458596855402,
-0.6248528957366943,
-0.2311374396085739,
-0.6512537002563477,
0.5774536728858948,
-0.4231584072113037,
-0.2943442761898041,
-0.4134405851364136,
-0.18799103796482086,
-0.29585421085357666,
0.18901187181472778,
-0.41297727823257446,
-0.006430826615542173,
0.5052074193954468,
1.1939435005187988,
-0.3953893184661865,
-0.314797043800354,
-0.688632607460022,
0.3189775049686432,
-0.5661863684654236,
0.6114551424980164,
-0.17520524561405182,
-0.7387316226959229,
-0.407338410615921,
-0.23971717059612274,
-0.11077996343374252,
-0.6386566758155823,
0.26996785402297974,
-0.30910271406173706,
0.5482484102249146,
-0.03608463332056999,
-0.6562849283218384,
0.07053763419389725,
-0.2552955746650696,
-0.8517672419548035,
1.0476261377334595,
0.5417349338531494,
-0.49165037274360657,
0.26875996589660645,
-0.7526528835296631,
-0.7180214524269104,
0.01861182413995266,
0.08298230916261673,
-0.5286858081817627,
0.40889301896095276,
-0.18388579785823822,
0.25281134247779846,
-0.23276154696941376,
0.3944835960865021,
-0.14517545700073242,
-0.39988934993743896,
0.305090069770813,
-0.24212108552455902,
0.6623948812484741,
0.4446297287940979,
-0.12760496139526367,
0.4124370813369751,
-0.7496549487113953,
0.2345689833164215,
0.14674687385559082,
-0.49953436851501465,
-0.14869257807731628,
-0.005551125854253769,
0.6169441342353821,
0.2509053945541382,
0.3756352663040161,
-0.191076397895813,
-0.06265583634376526,
-0.3445042073726654,
0.39319971203804016,
0.43186697363853455,
0.06876873970031738,
0.5497648119926453,
-0.7468558549880981,
0.7722554802894592,
-0.36488640308380127,
0.04538685455918312,
-0.12805624306201935,
-0.39555293321609497,
-0.24514085054397583,
-0.32045552134513855,
0.5413559079170227,
0.4539563059806824,
-0.4382508397102356,
0.6337212920188904,
0.12254969775676727,
-0.3022138774394989,
-0.7456265091896057,
0.0934382751584053,
0.17418739199638367,
0.30224427580833435,
0.23185791075229645,
0.1866709589958191,
-0.8038363456726074,
-0.46118754148483276,
-0.04519753158092499,
-0.24888379871845245,
-0.4512021243572235,
0.03215248882770538,
-0.18246671557426453,
0.3885117769241333,
0.9797834157943726,
-0.06498990952968597,
-0.48607659339904785,
-0.548373281955719,
0.027703844010829926,
0.2564930319786072,
0.5774396657943726,
0.7694436311721802,
-0.8377686142921448,
-0.45246872305870056,
-0.22974976897239685,
-0.4707769751548767,
-0.6604294776916504,
-0.1937044858932495,
-0.35360270738601685,
0.15851251780986786,
0.4344400465488434,
-0.5364925861358643,
0.05233842879533768,
0.9167024493217468,
-0.4851002097129822,
0.5236930251121521,
0.10381001979112625,
0.3020128905773163,
-1.2940105199813843,
0.2535248100757599,
-0.11814960092306137,
-0.6023167967796326,
-0.8888818025588989,
-0.1881714016199112,
-0.28548359870910645,
-0.3220230042934418,
-0.307987779378891,
0.16985444724559784,
-0.2628170847892761,
-0.19530870020389557,
-0.35815274715423584,
0.05769004672765732,
0.12595809996128082,
0.3216407299041748,
0.12399951368570328,
0.8875736594200134,
0.506519615650177,
-0.5150139331817627,
0.18515793979167938,
0.1480027586221695,
-0.21750184893608093,
0.5645471215248108,
-0.7697632312774658,
0.3030044138431549,
0.2369438111782074,
0.07088872045278549,
-0.9972034692764282,
-0.22059054672718048,
0.021446088328957558,
-0.7769949436187744,
0.39146125316619873,
-0.2750253677368164,
-0.5268067121505737,
-0.24675188958644867,
0.18767549097537994,
0.24166226387023926,
0.986078679561615,
-0.4434310793876648,
0.7412954568862915,
0.10107439756393433,
-0.48962610960006714,
0.36922645568847656,
-0.6120263338088989,
0.0871877521276474,
-0.5010486245155334,
-0.2653508186340332,
0.39657148718833923,
-0.17433759570121765,
-0.005049869883805513,
-0.13186107575893402,
-0.2398327887058258,
0.05759115889668465,
-0.07421983778476715,
0.30853933095932007,
0.28730878233909607,
-0.12389015406370163,
0.30073538422584534,
0.28513291478157043,
0.002566297072917223,
-0.025931578129529953,
-0.6960456371307373,
0.7044457197189331,
0.4912954568862915,
-0.18151608109474182,
-0.5163789391517639,
0.7527027130126953,
0.6872372031211853,
-0.19280210137367249,
0.15099255740642548,
0.4121790826320648,
-0.09526961296796799,
-0.49248868227005005,
-0.1258220374584198,
-0.003518328769132495,
-0.4659093916416168,
0.10154233127832413,
-0.16799579560756683,
-0.7735891342163086,
0.37402766942977905,
-0.12207107990980148,
0.2643030285835266,
0.3606933355331421,
0.352224200963974,
-0.6300813555717468,
1.3244072198867798,
0.45713672041893005,
0.1895170658826828,
0.8206902146339417,
0.03242648392915726,
-0.3229236602783203,
-0.6610798239707947,
-0.4163331985473633,
-0.5427296161651611,
-0.3750733733177185,
-0.3580548167228699,
-0.41469940543174744,
0.7939767241477966,
0.16666044294834137,
-0.3406599462032318,
0.16176368296146393,
-0.5999447703361511,
-0.06429734826087952,
0.8037860989570618,
0.2584063708782196,
0.15040931105613708,
0.01756337843835354,
-0.25370147824287415,
-0.08906655013561249,
-0.5896145701408386,
-0.2676810920238495,
1.0557384490966797,
-0.0010457495227456093,
0.7964223027229309,
-0.011529630050063133,
0.9391214847564697,
0.5035433769226074,
-0.013278188183903694,
-0.70791095495224,
0.4349270164966583,
-0.37372422218322754,
-0.48193293809890747,
-0.11134717613458633,
-0.5216332077980042,
-0.5106638073921204,
-0.12280944734811783,
-0.3742496371269226,
-0.5339685678482056,
-0.6861883997917175,
0.45267340540885925,
-0.36011838912963867,
0.06914099305868149,
-0.6094462275505066,
0.3724794089794159,
-0.33640220761299133,
-0.18298478424549103,
0.21046091616153717,
-0.5352185964584351,
0.26301148533821106,
-0.3040587604045868,
-0.08567388355731964,
-0.13126759231090546,
-0.03913198038935661,
0.6864115595817566,
-0.24782954156398773,
0.6774385571479797,
-0.26240983605384827,
-0.1817588359117508,
0.23514053225517273,
0.21061252057552338,
0.3293636441230774,
-0.15979763865470886,
-0.012052349746227264,
-0.07549485564231873,
-0.15071171522140503,
-0.3849087655544281,
-0.6158180236816406,
0.7710999846458435,
-0.4797154664993286,
-0.6094918251037598,
-0.05214859917759895,
-0.5626373887062073,
-0.4492802917957306,
0.17421092092990875,
0.6512757539749146,
0.34410810470581055,
0.01344472635537386,
0.11918557435274124,
0.6560590863227844,
-0.2790628671646118,
0.35572490096092224,
0.12326761335134506,
-0.7584352493286133,
-0.8123815655708313,
0.5578458905220032,
-0.18811474740505219,
0.5725263953208923,
0.3244592547416687,
0.3166000247001648,
-0.6842790246009827,
-0.6807242035865784,
-0.6172555088996887,
0.03107593022286892,
-0.2136194258928299,
-0.0035368462558835745,
-0.49629855155944824,
-0.3975309729576111,
-0.2649513781070709,
-0.0017137600807473063,
-0.39719057083129883,
-0.35334891080856323,
-0.5324344038963318,
0.06028459593653679,
0.5074268579483032,
0.7860184907913208,
0.0640648677945137,
0.4001530408859253,
-0.9567721486091614,
0.6132268309593201,
0.2049003541469574,
0.3957348167896271,
-0.2075682431459427,
-0.39695310592651367,
-0.2092994600534439,
-0.12330715358257294,
-0.05002118647098541,
-1.0406841039657593,
0.09354975819587708,
0.1907440572977066,
0.3624126613140106,
0.1438785344362259,
-0.05470386520028114,
0.6598755717277527,
-0.5775507688522339,
1.2001410722732544,
0.45752108097076416,
-1.070196509361267,
0.7883592844009399,
-0.6013664603233337,
0.5157778859138489,
0.1596413403749466,
-0.1448061466217041,
-0.45876210927963257,
-0.7805348038673401,
-0.2783232629299164,
-0.7366021275520325,
0.6866309642791748,
0.6787651777267456,
-0.08962046355009079,
0.28556910157203674,
0.18214285373687744,
0.17966246604919434,
0.4779077172279358,
-0.5121623873710632,
-0.33665162324905396,
-0.5077677965164185,
-0.5308797955513,
-0.3309228718280792,
0.25110986828804016,
-0.027683274820446968,
-0.10014636814594269,
0.6090813875198364,
0.05580814182758331,
0.41283026337623596,
0.25308170914649963,
0.33203572034835815,
-0.3877568244934082,
0.09329525381326675,
0.5285331606864929,
0.23934943974018097,
-0.04441779851913452,
-0.10191593319177628,
-0.4094196856021881,
-0.4177713692188263,
0.23371247947216034,
0.23957213759422302,
-0.5330226421356201,
0.19226832687854767,
0.31127703189849854,
0.9898333549499512,
0.1477620005607605,
-0.4939812421798706,
0.23789465427398682,
-0.09444918483495712,
-0.24631758034229279,
-0.4119389057159424,
0.24311484396457672,
0.27605265378952026,
0.2491941899061203,
0.4983932375907898,
0.09468621015548706,
0.047962311655282974,
-0.10666153579950333,
0.32718899846076965,
0.21981337666511536,
-0.6227822303771973,
-0.33636343479156494,
1.2318902015686035,
-0.0536595843732357,
-0.45966604351997375,
0.1127561703324318,
0.18384923040866852,
-0.32878080010414124,
0.6078808307647705,
0.7143524885177612,
1.2291533946990967,
-0.5215415358543396,
0.18757660686969757,
0.11610687524080276,
0.07570953667163849,
0.17323464155197144,
0.6418852210044861,
-0.28222817182540894,
0.09798939526081085,
-0.43999025225639343,
-0.7786223888397217,
-0.055521462112665176,
0.3549313545227051,
-0.6387137770652771,
0.2692332863807678,
-0.5287089943885803,
-0.3926929831504822,
0.029673639684915543,
-0.2856441140174866,
-0.3651517927646637,
0.3665274381637573,
0.0017877817153930664,
0.9416770935058594,
-0.6598126888275146,
0.600058913230896,
0.6550462245941162,
-0.10010822862386703,
-0.9593978524208069,
0.3858995735645294,
0.17808224260807037,
-0.2930566668510437,
0.1364692598581314,
-0.05133632570505142,
-0.1641164869070053,
0.4907669425010681,
-0.577225387096405,
-0.5170619487762451,
0.8712876439094543,
0.18390372395515442,
-0.5922165513038635,
-0.3488706648349762,
0.08432359993457794,
0.5598607063293457,
-0.33607232570648193,
-0.3389315605163574,
0.468771755695343,
0.41887420415878296,
0.635602593421936,
-0.8095880150794983,
-0.33865952491760254,
-0.3685401380062103,
0.09855586290359497,
0.2874522805213928,
-0.41101399064064026,
0.8057344555854797,
0.07009152323007584,
-0.23266400396823883,
0.718701183795929,
0.6225875020027161,
0.505936324596405,
0.5390692353248596,
0.7732742428779602,
0.32373419404029846,
0.5585815906524658,
-0.40870875120162964,
0.8240078091621399,
-0.2553468942642212,
0.06027201563119888,
1.2406389713287354,
-0.29833173751831055,
0.3802095651626587,
0.4198237657546997,
-0.18355177342891693,
0.057651933282613754,
0.7753585577011108,
0.18539312481880188,
0.8348490595817566,
0.234142005443573,
-0.46363750100135803,
-0.36744534969329834,
-0.04429321363568306,
-0.1794840395450592,
0.4189460277557373,
0.3061275780200958,
-0.7190072536468506,
0.08013974130153656,
0.33432525396347046,
-0.3260068893432617,
0.10843764990568161,
-0.4092230498790741,
1.1000216007232666,
0.038291431963443756,
-0.8405742645263672,
0.3312947750091553,
-0.41065263748168945,
0.4016742408275604,
-0.970156192779541,
-0.08360700309276581,
-0.1293475478887558,
-0.3624749183654785,
-0.043869197368621826,
-0.8349843621253967,
0.12760180234909058,
0.253052681684494,
-0.21280503273010254,
-0.3280354142189026,
0.46628761291503906,
-0.8901708722114563,
-0.4458763599395752,
0.2968437969684601,
0.5490203499794006,
-0.24961070716381073,
-0.10326340794563293,
-0.4989721179008484,
-0.1825309544801712,
0.13553282618522644,
-0.19157902896404266,
0.0755678191781044,
0.4149510860443115,
0.1688687950372696,
0.31676769256591797,
0.7474594712257385,
0.5788465738296509,
0.34314119815826416,
0.4786512851715088,
0.5485389828681946,
-0.7598612904548645,
-1.0368897914886475,
-0.47008341550827026,
0.5439640879631042,
0.08688980340957642,
-0.08159264922142029,
0.5671461820602417,
0.6686534881591797,
0.3727443218231201,
-0.13413657248020172,
1.3133800029754639,
-0.12569555640220642,
0.9382393956184387,
-0.8917759656906128,
0.8027498722076416,
-0.8966151475906372,
-0.048594992607831955,
-0.5679015517234802,
-0.9359332919120789,
-0.08505699038505554,
0.13802865147590637,
0.4776783287525177,
0.21717754006385803,
0.43350908160209656,
0.4670690596103668,
-0.19565753638744354,
0.28233617544174194,
0.5818740129470825,
0.012648946605622768,
0.17153175175189972,
0.7354753017425537,
1.1654812097549438,
0.0013459301553666592,
0.45779284834861755,
-0.2109793871641159,
0.018910059705376625,
0.15983206033706665,
-0.80839604139328,
-1.058488368988037,
-0.8447099924087524,
-0.1724659949541092,
-0.46017032861709595,
-0.13582955300807953,
1.2866944074630737,
0.855987012386322,
-0.7036759257316589,
-0.10272650420665741,
-0.10614743083715439,
0.07571984082460403,
-0.41175633668899536,
-0.2267753630876541,
0.22793738543987274,
-0.07012953609228134,
-0.9087297320365906,
0.7167899012565613,
0.2701830267906189,
0.6785427927970886,
-0.21028542518615723,
-0.13520202040672302,
0.3596615195274353,
0.15010672807693481,
0.44922202825546265,
-0.20074447989463806,
-0.7325746417045593,
0.00909416563808918,
0.1682882457971573,
-0.10580193996429443,
0.09341293573379517,
1.1927896738052368,
-0.3446079194545746,
0.4146832823753357,
0.3907569348812103,
0.10658728331327438,
0.31703269481658936,
0.3065347373485565,
0.6221737861633301,
-1.0486072301864624,
-0.13806265592575073,
0.44117406010627747,
-0.05816635116934776,
0.27410170435905457,
-0.27035999298095703,
0.024541441351175308,
0.22179025411605835,
-0.29474347829818726,
-0.490503191947937,
0.3040756285190582,
-1.3007404804229736,
-0.03941177576780319,
1.1107574701309204,
-0.06488263607025146,
-0.14464960992336273,
-0.023777656257152557,
-0.4840817451477051,
0.5680304765701294,
-0.4146677255630493,
0.5815801620483398,
0.4459231495857239,
-0.028253845870494843,
-0.2543814480304718,
-0.43306419253349304,
0.8943813443183899,
-0.05418957397341728,
-0.7334609031677246,
-0.07347028702497482,
0.7816168665885925,
0.2547398805618286,
-0.07600963860750198,
0.5787404179573059,
-0.2850682735443115,
0.5679765939712524,
-0.16495345532894135,
-0.09544410556554794,
-0.3313179612159729,
-0.5705622434616089,
-0.3368334174156189,
0.47842487692832947,
0.065447136759758,
-0.31341370940208435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02043v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02043v1 | Concise and Precise Context Compression for Tool-Using Language Models | 2024-07-02T08:17:00 | 2024-07-02T08:17:00 | Yang Xu, Yunlong Feng, Honglin Mu, Yutai Hou, Yitong Li, Xinghao Wang, Wanjun Zhong, Zhongyang Li, Dandan Tu, Qingfu Zhu, Min Zhang, Wanxiang Che | cs.CL | cs.CL | Through reading the documentation in the context, tool-using language models
can dynamically extend their capability using external tools. The cost is that
we have to input lengthy documentation every time the model needs to use the
tool, occupying the input window as well as slowing down the decoding process.
Given the progress in general-purpose compression, soft context compression
is a suitable approach to alleviate the problem. However, when compressing tool
documentation, existing methods suffer from the weaknesses of key information
loss (specifically, tool/parameter name errors) and difficulty in adjusting the
length of compressed sequences based on documentation lengths.
To address these problems, we propose two strategies for compressing tool
documentation into concise and precise summary sequences for tool-using
language models. 1) Selective compression strategy mitigates key information
loss by deliberately retaining key information as raw text tokens. 2) Block
compression strategy involves dividing tool documentation into short chunks and
then employing a fixed-length compression model to achieve variable-length
compression. This strategy facilitates the flexible adjustment of the
compression ratio.
Results on API-Bank and APIBench show that our approach reaches a performance
comparable to the upper-bound baseline under up to 16x compression ratio. | [
-0.3441961109638214,
-0.581451952457428,
0.41755661368370056,
0.0930330827832222,
-0.6108159422874451,
-0.029732463881373405,
-0.6181188821792603,
-0.41002219915390015,
-0.015012425370514393,
0.48789095878601074,
-0.4839176535606384,
-0.42402973771095276,
-0.3592270314693451,
0.1272345781326294,
-0.5087476968765259,
0.7925702333450317,
-0.05256713926792145,
-0.1989036649465561,
-0.07296760380268097,
-0.13554523885250092,
-0.8209094405174255,
-0.6347419619560242,
-0.5127024054527283,
-0.09941725432872772,
0.34859079122543335,
0.3151315748691559,
0.6625781059265137,
0.9562825560569763,
0.3652048707008362,
0.282541424036026,
-0.2120876908302307,
0.11146286875009537,
-0.2738131880760193,
0.42936402559280396,
-0.1194533258676529,
-0.35840144753456116,
-0.4006724953651428,
-0.23669303953647614,
0.5923969149589539,
0.7550630569458008,
-0.2639562487602234,
0.25762614607810974,
0.2208097279071808,
0.28033435344696045,
-0.5340133309364319,
0.1251094788312912,
-0.3438858091831207,
-0.15155774354934692,
-0.24041303992271423,
-0.5434945821762085,
-0.620749294757843,
-0.018028624355793,
0.025897158309817314,
-0.31891775131225586,
0.4926838278770447,
-0.2054675668478012,
0.7757841944694519,
0.3527887761592865,
-0.26180100440979004,
-0.18627092242240906,
-0.8688805103302002,
0.6514454483985901,
-0.7459391951560974,
0.37519314885139465,
0.4096616208553314,
0.22171653807163239,
0.08908647298812866,
-0.7641075253486633,
-0.224935382604599,
0.06228159740567207,
-0.1729920357465744,
-0.32744842767715454,
0.13031402230262756,
0.2917098104953766,
0.5352231860160828,
0.3635239601135254,
-0.4732111692428589,
0.07080945372581482,
-0.5657542943954468,
-0.47723671793937683,
0.5938531160354614,
0.031735293567180634,
-0.01452621165663004,
-0.0734032690525055,
-0.17225706577301025,
-0.5630270838737488,
-0.676590085029602,
0.08897649496793747,
0.5181788206100464,
0.44388628005981445,
-0.03518329933285713,
0.33060145378112793,
-0.22126515209674835,
1.0140544176101685,
-0.0686197280883789,
-0.4680625796318054,
0.05174488201737404,
-0.6339949369430542,
-0.22543129324913025,
0.012129147537052631,
0.4255642294883728,
0.47809818387031555,
-0.13860675692558289,
-0.4256686866283417,
-0.47814247012138367,
-0.08242928236722946,
0.49219247698783875,
-0.9306730628013611,
0.1416144222021103,
0.37535345554351807,
-0.4519343078136444,
-0.15762998163700104,
0.0723777785897255,
-0.5401846766471863,
-0.19203664362430573,
-0.4772639870643616,
0.18980230391025543,
-0.3191855549812317,
-0.09164654463529587,
0.16187338531017303,
-0.49882665276527405,
-0.018721185624599457,
0.41290587186813354,
-0.7729794979095459,
0.31061649322509766,
0.5962145328521729,
1.106473684310913,
0.1013936921954155,
0.17168672382831573,
-0.7221411466598511,
0.26929327845573425,
0.10855001211166382,
0.8542353510856628,
-0.5030459761619568,
-0.7171618342399597,
0.0574430413544178,
0.08578222990036011,
0.4193686544895172,
-0.33344435691833496,
0.6741730570793152,
-0.1548347771167755,
0.09092061221599579,
-0.09061896800994873,
-0.5487350225448608,
-0.09569335728883743,
0.11432162672281265,
-0.8788382411003113,
0.7731800675392151,
0.43015220761299133,
-0.6453306078910828,
0.1501947045326233,
-0.37094005942344666,
-0.5141401886940002,
0.10727578401565552,
-0.10486186295747757,
-0.11658407747745514,
0.3922263979911804,
0.14059753715991974,
0.517790675163269,
-0.4137597680091858,
0.28349539637565613,
-0.1260562241077423,
-0.5994127988815308,
0.0627504289150238,
-0.4007721245288849,
0.5042421817779541,
0.3163415789604187,
-0.04870093613862991,
0.27898645401000977,
-0.5473679304122925,
-0.00780482916161418,
-0.0569315068423748,
-0.5933892130851746,
-0.3386903405189514,
-0.061685699969530106,
0.13698545098304749,
0.16779741644859314,
0.25050899386405945,
-0.37189045548439026,
0.6590244174003601,
-0.47620198130607605,
0.41350167989730835,
0.7101191282272339,
-0.16560539603233337,
0.5866851210594177,
-0.19141420722007751,
0.6116830110549927,
-0.36852598190307617,
0.37891268730163574,
-0.41476234793663025,
0.00467247748747468,
-0.6805770993232727,
0.09514746814966202,
0.7069398164749146,
0.4979855418205261,
-0.7155224084854126,
0.4263051748275757,
-0.5301199555397034,
-0.4156954288482666,
-0.36399900913238525,
0.05051058903336525,
0.33951979875564575,
0.6176595687866211,
0.19604308903217316,
-0.685493528842926,
-0.5568000078201294,
-0.7587680816650391,
-0.14096172153949738,
-0.150589719414711,
-0.314067006111145,
0.3444875478744507,
0.06513360142707825,
0.11287279427051544,
0.9379391670227051,
-0.41470423340797424,
0.04689790681004524,
-0.41559654474258423,
0.3294789791107178,
0.32860884070396423,
0.5607157945632935,
0.40489065647125244,
-0.9164896607398987,
-0.31833404302597046,
-0.3092972934246063,
-0.16969746351242065,
-0.32142701745033264,
-0.2830352783203125,
0.16849355399608612,
0.2416081428527832,
0.46582290530204773,
-0.6371121406555176,
0.5865151882171631,
0.5015094876289368,
-0.28187403082847595,
0.7338647246360779,
-0.27387744188308716,
-0.15907247364521027,
-0.8781441450119019,
0.22463545203208923,
-0.16125378012657166,
-0.4734228849411011,
-0.6560574173927307,
0.3362612724304199,
0.3162781000137329,
-0.04465598613023758,
-0.5251303315162659,
0.6441367864608765,
-0.5534417033195496,
0.151258185505867,
-0.42368531227111816,
-0.024097299203276634,
0.1592174619436264,
0.45838913321495056,
0.21609604358673096,
0.7702779769897461,
0.34199976921081543,
-0.6309743523597717,
0.27144238352775574,
-0.006204687524586916,
-0.18222405016422272,
0.44613829255104065,
-0.6538569927215576,
0.41505134105682373,
0.019627578556537628,
0.6100159287452698,
-0.3102589249610901,
-0.07455994933843613,
0.14497166872024536,
-0.18101009726524353,
0.7404004335403442,
-0.42354902625083923,
-0.9242551326751709,
-0.22935748100280762,
-0.619874119758606,
0.28138870000839233,
0.5921472311019897,
-0.08116617798805237,
0.5160480737686157,
0.16638940572738647,
-0.25592824816703796,
-0.4881516993045807,
-0.6460297107696533,
0.218702033162117,
-0.3043668866157532,
-0.6307603716850281,
0.7824177145957947,
-0.40498214960098267,
0.1077759712934494,
-0.10148443281650543,
-0.5661782026290894,
-0.05114750191569328,
0.08166021853685379,
0.09476113319396973,
0.06548739969730377,
-0.04590488597750664,
0.251615971326828,
0.08491038531064987,
-0.23431487381458282,
-0.22833536565303802,
-0.32245203852653503,
0.7484146356582642,
0.1140471026301384,
-0.08957751840353012,
-0.10870540142059326,
0.7810048460960388,
0.31471410393714905,
0.041053012013435364,
0.7209213376045227,
0.4658125638961792,
-0.2826969623565674,
-0.07857665419578552,
-0.6267117857933044,
-0.31360456347465515,
-0.49276816844940186,
0.026649165898561478,
-0.45030686259269714,
-0.7306095361709595,
0.5546953678131104,
-0.42121168971061707,
0.27243858575820923,
0.18505756556987762,
0.28645849227905273,
0.34099045395851135,
1.0138883590698242,
1.0571752786636353,
-0.017706509679555893,
0.6217156052589417,
-0.21789664030075073,
0.2069295197725296,
-0.7832152247428894,
-0.04902319982647896,
-0.7658919095993042,
-0.2486550360918045,
-0.0643882304430008,
-0.4609801471233368,
0.1652836948633194,
0.39834004640579224,
0.2604687809944153,
0.611492395401001,
-0.7567048668861389,
0.4297536611557007,
0.5464881658554077,
-0.043385084718465805,
0.10110791772603989,
0.07744955271482468,
-0.07827655971050262,
0.337966650724411,
-0.910492479801178,
-0.6206445097923279,
0.9567826986312866,
0.38225340843200684,
0.7376154065132141,
0.18876244127750397,
0.6280736923217773,
0.09279336780309677,
0.1180591881275177,
-0.7911785840988159,
0.4174409806728363,
0.03489907085895538,
-0.36577707529067993,
-0.2682131230831146,
-0.2595984935760498,
-0.8878576755523682,
-0.13922464847564697,
0.2676370441913605,
-0.8625448942184448,
0.20886094868183136,
0.13648465275764465,
-0.46873924136161804,
0.030739326030015945,
-0.7516266107559204,
0.6955525279045105,
0.00777746457606554,
-0.2129163146018982,
-0.1274494081735611,
-0.8443084359169006,
-0.0028134232852607965,
-0.17943376302719116,
0.2897931933403015,
0.10814250260591507,
-0.21371129155158997,
0.5251753330230713,
-0.8853669166564941,
0.7741111516952515,
-0.1529264748096466,
-0.12460976839065552,
0.05269128829240799,
0.03708012029528618,
0.6478338241577148,
-0.037686336785554886,
-0.152486190199852,
0.02247435599565506,
0.2090674489736557,
-0.41652029752731323,
-0.8945218324661255,
0.3222532272338867,
-0.1917106956243515,
-0.6795930862426758,
-0.13128863275051117,
-0.813713550567627,
0.07845739275217056,
0.20589932799339294,
0.3229118883609772,
0.9472155570983887,
0.03921973705291748,
0.2989746034145355,
0.49823254346847534,
-0.16480572521686554,
0.492659330368042,
0.5396764874458313,
0.1824754774570465,
-0.10933507978916168,
0.5856826305389404,
0.1828724443912506,
0.27412253618240356,
0.26823389530181885,
0.09502027928829193,
-0.29120635986328125,
-0.6629129648208618,
-0.5481813549995422,
0.08461631834506989,
-1.0604678392410278,
-0.569150984287262,
-0.3075012266635895,
-0.10160916298627853,
-0.6501527428627014,
-0.45677649974823,
-0.1703067421913147,
-0.6319778561592102,
-0.16417916119098663,
0.0811559334397316,
0.2972226142883301,
0.36107030510902405,
0.04388316348195076,
0.4867764115333557,
-0.9852439165115356,
0.2168431282043457,
-0.1938316375017166,
0.4944707155227661,
-0.16787289083003998,
-0.4076179563999176,
-0.38471028208732605,
-0.025580381974577904,
-0.10506126284599304,
-1.0228203535079956,
0.37051892280578613,
0.2134658843278885,
0.454129695892334,
0.5057798027992249,
0.4149351716041565,
0.8589409589767456,
-0.4382319152355194,
0.7710129618644714,
-0.08147334307432175,
-0.8268859386444092,
0.6167815327644348,
-0.0399237759411335,
0.7068082690238953,
0.5386731624603271,
0.10673331469297409,
-0.6795727014541626,
-0.4798211455345154,
-0.6962077617645264,
-1.177721619606018,
0.7396798729896545,
0.16869476437568665,
0.3064318895339966,
0.036995358765125275,
0.5654815435409546,
0.22890369594097137,
0.1389165073633194,
-0.4276711344718933,
-0.031185349449515343,
-0.09824918210506439,
-0.3968954384326935,
0.08984033018350601,
-0.30111756920814514,
-0.4116447865962982,
-0.104851633310318,
0.4126077890396118,
-0.26215285062789917,
0.17688798904418945,
0.18294759094715118,
-0.3041195869445801,
0.2229553610086441,
0.42552649974823,
0.5838513970375061,
0.6157365441322327,
-0.28775906562805176,
0.2928701639175415,
0.1735638678073883,
-0.4269200265407562,
0.07415555417537689,
0.17877404391765594,
-0.1797429919242859,
0.29954537749290466,
0.27535805106163025,
0.7424397468566895,
0.24710498750209808,
-0.8639968037605286,
0.39256709814071655,
-0.32971063256263733,
0.09335776418447495,
0.02220676839351654,
0.18588843941688538,
-0.011414313688874245,
0.053592853248119354,
0.23635289072990417,
-0.10791015625,
0.35968977212905884,
-0.3649294078350067,
-0.005458863917738199,
0.17097152769565582,
-0.14805015921592712,
-0.17346489429473877,
0.13900138437747955,
0.3432983458042145,
-0.49762341380119324,
0.46329909563064575,
-0.17268231511116028,
-0.2699473798274994,
0.41509753465652466,
0.4998014569282532,
0.7340198159217834,
-0.1650398075580597,
-0.17540593445301056,
0.27183997631073,
0.18978002667427063,
-0.39163556694984436,
0.09976426512002945,
-0.6925917267799377,
-0.19967958331108093,
-0.6459690928459167,
-0.5855313539505005,
-0.35146573185920715,
0.08933990448713303,
-0.7238479852676392,
0.4953661262989044,
-0.37380096316337585,
-0.21522800624370575,
-0.23768815398216248,
0.040809568017721176,
-0.7699388861656189,
-0.041421838104724884,
-0.01997554488480091,
1.5032278299331665,
-0.40598341822624207,
0.9121533036231995,
0.2707935571670532,
-0.4584782123565674,
-1.0530999898910522,
-0.1619160920381546,
0.03982125595211983,
-0.05147519335150719,
0.12820734083652496,
0.45704591274261475,
-0.12632900476455688,
-0.18680915236473083,
-0.503023624420166,
-0.8453038930892944,
0.9549387693405151,
0.43833479285240173,
-0.6487801671028137,
-0.2850065529346466,
-0.171415314078331,
0.30198028683662415,
-0.12200695276260376,
-0.07062613219022751,
0.5355420708656311,
0.5280490517616272,
0.04707377403974533,
-1.182796835899353,
0.42879432439804077,
-0.3663197457790375,
0.1394462138414383,
0.23232685029506683,
-0.21990551054477692,
0.3914288580417633,
0.33282673358917236,
-0.6270104050636292,
0.28030285239219666,
0.3655114769935608,
-0.02858058363199234,
-0.0639653280377388,
0.6251617074012756,
0.2976389527320862,
0.6770764589309692,
0.10448580980300903,
1.3786040544509888,
-0.5225921869277954,
0.1625707447528839,
0.9794161319732666,
0.08590318262577057,
0.6510651707649231,
0.4988544285297394,
0.17997229099273682,
0.5253815650939941,
0.817431628704071,
0.07567448168992996,
0.39174026250839233,
0.07487045973539352,
-0.31567928194999695,
0.09758106619119644,
-0.304474413394928,
-0.35059455037117004,
0.13985329866409302,
0.3556658625602722,
-0.3287990391254425,
-0.11531851440668106,
-0.11095032840967178,
0.16251574456691742,
-0.2456560581922531,
-0.05815742537379265,
0.5960648655891418,
-0.010051500052213669,
-0.8704749345779419,
0.7018693089485168,
0.4938119053840637,
0.6827334761619568,
-0.733716607093811,
0.07749068737030029,
-0.07906392961740494,
-0.19571559131145477,
-0.013321859762072563,
-0.580028235912323,
0.6141164898872375,
0.17019610106945038,
-0.21170590817928314,
-0.6876286268234253,
0.9088443517684937,
-0.43839818239212036,
-0.2651221752166748,
-0.116070456802845,
0.1464110165834427,
0.31372377276420593,
-0.16080616414546967,
-0.4709472060203552,
0.3821726441383362,
-0.2141796350479126,
-0.2668212056159973,
0.2719855010509491,
0.32674741744995117,
-0.17277470231056213,
0.4455525279045105,
0.6232587695121765,
0.17885148525238037,
-0.331882119178772,
0.3437104821205139,
1.0600734949111938,
-0.6165443062782288,
-0.6252745389938354,
-0.7540974020957947,
0.6884868741035461,
-0.4556560814380646,
-0.030736731365323067,
0.5172019600868225,
0.345564603805542,
0.8231872916221619,
0.10141562670469284,
0.6238297820091248,
-0.09642752259969711,
0.1939823031425476,
-0.6103457808494568,
0.38017770648002625,
-0.46883687376976013,
0.2787572145462036,
-0.1228787750005722,
-0.7289490699768066,
-0.35928788781166077,
0.48875969648361206,
0.12905320525169373,
-0.19108600914478302,
0.7414925694465637,
0.6329610347747803,
-0.2102373093366623,
-0.4060351252555847,
-0.05244773253798485,
-0.15323103964328766,
0.32059967517852783,
0.4425826966762543,
0.2226034700870514,
-0.11698875576257706,
0.8570241928100586,
-0.4103381633758545,
-0.06851524859666824,
-0.4381515383720398,
-1.0457744598388672,
-0.5147280693054199,
-0.5800329446792603,
-0.429731547832489,
-0.22023719549179077,
-0.2945217788219452,
0.6979268193244934,
1.2301007509231567,
-0.20789916813373566,
-0.16052694618701935,
0.038653790950775146,
0.19347189366817474,
-0.3026706576347351,
-0.19264577329158783,
0.2879903316497803,
-0.27586081624031067,
-0.6719528436660767,
0.43760451674461365,
0.49626368284225464,
0.10109058767557144,
-0.4635631740093231,
-0.15076081454753876,
0.268316388130188,
0.26112520694732666,
0.45540279150009155,
0.32461392879486084,
-0.8189066052436829,
-0.29753315448760986,
-0.1173403412103653,
0.06605270504951477,
-0.0702657401561737,
1.1298750638961792,
-0.9473145604133606,
0.5115063786506653,
0.6499391198158264,
0.3196566700935364,
0.41234341263771057,
0.0719417929649353,
0.9662862420082092,
-1.3749980926513672,
0.5189743041992188,
0.15503975749015808,
0.37813442945480347,
0.4789074957370758,
-0.5594997406005859,
0.7334756851196289,
-0.04411829635500908,
-0.2837879955768585,
-1.1282823085784912,
0.3549382984638214,
-1.1793724298477173,
-0.7169913053512573,
1.1252856254577637,
-0.3040746748447418,
-0.311492383480072,
-0.27595147490501404,
-0.5231418013572693,
0.5255479216575623,
-0.36847078800201416,
0.7130084037780762,
0.8765057325363159,
-0.047752417623996735,
-0.19654159247875214,
-0.5571273565292358,
0.43953704833984375,
0.005127516109496355,
-0.45164036750793457,
0.16868315637111664,
0.4440997242927551,
0.1249702125787735,
0.30583736300468445,
0.4693275988101959,
0.02130415290594101,
0.374281108379364,
0.08662040531635284,
-0.014004184864461422,
-0.24557502567768097,
-0.19936229288578033,
-0.5120723843574524,
0.30399489402770996,
0.030718214809894562,
0.16256147623062134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02042v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02042v1 | Fake News Detection and Manipulation Reasoning via Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-07-02T08:16:43 | 2024-07-02T08:16:43 | Ruihan Jin, Ruibo Fu, Zhengqi Wen, Shuai Zhang, Yukun Liu, Jianhua Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Fake news becomes a growing threat to information security and public opinion
with the rapid sprawl of media manipulation. Therefore, fake news detection
attracts widespread attention from academic community. Traditional fake news
detection models demonstrate remarkable performance on authenticity binary
classification but their ability to reason detailed faked traces based on the
news content remains under-explored. Furthermore, due to the lack of external
knowledge, the performance of existing methods on fact-related news is
questionable, leaving their practical implementation unclear. In this paper, we
propose a new multi-media research topic, namely manipulation reasoning.
Manipulation reasoning aims to reason manipulations based on news content. To
support the research, we introduce a benchmark for fake news detection and
manipulation reasoning, referred to as Human-centric and Fact-related Fake News
(HFFN). The benchmark highlights the centrality of human and the high factual
relevance, with detailed manual annotations. HFFN encompasses four realistic
domains with fake news samples generated through three manipulation approaches.
Moreover, a Multi-modal news Detection and Reasoning langUage Model (M-DRUM) is
presented not only to judge on the authenticity of multi-modal news, but also
raise analytical reasoning about potential manipulations. On the feature
extraction level, a cross-attention mechanism is employed to extract
fine-grained fusion features from multi-modal inputs. On the reasoning level, a
large vision-language model (LVLM) serves as the backbone to facilitate
fact-related reasoning. A two-stage training framework is deployed to better
activate the capacity of identification and reasoning. Comprehensive
experiments demonstrate that our model outperforms state-of-the-art (SOTA) fake
news detection models and powerful LVLMs like GPT-4 and LLaVA. | [
-0.5419700741767883,
-1.188395619392395,
0.7685535550117493,
-0.10509663820266724,
-0.2780309319496155,
-0.0016870973631739616,
-0.013525775633752346,
-0.6288367509841919,
0.18048562109470367,
0.5387177467346191,
-0.4359472095966339,
-0.22390396893024445,
-0.43390771746635437,
-0.1299101710319519,
-0.6142848134040833,
0.5430728793144226,
-0.03946699574589729,
0.12337138503789902,
-0.022359699010849,
-0.2628495395183563,
-0.30371707677841187,
-0.6844223737716675,
-0.11897797137498856,
-0.12424491345882416,
0.607718825340271,
0.1992383897304535,
0.5435937643051147,
0.6468406319618225,
0.34091275930404663,
0.33783528208732605,
0.17804837226867676,
0.42004847526550293,
-0.23073506355285645,
-0.3256317675113678,
-0.5188985466957092,
-0.37372279167175293,
-0.25045913457870483,
0.3693115711212158,
0.3664512038230896,
0.23850370943546295,
0.029773084446787834,
0.1551905870437622,
-0.25480934977531433,
0.37318411469459534,
-0.6749019026756287,
-0.08073705434799194,
-0.6795437932014465,
-0.28752490878105164,
-0.2935544550418854,
-0.17662237584590912,
-0.4181709289550781,
-0.1445665806531906,
-0.2774059474468231,
-0.5860731601715088,
0.16045184433460236,
0.26828524470329285,
1.0051859617233276,
0.19508764147758484,
-0.5492292642593384,
-0.04792631044983864,
-0.6279247403144836,
0.6707080006599426,
-0.4079667031764984,
0.7257645726203918,
0.2140425443649292,
0.5357770323753357,
-0.047001369297504425,
-0.4945778250694275,
-1.1254056692123413,
-0.2321626991033554,
-0.07655537128448486,
-0.0829043984413147,
-0.15032704174518585,
-0.1538388431072235,
0.43256568908691406,
0.23943324387073517,
-0.4726197421550751,
-0.10137628763914108,
-0.3690291941165924,
-0.5013294219970703,
0.5297206044197083,
-0.13020280003547668,
0.2858133316040039,
-0.3736611604690552,
-0.6942681670188904,
-0.10262106359004974,
-0.5332263112068176,
-0.15688380599021912,
0.5421017408370972,
-0.05374115705490112,
-0.004485458135604858,
0.5803608894348145,
-0.3683488965034485,
0.7452082633972168,
0.032695572823286057,
-0.4534117579460144,
0.1492622345685959,
-0.44046851992607117,
-0.43951570987701416,
-0.07096695154905319,
0.5807162523269653,
0.4331916868686676,
-0.057439059019088745,
0.02809896320104599,
-0.10874728858470917,
0.5267256498336792,
0.40010082721710205,
-0.4399128556251526,
0.23134569823741913,
0.10630933940410614,
-0.6400724649429321,
-0.48381248116493225,
0.3276800811290741,
-0.7528102397918701,
-0.4009760916233063,
-0.6384080052375793,
0.7917089462280273,
-0.4818316698074341,
-0.4639059603214264,
0.2062975913286209,
-0.19452452659606934,
0.23630814254283905,
0.6172125339508057,
-0.17735619843006134,
-0.13259315490722656,
0.8067508339881897,
0.5061063170433044,
-0.21933190524578094,
-0.5229642987251282,
-0.6604029536247253,
0.03183167800307274,
-0.21404196321964264,
0.7291564345359802,
-0.34054622054100037,
0.3929942548274994,
-0.05981265380978584,
0.011560074053704739,
0.07061149924993515,
-0.3763697147369385,
0.8093733787536621,
-0.8870823979377747,
0.3201640546321869,
-0.39594370126724243,
-0.42233309149742126,
-0.5330047607421875,
0.7176238298416138,
-0.7672364115715027,
0.6493573188781738,
0.05449989065527916,
-0.8294742107391357,
0.48548999428749084,
-0.5536729097366333,
-0.5363859534263611,
-0.3221336007118225,
0.06531762331724167,
-0.34458810091018677,
-0.22470204532146454,
0.2360256165266037,
0.24171961843967438,
-0.1919412910938263,
0.5553529858589172,
-0.43812114000320435,
-0.3808881640434265,
0.5169022679328918,
-0.6599535942077637,
0.7184641361236572,
0.21872763335704803,
-0.35768887400627136,
0.23221845924854279,
-0.5680429935455322,
-0.3774009346961975,
-0.002701191231608391,
-0.31978708505630493,
-0.2828543186187744,
-0.30725955963134766,
-0.038042306900024414,
0.5734319686889648,
0.029489995911717415,
-0.5781339406967163,
0.28242966532707214,
-0.010640043765306473,
0.2835533618927002,
0.45420151948928833,
0.07803510129451752,
0.47158724069595337,
-0.33523401618003845,
0.09362147003412247,
0.3660765290260315,
0.4795372784137726,
-0.37627944350242615,
-0.2036331295967102,
-0.6244643926620483,
-0.22514759004116058,
0.3310811221599579,
0.6306618452072144,
-1.2040733098983765,
0.26674404740333557,
-0.1323675960302353,
-0.23954761028289795,
-0.5511143803596497,
-0.006899124011397362,
0.2840001583099365,
0.6438487768173218,
0.5709713697433472,
0.11265181750059128,
-0.5099742412567139,
-0.833545446395874,
-0.8563024401664734,
0.08846373111009598,
0.25373512506484985,
-0.22985607385635376,
0.6080774068832397,
-0.13727310299873352,
0.8558109402656555,
-0.16451624035835266,
-0.37921142578125,
-0.17594240605831146,
0.25222381949424744,
0.0617682971060276,
0.14256419241428375,
0.4692479968070984,
-1.4927948713302612,
-0.0840008333325386,
-0.17044943571090698,
-0.7282770872116089,
0.019935857504606247,
-0.4394887089729309,
-0.14363116025924683,
0.5060933232307434,
0.5179967880249023,
-0.9564430117607117,
0.7693641781806946,
0.38209962844848633,
-0.34927475452423096,
1.0004209280014038,
0.19958795607089996,
0.6446936130523682,
-0.8425824642181396,
-0.03320121020078659,
0.2218019664287567,
-0.6145715713500977,
-0.6734029650688171,
0.3998410105705261,
0.12660305202007294,
0.057636991143226624,
-0.7054497599601746,
0.5935271382331848,
-0.44191956520080566,
-0.17873026430606842,
-0.5246874690055847,
0.1207413375377655,
0.12363959103822708,
0.46191251277923584,
-0.08243903517723083,
0.40035152435302734,
0.3466609716415405,
-0.40943431854248047,
0.7767600417137146,
-0.1935988813638687,
-0.5749712586402893,
0.5763541460037231,
-0.3202994763851166,
-0.23023106157779694,
0.012540471740067005,
0.45324480533599854,
-0.6396992206573486,
-0.4882436692714691,
0.5648559331893921,
-0.6020866632461548,
0.05844027176499367,
-0.1598689705133438,
-0.9405757188796997,
-0.29949426651000977,
-0.14684249460697174,
0.21618764102458954,
0.23087018728256226,
-0.7469609379768372,
0.7110104560852051,
0.15488800406455994,
0.47694113850593567,
-0.5421655178070068,
-0.6182687282562256,
0.17989295721054077,
-0.12886328995227814,
-0.694427490234375,
0.34471625089645386,
0.029713213443756104,
-0.49976667761802673,
0.23085059225559235,
-0.29342523217201233,
0.08322186768054962,
-0.12247012555599213,
0.17494308948516846,
0.18842539191246033,
-0.09007146954536438,
0.06465914100408554,
0.04971720650792122,
-0.07303626835346222,
-0.11441894620656967,
-0.0019241137197241187,
0.44819578528404236,
-0.051123980432748795,
-0.7341150641441345,
-0.6157947182655334,
0.29153743386268616,
1.0224553346633911,
-0.39863067865371704,
0.7521117925643921,
0.8436506986618042,
-0.5427447557449341,
0.04800461232662201,
-0.954479455947876,
-0.48854878544807434,
-0.36008620262145996,
0.14169995486736298,
-0.3724360167980194,
-0.6519985198974609,
0.3013891875743866,
-0.14831790328025818,
-0.2525211274623871,
0.22296196222305298,
0.6826000809669495,
0.1887005716562271,
1.006019115447998,
0.30075711011886597,
-0.07332708686590195,
0.3315599262714386,
-0.11742863804101944,
0.2565283179283142,
-0.4271632134914398,
-0.10087911039590836,
0.007689912803471088,
-0.27632465958595276,
-0.16514788568019867,
-0.7735468745231628,
0.4438115060329437,
0.10641425102949142,
-0.06910062581300735,
0.21957628428936005,
-0.11095947027206421,
0.5320433974266052,
0.566321074962616,
0.17814575135707855,
0.54765784740448,
0.16289378702640533,
0.02519918605685234,
0.1822037398815155,
-0.41969171166419983,
-0.27162638306617737,
0.5437150597572327,
0.4470014274120331,
0.6139678359031677,
0.1482376903295517,
0.11629214882850647,
0.3925008475780487,
0.39530840516090393,
-0.7116225361824036,
0.4847119152545929,
0.1757345050573349,
-0.8331459760665894,
-0.32729700207710266,
-0.43513599038124084,
-0.3884353041648865,
0.672686755657196,
-0.2773432433605194,
-0.4391985833644867,
0.16428276896476746,
0.028807802125811577,
-0.0708954781293869,
0.6283512711524963,
-0.6502810716629028,
0.6227558851242065,
-0.2881421744823456,
-0.4626065194606781,
-0.6774269938468933,
-0.6503562331199646,
0.787092924118042,
-0.07332742214202881,
0.5940661430358887,
-0.022881289944052696,
0.23370608687400818,
0.04722926393151283,
-0.2818986475467682,
0.8587568402290344,
-0.11363035440444946,
-0.009866940788924694,
0.17836040258407593,
0.3589923083782196,
0.3148666024208069,
0.12098420411348343,
0.059456292539834976,
0.2789769172668457,
-0.25388243794441223,
-0.29357919096946716,
-0.5812062621116638,
0.6871870756149292,
-0.3158344030380249,
-0.7968129515647888,
-0.5841845273971558,
-0.542275071144104,
-0.04637479782104492,
0.2594400942325592,
0.20631101727485657,
0.402685284614563,
0.05460195615887642,
0.21597576141357422,
0.4476602077484131,
-0.05841705948114395,
0.3043335974216461,
0.5750997066497803,
-0.46462544798851013,
-0.11577674001455307,
0.8797423243522644,
0.0372476689517498,
0.1976395696401596,
0.380940318107605,
0.29217734932899475,
-0.2904452979564667,
-0.036889977753162384,
-0.8149573802947998,
0.2077564150094986,
-0.5775004625320435,
-0.1974279135465622,
-0.5830483436584473,
-0.18289153277873993,
-0.3636993169784546,
0.055336903780698776,
-0.28947722911834717,
-0.2807549238204956,
-0.042532965540885925,
0.08322728425264359,
0.06052171438932419,
0.13861608505249023,
-0.19720733165740967,
0.04974702373147011,
-0.6769477725028992,
1.0735468864440918,
0.42500150203704834,
0.25751328468322754,
-0.1196441575884819,
-0.602014422416687,
-0.1886747181415558,
0.33608436584472656,
-0.40385672450065613,
-1.2388007640838623,
0.2213602364063263,
-0.2935275137424469,
0.7047492861747742,
0.4877811670303345,
0.026189297437667847,
0.2276613861322403,
-0.06884714961051941,
0.5833615064620972,
0.2078273594379425,
-1.0071747303009033,
0.507125973701477,
-0.45874011516571045,
-0.05811741575598717,
0.1489981859922409,
0.4074798822402954,
-0.36722031235694885,
-0.2729593813419342,
-0.5596153140068054,
-0.23527757823467255,
0.7008853554725647,
0.01395923551172018,
-0.13998135924339294,
0.40226250886917114,
0.21397428214550018,
0.18085640668869019,
0.3646324872970581,
-0.934141993522644,
-0.13112029433250427,
-0.35490697622299194,
0.15017864108085632,
0.2589828670024872,
-0.06742293387651443,
-0.25747379660606384,
-0.5380831360816956,
0.6318594217300415,
-0.29320386052131653,
0.002559269778430462,
0.15260033309459686,
-0.4274333119392395,
-0.07627922296524048,
0.25119292736053467,
0.7643101811408997,
0.9176109433174133,
0.11198490858078003,
0.3245055675506592,
0.004437614232301712,
-0.2158680558204651,
0.0753680095076561,
0.10698897391557693,
-0.21524865925312042,
-0.09378807246685028,
0.39151531457901,
0.7808937430381775,
0.1303865760564804,
-0.47783035039901733,
0.8768182992935181,
0.07190613448619843,
-0.33547696471214294,
-0.13271376490592957,
0.009449637494981289,
0.028022507205605507,
0.3270646631717682,
0.49953776597976685,
0.4224929213523865,
0.16741131246089935,
-0.9442588090896606,
0.21950070559978485,
0.2779347598552704,
-0.10437227785587311,
-0.3844512701034546,
0.47559916973114014,
-0.007125751581043005,
-0.0021091175731271505,
0.3407866358757019,
-0.3984847664833069,
-0.9670113325119019,
0.4390474259853363,
0.42957571148872375,
0.32373812794685364,
-0.22398334741592407,
0.5019099116325378,
0.13098743557929993,
0.4880705177783966,
-0.3073592782020569,
0.15754736959934235,
0.11753915995359421,
-1.1467760801315308,
-0.7800154685974121,
-0.4696623980998993,
-0.19250023365020752,
0.4387678802013397,
-0.3536243736743927,
0.5238246321678162,
-0.22210635244846344,
0.15247954428195953,
0.1846068948507309,
-0.1706690788269043,
-0.41771236062049866,
0.2056143432855606,
0.2355274260044098,
1.0880151987075806,
-0.9270789623260498,
0.9173066020011902,
0.6130099296569824,
-0.5357832312583923,
-0.5228897333145142,
0.2503200173377991,
0.4171648919582367,
-0.5451836585998535,
0.4708380401134491,
0.31266525387763977,
-0.15120387077331543,
-0.37818342447280884,
-0.84395432472229,
-0.449826717376709,
0.7239571809768677,
0.5850242376327515,
-0.4983643889427185,
0.07057950645685196,
0.039736561477184296,
0.29657411575317383,
-0.2465561181306839,
-0.17461568117141724,
0.6000848412513733,
0.8712156414985657,
0.17756831645965576,
-0.7004171013832092,
0.1172463446855545,
0.029650017619132996,
-0.4486410617828369,
0.2637518644332886,
-0.9101873636245728,
0.9550857543945312,
-0.18770231306552887,
-0.13392823934555054,
-0.3064551055431366,
0.517853319644928,
0.41052961349487305,
0.7192932367324829,
0.7736622095108032,
0.7694555521011353,
0.35381874442100525,
-0.10943073034286499,
1.100318193435669,
-0.16030257940292358,
0.27704212069511414,
0.7669607996940613,
-0.31096598505973816,
0.5461837649345398,
0.5370445251464844,
0.16342803835868835,
0.6788060665130615,
0.2912500500679016,
-0.16689488291740417,
0.2356119453907013,
-0.10319648683071136,
-0.1782706081867218,
-0.6706538200378418,
0.017920611426234245,
-0.18089252710342407,
0.9921138882637024,
0.4136590361595154,
-0.1507749706506729,
-0.28522995114326477,
0.3426053524017334,
0.18512023985385895,
0.11881420761346817,
-0.24989533424377441,
0.40821218490600586,
-0.023583749309182167,
-0.6953285336494446,
0.37945348024368286,
0.39092954993247986,
0.6100038886070251,
-0.2527892291545868,
-0.17299263179302216,
0.09130653738975525,
0.09873536974191666,
-0.15414240956306458,
-0.700263500213623,
0.28514567017555237,
-0.14582982659339905,
-0.3868090808391571,
-0.26422232389450073,
1.3160340785980225,
-0.4417652189731598,
-0.2617079019546509,
0.2736032009124756,
0.7196789383888245,
-0.06880572438240051,
-0.683484673500061,
-0.6763667464256287,
0.3552475869655609,
-0.1653715819120407,
-0.3120643198490143,
0.39700251817703247,
0.4388746917247772,
-0.30489981174468994,
0.6089111566543579,
1.1202189922332764,
0.14304572343826294,
-0.12609441578388214,
0.1185849979519844,
0.9093576669692993,
-0.5305964350700378,
-0.6426675319671631,
-0.8066022992134094,
0.19344158470630646,
-0.36321166157722473,
0.022854827344417572,
0.7977790832519531,
0.5395525693893433,
0.6380954384803772,
-0.14579728245735168,
0.7259088754653931,
0.06195709854364395,
0.8218961954116821,
-0.6445691585540771,
0.7036349773406982,
-0.6606587767601013,
0.05092405527830124,
-0.02469293214380741,
-0.8504621982574463,
-0.2339123636484146,
0.3460720479488373,
-0.31754353642463684,
-0.038589101284742355,
0.6007680296897888,
0.8117785453796387,
-0.5189233422279358,
0.21370945870876312,
0.4694494307041168,
0.3523765504360199,
0.22994506359100342,
0.20644068717956543,
1.0359911918640137,
-0.3738650977611542,
0.5560672879219055,
-0.29586610198020935,
-0.18583807349205017,
-0.6762564778327942,
-0.9617939591407776,
-0.7072066068649292,
-0.6106797456741333,
-0.25589537620544434,
-0.43269434571266174,
-0.09920675307512283,
0.6049215197563171,
1.0029239654541016,
-0.521735429763794,
0.31938183307647705,
0.1400202214717865,
0.5776494741439819,
-0.4399258494377136,
-0.32655996084213257,
0.3461024761199951,
0.1300007402896881,
-0.43875977396965027,
0.44733208417892456,
0.25590407848358154,
-0.10893271863460541,
-0.6242225766181946,
0.07784087210893631,
-0.46977972984313965,
0.16595305502414703,
0.8715572953224182,
0.2735583782196045,
-0.9923492074012756,
-0.46046802401542664,
-0.028947774320840836,
-0.09048443287611008,
-0.12131237238645554,
1.0482401847839355,
-1.0020543336868286,
0.290367066860199,
0.5567170977592468,
0.413751482963562,
0.5102465152740479,
0.3545355796813965,
0.10169071704149246,
-0.8387655019760132,
0.23786337673664093,
-0.1825595647096634,
0.3058590292930603,
0.4111965298652649,
-0.40671461820602417,
0.14420492947101593,
0.7048121094703674,
-0.3404771685600281,
-0.8598510026931763,
0.44039592146873474,
-0.9187538027763367,
-0.6687542200088501,
1.3018606901168823,
0.21388302743434906,
-0.49161845445632935,
-0.2745884358882904,
-0.3458743095397949,
0.3353937268257141,
-0.23414826393127441,
0.7816341519355774,
0.7668544054031372,
-0.13576218485832214,
-0.5339251160621643,
-0.6637371182441711,
0.34586501121520996,
0.054321032017469406,
-0.990890383720398,
-0.03180946782231331,
0.6087604761123657,
0.2584019899368286,
0.47878846526145935,
0.25736165046691895,
-0.24379664659500122,
0.5278089046478271,
0.005351284984499216,
0.03804778680205345,
-0.35175806283950806,
-0.6524669528007507,
-0.09350715577602386,
0.18479150533676147,
-0.6713435053825378,
-0.1602938324213028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02039v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02039v1 | Prompt Stability Scoring for Text Annotation with Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T08:11:18 | 2024-07-02T08:11:18 | Christopher Barrie, Elli Palaiologou, Petter Törnberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | Researchers are increasingly using language models (LMs) for text annotation.
These approaches rely only on a prompt telling the model to return a given
output according to a set of instructions. The reproducibility of LM outputs
may nonetheless be vulnerable to small changes in the prompt design. This calls
into question the replicability of classification routines. To tackle this
problem, researchers have typically tested a variety of semantically similar
prompts to determine what we call "prompt stability." These approaches remain
ad-hoc and task specific. In this article, we propose a general framework for
diagnosing prompt stability by adapting traditional approaches to intra- and
inter-coder reliability scoring. We call the resulting metric the Prompt
Stability Score (PSS) and provide a Python package PromptStability for its
estimation. Using six different datasets and twelve outcomes, we classify >150k
rows of data to: a) diagnose when prompt stability is low; and b) demonstrate
the functionality of the package. We conclude by providing best practice
recommendations for applied researchers. | [
-0.2694196403026581,
-0.7679955363273621,
0.5963839292526245,
0.5549969673156738,
-0.022965535521507263,
-0.20379824936389923,
-0.366293340921402,
-0.21394293010234833,
0.1379386931657791,
0.30471286177635193,
-0.28035131096839905,
-0.38429778814315796,
-0.4994271397590637,
0.5603801608085632,
-0.3021984398365021,
1.2334554195404053,
0.05479871854186058,
0.13840439915657043,
-0.6386119723320007,
-0.35283681750297546,
-0.7148144245147705,
-0.7172585725784302,
-0.713866651058197,
0.02471291646361351,
0.613976240158081,
0.25427302718162537,
0.8487039804458618,
0.49860864877700806,
0.524908185005188,
0.33667969703674316,
-0.30573588609695435,
-0.029774226248264313,
-0.06774481385946274,
0.6239635944366455,
0.06635958701372147,
-0.29128775000572205,
-0.3023029565811157,
-0.048997484147548676,
0.721255362033844,
0.7190313935279846,
0.05753618851304054,
-0.008403496816754341,
0.3505309224128723,
0.15595197677612305,
-0.28581181168556213,
0.206294983625412,
-0.20473386347293854,
-0.18085548281669617,
-0.1398230642080307,
-0.2570347487926483,
-0.7608436942100525,
-0.7730550765991211,
0.22371219098567963,
-0.27318504452705383,
-0.05685599148273468,
0.015508025884628296,
0.5368446111679077,
0.23098820447921753,
-0.12102361023426056,
-0.31242504715919495,
-0.5154322981834412,
0.6502072811126709,
-0.568560004234314,
0.01756666973233223,
0.5318951606750488,
0.31206631660461426,
-0.2917378544807434,
-0.37710297107696533,
-0.2966920733451843,
-0.6624764800071716,
-0.20962311327457428,
-0.23218700289726257,
-0.0058210911229252815,
0.0676213800907135,
0.5599611401557922,
0.1329817920923233,
-0.429874062538147,
0.27227577567100525,
-0.16531820595264435,
-0.585791289806366,
0.28013667464256287,
0.34289121627807617,
0.532005786895752,
-0.11141598969697952,
-0.33080020546913147,
0.1275705099105835,
-0.518647313117981,
0.3815414607524872,
0.29278144240379333,
0.633453369140625,
0.11531603336334229,
0.6368176937103271,
-0.03597618639469147,
0.5447075963020325,
0.24097004532814026,
-0.22443445026874542,
0.22993777692317963,
-0.33308449387550354,
0.2734738290309906,
0.14743857085704803,
0.8467526435852051,
0.6143747568130493,
0.13355612754821777,
-0.04837426170706749,
-0.4473406672477722,
0.14339576661586761,
0.31190869212150574,
-0.6622139811515808,
-0.3799465596675873,
0.24675048887729645,
-0.5727663040161133,
-0.1313905417919159,
0.07682415843009949,
-0.6569607257843018,
-0.7925176620483398,
-0.0659932866692543,
0.4055408537387848,
-0.5561528205871582,
-0.19073912501335144,
-0.20459650456905365,
0.06646101176738739,
-0.13739138841629028,
0.454524964094162,
-0.7089714407920837,
0.24777576327323914,
0.5580118298530579,
1.1820638179779053,
-0.11670650541782379,
-0.5411522388458252,
-0.9980015158653259,
-0.5655089020729065,
-0.407720685005188,
0.9256365895271301,
-0.32327529788017273,
-0.28801894187927246,
0.221944659948349,
0.382071852684021,
-0.04975833743810654,
-0.21214255690574646,
0.7521798014640808,
-0.2725282609462738,
0.3862854540348053,
-0.5168500542640686,
-0.7092536091804504,
0.11132840812206268,
0.32268476486206055,
-0.7044520378112793,
1.0853267908096313,
0.1908174753189087,
-1.0947459936141968,
0.3210878074169159,
-0.2406487613916397,
-0.1749371588230133,
0.1015210896730423,
0.018048809841275215,
-0.633650004863739,
0.11986499279737473,
-0.09703537821769714,
0.39417973160743713,
-0.04157154634594917,
0.30397120118141174,
-0.4980969727039337,
-0.5586721897125244,
0.37149253487586975,
-0.28173550963401794,
0.6605985164642334,
-0.06117106229066849,
0.04406246542930603,
0.2799157202243805,
-0.6995309591293335,
-0.10766395181417465,
-0.2616157829761505,
-0.4167156517505646,
-0.39645475149154663,
0.18363964557647705,
-0.1668747216463089,
0.26347529888153076,
0.08906372636556625,
-0.47142377495765686,
0.32504698634147644,
-0.0992707833647728,
0.3120301067829132,
0.5808060169219971,
0.08989322930574417,
0.4057791233062744,
-0.4768625497817993,
0.8603554368019104,
-0.028884869068861008,
-0.048667509108781815,
-0.8006463646888733,
-0.6374620795249939,
-0.5552155375480652,
-0.1789727807044983,
0.18098199367523193,
0.6046470999717712,
-0.6719867587089539,
0.6530431509017944,
-0.22576145827770233,
-0.46341967582702637,
-0.35162240266799927,
-0.26542985439300537,
0.4304688274860382,
0.6519160866737366,
0.2478516548871994,
-0.04813303425908089,
-0.3654595911502838,
-0.6880301237106323,
-0.23745770752429962,
-0.4912090003490448,
0.04994563013315201,
-0.34714463353157043,
0.338031530380249,
-0.23600582778453827,
1.1752598285675049,
-0.19749465584754944,
0.04215000569820404,
-0.184464231133461,
0.3977668583393097,
0.24306154251098633,
0.5337033271789551,
0.8392728567123413,
-0.26241979002952576,
-0.15118978917598724,
-0.2908782362937927,
-0.40348926186561584,
-0.4185112416744232,
-0.10382293164730072,
0.22487203776836395,
0.5866476893424988,
0.4747711718082428,
-0.5797756910324097,
0.33857622742652893,
0.5466536283493042,
-0.6072818636894226,
0.9610594511032104,
-0.3539925813674927,
0.38225921988487244,
-0.9518399834632874,
0.2439744621515274,
0.34274449944496155,
-0.32627424597740173,
-0.5021159648895264,
-0.3916165232658386,
0.17535144090652466,
-0.12853200733661652,
-0.07132606208324432,
0.34776580333709717,
-0.11470910161733627,
0.17355604469776154,
-0.4535197913646698,
-0.05662372708320618,
-0.09283734858036041,
-0.024073755368590355,
0.019882172346115112,
0.7804275155067444,
0.5099871158599854,
-0.6435264945030212,
0.4117823541164398,
0.18916741013526917,
-0.2428494393825531,
0.6888060569763184,
-0.9915911555290222,
0.14210233092308044,
-0.23422729969024658,
0.24267184734344482,
-1.2722235918045044,
-0.045427046716213226,
0.3148657977581024,
-0.537554919719696,
0.09546582400798798,
-0.3773149847984314,
-0.5828186869621277,
-0.2839600145816803,
-0.48477664589881897,
0.26130080223083496,
0.3093702793121338,
-0.4813462197780609,
0.29856184124946594,
0.29370686411857605,
-0.5089105367660522,
-0.5558602213859558,
-0.4902377128601074,
-0.12499218434095383,
-0.25084710121154785,
-0.6106634736061096,
-0.19671639800071716,
-0.2480204701423645,
-0.3605194091796875,
0.07756403088569641,
0.1002054363489151,
0.022510118782520294,
0.29821285605430603,
0.6152357459068298,
0.2487475425004959,
-0.23172307014465332,
0.2680038511753082,
-0.0809260681271553,
-0.46304038166999817,
0.14513163268566132,
-0.005783038213849068,
0.4105581045150757,
-0.16216839849948883,
-0.10809639096260071,
-0.37451574206352234,
0.33533230423927307,
0.6597234010696411,
-0.17612700164318085,
0.9463874101638794,
0.28293800354003906,
-0.39376431703567505,
-0.18097691237926483,
-0.2489258497953415,
-0.00777911813929677,
-0.4411373436450958,
0.30152472853660583,
-0.33916163444519043,
-0.7250831723213196,
0.8365398049354553,
0.09773935377597809,
0.14632554352283478,
0.4190203547477722,
0.40556973218917847,
-0.0956161692738533,
1.0143897533416748,
0.8293231129646301,
-0.034680504351854324,
0.3639902174472809,
0.42499032616615295,
0.15287508070468903,
-0.29229435324668884,
-0.255836546421051,
-0.9837273955345154,
0.1368715763092041,
-0.3796926736831665,
-0.17613935470581055,
0.1732882559299469,
0.2522520422935486,
-0.25439780950546265,
0.31867489218711853,
-0.41881218552589417,
0.5219524502754211,
0.4583408832550049,
-0.13634918630123138,
0.07487797737121582,
-0.2444199025630951,
-0.12321396917104721,
-0.10330983251333237,
-0.39834627509117126,
-0.9535667300224304,
0.4393085539340973,
0.4901931881904602,
0.5982171893119812,
-0.14750832319259644,
0.32440507411956787,
0.4692629277706146,
0.16501712799072266,
-0.6752007007598877,
0.534652590751648,
-0.1310281902551651,
-0.17180727422237396,
-0.3114372193813324,
-0.5274199843406677,
-0.8220942616462708,
-0.11305349320173264,
-0.19976019859313965,
-0.716171383857727,
-0.03038121946156025,
0.27132973074913025,
-0.6134894490242004,
-0.12438251823186874,
-0.5735970735549927,
1.0039290189743042,
-0.09864267706871033,
0.026164747774600983,
0.36820119619369507,
-0.6907908320426941,
0.0717850849032402,
-0.033604301512241364,
0.1854964643716812,
-0.15031082928180695,
-0.1351638287305832,
0.8876693248748779,
-0.5737325549125671,
0.8091850280761719,
-0.28478357195854187,
-0.3152141869068146,
0.21281911432743073,
0.2673843204975128,
0.3470938801765442,
0.11288830637931824,
-0.40333008766174316,
-0.04864993318915367,
0.22302067279815674,
-0.2465892732143402,
-0.5952828526496887,
0.7844109535217285,
-0.5730400085449219,
-0.15266220271587372,
-0.7891032099723816,
-0.33139488101005554,
-0.1628233939409256,
0.14367707073688507,
0.373364120721817,
0.6640980839729309,
0.02332782745361328,
0.05269499495625496,
0.49420201778411865,
-0.32843950390815735,
0.7187890410423279,
0.3217853307723999,
-0.367885947227478,
-0.6757224798202515,
0.6237001419067383,
0.3177196681499481,
0.11932820081710815,
0.018003683537244797,
0.28008535504341125,
-0.3627590537071228,
-0.5688341856002808,
-0.37308767437934875,
-0.16518336534500122,
-0.8492804169654846,
-0.34173330664634705,
-0.43515744805336,
-0.030853036791086197,
-0.13232573866844177,
-0.22097763419151306,
-0.20268090069293976,
-0.48715218901634216,
-0.32880908250808716,
-0.1917458474636078,
0.6947960257530212,
0.7509319186210632,
0.2191341668367386,
0.333143949508667,
-0.9125350117683411,
-0.051460616290569305,
-0.12429607659578323,
0.6102070808410645,
-0.3818407654762268,
-0.5855018496513367,
-0.21205756068229675,
-0.15463021397590637,
0.10812593996524811,
-0.9771880507469177,
0.11265479773283005,
0.153299018740654,
0.6069658994674683,
0.272868275642395,
0.4209290146827698,
0.36846470832824707,
-0.4603191912174225,
1.1326872110366821,
0.25740256905555725,
-1.1235342025756836,
0.7409167289733887,
-0.5441622138023376,
0.2190965712070465,
0.7378573417663574,
0.42605650424957275,
-0.7570548057556152,
-0.47337570786476135,
-0.17597272992134094,
-0.8293269872665405,
0.6931551098823547,
-0.26140642166137695,
0.06047039106488228,
-0.2732466757297516,
0.6579080820083618,
0.4980587661266327,
-0.03690218925476074,
-0.5791518092155457,
-0.10039109736680984,
-0.2434699386358261,
-0.4528938829898834,
-0.27635759115219116,
-0.5033082365989685,
0.0956151932477951,
-0.0732957273721695,
0.4560645520687103,
-0.3915637135505676,
-0.06294475495815277,
-0.002346829976886511,
-0.13391700387001038,
-0.17265452444553375,
0.041691459715366364,
0.5561420321464539,
0.8337754607200623,
-0.1458410769701004,
0.3428419232368469,
-0.209828719496727,
-0.49747976660728455,
0.3703259229660034,
0.024181412532925606,
-0.4917905032634735,
0.02740573137998581,
0.528021514415741,
0.6424521207809448,
0.2120370715856552,
-0.7035212516784668,
0.6880329251289368,
-0.3419416546821594,
0.1727181077003479,
-0.21062682569026947,
-0.1413271576166153,
-0.3118763566017151,
0.024347487837076187,
0.23896236717700958,
0.32009679079055786,
-0.2436913698911667,
-0.3562792241573334,
0.4508412778377533,
0.21092164516448975,
-0.416042685508728,
-0.5968561172485352,
0.5018766522407532,
0.42697855830192566,
-0.4770444631576538,
0.5969343781471252,
-0.41398924589157104,
-0.607083797454834,
0.435955286026001,
0.5738407969474792,
0.9704429507255554,
-0.3899611234664917,
0.5075228214263916,
0.4589940011501312,
0.4649626612663269,
-0.5975750684738159,
0.39625996351242065,
0.3938032388687134,
-0.477557897567749,
-0.3889543414115906,
-0.5499092936515808,
-0.4672240614891052,
-0.221708282828331,
-0.7202541828155518,
0.4590681195259094,
-0.5511921644210815,
-0.37649282813072205,
-0.3456941843032837,
-0.025566864758729935,
-0.05919500067830086,
0.06737573444843292,
0.07879040390253067,
0.7987745404243469,
-1.2295392751693726,
0.6738160848617554,
0.9105269312858582,
-0.548130989074707,
-0.5019581913948059,
0.15386661887168884,
-0.10658065974712372,
-0.3033638894557953,
0.3657081723213196,
0.5322693586349487,
-0.023610919713974,
-0.5209174156188965,
-0.3854735791683197,
-0.8067668080329895,
0.7789655327796936,
0.6891394853591919,
-0.5714117884635925,
0.3440680503845215,
-0.2097432166337967,
0.7606834173202515,
-0.17857907712459564,
0.46236947178840637,
0.425629585981369,
0.31299495697021484,
-0.17579296231269836,
-1.1560571193695068,
0.23949852585792542,
-0.4395456314086914,
-0.027946114540100098,
0.21686503291130066,
-0.43714576959609985,
0.7444655895233154,
-0.22814691066741943,
-0.17594300210475922,
0.586283266544342,
0.5248337388038635,
0.5333608388900757,
0.5396168828010559,
0.5501202344894409,
0.47551026940345764,
0.9655246734619141,
-0.40820831060409546,
1.0501559972763062,
-0.3592911660671234,
0.4241980016231537,
0.7946662902832031,
-0.037951041013002396,
0.8237854838371277,
0.30348846316337585,
0.0014023687690496445,
0.3986014723777771,
0.766154408454895,
-0.08810131251811981,
0.308998167514801,
0.2453484684228897,
0.07449921220541,
-0.2727351188659668,
-0.1996280997991562,
-0.32189568877220154,
0.12088306993246078,
0.04426183924078941,
-0.35139861702919006,
-0.023500192910432816,
0.22367490828037262,
0.0868929848074913,
0.127419114112854,
-0.32749035954475403,
0.5532403588294983,
-0.08088155090808868,
-0.6477632522583008,
0.40277767181396484,
-0.4131433367729187,
0.5304916501045227,
-0.5261631608009338,
-0.038069773465394974,
-0.14016471803188324,
0.2637921869754791,
-0.19979603588581085,
-0.9909178018569946,
0.25215986371040344,
0.07989044487476349,
-0.5423860549926758,
-0.18841750919818878,
0.6784709692001343,
-0.32281798124313354,
-0.5551016926765442,
0.23028455674648285,
0.20019343495368958,
0.07858486473560333,
0.16450415551662445,
-0.24230597913265228,
0.5510669946670532,
-0.47179630398750305,
-0.20130681991577148,
0.3404993712902069,
0.7395821809768677,
-0.031190522015094757,
0.6991546750068665,
0.13566792011260986,
0.08762368559837341,
0.17359833419322968,
0.03493158146739006,
0.7337969541549683,
-0.6321117877960205,
-0.48198214173316956,
-0.9198856353759766,
0.671529233455658,
-0.061879515647888184,
-0.7124843001365662,
1.1089160442352295,
0.2584857642650604,
0.34676310420036316,
0.13561342656612396,
0.7846173048019409,
0.06131329759955406,
0.440662682056427,
-0.45939892530441284,
0.5371050238609314,
-0.005670723505318165,
0.47105327248573303,
-0.5519494414329529,
-0.9600658416748047,
-0.6683967113494873,
0.47839102149009705,
-0.18097816407680511,
-0.15375617146492004,
0.6290599703788757,
0.45732730627059937,
0.43461909890174866,
0.17440713942050934,
-0.022538509219884872,
0.16881848871707916,
0.38048067688941956,
0.1945601850748062,
1.2941005229949951,
-0.07673089951276779,
0.46256235241889954,
-0.3733918368816376,
-0.42097198963165283,
-0.23223677277565002,
-1.1154617071151733,
-0.881377637386322,
-0.6926873326301575,
-0.6407349705696106,
-0.738033652305603,
0.10388467460870743,
0.9828490614891052,
0.4258241057395935,
-0.8479124307632446,
0.1772938370704651,
0.04206395149230957,
-0.09035750478506088,
-0.3547792136669159,
-0.17198914289474487,
0.5435665845870972,
-0.7302786111831665,
-0.3599080443382263,
0.23054079711437225,
0.378447026014328,
0.0037854821421205997,
-0.14319299161434174,
0.03665035218000412,
0.3724425435066223,
-0.10624329745769501,
0.4393513798713684,
0.3406676650047302,
-0.58021479845047,
-0.6706385016441345,
0.013027992099523544,
-0.09211360663175583,
-0.14175070822238922,
0.833061933517456,
-0.7880987524986267,
0.4178500175476074,
0.6726422309875488,
0.6903964877128601,
-0.5966595411300659,
0.23481252789497375,
0.6623739004135132,
-0.684708297252655,
-0.07994765043258667,
0.42062103748321533,
0.7218978404998779,
0.44846001267433167,
-0.2565914988517761,
0.10479050874710083,
0.25027796626091003,
-1.0379819869995117,
-0.9445239305496216,
0.06972146779298782,
-0.9544070959091187,
-0.012568983249366283,
1.2360950708389282,
-0.5843285322189331,
-0.12912671267986298,
-0.30829572677612305,
-0.4750610888004303,
-0.09590213000774384,
-0.585811972618103,
0.8354818224906921,
0.7108926773071289,
-0.05494261533021927,
-0.24411334097385406,
-0.0075857448391616344,
0.5529177188873291,
0.1986168920993805,
-0.572047233581543,
0.2673681676387787,
0.6780300736427307,
0.3648822009563446,
0.5913496613502502,
0.6445220708847046,
0.04407430440187454,
0.37186357378959656,
0.06930878758430481,
-0.24256637692451477,
0.048962485045194626,
-0.4362926781177521,
-0.7858717441558838,
0.42926767468452454,
0.27765217423439026,
-0.23761017620563507
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02030v1 | Breaking Bias, Building Bridges: Evaluation and Mitigation of Social Biases in LLMs via Contact Hypothesis | 2024-07-02T07:58:46 | 2024-07-02T07:58:46 | Chahat Raj, Anjishnu Mukherjee, Aylin Caliskan, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Ziwei Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) perpetuate social biases, reflecting prejudices
in their training data and reinforcing societal stereotypes and inequalities.
Our work explores the potential of the Contact Hypothesis, a concept from
social psychology for debiasing LLMs. We simulate various forms of social
contact through LLM prompting to measure their influence on the model's biases,
mirroring how intergroup interactions can reduce prejudices in social contexts.
We create a dataset of 108,000 prompts following a principled approach
replicating social contact to measure biases in three LLMs (LLaMA 2, Tulu, and
NousHermes) across 13 social bias dimensions. We propose a unique debiasing
technique, Social Contact Debiasing (SCD), that instruction-tunes these models
with unbiased responses to prompts. Our research demonstrates that LLM
responses exhibit social biases when subject to contact probing, but more
importantly, these biases can be significantly reduced by up to 40% in 1 epoch
of instruction tuning LLaMA 2 following our SCD strategy. Our code and data are
available at https://github.com/chahatraj/breakingbias. | [
-0.4306691884994507,
-0.9230830073356628,
0.5321648120880127,
0.30125200748443604,
-0.12765727937221527,
0.37903451919555664,
-0.2089897096157074,
-0.4628309905529022,
0.47855138778686523,
0.5283434391021729,
-0.4711802005767822,
-0.544740617275238,
-0.6307036876678467,
-0.06930217146873474,
-0.23166242241859436,
0.6853876113891602,
0.03635615482926369,
0.4450683891773224,
-0.3017721176147461,
-0.14323914051055908,
-0.2502692639827728,
-0.4917990565299988,
-0.41787809133529663,
-0.5385427474975586,
0.6914284825325012,
0.7302039265632629,
0.4911089241504669,
0.40213826298713684,
0.3822346031665802,
0.1814335137605667,
-0.41342613101005554,
0.10508943349123001,
-0.6405549049377441,
-0.04064793512225151,
-0.23031120002269745,
-0.7288886904716492,
-0.08883841335773468,
0.2953178882598877,
0.4752104878425598,
1.0050888061523438,
0.0954224243760109,
0.33190470933914185,
0.3471737205982208,
0.7578257918357849,
-0.5247219204902649,
0.13323745131492615,
-0.4388837218284607,
0.016178114339709282,
-0.5017176270484924,
-0.02328842133283615,
-0.3947941064834595,
-0.5445786714553833,
-0.04438861086964607,
-0.030837399885058403,
0.3345904052257538,
0.0652802512049675,
0.5705196261405945,
0.14114566147327423,
-0.548838198184967,
0.040500301867723465,
-0.46425896883010864,
0.6167660355567932,
-0.5593046545982361,
0.4472431540489197,
0.73907870054245,
-0.040074001997709274,
-0.11937107145786285,
0.09879469871520996,
-0.3619391918182373,
-0.39616650342941284,
0.27140066027641296,
-0.16988711059093475,
0.26787069439888,
0.17848922312259674,
0.7209120392799377,
0.14535099267959595,
-0.05195067450404167,
0.020446402952075005,
-0.6025709509849548,
0.14893341064453125,
0.6834405660629272,
0.030794808641076088,
0.31364285945892334,
-0.045667681843042374,
-0.24977393448352814,
0.04685818776488304,
-1.0704904794692993,
0.004645165521651506,
0.6941016316413879,
0.09459932148456573,
-0.4628170430660248,
0.6065411567687988,
-0.2754514217376709,
0.26001712679862976,
0.30556124448776245,
0.02335404045879841,
0.3529489040374756,
-0.010394822806119919,
0.047559741884469986,
0.09070097655057907,
0.5971643924713135,
0.7541511058807373,
0.6261791586875916,
-0.2522885799407959,
0.20589886605739594,
0.4765010178089142,
0.009006150998175144,
-0.5912395715713501,
0.08585367351770401,
-0.09740883111953735,
-0.4030746817588806,
-0.663358211517334,
-0.18634198606014252,
-0.8540257811546326,
-0.7980130910873413,
-0.28552088141441345,
-0.059817537665367126,
-0.14524339139461517,
-0.3443346619606018,
-0.04106305167078972,
-0.03546670079231262,
0.3055523931980133,
0.10999101400375366,
-0.8954616189002991,
0.3120652735233307,
0.41159823536872864,
0.8847400546073914,
-0.10883249342441559,
-0.1909996122121811,
-0.5773509740829468,
-0.027118565514683723,
-0.22295188903808594,
0.7222508192062378,
-0.6784861087799072,
-0.6689500212669373,
0.17165476083755493,
-0.0865921899676323,
0.10787131637334824,
-0.6310997009277344,
0.39003121852874756,
-0.4064195156097412,
-0.18018943071365356,
-0.6450947523117065,
-0.35164353251457214,
0.22318726778030396,
0.3134547173976898,
-0.5816420316696167,
0.9832190275192261,
-0.10431499779224396,
-0.9177807569503784,
0.2809562087059021,
-0.5025718212127686,
-0.5092244744300842,
-0.2450827807188034,
-0.22100362181663513,
-0.08879494667053223,
0.20125815272331238,
0.05785629525780678,
0.1320219188928604,
-0.5623083710670471,
0.19696977734565735,
-1.0671716928482056,
-0.3566366732120514,
0.09093284606933594,
-0.1953875571489334,
0.9287503361701965,
-0.030085356906056404,
-0.6514718532562256,
0.035346128046512604,
-0.4876992702484131,
-0.4178771376609802,
0.14506657421588898,
-0.24797150492668152,
-0.5341444611549377,
0.11041068285703659,
-0.1473618447780609,
0.19597098231315613,
-0.07992765307426453,
-0.7757250070571899,
0.25527438521385193,
-0.2911689579486847,
0.23215430974960327,
0.9846799373626709,
-0.06348173320293427,
0.5077743530273438,
-0.3517650067806244,
0.4170186519622803,
0.1448790431022644,
0.27424079179763794,
0.3223320245742798,
-0.1665154993534088,
-0.9183054566383362,
0.21071742475032806,
0.18868888914585114,
0.3880498707294464,
-0.8216912150382996,
0.03455006703734398,
0.10894094407558441,
-0.5997292995452881,
-0.47090309858322144,
0.4805490970611572,
0.48968544602394104,
0.378736287355423,
0.1369081735610962,
-0.4496338665485382,
-0.5557886958122253,
-0.820516049861908,
-0.5045181512832642,
-0.14756028354167938,
0.016552308574318886,
0.28036513924598694,
0.2675504684448242,
-0.22367559373378754,
0.7418628334999084,
-0.32000067830085754,
-0.09629149734973907,
-0.12406796216964722,
-0.23954488337039948,
-0.10464531928300858,
0.2197207510471344,
0.2705283761024475,
-0.4786854386329651,
-0.5612162351608276,
-0.4969719350337982,
-0.8170690536499023,
-0.5313630700111389,
0.27793973684310913,
-0.16806095838546753,
0.19543105363845825,
0.7562820315361023,
-0.5357791185379028,
0.5479404330253601,
0.46669116616249084,
-0.5408486723899841,
0.6352160573005676,
0.3255052864551544,
0.11528905481100082,
-0.8653916716575623,
-0.3687840402126312,
0.4763432443141937,
0.18445630371570587,
-0.43757522106170654,
-0.3046249747276306,
-0.10908112674951553,
0.1693701297044754,
-0.45588499307632446,
0.5377121567726135,
-0.7019504904747009,
0.017059285193681717,
-0.11576254665851593,
0.24414245784282684,
-0.1325291246175766,
0.20736004412174225,
-0.14043673872947693,
0.4130173921585083,
0.45560958981513977,
-0.36879652738571167,
0.23488278687000275,
0.42359602451324463,
-0.5940959453582764,
0.6805282235145569,
-0.8277738690376282,
0.42251691222190857,
-0.18413971364498138,
0.2387668639421463,
-0.9868902564048767,
-0.03593495860695839,
0.2912444770336151,
-0.22140398621559143,
-0.036605190485715866,
-0.1631796956062317,
-0.4299238622188568,
-0.2171488106250763,
-0.6514570116996765,
0.46588408946990967,
0.2734919488430023,
-0.6944969892501831,
0.3250957727432251,
0.636434018611908,
-0.1746583729982376,
-0.5221356153488159,
-0.5683236718177795,
0.13494539260864258,
-0.42830973863601685,
-0.6695111989974976,
0.15908902883529663,
-0.15388213098049164,
-0.816936731338501,
-0.3439798057079315,
-0.1475081741809845,
0.30321669578552246,
0.10067692399024963,
0.44767341017723083,
0.3033835291862488,
0.28281402587890625,
-0.08587951213121414,
0.06528979539871216,
0.10089275240898132,
0.3878334164619446,
0.3090495467185974,
0.773716151714325,
0.17904017865657806,
-0.7502048015594482,
-0.06796716153621674,
0.16990415751934052,
0.6940964460372925,
-0.06836991012096405,
0.5438421368598938,
0.12708024680614471,
-0.21085447072982788,
-0.12255886197090149,
-0.9706411957740784,
-0.4749700725078583,
-0.47242769598960876,
0.10731370002031326,
-0.21480903029441833,
-0.9392248392105103,
0.3645334243774414,
-0.22921137511730194,
-0.11858459562063217,
-0.24967995285987854,
0.4590831696987152,
-0.09019961953163147,
0.8466234803199768,
0.767810583114624,
-0.5121600031852722,
0.6526257395744324,
0.040560148656368256,
0.2855014503002167,
-0.9619568586349487,
-0.20479311048984528,
-0.37945517897605896,
-0.34901654720306396,
-0.46002882719039917,
-0.6342798471450806,
0.23977331817150116,
0.20732390880584717,
-0.1841692477464676,
-0.08152535557746887,
-0.20529796183109283,
0.7014997005462646,
0.6197067499160767,
0.4089485704898834,
0.29696816205978394,
-0.0718500092625618,
-0.2380407154560089,
-0.04384692385792732,
-0.5273597240447998,
-0.5426483750343323,
1.1913108825683594,
0.5265341401100159,
1.0022740364074707,
-0.023220237344503403,
0.7963298559188843,
0.4382779598236084,
0.5093011260032654,
-0.5365395545959473,
0.6156545281410217,
0.4151408076286316,
-0.4615546464920044,
-0.22093500196933746,
-0.3455981910228729,
-0.6136340498924255,
0.15267492830753326,
-0.2155659794807434,
-0.8643732666969299,
0.3341851234436035,
0.0386011116206646,
-0.016479965299367905,
0.4156741201877594,
-0.5300899744033813,
0.3508193790912628,
-0.1930713802576065,
-0.8287615776062012,
-0.3269079625606537,
-0.6606018543243408,
0.6233165264129639,
0.114513099193573,
0.34966516494750977,
-0.3200811445713043,
0.47138383984565735,
0.7267186641693115,
-0.34765103459358215,
1.5263381004333496,
-0.34624260663986206,
-0.35436829924583435,
0.28473353385925293,
0.0038859795313328505,
0.5396853089332581,
-0.007460869383066893,
-0.2409936487674713,
0.41024601459503174,
-0.10021147131919861,
-0.41834643483161926,
-0.283299058675766,
0.6294500231742859,
-0.6808050870895386,
-0.6049793362617493,
-0.25148117542266846,
-0.6508494019508362,
-0.37034130096435547,
-0.06944236904382706,
0.007377310656011105,
0.12591324746608734,
-0.4204234182834625,
0.10774368792772293,
0.716327428817749,
-0.1582019329071045,
0.1910380721092224,
0.5398906469345093,
-0.16248349845409393,
-0.2967008948326111,
0.47419053316116333,
0.2133992314338684,
0.4679807722568512,
-0.2695459723472595,
0.06972187012434006,
-0.3128226101398468,
-0.22135832905769348,
-0.18154798448085785,
0.37972959876060486,
-0.3735008239746094,
-0.013196281157433987,
-0.3989339768886566,
-0.01709536463022232,
-0.6663282513618469,
-0.04422234371304512,
-0.1151341125369072,
-0.07052634656429291,
0.1859949380159378,
-0.4619872272014618,
0.21644285321235657,
0.8173761367797852,
-0.38714680075645447,
0.2949986755847931,
-0.5261862874031067,
0.28260037302970886,
0.21061035990715027,
0.4219842851161957,
-0.05551201477646828,
-0.3287685513496399,
-0.31763672828674316,
0.05000155791640282,
-0.3696383237838745,
-1.1735774278640747,
0.06844601780176163,
-0.34428703784942627,
0.4230983853340149,
0.5362820625305176,
0.2802838087081909,
0.294026255607605,
-0.5601726770401001,
0.4477308988571167,
0.21845786273479462,
-1.0320639610290527,
0.4422178864479065,
-0.5372936129570007,
-0.00046436922275461257,
0.6155856251716614,
0.3796887993812561,
-0.6972086429595947,
-0.4237646460533142,
-0.7694807648658752,
-0.779094398021698,
0.4409417510032654,
-0.3032042384147644,
0.06140756234526634,
-0.3048810362815857,
0.3506239354610443,
-0.41183608770370483,
0.1751987487077713,
-0.6159665584564209,
-0.3175993859767914,
0.34704816341400146,
-0.08466340601444244,
-0.07901698350906372,
-0.8357049226760864,
-0.48020118474960327,
-0.2230224907398224,
0.5655772089958191,
0.006182380951941013,
-0.3138349950313568,
0.19238974153995514,
-0.21615828573703766,
-0.2919144928455353,
0.10553343594074249,
0.38329049944877625,
0.48752906918525696,
-0.01028961967676878,
0.2651151418685913,
0.5039656162261963,
-0.3732827603816986,
0.2987994849681854,
-0.13309429585933685,
-0.36349329352378845,
-0.036347534507513046,
0.06819119304418564,
0.5863454341888428,
0.10637860745191574,
-0.5084220767021179,
0.3268849849700928,
0.14830920100212097,
-0.19264817237854004,
-0.12636925280094147,
-0.03188672661781311,
0.36581093072891235,
0.4254061281681061,
0.08686312288045883,
-0.4301983416080475,
-0.11640584468841553,
-0.5532093048095703,
0.27939513325691223,
0.6293746829032898,
-0.61380934715271,
-0.31606653332710266,
0.5178959965705872,
0.6366032361984253,
-0.5667080879211426,
0.27531301975250244,
-0.07656155526638031,
-0.5673953294754028,
0.4787403345108032,
0.5421289801597595,
0.6169564723968506,
-0.44315192103385925,
0.21077176928520203,
0.2019270807504654,
0.5996341705322266,
-0.061168916523456573,
0.10394839942455292,
-0.11418777704238892,
-1.1443607807159424,
-0.48636865615844727,
-0.41281867027282715,
-0.7898407578468323,
0.11547762900590897,
-0.8249555826187134,
0.39927077293395996,
-0.5146998763084412,
-0.03668740764260292,
-0.3096654713153839,
0.11633722484111786,
-0.41365790367126465,
-0.13406533002853394,
0.30884402990341187,
1.0643627643585205,
-1.2122817039489746,
0.7668701410293579,
0.48520633578300476,
-0.44863784313201904,
-0.46736201643943787,
0.10265082865953445,
0.4118186831474304,
-0.7687788009643555,
0.7805099487304688,
0.33882662653923035,
-0.19718186557292938,
-0.19311729073524475,
-0.7107216715812683,
-0.6312443017959595,
0.69725501537323,
0.5688102841377258,
-0.7202920913696289,
0.04686162620782852,
0.43353402614593506,
-0.0031242261175066233,
-0.11814470589160919,
0.37999293208122253,
1.0952152013778687,
0.4725227952003479,
-0.26863521337509155,
-0.9168241620063782,
0.2366696447134018,
-0.35397276282310486,
-0.10889473557472229,
0.09805832803249359,
-1.083508014678955,
0.4084246754646301,
-0.49067553877830505,
-0.008989399299025536,
-0.24397142231464386,
0.3853852152824402,
0.50772625207901,
0.39928552508354187,
0.8714584112167358,
0.7087585926055908,
0.7246464490890503,
0.03223898261785507,
0.5281767845153809,
-0.470755010843277,
0.17740178108215332,
1.1720452308654785,
-0.7552529573440552,
0.3619135618209839,
0.8095433712005615,
-0.14058242738246918,
0.5245386958122253,
0.585983157157898,
0.12817227840423584,
0.29260000586509705,
0.851470947265625,
-0.5570911765098572,
-0.02577928826212883,
-0.47347477078437805,
-0.3643590807914734,
0.35069042444229126,
0.25790318846702576,
-0.23682159185409546,
-0.269547700881958,
-0.05459824576973915,
0.36436399817466736,
0.1843889206647873,
-0.10972049087285995,
0.5175454020500183,
0.28354254364967346,
-0.38021615147590637,
0.30832189321517944,
-0.33271339535713196,
0.8843552470207214,
-0.3929820656776428,
-0.0661492794752121,
-0.47755399346351624,
0.14167705178260803,
-0.31802380084991455,
-0.46734997630119324,
0.22734183073043823,
0.05541425570845604,
-0.35459864139556885,
-0.20081904530525208,
0.8603783249855042,
-0.5371474623680115,
-0.2775191068649292,
0.7312954068183899,
0.6224426031112671,
0.13193701207637787,
-0.1747228354215622,
-0.5006589889526367,
0.48406341671943665,
0.20263224840164185,
-0.33311188220977783,
0.5771056413650513,
0.3587418794631958,
-0.019685493782162666,
0.666816771030426,
0.7162674069404602,
0.184183269739151,
-0.1563100814819336,
0.4072164297103882,
0.9272807240486145,
-0.7722508907318115,
0.045129306614398956,
-0.9572799205780029,
0.3497845232486725,
-0.3649538457393646,
-0.18449681997299194,
0.9817062616348267,
0.43050625920295715,
0.7800936698913574,
0.22918887436389923,
0.9012003540992737,
0.2080884426832199,
0.49143651127815247,
-0.19995339214801788,
0.6619967222213745,
-0.04159459099173546,
0.35763686895370483,
-0.486941397190094,
-0.9406654834747314,
0.04304582625627518,
0.5895516276359558,
-0.7004223465919495,
-0.1781398057937622,
0.46667394042015076,
1.03081214427948,
0.16315284371376038,
-0.005851975176483393,
0.2920399010181427,
0.2889835238456726,
0.3065810799598694,
0.36543506383895874,
1.0763431787490845,
-0.1893869936466217,
0.3061498999595642,
-0.30603092908859253,
-0.5364795923233032,
0.009038768708705902,
-0.6961904764175415,
-1.1878553628921509,
-0.16456341743469238,
-0.28581568598747253,
-0.8369439840316772,
0.18821635842323303,
0.916354775428772,
0.4374043941497803,
-0.35342535376548767,
-0.559177041053772,
0.12405145168304443,
0.35310375690460205,
0.3302329182624817,
-0.26610368490219116,
0.09065885096788406,
-0.5348429083824158,
-0.7392587065696716,
0.45723238587379456,
0.15687522292137146,
-0.17634519934654236,
-0.47879618406295776,
-0.02510790526866913,
-0.2014859914779663,
0.09351782500743866,
0.7646217942237854,
0.20495526492595673,
-0.34021803736686707,
-0.43724358081817627,
-0.052207399159669876,
0.004007613752037287,
-0.02830597572028637,
0.49795660376548767,
-0.5244578719139099,
0.06920932233333588,
0.25746431946754456,
0.5236089825630188,
0.5209596753120422,
0.006110091228038073,
0.6940671801567078,
-0.4904066026210785,
0.24276575446128845,
-0.08301382511854172,
0.42935776710510254,
0.45707252621650696,
-0.3179641366004944,
0.8586642742156982,
0.4458024501800537,
-0.4840215742588043,
-1.114513635635376,
0.4725567102432251,
-0.6890660524368286,
0.06083465367555618,
1.5831189155578613,
0.1248120665550232,
-0.24555104970932007,
-0.2650073170661926,
-0.25910305976867676,
0.25041210651397705,
-0.26013368368148804,
1.2438825368881226,
0.7321609854698181,
0.018300995230674744,
-0.000675581453833729,
-0.48478275537490845,
0.3696194887161255,
0.7516466975212097,
-0.7480577826499939,
0.19355374574661255,
0.5276783108711243,
0.5303096771240234,
0.15706926584243774,
0.8221859335899353,
-0.08524371683597565,
-0.05590452253818512,
-0.1505902260541916,
0.44401830434799194,
0.24054394662380219,
-0.1797158122062683,
-0.13353665173053741,
-0.1391267478466034,
0.11246484518051147,
-0.17438343167304993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02028v1 | Why does in-context learning fail sometimes? Evaluating in-context learning on open and closed questions | 2024-07-02T07:52:30 | 2024-07-02T07:52:30 | Xiang Li, Haoran Tang, Siyu Chen, Ziwei Wang, Ryan Chen, Marcin Abram | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | We measure the performance of in-context learning as a function of task
novelty and difficulty for open and closed questions. For that purpose, we
created a novel benchmark consisting of hard scientific questions, each paired
with a context of various relevancy. We show that counter-intuitively, a
context that is more aligned with the topic does not always help more than a
less relevant context. This effect is especially visible for open questions and
questions of high difficulty or novelty. This result reveals a fundamental
difference between the treatment of close-form and open-form questions by
large-language models and shows a need for a more robust evaluation of
in-context learning on the variety of different types of questions. It also
poses a new question of how to optimally select a context for large language
models, especially in the context of Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
systems. Our results suggest that the answer to this question can be highly
application-dependent and might be contingent on factors including the format
of the question, the perceived difficulty level of the questions, and the
novelty or popularity of the information we seek. | [
-0.46099501848220825,
-1.000093698501587,
0.6813961863517761,
0.027244245633482933,
-0.14449414610862732,
-0.15643160045146942,
-0.5586748123168945,
-0.3165847957134247,
-0.4415407180786133,
-0.04012920707464218,
-0.34698551893234253,
-0.1271960735321045,
-0.3431183397769928,
0.3051954209804535,
-0.24000366032123566,
1.1489129066467285,
-0.2353365421295166,
0.06402509659528732,
-0.941727340221405,
-0.5714078545570374,
-0.5716538429260254,
-0.5754427909851074,
-0.6695396900177002,
-0.35036954283714294,
0.41504666209220886,
0.6259920001029968,
0.17544426023960114,
0.07435645908117294,
0.6850072741508484,
0.1943621188402176,
-0.29446521401405334,
0.13107311725616455,
-0.6433954238891602,
0.42176586389541626,
-0.3684285581111908,
-0.583314061164856,
0.3078106641769409,
-0.015908660367131233,
0.7514504194259644,
1.4116318225860596,
0.11781470477581024,
0.30595913529396057,
0.29823923110961914,
0.6538949012756348,
-0.8905666470527649,
-0.11895585060119629,
-0.6822732090950012,
-0.040988169610500336,
-0.2535558044910431,
-0.2656245529651642,
-0.2475232034921646,
-0.3380320370197296,
0.42617514729499817,
-0.35518455505371094,
0.3539178669452667,
-0.15895995497703552,
0.6127535700798035,
0.23030409216880798,
-0.6267105937004089,
-0.5774365663528442,
-0.7905541658401489,
0.8746498227119446,
-0.16830924153327942,
0.38310322165489197,
0.1929551064968109,
0.42944490909576416,
-0.3366208076477051,
-0.5114816427230835,
-0.39674675464630127,
-0.39554616808891296,
0.12470808625221252,
0.10089411586523056,
0.14818532764911652,
-0.5048522353172302,
0.5424782037734985,
0.2735331952571869,
-0.4339727759361267,
-0.19965513050556183,
-0.5080521106719971,
0.19875115156173706,
0.16168324649333954,
0.18904778361320496,
0.0359019860625267,
-0.03654509782791138,
-0.5738236308097839,
-0.2646309435367584,
-0.8568745851516724,
0.599209725856781,
0.2508274018764496,
0.30493396520614624,
0.07782791554927826,
0.42675867676734924,
-0.19594885408878326,
0.8727169036865234,
0.041907720267772675,
-0.04863862693309784,
0.15255104005336761,
-0.0848935917019844,
0.01351037248969078,
-0.20414133369922638,
0.3853924870491028,
0.19729100167751312,
-0.07651189714670181,
-0.13434165716171265,
-0.3244796693325043,
-0.2705625891685486,
0.25293979048728943,
-0.6581518054008484,
0.21029533445835114,
0.1670108288526535,
-0.23529326915740967,
0.00798771996051073,
0.373309463262558,
-0.55503910779953,
-0.03427927568554878,
-0.14707854390144348,
0.6164495348930359,
-0.29850125312805176,
0.0008844737894833088,
-0.09724348783493042,
-0.2740647494792938,
0.2399013638496399,
0.42811262607574463,
-0.7893418669700623,
0.44162052869796753,
0.5434732437133789,
0.6320167779922485,
-0.506199061870575,
-0.2564123570919037,
-0.600957989692688,
-0.11494996398687363,
-0.31493255496025085,
0.8111466765403748,
-0.5820796489715576,
-0.36144310235977173,
-0.1697445660829544,
0.10790867358446121,
-0.264486700296402,
-0.9171003699302673,
0.24382981657981873,
-0.5855306386947632,
0.47174906730651855,
-0.6984608769416809,
-0.42182108759880066,
-0.08535841107368469,
0.38942375779151917,
-0.36903396248817444,
0.9293733835220337,
0.3300570547580719,
-0.762864887714386,
0.7211722731590271,
-0.5938503742218018,
-0.28721585869789124,
0.008303766138851643,
-0.3171094059944153,
-0.1731027364730835,
0.3622731864452362,
-0.41129061579704285,
0.24332493543624878,
-0.4407200217247009,
0.21411649882793427,
-0.2069644331932068,
-0.6363365054130554,
0.6231397390365601,
-0.2907348871231079,
0.6551812887191772,
0.2185683399438858,
-0.4848845303058624,
-0.17978361248970032,
-0.5969541668891907,
0.04379095137119293,
0.15889477729797363,
-0.5592207312583923,
-0.8178362846374512,
0.03234301880002022,
0.0028615714982151985,
-0.023671720176935196,
0.2573170065879822,
-0.7348246574401855,
0.03901991248130798,
-0.30909040570259094,
0.27187976241111755,
0.49672043323516846,
0.032481446862220764,
0.4052383303642273,
-0.2974116802215576,
0.3153482973575592,
0.04419710487127304,
-0.06893308460712433,
-0.0986492931842804,
-0.5261797904968262,
-0.213426873087883,
0.3826253414154053,
0.1707126796245575,
0.3157445788383484,
-0.4799967408180237,
-0.2456093579530716,
0.1276412308216095,
-0.5734657645225525,
-0.16140305995941162,
0.1993514895439148,
0.6580588221549988,
1.11319899559021,
0.41331663727760315,
-0.5601807832717896,
-0.2928793430328369,
-0.6455418467521667,
-0.3148254454135895,
-0.02891029603779316,
0.08407501876354218,
0.8747173547744751,
0.7795459628105164,
0.042438000440597534,
1.0628199577331543,
-0.4818327724933624,
0.12695781886577606,
0.014996110461652279,
0.021492771804332733,
0.19018609821796417,
0.48772308230400085,
0.5179892182350159,
-1.1659469604492188,
-0.5298634171485901,
0.11961093544960022,
-1.0550459623336792,
0.008597138337790966,
0.1588282436132431,
0.26175639033317566,
0.19008275866508484,
0.6400255560874939,
-0.4680313766002655,
0.16658039391040802,
0.19984231889247894,
-0.10711902379989624,
0.5247182250022888,
-0.24953438341617584,
0.11682774871587753,
-0.844731867313385,
0.4486481845378876,
-0.01869487762451172,
0.22362129390239716,
-0.5764951109886169,
0.24371236562728882,
0.19286896288394928,
-0.09296998381614685,
-0.7152345180511475,
0.7195621132850647,
-0.25442221760749817,
-0.08745058625936508,
-0.12385690957307816,
0.16808471083641052,
-0.08138401061296463,
0.23304283618927002,
-0.30727440118789673,
0.7603049874305725,
0.415073961019516,
-0.8484645485877991,
0.11521755903959274,
0.18797127902507782,
-0.531834602355957,
0.5947443246841431,
-0.847173810005188,
0.2210761308670044,
-0.42324304580688477,
0.2750012278556824,
-0.9250215888023376,
-0.5919044017791748,
-0.03365105763077736,
-0.20538939535617828,
0.42960095405578613,
0.09838524460792542,
-0.1179778054356575,
-0.20407384634017944,
-0.07866507768630981,
0.9611864686012268,
0.3458264172077179,
-0.8089221119880676,
0.008340008556842804,
0.08743519335985184,
0.18274666368961334,
-0.7818900942802429,
-0.4484497904777527,
-0.37307289242744446,
-0.40536853671073914,
-0.46004217863082886,
0.26197946071624756,
-0.24578824639320374,
-0.5870196223258972,
0.16869854927062988,
-0.4100205600261688,
-0.026530634611845016,
0.4037192463874817,
0.16387563943862915,
-0.003030891064554453,
-0.34527072310447693,
0.3039185106754303,
-0.1317826360464096,
0.19900284707546234,
0.07421829551458359,
-0.17565259337425232,
0.3176014721393585,
-0.33158618211746216,
-0.5600852966308594,
0.3057742118835449,
0.5869210958480835,
0.4147930443286896,
-0.07813121378421783,
0.8357923626899719,
0.14278726279735565,
-0.3984309136867523,
-0.3704141676425934,
-0.3427095413208008,
-0.29408004879951477,
-0.4022764563560486,
0.3366689682006836,
-0.4701865315437317,
-1.0786479711532593,
0.5421515107154846,
-0.033168140798807144,
-0.13490904867649078,
0.445731520652771,
0.46667784452438354,
-0.3315553069114685,
0.7751240134239197,
0.4911750257015228,
0.5183659791946411,
0.3546065390110016,
-0.3077343702316284,
-0.01029294729232788,
-0.8688986897468567,
-0.49179723858833313,
-0.7049347162246704,
-0.22172361612319946,
-0.6195303797721863,
0.02062847465276718,
0.7654536366462708,
0.29105812311172485,
-0.3749622702598572,
0.1377580463886261,
-0.45115235447883606,
0.4763377606868744,
0.5826839208602905,
0.11094848066568375,
0.15317489206790924,
-0.08580535650253296,
-0.2558881342411041,
0.09158448129892349,
-0.7488654255867004,
-0.4677528738975525,
1.2069916725158691,
0.07619552314281464,
0.6909253597259521,
0.18956758081912994,
0.6162915229797363,
-0.30195149779319763,
0.4573596715927124,
-0.6273807287216187,
0.28375008702278137,
0.007669336162507534,
-0.7593594789505005,
-0.4927613437175751,
-0.5149747133255005,
-1.2459474802017212,
0.4057742953300476,
0.0165189728140831,
-0.5819171071052551,
0.272541344165802,
-0.017119331285357475,
-0.25175783038139343,
0.21253646910190582,
-0.8422024250030518,
0.9582934975624084,
-0.08774793148040771,
-0.5375787019729614,
0.3215201497077942,
-0.7793583273887634,
0.3793788552284241,
-0.3765544593334198,
0.18157845735549927,
0.2658102512359619,
-0.04609675705432892,
0.7837338447570801,
-0.26459261775016785,
0.577374279499054,
-0.17601917684078217,
0.22409681975841522,
0.4816707372665405,
-0.15159748494625092,
0.011901798658072948,
0.15357452630996704,
-0.0010238036047667265,
-0.19697315990924835,
-0.009228771552443504,
-0.3902938663959503,
-0.9491066932678223,
0.6167452931404114,
-0.5486258864402771,
-0.7655778527259827,
-0.5118736028671265,
-0.4462678134441376,
-0.35489094257354736,
0.09344460815191269,
0.5293275117874146,
0.7043882608413696,
-0.27617135643959045,
0.7459157109260559,
0.9606006741523743,
-0.27424100041389465,
0.4549005329608917,
0.3894587457180023,
0.19085253775119781,
-0.05761612951755524,
0.8051984310150146,
0.2119835615158081,
0.5714474320411682,
0.28418663144111633,
0.3996984362602234,
-0.11414580792188644,
-0.3727319836616516,
-0.42783668637275696,
0.1603473424911499,
-0.8626238107681274,
-0.09673702716827393,
-0.4930787682533264,
0.011005406267940998,
-0.0559777207672596,
-0.04048822075128555,
-0.06606582552194595,
-0.11748651415109634,
-0.31807923316955566,
0.32316046953201294,
0.06543952971696854,
0.8500954508781433,
0.09235712885856628,
-0.2058359682559967,
-0.5154997110366821,
0.0784577876329422,
0.5663155913352966,
0.4658331573009491,
0.13252776861190796,
-0.5933533310890198,
-0.33212676644325256,
-0.0634751096367836,
-0.6300851106643677,
-0.8218585848808289,
-0.18414565920829773,
0.2745778262615204,
0.6652607917785645,
0.19699066877365112,
0.06361950188875198,
0.2929445207118988,
-0.5047256350517273,
0.8096967935562134,
-0.062206726521253586,
-0.5445915460586548,
0.4877315163612366,
-0.29441866278648376,
0.48023363947868347,
0.8374969363212585,
0.7672943472862244,
-0.41995444893836975,
-0.19410490989685059,
-0.600730836391449,
-0.8468289375305176,
0.5926957130432129,
-0.04702313244342804,
0.20593157410621643,
-0.358071506023407,
0.5788405537605286,
0.48767992854118347,
0.2622053325176239,
-0.5504368543624878,
-0.24640843272209167,
-0.06916462630033493,
0.11398434638977051,
-0.20466609299182892,
-0.0952494889497757,
-0.29030221700668335,
-0.24491071701049805,
0.26577454805374146,
-0.33767279982566833,
0.1289401352405548,
0.4368842542171478,
-0.04341930150985718,
-0.41439810395240784,
0.40052250027656555,
0.867080807685852,
0.8191260099411011,
-0.5371401309967041,
-0.054962534457445145,
0.33227694034576416,
-0.3982638418674469,
0.05632340535521507,
-0.1703587919473648,
-0.2448786497116089,
-0.22922435402870178,
0.3949589729309082,
0.6739228963851929,
0.5930339694023132,
-0.8142516613006592,
0.5886826515197754,
0.010818826965987682,
-0.3050719201564789,
-0.1662643402814865,
0.13257156312465668,
-0.11471632868051529,
0.04230727255344391,
0.7830471992492676,
0.12668871879577637,
-0.03429709002375603,
-1.1320757865905762,
0.056962594389915466,
0.7311210036277771,
-0.31951311230659485,
-0.021067751571536064,
0.7080681920051575,
-0.23874756693840027,
-0.40748798847198486,
0.40729784965515137,
-0.12852400541305542,
-0.5458399057388306,
0.7087161540985107,
0.7810284495353699,
0.7154720425605774,
0.01606069505214691,
-0.020948423072695732,
0.2940692901611328,
0.043122000992298126,
-0.15842734277248383,
0.46577051281929016,
-0.3436465859413147,
-0.40864840149879456,
-0.20054976642131805,
-0.6080319881439209,
-0.8949308395385742,
0.15938270092010498,
-0.6679801344871521,
-0.007442482281476259,
-0.2337489128112793,
-0.05776442959904671,
-0.32490214705467224,
-0.13520455360412598,
-0.77691650390625,
0.5559787154197693,
-0.42445826530456543,
0.9175947904586792,
-0.8000270128250122,
0.36449769139289856,
1.0985034704208374,
-0.5782234072685242,
-0.5176374316215515,
0.08487588167190552,
-0.44240260124206543,
-0.2010573148727417,
0.9054009914398193,
0.2797688841819763,
0.05082378163933754,
-0.4254567325115204,
-0.8343746066093445,
-1.0695890188217163,
0.856272280216217,
0.16829270124435425,
-0.031429316848516464,
0.052746206521987915,
-0.08974263817071915,
0.7049635052680969,
-0.5896005630493164,
0.24390225112438202,
0.2360948771238327,
0.22714641690254211,
0.19451938569545746,
-1.0930719375610352,
0.04035795480012894,
-0.16199088096618652,
-0.28885897994041443,
0.20697157084941864,
-0.7335218787193298,
1.1743780374526978,
-0.2670690417289734,
-0.13623760640621185,
-0.18005883693695068,
0.45230114459991455,
0.29482388496398926,
0.9906150698661804,
0.499525785446167,
0.41012951731681824,
0.6402592658996582,
-0.20885193347930908,
1.1167199611663818,
0.2630139887332916,
0.3593958020210266,
0.9286292195320129,
-0.22654546797275543,
0.9065127968788147,
0.582563042640686,
-0.04037394002079964,
0.6266900897026062,
0.7682511806488037,
0.1324027180671692,
0.6802721619606018,
0.2946265637874603,
-0.15254457294940948,
0.09429654479026794,
0.046152982860803604,
-0.5772688984870911,
0.498982697725296,
0.3011242747306824,
0.028717856854200363,
-0.5044422149658203,
0.4272131025791168,
-0.40290847420692444,
0.39069247245788574,
-0.08019376546144485,
0.6448336243629456,
0.1566520631313324,
-0.9674610495567322,
0.6923651099205017,
-0.24286560714244843,
0.4083118438720703,
-0.4193700850009918,
-0.07884852588176727,
-0.25004667043685913,
0.01969386450946331,
-0.24480602145195007,
-0.6724463105201721,
0.25753435492515564,
-0.0937601700425148,
-0.3025175631046295,
0.03486165776848793,
0.4175139367580414,
-0.2696346044540405,
0.028800874948501587,
0.09636595845222473,
0.6509669423103333,
0.3773157596588135,
0.08019337803125381,
-0.3566838204860687,
0.07441512495279312,
-0.3925372362136841,
-0.40277668833732605,
0.6876718997955322,
0.5560517907142639,
-0.1486371010541916,
0.6760455965995789,
0.5339382886886597,
-0.207187220454216,
-0.03741554915904999,
-0.24959692358970642,
0.7858191728591919,
-0.4690607488155365,
-0.25361368060112,
-0.5700751543045044,
0.3503195345401764,
-0.028563525527715683,
-0.6475451588630676,
0.8787275552749634,
0.4961859881877899,
1.3656973838806152,
0.00944599974900484,
0.6042197942733765,
-0.06492525339126587,
0.5042443871498108,
-0.31453901529312134,
0.506382405757904,
-1.063920497894287,
0.18768158555030823,
-0.3477904796600342,
-1.256884217262268,
-0.0604163222014904,
0.26898127794265747,
-0.4189659357070923,
0.22988614439964294,
1.0626329183578491,
0.4012332558631897,
-0.11491677165031433,
0.05531974509358406,
0.26408204436302185,
-0.20158828794956207,
0.19502148032188416,
0.6619988083839417,
0.8706138730049133,
-0.3460623621940613,
0.3969813287258148,
-0.3111197352409363,
-0.4519103169441223,
-0.246672123670578,
-0.7690999507904053,
-0.8699421882629395,
-0.9841402173042297,
-0.05679480358958244,
-0.4566713571548462,
-0.0030786420684307814,
0.8346558809280396,
0.3081674575805664,
-0.7987303137779236,
-0.31848543882369995,
0.005088464356958866,
0.30576273798942566,
-0.13505971431732178,
-0.25881049036979675,
0.4487278163433075,
-0.587127685546875,
-0.6344194412231445,
0.6722089648246765,
0.02972719818353653,
-0.012094436213374138,
-0.14310994744300842,
0.22201722860336304,
-0.0955624133348465,
-0.11067716032266617,
0.4278116822242737,
0.7424389123916626,
-0.5236577391624451,
-0.3201938271522522,
0.15709899365901947,
-0.23151464760303497,
-0.0785670056939125,
0.8234093189239502,
-0.7987661957740784,
0.5743823647499084,
0.35669368505477905,
0.8067359328269958,
0.49952882528305054,
0.11570858955383301,
0.3981652855873108,
-0.6770780682563782,
-0.10459685325622559,
0.28376471996307373,
0.1340162754058838,
0.42214444279670715,
-0.31295526027679443,
0.3864046037197113,
0.48526421189308167,
-0.7368210554122925,
-1.1860090494155884,
0.16353902220726013,
-0.7686662077903748,
-0.38346657156944275,
1.093424677848816,
0.062188852578401566,
-0.3199347257614136,
-0.164226695895195,
0.12991972267627716,
-0.1077803373336792,
-0.03452513739466667,
0.7890379428863525,
0.8124672174453735,
-0.34836244583129883,
0.3373816907405853,
-0.8223497867584229,
0.555121898651123,
0.6143922805786133,
-0.2777042090892792,
-0.3749808073043823,
0.1452864706516266,
0.3664509654045105,
0.2544701397418976,
0.38945871591567993,
0.0741555318236351,
0.5907801985740662,
-0.225862056016922,
-0.5395709276199341,
0.08351198583841324,
-0.4576921761035919,
-0.38045090436935425,
0.8034050464630127,
0.07580918073654175,
-0.0689375102519989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02005v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02005v1 | An End-to-End Speech Summarization Using Large Language Model | 2024-07-02T07:22:57 | 2024-07-02T07:22:57 | Hengchao Shang, Zongyao Li, Jiaxin Guo, Shaojun Li, Zhiqiang Rao, Yuanchang Luo, Daimeng Wei, Hao Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Abstractive Speech Summarization (SSum) aims to generate human-like text
summaries from spoken content. It encounters difficulties in handling long
speech input and capturing the intricate cross-modal mapping between long
speech inputs and short text summaries. Research on large language models
(LLMs) and multimodal information fusion has provided new insights for
addressing these challenges. In this paper, we propose an end-to-end SSum model
that utilizes Q-Former as a connector for the audio-text modality and employs
LLMs to generate text summaries directly from speech features. We adopt a
multi-stage training approach that includes LLM based ASR and Text
Summarization (TSum) tasks as auxiliary tasks. ASR tasks are used to align
feature spaces and enhance the LLM's ability to handle longer speech. Then, we
utilize a curriculum learning strategy to facilitate the model's transition
from TSum to SSum. Finally, our model achieves competitive performance on the
How-2 dataset. | [
-0.28098157048225403,
-0.6579256057739258,
0.47061625123023987,
-0.32940536737442017,
-0.6139540076255798,
0.3286120593547821,
-0.4162774384021759,
-0.36445391178131104,
0.21949942409992218,
0.37481242418289185,
-0.5403532385826111,
-0.4850418269634247,
-0.6337459087371826,
-0.024585621431469917,
-0.4921853244304657,
1.1379895210266113,
0.10513150691986084,
0.1037312000989914,
-0.3119419515132904,
-0.0017765492666512728,
-0.4437081217765808,
-0.6423971652984619,
-0.5413833856582642,
-0.2084505259990692,
0.34354981780052185,
0.6130685210227966,
0.3726557195186615,
0.3413594365119934,
0.2060943841934204,
0.22663311660289764,
-0.3231408894062042,
0.14669573307037354,
-0.6266919374465942,
0.27204960584640503,
-0.070393405854702,
-0.44012370705604553,
-0.610802412033081,
-0.12481120973825455,
1.0373262166976929,
0.5817797183990479,
-0.07455857843160629,
0.3710339367389679,
0.02148371934890747,
0.4185766875743866,
-0.3321862816810608,
0.09767217934131622,
-0.4635014235973358,
-0.26510486006736755,
-0.21856991946697235,
-0.3817293345928192,
-0.2917344570159912,
-0.13870051503181458,
0.0557946152985096,
-0.23800882697105408,
-0.07401879876852036,
-0.0430842787027359,
0.640826940536499,
0.1653609424829483,
-0.7494828104972839,
-0.23424801230430603,
-0.9100935459136963,
0.7395267486572266,
-0.9306057691574097,
0.4979279637336731,
0.3081209659576416,
0.57268226146698,
0.01490781456232071,
-0.48017075657844543,
-0.6302792429924011,
-0.17429575324058533,
0.32323768734931946,
0.2821396291255951,
0.12542806565761566,
-0.0021575801074504852,
-0.046769995242357254,
0.22897212207317352,
-0.6509937047958374,
0.24175740778446198,
-0.5949282050132751,
0.14710380136966705,
0.6047710180282593,
0.2966533899307251,
0.3482440710067749,
-0.09381258487701416,
-0.2980346381664276,
0.008683770895004272,
-0.5535839200019836,
-0.06891902536153793,
0.20257242023944855,
0.4794950485229492,
-0.5308099389076233,
0.7864970564842224,
-0.23329836130142212,
0.45834457874298096,
-0.23708991706371307,
-0.5049811601638794,
0.25541865825653076,
-0.49962499737739563,
-0.14051754772663116,
0.3103271424770355,
0.56375652551651,
0.4605286419391632,
0.18264833092689514,
-0.16875770688056946,
-0.226039320230484,
0.04440826177597046,
-0.2197573482990265,
-0.7507922649383545,
0.3319653868675232,
0.2839128375053406,
-0.3675755262374878,
0.05059797689318657,
-0.2671510875225067,
-0.5714930295944214,
-0.0033956195693463087,
-0.6890989542007446,
0.5061491131782532,
-0.5137794613838196,
-0.31990399956703186,
0.0023095111828297377,
-0.11393889039754868,
0.3160184919834137,
0.21852827072143555,
-0.7023308873176575,
0.3190353214740753,
0.5560094714164734,
1.0555610656738281,
-0.1800771802663803,
-0.22159691154956818,
-0.6441875696182251,
0.6978604197502136,
-0.11806140094995499,
0.6307615637779236,
-0.5718898177146912,
-0.4932308495044708,
-0.05744079872965813,
-0.224380224943161,
-0.07605184614658356,
-0.29397687315940857,
0.3383578062057495,
-0.35321125388145447,
0.544083833694458,
0.08082554489374161,
-0.7001321911811829,
-0.18861262500286102,
0.1425570249557495,
-0.3578883111476898,
0.7650524973869324,
-0.012429922819137573,
-0.633406937122345,
0.021054137498140335,
-0.504406750202179,
-0.6120789051055908,
-0.06630436331033707,
-0.3073582947254181,
-0.4637566804885864,
0.1044030636548996,
0.12234915792942047,
0.5767841935157776,
-0.4827531576156616,
0.5547469258308411,
0.04975227639079094,
-0.34780657291412354,
0.18539020419120789,
-0.20030173659324646,
0.43030276894569397,
0.07222170382738113,
-0.0652782991528511,
0.34361907839775085,
-0.8327623009681702,
-0.2965604066848755,
0.1442694067955017,
-0.2930219769477844,
-0.2171340435743332,
0.0261615589261055,
0.2489103227853775,
0.46443676948547363,
0.3588238060474396,
-0.38840872049331665,
-0.14121167361736298,
-0.27627626061439514,
0.5787941217422485,
0.47369468212127686,
-0.10279268026351929,
0.4454285204410553,
-0.5670682787895203,
0.42914116382598877,
0.033419713377952576,
-0.1767687201499939,
-0.5297660827636719,
-0.2417616844177246,
-0.5803037881851196,
-0.39916902780532837,
0.320050984621048,
0.5620893239974976,
-0.6987085342407227,
0.4790361523628235,
-0.5522089600563049,
-0.48916199803352356,
-0.21564434468746185,
-0.09275182336568832,
0.36134448647499084,
0.4115103483200073,
0.2421572357416153,
-0.1322566419839859,
-0.5682976245880127,
-0.7463287711143494,
0.11834642291069031,
-0.16155944764614105,
-0.2824833393096924,
-0.10862091183662415,
0.44000211358070374,
-0.16093650460243225,
0.9075658321380615,
-0.31257134675979614,
-0.6736447215080261,
-0.8566145300865173,
0.28532838821411133,
0.15065936744213104,
0.24945709109306335,
0.20191271603107452,
-0.588081955909729,
-0.09168718010187149,
-0.11034661531448364,
-0.5739308595657349,
-0.02395448461174965,
-0.3153640329837799,
0.10820228606462479,
0.10938578099012375,
0.5601205825805664,
-0.47049736976623535,
0.027785085141658783,
0.4327932298183441,
-0.11417771130800247,
0.45709580183029175,
-0.16931821405887604,
0.22211125493049622,
-1.6123559474945068,
0.14320316910743713,
0.08637993782758713,
-0.29503780603408813,
-0.7344295978546143,
0.018510783091187477,
-0.09043534845113754,
-0.3744751513004303,
-0.41844627261161804,
0.30162501335144043,
-0.43235015869140625,
-0.36279866099357605,
-0.5323002338409424,
0.49284595251083374,
-0.2110596001148224,
0.6326150894165039,
0.15032140910625458,
0.7700064182281494,
0.2567155361175537,
-0.5745251774787903,
0.2124357372522354,
0.2148650884628296,
-0.16261117160320282,
0.40207505226135254,
-0.5742214322090149,
-0.19965656101703644,
-0.34397053718566895,
0.4679996073246002,
-1.1268947124481201,
-0.32092738151550293,
-0.24289458990097046,
-0.7011358737945557,
0.4406885504722595,
0.1974039524793625,
-0.4690771996974945,
0.11271212995052338,
-0.4627249538898468,
0.47971007227897644,
0.5355480313301086,
-0.10789020359516144,
0.889122724533081,
0.5508899688720703,
-0.812515914440155,
0.004017992876470089,
-0.5832621455192566,
0.33245328068733215,
-0.280857652425766,
-0.6406060457229614,
0.5669304728507996,
-0.054576147347688675,
-0.027340751141309738,
-0.3488200306892395,
0.19566668570041656,
0.030907979235053062,
-0.30562323331832886,
0.13693924248218536,
0.3674548268318176,
-0.14249037206172943,
0.043821755796670914,
0.4013400375843048,
-0.04673765227198601,
0.042974747717380524,
0.27608004212379456,
0.6368435025215149,
0.2803983688354492,
-0.23150892555713654,
-0.6831969022750854,
0.7549021244049072,
0.7779939770698547,
-0.32166823744773865,
0.46829333901405334,
0.4351285398006439,
-0.43773460388183594,
0.17270183563232422,
-0.49199196696281433,
-0.0637592002749443,
-0.28855466842651367,
0.8060901761054993,
-0.15982547402381897,
-0.9545502066612244,
0.5273376107215881,
-0.09657300263643265,
0.41448482871055603,
0.28226083517074585,
0.7215430736541748,
-0.07479505985975266,
1.0564532279968262,
0.6630445122718811,
-0.2676435708999634,
0.6411340236663818,
-0.18849502503871918,
0.11824067682027817,
-0.932685911655426,
-0.45832252502441406,
-0.34317928552627563,
-0.15686176717281342,
0.017363745719194412,
-0.5064430236816406,
0.5676495432853699,
-0.059936411678791046,
-0.10199376940727234,
0.2321629822254181,
0.11010974645614624,
0.22658100724220276,
0.4693087041378021,
0.025277692824602127,
0.35860103368759155,
-0.002784268232062459,
0.2635934352874756,
0.0314556360244751,
-0.483614981174469,
-0.28803756833076477,
0.8409965634346008,
0.5291273593902588,
0.6013646125793457,
0.3703453242778778,
0.6729905009269714,
0.23209741711616516,
-0.17551647126674652,
-0.7258901000022888,
0.6381590962409973,
-0.16239768266677856,
-0.13470344245433807,
-0.540327250957489,
-0.446378618478775,
-0.3799223005771637,
0.2546001076698303,
-0.21535636484622955,
-0.389974981546402,
-0.290702760219574,
-0.10425792634487152,
-0.23634697496891022,
0.10928326845169067,
-0.45919230580329895,
0.26229456067085266,
-0.24811160564422607,
-0.1258263885974884,
-0.36678001284599304,
-0.9632524251937866,
0.523489236831665,
-0.09667687863111496,
0.5302843451499939,
-0.027733702212572098,
-0.046423640102148056,
0.8658409714698792,
-0.22869636118412018,
0.8310995697975159,
0.06667120009660721,
-0.17064964771270752,
0.1181076392531395,
-0.19325114786624908,
0.3343491554260254,
-0.12695083022117615,
0.23579145967960358,
0.016964895650744438,
-0.25366294384002686,
-0.12610095739364624,
-0.370076447725296,
0.3953922688961029,
-0.784101128578186,
-0.3369239568710327,
-0.3697398900985718,
-0.623479425907135,
-0.35179394483566284,
-0.0009060419979505241,
0.22124484181404114,
0.7277626991271973,
-0.17676454782485962,
0.03468800336122513,
0.7013878226280212,
-0.18050722777843475,
0.5637363195419312,
0.4928399920463562,
-0.21126534044742584,
-0.6161234974861145,
1.0442358255386353,
0.1380409598350525,
0.4442860186100006,
0.5161104202270508,
0.03454233333468437,
-0.5528907179832458,
-0.5230152010917664,
-0.6011959314346313,
0.48134708404541016,
-0.47409725189208984,
-0.18221314251422882,
-0.6593946814537048,
-0.5215486884117126,
-0.7313752770423889,
-0.136951744556427,
-0.20014414191246033,
-0.405855268239975,
-0.39820724725723267,
0.01220177486538887,
0.12577837705612183,
0.3875223994255066,
0.0930212065577507,
0.5547495484352112,
-0.8850054740905762,
0.5657362341880798,
0.277624249458313,
0.0020702239125967026,
0.042996782809495926,
-1.1201367378234863,
-0.40508055686950684,
0.046257831156253815,
-0.1546284556388855,
-0.8535507321357727,
0.49774330854415894,
0.6019513607025146,
0.47627565264701843,
0.40808653831481934,
-0.10069607943296432,
0.597812294960022,
-0.5563773512840271,
0.9299725294113159,
0.5914337038993835,
-0.9630833864212036,
0.45615947246551514,
-0.5064635276794434,
0.7206299304962158,
0.303479939699173,
0.26289305090904236,
-0.8272504806518555,
-0.6151657700538635,
-0.08160010725259781,
-1.113998293876648,
0.5599526166915894,
0.1458357870578766,
-0.05297374725341797,
0.0736520066857338,
0.020814061164855957,
0.045662492513656616,
0.1472882777452469,
-0.5101287961006165,
0.026539137586951256,
-0.1328914612531662,
-0.4332416355609894,
-0.23063792288303375,
-0.4708661735057831,
-0.003867751220241189,
-0.010892404243350029,
0.9001434445381165,
-0.05234845355153084,
0.03865182399749756,
-0.1685325652360916,
-0.3335121273994446,
0.061192046850919724,
0.635962188243866,
0.9573732614517212,
0.6053192615509033,
-0.12403922528028488,
0.04519176855683327,
0.24578501284122467,
-0.22747665643692017,
0.03587542474269867,
0.0615069754421711,
0.15424799919128418,
-0.013768013566732407,
0.4037627577781677,
0.6622676253318787,
0.5004755854606628,
-1.0165417194366455,
0.6121748685836792,
-0.056693777441978455,
-0.2898311913013458,
-0.4910281300544739,
-0.23248985409736633,
0.310955673456192,
0.3710840344429016,
0.6413885951042175,
-0.5070213079452515,
0.2628411054611206,
-0.6334575414657593,
0.19184668362140656,
0.21719342470169067,
-0.17869099974632263,
-0.2039088010787964,
0.8214730024337769,
0.20857642590999603,
-0.08170819282531738,
0.27082058787345886,
0.15880054235458374,
-0.4257890284061432,
0.42417389154434204,
0.7142660617828369,
0.6340832710266113,
-0.4355545938014984,
0.08585862815380096,
0.13833776116371155,
0.06485513597726822,
0.0526316836476326,
0.32387080788612366,
-0.15003782510757446,
-0.13900747895240784,
-0.8252475261688232,
-0.5380286574363708,
-0.4239293336868286,
0.09620259702205658,
-0.671840488910675,
0.4276314675807953,
-0.17993737757205963,
-0.048302315175533295,
-0.1708454191684723,
-0.31104183197021484,
-0.05412178114056587,
0.34437093138694763,
0.3912908434867859,
0.6145584583282471,
-1.0161644220352173,
0.7175959348678589,
0.4986705482006073,
-0.5397229194641113,
-0.4287111461162567,
-0.2748255431652069,
0.06677109003067017,
-0.4902963638305664,
0.36185675859451294,
0.13621167838573456,
-0.21275228261947632,
-0.13951119780540466,
-0.1983662247657776,
-0.860671877861023,
1.20688796043396,
0.2679027020931244,
-0.8787932395935059,
-0.5143031477928162,
0.24267615377902985,
0.3564724624156952,
-0.4443887770175934,
0.31738749146461487,
0.3602107763290405,
-0.16971680521965027,
0.44633010029792786,
-0.9001426696777344,
-0.14369669556617737,
-0.19080498814582825,
0.1667625904083252,
0.2818915545940399,
-0.6899851560592651,
0.833075761795044,
-0.26490896940231323,
-0.23701268434524536,
0.007295078132301569,
1.2023953199386597,
0.35868552327156067,
0.3942853510379791,
0.4367583096027374,
0.35226547718048096,
0.2748848795890808,
0.2869287431240082,
0.4236094057559967,
-0.31209784746170044,
0.11376070231199265,
1.540436029434204,
-0.3539620041847229,
1.131704330444336,
0.38751667737960815,
0.07262789458036423,
0.2736247479915619,
0.6431907415390015,
0.3284304738044739,
0.5598158240318298,
0.0967571809887886,
-0.35647377371788025,
-0.2597438395023346,
-0.23204748332500458,
-0.5352575778961182,
0.6533017754554749,
0.46890637278556824,
-0.3666500747203827,
-0.4439510107040405,
0.26148781180381775,
-0.0034658194053918123,
0.05194711312651634,
-0.437548965215683,
1.002042293548584,
0.1266702562570572,
-0.23895472288131714,
0.19300317764282227,
0.12458885461091995,
0.7346116304397583,
-0.6929845213890076,
-0.033611856400966644,
-0.038376472890377045,
-0.28087082505226135,
-0.041698575019836426,
-0.4728569984436035,
0.19076043367385864,
0.08619524538516998,
-0.34158599376678467,
0.13705849647521973,
0.41523560881614685,
-1.001617670059204,
-0.4395398497581482,
0.16969949007034302,
0.4424789845943451,
0.3397669196128845,
0.08201836049556732,
-0.18075726926326752,
0.03708842396736145,
-0.1392797827720642,
-0.026761937886476517,
0.5921216607093811,
0.25004324316978455,
-0.13991712033748627,
0.6377660036087036,
0.5093943476676941,
0.14294564723968506,
-0.013398820534348488,
0.4197804927825928,
0.9071625471115112,
-0.6309675574302673,
-0.9251288175582886,
-0.7463275790214539,
0.5239182710647583,
-0.07532117515802383,
-0.129053995013237,
0.4021938741207123,
0.8978224992752075,
0.6482270956039429,
0.2018262892961502,
0.9678780436515808,
0.18124960362911224,
0.8922133445739746,
-0.668473482131958,
0.6513212323188782,
-0.6294406056404114,
0.06466469168663025,
-0.21255695819854736,
-0.9107920527458191,
-0.04920084401965141,
0.24974648654460907,
0.07755595445632935,
0.07161588966846466,
0.49344703555107117,
0.42534369230270386,
0.05817379802465439,
0.09275984019041061,
0.6135937571525574,
0.08558617532253265,
0.36025893688201904,
0.6901001334190369,
0.5883591175079346,
-0.2805672287940979,
0.5719119906425476,
0.1584024280309677,
-0.4533226191997528,
-0.30998024344444275,
-0.6398273706436157,
-0.9507198929786682,
-0.8906713128089905,
-0.16936054825782776,
-0.1480296105146408,
0.08388251811265945,
1.042262077331543,
0.4621872305870056,
-0.46446725726127625,
-0.48744693398475647,
0.45850110054016113,
-0.2860984206199646,
0.08342166990041733,
-0.17120930552482605,
0.4024493992328644,
-0.09799627959728241,
-0.7643453478813171,
0.5213629007339478,
0.3680879473686218,
0.16829420626163483,
-0.27929964661598206,
0.012645328417420387,
-0.20959746837615967,
0.131146639585495,
0.8672831654548645,
0.1359979212284088,
-0.6489116549491882,
-0.06675311177968979,
-0.3077818751335144,
-0.021628379821777344,
-0.0898049920797348,
0.819708526134491,
-0.6014672517776489,
0.2431574910879135,
0.3858244717121124,
0.6473571062088013,
0.524642288684845,
-0.06114530190825462,
0.7122383117675781,
-0.6811383366584778,
-0.061100367456674576,
0.05083075538277626,
0.40451928973197937,
0.24504177272319794,
-0.24805636703968048,
0.1231812834739685,
-0.1567329317331314,
-0.5230695009231567,
-0.770032525062561,
0.1826803833246231,
-1.2708758115768433,
-0.2739684581756592,
1.252140760421753,
0.0935811698436737,
-0.21854257583618164,
-0.18298140168190002,
-0.2734258770942688,
0.8420169949531555,
-0.5192379951477051,
0.7650039196014404,
0.36213093996047974,
-0.06552160531282425,
-0.3674045503139496,
-0.3786402642726898,
0.09976227581501007,
0.28899040818214417,
-0.9545772671699524,
0.08097022771835327,
0.6224378943443298,
0.23282243311405182,
-0.040337346494197845,
0.7006254196166992,
-0.17616933584213257,
0.2642872929573059,
-0.23509939014911652,
0.07685396820306778,
-0.36499419808387756,
-0.4917096495628357,
-0.37457191944122314,
0.25690779089927673,
-0.11214999854564667,
-0.3541414141654968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.02543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.02543v1 | Towards the Next Frontier in Speech Representation Learning Using Disentanglement | 2024-07-02T07:13:35 | 2024-07-02T07:13:35 | Varun Krishna, Sriram Ganapathy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | The popular frameworks for self-supervised learning of speech representations
have largely focused on frame-level masked prediction of speech regions. While
this has shown promising downstream task performance for speech recognition and
related tasks, this has largely ignored factors of speech that are encoded at
coarser level, like characteristics of the speaker or channel that remain
consistent through-out a speech utterance. In this work, we propose a framework
for Learning Disentangled Self Supervised (termed as Learn2Diss)
representations of speech, which consists of frame-level and an utterance-level
encoder modules. The two encoders are initially learned independently, where
the frame-level model is largely inspired by existing self supervision
techniques, thereby learning pseudo-phonemic representations, while the
utterance-level encoder is inspired by constrastive learning of pooled
embeddings, thereby learning pseudo-speaker representations. The joint learning
of these two modules consists of disentangling the two encoders using a mutual
information based criterion. With several downstream evaluation experiments, we
show that the proposed Learn2Diss achieves state-of-the-art results on a
variety of tasks, with the frame-level encoder representations improving
semantic tasks, while the utterance-level representations improve non-semantic
tasks. | [
-0.22471721470355988,
-0.3799397051334381,
0.3057296872138977,
-0.03483537212014198,
-0.2489052414894104,
0.29904890060424805,
-0.0815284475684166,
-0.2966408431529999,
0.451781302690506,
0.09844502061605453,
-0.5789373517036438,
-0.257061630487442,
-1.0047067403793335,
-0.0887545645236969,
-0.2508823275566101,
0.5472679138183594,
0.23847882449626923,
0.33154305815696716,
-0.4560645520687103,
0.11529846489429474,
-0.5160202980041504,
-0.420144259929657,
-0.42904797196388245,
-0.5287168025970459,
0.40542662143707275,
0.28367942571640015,
0.07093878090381622,
0.5320854187011719,
-0.07155265659093857,
0.37814998626708984,
-0.062005240470170975,
0.09390437602996826,
-0.6228935718536377,
0.28910478949546814,
-0.3493468463420868,
-0.5853658318519592,
0.007542500272393227,
0.23400840163230896,
0.5555689930915833,
0.7004544734954834,
-0.4088089168071747,
0.17106835544109344,
0.37739402055740356,
0.7056878805160522,
-0.4941280484199524,
0.6589373350143433,
-0.5472962260246277,
0.19894418120384216,
-0.3528463542461395,
0.005408821627497673,
-0.4141654968261719,
0.21511420607566833,
0.14907221496105194,
-0.3889947533607483,
-0.015654264017939568,
-0.34239688515663147,
0.3320450484752655,
0.5510317087173462,
-0.4342029094696045,
-0.3692418038845062,
-0.7701387405395508,
0.5757121443748474,
-0.43293648958206177,
0.7243401408195496,
0.7830873131752014,
0.4355252981185913,
-0.04995947703719139,
-0.7446708679199219,
-0.36227020621299744,
0.2535991668701172,
-0.2115890085697174,
0.19268161058425903,
-0.43938469886779785,
-0.07975438982248306,
0.20293690264225006,
0.24481575191020966,
-0.6183600425720215,
0.3655479848384857,
-0.48279741406440735,
-0.3695847690105438,
0.6141472458839417,
-0.16608868539333344,
-0.06232694908976555,
-0.10172963887453079,
-0.45652005076408386,
-0.2030966877937317,
-0.3852021396160126,
0.16812199354171753,
0.18502706289291382,
0.10978315025568008,
-0.31906771659851074,
0.24913837015628815,
-0.2074558138847351,
0.4097820818424225,
0.5503137111663818,
-0.19744692742824554,
0.5712680816650391,
0.16865380108356476,
0.11293713748455048,
0.5240933895111084,
0.5891218781471252,
-0.07992223650217056,
-0.25418925285339355,
-0.3185522258281708,
-0.23127812147140503,
0.03836066275835037,
0.09905283898115158,
-0.5106019377708435,
-0.43505924940109253,
0.08450642228126526,
-0.4767129123210907,
0.11259998381137848,
0.0663699135184288,
-0.7116900682449341,
-0.37308424711227417,
-0.652324378490448,
0.5619874000549316,
-0.3483113646507263,
-0.8246608376502991,
-0.12576399743556976,
-0.07163248211145401,
0.09280507266521454,
-0.04153197631239891,
-1.245714783668518,
0.3075140714645386,
0.5318296551704407,
0.7917839884757996,
-0.10552465915679932,
-0.07846888899803162,
-0.7066885232925415,
0.21356606483459473,
-0.48256781697273254,
0.28483089804649353,
-0.376482218503952,
-0.21513454616069794,
-0.17872637510299683,
-0.011967413127422333,
-0.04928479343652725,
-0.5055906176567078,
-0.17350886762142181,
-0.5196875929832458,
0.10947330296039581,
-0.16541986167430878,
-0.7997915744781494,
-0.2620844542980194,
-0.29121318459510803,
-0.7285804748535156,
0.6510719656944275,
0.12060829997062683,
-0.6756976842880249,
0.2890418767929077,
-0.2433399260044098,
-0.3929074704647064,
-0.00026983299176208675,
-0.6399291157722473,
-0.6327483057975769,
0.22695720195770264,
0.13662631809711456,
0.585433840751648,
0.05193058401346207,
0.16643182933330536,
-0.16066162288188934,
-0.3167709410190582,
0.020989710465073586,
-0.43448778986930847,
0.6702466607093811,
0.33040809631347656,
-0.6095612645149231,
-0.17342276871204376,
-0.6675097942352295,
-0.24011658132076263,
0.08220944553613663,
0.10401459783315659,
-0.3281388282775879,
0.07985295355319977,
-0.5534749627113342,
0.2600999176502228,
0.2926265597343445,
-0.711236834526062,
-0.45426011085510254,
-0.49023258686065674,
0.8128126859664917,
0.5487367510795593,
-0.018041759729385376,
0.663654625415802,
-0.017214426770806313,
0.17674300074577332,
0.4270758628845215,
-0.27595412731170654,
-0.09007270634174347,
-0.3271970748901367,
-0.49078258872032166,
-0.33562469482421875,
0.4025188386440277,
0.3382818400859833,
-0.7716464996337891,
0.528775155544281,
-0.0797995999455452,
-0.39968374371528625,
-0.6437088847160339,
0.1904914826154709,
0.5500485301017761,
0.3929883539676666,
0.4934733211994171,
-0.17727303504943848,
-0.4277949333190918,
-0.6907843351364136,
0.06451509892940521,
-0.2200099676847458,
-0.018539775162935257,
-0.25726619362831116,
0.19738517701625824,
-0.15240025520324707,
1.1646333932876587,
-0.20314541459083557,
-0.7542355060577393,
-0.19094304740428925,
0.35213369131088257,
0.020331094041466713,
0.6642355918884277,
0.2100325971841812,
-1.0073199272155762,
-0.2368888258934021,
-0.22724106907844543,
-0.7109174132347107,
0.24833008646965027,
-0.011024967767298222,
0.28405576944351196,
0.0534142442047596,
0.8603692650794983,
-0.2367444485425949,
0.29086098074913025,
0.6576046943664551,
0.12073413282632828,
-0.06605871766805649,
-0.4317847788333893,
-0.2985849380493164,
-1.0337433815002441,
-0.46988388895988464,
-0.0066767847165465355,
-0.4289889931678772,
-0.6157929301261902,
-0.6059865355491638,
0.1602727621793747,
-0.2080526500940323,
-0.33320122957229614,
0.04441474750638008,
-0.7374668717384338,
-0.23275329172611237,
-0.2859886586666107,
0.2518591284751892,
-0.023868199437856674,
0.6776580810546875,
0.235714852809906,
0.7484942674636841,
1.0610604286193848,
-0.4148821234703064,
0.4759864807128906,
0.18606136739253998,
-0.17073483765125275,
0.31514644622802734,
-0.5058425068855286,
0.3980698585510254,
-0.4246617555618286,
0.2894100546836853,
-1.0449556112289429,
-0.20704135298728943,
0.0036551151424646378,
-0.6893841028213501,
0.7803128957748413,
-0.24135474860668182,
-0.23960570991039276,
-0.16608449816703796,
0.08225388079881668,
0.35089021921157837,
0.849825918674469,
-0.8502792119979858,
0.6059721112251282,
0.8984047770500183,
0.01057600136846304,
-0.3510074317455292,
-1.037249207496643,
-0.16616453230381012,
-0.22967197000980377,
-0.2619052231311798,
0.47059255838394165,
0.6105364561080933,
0.21788549423217773,
0.1155722588300705,
-0.4065471589565277,
0.086070716381073,
-0.15396443009376526,
0.4546653628349304,
-0.2566092908382416,
0.07441582530736923,
0.3198698163032532,
0.40105628967285156,
-0.3206837773323059,
0.24797320365905762,
-0.5045520663261414,
0.4653134346008301,
0.11466433852910995,
-0.5516825914382935,
-0.5905851721763611,
0.4935225248336792,
0.12151332944631577,
-0.5255386829376221,
0.34716716408729553,
0.8698428273200989,
-0.558509349822998,
-0.413175493478775,
-0.3805047273635864,
-0.3820550739765167,
-0.5291012525558472,
0.6953160166740417,
-0.6050283312797546,
-1.226540207862854,
0.23992794752120972,
-0.4451981484889984,
-0.354104608297348,
0.3847604990005493,
0.5627498626708984,
-0.46136507391929626,
0.9149139523506165,
0.558427095413208,
-0.19720053672790527,
0.35534846782684326,
-0.5680293440818787,
0.24979542195796967,
-0.8595455288887024,
-0.6934605836868286,
-0.10697222501039505,
-0.3135402500629425,
-0.7186400890350342,
-0.6742708683013916,
0.4010869562625885,
0.4589880704879761,
0.03184248134493828,
0.57485032081604,
-0.4174792170524597,
0.28345733880996704,
0.5990514755249023,
0.27064383029937744,
-0.1536576747894287,
0.18462522327899933,
-0.004978811834007502,
-0.0423850417137146,
-0.7601301670074463,
-0.18389396369457245,
0.8759444355964661,
0.6247310638427734,
0.727787435054779,
0.2894061803817749,
1.2280793190002441,
0.6321664452552795,
-0.71263587474823,
-0.4599136412143707,
0.3229371905326843,
-0.3183691203594208,
-0.30793333053588867,
-0.4341992735862732,
-0.6568728089332581,
-0.9282500147819519,
0.2609507143497467,
-0.04332640394568443,
-0.8313496708869934,
0.5340350866317749,
0.10970429331064224,
-0.2039279341697693,
0.14473013579845428,
-0.6877673268318176,
0.550757110118866,
-0.03321090713143349,
-0.3142702281475067,
-0.5792154669761658,
-0.8309735059738159,
0.023697849363088608,
0.04116338491439819,
0.18511128425598145,
-0.0879695862531662,
0.2039201706647873,
0.9650750160217285,
0.08988358080387115,
1.1515791416168213,
-0.6325725317001343,
-0.1610845923423767,
0.43251243233680725,
0.17109960317611694,
0.2527880072593689,
0.31886935234069824,
0.06671954691410065,
0.4950070083141327,
0.11334124952554703,
-0.18302717804908752,
-0.640368640422821,
0.6565839648246765,
-0.6906704902648926,
-0.6175965666770935,
-0.36319687962532043,
-0.11120080202817917,
-0.527198851108551,
0.032000720500946045,
0.18971337378025055,
0.9404058456420898,
-0.012412624433636665,
-0.0025704512372612953,
0.8735390901565552,
0.16794231534004211,
0.5535218119621277,
0.17699034512043,
0.038321591913700104,
-0.41618654131889343,
1.3054232597351074,
0.09074727445840836,
0.3057602345943451,
0.5024833679199219,
-0.02690003626048565,
-0.8815295696258545,
-0.415996789932251,
-0.43036535382270813,
0.20716248452663422,
-0.7214033603668213,
-0.1916685402393341,
-0.325015664100647,
-0.42953217029571533,
-0.5555771589279175,
0.49885472655296326,
-0.5047659873962402,
-0.3100474774837494,
-0.7939163446426392,
-0.3003205955028534,
0.05529078096151352,
0.8237782716751099,
-0.7692239284515381,
0.1130342110991478,
-0.5112277269363403,
0.40584951639175415,
0.688543438911438,
0.2830098271369934,
-0.10113532096147537,
-0.6898958683013916,
-0.37715327739715576,
0.2758725583553314,
-0.21095895767211914,
-0.8370962142944336,
0.06989811360836029,
0.41795024275779724,
0.7384262681007385,
0.5408377051353455,
0.30613136291503906,
0.5029147863388062,
-0.5745155215263367,
0.6788594126701355,
0.5785585045814514,
-0.947844386100769,
0.6171762943267822,
0.14845392107963562,
0.07574660331010818,
0.34603139758110046,
0.5108823776245117,
-0.28212785720825195,
-0.28543031215667725,
-0.4107142388820648,
-0.3777123689651489,
0.9616461396217346,
0.18351058661937714,
0.3751409947872162,
0.012830998748540878,
0.15426915884017944,
0.20566865801811218,
-0.05305123329162598,
-0.41790318489074707,
-0.2749690115451813,
-0.4971335232257843,
-0.22809801995754242,
-0.13959354162216187,
-0.49211975932121277,
-0.07451236993074417,
-0.12653152644634247,
0.3559582829475403,
-0.019687607884407043,
0.51641845703125,
0.2788141667842865,
-0.15896956622600555,
0.15321384370326996,
0.06816765666007996,
0.1939581036567688,
0.42088785767555237,
-0.04687299579381943,
0.5270658731460571,
0.007209328468888998,
-0.21533802151679993,
0.3937862813472748,
0.1860651820898056,
0.28989535570144653,
0.0693536326289177,
0.46342599391937256,
1.1601790189743042,
-0.07204923778772354,
-0.2641116678714752,
0.7039300203323364,
0.14913664758205414,
-0.3199957609176636,
-0.3806961476802826,
-0.005131447222083807,
0.2420670986175537,
0.5926861763000488,
0.3571226894855499,
-0.008566126227378845,
0.3777530789375305,
-0.45013734698295593,
0.5987221002578735,
0.2852335572242737,
-0.7222611308097839,
-0.3949786424636841,
0.7289300560951233,
0.31539496779441833,
-0.22210025787353516,
0.3058113753795624,
-0.6517393589019775,
-0.3468095660209656,
0.21904747188091278,
0.5851207375526428,
0.7163347601890564,
-0.5972145199775696,
0.3954682946205139,
0.35189810395240784,
-0.08204594999551773,
0.019282013177871704,
0.048680245876312256,
-0.682019829750061,
-0.4150902032852173,
-0.3065849840641022,
-0.48414796590805054,
-0.040959492325782776,
-0.10098414868116379,
-0.8433688282966614,
0.051718540489673615,
-0.09067203104496002,
-0.19155776500701904,
-0.23203817009925842,
-0.3227912485599518,
-0.20887476205825806,
0.07809576392173767,
0.660874605178833,
0.3808504343032837,
-0.6955738663673401,
1.0600483417510986,
0.2889386713504791,
-0.2752102315425873,
-0.7794980406761169,
0.053370341658592224,
0.2056129276752472,
-0.5086007118225098,
0.6509087085723877,
0.357291579246521,
-0.49136602878570557,
0.22529982030391693,
0.13467644155025482,
-1.108365774154663,
1.2552987337112427,
0.5674033761024475,
-1.1309465169906616,
-0.026479599997401237,
0.39369454979896545,
0.24119050800800323,
-0.1326143741607666,
0.14556342363357544,
0.49829238653182983,
-0.22144179046154022,
0.13323630392551422,
-0.9545318484306335,
-0.17720861732959747,
-0.02952408790588379,
0.3179008960723877,
-0.05881586670875549,
-0.4440702497959137,
0.7552213668823242,
0.039142001420259476,
-0.5305368304252625,
-0.3101401627063751,
1.1147594451904297,
-0.014334491454064846,
0.37703531980514526,
0.676679790019989,
0.46088361740112305,
0.6281285285949707,
-0.2185673713684082,
0.35802382230758667,
-0.016398722305893898,
0.4441666901111603,
1.299537181854248,
-0.15073484182357788,
0.7595833539962769,
0.4547349512577057,
-0.3782252371311188,
0.49790462851524353,
0.5272632837295532,
0.22581538558006287,
1.2528040409088135,
0.38119494915008545,
-0.20157043635845184,
-0.24516430497169495,
0.2172393649816513,
-0.4823116362094879,
0.9230446815490723,
0.5245154500007629,
-0.05012354254722595,
-0.39648154377937317,
0.5719868540763855,
-0.34434959292411804,
0.3577924966812134,
-0.1986238658428192,
1.2238359451293945,
0.2641138434410095,
-0.24815194308757782,
0.6789230704307556,
-0.0721469596028328,
0.583442211151123,
-0.5715875029563904,
-0.32484516501426697,
-0.07289787381887436,
0.11278924345970154,
-0.24303390085697174,
-0.5498290061950684,
0.45667219161987305,
-0.2857173979282379,
-0.13893453776836395,
-0.3405483365058899,
0.5109754204750061,
-0.8122163414955139,
-0.17960911989212036,
0.7151002883911133,
0.18122367560863495,
0.1425209641456604,
0.01803186908364296,
-0.5505990982055664,
0.12114891409873962,
-0.045787837356328964,
0.15455161035060883,
0.5021219253540039,
0.5144796371459961,
0.19594846665859222,
0.3870667517185211,
0.22908581793308258,
0.06446399539709091,
0.20013990998268127,
0.06232922524213791,
0.9300318956375122,
-0.22872868180274963,
-0.7040553092956543,
-0.6181538701057434,
0.3730514347553253,
-0.0849120244383812,
0.1426790952682495,
0.44463542103767395,
0.4457811713218689,
1.1015057563781738,
0.14604544639587402,
0.5515263080596924,
-0.1629572957754135,
0.7849728465080261,
-0.774591326713562,
0.7335126996040344,
-0.45800793170928955,
0.1585940569639206,
-0.05147749185562134,
-0.670771062374115,
0.11355102807283401,
0.7135541439056396,
-0.2259061336517334,
-0.11133995652198792,
0.3947145640850067,
0.818423330783844,
-0.19014842808246613,
0.1690322905778885,
0.489990234375,
-0.036495380103588104,
0.3376424312591553,
0.5292422771453857,
0.8233976364135742,
-0.3058863878250122,
0.22685374319553375,
-0.501160204410553,
-0.5477546453475952,
0.24525034427642822,
-0.3886663615703583,
-0.906089186668396,
-1.3844834566116333,
-0.381104975938797,
0.07297788560390472,
0.044902604073286057,
0.7955918908119202,
1.0214290618896484,
-0.6795253157615662,
-0.2544695734977722,
-0.20987547934055328,
-0.16493535041809082,
-0.23428447544574738,
-0.14302372932434082,
0.40530410408973694,
-0.5889289975166321,
-0.6302531957626343,
0.8188197016716003,
0.2831391990184784,
-0.14410318434238434,
-0.4961455166339874,
-0.4225243628025055,
-0.061148595064878464,
-0.32791438698768616,
0.39333832263946533,
0.11622314155101776,
-0.7540006637573242,
0.028404271230101585,
-0.4747752547264099,
0.02714654430747032,
-0.11166584491729736,
0.626285195350647,
-0.893226146697998,
0.6440281271934509,
0.11888819932937622,
0.7789831161499023,
0.9401144981384277,
-0.159584641456604,
0.23977339267730713,
-0.8754187226295471,
0.3785918354988098,
0.2619328498840332,
0.22753378748893738,
0.2921157479286194,
-0.20089977979660034,
0.013079630210995674,
0.10820358991622925,
-0.21286676824092865,
-0.5527334809303284,
0.3335549235343933,
-0.7973602414131165,
-0.24279141426086426,
0.9495941400527954,
-0.46321678161621094,
-0.1269400417804718,
-0.08956029266119003,
0.07719910144805908,
0.4935091733932495,
-0.35010066628456116,
0.6229599118232727,
0.30749085545539856,
-0.22571299970149994,
-0.358173131942749,
-0.050661928951740265,
0.571616530418396,
0.4658326804637909,
-0.3840562403202057,
0.13535939157009125,
0.3482719659805298,
0.23310033977031708,
0.21024562418460846,
0.5050966739654541,
-0.2865165174007416,
0.09374312311410904,
0.1388465166091919,
-0.26733991503715515,
-0.3920218050479889,
-0.48494234681129456,
-0.510877251625061,
-0.1234944611787796,
-0.1475675404071808,
-0.8658914566040039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01994v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01994v1 | Simple Augmentations of Logical Rules for Neuro-Symbolic Knowledge Graph Completion | 2024-07-02T07:07:59 | 2024-07-02T07:07:59 | Ananjan Nandi, Navdeep Kaur, Parag Singla, Mausam | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR | High-quality and high-coverage rule sets are imperative to the success of
Neuro-Symbolic Knowledge Graph Completion (NS-KGC) models, because they form
the basis of all symbolic inferences. Recent literature builds neural models
for generating rule sets, however, preliminary experiments show that they
struggle with maintaining high coverage. In this work, we suggest three simple
augmentations to existing rule sets: (1) transforming rules to their abductive
forms, (2) generating equivalent rules that use inverse forms of constituent
relations and (3) random walks that propose new rules. Finally, we prune
potentially low quality rules. Experiments over four datasets and five
ruleset-baseline settings suggest that these simple augmentations consistently
improve results, and obtain up to 7.1 pt MRR and 8.5 pt Hits@1 gains over using
rules without augmentations. | [
-0.38773858547210693,
-0.4613704979419708,
0.6113485097885132,
-0.10256616026163101,
-0.3702939450740814,
-0.37391021847724915,
-0.05203483626246452,
-0.4751686155796051,
0.5268467664718628,
0.8731878995895386,
-0.7533667087554932,
-0.4384090304374695,
-0.734937310218811,
0.16874337196350098,
-0.366108775138855,
0.9200542569160461,
0.15164893865585327,
-0.06258616596460342,
-0.2763775587081909,
-0.18808984756469727,
-0.6424133777618408,
-0.09828798472881317,
-0.33091410994529724,
-0.8066048622131348,
0.5381653904914856,
0.3570016622543335,
0.9524216055870056,
0.9959331750869751,
0.4960552155971527,
0.2733091413974762,
-0.34873637557029724,
0.754189670085907,
-0.34267866611480713,
-0.05643519014120102,
0.12611015141010284,
-0.4706973731517792,
-0.5048902630805969,
-0.06040768325328827,
0.28741908073425293,
1.0713592767715454,
-0.08061327040195465,
-0.20215670764446259,
-0.06150364875793457,
0.6750137805938721,
-0.6424828171730042,
0.2907200753688812,
-0.3178858160972595,
0.1600600928068161,
0.2745790481567383,
-0.26834598183631897,
-0.5152416825294495,
-0.7103656530380249,
-0.023429185152053833,
-0.9695410132408142,
-0.10233135521411896,
-0.10928688198328018,
0.712943434715271,
0.14279235899448395,
-0.8041632771492004,
-0.10198300331830978,
-0.4765056371688843,
0.23633818328380585,
-0.9447101354598999,
0.3404397964477539,
0.6175593137741089,
0.3776579201221466,
-0.2901267111301422,
-0.692024290561676,
-0.39607253670692444,
-0.26483792066574097,
-0.7316321730613708,
-0.0036597331054508686,
-0.27525031566619873,
0.4068562686443329,
0.8890310525894165,
-0.08014040440320969,
0.023450924083590508,
-0.013035970740020275,
-0.4699336588382721,
-0.22320261597633362,
0.4825437366962433,
0.15108469128608704,
0.2684098482131958,
-0.5043043494224548,
0.05143439769744873,
-0.13521437346935272,
-1.1654529571533203,
-0.08026384562253952,
0.4792521595954895,
0.2815936505794525,
0.2111581265926361,
0.9796590805053711,
-0.6960979700088501,
1.022748589515686,
0.05912140756845474,
-0.08950668573379517,
0.43624499440193176,
-0.6490848064422607,
-0.14800895750522614,
0.052009060978889465,
0.329496830701828,
0.2625521421432495,
0.34354937076568604,
-0.49696213006973267,
-0.29130393266677856,
-0.13883177936077118,
0.3400759696960449,
-0.7839868664741516,
-0.49944090843200684,
-0.35484474897384644,
-0.4563937485218048,
-0.2712732255458832,
0.08477474749088287,
0.011327721178531647,
-0.6426455974578857,
-1.0783863067626953,
0.7207234501838684,
-0.9108433723449707,
0.03786718472838402,
0.1434105634689331,
-0.5839671492576599,
0.2449207752943039,
0.7031229138374329,
-0.5138077735900879,
0.4224269688129425,
0.7318130135536194,
0.4402666985988617,
0.40231069922447205,
-0.1606108844280243,
-0.559131383895874,
0.032798606902360916,
-0.6501452922821045,
0.5726245045661926,
-0.436796098947525,
-0.06889209151268005,
-0.28844621777534485,
-0.07765474170446396,
0.14266344904899597,
-0.4328083097934723,
0.5197594165802002,
-0.6560683250427246,
0.0577375665307045,
-0.7732754349708557,
-0.373319536447525,
-0.4319635331630707,
0.2964596152305603,
-0.60324627161026,
0.6171422004699707,
0.026862001046538353,
-0.481497585773468,
0.5042548179626465,
-0.5406970381736755,
-0.9976904392242432,
-0.09402796626091003,
0.05647611990571022,
0.08595191687345505,
0.2768288850784302,
0.28901636600494385,
0.2674567699432373,
-0.03787276893854141,
-0.11494282633066177,
-0.256520539522171,
-0.32508453726768494,
0.10316937416791916,
-0.011026610620319843,
0.9627345204353333,
0.01628050021827221,
-0.24986852705478668,
0.035844866186380386,
-0.8664942979812622,
0.23078472912311554,
-0.17011971771717072,
-0.09256982803344727,
-0.5796359181404114,
0.14129865169525146,
-0.4938710927963257,
0.4716438353061676,
-0.10087253153324127,
-0.44684988260269165,
0.3315926194190979,
-0.5656282305717468,
0.3245057165622711,
0.8584890365600586,
0.1390443593263626,
0.6052536964416504,
-0.5238373279571533,
0.02149258553981781,
0.18208087980747223,
0.05730408430099487,
-0.09228617697954178,
-0.5199596881866455,
-0.8352392911911011,
-0.38488736748695374,
0.3688231110572815,
0.1611248254776001,
-0.9564061164855957,
0.736214816570282,
-0.47042137384414673,
-0.47541487216949463,
-0.3508296012878418,
0.07328842580318451,
0.21118025481700897,
0.6137740015983582,
0.3975798785686493,
-0.28768184781074524,
-0.6322806477546692,
-1.0521869659423828,
-0.13942210376262665,
-0.03337407857179642,
0.0006368991453200579,
0.41036126017570496,
0.3836418092250824,
-0.2218295782804489,
0.915216863155365,
-0.6028960347175598,
-0.26036661863327026,
-0.12009129673242569,
0.07286714017391205,
0.312790185213089,
0.2627849578857422,
0.4240991175174713,
-0.5337384939193726,
-0.12654240429401398,
0.03970876708626747,
-0.7169431447982788,
-0.08878592401742935,
0.010542497970163822,
-0.29273664951324463,
-0.30813783407211304,
0.39114341139793396,
-0.8732172846794128,
0.7002217769622803,
-0.09766954183578491,
-0.313883900642395,
0.492701917886734,
-0.14659489691257477,
0.26789265871047974,
-0.7540397644042969,
-0.17768973112106323,
-0.18713560700416565,
-0.3998449444770813,
-0.8477720618247986,
0.0416865274310112,
0.026939062401652336,
0.0711318850517273,
-0.1610824316740036,
0.28758835792541504,
-0.2597484290599823,
0.1514156013727188,
-0.36962032318115234,
0.18441660702228546,
-0.08455073088407516,
0.39987972378730774,
-0.23034369945526123,
0.13268236815929413,
0.4618217349052429,
-0.8490883111953735,
0.24287676811218262,
0.3729884922504425,
-0.0989636704325676,
0.4749416708946228,
-0.6459296941757202,
-0.1468154340982437,
-0.493142306804657,
0.31497296690940857,
-0.9281588792800903,
-0.39652112126350403,
0.4457441568374634,
-0.20706869661808014,
0.11946947872638702,
-0.22541272640228271,
-0.7379836440086365,
-0.23755569756031036,
-0.09843753278255463,
0.23426245152950287,
1.1023943424224854,
-0.7701881527900696,
1.02161705493927,
0.20383568108081818,
0.38879919052124023,
-0.3924630880355835,
-0.7069087028503418,
0.0065366108901798725,
0.13027158379554749,
-0.6370869874954224,
0.34632211923599243,
0.1644648164510727,
-0.13293014466762543,
0.24599885940551758,
-0.2588039040565491,
0.15846510231494904,
0.03449983522295952,
0.4681743383407593,
-0.10612188279628754,
-0.10301834344863892,
-0.03946457803249359,
0.22847817838191986,
0.008097546175122261,
0.25485000014305115,
-0.2907547652721405,
0.5032914280891418,
0.24784667789936066,
-0.59902024269104,
-0.45868080854415894,
0.046294569969177246,
0.4018283188343048,
-0.1536291241645813,
0.3591425120830536,
0.09658545255661011,
-0.7101595401763916,
-0.2790743410587311,
-0.46219030022621155,
-0.8136134147644043,
-0.45400530099868774,
0.1920105218887329,
-0.46209049224853516,
-0.34931129217147827,
0.41176894307136536,
-0.017827797681093216,
-0.21579085290431976,
0.5055533051490784,
0.01439583394676447,
-0.1299542486667633,
1.0723028182983398,
0.2956458330154419,
0.4031204879283905,
0.29638656973838806,
-0.22325602173805237,
0.09534893184900284,
-0.660244882106781,
-0.31990957260131836,
-0.3310280442237854,
-0.46439260244369507,
-0.6230002641677856,
-0.11181546002626419,
0.36712968349456787,
0.17999713122844696,
-0.2954169511795044,
0.7739275693893433,
-0.4574041962623596,
0.6538347601890564,
0.7533857822418213,
0.7427456378936768,
0.36865442991256714,
0.24652236700057983,
-0.1573445051908493,
-0.059131838381290436,
-0.9220793843269348,
-0.0544583685696125,
0.9787991046905518,
-0.025069501250982285,
0.6278032064437866,
0.2502255141735077,
0.7792776226997375,
0.16941900551319122,
0.3320104777812958,
-0.7468599677085876,
0.77793288230896,
-0.2323540896177292,
-0.3283466696739197,
-0.11366694420576096,
-0.7723162770271301,
-0.5727775692939758,
0.14205078780651093,
-0.43806490302085876,
-0.43070295453071594,
0.2486303150653839,
0.29410019516944885,
-0.28343528509140015,
0.18558230996131897,
-0.5265712141990662,
0.47005385160446167,
0.022187789902091026,
0.0937669426202774,
-0.46157950162887573,
-0.6715372800827026,
0.6319101452827454,
0.09022274613380432,
-0.37081626057624817,
-0.05679737403988838,
0.21945247054100037,
0.6539306044578552,
-0.756446897983551,
0.8344573378562927,
-0.22154216468334198,
0.342337429523468,
0.35225650668144226,
0.15092679858207703,
0.9296829700469971,
-0.2823347747325897,
0.16707617044448853,
-0.07027841359376907,
-0.19622483849525452,
-0.1968347728252411,
-0.9716897010803223,
0.472103476524353,
-0.6818437576293945,
-0.3955155611038208,
-0.19269520044326782,
-0.4870704114437103,
-0.1571006029844284,
0.4344295263290405,
0.010805873200297356,
0.39703577756881714,
0.25205495953559875,
0.36297309398651123,
0.6753817200660706,
0.24880823493003845,
0.09734838455915451,
0.2384701669216156,
0.006704101804643869,
-0.64692622423172,
0.7357007265090942,
0.4244103729724884,
0.22840087115764618,
0.003738691797479987,
0.14750471711158752,
-0.32093238830566406,
-0.4494692385196686,
-0.1597343236207962,
0.3422476649284363,
-0.8857997059822083,
-0.3824772834777832,
-0.6775817275047302,
-0.5998722314834595,
-0.5754373669624329,
0.11306849867105484,
0.08966261893510818,
-0.8427662253379822,
-0.10234091430902481,
-0.19571256637573242,
0.5944156646728516,
0.7543964385986328,
-0.3175273537635803,
0.48056328296661377,
-0.41180944442749023,
0.6207615733146667,
0.3083552420139313,
0.08296810835599899,
0.007113424129784107,
-0.523419976234436,
0.028701428323984146,
0.4759967625141144,
-0.2281194031238556,
-1.0054190158843994,
0.09422001242637634,
0.1374010294675827,
0.5922669172286987,
0.4467906951904297,
0.017341341823339462,
0.9276578426361084,
-0.5935461521148682,
0.16899269819259644,
0.4410165548324585,
-0.47921237349510193,
0.33733227849006653,
-0.37176528573036194,
0.12236960232257843,
0.6202409267425537,
0.34690380096435547,
-0.5310039520263672,
-0.011721783317625523,
-0.7368975281715393,
-0.6802193522453308,
0.7695249319076538,
0.39781105518341064,
0.14878453314304352,
0.06986567378044128,
0.4747350811958313,
-0.17960509657859802,
0.32902753353118896,
-0.46288588643074036,
-0.14693520963191986,
-0.3417873680591583,
-0.15984705090522766,
0.1601368933916092,
0.03296215832233429,
-0.48237287998199463,
-0.4230665862560272,
0.8590215444564819,
-0.17589369416236877,
0.09951666742563248,
-0.05340180918574333,
-0.03364727646112442,
0.10710209608078003,
0.031078463420271873,
0.46448737382888794,
0.5382797122001648,
-0.12167354673147202,
0.2530025839805603,
0.24835105240345,
-0.2572370767593384,
0.06501258164644241,
0.3662285804748535,
-0.5413958430290222,
-0.2576795220375061,
0.31880635023117065,
0.72251957654953,
-0.003795203287154436,
-0.24993790686130524,
0.353838175535202,
0.27783066034317017,
-0.38631168007850647,
-0.06558847427368164,
0.407086580991745,
-0.01886032335460186,
-0.10446999222040176,
0.04876694828271866,
0.6386513710021973,
0.1052965372800827,
-0.3325521647930145,
0.3882642984390259,
0.3934507668018341,
-0.49690473079681396,
-0.15588514506816864,
0.27339768409729004,
-0.07515314966440201,
-0.012754675932228565,
1.0145716667175293,
-0.4289346933364868,
-0.48081257939338684,
0.5990243554115295,
0.5611914992332458,
0.49403923749923706,
0.46552374958992004,
0.2787797451019287,
0.48436638712882996,
0.659571647644043,
-0.32352587580680847,
0.1457376629114151,
-0.18610024452209473,
-0.7576315999031067,
-0.6570276618003845,
-0.2716371715068817,
-0.014511004090309143,
-0.2689089775085449,
-0.2911432683467865,
0.43869057297706604,
-0.40734541416168213,
-0.1273253858089447,
-0.012705767527222633,
-0.277790367603302,
-0.6017080545425415,
0.1643899828195572,
-0.23623667657375336,
1.0656547546386719,
-0.9747756719589233,
0.5087388157844543,
0.5118118524551392,
-0.5806195139884949,
-0.9072713851928711,
-0.32331642508506775,
0.005812153220176697,
-0.6898984313011169,
0.8406585454940796,
0.11448317021131516,
0.10388827323913574,
-0.059736814349889755,
-0.42865899205207825,
-0.6850859522819519,
0.985424816608429,
0.4038032293319702,
-0.09245656430721283,
-0.3280627727508545,
0.4020593762397766,
0.4801071882247925,
-0.1506289392709732,
0.432035893201828,
0.47127509117126465,
0.8307907581329346,
0.3933027684688568,
-0.39050915837287903,
0.40247830748558044,
-0.18298779428005219,
-0.32479098439216614,
0.40799859166145325,
-0.29829898476600647,
0.5164175629615784,
-0.23657265305519104,
-0.01552293449640274,
-0.025985395535826683,
0.616473376750946,
0.38309577107429504,
0.2288590520620346,
0.6205582618713379,
1.0194419622421265,
0.6003273725509644,
-0.3826354444026947,
1.0798393487930298,
-0.14790524542331696,
-0.17708145081996918,
1.10689377784729,
-0.022843994200229645,
0.3844826817512512,
0.29835715889930725,
0.18735717236995697,
0.3530363440513611,
0.4612088203430176,
0.042053960263729095,
0.5159740447998047,
0.2628754675388336,
-0.012974242679774761,
-0.6130548119544983,
-0.2889588177204132,
-0.3400932848453522,
0.3546983003616333,
0.1580898016691208,
-0.41065850853919983,
-0.4081929624080658,
-0.14855089783668518,
0.10111189633607864,
-0.1231238916516304,
-0.46680888533592224,
0.866381824016571,
0.022649608552455902,
-0.8407347798347473,
0.4530586004257202,
0.0597543902695179,
0.28957071900367737,
-0.7711521983146667,
-0.32431739568710327,
-0.25614508986473083,
-0.0019827932119369507,
-0.43058040738105774,
-0.6502922773361206,
0.1731099635362625,
-0.45236635208129883,
-0.24282445013523102,
-0.08900941908359528,
1.0159176588058472,
-0.309045672416687,
-0.36937201023101807,
0.013490254059433937,
0.31759053468704224,
-0.11385874450206757,
-0.03840812295675278,
-0.23050683736801147,
-0.6696373820304871,
-0.06514649093151093,
0.02987964078783989,
0.11144280433654785,
0.5243397355079651,
-0.17050187289714813,
0.5977091193199158,
0.8073055744171143,
0.3179068863391876,
0.23132404685020447,
-0.12399660795927048,
1.0859622955322266,
-0.49618208408355713,
-0.18592409789562225,
-0.6480754613876343,
0.4950464963912964,
-0.39106684923171997,
-0.13808423280715942,
0.9342819452285767,
0.5546895265579224,
0.54468834400177,
-0.11024634540081024,
0.4549873471260071,
-0.24417972564697266,
-0.13951121270656586,
-0.5172919034957886,
0.8658159375190735,
-0.49964502453804016,
-0.03526369109749794,
-0.09259503334760666,
-0.8203561902046204,
-0.47537684440612793,
0.4985910654067993,
-0.2742668688297272,
0.1637139618396759,
0.5538375973701477,
0.9911758899688721,
-0.46309584379196167,
0.17815791070461273,
0.2924925982952118,
0.21962717175483704,
0.22879579663276672,
0.34850338101387024,
0.7675390839576721,
-0.5039433836936951,
0.3686753213405609,
-0.5953428149223328,
-0.08334944397211075,
-0.04375031962990761,
-0.9637678861618042,
-0.5756409764289856,
-0.3050660192966461,
-0.3260948061943054,
-0.8434016108512878,
0.08146815001964569,
1.0120564699172974,
0.9745656251907349,
-0.5888219475746155,
0.13415829837322235,
-0.32403281331062317,
0.33913499116897583,
-0.5535894632339478,
-0.18953080475330353,
0.36077672243118286,
-0.39973440766334534,
-0.10759027302265167,
0.4432835578918457,
-0.12466643005609512,
0.08694779872894287,
0.44178929924964905,
-0.3033234477043152,
-0.16505959630012512,
0.0888436809182167,
0.7324415445327759,
0.25786176323890686,
-0.48517969250679016,
-0.27549928426742554,
0.15194766223430634,
-0.0819145068526268,
-0.09148375689983368,
0.8470699191093445,
-1.0141814947128296,
0.3001185357570648,
0.9661427140235901,
0.6640413999557495,
0.38647589087486267,
0.17402343451976776,
0.23040185868740082,
-0.8108340501785278,
-0.1933746337890625,
0.23812635242938995,
0.4805864095687866,
-0.027538351714611053,
-0.003374506952241063,
0.6134194731712341,
0.4429139494895935,
-0.18158859014511108,
-0.8500390648841858,
0.3712764382362366,
-1.0281003713607788,
-0.08194985240697861,
1.1131690740585327,
0.30663660168647766,
-0.28029218316078186,
0.33814772963523865,
-0.1924045830965042,
0.05212632194161415,
-0.12163421511650085,
0.4846021234989166,
0.4358949661254883,
-0.4404694736003876,
0.21960079669952393,
-0.21073521673679352,
0.5249552726745605,
0.21921302378177643,
-0.8437232375144958,
0.10022922605276108,
0.9165064692497253,
0.3040265142917633,
0.4150393009185791,
0.33614978194236755,
-0.1801835149526596,
0.5726226568222046,
-0.13809548318386078,
0.009314646013081074,
-0.5499832034111023,
-0.5499511957168579,
-0.011597267352044582,
0.21082989871501923,
-0.08075650036334991,
0.3024485111236572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01992v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01992v1 | Is Your Large Language Model Knowledgeable or a Choices-Only Cheater? | 2024-07-02T07:06:53 | 2024-07-02T07:06:53 | Nishant Balepur, Rachel Rudinger | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent work shows that large language models (LLMs) can answer
multiple-choice questions using only the choices, but does this mean that MCQA
leaderboard rankings of LLMs are largely influenced by abilities in
choices-only settings? To answer this, we use a contrast set that probes if
LLMs over-rely on choices-only shortcuts in MCQA. While previous works build
contrast sets via expensive human annotations or model-generated data which can
be biased, we employ graph mining to extract contrast sets from existing MCQA
datasets. We use our method on UnifiedQA, a group of six commonsense reasoning
datasets with high choices-only accuracy, to build an 820-question contrast
set. After validating our contrast set, we test 12 LLMs, finding that these
models do not exhibit reliance on choice-only shortcuts when given both the
question and choices. Thus, despite the susceptibility~of MCQA to high
choices-only accuracy, we argue that LLMs are not obtaining high ranks on MCQA
leaderboards just due to their ability to exploit choices-only shortcuts. | [
-0.38209933042526245,
-0.6209117770195007,
0.8391385078430176,
-0.1362139880657196,
-0.09566696733236313,
0.12252676486968994,
-0.07950020581483841,
-0.26720330119132996,
0.22249700129032135,
1.0398281812667847,
-0.33028629422187805,
-0.4656536877155304,
-0.7734780311584473,
0.03611396625638008,
-0.07841303199529648,
0.8522469401359558,
0.06854851543903351,
0.07386002689599991,
-0.4620603919029236,
-0.34054797887802124,
-0.2808978259563446,
-0.5711036324501038,
-0.8560529351234436,
-0.5435203313827515,
0.8212818503379822,
0.572186291217804,
1.1526949405670166,
0.598457396030426,
0.1741834282875061,
0.26636186242103577,
-0.392616331577301,
0.17991957068443298,
-0.5104725956916809,
-0.015291884541511536,
-0.40505242347717285,
-0.5133397579193115,
-0.1362600326538086,
0.02297981083393097,
0.38573697209358215,
0.6982126832008362,
0.15613920986652374,
0.22751544415950775,
0.06452123820781708,
0.5382820963859558,
-0.5931727886199951,
0.1140940710902214,
-0.8081935048103333,
-0.14646059274673462,
-0.4130217134952545,
0.07157059758901596,
-0.45082464814186096,
-0.11072799563407898,
-0.19192039966583252,
-0.21497167646884918,
-0.05992833897471428,
0.08169934153556824,
0.788501501083374,
0.3495290279388428,
-0.8962713479995728,
-0.3727911412715912,
-0.22667749226093292,
0.9780452847480774,
-0.6979245543479919,
0.3229723572731018,
0.5434368252754211,
0.36205607652664185,
-0.2652861475944519,
-0.5392454266548157,
-0.35791242122650146,
-0.41424208879470825,
-0.15019336342811584,
0.07360053807497025,
0.020835718140006065,
0.08559833467006683,
0.3751192092895508,
0.06640173494815826,
-0.26941370964050293,
0.526706874370575,
-0.3824171721935272,
-0.33484888076782227,
0.49407726526260376,
0.11922328919172287,
0.36526545882225037,
-0.2589106559753418,
-0.17325763404369354,
0.029231054708361626,
-0.7778230905532837,
0.18414932489395142,
0.4398820996284485,
0.4735928177833557,
0.21115879714488983,
0.8520686626434326,
-0.2978784143924713,
0.8022833466529846,
-0.3578449487686157,
-0.26276934146881104,
-0.0525234118103981,
-0.002451271517202258,
-0.2248208075761795,
-0.15808655321598053,
0.739841103553772,
0.24182254076004028,
0.48830896615982056,
-0.10928016155958176,
-0.08971913903951645,
-0.11232805252075195,
-0.06158461049199104,
-0.7253555059432983,
-0.5756522417068481,
0.32688596844673157,
-0.22042252123355865,
-0.2703307867050171,
-0.14351403713226318,
-0.5167972445487976,
-0.5457003116607666,
-0.0632234588265419,
0.41021889448165894,
0.078803651034832,
-0.09515844285488129,
-0.04990653693675995,
-0.28260329365730286,
-0.024954576045274734,
0.20616355538368225,
-0.5896349549293518,
0.20977550745010376,
0.4648534953594208,
0.7900912165641785,
-0.16107094287872314,
-0.4274732172489166,
-0.6222200393676758,
-0.05434464290738106,
-0.3928776979446411,
0.7598690390586853,
-0.7285013794898987,
-0.5276755690574646,
-0.1655367910861969,
-0.03586293011903763,
-0.08046159893274307,
-0.7004044055938721,
0.7214354872703552,
-0.7427250146865845,
-0.06468866765499115,
-0.6879434585571289,
-0.5539378523826599,
-0.00942049827426672,
0.017521554604172707,
-0.9406649470329285,
0.7559987902641296,
-0.1073715090751648,
-0.906817615032196,
0.37126466631889343,
-0.4009793996810913,
-0.4030115604400635,
-0.09627334773540497,
-0.3232073485851288,
-0.3080084025859833,
-0.18823932111263275,
0.3325057327747345,
0.30167800188064575,
0.08547510951757431,
0.15094883739948273,
-0.6502793431282043,
-0.4200516641139984,
0.6010834574699402,
-0.3166113495826721,
1.0713015794754028,
0.08569972217082977,
-0.1912996768951416,
-0.18004173040390015,
-0.42157039046287537,
0.1754077821969986,
0.17247971892356873,
-0.6143139600753784,
-0.24934765696525574,
0.09450419992208481,
-0.37664493918418884,
0.7030031681060791,
0.15078067779541016,
-0.3780567944049835,
0.1342080682516098,
0.06979241222143173,
0.11809901893138885,
1.2095218896865845,
-0.11419468373060226,
0.2546476423740387,
-0.5536207556724548,
0.45121726393699646,
0.09918835759162903,
-0.145417258143425,
0.4918563663959503,
-0.6419737339019775,
-0.8494492769241333,
-0.37712356448173523,
0.5216761231422424,
0.4678066372871399,
-0.9453666806221008,
0.21645744144916534,
-0.07877742499113083,
-0.392559677362442,
-0.6058629155158997,
0.46463078260421753,
0.599247932434082,
0.5632230639457703,
0.17820456624031067,
-0.03687645494937897,
-0.3211606740951538,
-1.1559590101242065,
-0.6018655896186829,
-0.005704350303858519,
0.12733644247055054,
0.7883716821670532,
0.5988363027572632,
-0.011949644424021244,
0.7364044189453125,
-0.7594625949859619,
-0.048022471368312836,
-0.24103397130966187,
-0.3249797224998474,
0.395719975233078,
0.15149015188217163,
0.38051286339759827,
-0.7812934517860413,
-0.44523921608924866,
-0.3664441704750061,
-0.5802320241928101,
-0.1468694657087326,
0.2640533447265625,
-0.3152300715446472,
-0.035754382610321045,
0.6094892024993896,
-0.4464823305606842,
0.07936287671327591,
0.6386121511459351,
-0.39981088042259216,
0.6200729608535767,
0.006275358144193888,
0.03814501315355301,
-0.7250317931175232,
0.0089945700019598,
-0.1775798499584198,
-0.14839033782482147,
-0.47160905599594116,
0.03192688897252083,
-0.07013044506311417,
0.07797064632177353,
-0.5333530306816101,
0.9742375612258911,
-0.1996547281742096,
-0.10273363441228867,
-0.21612617373466492,
0.2500394582748413,
-0.002031094627454877,
0.47913244366645813,
0.017181959003210068,
0.7123810648918152,
0.5985288619995117,
-0.8241418600082397,
0.14064976572990417,
0.3531958758831024,
-0.4643053412437439,
0.3227725923061371,
-0.49470824003219604,
0.2838016748428345,
-0.07263751327991486,
0.35344982147216797,
-0.9016991257667542,
-0.3257162868976593,
0.05502450093626976,
-0.23551127314567566,
-0.07965455204248428,
-0.2609061300754547,
-0.5047485828399658,
-0.34683528542518616,
-0.17284318804740906,
0.023937884718179703,
0.3752998411655426,
-0.8194491863250732,
0.3605417013168335,
0.3902668058872223,
-0.3001880943775177,
-0.9117262959480286,
-0.7156000733375549,
-0.10029798746109009,
-0.011719957925379276,
-0.43381452560424805,
-0.058445658534765244,
-0.3849332630634308,
-0.49674713611602783,
-0.181053027510643,
-0.14843635261058807,
-0.07703975588083267,
0.2148459106683731,
0.3631579875946045,
0.1996520757675171,
0.0111745810136199,
0.17486083507537842,
0.06042185053229332,
0.0750804990530014,
-0.050606559962034225,
0.14206738770008087,
0.42996278405189514,
0.001628353726118803,
-0.4025844931602478,
0.07892604917287827,
0.24414442479610443,
0.619501531124115,
-0.25666627287864685,
0.7717103362083435,
0.1489790976047516,
0.008851241320371628,
-0.3475002944469452,
-0.46347561478614807,
-0.02073211409151554,
-0.4799948036670685,
0.493868350982666,
-0.5548304319381714,
-1.1236258745193481,
0.6882665753364563,
0.0846571996808052,
0.1799742877483368,
0.3343358039855957,
0.3907340168952942,
-0.18088562786579132,
1.276955008506775,
0.28410476446151733,
-0.19621464610099792,
0.2998879849910736,
0.014448466710746288,
-0.03885821998119354,
-0.719146728515625,
-0.03282952681183815,
-0.6662735939025879,
-0.40414413809776306,
-0.7765799164772034,
-0.13413368165493011,
0.2780884802341461,
0.08670670539140701,
-0.4998602867126465,
-0.16717953979969025,
-0.2403375506401062,
0.9043652415275574,
0.6447659134864807,
0.3939771354198456,
0.35621923208236694,
-0.2541031539440155,
-0.24365058541297913,
0.14302587509155273,
-0.803979218006134,
-0.41188594698905945,
1.3828729391098022,
0.025065740570425987,
0.6667236089706421,
0.3462183177471161,
0.6949650645256042,
-0.03092673048377037,
0.13352808356285095,
-0.6315035820007324,
0.6687390208244324,
-0.3409196138381958,
-0.9646176695823669,
-0.36616477370262146,
-0.7294150590896606,
-0.7723029851913452,
0.42799341678619385,
-0.2107807993888855,
-0.6206692457199097,
0.018141383305191994,
0.16955780982971191,
-0.2567477226257324,
0.5710051655769348,
-0.5904579162597656,
0.7609575390815735,
-0.32596760988235474,
-0.2520093321800232,
0.3246783912181854,
-0.6133645176887512,
0.6773316860198975,
-0.12061939388513565,
0.3447849154472351,
-0.00031797666451893747,
0.08481977134943008,
0.8693296909332275,
-0.1638917326927185,
0.8327128887176514,
0.003979681525379419,
0.14165247976779938,
0.19829225540161133,
0.1679273098707199,
0.451860636472702,
-0.0256524495780468,
-0.31566253304481506,
-0.0016321575967594981,
-0.22021523118019104,
-0.8556057810783386,
-0.45026102662086487,
1.0383504629135132,
-0.8507760763168335,
-0.6817941069602966,
-0.37254953384399414,
-0.41367560625076294,
-0.40592071413993835,
0.39693939685821533,
0.34528103470802307,
0.4216563403606415,
-0.06246354058384895,
-0.04867332801222801,
0.6587401032447815,
-0.06320010870695114,
0.27425846457481384,
0.2803401052951813,
-0.40236374735832214,
-0.2251506745815277,
0.7411803603172302,
0.3443912863731384,
0.5402382016181946,
0.005278219468891621,
0.35685595870018005,
-0.36078161001205444,
-0.61362224817276,
-0.3898705542087555,
0.46812647581100464,
-1.1701985597610474,
-0.06421114504337311,
-0.5359331965446472,
-0.29470089077949524,
-0.19897235929965973,
-0.1710519790649414,
-0.21355389058589935,
-0.3624616265296936,
-0.2879723608493805,
-0.28115636110305786,
0.08268290013074875,
0.879302442073822,
0.21799598634243011,
0.09845975041389465,
-0.5203127861022949,
0.38772279024124146,
0.8382671475410461,
0.4097471833229065,
-0.06701505929231644,
-0.5011330246925354,
-0.15341879427433014,
-0.06649462133646011,
-0.2589150369167328,
-0.8185402154922485,
-0.03631307929754257,
0.011717567220330238,
0.7842715978622437,
0.35639286041259766,
0.09737003594636917,
0.32963576912879944,
-0.21640178561210632,
0.8154067397117615,
-0.18930457532405853,
-0.7402178645133972,
0.11000943928956985,
-0.11732510477304459,
0.3656407296657562,
0.844560444355011,
0.3759085536003113,
-0.4211929440498352,
-0.5559742450714111,
-0.8373650312423706,
-0.33314049243927,
0.6490639448165894,
0.02533082477748394,
0.07096114754676819,
-0.039774637669324875,
0.2645299732685089,
0.035058729350566864,
0.2896304130554199,
-0.9843849539756775,
-0.39155593514442444,
-0.037553586065769196,
0.014364460483193398,
-0.36728283762931824,
-0.16346877813339233,
-0.28226709365844727,
-0.06730980426073074,
0.6884980797767639,
-0.2508941888809204,
-0.1642070710659027,
-0.26487112045288086,
-0.0875949040055275,
0.11741318553686142,
0.5290336012840271,
0.32385843992233276,
0.8647556304931641,
-0.23338443040847778,
0.4454435706138611,
0.33578765392303467,
-0.2783496379852295,
-0.09164063632488251,
-0.08185888826847076,
-0.1811412125825882,
0.06863424181938171,
0.2814626395702362,
0.5719001889228821,
0.11275219172239304,
-0.7589452862739563,
0.5180160403251648,
0.19368231296539307,
-0.1946752816438675,
0.13420605659484863,
0.27288123965263367,
0.4098721444606781,
0.18300968408584595,
-0.17496222257614136,
0.054458532482385635,
0.006444798316806555,
-0.6714887619018555,
0.10217151045799255,
0.7099570035934448,
-0.4158768653869629,
0.1359139233827591,
0.3174641728401184,
0.0857219249010086,
-0.21125739812850952,
0.8300379514694214,
-0.026370396837592125,
-0.7156912088394165,
0.7724668979644775,
0.43058523535728455,
0.36165058612823486,
-0.16215595602989197,
0.33546683192253113,
0.14891143143177032,
0.1682947874069214,
-0.25074502825737,
0.2486823946237564,
0.2095714658498764,
-0.9121392965316772,
-0.24382159113883972,
-0.38932493329048157,
-0.6640976071357727,
0.2833702266216278,
-0.5870568752288818,
0.4185720384120941,
-0.42236021161079407,
-0.10021866858005524,
0.0508250892162323,
-0.01722949743270874,
-0.6083196401596069,
0.5209445953369141,
-0.0861530527472496,
0.803605318069458,
-0.9010241627693176,
0.8633753657341003,
0.44579094648361206,
-0.28099822998046875,
-0.7345776557922363,
-0.08995741605758667,
-0.04162351042032242,
-0.8961355090141296,
0.5327404141426086,
-0.04684955254197121,
-0.09456046670675278,
-0.1450110226869583,
-0.8676241040229797,
-0.6683728694915771,
1.0900955200195312,
0.32184073328971863,
-0.355585515499115,
-0.06547514349222183,
0.06116902828216553,
0.20571866631507874,
-0.13928556442260742,
0.3718969523906708,
0.7568709254264832,
0.5435091257095337,
0.30522555112838745,
-0.792715847492218,
-0.06671438366174698,
0.0077330442145466805,
-0.352094829082489,
0.26649153232574463,
-0.8889986872673035,
0.99281245470047,
-0.3827226161956787,
-0.025773344561457634,
-0.18063855171203613,
0.1528458595275879,
0.5391868352890015,
0.1758870631456375,
0.5625712871551514,
0.420711487531662,
0.8941136598587036,
0.07830219715833664,
1.1142431497573853,
-0.019692935049533844,
0.2186603993177414,
1.3974065780639648,
-0.18514353036880493,
0.9083681106567383,
0.4873238801956177,
0.01949843391776085,
0.4061211943626404,
0.6432334184646606,
0.09567486494779587,
0.5514545440673828,
0.3468608856201172,
0.037186406552791595,
-0.7933551669120789,
-0.08849620074033737,
-0.08978879451751709,
0.5740368962287903,
0.060747310519218445,
-0.45355021953582764,
-0.1604960858821869,
-0.20581257343292236,
0.4615343511104584,
0.029420239850878716,
-0.40341612696647644,
0.5909743905067444,
0.2720251679420471,
-0.7932703495025635,
0.42304903268814087,
-0.07674775272607803,
0.5095460414886475,
-0.655238151550293,
0.05651719123125076,
-0.21773825585842133,
-0.1539316028356552,
-0.2820838391780853,
-0.9987643361091614,
-0.24620041251182556,
-0.09375692903995514,
-0.05929197743535042,
0.003995399922132492,
0.6336613297462463,
-0.26261985301971436,
-0.4539816379547119,
0.20652881264686584,
0.7320796847343445,
0.1465042382478714,
-0.07804486155509949,
-0.7686248421669006,
-0.22480043768882751,
0.1414622664451599,
-0.13209722936153412,
0.49904370307922363,
0.02665984071791172,
-0.10396233201026917,
0.7487137317657471,
0.6595898270606995,
0.22052700817584991,
-0.09018510580062866,
0.05165170505642891,
1.0150972604751587,
-0.6837697625160217,
-0.46003225445747375,
-0.8673690557479858,
0.43173137307167053,
-0.24803586304187775,
-0.48185253143310547,
0.7940880060195923,
0.5766971111297607,
0.6986188292503357,
0.13418056070804596,
1.0320566892623901,
0.40708428621292114,
0.5827596783638,
-0.8673524856567383,
0.800620436668396,
-0.6132893562316895,
0.39008840918540955,
-0.18707366287708282,
-0.6923539042472839,
-0.13552320003509521,
0.14864911139011383,
-0.5710115432739258,
0.2963431477546692,
0.6489656567573547,
0.8896945714950562,
-0.19130459427833557,
-0.13927076756954193,
0.4172047972679138,
0.29998138546943665,
0.37112605571746826,
0.6693967580795288,
0.9044312238693237,
0.10637383908033371,
0.7427939772605896,
-0.058280400931835175,
-0.3009626865386963,
-0.19070062041282654,
-0.7284135222434998,
-1.2687608003616333,
-0.251985102891922,
-0.10799463838338852,
-0.5764561295509338,
-0.052969325333833694,
0.5017401576042175,
0.321879506111145,
-0.6419139504432678,
-0.20502838492393494,
0.31486067175865173,
0.6972742080688477,
-0.04236086457967758,
-0.15512986481189728,
0.4902927279472351,
-0.02825157903134823,
-0.5866357088088989,
0.24468480050563812,
-0.16829457879066467,
-0.014604673720896244,
-0.09636227786540985,
-0.061326730996370316,
-0.1986466348171234,
0.4697710871696472,
0.2906528115272522,
0.25820544362068176,
-0.6528325080871582,
-0.4913778603076935,
0.0444469153881073,
-0.25068050622940063,
0.26083460450172424,
0.704289972782135,
-0.4562434256076813,
0.4462924599647522,
0.3926621377468109,
0.3785490095615387,
0.45666247606277466,
-0.22706860303878784,
0.09792081266641617,
-0.6231895089149475,
-0.18508967757225037,
0.21511511504650116,
0.47339552640914917,
0.35961851477622986,
-0.1787293404340744,
0.17983698844909668,
-0.09931506961584091,
-0.787884533405304,
-0.5938096642494202,
0.6164491772651672,
-0.8506240248680115,
-0.5792977213859558,
1.4372855424880981,
0.02645760402083397,
-0.20436902344226837,
-0.3450005352497101,
-0.34417101740837097,
-0.03533755615353584,
-0.3219584822654724,
0.49153366684913635,
1.0113935470581055,
-0.36222976446151733,
-0.006222790107131004,
-0.6950576901435852,
0.6065367460250854,
0.32422569394111633,
-0.7357504367828369,
-0.032713137567043304,
0.4382789134979248,
0.5532122850418091,
0.09423137456178665,
0.738272488117218,
0.034623656421899796,
0.14811237156391144,
0.0469478964805603,
-0.30834147334098816,
-0.2787630558013916,
-0.33015283942222595,
-0.3559894561767578,
0.30561208724975586,
0.5071289539337158,
0.031214633956551552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01976v1 | A Bounding Box is Worth One Token: Interleaving Layout and Text in a Large Language Model for Document Understanding | 2024-07-02T06:29:05 | 2024-07-02T06:29:05 | Jinghui Lu, Haiyang Yu, Yanjie Wang, Yongjie Ye, Jingqun Tang, Ziwei Yang, Binghong Wu, Qi Liu, Hao Feng, Han Wang, Hao Liu, Can Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM | Recently, many studies have demonstrated that exclusively incorporating
OCR-derived text and spatial layouts with large language models (LLMs) can be
highly effective for document understanding tasks. However, existing methods
that integrate spatial layouts with text have limitations, such as producing
overly long text sequences or failing to fully leverage the autoregressive
traits of LLMs. In this work, we introduce Interleaving Layout and Text in a
Large Language Model (LayTextLLM)} for document understanding. In particular,
LayTextLLM projects each bounding box to a single embedding and interleaves it
with text, efficiently avoiding long sequence issues while leveraging
autoregressive traits of LLMs. LayTextLLM not only streamlines the interaction
of layout and textual data but also shows enhanced performance in Key
Information Extraction (KIE) and Visual Question Answering (VQA). Comprehensive
benchmark evaluations reveal significant improvements, with a 27.0% increase on
KIE tasks and 24.1% on VQA tasks compared to previous state-of-the-art document
understanding MLLMs, as well as a 15.5% improvement over other SOTA OCR-based
LLMs on KIE tasks. | [
-0.3758614659309387,
-0.889535129070282,
0.8260194063186646,
0.337634801864624,
-0.3925741910934448,
0.08062747865915298,
-0.27907752990722656,
-0.38808485865592957,
-0.1364239752292633,
0.8132227063179016,
-0.3921511471271515,
-0.6631444096565247,
-0.6452037692070007,
-0.09296449273824692,
-0.31355148553848267,
0.619429886341095,
-0.381596177816391,
0.05325942113995552,
-0.48923707008361816,
-0.18370798230171204,
-0.6955397129058838,
-0.46398523449897766,
-0.09060424566268921,
-0.184172585606575,
0.194583460688591,
0.35107487440109253,
0.8278659582138062,
0.9902408123016357,
0.5052326917648315,
0.33537301421165466,
-0.3015405535697937,
0.2469893991947174,
-0.3750563859939575,
0.048956502228975296,
-0.22855590283870697,
-0.47189828753471375,
-0.30294501781463623,
-0.03151903301477432,
0.5877101421356201,
0.701144814491272,
0.0876440778374672,
-0.2539622485637665,
0.07877185940742493,
0.6511660218238831,
-0.4071330726146698,
0.36655566096305847,
-0.36810991168022156,
0.33527156710624695,
0.06108033284544945,
-0.35698315501213074,
-0.6692626476287842,
-0.27946239709854126,
0.2077428698539734,
-0.8150061368942261,
0.06552824378013611,
-0.006754948291927576,
0.6689605116844177,
0.43774986267089844,
-0.501220703125,
-0.6411083936691284,
-0.35338547825813293,
0.42207154631614685,
-0.5862147808074951,
0.7203291654586792,
0.5867674946784973,
0.08553510159254074,
-0.07188007980585098,
-0.6796537041664124,
-0.5122472643852234,
0.07636401802301407,
-0.42287272214889526,
0.41051632165908813,
-0.07781309634447098,
0.048919305205345154,
0.4575640559196472,
0.3684881627559662,
-0.766030490398407,
0.2557438910007477,
-0.39302951097488403,
0.031941886991262436,
0.3486004173755646,
-0.07099048793315887,
0.668916642665863,
-0.32232868671417236,
-0.4186749756336212,
-0.22087439894676208,
-0.5765056610107422,
-0.07018522918224335,
0.08796631544828415,
0.07275804877281189,
-0.11942186206579208,
0.6255207061767578,
0.20772643387317657,
0.7916551232337952,
-0.18690745532512665,
-0.10325871407985687,
-0.08522279560565948,
-0.31773701310157776,
-0.34752267599105835,
-0.12516582012176514,
0.6431618928909302,
0.16103041172027588,
0.15077465772628784,
-0.3844291567802429,
0.1582508683204651,
-0.2789335250854492,
0.27704933285713196,
-0.890873372554779,
-0.008090752176940441,
0.22141098976135254,
-0.5882915258407593,
0.26556381583213806,
0.21752895414829254,
-0.7901447415351868,
-0.3378904163837433,
-0.44978803396224976,
0.3370872735977173,
-0.8602448105812073,
0.11528568714857101,
0.41596877574920654,
-0.12959912419319153,
0.39902564883232117,
0.7005409598350525,
-0.6409706473350525,
0.22839340567588806,
0.797263503074646,
0.9558101892471313,
-0.12241833657026291,
-0.2981151342391968,
-0.8294200301170349,
0.16496887803077698,
-0.2781389355659485,
0.7632729411125183,
-0.4462089240550995,
-0.3345668613910675,
0.14943934977054596,
0.059441711753606796,
0.030106807127594948,
-0.5060815215110779,
0.47987592220306396,
-0.7924002408981323,
0.5752733945846558,
-0.14442512392997742,
-0.7147213220596313,
-0.1586349904537201,
0.10511701554059982,
-0.7110593318939209,
0.8235688209533691,
-0.1277269870042801,
-0.5510045886039734,
0.31452664732933044,
-0.5259702205657959,
-0.4617384672164917,
0.29721397161483765,
-0.3575228452682495,
-0.4691713750362396,
0.21957534551620483,
0.3579672873020172,
0.5452147722244263,
0.07055314630270004,
0.2869495749473572,
-0.1680006980895996,
-0.3296513259410858,
0.19636724889278412,
-0.2577361762523651,
0.5430893898010254,
0.24063754081726074,
-0.27577531337738037,
-0.21371373534202576,
-0.6027988195419312,
0.03334115073084831,
-0.09387984126806259,
-0.4197278618812561,
-0.5154425501823425,
-0.07984641194343567,
0.0714816227555275,
0.23093219101428986,
0.27178943157196045,
-0.30985093116760254,
0.3774860203266144,
-0.3057319223880768,
0.36651158332824707,
0.47989097237586975,
-0.3598390221595764,
0.8969526290893555,
0.001868022489361465,
0.626676619052887,
0.03163424879312515,
-0.18493005633354187,
-0.6839621067047119,
-0.13105672597885132,
-0.456694096326828,
-0.4565003514289856,
0.23533450067043304,
0.47553104162216187,
-0.811530351638794,
0.6090049147605896,
-0.2254350334405899,
-0.1735394448041916,
-0.19946503639221191,
0.0630243718624115,
0.5011656880378723,
0.1637318879365921,
0.3119962513446808,
-0.09311439841985703,
-0.2618350088596344,
-0.7277376055717468,
-0.2903265357017517,
0.187901571393013,
0.1228894516825676,
0.29488128423690796,
0.3976530134677887,
-0.09071718901395798,
0.9762598872184753,
-0.6531268954277039,
-0.4457891285419464,
-0.14884278178215027,
0.22470766305923462,
0.3361091911792755,
0.30764150619506836,
0.26173675060272217,
-1.041284441947937,
-0.8678616285324097,
0.10489907115697861,
-0.845634937286377,
-0.1385520100593567,
-0.07591840624809265,
-0.3512420058250427,
0.07851038128137589,
0.9363852143287659,
-0.5896944403648376,
0.927506148815155,
0.49898937344551086,
-0.6537927389144897,
0.11226877570152283,
-0.5475724935531616,
0.10199904441833496,
-1.0668529272079468,
-0.1720510572195053,
-0.023587727919220924,
-0.34295737743377686,
-0.6737875938415527,
0.19985240697860718,
0.6676797866821289,
-0.2680118978023529,
-0.18731580674648285,
0.7211102247238159,
-0.9498055577278137,
-0.3687364459037781,
-0.23907965421676636,
0.49564266204833984,
0.45040085911750793,
0.2902268171310425,
0.3924865126609802,
0.9699040055274963,
-0.02174849808216095,
-0.30256226658821106,
-0.25600430369377136,
0.6981224417686462,
-0.6507799625396729,
0.5840813517570496,
-0.3870204985141754,
0.08533705770969391,
-0.5622872710227966,
0.38973021507263184,
-1.1195471286773682,
-0.05348288640379906,
-0.18280000984668732,
-0.25201573967933655,
0.4676186442375183,
0.007500401232391596,
-0.5989851951599121,
-0.20117858052253723,
-0.22711926698684692,
0.38188523054122925,
0.3980731964111328,
-0.8699495196342468,
0.8274695873260498,
0.2451651245355606,
-0.27480778098106384,
-0.5505260229110718,
-0.7491499781608582,
0.1070040613412857,
-0.13610389828681946,
-0.7944765090942383,
0.3956313729286194,
-0.15069779753684998,
-0.24450922012329102,
-0.03001665696501732,
0.08577550202608109,
-0.08332068473100662,
0.0006023191963322461,
0.23931224644184113,
0.0684671476483345,
-0.2501028776168823,
0.42731380462646484,
-0.036113809794187546,
-0.1638573855161667,
-0.21370503306388855,
-0.4526112973690033,
0.6620135307312012,
0.21813121438026428,
-0.4068332016468048,
-0.20017175376415253,
0.7494933009147644,
0.7650989294052124,
-0.38505497574806213,
0.9821087121963501,
0.34243717789649963,
-0.41725561022758484,
-0.22533829510211945,
-0.5844240188598633,
0.2299693375825882,
-0.450744092464447,
0.6433905363082886,
-0.7328364253044128,
-0.9218549728393555,
0.46062350273132324,
-0.10638729482889175,
0.1339310109615326,
0.1625746339559555,
0.33521977066993713,
-0.4285672903060913,
0.8040798902511597,
0.8709971904754639,
0.16874799132347107,
0.5476511120796204,
-0.17954640090465546,
0.470148503780365,
-0.9395216703414917,
-0.2417306751012802,
-0.6203933954238892,
-0.1920361965894699,
-0.23363757133483887,
-0.9203727841377258,
0.4506376385688782,
0.335751473903656,
0.20689590275287628,
0.19036263227462769,
-0.3769485354423523,
0.7559497952461243,
0.43015792965888977,
0.2355881780385971,
0.5166434049606323,
0.21671544015407562,
-0.015473728999495506,
-0.37303242087364197,
-0.6298310160636902,
-0.5645052194595337,
0.612718403339386,
0.5072021484375,
0.9081705212593079,
0.26897892355918884,
0.5123465657234192,
-0.013590577989816666,
0.1983385980129242,
-0.6578577160835266,
0.44974270462989807,
-0.6617483496665955,
-0.029659809544682503,
-0.3192095160484314,
-0.29221615195274353,
-1.0020029544830322,
0.4706067144870758,
0.1215556338429451,
-0.8765754699707031,
0.2318449169397354,
-0.15305228531360626,
-0.14761117100715637,
0.32833313941955566,
-0.6421953439712524,
0.7244898676872253,
-0.3120708465576172,
-0.3669252395629883,
-0.008648443967103958,
-0.21873816847801208,
0.17077666521072388,
-0.0036643489729613066,
0.3749459981918335,
0.22806017100811005,
-0.14399276673793793,
0.5945233106613159,
-0.6313422918319702,
0.6946685314178467,
0.11186487227678299,
-0.45176106691360474,
-0.03788229450583458,
0.1198611706495285,
0.5877140760421753,
-0.08930513262748718,
-0.16025079786777496,
-0.12077279388904572,
-0.03331489861011505,
-0.29258525371551514,
-0.796581506729126,
0.6314052939414978,
-0.7969284653663635,
-0.4690198004245758,
-0.24002650380134583,
-0.9130752682685852,
-0.18850213289260864,
0.17337782680988312,
0.41555243730545044,
0.8274403810501099,
-0.2657106816768646,
0.41006144881248474,
1.2716673612594604,
-0.6084727644920349,
0.36857926845550537,
0.4735686182975769,
-0.38885200023651123,
-0.4954179525375366,
0.515127956867218,
0.23862217366695404,
0.24704720079898834,
0.8896111845970154,
0.09473859518766403,
-0.604254961013794,
-0.39439383149147034,
-0.4296010136604309,
0.4495265781879425,
-0.8848291039466858,
-0.19719699025154114,
-1.2704529762268066,
-0.29597151279449463,
-0.3777633011341095,
-0.5917449593544006,
0.03259558975696564,
-0.13027700781822205,
-0.4098694324493408,
-0.12161020934581757,
0.25573763251304626,
0.9418937563896179,
0.040153224021196365,
0.5358090996742249,
-0.79155033826828,
0.38966670632362366,
0.18901510536670685,
0.42147865891456604,
0.010432054288685322,
-0.633088231086731,
-0.30274537205696106,
-0.322042852640152,
-0.060186952352523804,
-0.948292076587677,
0.47355037927627563,
-0.13505828380584717,
0.41300836205482483,
0.1808498501777649,
-0.2981936037540436,
0.9074205160140991,
-0.5108270645141602,
0.3945505917072296,
0.16571059823036194,
-1.0117417573928833,
0.31349316239356995,
-0.3443117141723633,
0.9830553531646729,
0.47877591848373413,
0.302738755941391,
-0.67234206199646,
-0.38324257731437683,
-0.45180174708366394,
-0.6214654445648193,
0.8232666254043579,
-0.05076152831315994,
-0.1166449710726738,
0.2270670384168625,
0.5104896426200867,
0.2565198540687561,
0.13469305634498596,
-0.9169999361038208,
0.14796864986419678,
0.14046403765678406,
-0.604900062084198,
-0.30154523253440857,
-0.5971024036407471,
0.08781927824020386,
-0.05101945996284485,
0.5508670210838318,
-0.254939466714859,
0.2116260975599289,
0.28947582840919495,
-0.6574621796607971,
0.07186859101057053,
0.28300729393959045,
0.40457192063331604,
0.6157302260398865,
-0.042265843600034714,
0.2506220042705536,
0.029169531539082527,
-0.5809618830680847,
0.0502106249332428,
0.23862062394618988,
-0.14616179466247559,
-0.04314009100198746,
0.6190029382705688,
0.7246545553207397,
0.1725866049528122,
-0.6307302713394165,
0.5754237771034241,
-0.3083741068840027,
-0.4208436608314514,
-0.01582353748381138,
-0.3179299235343933,
0.11078781634569168,
0.26486003398895264,
0.16658896207809448,
-0.5607107877731323,
0.03153093159198761,
-0.6247920989990234,
0.3197042942047119,
0.5404343605041504,
-0.4303179383277893,
0.10744643956422806,
0.4883703291416168,
0.07457070797681808,
-0.4514539837837219,
0.6051639318466187,
0.11650911718606949,
-0.7583574652671814,
0.6990565657615662,
0.7305838465690613,
0.6377242207527161,
0.11239700019359589,
0.20157216489315033,
0.3747731149196625,
0.3852982819080353,
0.073104627430439,
0.21652865409851074,
-0.37845245003700256,
-0.43058449029922485,
-0.5544429421424866,
-0.6323756575584412,
-0.24224013090133667,
0.14000658690929413,
-0.5226656198501587,
0.14741383492946625,
-0.302641361951828,
0.28213030099868774,
-0.24246154725551605,
0.07777119427919388,
-0.7979938387870789,
0.1826666295528412,
0.004284349270164967,
1.2567954063415527,
-0.6835927367210388,
0.5932801365852356,
0.6678507328033447,
-0.10717349499464035,
-0.6804487109184265,
0.18502411246299744,
-0.2545553147792816,
-0.6960172057151794,
0.78200364112854,
0.4149183928966522,
0.11527519673109055,
-0.1550930142402649,
-0.39725834131240845,
-0.9393193125724792,
0.9279345273971558,
0.0859428197145462,
-0.7203059792518616,
-0.01638944260776043,
0.34432312846183777,
0.429962694644928,
-0.24668516218662262,
0.5546495914459229,
0.3445972502231598,
0.4586791396141052,
-0.018099918961524963,
-0.6911568641662598,
0.0488252118229866,
-0.16804169118404388,
0.14916442334651947,
0.496833473443985,
-0.7133220434188843,
0.5787178874015808,
0.05523589625954628,
-0.3920615613460541,
0.20595741271972656,
0.7161937952041626,
0.06845753639936447,
0.22224785387516022,
0.5582054853439331,
0.6912296414375305,
0.7953475713729858,
-0.19267618656158447,
0.848824143409729,
-0.02666749432682991,
0.10368483513593674,
1.350287914276123,
-0.17081694304943085,
0.6834559440612793,
0.40468019247055054,
-0.06267504394054413,
0.4207305908203125,
0.36163222789764404,
0.572470486164093,
0.5235572457313538,
0.1606159657239914,
-0.10040544718503952,
-0.14109373092651367,
0.10270416736602783,
-0.30721163749694824,
0.4127861261367798,
0.5951610803604126,
-0.35364633798599243,
-0.33333250880241394,
0.41374823451042175,
0.04525841400027275,
0.5032919645309448,
-0.05457951873540878,
1.1286230087280273,
0.1435067504644394,
-0.8699405193328857,
0.05425979569554329,
-0.2112647145986557,
0.5341666340827942,
-0.6041930913925171,
-0.15074631571769714,
-0.30942025780677795,
0.1961851716041565,
-0.08114957064390182,
-1.0982391834259033,
0.10698331892490387,
-0.09729836136102676,
-0.42018455266952515,
-0.6630016565322876,
0.7009435892105103,
-0.846458911895752,
-0.25085002183914185,
0.4359740912914276,
0.4679032564163208,
0.023991594091057777,
0.09935041517019272,
-0.40146058797836304,
0.40362322330474854,
0.08215730637311935,
-0.061806969344615936,
0.45741990208625793,
0.7321153283119202,
-0.0017386674880981445,
0.43094655871391296,
0.5369386672973633,
-0.16564218699932098,
0.07672087848186493,
0.042922697961330414,
0.5820541977882385,
-0.7595477104187012,
-0.8911505341529846,
-0.8178794980049133,
0.5294331312179565,
-0.38049209117889404,
-0.024883607402443886,
0.5614128708839417,
0.6110101342201233,
0.5115976333618164,
-0.0031616592314094305,
0.7723236680030823,
0.2039221227169037,
0.20223599672317505,
-0.9436858892440796,
0.581569254398346,
-0.6374243497848511,
0.054564375430345535,
-0.21199582517147064,
-0.9290264248847961,
-0.2705189287662506,
0.6544950008392334,
-0.5960565805435181,
-0.35587990283966064,
0.8341575264930725,
0.41247430443763733,
-0.23972022533416748,
0.047011494636535645,
0.5124000906944275,
0.37662988901138306,
0.5233862996101379,
0.5076612234115601,
1.0015758275985718,
-0.4508510231971741,
0.33805128931999207,
-0.1849416047334671,
-0.5050675868988037,
-0.18068212270736694,
-0.8497717380523682,
-1.012649655342102,
-0.8279626965522766,
-0.24626745283603668,
-0.45270049571990967,
-0.14691336452960968,
0.4989544451236725,
0.7954220771789551,
-0.3152126371860504,
-0.15916292369365692,
0.012777132913470268,
0.18265807628631592,
0.3370003402233124,
-0.2668793499469757,
0.6028637886047363,
-0.2875238358974457,
-0.7952102422714233,
0.2616267502307892,
0.7807387709617615,
0.15545654296875,
-0.1901833415031433,
0.06748691201210022,
-0.21619130671024323,
0.0729702040553093,
0.6951817870140076,
0.23968738317489624,
-0.6003623008728027,
-0.18210943043231964,
-0.0890585407614708,
-0.3803800642490387,
0.16408605873584747,
0.846207857131958,
-0.6603097319602966,
0.5699215531349182,
0.6194586753845215,
0.8500307202339172,
0.6805264353752136,
0.15723483264446259,
0.742181122303009,
-0.4737676680088043,
0.37522104382514954,
-0.05571785196661949,
0.6119939684867859,
0.2621318995952606,
-0.7687286138534546,
0.517065167427063,
-0.4083860516548157,
-0.5504264235496521,
-0.662960410118103,
0.17371782660484314,
-0.7841978073120117,
-0.5103145837783813,
0.9904114007949829,
-0.005215988494455814,
-0.4179750382900238,
0.061498794704675674,
-0.4369524121284485,
-0.01087190955877304,
-0.08923828601837158,
0.39377206563949585,
0.7440748810768127,
0.09773716330528259,
-0.14452247321605682,
-0.43592891097068787,
0.246857687830925,
0.6235569715499878,
-1.2471458911895752,
0.09593506157398224,
0.5189409852027893,
-0.08157306909561157,
0.2662299573421478,
0.8241744637489319,
-0.1231861412525177,
0.2733664810657501,
-0.34245216846466064,
-0.13703161478042603,
0.18516066670417786,
-0.3540833294391632,
-0.4155426025390625,
0.16740846633911133,
-0.21801458299160004,
-0.024687431752681732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01965v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01965v1 | AdaCQR: Enhancing Query Reformulation for Conversational Search via Sparse and Dense Retrieval Alignment | 2024-07-02T05:50:16 | 2024-07-02T05:50:16 | Yilong Lai, Jialong Wu, Congzhi Zhang, Haowen Sun, Deyu Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Conversational Query Reformulation (CQR) has significantly advanced in
addressing the challenges of conversational search, particularly those stemming
from the latent user intent and the need for historical context. Recent works
aimed to boost the performance of CRQ through alignment. However, they are
designed for one specific retrieval system, which potentially results in poor
generalization. To overcome this limitation, we present a novel framework
AdaCQR. By aligning reformulation models with both term-based and
semantic-based retrieval systems, AdaCQR enhances the generalizability of
information-seeking queries across diverse retrieval environments through a
dual-phase training strategy. We also developed two effective approaches for
acquiring superior labels and diverse input candidates, boosting the efficiency
and robustness of the framework. Experimental evaluations on the TopiOCQA and
QReCC datasets demonstrate that AdaCQR significantly outperforms existing
methods, offering both quantitative and qualitative improvements in
conversational query reformulation. | [
-0.21148090064525604,
-1.0013139247894287,
0.24576641619205475,
-0.19222266972064972,
-0.08780589699745178,
0.229444682598114,
-0.027100853621959686,
-0.06546109914779663,
0.31577038764953613,
0.36975955963134766,
-0.5161968469619751,
-0.4699113368988037,
-0.16091232001781464,
-0.2109142690896988,
-0.4774942100048065,
0.8897624611854553,
0.27875903248786926,
0.2748591899871826,
-0.2017708122730255,
-0.4677715301513672,
-0.6644280552864075,
-0.7188823819160461,
-0.8120166063308716,
0.004443014040589333,
0.5457063317298889,
0.4573940336704254,
0.9997845888137817,
0.7275606989860535,
0.4893074333667755,
0.19237910211086273,
-0.3100643455982208,
0.39220789074897766,
-0.7887953519821167,
0.6088160872459412,
0.09151437133550644,
-0.34833458065986633,
-0.15213419497013092,
-0.495903342962265,
0.7048014998435974,
0.7870140671730042,
-0.7156903743743896,
-0.20657312870025635,
0.16341909766197205,
0.6994711756706238,
-0.7911480069160461,
0.039776477962732315,
-0.9577891230583191,
-0.07652468234300613,
0.052558545023202896,
-0.346243292093277,
-0.06169101595878601,
-0.42190197110176086,
-0.019577687606215477,
-0.7720970511436462,
0.4607211649417877,
0.17211219668388367,
0.7994807362556458,
0.15031985938549042,
-0.8251837491989136,
-0.3026871979236603,
-0.8373721837997437,
0.5503585338592529,
-0.2987556755542755,
0.684998631477356,
0.12673541903495789,
0.5510660409927368,
-0.14217261970043182,
-0.8134261965751648,
-0.3823070526123047,
0.10843627899885178,
-0.0514487624168396,
-0.026246173307299614,
-0.14530012011528015,
0.15396855771541595,
0.025060076266527176,
0.515674889087677,
-0.7048301100730896,
-0.2060035914182663,
-0.43725651502609253,
-0.2726707458496094,
0.49438393115997314,
0.4265531599521637,
0.34792691469192505,
0.2923431396484375,
-0.4022071659564972,
-0.2434280514717102,
-0.5871825218200684,
0.2595100998878479,
0.2450169324874878,
0.5723719000816345,
0.48140811920166016,
0.5862330794334412,
-0.5952049493789673,
0.6889103651046753,
0.38598886132240295,
0.20821936428546906,
-0.014121081680059433,
-0.7902271151542664,
0.14636357128620148,
0.19410552084445953,
0.7420694828033447,
0.2890235185623169,
-0.4397631585597992,
-0.25778841972351074,
-0.2680824100971222,
-0.22045348584651947,
0.3619120717048645,
-0.7991976737976074,
-0.22508931159973145,
0.1885235607624054,
-0.2923636734485626,
0.0008224874618463218,
0.16111864149570465,
-0.6370792984962463,
-0.15839257836341858,
-0.4146987199783325,
0.42196694016456604,
-0.3247069716453552,
0.0004982953541912138,
0.007040561642497778,
-0.011870641261339188,
0.6061716079711914,
0.3443765640258789,
-0.9684012532234192,
0.6113461852073669,
0.8873692154884338,
0.616026759147644,
-0.1757032424211502,
0.3135623335838318,
-0.7643733024597168,
0.14931295812129974,
-0.3502417206764221,
0.6656731367111206,
-1.0114573240280151,
-0.44842734932899475,
0.03316962346434593,
-0.1351408213376999,
-0.23047223687171936,
-0.7259670495986938,
0.6941399574279785,
-1.0833866596221924,
0.24352878332138062,
-0.37425026297569275,
-0.2613857388496399,
-0.12480290979146957,
0.4399929642677307,
-0.67875736951828,
1.257174015045166,
-0.08153738081455231,
-0.5956708192825317,
0.24407929182052612,
-0.39770159125328064,
-0.33025357127189636,
0.1188385933637619,
-0.23345312476158142,
-0.27316269278526306,
-0.3050765097141266,
0.40655478835105896,
-0.13576793670654297,
-0.2006477564573288,
0.29499173164367676,
-0.16726583242416382,
-0.6371216773986816,
0.18618257343769073,
-0.1373293250799179,
0.5477568507194519,
0.3121853768825531,
-0.017270402982831,
0.16154712438583374,
-0.4171377420425415,
0.341137558221817,
-0.0313548780977726,
-0.35515111684799194,
-0.46398431062698364,
0.050819750875234604,
-0.127916619181633,
0.053825099021196365,
0.3776289224624634,
-0.49786561727523804,
0.19242796301841736,
-0.3739748001098633,
0.45606350898742676,
0.16603419184684753,
0.10075756162405014,
0.5569009184837341,
-0.3725949227809906,
0.5212435126304626,
0.12671872973442078,
0.04143594205379486,
-0.23344656825065613,
-0.16234827041625977,
-0.7692357301712036,
-0.1361909657716751,
0.5218605399131775,
0.7134506702423096,
-0.6120912432670593,
0.3747798204421997,
-0.30460619926452637,
-0.19188609719276428,
-0.7532377243041992,
0.19338539242744446,
0.4453224539756775,
0.5516708493232727,
0.5954543352127075,
-0.5442777276039124,
-0.592923104763031,
-0.7698158025741577,
-0.22688844799995422,
-0.1642606556415558,
0.004386717453598976,
0.6250417828559875,
0.03053073026239872,
-0.13971003890037537,
0.8723878264427185,
-0.5756444334983826,
-0.3765159547328949,
-0.027746083214879036,
-0.027107803151011467,
-0.0367572195827961,
0.6081354022026062,
-0.08605732023715973,
-1.2172123193740845,
-0.33885490894317627,
-0.13187409937381744,
-0.23648397624492645,
0.11025370657444,
0.03117871843278408,
-0.5204311013221741,
-0.08102915436029434,
0.598111093044281,
-0.4729665517807007,
0.42481523752212524,
0.07604574412107468,
-0.20494526624679565,
0.3348630964756012,
-0.031638775020837784,
0.5701349973678589,
-0.8707339763641357,
0.14570771157741547,
-0.17783568799495697,
-0.21343204379081726,
-0.5913029909133911,
0.05618421360850334,
0.04594632238149643,
-0.20845074951648712,
-0.10215124487876892,
0.4191860854625702,
-0.4403056204319,
0.22124332189559937,
-0.1527230143547058,
0.2956799864768982,
0.2544201612472534,
0.3989817202091217,
-0.027962075546383858,
0.8992931842803955,
0.3213394582271576,
-0.8135019540786743,
0.38144347071647644,
0.6704768538475037,
-0.04759884998202324,
0.6583430767059326,
-0.8912556767463684,
0.4541482627391815,
-0.38587746024131775,
0.31546616554260254,
-1.2823859453201294,
-0.041408196091651917,
0.18433557450771332,
-0.3881107568740845,
0.40357518196105957,
-0.40381383895874023,
-0.28067129850387573,
-0.12790295481681824,
-0.25462210178375244,
0.9312089085578918,
0.32903119921684265,
-0.553475558757782,
0.633639395236969,
0.4248943626880646,
-0.3567572832107544,
-0.8050519824028015,
-0.4877467155456543,
0.12459342181682587,
-0.17624139785766602,
-0.7207472324371338,
0.5344327092170715,
-0.13347823917865753,
-0.08852183818817139,
-0.2038320153951645,
-0.4536881446838379,
-0.39214026927948,
-0.1506148874759674,
-0.20982778072357178,
0.17063622176647186,
-0.3281860947608948,
0.08051086962223053,
0.07602094113826752,
0.24394558370113373,
-0.35678377747535706,
-0.21573005616664886,
0.6226270198822021,
0.018748236820101738,
-0.41922229528427124,
-0.4292232394218445,
0.4567420780658722,
0.007894572801887989,
-0.444752961397171,
0.6374461054801941,
0.469412624835968,
-0.09816093742847443,
0.24213331937789917,
-0.7494673728942871,
-0.3852404057979584,
-0.4230077564716339,
0.2749616801738739,
-0.37423989176750183,
-1.1849520206451416,
0.33114758133888245,
0.1899598240852356,
-0.0353865884244442,
0.21567294001579285,
0.3082898259162903,
0.057799115777015686,
1.5544319152832031,
0.49183762073516846,
0.2294083535671234,
0.5850660800933838,
-0.059610530734062195,
0.1890910267829895,
-1.1108367443084717,
-0.5748931765556335,
-0.6810100674629211,
-0.2100500464439392,
-0.43091925978660583,
-0.3797799050807953,
0.34196728467941284,
0.19878308475017548,
-0.27245643734931946,
0.16312791407108307,
-0.6302125453948975,
0.35788494348526,
0.43405675888061523,
0.2940411865711212,
0.47245436906814575,
0.06105891242623329,
-0.23438045382499695,
-0.21507389843463898,
-0.6464460492134094,
-0.46012693643569946,
0.9776151776313782,
-0.08063773065805435,
0.750740647315979,
0.40174975991249084,
0.42937424778938293,
0.12697957456111908,
-0.20684818923473358,
-0.9151902198791504,
0.387879878282547,
0.03155452013015747,
-0.7457775473594666,
-0.2870326042175293,
-0.7049106955528259,
-1.2565101385116577,
0.7054691910743713,
-0.10187423974275589,
-0.7201659679412842,
0.48889395594596863,
0.2129056751728058,
-0.40433019399642944,
-0.1668637990951538,
-0.48320403695106506,
0.8911406993865967,
-0.3630988895893097,
-0.24967998266220093,
-0.10259347409009933,
-0.7658535242080688,
0.2298658937215805,
0.07928341627120972,
0.10510934889316559,
-0.11404488980770111,
-0.37603452801704407,
0.45876726508140564,
-0.298056036233902,
0.43367671966552734,
-0.13623782992362976,
0.23741385340690613,
0.20764625072479248,
0.23472224175930023,
0.39326295256614685,
0.10599535703659058,
-0.08960273116827011,
-0.270176500082016,
0.5281504392623901,
-0.540467381477356,
-0.8581334352493286,
0.5106415152549744,
-0.37278786301612854,
-0.8244012594223022,
-0.2609107792377472,
-0.5942752957344055,
-0.3434625566005707,
0.2842618525028229,
-0.06611853092908859,
0.6786165237426758,
-0.8011312484741211,
0.4639561176300049,
0.8746500015258789,
0.16851875185966492,
-0.21578878164291382,
0.5830937623977661,
-0.060955338180065155,
-0.4405459761619568,
0.6051576137542725,
-0.23206588625907898,
0.05670388415455818,
0.733120858669281,
-0.19051581621170044,
-0.5367938280105591,
-0.5446247458457947,
-0.27562111616134644,
0.008876754902303219,
-0.43395131826400757,
-0.3091907501220703,
-0.8435386419296265,
-0.15467974543571472,
-0.7469490170478821,
0.28193557262420654,
-0.12434062361717224,
-0.5586005449295044,
-0.2401704639196396,
0.34834128618240356,
-0.06116341054439545,
0.23188847303390503,
0.13088726997375488,
0.3140874207019806,
-0.6656360626220703,
0.3353997468948364,
0.4232928156852722,
0.08851779252290726,
-0.18465344607830048,
-0.7320154309272766,
-0.06419443339109421,
0.3959004282951355,
-0.4887256324291229,
-0.5372017025947571,
0.34261053800582886,
0.6251290440559387,
0.5984249114990234,
0.2629000246524811,
0.3127184808254242,
0.9166461229324341,
-0.4027632772922516,
0.5122069120407104,
0.06702589243650436,
-0.5310722589492798,
0.5410899519920349,
-0.18164986371994019,
0.38536974787712097,
1.0288820266723633,
0.399727463722229,
-0.8141825795173645,
-0.12681075930595398,
-0.34567537903785706,
-1.241576910018921,
0.6776153445243835,
0.24423520267009735,
0.274526447057724,
0.1347796469926834,
0.4029422700405121,
-0.14181673526763916,
0.2552257478237152,
0.03995855897665024,
-0.19527339935302734,
-0.27666446566581726,
-0.4709091782569885,
0.24086280167102814,
-0.28982269763946533,
-0.49270543456077576,
-0.13018211722373962,
0.6441048383712769,
-0.259666383266449,
0.2270803451538086,
0.3834567666053772,
-0.12149182707071304,
0.06826779991388321,
0.4904336631298065,
0.003108910284936428,
0.3377678096294403,
-0.17638559639453888,
-0.12099761515855789,
-0.018297947943210602,
-0.47502097487449646,
0.07534152269363403,
0.6292873620986938,
-0.3936010003089905,
-0.3000468313694,
-0.37202468514442444,
0.7217653393745422,
0.34011030197143555,
-0.7823821902275085,
0.5636451840400696,
-0.6567699909210205,
-0.07255631685256958,
-0.17067186534404755,
0.30117911100387573,
-0.060782212764024734,
0.2709288001060486,
0.6360324025154114,
-0.1933879554271698,
0.7302736043930054,
-0.5611971020698547,
0.2661852538585663,
0.8092161417007446,
-0.7421978116035461,
-0.04596159979701042,
0.8520128726959229,
-0.035631198436021805,
-0.12460283190011978,
0.765928328037262,
-0.06043751537799835,
-0.3487050235271454,
0.36012306809425354,
0.5026607513427734,
0.5203063488006592,
-0.15408268570899963,
0.111978679895401,
0.4315909147262573,
-0.15737716853618622,
-0.20833943784236908,
0.22676615417003632,
-0.5032082796096802,
-0.739297091960907,
-0.07936079800128937,
-0.5031290054321289,
-0.41559550166130066,
-0.2630097270011902,
-0.9628299474716187,
0.2146633416414261,
-0.21033984422683716,
-0.11702044308185577,
-0.06613340228796005,
0.08942830562591553,
-0.4435864984989166,
0.037007302045822144,
-0.008682917803525925,
0.6728035807609558,
-0.04560358449816704,
0.6260155439376831,
0.9420495629310608,
-0.3700830042362213,
-0.7956739068031311,
0.033235110342502594,
0.17378084361553192,
-0.6446278691291809,
0.33556029200553894,
0.10826437920331955,
-0.14895235002040863,
0.15028899908065796,
-0.5439035892486572,
-1.0749237537384033,
1.2702281475067139,
0.2728687822818756,
-0.5930581092834473,
-0.3638514280319214,
-0.10095420479774475,
0.4898071885108948,
-0.5378863215446472,
0.2973697781562805,
0.6219797730445862,
0.04339258000254631,
0.7792412042617798,
-0.8758900761604309,
0.1435304880142212,
-0.23642240464687347,
0.2539529800415039,
0.348909854888916,
-0.7018835544586182,
0.28485769033432007,
-0.14342457056045532,
-0.6241007447242737,
0.49310988187789917,
0.7297188639640808,
0.37299758195877075,
0.3430574834346771,
0.4265722632408142,
0.5573451519012451,
0.942556619644165,
-0.2831317186355591,
0.6838861703872681,
-0.35379788279533386,
0.1815139204263687,
1.0085959434509277,
-0.2196367233991623,
0.7706173062324524,
0.15039129555225372,
-0.07998606562614441,
0.5108590126037598,
0.5150351524353027,
0.18253028392791748,
0.5869779586791992,
-0.04793683812022209,
-0.40279462933540344,
-0.3305067718029022,
-0.2498709112405777,
-0.30975577235221863,
0.42007142305374146,
0.5203058123588562,
0.10098814964294434,
-0.10839619487524033,
-0.40429070591926575,
0.024986213073134422,
0.2196255475282669,
-0.209562286734581,
1.1120775938034058,
-0.07378414273262024,
-0.6395294070243835,
0.796050488948822,
-0.1473267376422882,
0.6818659901618958,
-0.5128735303878784,
-0.06283554434776306,
-0.34629499912261963,
0.1438262164592743,
-0.18313297629356384,
-0.43388137221336365,
0.20555546879768372,
-0.42313599586486816,
-0.041744425892829895,
0.12177573889493942,
0.6709228754043579,
-0.8809396624565125,
-0.19696758687496185,
-0.020841076970100403,
0.4106990694999695,
0.0822448804974556,
-0.13085715472698212,
-1.0586309432983398,
-0.016426177695393562,
0.019960712641477585,
0.0869150385260582,
0.3152261972427368,
0.4987541735172272,
0.1343880295753479,
0.5188068747520447,
0.5005816221237183,
-0.21236692368984222,
0.031748633831739426,
0.050288621336221695,
0.9402046799659729,
-0.8049389719963074,
-0.3150406777858734,
-0.1868375837802887,
0.24924644827842712,
-0.034187521785497665,
-0.13306865096092224,
0.49474191665649414,
0.9494855999946594,
0.726080060005188,
0.6050524115562439,
0.4992380738258362,
-0.10001224279403687,
0.6848759055137634,
-0.5006499290466309,
0.28456273674964905,
-0.5601848363876343,
0.5387763381004333,
0.09755217283964157,
-1.0766475200653076,
-0.22756832838058472,
0.1651884913444519,
-0.1702161431312561,
0.21230413019657135,
0.45877331495285034,
1.2871512174606323,
-0.176451176404953,
0.019431542605161667,
0.06558912247419357,
0.049246206879615784,
0.21546094119548798,
0.43240317702293396,
0.8624473810195923,
-0.6151171922683716,
1.2109196186065674,
0.06881079822778702,
-0.1057521402835846,
-0.32882729172706604,
-0.24807403981685638,
-0.41863560676574707,
-0.5973700284957886,
-0.3062666952610016,
-0.46793878078460693,
0.46714112162590027,
0.7273526787757874,
0.8099299669265747,
-0.9517028331756592,
-0.14792586863040924,
0.17698527872562408,
-0.00939992256462574,
-0.14320658147335052,
-0.27085983753204346,
0.1837754249572754,
-0.6250861287117004,
-0.6602643132209778,
0.5497928857803345,
0.016039511188864708,
-0.09803207963705063,
0.03735446184873581,
-0.030407976359128952,
-0.32719236612319946,
0.02993939258158207,
0.23767922818660736,
0.6371680498123169,
-0.462936133146286,
-0.002530870493501425,
0.16400809586048126,
-0.42266660928726196,
0.5652891993522644,
1.037209391593933,
-0.9287068247795105,
0.4906793236732483,
0.447864830493927,
0.6604950428009033,
0.6794931888580322,
0.7826946973800659,
0.7652917504310608,
-0.6458624005317688,
-0.030166903510689735,
0.5502428412437439,
-0.049532726407051086,
0.6320154666900635,
-0.544025182723999,
0.3442031443119049,
-0.025506552308797836,
-0.8034060597419739,
-0.6658427715301514,
0.25304317474365234,
-1.0836577415466309,
-0.1507619023323059,
1.161717176437378,
0.27898696064949036,
-0.028073089197278023,
-0.46534979343414307,
-0.414279967546463,
0.17763949930667877,
-0.9025559425354004,
0.5886247754096985,
0.19200235605239868,
-0.36515262722969055,
-0.05735637620091438,
-0.4603149890899658,
0.26494044065475464,
0.47854292392730713,
-0.2150808572769165,
-0.04861512780189514,
0.8185588121414185,
0.32197144627571106,
-0.1555144339799881,
0.7296234965324402,
-0.4973941445350647,
0.25991103053092957,
-0.2565312087535858,
-0.0359991192817688,
0.31518712639808655,
-0.060902584344148636,
-0.4058385491371155,
0.25096479058265686,
0.21443481743335724,
0.032410744577646255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01964v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01964v2 | Enabling Discriminative Reasoning in LLMs for Legal Judgment Prediction | 2024-07-02T05:43:15 | 2024-07-03T02:25:23 | Chenlong Deng, Kelong Mao, Yuyao Zhang, Zhicheng Dou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Legal judgment prediction is essential for enhancing judicial efficiency. In
this work, we identify that existing large language models (LLMs) underperform
in this domain due to challenges in understanding case complexities and
distinguishing between similar charges. To adapt LLMs for effective legal
judgment prediction, we introduce the Ask-Discriminate-Predict (ADAPT)
reasoning framework inspired by human judicial reasoning. ADAPT involves
decomposing case facts, discriminating among potential charges, and predicting
the final judgment. We further enhance LLMs through fine-tuning with multi-task
synthetic trajectories to improve legal judgment prediction accuracy and
efficiency under our ADAPT framework. Extensive experiments conducted on two
widely-used datasets demonstrate the superior performance of our framework in
legal judgment prediction, particularly when dealing with complex and confusing
charges. | [
-0.15845245122909546,
-0.5919941067695618,
1.0542641878128052,
0.18707908689975739,
-0.3716583549976349,
0.07493699342012405,
-0.19485940039157867,
-0.7089329361915588,
-0.02531149424612522,
0.78830885887146,
-0.40070775151252747,
-0.4600927233695984,
-0.42295363545417786,
-0.18676036596298218,
-0.21878360211849213,
0.6828274130821228,
0.26249709725379944,
0.3253256380558014,
-0.18117214739322662,
-0.20843301713466644,
-0.7808128595352173,
-0.5492144227027893,
-0.6236719489097595,
-0.34381553530693054,
0.2187604010105133,
0.3915759027004242,
0.4156562089920044,
0.3486902415752411,
0.46389147639274597,
0.30026790499687195,
-0.05936961993575096,
0.3255908787250519,
-0.2700890302658081,
0.17709946632385254,
-0.49312180280685425,
-0.8902895450592041,
-0.4856756031513214,
-0.33694398403167725,
0.09785812348127365,
0.5918801426887512,
-0.6254986524581909,
-0.107208751142025,
-0.4143270254135132,
0.7613020539283752,
-0.768268346786499,
0.10074172168970108,
-0.9658886194229126,
0.15927952527999878,
0.0031303404830396175,
-0.26626574993133545,
-0.6797332167625427,
-0.369867205619812,
0.05074667930603027,
-0.7799558639526367,
0.3863639831542969,
0.43689432740211487,
0.15903371572494507,
0.3715001046657562,
-0.5330303311347961,
-0.28476858139038086,
-0.9492132067680359,
0.36437588930130005,
-0.6897158026695251,
0.3876117765903473,
0.3001135587692261,
0.7065456509590149,
-0.41840335726737976,
-0.7678425312042236,
-0.5570388436317444,
-0.519625186920166,
-0.01049606129527092,
0.3032331168651581,
-0.23948034644126892,
0.3644280731678009,
0.4238229990005493,
-0.13315346837043762,
-0.6321016550064087,
0.34685349464416504,
-0.3310944736003876,
-0.07163983583450317,
0.8981901407241821,
0.2851388454437256,
0.02254924364387989,
0.08489019423723221,
-0.20660963654518127,
0.2306479811668396,
-0.6088899374008179,
0.12253108620643616,
0.27361270785331726,
0.407439261674881,
0.040752582252025604,
0.4152037799358368,
-0.20255574584007263,
0.6990894675254822,
0.4929957091808319,
0.039143677800893784,
0.22127972543239594,
-0.011524912901222706,
-0.23866333067417145,
0.4565734565258026,
0.4822499454021454,
0.576465368270874,
0.33336183428764343,
0.07150458544492722,
-0.2596314549446106,
-0.012020028196275234,
0.49031445384025574,
-0.6602029800415039,
-0.17220811545848846,
0.3510786294937134,
-0.570533037185669,
-0.0694439560174942,
0.08473777025938034,
-0.8436475396156311,
-1.0892099142074585,
-0.5094530582427979,
0.03705239295959473,
-0.3358041048049927,
-0.23430436849594116,
0.7565100193023682,
-0.13696934282779694,
-0.1891285479068756,
0.9592782855033875,
-0.6250131130218506,
0.30061256885528564,
0.6377769708633423,
0.42255479097366333,
-0.12864811718463898,
0.03533810004591942,
-0.6966235637664795,
0.2730245292186737,
-0.2938353419303894,
0.9491046667098999,
-0.6695878505706787,
-0.29957565665245056,
0.24771809577941895,
0.07456953078508377,
0.05329488217830658,
-0.7810637950897217,
1.2010151147842407,
-0.409748911857605,
-0.23685795068740845,
-0.23120389878749847,
-0.5462342500686646,
-0.44025087356567383,
0.16527709364891052,
-0.7875154614448547,
0.4276914596557617,
0.0787760317325592,
-0.5995435118675232,
1.0030608177185059,
-0.8710548281669617,
-0.6826099753379822,
0.5721333026885986,
0.02307152934372425,
-0.4106859266757965,
0.2724967896938324,
0.27255624532699585,
0.4425382912158966,
-0.2957073450088501,
0.5570178031921387,
-0.6128323078155518,
-0.3470678925514221,
0.18703597784042358,
-0.19009776413440704,
0.6420585513114929,
0.41280290484428406,
-0.22030137479305267,
0.3563762903213501,
-0.8630069494247437,
-0.429293155670166,
0.048936303704977036,
-0.36452433466911316,
-0.34082862734794617,
0.41477301716804504,
-0.3311533033847809,
0.2523539364337921,
0.008955923840403557,
-0.6409004330635071,
0.07652115076780319,
-0.43372833728790283,
0.30261948704719543,
0.9134311079978943,
-0.10003486275672913,
0.4976811110973358,
-0.42421600222587585,
0.7699031829833984,
0.22170013189315796,
0.013000347651541233,
0.34095731377601624,
-0.25702184438705444,
-0.5510229468345642,
-0.03692254424095154,
0.0217001810669899,
0.7049570679664612,
-0.6515474319458008,
0.13208633661270142,
-0.47141551971435547,
-0.49540650844573975,
-0.3488669693470001,
-0.04878702014684677,
0.12338757514953613,
0.1493011862039566,
0.31270310282707214,
0.0864860787987709,
-1.0175944566726685,
-0.6035878658294678,
-0.6501513123512268,
-0.5020487308502197,
0.13574710488319397,
0.4269742965698242,
0.474328875541687,
-0.025326747447252274,
0.7745981216430664,
-0.23753418028354645,
-0.10105817764997482,
-0.38990518450737,
-0.006529228296130896,
0.4463938772678375,
0.19389204680919647,
0.565998375415802,
-1.0352437496185303,
-0.27677708864212036,
0.16283346712589264,
-0.5343784689903259,
-0.07736330479383469,
-0.44014567136764526,
-0.10466006398200989,
-0.0697178840637207,
0.5727640986442566,
-0.5833311080932617,
0.2983340620994568,
-0.033769261091947556,
-0.855603039264679,
0.7340713143348694,
-0.42190587520599365,
0.16237913072109222,
-0.592334508895874,
-0.3794684112071991,
0.2835758924484253,
-0.3466254472732544,
-0.6588095426559448,
-0.04454457387328148,
0.20322561264038086,
0.3856995403766632,
-0.48978564143180847,
0.47678497433662415,
-0.09182989597320557,
-0.20834055542945862,
-0.2106369137763977,
0.03343576565384865,
-0.15762285888195038,
0.2620985805988312,
-0.07639044523239136,
0.7966555953025818,
0.2178937941789627,
-0.7431874871253967,
0.5332874059677124,
0.09360045939683914,
-0.6920099854469299,
0.8065273761749268,
-0.4808183014392853,
-0.17017120122909546,
-0.2574830651283264,
0.2830106019973755,
-0.5704883933067322,
-0.1352396458387375,
-0.03720280900597572,
-0.0800604298710823,
0.2072426676750183,
-0.23531809449195862,
-0.5833004117012024,
-0.6372207999229431,
-0.1618184596300125,
0.43023473024368286,
0.25525370240211487,
-0.7375476956367493,
1.1256442070007324,
0.37228289246559143,
-0.0019602214451879263,
-0.5106332898139954,
-0.5823862552642822,
0.040399011224508286,
-0.6080442070960999,
-0.27053311467170715,
0.5393149256706238,
-0.12440510094165802,
-0.5363947153091431,
-0.27832382917404175,
0.21202106773853302,
0.18083390593528748,
0.38245880603790283,
0.44659510254859924,
0.23864112794399261,
-0.09179887175559998,
0.32121992111206055,
0.3104022145271301,
0.4029460847377777,
0.4789230525493622,
-0.273477703332901,
0.40767642855644226,
0.06347479671239853,
-0.49410393834114075,
-0.10449007153511047,
0.05907243862748146,
0.6609928607940674,
-0.15237291157245636,
0.11481273919343948,
0.013104758225381374,
-0.3085760474205017,
-0.4220094382762909,
-0.7514558434486389,
0.25230827927589417,
-0.502799928188324,
0.6083964705467224,
-0.5553283095359802,
-1.0600956678390503,
0.48138102889060974,
-0.22035914659500122,
0.028750600293278694,
0.3397899568080902,
0.9128212332725525,
0.01736641302704811,
1.1099865436553955,
0.3382868468761444,
0.1351773589849472,
0.43348026275634766,
0.3202458620071411,
0.1932401806116104,
-0.6435178518295288,
-0.3467477560043335,
-0.37300407886505127,
-0.03584868460893631,
-0.6424726247787476,
-0.278167188167572,
0.12717238068580627,
0.051031529903411865,
-0.3517201542854309,
0.3322780430316925,
-0.34447458386421204,
0.303181916475296,
0.4841386675834656,
0.254969984292984,
0.3198600113391876,
-0.1417129635810852,
-0.21006527543067932,
0.27701953053474426,
-0.3840060234069824,
-0.2695758044719696,
1.2742400169372559,
0.24653981626033783,
0.6391341686248779,
0.32571208477020264,
0.36038827896118164,
0.654225766658783,
0.06854786723852158,
-0.7636874914169312,
0.6806238293647766,
-0.5178695321083069,
-0.6100634932518005,
0.01603359915316105,
-0.37898704409599304,
-0.8841037750244141,
0.44089949131011963,
-0.3556267023086548,
-0.6801653504371643,
0.32646024227142334,
0.02413300797343254,
-0.6926243901252747,
0.13565593957901,
-0.51801598072052,
0.47092679142951965,
-0.31320416927337646,
-0.3276604115962982,
-0.5343298316001892,
-0.29386600852012634,
0.4557206332683563,
-0.1765580028295517,
0.5913288593292236,
-0.3463485836982727,
0.2852312922477722,
0.7032655477523804,
-0.267456978559494,
0.6814863681793213,
-0.4523420035839081,
-0.11784566193819046,
0.37569311261177063,
0.30872300267219543,
0.3970448672771454,
0.06067522615194321,
-0.35789892077445984,
-0.3850373327732086,
-0.006145871710032225,
0.00782303512096405,
-0.8235248327255249,
0.4554279148578644,
-0.26969245076179504,
-0.90826815366745,
-0.24843649566173553,
-0.8615780472755432,
-0.2468881607055664,
-0.03261679410934448,
-0.13449621200561523,
-0.03467932716012001,
-0.16122032701969147,
-0.28131839632987976,
0.32362836599349976,
-0.07756821066141129,
0.23823994398117065,
0.803826093673706,
-0.24850326776504517,
-0.3098405599594116,
0.6821126937866211,
-0.07257304340600967,
-0.015737516805529594,
0.23669472336769104,
0.31068241596221924,
-0.5385315418243408,
-0.8725412487983704,
-0.38174888491630554,
0.0753457173705101,
-0.9902887344360352,
-0.31485578417778015,
-0.5230811834335327,
0.18498854339122772,
-0.5519519448280334,
0.005321447271853685,
0.14240306615829468,
-0.5365833044052124,
-0.1167280450463295,
-0.3833424746990204,
0.562274694442749,
0.5657764077186584,
0.08428916335105896,
0.1442510485649109,
-0.601323664188385,
0.3503619432449341,
0.3111383318901062,
0.27548378705978394,
-0.3629299998283386,
-0.9403378963470459,
0.035876963287591934,
-0.057308923453092575,
-0.12783220410346985,
-0.23210345208644867,
0.2540535628795624,
0.18673516809940338,
0.6865614056587219,
0.35586369037628174,
0.34898361563682556,
0.78012615442276,
-0.7346105575561523,
0.537559449672699,
0.32034432888031006,
-0.5469459891319275,
0.7093830704689026,
-0.09291631728410721,
-0.04030049219727516,
0.4783908724784851,
-0.04180034622550011,
-0.07138259708881378,
-0.24283471703529358,
-0.23762013018131256,
-0.5610336661338806,
0.7073062062263489,
-0.15016311407089233,
0.15108123421669006,
0.10691297799348831,
0.5376525521278381,
0.2530417740345001,
0.03993188962340355,
-0.43525999784469604,
0.14374904334545135,
-0.08124463260173798,
-0.32887694239616394,
0.04356081783771515,
-0.24531130492687225,
0.00911204144358635,
-0.6582902669906616,
0.4232446849346161,
-0.23001287877559662,
0.18899482488632202,
-0.020335564389824867,
-0.1366872489452362,
-0.10965944081544876,
0.348206490278244,
0.7763567566871643,
0.6810537576675415,
-0.17699609696865082,
-0.025816679000854492,
0.4986342191696167,
-0.43065765500068665,
0.20120002329349518,
0.1512487828731537,
0.05499007925391197,
-0.05645444616675377,
0.261161208152771,
1.064765214920044,
-0.150221049785614,
-1.015690803527832,
0.4531896710395813,
-0.3262684941291809,
-0.5538660883903503,
-0.698357343673706,
0.24479255080223083,
0.06513816863298416,
0.6906682252883911,
0.21831659972667694,
0.1473829597234726,
0.429929256439209,
-0.5472092032432556,
0.10094301402568817,
0.39161595702171326,
-0.24430051445960999,
-0.01224831584841013,
0.8226431012153625,
0.12160567939281464,
-0.21781641244888306,
0.15189363062381744,
-0.3318215310573578,
-0.6760262846946716,
0.6181586384773254,
0.6625756621360779,
0.7041795253753662,
-0.19439950585365295,
0.0007304353057406843,
0.4212858974933624,
-0.0982106477022171,
-0.44888123869895935,
0.39377012848854065,
0.0648680031299591,
-0.884586751461029,
-0.4486008882522583,
-0.7314481735229492,
-0.21946567296981812,
-0.2939056158065796,
-0.5513678193092346,
0.3701331317424774,
-0.776206910610199,
-0.2380746752023697,
0.04576658084988594,
-0.17372293770313263,
-0.5195481181144714,
0.2982291579246521,
0.2711494266986847,
0.9187110662460327,
-0.5800856947898865,
0.8373014330863953,
0.5886600017547607,
-0.18573355674743652,
-0.48318517208099365,
-0.2279418557882309,
-0.07006974518299103,
-0.7188961505889893,
0.889756441116333,
0.24962009489536285,
-0.34031379222869873,
-0.3184780180454254,
-0.3883843421936035,
-0.39832964539527893,
0.9909681081771851,
0.6917431354522705,
-0.9915750622749329,
-0.19787797331809998,
0.08292580395936966,
0.39434659481048584,
-0.5538453459739685,
-0.006554566789418459,
1.0514185428619385,
0.37485453486442566,
0.3057807683944702,
-0.7692546844482422,
0.3407333791255951,
-0.12272894382476807,
0.06882745027542114,
0.1746223419904709,
0.06879505515098572,
0.6823925375938416,
-0.5242376923561096,
-0.1045147106051445,
-0.006004711613059044,
0.6321613788604736,
0.5608610510826111,
0.5365676283836365,
0.8552493453025818,
0.64382404088974,
0.9813757538795471,
-0.19914127886295319,
1.0951288938522339,
-0.18626262247562408,
0.15743762254714966,
1.443649172782898,
-0.6381807923316956,
0.674364447593689,
0.38029786944389343,
-0.4270244836807251,
0.7957712411880493,
0.38493040204048157,
-0.340511292219162,
0.46589308977127075,
0.4045311212539673,
-0.3936425447463989,
-0.6902967095375061,
-0.3625272512435913,
0.1316775679588318,
0.590888261795044,
0.6139689087867737,
-0.3945671319961548,
0.06992476433515549,
0.08168677240610123,
-0.3401021957397461,
0.45048996806144714,
-0.6681551933288574,
0.898952305316925,
-0.03682892024517059,
-0.7186133861541748,
0.31140008568763733,
0.10297440737485886,
0.6483784317970276,
-0.16594594717025757,
-0.2821444272994995,
0.15706908702850342,
0.4164828956127167,
-0.39245834946632385,
-1.0567203760147095,
0.019598526880145073,
-0.15537762641906738,
-0.2665694057941437,
0.08764605224132538,
0.783399224281311,
-0.051275208592414856,
-0.6280069947242737,
0.6452621221542358,
0.14964699745178223,
-0.12017618864774704,
-0.14559629559516907,
-0.8495749831199646,
-0.3065597414970398,
0.007006950676441193,
0.0678567960858345,
0.2861233651638031,
0.641758143901825,
-0.3145654499530792,
0.8800580501556396,
0.6711072325706482,
0.3115626573562622,
0.06997224688529968,
0.5582876801490784,
0.8603506088256836,
-0.6255276799201965,
-0.5044599175453186,
-0.9012739062309265,
0.5773437023162842,
-0.18850816786289215,
-0.10281937569379807,
0.15822206437587738,
0.4536909759044647,
0.7636444568634033,
0.04490819573402405,
0.7663366198539734,
0.21061448752880096,
0.782640278339386,
-0.8402484655380249,
0.4782944619655609,
-0.4794412851333618,
0.36973801255226135,
-0.06941424310207367,
-0.5624080300331116,
-0.293828547000885,
0.5941588878631592,
-0.47625207901000977,
0.04428372159600258,
0.44261521100997925,
0.6596912741661072,
-0.10016994178295135,
0.0900283083319664,
0.5257863998413086,
0.06991956382989883,
0.4956059157848358,
0.7586769461631775,
0.7755061984062195,
-0.02620157040655613,
0.5760328769683838,
-0.17725150287151337,
0.1881839632987976,
-0.524753987789154,
-0.7488729357719421,
-0.7978387475013733,
-0.22241009771823883,
-0.1281166672706604,
-0.30945613980293274,
0.061904214322566986,
0.9174910187721252,
0.6100771427154541,
-0.9231423735618591,
-0.23191146552562714,
-0.6181036829948425,
-0.22433950006961823,
-0.06091015040874481,
-0.2276676744222641,
0.16177310049533844,
-0.32192370295524597,
-0.47246867418289185,
0.39362069964408875,
0.14097453653812408,
-0.07061424851417542,
0.22066758573055267,
-0.36585232615470886,
-0.2004866749048233,
-0.023589344695210457,
0.7968074679374695,
-0.06720424443483353,
-1.0406553745269775,
-0.3848322629928589,
-0.46686026453971863,
0.14385002851486206,
0.1377135068178177,
1.0066832304000854,
-0.6926201581954956,
0.5965272188186646,
0.112523153424263,
0.6637099981307983,
0.5035904049873352,
0.1926133632659912,
0.7340686321258545,
-0.2965621054172516,
0.18952153623104095,
0.6113108992576599,
0.8983917236328125,
0.11551684886217117,
-0.49733829498291016,
0.4610048234462738,
-0.02093343250453472,
-0.46864384412765503,
-0.5427393913269043,
0.4758581817150116,
-0.8724365234375,
-0.6124725937843323,
1.019385814666748,
-0.4552522897720337,
-0.01298829261213541,
-0.3427838981151581,
-0.3297507166862488,
0.12420050799846649,
-0.5196125507354736,
0.7371309399604797,
0.5189180374145508,
-0.08941635489463806,
-0.4434097111225128,
-0.6960470080375671,
0.36739253997802734,
0.5529282093048096,
-0.8687387704849243,
0.36136749386787415,
0.7647771835327148,
0.17404909431934357,
0.10164488106966019,
0.2285320907831192,
-0.05395391955971718,
0.6104971170425415,
-0.27727210521698,
-0.07411183416843414,
-0.058674540370702744,
-0.11706846207380295,
-0.45735299587249756,
0.12212681025266647,
0.2742880880832672,
0.07659886032342911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01955v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01955v1 | S2D: Sorted Speculative Decoding For More Efficient Deployment of Nested Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T05:14:15 | 2024-07-02T05:14:15 | Parsa Kavehzadeh, Mohammadreza Pourreza, Mojtaba Valipour, Tinashu Zhu, Haoli Bai, Ali Ghodsi, Boxing Chen, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deployment of autoregressive large language models (LLMs) is costly, and as
these models increase in size, the associated costs will become even more
considerable. Consequently, different methods have been proposed to accelerate
the token generation process and reduce costs. Speculative decoding (SD) is
among the most promising approaches to speed up the LLM decoding process by
verifying multiple tokens in parallel and using an auxiliary smaller draft
model to generate the possible tokens. In SD, usually, one draft model is used
to serve a specific target model; however, in practice, LLMs are diverse, and
we might need to deal with many target models or more than one target model
simultaneously. In this scenario, it is not clear which draft model should be
used for which target model, and searching among different draft models or
training customized draft models can further increase deployment costs. In this
paper, we first introduce a novel multi-target scenario for the deployment of
draft models for faster inference. Then, we present a novel, more efficient
sorted speculative decoding mechanism that outperforms regular baselines in
multi-target settings. We evaluated our method on Spec-Bench in different
settings, including base models such as Vicuna 7B, 13B, and LLama Chat 70B. Our
results suggest that our draft models perform better than baselines for
multiple target models at the same time. | [
-0.11695541441440582,
-0.5160360932350159,
0.5571261048316956,
0.5577836632728577,
-0.5224238634109497,
0.3354877531528473,
-0.1464879959821701,
-0.5074278712272644,
0.09727974236011505,
0.6360504031181335,
-0.5293903946876526,
-0.524304211139679,
-0.7355433106422424,
-0.010546543635427952,
-0.49674564599990845,
0.6718013286590576,
0.025938808917999268,
-0.06050070375204086,
-0.12174206972122192,
0.11968822032213211,
-0.17181970179080963,
-0.5184025764465332,
-0.8423049449920654,
0.035675548017024994,
0.3619901239871979,
0.5580779910087585,
0.4991134703159332,
1.018568992614746,
0.5167646408081055,
0.32320699095726013,
-0.2968864142894745,
0.47159579396247864,
-0.6071003079414368,
0.37840351462364197,
0.11106783151626587,
-0.8500970602035522,
-0.4339483380317688,
-0.2112579345703125,
0.6852741837501526,
0.4265824854373932,
-0.2236853986978531,
0.15317629277706146,
-0.36888134479522705,
0.357999712228775,
-0.7606448531150818,
0.00017888729053083807,
-0.7544767260551453,
-0.16745691001415253,
-0.37986865639686584,
-0.21512822806835175,
-0.7048462629318237,
-0.17083846032619476,
-0.3596374988555908,
-0.35969486832618713,
0.40923887491226196,
0.16364996135234833,
0.5018491744995117,
0.27517035603523254,
-0.712694525718689,
-0.20532788336277008,
-0.7220348119735718,
0.7199243903160095,
-0.7058436870574951,
0.5346277952194214,
0.21835462749004364,
0.22065860033035278,
-0.2407950460910797,
-0.8244411945343018,
-0.4571059048175812,
-0.022689059376716614,
0.0934566855430603,
0.07617324590682983,
-0.007039468735456467,
-0.07779186218976974,
0.35950371623039246,
0.2533152103424072,
-0.748215913772583,
0.7357006072998047,
-0.2689761817455292,
-0.23092257976531982,
0.568750262260437,
0.3320150077342987,
-0.17769776284694672,
-0.23134687542915344,
-0.4264184832572937,
-0.1046341061592102,
-0.6622687578201294,
-0.15918193757534027,
0.6950913667678833,
0.3304736018180847,
-0.21448542177677155,
0.6047645211219788,
-0.4939936399459839,
0.4667487144470215,
0.2991589903831482,
-0.24026145040988922,
0.09368441998958588,
-0.6147377490997314,
0.12094823271036148,
-0.18543243408203125,
0.4772900640964508,
0.4406163692474365,
-0.3681139051914215,
-0.16454489529132843,
-0.309990257024765,
0.3564399480819702,
0.2702675759792328,
-0.8930399417877197,
-0.00653529167175293,
0.470318078994751,
-0.7154727578163147,
-0.5056307911872864,
-0.4804067015647888,
-0.6236268877983093,
-0.31197455525398254,
0.09951739013195038,
-0.24899818003177643,
-0.30205151438713074,
-0.5039448738098145,
0.3668522238731384,
-0.27479544281959534,
0.07026214152574539,
0.23990817368030548,
-1.2390114068984985,
0.183030903339386,
0.8702670931816101,
0.7267211675643921,
-0.3280404210090637,
-0.2766057848930359,
-0.4261645972728729,
0.15984240174293518,
-0.6289798021316528,
1.1770005226135254,
-0.3830219507217407,
-0.39447325468063354,
-0.08661054819822311,
-0.38063323497772217,
0.000007879773875174578,
-0.39212149381637573,
0.8655256628990173,
-0.8281697034835815,
-0.09888725727796555,
-0.35727086663246155,
-0.6112712621688843,
0.14382226765155792,
0.1329944133758545,
-0.5048673152923584,
1.2406301498413086,
0.14185068011283875,
-0.8625475168228149,
0.5124963521957397,
-0.17656569182872772,
-0.4153074324131012,
0.17697511613368988,
-0.15334253013134003,
-0.14089766144752502,
0.24790066480636597,
0.30739468336105347,
0.6827569603919983,
-0.5761643052101135,
0.20325174927711487,
-0.36642658710479736,
-0.5660288333892822,
-0.2957347631454468,
-0.4392751157283783,
0.6370904445648193,
0.6690593361854553,
-0.20456087589263916,
0.11561423540115356,
-0.63894122838974,
-0.00027531167143024504,
0.27056846022605896,
-0.3282169699668884,
-0.31790658831596375,
0.2442423403263092,
0.13743391633033752,
0.12320385128259659,
0.2289290875196457,
-0.38820508122444153,
0.5160900354385376,
-0.40648823976516724,
0.3598325550556183,
0.519280731678009,
-0.0665234625339508,
0.6042481660842896,
-0.09035052359104156,
0.4689658284187317,
0.1927971988916397,
0.21088078618049622,
-0.27343904972076416,
-0.363389253616333,
-0.6415910720825195,
-0.45594459772109985,
0.013837205246090889,
0.3585912883281708,
-0.8617398738861084,
0.3853376507759094,
-0.2959045171737671,
-0.6931101679801941,
-0.44918176531791687,
-0.02672295831143856,
0.26783788204193115,
0.10776188224554062,
0.11152295768260956,
0.024988949298858643,
-0.6428601741790771,
-0.8756042122840881,
-0.16180646419525146,
-0.3844505846500397,
0.22356915473937988,
0.11351468414068222,
0.17325833439826965,
-0.49576336145401,
0.5314309597015381,
-0.5221170783042908,
0.24078692495822906,
-0.4528459906578064,
0.138001948595047,
0.14565420150756836,
0.42206692695617676,
0.7557445764541626,
-0.6113254427909851,
-0.3115403354167938,
-0.2019866406917572,
-0.5691810250282288,
0.041335705667734146,
-0.17890286445617676,
-0.2271769642829895,
0.3857666254043579,
0.7813027501106262,
-0.827403724193573,
0.20026272535324097,
0.7367638945579529,
-0.2851807177066803,
0.6913884282112122,
-0.33031728863716125,
0.23591144382953644,
-1.2180242538452148,
-0.18358013033866882,
-0.4127941131591797,
0.09354794770479202,
-0.6122967004776001,
0.5434941649436951,
0.3494435250759125,
0.09815051406621933,
-0.31233295798301697,
0.3731541037559509,
-0.52228844165802,
-0.24188360571861267,
-0.3666006028652191,
-0.224919393658638,
-0.0025130051653832197,
0.1083831638097763,
0.12375306338071823,
0.9212170839309692,
0.5278652310371399,
-0.4187692105770111,
0.23105427622795105,
0.0034313807263970375,
-0.3387339413166046,
0.19160063564777374,
-0.5079801082611084,
0.3561542332172394,
-0.2943466603755951,
0.626860499382019,
-1.2194069623947144,
-0.11479899287223816,
0.13998515903949738,
0.0027920936699956656,
0.2189522385597229,
-0.48662877082824707,
-0.8254753947257996,
-0.648041844367981,
-0.2176879346370697,
0.8224431872367859,
0.3886743187904358,
-0.6755653023719788,
0.45474642515182495,
0.20955143868923187,
-0.023805102333426476,
-0.6645157933235168,
-0.7023237347602844,
0.18815800547599792,
-0.3581400215625763,
-0.8018701672554016,
0.3978474736213684,
-0.2071210741996765,
-0.06952502578496933,
-0.07230239361524582,
-0.22915960848331451,
0.12655264139175415,
0.03292595595121384,
0.234351247549057,
0.15245173871517181,
-0.3033727705478668,
-0.18887242674827576,
0.2612266540527344,
-0.39848586916923523,
-0.2146121859550476,
-0.5131391286849976,
0.6541546583175659,
0.2502909004688263,
-0.44686976075172424,
-0.16934804618358612,
0.7385509014129639,
0.7616279125213623,
-0.2213384509086609,
0.7756178975105286,
0.7079038023948669,
-0.2778981328010559,
-0.5002760887145996,
-0.9653909206390381,
-0.10777527838945389,
-0.5240423679351807,
0.5305566191673279,
-0.7230505347251892,
-0.8743816614151001,
0.776710569858551,
-0.1916818767786026,
0.2845180928707123,
0.4522756040096283,
0.6831883788108826,
0.13124814629554749,
1.170282244682312,
0.7367293238639832,
-0.00432849396020174,
0.332138329744339,
-0.3463065028190613,
0.324207603931427,
-0.5655884742736816,
-0.39673277735710144,
-0.6865286231040955,
0.06220674514770508,
-0.35297173261642456,
-1.0095622539520264,
0.04663173854351044,
0.29234760999679565,
0.05672850459814072,
0.3981403410434723,
-0.3315088450908661,
0.43648746609687805,
0.4849330484867096,
-0.05188190937042236,
0.2888393998146057,
0.2132340669631958,
-0.3136182725429535,
0.15388436615467072,
-1.012881875038147,
-0.25747600197792053,
1.2294591665267944,
0.35222187638282776,
0.7026070356369019,
0.13910803198814392,
0.8677319288253784,
0.1696297973394394,
0.08056311309337616,
-0.7787726521492004,
0.5709236860275269,
-0.49668005108833313,
-0.5421513319015503,
-0.07790125161409378,
-0.4392738938331604,
-0.7921597361564636,
0.2710511088371277,
-0.130870059132576,
-0.545407235622406,
0.44113293290138245,
0.021729914471507072,
-0.41536760330200195,
0.4185326099395752,
-0.8333795666694641,
0.5742927193641663,
-0.0758715569972992,
-0.05627333000302315,
-0.6371174454689026,
-0.26921480894088745,
0.6357338428497314,
-0.17128078639507294,
0.04892013967037201,
-0.09542492777109146,
-0.04697295278310776,
0.6565110087394714,
-0.33705970644950867,
0.5360146164894104,
-0.1370096504688263,
-0.2713935971260071,
0.12265827506780624,
0.19043728709220886,
1.0070492029190063,
0.098749540746212,
-0.581939160823822,
0.10216528922319412,
0.13682347536087036,
-0.5655430555343628,
-0.4566676914691925,
0.7567704916000366,
-0.8819539546966553,
-0.48877519369125366,
-0.3202027380466461,
-0.6789348721504211,
-0.1584528237581253,
0.16689172387123108,
0.621195375919342,
0.4280264973640442,
0.07255301624536514,
-0.07234109938144684,
0.39694541692733765,
-0.078269824385643,
0.36205172538757324,
0.6815712451934814,
0.04870084300637245,
-0.13081353902816772,
0.5945374369621277,
0.04266030341386795,
0.3170773386955261,
0.26092028617858887,
-0.32770654559135437,
-0.5171710252761841,
-1.2757325172424316,
-0.29902562499046326,
0.25101444125175476,
-0.8950766921043396,
-0.29760029911994934,
-0.8968150615692139,
-0.17999014258384705,
-0.677418053150177,
-0.12511791288852692,
-0.7182914614677429,
-0.3128814101219177,
-0.16226297616958618,
-0.16380740702152252,
0.37492379546165466,
0.7881805896759033,
-0.09092459082603455,
0.43790867924690247,
-0.5879500508308411,
0.5577199459075928,
-0.029324913397431374,
0.5013080835342407,
0.06039894372224808,
-0.602567732334137,
-0.32853245735168457,
0.02301091141998768,
0.3529757857322693,
-0.602609395980835,
0.29233691096305847,
-0.3238072395324707,
0.5958320498466492,
0.6065509915351868,
0.2721088230609894,
0.9240100979804993,
-0.5150449275970459,
0.5330564379692078,
-0.0687284767627716,
-0.6159571409225464,
0.27744561433792114,
-0.4298623502254486,
0.23128613829612732,
0.42982345819473267,
0.228593647480011,
-0.4549051821231842,
-0.36421695351600647,
-0.5495727062225342,
-1.0181522369384766,
1.0518826246261597,
-0.11876290291547775,
0.02556009776890278,
-0.2535549998283386,
0.5030208826065063,
0.27216699719429016,
-0.12523774802684784,
-0.05624831095337868,
-0.3983113169670105,
0.10755503177642822,
-0.0034908538218587637,
-0.3865469694137573,
-0.9693796634674072,
0.050746165215969086,
0.01569412276148796,
0.4004138112068176,
-0.08042784035205841,
0.4243896007537842,
-0.2542687654495239,
-0.029338309541344643,
-0.18784691393375397,
0.07159952074289322,
0.4945307672023773,
0.05049051716923714,
-0.3245368003845215,
0.19324982166290283,
0.057076554745435715,
-0.3854670822620392,
0.23424634337425232,
-0.004326323512941599,
-0.25007355213165283,
-0.10519948601722717,
0.3478098511695862,
0.9703670144081116,
0.2764919102191925,
-0.536879301071167,
0.21308282017707825,
-0.24059166014194489,
-0.38340339064598083,
-0.04646686092019081,
-0.0020302594639360905,
0.19062967598438263,
0.5766237378120422,
0.3394485116004944,
0.5320751667022705,
0.19687174260616302,
-0.3892365097999573,
0.1690903604030609,
0.15691207349300385,
0.3332253694534302,
-0.14135488867759705,
0.6542338728904724,
0.13776594400405884,
-0.10191885381937027,
0.8694886565208435,
-0.4014813303947449,
-0.3809598684310913,
0.7244977951049805,
0.7884816527366638,
0.8454700112342834,
-0.0029639289714396,
0.2922842502593994,
0.17715512216091156,
0.2718965709209442,
-0.5369700193405151,
0.38848817348480225,
-0.0015772880287840962,
-0.8254649639129639,
-0.4804755747318268,
-0.6703908443450928,
-0.29789334535598755,
0.009835313074290752,
-0.6454871296882629,
0.09922056645154953,
-0.3664935529232025,
-0.1991950422525406,
-0.17085640132427216,
0.03474997729063034,
-0.8167203068733215,
-0.13128480315208435,
0.3348783850669861,
1.0993446111679077,
-0.8385776281356812,
0.9190409183502197,
0.444328635931015,
0.16029389202594757,
-0.9884503483772278,
0.0836159810423851,
0.08494237065315247,
-0.7551578879356384,
0.6921924352645874,
-0.004840698558837175,
-0.09337984770536423,
0.28762155771255493,
-0.13921144604682922,
-1.3524730205535889,
0.9779745936393738,
0.4965590536594391,
-0.5594058632850647,
-0.05568594112992287,
-0.06761444360017776,
0.5026208758354187,
-0.41357511281967163,
0.6527919769287109,
0.6348323822021484,
0.24037379026412964,
0.3868195116519928,
-0.6493698954582214,
0.23521895706653595,
-0.3233395516872406,
0.07311330735683441,
-0.050216320902109146,
-0.7378754615783691,
0.9455777406692505,
-0.40321916341781616,
-0.3827306926250458,
0.31898075342178345,
0.5900614261627197,
0.5005499124526978,
0.08662090450525284,
0.5322261452674866,
0.46526697278022766,
0.7589439749717712,
0.05073285102844238,
1.1774876117706299,
-0.3398951590061188,
0.07477961480617523,
0.8175987601280212,
-0.5546984672546387,
1.0781546831130981,
0.1791272908449173,
-0.11850669980049133,
0.3110055923461914,
0.8729471564292908,
0.06697173416614532,
0.567076563835144,
0.052438996732234955,
-0.09262654930353165,
-0.32784879207611084,
-0.10379577428102493,
-0.4427812397480011,
0.5013439059257507,
0.4646890163421631,
0.030812866985797882,
-0.376153826713562,
-0.060595910996198654,
-0.24321407079696655,
-0.12294437736272812,
-0.051935747265815735,
0.6176755428314209,
-0.1251411885023117,
-0.7602065205574036,
0.8025347590446472,
0.5655760169029236,
0.8842448592185974,
-0.6824659109115601,
0.45203301310539246,
-0.47367072105407715,
0.2765587568283081,
-0.1645651012659073,
-0.5011208057403564,
0.23865634202957153,
0.014621689915657043,
-0.4257368743419647,
-0.48127880692481995,
0.5340080857276917,
-0.4513167142868042,
-0.5011469721794128,
0.4927974343299866,
0.43040603399276733,
0.23865026235580444,
-0.16188199818134308,
-0.5502638816833496,
0.5536025166511536,
-0.14567497372627258,
-0.24881374835968018,
0.3372415602207184,
0.5230969786643982,
-0.3322376608848572,
0.7912997007369995,
0.9487413763999939,
0.21961058676242828,
0.3021918833255768,
0.4043768048286438,
0.9709170460700989,
-0.5438612699508667,
-0.8523387908935547,
-0.5315901637077332,
0.3643935024738312,
0.13359065353870392,
-0.040998026728630066,
0.9153615832328796,
0.6046241521835327,
0.5092253684997559,
-0.0876258835196495,
0.6398391723632812,
0.15476290881633759,
0.3900182247161865,
-0.5729498863220215,
0.4424949884414673,
-0.35266247391700745,
0.6115905046463013,
0.0461888313293457,
-0.8489052653312683,
-0.13388097286224365,
0.2431245893239975,
-0.06490138173103333,
-0.07830541580915451,
0.7357303500175476,
0.9822984933853149,
-0.020991897210478783,
0.02484002709388733,
0.16380947828292847,
0.19445250928401947,
0.24318741261959076,
0.4712783694267273,
0.888359546661377,
-0.5330659747123718,
0.5516837239265442,
-0.34637460112571716,
-0.0733870342373848,
-0.45373213291168213,
-0.6916197538375854,
-0.906991720199585,
-0.387554794549942,
-0.2388552725315094,
-0.28965604305267334,
0.21106112003326416,
0.8873625993728638,
0.9557585120201111,
-0.6965727806091309,
-0.2999052405357361,
-0.049687277525663376,
0.01949124038219452,
-0.39985576272010803,
-0.1599654257297516,
0.42982345819473267,
-0.4182128310203552,
-0.7457208037376404,
0.7748132944107056,
0.2934199571609497,
0.02689417079091072,
-0.08954492956399918,
-0.13361455500125885,
-0.0926320031285286,
0.14697927236557007,
0.629953920841217,
0.02591949701309204,
-0.7566958069801331,
-0.10594131052494049,
0.07211519777774811,
-0.3633705973625183,
-0.4257345497608185,
1.0197486877441406,
-0.7349807024002075,
0.14981362223625183,
0.695663571357727,
0.5753617882728577,
0.7122097611427307,
0.011853697709739208,
0.5980709791183472,
-0.6102114319801331,
0.7508845329284668,
0.16565023362636566,
0.1933782547712326,
-0.010649556294083595,
-0.6079436540603638,
0.29120898246765137,
0.3021951913833618,
-0.19325536489486694,
-1.1105217933654785,
0.2742757797241211,
-0.95283043384552,
-0.42532190680503845,
1.344793677330017,
-0.0007529243011958897,
0.23200684785842896,
-0.19265121221542358,
-0.11114653944969177,
0.14691247045993805,
-0.43207597732543945,
0.6789630055427551,
0.51262366771698,
0.1783914864063263,
-0.2108704000711441,
-0.22691398859024048,
0.5370814204216003,
0.5062799453735352,
-0.4578593969345093,
0.3331230580806732,
0.3460944890975952,
0.08985601365566254,
-0.15313278138637543,
0.8128786683082581,
0.11741453409194946,
0.11247225105762482,
0.6303402185440063,
-0.15185995399951935,
-0.24355639517307281,
-0.4162479639053345,
-0.21399350464344025,
0.28720128536224365,
0.12675660848617554,
0.0800328403711319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01948v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01948v1 | Extracting and Encoding: Leveraging Large Language Models and Medical Knowledge to Enhance Radiological Text Representation | 2024-07-02T04:39:19 | 2024-07-02T04:39:19 | Pablo Messina, René Vidal, Denis Parra, Álvaro Soto, Vladimir Araujo | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Advancing representation learning in specialized fields like medicine remains
challenging due to the scarcity of expert annotations for text and images. To
tackle this issue, we present a novel two-stage framework designed to extract
high-quality factual statements from free-text radiology reports in order to
improve the representations of text encoders and, consequently, their
performance on various downstream tasks. In the first stage, we propose a
\textit{Fact Extractor} that leverages large language models (LLMs) to identify
factual statements from well-curated domain-specific datasets. In the second
stage, we introduce a \textit{Fact Encoder} (CXRFE) based on a BERT model
fine-tuned with objective functions designed to improve its representations
using the extracted factual data. Our framework also includes a new
embedding-based metric (CXRFEScore) for evaluating chest X-ray text generation
systems, leveraging both stages of our approach. Extensive evaluations show
that our fact extractor and encoder outperform current state-of-the-art methods
in tasks such as sentence ranking, natural language inference, and label
extraction from radiology reports. Additionally, our metric proves to be more
robust and effective than existing metrics commonly used in the radiology
report generation literature. The code of this project is available at
\url{https://github.com/PabloMessina/CXR-Fact-Encoder}. | [
-0.028833579272031784,
-0.4237920045852661,
1.0010008811950684,
-0.07909030467271805,
-0.3439320921897888,
-0.06451686471700668,
-0.18017476797103882,
-0.635246992111206,
-0.005984922405332327,
0.5612229108810425,
-0.06654197722673416,
-0.5478231906890869,
-1.0780930519104004,
0.02512587606906891,
-0.33831316232681274,
1.1206904649734497,
0.12328378111124039,
0.30765578150749207,
-0.4126185178756714,
0.07980090379714966,
-0.35669049620628357,
-0.33638009428977966,
-0.4467605948448181,
-0.43828216195106506,
0.461604505777359,
0.5333897471427917,
0.9665960669517517,
1.0111902952194214,
0.7174464464187622,
0.09175185114145279,
0.20044589042663574,
0.3409039378166199,
-0.3134151101112366,
0.19881904125213623,
-0.11389806121587753,
-0.20372900366783142,
-0.08574557304382324,
-0.18800806999206543,
0.4591202139854431,
0.35370028018951416,
-0.16606499254703522,
-0.12082740664482117,
-0.16169510781764984,
0.3975904881954193,
-0.6055165529251099,
0.5490812063217163,
-0.19644297659397125,
-0.008987429551780224,
-0.0024810610339045525,
-0.5111582279205322,
-0.6958133578300476,
-0.5414724349975586,
0.23036658763885498,
-0.46874478459358215,
0.1494610607624054,
0.0839444100856781,
1.1596002578735352,
-0.0010662880958989263,
-0.4324958622455597,
-0.7400433421134949,
-0.5116925239562988,
0.5789196491241455,
-0.5469341278076172,
0.6705776453018188,
0.19905877113342285,
0.2606995701789856,
0.27165690064430237,
-1.125548243522644,
-0.19244161248207092,
-0.15050573647022247,
-0.36538687348365784,
0.1099010556936264,
-0.3413740396499634,
0.04626728966832161,
0.2165985107421875,
0.5062242150306702,
-0.7124812602996826,
-0.02513211779296398,
-0.33515989780426025,
-0.29463720321655273,
0.5391271710395813,
-0.06080237403512001,
0.4571659564971924,
-0.4815964996814728,
-0.4003153145313263,
-0.2967770993709564,
-0.7503028512001038,
-0.4504650831222534,
-0.5412582159042358,
0.12359948456287384,
-0.18749170005321503,
0.5541151762008667,
-0.07425176352262497,
0.25583189725875854,
-0.01363026350736618,
-0.41487863659858704,
0.48261693120002747,
-0.01326767448335886,
-0.3065221309661865,
0.3357584476470947,
0.6643252968788147,
0.16656211018562317,
-0.14487743377685547,
-0.387677401304245,
-0.2298462688922882,
0.009705777280032635,
0.13127630949020386,
-1.0596811771392822,
-0.1734279841184616,
0.2662576735019684,
-0.8325373530387878,
-0.4682641923427582,
0.1630980521440506,
-0.782378077507019,
-0.5699701309204102,
-0.048797279596328735,
0.5908920168876648,
-0.70245361328125,
-0.21108344197273254,
0.44989073276519775,
-0.1383017748594284,
0.16032934188842773,
0.059021007269620895,
-0.5966385006904602,
0.21638217568397522,
0.6070957183837891,
0.8285815715789795,
0.2261386662721634,
0.45956850051879883,
-0.7899237275123596,
0.215214341878891,
-0.2783118486404419,
0.8111689686775208,
-0.5393568873405457,
-0.4503159821033478,
0.07198990881443024,
-0.06782016158103943,
0.20333430171012878,
-0.5938575267791748,
0.8631194233894348,
-0.680128276348114,
0.23742283880710602,
-0.16077834367752075,
-0.5887352228164673,
-0.11267394572496414,
0.2205023169517517,
-0.6395080089569092,
0.869006872177124,
0.07318209856748581,
-0.7123584747314453,
0.3079320192337036,
-0.510925829410553,
-0.46024054288864136,
0.20097780227661133,
-0.6746802926063538,
-0.5177798271179199,
0.29101523756980896,
0.5736570954322815,
0.6804338097572327,
-0.8435596227645874,
0.39864808320999146,
0.19214580953121185,
-0.009797397069633007,
0.518763542175293,
-0.24248425662517548,
0.5691532492637634,
0.34509432315826416,
-0.16791951656341553,
-0.25931107997894287,
-0.8524734377861023,
0.01794476993381977,
0.23780694603919983,
-0.4760872423648834,
-0.15652145445346832,
0.1501118689775467,
-0.012872716411948204,
0.31289300322532654,
-0.004273585043847561,
-1.045061469078064,
-0.03364550322294235,
-0.3871449828147888,
0.032685697078704834,
0.14944486320018768,
0.30793967843055725,
0.1629989743232727,
-0.6429079174995422,
0.332261860370636,
0.030931415036320686,
-0.03114359639585018,
-0.3437473773956299,
-0.2905421853065491,
-0.5674636363983154,
-0.7271177172660828,
0.37228962779045105,
0.5325396060943604,
-0.8683399558067322,
0.16972574591636658,
-0.6079212427139282,
-0.43635988235473633,
-0.43761515617370605,
-0.23588360846042633,
0.5055006146430969,
0.6346854567527771,
0.39925476908683777,
-0.34816399216651917,
-0.6492063999176025,
-0.6936426162719727,
0.13519509136676788,
-0.02250158041715622,
-0.060279373079538345,
0.04747002571821213,
0.23935876786708832,
-0.21104727685451508,
0.8091854453086853,
-1.0297726392745972,
-0.3935151994228363,
-0.2516474723815918,
0.4760934114456177,
0.24931146204471588,
0.3940524756908417,
0.4716755747795105,
-0.7224617600440979,
-0.15910278260707855,
0.2616858184337616,
-1.2329881191253662,
-0.03308865800499916,
-0.2683252692222595,
0.11802629381418228,
0.1387544572353363,
0.6021654009819031,
-0.4687447249889374,
0.3562451899051666,
0.5421482920646667,
-0.24366934597492218,
0.3800433874130249,
-0.3277149796485901,
0.2593565285205841,
-0.8733199238777161,
0.06121131032705307,
0.10842248052358627,
-0.4947594106197357,
-0.45597130060195923,
0.14426161348819733,
0.16191433370113373,
-0.3500502407550812,
-0.1380763202905655,
0.2867262661457062,
-0.6826497912406921,
0.08338525891304016,
-0.22997888922691345,
-0.008872668258845806,
0.24923834204673767,
0.07375765591859818,
0.43083760142326355,
0.3101694583892822,
0.5288074016571045,
-0.3342292606830597,
0.027555815875530243,
0.3586222231388092,
-0.6079057455062866,
0.11363369226455688,
-0.5791040062904358,
0.1402210295200348,
-0.3510400950908661,
0.11860378831624985,
-0.6036974191665649,
-0.34647658467292786,
0.17346489429473877,
-0.5376858115196228,
0.656541109085083,
-0.10305047780275345,
-0.667334258556366,
-0.19289879500865936,
-0.10856551676988602,
0.019139474257826805,
0.7165413498878479,
-0.4718879461288452,
0.6220162510871887,
0.4976576268672943,
-0.310251921415329,
-0.49680447578430176,
-0.8324944972991943,
0.23341859877109528,
0.3583869934082031,
-0.5264323353767395,
0.28135547041893005,
0.10488751530647278,
-0.10320775210857391,
0.27653899788856506,
0.023768173530697823,
-0.3191659450531006,
-0.14746540784835815,
0.16495898365974426,
0.3028844892978668,
-0.46134158968925476,
0.28558358550071716,
0.26639631390571594,
-0.28965190052986145,
0.3277701139450073,
-0.293648362159729,
0.2455260008573532,
0.1571979820728302,
-0.3659779131412506,
-0.31926268339157104,
0.5676923990249634,
0.5042957663536072,
-0.2911195456981659,
0.5598503947257996,
0.558204174041748,
-0.6316576600074768,
0.003922555595636368,
-0.5405350923538208,
-0.2014242559671402,
-0.3597792983055115,
0.7004144191741943,
-0.041351377964019775,
-0.9036245346069336,
0.006528179161250591,
-0.04950015991926193,
0.06864093244075775,
0.4509848952293396,
0.6491483449935913,
0.06108562648296356,
1.1354597806930542,
0.58769690990448,
0.41483449935913086,
-0.04552052170038223,
-0.12163595110177994,
0.1934775710105896,
-0.5327344536781311,
-0.510986864566803,
-0.5388663411140442,
0.3397303819656372,
-0.38665270805358887,
-0.7552094459533691,
0.7316929697990417,
-0.29697340726852417,
0.14982974529266357,
-0.2902924418449402,
-0.503673255443573,
0.39611876010894775,
0.0571930930018425,
0.5261674523353577,
0.34431910514831543,
0.3457229435443878,
0.07293660193681717,
-0.21698720753192902,
-0.8272508978843689,
-0.4873500466346741,
1.1323078870773315,
0.49889421463012695,
0.6220682859420776,
0.22432953119277954,
0.8436312675476074,
0.4296734631061554,
0.5952755212783813,
-0.9095102548599243,
0.2587827742099762,
-0.5499324798583984,
-0.6396107077598572,
0.156202033162117,
-0.3096078336238861,
-0.7633363008499146,
0.15217287838459015,
-0.6585425138473511,
-0.3706260323524475,
0.366924911737442,
-0.13957475125789642,
-0.4436309039592743,
0.16771571338176727,
-0.3314507305622101,
0.3230268359184265,
-0.27287253737449646,
-0.31068354845046997,
-0.4455742835998535,
-0.5359418392181396,
0.2476479709148407,
-0.10422912240028381,
0.5070860981941223,
-0.0072279153391718864,
0.029477113857865334,
0.6253240704536438,
-0.40490394830703735,
0.848300039768219,
-0.2872816026210785,
-0.11348085105419159,
0.2274443805217743,
0.1319892853498459,
0.3013845682144165,
0.2694701850414276,
-0.22228975594043732,
0.1464328169822693,
0.13826796412467957,
-0.2147645652294159,
-0.5442317128181458,
0.4756917357444763,
-0.7550587058067322,
-0.393040269613266,
-0.7876390814781189,
-0.5833291411399841,
-0.19930964708328247,
0.29651254415512085,
0.27385565638542175,
1.1860252618789673,
-0.4192304313182831,
0.3389885723590851,
1.0194333791732788,
-0.4753093123435974,
0.012114697135984898,
0.36784520745277405,
-0.18262973427772522,
-0.6505918502807617,
1.09458327293396,
0.04484567418694496,
0.023945914581418037,
0.9323611855506897,
0.35110509395599365,
-0.18294768035411835,
-0.6676905751228333,
-0.37123745679855347,
0.5653242468833923,
-0.9796112775802612,
-0.5889320969581604,
-0.7829279899597168,
-0.43035849928855896,
-0.4278241693973541,
-0.17774555087089539,
-0.12497855722904205,
-0.4555054306983948,
-0.3267749845981598,
-0.07289297878742218,
0.26491817831993103,
0.9206089377403259,
-0.44962364435195923,
0.2120833396911621,
-1.205773949623108,
0.2035343050956726,
-0.008475414477288723,
0.09494234621524811,
-0.17501533031463623,
-0.38987717032432556,
-0.7557098865509033,
-0.3721352815628052,
-0.19210848212242126,
-0.7880099415779114,
0.513202428817749,
0.19621668756008148,
0.4357033967971802,
0.5116041302680969,
0.0319984033703804,
0.27796822786331177,
-0.23706814646720886,
0.5522796511650085,
0.3533216416835785,
-0.7175630331039429,
0.43980085849761963,
-0.27777132391929626,
0.09788618236780167,
0.266206294298172,
0.4299705922603607,
-0.4794078767299652,
-0.27460384368896484,
-0.5488654375076294,
-0.6627175807952881,
0.6545344591140747,
-0.0004226789460517466,
-0.010936967097222805,
-0.3947235345840454,
0.5169564485549927,
0.20837105810642242,
-0.2003295123577118,
-0.5803221464157104,
-0.09979484975337982,
-0.2008179873228073,
-0.6167031526565552,
0.1685686707496643,
-0.80374675989151,
-0.3169631063938141,
0.03687124699354172,
0.7395787835121155,
-0.23678964376449585,
0.5769941210746765,
0.5961878895759583,
-0.4594719111919403,
0.13710352778434753,
0.30680525302886963,
0.41250577569007874,
0.5768992304801941,
-0.3549712002277374,
0.2979799509048462,
-0.16861191391944885,
-0.5644067525863647,
0.008168403059244156,
0.1309252232313156,
0.02284615859389305,
0.20946919918060303,
0.725751519203186,
0.48227623105049133,
0.44768497347831726,
-0.735651969909668,
0.744473397731781,
-0.24582618474960327,
-0.30096203088760376,
-0.04836862161755562,
-0.13060469925403595,
-0.06780269742012024,
0.09745669364929199,
0.46019965410232544,
0.03529650345444679,
0.32628941535949707,
-0.24750758707523346,
0.5910370349884033,
0.03601980581879616,
-0.5922895669937134,
-0.23834627866744995,
0.466337651014328,
0.2466672658920288,
0.4372623860836029,
0.553788423538208,
0.027580033987760544,
-0.05126379057765007,
0.41379454731941223,
0.7941140532493591,
0.6789945960044861,
0.11636098474264145,
0.4013291001319885,
0.6462200880050659,
0.18776163458824158,
-0.15703639388084412,
0.23521339893341064,
0.20501470565795898,
-0.6910744309425354,
-0.6773160099983215,
-0.23237626254558563,
-0.22788231074810028,
-0.20541447401046753,
-0.9642281532287598,
0.3232858180999756,
-0.5702008008956909,
0.03213862329721451,
-0.04879390820860863,
-0.06051209941506386,
-0.48191893100738525,
0.6339365839958191,
0.49989524483680725,
0.97710120677948,
-0.7440036535263062,
0.8856858015060425,
0.47106513381004333,
-0.3956618010997772,
-0.8321279287338257,
-0.14538054168224335,
0.0883086696267128,
-0.9357520937919617,
0.7076447010040283,
0.07534365355968475,
-0.10543008893728256,
-0.22155626118183136,
-0.4156700372695923,
-0.9573251605033875,
1.1111959218978882,
0.4298033118247986,
-0.535675585269928,
-0.10259386897087097,
0.03346441313624382,
0.3265318274497986,
-0.6938796043395996,
0.27416688203811646,
0.4162552058696747,
0.197430819272995,
0.11711286008358002,
-0.5345500707626343,
0.5224325060844421,
-0.016266288235783577,
-0.28982600569725037,
0.012633728794753551,
-0.2802170217037201,
0.46677541732788086,
-0.34954530000686646,
-0.37599489092826843,
0.08167128264904022,
0.7841823101043701,
0.06217312440276146,
0.2176162749528885,
0.2434810847043991,
0.47208499908447266,
0.9204419851303101,
-0.12539055943489075,
1.393728256225586,
-0.25547054409980774,
0.3607769310474396,
0.8162219524383545,
-0.14933322370052338,
0.5998825430870056,
0.1273117959499359,
0.39697563648223877,
0.8664464950561523,
0.20423971116542816,
0.03498790040612221,
0.6482459306716919,
-0.2696937322616577,
-0.27654701471328735,
-0.4237663447856903,
-0.2842591404914856,
-0.3518986403942108,
0.5809810757637024,
0.5799086093902588,
-0.7632367610931396,
-0.28894907236099243,
0.12395910918712616,
0.4794016480445862,
-0.0665501281619072,
-0.11015476286411285,
0.833804726600647,
0.11825668811798096,
-0.4071109890937805,
0.6074435710906982,
0.07576151192188263,
0.344368577003479,
-0.8209267854690552,
-0.20195497572422028,
0.05305849760770798,
0.23450173437595367,
-0.3646877110004425,
-0.7551396489143372,
0.4371586740016937,
0.025155846029520035,
-0.4873475134372711,
-0.19881702959537506,
0.8896554112434387,
-0.376329630613327,
-0.5536090135574341,
0.15197020769119263,
0.3827773332595825,
-0.018009772524237633,
0.31619149446487427,
-0.39871636033058167,
0.4283355474472046,
0.2477436363697052,
0.0209178663790226,
0.2300817221403122,
0.41446152329444885,
0.029597941786050797,
0.3581197261810303,
0.487248957157135,
0.32103231549263,
-0.5166811943054199,
0.047524433583021164,
0.9827509522438049,
-0.4942701756954193,
-0.3477504253387451,
-0.5847828984260559,
0.4498220682144165,
-0.11461400240659714,
-0.09506909549236298,
0.2652086913585663,
0.6051670908927917,
0.37490689754486084,
0.024692237377166748,
1.0113271474838257,
-0.32215026021003723,
0.5606677532196045,
-0.7991319894790649,
0.785088300704956,
-0.3854888677597046,
0.13791413605213165,
-0.018653830513358116,
-0.24733246862888336,
-0.6786037087440491,
0.46529772877693176,
-0.08115631341934204,
-0.32517099380493164,
0.9506553411483765,
0.8466701507568359,
0.014644784852862358,
0.19109086692333221,
0.35003721714019775,
0.5380776524543762,
0.5856818556785583,
0.3450518846511841,
0.5226235389709473,
-0.4590909481048584,
0.7596651911735535,
-0.11350955814123154,
-0.4571053385734558,
-0.17480064928531647,
-0.8685680627822876,
-0.48350170254707336,
-0.4480881989002228,
-0.6914801001548767,
-0.6311155557632446,
0.12904247641563416,
1.0096498727798462,
0.9791643619537354,
-0.6184826493263245,
0.05335744097828865,
0.41443440318107605,
-0.07858408987522125,
-0.12219507992267609,
-0.19363464415073395,
0.6240063905715942,
-0.33304527401924133,
-0.3313341736793518,
0.3925660252571106,
0.38727325201034546,
-0.2622818350791931,
0.11041666567325592,
-0.023657558485865593,
-0.032752953469753265,
0.13614137470722198,
0.7824118137359619,
0.24916142225265503,
-0.21848595142364502,
-0.5651247501373291,
-0.036160554736852646,
-0.2820563018321991,
0.37994900345802307,
0.9895065426826477,
-0.9414783120155334,
0.6149451732635498,
0.38706669211387634,
0.751029372215271,
0.6081046462059021,
-0.3105510473251343,
0.4877128005027771,
-0.8328911662101746,
-0.059306416660547256,
0.2318502962589264,
0.29211699962615967,
0.6329380869865417,
-0.553390383720398,
0.2558334171772003,
0.2718600928783417,
-0.5304844379425049,
-0.7913521528244019,
0.1092463955283165,
-0.9736811518669128,
-0.445655882358551,
1.099824070930481,
-0.1405000388622284,
-0.17249754071235657,
-0.22729676961898804,
-0.24229587614536285,
0.35518908500671387,
-0.37429577112197876,
0.5980865955352783,
0.2821681499481201,
-0.41346475481987,
-0.31164979934692383,
-0.20010362565517426,
0.3311484158039093,
0.1732877641916275,
-0.7795995473861694,
-0.095245860517025,
0.6133464574813843,
0.4799833595752716,
0.28340640664100647,
0.7878932356834412,
-0.7087186574935913,
0.5661675333976746,
-0.055915430188179016,
0.3070160448551178,
-0.18096300959587097,
-0.18550871312618256,
-0.2802461087703705,
0.4438852071762085,
0.3048631250858307,
-0.004011743236333132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01942v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01942v1 | Certainly Uncertain: A Benchmark and Metric for Multimodal Epistemic and Aleatoric Awareness | 2024-07-02T04:23:54 | 2024-07-02T04:23:54 | Khyathi Raghavi Chandu, Linjie Li, Anas Awadalla, Ximing Lu, Jae Sung Park, Jack Hessel, Lijuan Wang, Yejin Choi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | The ability to acknowledge the inevitable uncertainty in their knowledge and
reasoning is a prerequisite for AI systems to be truly truthful and reliable.
In this paper, we present a taxonomy of uncertainty specific to vision-language
AI systems, distinguishing between epistemic uncertainty (arising from a lack
of information) and aleatoric uncertainty (due to inherent unpredictability),
and further explore finer categories within. Based on this taxonomy, we
synthesize a benchmark dataset, CertainlyUncertain, featuring 178K visual
question answering (VQA) samples as contrastive pairs. This is achieved by 1)
inpainting images to make previously answerable questions into unanswerable
ones; and 2) using image captions to prompt large language models for both
answerable and unanswerable questions. Additionally, we introduce a new metric
confidence-weighted accuracy, that is well correlated with both accuracy and
calibration error, to address the shortcomings of existing metrics. | [
-0.3997447192668915,
-0.8696395754814148,
0.7754284143447876,
0.004579868633300066,
0.14549706876277924,
0.10919845104217529,
0.004528517369180918,
-0.4592074751853943,
0.04678872227668762,
-0.035012342035770416,
-0.31796613335609436,
-0.08744343370199203,
-0.7644458413124084,
-0.04317322000861168,
-0.24363791942596436,
0.45497092604637146,
-0.23602460324764252,
-0.0189644955098629,
-0.4014650881290436,
-0.5443689227104187,
-0.3622300922870636,
-0.06580201536417007,
-0.26204416155815125,
0.11235391348600388,
0.5285077691078186,
0.317035436630249,
0.9035239815711975,
0.4449858069419861,
0.8424692749977112,
0.3718421161174774,
0.2545330226421356,
0.13132797181606293,
0.0780482366681099,
0.0831177681684494,
-0.20242954790592194,
-0.8039438128471375,
-0.2030303031206131,
-0.16010050475597382,
0.4369318187236786,
0.5903934240341187,
-0.22401313483715057,
0.33918851613998413,
-0.20770026743412018,
0.43598565459251404,
-1.0370745658874512,
0.22100993990898132,
-0.7151374816894531,
0.1671934276819229,
0.1887214481830597,
0.04811832308769226,
0.06655876338481903,
-0.1155347153544426,
0.39381715655326843,
-1.1827324628829956,
-0.33082523941993713,
0.21131645143032074,
1.1079977750778198,
1.1958638429641724,
-0.1386590301990509,
-0.17003078758716583,
-0.639721691608429,
0.8089805841445923,
-0.40675660967826843,
0.5047900080680847,
0.49945068359375,
0.6361430883407593,
0.3321242332458496,
-0.8443065881729126,
-0.7156105637550354,
0.21324001252651215,
0.21456752717494965,
0.5669584274291992,
-0.5292009115219116,
0.1282757818698883,
-0.03776967525482178,
0.07290685176849365,
-0.34105464816093445,
-0.18271121382713318,
-0.005266107618808746,
-0.4185105264186859,
0.22413797676563263,
0.04151890054345131,
0.14762215316295624,
0.03500935807824135,
-0.4889805018901825,
-0.2336287945508957,
-0.21365518867969513,
0.30420735478401184,
0.10340095311403275,
-0.21170829236507416,
-0.26280784606933594,
0.7666385769844055,
-0.45813968777656555,
0.8136467337608337,
-0.20536324381828308,
-0.09813208878040314,
0.37987977266311646,
-0.3549439609050751,
-0.32438549399375916,
-0.31653594970703125,
0.637677013874054,
0.6173029541969299,
0.2517399787902832,
0.05158295854926109,
-0.2402878701686859,
0.3725922405719757,
0.3847349286079407,
-0.219462588429451,
-0.3924187123775482,
0.5469562411308289,
-0.041296977549791336,
0.022421957924962044,
0.17337095737457275,
-0.5952905416488647,
-0.3364904224872589,
-0.052031099796295166,
0.854630172252655,
-0.5296136736869812,
-0.1465921401977539,
-0.0339629128575325,
-0.1926996260881424,
0.337770938873291,
0.9708355069160461,
-0.31568431854248047,
-0.24197813868522644,
0.33948999643325806,
0.5336570739746094,
0.06901197135448456,
-0.49379345774650574,
-0.3144843280315399,
-0.03943154588341713,
-0.6682952046394348,
0.777171790599823,
-0.5342522263526917,
0.14852288365364075,
-0.025087762624025345,
-0.15353000164031982,
-0.16118040680885315,
-0.3582814335823059,
0.4778587520122528,
-0.4948198199272156,
-0.055491261184215546,
-0.08643152564764023,
-0.5482839345932007,
-0.40965864062309265,
0.7651708722114563,
-0.5589689016342163,
0.8185563087463379,
0.1456715315580368,
-0.7725388407707214,
0.5142933130264282,
-0.21538233757019043,
0.12761043012142181,
0.161891907453537,
-0.5406821370124817,
-0.291081964969635,
-0.07163744419813156,
0.2516425549983978,
0.4809478223323822,
-0.18298982083797455,
0.2805292010307312,
-0.3013482689857483,
-0.2316141128540039,
0.6312252283096313,
-0.6970757246017456,
0.22295768558979034,
0.2433142364025116,
-0.1557479351758957,
-0.04500522091984749,
-0.787203848361969,
0.4786616265773773,
-0.2502572536468506,
-0.27658870816230774,
-0.2956405580043793,
0.0205937922000885,
-0.08255214244127274,
0.13024619221687317,
0.6378530859947205,
-0.44574227929115295,
-0.28857165575027466,
-0.0536203496158123,
0.2997203469276428,
0.8155110478401184,
-0.05283726006746292,
0.26667875051498413,
-0.48496729135513306,
0.36390432715415955,
0.2543235421180725,
0.3039725124835968,
-0.22924461960792542,
-0.864465594291687,
-1.1121066808700562,
-0.26773175597190857,
0.11750049144029617,
0.9313036203384399,
-1.2112067937850952,
0.1720304638147354,
-0.24102459847927094,
-0.6108105778694153,
-0.825938880443573,
0.005035809241235256,
0.6008464694023132,
0.605760931968689,
0.2720091938972473,
-0.27073320746421814,
-0.18275511264801025,
-0.8798599243164062,
-0.17645858228206635,
-0.7738553285598755,
0.06481403857469559,
0.6022577285766602,
0.48595795035362244,
-0.13530704379081726,
0.6999251246452332,
-0.2846319079399109,
-0.03515009582042694,
0.39995914697647095,
0.3491826057434082,
0.07996844500303268,
0.2541612684726715,
0.3541516363620758,
-1.2219343185424805,
-0.3938533365726471,
0.1130303367972374,
-0.994513213634491,
0.37128427624702454,
-0.21774324774742126,
0.04993109032511711,
-0.014554495923221111,
0.4147144854068756,
-0.44304385781288147,
0.6244186758995056,
0.3471306264400482,
0.07957931607961655,
0.3285970091819763,
-0.3409925401210785,
0.47570985555648804,
-0.8904668092727661,
0.04744219779968262,
0.156973198056221,
-0.052235398441553116,
-0.542487621307373,
0.17999400198459625,
0.15553228557109833,
0.4725332260131836,
-0.6437716484069824,
0.40030741691589355,
-0.2131904661655426,
0.05556177720427513,
0.37290921807289124,
0.043494272977113724,
-0.029748359695076942,
0.47000589966773987,
0.12910424172878265,
0.9646857380867004,
1.0057519674301147,
-0.5367036461830139,
0.5551012754440308,
0.32436326146125793,
-0.7386671304702759,
1.0095828771591187,
-0.7311323285102844,
-0.25013938546180725,
-0.22607581317424774,
-0.43000882863998413,
-1.3070976734161377,
-0.5881937742233276,
0.25249478220939636,
-0.9493473172187805,
0.11387579143047333,
0.12747520208358765,
-0.24574701488018036,
-0.32373958826065063,
0.04889870434999466,
0.3715064227581024,
0.28442317247390747,
-0.1655965894460678,
0.5724385976791382,
0.2405097484588623,
-0.05241688713431358,
-1.0831472873687744,
-0.8772192001342773,
0.053283385932445526,
-0.027170121669769287,
-0.2643866240978241,
-0.14114926755428314,
-0.22006604075431824,
-0.6680941581726074,
0.08699001371860504,
-0.08426745235919952,
-0.3604423999786377,
0.2593390643596649,
0.57755047082901,
0.36434680223464966,
-0.1831962913274765,
0.26692476868629456,
-0.3827909827232361,
-0.01810316927731037,
-0.14954014122486115,
-0.2504461109638214,
0.041847240179777145,
-0.6835578083992004,
-0.7896457314491272,
-0.48496419191360474,
0.1221945509314537,
0.6349336504936218,
-0.13170576095581055,
0.4702882170677185,
0.5968925356864929,
-0.590171217918396,
0.199256032705307,
-0.6033636927604675,
0.22013890743255615,
-0.38454169034957886,
0.3819265365600586,
-0.4262371063232422,
-0.821563184261322,
0.7044631838798523,
0.1345204859972,
-0.11580561846494675,
0.570189356803894,
0.4780159592628479,
-0.5276274085044861,
0.7432776093482971,
0.6308112144470215,
0.05813024565577507,
0.140628844499588,
0.03106999769806862,
-0.01885407231748104,
-0.41042107343673706,
-0.3771895468235016,
-0.46868258714675903,
-0.1843329519033432,
-0.5780936479568481,
-0.6024512052536011,
0.6505966186523438,
-0.1621488779783249,
-0.4313012957572937,
-0.08860252797603607,
-0.44506436586380005,
0.2543526291847229,
0.8002007603645325,
0.009141025133430958,
0.10625497996807098,
-0.2128378450870514,
0.04523582011461258,
0.034236375242471695,
-0.7271407842636108,
-0.3799009621143341,
1.0254223346710205,
0.2003016173839569,
0.9899153709411621,
0.2910177409648895,
0.18469953536987305,
0.19964374601840973,
0.008393208496272564,
-0.6385132074356079,
0.1245918869972229,
0.23103450238704681,
-0.9086183905601501,
-0.49992066621780396,
-0.28110501170158386,
-0.5109394192695618,
-0.033163510262966156,
-0.42429080605506897,
-0.9374476671218872,
0.3770589232444763,
0.18971478939056396,
-0.838287353515625,
0.41135525703430176,
-0.7046881318092346,
0.672036349773407,
-0.1953577995300293,
-0.2903359830379486,
0.13958211243152618,
-1.3400919437408447,
0.042892713099718094,
-0.19460691511631012,
0.27376118302345276,
-0.03887903690338135,
-0.4426014721393585,
0.3522292673587799,
-0.08419530838727951,
0.7102612257003784,
0.23467232286930084,
0.3166421949863434,
0.5733991861343384,
-0.002087897155433893,
0.16031253337860107,
0.026324670761823654,
0.11721733957529068,
0.24145539104938507,
0.23675288259983063,
-0.40948647260665894,
-0.5212174654006958,
0.16979797184467316,
-0.9992685317993164,
-0.4683232009410858,
-0.542190432548523,
-0.4636826515197754,
-0.40821605920791626,
0.04012439027428627,
0.4549064040184021,
0.08333870023488998,
-0.03347960114479065,
0.10655190050601959,
0.9882636070251465,
-0.3457736074924469,
0.28689342737197876,
0.1983160674571991,
0.18268606066703796,
-0.4949546158313751,
0.8880141973495483,
0.08687068521976471,
0.3864307701587677,
0.8260318040847778,
-0.2078133523464203,
-0.234535813331604,
-0.39176225662231445,
-0.6086384057998657,
-0.3042813241481781,
-0.8791264891624451,
-0.26576587557792664,
-0.5664264559745789,
-0.426605761051178,
-0.10918249189853668,
-0.23226796090602875,
-0.4550347924232483,
-0.6044797301292419,
-0.25397878885269165,
-0.005090018268674612,
0.31146806478500366,
0.6626973748207092,
-0.18591001629829407,
0.2563847601413727,
-0.5913382768630981,
0.3696782886981964,
0.6091461777687073,
0.43699806928634644,
-0.3507329523563385,
-0.5925930738449097,
-0.164913609623909,
0.20746953785419464,
0.07242348045110703,
-0.5606061816215515,
0.045893389731645584,
0.38521718978881836,
0.8539614081382751,
0.6880698204040527,
0.24638743698596954,
0.5142003893852234,
-0.2856540381908417,
0.797593891620636,
0.3896058201789856,
-0.6282267570495605,
0.5089209675788879,
-0.14810898900032043,
0.29567044973373413,
0.963060200214386,
0.4294106960296631,
-0.4622092545032501,
-0.5043896436691284,
-0.5730288624763489,
-0.7885873913764954,
0.3516467213630676,
0.1753651201725006,
0.015214868821203709,
0.1889820396900177,
0.16086013615131378,
-0.000412317254813388,
0.558742880821228,
-0.3324584364891052,
-0.4301653802394867,
-0.46234366297721863,
-0.25500982999801636,
-0.19664478302001953,
0.08610193431377411,
-0.432710736989975,
-0.09031461179256439,
0.41600900888442993,
-0.30388960242271423,
0.39965328574180603,
0.3419639468193054,
-0.08541656285524368,
0.006433137692511082,
0.33867841958999634,
0.34239500761032104,
0.7242797017097473,
-0.31249549984931946,
0.3758074641227722,
0.13876481354236603,
-0.5547083616256714,
0.19255682826042175,
-0.027267247438430786,
-0.1731462925672531,
-0.2959115505218506,
0.6030123829841614,
0.7284404039382935,
-0.20927433669567108,
-0.9912172555923462,
0.7373804450035095,
-0.2927807867527008,
0.013902338221669197,
-0.5447942018508911,
0.020332152023911476,
-0.164964959025383,
0.3506084382534027,
0.3493949770927429,
0.6143879294395447,
0.10274475812911987,
-0.47236600518226624,
0.33200374245643616,
0.28908392786979675,
-0.8014019727706909,
-0.009103217162191868,
0.8009019494056702,
-0.07530277967453003,
0.032572004944086075,
0.47369077801704407,
-0.09178616851568222,
-0.43641239404678345,
0.8121610283851624,
-0.22231264412403107,
0.49654242396354675,
0.009437148459255695,
0.3357401192188263,
0.24933528900146484,
0.6913271546363831,
0.11592794209718704,
0.563200056552887,
-0.0002696886658668518,
-1.2684234380722046,
-0.08929786831140518,
-0.4540993273258209,
-0.7581356167793274,
-0.32428690791130066,
-0.8129825592041016,
-0.2870512008666992,
-0.6514740586280823,
-0.3191256523132324,
0.18296931684017181,
-0.4671047329902649,
-0.7881379723548889,
0.6967231631278992,
-0.01892172358930111,
0.7391318082809448,
-0.7822502255439758,
0.38499173521995544,
1.1736280918121338,
-0.6084304451942444,
-0.8731796145439148,
0.017829010263085365,
0.18406496942043304,
-1.067036747932434,
0.24616898596286774,
-0.1338251680135727,
-0.15212611854076385,
-0.2621108889579773,
-0.7498191595077515,
-0.8465027213096619,
1.0830258131027222,
0.221565380692482,
-0.1954728215932846,
0.30339711904525757,
0.06787234544754028,
0.49615103006362915,
-0.14876969158649445,
0.4391708970069885,
0.41858887672424316,
0.6562668681144714,
0.3496466279029846,
-0.7456147074699402,
-0.5133083462715149,
-0.5060755610466003,
-0.08619678765535355,
-0.09393510967493057,
-0.8127029538154602,
0.8691662549972534,
-0.44370847940444946,
-0.1884915977716446,
0.3068353831768036,
0.5186594724655151,
-0.10235793888568878,
0.4900765120983124,
0.4307780861854553,
0.8336842656135559,
0.8425878286361694,
-0.5194603204727173,
0.9780111908912659,
-0.31450533866882324,
0.05009168013930321,
1.11741042137146,
-0.01936175487935543,
0.9263969659805298,
0.7670668363571167,
-0.37180501222610474,
0.10200079530477524,
0.9544685482978821,
0.11036847531795502,
0.42837491631507874,
-0.2986821234226227,
-0.22991906106472015,
-0.7207016348838806,
-0.27754876017570496,
-0.2800563871860504,
0.558015763759613,
0.6506708860397339,
-0.017865583300590515,
0.13163985311985016,
-0.07464687526226044,
-0.36219123005867004,
0.2005845606327057,
-0.34807807207107544,
0.7893137335777283,
-0.08767907321453094,
-0.7806008458137512,
0.36896634101867676,
-0.19649448990821838,
0.5399712920188904,
-0.40693163871765137,
0.08270357549190521,
-0.028808075934648514,
0.06299881637096405,
0.035148102790117264,
-1.3404951095581055,
0.021796153858304024,
-0.27540621161460876,
0.018346233293414116,
0.23315544426441193,
0.4209090769290924,
-0.20609895884990692,
-0.6268525719642639,
-0.010611012578010559,
1.0404475927352905,
0.3002401888370514,
0.09268250316381454,
-0.7742083668708801,
-0.1842668056488037,
-0.020454004406929016,
-0.07195878028869629,
-0.18348398804664612,
0.7116049528121948,
0.0642399936914444,
1.1711570024490356,
0.01799638755619526,
-0.013671725988388062,
0.3046826422214508,
-0.17018403112888336,
0.6390656232833862,
-0.06802767515182495,
-0.1838623434305191,
-0.38759759068489075,
0.7105972170829773,
0.11625739187002182,
-0.7574472427368164,
0.6080783009529114,
0.2512238323688507,
0.915148913860321,
-0.005142982583492994,
0.9640897512435913,
-0.2862668037414551,
0.220841646194458,
-0.34829458594322205,
0.5939307808876038,
-1.0509059429168701,
-0.08921175450086594,
-0.5396453142166138,
-0.5964613556861877,
-0.5775848031044006,
0.7502539753913879,
-0.04374147579073906,
-0.041667453944683075,
0.480347216129303,
0.6944283246994019,
0.1667013019323349,
-0.02735498733818531,
0.7444784045219421,
0.2036137580871582,
-0.3479774296283722,
0.6806808114051819,
1.010264277458191,
-0.4463689923286438,
0.4386271834373474,
-0.2524546980857849,
-0.2914251983165741,
-0.020607247948646545,
-0.6038633584976196,
-0.3522278964519501,
-1.0251795053482056,
-0.34702247381210327,
-0.167543426156044,
0.21511082351207733,
0.550332248210907,
0.6864472031593323,
-0.8339778780937195,
0.18279404938220978,
0.12334506958723068,
0.1795300543308258,
-0.27815762162208557,
-0.052857596427202225,
0.207212895154953,
-0.03629749268293381,
-0.6086099743843079,
-0.17936311662197113,
0.4946587383747101,
0.4447384774684906,
-0.14337940514087677,
-0.10530691593885422,
-0.31424424052238464,
0.26850274205207825,
0.07992960512638092,
0.40937891602516174,
-0.8020182251930237,
-0.6195815205574036,
0.053038328886032104,
-0.20000478625297546,
0.2974493205547333,
-0.008732708171010017,
-0.48652490973472595,
0.9014121294021606,
0.17588450014591217,
0.8483838438987732,
0.1767573207616806,
0.12450619041919708,
0.2214750200510025,
-0.6266661286354065,
0.1956145316362381,
0.31765761971473694,
0.49110791087150574,
0.45876187086105347,
-0.2602366507053375,
0.5946972966194153,
0.17121902108192444,
-0.3418380916118622,
-0.4994971752166748,
0.31534436345100403,
-0.974942147731781,
-0.13754591345787048,
0.845912516117096,
-0.5661479234695435,
-0.43258026242256165,
-0.23448459804058075,
0.06583644449710846,
0.10510019958019257,
-0.2634272873401642,
0.5471122860908508,
1.0875414609909058,
-0.09893249720335007,
-0.4198024868965149,
-0.5891933441162109,
0.13166043162345886,
0.42413535714149475,
-0.8812861442565918,
-0.32769545912742615,
0.6048471331596375,
-0.05925330892205238,
0.6601869463920593,
0.2667340934276581,
0.0793728232383728,
0.5598846077919006,
0.5517128705978394,
0.1502152979373932,
0.36802878975868225,
-0.7256287932395935,
-0.09859190881252289,
0.16564568877220154,
0.29790931940078735,
-0.3417682349681854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01937v1 | Efficient-Empathy: Towards Efficient and Effective Selection of Empathy Data | 2024-07-02T04:11:52 | 2024-07-02T04:11:52 | Linzhuang Sun, Hao Liang, Jingxuan Wei, Linkun Sun, Bihui Yu, Bin Cui, Wentao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, with the rapid advancements in large language models (LLMs),
achieving excellent empathetic response capability has become a crucial
prerequisite. Consequently, managing and understanding large-scale video
datasets has gained increasing importance. However, empathetic data are
typically trained without any quality selection, leading to inefficient data
usage and wasted computational resources. Additionally, using raw data can
result in low performance in empathetic dialogues. In this work, we present
Efficient-Empathy, a sensibility and rationality score-based data selection
algorithm that automatically selects sensibility and rationality data while
discarding low-quality data. With only the sensibility data (59% of the full
dataset), our trained sensibility model efficiently achieves state-of-the-art
(SoTA) performance. Furthermore, with multiple data selection hyperparameters,
the sensibility model demonstrates SoTA performance, showcasing the robustness
of our method. By integrating sensibility and rationality data with a MoE
structure, we achieve even higher performance, demonstrating the effectiveness
of our Efficient-Empathy algorithm. | [
-0.43750229477882385,
-0.8222341537475586,
0.6806814670562744,
0.28193411231040955,
-0.3100815415382385,
-0.5431046485900879,
-0.31024253368377686,
-0.15938422083854675,
0.09848085790872574,
0.01602298580110073,
-0.48494356870651245,
-0.4872335195541382,
-0.6905547976493835,
0.07269192487001419,
0.056900933384895325,
0.6115611791610718,
-0.07747471332550049,
0.2710704505443573,
-0.0589926578104496,
-0.8027775883674622,
-0.16203635931015015,
-0.2843375504016876,
-0.6768115162849426,
-0.1837870180606842,
0.4678582549095154,
0.92892986536026,
0.537031352519989,
1.0207797288894653,
0.4628452658653259,
0.2754758894443512,
0.12659291923046112,
0.2718835771083832,
-0.6812522411346436,
0.19200842082500458,
-0.06368944048881531,
-0.23622485995292664,
-0.8852071166038513,
0.18501843512058258,
0.1804163008928299,
0.13512007892131805,
-0.2218230664730072,
0.3885807991027832,
-0.010103227570652962,
0.6801645755767822,
-0.5915820002555847,
0.08050892502069473,
-0.4367680251598358,
0.2176234871149063,
0.2486654669046402,
-0.34511470794677734,
-0.489981085062027,
-0.2883833050727844,
-0.0035902587696909904,
-0.664812445640564,
-0.3503339886665344,
-0.010086282156407833,
0.6154791712760925,
0.29707610607147217,
-0.18917420506477356,
-0.17437154054641724,
-0.1388414353132248,
1.0384999513626099,
-0.27990320324897766,
0.38637909293174744,
0.663508951663971,
0.31033170223236084,
0.447256863117218,
-0.3895733654499054,
-0.5409818291664124,
-0.1668454110622406,
0.34580278396606445,
0.29429101943969727,
-0.31682875752449036,
0.08803664892911911,
0.5733941793441772,
0.11189538240432739,
-0.4595987796783447,
0.05107802897691727,
0.3194580674171448,
0.03136248141527176,
0.6476780772209167,
0.4982946813106537,
0.29571837186813354,
-0.24181991815567017,
-0.23246441781520844,
-0.18232181668281555,
-0.1685764342546463,
0.1484716534614563,
0.3832131028175354,
0.10950370132923126,
-0.18883128464221954,
0.8121512532234192,
-0.28957927227020264,
0.5075117945671082,
0.0670183002948761,
-0.11130696535110474,
0.29202690720558167,
0.10318482667207718,
-0.2586420476436615,
-0.14870215952396393,
0.5994393229484558,
0.9029948711395264,
0.5160571932792664,
0.12451156973838806,
-0.15555939078330994,
0.4159383773803711,
0.15362748503684998,
-1.0119259357452393,
-0.19604481756687164,
0.3009193539619446,
-0.7452410459518433,
-0.10016729682683945,
-0.4713687598705292,
-0.9144430160522461,
-0.3065774142742157,
-0.4922185242176056,
0.10227951407432556,
-0.6289984583854675,
-0.2802097201347351,
-0.07138252258300781,
-0.041577212512493134,
0.14718909561634064,
0.5313065052032471,
-0.758520245552063,
0.09103857725858688,
0.44739264249801636,
0.7855835556983948,
0.15101762115955353,
-0.08947096765041351,
-0.988792359828949,
-0.05315859615802765,
-0.0397811196744442,
0.5806090235710144,
-1.0980907678604126,
-0.16495488584041595,
-0.3168863356113434,
-0.36853933334350586,
-0.1028117910027504,
-0.2952940762042999,
1.065977692604065,
-0.24061177670955658,
-0.16994071006774902,
-0.28915777802467346,
-0.6808976531028748,
-0.3009442985057831,
0.5501105189323425,
-0.7526733875274658,
0.5185967087745667,
0.36973127722740173,
-0.8167100548744202,
0.6117567420005798,
-0.6394084692001343,
-0.15314915776252747,
-0.3618074655532837,
-0.05477762222290039,
-0.28609326481819153,
0.08343815803527832,
0.3206115663051605,
0.8534098267555237,
-0.3532356917858124,
0.23374983668327332,
-0.5742584466934204,
-0.290372759103775,
0.1392800658941269,
-0.6852649450302124,
0.5051290988922119,
0.49396321177482605,
0.0038487333804368973,
-0.0670628622174263,
-0.6450034379959106,
0.038018692284822464,
-0.007401503622531891,
-0.2001105695962906,
-0.3659905195236206,
-0.17219796776771545,
0.3017944395542145,
0.36707204580307007,
-0.15379305183887482,
-0.6957969069480896,
0.07471877336502075,
-0.1588272601366043,
0.35195839405059814,
0.8983032703399658,
-0.37564635276794434,
0.736974835395813,
-0.2606136202812195,
0.613043487071991,
-0.09212705492973328,
0.5442595481872559,
0.07424625754356384,
-0.3548814058303833,
-0.25343000888824463,
-0.9600997567176819,
-0.17204684019088745,
0.5164343118667603,
-0.4065730571746826,
0.5459431409835815,
-0.28621017932891846,
-0.6629701852798462,
-0.7940084338188171,
0.14887402951717377,
0.366636723279953,
0.7906320095062256,
0.32967856526374817,
-0.404917448759079,
-0.24616199731826782,
-0.8436919450759888,
-0.504176139831543,
-0.03725550323724747,
0.040730372071266174,
0.8948627710342407,
-0.03200995549559593,
-0.27187785506248474,
0.8231191635131836,
-0.4844813346862793,
-0.24043844640254974,
-0.3353414535522461,
-0.17443819344043732,
0.26492223143577576,
0.4906669557094574,
0.44855207204818726,
-0.9791871309280396,
-0.669252336025238,
-0.0073877740651369095,
-0.7999212741851807,
-0.0404830165207386,
0.022079117596149445,
-0.46075117588043213,
0.2204381823539734,
-0.07929212599992752,
-0.9001643657684326,
0.48837828636169434,
0.4931148290634155,
-0.48322439193725586,
-0.0425582230091095,
0.09758571535348892,
0.5620137453079224,
-0.965509295463562,
0.3907043933868408,
0.2481125444173813,
-0.15831425786018372,
-0.5706605911254883,
-0.45872315764427185,
0.15653172135353088,
0.2686995267868042,
-0.4618361294269562,
0.759799599647522,
-0.17553295195102692,
0.16868264973163605,
0.33011722564697266,
0.09814237058162689,
-0.09188235551118851,
0.7556278705596924,
0.15032033622264862,
0.22590157389640808,
0.7119861245155334,
-0.3948309123516083,
0.5539644956588745,
0.648206353187561,
-0.11074907332658768,
0.9676487445831299,
-0.16866634786128998,
0.048219721764326096,
-0.20578695833683014,
-0.12273701280355453,
-0.5282163023948669,
-0.5876909494400024,
0.38455846905708313,
-0.6208834052085876,
0.20877426862716675,
-0.16320687532424927,
-0.32292649149894714,
0.052146513015031815,
-0.5082941055297852,
0.5010740160942078,
0.5651148557662964,
-0.6368463635444641,
0.9507441520690918,
0.6286628842353821,
-0.3770884871482849,
-0.48275819420814514,
-0.5030330419540405,
-0.10191242396831512,
-0.5557361245155334,
-0.4991858899593353,
-0.36296477913856506,
-0.1937575340270996,
-0.20399317145347595,
-0.02410220168530941,
-0.012237755581736565,
-0.16325965523719788,
-0.05543062463402748,
0.2650088667869568,
0.11146390438079834,
0.2918036878108978,
0.13232944905757904,
0.30715301632881165,
-0.3292546570301056,
0.0035706572234630585,
0.5383168458938599,
0.46780523657798767,
-0.04691675677895546,
-0.32834407687187195,
-0.7778017520904541,
0.36131393909454346,
0.7207013964653015,
-0.060245875269174576,
0.47889015078544617,
0.5480392575263977,
-0.19335371255874634,
-0.1411600261926651,
-0.5896617770195007,
-0.30279409885406494,
-0.3989159166812897,
0.38663530349731445,
-0.48580729961395264,
-0.6646607518196106,
0.5759971141815186,
0.059975169599056244,
-0.03505517542362213,
-0.18555261194705963,
0.4298873841762543,
0.20967967808246613,
1.6282463073730469,
0.18899285793304443,
-0.22322200238704681,
0.7339248657226562,
-0.185423344373703,
0.3160174787044525,
-0.9729689359664917,
-0.1540490984916687,
-0.20554818212985992,
-0.24343006312847137,
-0.4802384078502655,
-0.044513680040836334,
0.44881898164749146,
-0.2575127184391022,
-0.5904159545898438,
0.07821311056613922,
-0.5070356130599976,
0.2677745521068573,
0.231283038854599,
0.5296266078948975,
0.15441064536571503,
0.062205132097005844,
0.3794633150100708,
-0.18465860188007355,
-0.6534814238548279,
-0.7128633260726929,
1.1480193138122559,
0.5342713594436646,
0.7952041029930115,
0.0792289599776268,
0.45911407470703125,
0.18536004424095154,
0.7436661720275879,
-1.061287760734558,
0.728611171245575,
-0.1371767520904541,
-0.14900077879428864,
-0.39290595054626465,
-0.7079252600669861,
-0.7243852019309998,
0.1029292643070221,
-0.09691018611192703,
-0.6331234574317932,
0.12600375711917877,
0.48842689394950867,
-0.40768590569496155,
0.07938779145479202,
-0.9501101970672607,
0.7977238893508911,
0.04251851886510849,
-0.8562373518943787,
-0.4694286584854126,
-0.6524851322174072,
0.18611426651477814,
-0.16208866238594055,
-0.03985917568206787,
-0.42868301272392273,
0.07156681269407272,
0.5581697225570679,
-0.19398047029972076,
0.36637184023857117,
-0.5966165065765381,
0.2234381139278412,
0.1834827959537506,
0.31144246459007263,
0.4721425771713257,
0.3936406970024109,
-0.5885531306266785,
-0.011414007283747196,
-0.3000248670578003,
-0.38254982233047485,
-0.708696722984314,
0.6337525844573975,
-0.5561735033988953,
-0.21988454461097717,
-0.013705453835427761,
-0.3566666543483734,
-0.43937161564826965,
0.013444941490888596,
0.05480487644672394,
0.5629205703735352,
-0.18502596020698547,
0.2730088233947754,
0.4891729950904846,
-0.32814711332321167,
0.2874811887741089,
0.23619996011257172,
0.4801475703716278,
-0.565609335899353,
0.9025696516036987,
0.07113990932703018,
0.09748504310846329,
0.19085177779197693,
0.28268834948539734,
-0.4378178119659424,
0.13405482470989227,
-0.46065863966941833,
-0.014145012013614178,
-0.5849823355674744,
-0.5110160708427429,
-0.9860903024673462,
0.24000151455402374,
-0.14961054921150208,
-0.41338106989860535,
-0.33978551626205444,
-0.10772686451673508,
-0.1583845168352127,
-0.5268938541412354,
0.6572096347808838,
0.15145528316497803,
-0.343247652053833,
-0.028352223336696625,
-0.9592291116714478,
0.5789158344268799,
0.22112606465816498,
0.5525708794593811,
0.19369971752166748,
-0.44924458861351013,
-0.14512303471565247,
0.13190878927707672,
-0.16672439873218536,
-0.5881378650665283,
0.8165030479431152,
0.24862757325172424,
0.47635096311569214,
0.7154122591018677,
0.2067531943321228,
0.7289080023765564,
-0.1922585517168045,
0.24189680814743042,
0.323306679725647,
-1.0249303579330444,
0.5467180013656616,
-0.4117623269557953,
-0.16906650364398956,
0.758596658706665,
0.3190971314907074,
-0.13331414759159088,
-0.13151778280735016,
-0.6587262153625488,
-0.9057409167289734,
0.9997513890266418,
0.1907797008752823,
0.36082345247268677,
-0.041654277592897415,
0.12739484012126923,
0.3304287791252136,
0.10358314961194992,
-0.2838744819164276,
0.22881729900836945,
-0.2681918740272522,
-0.8136025667190552,
-0.04470543563365936,
-0.20545504987239838,
-0.1322782337665558,
-0.36102408170700073,
0.2632591724395752,
-0.24492919445037842,
0.2952289879322052,
0.3832184672355652,
-0.15828436613082886,
-0.29762986302375793,
0.09064371883869171,
-0.1379242241382599,
0.04502733051776886,
-0.2552582621574402,
-0.23021632432937622,
0.21650108695030212,
-0.6123688817024231,
0.11470703035593033,
-0.21214407682418823,
0.1951305866241455,
-0.4195326268672943,
0.29320597648620605,
0.7133787870407104,
-0.04077685624361038,
-1.142594814300537,
0.8288538455963135,
-0.21510978043079376,
0.11613547801971436,
-0.06933819502592087,
0.14442561566829681,
-0.24828654527664185,
0.37350204586982727,
-0.17752157151699066,
0.18874841928482056,
0.5025600790977478,
-0.5037192702293396,
0.31300464272499084,
0.25664255023002625,
-0.17597328126430511,
-0.3046683967113495,
0.29956480860710144,
0.25655463337898254,
-0.18096697330474854,
0.9587612152099609,
0.14359532296657562,
-0.18933025002479553,
0.5113595724105835,
-0.042634718120098114,
0.9627314805984497,
-0.3747856616973877,
0.20708207786083221,
0.47894975543022156,
-0.3513478636741638,
-0.2844083309173584,
0.7394291162490845,
-0.38274967670440674,
-0.9231715798377991,
-0.2060137838125229,
-0.44100725650787354,
-0.48170408606529236,
-0.3622836172580719,
-1.2975428104400635,
0.0018235864117741585,
-0.23178623616695404,
-0.46667012572288513,
-0.4703614115715027,
-0.06255195289850235,
-0.9757437109947205,
0.4300706386566162,
-0.21669507026672363,
1.1427643299102783,
-1.019195556640625,
0.6862830519676208,
0.43674135208129883,
-0.23836037516593933,
-1.1580171585083008,
-0.2913687229156494,
-0.21289323270320892,
-0.8672094345092773,
0.5154920816421509,
0.4479581117630005,
-0.102302685379982,
0.2479415088891983,
-0.6330086588859558,
-0.31850022077560425,
1.02358078956604,
0.7116118669509888,
-0.458251029253006,
0.422140508890152,
-0.2941220998764038,
0.5216784477233887,
-0.5026246905326843,
0.7040622234344482,
0.7250253558158875,
0.7228062748908997,
0.026552705094218254,
-0.5908470749855042,
0.027162820100784302,
-0.6281458735466003,
-0.29454338550567627,
-0.18895266950130463,
-0.7542793154716492,
0.3713260889053345,
-0.23520171642303467,
-0.13470810651779175,
0.15730474889278412,
0.10917104035615921,
0.6146852970123291,
0.7648515701293945,
0.6641947031021118,
0.7861337661743164,
0.5803471207618713,
0.001113595557399094,
0.9292603731155396,
-0.42856356501579285,
0.2536567449569702,
0.5385721921920776,
-0.5962046980857849,
0.9639842510223389,
0.5862927436828613,
0.280253142118454,
-0.06739065796136856,
0.5991436839103699,
0.04530731961131096,
0.5267596244812012,
-0.09922857582569122,
-0.2538461983203888,
-0.5932697057723999,
-0.48006415367126465,
0.2921176254749298,
0.7598038911819458,
0.2956218123435974,
-0.29819485545158386,
0.08829769492149353,
0.1523188054561615,
0.010731836780905724,
0.16518808901309967,
-0.37228646874427795,
0.83867347240448,
0.1605253666639328,
-0.6662755012512207,
0.2781769633293152,
-0.34246331453323364,
0.3983778953552246,
-0.33520805835723877,
-0.25574791431427,
-0.5061265826225281,
0.04674062505364418,
-0.3765646815299988,
-0.9269344210624695,
0.12064807862043381,
0.6069877743721008,
-0.12089519947767258,
-0.5231920480728149,
0.4749549925327301,
-0.3181705176830292,
-0.0631343424320221,
0.6237955093383789,
0.5884557962417603,
0.16066798567771912,
-0.1346791684627533,
-0.4703119099140167,
0.3335367441177368,
-0.24627685546875,
-0.9725282788276672,
0.21021179854869843,
0.7603951692581177,
-0.008451608009636402,
1.0378376245498657,
0.5961189866065979,
0.09592189639806747,
-0.4884971082210541,
0.2413649559020996,
1.1787221431732178,
-0.8262415528297424,
-0.4597676992416382,
-0.8869934678077698,
0.7916603684425354,
-0.3399680554866791,
-0.256538450717926,
0.6152748465538025,
0.3744518458843231,
0.47722288966178894,
-0.02149997465312481,
0.6711633205413818,
-0.09948962926864624,
0.5942602157592773,
-0.48545312881469727,
0.5779113173484802,
-0.5281471014022827,
0.07294578850269318,
-0.4180222451686859,
-0.7663222551345825,
-0.35907161235809326,
0.9612216353416443,
-0.3407973647117615,
0.16205543279647827,
0.20412351191043854,
1.051506757736206,
-0.10172193497419357,
0.03321041166782379,
0.531487762928009,
0.241759791970253,
0.1459987610578537,
0.8256253600120544,
0.8482650518417358,
-0.06642311066389084,
0.059796832501888275,
0.026520060375332832,
-0.6798665523529053,
-0.35405412316322327,
-0.7158228754997253,
-0.6149579882621765,
-0.32493817806243896,
-0.03604239597916603,
-0.09409204870462418,
-0.11366239935159683,
1.2506554126739502,
0.7546436190605164,
-0.4159412980079651,
0.12193484604358673,
-0.09485649317502975,
-0.12307186424732208,
-0.1266135424375534,
-0.19672615826129913,
0.46900302171707153,
0.1657087504863739,
-0.9190423488616943,
0.10849439352750778,
0.45935526490211487,
-0.28479424118995667,
0.3478555679321289,
-0.5769674181938171,
0.298722505569458,
0.3145570456981659,
0.6987901329994202,
0.07302846759557724,
-0.22494161128997803,
-0.23463432490825653,
0.2111094743013382,
-0.1796785444021225,
-0.02118527516722679,
0.541881799697876,
-0.44998595118522644,
0.5519809722900391,
0.47885456681251526,
0.4902920424938202,
-0.11067518591880798,
0.4734891653060913,
0.5567942261695862,
-0.17492333054542542,
0.010883382521569729,
0.5549843311309814,
0.3510388433933258,
0.34240031242370605,
-0.5505859851837158,
0.6389868259429932,
-0.042751096189022064,
-0.5417323708534241,
-1.145658016204834,
0.33614078164100647,
-1.3605847358703613,
0.2499087154865265,
1.4316247701644897,
-0.37523704767227173,
-0.15231218934059143,
-0.004043457098305225,
-0.6939926743507385,
0.4181682765483856,
-0.8096926808357239,
0.8208957314491272,
0.28041186928749084,
-0.48337283730506897,
-0.3403855860233307,
-0.3102627396583557,
0.44186022877693176,
0.49022695422172546,
-0.5588908791542053,
0.26814863085746765,
0.5652592778205872,
0.07786576449871063,
-0.46229565143585205,
0.7045720815658569,
-0.04298042505979538,
0.16462495923042297,
-0.0010920421918854117,
0.018129194155335426,
-0.10651376098394394,
-0.29033640027046204,
-0.43678560853004456,
0.23219621181488037,
-0.07269202917814255,
-0.17783643305301666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01929v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01929v1 | What We Talk About When We Talk About LMs: Implicit Paradigm Shifts and the Ship of Language Models | 2024-07-02T03:45:55 | 2024-07-02T03:45:55 | Shengqi Zhu, Jeffrey M. Rzeszotarski | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The term Language Models (LMs), as a time-specific collection of models of
interest, is constantly reinvented, with its referents updated much like the
$\textit{Ship of Theseus}$ replaces its parts but remains the same ship in
essence. In this paper, we investigate this $\textit{Ship of Language Models}$
problem, wherein scientific evolution takes the form of continuous, implicit
retrofits of key existing terms. We seek to initiate a novel perspective of
scientific progress, in addition to the more well-studied emergence of new
terms. To this end, we construct the data infrastructure based on recent NLP
publications. Then, we perform a series of text-based analyses toward a
detailed, quantitative understanding of the use of Language Models as a term of
art. Our work highlights how systems and theories influence each other in
scientific discourse, and we call for attention to the transformation of this
Ship that we all are contributing to. | [
-0.20174351334571838,
-0.7254660129547119,
0.794089138507843,
0.08807811141014099,
-0.15063346922397614,
0.2427331656217575,
-0.05478215962648392,
-0.6360512375831604,
0.11555728316307068,
0.6727584004402161,
-0.6038550138473511,
-0.12449585646390915,
-0.6143398284912109,
0.40983662009239197,
-0.6961690187454224,
1.1053498983383179,
0.0010312128579244018,
0.23947355151176453,
-0.10729668289422989,
-0.29103970527648926,
-0.4424169361591339,
0.03322259709239006,
-0.5361807942390442,
-0.4594915211200714,
0.7551923394203186,
-0.19131790101528168,
0.914713442325592,
0.8627985119819641,
0.3836513161659241,
0.29203131794929504,
-0.41553884744644165,
0.05939209833741188,
-0.23543842136859894,
0.4260254204273224,
-0.25436633825302124,
-0.71315997838974,
-0.4576776623725891,
-0.0665985643863678,
0.962165355682373,
1.124385952949524,
-0.0014475201023742557,
0.38274240493774414,
-0.0355701670050621,
0.6341025233268738,
-0.21782590448856354,
0.2817581295967102,
-0.8293765187263489,
-0.01845131814479828,
-0.04354395717382431,
-0.332120805978775,
-0.37593144178390503,
-0.25565439462661743,
0.30004754662513733,
-0.6500036716461182,
0.07270561158657074,
0.3445379137992859,
0.7940343618392944,
0.10668277740478516,
-0.28977006673812866,
-0.21995824575424194,
-0.9735081791877747,
0.7348676919937134,
-0.8624444007873535,
0.5892333388328552,
-0.37147244811058044,
0.24714267253875732,
-0.550948441028595,
-1.0604051351547241,
-0.6344160437583923,
-0.4944511950016022,
0.17495930194854736,
-0.13735899329185486,
-0.2096618264913559,
-0.30158743262290955,
0.08622612804174423,
-0.03666176274418831,
-0.40743598341941833,
0.14091739058494568,
-0.6130507588386536,
0.2805769145488739,
0.5808217525482178,
0.12091907858848572,
0.5341829657554626,
0.0047211251221597195,
-0.28350162506103516,
0.10485021770000458,
-1.0413262844085693,
-0.3612325191497803,
-0.24348647892475128,
0.38193678855895996,
-0.016777100041508675,
0.43817123770713806,
0.043981634080410004,
0.5766009092330933,
-0.17465348541736603,
0.14645345509052277,
0.05422009527683258,
-0.03645213693380356,
-0.2574998736381531,
-0.055345404893159866,
0.7862385511398315,
0.2451288104057312,
0.21451371908187866,
-0.2045348584651947,
-0.07487449049949646,
0.08913059532642365,
0.4183196425437927,
-0.3087712526321411,
-0.06592630594968796,
0.0596119724214077,
-0.36462119221687317,
-0.3560333549976349,
-0.1964348554611206,
-0.5071855187416077,
-0.4312744438648224,
-0.48464319109916687,
0.2376226782798767,
-0.12142391502857208,
-0.34087246656417847,
0.3056134581565857,
0.04099581763148308,
0.04962857812643051,
0.3172205984592438,
-0.6912622451782227,
0.27201592922210693,
0.8399755954742432,
1.098970651626587,
-0.10583565384149551,
-0.04852815344929695,
0.15034803748130798,
0.2790306508541107,
-0.5839173197746277,
0.904806911945343,
-0.45591795444488525,
-0.8118354678153992,
0.03865639492869377,
0.4569501280784607,
0.021161895245313644,
-0.08131413161754608,
0.38790443539619446,
-0.6273060441017151,
0.467451810836792,
-0.35068878531455994,
-0.5121537446975708,
-0.10020973533391953,
-0.10689675062894821,
-0.5812985897064209,
1.0459882020950317,
-0.3008520007133484,
-0.473217636346817,
0.19151927530765533,
-1.0672074556350708,
0.054445281624794006,
0.5020036697387695,
-0.20960864424705505,
-0.28656870126724243,
0.4959102272987366,
-0.3040292263031006,
0.2715878188610077,
-0.4036523997783661,
0.4219343066215515,
-0.46499961614608765,
-0.16902343928813934,
0.46778562664985657,
0.14050839841365814,
0.5363072156906128,
0.4326348900794983,
-0.3482690155506134,
-0.1333700269460678,
-0.7428036332130432,
-0.029740160331130028,
0.14121775329113007,
-0.1024920791387558,
-0.7964464426040649,
0.5975415110588074,
-0.14622561633586884,
0.2209765464067459,
0.2347424477338791,
-0.5945972800254822,
0.6768960952758789,
-0.38352060317993164,
0.6840803027153015,
0.866917610168457,
-0.12951484322547913,
0.675477921962738,
-0.3716870844364166,
0.30569329857826233,
-0.2051742672920227,
0.2702287435531616,
-0.22681666910648346,
-0.7968676090240479,
-0.9815697073936462,
0.16554373502731323,
0.117952361702919,
0.2581601142883301,
-0.6187405586242676,
-0.04991820827126503,
-0.6877562403678894,
-0.472806841135025,
-0.5053121447563171,
-0.3089412748813629,
-0.19071470201015472,
0.2774233818054199,
0.37785619497299194,
0.046812284737825394,
-0.5376649498939514,
-0.8551363348960876,
-0.4033088684082031,
-0.505959153175354,
-0.03040238283574581,
0.19034574925899506,
0.580725908279419,
-0.4408699870109558,
1.0827637910842896,
-0.3898427486419678,
0.49953386187553406,
0.17848047614097595,
0.2561856508255005,
0.1561257392168045,
0.5286433100700378,
0.5236047506332397,
-0.5984033942222595,
-0.14411118626594543,
0.11631239950656891,
-0.9250609874725342,
-0.36530107259750366,
-0.23203913867473602,
-0.07456664741039276,
0.3177710473537445,
0.8817635178565979,
-0.6191591024398804,
-0.11338143050670624,
0.48228031396865845,
-0.5445273518562317,
0.368709534406662,
-0.11705111712217331,
-0.017591707408428192,
-1.1418046951293945,
-0.007734718732535839,
-0.1337730884552002,
0.10343469679355621,
-0.7550989389419556,
0.19809208810329437,
-0.04472280293703079,
0.13368654251098633,
-0.4524681866168976,
0.7546021938323975,
-0.696142852306366,
-0.0028124514501541853,
-0.4554259181022644,
0.24635693430900574,
-0.23143894970417023,
-0.02577146515250206,
0.2523779273033142,
0.03649476543068886,
0.4843778908252716,
-0.7836621403694153,
0.059481389820575714,
0.061823952943086624,
-0.04051988944411278,
0.44752034544944763,
-0.7396070957183838,
0.3482837975025177,
-0.5868166089057922,
0.2795311510562897,
-1.0062363147735596,
0.4360116720199585,
0.2841734290122986,
-0.049465328454971313,
0.15032245218753815,
-0.13256655633449554,
-0.2531276047229767,
-0.26023492217063904,
-0.019944703206419945,
0.14367693662643433,
0.4062524437904358,
-0.26684772968292236,
0.5849171876907349,
0.16123609244823456,
-0.6310203671455383,
-0.45231232047080994,
-0.491097629070282,
0.32195770740509033,
-0.16552536189556122,
-0.5820671319961548,
0.19296225905418396,
-0.24627874791622162,
-0.7651798129081726,
0.21873849630355835,
-0.15243223309516907,
0.42182859778404236,
0.21291320025920868,
0.2782539427280426,
0.5842304229736328,
-0.6116280555725098,
0.4613078832626343,
0.16581162810325623,
0.1658911108970642,
0.17900890111923218,
-0.7576376795768738,
0.4820080101490021,
-0.14537949860095978,
0.08321394771337509,
0.01875322498381138,
0.3186763525009155,
0.7396827340126038,
0.13914702832698822,
0.9628577828407288,
0.19999252259731293,
-0.18073029816150665,
-0.2208033800125122,
-0.3582254946231842,
-0.12251690030097961,
-0.4623579680919647,
0.4693300426006317,
-0.38174009323120117,
-0.9250742793083191,
0.42866742610931396,
-0.23416632413864136,
0.5155293345451355,
0.6491063833236694,
0.2721329927444458,
-0.33656173944473267,
0.9447098970413208,
0.9618249535560608,
0.23202021420001984,
0.39710450172424316,
0.02142171375453472,
0.11312557011842728,
-0.8314208388328552,
-0.2810514271259308,
-0.8100510835647583,
-0.1878148764371872,
-0.8963474631309509,
-0.3977252244949341,
0.2657943367958069,
-0.029716091230511665,
-0.3840579390525818,
0.4008414149284363,
-0.440964013338089,
0.083971306681633,
-0.2217831164598465,
-0.30373239517211914,
0.5212556719779968,
-0.11131544411182404,
0.1046062633395195,
-0.12499619275331497,
-0.7270241379737854,
-0.9796833395957947,
1.3582571744918823,
0.6050218343734741,
0.6330698132514954,
0.17627912759780884,
0.3405002951622009,
0.41582414507865906,
0.8752581477165222,
-0.39008209109306335,
0.7224284410476685,
0.06356044858694077,
-0.4359690845012665,
-0.22745637595653534,
-0.29496973752975464,
-1.1432279348373413,
0.44672930240631104,
-0.3008251488208771,
-0.6286119818687439,
0.34187930822372437,
-0.18393242359161377,
0.11588959395885468,
0.34464728832244873,
-0.2551850378513336,
0.479301780462265,
-0.35341522097587585,
-0.27434664964675903,
-0.16754266619682312,
-0.5911195874214172,
0.41180557012557983,
-0.2534925937652588,
0.7562242150306702,
-0.31360211968421936,
-0.47569337487220764,
0.743995189666748,
-0.12837420403957367,
0.8281864523887634,
0.024421678856015205,
-0.8614693880081177,
-0.06976296752691269,
0.42681601643562317,
0.45262548327445984,
0.15407036244869232,
0.20749694108963013,
0.20505274832248688,
0.2619797885417938,
-0.32226961851119995,
-0.5506103038787842,
0.921157717704773,
-0.5461398363113403,
-0.5746598839759827,
-0.5042372345924377,
-0.6014307737350464,
-0.15563926100730896,
-0.01310846209526062,
-0.20740479230880737,
0.1122811958193779,
-0.4196833372116089,
-0.19653970003128052,
0.7232619524002075,
-0.2686541974544525,
0.5507039427757263,
1.0492346286773682,
-0.5193667411804199,
0.32863521575927734,
0.4565355181694031,
-0.036888621747493744,
0.4153592884540558,
0.2905948758125305,
0.10729078203439713,
-0.3640647530555725,
-0.3952798545360565,
-0.2084774374961853,
0.6052142381668091,
-0.6915614008903503,
0.4008638560771942,
-0.7639248371124268,
0.0894632637500763,
-0.24508841335773468,
-0.07102587819099426,
-0.37966716289520264,
-0.5430223941802979,
-0.3018079996109009,
0.20925699174404144,
0.2591606080532074,
1.208337664604187,
0.2162432223558426,
0.15880049765110016,
-0.6436024904251099,
0.01511866133660078,
0.1097407191991806,
0.2307291179895401,
-0.20098140835762024,
-0.7605022192001343,
-0.22561846673488617,
0.28297722339630127,
-0.07909384369850159,
-0.8900234699249268,
0.396119087934494,
0.37258535623550415,
0.49334579706192017,
0.1187896877527237,
-0.4310956597328186,
0.36479154229164124,
-0.9601757526397705,
1.0237501859664917,
0.03810455650091171,
-0.8876711130142212,
0.27808788418769836,
-0.5709283947944641,
0.5292271375656128,
-0.17976593971252441,
0.5756743550300598,
-1.1031845808029175,
-0.5607854723930359,
-0.7803680896759033,
-0.7866849303245544,
0.1756761223077774,
-0.19540557265281677,
0.21557298302650452,
0.11023066192865372,
0.6839395761489868,
0.16240060329437256,
0.3331403434276581,
-1.0298798084259033,
-0.3568936884403229,
-0.22555799782276154,
-0.002708864863961935,
-0.332210898399353,
0.027536330744624138,
-0.06237947940826416,
-0.19135816395282745,
0.7264949679374695,
-0.2619355320930481,
0.28336405754089355,
-0.04191316291689873,
-0.04718635231256485,
-0.1710992157459259,
0.5310779809951782,
0.8737661838531494,
0.5969763398170471,
0.12024696916341782,
0.22773653268814087,
-0.01222278643399477,
-0.3225954473018646,
0.09098420292139053,
-0.10010775923728943,
-0.37404993176460266,
0.4265900254249573,
0.33470258116722107,
0.9095447659492493,
0.5017277598381042,
-0.4488218426704407,
-0.30896249413490295,
0.2061799019575119,
-0.07805538922548294,
-0.24334843456745148,
-0.12953568994998932,
0.25869220495224,
0.417150616645813,
0.5262426137924194,
0.20069487392902374,
0.005519662518054247,
-0.8603131771087646,
-0.0831519216299057,
0.38873398303985596,
-0.39390459656715393,
-0.5401775240898132,
0.8429083824157715,
0.07800459861755371,
-0.37957364320755005,
-0.01546584814786911,
0.12925103306770325,
-0.24415427446365356,
0.14733174443244934,
0.6042894124984741,
0.9312000274658203,
-0.38044270873069763,
0.5452276468276978,
0.09586495161056519,
0.4169992506504059,
-0.5155172348022461,
0.12106397747993469,
0.13867461681365967,
-0.8329598903656006,
-0.45006075501441956,
-0.7830883264541626,
-0.1759088635444641,
0.2188488394021988,
-0.2805479168891907,
0.3155391812324524,
-0.2710331976413727,
-0.2045670598745346,
0.1656017005443573,
-0.5278323292732239,
-0.1892382949590683,
-0.10384013503789902,
0.4982398748397827,
0.7163998484611511,
-0.9058571457862854,
0.6357804536819458,
0.945790708065033,
-0.12010936439037323,
-0.2046477496623993,
-0.2589495778083801,
0.05200541019439697,
-0.4854015111923218,
1.095473051071167,
-0.4647466540336609,
-0.32134443521499634,
0.02525697462260723,
-0.9614097476005554,
-1.2594034671783447,
0.765090823173523,
0.26445916295051575,
-0.939245879650116,
-0.12779904901981354,
0.17309342324733734,
0.9836573600769043,
-0.5367121696472168,
0.016047324985265732,
0.5024469494819641,
0.5648124814033508,
-0.4432542026042938,
-0.9640212655067444,
0.07778769731521606,
-0.33763837814331055,
0.278338223695755,
0.4678245186805725,
-0.35165491700172424,
1.1267039775848389,
-0.08875716477632523,
-0.42341867089271545,
0.2675663232803345,
0.6908226609230042,
0.13466252386569977,
0.018171541392803192,
0.20264063775539398,
0.047145236283540726,
0.44188493490219116,
-0.3115835189819336,
0.9309333562850952,
-0.14570647478103638,
0.420402467250824,
0.7095900177955627,
-0.3691287934780121,
0.8732455968856812,
0.7591900825500488,
-0.33302274346351624,
1.0078035593032837,
0.29114001989364624,
-0.130350261926651,
0.16138173639774323,
0.5208100080490112,
-0.21724562346935272,
-0.024178186431527138,
0.15144465863704681,
-0.4884382486343384,
0.2524617314338684,
0.600248396396637,
-0.48132631182670593,
-0.18324130773544312,
0.014063578099012375,
0.39158353209495544,
0.08740194141864777,
-0.3381607234477997,
0.6346034407615662,
0.28060182929039,
-0.6374892592430115,
0.8315823674201965,
-0.001065513351932168,
0.6029950976371765,
-0.7141686081886292,
0.03538266196846962,
-0.1353023797273636,
-0.012164140120148659,
-0.054406359791755676,
-0.4369906485080719,
-0.00006498218863271177,
-0.2558005154132843,
-0.025426741689443588,
-0.30357348918914795,
0.24166561663150787,
-0.649685800075531,
-0.5316616296768188,
0.1758643388748169,
0.7139562368392944,
0.1912560611963272,
0.33940058946609497,
-0.7308739423751831,
0.22495633363723755,
-0.12086667865514755,
-0.15902407467365265,
0.1327570676803589,
0.21989230811595917,
-0.31255438923835754,
0.9405584335327148,
0.5737133622169495,
0.44447964429855347,
0.29105159640312195,
-0.1260836124420166,
0.3983771502971649,
-0.7822668552398682,
-0.38277748227119446,
-0.8727893233299255,
0.3687245845794678,
-0.05579626187682152,
-0.26092225313186646,
0.677761971950531,
0.24353928864002228,
0.45721474289894104,
-0.4481089413166046,
0.9258208870887756,
-0.11348804831504822,
0.3696034848690033,
-0.6622718572616577,
0.9470834136009216,
-0.6813331842422485,
0.5921168327331543,
-0.6772434115409851,
-0.9503870010375977,
-0.18787063658237457,
0.25901952385902405,
-0.042113956063985825,
-0.22269299626350403,
0.9445763230323792,
0.46464598178863525,
0.2272021621465683,
0.4379507303237915,
-0.01590672694146633,
0.5343108773231506,
0.3747817873954773,
0.17122843861579895,
1.1335852146148682,
-0.44445839524269104,
-0.011190720833837986,
0.37504103779792786,
0.04077906906604767,
-0.14322450757026672,
-1.0067191123962402,
-0.46218013763427734,
-0.9370439648628235,
-0.7583845853805542,
-0.08502313494682312,
0.35655421018600464,
0.6997931003570557,
0.41779986023902893,
-0.7255629301071167,
-0.5700264573097229,
-0.27964910864830017,
-0.22182391583919525,
-0.1772802621126175,
-0.19600847363471985,
0.3420793116092682,
-0.37013280391693115,
-0.7700139284133911,
0.6498377323150635,
0.3916091322898865,
0.3837435245513916,
-0.6212857961654663,
0.06125430762767792,
-0.3937382102012634,
0.48893043398857117,
0.7504090070724487,
0.7024934887886047,
-0.7576394081115723,
-0.489961177110672,
0.1955723911523819,
0.02148902788758278,
-0.22124217450618744,
0.931617796421051,
-0.7979285717010498,
0.26365193724632263,
0.17885155975818634,
0.3190540075302124,
0.43960508704185486,
-0.5109427571296692,
0.9837589859962463,
-0.38471561670303345,
0.09280244261026382,
0.10814071446657181,
0.5001769661903381,
0.272257000207901,
0.21277517080307007,
0.42058470845222473,
0.6369071006774902,
-0.4835231900215149,
-1.3986899852752686,
0.32216960191726685,
-0.7846158742904663,
-0.7108032703399658,
1.0255546569824219,
0.33462899923324585,
-0.2603702247142792,
-0.21080425381660461,
-0.034112777560949326,
0.07707734405994415,
-0.11425373703241348,
1.0296519994735718,
0.6547369360923767,
-0.17858628928661346,
-0.30820056796073914,
-0.6503586173057556,
0.7200226187705994,
0.47952717542648315,
-0.5859203934669495,
-0.13135963678359985,
0.33913618326187134,
0.5113898515701294,
0.6193956732749939,
0.24806536734104156,
-0.2875361442565918,
-0.10020657628774643,
-0.32060450315475464,
0.22027377784252167,
0.2734255790710449,
-0.2786032259464264,
-0.3399391770362854,
0.1018630787730217,
0.07062482833862305,
0.19075685739517212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01920v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01920v1 | To Forget or Not? Towards Practical Knowledge Unlearning for Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T03:34:16 | 2024-07-02T03:34:16 | Bozhong Tian, Xiaozhuan Liang, Siyuan Cheng, Qingbin Liu, Mengru Wang, Dianbo Sui, Xi Chen, Huajun Chen, Ningyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.MM | Large Language Models (LLMs) trained on extensive corpora inevitably retain
sensitive data, such as personal privacy information and copyrighted material.
Recent advancements in knowledge unlearning involve updating LLM parameters to
erase specific knowledge. However, current unlearning paradigms are mired in
vague forgetting boundaries, often erasing knowledge indiscriminately. In this
work, we introduce KnowUnDo, a benchmark containing copyrighted content and
user privacy domains to evaluate if the unlearning process inadvertently erases
essential knowledge. Our findings indicate that existing unlearning methods
often suffer from excessive unlearning. To address this, we propose a simple
yet effective method, MemFlex, which utilizes gradient information to precisely
target and unlearn sensitive parameters. Experimental results show that MemFlex
is superior to existing methods in both precise knowledge unlearning and
general knowledge retaining of LLMs. Code and dataset will be released at
https://github.com/zjunlp/KnowUnDo. | [
-0.27122658491134644,
-0.5113420486450195,
0.3416799008846283,
-0.032719455659389496,
-0.14030034840106964,
0.07974303513765335,
-0.3566441237926483,
-0.12473952025175095,
-0.36027467250823975,
0.6105113625526428,
-0.5734286308288574,
-0.48553040623664856,
-0.5045602917671204,
-0.30331090092658997,
-0.3223852515220642,
1.0387353897094727,
0.019507018849253654,
-0.09212524443864822,
-0.21860195696353912,
-0.37406817078590393,
-0.31663253903388977,
-0.36303651332855225,
-0.5475229620933533,
-0.5451455116271973,
0.5626195669174194,
0.5289559960365295,
0.3608720302581787,
0.42261049151420593,
-0.143931582570076,
0.27324098348617554,
-0.36012130975723267,
0.32792311906814575,
-0.8721446990966797,
-0.01203121431171894,
-0.5461556911468506,
-0.45113739371299744,
-0.18929076194763184,
-0.25188565254211426,
0.7115800976753235,
1.0701431035995483,
-0.4220481514930725,
0.15515615046024323,
0.1904977560043335,
0.859748899936676,
-1.0913846492767334,
-0.11585649847984314,
-0.7012088298797607,
0.18046855926513672,
0.06884647905826569,
-0.2116398960351944,
-0.3359273374080658,
-0.23732012510299683,
0.05703466758131981,
-0.6427792906761169,
0.21883267164230347,
0.17870549857616425,
0.5259065628051758,
0.24995389580726624,
-0.16992056369781494,
-0.3036611080169678,
-0.7738310098648071,
1.0745222568511963,
-0.7330008149147034,
0.5917481184005737,
0.49452799558639526,
0.24343430995941162,
-0.27030858397483826,
-0.5832422375679016,
-0.4397023320198059,
0.2382708340883255,
0.23204125463962555,
0.03667927905917168,
-0.3716757893562317,
-0.21275345981121063,
0.35868608951568604,
0.18106982111930847,
-0.4049023985862732,
0.1847529411315918,
-0.6435128450393677,
-0.3890529274940491,
0.34345531463623047,
-0.13396218419075012,
0.06799177825450897,
0.12060829252004623,
-0.6559187769889832,
-0.019099444150924683,
-1.1712778806686401,
-0.06653451919555664,
0.392654150724411,
-0.1480851173400879,
0.10594119131565094,
0.37114787101745605,
-0.07591036707162857,
0.5058606266975403,
-0.20202405750751495,
-0.15124370157718658,
0.4592278301715851,
0.213134765625,
-0.2218964397907257,
-0.10243000835180283,
0.7365670204162598,
0.17046096920967102,
0.6226260662078857,
-0.6618461608886719,
-0.3251437246799469,
-0.6810676455497742,
0.1814180314540863,
-0.5433201193809509,
0.003910240717232227,
0.3068045675754547,
-0.14050622284412384,
0.32678860425949097,
-0.12223459780216217,
-0.7037128210067749,
-0.377400666475296,
-0.4469311535358429,
0.3728313744068146,
-0.6830093860626221,
-0.3543059527873993,
0.08182651549577713,
-0.21949312090873718,
0.08937240391969681,
0.4689471125602722,
-0.802955687046051,
0.2828386127948761,
0.6462047100067139,
0.5262778401374817,
0.10210935771465302,
-0.616978108882904,
-0.5647269487380981,
0.33064594864845276,
-0.31412217020988464,
0.3174177408218384,
-0.49795782566070557,
-0.31907111406326294,
0.07447605580091476,
-0.1267329454421997,
0.008221848867833614,
-1.0071028470993042,
0.40351542830467224,
-0.7750179171562195,
0.15095968544483185,
-0.3447033166885376,
-1.01619291305542,
-0.41482484340667725,
0.17808912694454193,
-0.5185508728027344,
0.7193576693534851,
0.339223176240921,
-0.5831462740898132,
0.24637743830680847,
0.08558148145675659,
-0.2137288898229599,
-0.08977824449539185,
-0.160850390791893,
-0.5357208251953125,
0.06403730809688568,
-0.16734939813613892,
0.7516012191772461,
-0.24645458161830902,
0.653881847858429,
-0.55849689245224,
-0.3994973599910736,
0.35819941759109497,
-0.29828813672065735,
0.7500755190849304,
0.3561752438545227,
-0.30361923575401306,
-0.28607624769210815,
-0.8950284123420715,
-0.05944475904107094,
-0.00860267411917448,
-0.5134619474411011,
-0.5156305432319641,
-0.21829041838645935,
-0.2303977757692337,
0.22442567348480225,
0.28110748529434204,
-0.5993964076042175,
-0.2118101865053177,
-0.1512909233570099,
0.5128781199455261,
1.0310921669006348,
-0.024971557781100273,
0.6783897876739502,
-0.5174713730812073,
0.29194849729537964,
0.04831394925713539,
-0.0008114064112305641,
-0.10926607996225357,
-0.11304176598787308,
-0.7201652526855469,
-0.2784426510334015,
0.1690107136964798,
0.3535853624343872,
-0.5956299304962158,
0.40821850299835205,
-0.10526351630687714,
-0.3276955783367157,
-0.2599787414073944,
0.7793086767196655,
0.8018773794174194,
0.6676365733146667,
0.3577083945274353,
0.04368073493242264,
-0.2871764898300171,
-0.7228806614875793,
-0.5200851559638977,
0.18171943724155426,
-0.1909244805574417,
0.4074048399925232,
0.46723440289497375,
-0.16802598536014557,
0.7473796606063843,
-0.4381936490535736,
-0.5730796456336975,
-0.09398140758275986,
0.16886001825332642,
-0.09675628691911697,
0.4650600552558899,
0.35113993287086487,
-0.6175422072410583,
0.008993004448711872,
-0.13238433003425598,
-1.0266404151916504,
0.15330402553081512,
0.08497009426355362,
0.16145844757556915,
0.1896594762802124,
0.7560827136039734,
-0.3385266065597534,
0.05958586186170578,
0.3950205147266388,
-0.14128170907497406,
0.2914927899837494,
-0.670330822467804,
-0.05854134261608124,
-0.7883023619651794,
0.39600351452827454,
-0.3489990830421448,
-0.2901792824268341,
-0.6075729131698608,
-0.19894467294216156,
0.38741737604141235,
-0.030881699174642563,
-0.7503563165664673,
0.919078528881073,
-0.7019915580749512,
0.13632868230342865,
-0.1381721943616867,
0.11686846613883972,
0.014424742199480534,
0.823517382144928,
-0.04019559174776077,
0.6339625120162964,
0.34717950224876404,
-0.888229489326477,
-0.1723613142967224,
0.09786578267812729,
-0.30682405829429626,
0.2972269058227539,
-0.3655206859111786,
0.3869049847126007,
-0.2973337173461914,
-0.31143903732299805,
-0.8187381029129028,
0.13102945685386658,
0.03066260926425457,
-0.3728109300136566,
0.631064236164093,
-0.15379880368709564,
-0.6630449295043945,
-0.06638374924659729,
-0.438972532749176,
0.5298678278923035,
0.5884479284286499,
-0.6391952633857727,
0.43709495663642883,
0.5766482353210449,
0.021168550476431847,
-1.0084095001220703,
-0.45728278160095215,
-0.16021431982517242,
-0.33805230259895325,
-0.29138997197151184,
0.00856997910887003,
-0.10264620929956436,
-0.062949039041996,
-0.08070853352546692,
-0.14149832725524902,
-0.22800514101982117,
0.10607462376356125,
0.25729092955589294,
-0.16657601296901703,
0.145525723695755,
0.4661840796470642,
0.06947272270917892,
-0.17058025300502777,
0.00883480254560709,
-0.40611231327056885,
0.5206812024116516,
-0.004852020647376776,
-0.2827926278114319,
0.015164474956691265,
0.08617459237575531,
0.39033767580986023,
-0.1422249972820282,
0.7342687249183655,
0.42453569173812866,
-0.6071828603744507,
-0.8043228387832642,
-0.7951712608337402,
-0.07674475014209747,
-0.48320236802101135,
0.3026581108570099,
-0.10171632468700409,
-1.137339472770691,
0.7182959914207458,
-0.6070050597190857,
0.07719997316598892,
0.09571640938520432,
0.24545252323150635,
-0.11302497237920761,
0.3467421233654022,
0.8044988512992859,
-0.21028481423854828,
0.24988088011741638,
-0.39475294947624207,
0.21103504300117493,
-0.9072809219360352,
-0.39801597595214844,
-0.37515485286712646,
-0.2055106908082962,
-0.16015054285526276,
-0.44729459285736084,
0.14502055943012238,
0.38045260310173035,
-0.46715685725212097,
0.16577288508415222,
-0.07075732946395874,
0.5292744636535645,
0.6643399000167847,
0.18048113584518433,
0.48528096079826355,
0.05508283153176308,
-0.11414159089326859,
-0.02577713131904602,
-0.7439613342285156,
-0.3747139871120453,
1.4871963262557983,
0.12772400677204132,
0.8083813190460205,
0.07393795251846313,
0.6518692970275879,
0.4026986062526703,
0.22461074590682983,
-0.39514485001564026,
0.3544257581233978,
-0.13945117592811584,
-0.5723056197166443,
-0.45956918597221375,
-0.7554749250411987,
-1.001624584197998,
0.029335975646972656,
-0.041359733790159225,
-0.7140551805496216,
0.23000210523605347,
0.35179898142814636,
-0.2709294557571411,
0.7660533785820007,
-0.5644294619560242,
0.6588532328605652,
-0.03652211278676987,
-0.7049785852432251,
-0.19663946330547333,
-0.3875603675842285,
0.32247447967529297,
-0.5662861466407776,
0.544884979724884,
-0.2884671092033386,
-0.212554469704628,
0.9779937267303467,
-0.4411352872848511,
0.9739758968353271,
-0.23651397228240967,
-0.11625464260578156,
0.3353055715560913,
0.15162989497184753,
0.38394439220428467,
-0.043219320476055145,
-0.225274458527565,
0.32139673829078674,
-0.21086597442626953,
-0.39239856600761414,
-0.4705715477466583,
0.7768511176109314,
-0.6717045307159424,
-0.3132585883140564,
-0.1265202909708023,
-0.3823493719100952,
-0.3679719865322113,
0.43897393345832825,
0.36705154180526733,
0.19458848237991333,
-0.3530443608760834,
0.030505485832691193,
1.1472922563552856,
-0.38517338037490845,
0.5108248591423035,
0.9053869843482971,
0.10150393843650818,
-0.45821577310562134,
1.2699894905090332,
0.33935225009918213,
0.1489904373884201,
0.6106765270233154,
0.1311648041009903,
-0.25853458046913147,
-0.5163925290107727,
-0.3102092742919922,
0.6597675681114197,
-0.8690847754478455,
-0.33825021982192993,
-0.565995454788208,
-0.049618370831012726,
-0.08306369185447693,
-0.14578333497047424,
-0.6461698412895203,
-0.27057453989982605,
-0.3530171811580658,
-0.004219408147037029,
0.21888969838619232,
0.6893719434738159,
-0.18048319220542908,
0.208955779671669,
-0.7749094367027283,
0.14508379995822906,
0.14768099784851074,
0.6400100588798523,
0.32967790961265564,
-0.7252046465873718,
-0.09603019803762436,
0.08168483525514603,
-0.2586786448955536,
-0.27706223726272583,
0.34521496295928955,
0.2822149693965912,
0.8407642245292664,
0.6959433555603027,
0.2605278789997101,
0.2629624605178833,
-0.5105233192443848,
0.18677064776420593,
0.5014705657958984,
-0.9672812819480896,
0.3690471053123474,
-0.3426281213760376,
0.3161403238773346,
0.5723201036453247,
0.49512237310409546,
-0.5544118285179138,
-0.38402870297431946,
-0.8595684766769409,
-0.9282709360122681,
0.5615714192390442,
-0.25298985838890076,
0.21676358580589294,
0.2126287817955017,
0.6020047068595886,
0.4682505428791046,
0.6441311240196228,
-0.3627552390098572,
-0.33136188983917236,
0.18252849578857422,
-0.10205435007810593,
-0.29002970457077026,
-0.5019777417182922,
-0.12493245303630829,
0.03611917421221733,
0.5737359523773193,
0.12002119421958923,
-0.08954256772994995,
-0.05148360878229141,
-0.4920525848865509,
-0.11338218301534653,
0.4168989360332489,
0.49028098583221436,
1.1352218389511108,
-0.27849259972572327,
0.26496919989585876,
0.26522377133369446,
-0.45592358708381653,
0.14291024208068848,
-0.22509245574474335,
-0.4086935222148895,
-0.29289841651916504,
0.4543079435825348,
0.2884911000728607,
0.5415374636650085,
-1.1820012331008911,
0.6600886583328247,
0.13765186071395874,
-0.4832564890384674,
-0.5546421408653259,
0.3029712736606598,
0.273700088262558,
0.11443372815847397,
0.15732626616954803,
0.1255481243133545,
0.11865448206663132,
-0.5368798971176147,
0.4376775324344635,
0.2916964888572693,
-0.6015381217002869,
-0.33158648014068604,
0.7328609228134155,
-0.04285319149494171,
0.03410173952579498,
0.6568729281425476,
-0.03223622590303421,
-0.33438876271247864,
0.32183557748794556,
0.3610740900039673,
0.5642125606536865,
-0.456156462430954,
0.0371306873857975,
0.3085108995437622,
0.20789465308189392,
-0.2477015107870102,
0.13081862032413483,
-0.12136147916316986,
-0.7170936465263367,
-0.10504306852817535,
-0.4075106382369995,
-0.33176684379577637,
0.5251332521438599,
-0.5651630163192749,
0.1001020148396492,
-1.0082865953445435,
0.19560670852661133,
-0.05023837462067604,
-0.08680865168571472,
-0.7308200001716614,
0.24013027548789978,
0.02025926299393177,
0.8269026875495911,
-0.7828319668769836,
0.6679361462593079,
0.4273804724216461,
-0.31506621837615967,
-0.8217916488647461,
-0.31306785345077515,
0.12256243824958801,
-1.0368931293487549,
0.3403889536857605,
0.003829715307801962,
-0.23585696518421173,
-0.1128484383225441,
-0.541301429271698,
-0.6393705606460571,
0.9863957166671753,
0.6677057147026062,
-0.7653087377548218,
0.4444977641105652,
0.18191014230251312,
0.3372233211994171,
-0.0767742320895195,
0.05322724208235741,
0.43087249994277954,
0.24714259803295135,
0.2102409452199936,
-0.5640476942062378,
0.07552804052829742,
-0.1777271181344986,
-0.40150195360183716,
0.20913206040859222,
-0.7558457255363464,
0.9577995538711548,
-0.5153495073318481,
-0.10940085351467133,
-0.15365059673786163,
0.3196944296360016,
-0.023666774854063988,
0.46952736377716064,
0.34855660796165466,
0.7272052764892578,
1.3276249170303345,
0.1640872359275818,
0.6783301830291748,
-0.05496341735124588,
0.3125937879085541,
1.3185393810272217,
-0.15994472801685333,
0.7664465308189392,
0.41191816329956055,
-0.00701384199783206,
-0.19856655597686768,
0.28365644812583923,
0.09499038755893707,
0.5295996069908142,
0.4849996864795685,
-0.3308163583278656,
-0.25339436531066895,
0.1514381468296051,
-0.29617995023727417,
0.24757714569568634,
0.2629956305027008,
-0.25997281074523926,
-0.4156091809272766,
0.07786636054515839,
0.6738296151161194,
0.2761300504207611,
-0.3476085066795349,
1.0096956491470337,
0.311678409576416,
-0.6309978365898132,
1.026686429977417,
-0.02929142862558365,
0.391135573387146,
-0.7222592234611511,
0.01432062964886427,
-0.5340248346328735,
0.7912386059761047,
-0.18258988857269287,
-0.6777629256248474,
0.08447277545928955,
-0.10114151239395142,
-0.2780637741088867,
-0.15980127453804016,
0.3897969722747803,
-0.5912651419639587,
-0.23159396648406982,
0.8672451376914978,
0.6301312446594238,
0.2312672734260559,
-0.25672465562820435,
-0.5844844579696655,
-0.18318034708499908,
0.22488252818584442,
-0.1060996949672699,
0.6493892669677734,
0.6070882678031921,
-0.06266313791275024,
1.1745412349700928,
0.5357893705368042,
0.016831547021865845,
0.08360039442777634,
0.2830398678779602,
1.01143479347229,
-0.6190149188041687,
-0.02265041507780552,
-0.676948606967926,
0.19730302691459656,
-0.03193524479866028,
-0.40839090943336487,
0.7513749003410339,
0.7591043710708618,
1.0183740854263306,
0.013011462055146694,
0.8688497543334961,
0.4756671190261841,
0.8050439953804016,
-0.6579936742782593,
0.9086291193962097,
-0.8253008127212524,
0.6517609357833862,
-0.1457817703485489,
-0.9411253333091736,
-0.3390016555786133,
0.1576668918132782,
-0.2629191279411316,
0.17938165366649628,
0.5226058959960938,
0.6964088082313538,
-0.25156739354133606,
0.04006466269493103,
0.6554874777793884,
0.21259242296218872,
0.1357690542936325,
0.7622970938682556,
0.7818422317504883,
-0.29310473799705505,
0.5691149830818176,
-0.3403669595718384,
-0.4025479555130005,
-0.04799073934555054,
-0.7975016236305237,
-1.0757637023925781,
-0.46073275804519653,
-0.23396238684654236,
-0.2284093052148819,
0.39629021286964417,
0.49522650241851807,
0.48219984769821167,
-0.9330712556838989,
-0.2457243949174881,
0.037130795419216156,
0.37229588627815247,
-0.07955526560544968,
-0.04913203418254852,
0.4764545261859894,
-0.4041591286659241,
-0.5050163865089417,
0.09937405586242676,
0.22360427677631378,
0.05556605011224747,
-0.024963174015283585,
-0.28459301590919495,
-0.22308145463466644,
-0.14389093220233917,
0.2741733193397522,
0.6851155161857605,
-0.3784794509410858,
0.02261575311422348,
-0.08745323866605759,
0.2388899028301239,
-0.009817315265536308,
0.916751503944397,
-0.6949002742767334,
0.40054255723953247,
0.25947609543800354,
0.5360614061355591,
0.46763354539871216,
-0.1010989397764206,
0.648017406463623,
-0.9465991854667664,
0.19177410006523132,
0.07562509924173355,
0.5585592985153198,
0.5666188597679138,
-0.32310187816619873,
0.3349355459213257,
0.0719832256436348,
-0.4083014726638794,
-0.6118106245994568,
-0.1661776602268219,
-0.6573547720909119,
-0.7123993039131165,
1.1180025339126587,
-0.5298277735710144,
-0.364991694688797,
-0.31697767972946167,
0.1847444623708725,
0.06249706447124481,
-0.5100241899490356,
0.7204050421714783,
0.38903090357780457,
0.46913668513298035,
-0.23313723504543304,
-0.636621356010437,
0.48153164982795715,
0.41221755743026733,
-0.34575238823890686,
0.5325313806533813,
0.34842702746391296,
0.7509983777999878,
-0.05099543556571007,
0.7189193964004517,
-0.19157187640666962,
0.1993297040462494,
-0.11310344934463501,
0.15497957170009613,
-0.3097895383834839,
-0.4236418604850769,
-0.34757480025291443,
0.231174036860466,
0.05150677636265755,
0.0550522580742836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01911v1 | Investigating the Effects of Large-Scale Pseudo-Stereo Data and Different Speech Foundation Model on Dialogue Generative Spoken Language Model | 2024-07-02T03:22:41 | 2024-07-02T03:22:41 | Yu-Kuan Fu, Cheng-Kuang Lee, Hsiu-Hsuan Wang, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent efforts in Spoken Dialogue Modeling aim to synthesize spoken dialogue
without the need for direct transcription, thereby preserving the wealth of
non-textual information inherent in speech. However, this approach faces a
challenge when speakers talk simultaneously, requiring stereo dialogue data
with speakers recorded on separate channels, a notably scarce resource. To
address this, we have developed an innovative pipeline capable of transforming
single-channel dialogue data into pseudo-stereo data. This expanded our
training dataset from a mere 2,000 to an impressive 17,600 hours, significantly
enriching the diversity and quality of the training examples available. The
inclusion of this pseudo-stereo data has proven to be effective in improving
the performance of spoken dialogue language models. Additionally, we explored
the use of discrete units of different speech foundation models for spoken
dialogue generation. | [
-0.6563704609870911,
-0.7362640500068665,
0.29311564564704895,
-0.007545697037130594,
-0.41536614298820496,
-0.09547338634729385,
-0.04837183654308319,
-0.41611626744270325,
0.25876355171203613,
0.6379773616790771,
-0.598091721534729,
-0.37042421102523804,
-0.26636940240859985,
0.1336163729429245,
-0.5435286164283752,
0.778944194316864,
0.5279791355133057,
0.46188420057296753,
-0.1442907750606537,
-0.05475897341966629,
-0.35423845052719116,
-0.5283364057540894,
-0.5829305648803711,
0.12012887746095657,
-0.07695937156677246,
0.3822409510612488,
0.5034509897232056,
0.10710448026657104,
0.11040380597114563,
0.34079599380493164,
0.07858055830001831,
-0.11578455567359924,
-0.9091976284980774,
-0.05301785469055176,
0.09605441242456436,
-0.36718231439590454,
-0.415600061416626,
0.10109715908765793,
1.0731562376022339,
0.8894938230514526,
-0.42784640192985535,
-0.23156435787677765,
-0.2642577886581421,
0.5162011384963989,
-0.21879927814006805,
0.20720317959785461,
-0.5026270151138306,
0.045284517109394073,
-0.22219498455524445,
0.006877427455037832,
-0.3423349857330322,
-0.38910743594169617,
0.6962065100669861,
-0.4444293677806854,
0.4742598533630371,
-0.05031237751245499,
0.30748629570007324,
0.15962184965610504,
-0.16337843239307404,
-0.1399410516023636,
-1.0235035419464111,
0.5435146689414978,
-0.8908221125602722,
0.5503773093223572,
0.23891986906528473,
0.4014464318752289,
-0.10541976243257523,
-0.9850536584854126,
-0.6688807010650635,
-0.1702813357114792,
0.09242260456085205,
0.19374875724315643,
-0.11331292986869812,
0.3106970489025116,
0.31414535641670227,
0.5198178887367249,
-0.4769037067890167,
-0.30252283811569214,
-0.46278515458106995,
-0.3670172393321991,
0.6418707370758057,
0.1513843983411789,
0.23208212852478027,
-0.16389286518096924,
-0.15246175229549408,
-0.3844103515148163,
-0.7683205008506775,
-0.11706888675689697,
0.3336421847343445,
0.4210520088672638,
-0.34446293115615845,
0.636910080909729,
-0.3569306433200836,
0.9451223611831665,
-0.08571035414934158,
-0.22166404128074646,
0.31810176372528076,
-0.7393311858177185,
-0.23511379957199097,
0.46792468428611755,
0.9428504705429077,
0.2699836790561676,
0.15332132577896118,
0.008503174409270287,
-0.03536742553114891,
-0.07514940202236176,
0.13242173194885254,
-0.9700120091438293,
-0.4493003785610199,
-0.09143473207950592,
-0.2561967372894287,
-0.053965531289577484,
0.09041675180196762,
-0.8976675271987915,
-0.11923260241746902,
-0.4361910820007324,
0.12874546647071838,
-0.3775669038295746,
-0.4776347875595093,
0.15001770853996277,
-0.1586536020040512,
0.0907910168170929,
0.15260760486125946,
-0.7387259602546692,
0.0944850742816925,
0.2570309042930603,
0.9163931012153625,
0.22625266015529633,
0.1877543330192566,
-0.5270220637321472,
-0.1105375736951828,
-0.5553841590881348,
0.3346969485282898,
-0.590971052646637,
-0.8370681405067444,
-0.22447529435157776,
-0.17457230389118195,
-0.09021562337875366,
-0.5346224904060364,
0.1654474288225174,
-0.2902272045612335,
0.5251950025558472,
-0.12803272902965546,
-0.3152356743812561,
0.10321127623319626,
-0.10465966910123825,
-0.7081299424171448,
0.7389320135116577,
0.5325733423233032,
-0.8162627816200256,
0.10835414379835129,
-0.5000045299530029,
-0.36966824531555176,
0.09214617311954498,
-0.37195587158203125,
-0.39514070749282837,
0.2288375347852707,
0.1366022825241089,
0.08802378922700882,
-0.5340993404388428,
0.2930450141429901,
-0.34607815742492676,
-0.16491346061229706,
0.22531801462173462,
-0.4874208867549896,
0.808721125125885,
0.09761212766170502,
-0.3389682173728943,
-0.09629437327384949,
-0.9970866441726685,
-0.18704135715961456,
-0.09779854863882065,
0.041567638516426086,
-0.25365307927131653,
-0.22013068199157715,
-0.10404619574546814,
0.5307096242904663,
-0.16244733333587646,
-0.768164336681366,
0.0030832316260784864,
-0.8022973537445068,
0.48414158821105957,
0.49383872747421265,
0.0647057518362999,
0.5043046474456787,
-0.08991767466068268,
0.5692766308784485,
-0.013888255693018436,
-0.18225876986980438,
-0.004722104407846928,
-0.7000461220741272,
-0.6464680433273315,
-0.5337438583374023,
0.43961668014526367,
0.33398303389549255,
-0.7380265593528748,
0.18272538483142853,
-0.30187371373176575,
-0.3836230933666229,
-0.7475762963294983,
-0.07202359288930893,
0.3975197672843933,
0.8291537165641785,
0.20622387528419495,
-0.8323047757148743,
-0.7098437547683716,
-0.8503378033638,
0.5105080008506775,
-0.5254042744636536,
-0.12443522363901138,
0.4756107032299042,
0.1426214724779129,
-0.2944590449333191,
1.4689300060272217,
-0.23836416006088257,
0.06827211380004883,
-0.3923247158527374,
0.38413628935813904,
-0.008071815595030785,
0.26964765787124634,
0.6643664836883545,
-0.8042517900466919,
-0.33527716994285583,
-0.20984408259391785,
-0.7289419174194336,
-0.2524224817752838,
-0.11645682901144028,
-0.1569768786430359,
-0.09869330376386642,
0.5504908561706543,
-0.6349499225616455,
0.4037737548351288,
0.7458541989326477,
0.09704341739416122,
0.6049273610115051,
0.09302733093500137,
0.10808118432760239,
-1.020816445350647,
-0.20358283817768097,
-0.18765047192573547,
-0.24309289455413818,
-0.8975200057029724,
-0.5382252931594849,
-0.2115817368030548,
-0.5351676940917969,
-0.519736647605896,
0.16885316371917725,
-0.2998025119304657,
-0.3760424554347992,
-0.26599377393722534,
0.0201579537242651,
-0.26177123188972473,
0.18912920355796814,
0.6477073431015015,
0.9713273644447327,
0.7214885950088501,
-0.41989666223526,
0.5882636904716492,
0.44539839029312134,
-0.6855810880661011,
0.21693851053714752,
-0.7385995388031006,
0.25728991627693176,
-0.20270097255706787,
0.7323499917984009,
-1.2901135683059692,
-0.19452203810214996,
0.1334819495677948,
-0.26688477396965027,
0.2601203918457031,
-0.11631006747484207,
-0.23460270464420319,
-0.18771794438362122,
0.09032319486141205,
0.5257748365402222,
0.49625200033187866,
-0.3842271566390991,
0.5344802737236023,
0.40765050053596497,
-0.6467305421829224,
-0.1754501312971115,
-0.39004239439964294,
0.10858099162578583,
-0.348907470703125,
-0.9520218968391418,
0.32366788387298584,
-0.18656529486179352,
-0.34257450699806213,
-0.1497572660446167,
0.003509997623041272,
0.21878349781036377,
-0.2868702709674835,
0.22252385318279266,
0.21775133907794952,
-0.42624711990356445,
-0.05751797929406166,
0.06425696611404419,
-0.07997668534517288,
0.15601330995559692,
-0.25146281719207764,
0.7614429593086243,
0.02026679739356041,
-0.20532138645648956,
-0.6790522933006287,
0.4069875180721283,
0.7947077751159668,
-0.1062886044383049,
1.0731241703033447,
0.10193159431219101,
0.019158465787768364,
-0.2629472315311432,
-0.3232853412628174,
-0.32072970271110535,
-0.3913959860801697,
0.313790887594223,
-0.4797387719154358,
-0.8261035084724426,
0.22304309904575348,
-0.31789854168891907,
-0.09054332971572876,
0.1890992373228073,
0.5525327324867249,
-0.17163754999637604,
0.8875973224639893,
0.47747206687927246,
-0.2203560471534729,
0.5304566025733948,
-0.3879251182079315,
0.4327687621116638,
-0.630866289138794,
-0.2569674253463745,
-0.28540855646133423,
0.16323691606521606,
-0.42931345105171204,
-0.6123760342597961,
0.4488242268562317,
0.11428353935480118,
0.21215902268886566,
0.41588422656059265,
-0.11253621429204941,
0.010583577677607536,
0.4473719000816345,
-0.002801779191941023,
0.05599675700068474,
0.06168613210320473,
-0.1449810266494751,
-0.05359009653329849,
-0.8705331087112427,
-0.12447737902402878,
1.239458441734314,
0.2663212716579437,
0.5169081091880798,
0.07540332525968552,
0.5282572507858276,
0.24961642920970917,
-0.0875534638762474,
-0.4271833002567291,
0.5295869708061218,
0.06359922140836716,
-0.5737281441688538,
-0.49707359075546265,
-0.6636112332344055,
-0.47408878803253174,
0.22663253545761108,
-0.03601374477148056,
-0.34668809175491333,
0.4952954351902008,
0.1559934914112091,
-0.28555431962013245,
-0.08755034953355789,
-0.8411381244659424,
0.6596629619598389,
-0.18803581595420837,
-0.1233513280749321,
-0.21550773084163666,
-0.8423970937728882,
0.44357025623321533,
-0.4667436182498932,
0.3764996826648712,
0.29257819056510925,
0.6951630115509033,
0.7270271182060242,
-0.7253000140190125,
0.8148211240768433,
-0.19121965765953064,
-0.1245662048459053,
0.5227457284927368,
-0.22258415818214417,
0.4989343285560608,
0.12123960256576538,
-0.06467091292142868,
0.3615553379058838,
-0.30635708570480347,
-0.3410559296607971,
-0.4163658022880554,
0.5196093320846558,
-0.8745385408401489,
-0.5227754712104797,
-0.26087430119514465,
-0.564854621887207,
-0.717637836933136,
-0.22596310079097748,
0.46514084935188293,
0.641273558139801,
-0.6365719437599182,
0.416595458984375,
0.7850321531295776,
-0.27341127395629883,
0.3445557653903961,
0.4977686405181885,
0.05922354757785797,
-0.417400985956192,
0.6643598079681396,
-0.04152800142765045,
0.8690221309661865,
0.13867095112800598,
-0.011563913896679878,
-0.5493561625480652,
-0.5961621999740601,
-0.5887544751167297,
0.37007570266723633,
-0.35820862650871277,
0.17990508675575256,
-0.6740961670875549,
-0.4309009909629822,
-0.8557068705558777,
0.17346903681755066,
-0.626295804977417,
-0.6754887700080872,
-0.13828757405281067,
-0.3306660056114197,
0.13676001131534576,
0.46783092617988586,
-0.2679307758808136,
0.5406093001365662,
-0.715232789516449,
0.5083486437797546,
0.4892811179161072,
0.07812625169754028,
-0.18546609580516815,
-0.6407692432403564,
-0.1845281720161438,
0.4671679735183716,
0.2334662824869156,
-0.835114598274231,
0.5057833790779114,
0.20009204745292664,
0.48697662353515625,
0.6015572547912598,
0.007354425732046366,
0.6841009855270386,
-0.5156265497207642,
0.980078935623169,
0.6027804017066956,
-0.7775974273681641,
0.5427064299583435,
-0.40299564599990845,
0.3349859416484833,
0.4436805546283722,
0.3206900656223297,
-0.3791239261627197,
-0.22471222281455994,
-0.5427653789520264,
-0.7113006711006165,
1.168026089668274,
0.6163082122802734,
0.08771997690200806,
0.07479870319366455,
-0.24098198115825653,
0.0588163323700428,
0.3103368580341339,
-0.38665860891342163,
-0.1677061766386032,
-0.813702404499054,
0.13486482203006744,
-0.4287644922733307,
-0.28784874081611633,
-0.3059850335121155,
-0.36418086290359497,
0.7294415235519409,
0.26055020093917847,
0.31317558884620667,
0.1204482689499855,
-0.029715945944190025,
0.03094400279223919,
0.28201448917388916,
0.5372163653373718,
0.4658423960208893,
-0.3736441433429718,
-0.12161412835121155,
-0.06870229542255402,
-0.3133373260498047,
0.09721004962921143,
0.30956050753593445,
0.017774369567632675,
0.3416018486022949,
0.3652069866657257,
1.1092329025268555,
0.10790495574474335,
-0.6738852262496948,
0.3087044060230255,
-0.16144689917564392,
-0.22094598412513733,
-0.2898603081703186,
-0.07871785759925842,
0.2568894326686859,
-0.05115737393498421,
0.05010010674595833,
-0.14175787568092346,
0.15806639194488525,
-0.8607134222984314,
0.37915676832199097,
0.38968223333358765,
-0.2839759886264801,
-0.21400251984596252,
0.2678484320640564,
0.49204665422439575,
-0.15851105749607086,
1.0617249011993408,
0.025944175198674202,
-0.3943588435649872,
0.3915666937828064,
0.6871466636657715,
0.6050450801849365,
-0.6631340980529785,
0.4206971824169159,
0.43764880299568176,
-0.005319862626492977,
-0.17000006139278412,
-0.2845720946788788,
-0.3685194253921509,
-0.8015152215957642,
-0.17948724329471588,
-0.7309734225273132,
-0.1545015424489975,
0.2861863076686859,
-0.6172633171081543,
0.1168084666132927,
-0.2897896468639374,
-0.088555708527565,
-0.03532750904560089,
-0.46379354596138,
-0.26378634572029114,
0.4501088559627533,
0.39088350534439087,
0.5760902762413025,
-1.1449421644210815,
1.008406639099121,
0.2832351326942444,
-0.33027347922325134,
-0.6830694675445557,
-0.07488446682691574,
0.15236268937587738,
-0.4378322958946228,
0.4632698595523834,
-0.1053595319390297,
-0.5166091322898865,
0.040014028549194336,
-0.3008478283882141,
-0.7643176317214966,
0.7057831883430481,
0.26071229577064514,
-1.2883187532424927,
-0.27329587936401367,
0.774695634841919,
0.6649574637413025,
-0.6186249256134033,
0.22915279865264893,
0.8477646112442017,
0.02410159632563591,
0.6049025654792786,
-1.044450044631958,
-0.5248745083808899,
-0.290138304233551,
0.16052892804145813,
0.20948922634124756,
-0.39337292313575745,
0.6536093950271606,
0.2812606394290924,
-0.18149295449256897,
0.14191509783267975,
0.5738776326179504,
0.3068997859954834,
0.2426203191280365,
0.6547325253486633,
0.7318555116653442,
0.5343230366706848,
-0.1174001544713974,
0.9828873872756958,
-0.13657280802726746,
0.037268463522195816,
1.284274697303772,
-0.3544250726699829,
0.3990711569786072,
0.23263880610466003,
-0.1079220175743103,
0.5046364068984985,
0.4776359498500824,
0.3656660318374634,
0.9469343423843384,
0.1782948225736618,
-0.6626213192939758,
-0.4318009912967682,
-0.08585387468338013,
-0.6784054040908813,
0.5746037364006042,
0.5944409966468811,
-0.4532589018344879,
-0.09382680058479309,
0.27606263756752014,
-0.46176040172576904,
-0.10540204495191574,
-0.08659064769744873,
0.922157883644104,
0.1637634038925171,
-0.5095820426940918,
0.5655325651168823,
-0.18709827959537506,
0.2972458302974701,
-0.7243344783782959,
-0.04080307483673096,
-0.2791931927204132,
-0.0935950055718422,
-0.0006262953393161297,
-0.2841540277004242,
0.16861362755298615,
0.09900504350662231,
-0.08760089427232742,
-0.3318191170692444,
0.3664344251155853,
-0.56904137134552,
-0.5031359791755676,
0.31809958815574646,
0.24950572848320007,
0.31255435943603516,
0.07872210443019867,
-0.5395563244819641,
0.057556428015232086,
0.3663567006587982,
-0.023947734385728836,
0.32350122928619385,
0.4298606812953949,
-0.05330067500472069,
0.19751155376434326,
0.6749555468559265,
0.18580831587314606,
0.24284635484218597,
0.41300132870674133,
0.907560408115387,
-0.42698514461517334,
-0.5086543560028076,
-0.3671121895313263,
0.6928849816322327,
-0.17964577674865723,
-0.1641019880771637,
0.61276775598526,
0.822450578212738,
0.8478612303733826,
-0.08718457072973251,
1.0019218921661377,
-0.17876377701759338,
0.6155164241790771,
-0.4775819480419159,
0.4231216609477997,
-0.20882371068000793,
0.2888876795768738,
-0.5330448150634766,
-1.1417841911315918,
0.182676300406456,
0.7078120708465576,
-0.4169081747531891,
0.0164239052683115,
0.5540581941604614,
1.0086928606033325,
-0.16945673525333405,
0.3983636200428009,
0.35610952973365784,
0.3113018274307251,
0.28721120953559875,
0.34800609946250916,
0.9307401776313782,
-0.16419145464897156,
0.3984706997871399,
-0.3335959017276764,
-0.24877917766571045,
-0.08702639490365982,
-0.33798155188560486,
-0.8984824419021606,
-0.7316792607307434,
-0.3046276867389679,
-0.31916677951812744,
0.07399367541074753,
0.5888883471488953,
0.9980544447898865,
-0.8827855587005615,
-0.29445549845695496,
-0.5266262888908386,
-0.5871145725250244,
0.2634254992008209,
-0.2079470455646515,
0.11892330646514893,
0.2178531438112259,
-0.8441765308380127,
0.9086902737617493,
0.19087670743465424,
0.16168811917304993,
-0.08418703824281693,
-0.21042783558368683,
-0.138666570186615,
0.1904952973127365,
0.5812352895736694,
0.3573002219200134,
-0.4959847331047058,
-0.052332598716020584,
-0.16021083295345306,
0.03283632919192314,
0.056672416627407074,
1.0089205503463745,
-0.8490918278694153,
0.9892705678939819,
0.5363293290138245,
0.3662136197090149,
1.0041431188583374,
0.2788369357585907,
1.1439114809036255,
-0.7688644528388977,
0.4434797465801239,
0.33664414286613464,
0.24463997781276703,
0.5023573040962219,
-0.006918473169207573,
0.2936457693576813,
0.32161056995391846,
-0.1521104872226715,
-0.8063982129096985,
0.30609673261642456,
-0.9752235412597656,
-0.26947277784347534,
0.9251720309257507,
-0.05558609217405319,
0.39619868993759155,
-0.1418977677822113,
-0.26899781823158264,
0.46061962842941284,
-0.3993407189846039,
0.7286509871482849,
0.8038061857223511,
-0.30033236742019653,
-0.3486535847187042,
-0.25908592343330383,
0.6973724365234375,
0.3862625062465668,
-0.7486499547958374,
-0.054251108318567276,
0.8946459889411926,
0.2175396829843521,
0.23565462231636047,
0.7652345299720764,
-0.23877765238285065,
0.23096808791160583,
0.20026275515556335,
-0.3380539119243622,
0.2305688112974167,
-0.552833616733551,
-0.33200186491012573,
0.1953977644443512,
-0.2905840575695038,
-0.17809303104877472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01909v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01909v1 | Pinyin Regularization in Error Correction for Chinese Speech Recognition with Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T03:16:47 | 2024-07-02T03:16:47 | Zhiyuan Tang, Dong Wang, Shen Huang, Shidong Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Recent studies have demonstrated the efficacy of large language models (LLMs)
in error correction for automatic speech recognition (ASR). However, much of
the research focuses on the English language. This paper redirects the
attention to Chinese. Firstly, we construct a specialized benchmark dataset
aimed at error correction for Chinese ASR with 724K hypotheses-transcription
pairs, named the Chinese Hypotheses Paradise dataset (ChineseHP), which
contains a wide range of scenarios and presents significant challenges.
Subsequently, we conduct a preliminary evaluation using the dataset for both
direct-prompting and fine-tuning pre-trained LLMs. Furthermore, we propose a
straightforward method of Pinyin regularization for prompts, which involves the
transcription of Pinyin directly from text hypotheses. The experimental results
reveal that Pinyin regularization consistently enhances the error-correcting
ability of LLMs when compared with those without regularization. The dataset is
available on the website. | [
0.3196429908275604,
-0.5273849368095398,
0.27635422348976135,
0.3339489698410034,
-0.3498096168041229,
-0.13130687177181244,
-0.6708921790122986,
-0.19903384149074554,
0.1001177430152893,
0.34270530939102173,
-0.27898937463760376,
-0.5431739687919617,
-0.3051818907260895,
0.4607347249984741,
-0.15165214240550995,
0.4264715015888214,
-0.24395130574703217,
0.5436026453971863,
0.2982524335384369,
0.02839333936572075,
-0.7150859832763672,
-0.4423949420452118,
-0.9277629852294922,
-0.10877881199121475,
0.8559672832489014,
0.5315709710121155,
0.4289478659629822,
0.8974047303199768,
0.6352358460426331,
0.17039433121681213,
0.019620997831225395,
0.27182191610336304,
-0.3460440933704376,
-0.06507416069507599,
0.543788492679596,
-0.23995639383792877,
-0.33969563245773315,
-0.23157311975955963,
1.2076694965362549,
0.7642782926559448,
-0.21964231133460999,
-0.08217956870794296,
0.24209530651569366,
0.516444742679596,
-0.3925340473651886,
0.19972825050354004,
-0.7128346562385559,
0.09604059159755707,
-0.3043348789215088,
-0.33542901277542114,
-0.4831933081150055,
-0.32152754068374634,
-0.07567604631185532,
-0.525168776512146,
0.24622905254364014,
0.1404881477355957,
0.7347630858421326,
0.47306326031684875,
-0.21806199848651886,
0.06266195327043533,
-0.838054895401001,
0.8177111148834229,
-0.9576332569122314,
0.5605072975158691,
0.30645954608917236,
0.30533331632614136,
-0.19500213861465454,
-0.6038438081741333,
-0.47951000928878784,
-0.45540523529052734,
-0.1102532148361206,
0.08474491536617279,
0.06391641497612,
0.3452005088329315,
0.5765859484672546,
0.2224796712398529,
-0.542219340801239,
0.32198429107666016,
-0.3249712288379669,
-0.49588701128959656,
0.74980628490448,
0.09004560112953186,
0.458197683095932,
-0.10702361911535263,
0.047211553901433945,
-0.1370401680469513,
-0.9020179510116577,
0.2667262852191925,
0.15310443937778473,
0.8561129570007324,
-0.07176529616117477,
0.38265594840049744,
-0.2230161875486374,
0.7895330190658569,
-0.019144712015986443,
-0.13809368014335632,
0.15073271095752716,
-0.2862309515476227,
-0.24490058422088623,
0.5885034203529358,
0.77197265625,
0.22517012059688568,
0.25870585441589355,
-0.07355251163244247,
-0.276652991771698,
-0.18038834631443024,
-0.11781203001737595,
-0.604047954082489,
-0.36413145065307617,
0.30117732286453247,
-0.4375630021095276,
0.4082861840724945,
0.3828430473804474,
-0.24987930059432983,
-0.3330675959587097,
-0.36715149879455566,
0.40277576446533203,
-0.16189327836036682,
0.04625534266233444,
0.16914913058280945,
0.09695079177618027,
0.38273489475250244,
0.599555492401123,
-0.7108383774757385,
0.14750617742538452,
0.5807896256446838,
0.7668174505233765,
-0.29823288321495056,
-0.46863681077957153,
-0.8137723207473755,
0.20900987088680267,
-0.6275548934936523,
0.6925733089447021,
-0.237367182970047,
-0.45382076501846313,
0.2180076241493225,
0.07253444194793701,
-0.2204463928937912,
-0.6266623735427856,
0.8626622557640076,
-0.20918262004852295,
-0.13989312946796417,
-0.6870192289352417,
-0.4668256938457489,
0.018245244398713112,
0.07000156491994858,
-0.6470189094543457,
0.6004697680473328,
-0.3920147716999054,
-0.6391681432723999,
0.17726890742778778,
-0.5233992338180542,
-0.6835235953330994,
0.022009577602148056,
-0.15424227714538574,
-0.37197524309158325,
-0.13239485025405884,
0.2614336609840393,
0.20533031225204468,
-0.14552751183509827,
0.09460308402776718,
0.08020909875631332,
-0.7704971432685852,
0.05067766457796097,
-0.6075316667556763,
0.8370878100395203,
0.15585988759994507,
-0.40392595529556274,
0.25562092661857605,
-0.7046316266059875,
-0.0192900188267231,
0.09179573506116867,
-0.5741708278656006,
-0.15751424431800842,
0.13078637421131134,
0.010773361660540104,
-0.14714381098747253,
0.33336859941482544,
-0.6938095092773438,
-0.022915029898285866,
-0.3396975100040436,
0.35359519720077515,
0.6785010695457458,
-0.17532463371753693,
0.014415196143090725,
-0.2498013824224472,
0.14946265518665314,
0.09212751686573029,
0.09288617968559265,
-0.29322338104248047,
-0.39869633316993713,
-0.8231746554374695,
-0.14442695677280426,
0.6151649355888367,
0.5800212025642395,
-0.44995465874671936,
0.45663580298423767,
-0.16718320548534393,
-0.32363057136535645,
-0.5463541150093079,
0.1401551067829132,
0.3837258815765381,
0.669109582901001,
0.39666998386383057,
-0.10253821313381195,
-0.7326145768165588,
-0.6389791965484619,
-0.39788350462913513,
-0.34800490736961365,
-0.2872503697872162,
0.4243626892566681,
-0.13010773062705994,
-0.27988219261169434,
0.6248511672019958,
-0.2814277708530426,
-0.5087839365005493,
-0.17215554416179657,
-0.055303920060396194,
0.22385117411613464,
0.6258817315101624,
-0.00155835400801152,
-0.8186477422714233,
-0.9060163497924805,
0.038990318775177,
-0.28079068660736084,
-0.13549841940402985,
-0.04922845959663391,
0.0428289920091629,
0.3169317841529846,
0.5786443948745728,
-0.400877982378006,
0.2883197069168091,
0.36895278096199036,
0.09073549509048462,
0.6005702614784241,
-0.31857460737228394,
0.39695218205451965,
-0.9122088551521301,
0.03415711224079132,
0.06375433504581451,
0.11308348923921585,
-0.8453422784805298,
-0.30732402205467224,
0.45216846466064453,
0.050317056477069855,
-0.2990562617778778,
0.36670631170272827,
-0.5133382081985474,
-0.060080934315919876,
-0.16715756058692932,
0.10164101421833038,
-0.21360644698143005,
0.3307816684246063,
0.09699118137359619,
0.6080041527748108,
0.43670201301574707,
-0.5121012330055237,
0.6121448278427124,
0.21077938377857208,
-0.17493675649166107,
-0.03565452620387077,
-0.8379019498825073,
0.1608082354068756,
0.05659152939915657,
0.39659935235977173,
-1.311582326889038,
-0.4177195727825165,
0.22301052510738373,
-0.6827405691146851,
0.42482906579971313,
0.11982503533363342,
-0.6697784066200256,
-0.4039771556854248,
-0.3828776478767395,
0.37108105421066284,
0.6748071908950806,
-0.6573818325996399,
0.4014621675014496,
0.07357420772314072,
-0.14846737682819366,
-0.629734992980957,
-0.5914700031280518,
0.20044153928756714,
-0.10014496743679047,
-0.5303128361701965,
0.4301269054412842,
-0.12709224224090576,
-0.24767188727855682,
-0.33498504757881165,
-0.03873191401362419,
-0.18377847969532013,
-0.03830527886748314,
0.07174523174762726,
0.3130984306335449,
-0.46591877937316895,
-0.02853703685104847,
-0.21513254940509796,
0.03386727720499039,
-0.008266631513834,
-0.01960664428770542,
0.4160632789134979,
0.34911641478538513,
-0.352678507566452,
-0.9960771203041077,
-0.06238413229584694,
0.20634840428829193,
-0.2845091223716736,
0.22820927202701569,
0.4279424846172333,
-0.7130658626556396,
-0.05897479131817818,
-0.6868695616722107,
-0.2911369800567627,
-0.45573827624320984,
0.43420904874801636,
-0.16243977844715118,
-0.6058586835861206,
0.6233052611351013,
0.45036640763282776,
0.27412185072898865,
0.3728267252445221,
0.38700103759765625,
-0.023126430809497833,
1.2455652952194214,
0.32962119579315186,
-0.5109140276908875,
0.41280597448349,
0.2583516836166382,
0.22550547122955322,
-0.6799936294555664,
0.06754621118307114,
-0.8434117436408997,
-0.06060890853404999,
-0.6088212728500366,
-0.3536342680454254,
0.25663211941719055,
-0.31277376413345337,
-0.17991557717323303,
0.07629123330116272,
-0.24159084260463715,
0.4852727949619293,
0.6771218180656433,
0.273897647857666,
0.3641907870769501,
-0.00961233489215374,
0.2809261679649353,
-0.3116246163845062,
-0.7179343700408936,
-0.26205137372016907,
0.8034530878067017,
0.24764414131641388,
0.8190982937812805,
-0.11852575093507767,
0.5312601327896118,
0.16239464282989502,
-0.003084859112277627,
-0.8565080761909485,
0.36962923407554626,
-0.4731247127056122,
-0.2001151144504547,
-0.6620196104049683,
-0.5982924699783325,
-0.9015709757804871,
-0.04531680792570114,
0.0920773521065712,
-0.3280947208404541,
-0.12181151658296585,
0.3901034891605377,
-0.7679694294929504,
0.18513798713684082,
-0.620905339717865,
0.7660163640975952,
-0.1789645254611969,
-0.06735141575336456,
-0.0681895837187767,
-0.6172653436660767,
0.2596553564071655,
-0.08466579765081406,
0.018972784280776978,
0.04344329610466957,
0.11161858588457108,
0.8709638118743896,
-0.18050502240657806,
0.740395724773407,
-0.3865363299846649,
-0.32723432779312134,
0.23201335966587067,
-0.29749080538749695,
0.6119704842567444,
-0.2097095400094986,
-0.07749797403812408,
0.17711623013019562,
-0.17533516883850098,
-0.28708815574645996,
-0.44181570410728455,
0.5634594559669495,
-0.7672533392906189,
-0.6771384477615356,
-0.18293222784996033,
-0.5367187261581421,
-0.2877825200557709,
0.25892603397369385,
0.34538617730140686,
0.5447443127632141,
0.07571528106927872,
0.3481569290161133,
0.7992225289344788,
-0.46095046401023865,
0.23353450000286102,
0.6248507499694824,
0.1620870977640152,
-0.2671065926551819,
0.9266912341117859,
0.6367822885513306,
0.055281806737184525,
0.4326256811618805,
0.3552206754684448,
-0.2945617437362671,
-0.7844223380088806,
-0.35084646940231323,
0.31692102551460266,
-0.6064299941062927,
-0.04566087946295738,
-0.4399252235889435,
-0.551253616809845,
-0.7707182168960571,
0.05666104704141617,
-0.3055073618888855,
0.011141031980514526,
-0.4048191010951996,
0.2306893914937973,
0.10735276341438293,
0.4432918131351471,
-0.11272849142551422,
0.19837304949760437,
-1.0121166706085205,
0.42894092202186584,
0.3534158766269684,
0.2554701268672943,
0.06340361386537552,
-0.9970415830612183,
-0.4712335765361786,
0.311867356300354,
0.04731028899550438,
-0.5059956908226013,
0.26915720105171204,
0.2449672520160675,
0.6045508980751038,
0.4962548315525055,
0.25833943486213684,
0.9486653208732605,
-0.9472783803939819,
0.8298887610435486,
-0.005468530580401421,
-0.8266231417655945,
0.5985936522483826,
-0.35500094294548035,
0.20670542120933533,
0.3016977608203888,
0.1562642604112625,
-0.9640868902206421,
-0.2837202847003937,
-0.29958221316337585,
-0.5772351026535034,
0.723271906375885,
-0.1437668353319168,
0.19496315717697144,
0.2528873085975647,
0.46015113592147827,
-0.13851410150527954,
-0.0998142659664154,
-0.4400116503238678,
-0.3481532633304596,
0.069317527115345,
-0.45226797461509705,
-0.406644344329834,
-0.39196890592575073,
-0.012939519248902798,
-0.37887445092201233,
0.6419000625610352,
-0.05176696926355362,
0.07417251914739609,
0.339528888463974,
-0.08206541836261749,
-0.5305771231651306,
-0.02202538400888443,
0.6555364727973938,
0.6001788973808289,
-0.29242557287216187,
-0.06607215106487274,
0.30348366498947144,
-0.5603622794151306,
-0.12475791573524475,
0.3003862202167511,
-0.20492002367973328,
0.3108026385307312,
0.3840579390525818,
0.636080801486969,
0.04582015052437782,
-0.7506564259529114,
0.32555094361305237,
-0.3189938962459564,
-0.08948981016874313,
-0.3931995630264282,
0.08430009335279465,
-0.17961405217647552,
0.061167746782302856,
0.7218256592750549,
-0.373369425535202,
0.19382637739181519,
-0.26751434803009033,
0.11326924711465836,
0.36724603176116943,
-0.33993950486183167,
-0.2657146751880646,
0.6981480121612549,
0.14556293189525604,
-0.37598979473114014,
0.545488715171814,
0.1787644326686859,
-0.6984003186225891,
0.7343547344207764,
0.44444000720977783,
0.8497084379196167,
-0.5665132999420166,
-0.19937336444854736,
0.7329493761062622,
0.328387975692749,
-0.41621115803718567,
0.14078176021575928,
0.0092812180519104,
-0.811135470867157,
-0.5002020597457886,
-0.19511723518371582,
-0.9450199007987976,
0.10124257206916809,
-0.6020490527153015,
0.6354765295982361,
-0.5190716981887817,
0.26341941952705383,
-0.16753536462783813,
0.21861810982227325,
-0.06752397865056992,
0.3011888265609741,
0.3973836898803711,
0.8717782497406006,
-0.6071751713752747,
1.01625394821167,
0.5003623962402344,
-0.04265150800347328,
-1.277667760848999,
0.4428194761276245,
-0.19418050348758698,
-0.7710192799568176,
0.6879519820213318,
0.3263151943683624,
-0.015674220398068428,
0.14059922099113464,
-0.6982688307762146,
-0.8389045000076294,
0.9603292942047119,
0.36164021492004395,
-0.8204255104064941,
0.07174649089574814,
0.12587450444698334,
0.48755988478660583,
-0.08313804119825363,
-0.27354860305786133,
0.6202453374862671,
0.43112948536872864,
0.06679392606019974,
-1.192857027053833,
-0.05028436705470085,
-0.036181747913360596,
-0.035358887165784836,
-0.20360401272773743,
-0.8711562156677246,
1.0418455600738525,
-0.32199332118034363,
-0.30441299080848694,
0.10328802466392517,
0.781437873840332,
0.41394466161727905,
0.21718533337116241,
0.5437136292457581,
0.0658259466290474,
0.7528138756752014,
-0.14670592546463013,
0.5743424296379089,
-0.3193569779396057,
0.17217396199703217,
0.9865866899490356,
-0.4687964618206024,
1.0137860774993896,
0.416066974401474,
-0.39860713481903076,
0.16941200196743011,
1.0252468585968018,
-0.019045786932110786,
0.31750163435935974,
0.25636860728263855,
-0.03697023540735245,
-0.033905114978551865,
-0.12337619811296463,
-0.4695087671279907,
0.321033239364624,
0.12367688119411469,
-0.020837239921092987,
0.15132147073745728,
-0.2745145857334137,
-0.04765805974602699,
0.030361467972397804,
-0.59132981300354,
0.7580364346504211,
-0.016805797815322876,
-0.5176726579666138,
0.7378043532371521,
-0.06960059702396393,
0.7936598658561707,
-0.6254795789718628,
-0.15871120989322662,
-0.3981205224990845,
0.1523933708667755,
-0.2663610875606537,
-0.2688935399055481,
0.017619313672184944,
0.10997828096151352,
-0.12256194651126862,
0.05417783185839653,
0.7490180134773254,
-0.7493071556091309,
-0.3563835620880127,
-0.03706207498908043,
0.02160303108394146,
0.21498259902000427,
-0.09823736548423767,
-0.4797494113445282,
0.19520996510982513,
0.19169114530086517,
-0.008096982724964619,
0.08054706454277039,
0.3919406533241272,
0.17751024663448334,
0.41446855664253235,
0.5990167260169983,
0.5214411020278931,
0.2060369849205017,
0.24469046294689178,
0.5129761695861816,
-0.8041139245033264,
-0.5770342946052551,
-0.9401567578315735,
0.38669148087501526,
0.12504614889621735,
0.03536437079310417,
1.1317652463912964,
0.4338703751564026,
0.816675066947937,
-0.026371657848358154,
0.9151701331138611,
0.3251315653324127,
0.7771368026733398,
-0.6356866955757141,
0.723677396774292,
-0.5758277177810669,
0.22333580255508423,
-0.3818795084953308,
-0.8054667115211487,
-0.7559520602226257,
0.640610933303833,
-0.1371401995420456,
-0.007768065668642521,
0.46705543994903564,
0.792483389377594,
0.30381789803504944,
-0.07177981734275818,
0.49416184425354004,
0.37335219979286194,
0.254959374666214,
0.48018452525138855,
0.810563862323761,
-0.5956642031669617,
0.3955296277999878,
-0.27018243074417114,
-0.08523941040039062,
-0.5215533971786499,
-0.5572065114974976,
-0.6338096261024475,
-0.44049230217933655,
-0.27911844849586487,
-0.35190340876579285,
0.09865523129701614,
1.2845159769058228,
0.2724830210208893,
-1.1235116720199585,
-0.497840940952301,
0.21510399878025055,
0.17251957952976227,
-0.19031676650047302,
-0.11769773066043854,
0.7333651185035706,
-0.5428866744041443,
-0.8818975687026978,
0.2744607925415039,
0.14743350446224213,
0.2100847065448761,
-0.10047753900289536,
-0.40147921442985535,
0.19833527505397797,
-0.07637476921081543,
0.28913867473602295,
0.40795159339904785,
-0.7554286122322083,
-0.4290355145931244,
0.19056041538715363,
-0.27372926473617554,
0.2839983105659485,
0.8539162874221802,
-0.24689295887947083,
0.4434375464916229,
0.3934367597103119,
0.8130582571029663,
-0.21754708886146545,
0.08940500766038895,
0.6356146335601807,
-0.5227321982383728,
0.11438968032598495,
0.1271713227033615,
0.5341635942459106,
0.6568885445594788,
-0.3302607238292694,
0.19593138992786407,
0.295083224773407,
-0.6284288167953491,
-1.2276523113250732,
-0.23500554263591766,
-0.8446796536445618,
0.12089937925338745,
1.4373950958251953,
-0.23838859796524048,
-0.3033227026462555,
-0.08771201223134995,
-0.5790709853172302,
0.5272987484931946,
-0.3144433796405792,
0.9521190524101257,
0.6483644843101501,
-0.06349024176597595,
-0.1886720359325409,
-0.35543692111968994,
0.736668586730957,
0.48775577545166016,
-0.5254149436950684,
0.506809651851654,
0.5922393202781677,
0.07090044021606445,
-0.020581599324941635,
0.6300382018089294,
0.21762578189373016,
0.6540975570678711,
0.0003008641942869872,
-0.011492813937366009,
0.2524314522743225,
-0.35156726837158203,
-0.6033085584640503,
-0.4697968363761902,
0.4413297176361084,
-0.32250553369522095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01906v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01906v1 | Let the Expert Stick to His Last: Expert-Specialized Fine-Tuning for Sparse Architectural Large Language Models | 2024-07-02T03:11:13 | 2024-07-02T03:11:13 | Zihan Wang, Deli Chen, Damai Dai, Runxin Xu, Zhuoshu Li, Y. Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) is crucial for customizing Large
Language Models (LLMs) with constrained resources. Although there have been
various PEFT methods for dense-architecture LLMs, PEFT for sparse-architecture
LLMs is still underexplored. In this work, we study the PEFT method for LLMs
with the Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) architecture and the contents of this work
are mainly threefold: (1) We investigate the dispersion degree of the activated
experts in customized tasks, and found that the routing distribution for a
specific task tends to be highly concentrated, while the distribution of
activated experts varies significantly across different tasks. (2) We propose
Expert-Specialized Fine-Tuning, or ESFT, which tunes the experts most relevant
to downstream tasks while freezing the other experts and modules; experimental
results demonstrate that our method not only improves the tuning efficiency,
but also matches or even surpasses the performance of full-parameter
fine-tuning. (3) We further analyze the impact of the MoE architecture on
expert-specialized fine-tuning. We find that MoE models with finer-grained
experts are more advantageous in selecting the combination of experts that are
most relevant to downstream tasks, thereby enhancing both the training
efficiency and effectiveness. | [
-0.792337954044342,
-1.0734374523162842,
0.6637261509895325,
0.08611564338207245,
-0.17505477368831635,
0.33225563168525696,
-0.6113923788070679,
-0.33588576316833496,
0.19894063472747803,
0.49906012415885925,
-0.2927660644054413,
-0.2689562737941742,
-0.5994871854782104,
0.0604911707341671,
-0.22029554843902588,
0.6204383373260498,
0.1326056569814682,
-0.3326675593852997,
0.09841042757034302,
0.12343161553144455,
-0.37061285972595215,
-0.17182482779026031,
-0.6474904417991638,
-0.28174400329589844,
0.3901274800300598,
0.4863247275352478,
0.7030278444290161,
0.8255735635757446,
0.1795484870672226,
0.4446931481361389,
-0.29990118741989136,
0.43750664591789246,
-0.47245875000953674,
-0.046153269708156586,
-0.35195666551589966,
-0.21399351954460144,
-0.7409459352493286,
-0.263749361038208,
0.3500477969646454,
0.7898427248001099,
-0.4245237112045288,
-0.04092799499630928,
0.3174791932106018,
0.5615555644035339,
-0.5944905877113342,
0.04636392742395401,
-1.1377675533294678,
-0.15939228236675262,
-0.29871827363967896,
-0.42927032709121704,
-0.3649066090583801,
0.2097976803779602,
0.13905078172683716,
-0.38288015127182007,
0.13751979172229767,
0.2561900317668915,
0.6922966837882996,
0.6609553098678589,
-0.2864369750022888,
0.15450608730316162,
-0.5800076127052307,
1.0162510871887207,
-0.642220139503479,
0.2569153904914856,
0.4708075523376465,
-0.010056299157440662,
-0.1981123387813568,
-0.1103370413184166,
-0.1507466435432434,
-0.03794136643409729,
0.21498872339725494,
-0.06673288345336914,
-0.05024940147995949,
0.19466440379619598,
-0.21356797218322754,
0.17810146510601044,
-0.33388620615005493,
0.3660385310649872,
-0.2754075229167938,
0.01868259347975254,
0.761160671710968,
0.11471333354711533,
-0.09503542631864548,
0.4619438350200653,
-0.28037676215171814,
0.3661356568336487,
-0.6179922223091125,
-0.27474191784858704,
0.3996967077255249,
0.1824636459350586,
0.1375061571598053,
0.21825970709323883,
-0.4192993640899658,
0.911764919757843,
0.6671173572540283,
-0.28054001927375793,
0.18081721663475037,
0.11263792216777802,
-0.2559361159801483,
-0.0008701086044311523,
0.581316351890564,
0.14737549424171448,
0.44994056224823,
-0.42520830035209656,
-0.39435717463493347,
-0.7016050219535828,
0.21511708199977875,
-0.46832701563835144,
-0.49799737334251404,
0.02343439869582653,
-0.2678130269050598,
-0.19370456039905548,
-0.38247719407081604,
-0.5789692997932434,
-0.018773818388581276,
-0.5122383236885071,
0.4491610825061798,
-0.3260970711708069,
-0.49628913402557373,
0.27688002586364746,
-0.026564644649624825,
-0.08004938811063766,
0.28511154651641846,
-1.2717161178588867,
0.37261298298835754,
0.9452916383743286,
0.5323113799095154,
-0.2172011286020279,
-0.47123411297798157,
-0.4948972463607788,
0.48693761229515076,
-0.311442106962204,
1.0270013809204102,
-0.9287586808204651,
-0.2574880123138428,
-0.2683333456516266,
-0.44250109791755676,
-0.2615974247455597,
-0.7774772644042969,
0.33981695771217346,
-0.5944774746894836,
-0.4613933265209198,
-0.30287495255470276,
-0.5711226463317871,
-0.12962546944618225,
0.06063603237271309,
-0.1544322818517685,
1.0527173280715942,
0.1983753740787506,
-0.18376107513904572,
0.40829867124557495,
-0.11754199862480164,
-0.3510660231113434,
0.18725238740444183,
-0.4586591124534607,
-0.12194210290908813,
0.5178995132446289,
0.16756033897399902,
0.8318046927452087,
-0.11562519520521164,
0.32341691851615906,
-0.5853583216667175,
-0.5001593232154846,
-0.03781123831868172,
-0.37640491127967834,
0.31674399971961975,
0.30747583508491516,
-0.4154544174671173,
-0.3476453423500061,
-0.8098475337028503,
-0.09888448566198349,
-0.18176716566085815,
-0.6677054762840271,
-0.49689120054244995,
0.22407099604606628,
-0.03042096644639969,
-0.14130468666553497,
0.5249022245407104,
-0.27738314867019653,
0.23861439526081085,
-0.35763660073280334,
0.4757806360721588,
1.0817307233810425,
-0.0164275411516428,
0.6345962882041931,
-0.4153979420661926,
0.14148469269275665,
-0.08104225248098373,
0.01434138510376215,
0.0280451737344265,
-0.6616506576538086,
-0.5506766438484192,
-0.48523983359336853,
0.1928863227367401,
0.36841467022895813,
-0.35079658031463623,
0.6287251114845276,
-0.11557921022176743,
-0.4564049243927002,
-0.4495369791984558,
0.482965350151062,
0.3697984516620636,
0.6075248122215271,
0.301354318857193,
0.0581667535007,
0.003003461053594947,
-1.139997124671936,
-0.3052990436553955,
-0.005164679139852524,
0.11805055290460587,
0.4596588909626007,
0.16672377288341522,
0.0046986863017082214,
0.8718827962875366,
-0.5741673707962036,
-0.09417924284934998,
0.05143452435731888,
0.22091086208820343,
0.3532642424106598,
0.6951928734779358,
0.8839478492736816,
-0.6067224740982056,
-0.958283007144928,
0.26102980971336365,
0.10161782801151276,
-0.24808773398399353,
-0.10349784046411514,
-0.16976958513259888,
0.17718416452407837,
0.2600536048412323,
-0.5112020969390869,
-0.2996189594268799,
0.3702276945114136,
-0.18324726819992065,
0.24427051842212677,
-0.42279115319252014,
0.049051228910684586,
-0.7869293093681335,
-0.2983298599720001,
0.005133256781846285,
-0.19152674078941345,
-0.4742099344730377,
0.19720587134361267,
-0.014056367799639702,
0.2685628831386566,
-0.09227769076824188,
0.37645089626312256,
-0.411482036113739,
0.16669906675815582,
-0.31134840846061707,
-0.27008581161499023,
-0.20209839940071106,
0.8437177538871765,
0.06127224862575531,
0.6343119740486145,
0.8167577385902405,
-0.5586193203926086,
-0.07078594714403152,
-0.048333603888750076,
-0.27126795053482056,
0.5436760187149048,
-0.6543651819229126,
0.3435463607311249,
0.03309795260429382,
-0.428789883852005,
-0.9583443999290466,
-0.21914036571979523,
0.06266146898269653,
-0.09046053141355515,
0.5763895511627197,
-0.29288432002067566,
-0.5965085625648499,
0.17249615490436554,
-0.1401291936635971,
0.2251599282026291,
0.795760452747345,
-0.14979279041290283,
0.7743328809738159,
0.4577377140522003,
-0.38923242688179016,
-0.3509330749511719,
-0.6232995986938477,
-0.03263837471604347,
-0.3344763219356537,
-0.6838651895523071,
0.6920043230056763,
-0.31222549080848694,
-0.2983093857765198,
0.050744518637657166,
-0.24159765243530273,
-0.4813201129436493,
0.4472328722476959,
-0.10695923119783401,
-0.286177396774292,
-0.3757527470588684,
-0.16374659538269043,
0.7682835459709167,
-0.19215354323387146,
-0.25620049238204956,
0.04456459358334541,
0.4751567840576172,
-0.18027137219905853,
-0.48639100790023804,
-0.24986781179904938,
0.6424509286880493,
0.49983474612236023,
-0.27733686566352844,
0.7539102435112,
0.6673813462257385,
-0.14692246913909912,
-0.361677885055542,
-1.084183692932129,
0.06597362458705902,
-0.5802674889564514,
0.5017861127853394,
-0.4969780445098877,
-0.9132624268531799,
0.47799140214920044,
-0.18330925703048706,
0.3205958604812622,
0.33262377977371216,
0.7389723062515259,
-0.14494355022907257,
1.1596466302871704,
0.7885046005249023,
-0.23667927086353302,
0.38521191477775574,
-0.045316461473703384,
0.04675464332103729,
-0.5713202357292175,
-0.09780809283256531,
-0.6389482617378235,
-0.5411445498466492,
-0.23169320821762085,
-0.24175633490085602,
0.4623448848724365,
0.24624554812908173,
-0.4113897681236267,
0.06348538398742676,
-0.565555989742279,
0.7038713097572327,
0.4225229024887085,
0.322086900472641,
0.31191280484199524,
0.24901853501796722,
0.14343878626823425,
0.25002261996269226,
-0.8204008340835571,
-0.2874828279018402,
0.8061542510986328,
0.28978589177131653,
0.6302772760391235,
-0.14223673939704895,
0.8575165867805481,
0.04689778760075569,
-0.08584560453891754,
-0.5539319515228271,
0.6097407341003418,
-0.41150322556495667,
-0.3741306960582733,
-0.20787370204925537,
-0.1842191219329834,
-0.542746901512146,
0.2230074256658554,
-0.05605141818523407,
-0.600968062877655,
0.5383426547050476,
0.3612307608127594,
-0.6751876473426819,
0.26610666513442993,
-0.7743363380432129,
0.40696224570274353,
-0.17739903926849365,
-0.19543716311454773,
-0.6001992225646973,
-0.35935795307159424,
-0.02470329776406288,
-0.553275465965271,
0.22946657240390778,
-0.35018590092658997,
-0.5470227599143982,
0.5193594098091125,
-0.32058045268058777,
0.8163554072380066,
-0.09446913003921509,
-0.10875425487756729,
-0.08194810897111893,
0.16931408643722534,
0.7741928696632385,
-0.06916046142578125,
-0.4245801568031311,
0.11914771050214767,
-0.19419057667255402,
-0.5827001333236694,
-0.34528157114982605,
0.8480053544044495,
-0.953454852104187,
-0.8667226433753967,
0.32662394642829895,
-0.5109965801239014,
-0.43849459290504456,
0.1525946855545044,
0.195415660738945,
0.36318692564964294,
0.40173670649528503,
0.48315781354904175,
1.0799506902694702,
0.1044730395078659,
0.3216140866279602,
0.7943050861358643,
0.49443161487579346,
-0.17845268547534943,
0.8329302668571472,
0.42133256793022156,
-0.05949407443404198,
0.5657405853271484,
0.27854371070861816,
0.154408261179924,
-1.2498010396957397,
-0.28942105174064636,
-0.027268080040812492,
-0.29272928833961487,
-0.1338992863893509,
-0.6902926564216614,
0.20883844792842865,
-0.019825495779514313,
-0.6409965753555298,
-0.6403198838233948,
-0.09401704370975494,
-0.4929821491241455,
0.13148002326488495,
0.48311832547187805,
0.4152601957321167,
0.18054385483264923,
0.43510958552360535,
-0.8255340456962585,
0.03731057420372963,
0.34552818536758423,
0.3637199401855469,
0.12726441025733948,
-0.5856826901435852,
-0.48562097549438477,
-0.052757538855075836,
-0.2185756415128708,
-0.7272153496742249,
0.08307521045207977,
0.5619456768035889,
0.9785557985305786,
0.6662288904190063,
0.022440025582909584,
0.9537708759307861,
-0.6355692148208618,
0.613699197769165,
-0.16189910471439362,
-0.7232000827789307,
0.10259187966585159,
-0.6614019870758057,
-0.027101419866085052,
0.7083549499511719,
0.14053770899772644,
0.2503112554550171,
-0.6229502558708191,
-0.4465949535369873,
-1.0164111852645874,
0.5883268117904663,
-0.07445989549160004,
0.4789400100708008,
0.016687870025634766,
0.5233355760574341,
0.3973170816898346,
0.269400417804718,
-0.09398914873600006,
-0.19397781789302826,
0.3764890432357788,
-0.1910640001296997,
0.0698118656873703,
-0.4332028031349182,
-0.11483285576105118,
-0.39901798963546753,
0.5575910210609436,
-0.058241505175828934,
0.0437457375228405,
-0.13075916469097137,
0.07005424797534943,
-0.5162858366966248,
0.1125362440943718,
0.48339876532554626,
0.8233451843261719,
-0.18715214729309082,
0.05540712550282478,
0.4085612893104553,
-0.08557829260826111,
-0.1444372981786728,
0.024004226550459862,
-0.07578667998313904,
-0.05652289092540741,
0.30097997188568115,
0.6981662511825562,
0.5873023271560669,
-0.5838313102722168,
0.2747472822666168,
0.5000958442687988,
-0.4912415146827698,
-0.0844249501824379,
0.5361688733100891,
0.04637283459305763,
0.6860846877098083,
0.7232641577720642,
0.536449134349823,
0.07728227972984314,
-0.23318368196487427,
0.10610383749008179,
0.39471811056137085,
0.2345496118068695,
-0.3809738755226135,
0.5957886576652527,
0.2873896062374115,
-0.34856125712394714,
0.2734317481517792,
0.05520712584257126,
-0.24678337574005127,
0.5924267172813416,
0.12724114954471588,
0.840542733669281,
-0.0990060493350029,
-0.1274203509092331,
-0.1172841489315033,
0.17727869749069214,
-0.31379809975624084,
0.09818564355373383,
-0.3949604034423828,
-0.5516853332519531,
-0.6505233645439148,
-0.7010232210159302,
-0.15051373839378357,
-0.03191103786230087,
-0.5236284136772156,
0.10230617970228195,
-0.36524009704589844,
-0.1191864013671875,
-0.11302858591079712,
-0.06609343737363815,
-0.6019941568374634,
-0.13163429498672485,
0.13049986958503723,
1.0191479921340942,
-0.7382247447967529,
0.7308798432350159,
0.9280604124069214,
0.1893659234046936,
-0.8827653527259827,
0.02471485175192356,
-0.2574218511581421,
-0.9236467480659485,
0.43588122725486755,
-0.5139478445053101,
0.05978337302803993,
0.21104015409946442,
-0.42586749792099,
-0.9101102352142334,
0.9022451043128967,
0.646224856376648,
-0.9023792743682861,
-0.003069237107411027,
-0.07484541833400726,
0.5843498110771179,
-0.16584156453609467,
0.10694823414087296,
0.5624621510505676,
0.5433576107025146,
-0.058743659406900406,
-1.1163424253463745,
-0.24831955134868622,
-0.19614066183567047,
-0.06800149381160736,
0.21033480763435364,
-1.0679588317871094,
0.955905020236969,
0.16789500415325165,
0.41204702854156494,
0.06073520705103874,
0.5395384430885315,
0.31524938344955444,
0.04165443032979965,
0.6557142734527588,
0.5517842769622803,
0.6226451396942139,
0.14609768986701965,
0.7243363261222839,
-0.760491132736206,
0.42251408100128174,
0.8015424013137817,
-0.015696972608566284,
0.954409122467041,
0.5246846675872803,
-0.23820197582244873,
0.0856509730219841,
0.8222494721412659,
-0.01574193313717842,
0.8139657378196716,
-0.2703469395637512,
-0.13099288940429688,
-0.8094565272331238,
0.2005736529827118,
-0.42012596130371094,
0.20851123332977295,
0.3593859374523163,
-0.30431658029556274,
-0.34213021397590637,
-0.1293247640132904,
0.003862296463921666,
-0.029255203902721405,
-0.5957321524620056,
0.7691503763198853,
0.08794040232896805,
-0.6321647763252258,
0.721152663230896,
0.11528929322957993,
0.7498272657394409,
-0.4258628785610199,
0.16699503362178802,
-0.17214863002300262,
0.1114233061671257,
-0.2399008423089981,
-0.8227723836898804,
0.27722546458244324,
-0.09327944368124008,
-0.2413506954908371,
-0.5133638978004456,
0.6022561192512512,
-0.5375023484230042,
-0.2419041097164154,
0.11937831342220306,
0.5590582489967346,
0.17300136387348175,
-0.3544233739376068,
-0.7996042370796204,
-0.07996191829442978,
-0.15135711431503296,
-0.6836090087890625,
0.5950005650520325,
0.6216774582862854,
0.25031137466430664,
0.505593478679657,
0.2568538188934326,
0.15470893681049347,
0.142020121216774,
-0.1847754716873169,
1.0146937370300293,
-0.10072772204875946,
-0.5321832895278931,
-1.0588774681091309,
0.5096760988235474,
0.2628342807292938,
-0.3348357081413269,
0.5229396224021912,
0.45957741141319275,
0.8190717697143555,
-0.26375290751457214,
0.5070559978485107,
0.009865234605967999,
0.17155787348747253,
-0.5407888889312744,
0.5845898985862732,
-0.9535746574401855,
0.40715715289115906,
-0.28031671047210693,
-0.8907485604286194,
0.11213786154985428,
0.3120858073234558,
-0.26050540804862976,
0.1419283002614975,
0.18636995553970337,
0.8390887379646301,
-0.4041949510574341,
-0.30806028842926025,
0.5326963663101196,
0.42564353346824646,
0.03351609781384468,
0.6298246383666992,
0.5507524013519287,
0.1433696746826172,
0.4337272644042969,
-0.4391917884349823,
-0.22492855787277222,
-0.4893556535243988,
-0.6738777756690979,
-0.9910224080085754,
-0.5419831871986389,
-0.45177605748176575,
0.5250605940818787,
0.056355349719524384,
1.03556489944458,
1.0297541618347168,
-0.7415038347244263,
0.1075587049126625,
-0.08279580622911453,
0.02603338100016117,
-0.32226288318634033,
-0.10917343199253082,
0.328348845243454,
-0.38645392656326294,
-1.0082792043685913,
0.5341666340827942,
0.6023350358009338,
-0.2722068130970001,
-0.12323931604623795,
-0.09289976954460144,
0.23458650708198547,
0.14719218015670776,
0.477053701877594,
-0.0807899460196495,
-0.653562605381012,
-0.21813900768756866,
-0.010463905520737171,
0.14355270564556122,
0.0536407046020031,
0.5477707982063293,
-0.4277932345867157,
0.16422389447689056,
0.6447921395301819,
0.8420198559761047,
0.21400918066501617,
-0.012821871787309647,
0.523034393787384,
-0.7069773077964783,
0.06803832948207855,
0.18277989327907562,
0.5403852462768555,
-0.3321211636066437,
-0.5995907187461853,
0.17635074257850647,
0.23774565756320953,
-0.7356160283088684,
-0.788953423500061,
-0.0005866584833711386,
-1.224204182624817,
-0.4667165279388428,
1.0660897493362427,
-0.022890198975801468,
-0.012947439216077328,
-0.4070906341075897,
-0.3488856852054596,
-0.20319388806819916,
-0.7877859473228455,
0.8802803158760071,
0.6523733735084534,
-0.2913074791431427,
-0.3698117434978485,
-0.3586960434913635,
0.18117789924144745,
0.630879282951355,
-0.2615765631198883,
-0.2674090266227722,
0.05247124284505844,
0.5126745700836182,
0.011587296612560749,
0.6619635820388794,
0.3639599084854126,
0.06774338334798813,
-0.17565219104290009,
-0.5410332083702087,
-0.6570935845375061,
-0.3721352517604828,
0.0002704808139242232,
0.39875853061676025,
0.2853044271469116,
0.1090385913848877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01902v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01902v1 | SoP: Unlock the Power of Social Facilitation for Automatic Jailbreak Attack | 2024-07-02T02:58:29 | 2024-07-02T02:58:29 | Yan Yang, Zeguan Xiao, Xin Lu, Hongru Wang, Hailiang Huang, Guanhua Chen, Yun Chen | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | The widespread applications of large language models (LLMs) have brought
about concerns regarding their potential misuse. Although aligned with human
preference data before release, LLMs remain vulnerable to various malicious
attacks. In this paper, we adopt a red-teaming strategy to enhance LLM safety
and introduce SoP, a simple yet effective framework to design jailbreak prompts
automatically. Inspired by the social facilitation concept, SoP generates and
optimizes multiple jailbreak characters to bypass the guardrails of the target
LLM. Different from previous work which relies on proprietary LLMs or seed
jailbreak templates crafted by human expertise, SoP can generate and optimize
the jailbreak prompt in a cold-start scenario using open-sourced LLMs without
any seed jailbreak templates. Experimental results show that SoP achieves
attack success rates of 88% and 60% in bypassing the safety alignment of
GPT-3.5-1106 and GPT-4, respectively. Furthermore, we extensively evaluate the
transferability of the generated templates across different LLMs and held-out
malicious requests, while also exploring defense strategies against the
jailbreak attack designed by SoP. Code is available at
https://github.com/Yang-Yan-Yang-Yan/SoP. | [
-0.3046431243419647,
-0.7765036821365356,
0.45847198367118835,
0.5947926640510559,
-0.08617831021547318,
0.2955935001373291,
-0.14611674845218658,
-0.3133343458175659,
0.5393296480178833,
0.5368375182151794,
-0.6545831561088562,
-0.45848098397254944,
-0.5792725682258606,
0.17387069761753082,
-0.3379354178905487,
1.0447672605514526,
0.11529775708913803,
-0.20479151606559753,
0.36046162247657776,
0.006865652743726969,
-0.38664114475250244,
-0.5061001777648926,
-0.5702545046806335,
0.17893525958061218,
0.3605876863002777,
0.5200549960136414,
0.54107266664505,
0.49165740609169006,
0.3450077474117279,
0.24503758549690247,
0.09206247329711914,
-0.02059413678944111,
-0.35012322664260864,
0.24268943071365356,
-0.07472781836986542,
-0.19151604175567627,
-0.5545828938484192,
-0.05848734825849533,
0.0396137572824955,
-0.09134574234485626,
-0.22790051996707916,
-0.038856104016304016,
0.06741880625486374,
0.8251718282699585,
-0.7008852362632751,
-0.02588781528174877,
-0.797940194606781,
-0.07523220032453537,
-0.32387301325798035,
0.05001130700111389,
-0.3699057698249817,
-0.6175550818443298,
-0.19679713249206543,
-0.4153379499912262,
-0.09942237287759781,
0.20432792603969574,
0.48126208782196045,
0.20402361452579498,
0.09202027320861816,
-0.2017538994550705,
-0.14882990717887878,
0.22463278472423553,
-0.5726449489593506,
0.06125272065401077,
0.3593050241470337,
0.3699171245098114,
-0.41301876306533813,
-0.25005897879600525,
-0.5286340713500977,
-0.391200989484787,
0.2571045160293579,
-0.1699029952287674,
-0.24804416298866272,
0.04403955861926079,
0.21287760138511658,
-0.2215918004512787,
-0.5203287601470947,
0.15852996706962585,
-0.3115887939929962,
-0.10320106148719788,
0.9210954904556274,
-0.003669705241918564,
0.7340553998947144,
-0.21055297553539276,
-0.6366335153579712,
0.24555952847003937,
-0.9727025628089905,
-0.13058006763458252,
0.3450564444065094,
0.33609598875045776,
-0.49774429202079773,
0.4568607211112976,
-0.11524670571088791,
0.5669944882392883,
0.2565971314907074,
0.11940327286720276,
0.02827269956469536,
-0.2785557210445404,
0.00964756216853857,
0.2714049518108368,
1.127958059310913,
0.5731792449951172,
0.34441906213760376,
-0.20747293531894684,
-0.0739896148443222,
-0.03270015865564346,
0.17550207674503326,
-0.6324998140335083,
-0.14158064126968384,
0.23716752231121063,
-0.24032887816429138,
-0.7391842603683472,
0.11891490966081619,
-0.7583112120628357,
-0.8107430934906006,
0.3511256277561188,
0.16214774549007416,
-0.5009474158287048,
-0.25940996408462524,
0.089310422539711,
-0.1416599154472351,
0.061000529676675797,
0.08184858411550522,
-1.1273103952407837,
0.27346038818359375,
0.6246834993362427,
1.0030274391174316,
-0.2286771833896637,
-0.4780242145061493,
-0.7226405143737793,
0.45059773325920105,
-0.008350111544132233,
0.5954933166503906,
-0.1586771160364151,
-0.3433627486228943,
-0.19607289135456085,
-0.18224476277828217,
0.11177370697259903,
-0.34634095430374146,
-0.03322179988026619,
-0.6361048817634583,
-0.4803703725337982,
-0.14653481543064117,
-0.222611665725708,
0.39242976903915405,
0.1647656410932541,
-0.5503436326980591,
0.5730128288269043,
-0.24169887602329254,
-0.8306779265403748,
0.20673923194408417,
-0.7181696891784668,
-0.5981348752975464,
0.18483242392539978,
-0.23584771156311035,
-0.27482372522354126,
0.026111522689461708,
0.17991432547569275,
0.5849123001098633,
-0.19459539651870728,
0.37352603673934937,
-0.46858176589012146,
-0.1908511519432068,
0.03022541105747223,
0.21587328612804413,
0.9742997884750366,
0.371454656124115,
-0.6942288279533386,
0.3057480752468109,
-0.5467658042907715,
-0.10364454984664917,
0.5137600898742676,
-0.20453932881355286,
-0.3875126242637634,
-0.0731244683265686,
-0.10157264769077301,
0.13430267572402954,
0.28742676973342896,
-0.602867603302002,
0.39394238591194153,
-0.35969072580337524,
0.7324711084365845,
0.9923284649848938,
-0.15276938676834106,
0.43175917863845825,
0.008043521083891392,
0.5618494749069214,
-0.5939466953277588,
0.28146106004714966,
0.05425828695297241,
-0.3967036008834839,
-0.1790604144334793,
-0.34557652473449707,
0.03982266038656235,
0.7754210233688354,
-0.6874634027481079,
0.5230178236961365,
0.24893328547477722,
-0.6974851489067078,
-0.2601374089717865,
0.3079563081264496,
0.5577545166015625,
0.11924616247415543,
0.32699906826019287,
-0.16268031299114227,
-0.6594172716140747,
-0.6207795739173889,
-0.5337878465652466,
-0.2469419240951538,
-0.016579631716012955,
0.1264886111021042,
0.297608345746994,
-0.194504514336586,
0.8421033620834351,
-0.5411903262138367,
-0.22358477115631104,
-0.7586749196052551,
-0.10964670777320862,
0.2549375891685486,
0.5138064026832581,
0.5371344089508057,
-0.39850857853889465,
-0.7118309736251831,
-0.47457751631736755,
-0.7253931164741516,
-0.6043670177459717,
-0.10779467225074768,
-0.07790903002023697,
0.22172515094280243,
0.8100512623786926,
-0.5328668355941772,
0.41405582427978516,
0.6173254251480103,
-0.7444268465042114,
0.9261983036994934,
-0.1335470974445343,
-0.009333484806120396,
-1.000243067741394,
-0.11181141436100006,
0.1007935181260109,
-0.020014964044094086,
-0.7481734156608582,
0.4221999943256378,
0.25248873233795166,
-0.3243112564086914,
-0.6722269654273987,
0.5307495594024658,
-0.34904614090919495,
0.07104218006134033,
-0.09180084615945816,
0.3274490535259247,
-0.30560508370399475,
0.12554733455181122,
-0.13072310388088226,
0.6991397738456726,
0.38261231780052185,
-0.3233584761619568,
0.37325000762939453,
0.18424876034259796,
-0.11975820362567902,
0.32150304317474365,
-0.9474878311157227,
0.35536882281303406,
0.014837103895843029,
0.22967027127742767,
-0.8714608550071716,
-0.21073177456855774,
0.2584393322467804,
-0.2832980751991272,
0.12363699823617935,
-0.33195239305496216,
-0.6055662035942078,
-0.02812022529542446,
-0.41628769040107727,
0.015219234861433506,
0.2974146902561188,
-0.5049758553504944,
0.318325400352478,
0.6055890917778015,
-0.38168540596961975,
-0.27208396792411804,
-0.35308510065078735,
0.3726296126842499,
-0.3589027523994446,
-0.9282127618789673,
0.3165551722049713,
-0.13991416990756989,
-0.35341235995292664,
-0.572134256362915,
-0.03583966940641403,
0.1934509575366974,
0.5083678960800171,
0.5177580118179321,
0.5104783177375793,
0.2305590957403183,
-0.32124584913253784,
-0.030275506898760796,
-0.427598237991333,
0.09322917461395264,
-0.13343843817710876,
0.8919722437858582,
-0.2286583036184311,
-0.22585570812225342,
-0.46148574352264404,
0.37872883677482605,
0.594044029712677,
-0.13606345653533936,
0.6683719158172607,
0.11373307555913925,
-0.029816681519150734,
-0.011488592252135277,
-0.5052507519721985,
-0.33995944261550903,
-0.5300841331481934,
0.12434377521276474,
-0.22685188055038452,
-0.8910088539123535,
0.2283720076084137,
0.07699408382177353,
0.2203618884086609,
-0.19484181702136993,
0.4267415702342987,
-0.07198777794837952,
0.8462400436401367,
0.6193968057632446,
-0.6195964813232422,
0.638620138168335,
0.08863183110952377,
0.21767525374889374,
-0.34480735659599304,
-0.0811484083533287,
-0.5061020255088806,
-0.15460078418254852,
-0.3261127471923828,
-0.1443203240633011,
0.3967411518096924,
0.2623126804828644,
-0.3406282663345337,
0.617684006690979,
-0.49402961134910583,
0.7035298943519592,
0.4486340880393982,
0.1393129527568817,
0.14746186137199402,
-0.14730730652809143,
-0.28512775897979736,
0.06321971863508224,
-0.6374836564064026,
-0.4598473012447357,
0.9976791739463806,
0.41003158688545227,
0.8910176157951355,
0.21214942634105682,
1.1588925123214722,
0.39214256405830383,
0.10350680351257324,
-0.30775725841522217,
0.9185812473297119,
-0.04864857345819473,
-0.5907540917396545,
-0.22023366391658783,
-0.10164720565080643,
-0.6675599217414856,
-0.08082332462072372,
-0.33175164461135864,
-0.9755396246910095,
-0.17261385917663574,
0.3811427354812622,
-0.7249848246574402,
0.14974521100521088,
-0.8080097436904907,
0.7684803009033203,
-0.3393086791038513,
-0.4134674072265625,
-0.21152402460575104,
-0.8583948612213135,
0.39283880591392517,
-0.02041258104145527,
0.42939096689224243,
-0.1995934247970581,
0.280680388212204,
0.7985615730285645,
-0.6640468835830688,
0.9821373224258423,
-0.5437068939208984,
0.13068729639053345,
-0.029556123539805412,
0.43660786747932434,
0.8950610756874084,
0.23926915228366852,
0.009009800851345062,
0.26182419061660767,
-0.29281747341156006,
-0.27742519974708557,
-0.4560299813747406,
0.5378320217132568,
-0.659868061542511,
-1.0049636363983154,
-0.19132089614868164,
-0.4030880331993103,
0.08044158667325974,
0.30138298869132996,
0.22592855989933014,
-0.041287243366241455,
0.09464704245328903,
-0.032182592898607254,
0.5920722484588623,
-0.4532141387462616,
0.504435658454895,
0.5054063200950623,
-0.2746773362159729,
-0.46988043189048767,
0.7118402123451233,
-0.0835237056016922,
0.4833064675331116,
-0.1771736592054367,
0.3497408628463745,
0.0026173649821430445,
-0.6172264218330383,
-0.487870991230011,
0.16685263812541962,
-0.2952329218387604,
-0.22670313715934753,
-0.6912351846694946,
-0.2902440130710602,
-0.6941767334938049,
-0.7763222455978394,
-0.30810266733169556,
-0.42299750447273254,
0.14162109792232513,
-0.22694580256938934,
0.559208869934082,
0.4319440424442291,
-0.3672219514846802,
0.37647417187690735,
-0.8232410550117493,
0.546239972114563,
0.2094859480857849,
-0.06334207206964493,
-0.1617274433374405,
-0.08025162667036057,
0.010628930293023586,
-0.447377473115921,
-0.13936789333820343,
-1.2611266374588013,
0.5136559009552002,
-0.1579706370830536,
0.40558677911758423,
0.3573324680328369,
0.4887571334838867,
0.4229089021682739,
-0.7138336896896362,
0.5954699516296387,
0.5914964079856873,
-1.0576119422912598,
1.0480844974517822,
-0.5025749802589417,
0.08459271490573883,
0.7216406464576721,
0.17360493540763855,
-0.4858572483062744,
-0.7717785835266113,
-0.7189368009567261,
-1.144113302230835,
0.6926863193511963,
0.024227110669016838,
-0.021990980952978134,
-0.12743212282657623,
0.2196841984987259,
-0.043579865247011185,
0.21633972227573395,
-0.7291965484619141,
-0.35486289858818054,
-0.21712541580200195,
-0.10859309136867523,
0.2124509960412979,
-0.2794784903526306,
-0.28988808393478394,
0.08015697449445724,
0.44092029333114624,
0.039629459381103516,
0.0587703213095665,
0.04565757140517235,
-0.10879375040531158,
0.207559272646904,
0.40037083625793457,
0.3507390022277832,
0.11831839382648468,
-0.13562968373298645,
0.2327916920185089,
0.15026921033859253,
-0.6868959665298462,
0.40554285049438477,
-0.01354698371142149,
-0.46639585494995117,
-0.40224334597587585,
0.19383931159973145,
0.395669549703598,
-0.029847675934433937,
-0.5625714659690857,
0.47400224208831787,
-0.10970664024353027,
-0.008666910231113434,
-0.2440004199743271,
0.5920810699462891,
0.05618195980787277,
0.5206611752510071,
0.2731248438358307,
0.02708003669977188,
-0.12429396063089371,
-0.48934313654899597,
0.2518850564956665,
0.4379591643810272,
-0.2789827883243561,
-0.2782389223575592,
0.8055355548858643,
0.4425528645515442,
-0.6277661323547363,
0.3914039433002472,
-0.16813215613365173,
-0.6500272750854492,
0.593159019947052,
0.8442222476005554,
0.9591425657272339,
-0.37912383675575256,
0.16431185603141785,
0.05525090917944908,
0.4683215320110321,
-0.038286417722702026,
0.4023457467556,
-0.2015523761510849,
-0.8215149641036987,
-0.1418774574995041,
-0.2868894040584564,
-0.2240609973669052,
0.010518049821257591,
-0.47851601243019104,
0.5187552571296692,
-1.1243598461151123,
-0.05130553990602493,
-0.19211646914482117,
-0.27023276686668396,
-0.06529533863067627,
-0.1355956643819809,
-0.01774728111922741,
1.223023533821106,
-0.9291344285011292,
0.8660845756530762,
0.5092891454696655,
-0.138466015458107,
-0.7554723024368286,
0.0994575098156929,
0.4982881247997284,
-0.9520326852798462,
0.8736264705657959,
0.32801172137260437,
-0.18697704374790192,
0.0601937472820282,
-0.7019701600074768,
-0.613092303276062,
0.7893007397651672,
0.3606947064399719,
-0.7573755979537964,
-0.08345794677734375,
-0.09445555508136749,
-0.0849897563457489,
-0.2801646888256073,
-0.14378349483013153,
0.7972522377967834,
0.5117987394332886,
-0.10413920134305954,
-0.8012370467185974,
0.6232085824012756,
-0.2861616015434265,
-0.2690643072128296,
0.1076972484588623,
-0.6127087473869324,
0.2819790542125702,
-0.6804201602935791,
-0.03449154645204544,
-0.03398750349879265,
0.27605941891670227,
1.1684468984603882,
0.2867361605167389,
0.6513459086418152,
0.37148308753967285,
0.316915363073349,
0.021431436762213707,
0.7189372181892395,
-0.4786034822463989,
-0.1998862475156784,
1.1012067794799805,
-0.34244978427886963,
0.7112113833427429,
0.7240663170814514,
-0.02349078841507435,
0.11126518994569778,
0.2690964341163635,
0.11359249800443649,
0.8456859588623047,
0.3944966793060303,
-0.23935820162296295,
-0.1375325322151184,
0.10061655938625336,
-0.46229004859924316,
0.20233429968357086,
0.27219775319099426,
-0.21564523875713348,
-0.12844790518283844,
-0.06562189757823944,
0.6612268090248108,
0.042113788425922394,
-0.1895999163389206,
0.7581602931022644,
0.1682296246290207,
-0.3972605764865875,
0.4930209815502167,
0.1842399537563324,
0.7720901966094971,
-0.65914386510849,
0.25181320309638977,
-0.18458154797554016,
-0.12896040081977844,
-0.38917428255081177,
-0.5319045186042786,
0.38974276185035706,
0.3792857527732849,
-0.03637448325753212,
-0.4121220111846924,
0.8725641369819641,
0.05304167792201042,
0.042081139981746674,
0.39967912435531616,
-0.01977963000535965,
0.02306976541876793,
-0.04259130731225014,
-0.7692323327064514,
0.41302645206451416,
0.14351187646389008,
-0.1431502103805542,
0.552455723285675,
0.13763201236724854,
0.03879829868674278,
0.746656060218811,
0.772051215171814,
0.38030245900154114,
-0.038091450929641724,
-0.0599844753742218,
1.0731264352798462,
-0.7402340769767761,
-0.7739449143409729,
-1.4219659566879272,
0.5032908320426941,
-0.281742125749588,
0.04114644229412079,
0.8930920958518982,
0.2171071618795395,
0.4025948941707611,
0.0975068211555481,
1.0131806135177612,
-0.38141801953315735,
0.10607197880744934,
-0.6917122602462769,
1.1266928911209106,
-0.17327260971069336,
0.6660027503967285,
-0.8410884737968445,
-0.5316826105117798,
-0.41121405363082886,
0.7068554759025574,
-0.49799904227256775,
-0.40760448575019836,
0.3743317127227783,
0.8905854821205139,
0.35047078132629395,
0.09160948544740677,
0.18142254650592804,
0.20039090514183044,
0.5261289477348328,
0.5547910928726196,
0.8028409481048584,
0.026600012555718422,
0.38472920656204224,
0.15403567254543304,
-0.6867974400520325,
-0.3926715552806854,
-1.0282680988311768,
-0.9649200439453125,
-0.1930922120809555,
-0.1874590367078781,
-0.7327246069908142,
0.48269975185394287,
1.209695816040039,
0.716107964515686,
-0.6678388118743896,
-0.33523982763290405,
-0.30835244059562683,
0.12507759034633636,
0.02903209626674652,
-0.18161281943321228,
0.1400827020406723,
-0.2747560739517212,
-0.06171908229589462,
0.7825309038162231,
0.6487368941307068,
-0.03692614287137985,
-0.24964436888694763,
-0.16341203451156616,
-0.02992231398820877,
-0.033786337822675705,
0.334702730178833,
0.46660077571868896,
-0.43579986691474915,
-0.17395848035812378,
-0.005444533657282591,
-0.11657501012086868,
-0.23174333572387695,
0.7906425595283508,
-0.4423988163471222,
0.2077488750219345,
0.40327849984169006,
0.6424944996833801,
0.16074660420417786,
-0.16855287551879883,
0.9506953954696655,
-0.7099592089653015,
0.24732348322868347,
-0.059495825320482254,
0.3545565903186798,
-0.042899034917354584,
-0.49211663007736206,
0.48215967416763306,
0.2736327052116394,
-0.40283751487731934,
-0.8343451619148254,
0.48349258303642273,
-0.4873204231262207,
-0.3447349965572357,
1.2349191904067993,
-0.3751120865345001,
-0.3709295690059662,
-0.5034283399581909,
-0.29755493998527527,
-0.050146520137786865,
-0.7897735238075256,
1.1426352262496948,
0.31027474999427795,
-0.022765086963772774,
-0.13500504195690155,
-0.3826739490032196,
0.6418415307998657,
0.1318490356206894,
-0.8504058122634888,
0.37678366899490356,
0.2310783714056015,
0.3720255494117737,
0.18638181686401367,
0.9330570101737976,
-0.17679063975811005,
0.3446310758590698,
-0.23839305341243744,
0.16415540874004364,
-0.42579999566078186,
-0.5536167025566101,
-0.1326487809419632,
0.34812358021736145,
0.05638658627867699,
-0.059301819652318954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01899v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01899v1 | Scope-enhanced Compositional Semantic Parsing for DRT | 2024-07-02T02:50:15 | 2024-07-02T02:50:15 | Xiulin Yang, Jonas Groschwitz, Alexander Koller, Johan Bos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Discourse Representation Theory (DRT) distinguishes itself from other
semantic representation frameworks by its ability to model complex semantic and
discourse phenomena through structural nesting and variable binding. While
seq2seq models hold the state of the art on DRT parsing, their accuracy
degrades with the complexity of the sentence, and they sometimes struggle to
produce well-formed DRT representations. We introduce the AMS parser, a
compositional, neurosymbolic semantic parser for DRT. It rests on a novel
mechanism for predicting quantifier scope. We show that the AMS parser reliably
produces well-formed outputs and performs well on DRT parsing, especially on
complex sentences. | [
-0.19502666592597961,
-0.6318234801292419,
0.7577241659164429,
0.21142730116844177,
-0.1535700261592865,
0.31914055347442627,
-0.11968661099672318,
-0.2559935748577118,
0.5148952603340149,
0.3624247908592224,
-0.5346673130989075,
-0.28123924136161804,
-0.6896774768829346,
0.05855325609445572,
-0.34819597005844116,
0.5635092854499817,
-0.02735881879925728,
0.19984738528728485,
-0.24952374398708344,
-0.11169365793466568,
-0.5431840419769287,
-0.511290431022644,
-0.7343198657035828,
-0.3441021144390106,
0.2973775267601013,
0.11002472788095474,
0.6648852229118347,
0.5654304623603821,
0.4733601212501526,
0.3961013853549957,
-0.1614171862602234,
0.06548047810792923,
-0.05186590179800987,
0.5848805904388428,
-0.2254849225282669,
-0.515852153301239,
-0.5527680516242981,
-0.2884584963321686,
0.7993829250335693,
0.8667154312133789,
-0.25940021872520447,
-0.28197139501571655,
-0.024318912997841835,
0.5686179995536804,
-0.6575258374214172,
0.21177276968955994,
-0.45228391885757446,
0.1780991405248642,
-0.09170685708522797,
-0.10948103666305542,
-0.41078171133995056,
0.06002957373857498,
0.3187885284423828,
-0.5712344646453857,
-0.08624020963907242,
-0.38116928935050964,
0.5951454043388367,
0.27412623167037964,
-1.001894474029541,
-0.009419264271855354,
-0.5482258796691895,
0.752991795539856,
-0.6513156890869141,
0.46045878529548645,
0.029531093314290047,
0.4758526682853699,
-0.12327361106872559,
-1.0545551776885986,
-0.45027223229408264,
-0.05541325733065605,
-0.3427376449108124,
0.32615140080451965,
-0.28087112307548523,
0.36434510350227356,
0.20889391005039215,
0.5468980073928833,
-0.6561678051948547,
-0.39216241240501404,
-0.04626055434346199,
-0.23142307996749878,
0.25611570477485657,
0.3863126039505005,
-0.013344971463084221,
-0.8080580830574036,
-0.36252960562705994,
0.018102237954735756,
-0.42967918515205383,
0.047012023627758026,
0.01577233523130417,
-0.04181218519806862,
0.016279393807053566,
0.8224349021911621,
-0.31591376662254333,
0.9795898199081421,
0.010722893290221691,
0.18442673981189728,
0.008126051165163517,
-0.210717111825943,
-0.2507514953613281,
-0.1874927431344986,
0.6916130781173706,
0.14095519483089447,
-0.042416058480739594,
0.09014464914798737,
-0.22629687190055847,
0.32001957297325134,
0.4747055172920227,
-0.5955238938331604,
-0.3472757041454315,
0.04584604501724243,
-0.3200607895851135,
-0.18829670548439026,
0.38541126251220703,
-0.5115876793861389,
-0.058815207332372665,
-0.5632607936859131,
0.14257527887821198,
-0.5662487149238586,
-0.1613440215587616,
0.27639853954315186,
-0.3262168765068054,
0.114039845764637,
0.23505225777626038,
-0.7814490795135498,
0.5615544319152832,
0.6687000393867493,
0.8028303384780884,
-0.12560485303401947,
-0.13301242887973785,
-0.5239733457565308,
0.4883808195590973,
-0.2712916135787964,
0.9471538662910461,
-0.8322722911834717,
-0.14381645619869232,
-0.10372807830572128,
-0.06429913640022278,
-0.23052702844142914,
-0.49844127893447876,
0.4902186691761017,
-0.5519232153892517,
0.1945727914571762,
-0.3507329821586609,
-0.7036656141281128,
-0.3360197842121124,
0.41447073221206665,
-0.6525738835334778,
0.6392396092414856,
0.5040416717529297,
-0.5862591862678528,
0.3409006595611572,
-0.8318285346031189,
-0.5745958089828491,
-0.014795768074691296,
-0.49292850494384766,
-0.02547616884112358,
0.4236483871936798,
0.06436996906995773,
0.2623329162597656,
-0.06937959045171738,
0.5998400449752808,
-0.13549384474754333,
-0.06273742765188217,
0.49030062556266785,
-0.5905504822731018,
0.513131320476532,
0.2303636223077774,
-0.1988791525363922,
0.2519685924053192,
-0.807220458984375,
0.23915722966194153,
-0.10464028269052505,
-0.4542560279369354,
-0.3486035168170929,
0.06335920095443726,
-0.18167664110660553,
-0.013975934125483036,
0.2279966026544571,
-0.5581985116004944,
0.07546822726726532,
-0.6786360740661621,
0.8741648197174072,
0.5355708599090576,
0.11160583794116974,
0.4421841502189636,
-0.12801866233348846,
0.6009067296981812,
0.3701530992984772,
-0.3191883862018585,
-0.2725861668586731,
-0.3013014495372772,
-0.87812340259552,
-0.33018386363983154,
0.48400503396987915,
0.5165969729423523,
-0.4701777994632721,
0.6326760649681091,
-0.39661043882369995,
-0.04412427917122841,
-0.2822052538394928,
-0.4951072931289673,
0.3082314729690552,
0.16114981472492218,
0.27341634035110474,
-0.5154351592063904,
-0.7810925245285034,
-1.1704462766647339,
-0.38359004259109497,
-0.15273763239383698,
-0.2442140430212021,
0.2460864782333374,
0.3159826397895813,
-0.22984053194522858,
1.0916353464126587,
-0.8371530771255493,
-0.12672294676303864,
-0.13787132501602173,
0.2616824209690094,
-0.011441454291343689,
0.3786839246749878,
0.2989226281642914,
-0.8185991644859314,
-0.40983885526657104,
-0.15069787204265594,
-0.8042399287223816,
-0.05861864238977432,
0.14130009710788727,
-0.05251022428274155,
-0.10482247173786163,
0.5487555265426636,
-0.8810902833938599,
0.4530223309993744,
0.4447076916694641,
-0.7865488529205322,
0.38352155685424805,
-0.0300873015075922,
0.12200980633497238,
-1.2530730962753296,
-0.23040947318077087,
-0.3614961504936218,
-0.6765778064727783,
-0.39129897952079773,
0.04058271273970604,
0.243808776140213,
-0.07165757566690445,
-0.13809169828891754,
0.1319103240966797,
-0.25445905327796936,
-0.06649892777204514,
-0.30452629923820496,
0.02951553836464882,
0.5030073523521423,
0.19942370057106018,
0.11826534569263458,
0.6864283084869385,
0.35953792929649353,
-0.436372309923172,
0.49124953150749207,
0.31169313192367554,
0.036815810948610306,
0.8198036551475525,
-0.9146689772605896,
-0.421638160943985,
0.014623276889324188,
0.43902596831321716,
-0.9307330846786499,
-0.47984662652015686,
0.028453456237912178,
-0.28766393661499023,
0.4485152065753937,
0.03428655490279198,
-0.39426618814468384,
-0.43574297428131104,
-0.19617371261119843,
0.6658517718315125,
-0.03242307901382446,
-0.2567082941532135,
0.791305661201477,
0.3842315971851349,
0.07249362766742706,
-0.5001223683357239,
-1.0767768621444702,
0.3127231001853943,
-0.1296842396259308,
-0.8081221580505371,
0.5992956757545471,
0.3251574635505676,
-0.23961141705513,
0.16257111728191376,
-0.10040333122015,
0.025152547284960747,
-0.030317019671201706,
0.03566083312034607,
-0.21782244741916656,
-0.4912121593952179,
0.2010626345872879,
0.39079761505126953,
-0.46523648500442505,
0.19750401377677917,
-0.3521759510040283,
0.5405722260475159,
-0.30494216084480286,
-0.5772430300712585,
-0.2897660434246063,
0.711692214012146,
0.49261316657066345,
-0.43355318903923035,
0.3692304491996765,
0.23556432127952576,
-0.32664862275123596,
-0.08484965562820435,
-0.2528548240661621,
-0.34132224321365356,
-0.44614046812057495,
0.4103233218193054,
-0.7546844482421875,
-1.088982343673706,
0.5899306535720825,
-0.202632874250412,
-0.41176319122314453,
0.49272122979164124,
0.42685845494270325,
0.2632298469543457,
0.9739954471588135,
0.4753117561340332,
0.5021600127220154,
0.29725587368011475,
-0.3944561779499054,
0.30876848101615906,
-1.1261756420135498,
0.10473033785820007,
-0.025233658030629158,
-0.3173786997795105,
-0.7115187048912048,
-0.549760639667511,
0.45635518431663513,
-0.31556451320648193,
-0.3249446153640747,
0.4104331433773041,
-0.4793444871902466,
0.5355964303016663,
0.7547426223754883,
0.10264132171869278,
0.41087591648101807,
-0.2143462747335434,
-0.20421762764453888,
-0.26838865876197815,
-0.47304385900497437,
-0.6086770296096802,
0.7325529456138611,
0.402580201625824,
0.7642022371292114,
0.4443216025829315,
0.6165236830711365,
0.08900836110115051,
-0.3507935702800751,
-0.9731587171554565,
0.5786133408546448,
-0.48017725348472595,
-0.5091594457626343,
-0.1562032848596573,
-0.2649590075016022,
-0.7964315414428711,
0.6456566452980042,
0.23131269216537476,
-0.5549296140670776,
0.5418351292610168,
-0.1541326940059662,
-0.4229675531387329,
0.06762722134590149,
-0.6411053538322449,
0.9839181900024414,
0.3200068771839142,
-0.13439291715621948,
-0.18679405748844147,
-0.8994592428207397,
0.36592626571655273,
0.16137123107910156,
-0.20583580434322357,
0.04090433567762375,
-0.328327476978302,
0.7809578776359558,
-0.3581189215183258,
0.9270519018173218,
-0.08133399486541748,
0.06510467082262039,
0.3407946228981018,
0.32304781675338745,
0.3081117272377014,
0.3813513219356537,
-0.08171647042036057,
-0.06225159019231796,
0.2167108803987503,
-0.309455543756485,
-0.6581546664237976,
0.5600119233131409,
-0.5036225318908691,
-0.4741798937320709,
-0.5479795932769775,
-0.6076241731643677,
-0.3494851887226105,
0.27765050530433655,
0.23023106157779694,
0.4522325396537781,
-0.30296486616134644,
0.23508767783641815,
0.5566275119781494,
0.16658370196819305,
0.28362923860549927,
0.29769784212112427,
0.02899867668747902,
-0.6892085075378418,
0.5180985927581787,
0.13726451992988586,
0.30565276741981506,
0.5522642731666565,
0.18960663676261902,
-0.14987541735172272,
-0.2657581865787506,
-0.44884422421455383,
0.17561252415180206,
-0.9751026630401611,
-0.6931593418121338,
-0.8849168419837952,
-0.4696153998374939,
-0.4734064042568207,
-0.025380786508321762,
-0.43328630924224854,
-0.9840213656425476,
-0.23973308503627777,
-0.20111025869846344,
0.01929726079106331,
1.0039355754852295,
-0.07763893157243729,
0.5547720789909363,
-0.5501063466072083,
0.2796802222728729,
0.5535697340965271,
0.3805985748767853,
-0.35401371121406555,
-0.30783939361572266,
-0.007558576762676239,
0.10780616849660873,
-0.7493841648101807,
-1.0009565353393555,
0.25432226061820984,
0.24232915043830872,
0.23298512399196625,
0.3704513609409332,
0.009079228155314922,
0.8511675000190735,
-0.4922175705432892,
0.9757331013679504,
0.003122955095022917,
-1.2919819355010986,
0.6219390034675598,
-0.47861436009407043,
0.5525216460227966,
0.5049703121185303,
-0.08778472989797592,
-0.4548937678337097,
-0.7271102070808411,
-0.5968077778816223,
-0.7885523438453674,
0.5774403810501099,
0.0646369606256485,
0.2960721552371979,
-0.2990795373916626,
0.38068142533302307,
0.09709420055150986,
0.3419490456581116,
-0.8839159607887268,
-0.10388337075710297,
-0.39268729090690613,
-0.4478966295719147,
0.14885129034519196,
-0.8072667717933655,
-0.12359948456287384,
-0.2576577961444855,
0.3505205810070038,
-0.18787707388401031,
0.4368758499622345,
0.38464343547821045,
0.08177303522825241,
-0.3960469663143158,
0.42551669478416443,
0.49896419048309326,
0.7070291042327881,
0.031917572021484375,
0.6299206018447876,
-0.1481190323829651,
-0.3345617353916168,
0.2780214548110962,
0.05137915536761284,
-0.20496918261051178,
-0.03406750410795212,
0.5032806396484375,
0.7324519157409668,
0.4403831958770752,
-0.546042799949646,
0.8899003267288208,
-0.1527605950832367,
-0.3701740801334381,
-0.4638722538948059,
0.010687964968383312,
0.05850296840071678,
0.520285964012146,
0.053507279604673386,
0.06934945285320282,
0.6092969179153442,
-0.26668745279312134,
0.547957718372345,
0.516183078289032,
-0.2433444857597351,
-0.29778242111206055,
0.611188530921936,
-0.167165145277977,
0.01750043034553528,
0.34849387407302856,
-0.2888222634792328,
-0.7817862629890442,
0.29889997839927673,
0.7181355953216553,
0.8600962162017822,
-0.27649813890457153,
0.31019267439842224,
0.31435707211494446,
0.018780648708343506,
0.25778892636299133,
0.36424586176872253,
-0.10463673621416092,
-0.5140471458435059,
-0.5995647311210632,
-0.8155511617660522,
-0.29572582244873047,
-0.15857011079788208,
-0.696142315864563,
0.3181474208831787,
-0.16239584982395172,
-0.1783231496810913,
0.07183221727609634,
-0.20095445215702057,
-0.17002253234386444,
0.11494167149066925,
-0.046351686120033264,
0.4002649784088135,
-0.7178286910057068,
0.5945570468902588,
0.9970595836639404,
-0.16808828711509705,
-0.7383060455322266,
0.1503809690475464,
-0.14976201951503754,
-0.6539570689201355,
0.593187689781189,
0.14895473420619965,
0.09270928800106049,
-0.020740259438753128,
-0.10166510939598083,
-1.1108375787734985,
1.0308929681777954,
0.5656682252883911,
-0.32674655318260193,
-0.018018363043665886,
0.3844127953052521,
0.49359938502311707,
-0.5686520338058472,
0.015397085808217525,
0.5442453622817993,
0.5169098973274231,
0.33985671401023865,
-0.780733585357666,
0.373488187789917,
0.14531932771205902,
0.19586822390556335,
0.4101835787296295,
-0.3882766664028168,
1.0265276432037354,
0.008591641671955585,
-0.18952283263206482,
0.03734169155359268,
0.8441734910011292,
0.01535087265074253,
0.3098287582397461,
0.3859243094921112,
0.9434118866920471,
0.6286231875419617,
-0.09615731239318848,
0.6731885075569153,
-0.08087194710969925,
0.18037328124046326,
1.251470685005188,
-0.059052757918834686,
0.842166006565094,
0.5581462383270264,
-0.3239794373512268,
0.9080606698989868,
0.48277220129966736,
0.16479213535785675,
0.5719809532165527,
0.2738645672798157,
-0.44212472438812256,
-0.2739885151386261,
0.013508151285350323,
-0.21883535385131836,
0.8621513247489929,
0.469499796628952,
-0.43905436992645264,
-0.41877231001853943,
0.3097035884857178,
-0.2757744789123535,
0.22528772056102753,
0.21816079318523407,
1.217074990272522,
0.2994990646839142,
-0.7604314684867859,
0.5384141206741333,
0.10943535715341568,
0.16889242827892303,
-0.5588377118110657,
-0.04269259050488472,
0.22665506601333618,
0.2568282186985016,
-0.15672554075717926,
-0.846023678779602,
0.8513582348823547,
-0.5428209900856018,
-0.18221168220043182,
-0.015735719352960587,
0.8345966339111328,
-0.4472910761833191,
-0.2660571336746216,
0.26681914925575256,
0.7373401522636414,
-0.24709858000278473,
-0.21541330218315125,
-0.563062846660614,
-0.06145082414150238,
-0.22752396762371063,
-0.4932907223701477,
0.09227531403303146,
0.9400656819343567,
0.14657196402549744,
0.39842814207077026,
0.168466255068779,
-0.021814147010445595,
0.018663855269551277,
-0.038580697029829025,
1.112663984298706,
-0.9201473593711853,
-0.5798211693763733,
-0.8875797390937805,
0.6143277883529663,
-0.1134689673781395,
-0.03874753415584564,
0.5500612854957581,
0.6589290499687195,
0.5505180954933167,
0.038710981607437134,
0.6622404456138611,
-0.32603511214256287,
0.38474756479263306,
-0.3886803388595581,
0.21627849340438843,
-0.4984686076641083,
0.2631455957889557,
0.04256331920623779,
-0.9135270118713379,
-0.5766547322273254,
0.8784675002098083,
-0.3655608594417572,
0.00939206499606371,
1.0602561235427856,
0.5115718841552734,
-0.3717396557331085,
0.2666708827018738,
0.5071372985839844,
0.26427116990089417,
0.5485084056854248,
0.4935416579246521,
0.9371384978294373,
-0.41140443086624146,
0.061119694262742996,
-0.3802162706851959,
-0.35171300172805786,
0.015434140339493752,
-0.7572828531265259,
-0.6716424226760864,
-0.6651305556297302,
-0.20194387435913086,
-0.2423112541437149,
-0.10908757150173187,
0.6399258971214294,
0.7445343732833862,
-0.7181864976882935,
-0.20421257615089417,
-0.5960049033164978,
-0.05563873425126076,
-0.09441956132650375,
-0.290719598531723,
0.28017908334732056,
-0.6523623466491699,
-0.42836806178092957,
0.3866698443889618,
0.4252457916736603,
0.14233945310115814,
-0.3135119378566742,
0.13179384171962738,
-0.08716388046741486,
0.19413761794567108,
0.9958858489990234,
-0.37078529596328735,
-0.7447355389595032,
-0.4171803295612335,
-0.1576988399028778,
-0.04349058121442795,
0.2386329025030136,
0.9954161047935486,
-0.8293451070785522,
0.3173062801361084,
0.511078417301178,
0.46137943863868713,
0.2963758409023285,
-0.0590481273829937,
0.745210587978363,
-0.7365530729293823,
-0.01481954101473093,
0.6049944162368774,
0.5809553861618042,
0.2624437212944031,
-0.2495916336774826,
0.5961155891418457,
0.40011897683143616,
-0.6131526231765747,
-0.73172926902771,
0.630276083946228,
-1.3294848203659058,
-0.4132397472858429,
1.0297406911849976,
-0.09690209478139877,
-0.33987343311309814,
-0.08013778179883957,
-0.20339514315128326,
0.22670142352581024,
-0.30494654178619385,
0.3261948823928833,
0.6386430859565735,
-0.2764416038990021,
0.06928066909313202,
-0.5131682753562927,
0.2713128626346588,
0.6386140584945679,
-0.575343132019043,
0.4609132707118988,
0.638775646686554,
-0.008214788511395454,
0.22556732594966888,
0.5485439896583557,
-0.35708245635032654,
0.23607008159160614,
0.0076116533018648624,
-0.5158611536026001,
0.22629696130752563,
-0.14133179187774658,
-0.30220577120780945,
0.36460018157958984,
0.2715321183204651,
0.004894590005278587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01897v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01897v1 | Proposal Report for the 2nd SciCAP Competition 2024 | 2024-07-02T02:42:29 | 2024-07-02T02:42:29 | Pengpeng Li, Tingmin Li, Jingyuan Wang, Boyuan Wang, Yang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we propose a method for document summarization using auxiliary
information. This approach effectively summarizes descriptions related to
specific images, tables, and appendices within lengthy texts. Our experiments
demonstrate that leveraging high-quality OCR data and initially extracted
information from the original text enables efficient summarization of the
content related to described objects. Based on these findings, we enhanced
popular text generation model models by incorporating additional auxiliary
branches to improve summarization performance. Our method achieved top scores
of 4.33 and 4.66 in the long caption and short caption tracks, respectively, of
the 2024 SciCAP competition, ranking highest in both categories. | [
-0.31581470370292664,
-0.1463802456855774,
0.5241679549217224,
0.16769258677959442,
-0.47895798087120056,
0.3506648540496826,
-0.02670997567474842,
-1.0632034540176392,
0.343095600605011,
0.2491111010313034,
-0.16984279453754425,
-0.27895188331604004,
-0.41516533493995667,
0.5018187165260315,
-0.4859892427921295,
0.9153555035591125,
-0.160994753241539,
-0.12727750837802887,
-0.6002405881881714,
0.014412231743335724,
-0.4424683749675751,
-0.187656432390213,
-0.43496423959732056,
0.1762852966785431,
0.5383545160293579,
0.6752303242683411,
0.23874874413013458,
0.7846840023994446,
1.0600656270980835,
0.32104137539863586,
-0.09239273518323898,
0.5130949020385742,
-0.13069652020931244,
0.16304826736450195,
-0.08989217132329941,
-0.6272150874137878,
-0.6505905985832214,
-0.06199375167489052,
0.8784643411636353,
0.43891486525535583,
0.3034175932407379,
-0.060323912650346756,
-0.02903897687792778,
0.45267748832702637,
-0.3019125759601593,
0.43779054284095764,
-0.477224200963974,
0.11871271580457687,
-0.1082562804222107,
-0.7089002132415771,
-0.5400908589363098,
-0.18630242347717285,
-0.03407737985253334,
-0.5839710235595703,
0.5698899626731873,
0.40601080656051636,
1.0045734643936157,
-0.10147323459386826,
-0.08474359661340714,
-0.46383047103881836,
-0.4222191572189331,
0.545600414276123,
-0.610598623752594,
-0.14281295239925385,
0.2939755618572235,
0.27482032775878906,
0.1347312182188034,
-1.0314948558807373,
-0.39663079380989075,
-0.07070139795541763,
-0.27185410261154175,
0.5129919648170471,
-0.30988624691963196,
-0.024563932791352272,
0.07822227478027344,
0.470650851726532,
-0.41782599687576294,
0.16555878520011902,
-1.1843187808990479,
-0.20631290972232819,
0.7887734770774841,
0.39296239614486694,
0.3353549540042877,
0.05064733698964119,
-0.050409749150276184,
0.03541060537099838,
-0.5390323400497437,
0.021209802478551865,
0.41398340463638306,
0.13600505888462067,
-0.15322662889957428,
1.159980058670044,
-0.4844353199005127,
0.29900553822517395,
-0.2033938467502594,
-0.06424739211797714,
0.18263734877109528,
-0.8980616331100464,
0.21156062185764313,
0.32558462023735046,
0.6651600003242493,
0.8859755992889404,
-0.3498055338859558,
0.0378560908138752,
-0.04577559605240822,
-0.056389205157756805,
-0.012827529571950436,
-0.9073501825332642,
-0.18742366135120392,
0.27141809463500977,
-0.5788285732269287,
-0.38961419463157654,
-0.07177857309579849,
-0.7862696051597595,
-0.1515122950077057,
-0.2586028575897217,
0.04234280437231064,
-0.37756776809692383,
0.4427776038646698,
-0.24710778892040253,
-0.7828906178474426,
0.032685160636901855,
0.47678837180137634,
-0.9067261219024658,
0.3242332637310028,
0.44502130150794983,
1.4375865459442139,
-0.3930433988571167,
-0.2518341541290283,
-0.4460797905921936,
0.2426302582025528,
-0.19390656054019928,
1.2294691801071167,
-0.19400647282600403,
-0.5536295771598816,
-0.2247588187456131,
0.03228266164660454,
0.3155643939971924,
0.09001918137073517,
0.5600741505622864,
-0.4754069149494171,
0.443665474653244,
-0.2930507957935333,
-0.2981583774089813,
0.07197890430688858,
-0.08140943199396133,
-0.7037766575813293,
0.7305862903594971,
-0.011338640004396439,
-1.0933064222335815,
0.40287265181541443,
-0.6839301586151123,
-0.757114052772522,
0.3928470313549042,
-0.2154437005519867,
-0.6119626760482788,
0.22350521385669708,
0.3473331332206726,
0.3502858877182007,
-0.22654537856578827,
-0.1461092233657837,
-0.0013242664281278849,
-0.46383804082870483,
-0.0009358153329230845,
0.0762333795428276,
0.331554651260376,
0.19220589101314545,
0.016131684184074402,
0.3220319449901581,
-0.3800016939640045,
-0.4575526714324951,
0.23991696536540985,
-0.26946932077407837,
-0.15649037063121796,
0.021655915305018425,
-0.1194203794002533,
-0.11203673481941223,
0.33522844314575195,
-0.6152781248092651,
0.4069000780582428,
-0.3971419930458069,
0.6592037081718445,
0.4919586181640625,
0.14432241022586823,
0.7124908566474915,
-0.48839831352233887,
0.39361119270324707,
-0.46224135160446167,
0.09275846928358078,
-0.8288891315460205,
-0.5776837468147278,
-0.558976948261261,
-0.5556460618972778,
0.40716832876205444,
0.17427067458629608,
-0.7078289985656738,
0.39839333295822144,
-0.2550373673439026,
-0.6153486371040344,
-0.010375713929533958,
-0.47706902027130127,
0.09869412332773209,
0.73687744140625,
0.45066598057746887,
-0.45649561285972595,
-0.8846938610076904,
-0.895635187625885,
0.13099811971187592,
-0.22505013644695282,
-0.07155900448560715,
0.17257648706436157,
0.7186757326126099,
0.16376164555549622,
0.8777156472206116,
-0.9411348700523376,
-0.5813282132148743,
-0.5646750926971436,
0.48207229375839233,
0.2883330285549164,
0.33643803000450134,
0.6337869763374329,
-0.6735277771949768,
-0.4324752986431122,
-0.006977049168199301,
-0.6110780239105225,
0.06895915418863297,
0.040363579988479614,
-0.1152699887752533,
0.2629469931125641,
0.551511824131012,
-0.6789709329605103,
0.48287272453308105,
0.12640705704689026,
-0.2851231098175049,
0.7307268977165222,
-0.6155881881713867,
0.5044702887535095,
-0.8443589806556702,
0.3643007278442383,
-0.4135870337486267,
-0.015798743814229965,
-0.23378221690654755,
0.04274154081940651,
0.15857671201229095,
-0.35180482268333435,
-0.2766003906726837,
0.2339867502450943,
-0.6683467030525208,
-0.08559685200452805,
-0.42406848073005676,
0.187494695186615,
0.1898835003376007,
0.19621612131595612,
0.5323419570922852,
0.7309256792068481,
0.15231813490390778,
-0.4514895975589752,
0.315807580947876,
0.5035271048545837,
-0.5161784887313843,
0.26713576912879944,
-0.9826122522354126,
-0.16974107921123505,
-0.550748884677887,
0.6503164172172546,
-1.2988641262054443,
-0.7884945869445801,
-0.2223520427942276,
-0.6756230592727661,
0.40304410457611084,
0.42074456810951233,
-0.34104976058006287,
-0.5419756770133972,
-0.8004096150398254,
0.23221534490585327,
0.5210906267166138,
-0.23479130864143372,
0.7286601066589355,
0.48224204778671265,
-0.803554356098175,
-0.45208004117012024,
-0.7545156478881836,
0.23238836228847504,
-0.12165267765522003,
-0.5119904279708862,
0.6921287775039673,
-0.04711386188864708,
0.15218573808670044,
-0.05214511975646019,
0.20489704608917236,
0.1799841821193695,
-0.1359848827123642,
0.19327344000339508,
0.518116295337677,
0.023219125345349312,
-0.09060520678758621,
0.37864071130752563,
0.12297223508358002,
-0.08047711104154587,
0.06827343255281448,
0.5092271566390991,
0.11153638362884521,
0.1839597076177597,
-0.1624782383441925,
0.7789744138717651,
0.45241931080818176,
-0.22856557369232178,
0.3230641484260559,
0.2141241580247879,
-0.25708499550819397,
0.15132342278957367,
-0.31768283247947693,
-0.1196410283446312,
-0.4175088703632355,
0.5328081250190735,
-0.19592083990573883,
-0.5743790864944458,
0.5511488318443298,
0.36380743980407715,
0.5141265392303467,
0.7425252795219421,
0.3922979235649109,
-0.49541082978248596,
1.0838897228240967,
0.70442795753479,
0.07321268320083618,
0.4857640564441681,
-0.318010151386261,
0.12580513954162598,
-0.7519924640655518,
-0.643771767616272,
-0.8970763683319092,
-0.15006132423877716,
-0.11261385679244995,
-0.41834115982055664,
0.4776987135410309,
-0.08568451553583145,
0.37193238735198975,
0.7361876964569092,
-0.6548030972480774,
0.6197593212127686,
0.5686562657356262,
0.04241993650794029,
0.4144115746021271,
0.11873749643564224,
0.07474341243505478,
-0.046119917184114456,
-0.6904008388519287,
-0.34105199575424194,
0.948828399181366,
0.47064217925071716,
0.4197969138622284,
0.01921098493039608,
0.7060524225234985,
0.5766283869743347,
0.23410369455814362,
-0.6861897706985474,
0.4602201282978058,
0.01785174384713173,
-0.4073795974254608,
-0.44356122612953186,
-0.10694004595279694,
-0.7220851182937622,
0.24033933877944946,
-0.19023527204990387,
-0.4521268904209137,
0.3924678564071655,
0.08873701840639114,
-0.4969944357872009,
-0.17140384018421173,
-0.4594934582710266,
0.32427147030830383,
-0.17077481746673584,
-0.15842939913272858,
-0.1457294374704361,
-0.7775880694389343,
0.41895467042922974,
0.033347275108098984,
0.5006816983222961,
0.06472276896238327,
-0.2681751251220703,
1.0456743240356445,
-0.5617740154266357,
0.46224626898765564,
0.17902453243732452,
0.3446909785270691,
0.4253407418727875,
-0.4325023889541626,
0.6368180513381958,
0.08680657297372818,
0.12688378989696503,
-0.08441818505525589,
-0.1575363129377365,
-0.23808032274246216,
-0.30104464292526245,
0.46962618827819824,
-0.48618224263191223,
-0.19637449085712433,
-0.7355221509933472,
-0.6073347330093384,
0.22027947008609772,
0.39027759432792664,
0.7713586091995239,
0.40777137875556946,
-0.05617829039692879,
0.21776258945465088,
0.4231213331222534,
-0.0951613187789917,
0.6973204612731934,
0.49166426062583923,
0.2632741630077362,
-0.7354130148887634,
0.8964759707450867,
0.16422511637210846,
0.12646976113319397,
0.48227086663246155,
0.19576619565486908,
-0.33010798692703247,
-0.7421173453330994,
-0.2235846072435379,
0.20349246263504028,
-0.7086083292961121,
-0.5108689069747925,
-0.9971774220466614,
-0.033277321606874466,
-0.7228409051895142,
-0.5279025435447693,
-0.10487042367458344,
-0.7600590586662292,
-0.4181441068649292,
-0.1468222290277481,
0.05536472424864769,
0.5197489261627197,
-0.16502748429775238,
0.2383514791727066,
-0.5736177563667297,
0.34505635499954224,
-0.04285259544849396,
-0.10577297955751419,
-0.16135011613368988,
-0.5880226492881775,
-0.19699087738990784,
-0.32170790433883667,
-0.2940562665462494,
-0.558417558670044,
0.45276913046836853,
0.3180006146430969,
0.48771026730537415,
0.15644679963588715,
-0.003210337134078145,
0.5388113856315613,
-0.6659450531005859,
1.0698939561843872,
0.6626054644584656,
-0.6815446615219116,
0.6603822708129883,
-0.3888781666755676,
0.46729761362075806,
0.6260585784912109,
0.39329439401626587,
0.060555581003427505,
-0.593369722366333,
-0.4365922510623932,
-1.2402362823486328,
0.7326379418373108,
0.3214135766029358,
0.009121455252170563,
0.0787242129445076,
-0.10548928380012512,
0.1481357365846634,
0.19922243058681488,
-0.46318867802619934,
0.2158564329147339,
-0.004840236157178879,
-0.2991982400417328,
-0.02911961078643799,
-0.48608940839767456,
0.02706049010157585,
-0.12070311605930328,
0.6641566157341003,
-0.11521705240011215,
0.5262897610664368,
0.3369928002357483,
0.02265959605574608,
0.20394384860992432,
0.06192460283637047,
0.97011798620224,
0.6746213436126709,
-0.2550901770591736,
0.05871402844786644,
0.22314631938934326,
-0.6655468344688416,
-0.19960524141788483,
0.06854266673326492,
-0.1598382294178009,
0.29201504588127136,
0.9510858654975891,
0.41007986664772034,
0.19663278758525848,
-0.770453691482544,
0.5419204235076904,
-0.2711678147315979,
-0.4987710416316986,
-0.2857814431190491,
-0.097201868891716,
-0.17114271223545074,
0.03237348049879074,
0.7236227989196777,
0.05620066076517105,
0.7053952217102051,
-0.7869720458984375,
0.22810253500938416,
0.1496840864419937,
-0.24771089851856232,
-0.2808725833892822,
0.6553931832313538,
0.33781346678733826,
0.14229652285575867,
0.264438271522522,
0.17988727986812592,
-0.40555471181869507,
0.7694807052612305,
0.5155521631240845,
0.41651779413223267,
-0.08892293274402618,
0.03778785839676857,
0.5709405541419983,
0.36864134669303894,
-0.1480696052312851,
0.332474023103714,
-0.3771234154701233,
0.1107584536075592,
-0.5559990406036377,
-0.3547009527683258,
-0.5947139859199524,
-0.3703799247741699,
-0.39143234491348267,
0.5776503682136536,
-0.10560673475265503,
-0.024629348888993263,
0.30059733986854553,
-0.2021663337945938,
-0.38768383860588074,
0.0908355712890625,
-0.09545168280601501,
1.0411522388458252,
-0.7300621867179871,
0.26167744398117065,
0.3039007782936096,
-0.6779303550720215,
-0.3807673454284668,
-0.6845341324806213,
-0.5345162749290466,
-0.333416223526001,
0.5541906356811523,
0.12438813596963882,
-0.0016404156340286136,
-0.29409393668174744,
-0.5193969011306763,
-0.8519759178161621,
1.3580143451690674,
-0.1085229367017746,
-0.5237013697624207,
-0.5501739978790283,
-0.13420484960079193,
0.35711461305618286,
-0.4312009811401367,
0.7252633571624756,
0.44827044010162354,
0.2891203463077545,
0.3947543799877167,
-0.7372989058494568,
-0.10186292976140976,
-0.46679139137268066,
-0.14019843935966492,
-0.10024690628051758,
-0.6735245585441589,
0.763649582862854,
-0.48781830072402954,
-0.46153950691223145,
0.550977349281311,
1.2236979007720947,
0.29234856367111206,
0.5560339093208313,
0.029289251193404198,
-0.12573206424713135,
0.5171777606010437,
-0.17340105772018433,
0.9807301759719849,
-0.032039131969213486,
0.007420336827635765,
1.5234575271606445,
-0.1352151781320572,
0.8034535646438599,
0.45923635363578796,
-0.11176210641860962,
0.21857303380966187,
0.5181474685668945,
-0.16632111370563507,
0.839726984500885,
0.059820424765348434,
-0.004011223558336496,
0.3734515607357025,
-0.40945154428482056,
-0.6444988250732422,
0.508791983127594,
0.33932429552078247,
-0.7568159103393555,
-0.15817391872406006,
0.15045276284217834,
-0.2591354548931122,
-0.03508409857749939,
-0.3160010874271393,
0.8843538165092468,
-0.03165147081017494,
-0.8938698172569275,
0.03177359700202942,
0.22614270448684692,
0.47975799441337585,
-0.6139616370201111,
-0.3179377019405365,
-0.2325602024793625,
0.03324032202363014,
-0.30236151814460754,
-0.8090863227844238,
0.3201814889907837,
0.012228935956954956,
-0.139559805393219,
0.12020573019981384,
0.6889327168464661,
-0.4080740511417389,
-0.40139642357826233,
-0.3933677077293396,
-0.5899521708488464,
0.28507715463638306,
0.2197151929140091,
0.0628017708659172,
0.3045007586479187,
-0.2820805013179779,
0.08884567767381668,
0.11643917858600616,
-0.03257879987359047,
-0.18154358863830566,
0.2175282984972,
0.5219986438751221,
-0.03494247794151306,
-0.25919005274772644,
-0.14263451099395752,
0.9569037556648254,
-0.2989221215248108,
-1.0712498426437378,
-0.568544864654541,
0.8332727551460266,
-0.7377438545227051,
-0.32701432704925537,
0.8519026041030884,
1.1506041288375854,
0.29674333333969116,
-0.3861421048641205,
1.0590564012527466,
-0.21283923089504242,
0.42060279846191406,
-0.5064542293548584,
0.5762966871261597,
-0.18384715914726257,
-0.03457412123680115,
-0.3000730276107788,
-0.7798922061920166,
-0.3282598555088043,
0.4467340111732483,
-0.04484732076525688,
-0.45571234822273254,
0.7668541669845581,
0.21327191591262817,
0.06365139782428741,
0.28442519903182983,
-0.14842215180397034,
-0.19331493973731995,
0.36048269271850586,
0.4598574638366699,
0.7951217293739319,
-0.5573748350143433,
0.5221604704856873,
-0.3442121148109436,
-0.6487216353416443,
-0.6173838973045349,
-0.9382901787757874,
-1.1442433595657349,
-0.7282382249832153,
-0.36516672372817993,
-0.2265666425228119,
-0.04778645187616348,
0.3635213077068329,
0.5121068358421326,
-0.7997696995735168,
-0.07264619320631027,
-0.12284893542528152,
-0.2130667120218277,
0.07611068338155746,
-0.17969754338264465,
0.6499549746513367,
-0.19757594168186188,
-0.7550926208496094,
0.50458163022995,
0.46517330408096313,
0.1437682956457138,
0.01597670651972294,
0.09979758411645889,
-0.0014798793708905578,
0.11528491228818893,
0.7770155072212219,
0.3522587716579437,
-0.34128615260124207,
-0.12022503465414047,
0.06618881225585938,
0.09065760672092438,
-0.308125376701355,
0.9631323218345642,
-0.27539440989494324,
0.4549243152141571,
0.9151666760444641,
0.10811203718185425,
0.7700601816177368,
0.2362019270658493,
0.6929695010185242,
-0.5609355568885803,
0.25497445464134216,
0.3546765446662903,
0.41565465927124023,
0.028822610154747963,
-0.692013144493103,
0.6075425148010254,
-0.01916547678411007,
-0.5035035014152527,
-1.063710331916809,
-0.12993083894252777,
-1.219146490097046,
-0.25945767760276794,
0.7139331102371216,
-0.15014739334583282,
-0.3253311812877655,
-0.04170482978224754,
-0.6244611144065857,
0.19536826014518738,
-0.5062181949615479,
0.6931777596473694,
0.4629877209663391,
-0.32963255047798157,
0.0023638089187443256,
-0.05460170656442642,
0.3053387403488159,
-0.039549387991428375,
-1.0847675800323486,
-0.21324887871742249,
0.653954029083252,
-0.06942498683929443,
0.5354801416397095,
0.7023881077766418,
-0.43970873951911926,
0.6220315098762512,
0.188865527510643,
0.06377175450325012,
-0.6037029027938843,
-0.5755443572998047,
0.01720181293785572,
0.4707235097885132,
-0.09055512398481369,
-0.16334185004234314
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01896v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01896v1 | LogEval: A Comprehensive Benchmark Suite for Large Language Models In Log Analysis | 2024-07-02T02:39:33 | 2024-07-02T02:39:33 | Tianyu Cui, Shiyu Ma, Ziang Chen, Tong Xiao, Shimin Tao, Yilun Liu, Shenglin Zhang, Duoming Lin, Changchang Liu, Yuzhe Cai, Weibin Meng, Yongqian Sun, Dan Pei | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Log analysis is crucial for ensuring the orderly and stable operation of
information systems, particularly in the field of Artificial Intelligence for
IT Operations (AIOps). Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated
significant potential in natural language processing tasks. In the AIOps
domain, they excel in tasks such as anomaly detection, root cause analysis of
faults, operations and maintenance script generation, and alert information
summarization. However, the performance of current LLMs in log analysis tasks
remains inadequately validated. To address this gap, we introduce LogEval, a
comprehensive benchmark suite designed to evaluate the capabilities of LLMs in
various log analysis tasks for the first time. This benchmark covers tasks such
as log parsing, log anomaly detection, log fault diagnosis, and log
summarization. LogEval evaluates each task using 4,000 publicly available log
data entries and employs 15 different prompts for each task to ensure a
thorough and fair assessment. By rigorously evaluating leading LLMs, we
demonstrate the impact of various LLM technologies on log analysis performance,
focusing on aspects such as self-consistency and few-shot contextual learning.
We also discuss findings related to model quantification, Chinese-English
question-answering evaluation, and prompt engineering. These findings provide
insights into the strengths and weaknesses of LLMs in multilingual environments
and the effectiveness of different prompt strategies. Various evaluation
methods are employed for different tasks to accurately measure the performance
of LLMs in log analysis, ensuring a comprehensive assessment. The insights
gained from LogEvals evaluation reveal the strengths and limitations of LLMs in
log analysis tasks, providing valuable guidance for researchers and
practitioners. | [
0.1522454023361206,
-0.9253270626068115,
0.19420962035655975,
0.5628402233123779,
-0.18836039304733276,
0.33491313457489014,
-0.3049105107784271,
-0.6127040386199951,
-0.19258169829845428,
0.35256654024124146,
-0.42288488149642944,
-0.822233259677887,
-0.40714791417121887,
0.20690113306045532,
-0.4953870177268982,
0.9721148610115051,
0.02928377129137516,
-0.041034843772649765,
-0.44530224800109863,
-0.34577563405036926,
-0.8933774828910828,
-0.7077549695968628,
-0.8438119292259216,
0.18044623732566833,
0.15805131196975708,
0.13587148487567902,
0.3821088969707489,
0.3326224982738495,
0.7499881386756897,
0.2982563376426697,
0.003327168058604002,
0.08268238604068756,
-0.42119306325912476,
0.24230922758579254,
0.06347265094518661,
-0.40822693705558777,
-0.6549575328826904,
-0.5074627995491028,
1.0671440362930298,
0.5532459616661072,
-0.25575464963912964,
0.45156192779541016,
0.10358025878667831,
0.6215813159942627,
-0.4818659722805023,
0.26546362042427063,
-0.7259522080421448,
-0.040237076580524445,
-0.2815173864364624,
0.011231242679059505,
-0.48767608404159546,
-0.376657634973526,
-0.05560838803648949,
-0.27632713317871094,
0.10061131417751312,
0.2113024890422821,
0.4535241723060608,
0.26642000675201416,
-0.43557071685791016,
-0.2588164508342743,
-0.4311242699623108,
1.0486730337142944,
-1.015923023223877,
0.4286547899246216,
0.14563648402690887,
0.3772304952144623,
-0.1297646164894104,
-0.6938087940216064,
-0.263551265001297,
-0.3012388050556183,
-0.36758825182914734,
-0.23300839960575104,
-0.18953897058963776,
0.025165732949972153,
0.23793452978134155,
0.20776860415935516,
-0.9720784425735474,
0.4602371156215668,
-0.30925339460372925,
-0.15862247347831726,
0.9171210527420044,
0.5648220777511597,
0.1911618411540985,
-0.15412096679210663,
-0.30126073956489563,
-0.04114418104290962,
-0.6122081875801086,
0.12013140320777893,
-0.1554342657327652,
0.33760595321655273,
0.052188754081726074,
0.2347344607114792,
-0.21505048871040344,
0.8533609509468079,
-0.48965173959732056,
-0.33482542634010315,
0.29609012603759766,
-0.2829059660434723,
-0.4187700152397156,
0.07674997299909592,
0.8296083211898804,
0.36747607588768005,
-0.08987141400575638,
0.05114230141043663,
-0.3882227838039398,
-0.055225227028131485,
-0.025408660992980003,
-0.8013254404067993,
-0.12009324133396149,
0.40829941630363464,
-0.5731358528137207,
-0.18082627654075623,
-0.32983145117759705,
-0.8677594065666199,
-0.5866209864616394,
-0.07550644129514694,
0.1582389920949936,
-0.10379888117313385,
-0.35325783491134644,
-0.005085757002234459,
0.2980383634567261,
0.23976300656795502,
0.2952234148979187,
-0.6765018701553345,
0.5826954245567322,
0.9681635499000549,
0.8638904690742493,
-0.4852219521999359,
-0.4394828975200653,
-1.106906533241272,
-0.12524622678756714,
-0.4348292648792267,
0.6558613181114197,
-0.5122928023338318,
-0.4428337812423706,
0.22786329686641693,
0.05918268486857414,
-0.28536561131477356,
-0.7382542490959167,
0.7065378427505493,
-0.5782602429389954,
-0.031596675515174866,
0.0571136474609375,
-0.7466566562652588,
-0.17092496156692505,
0.3984840512275696,
-0.695184588432312,
1.2255135774612427,
-0.11804039776325226,
-0.4110879898071289,
0.2893035411834717,
-0.6685476303100586,
-0.5321998000144958,
0.35776400566101074,
-0.2671336531639099,
-0.3024584650993347,
0.12440100312232971,
0.1609426587820053,
0.506970226764679,
-0.5711724162101746,
0.5095221996307373,
-0.028099479153752327,
-0.18063297867774963,
0.0210029985755682,
-0.436849981546402,
0.8379721641540527,
0.14522269368171692,
-0.3458852171897888,
0.3049943447113037,
-0.7000952959060669,
0.1955418586730957,
0.07453501224517822,
-0.29398787021636963,
-0.18730653822422028,
0.19525334239006042,
0.145480215549469,
-0.013622150756418705,
0.3662351369857788,
-0.31016188859939575,
0.19548945128917694,
-0.12724652886390686,
0.02969263307750225,
0.6373478770256042,
-0.1605517417192459,
-0.21662163734436035,
0.00762223033234477,
0.5911452174186707,
-0.25852856040000916,
0.1663678139448166,
-0.6178276538848877,
-0.26139065623283386,
-0.5687711238861084,
-0.3543796241283417,
0.17189949750900269,
0.7592534422874451,
-0.03806229308247566,
0.36019060015678406,
-0.3371744751930237,
-0.508802056312561,
-0.4582120478153229,
0.5258996486663818,
0.4680628180503845,
0.3581622540950775,
0.2530444860458374,
-0.013709809631109238,
-0.5568773746490479,
-0.8154711723327637,
-0.6377711892127991,
-0.3989558517932892,
-0.08777095377445221,
0.05212073028087616,
0.20576897263526917,
-0.1653553545475006,
0.61590176820755,
-0.4189438223838806,
-0.4259856343269348,
-0.25948280096054077,
0.19360356032848358,
0.45523524284362793,
0.2979772388935089,
0.36309704184532166,
-0.6632283926010132,
-0.71010822057724,
0.32189077138900757,
-0.9785581827163696,
-0.06881844252347946,
-0.23708683252334595,
0.19456353783607483,
0.5287733674049377,
0.6612892150878906,
-0.6313148140907288,
0.18414995074272156,
0.5775055885314941,
-0.4698799252510071,
0.6097265481948853,
-0.002239031018689275,
0.14988146722316742,
-0.6456222534179688,
0.39162981510162354,
-0.0835677981376648,
-0.3263644278049469,
-0.7037884593009949,
0.19543811678886414,
0.2285432666540146,
-0.1469835489988327,
-0.25153541564941406,
0.7387934923171997,
-0.36994802951812744,
-0.2676098942756653,
-0.0721815675497055,
0.27043190598487854,
0.06920011341571808,
0.19103214144706726,
-0.10356120765209198,
0.6424893736839294,
0.5595440864562988,
-0.4892444610595703,
0.5535505414009094,
0.08925759792327881,
-0.5531619191169739,
0.4941737651824951,
-0.7345559000968933,
0.19153402745723724,
-0.0013429205864667892,
-0.035610225051641464,
-1.1689891815185547,
-0.09348603338003159,
-0.29852768778800964,
-0.2283650040626526,
0.35193145275115967,
0.09581412374973297,
-0.6669490933418274,
-0.19244445860385895,
-0.2533947229385376,
0.35441267490386963,
0.5304940938949585,
-0.5581516623497009,
0.6261436343193054,
0.24715131521224976,
-0.3735980987548828,
-0.5769670009613037,
-0.22655634582042694,
0.2926492393016815,
-0.39256495237350464,
-0.7054936289787292,
0.04106749966740608,
-0.19892562925815582,
-0.6325640678405762,
-0.05889008194208145,
-0.0894009917974472,
-0.12149959057569504,
0.2557261884212494,
-0.030270133167505264,
0.550713300704956,
-0.4673427939414978,
0.3434098958969116,
-0.26462432742118835,
-0.015683235600590706,
0.16563230752944946,
-0.16240255534648895,
0.31701791286468506,
-0.5103664994239807,
-0.37081849575042725,
-0.4356100857257843,
0.17542633414268494,
0.5818634629249573,
-0.32977792620658875,
0.6279321312904358,
0.3148250877857208,
-0.4220295548439026,
0.07418480515480042,
-0.8756144642829895,
0.14465825259685516,
-0.43339988589286804,
0.6157323122024536,
-0.2581532299518585,
-0.6687375903129578,
0.35194262862205505,
-0.09413817524909973,
0.6180248856544495,
0.6597363948822021,
0.30885228514671326,
0.10867465287446976,
0.9653265476226807,
0.6035836338996887,
-0.5941752195358276,
0.11552198231220245,
0.16787442564964294,
0.19544894993305206,
-0.49924272298812866,
-0.3245594799518585,
-0.5864964723587036,
-0.020289231091737747,
-0.2946888208389282,
-0.3002474009990692,
0.42807456851005554,
0.1756073236465454,
0.010627473704516888,
-0.005301769822835922,
-0.1838032752275467,
0.5970638394355774,
0.018008172512054443,
-0.49409210681915283,
0.6755097508430481,
-0.09172897040843964,
0.25609925389289856,
-0.045316603034734726,
-0.5201056599617004,
-0.6711973547935486,
0.9406937956809998,
0.45642146468162537,
0.6206133961677551,
0.131747767329216,
0.39271876215934753,
0.6487705111503601,
0.30511829257011414,
-0.6866161823272705,
0.5911674499511719,
-0.16742800176143646,
-0.5117339491844177,
-0.4732532501220703,
-0.22597238421440125,
-0.898291826248169,
0.3599575459957123,
0.07045705616474152,
-0.9552472829818726,
-0.2921106517314911,
0.14035572111606598,
-0.2588658034801483,
0.28913411498069763,
-0.7504517436027527,
1.1122496128082275,
-0.5262975096702576,
-0.2566577196121216,
-0.4731391370296478,
-0.4494798481464386,
0.40315577387809753,
-0.31966614723205566,
0.48469552397727966,
-0.07611705362796783,
-0.10017353296279907,
0.7938682436943054,
-0.14165446162223816,
0.8484814167022705,
-0.16189037263393402,
-0.1715392768383026,
0.25217846035957336,
0.2718326151371002,
0.7442252039909363,
0.06861528754234314,
-0.37507542967796326,
0.361530601978302,
0.30295825004577637,
-0.41723451018333435,
-0.6296512484550476,
0.8702317476272583,
-0.43202725052833557,
-0.7029115557670593,
-0.28821301460266113,
-0.20485417544841766,
-0.12198344618082047,
0.19444765150547028,
-0.11069248616695404,
0.55071622133255,
-0.37245091795921326,
0.27502724528312683,
0.49878185987472534,
-0.1265581250190735,
0.5599270462989807,
0.5139173269271851,
-0.5505796074867249,
-0.1723715364933014,
0.7625141143798828,
-0.16948141157627106,
0.23885323107242584,
0.4414982497692108,
0.06451503932476044,
-0.2733544409275055,
-0.5539321303367615,
-0.4593125283718109,
0.07843280583620071,
-0.9032841920852661,
-0.28359052538871765,
-0.6063857078552246,
-0.18865877389907837,
-0.10574004799127579,
0.02248443104326725,
-0.34140530228614807,
-0.25900372862815857,
0.04167000204324722,
-0.026467151939868927,
0.20643334090709686,
0.7433684468269348,
0.3559400141239166,
0.14987482130527496,
-0.9866653680801392,
0.0039469473995268345,
0.19129422307014465,
0.22912687063217163,
0.14741304516792297,
-0.2945615351200104,
-0.3050827085971832,
-0.41065657138824463,
-0.10144365578889847,
-0.49243003129959106,
0.26854002475738525,
0.38598719239234924,
0.6764434576034546,
0.29283154010772705,
-0.012480179779231548,
0.6102680563926697,
-0.4426634907722473,
0.8775421977043152,
0.08758056163787842,
-0.9951369166374207,
0.5973350405693054,
-0.07143797725439072,
0.34197282791137695,
0.5389570593833923,
0.33301520347595215,
-0.7260030508041382,
-0.17095717787742615,
-0.40734559297561646,
-0.7296673655509949,
0.561440646648407,
-0.0324435792863369,
0.005702956113964319,
0.10896863788366318,
0.02819780632853508,
0.2511030435562134,
0.31074240803718567,
-0.6962658762931824,
-0.05361481383442879,
0.15841645002365112,
-0.19373781979084015,
-0.32642993330955505,
-0.27567100524902344,
-0.09346766024827957,
-0.09983161091804504,
0.6232318878173828,
-0.22856511175632477,
-0.1587856560945511,
-0.043902814388275146,
-0.4025602638721466,
-0.0565127395093441,
0.07386375218629837,
0.40547120571136475,
0.8903493881225586,
-0.1268523782491684,
0.028350070118904114,
0.6439071893692017,
-0.26254215836524963,
-0.17298898100852966,
0.027613308280706406,
0.22841474413871765,
0.19604520499706268,
0.854350209236145,
0.7561097741127014,
0.08852078020572662,
-1.20196533203125,
0.40599721670150757,
-0.12075173854827881,
0.29300838708877563,
-0.35839977860450745,
-0.045594505965709686,
-0.048034101724624634,
0.23595485091209412,
0.632964551448822,
-0.36151185631752014,
0.23794662952423096,
-0.47823071479797363,
-0.04247645288705826,
0.6474201679229736,
-0.16583335399627686,
-0.33828431367874146,
0.27212396264076233,
0.15543922781944275,
-0.4707697331905365,
0.7029238939285278,
0.04413200914859772,
-0.35739976167678833,
0.6705392003059387,
0.549832820892334,
0.9477041959762573,
-0.4656917154788971,
0.022307436913251877,
0.5587522983551025,
0.5781092047691345,
0.17898447811603546,
0.08811924606561661,
0.0757787674665451,
-0.17839214205741882,
-0.536697268486023,
-0.6819579601287842,
-0.25202637910842896,
0.26038604974746704,
-0.42148110270500183,
0.43437904119491577,
-0.49867039918899536,
0.1293468326330185,
-0.21066153049468994,
0.0863892138004303,
-0.7295673489570618,
0.16596895456314087,
-0.15865914523601532,
0.9626928567886353,
-0.676572859287262,
0.4579169452190399,
0.552376389503479,
0.15040606260299683,
-0.3863048851490021,
-0.031044190749526024,
0.14865805208683014,
-0.7269812822341919,
0.873085081577301,
0.2801944315433502,
0.037205908447504044,
-0.20246651768684387,
-0.26347342133522034,
-0.731184184551239,
0.963616132736206,
0.08653964102268219,
-0.7527548670768738,
0.11469440162181854,
0.14536692202091217,
0.6258381605148315,
-0.33863699436187744,
0.4422732889652252,
0.7372283935546875,
0.3511039912700653,
-0.18634165823459625,
-1.1396492719650269,
0.20769433677196503,
-0.2929416000843048,
-0.0352323055267334,
0.23484283685684204,
-0.6904067993164062,
0.6174046397209167,
-0.07339087128639221,
-0.29626643657684326,
0.013153075240552425,
0.43501919507980347,
0.30876755714416504,
0.47182005643844604,
0.5310415029525757,
0.0020851693116128445,
1.10994553565979,
0.24086390435695648,
1.0400220155715942,
-0.29531705379486084,
0.2236870974302292,
1.0728862285614014,
-0.5126340389251709,
1.2008012533187866,
0.21701869368553162,
-0.34433019161224365,
0.5762618780136108,
0.4574615955352783,
0.09817702323198318,
0.14489248394966125,
0.0900217667222023,
-0.4693244397640228,
-0.209742471575737,
-0.218233123421669,
-0.35184547305107117,
0.26004478335380554,
0.4415551424026489,
0.007901191711425781,
-0.21232280135154724,
-0.22118927538394928,
-0.1632469892501831,
-0.05984773859381676,
-0.2206028550863266,
0.856102466583252,
0.05470370873808861,
-0.573613703250885,
0.7924832701683044,
-0.05962487310171127,
0.3193596601486206,
-0.8417625427246094,
0.0023401668295264244,
-0.3684227764606476,
0.19396299123764038,
-0.37631461024284363,
-0.49969765543937683,
0.37092599272727966,
0.2120731920003891,
0.15797868371009827,
0.11981765925884247,
0.8079904317855835,
-0.010094460099935532,
-0.5853605270385742,
0.3649488091468811,
0.32162049412727356,
0.2044021338224411,
-0.022523852065205574,
-0.44098135828971863,
0.44342559576034546,
-0.08183537423610687,
-0.12923096120357513,
0.31126144528388977,
0.32403939962387085,
-0.34369292855262756,
0.7981977462768555,
0.4815748929977417,
-0.03479449078440666,
0.11995593458414078,
-0.09038104116916656,
0.7242227792739868,
-0.762793242931366,
-0.25159895420074463,
-1.1807401180267334,
0.7159133553504944,
-0.3330036997795105,
-0.2776337265968323,
0.8689668774604797,
0.8875275254249573,
0.5585363507270813,
0.005060319323092699,
0.760509192943573,
0.162043035030365,
0.3573388159275055,
-0.6449123024940491,
0.35978585481643677,
-0.5047751069068909,
0.5082321763038635,
-0.2852528691291809,
-1.1290833950042725,
-0.4611261785030365,
0.2797885239124298,
-0.17489533126354218,
-0.1943010836839676,
0.8947868943214417,
0.6219710111618042,
0.14385713636875153,
0.1344277709722519,
0.5066905617713928,
0.2566508650779724,
0.5308969616889954,
0.3916662931442261,
0.8549420237541199,
-0.403592973947525,
0.5778174996376038,
0.20539699494838715,
-0.33036571741104126,
-0.3033883273601532,
-1.09369957447052,
-1.1096762418746948,
-0.4368909001350403,
-0.38917189836502075,
0.036129117012023926,
0.12069287896156311,
0.9214275479316711,
0.5471007227897644,
-0.9701232314109802,
-0.7446085214614868,
0.036120034754276276,
0.1638304591178894,
-0.16872619092464447,
-0.22096411883831024,
0.5136426687240601,
-0.730085551738739,
-0.5195655822753906,
0.677456259727478,
0.4482983350753784,
-0.40766528248786926,
-0.3757432699203491,
-0.12180410325527191,
-0.03386090695858002,
-0.2596173584461212,
0.8164132237434387,
0.2674051523208618,
-0.7167878746986389,
0.07682838290929794,
0.15000930428504944,
0.08313494175672531,
-0.015797173604369164,
0.7377972602844238,
-0.6670940518379211,
0.5106905102729797,
0.44302892684936523,
1.0254199504852295,
0.4562273621559143,
-0.13866791129112244,
0.4409850239753723,
-0.7777534127235413,
-0.021145742386579514,
0.18060657382011414,
0.18426570296287537,
0.455938458442688,
-0.4585225582122803,
0.5770033597946167,
-0.06511600315570831,
-0.636330783367157,
-1.0960290431976318,
-0.1043960228562355,
-0.4847720265388489,
-0.21325932443141937,
1.024700403213501,
-0.21645072102546692,
0.0008750888518989086,
-0.03088151104748249,
-0.32566002011299133,
-0.2008320838212967,
-0.14159266650676727,
0.7056390047073364,
0.8476926684379578,
-0.14999574422836304,
-0.06894785910844803,
-0.7966627478599548,
0.4498414099216461,
0.7198769450187683,
-1.121597170829773,
0.44128236174583435,
0.5795141458511353,
0.11741384118795395,
0.08912406861782074,
0.6755226254463196,
0.04117546230554581,
0.11428196728229523,
-0.1626850664615631,
-0.24891093373298645,
0.2986392080783844,
-0.367147296667099,
-0.6890857219696045,
0.05441220477223396,
0.5091808438301086,
0.020145324990153313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01892v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01892v1 | GRASP: A Grid-Based Benchmark for Evaluating Commonsense Spatial Reasoning | 2024-07-02T02:27:46 | 2024-07-02T02:27:46 | Zhisheng Tang, Mayank Kejriwal | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Spatial reasoning, an important faculty of human cognition with many
practical applications, is one of the core commonsense skills that is not
purely language-based and, for satisfying (as opposed to optimal) solutions,
requires some minimum degree of planning. Existing benchmarks of Commonsense
Spatial Reasoning (CSR) tend to evaluate how Large Language Models (LLMs)
interpret text-based spatial descriptions rather than directly evaluate a plan
produced by the LLM in response to a spatial reasoning scenario. In this paper,
we construct a large-scale benchmark called $\textbf{GRASP}$, which consists of
16,000 grid-based environments where the agent is tasked with an energy
collection problem. These environments include 100 grid instances instantiated
using each of the 160 different grid settings, involving five different energy
distributions, two modes of agent starting position, and two distinct obstacle
configurations, as well as three kinds of agent constraints. Using GRASP, we
compare classic baseline approaches, such as random walk and greedy search
methods, with advanced LLMs like GPT-3.5-Turbo and GPT-4o. The experimental
results indicate that even these advanced LLMs struggle to consistently achieve
satisfactory solutions. | [
-0.5014075040817261,
-0.1467345505952835,
0.8459309935569763,
0.013198092579841614,
0.11730706691741943,
-0.2502194046974182,
-0.3557811379432678,
-0.26023775339126587,
-0.3142887353897095,
0.11236121505498886,
-0.19814574718475342,
-0.6473059058189392,
-0.5046161413192749,
0.11493587493896484,
0.031868912279605865,
0.5095900297164917,
-0.0670049786567688,
-0.06816332787275314,
-0.4075281322002411,
-0.18564358353614807,
-0.3525922894477844,
0.0546766072511673,
-0.30352628231048584,
-0.6168665289878845,
0.47240594029426575,
0.4952850937843323,
0.938928484916687,
0.25563761591911316,
0.3024975061416626,
0.37110161781311035,
-0.17332319915294647,
0.18727141618728638,
-0.5236109495162964,
-0.2941058874130249,
-0.5558468103408813,
-0.13684357702732086,
-0.28797969222068787,
0.16510993242263794,
0.5677131414413452,
0.6020177602767944,
-0.2599566876888275,
0.028589431196451187,
-0.18496480584144592,
0.4048413932323456,
-1.0394723415374756,
-0.0683075487613678,
-0.8078403472900391,
0.11479628086090088,
0.022009316831827164,
0.09575501084327698,
-0.24622492492198944,
-0.31606101989746094,
-0.029442114755511284,
-0.9512955546379089,
0.060156624764204025,
0.16421952843666077,
0.9929120540618896,
0.016621805727481842,
-0.4579108953475952,
0.03240858390927315,
-0.287276953458786,
0.9811606407165527,
-0.6409369707107544,
0.3703460097312927,
0.6005246043205261,
0.7404007315635681,
-0.1029399037361145,
-0.46613818407058716,
-0.5350286960601807,
-0.25046083331108093,
0.04115999862551689,
0.2001677006483078,
-0.07002332806587219,
0.02698558010160923,
0.6276498436927795,
-0.22612738609313965,
-0.638497531414032,
0.14262090623378754,
-0.30368712544441223,
-0.054547663778066635,
0.78642737865448,
0.3712305724620819,
0.04789132624864578,
-0.3164607584476471,
-0.7873610258102417,
-0.19519029557704926,
-0.6509201526641846,
-0.14068499207496643,
0.13411496579647064,
0.2463982254266739,
-0.06319455802440643,
0.5179958939552307,
-0.3460085988044739,
0.6870068311691284,
-0.2866995334625244,
0.13610130548477173,
0.12601079046726227,
-0.336690217256546,
-0.22606582939624786,
-0.4033950865268707,
0.608610212802887,
0.6148358583450317,
0.5179436802864075,
-0.1414376050233841,
-0.522634744644165,
-0.32486867904663086,
0.21918511390686035,
-0.30378997325897217,
-0.394334614276886,
0.11269746720790863,
-0.33640390634536743,
0.20931372046470642,
-0.3277800679206848,
-0.6807170510292053,
-0.5991562604904175,
-0.47188466787338257,
0.13925552368164062,
-0.48006945848464966,
-0.3497692346572876,
0.3644031584262848,
-0.42011919617652893,
0.6948075294494629,
0.5124059319496155,
-0.6880164742469788,
0.5506210923194885,
1.038085699081421,
1.0100992918014526,
-0.22018292546272278,
-0.5231686234474182,
-0.4166943430900574,
0.12171973288059235,
-0.10947972536087036,
1.010522484779358,
-0.5528833270072937,
-0.43936994671821594,
-0.08032936602830887,
-0.4316613972187042,
-0.326436847448349,
-0.5588956475257874,
0.4406222701072693,
-0.42911744117736816,
-0.40385499596595764,
-0.9278681874275208,
-0.44001832604408264,
0.09708516299724579,
0.601942241191864,
-0.5666090846061707,
0.9604617357254028,
0.1489787995815277,
-0.5164998173713684,
0.8212260603904724,
-0.5416917204856873,
-0.199149489402771,
0.4416566789150238,
-0.19707536697387695,
-0.006539918482303619,
0.01143844984471798,
0.12564578652381897,
0.31483370065689087,
-0.34163713455200195,
0.19695952534675598,
-0.5327748656272888,
-0.306493878364563,
0.025921054184436798,
-0.33278414607048035,
0.4748034179210663,
0.5396241545677185,
-0.12395933270454407,
-0.019392773509025574,
-0.42558473348617554,
0.32134220004081726,
0.241324782371521,
0.020420510321855545,
-0.3919321894645691,
0.13706399500370026,
0.09501946717500687,
0.14759106934070587,
0.4759194552898407,
-0.49073469638824463,
0.1671801507472992,
0.015008576214313507,
0.12571164965629578,
0.572431743144989,
-0.21245263516902924,
0.4802318215370178,
-0.4067491292953491,
0.4759102463722229,
-0.3272939920425415,
0.011696450412273407,
0.3730818033218384,
-0.0873812809586525,
-0.10441694408655167,
-0.16358038783073425,
-0.28402742743492126,
0.48621800541877747,
-0.6708662509918213,
0.14516960084438324,
-0.5542635321617126,
-0.6569692492485046,
0.27302828431129456,
-0.006738675758242607,
0.5200949907302856,
0.14372093975543976,
0.40558815002441406,
0.18312105536460876,
0.01691220887005329,
-0.7156510353088379,
-0.6348342299461365,
0.1517554223537445,
-0.11389970034360886,
0.8793712854385376,
0.6660058498382568,
0.2986645996570587,
1.0252692699432373,
-0.5810131430625916,
-0.0553908497095108,
-0.3068288564682007,
0.166444793343544,
0.14445483684539795,
0.242059588432312,
0.5667588114738464,
-0.7105182409286499,
-0.3741820752620697,
0.34929507970809937,
-0.7896965742111206,
-0.2044697254896164,
-0.15019400417804718,
0.014144325628876686,
-0.2983799874782562,
0.5125643014907837,
-0.9203426241874695,
0.3890160322189331,
0.11560423672199249,
-0.46319758892059326,
0.8956629633903503,
-0.23519079387187958,
0.02005706913769245,
-0.3821069598197937,
0.4268002510070801,
0.19485455751419067,
-0.1090763732790947,
-0.2846992313861847,
0.04275920242071152,
0.04008833318948746,
-0.289104163646698,
-0.6127442121505737,
0.8616306185722351,
-0.9155964851379395,
-0.660435676574707,
-0.061271511018276215,
0.5553901195526123,
-0.046003248542547226,
0.4103859066963196,
0.16911566257476807,
0.9487927556037903,
0.1391497254371643,
-0.49288037419319153,
0.22056853771209717,
0.15334215760231018,
-0.5765362977981567,
0.7105457186698914,
-0.7184847593307495,
0.10709641873836517,
-0.01966453529894352,
0.10532066971063614,
-0.9280465841293335,
-0.1476566046476364,
-0.34352433681488037,
-0.2105550765991211,
0.070383220911026,
0.10951368510723114,
-0.47484323382377625,
-0.5241698622703552,
-0.14279693365097046,
0.3752650320529938,
0.1147892028093338,
-0.5865381956100464,
0.45133206248283386,
0.2363753616809845,
0.19085843861103058,
-0.6951795816421509,
-0.30814090371131897,
0.1737087219953537,
-0.332277774810791,
-0.3261825442314148,
-0.23142899572849274,
0.22210046648979187,
-0.44487449526786804,
-0.05331860110163689,
-0.32499051094055176,
-0.0009780563414096832,
0.2207946926355362,
-0.2660825848579407,
-0.23780763149261475,
0.11518310755491257,
-0.03985169529914856,
-0.0950721800327301,
-0.09030722081661224,
0.23577021062374115,
-0.10702043026685715,
0.33241504430770874,
-0.2751484513282776,
-0.5900485515594482,
0.04634958133101463,
0.08823038637638092,
0.6761888265609741,
0.04029478877782822,
0.24500906467437744,
0.18805992603302002,
-0.3247477412223816,
-0.43967920541763306,
-0.4185881018638611,
0.14213861525058746,
-0.5052610039710999,
0.5120941996574402,
-0.9154101610183716,
-0.44186025857925415,
0.441279798746109,
-0.5118471384048462,
0.20608052611351013,
0.11843772232532501,
0.024945581331849098,
0.01533762738108635,
0.7775014638900757,
-0.1806432604789734,
-0.10173109918832779,
0.09542802721261978,
-0.36381006240844727,
-0.1599626988172531,
-0.9154930114746094,
-0.051350586116313934,
-0.6854298114776611,
-0.5114394426345825,
-0.0016426444053649902,
-0.6356056928634644,
0.4328457713127136,
0.11576741933822632,
-0.5814608931541443,
0.6391412019729614,
-0.43015068769454956,
0.7701120376586914,
0.27245864272117615,
-0.04979732632637024,
0.013277960941195488,
-0.13506200909614563,
-0.47585511207580566,
0.027549318969249725,
-0.7977975010871887,
-0.5238959789276123,
0.8091596961021423,
0.146318718791008,
0.5322574973106384,
0.2734317481517792,
0.4840451180934906,
0.274762898683548,
0.30418509244918823,
-0.5815541744232178,
0.9233771562576294,
0.0056717973202466965,
-0.32991278171539307,
-0.4240434467792511,
-0.542188823223114,
-1.2866714000701904,
0.6804450154304504,
0.01715398207306862,
-0.9941533803939819,
0.06046086549758911,
0.11509574204683304,
-0.06335293501615524,
0.5509498715400696,
-0.6299989819526672,
0.9881443977355957,
-0.41522806882858276,
-0.7375031113624573,
-0.29353559017181396,
-0.3023913502693176,
0.271721214056015,
0.4616524577140808,
0.18491223454475403,
-0.4823557734489441,
-0.32630982995033264,
0.2339702993631363,
-0.5235465168952942,
0.6259828805923462,
-0.7606071829795837,
-0.13305866718292236,
0.34174031019210815,
0.14243006706237793,
0.748779296875,
-0.1755913496017456,
-0.17706364393234253,
0.20017828047275543,
-0.02973087504506111,
-0.6763976812362671,
-0.5949593186378479,
0.6890213489532471,
-0.7803746461868286,
-0.4572640359401703,
-0.40375959873199463,
-0.5385390520095825,
-0.5159754157066345,
0.3116298019886017,
0.3616858422756195,
0.2523212432861328,
-0.5585692524909973,
-0.289542555809021,
0.5085698962211609,
-0.19867943227291107,
0.3626428246498108,
0.45675089955329895,
0.011013648472726345,
-0.3955250382423401,
0.6052333116531372,
-0.06176016107201576,
0.3364768624305725,
0.4727364778518677,
0.3137083649635315,
-0.7670786380767822,
-0.7398374080657959,
-0.3540568947792053,
0.05666578561067581,
-0.6166521906852722,
-0.5762557983398438,
-0.4846087396144867,
0.028885802254080772,
-0.15599460899829865,
-0.6606878638267517,
-0.26594120264053345,
-0.020234093070030212,
-0.030809367075562477,
-0.11143011599779129,
0.28884321451187134,
0.6851832270622253,
-0.2511940598487854,
0.14934498071670532,
-0.6307205557823181,
0.16448292136192322,
0.3364555537700653,
0.5560353398323059,
0.24675621092319489,
-0.12842854857444763,
-0.10520504415035248,
-0.02276509813964367,
-0.19562771916389465,
-0.709099292755127,
0.2688544988632202,
-0.12468130141496658,
0.7093496322631836,
0.44039759039878845,
0.04703240841627121,
0.5090203881263733,
-0.2950405776500702,
0.7276347279548645,
0.43793123960494995,
-0.7787516117095947,
0.3843999207019806,
-0.9120693802833557,
0.864995002746582,
0.7047332525253296,
0.24386784434318542,
-0.41552817821502686,
-0.02304014563560486,
-0.4025160074234009,
-0.7083398699760437,
0.37862759828567505,
-0.0738830640912056,
-0.2598864734172821,
-0.3392643928527832,
0.12710782885551453,
-0.03546613082289696,
0.009326038882136345,
-0.4997885227203369,
0.2517673969268799,
0.008318835869431496,
0.12306047976016998,
-0.019464053213596344,
-0.005171879194676876,
-0.049848828464746475,
-0.06553597003221512,
0.26486754417419434,
-0.2897464632987976,
0.17686757445335388,
0.05083359032869339,
-0.1605953723192215,
0.17017507553100586,
0.3613084852695465,
0.5368359088897705,
0.6552945971488953,
-0.11107981950044632,
0.250685453414917,
0.6150327324867249,
-0.4610859453678131,
-0.012013152241706848,
0.036287665367126465,
-0.08173777163028717,
-0.31982383131980896,
0.24439463019371033,
0.5328192114830017,
0.6024494171142578,
-0.8160338997840881,
0.5881156921386719,
0.2649364471435547,
-0.6113903522491455,
-0.14332951605319977,
0.027843235060572624,
0.04493838921189308,
0.08148890733718872,
0.2149091362953186,
-0.009842532686889172,
0.370478093624115,
0.08091108500957489,
0.15986225008964539,
0.6843551397323608,
-0.1777302771806717,
-0.18697874248027802,
0.4887230694293976,
0.2501066029071808,
0.00011229142546653748,
0.6627740263938904,
-0.5812528729438782,
-0.5552189946174622,
0.8450090885162354,
0.46114304661750793,
0.9093971848487854,
0.30305469036102295,
0.18466351926326752,
0.7514843344688416,
0.195317804813385,
-0.11942361295223236,
0.4086247682571411,
-0.5723824501037598,
-0.9338147044181824,
-0.39800432324409485,
-0.3438374698162079,
-0.4687145948410034,
-0.09072292596101761,
-0.6426498293876648,
0.02115069329738617,
-0.43794286251068115,
-0.18721641600131989,
-0.3433261215686798,
0.38222408294677734,
-0.8481147885322571,
-0.05399452522397041,
0.047819338738918304,
1.3926211595535278,
-0.7804346084594727,
0.38698092103004456,
0.9437268376350403,
0.06681656837463379,
-0.6249793767929077,
-0.3597371280193329,
0.1490391194820404,
-0.8896506428718567,
0.5904403328895569,
-0.03509822115302086,
-0.37778469920158386,
-0.31125378608703613,
-0.8339353799819946,
-1.1397255659103394,
1.1439270973205566,
-0.0333072654902935,
-0.7669399380683899,
0.352048397064209,
-0.029136933386325836,
0.34687304496765137,
0.15774716436862946,
0.4841732978820801,
0.7039470672607422,
0.9161856174468994,
0.18939068913459778,
-1.0583257675170898,
0.12834329903125763,
-0.2635500133037567,
0.13730855286121368,
0.44650593400001526,
-0.7985702157020569,
0.5723129510879517,
-0.5025435090065002,
-0.5056945085525513,
0.25983622670173645,
0.5654349327087402,
0.7834604382514954,
0.7686747312545776,
0.6349035501480103,
0.9079663753509521,
0.7904551029205322,
-0.050288017839193344,
0.962106466293335,
0.07107945531606674,
0.4889393448829651,
1.220073938369751,
-0.8391546010971069,
0.9191274046897888,
0.10215520113706589,
-0.5835580229759216,
0.11139842122793198,
0.2339572012424469,
-0.019398599863052368,
0.4543052315711975,
0.7265241742134094,
-0.28688928484916687,
-0.2911885380744934,
0.04062756523489952,
-0.26260480284690857,
0.47344425320625305,
0.6311737298965454,
0.44706469774246216,
-0.6562801003456116,
-0.03388761729001999,
0.13966208696365356,
0.6226723194122314,
-0.5657132267951965,
0.6777249574661255,
0.03491290658712387,
-0.8085719347000122,
0.5002985596656799,
-0.4620964527130127,
0.5436694622039795,
-0.3694092333316803,
0.09563227742910385,
-0.13061536848545074,
0.25279518961906433,
-0.016084130853414536,
-1.112876296043396,
0.10398221760988235,
-0.011781057342886925,
0.10157221555709839,
-0.4036419987678528,
0.8905838131904602,
-0.0016107000410556793,
0.053792186081409454,
0.3019360601902008,
0.5261733531951904,
0.5231859087944031,
0.09764602780342102,
-0.7631199955940247,
0.03342292457818985,
-0.2776354253292084,
-0.13301847875118256,
0.4363655745983124,
0.7777050137519836,
0.015592401847243309,
0.72892165184021,
0.406762033700943,
0.16566058993339539,
-0.19520138204097748,
-0.003872765228152275,
0.7822636365890503,
-0.8050345778465271,
-0.30866214632987976,
-0.17404863238334656,
-0.03983510658144951,
-0.43594789505004883,
-0.5392311215400696,
0.7511417865753174,
0.6774301528930664,
0.7093638181686401,
0.09105556458234787,
0.7556357979774475,
-0.08706633746623993,
0.2698586583137512,
-0.46869462728500366,
0.5237956047058105,
-0.48485079407691956,
0.20633052289485931,
-0.1941148042678833,
-0.838470995426178,
-0.0063269613310694695,
0.6775310039520264,
-0.9203290939331055,
0.47587743401527405,
0.5232885479927063,
0.4144406020641327,
-0.22306454181671143,
-0.012303099036216736,
0.6732539534568787,
0.005813548807054758,
0.1219838336110115,
1.0521286725997925,
1.0564337968826294,
-0.029493242502212524,
0.3838459253311157,
0.20196597278118134,
-0.21033702790737152,
0.11558087915182114,
-0.944382905960083,
-0.6692625880241394,
-0.11006978899240494,
-0.0933397188782692,
-0.10078971832990646,
0.06853698194026947,
0.7235093116760254,
0.7108908891677856,
-0.5190752148628235,
-0.34929996728897095,
-0.34913215041160583,
0.2305593341588974,
-0.6296355128288269,
-0.22967231273651123,
0.2921120524406433,
-0.4902448356151581,
-0.6070103049278259,
0.43210840225219727,
0.1344670057296753,
-0.2120690494775772,
-0.047117140144109726,
-0.2789974808692932,
-0.2785545885562897,
-0.14949211478233337,
0.5010529160499573,
0.7164870500564575,
-0.5568549036979675,
-0.32601267099380493,
0.048221390694379807,
-0.23036059737205505,
-0.19435995817184448,
0.9023975133895874,
-0.834518551826477,
0.33585911989212036,
0.5423361659049988,
0.4341656267642975,
0.6156995296478271,
0.16873356699943542,
0.4689805805683136,
-0.612001895904541,
-0.0870366096496582,
0.28525033593177795,
0.4536675810813904,
0.20232771337032318,
-0.17019332945346832,
0.4492053687572479,
0.07006722688674927,
-0.6827505826950073,
-0.37161704897880554,
0.24606430530548096,
-1.052709698677063,
-0.4908007085323334,
1.3878471851348877,
-0.2120470106601715,
-0.17378634214401245,
-0.292032390832901,
0.06668666750192642,
-0.35631734132766724,
-0.544769823551178,
0.3912125527858734,
0.43893563747406006,
-0.0009548254311084747,
-0.21201416850090027,
-0.34840458631515503,
0.3110158145427704,
0.534648060798645,
-0.6721251606941223,
0.4705214202404022,
0.8696152567863464,
0.1473791003227234,
0.016249332576990128,
0.7843649387359619,
0.09806817024946213,
0.4407947361469269,
0.49844813346862793,
0.06637692451477051,
-0.12779100239276886,
-0.28099337220191956,
-0.14169523119926453,
0.18670639395713806,
0.08596634864807129,
-0.1549362689256668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01887v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01887v1 | Beyond Numeric Awards: In-Context Dueling Bandits with LLM Agents | 2024-07-02T02:18:14 | 2024-07-02T02:18:14 | Fanzeng Xia, Hao Liu, Yisong Yue, Tongxin Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In-context decision-making is an important capability of artificial general
intelligence, which Large Language Models (LLMs) have effectively demonstrated
in various scenarios. However, LLMs often face challenges when dealing with
numerical contexts, and limited attention has been paid to evaluating their
performance through preference feedback generated by the environment. This
paper investigates the performance of LLMs as decision-makers in the context of
Dueling Bandits (DB). We first evaluate the performance of LLMs by comparing
GPT-3.5-Turbo, GPT-4, and GPT-4-Turbo against established DB algorithms. Our
results reveal that LLMs, particularly GPT-4 Turbo, quickly identify the
Condorcet winner, thus outperforming existing state-of-the-art algorithms in
terms of weak regret. Nevertheless, LLMs struggle to converge even when
explicitly prompted to do so, and are sensitive to prompt variations. To
overcome these issues, we introduce an LLM-augmented algorithm, IF-Enhanced
LLM, which takes advantage of both in-context decision-making capabilities of
LLMs and theoretical guarantees inherited from classic DB algorithms. The
design of such an algorithm sheds light on how to enhance trustworthiness for
LLMs used in decision-making tasks where performance robustness matters. We
show that IF-Enhanced LLM has theoretical guarantees on both weak and strong
regret. Our experimental results validate that IF-Enhanced LLM is robust even
with noisy and adversarial prompts. | [
-0.42526039481163025,
-0.6550487875938416,
0.7593138217926025,
0.21302589774131775,
-0.14279696345329285,
0.53459632396698,
-0.6317339539527893,
-0.480949342250824,
0.1111508160829544,
0.42642197012901306,
-0.2340756356716156,
-0.4467546045780182,
-0.8460034728050232,
0.3027896285057068,
-0.04819178208708763,
1.1520930528640747,
-0.06077359616756439,
-0.02639603242278099,
-0.41594821214675903,
-0.07848186045885086,
-0.5250899195671082,
-0.7800230979919434,
-1.0173771381378174,
-0.38209068775177,
0.4117662310600281,
0.13280050456523895,
0.7988006472587585,
0.15658056735992432,
0.36577680706977844,
0.4823901951313019,
-0.2134218066930771,
0.14102455973625183,
-0.5128487348556519,
0.14782632887363434,
-0.241375133395195,
-0.7201582193374634,
-0.4091198146343231,
-0.05379539355635643,
0.6248186230659485,
0.20647607743740082,
-0.049263548105955124,
-0.41472798585891724,
0.2016836255788803,
0.6586565375328064,
-0.6325461864471436,
0.3730969727039337,
-0.9042364358901978,
-0.1434641182422638,
-0.27160751819610596,
-0.28934216499328613,
-0.304644376039505,
-0.6290135979652405,
0.2689262330532074,
-0.38778114318847656,
-0.2086183726787567,
-0.08559831976890564,
0.6939003467559814,
0.39432770013809204,
-0.17841151356697083,
-0.5203267335891724,
-0.5124402046203613,
0.7288487553596497,
-0.6030407547950745,
0.013950060121715069,
0.3471910357475281,
0.24953143298625946,
-0.3069773316383362,
-0.49795177578926086,
-0.27522775530815125,
-0.48568567633628845,
-0.039193496108055115,
0.10237123817205429,
-0.23789222538471222,
0.3249799907207489,
0.30093613266944885,
0.0025729292538017035,
-0.10494839400053024,
0.34697675704956055,
-0.09919528663158417,
-0.1273949295282364,
0.6787700057029724,
0.1557670384645462,
-0.10962977260351181,
-0.1505270004272461,
-0.32833364605903625,
-0.09604440629482269,
-0.7043207287788391,
0.47686341404914856,
0.35773658752441406,
0.3026999235153198,
0.07742886990308762,
0.3601319193840027,
-0.18844203650951385,
0.6633427739143372,
0.31689155101776123,
-0.2805345058441162,
-0.05800474435091019,
-0.22231240570545197,
-0.09596811234951019,
0.2474503219127655,
0.6894760131835938,
0.4254087507724762,
0.38452067971229553,
-0.3532983958721161,
-0.5084275007247925,
0.054345108568668365,
0.0616450272500515,
-0.7477205395698547,
-0.04706312716007233,
0.18009448051452637,
-0.051935452967882156,
-0.4147803485393524,
-0.008295582607388496,
-0.681666910648346,
-0.5963765382766724,
-0.24999697506427765,
0.7453584671020508,
-0.450432687997818,
-0.042018093168735504,
-0.012702017091214657,
-0.36345505714416504,
0.3554615080356598,
0.3099605441093445,
-0.7670374512672424,
0.26103031635284424,
0.7954245805740356,
0.8386391401290894,
-0.2291707694530487,
-0.17730151116847992,
-0.7232948541641235,
0.10607276856899261,
-0.4029553532600403,
0.6816644072532654,
-0.7048031091690063,
-0.7063382267951965,
-0.09333110600709915,
-0.3680277168750763,
-0.0781932920217514,
-0.6252095103263855,
0.8708664178848267,
-0.8017047643661499,
0.0492778979241848,
-0.47585609555244446,
-0.4883667230606079,
-0.27600160241127014,
0.3137318193912506,
-0.47127941250801086,
0.6096218228340149,
0.15373897552490234,
-0.5563269853591919,
0.6415495872497559,
-0.6175727844238281,
-0.35971692204475403,
0.21654699742794037,
-0.33083558082580566,
-0.39205825328826904,
-0.016106117516756058,
0.1495225429534912,
0.40462422370910645,
-0.3534669578075409,
0.37870684266090393,
-0.6491934061050415,
-0.553472638130188,
0.5569813847541809,
-0.5178960561752319,
0.7180625796318054,
-0.12629586458206177,
-0.5344061851501465,
0.21018482744693756,
-0.29886287450790405,
0.1765352338552475,
-0.05884654447436333,
-0.43450942635536194,
-0.2901155352592468,
0.12072017043828964,
-0.5351120233535767,
-0.036673013120889664,
0.16801121830940247,
-0.3298386335372925,
0.23490311205387115,
-0.4063083827495575,
0.5339345335960388,
1.1195237636566162,
-0.1528870016336441,
0.4582633674144745,
-0.3945951461791992,
0.4782446026802063,
-0.2963111400604248,
-0.10820892453193665,
0.10924217104911804,
-0.38952502608299255,
-0.7378861308097839,
-0.4022495746612549,
0.725055992603302,
0.6859189867973328,
-1.0210455656051636,
0.35879817605018616,
-0.33320489525794983,
-0.10612265020608902,
-0.3396858274936676,
0.11600453406572342,
0.39941978454589844,
0.19042474031448364,
-0.06733084470033646,
-0.31583261489868164,
-0.4192158877849579,
-0.7978641390800476,
-0.4343767464160919,
-0.20833736658096313,
-0.00824645534157753,
0.5687369704246521,
0.22938266396522522,
-0.19705703854560852,
0.9291087985038757,
-0.05297716706991196,
-0.09197018295526505,
-0.21320849657058716,
-0.024096187204122543,
0.3216749429702759,
0.10886664688587189,
0.6112971901893616,
-0.6320430636405945,
-0.5398455262184143,
0.11471021175384521,
-0.7943865060806274,
-0.08772613108158112,
-0.057030100375413895,
0.09647759795188904,
0.4483504891395569,
0.2677806317806244,
-0.7317651510238647,
0.31175321340560913,
0.351396381855011,
-0.17477333545684814,
0.4914136826992035,
-0.26177024841308594,
0.2595611810684204,
-0.5088261365890503,
-0.2672230303287506,
0.004199910443276167,
-0.21970689296722412,
-0.3500402569770813,
-0.06867871433496475,
0.05506345257163048,
0.28384116291999817,
-0.07502972334623337,
0.47272366285324097,
-0.3361276090145111,
-0.2321329414844513,
-0.2968248128890991,
0.2903558611869812,
-0.30520719289779663,
0.504305899143219,
0.12325434386730194,
0.87814861536026,
0.7445182204246521,
-0.637044370174408,
0.3713080585002899,
-0.15412622690200806,
-0.4199562668800354,
0.8533576726913452,
-0.6019357442855835,
0.11509253829717636,
-0.07369605451822281,
0.4501667618751526,
-0.8687920570373535,
-0.21559017896652222,
0.08613167703151703,
-0.5976463556289673,
0.5529056787490845,
-0.12909461557865143,
-0.33046987652778625,
-0.23987853527069092,
-0.5659551024436951,
0.15717780590057373,
0.43988871574401855,
-0.7068054676055908,
0.6349727511405945,
0.31428152322769165,
-0.4198102653026581,
-0.6505249738693237,
-0.331289142370224,
0.5103524923324585,
-0.6092109680175781,
-0.714057207107544,
0.4739114046096802,
-0.1447819024324417,
-0.6995065808296204,
-0.10903307795524597,
0.0884506031870842,
0.10879054665565491,
0.2885356843471527,
0.19142358005046844,
0.42739811539649963,
0.025682605803012848,
-0.1355808675289154,
0.10227993875741959,
-0.2854249179363251,
0.2843838036060333,
-0.14394156634807587,
0.15470686554908752,
-0.42872777581214905,
-0.12969709932804108,
0.006522103678435087,
0.18153606355190277,
0.3873165547847748,
-0.08699540048837662,
0.6030182242393494,
0.3193342685699463,
-0.06304769963026047,
-0.45089155435562134,
-0.43196168541908264,
-0.22184033691883087,
-0.5738189220428467,
0.09521061182022095,
-0.5328730940818787,
-1.0773028135299683,
0.4004088044166565,
-0.2861078977584839,
0.13249903917312622,
0.36793339252471924,
0.6248775720596313,
-0.007838018238544464,
0.9659552574157715,
0.2689027488231659,
-0.34373417496681213,
0.3239178955554962,
-0.06991560757160187,
0.1468452662229538,
-0.6217465400695801,
-0.17176629602909088,
-0.4671441912651062,
-0.3158959448337555,
-0.7606265544891357,
-0.2548294961452484,
0.7413353323936462,
0.14064760506153107,
-0.16515874862670898,
0.01748845912516117,
-0.2782503068447113,
0.7683138847351074,
0.5179964303970337,
0.03136526420712471,
0.21487843990325928,
-0.2584241032600403,
-0.18280398845672607,
0.09894701093435287,
-0.8598232865333557,
-0.35014206171035767,
1.148685097694397,
0.06670528650283813,
0.5816952586174011,
0.3107347786426544,
0.6591873168945312,
0.40527990460395813,
0.5183255672454834,
-0.6409589648246765,
0.4700142741203308,
0.08696216344833374,
-0.3610987663269043,
-0.25535184144973755,
-0.46618029475212097,
-0.9887440204620361,
0.290248304605484,
-0.295925498008728,
-0.727901816368103,
0.0667215958237648,
-0.15033681690692902,
-0.7540082335472107,
0.33139172196388245,
-0.6532060503959656,
0.3662211000919342,
-0.5075678825378418,
-0.6962122321128845,
-0.1148374080657959,
-0.7234851121902466,
0.5993174910545349,
-0.19356398284435272,
0.09971008449792862,
0.24005363881587982,
-0.18228259682655334,
0.44516605138778687,
-0.18363094329833984,
0.6747656464576721,
-0.09539344161748886,
-0.028138425201177597,
0.3259027600288391,
0.08375586569309235,
0.9414545893669128,
0.23335954546928406,
-0.28628891706466675,
0.20837971568107605,
-0.1783982515335083,
-0.09532032161951065,
-0.585081160068512,
1.0319921970367432,
-0.797391414642334,
-0.9499672651290894,
-0.5081272125244141,
-0.2242375910282135,
-0.3871471881866455,
-0.0943252295255661,
0.1899486631155014,
0.431467205286026,
-0.12583491206169128,
0.5293525457382202,
0.7937590479850769,
-0.3048785328865051,
0.5509822368621826,
0.43475836515426636,
0.00012841913849115372,
-0.486888587474823,
0.8907272219657898,
0.12043803930282593,
0.26903611421585083,
0.2745458483695984,
0.11328531801700592,
-0.757633626461029,
-0.6443337202072144,
-0.5881235003471375,
-0.02204577811062336,
-0.6217973828315735,
-0.3387281000614166,
-0.42820537090301514,
-0.28345149755477905,
-0.03609141334891319,
-0.4287509620189667,
0.021926850080490112,
-0.21777690947055817,
-0.01307295449078083,
-0.1220187395811081,
0.3985646069049835,
0.7014856338500977,
-0.23902110755443573,
0.0684613510966301,
-0.424034059047699,
0.045645520091056824,
0.6668269038200378,
0.5072887539863586,
-0.09688861668109894,
-0.3826145529747009,
-0.09678693860769272,
-0.11461016535758972,
-0.19526945054531097,
-0.7528762817382812,
0.15907511115074158,
-0.09472670406103134,
0.6001240611076355,
0.29231205582618713,
-0.025568200275301933,
0.383452832698822,
-0.08965056389570236,
0.6546915173530579,
-0.2077779471874237,
-0.8461899757385254,
0.08465120196342468,
-0.6302359700202942,
0.03654617816209793,
0.5509702563285828,
0.11203079670667648,
-0.14878322184085846,
-0.21088692545890808,
-0.5981373190879822,
-0.6424028873443604,
0.8738400340080261,
0.24445609748363495,
-0.01823260262608528,
0.0871034562587738,
0.42083439230918884,
-0.021222401410341263,
0.32937565445899963,
-0.7298929691314697,
-0.1441342830657959,
0.048345740884542465,
0.3166632056236267,
-0.3107043206691742,
-0.23116576671600342,
-0.17574357986450195,
-0.1085064485669136,
0.5384936332702637,
-0.0472094863653183,
0.12176761031150818,
0.013734463602304459,
0.057837191969156265,
0.001983231632038951,
0.43391063809394836,
0.48267868161201477,
0.47019249200820923,
-0.22688859701156616,
-0.028520265594124794,
0.5007115602493286,
0.22989210486412048,
0.06219549477100372,
0.20016878843307495,
-0.18959686160087585,
-0.2078440934419632,
0.21153993904590607,
0.8479217886924744,
0.3986785113811493,
-0.6904877424240112,
0.5486728549003601,
-0.12265831232070923,
-0.28194040060043335,
-0.19593942165374756,
0.35260865092277527,
0.003761507337912917,
0.45603179931640625,
0.15327906608581543,
0.15191327035427094,
0.26532673835754395,
-0.5333670377731323,
0.011285541579127312,
0.9066817760467529,
-0.05200115591287613,
-0.1193385198712349,
0.4247383773326874,
0.3483186662197113,
-0.4321807622909546,
0.3142276406288147,
-0.43290460109710693,
-0.8932815790176392,
0.6674811840057373,
0.4483376741409302,
0.9894434809684753,
-0.07472328096628189,
0.13485360145568848,
0.19654083251953125,
0.28152701258659363,
0.03566955775022507,
0.007677081041038036,
-0.24024122953414917,
-0.6676836013793945,
-0.3567207157611847,
-0.47423049807548523,
-0.6708360314369202,
0.03327919915318489,
-0.2953105568885803,
0.2289874404668808,
-0.6679545044898987,
-0.2643517553806305,
-0.23028013110160828,
0.23417018353939056,
-0.5907597541809082,
-0.0372304804623127,
0.18700610101222992,
0.525816023349762,
-0.22826546430587769,
0.6175081133842468,
0.36908620595932007,
0.09128362685441971,
-0.535342812538147,
-0.16701917350292206,
0.11920053511857986,
-0.6762201189994812,
0.43990570306777954,
-0.008723831735551357,
-0.34500426054000854,
-0.23607246577739716,
-0.4513123333454132,
-0.9066764116287231,
1.0879563093185425,
0.3502923846244812,
-0.423706978559494,
0.2540854215621948,
-0.051995355635881424,
0.4562501609325409,
-0.21241429448127747,
0.4947509765625,
0.8938654065132141,
0.8106565475463867,
0.15742121636867523,
-1.0348272323608398,
-0.17112551629543304,
0.016969414427876472,
-0.019883420318365097,
0.41862863302230835,
-0.9660018682479858,
0.8915995359420776,
-0.44281259179115295,
-0.2064356952905655,
0.09486445784568787,
0.5332807898521423,
0.6399517059326172,
0.2729071080684662,
0.500406801700592,
0.39936429262161255,
0.8182319402694702,
-0.25217941403388977,
1.282711148262024,
-0.15814906358718872,
-0.0822799876332283,
0.9012921452522278,
-0.2764239013195038,
0.6441550850868225,
0.039606451988220215,
-0.3782173693180084,
0.6247696876525879,
0.73726487159729,
0.27323323488235474,
0.43825438618659973,
0.29609036445617676,
-0.49742361903190613,
-0.31309154629707336,
-0.03669719770550728,
-0.2914465069770813,
0.516250729560852,
0.5092284679412842,
-0.16642557084560394,
-0.11227802187204361,
-0.39841848611831665,
0.18427376449108124,
0.015400667674839497,
-0.40066081285476685,
0.8879486918449402,
-0.002841872163116932,
-1.0141942501068115,
0.5734286308288574,
0.31162744760513306,
0.9505882263183594,
-0.7737582325935364,
0.1400902271270752,
-0.16885752975940704,
0.1911868005990982,
-0.10718292742967606,
-0.9386100769042969,
-0.0008763967198319733,
0.059354111552238464,
-0.05068386718630791,
-0.10125543177127838,
0.8106272220611572,
-0.35858142375946045,
-0.1727273315191269,
0.3440048396587372,
0.2915637195110321,
-0.01826784759759903,
-0.1527986079454422,
-0.6672420501708984,
0.21131888031959534,
0.03670591861009598,
-0.07996276021003723,
0.5149447321891785,
0.5655445456504822,
-0.2731305956840515,
0.7411384582519531,
0.6253488659858704,
0.02989763580262661,
-0.28167369961738586,
-0.08800303936004639,
0.8334348797798157,
-0.5252660512924194,
-0.4763548672199249,
-1.0688450336456299,
0.09247870743274689,
-0.21682526171207428,
-0.19670747220516205,
0.9119020700454712,
0.3567049503326416,
0.7264512777328491,
0.3285027742385864,
0.9732900261878967,
0.07014703750610352,
0.18651600182056427,
-0.6017516255378723,
0.4381396174430847,
-0.2180747240781784,
0.4518078863620758,
-0.25674527883529663,
-0.7367860078811646,
-0.09325235337018967,
0.41827210783958435,
-0.5859277248382568,
0.3759509027004242,
0.23924598097801208,
0.7467712759971619,
0.3764999508857727,
0.09876665472984314,
0.364458829164505,
0.12748081982135773,
0.28771892189979553,
0.8913124799728394,
0.9833207130432129,
0.0835614800453186,
0.3836482763290405,
0.058487944304943085,
-0.4305551052093506,
-0.16326239705085754,
-0.9461511373519897,
-0.9681872725486755,
-0.23926155269145966,
0.1250634640455246,
-0.2720103859901428,
0.06712345033884048,
0.9110566973686218,
0.4475727081298828,
-0.4910931885242462,
-0.33694878220558167,
0.20584169030189514,
0.5948397517204285,
-0.02713678777217865,
-0.22347629070281982,
0.13754385709762573,
-0.3289635479450226,
-0.6723067760467529,
0.5315365195274353,
0.575326144695282,
-0.0924144983291626,
-0.28330355882644653,
-0.5467126965522766,
0.2901569604873657,
0.3570569157600403,
0.7264881134033203,
0.19024033844470978,
-0.8544868230819702,
-0.13919760286808014,
-0.2835306227207184,
0.08579855412244797,
-0.010407491587102413,
0.6430898904800415,
-1.0194827318191528,
0.5465227365493774,
0.2387889176607132,
0.7839890718460083,
0.35683587193489075,
0.12640263140201569,
0.6843668818473816,
-0.3782932460308075,
-0.10492784529924393,
0.26855385303497314,
0.3487650454044342,
0.3576148748397827,
-0.3300662934780121,
0.4270508885383606,
0.09232588112354279,
-0.7222343683242798,
-0.5974562764167786,
-0.1065509095788002,
-0.729170560836792,
-0.274170458316803,
1.3393464088439941,
-0.016849637031555176,
-0.050737105309963226,
0.02043004333972931,
-0.3962598145008087,
-0.2800382077693939,
-0.6821423172950745,
0.9211782813072205,
0.9465729594230652,
-0.06155690178275108,
-0.046596527099609375,
-0.18399329483509064,
0.928401529788971,
0.35545504093170166,
-0.7530454993247986,
-0.0026539857499301434,
0.5100414156913757,
0.06937555968761444,
-0.10179734230041504,
0.549623429775238,
-0.005599299445748329,
0.31465664505958557,
-0.028194427490234375,
-0.5845896601676941,
0.06281060725450516,
-0.37047410011291504,
-0.4775491952896118,
0.29006126523017883,
0.34024742245674133,
0.2539129853248596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01885v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01885v1 | Survey on Knowledge Distillation for Large Language Models: Methods, Evaluation, and Application | 2024-07-02T02:14:42 | 2024-07-02T02:14:42 | Chuanpeng Yang, Wang Lu, Yao Zhu, Yidong Wang, Qian Chen, Chenlong Gao, Bingjie Yan, Yiqiang Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have showcased exceptional capabilities in
various domains, attracting significant interest from both academia and
industry. Despite their impressive performance, the substantial size and
computational demands of LLMs pose considerable challenges for practical
deployment, particularly in environments with limited resources. The endeavor
to compress language models while maintaining their accuracy has become a focal
point of research. Among the various methods, knowledge distillation has
emerged as an effective technique to enhance inference speed without greatly
compromising performance. This paper presents a thorough survey from three
aspects: method, evaluation, and application, exploring knowledge distillation
techniques tailored specifically for LLMs. Specifically, we divide the methods
into white-box KD and black-box KD to better illustrate their differences.
Furthermore, we also explored the evaluation tasks and distillation effects
between different distillation methods, and proposed directions for future
research. Through in-depth understanding of the latest advancements and
practical applications, this survey provides valuable resources for
researchers, paving the way for sustained progress in this field. | [
-0.44325029850006104,
-0.9002842307090759,
0.987560510635376,
0.08919781446456909,
-0.3180069923400879,
0.3228190541267395,
-0.5499946475028992,
-0.24425846338272095,
-0.12824901938438416,
0.3906377851963043,
-0.19905102252960205,
-0.5098990797996521,
-0.9494197964668274,
0.09723780304193497,
-0.4508613646030426,
0.6439568996429443,
-0.023721275851130486,
0.15257035195827484,
-0.465882271528244,
-0.04110278934240341,
-0.4213531017303467,
-0.6475508213043213,
-0.5328856110572815,
-0.5465322732925415,
0.2699633538722992,
0.2357465773820877,
0.23583675920963287,
0.468262255191803,
0.34465792775154114,
0.3802264630794525,
-0.584672749042511,
0.09362290054559708,
-0.5303478837013245,
0.42251673340797424,
-0.07659530639648438,
-0.5166447162628174,
-0.09846454858779907,
-0.049419205635786057,
0.5691831707954407,
0.9062144756317139,
-0.3907873332500458,
0.35477808117866516,
0.3051673173904419,
0.8278080224990845,
-0.9459801316261292,
0.20690512657165527,
-0.6980503797531128,
0.02733003906905651,
-0.2455664724111557,
0.06262430548667908,
-0.348064661026001,
-0.5500870943069458,
0.32345452904701233,
-0.2565721869468689,
0.15087606012821198,
0.007263856939971447,
0.27939122915267944,
0.3527497351169586,
-0.6246842741966248,
-0.3880479037761688,
-1.0710681676864624,
1.0152840614318848,
-0.9344919919967651,
0.529086172580719,
0.2934570014476776,
0.55417400598526,
-0.2835037410259247,
-0.8699356317520142,
-0.6827149391174316,
-0.2657908797264099,
0.024781955406069756,
-0.17018619179725647,
-0.3150496780872345,
-0.03812029957771301,
0.4078674018383026,
0.48991361260414124,
-0.27160975337028503,
0.23535332083702087,
-0.3539537489414215,
-0.09807593375444412,
0.5656455159187317,
0.02344696968793869,
-0.024948574602603912,
0.1405361294746399,
-0.17421649396419525,
-0.1919427514076233,
-0.6390268206596375,
-0.3258320987224579,
0.2107166051864624,
-0.13136999309062958,
0.08584164828062057,
0.518721878528595,
-0.5244346261024475,
0.8861972093582153,
-0.09322399646043777,
-0.6653058528900146,
0.13407722115516663,
-0.3929517865180969,
-0.25985580682754517,
-0.04132749140262604,
0.8696401715278625,
0.34207871556282043,
0.15481051802635193,
-0.07251487672328949,
-0.13325117528438568,
-0.22535505890846252,
-0.11376474052667618,
-0.824592649936676,
-0.16581980884075165,
0.17217470705509186,
-0.48390135169029236,
-0.2065155804157257,
-0.34541282057762146,
-0.9972156882286072,
-0.7091320157051086,
-0.4550850987434387,
0.04764905199408531,
-0.19341941177845,
-0.5618197321891785,
0.19507546722888947,
-0.40140554308891296,
-0.052577100694179535,
0.33726203441619873,
-0.8802047967910767,
0.1966622769832611,
0.6390396952629089,
0.8042219281196594,
-0.24150575697422028,
0.034467004239559174,
-0.20212817192077637,
-0.023443320766091347,
-0.14553242921829224,
0.6107687950134277,
-0.27348390221595764,
-0.36549627780914307,
0.06693664193153381,
-0.3219050467014313,
0.29027876257896423,
-0.8454956412315369,
0.5621022582054138,
-0.6902112364768982,
-0.1735982745885849,
-0.17064164578914642,
-0.7741414904594421,
-0.2804153263568878,
0.3338198661804199,
-0.6968516111373901,
0.9192600846290588,
-0.05835713818669319,
-0.6192148327827454,
0.3639465868473053,
-0.4078649878501892,
-0.40466317534446716,
0.01695471815764904,
-0.05404981970787048,
-0.23479270935058594,
0.5814230442047119,
0.24168455600738525,
0.6611050963401794,
-0.6321091055870056,
0.3988102078437805,
-0.46742308139801025,
-0.05908564105629921,
0.3164370357990265,
-0.6390279531478882,
0.8242183923721313,
0.5344852209091187,
-0.16123788058757782,
-0.3108850419521332,
-0.8519083261489868,
-0.013286923058331013,
0.2449704110622406,
-0.2159031331539154,
-0.7425805330276489,
0.03705788403749466,
-0.23768074810504913,
0.05860920622944832,
0.4047219157218933,
-0.5702084302902222,
0.24679028987884521,
0.017628585919737816,
0.6069620251655579,
0.5325588583946228,
0.1530645340681076,
0.29316356778144836,
0.0714334100484848,
0.5687834024429321,
0.02870892733335495,
0.1021723672747612,
0.10599097609519958,
-0.1838492453098297,
-0.5780234336853027,
-0.15902352333068848,
0.5268789529800415,
0.2675524652004242,
-0.7907557487487793,
0.42123469710350037,
-0.11342299729585648,
-0.8728611469268799,
-0.47208258509635925,
0.26681259274482727,
0.2627219557762146,
0.3562662899494171,
0.21941718459129333,
0.20287449657917023,
-0.3378453850746155,
-0.9231037497520447,
-0.003204909386113286,
-0.2581704258918762,
0.0346665196120739,
0.19776876270771027,
0.4411459267139435,
0.04314987733960152,
0.9054977893829346,
-1.0123779773712158,
-0.012073635123670101,
-0.3829684257507324,
0.14207644760608673,
0.14084990322589874,
0.167616069316864,
0.5972290635108948,
-0.5900709629058838,
-0.6101312637329102,
-0.02160702832043171,
-0.6571013331413269,
-0.3326965570449829,
0.3341817259788513,
0.07656495273113251,
0.22296282649040222,
0.6604422330856323,
-0.4799349904060364,
0.16909758746623993,
0.8979548215866089,
-0.014222534373402596,
0.7076688408851624,
-0.26011255383491516,
0.31893476843833923,
-1.0527740716934204,
0.048492152243852615,
0.14628106355667114,
-0.20698684453964233,
-0.5831499099731445,
0.0048521580174565315,
0.0499863475561142,
0.22366872429847717,
-0.5084345936775208,
0.5220060348510742,
-0.7470538020133972,
0.10379648208618164,
-0.3465401828289032,
0.34403136372566223,
0.05913303792476654,
0.13244174420833588,
-0.010141122154891491,
0.47523918747901917,
0.44020918011665344,
-0.578085720539093,
0.709997296333313,
-0.002414698712527752,
-0.9567246437072754,
0.31812283396720886,
-0.5601556301116943,
0.1283232718706131,
-0.07772374898195267,
0.18632790446281433,
-1.0130695104599,
0.1598544865846634,
-0.06725318729877472,
-0.02194962464272976,
0.324307382106781,
-0.27867019176483154,
-0.7163517475128174,
-0.3647836446762085,
-0.1762154996395111,
0.4441802501678467,
0.8336400985717773,
-0.4268612861633301,
0.2931123673915863,
0.5636398196220398,
-0.229864239692688,
-0.5955521464347839,
-0.7534090280532837,
0.019290754571557045,
-0.5604979991912842,
-0.38175511360168457,
0.09355847537517548,
-0.1716567724943161,
-0.6682637929916382,
-0.10005909949541092,
-0.2824561595916748,
-0.11158616095781326,
0.2488081455230713,
-0.1209958866238594,
0.13232816755771637,
-0.04028644785284996,
-0.03888065740466118,
0.0661996528506279,
0.1672235131263733,
0.019586432725191116,
-0.2064516395330429,
0.5452765822410583,
0.35662373900413513,
-0.40778711438179016,
-0.3379329741001129,
0.06673873960971832,
0.6530129909515381,
-0.08183034509420395,
0.8149116635322571,
0.39928263425827026,
-0.22740784287452698,
-0.421954870223999,
-1.0288382768630981,
-0.16076628863811493,
-0.44574299454689026,
0.453718900680542,
-0.15065065026283264,
-1.1113317012786865,
0.43551069498062134,
-0.5597091913223267,
-0.03821861371397972,
0.2563783526420593,
0.8017794489860535,
0.03861445188522339,
0.7085696458816528,
0.690751314163208,
-0.26830053329467773,
0.427918016910553,
-0.2005704790353775,
0.32720908522605896,
-0.7351892590522766,
-0.24502213299274445,
-0.9156435132026672,
-0.28681230545043945,
-0.3310283422470093,
-0.5374467372894287,
0.4562799632549286,
0.3664897084236145,
0.31025230884552,
0.061855826526880264,
-0.33957159519195557,
0.5525510907173157,
0.33649924397468567,
-0.27352628111839294,
0.7598026990890503,
0.0453612245619297,
-0.13316628336906433,
0.008802337571978569,
-0.6321930885314941,
-0.5204487442970276,
1.2395848035812378,
0.39318594336509705,
0.8996403217315674,
0.02703203074634075,
0.7230256795883179,
0.2567373812198639,
0.1717422902584076,
-0.7695196270942688,
0.5468043684959412,
-0.12616510689258575,
-0.665594756603241,
-0.4792371690273285,
-0.5848627090454102,
-0.6710520386695862,
0.3153214156627655,
0.025650961324572563,
-0.7024627923965454,
0.055749744176864624,
0.27129754424095154,
-0.24737825989723206,
0.2466515600681305,
-0.912493884563446,
0.7169926762580872,
-0.30831465125083923,
-0.07254919409751892,
-0.3206367492675781,
-0.35371243953704834,
0.727077305316925,
-0.42208731174468994,
0.19744908809661865,
-0.258961945772171,
0.10183223336935043,
0.6723241209983826,
-0.4871751666069031,
0.5813941359519958,
-0.3861980736255646,
-0.5240196585655212,
0.3592628240585327,
-0.029820319265127182,
0.5840437412261963,
-0.055311109870672226,
-0.25399866700172424,
0.4232889711856842,
0.2574332058429718,
0.02596735768020153,
-0.842207133769989,
0.7449396252632141,
-0.4798464775085449,
-0.677628755569458,
-0.3267480731010437,
-0.484360933303833,
-0.384684681892395,
0.1454511284828186,
-0.007102964911609888,
0.27753305435180664,
-0.285961389541626,
0.41621920466423035,
0.7286034822463989,
-0.30608710646629333,
0.5554275512695312,
0.7045046091079712,
-0.4200894832611084,
-0.26417961716651917,
0.6860695481300354,
0.3006139099597931,
0.5663989782333374,
0.3722740709781647,
0.27545663714408875,
-0.6717939972877502,
-1.1427210569381714,
-0.32239940762519836,
0.1454440802335739,
-0.6299723982810974,
-0.18740437924861908,
-0.6003175973892212,
-0.10618039220571518,
-0.5269833207130432,
0.25312623381614685,
-0.45819997787475586,
-0.5278260111808777,
-0.10256170481443405,
-0.015747807919979095,
0.4785754680633545,
0.8640599250793457,
0.14429378509521484,
0.20544496178627014,
-0.7849110960960388,
0.38817352056503296,
0.2785731852054596,
0.387803852558136,
0.170089453458786,
-0.29140332341194153,
-0.3412884473800659,
0.18331322073936462,
-0.1991628110408783,
-0.6761792302131653,
0.26641616225242615,
0.05186919867992401,
0.6893669366836548,
0.317787766456604,
0.3722181022167206,
0.777832567691803,
-0.5337116122245789,
0.8362061977386475,
0.18090803921222687,
-0.6907559633255005,
0.3285049498081207,
0.052907805889844894,
0.3414439558982849,
0.6661343574523926,
0.4769134819507599,
-0.5624297261238098,
-0.39788565039634705,
-0.2764270603656769,
-0.7718942165374756,
0.5371261835098267,
0.11244108527898788,
-0.0910743772983551,
0.25231486558914185,
0.3014778196811676,
0.19241583347320557,
0.3223288059234619,
-0.32170993089675903,
-0.5418640375137329,
0.3574082851409912,
-0.11958137899637222,
-0.255647212266922,
-0.4553379714488983,
0.007334917783737183,
-0.21084293723106384,
0.7566235065460205,
0.13224250078201294,
-0.19315418601036072,
-0.11644349992275238,
-0.3865910768508911,
0.3210151195526123,
0.43508490920066833,
0.5237777829170227,
0.7625058889389038,
-0.14257973432540894,
0.24723708629608154,
0.2651248276233673,
-0.5046637058258057,
0.44788670539855957,
0.11110501736402512,
-0.1600220948457718,
-0.02656880021095276,
0.21804647147655487,
0.6501989364624023,
-0.17224068939685822,
-0.7090989351272583,
0.29052454233169556,
-0.2814183533191681,
-0.2766958177089691,
-0.14300890266895294,
0.09565497189760208,
0.4544440507888794,
0.3807293772697449,
0.36315372586250305,
-0.3694235384464264,
0.2557753920555115,
-0.43702730536460876,
-0.275100439786911,
0.4091699719429016,
-0.05771881714463234,
-0.012126967310905457,
0.3516353666782379,
0.18743199110031128,
0.06486837565898895,
0.4932318329811096,
-0.255750834941864,
-0.21420209109783173,
0.37784552574157715,
0.3888217806816101,
0.8251832723617554,
-0.10778018087148666,
-0.01771162450313568,
0.16929015517234802,
0.10982123762369156,
-0.33197519183158875,
0.025257164612412453,
-0.24730774760246277,
-0.7351356744766235,
-0.6968655586242676,
-1.0629267692565918,
-0.35511210560798645,
0.5333956480026245,
-0.505422830581665,
0.16319884359836578,
-0.12668879330158234,
-0.22977758944034576,
0.10531997680664062,
0.09007088840007782,
-0.46567288041114807,
-0.20354880392551422,
0.23073206841945648,
1.0500824451446533,
-0.8082937002182007,
0.8814840912818909,
0.6553903818130493,
0.005840476602315903,
-0.6829025745391846,
-0.04173111170530319,
0.18344184756278992,
-0.4546983242034912,
0.6975141167640686,
-0.3484744429588318,
-0.09256982803344727,
0.009194400161504745,
-0.35128656029701233,
-0.7372366189956665,
1.1645559072494507,
0.6107406616210938,
-1.0068432092666626,
0.2576052248477936,
0.28056755661964417,
0.6232677698135376,
-0.009678684175014496,
0.15218432247638702,
1.1082323789596558,
0.5809705853462219,
0.19472689926624298,
-1.0371419191360474,
-0.12300246208906174,
-0.11836422234773636,
0.25692883133888245,
0.19422437250614166,
-0.532438337802887,
0.27535706758499146,
0.2079906463623047,
-0.11136730760335922,
-0.12584814429283142,
0.526160717010498,
0.49141258001327515,
0.19259409606456757,
0.5970253944396973,
0.6378609538078308,
0.7216033935546875,
-0.15420468151569366,
0.7630640268325806,
-0.3686218559741974,
0.39835816621780396,
1.125143051147461,
-0.6415488719940186,
0.5914959907531738,
0.649054765701294,
-0.55390864610672,
0.24067334830760956,
0.30535945296287537,
0.06592784821987152,
0.4793143570423126,
0.4817001223564148,
-0.4891350269317627,
0.07712999731302261,
-0.17740897834300995,
-0.393756628036499,
0.47016680240631104,
0.31970182061195374,
-0.3086771070957184,
-0.32643449306488037,
0.06006297841668129,
0.09866494685411453,
0.031366728246212006,
-0.168403759598732,
1.0036455392837524,
0.2043914645910263,
-0.8276224732398987,
0.6268325448036194,
0.07243989408016205,
0.7469062805175781,
-0.634581983089447,
-0.1213296428322792,
-0.12931843101978302,
0.21690534055233002,
0.010365276597440243,
-0.7547540664672852,
0.21190130710601807,
0.1712736040353775,
-0.22989539802074432,
-0.44539541006088257,
0.7811945676803589,
-0.6443490386009216,
-0.38765305280685425,
0.24521590769290924,
0.6343313455581665,
0.23941071331501007,
-0.10947135090827942,
-0.38317400217056274,
0.369051069021225,
0.05148978903889656,
-0.36014965176582336,
0.3635188043117523,
0.6956701874732971,
0.13880158960819244,
0.6942054629325867,
0.4966997802257538,
0.4412064254283905,
0.2214697003364563,
0.2108718454837799,
0.7806051969528198,
-0.45763325691223145,
-0.05801703780889511,
-1.1908695697784424,
0.4663722515106201,
-0.13345736265182495,
-0.015005962923169136,
1.0214924812316895,
0.552447497844696,
0.8267161250114441,
-0.25866204500198364,
1.0291980504989624,
-0.1735859364271164,
0.4725884795188904,
-0.687629222869873,
0.9380221962928772,
-0.44126978516578674,
0.31776162981987,
-0.3360345661640167,
-1.1239120960235596,
-0.17316898703575134,
0.24445819854736328,
-0.2505270540714264,
0.030232388526201248,
0.7085555195808411,
0.6613187789916992,
0.04754872992634773,
-0.10320930927991867,
0.42313385009765625,
0.37301671504974365,
0.39022180438041687,
0.2568943500518799,
1.0243583917617798,
-0.032605379819869995,
0.4503837525844574,
-0.5459538102149963,
-0.17136821150779724,
-0.27506211400032043,
-1.268691062927246,
-0.7295767068862915,
-0.6664645075798035,
-0.5260879993438721,
-0.09443626552820206,
-0.16602633893489838,
0.6895309686660767,
0.7115218043327332,
-0.6661766171455383,
-0.32170209288597107,
0.11289728432893753,
0.2573243975639343,
-0.11960297077894211,
-0.1524801105260849,
0.2868070900440216,
-0.19790109992027283,
-0.946036696434021,
0.4029366075992584,
0.14249788224697113,
0.04163610190153122,
-0.5554559230804443,
0.10811372101306915,
-0.1822839081287384,
-0.2722420394420624,
0.8018588423728943,
0.09979934990406036,
-0.6131405830383301,
0.0006741986144334078,
-0.25650152564048767,
0.07204172760248184,
-0.3393571078777313,
0.9231627583503723,
-0.7267281413078308,
0.4219859540462494,
0.7895599603652954,
0.5511749982833862,
0.7256594300270081,
-0.13058367371559143,
0.6687710285186768,
-0.8063566088676453,
0.13967297971248627,
0.07980018109083176,
0.46528545022010803,
0.2304558902978897,
-0.14050766825675964,
0.4468587338924408,
0.11997205018997192,
-0.6493610143661499,
-1.1281083822250366,
0.07060153782367706,
-0.8008497357368469,
-0.38458535075187683,
1.326438069343567,
-0.2244260013103485,
-0.032618556171655655,
-0.2158477008342743,
-0.14852821826934814,
0.353675901889801,
-0.29588836431503296,
0.7146658897399902,
1.0397510528564453,
0.018295595422387123,
-0.07689141482114792,
-0.799776017665863,
0.5322461128234863,
0.048096608370542526,
-0.7570798993110657,
0.39733099937438965,
0.7244278192520142,
0.45899203419685364,
0.08578339964151382,
0.4592674970626831,
-0.1932864636182785,
-0.24170424044132233,
-0.2293374240398407,
0.13814173638820648,
-0.1507491171360016,
-0.1611577868461609,
-0.5331792235374451,
0.2681719660758972,
0.40427663922309875,
0.12977486848831177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01878v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01878v1 | Compare without Despair: Reliable Preference Evaluation with Generation Separability | 2024-07-02T01:37:56 | 2024-07-02T01:37:56 | Sayan Ghosh, Tejas Srinivasan, Swabha Swayamdipta | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human evaluation of generated language through pairwise preference judgments
is pervasive. However, under common scenarios, such as when generations from a
model pair are very similar, or when stochastic decoding results in large
variations in generations, it results in inconsistent preference ratings. We
address these challenges by introducing a meta-evaluation measure,
separability, which estimates how suitable a test instance is for pairwise
preference evaluation. For a candidate test instance, separability samples
multiple generations from a pair of models, and measures how distinguishable
the two sets of generations are. Our experiments show that instances with high
separability values yield more consistent preference ratings from both human-
and auto-raters. Further, the distribution of separability allows insights into
which test benchmarks are more valuable for comparing models. Finally, we
incorporate separability into ELO ratings, accounting for how suitable each
test instance might be for reliably ranking LLMs. Overall, separability has
implications for consistent, efficient and robust preference evaluation of LLMs
with both human- and auto-raters. | [
-0.49948593974113464,
-0.14394037425518036,
0.5597197413444519,
0.44777074456214905,
-0.1793857365846634,
0.26010188460350037,
-0.39651647210121155,
-0.7348132133483887,
0.26952415704727173,
0.2702297568321228,
-0.371517151594162,
-0.26853564381599426,
-0.5965585708618164,
0.454850435256958,
-0.31309598684310913,
0.8781054615974426,
0.04620368033647537,
-0.09894149005413055,
-0.6009630560874939,
-0.40049490332603455,
-0.1856294870376587,
-0.23516395688056946,
-0.7401385307312012,
-0.3235498070716858,
0.28962424397468567,
0.44949784874916077,
0.8128814697265625,
0.46670472621917725,
0.7012701630592346,
0.3597445487976074,
-0.07249906659126282,
0.18323199450969696,
-0.5102800130844116,
0.34762558341026306,
0.03555555269122124,
-0.3275982439517975,
-0.3012843430042267,
0.16902630031108856,
0.4121619462966919,
0.5452171564102173,
-0.24221430718898773,
0.0658099502325058,
0.32313090562820435,
0.8457428812980652,
-0.7848650217056274,
-0.07684676349163055,
-0.7397489547729492,
0.19736012816429138,
-0.004367699380964041,
-0.07582924515008926,
-0.37865740060806274,
-0.8156431913375854,
0.14244264364242554,
-0.22200851142406464,
0.3305158019065857,
-0.02845497615635395,
0.76054847240448,
0.25189125537872314,
-0.4130595624446869,
0.016986072063446045,
-0.6598106026649475,
0.9787160754203796,
-0.5847579836845398,
0.5094322562217712,
0.580555260181427,
0.2986413538455963,
0.06599916517734528,
-0.31060394644737244,
-0.3655751645565033,
-0.5262476801872253,
-0.03163127228617668,
0.20988976955413818,
-0.12009227275848389,
0.2579907476902008,
0.006841960828751326,
0.7126008868217468,
-0.5316410660743713,
-0.1877412050962448,
-0.03746639937162399,
-0.19726261496543884,
0.7762430906295776,
0.18342576920986176,
0.48182857036590576,
-0.46479547023773193,
-0.5107089877128601,
-0.19573622941970825,
-0.43027380108833313,
-0.07789695262908936,
0.6499746441841125,
0.16553127765655518,
0.03545219823718071,
0.26001474261283875,
-0.1629159152507782,
0.6040622591972351,
0.06695359945297241,
-0.08983559906482697,
0.4927266538143158,
-0.5039646029472351,
-0.23536960780620575,
-0.15745802223682404,
0.9715637564659119,
0.6599621772766113,
0.06314345449209213,
-0.4423264265060425,
-0.19407092034816742,
0.16742673516273499,
0.3958946764469147,
-0.5948845148086548,
-0.26018568873405457,
0.1552291214466095,
-0.8797529935836792,
-0.6257633566856384,
-0.13091669976711273,
-0.8682703375816345,
-0.4317176938056946,
0.014349035918712616,
0.35303744673728943,
-0.23976776003837585,
-0.5063440203666687,
0.012528613209724426,
-0.2307189404964447,
0.08817137777805328,
0.13575227558612823,
-1.067528247833252,
0.2674305737018585,
0.646390438079834,
0.8431724905967712,
-0.4925215244293213,
-0.4361070990562439,
-0.4062443971633911,
-0.3917151987552643,
-0.312255859375,
0.9904175400733948,
-0.5722333192825317,
-0.6321737170219421,
-0.1278858482837677,
-0.16047994792461395,
-0.2633872330188751,
-0.9310731291770935,
0.8622430562973022,
-0.2736950218677521,
0.071940578520298,
-0.32802918553352356,
-0.47794029116630554,
0.07585182040929794,
0.3387608528137207,
-0.6882964968681335,
0.8867747187614441,
0.0990736186504364,
-0.8941627144813538,
0.7539001703262329,
-0.36838820576667786,
-0.29688867926597595,
-0.10353226959705353,
0.02152514085173607,
-0.4340169131755829,
0.26190146803855896,
-0.19605551660060883,
0.10864130407571793,
-0.30680733919143677,
0.10405410081148148,
-1.0006513595581055,
-0.22286950051784515,
0.05193990841507912,
-0.5920232534408569,
0.6951781511306763,
0.27965620160102844,
-0.3765994906425476,
0.09270426630973816,
-0.7989097833633423,
0.15893231332302094,
-0.020958077162504196,
-0.23543724417686462,
-0.5796851515769958,
0.34536755084991455,
0.05900932475924492,
0.13005228340625763,
0.28368300199508667,
-0.49219244718551636,
-0.11357145011425018,
-0.3395301103591919,
0.4545256793498993,
0.6332132816314697,
-0.2229471653699875,
0.5293750762939453,
-0.4958984851837158,
0.49118348956108093,
-0.06110905855894089,
0.434678852558136,
0.31948599219322205,
-0.21118652820587158,
-1.0220645666122437,
-0.2559211850166321,
0.20058901607990265,
0.5464640259742737,
-0.41677382588386536,
0.8552307486534119,
0.07830378413200378,
-0.55140221118927,
-0.6760373711585999,
0.15153762698173523,
0.46591636538505554,
0.5290210843086243,
0.4096418023109436,
-0.688584566116333,
-0.6638839840888977,
-1.1227610111236572,
-0.4324961006641388,
-0.45427820086479187,
0.03266138583421707,
0.38989919424057007,
0.11524136364459991,
-0.2197040468454361,
0.854347825050354,
-0.3031058609485626,
0.20308943092823029,
-0.48912352323532104,
0.19765253365039825,
0.04695538803935051,
0.2899191975593567,
0.4172329604625702,
-0.5056527853012085,
-0.4212036430835724,
-0.21937952935695648,
-0.7656611800193787,
-0.3819127678871155,
0.30522793531417847,
-0.19534192979335785,
-0.012525972910225391,
0.15930244326591492,
-0.30055612325668335,
0.26528456807136536,
0.5788782835006714,
-0.13600091636180878,
0.5892632603645325,
-0.366010457277298,
0.6417003273963928,
-1.2232590913772583,
0.11824479699134827,
-0.1444060206413269,
-0.46906405687332153,
-0.3527960777282715,
-0.07303139567375183,
-0.020994368940591812,
0.2879100441932678,
-0.38036221265792847,
0.36987417936325073,
-0.24377192556858063,
-0.3631342649459839,
-0.27722010016441345,
0.07166516780853271,
0.0688309445977211,
-0.3198561370372772,
-0.08418723195791245,
0.906371533870697,
0.2108965516090393,
-0.3660236597061157,
0.2109997719526291,
0.3551517128944397,
-0.5462639927864075,
0.6699865460395813,
-0.6991363763809204,
0.23999758064746857,
0.09948371350765228,
0.08181213587522507,
-0.9215534329414368,
0.050375595688819885,
-0.010459944605827332,
-0.17532561719417572,
-0.04972120374441147,
-0.21933844685554504,
-0.386636346578598,
-0.21470798552036285,
-0.6126093864440918,
0.4681239724159241,
0.5064526796340942,
-0.529387354850769,
0.2139100730419159,
0.33658257126808167,
-0.10309872031211853,
-0.7370182275772095,
-0.42768239974975586,
-0.009852210991084576,
-0.46891865134239197,
-0.6006758809089661,
0.16063739359378815,
-0.43314653635025024,
-0.4119182229042053,
-0.07652245461940765,
-0.07906210422515869,
-0.05504443496465683,
0.3624158799648285,
0.3631645739078522,
0.3183176815509796,
-0.007470209151506424,
-0.1157485768198967,
0.15112319588661194,
-0.34356096386909485,
-0.07857801765203476,
0.02599399723112583,
0.500048041343689,
-0.169437438249588,
-0.25052449107170105,
-0.06591186672449112,
0.230093851685524,
0.6771600246429443,
-0.12058333307504654,
0.47598329186439514,
0.2680463194847107,
-0.07258773595094681,
-0.23163661360740662,
-0.7227708101272583,
-0.06142362952232361,
-0.4562389552593231,
0.052327342331409454,
-0.31983432173728943,
-0.7821108102798462,
0.47692444920539856,
0.3661744296550751,
0.13098542392253876,
0.29694342613220215,
0.31125375628471375,
-0.16799943149089813,
1.0580335855484009,
0.6862201690673828,
-0.22060807049274445,
0.49257802963256836,
0.26015329360961914,
0.18914514780044556,
-0.9032349586486816,
0.03244661167263985,
-0.5845175385475159,
-0.49409136176109314,
-0.6380859017372131,
-0.0881320908665657,
0.29491254687309265,
0.2732301950454712,
-0.07330228388309479,
0.42143791913986206,
-0.41151535511016846,
0.8333924412727356,
0.45642608404159546,
-0.02473183535039425,
0.6190211176872253,
-0.13232572376728058,
-0.19551755487918854,
-0.2386002540588379,
-0.3122446835041046,
-0.507950484752655,
1.2593302726745605,
-0.019907372072339058,
0.5025930404663086,
-0.0506182424724102,
1.1240609884262085,
0.5147351026535034,
0.49307218194007874,
-0.6735915541648865,
0.48158755898475647,
-0.5452825427055359,
-0.4997083246707916,
-0.04173538088798523,
-0.8440511226654053,
-1.066029667854309,
0.42715418338775635,
-0.36872398853302,
-0.6546446681022644,
0.20058032870292664,
0.04290327429771423,
-0.4825782775878906,
0.280173659324646,
-0.478436142206192,
1.014936923980713,
-0.2860642075538635,
-0.20973080396652222,
-0.317554235458374,
-0.7083085775375366,
0.6326558589935303,
0.027563054114580154,
-0.0014096697559580207,
-0.35883569717407227,
0.29909050464630127,
0.7857623100280762,
-0.3149453103542328,
0.22866494953632355,
0.2273600995540619,
0.18032020330429077,
-0.01754116080701351,
0.3697259724140167,
-0.06207863241434097,
-0.012263388372957706,
-0.3073742985725403,
0.09704563021659851,
0.04359704256057739,
-0.19741319119930267,
-0.5354529023170471,
0.854796290397644,
-0.8789196014404297,
-0.5063377022743225,
-0.3862675428390503,
-0.4413379430770874,
-0.3666206896305084,
0.2460700273513794,
0.43035370111465454,
0.2224588245153427,
-0.511969268321991,
0.08649039268493652,
0.5521137118339539,
-0.13171899318695068,
0.5506429672241211,
0.43386077880859375,
-0.3177379071712494,
-0.9326500296592712,
0.8823089003562927,
-0.1415935903787613,
0.4995884597301483,
0.3663026988506317,
0.23237121105194092,
-0.5166681408882141,
-0.24526074528694153,
-0.5189602375030518,
0.17490775883197784,
-0.43062475323677063,
-0.163490429520607,
-0.6527832746505737,
-0.07705830037593842,
0.028600750491023064,
-0.26800498366355896,
-0.5365190505981445,
-0.2853010892868042,
0.08378514647483826,
-0.35394835472106934,
0.05987713485956192,
0.6851029396057129,
-0.31102657318115234,
-0.3938899040222168,
-0.9505263566970825,
0.21680891513824463,
0.6563778519630432,
0.2865259647369385,
-0.02551092579960823,
-0.3935679793357849,
0.18686239421367645,
-0.24343453347682953,
-0.3132540285587311,
-0.728194534778595,
0.28012675046920776,
0.0458994060754776,
0.49570631980895996,
0.7477070689201355,
0.20931562781333923,
0.7134261131286621,
-0.3955813944339752,
0.6269535422325134,
0.2764667868614197,
-1.176767110824585,
0.4780017137527466,
-0.165168896317482,
-0.1985573172569275,
1.4417270421981812,
0.07075124233961105,
-0.40213853120803833,
-0.4809126555919647,
-0.9068920612335205,
-0.9447160363197327,
0.5830748677253723,
0.2360459566116333,
-0.040974073112010956,
-0.05869531258940697,
0.002305916277691722,
0.36323782801628113,
0.4340824484825134,
-0.4713183343410492,
-0.29482346773147583,
-0.06900421530008316,
-0.19296666979789734,
-0.38697221875190735,
-0.3628002107143402,
-0.23556050658226013,
0.06010887771844864,
0.17412260174751282,
0.32402491569519043,
-0.0160207636654377,
0.003170607378706336,
-0.05306858569383621,
-0.2738141417503357,
0.393574059009552,
0.5497727394104004,
0.46938419342041016,
-0.4579399824142456,
0.4350573420524597,
0.1242206022143364,
-0.26611122488975525,
0.406993567943573,
0.09713217616081238,
-0.2682614028453827,
0.044273629784584045,
0.2631685435771942,
0.6246964335441589,
0.4015517830848694,
-0.628782331943512,
0.7005841732025146,
-0.34772881865501404,
0.04347857087850571,
-0.09638283401727676,
0.09344872087240219,
0.0992005243897438,
0.01965600624680519,
-0.06311900913715363,
0.37709012627601624,
0.37020909786224365,
-0.6190990805625916,
0.3621024191379547,
0.523743212223053,
-0.44316765666007996,
-0.33675795793533325,
0.6626545786857605,
0.6310245990753174,
-0.35605600476264954,
0.6948132514953613,
-0.396685391664505,
-0.5095481872558594,
0.6646110415458679,
0.4309813380241394,
1.3770430088043213,
-0.3398733139038086,
0.4660206139087677,
0.19330859184265137,
0.476591557264328,
-0.4934510588645935,
0.13233625888824463,
-0.3777407109737396,
-0.8946201801300049,
-0.003917871043086052,
-0.8244786262512207,
-0.6461468935012817,
-0.0019760255236178637,
-0.9415446519851685,
0.03123854286968708,
-0.3293362557888031,
-0.3073244094848633,
-0.4862648546695709,
-0.04743916913866997,
-0.5536923408508301,
0.19420692324638367,
0.0779024288058281,
0.863959789276123,
-1.1902564764022827,
0.5263175368309021,
0.49343711137771606,
-0.3458452522754669,
-0.6440188884735107,
0.2246924191713333,
-0.19344943761825562,
-0.5908403992652893,
0.44680681824684143,
0.3317941427230835,
-0.3195027709007263,
-0.4167942702770233,
-0.05942973494529724,
-0.6890175342559814,
0.9057518243789673,
0.6317750811576843,
-0.4215865731239319,
0.3391701281070709,
-0.09173129498958588,
0.5117778182029724,
-0.22768530249595642,
0.8070739507675171,
0.8555577397346497,
0.49791115522384644,
-0.1626262217760086,
-1.1756911277770996,
-0.1384194791316986,
-0.20494428277015686,
-0.0524197518825531,
0.41082754731178284,
-0.9111577272415161,
0.5634641647338867,
-0.09087096154689789,
-0.2950664162635803,
0.07872384786605835,
0.44620510935783386,
0.49051469564437866,
0.6382794976234436,
0.875021755695343,
0.9397647976875305,
0.6457949280738831,
-0.07000976800918579,
0.9437063932418823,
-0.5774731636047363,
0.6218825578689575,
1.012085199356079,
-0.5824728012084961,
0.9805247783660889,
0.26893046498298645,
-0.44585567712783813,
0.38419613242149353,
0.6980162262916565,
0.29483938217163086,
0.556946873664856,
0.007798818871378899,
-0.4656251072883606,
-0.6566050052642822,
-0.08995994180440903,
-0.49636387825012207,
0.32172876596450806,
-0.3036758601665497,
-0.5544286370277405,
-0.20919714868068695,
-0.3190528154373169,
0.07002397626638412,
-0.011169164441525936,
-0.06933845579624176,
0.7583571672439575,
0.2965703010559082,
-0.7245415449142456,
0.4325201213359833,
-0.3098844587802887,
0.7532265782356262,
-0.6005036234855652,
0.3081595301628113,
-0.6807572245597839,
0.039828814566135406,
-0.45974960923194885,
-0.5759095549583435,
0.3805960714817047,
0.07581382244825363,
-0.47979551553726196,
-0.14205344021320343,
0.6192638874053955,
-0.4280899167060852,
-0.4856424927711487,
0.6475573778152466,
0.6055547595024109,
0.19754117727279663,
0.23728635907173157,
-0.6252142786979675,
0.2749669551849365,
0.0389106310904026,
-0.07635430991649628,
0.4933193624019623,
0.0030197312589734793,
0.2969402074813843,
0.7684721946716309,
0.6330994367599487,
0.3432607352733612,
-0.0932757630944252,
0.1656276136636734,
0.4008238613605499,
-0.5981009602546692,
-0.3422688841819763,
-0.9850801825523376,
0.2513892650604248,
-0.23568245768547058,
-0.477748304605484,
0.8391927480697632,
0.6611759066581726,
0.7902035117149353,
0.03580014407634735,
0.9249460101127625,
0.054737187922000885,
0.4224913418292999,
-0.16202092170715332,
0.9138607382774353,
-0.6510205268859863,
0.17875738441944122,
-0.42032095789909363,
-1.2873656749725342,
-0.24264481663703918,
0.6503686308860779,
-0.41830363869667053,
0.06610710918903351,
0.8083850145339966,
0.639976978302002,
-0.1177152618765831,
0.08499512076377869,
0.5745113492012024,
-0.09291087836027145,
0.03997163847088814,
0.7507079839706421,
1.0600545406341553,
-0.148529514670372,
0.4973279535770416,
-0.06423715502023697,
-0.2809034585952759,
-0.21157826483249664,
-0.8646617531776428,
-0.5875219106674194,
-0.2949143052101135,
-0.17802473902702332,
-0.40073832869529724,
0.07308003306388855,
1.0278677940368652,
0.634364664554596,
-0.7877287864685059,
-0.46381133794784546,
-0.08903069794178009,
0.5021803975105286,
-0.3742384612560272,
-0.2690398395061493,
0.07567761838436127,
-0.4124965965747833,
-0.8503628969192505,
0.6946489214897156,
0.6117455363273621,
-0.16200189292430878,
-0.3035382926464081,
0.026036156341433525,
0.6910994648933411,
0.2651139795780182,
0.4629201591014862,
0.27096349000930786,
-0.5533962845802307,
-0.3297208249568939,
-0.38142749667167664,
-0.19130727648735046,
0.2141013741493225,
0.8729658126831055,
-0.5496640801429749,
0.6862965822219849,
0.9389683604240417,
0.6180990934371948,
0.10319166630506516,
0.1953093409538269,
0.64472496509552,
-0.1746172159910202,
-0.13625037670135498,
0.17554068565368652,
0.41349196434020996,
0.522157609462738,
-0.0379255935549736,
0.49592289328575134,
0.27036601305007935,
-0.8948014378547668,
-1.0251456499099731,
0.44816288352012634,
-1.1003963947296143,
0.25194019079208374,
1.004321575164795,
-0.17122726142406464,
0.11597062647342682,
-0.15252016484737396,
0.20600096881389618,
-0.09010116755962372,
-0.5581123232841492,
1.2098692655563354,
0.6791043877601624,
-0.2704675793647766,
-0.037149421870708466,
-0.21364328265190125,
0.5994613766670227,
0.5948631167411804,
-0.9743547439575195,
-0.005373065825551748,
0.10105568915605545,
0.6187211275100708,
0.047470275312662125,
0.6683465838432312,
-0.1258087009191513,
0.08147276192903519,
-0.033835504204034805,
0.08091193437576294,
0.19417357444763184,
-0.24625970423221588,
-0.4356948435306549,
0.31301483511924744,
0.30316728353500366,
-0.28815916180610657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01873v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01873v1 | Automated Text Scoring in the Age of Generative AI for the GPU-poor | 2024-07-02T01:17:01 | 2024-07-02T01:17:01 | Christopher Michael Ormerod, Alexander Kwako | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Current research on generative language models (GLMs) for automated text
scoring (ATS) has focused almost exclusively on querying proprietary models via
Application Programming Interfaces (APIs). Yet such practices raise issues
around transparency and security, and these methods offer little in the way of
efficiency or customizability. With the recent proliferation of smaller,
open-source models, there is the option to explore GLMs with computers equipped
with modest, consumer-grade hardware, that is, for the "GPU poor." In this
study, we analyze the performance and efficiency of open-source, small-scale
GLMs for ATS. Results show that GLMs can be fine-tuned to achieve adequate,
though not state-of-the-art, performance. In addition to ATS, we take small
steps towards analyzing models' capacity for generating feedback by prompting
GLMs to explain their scores. Model-generated feedback shows promise, but
requires more rigorous evaluation focused on targeted use cases. | [
-0.2291690856218338,
-0.9682424664497375,
0.8048710227012634,
-0.14160574972629547,
-0.3189885914325714,
-0.05932225286960602,
-0.10801596194505692,
-0.5396161675453186,
-0.1719203144311905,
0.29390546679496765,
-0.16712285578250885,
-0.6581346988677979,
-0.47609788179397583,
0.07953465729951859,
-0.45507901906967163,
1.0269906520843506,
0.005925718229264021,
-0.2977498471736908,
-0.5750952363014221,
-0.23657751083374023,
-0.19234566390514374,
-0.5248745679855347,
-0.8541231155395508,
-0.2674146294593811,
0.3555208146572113,
0.3166775405406952,
1.014469861984253,
0.7706451416015625,
0.7513783574104309,
0.3446092903614044,
0.1323055475950241,
-0.0037858218420296907,
-0.24747344851493835,
0.09701907634735107,
0.08212413638830185,
-0.2239760309457779,
-0.5904350280761719,
0.30541813373565674,
0.5674766302108765,
0.35009798407554626,
-0.035049907863140106,
0.4521043598651886,
0.30679604411125183,
0.4873404800891876,
-0.7806025743484497,
0.08782485127449036,
-0.5418692231178284,
-0.09704093635082245,
-0.4045422375202179,
-0.08469825983047485,
-0.5768181085586548,
-0.708004891872406,
-0.16965794563293457,
-0.750568151473999,
0.4526347219944,
0.27321356534957886,
0.7681959271430969,
0.5090837478637695,
0.24660861492156982,
-0.569329023361206,
-0.6751733422279358,
0.9324732422828674,
-0.47085046768188477,
-0.051613178104162216,
0.5777092576026917,
0.3712400496006012,
0.2215481400489807,
-0.4613181948661804,
-0.23716919124126434,
-0.4972655177116394,
-0.1823597550392151,
-0.023109281435608864,
-0.6545098423957825,
0.0901917964220047,
0.2135884016752243,
0.8054528832435608,
-0.5542635321617126,
0.284297913312912,
-0.4520930349826813,
0.049340397119522095,
0.7177562117576599,
0.454661101102829,
0.3394382894039154,
-0.25564706325531006,
-0.07229159027338028,
0.06419070810079575,
-0.6038090586662292,
0.07029403746128082,
0.4875217080116272,
0.5270876288414001,
-0.21986041963100433,
0.8060290217399597,
0.04106933996081352,
0.9135033488273621,
-0.27553868293762207,
0.27082452178001404,
-0.18779322504997253,
-0.2514246106147766,
-0.42702895402908325,
-0.37718507647514343,
1.1293179988861084,
0.16442401707172394,
0.20490378141403198,
-0.20711228251457214,
-0.5979916453361511,
0.5917865037918091,
0.5976618528366089,
-0.5233862400054932,
-0.48124584555625916,
0.05906764417886734,
-0.7313742637634277,
-0.5382789373397827,
-0.24747616052627563,
-0.995851457118988,
-0.5016534328460693,
-0.3546374440193176,
0.45159468054771423,
-0.3398072123527527,
0.1335502415895462,
-0.3870498239994049,
-0.2578529119491577,
-0.09446287900209427,
0.5329350233078003,
-1.0431694984436035,
0.696670413017273,
0.4446115493774414,
1.2538650035858154,
-0.2733633518218994,
0.021727334707975388,
-0.7807590365409851,
-0.27083146572113037,
-0.3447713553905487,
1.0653963088989258,
-0.7960289716720581,
-0.8430124521255493,
-0.02658870443701744,
-0.5849214792251587,
-0.0033011671621352434,
-0.7092239260673523,
0.5554999113082886,
-0.3056366443634033,
0.3237992227077484,
-0.25446370244026184,
-0.4296858012676239,
0.1962146908044815,
0.1059061586856842,
-0.6206870079040527,
1.1382720470428467,
0.1764444261789322,
-0.6053378582000732,
0.318107008934021,
-1.005995750427246,
-0.4196949005126953,
0.4270130395889282,
-0.2521679997444153,
-0.3832958936691284,
0.6878452897071838,
0.31906914710998535,
0.13999877870082855,
-0.5188590884208679,
-0.06600061058998108,
-0.38413524627685547,
-0.7845450639724731,
-0.17121578752994537,
-0.7355061173439026,
0.7093163728713989,
0.3419433832168579,
-0.1806914210319519,
0.5191105008125305,
-0.594107985496521,
0.29413336515426636,
-0.050722189247608185,
-0.3917192816734314,
-0.4557645916938782,
0.2088797390460968,
0.18989065289497375,
-0.15910489857196808,
-0.009381736628711224,
-0.2853125333786011,
0.25450602173805237,
-0.24753043055534363,
0.5464400053024292,
0.8218467235565186,
-0.6081994771957397,
0.42941519618034363,
-0.39476144313812256,
0.6766760945320129,
-0.6884565949440002,
0.5743218660354614,
0.10128773003816605,
-0.8955258727073669,
-0.6235651969909668,
-0.4104764759540558,
0.1974932849407196,
0.5926012992858887,
-0.8284260630607605,
0.2866114377975464,
-0.14615310728549957,
-0.6280608177185059,
-0.9220775365829468,
0.1435728371143341,
0.48293596506118774,
0.42424824833869934,
0.5616810321807861,
-0.33835500478744507,
-0.030666420236229897,
-0.6718370318412781,
-0.3757556974887848,
-0.6478942632675171,
-0.32598528265953064,
0.6099194288253784,
0.4549637734889984,
-0.024714672937989235,
0.7790815234184265,
-0.6496943235397339,
-0.4651995003223419,
-0.08416637033224106,
0.4071289002895355,
-0.1741926074028015,
0.39834436774253845,
0.5057386755943298,
-0.40785932540893555,
-0.45523372292518616,
-0.05889764800667763,
-0.8041845560073853,
-0.09697044640779495,
0.4665497839450836,
0.34928297996520996,
0.3535425066947937,
0.5056174993515015,
-0.598285973072052,
0.6137023568153381,
0.8353817462921143,
-0.4740646779537201,
0.8445149064064026,
-0.7076514959335327,
0.24764873087406158,
-0.39981740713119507,
0.38144567608833313,
0.1922672837972641,
-0.1682535707950592,
-0.3649899959564209,
0.1817692518234253,
-0.1495378166437149,
-0.36277496814727783,
-0.021591216325759888,
0.6810863614082336,
-0.3469344675540924,
-0.1698383092880249,
-0.5331940650939941,
0.0412503257393837,
-0.058987729251384735,
0.10620220750570297,
-0.23745277523994446,
1.1664910316467285,
0.38280507922172546,
-0.6055592894554138,
0.46577656269073486,
-0.03305261582136154,
-0.47385266423225403,
0.530896008014679,
-0.8325368165969849,
0.32985812425613403,
0.01972656324505806,
-0.08533329516649246,
-0.8032611608505249,
-0.2565785348415375,
0.3531254529953003,
-0.5260792374610901,
0.10983555018901825,
-0.045561593025922775,
-0.5015429258346558,
-0.5208500027656555,
-0.3816514313220978,
0.5169147849082947,
0.7252312898635864,
-0.5136776566505432,
0.7692856788635254,
0.42874079942703247,
-0.29588451981544495,
-0.24228264391422272,
-0.5575318336486816,
0.07288310676813126,
-0.1926976591348648,
-0.4448665380477905,
0.33628830313682556,
-0.0029966814909130335,
-0.6074051856994629,
0.4091019928455353,
0.44861918687820435,
-0.056821469217538834,
0.30298537015914917,
0.138789564371109,
0.4587665796279907,
-0.35530322790145874,
0.17720702290534973,
-0.14487500488758087,
-0.19024677574634552,
-0.048456158488988876,
-0.19547463953495026,
0.3171968460083008,
-0.33992788195610046,
-0.4281425178050995,
-0.3675364553928375,
0.6700064539909363,
0.6364684700965881,
-0.13793356716632843,
0.5643313527107239,
0.4065820574760437,
-0.4280300438404083,
-0.22563424706459045,
-0.30488982796669006,
0.12299887835979462,
-0.5020451545715332,
0.10459300875663757,
-0.17981548607349396,
-0.6888421773910522,
0.3961009979248047,
0.44001835584640503,
0.07296649366617203,
0.7317306399345398,
0.594701886177063,
-0.052500590682029724,
1.193953037261963,
0.866627037525177,
-0.3060610592365265,
0.3515318036079407,
0.11602626740932465,
0.07007008790969849,
-0.5189522504806519,
-0.029033318161964417,
-0.9799593687057495,
-0.07826799154281616,
-0.5728073716163635,
-0.43375110626220703,
0.21848909556865692,
0.010317442938685417,
-0.22364374995231628,
-0.11077293753623962,
-0.7445387840270996,
0.6094987988471985,
0.833756148815155,
-0.03845449909567833,
0.48881620168685913,
-0.13621297478675842,
0.04167358577251434,
0.12891443073749542,
-0.5872141718864441,
-0.8534768223762512,
0.9525612592697144,
0.25107792019844055,
0.8861899375915527,
-0.026125963777303696,
0.34738659858703613,
0.8769019246101379,
1.0566107034683228,
-0.6839713454246521,
0.32035645842552185,
-0.8003771901130676,
-0.37258654832839966,
-0.39531636238098145,
-0.5512978434562683,
-0.6138851046562195,
0.016370739787817,
-0.034357424825429916,
-0.8787874579429626,
-0.09415414184331894,
0.5624958872795105,
-0.718252956867218,
0.2496577650308609,
-0.9547494053840637,
1.0167207717895508,
0.004811680875718594,
-0.33017590641975403,
-0.2216779887676239,
-0.061833661049604416,
0.39909178018569946,
0.08537894487380981,
0.2507120966911316,
-0.048312824219465256,
0.11939648538827896,
0.5508630275726318,
-0.4325733184814453,
0.6575681567192078,
-0.35263970494270325,
-0.1669316440820694,
0.3346477448940277,
-0.11979825049638748,
0.412447452545166,
-0.10803218185901642,
-0.2257559448480606,
0.044621385633945465,
-0.3700923025608063,
-0.3087611794471741,
-0.5091234445571899,
0.928229570388794,
-0.769089937210083,
-0.6073005795478821,
-0.37000399827957153,
-0.25281068682670593,
-0.1930186152458191,
-0.16850869357585907,
0.5837579965591431,
0.4234732389450073,
-0.20728975534439087,
-0.1275784820318222,
0.4714794456958771,
-0.3311783969402313,
0.39388641715049744,
0.1759316325187683,
-0.2610303461551666,
-0.35485202074050903,
1.1534678936004639,
-0.05176990479230881,
0.09157014638185501,
-0.10916087031364441,
0.0983261689543724,
-0.4157700836658478,
-0.6357557773590088,
-0.9482332468032837,
-0.09822417795658112,
-0.6426502466201782,
-0.37782710790634155,
-0.27551737427711487,
-0.06216312572360039,
-0.22939899563789368,
-0.22632530331611633,
-0.36588501930236816,
-0.04845557361841202,
-0.7214844822883606,
0.18281160295009613,
0.19460177421569824,
1.0762720108032227,
0.2713397145271301,
0.2437664270401001,
-0.7230086326599121,
0.4212583303451538,
0.2302529513835907,
0.8493943810462952,
0.09893833845853806,
-0.5277947783470154,
-0.23967689275741577,
-0.28702130913734436,
-0.4587022662162781,
-0.5073548555374146,
0.2962956428527832,
0.3048293888568878,
0.30785876512527466,
0.23923543095588684,
0.0007289621280506253,
0.500973641872406,
-0.5142056345939636,
1.0046700239181519,
-0.0022366452030837536,
-1.1432664394378662,
0.6615978479385376,
-0.2204897105693817,
0.33365246653556824,
0.5169354677200317,
0.2980940341949463,
-0.2618744969367981,
-0.6037503480911255,
-0.3457450568675995,
-0.5438205599784851,
0.793659508228302,
0.2892882823944092,
0.22833386063575745,
0.13609211146831512,
0.31749427318573,
0.10932847112417221,
0.0029153365176171064,
-0.5585350394248962,
-0.23176218569278717,
-0.20693828165531158,
-0.6175448894500732,
-0.3158869743347168,
-0.0984124094247818,
-0.07455509155988693,
-0.41838890314102173,
0.587285041809082,
-0.31155920028686523,
0.3824452757835388,
-0.027569545432925224,
0.10730282217264175,
-0.3535493314266205,
0.10200756788253784,
0.5739173889160156,
0.19351567327976227,
-0.03554408624768257,
-0.04961520433425903,
-0.1828595995903015,
-0.5987058877944946,
0.10489021241664886,
0.40479838848114014,
-0.557264506816864,
-0.06387246400117874,
0.256453275680542,
1.0132683515548706,
-0.2026134878396988,
-0.6099418997764587,
0.3935490846633911,
-0.46288374066352844,
-0.18196409940719604,
0.015847139060497284,
0.3162562847137451,
-0.37240177392959595,
0.029117679223418236,
0.2596874237060547,
0.3231409788131714,
0.1475629210472107,
-0.42254438996315,
-0.12998822331428528,
0.6437117457389832,
-0.540334165096283,
-0.3012332618236542,
0.9969078898429871,
0.23794151842594147,
-0.5094326138496399,
0.9534943103790283,
-0.16060638427734375,
-0.1621774584054947,
0.2568749487400055,
0.2639264762401581,
1.0611958503723145,
-0.24764016270637512,
0.2986924648284912,
0.2365313321352005,
0.39485499262809753,
-0.11624574661254883,
0.13338768482208252,
-0.21012148261070251,
-0.3321264386177063,
-0.38954922556877136,
-0.963588535785675,
-0.5726163387298584,
0.15390779078006744,
-0.47451505064964294,
0.23923945426940918,
-0.47142910957336426,
-0.4938295781612396,
0.004395500756800175,
-0.006476282607764006,
-0.49316656589508057,
0.36583730578422546,
0.2820695638656616,
0.7672060132026672,
-0.8051946759223938,
0.7587761282920837,
0.7800218462944031,
-0.40623411536216736,
-0.5212913155555725,
-0.14475871622562408,
-0.09493215382099152,
-0.5253285765647888,
0.325778067111969,
0.12107731401920319,
-0.07891528308391571,
-0.0016749707283452153,
-0.30002912878990173,
-0.6463695168495178,
0.6210520267486572,
0.41258105635643005,
-0.26895856857299805,
-0.3619287312030792,
0.20810237526893616,
0.7223336696624756,
-0.06842711567878723,
0.5011196732521057,
0.5338400602340698,
0.3969329595565796,
-0.3498867154121399,
-0.9002285003662109,
-0.11821406334638596,
-0.5706896781921387,
-0.012268977239727974,
0.22972357273101807,
-0.4469389319419861,
0.9463714361190796,
-0.18258218467235565,
-0.2854190468788147,
0.3481543958187103,
0.5695213079452515,
0.033472415059804916,
0.4093784689903259,
0.3892144560813904,
0.7720641493797302,
0.8618228435516357,
-0.3859294652938843,
1.5349880456924438,
-0.03841649740934372,
0.3038639426231384,
0.7079787850379944,
0.01363048143684864,
0.9228243231773376,
0.05788436159491539,
-0.3208179175853729,
0.45088112354278564,
0.3349452614784241,
-0.16746488213539124,
0.4490838944911957,
0.30913054943084717,
-0.3836674094200134,
-0.22693878412246704,
0.0026980217080563307,
-0.0919593870639801,
0.4402766525745392,
0.3898954391479492,
-0.5921990275382996,
-0.25043556094169617,
0.13631851971149445,
-0.37999847531318665,
0.19658046960830688,
-0.537554144859314,
0.7879723310470581,
0.1255587488412857,
-0.8555951714515686,
0.4784563481807709,
0.2071142941713333,
0.7196847796440125,
-0.49700888991355896,
0.12004800140857697,
-0.20285427570343018,
0.3417748212814331,
-0.056611184030771255,
-0.6039835214614868,
0.577227771282196,
0.7023217082023621,
-0.4952376186847687,
-0.16030342876911163,
0.772643506526947,
0.01939653791487217,
-0.5761426687240601,
0.2596982717514038,
0.5018925070762634,
0.0027025851886719465,
-0.2851974070072174,
-0.5704084038734436,
0.42609527707099915,
-0.3394579291343689,
-0.05617879331111908,
0.37392720580101013,
0.08127491921186447,
-0.13299836218357086,
0.710570216178894,
0.46127453446388245,
0.15526530146598816,
-0.03926151245832443,
0.193203866481781,
0.7624229788780212,
-0.607190728187561,
-0.3938610255718231,
-0.9843475222587585,
0.31064099073410034,
-0.051468007266521454,
-0.6010020971298218,
0.828106701374054,
0.5598417520523071,
0.5383404493331909,
-0.01140615250915289,
0.9440782070159912,
0.06250347942113876,
0.38320988416671753,
-0.5085098743438721,
0.9728464484214783,
-0.7409690022468567,
0.13478022813796997,
-0.3889100253582001,
-0.8174561858177185,
-0.4374206066131592,
0.33743953704833984,
-0.448168009519577,
0.10423402488231659,
0.42512521147727966,
0.5017192363739014,
0.11507228761911392,
0.3590528070926666,
0.2505614757537842,
-0.21638011932373047,
0.5227814316749573,
0.3632030487060547,
0.8768038153648376,
-0.36791250109672546,
0.5205810070037842,
-0.0465238131582737,
-0.488356351852417,
-0.16210106015205383,
-0.6492791175842285,
-0.5054372549057007,
-0.3138740360736847,
-0.3447602391242981,
-0.029556993395090103,
0.3105884790420532,
0.47298887372016907,
0.3108668923377991,
-0.8703563213348389,
-0.06102581322193146,
-0.2896481156349182,
-0.11020903289318085,
-0.10115866363048553,
-0.23300577700138092,
0.49830636382102966,
-0.7041847109794617,
-0.8444324135780334,
0.30607348680496216,
0.3102783262729645,
-0.007268714718520641,
-0.3653234839439392,
0.0014618929708376527,
0.47511962056159973,
0.13298380374908447,
0.5708045959472656,
0.302232027053833,
-0.6844762563705444,
-0.23917518556118011,
-0.14830902218818665,
-0.38103148341178894,
0.039801597595214844,
0.9275158643722534,
-0.9295927286148071,
0.2821634113788605,
0.2566254734992981,
0.5324016809463501,
-0.19113782048225403,
0.3301793336868286,
0.578777551651001,
-0.517723023891449,
-0.33074751496315,
0.5561845302581787,
0.1651904135942459,
0.5277045369148254,
-0.21100366115570068,
0.05773518607020378,
0.37414804100990295,
-0.8582342267036438,
-0.8504713177680969,
-0.19163042306900024,
-0.44301027059555054,
-0.2596246600151062,
0.9953025579452515,
-0.09329958260059357,
-0.17303256690502167,
-0.2576521635055542,
-0.08858731389045715,
-0.019550329074263573,
-0.3670711815357208,
1.0472397804260254,
0.5858932733535767,
-0.15304261445999146,
0.22315701842308044,
-0.482734352350235,
0.9554965496063232,
0.2850194275379181,
-1.068208932876587,
0.42256098985671997,
0.6912769079208374,
-0.2194131761789322,
0.1406124085187912,
0.9397628903388977,
-0.07736541330814362,
0.3392789661884308,
0.34780576825141907,
-0.2327214777469635,
0.08861009776592255,
-0.3736594021320343,
-0.40688765048980713,
0.5207195281982422,
0.2979406714439392,
-0.05160682275891304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01863v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01863v1 | VSP: Assessing the dual challenges of perception and reasoning in spatial planning tasks for VLMs | 2024-07-02T00:24:01 | 2024-07-02T00:24:01 | Qiucheng Wu, Handong Zhao, Michael Saxon, Trung Bui, William Yang Wang, Yang Zhang, Shiyu Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Vision language models (VLMs) are an exciting emerging class of language
models (LMs) that have merged classic LM capabilities with those of image
processing systems. However, the ways that these capabilities combine are not
always intuitive and warrant direct investigation. One understudied capability
in VLMs is visual spatial planning -- the ability to comprehend the spatial
arrangements of objects and devise action plans to achieve desired outcomes in
visual scenes. In our study, we introduce VSP, a benchmark that 1) evaluates
the spatial planning capability in these models in general, and 2) breaks down
the visual planning task into finer-grained sub-tasks, including perception and
reasoning, and measure the LMs capabilities in these sub-tasks. Our evaluation
shows that both open-source and private VLMs fail to generate effective plans
for even simple spatial planning tasks. Evaluations on the fine-grained
analytical tasks further reveal fundamental deficiencies in the models' visual
perception and bottlenecks in reasoning abilities, explaining their worse
performance in the general spatial planning tasks. Our work illuminates future
directions for improving VLMs' abilities in spatial planning. Our benchmark is
publicly available at
https://github.com/UCSB-NLP-Chang/Visual-Spatial-Planning. | [
-0.43078458309173584,
-0.3235538601875305,
0.9206902980804443,
0.32975441217422485,
0.021130396053195,
-0.2992292642593384,
-0.09533397108316422,
-0.6878137588500977,
-0.09934951364994049,
0.6876094341278076,
-0.5709300637245178,
-0.3511335551738739,
-0.347342312335968,
-0.10629023611545563,
-0.20073509216308594,
0.2581709027290344,
-0.170638769865036,
0.20983774960041046,
-0.5166599750518799,
-0.2755168378353119,
-0.8761356472969055,
-0.6228042244911194,
-0.1850416362285614,
-0.22094173729419708,
0.24804973602294922,
0.3564876914024353,
0.6471946239471436,
0.44023653864860535,
0.7510553598403931,
0.3401188552379608,
-0.12372484803199768,
0.33809009194374084,
-0.3594702184200287,
0.042574692517519,
-0.45900270342826843,
-0.1832781583070755,
-0.13162298500537872,
-0.36740607023239136,
0.542540967464447,
0.8893101811408997,
-0.05390024185180664,
0.2496623992919922,
-0.1577185094356537,
0.833848237991333,
-0.8661353588104248,
0.27146923542022705,
-0.654975414276123,
0.3956202268600464,
0.0194499883800745,
0.01533302292227745,
-0.133122980594635,
0.1064668744802475,
0.3097045123577118,
-0.3924858868122101,
0.11579815298318863,
0.15586549043655396,
0.7344105243682861,
0.3753657937049866,
-0.09209750592708588,
0.052441854029893875,
-1.1438857316970825,
0.596326470375061,
-0.29311615228652954,
0.45430251955986023,
0.21788041293621063,
0.6145211458206177,
0.07106006890535355,
-0.810658872127533,
-0.5270975232124329,
-0.28123342990875244,
-0.12200924009084702,
0.14905574917793274,
-0.3923867642879486,
-0.09410230070352554,
0.6707308888435364,
0.01966211199760437,
-0.8433864116668701,
-0.011890534311532974,
-0.6022003889083862,
0.09243917465209961,
0.6689568758010864,
0.4653468728065491,
0.012735418044030666,
-0.2237113118171692,
-0.8255670070648193,
-0.06873440742492676,
-0.314341276884079,
0.2254696488380432,
-0.04252500832080841,
0.2238520234823227,
0.03650471568107605,
1.0875962972640991,
-0.5323788523674011,
0.6947618722915649,
-0.5098493099212646,
0.3109845817089081,
0.028289951384067535,
-0.6767160892486572,
-0.592003583908081,
-0.5105717778205872,
0.5217499136924744,
0.6582393050193787,
0.4868783950805664,
0.19044692814350128,
-0.19449293613433838,
0.2186906933784485,
0.541297197341919,
-0.20865875482559204,
-0.3955269753932953,
0.32357752323150635,
-0.2935202121734619,
0.04634272679686546,
-0.3518431782722473,
-0.6996409296989441,
-0.4325600564479828,
-0.5672361850738525,
0.2909034788608551,
-0.3542282283306122,
-0.17579765617847443,
0.4872930347919464,
-0.40679240226745605,
0.2350427359342575,
0.45128482580184937,
-0.6743615865707397,
0.42928364872932434,
0.7637240290641785,
0.5024827718734741,
-0.09431234002113342,
-0.7105636596679688,
-0.2714003920555115,
-0.05275890603661537,
-0.36921557784080505,
1.1810423135757446,
-0.3377538323402405,
-0.5155710577964783,
0.0696646124124527,
-0.3284975290298462,
-0.19436271488666534,
-0.6753644943237305,
0.6110697984695435,
0.02279403805732727,
-0.2056562602519989,
-0.8601157665252686,
-0.11388659477233887,
0.03816941753029823,
0.42960652709007263,
-0.3836427927017212,
1.170979619026184,
0.17545561492443085,
-0.4454100430011749,
0.7890332341194153,
-0.28575313091278076,
-0.03685795143246651,
0.3815714418888092,
-0.5479772090911865,
-0.10987512767314911,
0.3814966380596161,
0.23560333251953125,
0.28975799679756165,
0.06187814474105835,
0.15325111150741577,
-0.44939932227134705,
-0.07160532474517822,
0.011296446435153484,
-0.002716681221500039,
0.5310686826705933,
0.07635995000600815,
-0.22980822622776031,
0.6130750179290771,
-0.7419388294219971,
0.5031983256340027,
0.39070743322372437,
-0.06089178845286369,
-0.24530771374702454,
0.49676215648651123,
0.0006722923717461526,
0.33781418204307556,
0.3013899624347687,
0.021733570843935013,
0.43272843956947327,
-0.20882442593574524,
0.08120749145746231,
0.7706379890441895,
-0.43153128027915955,
0.6195433139801025,
-0.04160759970545769,
0.19736936688423157,
-0.18110933899879456,
0.45863068103790283,
0.17173707485198975,
-0.5954526662826538,
-0.748533308506012,
0.05986905097961426,
-0.3435940444469452,
0.7307045459747314,
-0.8466054201126099,
-0.03842684254050255,
-0.2755776643753052,
-0.5807902216911316,
0.05981409549713135,
-0.034269072115421295,
0.4519243836402893,
0.40375959873199463,
0.4834047853946686,
-0.43428170680999756,
-0.5955116152763367,
-0.7579209804534912,
-0.32076752185821533,
-0.41405874490737915,
-0.0237271711230278,
0.4450767934322357,
0.6301950216293335,
-0.10824593156576157,
0.7386056184768677,
-0.578766942024231,
-0.3565196990966797,
-0.47458416223526,
-0.14074082672595978,
-0.21789059042930603,
0.1082247793674469,
0.6851701140403748,
-0.8478292226791382,
-0.3223414123058319,
-0.0992831289768219,
-0.8007730841636658,
-0.43223610520362854,
0.027183422818779945,
-0.029254905879497528,
0.08636727929115295,
0.4117136001586914,
-0.654727578163147,
0.6934089064598083,
0.39273372292518616,
-0.8894892930984497,
1.1506074666976929,
-0.40608084201812744,
-0.2133139967918396,
-0.03485669195652008,
-0.09078355878591537,
0.16266733407974243,
-0.04759614169597626,
-0.6845311522483826,
0.5606340765953064,
-0.04074375331401825,
-0.32501599192619324,
-0.4869352877140045,
0.43744972348213196,
-0.5256429314613342,
-0.8224072456359863,
-0.16933324933052063,
0.03112740069627762,
-0.06990459561347961,
0.6231616735458374,
0.5699903964996338,
0.6145929098129272,
0.4235045313835144,
-0.4494980573654175,
0.31130728125572205,
0.08805929124355316,
-0.3924065828323364,
0.6292478442192078,
-0.5974919199943542,
-0.21434837579727173,
-0.10551916062831879,
-0.22946476936340332,
-0.9076811671257019,
0.1672714799642563,
0.3202269673347473,
-0.05235535278916359,
-0.04532477259635925,
-0.06041690334677696,
-0.3104444146156311,
-0.6160833239555359,
-0.10987644642591476,
0.08569152653217316,
0.24458949267864227,
-0.29385486245155334,
0.6536349654197693,
0.21500325202941895,
-0.03690595552325249,
-0.3145824670791626,
-0.5518516302108765,
0.1548430621623993,
-0.027324911206960678,
-0.6138020753860474,
0.0369790755212307,
-0.0632786899805069,
-0.6670806407928467,
0.2389133721590042,
-0.2654270529747009,
-0.0708187073469162,
-0.11481475830078125,
0.3137618601322174,
0.05256877839565277,
-0.312715619802475,
-0.3148919641971588,
-0.4040287733078003,
-0.37904396653175354,
0.10717622190713882,
-0.3503192663192749,
0.5687118172645569,
-0.2989335060119629,
-0.8252202272415161,
-0.04588685557246208,
0.49195802211761475,
0.5438675880432129,
-0.6127819418907166,
0.4721309244632721,
0.33313658833503723,
-0.22123633325099945,
-0.2787921726703644,
-0.45761170983314514,
0.36953306198120117,
-0.3548382818698883,
0.3488849997520447,
-0.6168171167373657,
-0.4343920052051544,
0.19197005033493042,
-0.23026657104492188,
0.15421810746192932,
0.20896129310131073,
0.19210359454154968,
-0.29899948835372925,
0.8868006467819214,
0.9094110131263733,
0.2687324285507202,
0.32180076837539673,
-0.23599280416965485,
0.17827075719833374,
-0.5831772685050964,
-0.4288273751735687,
-0.624480128288269,
-0.3160081207752228,
-0.18060070276260376,
-0.9682877659797668,
0.20541886985301971,
0.1529940962791443,
-0.13315360248088837,
0.4463759958744049,
-0.4816959798336029,
0.4259459972381592,
0.7122013568878174,
-0.26282623410224915,
0.1195601373910904,
0.10761571675539017,
-0.0371818020939827,
-0.4641076624393463,
-0.569110631942749,
-0.6167098879814148,
0.8003737926483154,
0.2645156681537628,
0.3240865170955658,
-0.07940270006656647,
0.25621283054351807,
0.08854630589485168,
-0.41673678159713745,
-0.6598878502845764,
0.9572222828865051,
-0.15050508081912994,
-0.060995426028966904,
-0.4299389123916626,
-0.20825643837451935,
-0.4728272259235382,
0.8481637835502625,
-0.4265238344669342,
-1.0113544464111328,
0.5043632984161377,
0.17087894678115845,
-0.13982290029525757,
0.32847216725349426,
-0.8634522557258606,
1.0342934131622314,
-0.6142601370811462,
-0.3919464647769928,
-0.0811644047498703,
-0.4015175700187683,
0.21373039484024048,
0.31753814220428467,
0.026647482067346573,
-0.21916979551315308,
-0.048758722841739655,
0.07574048638343811,
-0.2553081214427948,
0.5256714820861816,
-0.3655134439468384,
0.3120180368423462,
0.05959610268473625,
0.1034795343875885,
0.4318172037601471,
-0.28392234444618225,
0.1375678926706314,
0.49340561032295227,
0.11902528256177902,
-0.37437787652015686,
-0.3813786804676056,
0.34499940276145935,
-0.43378618359565735,
-0.4065127670764923,
-0.42521846294403076,
-0.41442885994911194,
-0.28761178255081177,
0.2527869939804077,
0.18718521296977997,
0.20735853910446167,
-0.2491622269153595,
-0.23819981515407562,
0.5714347958564758,
-0.2760564684867859,
0.26649120450019836,
0.5282315611839294,
-0.8340063691139221,
-0.05444921925663948,
0.6851192712783813,
0.24439167976379395,
0.29087382555007935,
0.25922152400016785,
0.15987682342529297,
-0.2579003572463989,
-1.0535637140274048,
-0.38688600063323975,
0.017580591142177582,
-0.6690347790718079,
0.2893688380718231,
-0.536998450756073,
-0.27702176570892334,
-0.27721306681632996,
-0.20245516300201416,
-0.44248294830322266,
-0.23183271288871765,
0.1415940821170807,
-0.050859466195106506,
-0.3991374373435974,
0.8339203000068665,
-0.10735885053873062,
-0.12265745550394058,
-0.2967723608016968,
0.6253438591957092,
0.38689160346984863,
0.17658624053001404,
-0.31849372386932373,
0.04096546396613121,
0.04410324990749359,
-0.161531001329422,
-0.17884069681167603,
-0.631081223487854,
0.5064247846603394,
-0.38563477993011475,
0.5677082538604736,
0.2858979403972626,
-0.04115218669176102,
1.0540765523910522,
-0.7596583962440491,
0.9769865870475769,
-0.02903224341571331,
-0.5745077133178711,
0.668182909488678,
-0.07185275107622147,
0.45172950625419617,
0.4250355362892151,
0.12346058338880539,
-0.2158258557319641,
-0.3604592978954315,
-0.5634386539459229,
-0.9163901209831238,
0.45229360461235046,
0.24768556654453278,
-0.3639209568500519,
0.3033226430416107,
-0.13661576807498932,
-0.31263241171836853,
0.22151128947734833,
-0.7593554258346558,
-0.09815681725740433,
-0.04112047329545021,
0.44345882534980774,
-0.29002654552459717,
-0.8406370878219604,
-0.14254765212535858,
-0.4707942008972168,
0.12591297924518585,
-0.0128329461440444,
0.2544713020324707,
0.3580018877983093,
0.1581907868385315,
-0.17259865999221802,
0.10558383166790009,
0.9875528812408447,
0.8483926057815552,
0.02756122685968876,
0.18018923699855804,
0.22573259472846985,
-0.20826199650764465,
-0.4748450517654419,
0.16129569709300995,
-0.1893552839756012,
0.08050956577062607,
0.5862022042274475,
0.8029099702835083,
0.3063620328903198,
-0.8544846773147583,
0.46621719002723694,
-0.2535645365715027,
-0.45525339245796204,
-0.5048270225524902,
-0.02247561886906624,
-0.015612979419529438,
0.6304181218147278,
0.1540338546037674,
0.5207536220550537,
0.1463029533624649,
-0.43531954288482666,
-0.15269926190376282,
0.35110723972320557,
-0.42852067947387695,
-0.13707435131072998,
0.5365955829620361,
-0.09561256319284439,
-0.30121713876724243,
0.508078396320343,
-0.15122157335281372,
-0.5318801403045654,
0.5709858536720276,
0.2627307176589966,
0.700842022895813,
0.11214343458414078,
0.21748384833335876,
0.2973666787147522,
0.7521287202835083,
0.011851032264530659,
0.7024272680282593,
-0.2655932605266571,
-0.7653059959411621,
-0.32006514072418213,
-0.5166440010070801,
-0.3355414867401123,
0.11901506036520004,
-0.4907327890396118,
0.03350244089961052,
-0.47725364565849304,
-0.009364869445562363,
-0.1366644948720932,
0.016130048781633377,
-0.7993063926696777,
0.09436871856451035,
0.2631615102291107,
1.0512768030166626,
-0.8581292629241943,
0.46155330538749695,
0.9565563201904297,
-0.22836998105049133,
-0.6091534495353699,
-0.13513609766960144,
0.1697015017271042,
-1.0003275871276855,
0.7207133769989014,
0.03260313719511032,
-0.08707071095705032,
-0.5406815409660339,
-0.339971661567688,
-0.6913046836853027,
0.7406017780303955,
0.14919744431972504,
-0.8292579650878906,
-0.30839866399765015,
0.3985937833786011,
0.7742516398429871,
0.06416977196931839,
-0.19897696375846863,
0.40933528542518616,
0.5937032699584961,
0.04365729168057442,
-1.1099261045455933,
-0.3314012587070465,
-0.1555180698633194,
0.1693796068429947,
0.2879078686237335,
-0.2930808663368225,
0.7521907091140747,
-0.46450185775756836,
-0.27221325039863586,
0.13206130266189575,
0.5428406000137329,
0.41065502166748047,
0.7138275504112244,
0.5180793404579163,
0.9453694224357605,
0.4667600989341736,
-0.2547147870063782,
1.0737589597702026,
0.14513856172561646,
0.044060178101062775,
1.272464632987976,
-0.6756485104560852,
1.2153383493423462,
0.6435578465461731,
-0.2746690511703491,
0.057130277156829834,
0.08863696455955505,
0.00571045558899641,
0.6563893556594849,
0.13767118752002716,
-0.11125694215297699,
-0.40658849477767944,
-0.0006415380630642176,
-0.2797003388404846,
0.5868551731109619,
0.37835514545440674,
0.05686867982149124,
-0.3884984254837036,
0.015871146693825722,
-0.5742267370223999,
0.5015232563018799,
-0.4379321336746216,
0.6754118800163269,
0.12319213896989822,
-0.5819475650787354,
0.07699164003133774,
-0.229092538356781,
0.09079596400260925,
-0.7219107151031494,
-0.09720519930124283,
0.07156519591808319,
0.2878270447254181,
-0.07637245208024979,
-1.2508890628814697,
0.6905459761619568,
0.03383950516581535,
-0.14931389689445496,
-0.7309616804122925,
1.0188006162643433,
-0.07643712311983109,
-0.24991662800312042,
0.591291606426239,
0.6044664978981018,
0.0557393841445446,
-0.28291866183280945,
-0.7920086979866028,
0.4008640944957733,
-0.05294624716043472,
-0.12425705045461655,
0.28058573603630066,
0.539871335029602,
-0.1657843142747879,
0.8284274935722351,
0.5461170673370361,
0.43731799721717834,
0.03499574959278107,
0.0718003362417221,
0.6513864994049072,
-0.6755149364471436,
-0.30830010771751404,
-0.6606197953224182,
0.680072546005249,
-0.2140343189239502,
-0.30839771032333374,
0.7797915935516357,
0.5344506502151489,
1.271700143814087,
-0.2565074861049652,
0.45213958621025085,
0.043835606426000595,
0.2508157193660736,
-0.6587285399436951,
0.18453067541122437,
-0.5721927285194397,
0.2768732011318207,
-0.20968350768089294,
-0.7227005362510681,
-0.17252475023269653,
0.6458557844161987,
-0.8460255861282349,
-0.20893649756908417,
0.6657010316848755,
0.3474756181240082,
-0.020974051207304,
-0.3545321226119995,
0.7478258013725281,
-0.17459063231945038,
0.1636284589767456,
0.6913288831710815,
1.0593104362487793,
0.0018495188560336828,
0.46689340472221375,
-0.5868661403656006,
0.014095268212258816,
-0.07476072758436203,
-0.7976135015487671,
-0.689134418964386,
-0.680372953414917,
-0.01708492822945118,
0.12233058363199234,
-0.03516719117760658,
0.3648419976234436,
0.6526435017585754,
-0.31851255893707275,
-0.3341676890850067,
-0.2790166735649109,
0.09133106470108032,
-0.46470165252685547,
-0.2388806939125061,
-0.15224617719650269,
-0.11561311781406403,
-0.4170536398887634,
0.467277854681015,
0.662358820438385,
0.021417370066046715,
-0.32892122864723206,
0.10591310262680054,
0.09968973696231842,
-0.23896408081054688,
0.8824637532234192,
0.6147435903549194,
-0.8156506419181824,
-0.29473474621772766,
-0.1470615565776825,
-0.20607632398605347,
-0.13650895655155182,
0.776181161403656,
-0.7714560031890869,
0.5994055271148682,
0.5282456874847412,
0.26141446828842163,
0.4939156770706177,
-0.11980880796909332,
0.5043867826461792,
-0.43911945819854736,
0.2279645800590515,
0.2480381280183792,
0.6419599056243896,
0.04266652464866638,
-0.04301075637340546,
0.7423493266105652,
0.23385101556777954,
-0.5101120471954346,
-0.8162468075752258,
0.5226016044616699,
-1.2504024505615234,
-0.4562205672264099,
0.9305944442749023,
0.11561764776706696,
-0.1084817573428154,
0.012573632411658764,
-0.6316820383071899,
-0.4687711000442505,
0.10320448875427246,
0.4394359290599823,
0.3524491786956787,
-0.23229201138019562,
-0.32281625270843506,
-0.8521330952644348,
0.3691173493862152,
0.3310190439224243,
-0.5723639130592346,
0.26037585735321045,
0.8894385099411011,
-0.14059913158416748,
0.39871326088905334,
1.0061697959899902,
0.19145704805850983,
0.3129039406776428,
0.42956849932670593,
0.03734380379319191,
-0.17408016324043274,
-0.7759810090065002,
-0.262553870677948,
0.4217497706413269,
0.1696382462978363,
-0.07951303571462631
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01853v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01853v1 | Improving Multilingual Instruction Finetuning via Linguistically Natural and Diverse Datasets | 2024-07-01T23:47:09 | 2024-07-01T23:47:09 | Sathish Reddy Indurthi, Wenxuan Zhou, Shamil Chollampatt, Ravi Agrawal, Kaiqiang Song, Lingxiao Zhao, Chenguang Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly enhanced
instruction-following capabilities. However, most Instruction Fine-Tuning (IFT)
datasets are predominantly in English, limiting model performance in other
languages. Traditional methods for creating multilingual IFT datasets such as
translating existing English IFT datasets or converting existing NLP datasets
into IFT datasets by templating, struggle to capture linguistic nuances and
ensure prompt (instruction) diversity. To address this issue, we propose a
novel method for collecting multilingual IFT datasets that preserves linguistic
naturalness and ensures prompt diversity. This approach leverages
English-focused LLMs, monolingual corpora, and a scoring function to create
high-quality, diversified IFT datasets in multiple languages. Experiments
demonstrate that LLMs finetuned using these IFT datasets show notable
improvements in both generative and discriminative tasks, indicating enhanced
language comprehension by LLMs in non-English contexts. Specifically, on the
multilingual summarization task, LLMs using our IFT dataset achieved 17.57% and
15.23% improvements over LLMs fine-tuned with translation-based and
template-based datasets, respectively. | [
-0.46829164028167725,
-0.5942186713218689,
0.01737160235643387,
0.31859689950942993,
-0.18834571540355682,
0.3511142134666443,
-0.861416220664978,
-0.09582479298114777,
-0.0388515330851078,
0.2859448492527008,
-0.6064582467079163,
-0.8987272381782532,
-0.4340149164199829,
0.5627058744430542,
0.026637984439730644,
1.1585637331008911,
-0.033160414546728134,
0.3361039161682129,
0.017368461936712265,
-0.4285174608230591,
-0.899537205696106,
-0.10416272282600403,
-0.6739866137504578,
-0.01564856618642807,
0.49135446548461914,
0.9443471431732178,
0.34360793232917786,
0.5591074824333191,
0.18222902715206146,
0.25309818983078003,
0.1335241198539734,
0.9651027917861938,
-0.4530141353607178,
-0.06164206936955452,
-0.20375759899616241,
-0.5346994400024414,
-0.04489849880337715,
-0.2775639295578003,
0.9451311230659485,
0.9929690957069397,
-0.11680775880813599,
0.14605049788951874,
0.49073824286460876,
0.7097663879394531,
-0.4846723675727844,
0.40677085518836975,
-0.461943656206131,
0.045377217233181,
-0.24720758199691772,
-0.36746594309806824,
-0.4697270095348358,
-0.4885750114917755,
0.00798928551375866,
-0.47751009464263916,
0.3524441123008728,
-0.20908261835575104,
0.3961981534957886,
0.19636398553848267,
-0.5385406017303467,
-0.331226110458374,
-0.5534627437591553,
0.8436275720596313,
-0.6043590903282166,
0.6504672169685364,
0.3654806911945343,
0.14122234284877777,
0.08896862715482712,
-0.21465261280536652,
-0.133330836892128,
-0.1964908391237259,
-0.1277446448802948,
0.0620630718767643,
0.01040627807378769,
-0.14254945516586304,
0.045177362859249115,
0.45484936237335205,
-0.6296191811561584,
0.509120762348175,
-0.4534142017364502,
-0.2257978618144989,
0.5559628009796143,
0.2254793792963028,
0.2790879011154175,
-0.052335064858198166,
-0.11264785379171371,
-0.12741604447364807,
-0.7167264223098755,
0.3086336553096771,
0.3743988275527954,
0.913907527923584,
-0.4501323103904724,
0.382707417011261,
-0.15769752860069275,
0.8917617201805115,
-0.02231306955218315,
-0.3078930675983429,
0.2599486708641052,
-0.6353198289871216,
0.11281940340995789,
0.12639226019382477,
0.4892957806587219,
0.5659384727478027,
0.3599063754081726,
-0.21372561156749725,
-0.17489615082740784,
-0.18007171154022217,
-0.3135233521461487,
-0.8213807344436646,
-0.18387548625469208,
-0.03967287763953209,
-0.13974076509475708,
0.20614568889141083,
0.05737210065126419,
-0.7795384526252747,
-0.12224075198173523,
-0.7977210879325867,
-0.031305450946092606,
-0.7002264261245728,
0.07160817831754684,
0.2780636250972748,
0.26074132323265076,
0.2814561724662781,
0.13487136363983154,
-1.0702258348464966,
0.16929864883422852,
0.5225958824157715,
0.7884032726287842,
-0.28798791766166687,
-0.4410150647163391,
-0.6745352149009705,
-0.10241622477769852,
-0.417991578578949,
0.6788036227226257,
-0.46813181042671204,
-0.29746729135513306,
0.0535036139190197,
0.20538225769996643,
-0.18717123568058014,
-0.5108643770217896,
0.30990076065063477,
-0.25285717844963074,
0.4732480049133301,
-0.24770961701869965,
-0.6401169896125793,
-0.31672874093055725,
0.5611094236373901,
-0.5638485550880432,
0.7695748209953308,
-0.10490627586841583,
-0.43502938747406006,
0.3894592523574829,
-0.5706762671470642,
-0.8354004621505737,
0.07886952906847,
-0.24548375606536865,
-0.08808866888284683,
0.04026627913117409,
0.5933712720870972,
0.5487014651298523,
-0.16601069271564484,
0.35224685072898865,
0.20072387158870697,
-0.24675075709819794,
-0.19021612405776978,
-0.9022953510284424,
0.7872416973114014,
0.05536434054374695,
-0.20835790038108826,
-0.027870703488588333,
-0.8968847393989563,
0.06265238672494888,
-0.17670463025569916,
-0.7224496603012085,
-0.33159682154655457,
-0.22680096328258514,
-0.19327956438064575,
0.0005199878942221403,
0.26652446389198303,
-0.43124938011169434,
0.27028197050094604,
-0.3350059688091278,
0.11389899998903275,
0.6967576742172241,
-0.0404328815639019,
0.4077739417552948,
-0.39347586035728455,
0.604958713054657,
-0.042787324637174606,
-0.2034817636013031,
-0.5982255339622498,
-0.35373613238334656,
-0.738935649394989,
-0.489237517118454,
0.34292367100715637,
0.9256007671356201,
-0.9698948264122009,
0.33856263756752014,
-0.4045349657535553,
-0.21687966585159302,
-0.7152444124221802,
0.2838227450847626,
0.549482524394989,
0.4511314630508423,
0.5014399886131287,
0.02488303743302822,
-0.3474824130535126,
-0.7743223309516907,
-0.1542724072933197,
0.5708447694778442,
-0.038049813359975815,
0.09611157327890396,
0.0027403230778872967,
-0.1034327819943428,
0.6043039560317993,
-0.33163318037986755,
-0.13189344108104706,
-0.31356850266456604,
0.19747595489025116,
0.5136184692382812,
0.530563473701477,
0.42229020595550537,
-0.4999806880950928,
-0.6857634782791138,
0.18322281539440155,
-0.5803468823432922,
-0.06089582294225693,
-0.2687188684940338,
-0.1616128385066986,
0.20391660928726196,
0.3894723057746887,
-0.31621304154396057,
-0.02660006657242775,
0.45565855503082275,
-0.23160399496555328,
0.4382968842983246,
-0.4073083698749542,
0.56302410364151,
-1.2307413816452026,
-0.3826046288013458,
-0.058463357388973236,
-0.1489337831735611,
-0.5398623943328857,
0.1404992789030075,
0.2527352571487427,
-0.03418382629752159,
-0.5028020143508911,
0.5886253714561462,
-0.6122667193412781,
0.12160187214612961,
-0.05765099823474884,
-0.11606151610612869,
0.05974071845412254,
0.40868741273880005,
-0.07997214794158936,
0.9449302554130554,
0.6733964681625366,
-0.766783595085144,
0.13000284135341644,
0.2750745117664337,
-0.37009862065315247,
0.7212822437286377,
-0.16927722096443176,
-0.06154409423470497,
-0.49093055725097656,
-0.08734402805566788,
-0.8160473704338074,
-0.30826660990715027,
-0.08023805916309357,
-0.1268491894006729,
0.7486569881439209,
-0.10972113907337189,
-0.41453367471694946,
-0.029691923409700394,
-0.41650626063346863,
0.165489062666893,
0.241953507065773,
-0.8729798793792725,
0.3505549728870392,
-0.10654141008853912,
-0.3642047345638275,
-0.6594682931900024,
-0.7188603281974792,
0.024200353771448135,
-0.18600508570671082,
-0.6211991906166077,
0.22173038125038147,
-0.3292059600353241,
-0.13785533607006073,
-0.31631624698638916,
-0.13968193531036377,
-0.015800166875123978,
0.044525858014822006,
-0.4364548623561859,
0.3166287839412689,
-0.45048362016677856,
0.33279645442962646,
0.48656848073005676,
-0.022511431947350502,
-0.25658711791038513,
-0.3256862461566925,
0.5117653012275696,
-0.26398226618766785,
-0.2462480366230011,
-0.2873309850692749,
0.5576568841934204,
0.32214581966400146,
-0.5192993879318237,
0.7133713364601135,
0.6414647698402405,
-0.34736379981040955,
-0.6096775531768799,
-0.30203983187675476,
-0.35684770345687866,
-0.44189518690109253,
0.2986923158168793,
-0.4057398736476898,
-0.9762440323829651,
0.3858390748500824,
0.17064058780670166,
0.7566387057304382,
0.09986186027526855,
0.5095702409744263,
-0.09682722389698029,
0.8153524994850159,
0.4845491051673889,
0.03547677397727966,
0.4531959295272827,
-0.2593041956424713,
0.028612472116947174,
-0.4075244665145874,
-0.09353466331958771,
-0.33346110582351685,
-0.39968353509902954,
-0.8017755746841431,
-0.3679775893688202,
0.31850603222846985,
-0.019939348101615906,
-0.06951204687356949,
0.00030409087776206434,
-0.40808042883872986,
0.9504451751708984,
0.6309921741485596,
0.20111419260501862,
0.33699479699134827,
0.35165828466415405,
-0.16455739736557007,
-0.2675498127937317,
-0.802967369556427,
-0.5922048091888428,
1.1527174711227417,
-0.11141365766525269,
0.6495733261108398,
0.2505418062210083,
0.7573363780975342,
0.043643973767757416,
0.22027283906936646,
-0.4731627404689789,
0.33218228816986084,
-0.8450945615768433,
-0.22200722992420197,
-0.20795011520385742,
-0.6189362406730652,
-1.058190107345581,
0.17484869062900543,
-0.04143316671252251,
-0.4389338195323944,
-0.014049619436264038,
0.2442431002855301,
-0.497875839471817,
0.16517360508441925,
-0.914320170879364,
0.9174261093139648,
-0.37086281180381775,
-0.48175689578056335,
0.008801442570984364,
-0.5032246112823486,
0.3671557903289795,
-0.024605702608823776,
0.43699491024017334,
-0.11788955330848694,
0.09528910368680954,
0.48536205291748047,
-0.0984831303358078,
0.868293046951294,
-0.07903533428907394,
-0.28508734703063965,
0.07514070719480515,
0.14591604471206665,
0.21715910732746124,
0.1796926110982895,
-0.2258578985929489,
0.14103537797927856,
-0.21351948380470276,
-0.46772080659866333,
-0.45170873403549194,
0.8272375464439392,
-0.6827700138092041,
-0.39857518672943115,
0.04576313868165016,
-0.9209602475166321,
-0.31078264117240906,
0.1360141932964325,
0.4120275378227234,
0.6739047765731812,
-0.09170661121606827,
0.27574461698532104,
0.8245301246643066,
-0.3950888216495514,
0.39609888195991516,
0.8314465284347534,
0.21301628649234772,
-0.3079773783683777,
1.1697858572006226,
0.355901300907135,
0.32558393478393555,
0.579005241394043,
0.223972886800766,
-0.2569649815559387,
-0.550230860710144,
-0.5916991233825684,
0.04372629150748253,
-0.88838130235672,
-0.352286696434021,
-0.40866076946258545,
0.07750621438026428,
-0.24382631480693817,
-0.20427003502845764,
-0.2677004635334015,
-0.17947867512702942,
-0.29576966166496277,
-0.2809549868106842,
0.496528297662735,
0.321194589138031,
-0.1515519917011261,
0.24226030707359314,
-0.9767299890518188,
0.27807384729385376,
0.22639544308185577,
0.38165122270584106,
-0.27785778045654297,
-0.6142860054969788,
-0.34213903546333313,
0.253896027803421,
-0.08877523988485336,
-0.6332418322563171,
0.3568034768104553,
0.625862181186676,
0.5001854300498962,
0.1315818428993225,
-0.1108257919549942,
0.8130733370780945,
-0.698611319065094,
0.6179465651512146,
-0.10447264462709427,
-0.6835655570030212,
0.4037623107433319,
-0.39051756262779236,
0.7364782094955444,
0.7461097240447998,
0.4866860508918762,
-0.5825899839401245,
-0.4098752439022064,
-0.129557803273201,
-0.8709985017776489,
0.8136159181594849,
-0.15400788187980652,
0.3707364499568939,
-0.21297569572925568,
0.14959397912025452,
0.6047742366790771,
0.2268250435590744,
-0.5815832018852234,
-0.2988426387310028,
-0.07306258380413055,
-0.7159233689308167,
-0.32403963804244995,
0.11047295480966568,
-0.038995880633592606,
-0.2847718298435211,
0.6036695837974548,
-0.3642340898513794,
-0.1589592695236206,
-0.21048374474048615,
-0.25049886107444763,
0.218765988945961,
0.4873269200325012,
0.6142827868461609,
0.4902554452419281,
0.07820551842451096,
0.2502131164073944,
0.37636786699295044,
-0.3069392740726471,
0.16846111416816711,
0.4259209632873535,
-0.29189157485961914,
0.08295445144176483,
0.5098763704299927,
0.8618181943893433,
0.5000458359718323,
-0.6965944766998291,
0.08501880615949631,
-0.1811935305595398,
0.10008645057678223,
-0.006038209423422813,
0.15254269540309906,
0.0546695850789547,
0.16538040339946747,
0.1135219857096672,
0.08926234394311905,
0.0708843320608139,
-0.24226851761341095,
0.3213288486003876,
0.22054095566272736,
0.09121658653020859,
-0.1900145709514618,
0.37745362520217896,
0.18698836863040924,
-0.27859964966773987,
0.748149037361145,
-0.3645397126674652,
-0.09014494717121124,
0.5879493355751038,
0.6664159297943115,
0.5285953283309937,
-0.371310830116272,
0.15231843292713165,
0.7018755674362183,
0.5683590769767761,
-0.062452349811792374,
0.48569396138191223,
-0.07245006412267685,
-0.7200965881347656,
-0.4401398003101349,
-0.45551666617393494,
-0.33956655859947205,
-0.022328393533825874,
-0.6607763767242432,
0.4646638333797455,
-0.33838987350463867,
0.26891836524009705,
-0.17978987097740173,
-0.13956837356090546,
-0.9082126617431641,
0.07773728668689728,
0.40668556094169617,
0.7629660367965698,
-0.8795827031135559,
0.5757120251655579,
0.7759416103363037,
-0.3151397705078125,
-0.8617634773254395,
-0.14828552305698395,
-0.08101433515548706,
-0.7089348435401917,
0.3065076768398285,
0.44604822993278503,
0.0532161183655262,
0.10990457981824875,
-0.2636104226112366,
-0.7475048899650574,
0.8762272000312805,
0.7785394191741943,
-0.9016465544700623,
0.04027259722352028,
0.2811555862426758,
0.32747066020965576,
-0.29778483510017395,
0.09725411981344223,
0.7071288228034973,
0.4290917217731476,
-0.22012649476528168,
-0.6298417448997498,
-0.3408812880516052,
-0.24351921677589417,
-0.21927565336227417,
0.22447605431079865,
-0.40996021032333374,
0.802252471446991,
-0.16106219589710236,
-0.2645835280418396,
-0.23789948225021362,
0.605830729007721,
0.37182560563087463,
0.17396098375320435,
0.2608717978000641,
0.36212158203125,
1.049869418144226,
-0.21288517117500305,
0.9581595063209534,
-0.44614261388778687,
0.053242847323417664,
1.3333810567855835,
0.03425535932183266,
0.4537001848220825,
0.210203617811203,
0.07000858336687088,
0.2337459921836853,
0.7190414667129517,
-0.07466913759708405,
0.4597049355506897,
0.04608875885605812,
-0.37682849168777466,
-0.17093800008296967,
-0.1959289014339447,
-0.11321468651294708,
0.5032346844673157,
0.38309183716773987,
-0.06999202072620392,
-0.5906752347946167,
0.49560365080833435,
0.1255611777305603,
0.3936053514480591,
-0.4499289393424988,
0.6985131502151489,
-0.17302674055099487,
-0.8110882043838501,
0.893604576587677,
0.0719745010137558,
1.0157071352005005,
-0.7245132923126221,
-0.16110242903232574,
-0.6897229552268982,
0.12099963426589966,
-0.30768850445747375,
-0.7957496643066406,
0.1571146845817566,
0.33880287408828735,
-0.3794560730457306,
-0.3021872341632843,
0.11932143568992615,
-1.1168849468231201,
-0.7263147234916687,
0.05518191680312157,
0.4399358630180359,
0.0781397596001625,
0.5894651412963867,
-0.48408249020576477,
-0.04827844351530075,
0.2915603816509247,
-0.06451580673456192,
0.14850173890590668,
0.5660757422447205,
-0.1928631067276001,
0.42808783054351807,
0.6247291564941406,
-0.025949670001864433,
0.376816064119339,
0.29997366666793823,
0.556630551815033,
-0.33119717240333557,
-0.5381337404251099,
-0.8185482621192932,
0.766342043876648,
0.06327708810567856,
-0.5761935114860535,
0.8642268180847168,
0.6384775638580322,
1.1865785121917725,
-0.2405325025320053,
0.6199815273284912,
0.20099708437919617,
0.5164947509765625,
-0.8402566313743591,
0.396915465593338,
-0.521844744682312,
0.21321722865104675,
0.13712163269519806,
-0.8302275538444519,
-0.41037848591804504,
0.5095008015632629,
-0.21792326867580414,
-0.027087826281785965,
0.41600409150123596,
0.8254399299621582,
-0.4364170730113983,
0.07054900377988815,
0.2811947762966156,
-0.02382625639438629,
0.24743817746639252,
0.4473922550678253,
0.591762363910675,
-0.125589519739151,
0.23651693761348724,
-0.32192105054855347,
-0.33140942454338074,
0.18318240344524384,
-0.7498978972434998,
-0.9831322431564331,
-0.3235985040664673,
-0.31045570969581604,
0.2251509726047516,
0.03332449868321419,
1.2950488328933716,
0.48843032121658325,
-1.085225224494934,
-0.39492735266685486,
0.007740992587059736,
0.1940464973449707,
-0.2341374158859253,
-0.21611911058425903,
0.3239671587944031,
-0.8239730000495911,
-0.8859723210334778,
0.7639699578285217,
0.17659622430801392,
0.05196205526590347,
-0.05553654208779335,
-0.007457203231751919,
-0.17488037049770355,
-0.14098624885082245,
0.8086756467819214,
0.2101210057735443,
-0.44853541254997253,
-0.11762400716543198,
0.17620784044265747,
0.04047120362520218,
0.10505826771259308,
0.39366453886032104,
-0.4102941155433655,
0.6384376287460327,
0.2998531758785248,
0.989835798740387,
-0.0016771460650488734,
-0.25661998987197876,
0.6703205108642578,
-1.3737705945968628,
0.37090715765953064,
0.28762924671173096,
0.4388951361179352,
0.6863523125648499,
-0.3215446472167969,
0.32903721928596497,
-0.17497387528419495,
-0.22104036808013916,
-0.612930953502655,
0.07927315682172775,
-0.4756390154361725,
-0.2409641146659851,
0.8822414875030518,
-0.13799552619457245,
0.10965919494628906,
0.07154326885938644,
-0.2751673758029938,
0.3390471339225769,
-0.32977280020713806,
0.6522992253303528,
0.7069490551948547,
0.16265124082565308,
-0.3094503879547119,
-0.5547729134559631,
0.2687758207321167,
0.41332995891571045,
-1.0070979595184326,
0.149877667427063,
0.6792598962783813,
0.2861255705356598,
-0.08990231156349182,
0.2609001398086548,
0.1325002759695053,
0.43904563784599304,
-0.42602598667144775,
0.06569057703018188,
-0.14144743978977203,
-0.5001959800720215,
-0.4637373089790344,
-0.03755601495504379,
-0.11162038892507553,
-0.29808878898620605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01850v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01850v1 | Purple-teaming LLMs with Adversarial Defender Training | 2024-07-01T23:25:30 | 2024-07-01T23:25:30 | Jingyan Zhou, Kun Li, Junan Li, Jiawen Kang, Minda Hu, Xixin Wu, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Existing efforts in safeguarding LLMs are limited in actively exposing the
vulnerabilities of the target LLM and readily adapting to newly emerging safety
risks. To address this, we present Purple-teaming LLMs with Adversarial
Defender training (PAD), a pipeline designed to safeguard LLMs by novelly
incorporating the red-teaming (attack) and blue-teaming (safety training)
techniques. In PAD, we automatically collect conversational data that cover the
vulnerabilities of an LLM around specific safety risks in a self-play manner,
where the attacker aims to elicit unsafe responses and the defender generates
safe responses to these attacks. We then update both modules in a generative
adversarial network style by training the attacker to elicit more unsafe
responses and updating the defender to identify them and explain the unsafe
reason. Experimental results demonstrate that PAD significantly outperforms
existing baselines in both finding effective attacks and establishing a robust
safe guardrail. Furthermore, our findings indicate that PAD excels in striking
a balance between safety and overall model quality. We also reveal key
challenges in safeguarding LLMs, including defending multi-turn attacks and the
need for more delicate strategies to identify specific risks. | [
-0.3500516712665558,
-0.8169816136360168,
-0.09647485613822937,
0.25637418031692505,
-0.048276908695697784,
0.7137541770935059,
0.2743028700351715,
-0.2570731043815613,
0.17427755892276764,
0.48396751284599304,
-0.6062845587730408,
-0.4116207957267761,
-0.7907764911651611,
-0.14972467720508575,
-0.2583632171154022,
1.1958483457565308,
-0.11668960750102997,
0.09307932108640671,
0.34808269143104553,
-0.19606947898864746,
-0.4754834473133087,
-0.7094341516494751,
-0.7184383869171143,
-0.2248484194278717,
0.5244289040565491,
0.1749863624572754,
0.5128883123397827,
0.5602461695671082,
0.6631969213485718,
0.27871644496917725,
-0.0689188688993454,
0.1751174032688141,
-0.652866542339325,
0.33786144852638245,
0.16351687908172607,
-0.47930908203125,
-0.5970404148101807,
0.2052633911371231,
0.2318839728832245,
0.24331910908222198,
-0.06855259835720062,
-0.33145448565483093,
0.13723833858966827,
0.6991106271743774,
-0.9739419221878052,
-0.15485765039920807,
-0.8797733187675476,
0.41209977865219116,
-0.04793952777981758,
-0.42704567313194275,
-0.40071749687194824,
-0.18503010272979736,
-0.01953778974711895,
-0.5414646863937378,
0.031539712101221085,
-0.009503678418695927,
0.5126680135726929,
0.2044847309589386,
-0.6751245856285095,
-0.17277581989765167,
-0.406160831451416,
0.5102404356002808,
0.17872770130634308,
-0.22937336564064026,
0.19011400640010834,
0.6141289472579956,
-0.2757842242717743,
-0.6130689978599548,
-0.17103047668933868,
-0.10420079529285431,
0.16086894273757935,
0.5664513111114502,
-0.22579477727413177,
0.2634757161140442,
-0.17746801674365997,
-0.005742748733609915,
-0.650757372379303,
0.4055539667606354,
-0.3986120820045471,
-0.3108530044555664,
0.8890913724899292,
0.24120740592479706,
0.40035998821258545,
0.13448543846607208,
-1.1533584594726562,
-0.19863367080688477,
-1.079666256904602,
0.04583588242530823,
0.5882536172866821,
0.24801847338676453,
-0.3331831395626068,
0.35288089513778687,
0.18641652166843414,
0.13168728351593018,
0.1486825942993164,
-0.02164648473262787,
-0.016930658370256424,
-0.1478685587644577,
-0.27120333909988403,
0.2523920238018036,
0.9128881096839905,
0.5082852840423584,
0.18122632801532745,
-0.5646606683731079,
-0.2893907129764557,
0.4071964919567108,
0.6127490401268005,
-0.5411402583122253,
-0.9056890606880188,
0.3466798663139343,
-0.21854199469089508,
-0.9856847524642944,
0.07078021764755249,
-0.7678455710411072,
-0.880201518535614,
0.08718881756067276,
0.2932397723197937,
-0.4772789478302002,
-0.46438345313072205,
-0.05486658215522766,
-0.3595382571220398,
0.24512305855751038,
0.12890593707561493,
-1.0016593933105469,
0.14396625757217407,
0.838079571723938,
0.6149619221687317,
-0.42527028918266296,
-0.3259829580783844,
-0.8514081835746765,
0.4090324640274048,
-0.5744783282279968,
0.7320458292961121,
-0.0019539811182767153,
-0.7245252132415771,
0.10994119942188263,
-0.10758217424154282,
-0.0034343372099101543,
-0.4311298429965973,
0.12989197671413422,
-0.785305917263031,
-0.029781755059957504,
-0.265674889087677,
-0.33842402696609497,
0.2580788731575012,
0.6808159947395325,
-0.38206276297569275,
0.5498055815696716,
-0.06962774693965912,
-0.6923947930335999,
0.5408467650413513,
-0.6581428050994873,
-0.25110921263694763,
0.18396486341953278,
-0.25659576058387756,
-0.7225955128669739,
-0.4025385081768036,
0.0656028464436531,
0.37224748730659485,
0.23810826241970062,
-0.3504451811313629,
-0.7972851991653442,
-0.08360800892114639,
0.28885212540626526,
-0.41506966948509216,
1.203688383102417,
0.07209665328264236,
-0.20822685956954956,
0.38342493772506714,
-0.4229945242404938,
0.1473706215620041,
0.09259617328643799,
-0.4979094862937927,
0.190068781375885,
-0.4243376553058624,
-0.277458518743515,
0.16772997379302979,
0.21668364107608795,
-0.44218799471855164,
0.1068284884095192,
-0.04470205307006836,
0.434325248003006,
1.149064302444458,
0.07230555266141891,
0.7790889739990234,
-0.45525768399238586,
1.0145667791366577,
-0.11372219771146774,
0.4835106134414673,
0.07997139543294907,
-0.3892052173614502,
-0.6356377601623535,
-0.6050716638565063,
0.12145110219717026,
0.9054825305938721,
-0.8106217384338379,
0.26282554864883423,
0.17965854704380035,
-0.4798343777656555,
-0.2345338612794876,
0.34796586632728577,
0.8781740665435791,
0.3674441874027252,
0.3864164650440216,
-0.18956390023231506,
-0.656760036945343,
-0.6715981960296631,
0.13804398477077484,
-0.32325077056884766,
0.16102752089500427,
0.12187182903289795,
0.5966518521308899,
-0.13431178033351898,
0.5909194946289062,
-0.2557782828807831,
-0.28628185391426086,
-0.2907792627811432,
0.13581731915473938,
-0.37486785650253296,
0.5764524340629578,
0.7165945768356323,
-0.8956334590911865,
-0.6923349499702454,
-0.13814598321914673,
-0.9352160692214966,
0.11852602660655975,
0.07422780245542526,
-0.39031103253364563,
0.11787769943475723,
0.7621495723724365,
-0.6029186248779297,
0.1891690045595169,
0.5900228023529053,
-0.23671075701713562,
0.6199578642845154,
-0.06254251301288605,
-0.027098530903458595,
-0.9542941451072693,
-0.14513517916202545,
-0.14570342004299164,
-0.043405599892139435,
-0.8182229399681091,
0.29664307832717896,
0.3150339722633362,
-0.204921692609787,
-0.9051616787910461,
0.4799887239933014,
-0.3696231245994568,
-0.07901652902364731,
-0.3694719672203064,
0.03318508341908455,
-0.06607916206121445,
0.5564020872116089,
-0.18624375760555267,
0.8726606369018555,
0.5542454719543457,
-0.7994709014892578,
0.7274551391601562,
0.27869537472724915,
0.22817371785640717,
0.7364855408668518,
-0.4658059775829315,
0.2976658046245575,
0.05172160640358925,
0.32953089475631714,
-0.640684187412262,
-0.10054058581590652,
0.46158894896507263,
-0.41751885414123535,
0.8177322149276733,
-0.5925995707511902,
-0.1666773408651352,
-0.21119633316993713,
-0.6906810998916626,
0.036003477871418,
0.4145977795124054,
-0.607266902923584,
0.32349693775177,
0.9269391298294067,
-0.10638949275016785,
-1.0600144863128662,
-0.6365491151809692,
0.32789888978004456,
-0.8668830990791321,
-0.6108513474464417,
0.7025415897369385,
-0.06106641888618469,
-0.2682701051235199,
-0.2572260797023773,
-0.10471639037132263,
-0.2615898847579956,
0.7687929272651672,
0.32865971326828003,
0.39059334993362427,
0.007341248448938131,
-0.08566202223300934,
-0.6384981870651245,
-0.5206379294395447,
0.35630226135253906,
-0.14595022797584534,
0.45718544721603394,
-0.21907208859920502,
-0.4571799337863922,
-0.13120847940444946,
0.29283446073532104,
0.2646311819553375,
-0.0534973107278347,
0.7312979102134705,
0.6342155933380127,
-0.13403017818927765,
-0.3635191023349762,
-0.12771117687225342,
-0.33233383297920227,
-0.545499324798584,
0.31373587250709534,
-0.20495538413524628,
-0.7431581616401672,
0.3289914131164551,
0.18984413146972656,
0.08206045627593994,
0.03789810836315155,
0.4760638177394867,
-0.8196894526481628,
0.8983708620071411,
0.5814122557640076,
-0.31483930349349976,
0.428264856338501,
-0.5202544331550598,
-0.033755823969841,
-0.8403320908546448,
-0.43826544284820557,
-0.07124838978052139,
-0.44347310066223145,
-0.7251319885253906,
-0.15218707919120789,
0.6102437376976013,
0.27395135164260864,
-0.6905356645584106,
0.29954779148101807,
-0.5249736309051514,
0.43934980034828186,
0.7593784928321838,
0.3791079819202423,
-0.09136614203453064,
-0.16020306944847107,
-0.0643678680062294,
0.05232752114534378,
-0.8509218096733093,
-0.3627075254917145,
1.474927544593811,
0.5085837841033936,
0.6779177784919739,
0.4603886008262634,
0.8614616394042969,
0.1894262284040451,
0.3026564121246338,
-0.3801473081111908,
0.7265157103538513,
-0.15522240102291107,
-0.5656046867370605,
-0.13236874341964722,
-0.3532339930534363,
-1.1717112064361572,
0.17228618264198303,
-0.4547211527824402,
-0.2758784294128418,
-0.2708968222141266,
0.41943132877349854,
-0.4192794859409332,
0.41551440954208374,
-0.6130198240280151,
0.760695219039917,
-0.7139618992805481,
-0.33869874477386475,
-0.004305558744817972,
-0.5497345328330994,
0.5847229957580566,
0.13375543057918549,
-0.2775590419769287,
0.11198051273822784,
-0.21089963614940643,
0.4490177035331726,
-0.3035654127597809,
0.9026003479957581,
-0.1902872622013092,
0.16915683448314667,
0.2438964992761612,
0.13306580483913422,
0.5707318186759949,
0.03616419807076454,
0.38563767075538635,
-0.1900397688150406,
-0.7486744523048401,
-0.6768997311592102,
-0.34311729669570923,
0.5545160174369812,
-0.8405618071556091,
-0.7616497278213501,
-0.6250131130218506,
-0.491360068321228,
-0.4262330234050751,
-0.11512379348278046,
0.25883495807647705,
-0.09737247228622437,
-0.24654807150363922,
0.3371596038341522,
1.1301823854446411,
-0.21747556328773499,
0.6381144523620605,
0.5167626142501831,
0.16106016933918,
-0.7343560457229614,
0.7511749863624573,
-0.05367644503712654,
0.41561830043792725,
0.43360957503318787,
-0.139157235622406,
-0.39382195472717285,
-1.0852082967758179,
-0.41384366154670715,
-0.21143324673175812,
-0.47994187474250793,
-0.3354892432689667,
-0.4350571036338806,
-0.439538836479187,
-0.3440306782722473,
-0.42489075660705566,
-0.19400405883789062,
-0.4715239107608795,
0.027513688430190086,
-0.5543873906135559,
0.5456063151359558,
0.41550514101982117,
-0.3042055666446686,
0.1824730485677719,
-0.54543536901474,
0.3123372197151184,
0.8869072794914246,
-0.10734351724386215,
-0.6556711792945862,
-0.29587438702583313,
0.006474112160503864,
-0.05624175816774368,
-0.8675200939178467,
-0.9135358333587646,
0.4670620560646057,
-0.4217749238014221,
0.7311832904815674,
0.2135569155216217,
0.2258724570274353,
0.38265880942344666,
-0.2546512186527252,
0.5317388772964478,
0.6287800073623657,
-0.32907235622406006,
0.7766302227973938,
-0.7387991547584534,
-0.19617915153503418,
0.45504996180534363,
0.27284201979637146,
0.031669002026319504,
-0.18898330628871918,
-0.7040533423423767,
-0.7233707904815674,
0.43188023567199707,
0.3261064291000366,
-0.2508365213871002,
0.10111113637685776,
-0.054176319390535355,
-0.4757109582424164,
0.23239904642105103,
-1.0095700025558472,
-0.32767990231513977,
-0.2566901743412018,
0.019983047619462013,
0.14282627403736115,
-0.1799570918083191,
-0.8564488887786865,
0.6522314548492432,
0.8008896708488464,
-0.1455332189798355,
0.24880245327949524,
-0.271047979593277,
-0.08648596704006195,
0.18240971863269806,
0.07674648612737656,
0.29692432284355164,
-0.012286294251680374,
-0.11743923276662827,
0.07422860711812973,
0.6221694946289062,
-0.3137069642543793,
0.3472346365451813,
0.20851626992225647,
-0.15694670379161835,
-0.6733989715576172,
0.4607519507408142,
0.3239215314388275,
0.19337089359760284,
-0.3186810314655304,
0.5575476288795471,
-0.041640784591436386,
-0.39774712920188904,
-0.3474811315536499,
0.47357916831970215,
0.08964428305625916,
0.3439241647720337,
0.0765233188867569,
0.3684345781803131,
-0.2264649122953415,
-0.5224431753158569,
0.21467335522174835,
0.8785143494606018,
-0.5043626427650452,
0.042116470634937286,
0.6757736206054688,
0.6180216670036316,
-0.36528369784355164,
0.23611007630825043,
-0.2952743172645569,
-0.9133375883102417,
1.0443737506866455,
0.12551730871200562,
1.0522584915161133,
-0.17748500406742096,
0.17701596021652222,
-0.14929871261119843,
0.4829992949962616,
0.20669201016426086,
0.15575353801250458,
0.17034269869327545,
-0.7535147666931152,
0.12546764314174652,
-0.05747068673372269,
-0.7758297324180603,
0.26277777552604675,
-0.5622753500938416,
0.22563956677913666,
-0.8920618295669556,
0.02422933652997017,
-0.49355870485305786,
0.2221052050590515,
-0.3258751630783081,
0.23922161757946014,
0.3039637506008148,
0.7647200226783752,
-0.5950089693069458,
0.6295375823974609,
0.636671781539917,
-0.3570760190486908,
-0.5318523049354553,
-0.19661939144134521,
0.4889672100543976,
-1.0784586668014526,
0.6827154159545898,
0.11293505132198334,
-0.0769958570599556,
-0.44043096899986267,
-0.08732254803180695,
-0.28586545586586,
1.5037012100219727,
0.4946030378341675,
-0.3885764181613922,
0.07752213627099991,
0.20321980118751526,
0.3384057879447937,
-0.15517328679561615,
0.0451858788728714,
0.22962214052677155,
0.14391672611236572,
-0.292239248752594,
-0.7042993903160095,
-0.2959243059158325,
-0.21600289642810822,
-0.30783772468566895,
0.13951461017131805,
-1.0153992176055908,
0.7479304671287537,
-0.15144076943397522,
-0.17851722240447998,
-0.10131409019231796,
0.38779568672180176,
0.8906450271606445,
0.3618364632129669,
0.5366612672805786,
0.7914209961891174,
0.6910181045532227,
-0.19748538732528687,
1.005025029182434,
-0.5847613215446472,
-0.13502827286720276,
1.0314384698867798,
-0.08961176127195358,
0.657027006149292,
0.24384434521198273,
-0.17690147459506989,
-0.003060785587877035,
0.6019450426101685,
0.09502184391021729,
0.8208880424499512,
0.2738651633262634,
-0.7200344204902649,
-0.21743009984493256,
0.20999456942081451,
-0.4432811737060547,
0.27282199263572693,
0.19997183978557587,
-0.22532251477241516,
0.06296441704034805,
-0.054299432784318924,
0.23641318082809448,
0.12169941514730453,
-0.45728906989097595,
0.7896194458007812,
0.11395857483148575,
-0.6208813190460205,
0.2114942967891693,
-0.2386677861213684,
0.8058217167854309,
-0.6824766397476196,
0.35287392139434814,
-0.35681912302970886,
0.3762342035770416,
-0.0649556890130043,
-0.8624799847602844,
0.06942147016525269,
0.22490519285202026,
0.0522770881652832,
-0.662527322769165,
0.6444406509399414,
-0.1808934360742569,
-0.1809215545654297,
0.5829649567604065,
0.2828321158885956,
-0.37234416604042053,
0.2748973071575165,
-1.0810058116912842,
-0.11951392143964767,
-0.07850011438131332,
0.05387197807431221,
0.9152958989143372,
0.42865827679634094,
0.3534452021121979,
1.2080992460250854,
0.5895016193389893,
0.2797342538833618,
0.3533150851726532,
-0.10717785358428955,
0.88564532995224,
-0.47696107625961304,
-0.6427695751190186,
-0.8466553688049316,
0.551864504814148,
-0.343960702419281,
-0.3556137979030609,
0.6330571174621582,
0.3230018615722656,
0.5090898871421814,
0.17468610405921936,
0.974585235118866,
0.5276073813438416,
0.268101304769516,
-0.7074882388114929,
0.8041998744010925,
0.01944628171622753,
0.6498074531555176,
0.05529753491282463,
-0.45414820313453674,
-0.1355609893798828,
0.5018765330314636,
-0.05571621283888817,
-0.004702025558799505,
0.4237985610961914,
1.0951257944107056,
0.06267371028661728,
-0.05510544404387474,
0.12371306121349335,
0.1491488665342331,
0.8007066249847412,
0.8589080572128296,
1.1162219047546387,
-0.46379566192626953,
1.2543482780456543,
-0.4091707468032837,
-0.32690900564193726,
-0.10516924411058426,
-1.0402376651763916,
-1.156014323234558,
0.044187191873788834,
-0.6506809592247009,
-0.7194506525993347,
0.6665002703666687,
0.4456357955932617,
1.0656555891036987,
-0.7978633046150208,
0.12086515873670578,
-0.5527329444885254,
-0.044911500066518784,
0.08653979003429413,
-0.24442334473133087,
0.14591719210147858,
-0.3628232479095459,
-0.3048420548439026,
0.8415615558624268,
0.41971176862716675,
0.38327741622924805,
-0.44477295875549316,
-0.40802621841430664,
0.1106342002749443,
-0.39754581451416016,
0.22666163742542267,
0.6116233468055725,
-0.38908588886260986,
-0.2585750222206116,
-0.14775113761425018,
-0.41883373260498047,
-0.11488614976406097,
0.431570440530777,
-0.6370845437049866,
0.27737048268318176,
0.1938352882862091,
0.9516444802284241,
0.3469093143939972,
-0.3412471115589142,
0.8863222002983093,
-0.7132096886634827,
0.062178660184144974,
0.5032170414924622,
0.6103795766830444,
0.3361325263977051,
-0.2472820281982422,
0.7049881815910339,
0.1809099316596985,
-0.5597482919692993,
-0.9882155060768127,
0.5334333181381226,
-0.7815419435501099,
-0.26154014468193054,
1.0930049419403076,
-0.5191113948822021,
0.18667910993099213,
-0.3952377438545227,
-0.016848059371113777,
0.019346369430422783,
-0.13086505234241486,
1.2047382593154907,
0.44017085433006287,
-0.0345962755382061,
-0.12043891102075577,
-0.2537555992603302,
0.7543687224388123,
0.4512980282306671,
-0.86866694688797,
-0.1379547268152237,
-0.023625601083040237,
0.21215862035751343,
0.16234061121940613,
0.5455741286277771,
-0.013453257270157337,
0.7809824347496033,
0.23332786560058594,
-0.4466286897659302,
-0.4131281077861786,
-0.5180363655090332,
-0.31425604224205017,
0.605285108089447,
-0.29981034994125366,
-0.6740924119949341
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01834v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01834v1 | A Study of Nationality Bias in Names and Perplexity using Off-the-Shelf Affect-related Tweet Classifiers | 2024-07-01T22:17:17 | 2024-07-01T22:17:17 | Valentin Barriere, Sebastian Cifuentes | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we apply a method to quantify biases associated with named
entities from various countries. We create counterfactual examples with small
perturbations on target-domain data instead of relying on templates or specific
datasets for bias detection. On widely used classifiers for subjectivity
analysis, including sentiment, emotion, hate speech, and offensive text using
Twitter data, our results demonstrate positive biases related to the language
spoken in a country across all classifiers studied. Notably, the presence of
certain country names in a sentence can strongly influence predictions, up to a
23\% change in hate speech detection and up to a 60\% change in the prediction
of negative emotions such as anger. We hypothesize that these biases stem from
the training data of pre-trained language models (PLMs) and find correlations
between affect predictions and PLMs likelihood in English and unknown languages
like Basque and Maori, revealing distinct patterns with exacerbate
correlations. Further, we followed these correlations in-between counterfactual
examples from a same sentence to remove the syntactical component, uncovering
interesting results suggesting the impact of the pre-training data was more
important for English-speaking-country names. Our anonymized code is
[https://anonymous.4open.science/r/biases_ppl-576B/README.md](available here). | [
-0.4447935223579407,
-0.510556697845459,
0.3147130012512207,
0.2711728811264038,
-0.3259027898311615,
0.14304281771183014,
-0.280386358499527,
-0.34197482466697693,
0.5389843583106995,
0.5034621953964233,
-0.6561881303787231,
-0.44143742322921753,
-0.9017917513847351,
0.17294593155384064,
-0.3066861629486084,
1.0678154230117798,
-0.14195594191551208,
0.20185700058937073,
0.38608336448669434,
-0.37513014674186707,
-0.01522955670952797,
-0.8104602694511414,
-0.29063087701797485,
-0.16508543491363525,
0.7980247139930725,
0.41792118549346924,
0.6751442551612854,
-0.13973236083984375,
0.4207480251789093,
0.16509613394737244,
0.075204037129879,
-0.46912744641304016,
-0.5146584510803223,
0.15083003044128418,
-0.5337830781936646,
-0.5300549864768982,
-0.059482917189598083,
0.19498136639595032,
0.24104055762290955,
0.39856165647506714,
0.4286876618862152,
0.28489425778388977,
-0.39748817682266235,
0.4546642005443573,
-0.6734799742698669,
0.024954956024885178,
-0.6711968183517456,
0.22897936403751373,
-0.44661104679107666,
-0.07049110531806946,
-0.05017316713929176,
-0.49429455399513245,
0.3511027991771698,
-0.07745002210140228,
0.37621158361434937,
-0.007248665206134319,
0.925058126449585,
0.30732375383377075,
-0.4634886085987091,
-0.24708192050457,
-0.4544418454170227,
1.0146393775939941,
-0.42778944969177246,
0.4966171979904175,
0.23729810118675232,
0.09616976231336594,
0.097544826567173,
-0.09085512906312943,
-0.700340211391449,
0.0007124598487280309,
-0.04411883279681206,
0.17698216438293457,
-0.11924269795417786,
-0.12183699756860733,
0.5363674163818359,
0.33866456151008606,
-0.23866355419158936,
0.06621211767196655,
-0.2959507405757904,
-0.2053440809249878,
0.839057207107544,
-0.25900542736053467,
0.6880274415016174,
-0.2204921841621399,
-0.18906515836715698,
0.2232649028301239,
-0.9538113474845886,
0.07893548160791397,
0.8847984075546265,
0.4984965920448303,
-0.37710484862327576,
0.5883311629295349,
-0.3062000572681427,
0.3597874343395233,
0.046734053641557693,
0.1453149914741516,
0.4914323389530182,
0.33165183663368225,
-0.052887436002492905,
0.2601410150527954,
0.8892771005630493,
0.36288875341415405,
0.6813733577728271,
-0.3768312335014343,
0.08006095141172409,
0.29238495230674744,
0.0713297575712204,
-1.0228500366210938,
-0.09964870661497116,
0.23916630446910858,
-0.2998860776424408,
-0.15092991292476654,
0.06754276901483536,
-0.8121476173400879,
-0.6190412640571594,
-0.08241698145866394,
0.4515503942966461,
-0.12264683842658997,
-0.4805973470211029,
-0.14575551450252533,
-0.22522972524166107,
0.06668224930763245,
0.019026247784495354,
-0.6778331995010376,
-0.2789093255996704,
0.32098662853240967,
0.27147480845451355,
-0.3134208023548126,
-0.2072238326072693,
-0.2252669781446457,
-0.453590452671051,
-0.1607656478881836,
0.6691960096359253,
-0.7787842154502869,
-0.3347473740577698,
0.12087228149175644,
0.055655673146247864,
0.043336305767297745,
-0.33351802825927734,
0.49085187911987305,
-0.5259109139442444,
0.4005739092826843,
-0.7437911629676819,
-0.23768864572048187,
-0.1052764281630516,
0.1589173823595047,
-0.6598284840583801,
0.6005310416221619,
0.24589194357395172,
-1.2483941316604614,
0.7007026672363281,
-0.6883646845817566,
-0.5879748463630676,
-0.23004809021949768,
-0.185116708278656,
-0.3574984073638916,
0.21917149424552917,
0.02065914496779442,
0.4130465090274811,
-0.2817732095718384,
0.5440685153007507,
-0.3548779785633087,
-0.17560701072216034,
0.37256374955177307,
-0.1649874746799469,
1.163306713104248,
0.03560907766222954,
-0.7216044664382935,
-0.11673939973115921,
-0.4374614655971527,
-0.3937971889972687,
0.0384376235306263,
-0.012876220047473907,
-0.5507503747940063,
-0.2144099622964859,
0.044807035475969315,
0.4859384000301361,
-0.08750946074724197,
-1.0199086666107178,
-0.034549251198768616,
-0.30941900610923767,
0.11672551929950714,
0.4483707547187805,
0.1749361902475357,
0.19678077101707458,
-0.07135132700204849,
0.8076891303062439,
0.3600196838378906,
0.185927614569664,
0.08419361710548401,
-0.5049470663070679,
-0.6798423528671265,
0.09277662634849548,
0.3535658121109009,
0.43849655985832214,
-0.7759832143783569,
0.02471964806318283,
-0.015520981512963772,
-0.3389277458190918,
-0.6208544373512268,
-0.1275835484266281,
0.36535632610321045,
0.5844228863716125,
0.2953842282295227,
-0.1888779252767563,
-0.8722145557403564,
-1.1598173379898071,
-0.991568922996521,
-0.3066350221633911,
-0.03981272876262665,
0.3757437765598297,
0.5904229879379272,
-0.18136492371559143,
1.1026430130004883,
-0.28937697410583496,
-0.08069807291030884,
-0.09985867142677307,
0.14240466058254242,
-0.057435665279626846,
0.054005298763513565,
0.661457896232605,
-1.0424871444702148,
-0.7826774716377258,
-0.5152970552444458,
-0.5747533440589905,
-0.5654069185256958,
0.16558103263378143,
-0.3241693079471588,
0.41712382435798645,
0.06647972017526627,
-0.34995773434638977,
0.4643384516239166,
0.5478466153144836,
-0.5648049712181091,
0.5008507966995239,
0.7143699526786804,
0.3412666618824005,
-1.1458076238632202,
-0.026711324229836464,
0.30826789140701294,
0.3193894922733307,
-0.7712167501449585,
-0.18080057203769684,
0.1066402867436409,
0.32891249656677246,
-0.8676709532737732,
0.7734559178352356,
-0.16597068309783936,
0.34502163529396057,
0.1578790247440338,
-0.15717127919197083,
-0.20745500922203064,
0.15193699300289154,
0.3280206620693207,
0.6100441217422485,
0.47750452160835266,
-0.23746538162231445,
0.09621883928775787,
0.21653518080711365,
-0.27569788694381714,
0.6621766686439514,
-0.053698357194662094,
-0.16383929550647736,
-0.352317750453949,
0.031239112839102745,
-0.7739487886428833,
-0.274397611618042,
0.3496406078338623,
-0.47738444805145264,
0.15263773500919342,
-0.2962561547756195,
-0.19356653094291687,
-0.34514275193214417,
-0.22374102473258972,
0.3753148019313812,
0.48774412274360657,
-0.7082043886184692,
0.4679766297340393,
0.5692110061645508,
0.08343590050935745,
-0.8126513361930847,
-1.1572561264038086,
0.2147337645292282,
-0.7354891896247864,
-0.10155322402715683,
0.22456762194633484,
-0.01741747185587883,
-0.5912735462188721,
-0.19118937849998474,
-0.14769667387008667,
-0.18229468166828156,
0.023122340440750122,
0.3857881426811218,
-0.09500347822904587,
0.09453673660755157,
0.3551774024963379,
0.004620207007974386,
0.38293954730033875,
0.41482582688331604,
-0.08926265686750412,
0.4286886751651764,
0.24373823404312134,
0.1762366145849228,
-0.23894725739955902,
0.04221335053443909,
0.2801201045513153,
-0.12668541073799133,
0.727470338344574,
0.5258175730705261,
-0.19002608954906464,
-0.32629919052124023,
-0.7424342036247253,
-0.20481835305690765,
-0.36487746238708496,
0.20216228067874908,
-0.5647033452987671,
-0.8695269227027893,
0.8404253125190735,
0.20983737707138062,
-0.3841683864593506,
0.6912150979042053,
0.5312157869338989,
0.27319028973579407,
0.6377363801002502,
0.5688347220420837,
-0.33736202120780945,
0.6061971187591553,
-0.12826356291770935,
0.6619583368301392,
-0.5355912446975708,
-0.1322387009859085,
-0.5205541849136353,
-0.22344376146793365,
-1.1012760400772095,
-0.15472213923931122,
-0.19430306553840637,
-0.34125953912734985,
-0.49794140458106995,
0.18689903616905212,
-0.3280046284198761,
0.5544309616088867,
0.22057896852493286,
-0.08195949345827103,
-0.006274710409343243,
0.12011437863111496,
-0.0524803064763546,
-0.40979090332984924,
-0.4470258355140686,
-0.3521495461463928,
1.1944102048873901,
0.13585932552814484,
0.7273167967796326,
0.1024705171585083,
0.8287240862846375,
0.29299771785736084,
0.7348776459693909,
-0.8691343665122986,
0.19380170106887817,
-0.2806748151779175,
-0.8481594324111938,
-0.18466605246067047,
-0.44589516520500183,
-0.7947941422462463,
0.09389740228652954,
-0.056739676743745804,
-0.9430081248283386,
0.22999480366706848,
0.04770446568727493,
-0.15701471269130707,
0.5253676772117615,
-0.5436781644821167,
0.6852712631225586,
-0.31267645955085754,
-0.5079041719436646,
0.2502778172492981,
-0.5339236855506897,
0.6088864207267761,
-0.2730533480644226,
0.2166183441877365,
-0.20708654820919037,
0.17723669111728668,
0.9066401124000549,
-0.2950497269630432,
0.8191269636154175,
-0.4012434482574463,
-0.1822834312915802,
0.08712179958820343,
0.015116297639906406,
-0.11404338479042053,
-0.007332926150411367,
-0.46043410897254944,
0.5239008069038391,
-0.4334675073623657,
-0.4125986099243164,
-0.21526364982128143,
0.9135521650314331,
-0.9542176723480225,
-0.639209508895874,
-0.19605588912963867,
-0.44185927510261536,
-0.27406859397888184,
0.20837654173374176,
0.4577016830444336,
0.127455934882164,
-0.28381800651550293,
-0.059726230800151825,
0.544130265712738,
-0.46904635429382324,
0.288115918636322,
0.807417094707489,
-0.18971498310565948,
-0.0516422763466835,
0.7626461386680603,
0.5732201337814331,
-0.05162547156214714,
0.43013837933540344,
0.3225657343864441,
-0.3270609974861145,
-0.1224612221121788,
-0.30950284004211426,
0.2008693814277649,
-0.47935405373573303,
-0.05063735321164131,
-0.7545806765556335,
-0.052659619599580765,
-0.41991040110588074,
-0.0811678096652031,
-0.3219117224216461,
-0.4545907974243164,
-0.05289503186941147,
-0.04777161404490471,
0.41560861468315125,
0.8373842239379883,
0.24247030913829803,
0.5653190612792969,
-0.20310936868190765,
0.4238653779029846,
0.09542887657880783,
0.6786321997642517,
-0.22985097765922546,
-0.703014612197876,
-0.10412469506263733,
-0.04105016589164734,
-0.13497518002986908,
-1.1428636312484741,
0.40326714515686035,
-0.06550204008817673,
0.3911808431148529,
0.531721830368042,
0.48600390553474426,
0.3210466802120209,
-0.17554381489753723,
0.9860473871231079,
0.011652346700429916,
-0.978602409362793,
0.5710558891296387,
-0.28559568524360657,
0.3843458294868469,
0.5723557472229004,
0.8936878442764282,
-0.6287676692008972,
-0.8176288604736328,
-0.9153732657432556,
-0.8115170001983643,
0.945385754108429,
0.016263630241155624,
0.2604457437992096,
-0.13719220459461212,
0.25427165627479553,
0.4748555123806,
0.38650503754615784,
-0.6995550394058228,
-0.5432318449020386,
-0.25022393465042114,
-0.18315786123275757,
-0.2378104031085968,
-0.4845529794692993,
0.1830059438943863,
-0.037195753306150436,
0.7982388138771057,
0.277673602104187,
-0.02712046541273594,
0.2822036147117615,
-0.3868478238582611,
-0.32700249552726746,
0.3507525622844696,
0.44747820496559143,
0.54908287525177,
-0.3314078450202942,
0.12760286033153534,
0.08102727681398392,
-0.40344318747520447,
0.21414406597614288,
0.06545311212539673,
-0.3170256018638611,
0.18528200685977936,
0.041416268795728683,
0.8745372891426086,
-0.18216224014759064,
-0.31692156195640564,
0.456734836101532,
-0.08214117586612701,
-0.022948898375034332,
-0.38832640647888184,
-0.28414472937583923,
-0.05769980326294899,
0.0517299547791481,
0.450401246547699,
-0.011904846876859665,
0.24551957845687866,
-0.5770567059516907,
0.03307851031422615,
0.3821265995502472,
-0.39820972084999084,
-0.762834906578064,
0.6175214648246765,
0.2825959026813507,
-0.4387415647506714,
0.15223494172096252,
-0.3784672021865845,
-1.161929726600647,
0.7558897137641907,
0.18486745655536652,
1.050106406211853,
-0.6382883787155151,
0.39104732871055603,
0.3615911304950714,
0.33531567454338074,
0.014122530817985535,
0.48895063996315,
0.06630565226078033,
-1.1113901138305664,
-0.12386268377304077,
-0.5600866675376892,
-0.5039523839950562,
0.3443273603916168,
-0.5361452102661133,
0.348993718624115,
-0.32070910930633545,
-0.41022515296936035,
0.09697319567203522,
0.19417467713356018,
-1.096282720565796,
0.5308861136436462,
0.492765337228775,
0.6652852296829224,
-1.4507664442062378,
0.7972660660743713,
0.9621495604515076,
-0.3331657946109772,
-0.6582538485527039,
0.44767430424690247,
0.14200446009635925,
-0.4416557550430298,
0.8972222208976746,
0.501893937587738,
0.034916214644908905,
-0.23915401101112366,
-0.3204224407672882,
-0.8183814287185669,
0.1972096860408783,
0.4254499077796936,
-0.3948619067668915,
0.3952605426311493,
0.5202220678329468,
0.6866983771324158,
-0.39384913444519043,
0.5941075682640076,
0.8191651701927185,
0.5608224868774414,
-0.2099335491657257,
-0.7865428328514099,
0.05503601208329201,
-0.20246204733848572,
-0.1820056289434433,
0.1591159999370575,
-0.9580442309379578,
0.8997059464454651,
-0.012194739654660225,
-0.007812637835741043,
-0.6353943347930908,
0.10947482287883759,
0.014446351677179337,
0.337050199508667,
0.40119266510009766,
0.4299106001853943,
0.5405123829841614,
-0.23444435000419617,
0.8834713697433472,
-0.4850296974182129,
0.25554442405700684,
0.9884214401245117,
-0.3062071204185486,
0.44247812032699585,
0.6996249556541443,
-0.28716811537742615,
0.647905707359314,
0.6209036111831665,
0.05030159279704094,
0.42548081278800964,
0.5081591606140137,
-0.15665021538734436,
0.11574365943670273,
-0.4005992114543915,
-0.0441267192363739,
0.5409930944442749,
0.3285485506057739,
-0.5658977627754211,
-0.24364936351776123,
0.30493953824043274,
0.43992680311203003,
-0.12077552080154419,
-0.3338589668273926,
0.3533662259578705,
0.0644199326634407,
-0.7980570197105408,
0.24600662291049957,
-0.12610557675361633,
1.062303066253662,
-0.2689307630062103,
0.3529887795448303,
-0.4907738268375397,
-0.05262260511517525,
-0.6593059301376343,
-0.6980265974998474,
0.3289153277873993,
0.32867076992988586,
-0.29358944296836853,
-0.23781704902648926,
0.49645906686782837,
-0.6312762498855591,
-0.3942650556564331,
0.5582658052444458,
0.42523932456970215,
0.4266618490219116,
-0.27761244773864746,
-0.5313243865966797,
0.09537900239229202,
0.23007522523403168,
-0.6419519186019897,
0.24189521372318268,
0.45686668157577515,
-0.3746016025543213,
0.3379773199558258,
-0.009604750201106071,
0.2609013020992279,
0.09407918900251389,
0.4240415096282959,
0.6076899170875549,
-0.7023982405662537,
-0.3341449201107025,
-0.9005263447761536,
0.5008753538131714,
0.011602964252233505,
-0.34031909704208374,
0.8413457274436951,
0.5806582570075989,
1.0700417757034302,
-0.07374322414398193,
1.1579252481460571,
-0.17367199063301086,
0.6206197142601013,
-0.06317408382892609,
0.9047030806541443,
-0.5161582231521606,
-0.006642729509621859,
-0.2921488583087921,
-0.8769511580467224,
-0.5369880199432373,
0.2970137596130371,
-1.0392428636550903,
0.15297867357730865,
0.5747578144073486,
0.6595375537872314,
-0.03823775053024292,
-0.07750852406024933,
0.3013531565666199,
0.48753952980041504,
0.0965401828289032,
0.07284752279520035,
0.6148086190223694,
-0.38007962703704834,
0.0754450112581253,
-0.580951452255249,
-0.01040552742779255,
-0.21859829127788544,
-0.7984251379966736,
-1.1600114107131958,
-0.2943582832813263,
-0.6812421679496765,
-0.36906495690345764,
0.19123975932598114,
1.009008526802063,
0.29371410608291626,
-1.2543559074401855,
-0.12687990069389343,
0.24259518086910248,
0.3600960373878479,
0.5868166089057922,
-0.3257690966129303,
0.4334806799888611,
-0.2880060076713562,
-0.8943751454353333,
-0.11911690980195999,
-0.03963952511548996,
-0.09452939033508301,
-0.09592218697071075,
0.19003166258335114,
0.0295310877263546,
0.23542596399784088,
0.5396586656570435,
0.2525947391986847,
-0.9937414526939392,
-0.4025422930717468,
-0.3956201672554016,
0.0561554953455925,
-0.025296922773122787,
0.6488741040229797,
-0.7361283898353577,
0.6270957589149475,
0.4001881778240204,
0.15192480385303497,
0.23187275230884552,
0.33851882815361023,
0.2939967215061188,
-0.7031679153442383,
0.3476220965385437,
0.15814197063446045,
0.2973173260688782,
0.5701017379760742,
-0.41215649247169495,
0.27739623188972473,
0.13417747616767883,
-0.33704277873039246,
-0.764202356338501,
0.18140342831611633,
-0.5820409655570984,
-0.12756016850471497,
1.2991666793823242,
-0.2089167833328247,
-0.1629258692264557,
-0.027198972180485725,
-0.036605920642614365,
0.5044832229614258,
-0.590223491191864,
1.2272729873657227,
0.68398118019104,
-0.022872624918818474,
-0.019815675914287567,
-0.4964602589607239,
0.72115159034729,
0.5172938704490662,
-0.47581946849823,
-0.115755096077919,
0.1328352987766266,
0.48566147685050964,
-0.04236992821097374,
0.4001253545284271,
-0.013280642218887806,
-0.12604957818984985,
-0.26928025484085083,
0.6263805031776428,
0.34366464614868164,
-0.06118721514940262,
-0.4974389374256134,
0.010118592530488968,
-0.013010421767830849,
0.060768019407987595
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01824v1 | Empathic Grounding: Explorations using Multimodal Interaction and Large Language Models with Conversational Agents | 2024-07-01T21:46:30 | 2024-07-01T21:46:30 | Mehdi Arjmand, Farnaz Nouraei, Ian Steenstra, Timothy Bickmore | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.CL, cs.RO | We introduce the concept of "empathic grounding" in conversational agents as
an extension of Clark's conceptualization of grounding in conversation in which
the grounding criterion includes listener empathy for the speaker's affective
state. Empathic grounding is generally required whenever the speaker's emotions
are foregrounded and can make the grounding process more efficient and reliable
by communicating both propositional and affective understanding. Both speaker
expressions of affect and listener empathic grounding can be multimodal,
including facial expressions and other nonverbal displays. Thus, models of
empathic grounding for embodied agents should be multimodal to facilitate
natural and efficient communication. We describe a multimodal model that takes
as input user speech and facial expression to generate multimodal grounding
moves for a listening agent using a large language model. We also describe a
testbed to evaluate approaches to empathic grounding, in which a humanoid robot
interviews a user about a past episode of pain and then has the user rate their
perception of the robot's empathy. We compare our proposed model to one that
only generates non-affective grounding cues in a between-subjects experiment.
Findings demonstrate that empathic grounding increases user perceptions of
empathy, understanding, emotional intelligence, and trust. Our work highlights
the role of emotion awareness and multimodality in generating appropriate
grounding moves for conversational agents. | [
-0.31343352794647217,
-1.1434617042541504,
0.7877366542816162,
0.25188499689102173,
-0.06143154576420784,
0.03710471838712692,
-0.0583573579788208,
-0.3076304793357849,
0.5262845158576965,
0.25104373693466187,
-0.2336409091949463,
-0.4142536520957947,
-0.5819891095161438,
-0.12928619980812073,
0.06087827309966087,
0.6228160262107849,
0.20805564522743225,
0.1864682286977768,
-0.22366373240947723,
-0.34018978476524353,
-0.6435476541519165,
-0.8669469356536865,
-0.46676576137542725,
-0.5854442119598389,
0.31107228994369507,
0.4055202901363373,
0.9173280596733093,
0.12171301990747452,
0.3574282228946686,
0.38285622000694275,
-0.1243819072842598,
0.04586699604988098,
-0.2110462635755539,
0.3720739185810089,
-0.1790241003036499,
-0.30515483021736145,
-0.46056342124938965,
0.29244697093963623,
0.213911235332489,
0.48800453543663025,
-0.0844971165060997,
-0.32340312004089355,
-0.4446653723716736,
0.24920697510242462,
-0.5818378329277039,
-0.0030926507897675037,
0.0232862439006567,
0.463457316160202,
0.6683821678161621,
-0.713297963142395,
-0.48316285014152527,
-0.07944811135530472,
-0.02167697809636593,
-0.2321525514125824,
-0.11935959756374359,
0.032459016889333725,
0.4515100121498108,
0.2692909836769104,
-0.7239949703216553,
-0.15282042324543,
-0.5339874029159546,
0.4469572603702545,
-0.3051275312900543,
0.5852709412574768,
0.5826241374015808,
0.08124157041311264,
0.28512129187583923,
-0.2647230923175812,
-0.5460580587387085,
-0.7765882611274719,
-0.12535090744495392,
0.2380206435918808,
-0.25910329818725586,
0.4974258542060852,
0.5695614814758301,
0.2929943799972534,
-0.15697939693927765,
-0.3166358768939972,
0.10495053976774216,
0.09740933030843735,
0.18717342615127563,
0.07720215618610382,
0.6321117877960205,
-0.09544024616479874,
-0.428007036447525,
-0.21036654710769653,
-0.4342348277568817,
0.18097259104251862,
0.2004135102033615,
0.2271202653646469,
-0.47664010524749756,
0.7210891246795654,
0.1190178319811821,
0.7253998517990112,
0.31364506483078003,
-0.22593706846237183,
0.3171672523021698,
0.06732691824436188,
-0.24505619704723358,
0.20550361275672913,
0.22840598225593567,
1.0190414190292358,
0.18188150227069855,
-0.26243582367897034,
0.14624570310115814,
0.33205050230026245,
0.4916008710861206,
-0.7106420397758484,
0.026433318853378296,
0.5643290281295776,
-0.7416399121284485,
-0.3971192240715027,
-0.05124659836292267,
-0.8309817314147949,
-0.7983943819999695,
-0.5571019649505615,
0.2156607210636139,
-0.5583969354629517,
-0.6952401995658875,
-0.14132504165172577,
-0.6016514897346497,
0.27870598435401917,
0.1879677027463913,
-0.8330456018447876,
0.5507733821868896,
0.4738400876522064,
0.9015972018241882,
0.5334305167198181,
-0.5084176659584045,
-0.6420651078224182,
0.12430635094642639,
-0.20661203563213348,
0.6615419387817383,
-1.067555546760559,
-0.3581137955188751,
-0.07948189973831177,
0.2017877697944641,
0.02310136705636978,
-0.16341733932495117,
0.47162896394729614,
0.01315629668533802,
-0.19814270734786987,
-0.31054991483688354,
-0.044666025787591934,
-0.2626790404319763,
0.8248292207717896,
-0.376228004693985,
0.5138920545578003,
0.24619358777999878,
-0.49014467000961304,
0.1221054419875145,
-0.6989919543266296,
-0.3870882987976074,
-0.45042675733566284,
-0.13335148990154266,
0.2056715339422226,
0.43310311436653137,
0.08081647753715515,
0.5254104137420654,
-0.27363160252571106,
0.15110494196414948,
-0.31592434644699097,
-0.022772153839468956,
0.24184317886829376,
-0.1787867248058319,
0.342082679271698,
0.1223425567150116,
-0.48047706484794617,
0.03684792295098305,
-0.5934431552886963,
0.10324118286371231,
0.03351539745926857,
0.15949532389640808,
-0.5116147994995117,
-0.0551498718559742,
0.2085641473531723,
0.49278613924980164,
-0.1859687715768814,
-0.63938969373703,
-0.17176571488380432,
-0.2765241265296936,
0.43106839060783386,
0.5260570049285889,
0.021715136244893074,
0.5808645486831665,
-0.6434704065322876,
0.394950270652771,
0.08802050352096558,
0.13110290467739105,
-0.7947707176208496,
-0.34609490633010864,
-0.7763828039169312,
-0.17610576748847961,
-0.3469886779785156,
0.5475295782089233,
-0.22042086720466614,
0.4635368585586548,
0.022275879979133606,
-0.6780297160148621,
-0.438312828540802,
-0.2738882899284363,
0.6622007489204407,
0.36669260263442993,
0.47698119282722473,
-0.2697180509567261,
-0.25342831015586853,
-0.7352074980735779,
-0.26054322719573975,
-0.18094462156295776,
0.2576722800731659,
0.7954317927360535,
0.13375084102153778,
-0.5670695900917053,
0.7890651226043701,
-0.20486395061016083,
-0.2205117642879486,
-0.07598522305488586,
0.39568716287612915,
-0.09314200282096863,
0.7642149925231934,
0.4660626947879791,
-1.2185895442962646,
-0.3028217852115631,
0.2665431797504425,
-1.0324128866195679,
0.11210313439369202,
-0.2490444928407669,
-0.03022531233727932,
-0.08030843734741211,
0.5138339400291443,
-1.0738784074783325,
0.38790932297706604,
0.7159963250160217,
-0.7914067506790161,
-0.11918827891349792,
-0.3883349895477295,
0.8151049613952637,
-0.8665050268173218,
-0.015431885607540607,
-0.0426325798034668,
-0.09279638528823853,
-1.0141370296478271,
0.2661997675895691,
-0.11696580797433853,
-0.4637102484703064,
-0.49996277689933777,
0.5164536833763123,
-0.6031523942947388,
-0.0020477622747421265,
-0.2823774516582489,
0.21728268265724182,
0.18963362276554108,
0.39527449011802673,
0.36788901686668396,
0.18661431968212128,
0.7868934273719788,
-0.49888089299201965,
0.746939480304718,
0.3525279462337494,
0.5826824903488159,
1.0068016052246094,
-0.7297598123550415,
0.47138741612434387,
-0.25341615080833435,
0.3078139126300812,
-0.9316885471343994,
-0.02828807197511196,
0.41404256224632263,
-0.6864922046661377,
0.2234593629837036,
-0.20899662375450134,
-0.22941018640995026,
-0.0836126059293747,
-0.2325729876756668,
0.46162423491477966,
0.4609803259372711,
-0.5784426331520081,
1.2576485872268677,
0.3392510712146759,
-0.07129649072885513,
-0.14110597968101501,
-0.5651649236679077,
0.49050724506378174,
-0.44749075174331665,
-0.893050491809845,
0.09648337960243225,
-0.1962514966726303,
-0.6934354901313782,
-0.3384454548358917,
0.14530916512012482,
-0.10221081227064133,
0.09580115973949432,
0.511987030506134,
-0.3586241900920868,
0.17742066085338593,
0.3446986675262451,
0.08361577242612839,
-0.3328072726726532,
0.27228549122810364,
0.33270972967147827,
0.7469839453697205,
-0.3108155429363251,
-0.6878695487976074,
-0.4929593503475189,
0.5856142044067383,
0.7931767702102661,
-0.14514881372451782,
0.693864643573761,
0.44873446226119995,
-0.47444143891334534,
0.37968575954437256,
-0.8423460721969604,
-0.49237361550331116,
-0.3831848204135895,
-0.21417777240276337,
-0.631085216999054,
-0.4687594175338745,
0.5101746320724487,
-0.32652267813682556,
-0.4566713571548462,
-0.09424741566181183,
0.6911566853523254,
0.14421996474266052,
1.2262924909591675,
0.5560077428817749,
-0.040185682475566864,
0.33555322885513306,
0.08147716522216797,
0.5144455432891846,
-0.8052645921707153,
-0.3316165506839752,
-0.36739581823349,
-0.11912721395492554,
-0.6186844706535339,
-0.4992406666278839,
0.02113795466721058,
-0.16660811007022858,
-0.18058574199676514,
-0.15910165011882782,
-0.36133483052253723,
0.3083135485649109,
0.5011420845985413,
0.5482861399650574,
0.00793381780385971,
-0.1479644626379013,
0.12984304130077362,
0.0570647194981575,
-0.1724485605955124,
-0.5954492092132568,
0.768546462059021,
0.5072155594825745,
0.8710318207740784,
0.3070097863674164,
0.48480165004730225,
0.4349405765533447,
0.30096444487571716,
-0.836841881275177,
0.1800239533185959,
0.4928276538848877,
-0.3801758587360382,
-0.17331357300281525,
-0.05210845172405243,
-0.6116454005241394,
0.5658759474754333,
-0.23687732219696045,
-0.6350136995315552,
0.2846048176288605,
0.358129620552063,
-0.21592676639556885,
0.16049106419086456,
-0.8470559120178223,
0.6867954730987549,
-0.25050175189971924,
-0.5246894359588623,
-0.4237937033176422,
-1.0657544136047363,
-0.022900057956576347,
0.3838980793952942,
0.37248945236206055,
0.008217521011829376,
0.2753133475780487,
0.2660820186138153,
0.0055342973209917545,
1.1069679260253906,
-0.7103798389434814,
-0.15454860031604767,
0.10477352142333984,
0.19234055280685425,
0.516707718372345,
0.19155143201351166,
0.1442168951034546,
0.12116631865501404,
-0.19782143831253052,
-0.3134254515171051,
-0.8138353228569031,
0.5208351612091064,
-0.7371410131454468,
-0.6678273677825928,
-0.5812817811965942,
-0.43399202823638916,
-0.2952890992164612,
0.011048012413084507,
-0.15042206645011902,
0.352004736661911,
-0.5962998270988464,
0.2336861491203308,
0.5867986083030701,
-0.44575992226600647,
0.12675145268440247,
0.5608752965927124,
0.19951140880584717,
-0.4781644642353058,
0.7335284352302551,
-0.5535598993301392,
0.33188027143478394,
0.5713732838630676,
0.5062638521194458,
0.01519376877695322,
0.16379599273204803,
-0.06652647256851196,
0.25345972180366516,
-0.7604942321777344,
-0.023017553612589836,
-0.9971547722816467,
0.17051224410533905,
-0.7262730598449707,
-0.5647547841072083,
-0.33967527747154236,
-0.18979689478874207,
-0.01036955788731575,
-0.5645213723182678,
0.4180407226085663,
0.49919962882995605,
-0.4814392030239105,
0.4165646433830261,
-0.9568889737129211,
0.6252127289772034,
0.4155727028846741,
-0.01411353424191475,
-0.12443433701992035,
-0.22569754719734192,
0.0993255153298378,
0.428506076335907,
-0.4425642788410187,
-0.9296714067459106,
0.5315446853637695,
0.005986576434224844,
0.43177321553230286,
0.6376438736915588,
0.02778930403292179,
0.7150178551673889,
-0.5567754507064819,
0.779536783695221,
0.5830884575843811,
-1.296614646911621,
0.7044620513916016,
-0.5776580572128296,
-0.21732470393180847,
0.147775799036026,
0.21145062148571014,
-0.9853894114494324,
-0.386996865272522,
-0.773224949836731,
-0.6661545038223267,
0.46677452325820923,
0.12069709599018097,
0.6991720199584961,
-0.28654247522354126,
0.025795064866542816,
-0.13433517515659332,
0.3329479694366455,
-0.7924519181251526,
-0.20562243461608887,
-0.4363393187522888,
0.14640282094478607,
-0.5602304339408875,
-0.6146968603134155,
-0.8092671632766724,
-0.15680688619613647,
-0.15426714718341827,
-0.13799114525318146,
0.7148482203483582,
0.27657338976860046,
-0.34925439953804016,
-0.38642406463623047,
0.14251591265201569,
0.7883221507072449,
0.43710967898368835,
-0.35103723406791687,
0.4669029712677002,
0.09905805438756943,
0.015471120364964008,
0.21993355453014374,
-0.09238920360803604,
0.6217139959335327,
-0.06867033988237381,
0.3990364074707031,
0.676323652267456,
0.3442365527153015,
-0.7466074228286743,
0.7321525812149048,
0.05581244081258774,
0.018168173730373383,
-0.35299256443977356,
-0.3740677535533905,
-0.030678343027830124,
0.6676939129829407,
-0.05611702427268028,
0.00885276310145855,
0.23270319402217865,
-0.8629569411277771,
0.1407780945301056,
0.22423884272575378,
-0.5079757571220398,
-0.49321138858795166,
0.33574622869491577,
0.3159678876399994,
-0.598272442817688,
0.6280404925346375,
0.293268084526062,
-0.7222743034362793,
0.6561186909675598,
0.7583492398262024,
0.8504023551940918,
-0.6210836172103882,
0.28318893909454346,
0.03936861455440521,
0.35900622606277466,
0.13899217545986176,
0.32333314418792725,
-0.3968856930732727,
-0.9976566433906555,
0.36230695247650146,
0.05861647427082062,
-0.7599155902862549,
-0.6830246448516846,
-0.8477351665496826,
0.05217147618532181,
-0.3343638479709625,
-0.24929746985435486,
-0.45421329140663147,
-0.4278466999530792,
-0.6054243445396423,
0.4587688446044922,
0.20574618875980377,
0.605270504951477,
-1.3931448459625244,
0.24093344807624817,
0.8336727023124695,
-0.4469076097011566,
-0.4126090109348297,
-0.08381539583206177,
-0.0411381833255291,
-0.7726402878761292,
0.8610263466835022,
0.47733718156814575,
-0.26625150442123413,
-0.10172420740127563,
-0.4121885299682617,
-0.6196116209030151,
1.1173491477966309,
0.2297496795654297,
0.20454107224941254,
0.13382555544376373,
-0.13666729629039764,
0.5523800253868103,
-0.5592361092567444,
0.8470127582550049,
0.3776974081993103,
0.7085722088813782,
-0.011070853099226952,
-0.7955029606819153,
0.3334486782550812,
-0.6895661354064941,
-0.31919988989830017,
0.031159238889813423,
-1.0668985843658447,
1.1230483055114746,
-0.17691941559314728,
0.08325552940368652,
-0.011518743820488453,
0.12379774451255798,
0.317024290561676,
0.7003865242004395,
0.5654886364936829,
0.6931607723236084,
0.6417049765586853,
0.03460364043712616,
1.0611722469329834,
-0.6397781372070312,
0.10727422684431076,
0.6886828541755676,
-0.4800947308540344,
0.47400912642478943,
0.6152409911155701,
0.3451080322265625,
0.3735828697681427,
0.35748913884162903,
0.07899901270866394,
0.3296339809894562,
0.08727359026670456,
-0.2725488543510437,
-0.37059926986694336,
-0.5603554844856262,
-0.5920400023460388,
0.6995493173599243,
0.19104021787643433,
-0.5364724397659302,
-0.011059465818107128,
0.3754430413246155,
0.02938329428434372,
0.014239992946386337,
-0.0725354328751564,
0.7250812649726868,
0.15858253836631775,
-0.5124356746673584,
0.274800568819046,
0.06972954422235489,
0.19564177095890045,
-0.31701138615608215,
-0.4705203175544739,
-0.2596966326236725,
-0.10085658729076385,
-0.17884819209575653,
-0.34850016236305237,
0.03612438216805458,
-0.21188262104988098,
-0.22361870110034943,
-0.8850185871124268,
0.790593683719635,
-0.09519580751657486,
0.047842998057603836,
0.839789092540741,
0.6620750427246094,
0.48548853397369385,
-0.18887577950954437,
-0.40707242488861084,
0.023899802938103676,
-0.4756017029285431,
-0.5206378698348999,
0.3735380470752716,
0.5821163058280945,
0.32324180006980896,
0.8167935013771057,
0.7779950499534607,
-0.08101016283035278,
-0.18929342925548553,
0.3412277400493622,
1.1742061376571655,
-1.0258758068084717,
-0.393157422542572,
-0.8812469244003296,
0.7610991597175598,
-0.07087069004774094,
-0.08144520968198776,
0.7348605990409851,
0.1656302809715271,
0.1475083827972412,
-0.08961343765258789,
0.5406299233436584,
-0.3817148506641388,
0.2510108947753906,
-0.5766980051994324,
0.3454475402832031,
-0.5600067973136902,
-0.5504341721534729,
-0.639654815196991,
-0.8040745854377747,
-0.20733407139778137,
1.1088716983795166,
-0.053248245269060135,
0.31778275966644287,
0.8976321220397949,
0.7486782670021057,
0.12418027967214584,
0.10047424584627151,
0.8248403072357178,
0.20260187983512878,
0.35117748379707336,
0.32139497995376587,
1.2790017127990723,
-0.12330000847578049,
-0.21631324291229248,
-0.20114918053150177,
-0.46799227595329285,
-0.010022182017564774,
-0.8104968667030334,
-1.1490590572357178,
-0.3150618076324463,
0.022044451907277107,
-0.488285094499588,
-0.006218963302671909,
1.3234835863113403,
0.7085326910018921,
-0.3748752176761627,
-0.14151406288146973,
-0.05104225128889084,
-0.0537155345082283,
-0.21039769053459167,
-0.1908816546201706,
0.1015312522649765,
-0.2805386185646057,
-0.7659265995025635,
0.5439340472221375,
0.35480019450187683,
0.056200794875621796,
0.010955863632261753,
-0.28865042328834534,
-0.139859139919281,
-0.08018285781145096,
0.8574366569519043,
0.18375134468078613,
-0.6306574940681458,
-0.4442029595375061,
0.02573045901954174,
0.20905782282352448,
0.16757066547870636,
1.0678316354751587,
-0.5195577144622803,
0.5216564536094666,
0.01722221076488495,
0.42351704835891724,
0.05960594490170479,
0.5157957077026367,
0.6918922066688538,
-0.36095723509788513,
0.6049033999443054,
0.338477224111557,
0.281938761472702,
0.22334378957748413,
-0.6467516422271729,
0.4028635621070862,
0.26598140597343445,
-0.48243454098701477,
-0.8968641757965088,
0.20754659175872803,
-1.0683715343475342,
0.045218177139759064,
1.4098302125930786,
-0.24221448600292206,
0.11948661506175995,
0.04902799800038338,
-0.6465935707092285,
0.24533331394195557,
-0.41839587688446045,
0.6857035756111145,
0.6234452128410339,
-0.20019184052944183,
-0.5201650857925415,
-0.1435776948928833,
-0.031943440437316895,
0.328433096408844,
-0.7422970533370972,
0.06837838888168335,
0.6408230066299438,
-0.13317309319972992,
0.5036970376968384,
0.6543600559234619,
0.3884943127632141,
0.21255658566951752,
0.3950117528438568,
0.3617062270641327,
-0.027069758623838425,
-0.4748232066631317,
-0.3626824915409088,
0.20682016015052795,
0.07730992138385773,
0.03358431160449982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01817v1 | Race and Privacy in Broadcast Police Communications | 2024-07-01T21:34:51 | 2024-07-01T21:34:51 | Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Christopher Graziul, Miranda Ardith Goodman, Samantha Nicole Kenny, Shomir Wilson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | Radios are essential for the operations of modern police departments, and
they function as both a collaborative communication technology and a
sociotechnical system. However, little prior research has examined their usage
or their connections to individual privacy and the role of race in policing,
two growing topics of concern in the US. As a case study, we examine the
Chicago Police Department's (CPD's) use of broadcast police communications
(BPC) to coordinate the activity of law enforcement officers (LEOs) in the
city. From a recently assembled archive of 80,775 hours of BPC associated with
CPD operations, we analyze text transcripts of radio transmissions broadcast
9:00 AM to 5:00 PM on August 10th, 2018 in one majority Black, one majority
white, and one majority Hispanic area of the city (24 hours of audio) to
explore three research questions: (1) Do BPC reflect reported racial
disparities in policing? (2) How and when is gender, race/ethnicity, and age
mentioned in BPC? (3) To what extent do BPC include sensitive information, and
who is put at most risk by this practice? (4) To what extent can large language
models (LLMs) heighten this risk? We explore the vocabulary and speech acts
used by police in BPC, comparing mentions of personal characteristics to local
demographics, the personal information shared over BPC, and the privacy
concerns that it poses. Analysis indicates (a) policing professionals in the
city of Chicago exhibit disproportionate attention to Black members of the
public regardless of context, (b) sociodemographic characteristics like gender,
race/ethnicity, and age are primarily mentioned in BPC about event information,
and (c) disproportionate attention introduces disproportionate privacy risks
for Black members of the public. | [
-0.6108343005180359,
-0.3003610074520111,
0.5790543556213379,
0.4410419762134552,
0.00886804424226284,
0.36310961842536926,
-0.0908043310046196,
-1.0687559843063354,
0.2751214802265167,
0.1482006162405014,
-0.2812844514846802,
-0.3662404716014862,
-0.7606737017631531,
0.024156762287020683,
-0.25342586636543274,
0.8547840118408203,
0.26157641410827637,
0.22682742774486542,
0.39301201701164246,
-0.2023380994796753,
-0.13977736234664917,
-0.8789865970611572,
-0.5822186470031738,
-0.02842048369348049,
0.49490103125572205,
0.07294502854347229,
0.7082924246788025,
0.5610175132751465,
0.4339914917945862,
0.24071890115737915,
-0.39647141098976135,
-0.2773265838623047,
-0.6187095642089844,
-0.06818030029535294,
-0.3276864290237427,
0.03415561467409134,
-0.22773179411888123,
0.2836551070213318,
0.32457485795021057,
0.956467866897583,
0.15657731890678406,
0.24265041947364807,
-0.18248838186264038,
0.653131365776062,
-1.0208479166030884,
-0.07898908108472824,
-0.07476542145013809,
-0.13578519225120544,
-0.3234367072582245,
-0.33502379059791565,
-0.056589893996715546,
-0.6400997638702393,
0.13847199082374573,
-0.31572651863098145,
0.34450945258140564,
-0.02735539898276329,
0.3732324242591858,
-0.13167168200016022,
-0.6293168663978577,
-0.4088611900806427,
-1.299783706665039,
0.3947288990020752,
-0.22409573197364807,
0.24372081458568573,
0.8857110142707825,
0.024679144844412804,
0.13503457605838776,
-0.20205245912075043,
-0.6485267877578735,
-0.03699304163455963,
-0.11600270122289658,
0.39292898774147034,
-0.09504090994596481,
0.03922325745224953,
0.5226103663444519,
0.4064357280731201,
-0.14423546195030212,
-0.10313007235527039,
-1.0388760566711426,
0.11008947342634201,
1.0264060497283936,
0.4559173285961151,
-0.197291761636734,
0.06907293945550919,
0.06292355060577393,
-0.03710450232028961,
-0.518268346786499,
0.08092549443244934,
0.9241473078727722,
-0.01379040814936161,
-0.4416389763355255,
0.547080934047699,
-0.2530881464481354,
0.3828737735748291,
-0.1535917967557907,
-0.054969802498817444,
0.21182377636432648,
-0.329020619392395,
0.098751500248909,
0.4095523953437805,
0.7069569230079651,
0.5913999080657959,
0.45616570115089417,
0.0505729541182518,
0.11605386435985565,
-0.1078597754240036,
0.33634909987449646,
-0.3256348669528961,
-0.07136248797178268,
0.26546040177345276,
-0.38041210174560547,
-0.2809620201587677,
0.25698819756507874,
-0.5411812663078308,
-0.5002380609512329,
-0.2818499505519867,
-0.14416667819023132,
-0.10158965736627579,
-0.4043961763381958,
-0.034612640738487244,
-0.036574143916368484,
0.2571299076080322,
0.151092067360878,
-1.2384952306747437,
0.18148288130760193,
0.5751911997795105,
0.7031235694885254,
0.15746504068374634,
0.04962712153792381,
0.21737834811210632,
0.40788766741752625,
-0.4043165147304535,
0.19389070570468903,
-0.3802415132522583,
-0.7164621949195862,
0.13225075602531433,
0.03317412734031677,
0.274360716342926,
-0.47731027007102966,
0.07923295348882675,
-0.41363105177879333,
-0.025172846391797066,
-0.21720492839813232,
-0.2806472182273865,
0.18309789896011353,
-0.37231844663619995,
-0.17806239426136017,
1.016229271888733,
0.03231387212872505,
-1.027585506439209,
0.35534802079200745,
-0.40384262800216675,
-0.6519320607185364,
0.05121045187115669,
-0.00593540957197547,
-0.388072669506073,
0.33510881662368774,
-0.02644326724112034,
0.43467915058135986,
0.43717002868652344,
-0.045698653906583786,
-0.5739517211914062,
-0.6701940298080444,
0.4466524124145508,
0.05108313634991646,
0.9480500817298889,
0.5780994892120361,
-0.5468212366104126,
-0.3855944573879242,
-0.6342387795448303,
-0.44864222407341003,
0.1422274261713028,
-0.2362779974937439,
-0.5758159160614014,
0.18984787166118622,
-0.16425524652004242,
-0.1001887246966362,
-0.16189195215702057,
-0.9097628593444824,
-0.41411373019218445,
0.10014975816011429,
0.26727646589279175,
0.548418402671814,
-0.046993546187877655,
0.5275824069976807,
-0.3213362991809845,
0.4606258273124695,
-0.25292354822158813,
0.5801193118095398,
0.04675417020916939,
-0.5202805399894714,
-0.2275012582540512,
-0.3064296245574951,
0.08081916719675064,
0.39399412274360657,
0.14703388512134552,
0.6541946530342102,
0.008718722499907017,
-0.3739681839942932,
-0.4983794093132019,
-0.44914641976356506,
-0.10537569224834442,
0.14842963218688965,
-0.16939488053321838,
-0.2817513346672058,
-0.38771530985832214,
-0.7884810566902161,
0.1479334980249405,
-0.21511512994766235,
0.3132588565349579,
0.36232051253318787,
0.34606295824050903,
0.1767428070306778,
0.7396379113197327,
-0.30981963872909546,
0.0226337518543005,
-0.22277148067951202,
0.07134190201759338,
0.014900407753884792,
0.2894759178161621,
0.5380750894546509,
-0.5855236053466797,
-0.5460942983627319,
-0.3666180372238159,
-0.3198552429676056,
-0.288828045129776,
0.04312875494360924,
0.024371707811951637,
-0.28376898169517517,
0.6752985119819641,
0.12686368823051453,
0.8962686061859131,
0.8411766290664673,
-0.2703487277030945,
0.5544034838676453,
-0.003963324707001448,
0.2880796492099762,
-0.6744042634963989,
-0.0429341122508049,
-0.19341175258159637,
-0.49321094155311584,
-0.8598147630691528,
-0.23899054527282715,
-0.2524247169494629,
-0.30064311623573303,
-0.46039220690727234,
0.29516613483428955,
-0.42701324820518494,
-0.5502257943153381,
-0.46492746472358704,
0.03195282444357872,
-0.3899248242378235,
0.03751493990421295,
0.2920719087123871,
0.5144009590148926,
0.5061362981796265,
-0.673900842666626,
0.11228203028440475,
0.05711136385798454,
-0.7545521259307861,
0.1746664047241211,
-0.2770809233188629,
0.2847446799278259,
-0.4659132957458496,
0.1744173914194107,
-0.8414077162742615,
-0.02416871301829815,
0.33266711235046387,
-0.6133251786231995,
-0.02213364467024803,
-0.12971597909927368,
-0.48367103934288025,
-0.22937752306461334,
-0.08254402130842209,
0.6512652039527893,
0.1837782859802246,
-0.008835488930344582,
-0.04081429913640022,
0.9285857677459717,
-0.5315037369728088,
-0.48220327496528625,
-0.7973135709762573,
-0.2114483118057251,
0.11843664199113846,
-0.525839626789093,
-0.06111528351902962,
-0.032928451895713806,
-0.5157677531242371,
-0.02269558422267437,
-0.1228952556848526,
-0.28801771998405457,
0.4615720510482788,
0.4915064573287964,
0.05637872591614723,
0.06240185722708702,
-0.09997797757387161,
-0.25635385513305664,
0.407723069190979,
0.12118524312973022,
0.4121749699115753,
0.5568605661392212,
0.2760627567768097,
-0.1740051805973053,
-0.441758394241333,
1.001827359199524,
0.28749021887779236,
-0.22907936573028564,
1.065159559249878,
0.38038450479507446,
-0.18713730573654175,
0.32422637939453125,
-0.48258528113365173,
-0.27707383036613464,
-0.3593575954437256,
0.07147600501775742,
0.1515120267868042,
-1.0813181400299072,
0.539938747882843,
0.2797297239303589,
-0.04575984179973602,
-0.40102967619895935,
0.6576468348503113,
-0.5270698666572571,
0.6621496677398682,
0.7129200100898743,
0.010858061723411083,
1.0765079259872437,
-0.07682987302541733,
0.47049930691719055,
-0.597903847694397,
-0.4096938967704773,
-0.6074029207229614,
-0.18605315685272217,
-0.7561550140380859,
-0.1334523856639862,
0.34526243805885315,
0.030463693663477898,
-0.17743848264217377,
-0.04018383473157883,
-0.48427262902259827,
0.45184436440467834,
0.4455728530883789,
-0.12820133566856384,
0.37660470604896545,
-0.05662788450717926,
0.35335955023765564,
0.03688918426632881,
-0.41799744963645935,
-0.3949793577194214,
1.1710784435272217,
0.5831424593925476,
0.633994996547699,
0.35237476229667664,
0.791204571723938,
0.32112735509872437,
0.513027548789978,
-0.3627537488937378,
0.31223979592323303,
0.09453616291284561,
-1.4757771492004395,
-0.2701537311077118,
-0.23463693261146545,
-0.827972948551178,
0.13481351733207703,
-0.18111570179462433,
-0.8468661308288574,
0.8959079384803772,
0.06915786862373352,
-0.3413306176662445,
0.14604608714580536,
-0.5838267803192139,
0.38956859707832336,
-0.06494349241256714,
-0.1779361367225647,
-0.41575804352760315,
-0.6325787901878357,
0.5277976393699646,
-0.18297432363033295,
0.6059049963951111,
-0.8500005006790161,
0.20853646099567413,
0.8044353723526001,
-0.27476993203163147,
0.5937953591346741,
0.048891641199588776,
0.19750754535198212,
0.3270404040813446,
-0.16918541491031647,
0.28258445858955383,
0.2209269255399704,
0.30945855379104614,
0.34623122215270996,
0.014843396842479706,
-0.29329976439476013,
-0.0720854327082634,
0.1560794711112976,
-0.8036689758300781,
-0.4016847312450409,
-0.7223115563392639,
-0.4142484664916992,
-0.12929339706897736,
-0.10257641971111298,
0.32534053921699524,
0.580649197101593,
-0.0499795526266098,
0.07935117185115814,
0.40148210525512695,
-0.17384864389896393,
0.3310282826423645,
0.73752361536026,
0.017009057104587555,
-0.08885910362005234,
0.225419282913208,
-0.23670117557048798,
0.34619441628456116,
0.0982772633433342,
0.02767135202884674,
-0.3650037944316864,
-0.5763301849365234,
0.21993063390254974,
0.6630014777183533,
-0.41666460037231445,
0.19097870588302612,
-0.6248769760131836,
-0.3760625720024109,
-0.6322949528694153,
-0.20992860198020935,
-0.4582781195640564,
-0.3312697410583496,
0.008791455067694187,
-0.04262235015630722,
0.07711073756217957,
0.766859769821167,
-0.3958556354045868,
0.43328216671943665,
-0.3111882507801056,
0.43795737624168396,
0.16516490280628204,
0.1951894462108612,
-0.30619341135025024,
-0.36823055148124695,
-0.46906521916389465,
-0.1780996322631836,
-0.2822631001472473,
-1.0498274564743042,
0.04236496984958649,
-0.5159645080566406,
0.20215405523777008,
0.06952577829360962,
0.3483498990535736,
0.3976641893386841,
-0.42933905124664307,
0.5764436721801758,
0.3179880380630493,
-0.7011183500289917,
0.2983640432357788,
-0.4990762174129486,
0.16464301943778992,
0.6149399876594543,
0.5095070600509644,
-0.778151273727417,
-1.0781760215759277,
-0.5597512125968933,
-0.5349012017250061,
0.8460935354232788,
0.49635836482048035,
0.35051003098487854,
-0.13080298900604248,
0.11286275088787079,
-0.4094069004058838,
0.25012949109077454,
-0.7864600419998169,
-0.7979189157485962,
-0.27654460072517395,
-0.035423822700977325,
0.009384912438690662,
-0.6192675232887268,
-0.3426956534385681,
-0.38240376114845276,
0.15222972631454468,
0.39126333594322205,
0.44813114404678345,
0.4947340488433838,
0.3771618604660034,
-0.04624676704406738,
0.4804566502571106,
0.782326877117157,
1.0347100496292114,
-0.509965717792511,
0.09711132943630219,
-0.07439932227134705,
-0.5714206695556641,
0.3113069534301758,
-0.08436912298202515,
-0.08865171670913696,
0.006762887351214886,
0.36432090401649475,
0.46113547682762146,
-0.13900741934776306,
-0.402815580368042,
0.6504167914390564,
-0.06462130695581436,
-0.32510924339294434,
-0.6642627716064453,
-0.2673051953315735,
0.11774543672800064,
0.20378555357456207,
0.25899896025657654,
-0.05695214495062828,
0.029391605406999588,
-0.9814783334732056,
-0.15963955223560333,
0.22696411609649658,
-0.36168041825294495,
-0.22332006692886353,
0.8014129400253296,
0.410774827003479,
-0.005286105442792177,
0.3159864842891693,
-0.19353583455085754,
-0.46926239132881165,
0.3111063539981842,
0.18047483265399933,
0.5633484125137329,
-0.4850321412086487,
0.21058674156665802,
0.15597261488437653,
0.5682801008224487,
0.22119182348251343,
0.15069575607776642,
-0.23298747837543488,
-0.9204506278038025,
-0.4719768464565277,
-0.3829399347305298,
-0.27649402618408203,
0.17386330664157867,
-0.7513898015022278,
-0.12605872750282288,
-0.9715758562088013,
-0.6383902430534363,
0.18009087443351746,
0.008417341858148575,
-0.34662461280822754,
0.16384093463420868,
0.701318621635437,
0.7858570218086243,
-0.8987593650817871,
0.7432664632797241,
0.446427583694458,
0.12702210247516632,
-0.6954421401023865,
0.015072585083544254,
0.0923767164349556,
-0.4104907512664795,
0.7620958089828491,
-0.2994559109210968,
-0.13097065687179565,
-0.5506855845451355,
-0.3343738317489624,
-0.7450490593910217,
0.739041268825531,
0.17813311517238617,
-0.71226567029953,
0.39028099179267883,
0.3008498549461365,
0.5433677434921265,
-0.42380034923553467,
0.13346140086650848,
0.7481757998466492,
0.3982638716697693,
0.057148776948451996,
-1.2133700847625732,
-0.13355036079883575,
0.33846935629844666,
-0.06747594475746155,
0.13076677918434143,
-0.920962929725647,
0.4575536549091339,
-0.35593706369400024,
-0.4104117751121521,
-0.228118434548378,
0.33605220913887024,
0.11231352388858795,
0.5762177109718323,
0.37448203563690186,
0.11306951195001602,
0.5945004820823669,
-0.12345991283655167,
1.421235203742981,
0.19007232785224915,
0.20432040095329285,
0.9941774606704712,
-0.36255672574043274,
0.2291879951953888,
0.1257890909910202,
-0.33938056230545044,
0.13450312614440918,
0.5340813398361206,
0.050147514790296555,
0.8482711315155029,
0.17121002078056335,
-0.5666073560714722,
0.10705502331256866,
-0.4199550747871399,
-0.3017209768295288,
0.5342743992805481,
0.1172700971364975,
-0.38437584042549133,
0.1827806681394577,
-0.06810081750154495,
0.07511401176452637,
0.06140059605240822,
-0.4529787003993988,
0.786865234375,
0.016390733420848846,
-0.24325747787952423,
0.15914586186408997,
0.11786370724439621,
0.33232587575912476,
-0.592542290687561,
0.45358115434646606,
-0.3465036153793335,
0.032889969646930695,
-0.15333262085914612,
-0.8425137996673584,
0.786191999912262,
-0.05279237776994705,
-0.35661396384239197,
-0.10035835206508636,
0.18382953107357025,
-0.41973212361335754,
-0.17026695609092712,
0.5468276143074036,
-0.02827300876379013,
0.39461883902549744,
-0.1987387239933014,
-0.3924032151699066,
0.4007282853126526,
0.11534711718559265,
0.13736164569854736,
0.2623327970504761,
0.07030414044857025,
0.04153794050216675,
0.6375707387924194,
0.4577556848526001,
0.9771709442138672,
0.5408487915992737,
0.16195791959762573,
0.5316851139068604,
-0.7226442098617554,
-0.6437760591506958,
-0.4460759162902832,
0.25293177366256714,
-0.36045247316360474,
-0.37973639369010925,
0.5249221324920654,
0.7019103169441223,
1.0295454263687134,
0.21737711131572723,
0.8153597116470337,
-0.26009297370910645,
0.716839075088501,
-0.34394219517707825,
0.35287949442863464,
-0.11316027492284775,
0.10444322973489761,
-0.16510266065597534,
-1.0824055671691895,
0.00031501890043728054,
0.6051729321479797,
-0.38206812739372253,
-0.08748345822095871,
0.7536124587059021,
0.826633095741272,
0.04267168417572975,
0.4669148325920105,
0.34909823536872864,
-0.20782510936260223,
0.2726379930973053,
0.09501750767230988,
1.050957202911377,
-0.04680384323000908,
0.6324320435523987,
-0.7182855010032654,
-0.11356163769960403,
-0.2979166805744171,
-0.30186691880226135,
-0.9498164653778076,
-0.49451765418052673,
-0.5048869848251343,
0.015407060272991657,
0.23721961677074432,
0.47960031032562256,
1.0607608556747437,
-0.738194465637207,
-0.3165569007396698,
0.7451305985450745,
0.012519760057330132,
-0.09414149820804596,
-0.25296616554260254,
0.10087491571903229,
0.22478896379470825,
-0.8446873426437378,
0.22687353193759918,
0.19095616042613983,
0.40116873383522034,
0.09835979342460632,
0.15752579271793365,
0.053574346005916595,
-0.14477279782295227,
0.42964136600494385,
0.48558732867240906,
-0.2879057228565216,
-0.2866079807281494,
-0.3912915587425232,
-0.34759533405303955,
-0.1751808226108551,
1.2946410179138184,
-0.25057509541511536,
0.2826188802719116,
0.3384077250957489,
0.2015058845281601,
1.0114227533340454,
0.3049740493297577,
0.5336236357688904,
-0.9517250061035156,
0.6399005055427551,
0.45560914278030396,
0.037955183535814285,
0.29659202694892883,
-0.28564196825027466,
0.4510553479194641,
0.29025664925575256,
-0.7241017818450928,
-0.7040615677833557,
0.1983087956905365,
-0.9317835569381714,
-0.40699201822280884,
0.9517877697944641,
0.1979534924030304,
0.13505436480045319,
-0.8364711403846741,
0.18579690158367157,
0.04929644241929054,
-0.601458728313446,
0.627041757106781,
0.6712610125541687,
-0.1597583293914795,
-0.3200691044330597,
-0.9954010248184204,
0.5407037138938904,
-0.15692703425884247,
-0.3314659297466278,
0.33958762884140015,
0.2602687180042267,
0.5366930961608887,
0.2094084918498993,
1.0183942317962646,
-0.28501927852630615,
0.3420126438140869,
-0.17968112230300903,
-0.14225482940673828,
-0.17448650300502777,
-0.16642096638679504,
-0.29856836795806885,
0.03084752708673477,
-0.28574007749557495,
-0.3797306716442108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01796v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01796v1 | Ground Every Sentence: Improving Retrieval-Augmented LLMs with Interleaved Reference-Claim Generation | 2024-07-01T20:47:47 | 2024-07-01T20:47:47 | Sirui Xia, Xintao Wang, Jiaqing Liang, Yifei Zhang, Weikang Zhou, Jiaji Deng, Fei Yu, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has been widely adopted to enhance Large
Language Models (LLMs) in knowledge-intensive tasks. Recently, Attributed Text
Generation (ATG) has attracted growing attention, which provides citations to
support the model's responses in RAG, so as to enhance the credibility of
LLM-generated content and facilitate verification. Prior methods mainly adopt
coarse-grained attributions, linking to passage-level references or providing
paragraph-level citations. However, these methods still fall short in
verifiability and require certain time costs for fact checking. This paper
proposes a fine-grained ATG method called ReClaim(Refer & Claim), which
alternates the generation of references and answers step by step. Unlike
traditional coarse-grained attribution, ReClaim allows the model to add
sentence-level fine-grained citations to each answer sentence in long-form
question-answering tasks. Our experiments encompass various training and
inference methods and multiple LLMs, verifying the effectiveness of our
approach. | [
-0.07931145280599594,
-0.6993945837020874,
0.7970784306526184,
-0.11163507401943207,
-0.12204761058092117,
0.012384513393044472,
-0.062367286533117294,
-0.37724098563194275,
0.18200793862342834,
0.5978387594223022,
-0.4103245735168457,
-0.15457923710346222,
-0.3718779385089874,
0.26203909516334534,
-0.38839858770370483,
0.9227201342582703,
-0.000989706488326192,
-0.3265242576599121,
-0.7030565142631531,
0.06780314445495605,
-0.36894097924232483,
-0.41074270009994507,
-0.41386890411376953,
-0.48907580971717834,
0.43066495656967163,
0.6053658127784729,
0.38609760999679565,
0.6169810891151428,
0.46006378531455994,
0.21291334927082062,
-0.06631801277399063,
0.6888092756271362,
-0.21632401645183563,
0.16963845491409302,
-0.46971017122268677,
-0.5005516409873962,
-0.31620338559150696,
0.05730701982975006,
0.6051477789878845,
0.5259332060813904,
-0.12201551347970963,
0.3873154819011688,
0.032570868730545044,
0.5193366408348083,
-1.0123058557510376,
-0.23801858723163605,
-1.209685206413269,
-0.44429847598075867,
-0.2681834399700165,
-0.4904590845108032,
-0.6620935201644897,
-0.5246809124946594,
-0.17712117731571198,
-0.5092905759811401,
0.4134190082550049,
0.18045727908611298,
1.0848618745803833,
0.1295347362756729,
-0.3728782534599304,
-0.5190557241439819,
-0.405038446187973,
0.8380922675132751,
-0.6714587807655334,
0.021957378834486008,
0.5444571375846863,
0.031008552759885788,
-0.06496142596006393,
-0.9464800953865051,
-0.5813884735107422,
-0.49555593729019165,
-0.3655600845813751,
0.05914480239152908,
-0.165190652012825,
-0.17745843529701233,
0.21047364175319672,
0.3735611140727997,
-0.2580718398094177,
-0.205477774143219,
-0.1761108934879303,
-0.15723666548728943,
0.5278557538986206,
-0.08190078288316727,
0.04989160969853401,
-0.6944485902786255,
-0.6584402322769165,
0.026864655315876007,
-1.2410204410552979,
-0.05021878331899643,
0.12625376880168915,
0.48336368799209595,
0.265179306268692,
0.7561251521110535,
-0.3012554347515106,
0.8061275482177734,
0.23840270936489105,
-0.1887287199497223,
0.12135600298643112,
-0.37192392349243164,
-0.1520072966814041,
0.1564677506685257,
0.5715003609657288,
0.235091894865036,
0.14499199390411377,
-0.4972172975540161,
-0.13464957475662231,
-0.17680874466896057,
0.4719727337360382,
-0.726978600025177,
0.18527059257030487,
-0.05644327774643898,
-0.3021259605884552,
-0.44401392340660095,
-0.11076795309782028,
-0.37754425406455994,
-0.5038523077964783,
-0.21195931732654572,
0.363720566034317,
-0.4253222644329071,
0.0232545118778944,
-0.07321811467409134,
0.03982391580939293,
0.0457170344889164,
0.32334789633750916,
-0.33806025981903076,
0.14202210307121277,
0.5547800064086914,
0.4955408573150635,
-0.1571759134531021,
-0.047507863491773605,
-1.0682554244995117,
0.5444053411483765,
-0.22122140228748322,
1.1886855363845825,
-0.5202220678329468,
-0.26475560665130615,
0.2960728108882904,
-0.10368805378675461,
0.1399465650320053,
-0.7719098329544067,
1.0289777517318726,
-0.5922088027000427,
0.2055579125881195,
-0.5342564582824707,
-0.5726282596588135,
0.0318102203309536,
0.6812900304794312,
-0.35646969079971313,
1.204517126083374,
-0.03794995695352554,
-0.9093663096427917,
0.0010844154749065638,
-0.40601903200149536,
-0.4363013505935669,
0.04675028473138809,
-0.24806539714336395,
-0.3937808573246002,
0.28780418634414673,
0.24787454307079315,
0.43327587842941284,
-0.7197932600975037,
0.4767899513244629,
-0.22855141758918762,
-0.08460743725299835,
0.12158194184303284,
-0.3136005401611328,
0.5844615697860718,
0.31729260087013245,
-0.07613801956176758,
-0.052674829959869385,
-1.1507139205932617,
0.22277116775512695,
0.037505727261304855,
-0.45998334884643555,
-0.5692666172981262,
0.2512260377407074,
-0.06690645217895508,
-0.021902894601225853,
0.16695617139339447,
-0.7968202829360962,
0.15500693023204803,
-0.3428990840911865,
0.26460030674934387,
0.5907235145568848,
0.22851623594760895,
0.3832229971885681,
-0.4820431172847748,
0.308620810508728,
-0.003950708080083132,
-0.581878125667572,
-0.4931301474571228,
0.13299588859081268,
-0.7565016150474548,
-0.10930142551660538,
0.1654885709285736,
0.4736369848251343,
-0.8816543817520142,
0.33917587995529175,
-0.6513546705245972,
-0.19643637537956238,
-0.3475903868675232,
-0.0007583261467516422,
0.4943973422050476,
0.9024974703788757,
0.5095792412757874,
0.28865164518356323,
-0.6139625906944275,
-0.7936999201774597,
-0.537189781665802,
-0.47471633553504944,
-0.28044015169143677,
0.49344879388809204,
0.2012113332748413,
-0.0774308368563652,
1.3910819292068481,
-0.697292685508728,
-0.055885929614305496,
0.046563521027565,
0.20183426141738892,
-0.17165961861610413,
0.3825443685054779,
0.43596020340919495,
-0.5843470692634583,
-0.5633872747421265,
-0.12574918568134308,
-0.6194374561309814,
-0.4472087025642395,
-0.07633856683969498,
-0.23139688372612,
0.030883396044373512,
0.7163026928901672,
-0.7078655362129211,
0.17561829090118408,
0.035984404385089874,
-0.268903911113739,
0.5364872217178345,
-0.0026287164073437452,
0.3282599151134491,
-1.2504637241363525,
0.28332844376564026,
-0.20389670133590698,
-0.5825193524360657,
-0.2779289186000824,
0.3929964005947113,
0.2519737184047699,
-0.14354249835014343,
-0.22306978702545166,
0.7223869562149048,
-0.6023478507995605,
0.13825573027133942,
-0.4667917788028717,
0.4434903860092163,
0.12447211891412735,
0.12836892902851105,
-0.28336092829704285,
1.0458581447601318,
0.14233875274658203,
-0.5907527804374695,
0.1778201013803482,
0.22330552339553833,
-0.03818953409790993,
0.6269761323928833,
-0.505259096622467,
0.24309973418712616,
-0.4203953444957733,
0.4011179506778717,
-1.2507495880126953,
-0.22315385937690735,
-0.05335725471377373,
-0.4199889898300171,
0.20951931178569794,
0.022457893937826157,
-0.4799281060695648,
-0.19109362363815308,
-0.34615951776504517,
0.1435011923313141,
0.29197177290916443,
-0.7453482151031494,
0.9270226359367371,
0.1758567988872528,
-0.2769893407821655,
-0.6317280530929565,
-0.4298068881034851,
0.23194146156311035,
-0.39193594455718994,
-0.3914978802204132,
0.5589818954467773,
0.07293225824832916,
-0.44825735688209534,
-0.032765161246061325,
-0.32767343521118164,
0.00025592002202756703,
0.06941913068294525,
-0.02773246169090271,
0.08683362603187561,
-0.19283665716648102,
0.38420745730400085,
-0.14280998706817627,
-0.04576762765645981,
-0.01735644042491913,
-0.029659202322363853,
0.44984883069992065,
0.05808785557746887,
-0.21826526522636414,
0.16785553097724915,
0.43224579095840454,
0.325836181640625,
-0.36033183336257935,
0.2839275002479553,
0.4088139235973358,
-0.2843256890773773,
0.007238068617880344,
-0.9180386662483215,
-0.08530216664075851,
-0.4426337480545044,
0.1346483826637268,
-0.4401536285877228,
-0.6767826080322266,
0.4568767547607422,
-0.24634185433387756,
0.28967106342315674,
0.5546150207519531,
0.34718209505081177,
-0.1757553666830063,
0.1733006238937378,
0.40881064534187317,
-0.010518228635191917,
0.25806698203086853,
0.1518288403749466,
0.09095876663923264,
-0.7368771433830261,
-0.04481513798236847,
-0.9375677704811096,
0.061452098190784454,
-0.18743062019348145,
-0.43782684206962585,
0.18087264895439148,
0.3903874456882477,
-0.17133937776088715,
0.2135380506515503,
-0.33513960242271423,
0.5191321969032288,
0.4795646369457245,
0.3192330300807953,
0.5887529253959656,
0.2846640646457672,
0.06791718304157257,
-0.08657551556825638,
-0.4471757113933563,
-0.6207306385040283,
1.0841554403305054,
0.03838445991277695,
0.7113409042358398,
0.023144090548157692,
0.8161482214927673,
0.332396924495697,
0.503432035446167,
-0.7607823610305786,
0.6722199320793152,
-0.10366237908601761,
-0.45993322134017944,
0.12603819370269775,
-0.22122670710086823,
-0.7567110657691956,
0.2025279402732849,
-0.1854942888021469,
-0.5877677202224731,
-0.1266343593597412,
0.2689497470855713,
-0.4735294282436371,
0.09396322071552277,
-0.46570420265197754,
0.20799317955970764,
0.19826044142246246,
-0.4233914911746979,
-0.34026384353637695,
-0.6833673119544983,
0.3587575852870941,
-0.04477536678314209,
0.09619895368814468,
0.05877740681171417,
0.06449664384126663,
0.6370733976364136,
-0.4820006489753723,
0.6753481030464172,
-0.1735227108001709,
-0.2741663157939911,
0.7862306237220764,
-0.06762740015983582,
1.1060445308685303,
0.11330599337816238,
-0.10311481356620789,
-0.48508188128471375,
-0.5539129376411438,
-0.09107489138841629,
-0.5703017711639404,
0.8139622211456299,
-0.37560606002807617,
-0.7124022841453552,
-0.34114375710487366,
-0.6663414239883423,
-0.5332039594650269,
0.14353284239768982,
0.15323913097381592,
0.4175059497356415,
0.004151549190282822,
0.49637842178344727,
0.8479632139205933,
-0.1436460167169571,
0.6144925951957703,
0.6070339679718018,
0.08005090057849884,
-0.6230202317237854,
0.5214365720748901,
-0.14928336441516876,
0.36350515484809875,
0.4600759744644165,
0.10835505276918411,
-0.18024830520153046,
-0.30059000849723816,
-0.20929938554763794,
0.18254248797893524,
-0.5547024607658386,
-0.797164261341095,
-0.9541442394256592,
-0.16628329455852509,
-0.5737287402153015,
-0.07266634702682495,
-0.3176461160182953,
-0.4757166802883148,
-0.08862131834030151,
-0.11669987440109253,
0.48082900047302246,
0.09890434145927429,
0.09798286855220795,
0.6204317212104797,
-0.7643712759017944,
0.6550312042236328,
0.1783711165189743,
-0.055788956582546234,
-0.06131317466497421,
-0.517875611782074,
-0.24916821718215942,
0.15400105714797974,
-0.5644041895866394,
-0.6187851428985596,
-0.11254949122667313,
0.2515309751033783,
0.4139866828918457,
-0.006664641667157412,
0.24905286729335785,
1.1625040769577026,
-1.0213638544082642,
0.8786696195602417,
0.24672235548496246,
-0.6382955312728882,
0.4207889139652252,
-0.27905863523483276,
0.12187220901250839,
0.5242031812667847,
0.12481367588043213,
-0.18716011941432953,
-0.3205724060535431,
-0.9271266460418701,
-1.0510653257369995,
0.4746690094470978,
0.16901850700378418,
0.1407175213098526,
-0.2686496675014496,
0.6266024708747864,
-0.07751908153295517,
0.21087709069252014,
-0.7957344055175781,
-0.31330692768096924,
0.17332324385643005,
-0.19644424319267273,
0.1684992015361786,
-0.5666589736938477,
-0.2713829278945923,
0.10736553370952606,
0.8639379143714905,
-0.22752262651920319,
0.2531798481941223,
0.34338271617889404,
-0.26258695125579834,
-0.17276261746883392,
0.4892864525318146,
0.35956868529319763,
0.6011058688163757,
-0.0027909267228096724,
0.2586756646633148,
0.03014887496829033,
-0.221368670463562,
0.22378328442573547,
0.1885833591222763,
-0.3767237365245819,
0.2996717691421509,
0.34085994958877563,
0.46757254004478455,
0.1293977051973343,
-0.6304510235786438,
0.4191206097602844,
0.3833075165748596,
-0.09256196767091751,
-0.33559662103652954,
-0.097446508705616,
-0.01362364087253809,
0.20093974471092224,
0.7969117164611816,
0.10191159695386887,
0.07959304749965668,
-0.5432366132736206,
0.4912243187427521,
0.5413047075271606,
-0.07260680198669434,
0.0682985708117485,
0.7010108232498169,
0.0381886325776577,
-0.09278584271669388,
0.34998223185539246,
0.0525963231921196,
-0.2548849582672119,
0.23995612561702728,
0.8872855305671692,
0.9318647384643555,
0.02963121607899666,
0.1767723262310028,
0.5026134252548218,
0.04892490804195404,
-0.07407687604427338,
-0.015230098739266396,
-0.09488292038440704,
-0.6305416822433472,
-0.6784624457359314,
-0.5894875526428223,
-0.07859508693218231,
0.15003269910812378,
-0.6552234292030334,
0.13354356586933136,
-0.055429499596357346,
-0.09658857434988022,
-0.06921014189720154,
0.10749553143978119,
-0.25404036045074463,
0.29056528210639954,
0.12119562923908234,
0.9384489059448242,
-0.7854724526405334,
0.6775640249252319,
0.7724938988685608,
-0.468052476644516,
-0.8736326694488525,
0.46827977895736694,
-0.312355637550354,
-0.8827868103981018,
0.828088104724884,
-0.12891241908073425,
-0.2894303500652313,
0.2214369922876358,
-0.9339025616645813,
-0.9639068245887756,
0.9342581629753113,
0.5443101525306702,
-0.0793585479259491,
-0.36869847774505615,
-0.09358593076467514,
0.1739126294851303,
-0.3025149703025818,
0.1552429050207138,
0.211419939994812,
0.2026779055595398,
0.4580557644367218,
-0.8605083227157593,
0.2006170153617859,
0.039081159979104996,
0.21674591302871704,
-0.008087064139544964,
-0.40654256939888,
0.8658764362335205,
-0.09272604435682297,
-0.22127068042755127,
0.29156002402305603,
1.0666464567184448,
0.8238466382026672,
0.01801350712776184,
0.5987865924835205,
0.6567593216896057,
0.8439062833786011,
0.03012441284954548,
0.9400861263275146,
-0.16070832312107086,
0.4305811822414398,
1.454630732536316,
-0.30660295486450195,
0.9052909016609192,
0.6744611263275146,
-0.1468454897403717,
0.5659372806549072,
0.2553313076496124,
0.25231626629829407,
0.6560832262039185,
0.25146737694740295,
-0.3770033121109009,
-0.2030002772808075,
-0.34430521726608276,
-0.333297997713089,
0.18431665003299713,
0.12209212779998779,
-0.2982916235923767,
-0.8563074469566345,
0.16152456402778625,
0.3474371135234833,
0.437692791223526,
-0.4229314923286438,
0.6736421585083008,
-0.0910114273428917,
-0.9961795210838318,
0.8348262310028076,
0.04429521784186363,
0.5792258977890015,
-0.5896608233451843,
-0.15152889490127563,
-0.248052716255188,
0.37274008989334106,
-0.19161078333854675,
-0.5108897686004639,
0.1587342917919159,
0.3330119848251343,
-0.4643930494785309,
-0.3563477098941803,
0.9868931770324707,
-0.7351445555686951,
-0.30665382742881775,
-0.27715620398521423,
0.35257673263549805,
-0.03450138866901398,
-0.24670171737670898,
-0.34015393257141113,
-0.31574976444244385,
0.1816573143005371,
-0.3579556941986084,
0.08821739256381989,
0.6216439008712769,
-0.1171700730919838,
0.6361735463142395,
0.496177613735199,
0.09083899110555649,
0.11960567533969879,
-0.08305403590202332,
0.9959402084350586,
-0.530298113822937,
-0.29111942648887634,
-0.8876590132713318,
0.7539412975311279,
-0.3009231388568878,
0.19162024557590485,
0.9541578888893127,
0.7938070893287659,
0.5537635087966919,
-0.12667900323867798,
0.8699185252189636,
-0.4183802008628845,
1.0622522830963135,
-0.6154896020889282,
0.3328549861907959,
-0.6426296830177307,
0.047395866364240646,
-0.385066419839859,
-0.7738704681396484,
-0.15797846019268036,
0.5673023462295532,
0.07362212240695953,
-0.31709831953048706,
0.8661481738090515,
0.6880229115486145,
-0.13953472673892975,
-0.3740100860595703,
-0.09238345921039581,
0.18362244963645935,
0.5071460604667664,
0.33861789107322693,
0.5490425229072571,
-0.8485215902328491,
0.6067429184913635,
0.27019187808036804,
0.015203551389276981,
-0.013617734424769878,
-1.087127923965454,
-0.467715322971344,
-0.29254814982414246,
-0.373836874961853,
-0.780662477016449,
-0.08698078244924545,
0.9131121039390564,
0.1864876002073288,
-0.64646977186203,
-0.08348817378282547,
-0.20354816317558289,
-0.21014165878295898,
0.14468608796596527,
-0.19995427131652832,
0.37394481897354126,
-0.8379427790641785,
-0.6592579483985901,
0.39659857749938965,
-0.2143736332654953,
-0.1891183704137802,
0.105224609375,
0.12338899075984955,
-0.567051887512207,
-0.003735735546797514,
0.6760556101799011,
0.1491951197385788,
-0.7503681778907776,
-0.4411872923374176,
0.007072778418660164,
-0.3175833225250244,
0.1381760686635971,
1.0399200916290283,
-1.0448139905929565,
0.11909081041812897,
0.4061245918273926,
0.9757426977157593,
0.37201017141342163,
0.6259133815765381,
0.4687584340572357,
-1.1700488328933716,
0.19722631573677063,
0.16065986454486847,
0.2965489327907562,
0.296318918466568,
-0.27066299319267273,
0.6286726593971252,
0.2751488983631134,
-0.5145436525344849,
-1.0045573711395264,
0.17438070476055145,
-0.9061554074287415,
-0.1792425960302353,
1.4719676971435547,
-0.3137390613555908,
0.021663662046194077,
0.288790762424469,
-0.24539713561534882,
0.22253748774528503,
-0.03929469734430313,
0.6454662084579468,
0.8550527095794678,
0.20255795121192932,
0.16005612909793854,
-0.33157166838645935,
0.4576543867588043,
0.39205309748649597,
-0.9129084944725037,
0.6681497693061829,
0.7973302006721497,
0.3701831102371216,
0.601334273815155,
0.7921093702316284,
-0.25758546590805054,
-0.0547260120511055,
-0.1899932473897934,
0.03347261622548103,
-0.08220666646957397,
-0.2051389515399933,
0.23824366927146912,
0.2614405155181885,
0.027087131515145302,
-0.26752084493637085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01784v1 | Analyzing Persuasive Strategies in Meme Texts: A Fusion of Language Models with Paraphrase Enrichment | 2024-07-01T20:25:20 | 2024-07-01T20:25:20 | Kota Shamanth Ramanath Nayak, Leila Kosseim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | This paper describes our approach to hierarchical multi-label detection of
persuasion techniques in meme texts. Our model, developed as a part of the
recent SemEval task, is based on fine-tuning individual language models (BERT,
XLM-RoBERTa, and mBERT) and leveraging a mean-based ensemble model in addition
to dataset augmentation through paraphrase generation from ChatGPT. The scope
of the study encompasses enhancing model performance through innovative
training techniques and data augmentation strategies. The problem addressed is
the effective identification and classification of multiple persuasive
techniques in meme texts, a task complicated by the diversity and complexity of
such content. The objective of the paper is to improve detection accuracy by
refining model training methods and examining the impact of balanced versus
unbalanced training datasets. Novelty in the results and discussion lies in the
finding that training with paraphrases enhances model performance, yet a
balanced training set proves more advantageous than a larger unbalanced one.
Additionally, the analysis reveals the potential pitfalls of indiscriminate
incorporation of paraphrases from diverse distributions, which can introduce
substantial noise. Results with the SemEval 2024 data confirm these insights,
demonstrating improved model efficacy with the proposed methods. | [
-0.3512108623981476,
-0.8216984868049622,
0.22250792384147644,
0.28502699732780457,
-0.39586710929870605,
0.10738784819841385,
-0.06500721722841263,
0.15703940391540527,
0.047516483813524246,
0.6518043279647827,
-0.43980786204338074,
-0.6465141177177429,
-0.7032188177108765,
0.17155635356903076,
-0.3525589108467102,
1.0636100769042969,
0.14413383603096008,
0.10878732055425644,
-0.28760644793510437,
-0.2442249059677124,
-0.21214723587036133,
-0.795022189617157,
-0.2950631380081177,
-0.2942546308040619,
0.4574114680290222,
0.768375813961029,
0.5336652994155884,
0.38961276412010193,
0.1536797732114792,
0.253837913274765,
-0.15003326535224915,
-0.05290189012885094,
-0.2770049273967743,
0.20202095806598663,
-0.3282558023929596,
-0.21902237832546234,
-0.14919357001781464,
0.2818259000778198,
0.6899791955947876,
0.44012394547462463,
0.0014689320232719183,
-0.010424157604575157,
0.49340376257896423,
0.0809142217040062,
-0.6929560899734497,
-0.21614639461040497,
-0.8173159956932068,
-0.1633300632238388,
-0.37939733266830444,
-0.501137375831604,
-0.4268922507762909,
-0.030537180602550507,
0.19391298294067383,
-0.043257225304841995,
0.10765545070171356,
-0.10012009739875793,
0.722112238407135,
0.031401894986629486,
-0.6210947036743164,
-0.45850613713264465,
-0.5416954159736633,
1.0567079782485962,
-0.9775913953781128,
0.030380045995116234,
0.07483258843421936,
0.07260457426309586,
0.06213356554508209,
-0.6966574192047119,
-0.4630202353000641,
0.0506698340177536,
0.12557856738567352,
0.10769572108983994,
-0.41555848717689514,
-0.03905618563294411,
0.1402495950460434,
0.22048147022724152,
-0.4584478735923767,
0.142451211810112,
-0.048116836696863174,
-0.2903035581111908,
0.205782949924469,
-0.11349363625049591,
0.3830488622188568,
-0.4503426253795624,
-0.5715928077697754,
-0.4819633364677429,
-0.476793110370636,
0.20860739052295685,
0.5983198285102844,
0.09740907698869705,
0.11105893552303314,
0.5694540143013,
-0.3622966706752777,
0.4908430874347687,
0.0934552401304245,
-0.30097702145576477,
0.10367053747177124,
-0.4838730990886688,
-0.09711338579654694,
0.05033613368868828,
0.8231053352355957,
0.17414018511772156,
-0.05483834072947502,
0.02613433077931404,
-0.19762374460697174,
0.08629842847585678,
-0.07491593062877655,
-0.7407369613647461,
-0.5563318133354187,
-0.09242628514766693,
-0.6905850172042847,
-0.6470987200737,
-0.11320935189723969,
-1.117421269416809,
-0.39757972955703735,
-0.22635316848754883,
0.5650302171707153,
-0.4873763620853424,
-0.23440749943256378,
0.1865765005350113,
-0.4941254258155823,
0.19558720290660858,
-0.006848969962447882,
-0.9124338626861572,
-0.09906244277954102,
0.7178239822387695,
0.48094046115875244,
0.17384636402130127,
-0.28924331068992615,
-0.30614975094795227,
0.2577476501464844,
-0.1619468331336975,
1.146269679069519,
-1.305407166481018,
-0.1895221769809723,
-0.10455243289470673,
-0.024796733632683754,
-0.14270487427711487,
-0.5781847238540649,
1.0124088525772095,
-0.10202575474977493,
0.19163215160369873,
-0.4808773696422577,
-0.6603134274482727,
-0.2026500403881073,
0.29167860746383667,
-0.5094979405403137,
0.481235533952713,
-0.2508144974708557,
-0.7495437860488892,
0.27484673261642456,
-0.5941774249076843,
-0.331607848405838,
-0.15732568502426147,
-0.2055954784154892,
-0.5169599652290344,
-0.026436734944581985,
0.5449526906013489,
0.800514817237854,
-0.339096337556839,
0.2838863730430603,
-0.20837117731571198,
0.1838473230600357,
0.37207290530204773,
-0.7839891910552979,
0.6640394926071167,
0.515713095664978,
-0.32487010955810547,
0.09759165346622467,
-0.5988790392875671,
-0.17510554194450378,
-0.12071657180786133,
-0.4123533070087433,
-0.7117677927017212,
0.061567727476358414,
-0.2410849779844284,
0.2543818950653076,
0.3304036259651184,
-0.39550814032554626,
-0.09876757115125656,
-0.05439174547791481,
0.44503799080848694,
0.6550875902175903,
0.37516677379608154,
0.4226127862930298,
-0.3514717221260071,
0.5386391878128052,
0.08746553212404251,
0.0916975811123848,
-0.4011494219303131,
-0.453739196062088,
-0.4254641830921173,
-0.218598410487175,
0.25493231415748596,
0.4043959677219391,
-0.8528912663459778,
0.24108025431632996,
-0.1205974891781807,
-0.5075873732566833,
-0.33900466561317444,
0.286571204662323,
0.26169314980506897,
0.6287082433700562,
0.6468465924263,
0.19960007071495056,
-0.5620517730712891,
-1.1058179140090942,
-0.741399884223938,
0.14302031695842743,
0.1257125437259674,
-0.004380404949188232,
0.5055201053619385,
-0.05629371106624603,
0.390595942735672,
-0.08748417347669601,
0.1722189038991928,
-0.3338819444179535,
0.7267870306968689,
0.032637402415275574,
0.5597819685935974,
0.6430650949478149,
-0.8526241779327393,
-0.5348814129829407,
-0.11197559535503387,
-0.7175123691558838,
-0.4086534082889557,
-0.29609227180480957,
0.018516968935728073,
-0.41245895624160767,
0.49627256393432617,
0.07719425112009048,
0.19001871347427368,
0.6913892030715942,
-0.3367960453033447,
0.6635774374008179,
0.11692355573177338,
0.7337111830711365,
-1.1635916233062744,
-0.5233261585235596,
0.4017624258995056,
0.2186104655265808,
-0.8226180672645569,
-0.19745133817195892,
0.11914179474115372,
-0.0917004868388176,
-0.3507302701473236,
0.13642404973506927,
-0.3477388620376587,
0.6477037668228149,
-0.4139317274093628,
-0.3596794605255127,
0.01609279029071331,
0.25667044520378113,
-0.14254344999790192,
0.5847914218902588,
0.6928048729896545,
-0.7902432680130005,
0.16782021522521973,
0.20757868885993958,
-0.24459868669509888,
0.9042563438415527,
-0.6200602650642395,
0.0019083947408944368,
-0.25659555196762085,
0.1908467411994934,
-1.404853343963623,
-0.25933119654655457,
0.4118593633174896,
-0.35033664107322693,
0.22904974222183228,
-0.0032047261483967304,
-0.464692085981369,
-0.28355392813682556,
-0.4473816752433777,
0.10178572684526443,
0.3539934456348419,
-0.7479087710380554,
0.3691258132457733,
0.4325723350048065,
-0.3347139060497284,
-0.5925012230873108,
-0.3566528558731079,
0.4046150743961334,
-0.9018969535827637,
-0.5857309699058533,
0.2758692800998688,
0.09038181602954865,
-0.125558003783226,
-0.29853007197380066,
-0.13668383657932281,
0.0022656721994280815,
0.039589639753103256,
-0.13966739177703857,
-0.20101629197597504,
-0.15020820498466492,
0.20913854241371155,
0.49868300557136536,
-0.0727558508515358,
-0.14992620050907135,
-0.28052011132240295,
0.5107016563415527,
-0.11750101298093796,
-0.2090880572795868,
-0.45350438356399536,
0.4473828673362732,
0.5035197138786316,
-0.2910434305667877,
0.6192593574523926,
0.4976303279399872,
-0.07778347283601761,
0.09757594764232635,
-0.8767395615577698,
-0.3811482787132263,
-0.4502798318862915,
0.21683090925216675,
-0.5847707986831665,
-0.665073573589325,
0.19948235154151917,
-0.5044113993644714,
0.11070826649665833,
0.47135111689567566,
0.456989049911499,
-0.26071515679359436,
1.2054418325424194,
0.2014208436012268,
-0.0032462633680552244,
0.4163455665111542,
-0.05972772091627121,
0.09457959234714508,
-0.5483502745628357,
-0.2514309287071228,
-0.8285730481147766,
-0.5676725506782532,
-0.43606245517730713,
-0.500374436378479,
0.26103731989860535,
0.11856460571289062,
0.024437740445137024,
0.4068903625011444,
-0.7449710369110107,
0.3934504985809326,
0.5734735727310181,
0.13726508617401123,
0.216718390583992,
0.4106302857398987,
-0.09002264589071274,
-0.4161064624786377,
-0.7133610844612122,
-0.9958059787750244,
0.9879469871520996,
0.4158642590045929,
1.0386569499969482,
0.091155506670475,
0.6955521106719971,
0.231285959482193,
0.04567329213023186,
-0.23988094925880432,
0.6875831484794617,
-0.32809919118881226,
-0.4833816587924957,
-0.28112590312957764,
-0.17402289807796478,
-1.177742838859558,
0.3630225360393524,
-0.39420968294143677,
-0.5844429135322571,
0.413374662399292,
0.09106840193271637,
0.1813219040632248,
0.44594481587409973,
-0.6083218455314636,
1.0734602212905884,
-0.330248087644577,
-0.17703016102313995,
-0.39556950330734253,
-0.5040276050567627,
0.13765521347522736,
-0.03717683628201485,
0.006360442843288183,
-0.17081330716609955,
-0.1490394026041031,
1.0839569568634033,
-0.14500726759433746,
0.8140336871147156,
-0.11151926964521408,
-0.10953350365161896,
0.4411931037902832,
-0.42610105872154236,
0.6518642902374268,
-0.44154733419418335,
-0.24030862748622894,
-0.14988981187343597,
-0.057731419801712036,
-0.6448199152946472,
-0.41947436332702637,
0.7172924876213074,
-0.5096994638442993,
-0.6080600619316101,
0.08644826710224152,
-0.5199751257896423,
-0.13110025227069855,
-0.08863095939159393,
0.47820767760276794,
0.4468458592891693,
-0.27189958095550537,
0.9264835715293884,
0.7717663049697876,
-0.3107514977455139,
0.3250077962875366,
0.14085714519023895,
0.4884425401687622,
-0.5023322105407715,
1.1717431545257568,
0.2105327844619751,
0.24600064754486084,
0.5388274192810059,
0.6271236538887024,
-0.5543587803840637,
-0.638128936290741,
0.0783865824341774,
0.03807373344898224,
-0.9623530507087708,
0.0033701476640999317,
-1.052791953086853,
0.1986730843782425,
-0.8375808000564575,
0.05105817690491676,
-0.020682239904999733,
-0.4691890776157379,
-0.23630501329898834,
0.13622121512889862,
-0.059172723442316055,
0.4945734143257141,
0.15244635939598083,
0.7727954387664795,
-0.5718976855278015,
-0.09482841938734055,
0.3868125081062317,
-0.4336540699005127,
-0.1349489688873291,
-0.6506556272506714,
0.03340402618050575,
0.18838432431221008,
-0.83909010887146,
-1.4272122383117676,
0.26571473479270935,
0.008455692790448666,
0.9628437161445618,
0.642701268196106,
0.13311606645584106,
0.5747002959251404,
-0.0527176707983017,
0.6378024220466614,
0.33755946159362793,
-0.9055696129798889,
0.6424894332885742,
-0.508724570274353,
0.15311028063297272,
0.4713941812515259,
0.7013456225395203,
-0.16361579298973083,
-0.6612051129341125,
-1.0329824686050415,
-0.6488845348358154,
0.17862407863140106,
0.16944298148155212,
0.3815920352935791,
-0.07673019915819168,
0.1455218493938446,
0.24934318661689758,
0.3997761905193329,
-0.9502497315406799,
-0.22499586641788483,
-0.28507140278816223,
-0.2144797295331955,
-0.045759864151477814,
-0.5928588509559631,
-0.07562878727912903,
-0.3847467601299286,
0.8874427080154419,
0.049350857734680176,
-0.20195312798023224,
-0.14774607121944427,
-0.12940528988838196,
0.36303603649139404,
0.6361212730407715,
0.4253234267234802,
0.44714832305908203,
0.19012029469013214,
0.3797878921031952,
0.13657382130622864,
0.012395121157169342,
0.3365977108478546,
0.09482695162296295,
-0.17290997505187988,
0.15922893583774567,
0.11350417137145996,
0.7895958423614502,
0.32764825224876404,
-0.2316877692937851,
0.3164784610271454,
0.30437958240509033,
-0.4278493821620941,
0.5266287922859192,
-0.11320127546787262,
0.1201174333691597,
0.4643482565879822,
0.3604886829853058,
0.07158350199460983,
0.45062056183815,
-0.4359642267227173,
0.35697442293167114,
0.69688481092453,
-0.21780532598495483,
-0.3195533752441406,
0.6993594169616699,
0.3267512619495392,
-0.009396262466907501,
-0.02726617641746998,
0.0503111369907856,
-0.5061259269714355,
0.5887447595596313,
0.6023446917533875,
0.7346360087394714,
-0.6724199652671814,
0.454927533864975,
0.40443155169487,
0.40299761295318604,
-0.05018433928489685,
-0.21453194320201874,
-0.2713029086589813,
-0.6828157901763916,
-0.143288716673851,
-0.4105762243270874,
-0.4455937147140503,
0.7136726975440979,
-0.281410276889801,
0.4535270035266876,
-0.1792653650045395,
-0.09348927438259125,
0.5223056674003601,
-0.278125137090683,
-0.19667106866836548,
0.15360957384109497,
0.15809644758701324,
0.46813616156578064,
-1.278113842010498,
0.551738440990448,
1.0527423620224,
-0.32757899165153503,
-0.7225772142410278,
0.38119837641716003,
0.059590235352516174,
-0.4512646198272705,
0.0338849239051342,
0.14129655063152313,
0.07353188097476959,
0.13974569737911224,
-0.9523434042930603,
-0.4428131580352783,
0.7652032971382141,
0.20764650404453278,
-0.19601735472679138,
0.289825439453125,
-0.03297194093465805,
0.29568561911582947,
-0.6377900242805481,
0.028547124937176704,
0.6073916554450989,
0.5343467593193054,
0.3417636454105377,
-0.4225198030471802,
-0.02286847122013569,
-0.005850168410688639,
-0.17466117441654205,
-0.02999180741608143,
-0.3667067289352417,
0.9638595581054688,
0.12774887681007385,
-0.002794721396639943,
0.07146410644054413,
0.7498838901519775,
0.1568707525730133,
0.4243279695510864,
0.6624563336372375,
0.24617743492126465,
0.8275046944618225,
0.11796770989894867,
0.8585200309753418,
-0.11625986546278,
0.15930430591106415,
0.9334272742271423,
0.07819938659667969,
0.5227056741714478,
0.47422176599502563,
0.12121715396642685,
0.5164255499839783,
0.7382020950317383,
-0.10677814483642578,
0.6616449952125549,
0.03452911227941513,
-0.558553159236908,
-0.5092329978942871,
-0.24779385328292847,
-0.3456103503704071,
0.36652204394340515,
0.46774736046791077,
-0.5297873020172119,
-0.614225447177887,
0.3778657615184784,
0.14143496751785278,
0.3960166871547699,
-0.09004800766706467,
0.7520444393157959,
-0.14616802334785461,
-0.8576079607009888,
0.5419802665710449,
-0.002355702454224229,
0.7394102811813354,
-0.43926942348480225,
-0.003074723295867443,
0.13632963597774506,
0.1872311681509018,
-0.16329887509346008,
-0.6672219634056091,
0.09127786010503769,
-0.1731879860162735,
-0.030189266428351402,
-0.3158760964870453,
1.098631739616394,
-0.6974525451660156,
-0.40038561820983887,
-0.01071834284812212,
0.547315239906311,
0.3939572274684906,
-0.2083159238100052,
-1.1306949853897095,
-0.18443985283374786,
0.4683181345462799,
0.01513671875,
0.3548371493816376,
0.670963704586029,
-0.11414936929941177,
0.41280579566955566,
0.7660529017448425,
-0.23902899026870728,
-0.0621720589697361,
0.17891500890254974,
0.7927127480506897,
-0.4117106795310974,
-0.43811964988708496,
-1.2585430145263672,
0.42097365856170654,
-0.4719032347202301,
-0.05635790526866913,
1.1843245029449463,
0.5080727934837341,
0.33800366520881653,
-0.1994401067495346,
0.8790395855903625,
0.16250696778297424,
0.57237309217453,
-0.26735052466392517,
0.2970845401287079,
-0.5885980129241943,
0.38565051555633545,
-0.6867538690567017,
-0.8148120045661926,
-0.03837372735142708,
0.5639060735702515,
-0.5465531945228577,
-0.19803769886493683,
0.5884009599685669,
0.9626840353012085,
-0.08706321567296982,
0.19957248866558075,
0.4601183533668518,
0.15753918886184692,
0.607488751411438,
0.2714296281337738,
1.1807284355163574,
-0.24070076644420624,
0.9584514498710632,
-0.32984891533851624,
-0.5099031925201416,
-0.1597752869129181,
-0.8721839189529419,
-1.0311280488967896,
-0.648136556148529,
-0.713077187538147,
-0.43071621656417847,
0.01607508398592472,
0.5795947909355164,
0.47870171070098877,
-0.8043254613876343,
-0.22318097949028015,
0.011378505267202854,
0.2040620893239975,
-0.17255432903766632,
-0.19045878946781158,
0.020138783380389214,
-0.5985309481620789,
-1.0415526628494263,
0.41015535593032837,
0.3621702492237091,
0.2217322587966919,
0.09342938661575317,
0.06269069761037827,
-0.7836827039718628,
0.33631837368011475,
0.4432472586631775,
0.24634116888046265,
-0.4977680444717407,
0.04723786935210228,
-0.1488812118768692,
-0.0422435998916626,
-0.02914414182305336,
0.7264816761016846,
-0.3194167912006378,
0.5551074743270874,
0.628609836101532,
0.53668612241745,
0.1825818419456482,
0.49154385924339294,
0.41337043046951294,
-0.7087875008583069,
0.14611321687698364,
0.25599348545074463,
0.2366596907377243,
0.4274502992630005,
-0.1581040769815445,
0.3820192813873291,
0.2839326858520508,
-0.5874503254890442,
-0.6458051800727844,
-0.05392260476946831,
-0.5177472233772278,
-0.5463259816169739,
1.3473752737045288,
0.09138152748346329,
-0.026336876675486565,
-0.350643515586853,
-0.2894406020641327,
0.07110513001680374,
-0.422436386346817,
0.3567620515823364,
0.9892128705978394,
-0.0012302275281399488,
0.02668686956167221,
-0.40937745571136475,
0.4668988585472107,
0.8578025102615356,
-0.6191228032112122,
-0.16421553492546082,
0.3876500129699707,
0.3341338634490967,
0.3089849352836609,
0.4770641326904297,
-0.039436325430870056,
0.1232994869351387,
-0.005561720114201307,
-0.08626582473516464,
0.444557785987854,
-0.24138271808624268,
-0.22081191837787628,
0.3036804795265198,
-0.1716451197862625,
-0.4556225538253784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01725v1 | DiscoveryBench: Towards Data-Driven Discovery with Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T18:58:22 | 2024-07-01T18:58:22 | Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Harshit Surana, Dhruv Agarwal, Bhavana Dalvi Mishra, Abhijeetsingh Meena, Aryan Prakhar, Tirth Vora, Tushar Khot, Ashish Sabharwal, Peter Clark | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Can the rapid advances in code generation, function calling, and data
analysis using large language models (LLMs) help automate the search and
verification of hypotheses purely from a set of provided datasets? To evaluate
this question, we present DiscoveryBench, the first comprehensive benchmark
that formalizes the multi-step process of data-driven discovery. The benchmark
is designed to systematically assess current model capabilities in discovery
tasks and provide a useful resource for improving them. Our benchmark contains
264 tasks collected across 6 diverse domains, such as sociology and
engineering, by manually deriving discovery workflows from published papers to
approximate the real-world challenges faced by researchers, where each task is
defined by a dataset, its metadata, and a discovery goal in natural language.
We additionally provide 903 synthetic tasks to conduct controlled evaluations
across task complexity. Furthermore, our structured formalism of data-driven
discovery enables a facet-based evaluation that provides useful insights into
different failure modes. We evaluate several popular LLM-based reasoning
frameworks using both open and closed LLMs as baselines on DiscoveryBench and
find that even the best system scores only 25%. Our benchmark, thus,
illustrates the challenges in autonomous data-driven discovery and serves as a
valuable resource for the community to make progress. | [
-0.2635059654712677,
-0.6996192336082458,
0.8737143278121948,
0.2250177264213562,
0.22994856536388397,
0.28749880194664,
-0.3490622937679291,
-0.1674158275127411,
-0.235825315117836,
0.27207109332084656,
-0.7572829723358154,
-0.8737843632698059,
-0.4666304886341095,
0.024119805544614792,
-0.6734517216682434,
0.4007408916950226,
-0.24840794503688812,
-0.0427890382707119,
-0.4233342707157135,
0.12121488898992538,
-0.26243123412132263,
-0.39897826313972473,
-0.3876069188117981,
-0.33556345105171204,
0.514422595500946,
0.37262797355651855,
0.3912551701068878,
0.8283244967460632,
0.6445990204811096,
0.22289730608463287,
0.04658038914203644,
0.11313496530056,
-0.528460681438446,
0.18161743879318237,
-0.39034900069236755,
-0.4540429711341858,
-0.30877915024757385,
0.007181925233453512,
0.42153504490852356,
1.1859160661697388,
-0.22845126688480377,
0.2206687033176422,
-0.08991095423698425,
0.7228929996490479,
-0.48524680733680725,
0.5597501993179321,
-0.4987087845802307,
0.020294491201639175,
-0.3932982087135315,
0.0004201865231152624,
-0.38483452796936035,
-0.3462544083595276,
0.002143952762708068,
-0.3830767571926117,
0.43641942739486694,
0.1253679245710373,
0.39488422870635986,
0.2919318974018097,
-0.3886539041996002,
-0.230119526386261,
-0.6818758845329285,
0.9100478291511536,
-0.5273034572601318,
0.46974360942840576,
0.08540365099906921,
0.4977196753025055,
-0.6059060096740723,
-0.7274294495582581,
-0.3942975103855133,
-0.3534466028213501,
0.14424504339694977,
-0.3027864992618561,
-0.13444927334785461,
-0.143822580575943,
0.551989734172821,
0.6671916842460632,
-0.9192267060279846,
0.10479461401700974,
-0.022662706673145294,
-0.2783818542957306,
0.6647787690162659,
0.22778509557247162,
0.08873945474624634,
-0.10403377562761307,
-0.09041541814804077,
-0.3112770915031433,
-0.7409632205963135,
-0.21900273859500885,
0.2693227231502533,
0.4585784375667572,
0.042524270713329315,
0.5284799337387085,
-0.738252580165863,
0.5016464591026306,
-0.40425848960876465,
0.016450583934783936,
0.44634878635406494,
-0.4868353009223938,
-0.07429112493991852,
-0.20678286254405975,
0.7153405547142029,
0.1727437973022461,
0.06099109724164009,
-0.4109772741794586,
-0.29236897826194763,
0.15252576768398285,
0.021480636671185493,
-0.8621866703033447,
-0.31936684250831604,
0.24669504165649414,
-0.3920391798019409,
-0.3034685552120209,
0.03561989963054657,
-0.735111653804779,
-0.7811630964279175,
-0.3411514461040497,
0.2657761871814728,
-0.09304307401180267,
-0.289106160402298,
0.21354418992996216,
-0.01970096118748188,
0.059352319687604904,
0.319624125957489,
-0.39409416913986206,
0.5309364199638367,
0.6768481731414795,
0.696225106716156,
-0.4225550591945648,
-0.17087295651435852,
-0.4999062418937683,
-0.13225123286247253,
-0.6253980994224548,
0.7501498460769653,
-0.2179107367992401,
-0.28297585248947144,
-0.17463164031505585,
0.09790166467428207,
0.1343459039926529,
-0.7757635116577148,
0.7882224917411804,
-0.3709193766117096,
-0.2582235038280487,
-0.5547916293144226,
-0.6198461055755615,
-0.17080901563167572,
0.14247585833072662,
-0.855904221534729,
1.284099817276001,
0.09731623530387878,
-0.5682871341705322,
0.47143256664276123,
-0.7094059586524963,
-0.49346983432769775,
0.05929248780012131,
-0.24069741368293762,
-0.1359940767288208,
0.10105352103710175,
0.062312766909599304,
0.3503310978412628,
-0.8680912256240845,
0.6637875437736511,
-0.5474861860275269,
-0.36399295926094055,
0.18913981318473816,
-0.21667660772800446,
0.6105971932411194,
-0.003947235178202391,
-0.6828488707542419,
0.03405556082725525,
-0.9860254526138306,
0.14959096908569336,
0.3398934602737427,
-0.4343533515930176,
-0.060010313987731934,
0.3274533450603485,
0.039226021617650986,
0.2156999558210373,
0.24838024377822876,
-0.6903349161148071,
0.20682558417320251,
-0.2038865089416504,
0.22361722588539124,
0.6868584752082825,
-0.27941372990608215,
-0.04201383516192436,
-0.26942938566207886,
0.27902209758758545,
-0.1544719934463501,
0.011652631685137749,
-0.33113864064216614,
0.026663364842534065,
-0.8097015023231506,
-0.19603809714317322,
0.3582403063774109,
0.4517280161380768,
-0.30456218123435974,
0.5469775795936584,
-0.3332396149635315,
-0.721646249294281,
-0.31796443462371826,
0.27329427003860474,
0.2549075186252594,
0.5263211727142334,
0.33880341053009033,
-0.30723774433135986,
-0.7406396269798279,
-0.996933102607727,
-0.12503722310066223,
0.03920014202594757,
-0.05549142137169838,
0.4318658113479614,
0.49986690282821655,
-0.4660767912864685,
0.8006782531738281,
-0.3658025860786438,
-0.11369355022907257,
-0.2528465986251831,
0.19391551613807678,
0.5345428586006165,
0.27127039432525635,
0.21994754672050476,
-0.5888049006462097,
-0.23765450716018677,
0.0307806134223938,
-0.9829826354980469,
-0.334567129611969,
0.22113166749477386,
0.05101574584841728,
0.14456357061862946,
0.6095921397209167,
-0.47898831963539124,
0.42520490288734436,
0.3790723979473114,
-0.005177373066544533,
0.4909156560897827,
0.0834721103310585,
0.10842077434062958,
-0.4255262017250061,
0.5246638059616089,
-0.21638549864292145,
-0.12900657951831818,
-0.3971071243286133,
0.16454076766967773,
0.05288228765130043,
-0.1138627901673317,
0.014370188117027283,
0.5961539149284363,
-0.3659225404262543,
-0.3995822072029114,
-0.37321189045906067,
0.03351041302084923,
-0.1428598016500473,
0.1815047711133957,
-0.09111669659614563,
0.694166362285614,
0.8748496174812317,
-0.5349513292312622,
0.6168266534805298,
0.14650455117225647,
-0.6108987331390381,
0.24780933558940887,
-0.660846471786499,
0.32136255502700806,
0.010129242204129696,
0.37911996245384216,
-0.7932536005973816,
-0.3399663269519806,
-0.23110172152519226,
-0.10047841817140579,
-0.033194176852703094,
-0.1191869005560875,
-1.1211767196655273,
-0.551694929599762,
-0.10642093420028687,
0.13559292256832123,
0.1464393436908722,
-0.6986028552055359,
0.5081208944320679,
0.21492180228233337,
-0.2946106791496277,
-0.34725385904312134,
-0.3907504677772522,
0.35919100046157837,
0.06215476244688034,
-0.7297728657722473,
0.40134096145629883,
-0.3857031464576721,
-0.35520151257514954,
-0.263170450925827,
-0.40495020151138306,
0.12605412304401398,
0.31618398427963257,
0.46166667342185974,
-0.005650911945849657,
-0.01802206039428711,
0.31707730889320374,
-0.285288542509079,
-0.17675665020942688,
0.22627988457679749,
-0.2758093774318695,
0.7511110305786133,
-0.2568005621433258,
-0.5781681537628174,
-0.050458889454603195,
0.32952427864074707,
0.4746723175048828,
-0.31929320096969604,
0.23646309971809387,
0.21852204203605652,
-0.41145092248916626,
-0.41071417927742004,
-0.5803037285804749,
-0.15773767232894897,
-0.4427591860294342,
0.21754738688468933,
-0.42515915632247925,
-0.6507078409194946,
0.5076699256896973,
-0.40756338834762573,
0.1798088699579239,
0.43773555755615234,
0.5193893313407898,
0.2050226777791977,
1.0194015502929688,
0.6721978187561035,
-0.12811022996902466,
-0.026359528303146362,
-0.0727802962064743,
0.34009477496147156,
-0.27507907152175903,
-0.14655818045139313,
-0.5766671895980835,
-0.20369407534599304,
-0.5543107390403748,
-0.42983630299568176,
0.4693313539028168,
-0.12588626146316528,
-0.13407248258590698,
0.22858989238739014,
-0.15413667261600494,
0.27386295795440674,
0.6782602071762085,
-0.015480920672416687,
0.5091924667358398,
-0.3228745758533478,
-0.21198570728302002,
0.13846507668495178,
-0.46960341930389404,
-0.5502234697341919,
1.3706202507019043,
0.21112346649169922,
0.7600579857826233,
-0.0726052075624466,
0.8905648589134216,
0.3677370548248291,
0.2677180767059326,
-0.7651183009147644,
0.8085635900497437,
0.11643645167350769,
-0.7400854229927063,
-0.11651082336902618,
-0.5596100687980652,
-0.7949923276901245,
-0.1598670929670334,
0.1386997550725937,
-0.5348379611968994,
0.0995979830622673,
-0.10987989604473114,
-0.025696970522403717,
0.03524785116314888,
-0.3115834891796112,
0.8635798692703247,
-0.4192318618297577,
-0.5589045286178589,
-0.3454010784626007,
-0.4275625944137573,
0.34873467683792114,
-0.2966391444206238,
0.4465605318546295,
-0.26551195979118347,
0.30969810485839844,
0.6877757906913757,
-0.2982631027698517,
0.5714409351348877,
-0.2638837695121765,
-0.1986536830663681,
0.1500544399023056,
0.4230749011039734,
0.6309518218040466,
-0.06680400669574738,
-0.3486821949481964,
-0.020511822775006294,
-0.014870782382786274,
-0.27263325452804565,
-0.5284885168075562,
0.8073822259902954,
-0.20722346007823944,
-0.5280368328094482,
-0.27949562668800354,
-0.6149430871009827,
-0.27509257197380066,
0.4940786063671112,
-0.24824561178684235,
0.3641701638698578,
-0.38467326760292053,
0.37405169010162354,
0.7628670930862427,
-0.17359526455402374,
0.2915714681148529,
0.7678138613700867,
-0.41096416115760803,
0.057191938161849976,
0.7925965785980225,
-0.1933838278055191,
-0.002543986774981022,
0.2693038284778595,
0.12955056130886078,
-0.24055629968643188,
-0.8110170960426331,
-0.22084613144397736,
0.05924047529697418,
-0.8769394159317017,
-0.10874786227941513,
-0.5156206488609314,
0.09252133965492249,
-0.16428081691265106,
0.20903006196022034,
-0.5964277982711792,
-0.17195935547351837,
0.15837325155735016,
-0.2420523315668106,
0.12245063483715057,
0.7076999545097351,
-0.16627207398414612,
-0.15233364701271057,
-0.5345454812049866,
0.4181491434574127,
0.07437682151794434,
0.5915071368217468,
-0.24462847411632538,
0.008385974913835526,
-0.30090564489364624,
-0.24709869921207428,
-0.06830987334251404,
-0.5260438919067383,
0.12005972117185593,
-0.14333181083202362,
0.7187467813491821,
0.19461390376091003,
0.1656409502029419,
0.21439172327518463,
-0.3668213188648224,
0.4066561162471771,
-0.2843121886253357,
-0.8703023195266724,
0.6204604506492615,
-0.4570969343185425,
0.09414106607437134,
0.5759044885635376,
0.2343265414237976,
-0.2773786187171936,
0.005235029384493828,
-0.5943940281867981,
-0.7940333485603333,
0.27732232213020325,
-0.0706486627459526,
-0.29512178897857666,
0.1770164966583252,
0.15726517140865326,
0.30833402276039124,
0.34570637345314026,
-0.4928213357925415,
-0.26480796933174133,
0.10823867470026016,
-0.20575816929340363,
-0.08184580504894257,
0.11470407992601395,
-0.41092056035995483,
-0.08800004422664642,
0.5718211531639099,
-0.5332146883010864,
0.015205111354589462,
0.059274036437273026,
-0.1995960921049118,
-0.10972457379102707,
0.24266891181468964,
0.08644277602434158,
0.7838814854621887,
-0.3078870177268982,
0.14718154072761536,
-0.0787469819188118,
-0.08781356364488602,
0.10585691779851913,
0.6108275055885315,
-0.07785294950008392,
-0.015943991020321846,
0.3125755488872528,
0.5443756580352783,
0.2341526448726654,
-1.2657849788665771,
0.4246150851249695,
-0.1110280454158783,
-0.16636371612548828,
-0.2552798092365265,
0.27881959080696106,
0.09495944529771805,
0.3047632575035095,
0.6183189749717712,
-0.28374406695365906,
0.4433252215385437,
-0.5846650004386902,
0.38349130749702454,
0.5478976368904114,
0.020640840753912926,
-0.08824247866868973,
0.4322813153266907,
-0.06065629795193672,
0.09865880757570267,
0.44248053431510925,
-0.22490105032920837,
-0.35364803671836853,
0.5182892084121704,
0.03130919486284256,
0.7699697613716125,
0.09041561931371689,
0.032908257097005844,
0.3584579825401306,
0.3180830776691437,
-0.2697218358516693,
0.43567150831222534,
-0.09661925584077835,
-0.5172351002693176,
-0.3967932164669037,
-0.7035120725631714,
-0.6478533148765564,
0.1961309313774109,
-0.5727250576019287,
0.28480979800224304,
-0.4058274030685425,
0.1653267741203308,
0.21869242191314697,
0.28887203335762024,
-0.7818024754524231,
0.21424652636051178,
0.12155330926179886,
1.0588024854660034,
-0.6535605788230896,
0.5653356313705444,
0.41881176829338074,
0.028436126187443733,
-0.4930184483528137,
-0.23453927040100098,
0.25159838795661926,
-0.5785629153251648,
0.6980393528938293,
0.3630225956439972,
-0.08010221272706985,
-0.002966309664770961,
-0.7329321503639221,
-1.0507559776306152,
1.147694706916809,
0.3452921211719513,
-0.7008613348007202,
0.11502045392990112,
0.1315428614616394,
0.42956480383872986,
-0.3932850956916809,
0.08251285552978516,
0.8651612401008606,
0.7193148732185364,
-0.00833438616245985,
-1.0423916578292847,
0.24018746614456177,
-0.34046363830566406,
-0.256786048412323,
0.08849077671766281,
-0.26120105385780334,
0.8373827934265137,
-0.299148827791214,
-0.347869336605072,
0.16151918470859528,
0.3952828347682953,
0.31887713074684143,
0.3971443474292755,
0.4249333441257477,
0.6803160309791565,
0.8970499038696289,
-0.22616291046142578,
1.1410610675811768,
-0.16773858666419983,
0.3468019664287567,
1.1170295476913452,
-0.7282216548919678,
0.6401125192642212,
0.22860436141490936,
-0.4109930098056793,
0.6588342785835266,
0.5699774026870728,
-0.26748377084732056,
0.4053838551044464,
0.6980769038200378,
-0.17601802945137024,
-0.28657349944114685,
-0.24527718126773834,
-0.08169019967317581,
0.36338070034980774,
0.2674700915813446,
-0.30270418524742126,
-0.43024978041648865,
-0.19278591871261597,
-0.19780316948890686,
0.05696900561451912,
-0.10460592806339264,
0.6608889698982239,
-0.23800575733184814,
-0.5912246704101562,
0.6013135313987732,
0.10135690122842789,
0.2697972357273102,
-0.47456544637680054,
0.002765231067314744,
-0.2971534729003906,
0.32679709792137146,
-0.18332722783088684,
-0.6237121224403381,
0.03713969141244888,
-0.09280605614185333,
-0.36055222153663635,
-0.14966101944446564,
0.5726462602615356,
-0.056735605001449585,
-0.42824825644493103,
0.4684903919696808,
0.7020323276519775,
0.07814516127109528,
-0.3344569206237793,
-0.4865875244140625,
0.4061602056026459,
-0.15825635194778442,
-0.34367361664772034,
0.26360100507736206,
0.21356135606765747,
-0.017019588500261307,
0.8959330320358276,
0.7743198871612549,
-0.1599743664264679,
0.10663390159606934,
0.24476882815361023,
0.9550572633743286,
-0.7957537770271301,
-0.1051797941327095,
-0.5442703366279602,
0.18239744007587433,
-0.07666954398155212,
0.21197117865085602,
0.6887798309326172,
0.830572783946991,
0.8559940457344055,
0.04164992645382881,
1.2339537143707275,
-0.30890393257141113,
1.051202416419983,
-0.4398740530014038,
0.36204993724823,
-0.3269863426685333,
0.30652520060539246,
-0.10026846081018448,
-0.8272383213043213,
-0.20723822712898254,
0.3724938631057739,
-0.20395013689994812,
0.04921291023492813,
0.6922515034675598,
1.0692193508148193,
0.013972226530313492,
-0.047956325113773346,
-0.018712405115365982,
0.2770848870277405,
0.5984634757041931,
0.5529646277427673,
0.7139312624931335,
-0.2770266830921173,
0.40870925784111023,
-0.3428312838077545,
-0.38134077191352844,
-0.106179378926754,
-1.0140814781188965,
-0.8143448829650879,
-0.46274375915527344,
-0.3992759883403778,
-0.16705885529518127,
-0.07747403532266617,
0.7746245861053467,
0.597088098526001,
-0.8217440843582153,
-0.46955618262290955,
-0.6652167439460754,
0.04342884570360184,
-0.24785089492797852,
-0.26059243083000183,
0.2787075340747833,
-0.2939562499523163,
-0.6732280850410461,
1.1120496988296509,
0.27958038449287415,
-0.1700601428747177,
-0.5548450946807861,
0.08949767053127289,
-0.015629729256033897,
-0.07068116217851639,
0.3935628831386566,
0.3176948130130768,
-0.4751933217048645,
0.08517239987850189,
0.12494415789842606,
-0.046445805579423904,
-0.09498828649520874,
0.8872846364974976,
-0.9271392822265625,
0.4686327576637268,
0.42297354340553284,
0.7034645676612854,
0.6692637205123901,
-0.2433566153049469,
0.6341109275817871,
-0.5127911567687988,
-0.2533421218395233,
0.16259682178497314,
0.37135568261146545,
0.5084599256515503,
0.011703605763614178,
0.8504291772842407,
0.31915342807769775,
-0.4379940927028656,
-1.1106212139129639,
0.20914919674396515,
-0.8232342600822449,
-0.09453181177377701,
1.0224016904830933,
-0.09038086235523224,
0.090208500623703,
-0.09337794780731201,
-0.015774855390191078,
-0.024731606245040894,
-0.18078796565532684,
0.7756728529930115,
0.6798465251922607,
-0.13911141455173492,
-0.13643096387386322,
-0.8441722393035889,
0.48339366912841797,
0.3297193646430969,
-1.1533000469207764,
0.6258155703544617,
0.5687111616134644,
0.32832270860671997,
0.19884654879570007,
0.1249711737036705,
-0.1554594486951828,
0.22657868266105652,
-0.20445244014263153,
0.24129389226436615,
-0.050604447722435,
-0.4191111922264099,
-0.070341557264328,
0.22922883927822113,
0.15107294917106628,
0.3803468346595764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01697v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01697v1 | NLPGuard: A Framework for Mitigating the Use of Protected Attributes by NLP Classifiers | 2024-07-01T18:08:17 | 2024-07-01T18:08:17 | Salvatore Greco, Ke Zhou, Licia Capra, Tania Cerquitelli, Daniele Quercia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | AI regulations are expected to prohibit machine learning models from using
sensitive attributes during training. However, the latest Natural Language
Processing (NLP) classifiers, which rely on deep learning, operate as black-box
systems, complicating the detection and remediation of such misuse. Traditional
bias mitigation methods in NLP aim for comparable performance across different
groups based on attributes like gender or race but fail to address the
underlying issue of reliance on protected attributes. To partly fix that, we
introduce NLPGuard, a framework for mitigating the reliance on protected
attributes in NLP classifiers. NLPGuard takes an unlabeled dataset, an existing
NLP classifier, and its training data as input, producing a modified training
dataset that significantly reduces dependence on protected attributes without
compromising accuracy. NLPGuard is applied to three classification tasks:
identifying toxic language, sentiment analysis, and occupation classification.
Our evaluation shows that current NLP classifiers heavily depend on protected
attributes, with up to $23\%$ of the most predictive words associated with
these attributes. However, NLPGuard effectively reduces this reliance by up to
$79\%$, while slightly improving accuracy. | [
-0.33033567667007446,
-0.7443772554397583,
-0.1182553768157959,
0.17524197697639465,
0.07491464167833328,
0.16757573187351227,
-0.07031310349702835,
-0.6797390580177307,
-0.2991718649864197,
0.7543926239013672,
-0.3638576865196228,
-0.45473748445510864,
-0.6003175377845764,
-0.14672428369522095,
-0.06814480572938919,
1.4479126930236816,
0.3077071011066437,
-0.35950779914855957,
-0.3684537708759308,
-0.12726226449012756,
-0.5585751533508301,
-0.6587777137756348,
-0.8710632920265198,
-0.6842227578163147,
0.4508790373802185,
0.08921333402395248,
0.9350937604904175,
0.42191562056541443,
0.5574900507926941,
0.1996879130601883,
-0.13652312755584717,
-0.0613897331058979,
-0.29195913672447205,
0.10283613204956055,
-0.14252956211566925,
-0.5038502812385559,
-0.6155102252960205,
0.041860975325107574,
0.308774471282959,
0.5356333255767822,
-0.03531207889318466,
0.048007428646087646,
0.2867858409881592,
0.5595850348472595,
-0.9748392701148987,
0.29464349150657654,
-0.6978905200958252,
0.6438590884208679,
-0.3174288272857666,
-0.2725656032562256,
-0.4874875545501709,
-0.1805354356765747,
0.1572512984275818,
-0.37938112020492554,
0.39290615916252136,
-0.026447663083672523,
0.777668833732605,
0.41886138916015625,
-0.18483245372772217,
0.2487739622592926,
-0.6817596554756165,
0.9429764747619629,
-0.8139577507972717,
-0.07148679345846176,
0.9270699620246887,
0.09526955336332321,
0.13354846835136414,
-0.5070266723632812,
-0.4920656085014343,
-0.11219601333141327,
-0.4286271035671234,
-0.1092667356133461,
-0.5170460939407349,
0.4795740246772766,
0.5390105247497559,
0.3196125328540802,
-0.6685614585876465,
0.46246546506881714,
-0.4091778099536896,
-0.37420904636383057,
0.8642538189888,
-0.0371464379131794,
0.4222881495952606,
-0.22945840656757355,
-0.27196213603019714,
0.005707011558115482,
-0.7134799361228943,
0.08332511782646179,
0.4594447910785675,
0.40869930386543274,
0.20917540788650513,
0.32893937826156616,
-0.02859403006732464,
0.546734094619751,
-0.07989675551652908,
-0.33196568489074707,
0.5678439140319824,
0.23365183174610138,
-0.45466694235801697,
0.22495001554489136,
0.904047429561615,
0.3832376003265381,
0.09086630493402481,
-0.31851115822792053,
-0.14308544993400574,
0.3637765944004059,
0.3907780945301056,
-0.850469708442688,
-0.42931798100471497,
0.23621051013469696,
-0.369045227766037,
-0.7211750745773315,
-0.2941662073135376,
-0.9381445050239563,
-0.6038379073143005,
-0.05702381208539009,
0.2289426326751709,
-0.10710983723402023,
-0.27129101753234863,
0.15647538006305695,
-0.12750652432441711,
0.29401078820228577,
0.005296718329191208,
-1.049846887588501,
0.2063300758600235,
0.9430649876594543,
0.8018432259559631,
-0.21190060675144196,
-0.12187190353870392,
-0.41616180539131165,
0.16711381077766418,
0.10583525896072388,
0.5496135950088501,
-0.7255954146385193,
-0.34120360016822815,
0.026435017585754395,
-0.05325473099946976,
0.2358352690935135,
-0.4546775817871094,
0.8984144330024719,
-0.3348684310913086,
0.3503114581108093,
-0.0334341861307621,
-0.37088441848754883,
-0.23722928762435913,
0.24546149373054504,
-0.7972254157066345,
1.090227484703064,
0.04100915044546127,
-1.0828770399093628,
0.5088770985603333,
-0.7399239540100098,
-0.605011522769928,
0.3027639091014862,
0.06313546746969223,
-0.935146152973175,
-0.1664172261953354,
0.30365628004074097,
0.3663367033004761,
-0.13494336605072021,
0.22147051990032196,
-0.426436185836792,
-0.25464850664138794,
0.08997876942157745,
-0.6355559229850769,
1.0338224172592163,
0.11769706010818481,
-0.41759058833122253,
0.11359048634767532,
-0.7148346900939941,
0.06566748768091202,
-0.03789390251040459,
-0.2257544994354248,
-0.5796151161193848,
0.06978534907102585,
0.09711772203445435,
0.18577873706817627,
-0.05213214457035065,
-0.6052439212799072,
0.061425987631082535,
-0.3638138771057129,
0.35867658257484436,
1.04132080078125,
-0.22530020773410797,
0.5782783031463623,
-0.29964980483055115,
0.887080729007721,
-0.44671493768692017,
0.1987694501876831,
0.18270333111286163,
-0.5700787305831909,
-0.7454182505607605,
-0.355478435754776,
0.25500133633613586,
0.7639198899269104,
-0.712112307548523,
0.7976173162460327,
0.10704472661018372,
-0.4858686923980713,
-0.6892114281654358,
0.15357227623462677,
0.6578395962715149,
0.6176276206970215,
0.4535943269729614,
-0.4555516839027405,
-0.4255917966365814,
-0.8083810210227966,
-0.3003431260585785,
-0.20132039487361908,
-0.37021031975746155,
0.10496407747268677,
0.2789323329925537,
-0.2242291122674942,
0.9029378294944763,
-0.5101904273033142,
-0.664718508720398,
-0.2687508463859558,
0.2562403976917267,
-0.18425950407981873,
0.6626208424568176,
0.7932919859886169,
-0.6875917911529541,
-0.1698337346315384,
-0.10398995876312256,
-0.7078785300254822,
-0.5516705513000488,
-0.19041216373443604,
-0.15907838940620422,
0.05273326858878136,
0.42241156101226807,
-0.5444687604904175,
0.6097255945205688,
0.4839961528778076,
-0.31590309739112854,
0.5179594159126282,
0.10214649140834808,
-0.5050143003463745,
-0.48014113306999207,
0.3361990451812744,
-0.0840563178062439,
-0.2143935114145279,
-0.8139314651489258,
0.278804749250412,
-0.21956613659858704,
-0.219131737947464,
-0.3156495988368988,
0.5004802346229553,
-0.040963415056467056,
0.24978935718536377,
-0.4438669979572296,
-0.18743880093097687,
0.3074558973312378,
0.44924142956733704,
0.08599679917097092,
0.6623272895812988,
0.5448451638221741,
-0.6794013977050781,
0.2452600747346878,
0.40738531947135925,
-0.09017109125852585,
0.9163690209388733,
-0.8008244037628174,
0.3335517644882202,
-0.3750682771205902,
0.1367003470659256,
-0.32070788741111755,
0.10496014356613159,
0.2638837695121765,
-0.37782493233680725,
0.34867554903030396,
-0.25411257147789,
-0.035910218954086304,
-0.29776835441589355,
-0.441617488861084,
0.24268639087677002,
0.30087053775787354,
-0.505516529083252,
0.6834414005279541,
0.698858380317688,
-0.15929119288921356,
-1.0927757024765015,
-1.0411919355392456,
0.08818010985851288,
-0.4434666335582733,
-0.21589018404483795,
0.5622335076332092,
-0.008006729185581207,
0.05541011318564415,
0.1749449074268341,
0.052335914224386215,
-0.1889999508857727,
0.583009660243988,
0.38436561822891235,
0.17890681326389313,
0.09045498818159103,
0.39607444405555725,
0.04539322108030319,
-0.3853755593299866,
0.42501819133758545,
0.05861484259366989,
0.5669869184494019,
-0.13117611408233643,
-0.2100316733121872,
-0.22539487481117249,
0.36632585525512695,
0.044297754764556885,
-0.6466556787490845,
0.8085689544677734,
0.8846096992492676,
-0.3738532066345215,
-0.5574851036071777,
-0.13291077315807343,
-0.0187066663056612,
-0.5662532448768616,
0.42179661989212036,
0.05119245871901512,
-0.9885854125022888,
0.24432291090488434,
0.3311038315296173,
0.2709495723247528,
0.42024099826812744,
0.20286022126674652,
-0.0033318300265818834,
0.8076086044311523,
0.7367120981216431,
-0.5323854684829712,
0.5219194293022156,
-0.1655692756175995,
0.5825281739234924,
-0.8930434584617615,
-0.2535551190376282,
-0.6829257011413574,
-0.5285443067550659,
-0.8453692197799683,
-0.22290648519992828,
0.028901098296046257,
-0.19465915858745575,
-0.23615770041942596,
0.23858791589736938,
-0.8142204284667969,
0.7304793000221252,
0.7043433785438538,
0.23255431652069092,
0.1655687391757965,
-0.056958869099617004,
0.3228951096534729,
-0.13165178894996643,
-0.5303744077682495,
-0.4783761501312256,
1.2270467281341553,
0.4827575087547302,
0.8638554811477661,
-0.00048123387387022376,
0.5925334095954895,
0.6635552048683167,
0.4556938111782074,
-0.8610666394233704,
0.6732336282730103,
-0.22616751492023468,
-0.6749035716056824,
-0.12968838214874268,
-0.5326220989227295,
-1.026241421699524,
0.1949433535337448,
-0.5015963315963745,
-0.571033239364624,
0.17894349992275238,
0.29702702164649963,
-0.17292124032974243,
0.513714611530304,
-0.4443177580833435,
0.7818660736083984,
-0.3718113601207733,
-0.45840558409690857,
0.010020637884736061,
-0.47864073514938354,
0.33515381813049316,
-0.009130779653787613,
-0.12579850852489471,
-0.3118208050727844,
0.3227258324623108,
0.7262971997261047,
-0.2316288948059082,
1.0305951833724976,
-0.4169265627861023,
0.05651563033461571,
-0.06214621663093567,
-0.09553541988134384,
0.2284274399280548,
-0.05339463800191879,
-0.0916733518242836,
0.24984794855117798,
-0.34586432576179504,
-0.40699294209480286,
-0.36024412512779236,
0.5214343667030334,
-0.639131486415863,
-0.49099013209342957,
-0.7607462406158447,
-0.5436171889305115,
-0.21457640826702118,
0.27406665682792664,
0.13705964386463165,
-0.05889816954731941,
-0.3061928153038025,
0.3348504602909088,
0.7987922430038452,
-0.5824065208435059,
0.30624648928642273,
0.18884046375751495,
-0.23040184378623962,
-0.1715637445449829,
0.9257879257202148,
-0.09457346051931381,
0.29106178879737854,
0.34330302476882935,
0.2689222991466522,
0.10442735254764557,
-0.5510038137435913,
0.05029373988509178,
-0.2277214080095291,
-0.6496894359588623,
-0.5649198293685913,
-0.6498279571533203,
-0.5880476236343384,
-0.17641566693782806,
-0.06146492063999176,
0.10573539137840271,
-0.463387668132782,
-0.3078767955303192,
-0.5725783109664917,
0.4337193965911865,
0.30406105518341064,
0.03834786266088486,
0.504598081111908,
-0.44021862745285034,
0.37073370814323425,
0.5412505269050598,
0.5122537016868591,
-0.14335846900939941,
-0.2337673157453537,
0.12172074615955353,
-0.08481262624263763,
-0.5003865361213684,
-0.46835511922836304,
0.62589430809021,
0.5320168733596802,
0.6673574447631836,
0.4531233608722687,
0.38161757588386536,
0.26292380690574646,
-0.35092541575431824,
0.6468214988708496,
-0.005875640083104372,
-0.9170728921890259,
0.4537505805492401,
-0.03370577096939087,
0.11484797298908234,
0.6631824970245361,
0.24348042905330658,
-0.5641181468963623,
-0.5538919568061829,
-0.5555814504623413,
-1.1046411991119385,
0.4121573567390442,
0.19400319457054138,
0.3129338324069977,
0.2098563313484192,
0.08736888319253922,
0.04052198678255081,
0.47165271639823914,
-1.0019477605819702,
-0.12405193597078323,
-0.34039902687072754,
-0.16623154282569885,
0.11975588649511337,
-0.2653871178627014,
-0.18374328315258026,
-0.13054373860359192,
0.6997817754745483,
-0.18176236748695374,
0.27519354224205017,
-0.14951087534427643,
-0.1819375455379486,
0.31926533579826355,
0.4539960026741028,
0.030610764399170876,
0.1259114295244217,
-0.2296333611011505,
0.20502722263336182,
0.035208966583013535,
-0.7592915892601013,
-0.08862105756998062,
0.2973393201828003,
-0.8608976006507874,
-0.10676763951778412,
0.3378960192203522,
1.0195074081420898,
-0.22808118164539337,
-0.44833269715309143,
0.5221506953239441,
-0.010081679560244083,
-0.0819258987903595,
-0.2176521122455597,
0.2916198670864105,
-0.3059089183807373,
-0.0390794612467289,
0.13305498659610748,
0.2567296028137207,
0.3476274609565735,
-0.23708447813987732,
0.2677883505821228,
0.7116456031799316,
-0.3727246820926666,
-0.02328990399837494,
0.6581845283508301,
0.3494115471839905,
-0.2742745578289032,
0.4762382507324219,
-0.1534351110458374,
-0.6652666926383972,
0.47154852747917175,
0.4730769991874695,
1.144869327545166,
-0.37746766209602356,
0.34282150864601135,
0.19992490112781525,
0.6331973075866699,
0.058639951050281525,
0.1401756852865219,
0.043315887451171875,
-0.8117195963859558,
-0.3291296064853668,
-0.7116495370864868,
-0.5038670301437378,
0.30953896045684814,
-0.7408689260482788,
-0.010247588157653809,
-0.9613605737686157,
-0.3997785747051239,
-0.007229777984321117,
-0.2334713637828827,
-0.7157882452011108,
0.15808458626270294,
0.10815809667110443,
0.5582597851753235,
-1.188918113708496,
0.5265424251556396,
0.1465403288602829,
-0.33406534790992737,
-0.3676757216453552,
-0.035467036068439484,
0.11078435927629471,
-0.5644410252571106,
0.3077619671821594,
0.42281386256217957,
-0.051330357789993286,
-0.3867177367210388,
-0.6183100342750549,
-0.3607836365699768,
0.7429822087287903,
0.47631022334098816,
-0.23362836241722107,
0.0005099194822832942,
0.3751780688762665,
0.6855695247650146,
0.07345183193683624,
0.13124437630176544,
0.7829110622406006,
0.400993287563324,
-0.3757738769054413,
-0.8339123129844666,
-0.07661032676696777,
-0.5527495741844177,
0.023084085434675217,
0.12863683700561523,
-0.3733610212802887,
0.6054144501686096,
0.031133368611335754,
-0.059310007840394974,
-0.39408424496650696,
0.494621604681015,
0.16531546413898468,
0.2997620403766632,
0.4486829936504364,
0.663147509098053,
1.115465521812439,
-0.35471802949905396,
0.9143761396408081,
0.19480577111244202,
0.28031831979751587,
1.250658631324768,
-0.3143540322780609,
0.7825487852096558,
0.1681668609380722,
-0.2735864818096161,
0.48285630345344543,
0.18858779966831207,
-0.3352572023868561,
0.5945495963096619,
0.285093754529953,
-0.5788118243217468,
0.0863795354962349,
-0.5224709510803223,
-0.30294400453567505,
0.6420058012008667,
0.4329051971435547,
-0.4420870542526245,
0.1000613421201706,
0.25827130675315857,
0.42096400260925293,
0.11327844858169556,
-0.30736851692199707,
0.7350267171859741,
0.04716893658041954,
-0.3563051223754883,
0.3824431300163269,
-0.027835963293910027,
1.005819320678711,
-0.6623072028160095,
-0.011330417357385159,
-0.13880202174186707,
0.354441374540329,
-0.5911421775817871,
-0.9222760200500488,
0.4555017054080963,
0.17131006717681885,
-0.07202810049057007,
-0.5385246872901917,
1.0411657094955444,
-0.5470001101493835,
-0.632826566696167,
0.29487892985343933,
-0.16056956350803375,
-0.3615427613258362,
0.010554041713476181,
-0.8546876907348633,
-0.19270625710487366,
-0.11936068534851074,
-0.06035954877734184,
0.4293520450592041,
0.18200363218784332,
0.0440346784889698,
0.7512707710266113,
0.7819087505340576,
0.32339218258857727,
-0.1532278209924698,
0.05593599006533623,
0.7967406511306763,
-0.3898658752441406,
-0.6390647888183594,
-0.7001273036003113,
0.39842405915260315,
-0.4064314663410187,
-0.15420177578926086,
0.7204456925392151,
0.25784245133399963,
0.9863073825836182,
0.11791927367448807,
1.1634515523910522,
-0.1092461496591568,
0.3551453948020935,
-0.5414224863052368,
1.0705933570861816,
-0.16194520890712738,
0.43503421545028687,
-0.5640780925750732,
-0.7030470371246338,
-0.7233967781066895,
1.0495941638946533,
-0.18791092932224274,
0.09383215010166168,
0.30583375692367554,
0.8523491024971008,
0.1375487893819809,
0.014233501628041267,
0.03045952320098877,
-0.1663694977760315,
0.7607243657112122,
0.6186758875846863,
0.49355024099349976,
-0.20302477478981018,
0.3308495879173279,
-0.522576630115509,
-0.19071519374847412,
-0.0016668334137648344,
-1.2261650562286377,
-1.025748372077942,
-0.021493790671229362,
-0.4189404249191284,
-0.3889848589897156,
0.04156005382537842,
0.6226394176483154,
0.48625367879867554,
-0.8981817960739136,
0.06406552344560623,
-0.019722560420632362,
0.21969756484031677,
-0.377949059009552,
-0.29553160071372986,
0.3422933518886566,
-0.08686228096485138,
-0.4256850481033325,
0.06246933341026306,
0.18845760822296143,
-0.15961605310440063,
-0.4455280601978302,
0.02611934393644333,
0.04339412972331047,
-0.19723807275295258,
0.6023434996604919,
0.5613340139389038,
-0.3656025230884552,
-0.42103588581085205,
-0.3330737352371216,
0.0035079577937722206,
0.03108363226056099,
0.6592678427696228,
-0.8693272471427917,
0.519089937210083,
0.5987944602966309,
0.9304331541061401,
0.24168920516967773,
-0.18558160960674286,
0.5904644727706909,
-1.0308109521865845,
0.5043368339538574,
0.6434097290039062,
0.2634899318218231,
0.5626540184020996,
-0.4611389636993408,
0.595605194568634,
-0.0034706995356827974,
-0.5730857253074646,
-0.9103540182113647,
0.22247734665870667,
-0.8126556277275085,
-0.12178761512041092,
0.8414879441261292,
-0.23986946046352386,
-0.06167224049568176,
-0.2992735803127289,
-0.35069456696510315,
-0.07644900679588318,
-0.41874098777770996,
1.0240836143493652,
0.4389103353023529,
0.19077351689338684,
-0.43839526176452637,
-0.6915281414985657,
0.8765570521354675,
0.46689116954803467,
-1.1457653045654297,
0.2792322337627411,
0.4208814799785614,
0.0253120306879282,
0.15563271939754486,
0.496861070394516,
-0.08269244432449341,
0.17391884326934814,
-0.42720848321914673,
0.24923528730869293,
-0.04540678858757019,
-0.26084282994270325,
-0.3874572813510895,
0.22776827216148376,
0.10259923338890076,
-0.030176369473338127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01687v1 | Deciphering the Factors Influencing the Efficacy of Chain-of-Thought: Probability, Memorization, and Noisy Reasoning | 2024-07-01T18:01:07 | 2024-07-01T18:01:07 | Akshara Prabhakar, Thomas L. Griffiths, R. Thomas McCoy | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting has been shown to enhance the multi-step
reasoning capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). However, debates
persist about whether LLMs exhibit abstract generalization or rely on shallow
heuristics when given CoT prompts. To understand the factors influencing CoT
reasoning we provide a detailed case study of the symbolic reasoning task of
decoding shift ciphers, where letters are shifted forward some number of steps
in the alphabet. GPT-4 achieves zero accuracy on most shift ciphers with
standard prompting, but with CoT its accuracy improves to an average of 32%. By
focusing on a single relatively simple task, we are able to identify three
factors that systematically affect CoT performance: the probability of the
task's expected output (probability), what the model has implicitly learned
during pre-training (memorization), and the number of intermediate operations
involved in reasoning (noisy reasoning). We show that these factors can
drastically influence the task accuracy; e.g., varying the output's probability
of occurrence can shift accuracy from 26% to 70%. We also demonstrate that it
is essential for the model to explicitly produce intermediate steps as output
that can be conditioned on to increase the probability of the correct answer.
Our experiments indicate that as long as the model does so, the validity of the
demonstrations in the prompt does not matter. Overall, we conclude that CoT
prompting performance reflects both memorization and a probabilistic version of
genuine reasoning. | [
-0.23773622512817383,
-0.9373814463615417,
1.0946969985961914,
0.15034356713294983,
-0.4050060212612152,
0.2224678248167038,
-0.1481393426656723,
-0.5315983891487122,
-0.13461993634700775,
0.2683548629283905,
-0.5497817397117615,
-0.43634381890296936,
-0.8305355310440063,
0.27874213457107544,
-0.5095121264457703,
0.917587399482727,
-0.23120646178722382,
-0.047574784606695175,
0.3102657198905945,
0.29790663719177246,
-0.45005542039871216,
-0.8492704033851624,
-0.638620913028717,
-0.36530813574790955,
0.4864378273487091,
0.16331902146339417,
0.7636979818344116,
0.3990929424762726,
0.47921761870384216,
0.25990983843803406,
-0.15332232415676117,
0.0417940579354763,
-0.4744493067264557,
0.2036820352077484,
-0.27481162548065186,
-0.8810818791389465,
-0.23185394704341888,
0.0005752843571826816,
0.5503260493278503,
0.44780850410461426,
-0.17491400241851807,
-0.08451610803604126,
0.032150447368621826,
0.7408069372177124,
-0.6779102683067322,
0.06756050139665604,
-0.8448885083198547,
-0.17050518095493317,
-0.02599954791367054,
-0.2982696294784546,
-0.5406478643417358,
-0.29643383622169495,
0.16582190990447998,
-0.704664945602417,
0.27050846815109253,
0.027624206617474556,
0.3909212648868561,
0.0983085185289383,
-0.40613824129104614,
-0.7321996092796326,
-0.8987184166908264,
0.7645275592803955,
-0.3773845136165619,
0.4625180661678314,
0.620691180229187,
-0.2264084666967392,
-0.4231199622154236,
-0.6388959288597107,
-0.533559262752533,
-0.22111795842647552,
0.2050938904285431,
-0.046137094497680664,
0.027177594602108,
0.3225451111793518,
0.6775656342506409,
0.3210660219192505,
-0.050318751484155655,
-0.4264257550239563,
-0.558158278465271,
-0.21252499520778656,
0.35382112860679626,
0.2369946390390396,
0.2785833179950714,
0.27988094091415405,
-0.2448415756225586,
-0.2747141122817993,
-0.666401743888855,
0.14995510876178741,
0.5007028579711914,
0.13439132273197174,
0.01588992029428482,
0.3724325895309448,
0.030254043638706207,
0.7007933259010315,
0.3238249719142914,
-0.08680764585733414,
-0.04988120123744011,
-0.5823856592178345,
-0.16951575875282288,
0.2658310830593109,
0.5362958312034607,
-0.022091498598456383,
0.43973320722579956,
-0.032130759209394455,
-0.2757948338985443,
0.28232139348983765,
0.5307164788246155,
-0.5464627742767334,
-0.3814767599105835,
0.10267747938632965,
-0.17215405404567719,
-0.26698005199432373,
0.13915260136127472,
-0.40635910630226135,
-0.0971832424402237,
-0.4109288454055786,
0.35685864090919495,
-0.594506025314331,
-0.14372971653938293,
0.26710617542266846,
-0.3090876638889313,
0.030330194160342216,
0.3844955861568451,
-0.8362606167793274,
0.4475434422492981,
0.6990457773208618,
0.7530122995376587,
-0.09444144368171692,
-0.3009199798107147,
-0.3821122348308563,
0.11435558646917343,
-0.7508886456489563,
0.6785266995429993,
-0.7340223789215088,
-0.17813506722450256,
-0.06418796628713608,
-0.10973171144723892,
-0.36238425970077515,
-0.18310017883777618,
0.35787656903266907,
-0.553139865398407,
-0.010076899081468582,
-0.7362002730369568,
-0.5048884153366089,
-0.034333840012550354,
0.114400714635849,
-0.665515124797821,
0.8795809149742126,
0.016495579853653908,
-0.6038462519645691,
0.44518786668777466,
-0.3044726252555847,
-0.48245084285736084,
-0.2805982232093811,
-0.3864021897315979,
-0.016639554873108864,
0.3500320017337799,
0.25874921679496765,
0.06721977144479752,
-0.34462490677833557,
0.07911931723356247,
0.06449075788259506,
-0.6100965738296509,
0.7554437518119812,
-0.5533479452133179,
0.5794767141342163,
0.17819476127624512,
-0.6072319746017456,
-0.1567273736000061,
-0.47771674394607544,
0.09825490415096283,
-0.13851968944072723,
-0.1779792606830597,
-0.20210112631320953,
-0.0002959737030323595,
-0.5685417652130127,
0.378449946641922,
-0.11904197931289673,
-0.2848147749900818,
0.20745795965194702,
-0.25885719060897827,
0.2877131700515747,
0.8405560255050659,
0.43457821011543274,
0.36241841316223145,
-0.30575695633888245,
0.7573105096817017,
0.1801147162914276,
0.27412790060043335,
-0.06531931459903717,
-0.8350107669830322,
-0.399876207113266,
-0.0945405662059784,
0.25783878564834595,
0.29579758644104004,
-0.8166513442993164,
-0.1157865822315216,
0.20978780090808868,
-0.19461050629615784,
-0.4537732005119324,
0.18497450649738312,
0.546347439289093,
0.3213299810886383,
0.3288908004760742,
-0.3268110454082489,
-0.2775219976902008,
-0.4519847333431244,
-0.3423439860343933,
-0.4119105041027069,
0.22272203862667084,
-0.18103577196598053,
0.41780832409858704,
0.12630915641784668,
0.3590308725833893,
-0.4872930347919464,
0.009676551446318626,
-0.3113017976284027,
0.3947716951370239,
0.4270194172859192,
0.2484595626592636,
0.1149638444185257,
-0.49472489953041077,
-0.13883596658706665,
-0.334656685590744,
-0.4779813885688782,
0.029675854369997978,
-0.37670958042144775,
-0.3768146336078644,
0.2876904010772705,
0.6052169799804688,
-0.6363528966903687,
0.7637714743614197,
0.29314330220222473,
-0.36722806096076965,
0.8975529670715332,
-0.38182324171066284,
0.3940028250217438,
-0.5788127183914185,
-0.22201110422611237,
-0.25938886404037476,
0.2023225873708725,
-0.6302569508552551,
0.24403488636016846,
-0.016648245975375175,
0.19187979400157928,
-0.3540003299713135,
0.013819609768688679,
-0.5842026472091675,
-0.03432561829686165,
-0.19066718220710754,
0.18809621036052704,
-0.041686151176691055,
0.5160861611366272,
0.13690437376499176,
0.9441202878952026,
0.4777944087982178,
-0.8319281935691833,
-0.06662492454051971,
-0.08325760066509247,
-0.3565966784954071,
0.17458681762218475,
-0.5974728465080261,
0.42042288184165955,
0.19037851691246033,
0.2554357349872589,
-1.0524832010269165,
0.22879432141780853,
0.17764347791671753,
-0.20035074651241302,
-0.03074697032570839,
0.06999771296977997,
-0.4734537601470947,
-0.4465769827365875,
-0.24260002374649048,
0.5563160181045532,
0.5507787466049194,
-0.27947792410850525,
0.5075845718383789,
-0.10259193181991577,
0.21924754977226257,
-0.6819940209388733,
-0.4939965307712555,
-0.10877759754657745,
0.13314877450466156,
-0.18080724775791168,
0.24327495694160461,
-0.06693913042545319,
-0.38602402806282043,
-0.22899731993675232,
-0.6571865081787109,
-0.008019658736884594,
-0.04832129925489426,
0.13320501148700714,
0.29500436782836914,
0.09522100538015366,
0.19453610479831696,
0.027148695662617683,
-0.0629882961511612,
0.5109072923660278,
-0.4705468416213989,
0.6873130798339844,
-0.24252396821975708,
-0.4073773920536041,
-0.4233047068119049,
0.025705112144351006,
0.6382225155830383,
0.019897112622857094,
0.7216064929962158,
0.4071345329284668,
-0.11925968527793884,
-0.24255067110061646,
-0.4939233064651489,
-0.4120121896266937,
-0.46225932240486145,
0.11810916662216187,
-0.7914616465568542,
-0.4081689119338989,
0.5369221568107605,
-0.05453469604253769,
-0.15849484503269196,
0.23064546287059784,
0.5265836119651794,
-0.18958570063114166,
1.1031855344772339,
0.2658367455005646,
0.08718747645616531,
0.4643336236476898,
-0.3795260190963745,
0.4203004539012909,
-1.0243724584579468,
-0.17827779054641724,
-0.36074304580688477,
-0.3365495204925537,
-0.6108548045158386,
-0.5522500276565552,
0.33658912777900696,
0.29869547486305237,
-0.23924338817596436,
0.20890283584594727,
-0.6128287315368652,
0.5511035323143005,
0.45090949535369873,
0.41382691264152527,
0.3638533055782318,
-0.06229538470506668,
-0.4780825078487396,
0.4068796634674072,
-0.7396849989891052,
-0.3868290185928345,
1.189222812652588,
0.17149850726127625,
1.0991002321243286,
0.03235644847154617,
0.7822422981262207,
0.23414954543113708,
-0.2968847453594208,
-0.4823191165924072,
0.6440104246139526,
0.20579509437084198,
-0.5298075675964355,
-0.3546615242958069,
-0.23994317650794983,
-1.0538864135742188,
-0.01570604182779789,
-0.10608988255262375,
-0.8310877084732056,
0.3010237216949463,
0.24218623340129852,
-0.25591379404067993,
0.29968732595443726,
-0.6155972480773926,
0.29095935821533203,
-0.17601722478866577,
-0.3369285464286804,
-0.4857190251350403,
-0.48769786953926086,
0.3310638666152954,
-0.045567236840724945,
0.12033244222402573,
0.17216284573078156,
-0.05474293604493141,
0.8450502157211304,
-0.3300183415412903,
0.7890316843986511,
0.03031318262219429,
-0.26006874442100525,
0.6579420566558838,
0.423562616109848,
0.8774513006210327,
-0.07524184882640839,
-0.006861666217446327,
0.21437576413154602,
0.07485849410295486,
-0.24535633623600006,
-0.8548551201820374,
0.4124874770641327,
-0.8025408387184143,
-0.9575282335281372,
-0.5939714908599854,
-0.7030119895935059,
-0.1905030608177185,
-0.18228833377361298,
0.43750810623168945,
0.5282825827598572,
0.053853411227464676,
0.012901125475764275,
0.8468888998031616,
0.07733241468667984,
0.26332738995552063,
0.05855396389961243,
-0.2939036786556244,
-0.21186427772045135,
0.6130786538124084,
0.19749899208545685,
0.8408415913581848,
0.2864692211151123,
0.19201460480690002,
-0.40350061655044556,
-0.5332783460617065,
-0.19598668813705444,
0.08379193395376205,
-1.0562838315963745,
0.09049200266599655,
-0.5527750849723816,
-0.17377810180187225,
-0.14481885731220245,
-0.27378177642822266,
-0.12742601335048676,
-0.5124427676200867,
-0.07755690813064575,
-0.281180202960968,
0.35080304741859436,
0.9449723362922668,
0.1617186963558197,
0.11232613027095795,
-0.2756447494029999,
0.45234474539756775,
0.3707782030105591,
0.07536476105451584,
0.2490563988685608,
-0.4472270905971527,
-0.04302368685603142,
0.11849138885736465,
-0.4032316207885742,
-0.9911816120147705,
-0.14240103960037231,
-0.28177380561828613,
0.5296449661254883,
0.40982210636138916,
0.06955793499946594,
0.7679062485694885,
-0.2128031998872757,
0.9181358218193054,
0.3365863859653473,
-1.1807974576950073,
0.5241400599479675,
-0.12525629997253418,
0.5347534418106079,
0.3823072612285614,
0.35121235251426697,
-0.09016714990139008,
-0.9248071908950806,
-0.8211458921432495,
-0.5814324021339417,
0.6391529440879822,
0.47257137298583984,
-0.2849714756011963,
-0.38493964076042175,
0.2788260281085968,
-0.018621135503053665,
0.040180504322052,
-0.5277777910232544,
-0.044093526899814606,
-0.003256815252825618,
0.005878903437405825,
0.16245640814304352,
-0.1112397089600563,
-0.0164560005068779,
-0.3460996448993683,
0.5416703224182129,
0.045933276414871216,
0.5712767243385315,
0.5234208703041077,
-0.21605825424194336,
-0.18331246078014374,
0.36691734194755554,
0.8900070786476135,
1.094708800315857,
-0.1132676973938942,
0.3389948904514313,
0.42316946387290955,
-0.8152313828468323,
0.34873923659324646,
-0.5605267882347107,
-0.10158971697092056,
-0.04886975511908531,
0.7262924909591675,
0.7681713104248047,
0.17000427842140198,
-0.28211793303489685,
0.28015029430389404,
-0.017966926097869873,
-0.3509785830974579,
-0.03490722179412842,
0.4797757565975189,
-0.1723356992006302,
0.08469629287719727,
0.41925010085105896,
0.1976224035024643,
0.14179517328739166,
-0.8947781920433044,
-0.01359719131141901,
0.22866947948932648,
-0.18561974167823792,
-0.3949262499809265,
0.5576376914978027,
-0.08728265017271042,
-0.4558728337287903,
0.7977131605148315,
-0.2196260690689087,
-0.8049895167350769,
0.7962160110473633,
0.8622629642486572,
0.8541355133056641,
-0.30947163701057434,
0.21860124170780182,
0.36513954401016235,
0.5946044325828552,
-0.35169801115989685,
0.5852187871932983,
-0.3185766339302063,
-0.6045677065849304,
-0.4742928147315979,
-0.20863643288612366,
-0.3167557716369629,
-0.10133359581232071,
-0.75206458568573,
0.11656151711940765,
-0.5197950601577759,
-0.4437849521636963,
-0.28758934140205383,
-0.0725746899843216,
-0.9386735558509827,
0.24220415949821472,
0.04924724996089935,
0.9407833814620972,
-0.6656540632247925,
0.783251166343689,
0.18867227435112,
-0.3862791955471039,
-1.0754051208496094,
0.3078872859477997,
-0.17672209441661835,
-0.9592024683952332,
0.7412654161453247,
-0.1184813380241394,
-0.47531595826148987,
-0.18713660538196564,
-0.4095536470413208,
-0.974632978439331,
0.9203987717628479,
0.2199828326702118,
-0.9404523372650146,
-0.16407959163188934,
0.12103960663080215,
0.580815851688385,
-0.44406071305274963,
0.4669395685195923,
0.6706050038337708,
0.4281579256057739,
0.244195356965065,
-0.8623748421669006,
0.36173301935195923,
0.2157849669456482,
0.13449233770370483,
0.4342043399810791,
-0.24980005621910095,
0.8672335147857666,
-0.6711994409561157,
-0.1249704509973526,
-0.231846421957016,
0.3531584143638611,
0.5771798491477966,
0.29415595531463623,
0.4923209547996521,
0.3450244963169098,
0.97321617603302,
-0.02475176565349102,
1.243443250656128,
-0.412612646818161,
-0.14093482494354248,
1.0151036977767944,
-0.24041034281253815,
0.8014184832572937,
0.6827625632286072,
-0.275973916053772,
0.9885270595550537,
0.3167474865913391,
0.27789953351020813,
0.6704824566841125,
0.37648725509643555,
-0.2166619896888733,
-0.16156895458698273,
0.3559849262237549,
-0.3806048631668091,
0.19151459634304047,
0.5264241099357605,
-0.6099886298179626,
0.14892108738422394,
-0.09684192389249802,
-0.16325698792934418,
-0.17987069487571716,
-0.5242407321929932,
0.6927322149276733,
0.1464376002550125,
-1.033116102218628,
0.7149850130081177,
-0.34307780861854553,
0.10443954169750214,
-0.6143330931663513,
-0.12416155636310577,
0.21949388086795807,
0.12137782573699951,
-0.07605484127998352,
-0.955403208732605,
0.1627282351255417,
-0.16329823434352875,
-0.26071280241012573,
-0.09096626192331314,
0.6344711780548096,
-0.27615392208099365,
-0.5313470363616943,
0.22243870794773102,
0.4655744135379791,
0.27113327383995056,
-0.11514710634946823,
-0.5985510349273682,
0.4244688153266907,
0.011088117957115173,
-0.2880583703517914,
0.2266836315393448,
0.7154656052589417,
-0.3363337814807892,
0.5300790667533875,
0.817569375038147,
0.23975276947021484,
0.0878530740737915,
0.278193861246109,
0.8159758448600769,
-0.8126798272132874,
-0.5626296997070312,
-1.0418275594711304,
0.2262430042028427,
0.012481164187192917,
-0.35507217049598694,
0.5735241174697876,
0.1920040398836136,
0.6220245361328125,
-0.09597545117139816,
0.599253237247467,
0.2170586735010147,
-0.2781386077404022,
-0.7709420919418335,
0.22728416323661804,
0.21951664984226227,
0.38512662053108215,
-0.47660985589027405,
-0.941999077796936,
0.22739219665527344,
0.5879132151603699,
-0.6356241106987,
0.1810085028409958,
1.5075984001159668,
0.6991536021232605,
0.3116095960140228,
0.43746817111968994,
0.3498364984989166,
0.21645498275756836,
0.28708353638648987,
0.8683634996414185,
0.9742738604545593,
-0.4485108256340027,
0.6236072182655334,
-0.19452053308486938,
-0.24221208691596985,
0.17227473855018616,
-0.8563875555992126,
-1.0690248012542725,
-0.7067611217498779,
-0.44364118576049805,
-0.45664912462234497,
0.4060620963573456,
0.918627917766571,
0.4365501403808594,
-0.6707740426063538,
-0.1578998863697052,
-0.699662446975708,
0.3328114449977875,
-0.7273975610733032,
-0.16204191744327545,
0.3559315502643585,
-0.6299435496330261,
-0.24542129039764404,
0.12456799298524857,
0.19127947092056274,
-0.02403537556529045,
0.06444376707077026,
-0.027761584147810936,
-0.21438397467136383,
0.40154561400413513,
0.6115121841430664,
-0.11206923425197601,
-1.0803782939910889,
-0.19740575551986694,
0.0925988107919693,
0.008977586403489113,
-0.08131518214941025,
1.0678657293319702,
-0.8474459648132324,
0.3921357989311218,
0.3338563144207001,
0.16466893255710602,
0.6175570487976074,
0.053362421691417694,
0.7965793609619141,
-0.49223119020462036,
-0.08786536008119583,
0.09000873565673828,
0.21732346713542938,
-0.18632881343364716,
-0.7310001254081726,
0.5459726452827454,
0.23870952427387238,
-0.6817347407341003,
-0.5589946508407593,
0.1967320591211319,
-0.7100198268890381,
-0.43624210357666016,
1.2653944492340088,
0.016836930066347122,
-0.377385675907135,
-0.30295270681381226,
-0.35263705253601074,
0.15033692121505737,
-0.47245633602142334,
0.9686074256896973,
1.1495604515075684,
-0.41175469756126404,
-0.21582098305225372,
-0.26699575781822205,
0.5981578826904297,
0.304417222738266,
-0.3164631426334381,
0.18345901370048523,
0.22686603665351868,
0.12690187990665436,
0.2438945174217224,
0.7663450837135315,
-0.07082313299179077,
0.5590133666992188,
0.2972606122493744,
-0.22677509486675262,
0.03855019435286522,
-0.5618923306465149,
-0.1976521611213684,
0.1981942355632782,
0.15127867460250854,
-0.121149443089962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01527v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01527v1 | KV Cache Compression, But What Must We Give in Return? A Comprehensive Benchmark of Long Context Capable Approaches | 2024-07-01T17:59:47 | 2024-07-01T17:59:47 | Jiayi Yuan, Hongyi Liu, Shaochen, Zhong, Yu-Neng Chuang, Songchen Li, Guanchu Wang, Duy Le, Hongye Jin, Vipin Chaudhary, Zhaozhuo Xu, Zirui Liu, Xia Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long context capability is a crucial competency for large language models
(LLMs) as it mitigates the human struggle to digest long-form texts. This
capability enables complex task-solving scenarios such as book summarization,
code assistance, and many more tasks that are traditionally manpower-intensive.
However, transformer-based LLMs face significant challenges with long context
input due to the growing size of the KV cache and the intrinsic complexity of
attending to extended inputs; where multiple schools of efficiency-driven
approaches -- such as KV cache quantization, token dropping, prompt
compression, linear-time sequence models, and hybrid architectures -- have been
proposed to produce efficient yet long context-capable models. Despite these
advancements, no existing work has comprehensively benchmarked these methods in
a reasonably aligned environment. In this work, we fill this gap by providing a
taxonomy of current methods and evaluating 10+ state-of-the-art approaches
across seven categories of long context tasks. Our work reveals numerous
previously unknown phenomena and offers insights -- as well as a friendly
workbench -- for the future development of long context-capable LLMs. The
source code will be available at https://github.com/henryzhongsc/longctx_bench | [
-0.38154473900794983,
-0.28161269426345825,
0.6299436688423157,
0.5921337604522705,
-0.2524298131465912,
-0.020848888903856277,
-0.594892144203186,
-0.4863611161708832,
-0.024591058492660522,
0.4302581548690796,
-0.4333750605583191,
-0.2933328151702881,
-0.49502918124198914,
0.15435995161533356,
-0.6312612891197205,
0.5458239316940308,
-0.2752271592617035,
-0.1527663618326187,
-0.6310399770736694,
-0.17396670579910278,
-0.8063828349113464,
-0.6442215442657471,
-0.25458285212516785,
-0.2741531729698181,
0.4093123972415924,
0.30971917510032654,
0.031190019100904465,
0.3608822524547577,
0.3575960397720337,
0.2182169258594513,
-0.16582587361335754,
-0.07697460055351257,
-0.5822272300720215,
0.5170539617538452,
-0.03789890184998512,
-0.2803671956062317,
-0.49191927909851074,
-0.4338418245315552,
0.8185392618179321,
0.5401456356048584,
-0.08489765226840973,
0.26952770352363586,
0.27951595187187195,
0.8668667674064636,
-1.0288761854171753,
0.22597570717334747,
-0.4078506529331207,
-0.1664360910654068,
-0.4136928617954254,
0.005874933209270239,
-0.6441943049430847,
-0.05197684094309807,
-0.0803721621632576,
-0.32910946011543274,
-0.10058106482028961,
-0.2685537338256836,
0.4183363914489746,
0.5518317818641663,
-0.6574435830116272,
-0.06087777763605118,
-0.8948692679405212,
0.8909072875976562,
-0.4901074767112732,
0.6209544539451599,
0.2891814112663269,
0.601298451423645,
-0.2540242373943329,
-1.1348602771759033,
-0.5486399531364441,
-0.038404304534196854,
0.06290294229984283,
0.26999297738075256,
-0.09663683921098709,
-0.00024168951495084912,
0.1741492599248886,
0.3942195475101471,
-0.2660521864891052,
0.2006799727678299,
-0.10964144766330719,
-0.20359940826892853,
0.2095138132572174,
0.10979354381561279,
-0.17739591002464294,
-0.2437228560447693,
-0.5876598954200745,
-0.32884037494659424,
-0.7722585201263428,
0.3226451277732849,
0.03785460442304611,
0.052966002374887466,
-0.10592241585254669,
0.36192256212234497,
-0.6178465485572815,
0.6732453107833862,
-0.32295292615890503,
0.15831561386585236,
0.01122565008699894,
-0.2809065878391266,
-0.2154279351234436,
-0.11636391282081604,
0.49933290481567383,
0.3598891496658325,
0.05108386278152466,
-0.404714971780777,
-0.3966016173362732,
0.048188403248786926,
0.38718628883361816,
-0.8593923449516296,
0.18518410623073578,
0.23576796054840088,
-0.33080217242240906,
-0.15273575484752655,
-0.1289757639169693,
-0.9649608731269836,
-0.24754813313484192,
-0.2781822085380554,
0.37310147285461426,
0.04085656255483627,
-0.019154753535985947,
0.22477960586547852,
-0.15032124519348145,
0.41445547342300415,
0.19908159971237183,
-0.6800493001937866,
0.5462237596511841,
0.9105269312858582,
0.7301520109176636,
-0.6182416677474976,
-0.10717408359050751,
-0.623293936252594,
0.07284864783287048,
-0.04658105596899986,
0.7339574694633484,
-0.434916228055954,
-0.5504833459854126,
0.24627810716629028,
0.18569932878017426,
0.26305684447288513,
-0.49264654517173767,
1.000906229019165,
-0.5866222977638245,
-0.15292437374591827,
-0.6749114394187927,
-0.4899400770664215,
0.0544050857424736,
0.3118526041507721,
-0.8666532039642334,
1.239357590675354,
0.3614296019077301,
-0.4889857769012451,
0.22510451078414917,
-0.38505327701568604,
-0.4162079691886902,
0.11466707289218903,
-0.063213050365448,
-0.1556873321533203,
0.3304089903831482,
0.13801893591880798,
0.6066734790802002,
-0.5820099115371704,
0.4012482762336731,
-0.17834454774856567,
-0.29470911622047424,
0.19437895715236664,
-0.5163175463676453,
0.2823277711868286,
0.018307814374566078,
-0.4306011497974396,
0.13984790444374084,
-0.8106494545936584,
0.09825388342142105,
0.09158322215080261,
-0.41500845551490784,
-0.27064943313598633,
0.12134810537099838,
0.22503399848937988,
0.31945788860321045,
0.3412739038467407,
-0.42828884720802307,
0.33520954847335815,
-0.056711163371801376,
0.6070873141288757,
0.8058904409408569,
-0.39847561717033386,
0.3029044270515442,
-0.10578639060258865,
0.3566845655441284,
-0.13147780299186707,
0.056826576590538025,
-0.2724159359931946,
0.0312428530305624,
-0.925243079662323,
-0.14609195291996002,
0.3577161729335785,
0.23917359113693237,
-0.7530069947242737,
0.2853192389011383,
-0.970184862613678,
-0.503695011138916,
-0.11988360434770584,
-0.03593326359987259,
0.384016752243042,
0.6611360311508179,
0.4609195590019226,
-0.5000882148742676,
-0.4357343912124634,
-0.9929249286651611,
-0.09432381391525269,
0.020124267786741257,
-0.028945354744791985,
0.45495739579200745,
0.5290712118148804,
-0.053304754197597504,
1.078037142753601,
-0.29858019948005676,
0.05696415156126022,
0.08720006793737411,
0.016061702743172646,
0.09771737456321716,
0.3497181832790375,
0.34896793961524963,
-0.7861075401306152,
-0.23553839325904846,
-0.20113013684749603,
-0.5909021496772766,
-0.15212328732013702,
0.05966959521174431,
0.039032042026519775,
0.28377386927604675,
0.6327245235443115,
-0.7927919626235962,
0.42079633474349976,
0.624875009059906,
0.10130830854177475,
0.8115089535713196,
-0.08871059119701385,
0.017820170149207115,
-1.0497775077819824,
0.4302106499671936,
-0.2257210910320282,
-0.4206407368183136,
-0.5160589218139648,
0.27131760120391846,
0.4665493071079254,
0.03623172640800476,
-0.5093003511428833,
0.7164446711540222,
-0.381897896528244,
-0.22835543751716614,
-0.3949010968208313,
-0.1537889689207077,
-0.13155575096607208,
0.47887423634529114,
0.11103541404008865,
0.8605496883392334,
0.17276515066623688,
-0.6055203676223755,
0.42361772060394287,
-0.14961673319339752,
-0.4462305009365082,
0.35809850692749023,
-0.869361162185669,
0.23480679094791412,
0.007030023727566004,
0.8606192469596863,
-0.8972210884094238,
-0.1954239159822464,
-0.09634317457675934,
-0.14914126694202423,
0.5503906011581421,
-0.1120048314332962,
-0.7274935841560364,
-0.5538367033004761,
-0.3156116306781769,
0.874628484249115,
0.6414116024971008,
-0.719970166683197,
0.5178019404411316,
0.041388776153326035,
-0.001826789928600192,
-0.8009560108184814,
-0.48118409514427185,
0.29833951592445374,
-0.17764219641685486,
-0.5431715846061707,
0.6739850640296936,
-0.21131454408168793,
0.053441084921360016,
-0.31575337052345276,
-0.4481542408466339,
0.04234683886170387,
0.1287102997303009,
0.2850351333618164,
-0.03680609166622162,
-0.1913578063249588,
0.2831505239009857,
-0.1329669952392578,
-0.3058578372001648,
0.16905008256435394,
-0.2924283742904663,
0.70973801612854,
-0.23022033274173737,
-0.3530307114124298,
-0.12730008363723755,
0.4231269359588623,
0.7737830281257629,
-0.03512032330036163,
0.44359147548675537,
0.5663611888885498,
-0.3869890570640564,
-0.172099307179451,
-0.717460572719574,
-0.06325129419565201,
-0.4532494843006134,
0.3795887231826782,
-0.13214367628097534,
-1.0872398614883423,
0.620348334312439,
-0.30757102370262146,
0.03783983737230301,
0.4723312556743622,
0.6753638982772827,
0.2793046236038208,
0.5023759007453918,
0.5961124897003174,
-0.43800604343414307,
0.12689432501792908,
-0.00953941885381937,
0.048764824867248535,
-0.8486732840538025,
-0.18910843133926392,
-0.7442594766616821,
-0.3055786192417145,
-0.498912513256073,
-0.5757884979248047,
0.3253365755081177,
0.045399151742458344,
-0.05490977689623833,
0.37943947315216064,
-0.45960554480552673,
0.3993108868598938,
0.4175611138343811,
-0.2056414633989334,
0.11627370119094849,
-0.3324163258075714,
0.05448232963681221,
0.11263696849346161,
-0.4095980226993561,
-0.19915299117565155,
0.9018905758857727,
0.3469788730144501,
0.6573376059532166,
0.09892188012599945,
0.5462836623191833,
0.26677414774894714,
0.16314436495304108,
-1.0082306861877441,
0.5582613348960876,
0.12584702670574188,
-0.33203622698783875,
-0.19617213308811188,
-0.24952416121959686,
-0.9934667944908142,
-0.06428886204957962,
0.05173333361744881,
-0.7790878415107727,
0.009171465411782265,
-0.03020358830690384,
-0.011498215608298779,
0.05409492179751396,
-0.38207924365997314,
0.7497608065605164,
-0.05563740059733391,
-0.5828226804733276,
-0.2249918282032013,
-0.8878161311149597,
0.18299905955791473,
-0.09920168668031693,
-0.0031561872456222773,
0.21519075334072113,
-0.1788836121559143,
0.6491963267326355,
-0.28025415539741516,
0.8039615750312805,
0.03227798640727997,
-0.21560540795326233,
0.05873089283704758,
-0.03043479286134243,
0.78221195936203,
-0.08645247668027878,
0.142058864235878,
0.08046866953372955,
0.015048614703118801,
-0.5904783010482788,
-0.6380050778388977,
0.8737772107124329,
-0.46380844712257385,
-0.4484848380088806,
-0.2520723342895508,
-0.4295736849308014,
-0.40495428442955017,
0.3498685657978058,
0.25415414571762085,
0.5470010042190552,
-0.19510102272033691,
0.503073513507843,
0.5975269079208374,
0.017268341034650803,
0.8311430215835571,
0.20839683711528778,
-0.016907693818211555,
-0.3660971522331238,
0.7609105706214905,
-0.08611293137073517,
0.1407000720500946,
0.5016695857048035,
-0.03432073816657066,
-0.2134762406349182,
-0.6172680854797363,
-0.17710159718990326,
0.05219161882996559,
-0.9427239894866943,
-0.47968530654907227,
-0.44579941034317017,
-0.23407459259033203,
-0.3773326277732849,
-0.11675556749105453,
-0.6243270635604858,
-0.38115519285202026,
-0.1335626095533371,
0.25616830587387085,
-0.03877922147512436,
0.5881967544555664,
0.477803498506546,
0.24720993638038635,
-0.8612270355224609,
0.06958010047674179,
0.36622264981269836,
0.5420731902122498,
0.3104982376098633,
-0.06421341747045517,
-0.37960270047187805,
-0.14326788485050201,
-0.35523921251296997,
-0.45904111862182617,
0.17462530732154846,
-0.10602497309446335,
0.39444851875305176,
0.08374707400798798,
0.2989112138748169,
0.7290910482406616,
-0.49472296237945557,
1.0336925983428955,
-0.0071715423837304115,
-0.9305552840232849,
0.12364058941602707,
-0.1494174599647522,
0.5167381763458252,
0.5195426940917969,
0.2771313488483429,
-0.6866816878318787,
0.1608889102935791,
-0.39149898290634155,
-1.1711294651031494,
0.17518840730190277,
0.36923936009407043,
0.13663969933986664,
-0.14355488121509552,
0.3747766315937042,
0.1722833663225174,
0.20881761610507965,
-0.6165391206741333,
-0.036521248519420624,
0.007619488053023815,
-0.0811750739812851,
-0.13350525498390198,
-0.4218975007534027,
-0.07712660729885101,
-0.04796088486909866,
0.4320259094238281,
-0.1850825548171997,
0.27923375368118286,
0.24231305718421936,
-0.3376421332359314,
0.17796115577220917,
0.5882616639137268,
0.9583227038383484,
0.546954870223999,
-0.1355888694524765,
0.13962815701961517,
0.22825488448143005,
-0.4391123354434967,
-0.005068154539912939,
0.06849731504917145,
0.27956315875053406,
-0.19732071459293365,
0.3484251797199249,
0.52777099609375,
0.4362759292125702,
-0.6622155904769897,
0.6611757874488831,
-0.3815461993217468,
0.014567683450877666,
-0.4565865993499756,
-0.2217392772436142,
0.05959591269493103,
0.11811304092407227,
0.5599492788314819,
-0.2536240816116333,
0.06890862435102463,
-0.23540742695331573,
-0.022350171580910683,
0.4022371172904968,
-0.3745224177837372,
-0.4172707498073578,
0.2874804735183716,
0.36000093817710876,
-0.09298068284988403,
0.6485097408294678,
0.17755858600139618,
-0.5626969933509827,
0.37516921758651733,
0.6029976010322571,
0.9051654934883118,
0.21014495193958282,
-0.48351460695266724,
0.13382352888584137,
0.04370991513133049,
-0.340332567691803,
-0.139534592628479,
-0.6634876728057861,
-0.20415036380290985,
-0.7729017734527588,
-0.710298478603363,
-0.2390296757221222,
0.29426246881484985,
-0.8335826396942139,
0.26516294479370117,
0.09963005036115646,
-0.08450110256671906,
-0.17301033437252045,
0.06831743568181992,
-0.7243906855583191,
-0.09873530268669128,
0.06715112924575806,
1.3733770847320557,
-0.47320690751075745,
0.821897566318512,
0.31322845816612244,
0.2052570879459381,
-0.3994283974170685,
-0.027084296569228172,
-0.2073519080877304,
-0.6319743394851685,
0.6631777286529541,
0.41166990995407104,
-0.18144074082374573,
-0.14427268505096436,
-0.5248793363571167,
-0.7582105398178101,
1.2723852396011353,
0.24391299486160278,
-0.6214069128036499,
-0.27116626501083374,
0.08608034253120422,
0.38444793224334717,
-0.10131514072418213,
0.034254953265190125,
0.5088124871253967,
0.5142210721969604,
-0.0512496680021286,
-1.0427249670028687,
0.1873256415128708,
-0.2469014823436737,
0.15722115337848663,
0.5950236916542053,
-0.6348492503166199,
0.3230542242527008,
0.2971828579902649,
-0.18425308167934418,
0.45076680183410645,
0.8311149477958679,
-0.04248042032122612,
0.2860583961009979,
0.5217077136039734,
0.7016369104385376,
0.35473987460136414,
-0.010841552168130875,
1.1435580253601074,
-0.47397738695144653,
0.37478041648864746,
0.9784027338027954,
-0.2712632119655609,
1.046747088432312,
0.7615372538566589,
-0.14506615698337555,
0.33132699131965637,
0.5168558955192566,
0.21389709413051605,
0.45602551102638245,
0.34907662868499756,
-0.4667126536369324,
-0.26650765538215637,
-0.2727203071117401,
-0.4974064826965332,
0.36971449851989746,
0.30151039361953735,
-0.05698571354150772,
-0.23809297382831573,
-0.18702790141105652,
-0.1465027928352356,
-0.23075850307941437,
-0.1403246819972992,
0.6072098016738892,
0.1755560338497162,
-1.0059385299682617,
0.6373134255409241,
-0.11844512075185776,
0.7102141380310059,
-0.6064175367355347,
0.07324636727571487,
-0.022216279059648514,
-0.01872052066028118,
0.04908362776041031,
-0.6807148456573486,
0.04828619584441185,
-0.20178982615470886,
-0.32185205817222595,
-0.3050277829170227,
0.8223409056663513,
-0.08731008321046829,
-0.04104083031415939,
0.2468605488538742,
0.4280850291252136,
-0.05671578273177147,
-0.016220197081565857,
-0.00723665114492178,
0.28686171770095825,
-0.468133807182312,
-0.30640584230422974,
0.6141079068183899,
0.1683618277311325,
-0.23583872616291046,
0.6273661851882935,
0.49552035331726074,
-0.027230527251958847,
-0.1656348705291748,
0.04276076704263687,
1.0410972833633423,
-0.7361952662467957,
-0.29116109013557434,
-0.8360626101493835,
0.5458520650863647,
-0.08171652257442474,
-0.2832624912261963,
0.4817066788673401,
0.5172231197357178,
0.7678550481796265,
0.12188391387462616,
0.4658834934234619,
0.1323302686214447,
-0.07837027311325073,
-0.5927020311355591,
0.5003675818443298,
-0.555351197719574,
0.11724747717380524,
-0.15626126527786255,
-0.959077000617981,
-0.14916357398033142,
-0.05756150558590889,
0.13387738168239594,
0.10432597994804382,
0.6910131573677063,
0.4049535393714905,
-0.19759272038936615,
-0.13101008534431458,
0.21250692009925842,
0.04313766583800316,
0.48574861884117126,
0.6928457617759705,
0.7408174276351929,
-0.3368987441062927,
0.5604456067085266,
-0.3227013349533081,
-0.03313340246677399,
-0.42645394802093506,
-1.387575626373291,
-0.5164803862571716,
-0.9120378494262695,
0.047757767140865326,
-0.37844324111938477,
0.007231787778437138,
0.7233932614326477,
0.8706062436103821,
-0.28668490052223206,
-0.18977375328540802,
-0.11145156621932983,
-0.0494411326944828,
-0.1385677456855774,
-0.1631738543510437,
0.4196792542934418,
-0.21385367214679718,
-0.520400881767273,
0.3657454252243042,
0.35024333000183105,
0.0640743300318718,
-0.28718534111976624,
-0.09861435741186142,
0.4263383150100708,
-0.19709575176239014,
0.8442533612251282,
0.4164506196975708,
-0.7401641011238098,
-0.41229575872421265,
0.21908704936504364,
-0.10255077481269836,
0.0793614536523819,
1.0781363248825073,
-1.073327898979187,
0.5169929265975952,
0.5908963680267334,
0.9519029259681702,
0.677105188369751,
-0.171162411570549,
0.5851952433586121,
-0.9376751780509949,
0.004781276453286409,
0.40645286440849304,
0.4672657251358032,
0.25505179166793823,
-0.1051999032497406,
0.49459126591682434,
0.0442788265645504,
-0.9117075204849243,
-1.1440770626068115,
0.23363104462623596,
-1.5493766069412231,
-0.0997336134314537,
1.1356310844421387,
-0.05415475368499756,
-0.5516071319580078,
0.1781269609928131,
0.12206882983446121,
0.35428425669670105,
-0.36996135115623474,
0.8081880211830139,
1.0336902141571045,
0.16830477118492126,
-0.06023533642292023,
-0.5820691585540771,
0.38869407773017883,
0.4628070890903473,
-0.8211157917976379,
0.47611796855926514,
0.39316290616989136,
0.032894108444452286,
0.13955922424793243,
0.4432803988456726,
-0.06824740767478943,
0.4518890976905823,
-0.3378746807575226,
0.05819685384631157,
-0.04793010652065277,
-0.278105229139328,
-0.5824360847473145,
0.10093954205513,
0.08371874690055847,
0.1665199100971222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01525v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01525v2 | Empowering 3D Visual Grounding with Reasoning Capabilities | 2024-07-01T17:59:35 | 2024-07-02T07:37:56 | Chenming Zhu, Tai Wang, Wenwei Zhang, Kai Chen, Xihui Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Although great progress has been made in 3D visual grounding, current models
still rely on explicit textual descriptions for grounding and lack the ability
to reason human intentions from implicit instructions. We propose a new task
called 3D reasoning grounding and introduce a new benchmark ScanReason which
provides over 10K question-answer-location pairs from five reasoning types that
require the synerization of reasoning and grounding. We further design our
approach, ReGround3D, composed of the visual-centric reasoning module empowered
by Multi-modal Large Language Model (MLLM) and the 3D grounding module to
obtain accurate object locations by looking back to the enhanced geometry and
fine-grained details from the 3D scenes. A chain-of-grounding mechanism is
proposed to further boost the performance with interleaved reasoning and
grounding steps during inference. Extensive experiments on the proposed
benchmark validate the effectiveness of our proposed approach. | [
-0.7165826559066772,
-0.7675870656967163,
0.9318073391914368,
0.34799230098724365,
-0.27381739020347595,
-0.38465893268585205,
0.1585984230041504,
-0.44778743386268616,
-0.30781349539756775,
0.4732712507247925,
-0.3806362748146057,
-0.6161616444587708,
-0.23866835236549377,
0.1056915745139122,
-0.19678203761577606,
0.1798589825630188,
-0.27547770738601685,
0.09710289537906647,
-0.7115278244018555,
-0.2582820653915405,
-0.6063494682312012,
-0.7946932315826416,
-0.2848748564720154,
0.014838352799415588,
0.36115026473999023,
0.5097758173942566,
0.6928631067276001,
0.7328150868415833,
0.49329888820648193,
0.24952073395252228,
-0.2013261318206787,
0.42272892594337463,
-0.22085610032081604,
0.06051413342356682,
-0.41655781865119934,
-0.5320776700973511,
-0.2837084233760834,
0.007380231283605099,
0.4054422974586487,
0.6451777219772339,
0.13514932990074158,
-0.14357706904411316,
-0.22382478415966034,
0.9165976643562317,
-0.8479816317558289,
0.010385422967374325,
-0.10245359688997269,
0.11471021920442581,
0.15612445771694183,
-0.30752789974212646,
-0.1761036068201065,
-0.15876807272434235,
-0.021942706778645515,
-0.7200840711593628,
0.4123947024345398,
0.1775570511817932,
0.6720219850540161,
0.4434252679347992,
-0.1555841565132141,
0.2722102999687195,
-0.42864808440208435,
0.4755480885505676,
-0.5068589448928833,
0.7664743065834045,
0.37887319922447205,
0.6243898272514343,
0.07260862737894058,
-0.47586166858673096,
-0.3396768271923065,
-0.23311370611190796,
0.05275280401110649,
0.31269529461860657,
0.28147199749946594,
0.18862830102443695,
0.6496126055717468,
0.33513063192367554,
-0.3423060476779938,
-0.24164162576198578,
-0.07928306609392166,
-0.018841970711946487,
0.3596602976322174,
-0.050140541046857834,
0.17044539749622345,
-0.11138028651475906,
-0.5442313551902771,
-0.32810238003730774,
-0.4677179157733917,
0.24569162726402283,
0.16084185242652893,
0.04554421454668045,
-0.11982692033052444,
0.9447686672210693,
-0.698447585105896,
0.8498139977455139,
0.057470206171274185,
0.16395258903503418,
0.01987738162279129,
-0.2527727782726288,
-0.3171619176864624,
-0.005556631367653608,
0.3411330282688141,
0.9812402725219727,
0.1442168653011322,
-0.08749803155660629,
-0.08837161213159561,
-0.0037468578666448593,
0.3227619528770447,
-0.7149379849433899,
-0.10873101651668549,
0.3929069936275482,
-0.5873628258705139,
0.11469606310129166,
0.2060718685388565,
-0.6822168231010437,
-0.7033516764640808,
-0.42158758640289307,
0.17630676925182343,
-0.627385675907135,
-0.4144399166107178,
0.5602734684944153,
-0.44025951623916626,
0.3268938660621643,
0.8034346699714661,
-0.6267828941345215,
0.02568889781832695,
0.7249162197113037,
0.8438175916671753,
0.054943978786468506,
-0.4405505359172821,
-0.30359765887260437,
0.3873506486415863,
-0.3418721556663513,
1.0610672235488892,
-0.33000198006629944,
-0.20384898781776428,
-0.23630838096141815,
-0.0072258333675563335,
0.2181822657585144,
-0.5313737392425537,
0.44288170337677,
-0.3764181137084961,
0.23781050741672516,
-0.5453786849975586,
-0.20382238924503326,
-0.618719756603241,
0.7933660745620728,
-0.728901743888855,
0.8094085454940796,
0.038990288972854614,
-0.8902685642242432,
0.3874138295650482,
-0.19363640248775482,
-0.25139740109443665,
0.0004834050196222961,
-0.6274608373641968,
-0.06372120976448059,
0.20106028020381927,
0.6377242207527161,
0.4694007635116577,
-0.46877220273017883,
0.3663557469844818,
-0.4804222285747528,
-0.5595528483390808,
-0.28665974736213684,
-0.376220703125,
0.6528623700141907,
-0.043250229209661484,
-0.4155903160572052,
0.17680880427360535,
-0.7657579183578491,
-0.049622636288404465,
0.10273250192403793,
-0.1515483409166336,
-0.24348938465118408,
0.04727498069405556,
-0.3222752511501312,
0.37199702858924866,
0.17192815244197845,
-0.20613031089305878,
-0.008531290106475353,
-0.20435400307178497,
-0.09755177795886993,
0.39654794335365295,
-0.021328002214431763,
0.4778151512145996,
-0.33353447914123535,
0.3477858603000641,
0.10075339674949646,
0.10168442875146866,
-0.2820587456226349,
-0.7178044319152832,
-0.5445146560668945,
-0.13105984032154083,
-0.3870480954647064,
0.6420297622680664,
-0.5646080374717712,
0.3027523159980774,
-0.22906841337680817,
-0.4286588430404663,
-0.24610598385334015,
-0.21924525499343872,
0.4187870919704437,
0.7177362442016602,
0.6498247981071472,
0.4023944139480591,
-0.6168665885925293,
-1.1311588287353516,
-0.13122360408306122,
-0.21777257323265076,
-0.21639151871204376,
0.14986170828342438,
0.09049669653177261,
-0.01742379553616047,
0.9067548513412476,
-0.20960836112499237,
-0.09875714778900146,
-0.0837344229221344,
-0.19012106955051422,
0.08516427874565125,
0.6085861921310425,
0.49475786089897156,
-1.1722350120544434,
0.056843869388103485,
0.10229846090078354,
-1.2008638381958008,
-0.03905026614665985,
-0.021210385486483574,
-0.3726827800273895,
-0.11039910465478897,
1.0461201667785645,
-0.6766567826271057,
0.3848428428173065,
0.30190548300743103,
-0.4136459529399872,
0.29573461413383484,
-0.09725390374660492,
0.4798051118850708,
-0.740724503993988,
0.051329776644706726,
0.0276255514472723,
-0.08296336233615875,
-0.22761480510234833,
0.19687817990779877,
-0.04235079139471054,
-0.25509655475616455,
-0.4777675271034241,
0.48561811447143555,
-0.5911560654640198,
-0.12044965475797653,
-0.03188446909189224,
0.34107211232185364,
0.5415928959846497,
0.48324570059776306,
0.503153920173645,
0.4994172751903534,
0.6078779697418213,
-0.5748012661933899,
0.4492936432361603,
0.251634418964386,
-0.36929941177368164,
0.7032744288444519,
-0.548244059085846,
-0.13418221473693848,
-0.3201552629470825,
0.3602255582809448,
-1.030983805656433,
-0.0912654772400856,
-0.05751959979534149,
-0.30248433351516724,
-0.3170088827610016,
-0.47783714532852173,
-0.5015130639076233,
-0.33447057008743286,
0.004404999315738678,
0.607774555683136,
0.23775219917297363,
-0.7952155470848083,
0.910408616065979,
0.12168664485216141,
0.36587896943092346,
-0.3222111761569977,
-0.5417003631591797,
0.10337549448013306,
-0.3534717261791229,
-1.0017961263656616,
0.19799819588661194,
0.11611223965883255,
-0.5398462414741516,
-0.17352519929409027,
-0.4106796681880951,
0.16998229920864105,
0.19417636096477509,
0.4009242653846741,
-0.0022415632847696543,
-0.3066147267818451,
-0.1631310135126114,
-0.17461761832237244,
-0.49587684869766235,
0.24918067455291748,
-0.2798248529434204,
0.29333510994911194,
-0.33509087562561035,
-0.6984382271766663,
-0.3126964271068573,
0.5406833291053772,
0.8348233103752136,
-0.1876114159822464,
0.3947627544403076,
0.5758882164955139,
-0.6895973682403564,
0.15394844114780426,
-0.8926692008972168,
-0.13254158198833466,
-0.44467148184776306,
0.2626427412033081,
-0.8029204607009888,
-0.7363836169242859,
0.34356680512428284,
-0.38323214650154114,
-0.0030863138381391764,
0.20556364953517914,
0.24356675148010254,
-0.11917214095592499,
1.6365045309066772,
0.33334556221961975,
0.5211846828460693,
0.07655114680528641,
-0.2603999376296997,
0.10468390583992004,
-0.91681969165802,
-0.6411657333374023,
-0.2807080149650574,
-0.15043020248413086,
-0.1002051830291748,
-0.7733801603317261,
0.2567993998527527,
0.9653393626213074,
-0.3169073760509491,
0.005692539736628532,
-0.4880685806274414,
0.45095089077949524,
0.5930928587913513,
0.21966567635536194,
0.17793501913547516,
0.04844678193330765,
-0.3439210057258606,
0.11805211752653122,
-0.6976333260536194,
-0.4594905376434326,
0.25614768266677856,
0.17053115367889404,
0.44050133228302,
0.11531920731067657,
0.14704278111457825,
-0.06780171394348145,
0.1202445849776268,
-0.4067954123020172,
0.7167319059371948,
0.04859308898448944,
-0.4202152192592621,
-0.21948766708374023,
-0.20492124557495117,
-0.23576922714710236,
0.749015748500824,
-0.22678349912166595,
-0.49777835607528687,
0.35998430848121643,
0.1766573041677475,
-0.3406446576118469,
0.4767111539840698,
-0.7274425029754639,
0.9789683818817139,
-0.22501924633979797,
-0.6885420083999634,
-0.08008262515068054,
-0.6177853941917419,
0.4450798034667969,
0.6364789009094238,
0.20782260596752167,
-0.37414786219596863,
0.23746410012245178,
0.34346091747283936,
-0.4197937846183777,
0.5934146642684937,
-0.6152530312538147,
-0.3215787410736084,
0.24248914420604706,
0.1695919781923294,
0.3739200234413147,
0.5504456162452698,
-0.16170696914196014,
0.29970940947532654,
-0.26702168583869934,
-0.3192005455493927,
-0.8181678652763367,
0.7414661049842834,
-0.3695134222507477,
-0.9538374543190002,
-0.10062582045793533,
-0.5325958132743835,
-0.5865586996078491,
0.47109660506248474,
0.3030684292316437,
0.36194753646850586,
-0.10797637701034546,
0.37678763270378113,
0.6191766262054443,
-0.12004879862070084,
0.05281713232398033,
0.18687905371189117,
-0.41661766171455383,
-0.5295585989952087,
0.5632418394088745,
-0.4337288737297058,
0.03598485514521599,
0.7713393568992615,
0.19136519730091095,
-0.513482391834259,
-0.5762133598327637,
-0.6000162363052368,
-0.0732671394944191,
-0.9032513499259949,
-0.1636071503162384,
-0.880057692527771,
0.048772890120744705,
-0.2872178554534912,
-0.7814114689826965,
-0.4759924113750458,
-0.37444525957107544,
-0.07777544111013412,
-0.40190595388412476,
0.2189360111951828,
0.3282425105571747,
-0.16857409477233887,
-0.04001150280237198,
-0.6211686134338379,
0.900876522064209,
0.5377410650253296,
0.5305007696151733,
-0.1124710887670517,
-0.09181816130876541,
-0.14117880165576935,
0.3072611391544342,
0.3526139259338379,
-0.33091819286346436,
-0.12147468328475952,
-0.5938352942466736,
0.6649954915046692,
0.3301065266132355,
-0.18716007471084595,
1.1179161071777344,
-0.4443400502204895,
0.6410168409347534,
0.32696348428726196,
-0.6173379421234131,
0.8874296545982361,
-0.42179161310195923,
0.496109277009964,
0.5490548610687256,
-0.0033734370954334736,
-0.2810317277908325,
-0.2577110528945923,
-0.33705493807792664,
-0.6252449750900269,
0.6217210292816162,
0.10886555165052414,
-0.4019148051738739,
-0.26536765694618225,
0.3803640305995941,
-0.20701807737350464,
-0.25021910667419434,
-0.2971024811267853,
0.08602968603372574,
-0.5627194046974182,
0.2148483395576477,
-0.0016320212744176388,
-0.30245906114578247,
-0.4055810868740082,
-0.3808179795742035,
0.15580296516418457,
-0.342804878950119,
0.023023320361971855,
0.5316426157951355,
-0.15155400335788727,
0.11803315579891205,
-0.2661556005477905,
0.5966174006462097,
0.6984336972236633,
-0.42989376187324524,
0.46995291113853455,
0.2047128528356552,
-0.13087508082389832,
0.18292349576950073,
0.2007356435060501,
0.024351146072149277,
-0.17547725141048431,
0.4045206308364868,
0.773945152759552,
0.1920388787984848,
-0.7038931250572205,
0.6439171433448792,
-0.18942569196224213,
-0.3563055992126465,
-0.270781010389328,
0.08189374953508377,
0.09730111807584763,
0.47647303342819214,
0.1362198293209076,
0.3127535581588745,
0.04813142120838165,
0.0770740956068039,
0.21716803312301636,
0.20899981260299683,
-0.4550146162509918,
-0.045993536710739136,
1.000095009803772,
0.14256472885608673,
0.016850123181939125,
0.5948171615600586,
0.16473416984081268,
-0.24106360971927643,
0.7028297781944275,
0.5759057998657227,
0.7856146097183228,
-0.04827404022216797,
0.02746339701116085,
0.6525611281394958,
0.3100813329219818,
-0.5470723509788513,
0.38962024450302124,
-0.16342996060848236,
-0.8732328414916992,
-0.32799503207206726,
-0.14374566078186035,
-0.32777655124664307,
-0.09789306670427322,
-0.7335618138313293,
0.4609537124633789,
-0.636759340763092,
0.16549848020076752,
-0.5221133232116699,
-0.42533019185066223,
-0.620993435382843,
0.6009086966514587,
0.5371317267417908,
1.1210715770721436,
-0.5052252411842346,
0.2969665229320526,
0.9571423530578613,
-0.2738024890422821,
-0.20490799844264984,
-0.15301229059696198,
-0.008212798275053501,
-0.7553955316543579,
0.6285383701324463,
0.6922801733016968,
-0.6966068744659424,
0.005597073119133711,
-0.5588580369949341,
-0.8481324315071106,
1.2719604969024658,
0.26650938391685486,
-0.4783724844455719,
-0.01007064525038004,
-0.06552399694919586,
0.22926731407642365,
-0.32539093494415283,
0.23210957646369934,
0.3102405369281769,
0.5364091992378235,
0.1635071337223053,
-0.2785049080848694,
0.20216555893421173,
-0.551289439201355,
0.1393783539533615,
-0.14122654497623444,
-0.5700793862342834,
0.7270933985710144,
-0.29392099380493164,
-0.39805901050567627,
-0.15675385296344757,
0.764795184135437,
0.878868043422699,
0.11910901963710785,
0.7965101599693298,
0.9835412502288818,
0.48094943165779114,
-0.023227689787745476,
1.122607946395874,
-0.20879589021205902,
-0.18387530744075775,
1.0955288410186768,
-0.3323252499103546,
0.4295582175254822,
0.4448268711566925,
0.27161914110183716,
0.43283596634864807,
0.3247959315776825,
0.1810167282819748,
0.5920156240463257,
0.10978113114833832,
-0.10355735570192337,
-0.7128079533576965,
0.028648385778069496,
-0.5667791962623596,
0.36265072226524353,
0.49911946058273315,
0.060895901173353195,
-0.3958491384983063,
0.11993210762739182,
-0.3054027557373047,
0.19910567998886108,
-0.23590315878391266,
0.5313971042633057,
-0.11862258613109589,
-0.6293624639511108,
0.5786892771720886,
-0.0591319315135479,
0.20218820869922638,
-0.2993823289871216,
-0.5415015816688538,
-0.33824607729911804,
0.1357625126838684,
-0.10359573364257812,
-0.9298913478851318,
0.031739864498376846,
-0.3511255383491516,
-0.35631063580513,
-0.6691585779190063,
0.5220590829849243,
-0.13495242595672607,
-0.3120843172073364,
0.48459479212760925,
0.5083832144737244,
-0.09180627018213272,
-0.48323965072631836,
-0.49426698684692383,
0.08912047743797302,
-0.11795875430107117,
-0.20041051506996155,
0.02622200921177864,
0.9923390746116638,
-0.31056031584739685,
0.67621910572052,
0.8496643304824829,
-0.30355751514434814,
-0.10777030140161514,
0.4606838822364807,
0.8463766574859619,
-0.8472920656204224,
-0.6563525199890137,
-0.6508805751800537,
0.6236253380775452,
-0.3430386185646057,
-0.34025898575782776,
0.9406540393829346,
0.8170429468154907,
0.8025868535041809,
-0.012212462723255157,
0.6932026147842407,
0.07960037887096405,
0.35518380999565125,
-0.8502833247184753,
0.1070239394903183,
-0.6019811630249023,
0.3038835823535919,
-0.09721506386995316,
-1.054039716720581,
-0.7038084864616394,
0.8611276149749756,
-0.19777198135852814,
-0.0689619928598404,
0.7511451244354248,
0.6131996512413025,
-0.35339680314064026,
0.10615066438913345,
0.5464351177215576,
0.023314218968153,
0.5306265354156494,
0.3181256651878357,
1.2158136367797852,
-0.23124785721302032,
0.27576717734336853,
-0.581457793712616,
-0.3490673899650574,
-0.234941765666008,
-0.8573818802833557,
-1.004462718963623,
-0.4062860906124115,
-0.11699942499399185,
-0.4544907510280609,
-0.11821009963750839,
0.3879462778568268,
0.7419533729553223,
-0.6527636647224426,
0.05001651868224144,
-0.7596679925918579,
0.12783849239349365,
-0.4623929560184479,
-0.22396187484264374,
0.39676403999328613,
-0.11206988990306854,
-0.36388906836509705,
0.6957263350486755,
0.6090785264968872,
0.15038999915122986,
-0.2791050374507904,
0.059102337807416916,
-0.2987092435359955,
-0.39663705229759216,
0.70383220911026,
0.13384293019771576,
-0.8021608591079712,
-0.4772212505340576,
0.041206277906894684,
-0.08248111605644226,
0.07778237760066986,
1.0548763275146484,
-0.9503592848777771,
0.4994586110115051,
0.7157219648361206,
0.4195069968700409,
0.38346248865127563,
0.5906095504760742,
0.8361330032348633,
-0.4603620171546936,
0.5306829214096069,
0.2784174084663391,
0.5993337035179138,
0.477538526058197,
-0.27563464641571045,
0.6701191663742065,
0.22083567082881927,
-0.21588101983070374,
-0.5093571543693542,
0.19153520464897156,
-0.8767531514167786,
-0.24022266268730164,
1.1751842498779297,
-0.026356399059295654,
-0.16762220859527588,
-0.3232372999191284,
-0.5096083879470825,
0.0074601247906684875,
0.1511712223291397,
0.531424880027771,
0.5697177052497864,
-0.13844281435012817,
-0.5636464357376099,
-0.3927347958087921,
0.5574739575386047,
0.4296153783798218,
-0.9115787744522095,
0.24547381699085236,
0.8696386814117432,
-0.20233653485774994,
0.3344126343727112,
0.5556811094284058,
-0.33115193247795105,
0.40647992491722107,
0.2874208390712738,
0.09127180278301239,
-0.2816653549671173,
-0.6230694651603699,
-0.13504736125469208,
0.36830875277519226,
-0.32567718625068665,
-0.13034121692180634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01523v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01523v1 | MMLongBench-Doc: Benchmarking Long-context Document Understanding with Visualizations | 2024-07-01T17:59:26 | 2024-07-01T17:59:26 | Yubo Ma, Yuhang Zang, Liangyu Chen, Meiqi Chen, Yizhu Jiao, Xinze Li, Xinyuan Lu, Ziyu Liu, Yan Ma, Xiaoyi Dong, Pan Zhang, Liangming Pan, Yu-Gang Jiang, Jiaqi Wang, Yixin Cao, Aixin Sun | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Understanding documents with rich layouts and multi-modal components is a
long-standing and practical task. Recent Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs)
have made remarkable strides in various tasks, particularly in single-page
document understanding (DU). However, their abilities on long-context DU remain
an open problem. This work presents MMLongBench-Doc, a long-context,
multi-modal benchmark comprising 1,062 expert-annotated questions. Distinct
from previous datasets, it is constructed upon 130 lengthy PDF-formatted
documents with an average of 49.4 pages and 20,971 textual tokens. Towards
comprehensive evaluation, answers to these questions rely on pieces of evidence
from (1) different sources (text, image, chart, table, and layout structure)
and (2) various locations (i.e. page number). Moreover, 33.2% of the questions
are cross-page questions requiring evidence across multiple pages. 22.8% of the
questions are designed to be unanswerable for detecting potential
hallucinations. Experiments on 14 LVLMs demonstrate that long-context DU
greatly challenges current models. Notably, the best-performing model, GPT-4o,
achieves an F1 score of only 42.7%, while the second-best, GPT-4V, scores
31.4%. Furthermore, 12 LVLMs (all except GPT-4o and GPT-4V) even present worse
performance than their LLM counterparts which are fed with lossy-parsed OCR
documents. These results validate the necessity of future research toward more
capable long-context LVLMs. Project Page:
https://mayubo2333.github.io/MMLongBench-Doc | [
-0.6121030449867249,
-0.7030704617500305,
0.9369603395462036,
0.2208200991153717,
-0.4336342215538025,
-0.24026288092136383,
-0.3479480743408203,
-0.5138707756996155,
-0.06880462914705276,
0.5495509505271912,
-0.4988444149494171,
-0.6962695121765137,
-0.47677546739578247,
0.22447197139263153,
-0.33789271116256714,
0.6368950009346008,
-0.23133620619773865,
0.12686967849731445,
-0.42147988080978394,
-0.4557539224624634,
-0.38857507705688477,
-0.39520263671875,
-0.3777073621749878,
-0.04020145907998085,
0.7104601263999939,
0.05171431601047516,
0.3590599298477173,
0.4699363112449646,
0.3832913637161255,
0.2892749309539795,
-0.007599441334605217,
0.28081610798835754,
-0.49263304471969604,
0.11916520446538925,
-0.114668108522892,
-0.18240271508693695,
-0.5134232044219971,
0.027652112767100334,
0.7069332599639893,
0.7850563526153564,
0.10055314004421234,
-0.12061240524053574,
0.07512787729501724,
0.6832392811775208,
-0.6896258592605591,
0.25460541248321533,
-0.22654885053634644,
0.08192633837461472,
-0.1747361570596695,
-0.3289434611797333,
-0.6829062700271606,
0.019907137379050255,
0.004551082383841276,
-0.9011092185974121,
0.1547548770904541,
0.13918879628181458,
0.6093139052391052,
0.20399948954582214,
-0.8513720035552979,
-0.24842143058776855,
-0.27827340364456177,
0.7336260676383972,
-0.5320882797241211,
0.7433578372001648,
0.48234662413597107,
0.49644193053245544,
-0.18117401003837585,
-0.8414306640625,
-0.6929913759231567,
-0.3231262266635895,
-0.13748575747013092,
0.4484100341796875,
-0.14529886841773987,
0.04145872965455055,
0.6109725832939148,
0.26718223094940186,
-0.6936801671981812,
0.2495347410440445,
-0.516032874584198,
-0.2001320719718933,
0.33576682209968567,
0.28485435247421265,
-0.14755965769290924,
-0.4372386932373047,
-0.5151106715202332,
-0.28613728284835815,
-0.1889362633228302,
0.15319979190826416,
0.14908050000667572,
-0.09180516749620438,
-0.08666802197694778,
0.4943515956401825,
-0.25767213106155396,
0.9438662528991699,
-0.21624423563480377,
-0.3490687906742096,
0.4864463806152344,
-0.3395684063434601,
-0.32036924362182617,
-0.30833399295806885,
0.632113516330719,
0.8244707584381104,
0.1500319093465805,
-0.11666153371334076,
-0.16434074938297272,
-0.21071135997772217,
0.3515418767929077,
-1.0938125848770142,
0.10188260674476624,
0.17644727230072021,
-0.5321602821350098,
0.09058105200529099,
-0.04569069668650627,
-1.034178614616394,
-0.8274414539337158,
-0.5640780925750732,
0.2848273515701294,
-0.5852130651473999,
0.10001304000616074,
0.27240175008773804,
-0.29846101999282837,
0.18772536516189575,
0.7652343511581421,
-0.5680356621742249,
0.11025253683328629,
0.7999381422996521,
0.8905160427093506,
-0.44043949246406555,
-0.6840317249298096,
-0.8170385956764221,
0.11216862499713898,
-0.3540894389152527,
0.831432580947876,
-0.4634826183319092,
-0.7013856768608093,
-0.06565132737159729,
0.19801194965839386,
-0.1855156272649765,
-0.40470364689826965,
0.8514698147773743,
-0.19063207507133484,
0.4678746461868286,
-0.4411237835884094,
-0.6117655038833618,
-0.14966519176959991,
0.7247942090034485,
-0.7424357533454895,
0.7992609143257141,
0.15983006358146667,
-0.8371585607528687,
0.4894048869609833,
-0.6592473387718201,
-0.2443779706954956,
-0.24558499455451965,
-0.49281489849090576,
-0.025400297716259956,
0.20383921265602112,
0.335543155670166,
0.481882244348526,
-0.3411793112754822,
0.10457096993923187,
-0.3160976767539978,
-0.4043366611003876,
0.1450616717338562,
-0.6908115744590759,
0.492186576128006,
0.02544899471104145,
-0.3307896554470062,
0.3423434793949127,
-1.0150244235992432,
-0.12502461671829224,
0.06955191493034363,
-0.5258519649505615,
-0.36203262209892273,
-0.09509271383285522,
0.30077290534973145,
0.2892981469631195,
-0.021633757278323174,
-0.5005592703819275,
0.3870081901550293,
-0.117706798017025,
0.15361900627613068,
0.730440616607666,
-0.1730012148618698,
0.15078292787075043,
-0.13460084795951843,
0.45918524265289307,
0.04518429562449455,
0.09900245070457458,
-0.6333717703819275,
-0.2362501472234726,
-0.6777786612510681,
-0.41289222240448,
-0.020779510959982872,
0.15628543496131897,
-0.6780014038085938,
0.17589029669761658,
-0.6627724170684814,
-0.3072883188724518,
-0.2371675670146942,
-0.022021744400262833,
0.3925592601299286,
0.8976925611495972,
0.5610499382019043,
-0.3950289487838745,
-0.05602129548788071,
-1.0010275840759277,
-0.06760236620903015,
0.13574343919754028,
-0.23278866708278656,
0.5427885055541992,
0.7070390582084656,
-0.2859364449977875,
0.6278584003448486,
-0.568051815032959,
-0.34059739112854004,
0.1105218306183815,
0.36912301182746887,
0.14804454147815704,
0.1917431801557541,
0.5781805515289307,
-0.8632112741470337,
-0.3865819275379181,
-0.0482201874256134,
-0.9082111120223999,
-0.014925331808626652,
-0.22387073934078217,
0.09370891004800797,
0.45703357458114624,
0.6882786750793457,
-0.6423365473747253,
0.5167572498321533,
0.43503904342651367,
-0.5602278113365173,
0.6734621524810791,
-0.5441780686378479,
0.3765186071395874,
-1.0108646154403687,
0.30095598101615906,
0.011877963319420815,
-0.1852562576532364,
-0.4346924126148224,
0.20369772613048553,
0.4979093074798584,
-0.19022440910339355,
-0.40523311495780945,
0.7009297609329224,
-0.6037713289260864,
-0.16665993630886078,
-0.23516693711280823,
0.36014214158058167,
0.34929361939430237,
0.5235879421234131,
-0.07181637734174728,
0.9174652695655823,
0.25157463550567627,
-0.04933885857462883,
0.1568811982870102,
-0.047955844551324844,
-0.5147282481193542,
0.8508143424987793,
-0.4770190417766571,
0.11664809286594391,
-0.18387451767921448,
0.643826425075531,
-0.8554175496101379,
-0.1837310642004013,
-0.09141311049461365,
-0.09175457805395126,
0.46520379185676575,
-0.15542183816432953,
-0.7385619878768921,
-0.41077011823654175,
-0.5113587379455566,
0.40304744243621826,
0.13093923032283783,
-0.6226814985275269,
0.9926848411560059,
0.0047564879059791565,
0.20788902044296265,
-0.6415334343910217,
-0.4047694802284241,
0.23061122000217438,
-0.0834616869688034,
-0.8988141417503357,
0.30485570430755615,
-0.3418978452682495,
-0.26414257287979126,
-0.45809489488601685,
-0.27074089646339417,
0.13507506251335144,
-0.06039942800998688,
0.5826231241226196,
-0.11845103651285172,
-0.2731570899486542,
0.23035666346549988,
-0.1872524619102478,
-0.2772236466407776,
0.07362023741006851,
-0.022465582937002182,
0.6789398789405823,
-0.3430975377559662,
-0.7239188551902771,
-0.08858464658260345,
0.5784638524055481,
1.0121448040008545,
-0.39743709564208984,
0.4611898362636566,
0.7549224495887756,
-0.18919120728969574,
-0.1467324048280716,
-0.8128455281257629,
0.13988767564296722,
-0.42930683493614197,
0.3378792405128479,
-0.691417396068573,
-0.6805537343025208,
0.5055456757545471,
-0.11645905673503876,
-0.03755432739853859,
0.5220186114311218,
0.4480070173740387,
-0.0891881212592125,
0.7494436502456665,
0.6322044134140015,
-0.15474027395248413,
0.2733430564403534,
-0.3218061327934265,
-0.08046712726354599,
-0.7539425492286682,
-0.335236519575119,
-0.3129274249076843,
-0.1536007821559906,
-0.32728877663612366,
-0.9058661460876465,
0.4988013505935669,
0.11743393540382385,
0.2002238929271698,
-0.002542380942031741,
-0.2308456003665924,
0.5228720903396606,
0.45445889234542847,
-0.07229698449373245,
0.38505420088768005,
-0.2641991674900055,
-0.3014294505119324,
0.03302308917045593,
-0.17337974905967712,
-0.3668568730354309,
1.1331156492233276,
0.299381285905838,
0.6061596274375916,
-0.0885571613907814,
0.5496667623519897,
0.13562476634979248,
0.0993320643901825,
-0.7608603835105896,
0.6006560325622559,
-0.014219303615391254,
-0.4599197506904602,
-0.3352375328540802,
-0.18860183656215668,
-0.9914978742599487,
0.7747408747673035,
-0.016078747808933258,
-0.7688797116279602,
0.24404235184192657,
-0.230454221367836,
-0.03747982531785965,
0.1725233644247055,
-0.6749159693717957,
1.1690350770950317,
-0.5034512877464294,
-0.5565834641456604,
-0.376054584980011,
-0.5481134057044983,
0.203110009431839,
-0.3070639669895172,
0.32703694701194763,
-0.07021801918745041,
-0.14341671764850616,
0.7078453898429871,
-0.31841886043548584,
0.5658167004585266,
-0.2181147336959839,
-0.17240650951862335,
-0.06643850356340408,
-0.04477180913090706,
0.3921259939670563,
-0.006682620383799076,
-0.32020723819732666,
0.07212189584970474,
0.1965138167142868,
-0.39020848274230957,
-0.619221568107605,
0.8170405626296997,
-0.45074790716171265,
-0.5476034879684448,
-0.48433247208595276,
-0.6187594532966614,
-0.14796632528305054,
0.6031630039215088,
0.10509950667619705,
0.6774556040763855,
-0.34991636872291565,
0.5461968779563904,
0.5122069716453552,
-0.21181944012641907,
0.3850499391555786,
0.7164590358734131,
-0.38909223675727844,
-0.1630604863166809,
0.6931149363517761,
0.0280395969748497,
-0.06711579114198685,
0.3037979006767273,
0.24854247272014618,
-0.16681206226348877,
-0.7546761631965637,
-0.5303558111190796,
0.082480788230896,
-1.1154907941818237,
0.1073104739189148,
-0.8407440781593323,
0.1755104959011078,
-0.20747779309749603,
-0.13745933771133423,
-0.22799676656723022,
-0.13717573881149292,
-0.1703742891550064,
-0.09044095128774643,
-0.04927310347557068,
0.47790056467056274,
0.08720044791698456,
0.005838683806359768,
-0.5951234698295593,
0.578385591506958,
0.25279462337493896,
0.4624641537666321,
-0.03659845143556595,
-0.3209209442138672,
-0.11943241208791733,
-0.2053958922624588,
-0.29019078612327576,
-0.7993454337120056,
0.21816527843475342,
-0.13158324360847473,
0.6357048153877258,
0.6359405517578125,
-0.024575887247920036,
0.812407910823822,
-0.4539645314216614,
0.6585481762886047,
0.200154647231102,
-0.6810646653175354,
0.28746330738067627,
-0.6189150810241699,
0.3785291016101837,
0.8787638545036316,
0.3804478943347931,
-0.5028913021087646,
-0.06686365604400635,
-0.18346184492111206,
-0.8366365432739258,
0.5096351504325867,
0.020070575177669525,
-0.12297520041465759,
0.09625354409217834,
0.013274479657411575,
0.3761110305786133,
0.16811996698379517,
-0.5997754335403442,
0.08477676659822464,
-0.2818430960178375,
-0.035134207457304,
-0.43352341651916504,
-0.22223101556301117,
-0.25740936398506165,
-0.3488657474517822,
0.08315246552228928,
-0.4005981385707855,
-0.12442192435264587,
0.18182986974716187,
-0.31310445070266724,
0.21449866890907288,
0.32372015714645386,
0.9778127074241638,
1.2218674421310425,
-0.5280675888061523,
0.21949316561222076,
0.16076941788196564,
-0.3729070723056793,
-0.34199297428131104,
0.4939924478530884,
0.18054848909378052,
-0.009709232486784458,
0.5559430718421936,
0.7128806710243225,
0.20858490467071533,
-0.9621185660362244,
0.8432852029800415,
-0.2953590154647827,
-0.3374718129634857,
-0.435577392578125,
-0.23023301362991333,
0.11775873601436615,
0.25086119771003723,
0.3804146647453308,
-0.30234289169311523,
0.15717551112174988,
-0.5816183686256409,
-0.029928434640169144,
0.3245728015899658,
-0.31143343448638916,
-0.022833747789263725,
0.4548799395561218,
0.22228959202766418,
-0.1775747686624527,
0.6206295490264893,
0.05601320415735245,
-0.37291815876960754,
0.4805294871330261,
0.23452156782150269,
0.5240572690963745,
0.3404836058616638,
-0.2845174968242645,
0.1949409544467926,
0.10913972556591034,
-0.0069190156646072865,
0.12947344779968262,
-0.48073601722717285,
-0.10137423872947693,
-0.16735930740833282,
-0.6163778901100159,
-0.44220441579818726,
0.2613009214401245,
-0.6149168610572815,
0.16607244312763214,
-0.15279236435890198,
-0.018943723291158676,
0.3304574191570282,
0.06107838451862335,
-0.8883151412010193,
0.21966443955898285,
0.16376671195030212,
1.1800156831741333,
-0.4695790112018585,
0.9109829068183899,
0.14327234029769897,
-0.49001654982566833,
-0.28733736276626587,
0.021113088354468346,
0.2146541327238083,
-0.6868031024932861,
0.4712906777858734,
0.6222558617591858,
-0.16738736629486084,
-0.4194408059120178,
-0.26022690534591675,
-0.5003585815429688,
1.358263373374939,
0.03377918899059296,
-0.6880067586898804,
-0.11232544481754303,
0.078398197889328,
0.7038877606391907,
-0.19062937796115875,
0.3702031075954437,
0.48553529381752014,
0.8037282228469849,
-0.2508241534233093,
-0.9006772041320801,
0.0650615468621254,
-0.4297611713409424,
-0.41779136657714844,
0.2536604106426239,
-0.5811399817466736,
0.8579092025756836,
-0.07479425519704819,
-0.07645624876022339,
0.09581857919692993,
0.4371606707572937,
0.2148951292037964,
0.8444187641143799,
0.6664726734161377,
0.610819399356842,
0.7585506439208984,
0.06369229406118393,
1.312780737876892,
-0.410845011472702,
0.08847404271364212,
1.3544750213623047,
-0.21805447340011597,
0.9813150763511658,
0.8178699612617493,
0.11165797710418701,
0.34593644738197327,
0.4181371331214905,
-0.30310171842575073,
0.26987749338150024,
0.30627521872520447,
0.014050309546291828,
-0.2677422761917114,
0.022643551230430603,
-0.631428599357605,
0.4442364275455475,
0.2389635145664215,
-0.46714070439338684,
-0.35968783497810364,
0.17338694632053375,
-0.19482247531414032,
-0.041551604866981506,
0.024120770394802094,
0.6347652673721313,
0.12998996675014496,
-0.7623116374015808,
0.5917048454284668,
-0.02487371675670147,
0.6939869523048401,
-0.7691134810447693,
0.15454669296741486,
-0.357867032289505,
0.3225286304950714,
0.006471958477050066,
-0.8144033551216125,
-0.13312232494354248,
0.0014579652342945337,
-0.3669447600841522,
-0.3046828508377075,
0.4873948395252228,
-0.16734491288661957,
-0.5245690941810608,
0.6413344740867615,
0.6182538866996765,
0.29093092679977417,
-0.43353191018104553,
-0.39416974782943726,
0.22388993203639984,
-0.18216602504253387,
-0.49401044845581055,
0.5405017733573914,
0.4397822618484497,
-0.14404165744781494,
0.6392788290977478,
0.6351029276847839,
-0.331221342086792,
0.038154974579811096,
0.3498004376888275,
0.971330463886261,
-0.7112919688224792,
-0.514334499835968,
-0.7064725756645203,
0.53257155418396,
-0.35080382227897644,
-0.4936973750591278,
0.8743978142738342,
0.9484612941741943,
0.8459076881408691,
-0.047388073056936264,
0.4387113153934479,
0.380418598651886,
0.24802710115909576,
-0.5170499682426453,
0.895334005355835,
-1.0812616348266602,
-0.05146824195981026,
-0.2090553641319275,
-0.8422000408172607,
-0.11388739943504333,
0.2774742841720581,
-0.3203774094581604,
-0.1072985976934433,
0.9047455191612244,
0.6320206522941589,
-0.418378621339798,
-0.10011936724185944,
0.43335360288619995,
0.10926339030265808,
0.5671653747558594,
0.5497359037399292,
0.779130756855011,
-0.18210653960704803,
0.6622096300125122,
-0.3619595766067505,
-0.09213019907474518,
-0.3393348753452301,
-0.9475675821304321,
-1.0809621810913086,
-0.6820076107978821,
0.11003700643777847,
-0.18217645585536957,
-0.033759769052267075,
0.49497663974761963,
0.6615344882011414,
-0.3671139180660248,
-0.1410737782716751,
0.326365202665329,
-0.11480536311864853,
0.10383138805627823,
-0.13021887838840485,
0.7009913921356201,
-0.018756872043013573,
-0.5557161569595337,
0.7010310292243958,
0.48007673025131226,
0.050136007368564606,
-0.24344079196453094,
-0.11213697493076324,
0.08996587991714478,
-0.10368303954601288,
0.9059200286865234,
0.12310914695262909,
-0.9539611339569092,
-0.2543553113937378,
-0.13355933129787445,
-0.31651169061660767,
0.30387139320373535,
0.8853590488433838,
-0.6529841423034668,
0.9347435235977173,
0.6772454977035522,
0.5152567625045776,
1.0095278024673462,
0.06525598466396332,
0.34936708211898804,
-0.36077946424484253,
0.22845421731472015,
0.1938282996416092,
0.6879467964172363,
0.27906879782676697,
0.09394439309835434,
0.6595520973205566,
0.02945823222398758,
-0.3838198781013489,
-0.967056930065155,
-0.05914001911878586,
-1.5452327728271484,
-0.6546853184700012,
1.0153926610946655,
-0.16006337106227875,
-0.22777119278907776,
0.08181833475828171,
-0.4559778571128845,
0.05862206593155861,
-0.29959046840667725,
0.8047693967819214,
0.6733047962188721,
-0.07870057225227356,
-0.0829201489686966,
-0.8121013641357422,
0.15147921442985535,
0.3894079923629761,
-0.9856706261634827,
0.14922088384628296,
0.8880323171615601,
0.1791304051876068,
0.36775052547454834,
0.7760149836540222,
0.08474858105182648,
0.2998504638671875,
0.12316057831048965,
-0.2750980854034424,
-0.5988143682479858,
-0.39417850971221924,
-0.41506871581077576,
0.5309147834777832,
-0.22699163854122162,
0.01643509976565838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01509v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01509v1 | MIA-Bench: Towards Better Instruction Following Evaluation of Multimodal LLMs | 2024-07-01T17:53:35 | 2024-07-01T17:53:35 | Yusu Qian, Hanrong Ye, Jean-Philippe Fauconnier, Peter Grasch, Yinfei Yang, Zhe Gan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | We introduce MIA-Bench, a new benchmark designed to evaluate multimodal large
language models (MLLMs) on their ability to strictly adhere to complex
instructions. Our benchmark comprises a diverse set of 400 image-prompt pairs,
each crafted to challenge the models' compliance with layered instructions in
generating accurate responses that satisfy specific requested patterns.
Evaluation results from a wide array of state-of-the-art MLLMs reveal
significant variations in performance, highlighting areas for improvement in
instruction fidelity. Additionally, we create extra training data and explore
supervised fine-tuning to enhance the models' ability to strictly follow
instructions without compromising performance on other tasks. We hope this
benchmark not only serves as a tool for measuring MLLM adherence to
instructions, but also guides future developments in MLLM training methods. | [
-0.23514942824840546,
-0.7921776175498962,
0.6043781638145447,
0.3843908905982971,
-0.22887904942035675,
0.04255368933081627,
-0.28846505284309387,
-0.14126749336719513,
-0.27065277099609375,
0.35802462697029114,
-0.9857847690582275,
-0.7737044095993042,
-0.6068925261497498,
-0.00945428665727377,
-0.4267444610595703,
0.5493187308311462,
-0.1867426633834839,
0.6695141792297363,
-0.5719862580299377,
-0.3007492125034332,
-0.8369867205619812,
-0.45529013872146606,
-0.3045346736907959,
-0.09075414389371872,
0.5952324271202087,
0.28125596046447754,
0.39461299777030945,
0.7758121490478516,
0.6600073575973511,
0.31501322984695435,
0.21834664046764374,
0.4750024378299713,
-0.3611457943916321,
0.22088158130645752,
-0.1404677927494049,
-0.5178375840187073,
-0.5571408867835999,
-0.10668402165174484,
0.7597753405570984,
0.858342170715332,
-0.07612408697605133,
0.25934815406799316,
0.1222175732254982,
0.735817015171051,
-0.7734686732292175,
0.29370787739753723,
-0.26134949922561646,
0.0885116457939148,
-0.09775751084089279,
-0.23728784918785095,
-0.7971689105033875,
-0.48860296607017517,
-0.09275278449058533,
-0.5364274382591248,
-0.07661779969930649,
-0.009679525159299374,
0.7219281792640686,
0.430404394865036,
-0.5937193036079407,
-0.14229907095432281,
-0.3812093138694763,
0.8548548221588135,
-0.6374287605285645,
0.6582778692245483,
0.544740617275238,
0.5239531397819519,
-0.18662533164024353,
-0.6655935049057007,
-0.10146567970514297,
-0.5953735113143921,
0.17606280744075775,
-0.00761799979954958,
-0.07891823351383209,
0.04027071222662926,
0.2578546404838562,
-0.08569338917732239,
-0.39439648389816284,
0.007943126372992992,
0.030733052641153336,
-0.10750973224639893,
0.451391339302063,
0.5322741866111755,
0.1430489867925644,
0.29376980662345886,
-0.7324602603912354,
-0.20842494070529938,
-0.800100564956665,
-0.009871752001345158,
0.11333262920379639,
0.1726282835006714,
-0.33076614141464233,
0.656324565410614,
-0.23506580293178558,
0.7965256571769714,
0.04470032826066017,
-0.18881714344024658,
0.34557023644447327,
-0.4184095859527588,
-0.0697508379817009,
-0.23187825083732605,
0.42420288920402527,
0.6819384694099426,
0.30053094029426575,
-0.15158714354038239,
-0.4597623646259308,
-0.1922665387392044,
0.25235679745674133,
-0.7568746209144592,
-0.1012200191617012,
-0.1871330887079239,
-0.6613801717758179,
0.15112406015396118,
-0.13539308309555054,
-0.7446146011352539,
-0.6277197003364563,
-0.8604996204376221,
0.8669732213020325,
-0.5169678330421448,
0.052881255745887756,
0.030214574187994003,
0.1370234489440918,
0.25219660997390747,
0.6329588294029236,
-0.7311290502548218,
0.31374406814575195,
0.7897434234619141,
0.8185466527938843,
-0.08997932821512222,
-0.5911316275596619,
-0.9917417764663696,
0.1682928502559662,
-0.49317246675491333,
0.8135638236999512,
-0.734147310256958,
-0.25462043285369873,
0.12582983076572418,
0.025532294064760208,
-0.3405815064907074,
-0.5123357772827148,
0.5590079426765442,
-0.2092047780752182,
0.0595950111746788,
-0.4173315167427063,
-0.6935851573944092,
-0.18598349392414093,
0.45245686173439026,
-0.5510054230690002,
0.9302332997322083,
0.3706539273262024,
-0.16913634538650513,
0.3713100254535675,
-0.6135302782058716,
-0.3400239646434784,
-0.43853530287742615,
-0.059790607541799545,
-0.13223814964294434,
0.1817319244146347,
0.2525955140590668,
0.4299854636192322,
-0.3290099799633026,
0.07960183173418045,
-0.6282339096069336,
-0.5695900917053223,
0.43592801690101624,
-0.7703002691268921,
0.5366228222846985,
-0.007887016050517559,
-0.4648898243904114,
0.6231268048286438,
-0.9259102940559387,
0.23918507993221283,
-0.10747864842414856,
-0.4198029637336731,
-0.12274665385484695,
0.033991243690252304,
0.16267172992229462,
0.18530787527561188,
0.18754440546035767,
-0.24075019359588623,
0.3430823087692261,
0.021408110857009888,
0.1016225665807724,
1.244613528251648,
-0.2770158052444458,
0.2425832897424698,
-0.48464691638946533,
0.5980449914932251,
-0.2821793556213379,
0.4803377389907837,
-0.4557829201221466,
-0.15592895448207855,
-0.9245229363441467,
-0.66202712059021,
0.4804218113422394,
0.25549307465553284,
-0.3443681299686432,
0.27218735218048096,
-0.2618582844734192,
-0.4064743220806122,
-0.7821051478385925,
0.3825729489326477,
0.8067169785499573,
0.3108457922935486,
0.42638614773750305,
-0.43088898062705994,
-0.6098386645317078,
-1.0650416612625122,
0.03768410161137581,
0.22900040447711945,
0.04257235676050186,
0.3548297882080078,
0.4292619228363037,
-0.12079910188913345,
0.4179297089576721,
-0.06812530755996704,
-0.16373281180858612,
0.047536700963974,
0.2864518463611603,
0.043639346957206726,
0.5439793467521667,
0.6850740313529968,
-0.29942917823791504,
-0.7202980518341064,
-0.2504507601261139,
-0.7615990042686462,
-0.1602877378463745,
-0.12850280106067657,
-0.23209747672080994,
0.4386724531650543,
0.48865973949432373,
-0.6104065179824829,
0.14418432116508484,
0.5351729989051819,
-0.33285796642303467,
0.5555135011672974,
-0.18089322745800018,
0.4564652740955353,
-0.8471128344535828,
0.09761936217546463,
-0.25807860493659973,
-0.2507163882255554,
-0.5392218232154846,
0.2173917591571808,
0.3650234341621399,
0.1804993748664856,
-0.6414865851402283,
0.4875413179397583,
-0.7962670922279358,
-0.30607283115386963,
-0.06735425442457199,
-0.13067588210105896,
0.09931376576423645,
0.5028292536735535,
-0.25687292218208313,
0.931125819683075,
0.7419158816337585,
-0.3646351993083954,
0.3740816116333008,
0.14297935366630554,
-0.77190762758255,
0.783475399017334,
-0.5188822746276855,
0.37133559584617615,
-0.05203249305486679,
0.20688781142234802,
-1.2437382936477661,
-0.1784997284412384,
0.025340784341096878,
-0.00471308222040534,
0.5017156600952148,
-0.23922021687030792,
-0.7424459457397461,
-0.028813201934099197,
-0.6114327907562256,
0.12475214898586273,
0.43272578716278076,
-0.5918171405792236,
0.8102532029151917,
-0.09681251645088196,
0.1184055283665657,
-0.7552362084388733,
-0.5538986325263977,
0.04183672368526459,
-0.03445640951395035,
-0.5474050641059875,
0.13021354377269745,
-0.5345764756202698,
-0.11721239984035492,
-0.13869152963161469,
-0.16509495675563812,
-0.19801893830299377,
0.2987518310546875,
0.40304890275001526,
0.3036250174045563,
-0.5455965995788574,
0.07527681440114975,
-0.21720929443836212,
0.10873918235301971,
0.2472122609615326,
0.2343766987323761,
0.9255315065383911,
-0.14786332845687866,
-0.8235695958137512,
-0.865285336971283,
0.33179768919944763,
0.8942428827285767,
-0.19294363260269165,
0.5856456160545349,
0.8540781736373901,
-0.1559351533651352,
-0.039461929351091385,
-0.5914291739463806,
-0.1499291956424713,
-0.4998115301132202,
0.4376232922077179,
-0.5374967455863953,
-0.38387298583984375,
0.24018725752830505,
-0.012586918659508228,
0.08320329338312149,
-0.06731077283620834,
0.6401500105857849,
-0.3801862299442291,
1.367069125175476,
0.567035973072052,
0.03126058727502823,
0.45135796070098877,
-0.04358213394880295,
-0.30978211760520935,
-0.8405646681785583,
-0.4361056983470917,
-0.37277764081954956,
-0.6387293934822083,
0.007553926203399897,
-0.6234267354011536,
0.1517949402332306,
0.2266167551279068,
-0.24267098307609558,
0.05520752817392349,
-0.08522333949804306,
0.4117032289505005,
0.5918599963188171,
0.2398476004600525,
-0.0003733753110282123,
-0.2390090674161911,
-0.21953092515468597,
-0.0015072026289999485,
-0.5470291972160339,
-0.48463332653045654,
1.2691218852996826,
0.3551798462867737,
1.0489835739135742,
0.2632488012313843,
0.4767199754714966,
0.3476907014846802,
0.5500370860099792,
-0.5879767537117004,
0.6918514966964722,
-0.037110839039087296,
-0.5600281357765198,
0.046252861618995667,
-0.19673065841197968,
-0.8905158042907715,
0.29449349641799927,
-0.3023286461830139,
-0.5682616233825684,
-0.1719227135181427,
0.09486111998558044,
-0.29378798604011536,
-0.04524283856153488,
-0.9636907577514648,
0.9984096884727478,
-0.6900569796562195,
-0.6671602725982666,
-0.2893294095993042,
-0.6318908333778381,
0.2666148245334625,
0.12993460893630981,
0.15041352808475494,
-0.5199775695800781,
-0.4549330472946167,
0.39381033182144165,
-0.1117350310087204,
1.110583782196045,
-0.2527754306793213,
-0.06533241271972656,
-0.06783974170684814,
0.09188740700483322,
0.3296397626399994,
-0.32223808765411377,
-0.00335415150038898,
-0.3376118242740631,
0.033294640481472015,
-0.465963751077652,
-0.557037353515625,
0.8337331414222717,
-0.6472861766815186,
-0.7096072435379028,
-0.016573814675211906,
-1.0076322555541992,
-0.5892273783683777,
0.12226608395576477,
-0.24665941298007965,
0.6799401640892029,
-0.2675064206123352,
0.4425812065601349,
0.8491278886795044,
-0.1286713182926178,
0.4451974630355835,
0.738250732421875,
-0.2947710454463959,
-0.3728869557380676,
0.617946982383728,
-0.05341414362192154,
0.2522295117378235,
0.634661853313446,
0.019162969663739204,
-0.5857183933258057,
-0.678177535533905,
-0.8432136178016663,
0.03520571440458298,
-0.9097967743873596,
-0.331562340259552,
-0.4152473211288452,
0.03968029469251633,
-0.24201107025146484,
-0.08932135254144669,
-0.3112002909183502,
-0.3088124990463257,
-0.3262096643447876,
0.16292305290699005,
0.09324205666780472,
0.7519774436950684,
0.22682403028011322,
0.14139091968536377,
-1.0906449556350708,
-0.037973880767822266,
0.33419927954673767,
0.4731218218803406,
-0.09668334573507309,
-0.6977885961532593,
-0.20432735979557037,
0.028035659343004227,
-0.24677836894989014,
-0.8189310431480408,
-0.07584147900342941,
0.4002470374107361,
1.0595474243164062,
0.4547406733036041,
-0.16343219578266144,
0.8213697075843811,
-0.6639970541000366,
0.52349454164505,
0.23697619140148163,
-1.025091290473938,
0.5915019512176514,
-0.4193081259727478,
0.5392239689826965,
0.49025535583496094,
0.31718575954437256,
-0.20555461943149567,
-0.15112806856632233,
-0.16414213180541992,
-0.5443537831306458,
0.7002937197685242,
-0.15671291947364807,
0.3664313852787018,
0.22067251801490784,
-0.0392383448779583,
0.16539692878723145,
0.24953047931194305,
-0.5077996850013733,
-0.20083275437355042,
0.03491370379924774,
-0.4189353883266449,
0.09114299714565277,
-0.4139808714389801,
-0.4892738461494446,
-0.21753762662410736,
0.35681331157684326,
-0.09570607542991638,
0.21303100883960724,
-0.2521510720252991,
-0.3620246946811676,
-0.2667275667190552,
0.2658936083316803,
1.0899231433868408,
0.9414726495742798,
-0.3962497413158417,
0.18683330714702606,
0.3543812930583954,
-0.10278989374637604,
0.08343009650707245,
0.16752703487873077,
0.05665138363838196,
0.19379296898841858,
0.7029825448989868,
0.8462732434272766,
0.5769359469413757,
-1.0993988513946533,
0.6620805859565735,
-0.05264813452959061,
-0.28187429904937744,
-0.06148380786180496,
0.31553325057029724,
0.18822436034679413,
0.3990676701068878,
0.08513882756233215,
0.2892759144306183,
0.049806371331214905,
-0.8085894584655762,
0.31163260340690613,
0.5271937251091003,
-0.46406275033950806,
-0.26061108708381653,
0.5775818228721619,
0.2826322019100189,
-0.30486342310905457,
0.3945620656013489,
0.2540856599807739,
-0.40023261308670044,
0.609198272228241,
0.565838098526001,
0.543397068977356,
-0.36835145950317383,
0.05002996698021889,
0.32615622878074646,
0.3521531820297241,
-0.027175914496183395,
0.3928094506263733,
-0.16363947093486786,
-0.272745817899704,
-0.3111753761768341,
-0.31714117527008057,
-0.4088670015335083,
0.004289831966161728,
-0.8675473928451538,
0.30393096804618835,
-0.7175122499465942,
-0.1496284455060959,
0.00943551491945982,
-0.17203649878501892,
-0.6578163504600525,
-0.07608658075332642,
0.2506900131702423,
1.1828581094741821,
-0.5665947794914246,
1.0135290622711182,
0.6991140842437744,
-0.44988277554512024,
-0.4682905375957489,
-0.29784372448921204,
0.480670303106308,
-0.9240673780441284,
0.6153234839439392,
0.5495604872703552,
-0.2617461383342743,
-0.26872700452804565,
-0.4189457297325134,
-0.882742166519165,
1.239791750907898,
0.7464762330055237,
-0.7688818573951721,
0.21946899592876434,
-0.11953824013471603,
0.4919752776622772,
-0.5273715853691101,
0.34390658140182495,
0.5688280463218689,
0.6662200689315796,
-0.1701255440711975,
-0.7799357175827026,
-0.0571126826107502,
-0.417587548494339,
-0.1793210357427597,
0.19990573823451996,
-0.6840555667877197,
0.7523563504219055,
-0.2562800645828247,
-0.06620747596025467,
0.6151840686798096,
0.42253726720809937,
0.2816084623336792,
0.4976811707019806,
0.5372834205627441,
0.4844432473182678,
0.661647379398346,
-0.227091982960701,
1.0808639526367188,
-0.18756668269634247,
0.052839912474155426,
1.5744893550872803,
-0.43608230352401733,
1.1453403234481812,
0.4793887734413147,
-0.1320318579673767,
0.4073255658149719,
0.5404651761054993,
-0.29777365922927856,
0.7258663773536682,
0.22897788882255554,
-0.23470444977283478,
-0.36122679710388184,
-0.33421891927719116,
-0.5240522623062134,
0.36603760719299316,
0.22839023172855377,
-0.5331369042396545,
-0.12002293765544891,
0.10722361505031586,
-0.0980013981461525,
0.38141822814941406,
-0.4011932909488678,
0.6421682238578796,
-0.23824933171272278,
-0.6509751677513123,
0.8635663986206055,
-0.16899867355823517,
0.4608640670776367,
-0.7116682529449463,
-0.24246878921985626,
-0.38906463980674744,
0.38689619302749634,
0.006300007924437523,
-0.7290548086166382,
-0.10108855366706848,
0.11165443807840347,
-0.18600638210773468,
-0.26932790875434875,
0.36389926075935364,
-0.5785595178604126,
-0.3934117257595062,
0.38759374618530273,
0.5169692635536194,
0.15467210114002228,
0.33154624700546265,
-0.9363396763801575,
0.38179898262023926,
-0.04913197457790375,
-0.20699071884155273,
0.5012115240097046,
0.3219730257987976,
0.19113586843013763,
0.887355625629425,
0.5073032379150391,
-0.42401793599128723,
0.40794458985328674,
0.6091775894165039,
0.9353893399238586,
-0.3365543484687805,
0.26699966192245483,
-0.8333876729011536,
0.5812476277351379,
0.033110857009887695,
-0.5981284976005554,
0.8665586709976196,
0.6603260636329651,
0.791231632232666,
-0.3871346116065979,
0.33987516164779663,
0.1737542450428009,
0.30145588517189026,
-0.9932810068130493,
0.5788679718971252,
-0.7635914087295532,
0.3566465377807617,
0.0591091513633728,
-0.9545662999153137,
-0.2282407581806183,
0.4869343340396881,
-0.08235330134630203,
0.13045670092105865,
0.8114982843399048,
1.0716286897659302,
-0.18588116765022278,
-0.1970646232366562,
0.581614077091217,
0.08175867795944214,
-0.03596065193414688,
0.6822131276130676,
1.3690063953399658,
-0.2362598478794098,
0.6618993878364563,
-0.3639823794364929,
0.029455512762069702,
-0.5006787180900574,
-0.7513554692268372,
-1.193755030632019,
-0.48842528462409973,
-0.14101611077785492,
-0.08784141391515732,
0.39874815940856934,
1.2939119338989258,
0.9494253993034363,
-0.8133401870727539,
-0.23912668228149414,
0.20190078020095825,
-0.09553344547748566,
-0.5851554870605469,
-0.10746295005083084,
0.39023512601852417,
-0.6566987037658691,
-0.8947857022285461,
0.6578929424285889,
0.26484405994415283,
0.03907034546136856,
-0.30278801918029785,
-0.2483382672071457,
-0.5169968008995056,
0.19162125885486603,
0.728344738483429,
-0.331757128238678,
-0.8658966422080994,
-0.2900579869747162,
0.16845129430294037,
-0.579454779624939,
0.1915961354970932,
0.6763050556182861,
-0.30918100476264954,
0.605063259601593,
0.18714860081672668,
0.7473105192184448,
0.3202493190765381,
-0.026816481724381447,
0.5824817419052124,
-0.7658195495605469,
-0.0421224907040596,
0.24478118121623993,
0.5402255058288574,
0.40800949931144714,
0.09755837917327881,
0.7233452200889587,
-0.2273344099521637,
-0.2878859341144562,
-0.9704188108444214,
-0.04062912240624428,
-1.1833817958831787,
-0.3719564378261566,
1.045932412147522,
-0.5221177339553833,
-0.32865551114082336,
-0.03356025367975235,
-0.3488076329231262,
-0.00885025504976511,
-0.34307387471199036,
0.8503899574279785,
0.8825672268867493,
-0.04432329908013344,
-0.6141155958175659,
-0.6255022287368774,
0.1403706967830658,
0.8130815625190735,
-0.9251887202262878,
0.13026557862758636,
0.869561493396759,
0.23527076840400696,
-0.1695491075515747,
0.3994005024433136,
-0.021613752469420433,
0.6839855909347534,
0.10925338417291641,
0.036080896854400635,
-0.31271228194236755,
-0.47740092873573303,
-0.42372894287109375,
0.14378401637077332,
0.24234548211097717,
-0.46635717153549194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01505v1 | Self-Cognition in Large Language Models: An Exploratory Study | 2024-07-01T17:52:05 | 2024-07-01T17:52:05 | Dongping Chen, Jiawen Shi, Yao Wan, Pan Zhou, Neil Zhenqiang Gong, Lichao Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success across
various applications, they also raise concerns regarding self-cognition. In
this paper, we perform a pioneering study to explore self-cognition in LLMs.
Specifically, we first construct a pool of self-cognition instruction prompts
to evaluate where an LLM exhibits self-cognition and four well-designed
principles to quantify LLMs' self-cognition. Our study reveals that 4 of the 48
models on Chatbot Arena--specifically Command R, Claude3-Opus,
Llama-3-70b-Instruct, and Reka-core--demonstrate some level of detectable
self-cognition. We observe a positive correlation between model size, training
data quality, and self-cognition level. Additionally, we also explore the
utility and trustworthiness of LLM in the self-cognition state, revealing that
the self-cognition state enhances some specific tasks such as creative writing
and exaggeration. We believe that our work can serve as an inspiration for
further research to study the self-cognition in LLMs. | [
-0.34734153747558594,
-0.8885627388954163,
0.786024272441864,
0.17394313216209412,
0.09884920716285706,
-0.09584060311317444,
-0.378982812166214,
-0.4242347776889801,
0.28113362193107605,
0.6842885613441467,
-0.4419754147529602,
-0.35228341817855835,
-0.476499080657959,
0.030706267803907394,
-0.5748663544654846,
0.7400268316268921,
0.07755718380212784,
-0.10931618511676788,
-0.3497108221054077,
0.0886552557349205,
-0.6382879018783569,
-0.76351398229599,
-0.5994212627410889,
-0.4325183629989624,
0.5578644871711731,
0.45250821113586426,
0.43180763721466064,
0.6316560506820679,
0.430996298789978,
0.28340622782707214,
0.2305537462234497,
-0.09705545008182526,
-0.717384397983551,
0.43043550848960876,
-0.29369398951530457,
-0.7126185894012451,
-0.5691138505935669,
0.2998940050601959,
0.685659646987915,
0.3546343147754669,
-0.2082093060016632,
0.40630412101745605,
0.21266357600688934,
0.7285959124565125,
-0.44730982184410095,
0.3713900148868561,
-0.5528375506401062,
0.09965391457080841,
-0.10492075234651566,
-0.12846258282661438,
-0.6892896890640259,
0.2490258514881134,
0.0256310123950243,
-0.45571672916412354,
0.06905969232320786,
0.2631048858165741,
0.10252449661493301,
0.33611512184143066,
-0.47613266110420227,
-0.46141737699508667,
-0.8502293825149536,
0.7081891894340515,
-0.6323829293251038,
0.25288647413253784,
0.49207279086112976,
0.1724330484867096,
-0.19846530258655548,
-0.5536039471626282,
-0.659735381603241,
-0.34329116344451904,
0.08058410882949829,
0.18152454495429993,
-0.14871293306350708,
-0.14127936959266663,
0.14738033711910248,
0.478096604347229,
-0.5353994965553284,
0.5708804726600647,
-0.2420915812253952,
-0.24104849994182587,
0.6846089959144592,
0.31470543146133423,
0.16409774124622345,
-0.08511564135551453,
-0.27227815985679626,
-0.08342352509498596,
-0.6895961165428162,
-0.277650386095047,
0.18241246044635773,
0.16202379763126373,
-0.08823787420988083,
0.660946786403656,
-0.30297091603279114,
0.33464187383651733,
-0.16179530322551727,
-0.006991083268076181,
0.20074787735939026,
-0.2778407037258148,
-0.2872796356678009,
-0.09491250663995743,
1.0375185012817383,
0.13750508427619934,
0.5321877002716064,
0.0166912954300642,
-0.20152200758457184,
-0.09393508732318878,
0.5019576549530029,
-0.5627728700637817,
-0.3004796802997589,
0.17220920324325562,
-0.5469055771827698,
-0.37480881810188293,
-0.43644624948501587,
-0.1489693522453308,
-0.4101596176624298,
-0.1456441879272461,
0.6348176002502441,
-0.2808498740196228,
-0.405940979719162,
-0.014334458857774734,
0.30235931277275085,
0.30162307620048523,
0.3625756502151489,
-1.0355342626571655,
0.18256990611553192,
0.6676399111747742,
0.49392977356910706,
-0.30619338154792786,
-0.6371257305145264,
-0.0240542721003294,
0.012799026444554329,
-0.4266766905784607,
0.6864134669303894,
-0.45752379298210144,
-0.4571140706539154,
-0.12643034756183624,
-0.20143647491931915,
-0.07180993258953094,
-0.3305484354496002,
0.4227820634841919,
-0.266716867685318,
0.27180367708206177,
-0.018005309626460075,
-0.975806713104248,
0.03246447071433067,
0.43693089485168457,
-0.6587272882461548,
0.9236140847206116,
-0.18873246014118195,
-0.5514305233955383,
0.06847630441188812,
-0.24966828525066376,
-0.4220646321773529,
0.07813912630081177,
-0.46268564462661743,
-0.2388351708650589,
0.4051121771335602,
0.07417537271976471,
0.856776237487793,
-0.23232842981815338,
0.15251196920871735,
-0.3657536804676056,
-0.2328566461801529,
0.7518841624259949,
-0.5475319027900696,
0.38892313838005066,
0.13290919363498688,
-0.21310418844223022,
-0.15517841279506683,
-0.35915181040763855,
0.15918897092342377,
0.3405497968196869,
-0.1743021309375763,
-0.30465009808540344,
-0.17559540271759033,
-0.5091758966445923,
0.29173964262008667,
0.5115479826927185,
-0.3323151469230652,
0.32351022958755493,
-0.22428901493549347,
0.44236284494400024,
0.6736131906509399,
-0.1243843212723732,
0.49420365691185,
-0.1913735717535019,
0.4177130460739136,
-0.27867040038108826,
0.2427036464214325,
-0.3104116916656494,
-0.4036124050617218,
-0.919099748134613,
-0.20109403133392334,
0.12698249518871307,
0.20769314467906952,
-0.34354233741760254,
0.3663594126701355,
0.016939911991357803,
-0.48355942964553833,
-0.3516479730606079,
0.2977100610733032,
0.48779231309890747,
0.34753355383872986,
0.24227260053157806,
-0.15985645353794098,
-0.15450215339660645,
-1.1487842798233032,
-0.20912891626358032,
-0.22145026922225952,
0.3005305230617523,
0.44223901629447937,
0.7167014479637146,
-0.16216804087162018,
0.5703347325325012,
-0.497277170419693,
-0.36443647742271423,
-0.3481501042842865,
0.02342485450208187,
0.10838396102190018,
0.4630751609802246,
0.3837070167064667,
-0.1909979283809662,
-0.4635113775730133,
-0.46170997619628906,
-0.8786931037902832,
0.05772766098380089,
-0.16812549531459808,
-0.1429070383310318,
0.4150696098804474,
0.7544484734535217,
-0.6628249287605286,
0.20105738937854767,
0.7277449369430542,
-0.2681332528591156,
0.5112074613571167,
-0.6221307516098022,
-0.09189725667238235,
-0.876445472240448,
-0.19912225008010864,
-0.13485440611839294,
-0.0672624260187149,
-0.6129770278930664,
-0.05995398387312889,
0.05925456061959267,
0.22937734425067902,
-0.023354653269052505,
0.6411933302879333,
-0.7187740802764893,
-0.10943067073822021,
-0.5155088305473328,
0.28157612681388855,
-0.10908862203359604,
0.4710337221622467,
0.003999553620815277,
0.6254559755325317,
0.7781435251235962,
-0.5585339665412903,
0.045787762850522995,
0.11176689714193344,
-0.586781919002533,
0.3396380841732025,
-0.46937522292137146,
0.39877989888191223,
-0.052284035831689835,
0.3030930161476135,
-1.2193423509597778,
-0.002525355899706483,
0.17828860878944397,
-0.5020660161972046,
0.42310720682144165,
0.23327942192554474,
-0.6350874304771423,
-0.4674851894378662,
-0.015952283516526222,
0.24401429295539856,
0.5420010089874268,
-0.47928550839424133,
0.6234007477760315,
0.5383877754211426,
-0.0204346664249897,
-0.31856009364128113,
-0.7712416648864746,
0.03865944966673851,
-0.30021628737449646,
-0.25286805629730225,
-0.05940909683704376,
-0.21635395288467407,
-0.07015273720026016,
-0.3437930643558502,
-0.07607171684503555,
0.12194108963012695,
0.3065427243709564,
0.4175912141799927,
0.24603112041950226,
-0.02867314964532852,
0.4213772118091583,
-0.1253434270620346,
-0.0028756922110915184,
0.43796399235725403,
-0.2119525521993637,
0.6372979879379272,
-0.2686980664730072,
-0.5001009106636047,
-0.5483054518699646,
-0.09573158621788025,
0.46555060148239136,
-0.31345513463020325,
0.7365449070930481,
0.3688458800315857,
-0.001412800862453878,
-0.4071770906448364,
-0.8832412362098694,
-0.29281705617904663,
-0.431232213973999,
0.20269373059272766,
-0.3967231512069702,
-1.2695749998092651,
0.4884629249572754,
-0.012491620145738125,
-0.09056434035301208,
0.5136603713035583,
0.7716795802116394,
-0.5976276993751526,
0.8137614727020264,
0.5913683176040649,
-0.2791374623775482,
0.38970717787742615,
-0.3051273226737976,
0.10043621808290482,
-1.0608080625534058,
-0.2534644901752472,
-0.1852465718984604,
-0.27754467725753784,
-0.6739387512207031,
-0.6542802453041077,
0.20489001274108887,
-0.24254077672958374,
-0.31783270835876465,
0.07051681727170944,
-0.26721879839897156,
0.3527759611606598,
0.44897496700286865,
0.06557111442089081,
0.340753436088562,
-0.25377315282821655,
0.021594932302832603,
0.08123477548360825,
-0.769533634185791,
-0.5065037608146667,
1.2382678985595703,
0.5547996163368225,
1.0651978254318237,
0.0696955993771553,
0.9299843907356262,
0.35783857107162476,
0.2674713730812073,
-0.6692854166030884,
0.6558207869529724,
0.12128400057554245,
-0.8835089802742004,
-0.6772521734237671,
-0.446689635515213,
-1.0803430080413818,
0.28706544637680054,
-0.3544715344905853,
-0.6710191965103149,
-0.24326972663402557,
0.4512922465801239,
-0.19367615878582,
0.006057374645024538,
-0.6045324802398682,
0.976643443107605,
-0.6945805549621582,
-0.2676924765110016,
-0.7040502429008484,
-0.5012889504432678,
0.5269964933395386,
-0.23284085094928741,
0.24923935532569885,
-0.33079564571380615,
-0.04373330622911453,
0.6103159189224243,
0.12040100246667862,
1.2045660018920898,
0.22896456718444824,
-0.31239408254623413,
0.6171043515205383,
0.411471962928772,
0.4606427252292633,
-0.04495098814368248,
0.16665136814117432,
0.18305952847003937,
-0.08339187502861023,
-0.043998681008815765,
-0.7888562083244324,
0.8603609204292297,
-0.7729584574699402,
-0.9001484513282776,
-0.3747086822986603,
-0.5223520994186401,
-0.1990780234336853,
0.22827741503715515,
-0.10784371942281723,
0.33151575922966003,
-0.5862317085266113,
0.3730500638484955,
0.7801687121391296,
-0.20242302119731903,
0.26213884353637695,
0.7345759272575378,
-0.5866201519966125,
-0.09935300052165985,
0.7724403142929077,
0.21880997717380524,
0.5336183309555054,
0.3842267096042633,
0.39713358879089355,
-0.3394322693347931,
-0.5068106055259705,
-0.1192251592874527,
0.4541857838630676,
-0.7260443568229675,
-0.0751560777425766,
-0.5293005108833313,
-0.18095505237579346,
-0.3891580104827881,
0.26674360036849976,
-0.7148533463478088,
-0.5240668654441833,
-0.32831379771232605,
0.04342488944530487,
0.09848666936159134,
1.043488621711731,
0.09905288368463516,
0.2613826096057892,
-0.4387071132659912,
-0.0017783947987481952,
0.34933578968048096,
0.33273768424987793,
0.263088196516037,
-0.8329327702522278,
-0.3301404118537903,
-0.0692613497376442,
-0.06615883111953735,
-0.46543875336647034,
0.3439593017101288,
0.0892694890499115,
0.9149227738380432,
0.36564382910728455,
-0.051884595304727554,
0.1825857311487198,
-0.5138180255889893,
0.5769591927528381,
0.12728121876716614,
-0.8768633604049683,
0.38735541701316833,
-0.2750902473926544,
0.43355080485343933,
0.3960142433643341,
0.28331780433654785,
-0.47488588094711304,
-0.5935548543930054,
-0.7799801826477051,
-0.2841327488422394,
0.4743313491344452,
0.4216594994068146,
0.4901704490184784,
-0.1786910444498062,
0.5989590883255005,
-0.0071561867371201515,
0.15052306652069092,
-0.7340888977050781,
-0.43283966183662415,
-0.12258554995059967,
0.05308779701590538,
-0.44900843501091003,
-0.6138426065444946,
0.06331437826156616,
-0.10547851026058197,
0.524729311466217,
-0.2595537006855011,
0.2670288383960724,
0.049236565828323364,
-0.023834489285945892,
0.2282918095588684,
0.24572914838790894,
0.39549723267555237,
0.4405491054058075,
0.17009906470775604,
0.315165638923645,
0.3673149347305298,
-0.23160025477409363,
-0.15651844441890717,
-0.5109463930130005,
0.12550359964370728,
-0.6526051759719849,
0.4761863350868225,
0.6286726593971252,
0.3390742540359497,
-0.6172987222671509,
0.5542921423912048,
-0.14384935796260834,
-0.04223291575908661,
-0.52968430519104,
0.31869909167289734,
0.5635432004928589,
0.42696547508239746,
-0.03788997605443001,
-0.5424729585647583,
0.11376360058784485,
-0.8463782072067261,
-0.1459391862154007,
0.7172734141349792,
-0.1637154072523117,
-0.23078446090221405,
0.3613833487033844,
0.22925302386283875,
-0.16026651859283447,
0.8587294816970825,
-0.05280475318431854,
-0.38890495896339417,
0.38750559091567993,
0.7884339094161987,
0.762275755405426,
-0.2945297062397003,
0.05627346411347389,
0.36731866002082825,
0.4993242025375366,
-0.20976269245147705,
0.10194453597068787,
-0.30574458837509155,
-1.015268325805664,
-0.4173908829689026,
-0.3600693941116333,
-0.4992748498916626,
0.13208423554897308,
-0.6284489631652832,
-0.021654300391674042,
-0.33110934495925903,
-0.3104906380176544,
-0.15683229267597198,
0.01323068980127573,
-0.6373074054718018,
0.2468450516462326,
0.5139741897583008,
0.8205173015594482,
-0.5540323257446289,
1.0527377128601074,
0.24445396661758423,
-0.1619476079940796,
-0.8014009594917297,
-0.31158873438835144,
-0.21430398523807526,
-1.2392131090164185,
0.6792669892311096,
0.14736412465572357,
-0.31072309613227844,
0.07024352252483368,
-0.7525914907455444,
-1.0746948719024658,
1.317410945892334,
0.16100342571735382,
-0.6308051943778992,
0.0008792038424871862,
0.05437975376844406,
0.7014117240905762,
-0.6734253168106079,
0.12895174324512482,
0.5689312815666199,
0.052676405757665634,
0.09322835505008698,
-1.0094273090362549,
-0.02867029793560505,
-0.030271602794528008,
-0.1125626191496849,
-0.009502877481281757,
-1.1011379957199097,
0.763175368309021,
-0.3618296980857849,
-0.04166628047823906,
0.042876388877630234,
0.8905686736106873,
0.19446486234664917,
-0.006146556232124567,
0.37587541341781616,
0.5123217105865479,
0.8308854103088379,
0.2966996431350708,
1.0249377489089966,
-0.5250987410545349,
0.33681878447532654,
1.465716004371643,
-0.27201715111732483,
0.8849854469299316,
0.2966587245464325,
0.1677626371383667,
0.4402553141117096,
0.21134497225284576,
-0.03695840761065483,
0.11612576246261597,
0.2883681654930115,
0.0591890811920166,
-0.5983895659446716,
0.10774195939302444,
-0.14522327482700348,
0.83326655626297,
0.5707275867462158,
-0.6403613090515137,
0.23048701882362366,
-0.03819858282804489,
0.09056323021650314,
-0.08617362380027771,
-0.37115341424942017,
0.7340711355209351,
0.36348116397857666,
-0.7078279256820679,
0.13942398130893707,
-0.3116297423839569,
0.3222760856151581,
-0.4564878046512604,
0.11005045473575592,
-0.18946844339370728,
0.2024311125278473,
0.11534856259822845,
-1.3170084953308105,
-0.01950218714773655,
-0.16996310651302338,
0.0837562307715416,
-0.4537366032600403,
0.8407328724861145,
-0.2265709489583969,
-0.3008599579334259,
0.26072388887405396,
0.9899167418479919,
0.5819745659828186,
-0.26478731632232666,
-0.6249985098838806,
0.22070744633674622,
-0.06186577305197716,
-0.438580721616745,
0.4762974679470062,
0.5951672792434692,
0.09836067259311676,
1.0530859231948853,
0.32079073786735535,
-0.1348591148853302,
0.006858178414404392,
0.243312269449234,
0.6707421541213989,
-0.85279381275177,
-0.3155038356781006,
-0.9431452751159668,
0.011886651627719402,
0.03546849638223648,
-0.2625594139099121,
1.192194938659668,
0.6177491545677185,
0.8556110858917236,
-0.026976875960826874,
0.7751120924949646,
0.1706497222185135,
0.26169225573539734,
-0.514254093170166,
0.7097094655036926,
-0.3925156593322754,
0.13475118577480316,
-0.04469699412584305,
-0.769126832485199,
0.06085709109902382,
0.676713764667511,
-0.5593565702438354,
0.1406189352273941,
0.6298443675041199,
0.5876052379608154,
0.2702235281467438,
0.07770863175392151,
0.7273953557014465,
0.34704554080963135,
0.1519646793603897,
0.4133395552635193,
1.1751110553741455,
0.061800602823495865,
0.45580607652664185,
-0.28791314363479614,
-0.058318641036748886,
-0.16344138979911804,
-0.7691268920898438,
-1.3249216079711914,
-0.5978233218193054,
-0.20978905260562897,
-0.20232166349887848,
-0.3394281566143036,
0.8341391086578369,
0.43319982290267944,
-0.3020874857902527,
-0.4518410861492157,
0.06326954811811447,
-0.02710721641778946,
0.1631094068288803,
-0.0805489793419838,
0.13658258318901062,
-0.4906175434589386,
-0.5074795484542847,
0.44980084896087646,
0.3127959072589874,
0.2748147249221802,
-1.009932041168213,
-0.045753076672554016,
-0.06650697439908981,
0.19993990659713745,
0.6668314337730408,
0.15488828718662262,
-0.7472962141036987,
-0.3417626619338989,
0.17114217579364777,
-0.4113558828830719,
0.023201724514365196,
0.7573340535163879,
-0.6123109459877014,
0.618986964225769,
0.24598576128482819,
0.2770909070968628,
0.7675589919090271,
-0.2013179510831833,
0.5279765725135803,
-0.22990499436855316,
-0.2954607605934143,
0.0633259043097496,
0.4227275848388672,
0.3625113368034363,
-0.34551140666007996,
0.5072905421257019,
-0.060333844274282455,
-0.9168092012405396,
-0.5268750786781311,
0.25612977147102356,
-0.862060010433197,
-0.20807704329490662,
1.0948480367660522,
0.05855943262577057,
-0.3251659572124481,
0.3027728199958801,
-0.09532526135444641,
0.12447112053632736,
-0.2065291702747345,
0.8492944836616516,
0.8076698780059814,
-0.5903726816177368,
-0.1814655065536499,
-0.6067255735397339,
0.15204589068889618,
0.3646063208580017,
-0.7092424631118774,
0.3091284930706024,
0.45298701524734497,
0.35095474123954773,
0.21850739419460297,
0.8789529204368591,
0.20950959622859955,
-0.1578744500875473,
0.09228115528821945,
0.2455071657896042,
-0.0002671965048648417,
-0.5331675410270691,
-0.34042495489120483,
-0.08768077939748764,
0.376441091299057,
0.06844017654657364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01492v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01492v1 | RegMix: Data Mixture as Regression for Language Model Pre-training | 2024-07-01T17:31:03 | 2024-07-01T17:31:03 | Qian Liu, Xiaosen Zheng, Niklas Muennighoff, Guangtao Zeng, Longxu Dou, Tianyu Pang, Jing Jiang, Min Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The data mixture for large language model pre-training significantly impacts
performance, yet how to determine an effective mixture remains unclear. We
propose RegMix to automatically identify a high-performing data mixture by
formulating it as a regression task. RegMix involves training a set of small
models with diverse data mixtures and fitting a regression model to predict
their performance given their respective mixtures. With the fitted regression
model, we simulate the top-ranked mixture and use it to train a large-scale
model with orders of magnitude more compute. To empirically validate RegMix, we
train 512 models with 1M parameters for 1B tokens of different mixtures to fit
the regression model and find the optimal mixture. Using this mixture we train
a 1B parameter model for 25B tokens (i.e. 1000x larger and 25x longer) which we
find performs best among 64 candidate 1B parameter models with other mixtures.
Further, our method demonstrates superior performance compared to human
selection and achieves results that match or surpass DoReMi, while utilizing
only 10% of the compute budget. Our experiments also show that (1) Data
mixtures significantly impact performance with single-task performance
variations of up to 14.6%; (2) Web corpora rather than data perceived as
high-quality like Wikipedia have the strongest positive correlation with
downstream performance; (3) Domains interact in complex ways often
contradicting common sense, thus automatic approaches like RegMix are needed;
(4) Data mixture effects transcend scaling laws, and our approach captures the
complexity by considering all domains together. Our code is available at
https://github.com/sail-sg/regmix. | [
-0.4108628034591675,
-0.7276182174682617,
0.28460168838500977,
0.5078859925270081,
-0.18944253027439117,
0.40760499238967896,
-0.3749935030937195,
-0.32312530279159546,
0.1990528404712677,
0.540224552154541,
-0.49505940079689026,
-0.2564161717891693,
-0.6333510875701904,
0.07018034905195236,
-0.567961573600769,
0.6023794412612915,
0.11823461949825287,
0.20931516587734222,
-0.3988047242164612,
0.06376641243696213,
-0.6721421480178833,
-0.4970613420009613,
-0.5108567476272583,
-0.2818048298358917,
0.4884827435016632,
0.33303752541542053,
0.4178430140018463,
0.7607969641685486,
0.3641633093357086,
0.3119451105594635,
0.3081033229827881,
0.20782935619354248,
-0.762886106967926,
0.30687618255615234,
0.009569855406880379,
-0.6367435455322266,
-0.21931767463684082,
0.24319110810756683,
0.6416071653366089,
0.6588714718818665,
-0.36854061484336853,
0.22720180451869965,
0.16400976479053497,
0.4883303940296173,
-0.7016324996948242,
0.08904702961444855,
-0.6866406202316284,
-0.29738518595695496,
-0.23509959876537323,
-0.05885525792837143,
-0.42856723070144653,
-0.27150291204452515,
-0.27069830894470215,
-0.6578189730644226,
0.11454123258590698,
0.44420576095581055,
0.9920704960823059,
0.4229855239391327,
-0.19609695672988892,
0.19810162484645844,
-0.9697229862213135,
1.0523638725280762,
-0.5438631176948547,
0.7211101055145264,
0.33728089928627014,
0.46201732754707336,
-0.2687983512878418,
-0.7438340187072754,
-0.610022783279419,
-0.14996829628944397,
0.05911744758486748,
0.15920761227607727,
-0.1323002427816391,
-0.09856964647769928,
0.18244166672229767,
0.3397304117679596,
-0.8719673752784729,
0.05787993595004082,
-0.1173558309674263,
-0.14251980185508728,
0.540658712387085,
0.3704991340637207,
0.26354336738586426,
0.48058533668518066,
-0.270668089389801,
-0.25868406891822815,
-0.5332306027412415,
-0.12746915221214294,
0.27998971939086914,
0.5732342600822449,
0.061757802963256836,
0.34797003865242004,
-0.20418311655521393,
1.0285223722457886,
-0.1403733193874359,
-0.40282028913497925,
0.2316335141658783,
-0.3026522397994995,
-0.36004629731178284,
-0.24026307463645935,
0.6785247921943665,
-0.04928135126829147,
0.3520576059818268,
-0.19709710776805878,
-0.5052635669708252,
0.1305713802576065,
0.336601585149765,
-0.8842925429344177,
-0.21657699346542358,
0.08760662376880646,
-0.3647560775279999,
-0.03949397802352905,
0.1370597928762436,
-0.7086291909217834,
-0.3479749858379364,
-0.8598058223724365,
0.6596415638923645,
-0.3290620744228363,
-0.26515644788742065,
0.42719918489456177,
-0.21058113873004913,
-0.11777599900960922,
0.48589494824409485,
-0.5515108704566956,
0.664943277835846,
0.8388505578041077,
0.5553253889083862,
-0.20508074760437012,
-0.3340522348880768,
-0.739148736000061,
-0.14454768598079681,
-0.2744366526603699,
0.6938076615333557,
-0.7742635607719421,
-0.3696453869342804,
-0.15048862993717194,
-0.3407452404499054,
-0.394233763217926,
-0.9810669422149658,
-0.021488182246685028,
-0.3362770676612854,
0.25459232926368713,
0.12003330886363983,
-0.7939704060554504,
-0.00818372517824173,
-0.12357454001903534,
-0.7759815454483032,
1.1605485677719116,
0.5000700950622559,
-0.6569511294364929,
0.7366545796394348,
-0.25496768951416016,
-0.5786629915237427,
0.22854913771152496,
-0.12254723161458969,
-0.2876701354980469,
0.042792562395334244,
-0.11880391836166382,
0.45643192529678345,
-0.6753184795379639,
0.406877726316452,
-0.3979696035385132,
-0.35781019926071167,
0.24896809458732605,
-0.11377927660942078,
0.7176229357719421,
0.4286958873271942,
-0.12729790806770325,
0.14562062919139862,
-1.0028260946273804,
-0.10064438730478287,
-0.010131471790373325,
-0.1998026818037033,
-0.527150571346283,
-0.06281822919845581,
0.3848176896572113,
0.23780177533626556,
0.21117103099822998,
-0.5156295895576477,
-0.05075569823384285,
-0.00856870599091053,
-0.00048507415340282023,
0.5632516741752625,
-0.20592573285102844,
0.408631294965744,
-0.30765387415885925,
0.8411028385162354,
-0.02390204183757305,
0.25244829058647156,
0.16651958227157593,
-0.5261181592941284,
-0.707105278968811,
-0.6923474073410034,
0.6308175325393677,
0.5626134276390076,
-0.5241807699203491,
0.6540773510932922,
-0.20032934844493866,
-0.6513015031814575,
-0.7302432060241699,
0.34983837604522705,
0.10496854037046432,
0.545824408531189,
0.30655181407928467,
-0.26589247584342957,
-0.853157103061676,
-0.9097528457641602,
-0.17686203122138977,
-0.19124405086040497,
0.010170986875891685,
0.20015849173069,
0.3739699721336365,
-0.30238401889801025,
1.3582344055175781,
-0.7480279207229614,
-0.09613902866840363,
-0.37279462814331055,
0.35312092304229736,
0.14888310432434082,
0.5674468874931335,
0.5065163969993591,
-0.7847017645835876,
-0.5673545598983765,
-0.07013121992349625,
-0.33297860622406006,
-0.18774206936359406,
-0.12984047830104828,
-0.10574832558631897,
-0.17275437712669373,
0.2934637665748596,
-0.17866581678390503,
0.13680914044380188,
0.6232293844223022,
-0.15273703634738922,
0.43903878331184387,
-0.16075094044208527,
0.06486688554286957,
-1.1516231298446655,
0.33233195543289185,
0.4037114679813385,
-0.2951301634311676,
-0.6081821322441101,
-0.04391666501760483,
0.02912566252052784,
0.028605971485376358,
-0.20852792263031006,
0.6540171504020691,
-0.05626184865832329,
0.21714892983436584,
-0.29418784379959106,
-0.3994213044643402,
-0.11152470111846924,
0.09527194499969482,
0.14376424252986908,
1.0735098123550415,
0.5436542630195618,
-0.5055480003356934,
0.2546514570713043,
-0.10130222141742706,
-0.5113778710365295,
0.16498929262161255,
-0.3753925859928131,
-0.20219245553016663,
-0.06895000487565994,
0.31234055757522583,
-1.1821489334106445,
-0.15187259018421173,
-0.15375679731369019,
-0.44538062810897827,
0.2490168809890747,
-0.020821165293455124,
-0.6109732985496521,
-0.28199344873428345,
0.08351895958185196,
0.2595379650592804,
0.7179729342460632,
-0.20888416469097137,
0.7908620834350586,
0.5314440727233887,
-0.17772407829761505,
-0.5244973301887512,
-0.5165560841560364,
0.04133483022451401,
-0.43292248249053955,
-0.6998875737190247,
0.17081010341644287,
-0.11300737410783768,
-0.33052247762680054,
-0.28703784942626953,
-0.12561774253845215,
-0.6099709272384644,
0.40029728412628174,
0.20572663843631744,
0.33169859647750854,
-0.205934077501297,
-0.1767769753932953,
-0.2595444917678833,
-0.18325629830360413,
-0.11168379336595535,
-0.2597666084766388,
0.8144373893737793,
0.1894875317811966,
0.16147693991661072,
-0.2675504982471466,
0.3711400330066681,
0.4902305006980896,
-0.35290151834487915,
0.8270784616470337,
0.7792305946350098,
-0.32727789878845215,
-0.37175390124320984,
-0.6890941858291626,
-0.2782018482685089,
-0.4373887777328491,
0.33093515038490295,
-0.3463107645511627,
-0.9660003185272217,
0.5719730257987976,
-0.060609009116888046,
-0.0575752928853035,
0.24846896529197693,
0.48256948590278625,
0.07090143114328384,
1.0531328916549683,
0.7083796262741089,
-0.5145220160484314,
0.6256328225135803,
-0.15136821568012238,
0.2478337585926056,
-0.17930801212787628,
-0.17561161518096924,
-0.8097152709960938,
-0.26208266615867615,
-0.4592270851135254,
-0.36397942900657654,
0.13246402144432068,
-0.09206650406122208,
-0.22133731842041016,
0.4111330211162567,
-0.0028880322352051735,
0.3539264500141144,
0.6744616031646729,
-0.1018436849117279,
0.19917196035385132,
0.06549320369958878,
0.166428342461586,
0.10839252173900604,
-0.8340068459510803,
-0.20491796731948853,
0.9924490451812744,
0.25032904744148254,
1.1956034898757935,
-0.32661134004592896,
0.9110569953918457,
0.14083310961723328,
0.45314350724220276,
-0.6291311383247375,
0.5234514474868774,
-0.39972618222236633,
-0.5964723229408264,
-0.04943089559674263,
-0.8062790036201477,
-1.1541246175765991,
0.1025337353348732,
-0.39752012491226196,
-0.48627132177352905,
0.17750075459480286,
0.18348078429698944,
-0.43109840154647827,
-0.03836522251367569,
-0.8251270055770874,
0.8260366320610046,
-0.038291335105895996,
-0.2377474009990692,
-0.27721452713012695,
-0.7112028002738953,
0.2736290693283081,
-0.45897921919822693,
0.3625243008136749,
0.048578694462776184,
0.05543629080057144,
0.7757887840270996,
-0.3205530047416687,
0.689457356929779,
-0.17869743704795837,
-0.04400930553674698,
0.11700151115655899,
0.15433277189731598,
0.2817027270793915,
-0.20200124382972717,
0.146592378616333,
0.10925383865833282,
-0.20887434482574463,
-0.3478122055530548,
-0.672637403011322,
0.47687000036239624,
-0.7645424008369446,
-0.42719796299934387,
-0.09451491385698318,
-0.572152853012085,
-0.49024316668510437,
0.10794557631015778,
0.17630384862422943,
0.32716792821884155,
-0.04276721924543381,
0.35781243443489075,
0.5748828053474426,
0.0013541686348617077,
0.10447932034730911,
0.46746936440467834,
-0.4253472685813904,
-0.3268926441669464,
1.4142500162124634,
0.08773432672023773,
0.16586701571941376,
0.4250509738922119,
0.2976779341697693,
-0.23168885707855225,
-0.5160120725631714,
-0.22571584582328796,
0.1636863797903061,
-0.18083801865577698,
-0.20580434799194336,
-0.5619034171104431,
-0.13725368678569794,
-0.4107312560081482,
0.1621810793876648,
-0.5494464039802551,
-0.3410086929798126,
-0.16625939309597015,
0.235385462641716,
0.07772154361009598,
0.5702237486839294,
0.0019746816251426935,
0.5222293734550476,
-0.8019565343856812,
0.2657390832901001,
0.27630648016929626,
0.35497933626174927,
-0.1919611245393753,
-0.41539469361305237,
-0.5243028402328491,
0.025882959365844727,
0.29545846581459045,
-0.46207067370414734,
0.5968250036239624,
0.1003267914056778,
0.6308588981628418,
0.4648851752281189,
-0.33189329504966736,
0.7696367502212524,
-0.4091838300228119,
0.6165715456008911,
0.15089690685272217,
-0.694191038608551,
0.3314214050769806,
-0.2555027902126312,
-0.17591246962547302,
0.7142940163612366,
0.41491615772247314,
-0.4334798753261566,
-0.6079827547073364,
-0.6269863247871399,
-0.8890597820281982,
0.646418035030365,
0.2068583369255066,
-0.1983625292778015,
0.12574663758277893,
0.1570119857788086,
0.3291550576686859,
0.366739422082901,
-0.39353668689727783,
-0.4404953718185425,
0.13152968883514404,
-0.45039528608322144,
-0.3514356315135956,
0.008348705247044563,
-0.038090284913778305,
-0.44371652603149414,
0.568670392036438,
0.09225362539291382,
0.07140765339136124,
-0.39384764432907104,
-0.1214902475476265,
-0.04120125249028206,
-0.23182033002376556,
0.4900486469268799,
0.7246729731559753,
-0.43343865871429443,
0.023560935631394386,
-0.3753925561904907,
-0.7294561862945557,
0.2821091115474701,
0.23780854046344757,
0.0496523417532444,
-0.06693832576274872,
0.27511677145957947,
0.5993025302886963,
-0.19979828596115112,
-0.938451886177063,
0.43512994050979614,
-0.2610982060432434,
-0.2033078372478485,
0.041138656437397,
0.4514971673488617,
-0.12288223206996918,
-0.005808721762150526,
0.3969230353832245,
0.15913917124271393,
0.06496254354715347,
-0.3662557899951935,
0.421184241771698,
0.21422748267650604,
-0.1414235234260559,
-0.09560634940862656,
0.6430425643920898,
0.18050526082515717,
-0.01751595176756382,
0.5247806310653687,
0.0443168543279171,
-0.3890206813812256,
0.7904374003410339,
0.6221358776092529,
0.8352956771850586,
-0.5769719481468201,
0.1209603026509285,
0.1651875078678131,
0.16641192138195038,
-0.3143361210823059,
0.36579468846321106,
0.20851576328277588,
-0.8045727610588074,
-0.6507824063301086,
-0.7011595368385315,
-0.1464792937040329,
0.22783423960208893,
-0.6387431025505066,
0.17581401765346527,
-0.25451576709747314,
-0.07156669348478317,
0.04322793334722519,
-0.007736850529909134,
-0.687595546245575,
0.6914674043655396,
0.28323128819465637,
1.0003496408462524,
-1.336543321609497,
0.9591476917266846,
0.7224250435829163,
-0.28689393401145935,
-0.8776726126670837,
0.01619401015341282,
-0.11847083270549774,
-0.797241747379303,
0.8715306520462036,
-0.006691599730402231,
-0.05856732651591301,
0.05266861245036125,
-0.48144441843032837,
-0.8315203785896301,
0.6650722026824951,
0.5103622674942017,
-0.5749927163124084,
0.296716570854187,
0.2808464765548706,
0.3401969075202942,
-0.609534740447998,
0.18095892667770386,
0.6143808364868164,
0.5108445882797241,
0.058798648416996,
-0.8619176745414734,
-0.11288899928331375,
-0.1363086700439453,
-0.00039046755409799516,
0.22529879212379456,
-0.4966897666454315,
0.9459265470504761,
0.34300699830055237,
-0.11790072172880173,
-0.05073216184973717,
0.5900711417198181,
0.13350747525691986,
0.24693036079406738,
0.7706065773963928,
0.6812301874160767,
0.7933818101882935,
-0.020531650632619858,
1.0832198858261108,
-0.512567400932312,
0.32559216022491455,
1.1354461908340454,
-0.4096604585647583,
0.8541653752326965,
0.37123727798461914,
-0.3951742351055145,
0.32466354966163635,
0.8039858341217041,
0.18571123480796814,
0.5038609504699707,
0.37386611104011536,
-0.350828617811203,
-0.6398066878318787,
-0.02252984419465065,
-0.2649202346801758,
0.42315518856048584,
0.3068610429763794,
-0.10537154227495193,
-0.23762091994285583,
0.16810497641563416,
-0.030674023553729057,
0.07025403529405594,
-0.0666227713227272,
0.6394683122634888,
-0.14840173721313477,
-0.6892460584640503,
0.5294172167778015,
-0.027436863631010056,
0.5182706713676453,
-0.747158408164978,
0.018463097512722015,
-0.3821272850036621,
0.13536100089550018,
-0.03660835325717926,
-0.57110995054245,
0.07051267474889755,
-0.1699376404285431,
-0.08730269968509674,
-0.14715160429477692,
0.6045627593994141,
-0.719187319278717,
-0.45722702145576477,
0.1864999383687973,
0.7168238162994385,
-0.10830008238554001,
-0.32696056365966797,
-0.5626260638237,
0.12389888614416122,
0.15762367844581604,
-0.11253246665000916,
0.5819175839424133,
0.2629125714302063,
0.09285827726125717,
0.7656503319740295,
0.6044299602508545,
0.2394035905599594,
0.033781252801418304,
0.18582254648208618,
0.9640234708786011,
-0.4597247540950775,
-0.46686848998069763,
-0.764175295829773,
0.39879241585731506,
-0.10657372325658798,
-0.2739087641239166,
0.5723096132278442,
1.2212380170822144,
0.7677653431892395,
-0.06132116913795471,
0.8327107429504395,
0.08611661940813065,
0.4974954426288605,
-0.3360385298728943,
0.5111436247825623,
-0.7903870344161987,
0.011833563446998596,
-0.08673322945833206,
-1.1483631134033203,
-0.45678597688674927,
0.5289395451545715,
-0.11179443448781967,
0.09041575342416763,
0.47576236724853516,
0.9202173948287964,
-0.2294822484254837,
0.12262874096632004,
0.25501054525375366,
0.1995014250278473,
0.2254546731710434,
0.2188110202550888,
0.7542847990989685,
0.018241029232740402,
0.19929762184619904,
-0.2819161117076874,
-0.42995572090148926,
-0.2809496521949768,
-0.5952832102775574,
-0.5655423402786255,
-0.7097123861312866,
-0.40624940395355225,
-0.39193665981292725,
-0.016784271225333214,
1.0398361682891846,
0.9931997656822205,
-0.6663573384284973,
-0.751585066318512,
-0.10486271977424622,
-0.12703943252563477,
-0.35465824604034424,
-0.27101799845695496,
-0.018067505210638046,
-0.6668579578399658,
-0.7331390976905823,
0.45275309681892395,
0.2066497802734375,
-0.0009577901801094413,
-0.18016992509365082,
0.06023630499839783,
-0.1349358856678009,
0.14591488242149353,
0.42474180459976196,
0.024844089522957802,
-0.3412424325942993,
0.07821213454008102,
-0.049366191029548645,
-0.24293792247772217,
0.08662613481283188,
1.1700481176376343,
-0.8598608374595642,
0.523192286491394,
0.496914267539978,
0.880580723285675,
0.5307832956314087,
0.21408617496490479,
0.8127211332321167,
-0.751982569694519,
0.10381428897380829,
0.3407945930957794,
0.29879263043403625,
0.003522529499605298,
-0.20272856950759888,
0.48925942182540894,
0.42450544238090515,
-0.36532554030418396,
-0.7119377255439758,
-0.005442682188004255,
-1.10264253616333,
-0.442550390958786,
1.2285072803497314,
0.027165768668055534,
-0.2977323532104492,
-0.2279336154460907,
-0.21420849859714508,
0.025958649814128876,
-0.45390865206718445,
0.6032708287239075,
0.6809722781181335,
-0.069696806371212,
0.09246811270713806,
-0.5982447266578674,
0.46941378712654114,
0.3966711163520813,
-0.7191510200500488,
0.19259633123874664,
0.54681795835495,
0.384711354970932,
-0.16371269524097443,
0.3664962947368622,
0.204542338848114,
-0.05392027646303177,
0.10847505927085876,
0.12865447998046875,
0.05336170271039009,
-0.4892679452896118,
-0.15494132041931152,
0.10507284849882126,
-0.06981385499238968,
-0.15340659022331238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01491v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01491v1 | Expressive and Generalizable Low-rank Adaptation for Large Models via Slow Cascaded Learning | 2024-07-01T17:28:59 | 2024-07-01T17:28:59 | Siwei Li, Yifan Yang, Yifei Shen, Fangyun Wei, Zongqing Lu, Lili Qiu, Yuqing Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Efficient fine-tuning plays a fundamental role in modern large models, with
low-rank adaptation emerging as a particularly promising approach. However, the
existing variants of LoRA are hampered by limited expressiveness, a tendency to
overfit, and sensitivity to hyperparameter settings. This paper presents LoRA
Slow Cascade Learning (LoRASC), an innovative technique designed to enhance
LoRA's expressiveness and generalization capabilities while preserving its
training efficiency. Our approach augments expressiveness through a cascaded
learning strategy that enables a mixture-of-low-rank adaptation, thereby
increasing the model's ability to capture complex patterns. Additionally, we
introduce a slow-fast update mechanism and cascading noisy tuning to bolster
generalization. The extensive experiments on various language and vision
datasets, as well as robustness benchmarks, demonstrate that the proposed
method not only significantly outperforms existing baselines, but also
mitigates overfitting, enhances model stability, and improves OOD robustness.
Code will be release in https://github.com/microsoft/LoRASC very soon. | [
-0.17069777846336365,
-0.8197929263114929,
0.18150340020656586,
0.1429794281721115,
-0.3728320002555847,
-0.0009654985624365509,
-0.4207240045070648,
-0.6413177847862244,
0.21084684133529663,
0.171030655503273,
-0.42066457867622375,
-0.6552929282188416,
-0.6290420293807983,
-0.27619874477386475,
-0.36306944489479065,
1.1131374835968018,
0.05541441962122917,
-0.27311357855796814,
0.22775039076805115,
-0.5212027430534363,
-0.25857990980148315,
-0.20043790340423584,
-0.889992356300354,
-0.32098522782325745,
1.1813503503799438,
0.3554908037185669,
0.5961409211158752,
0.5920721292495728,
0.5666545629501343,
0.2644157409667969,
-0.2671610116958618,
0.31421178579330444,
-0.8045523762702942,
0.1862955093383789,
-0.3738948702812195,
-0.4839590787887573,
-0.8661341071128845,
-0.1947350800037384,
0.6784611940383911,
0.8599606156349182,
-0.3304077684879303,
0.3166753649711609,
0.47831687331199646,
0.7938811182975769,
-1.3232147693634033,
0.21207143366336823,
-0.7511412501335144,
0.05989151820540428,
-0.25975358486175537,
-0.13521072268486023,
-0.358515202999115,
-0.18395903706550598,
0.05050649121403694,
-0.786068856716156,
-0.20882634818553925,
-0.1864626705646515,
0.6168168187141418,
0.5847426652908325,
-0.13808399438858032,
0.013330044224858284,
-0.8092139363288879,
0.863620400428772,
-0.601694643497467,
0.01897485740482807,
0.2229768931865692,
0.66361004114151,
-0.026974502950906754,
-0.7079386711120605,
-0.0442713126540184,
-0.09522592276334763,
0.29770204424858093,
0.22062861919403076,
-0.30359381437301636,
-0.11882518976926804,
0.40856608748435974,
0.29007434844970703,
-0.11621540039777756,
0.6516382694244385,
0.04904696345329285,
-0.004061336163431406,
0.27685999870300293,
0.10585109889507294,
-0.171073317527771,
0.28255462646484375,
-0.24141505360603333,
0.015379419550299644,
-0.6595388650894165,
0.2301296889781952,
0.06843890249729156,
0.6906543970108032,
-0.3636402487754822,
0.3586035370826721,
-0.49659913778305054,
0.8764671683311462,
0.31313419342041016,
-0.04947376251220703,
0.20624935626983643,
0.11164744943380356,
-0.2753007411956787,
-0.15282781422138214,
0.3460804522037506,
-0.012177595868706703,
0.032795630395412445,
-0.0689922422170639,
-0.3617497980594635,
0.06812901794910431,
-0.13735027611255646,
-0.8735156655311584,
0.14496351778507233,
0.09195248037576675,
-0.6391004323959351,
-0.646704912185669,
-0.20033758878707886,
-0.6151100397109985,
-0.45039603114128113,
-0.45310601592063904,
0.5559080839157104,
-0.06091783195734024,
0.20418769121170044,
0.1188618466258049,
0.30925247073173523,
0.467749685049057,
0.9109645485877991,
-0.8170362710952759,
0.4200524687767029,
0.6032536029815674,
0.9176148772239685,
-0.282889187335968,
-0.4660094380378723,
-1.3918858766555786,
0.12547899782657623,
-0.5101279616355896,
0.6786021590232849,
-0.3847930133342743,
0.1325673609972,
-0.13641424477100372,
-0.1803886741399765,
0.05817658454179764,
-0.6081162691116333,
0.42754408717155457,
-0.5123226642608643,
-0.10031866282224655,
-0.12239184230566025,
0.2251594513654709,
0.19887754321098328,
0.03374315798282623,
-0.7433784008026123,
0.9526354670524597,
0.19819451868534088,
-0.7614359259605408,
0.34983035922050476,
-0.8448386788368225,
-0.5761364102363586,
-0.15862755477428436,
-0.03022388555109501,
-0.46832528710365295,
0.40719565749168396,
0.26260772347450256,
0.32832834124565125,
-0.167046457529068,
-0.18235954642295837,
-0.4168538451194763,
-0.6519608497619629,
0.12026794999837875,
-0.10465651005506516,
0.5641729235649109,
0.2625844478607178,
-0.09882916510105133,
0.20096810162067413,
-0.7839959263801575,
0.02841951884329319,
0.04542090371251106,
-0.6505177617073059,
-0.30250105261802673,
0.20671717822551727,
-0.04995173588395119,
0.22147223353385925,
0.10895217955112457,
-0.22541411221027374,
0.594094455242157,
-0.32589149475097656,
0.6570951342582703,
0.8394766449928284,
-0.2204154133796692,
0.46381035447120667,
-0.2620536983013153,
0.28772395849227905,
0.37974995374679565,
0.19101323187351227,
0.026436684653162956,
-0.3009304404258728,
-0.9061466455459595,
-0.5684851408004761,
0.7547200918197632,
0.5244261622428894,
-0.8928890228271484,
0.455562561750412,
-0.43594637513160706,
-0.3085532486438751,
-0.4650656282901764,
0.4031864404678345,
0.3170776963233948,
0.46233421564102173,
0.4322662353515625,
-0.6163131594657898,
-0.2730534076690674,
-0.6907839775085449,
-0.4470100998878479,
0.1547580063343048,
-0.016592908650636673,
0.18876929581165314,
0.46586793661117554,
-0.19788406789302826,
0.8979772925376892,
-0.533374011516571,
-0.7052630186080933,
-0.39754024147987366,
0.3451760411262512,
0.1672196090221405,
0.5907847285270691,
0.7065277695655823,
-0.48347851634025574,
-0.4128004312515259,
0.1637621819972992,
-0.5748399496078491,
0.08606428653001785,
0.19866310060024261,
-0.3448978066444397,
-0.022182010114192963,
0.6044356822967529,
-0.5320039987564087,
0.5629183053970337,
0.5659255981445312,
0.07613083720207214,
0.059116363525390625,
-0.12664727866649628,
-0.11218972504138947,
-1.041455626487732,
0.24501031637191772,
-0.10193564742803574,
-0.38024985790252686,
-0.49497994780540466,
0.22112970054149628,
-0.15530259907245636,
-0.32852524518966675,
-0.6535126566886902,
0.4792947471141815,
-0.32028767466545105,
-0.1351252943277359,
-0.21726839244365692,
0.08499764651060104,
-0.2113654762506485,
0.6016327142715454,
-0.06926410645246506,
0.38637199997901917,
0.9539497494697571,
-0.5313318967819214,
0.04607320576906204,
0.11494240909814835,
-0.6444610953330994,
0.62009197473526,
-0.49216827750205994,
0.2670113444328308,
-0.2591550052165985,
0.6270298361778259,
-0.4102419316768646,
-0.4672430157661438,
0.12303296476602554,
-0.01180736068636179,
0.2920348644256592,
-0.48713600635528564,
-0.19069278240203857,
-0.03350336477160454,
-0.4120020270347595,
0.5134309530258179,
0.7600080370903015,
-0.6980863213539124,
1.0586822032928467,
-0.1064697802066803,
0.06563830375671387,
-0.7257890105247498,
-1.0333861112594604,
-0.14091412723064423,
-0.2605954110622406,
-0.26252487301826477,
0.27589836716651917,
-0.020850224420428276,
-0.09041562676429749,
-0.3479413092136383,
-0.06767898797988892,
0.03960258141160011,
0.4001210033893585,
0.1381591111421585,
0.1323561668395996,
-0.4390312731266022,
-0.047020941972732544,
0.006957868114113808,
-0.0649024173617363,
-0.6357162594795227,
-0.2449713945388794,
0.40903833508491516,
-0.07366303354501724,
-0.29598695039749146,
-0.6036543250083923,
0.21317905187606812,
0.7124084830284119,
-0.25792261958122253,
0.6644681692123413,
0.6884860992431641,
-0.4261014461517334,
-0.7704339027404785,
-0.14517289400100708,
-0.11747163534164429,
-0.44463393092155457,
0.47375214099884033,
-0.5239765048027039,
-0.6902962327003479,
0.7728756666183472,
-0.3847694396972656,
-0.08786077797412872,
0.3743862211704254,
0.6536259055137634,
-0.0720338448882103,
0.931402325630188,
0.8332038521766663,
-0.41793501377105713,
0.8845603466033936,
-0.33312490582466125,
0.018629709258675575,
-0.9087870717048645,
0.029714923352003098,
-0.662962794303894,
-0.8485462665557861,
-0.6584941744804382,
-0.5290659666061401,
0.31330373883247375,
0.3361000716686249,
-0.15600961446762085,
0.09330322593450546,
-0.0819988027215004,
0.5820453763008118,
0.2737351059913635,
0.43461596965789795,
0.4969954788684845,
0.23134765028953552,
0.33802634477615356,
0.3087652623653412,
-0.5442253947257996,
-0.017980236560106277,
0.7899302840232849,
0.3822733759880066,
1.3391733169555664,
0.30039405822753906,
0.6374562382698059,
0.4276438057422638,
0.28681713342666626,
-1.0508891344070435,
0.35692858695983887,
-0.647698163986206,
-0.1134282797574997,
-0.2905418574810028,
-0.5736387968063354,
-0.7691187262535095,
0.13481658697128296,
-0.280640572309494,
-0.6900427341461182,
0.6734350323677063,
0.5257682800292969,
-0.6025195121765137,
0.20217037200927734,
-0.4546873867511749,
0.6454532742500305,
-0.0698002353310585,
-0.6160337328910828,
-0.25263741612434387,
-0.6279672980308533,
0.24784629046916962,
-0.31175294518470764,
0.116043820977211,
-0.0599193274974823,
-0.20118682086467743,
0.5806025266647339,
-0.35061049461364746,
1.060533046722412,
-0.3624729812145233,
-0.3019387722015381,
0.12898604571819305,
0.10816745460033417,
0.8848527073860168,
-0.3094768524169922,
-0.1566053330898285,
0.07859779894351959,
-0.469684362411499,
-0.7075536847114563,
-0.906252384185791,
0.8495250344276428,
-0.6755657196044922,
-0.13861973583698273,
-0.2369602769613266,
-0.43406954407691956,
-0.4751090407371521,
-0.016745533794164658,
0.1525297909975052,
0.45808857679367065,
-0.3143567442893982,
0.125952810049057,
0.5182197093963623,
0.00012033072562189773,
0.3754771947860718,
0.3383716344833374,
-0.23747257888317108,
-0.030848268419504166,
1.0903445482254028,
-0.0072685652412474155,
0.5351875424385071,
0.3087451756000519,
0.3540414273738861,
0.3067071735858917,
-0.6297492980957031,
-0.33005037903785706,
-0.04160873219370842,
-0.8473089933395386,
-0.23010462522506714,
-0.16576744616031647,
-0.21387328207492828,
-0.09745512902736664,
-0.17776881158351898,
-0.3618723750114441,
-0.6760640144348145,
-0.4406198561191559,
0.37552446126937866,
0.19692417979240417,
0.7454262971878052,
-0.00879912544041872,
0.4611378312110901,
-0.12970535457134247,
0.6227912902832031,
0.5981733798980713,
0.35871079564094543,
0.1472581923007965,
-0.7660125494003296,
-0.4421125650405884,
-0.04807459935545921,
-0.253522127866745,
-0.005554645787924528,
0.06540360301733017,
0.8538432121276855,
0.14686232805252075,
0.5592483282089233,
-0.1205364242196083,
0.8871257901191711,
-0.35941311717033386,
0.5017849206924438,
0.2571357190608978,
-1.010450839996338,
0.6076037287712097,
-0.3578779697418213,
0.5163249969482422,
0.68682861328125,
0.1703244149684906,
-0.14876215159893036,
-0.05057235062122345,
-0.15817797183990479,
-0.6347264647483826,
0.5885066390037537,
-0.08210309594869614,
0.02848845161497593,
0.4699731469154358,
0.3274528980255127,
0.034990113228559494,
0.030800608918070793,
-0.6130193471908569,
0.16185562312602997,
-0.2918069064617157,
-0.23196259140968323,
-0.09840632230043411,
0.09376879781484604,
-0.3469717502593994,
-0.37499967217445374,
0.48800092935562134,
-0.6499324440956116,
-0.021327028051018715,
-0.09848401695489883,
-0.35251152515411377,
-0.1932433843612671,
0.35618072748184204,
0.5775340795516968,
0.4391670525074005,
-0.23564141988754272,
0.11171486228704453,
0.2192162424325943,
-0.4683527648448944,
-0.11402907222509384,
-0.10873090475797653,
-0.16610200703144073,
-0.5157434940338135,
0.5788801908493042,
0.8768054246902466,
0.42993178963661194,
-0.41968968510627747,
0.5699214339256287,
0.1438731700181961,
0.020514370873570442,
0.33380645513534546,
0.14292526245117188,
-0.19897028803825378,
0.18213409185409546,
0.45803582668304443,
0.5782036781311035,
0.06022324785590172,
-0.8403013348579407,
-0.33808037638664246,
0.3949527442455292,
-0.3726557195186615,
-0.3907933831214905,
0.5113754868507385,
0.1804196983575821,
0.10594580322504044,
0.3143429458141327,
0.09620459377765656,
-0.2011755257844925,
0.24389944970607758,
0.3673076331615448,
0.9679571986198425,
-0.08447372168302536,
0.012315343134105206,
0.04177694395184517,
-0.025277670472860336,
-0.2351667284965515,
0.18885184824466705,
-0.20187167823314667,
-0.5315597057342529,
-0.5869625210762024,
-0.7189800143241882,
-0.3834061920642853,
-0.054436516016721725,
-0.7838574647903442,
0.501060426235199,
-0.6243035197257996,
-0.27809229493141174,
0.17925648391246796,
-0.24080979824066162,
-0.5647097229957581,
-0.01087633054703474,
0.17302876710891724,
1.0204384326934814,
-1.0026934146881104,
0.9548303484916687,
0.4646466076374054,
-0.34603041410446167,
-0.47101733088493347,
0.2785201966762543,
-0.1691688448190689,
-0.7622296810150146,
0.8905444145202637,
-0.17055818438529968,
-0.6440607905387878,
0.15310214459896088,
-0.9814977049827576,
-0.9128037691116333,
1.1373074054718018,
0.6588771343231201,
-0.5276570916175842,
-0.2837337851524353,
-0.045177146792411804,
0.6684359908103943,
-0.5531740784645081,
0.007689178455621004,
0.44733676314353943,
0.31771308183670044,
0.17775262892246246,
-0.8729313611984253,
-0.14862839877605438,
-0.03561067581176758,
0.1599915623664856,
-0.11348894983530045,
-0.8168027400970459,
1.0191932916641235,
-0.3389727771282196,
-0.06412803381681442,
0.5068730711936951,
0.6793032288551331,
-0.014419169165194035,
0.06937672942876816,
0.5113540291786194,
0.7026531100273132,
0.6616474986076355,
-0.10593095421791077,
0.8246022462844849,
-0.008689659647643566,
0.37977832555770874,
1.3455063104629517,
-0.6058211922645569,
1.1585792303085327,
0.41149264574050903,
0.13776880502700806,
0.9230606555938721,
0.41283726692199707,
0.25814616680145264,
0.8044888377189636,
0.27325376868247986,
-0.13652510941028595,
-0.41583898663520813,
-0.22775867581367493,
-0.20493827760219574,
0.6788869500160217,
0.2604331970214844,
-0.2769589126110077,
-0.41662752628326416,
0.2927274703979492,
-0.4231003224849701,
-0.24052657186985016,
-0.822160005569458,
0.7656088471412659,
0.12596182525157928,
-0.3994966447353363,
0.8817133903503418,
-0.16431988775730133,
0.650155246257782,
-0.6491025686264038,
-0.09423299878835678,
-0.19728313386440277,
0.47485920786857605,
-0.5430397391319275,
-0.2712463438510895,
-0.21625520288944244,
-0.1381673961877823,
-0.24537834525108337,
0.06393574178218842,
0.5885823369026184,
-0.24204394221305847,
-0.3896360397338867,
0.3163701593875885,
0.5375257730484009,
-0.04174785315990448,
-0.0007761625456623733,
-0.5876715183258057,
0.43689554929733276,
-0.4431665539741516,
-0.10694030672311783,
0.5978903770446777,
0.3875046372413635,
-0.48472344875335693,
0.7256066799163818,
0.541377604007721,
0.32619184255599976,
-0.1239345595240593,
0.4911339282989502,
1.1352862119674683,
-0.4204446077346802,
-0.4094986021518707,
-0.46509212255477905,
0.45231449604034424,
0.16401702165603638,
-0.260293185710907,
0.3614473342895508,
0.4970470070838928,
0.5167840123176575,
-0.19457808136940002,
0.6655948162078857,
0.01593651808798313,
0.5676494240760803,
-0.8603479266166687,
0.6201159954071045,
-0.5866411328315735,
0.25782981514930725,
-0.3283987045288086,
-1.0504813194274902,
-0.3393058180809021,
0.4899565577507019,
-0.33937811851501465,
0.2245682328939438,
0.626433789730072,
0.5444343686103821,
-0.6604062914848328,
-0.4753402769565582,
0.4264107048511505,
0.6052184700965881,
-0.06831349432468414,
0.7092614769935608,
1.0095200538635254,
-0.42956608533859253,
0.17220930755138397,
-0.12705154716968536,
-0.4901057183742523,
-0.43319371342658997,
-1.0642212629318237,
-0.8862640261650085,
-0.30593341588974,
-0.47023293375968933,
-0.44482871890068054,
0.097652368247509,
0.8103976249694824,
0.9596210718154907,
-0.8691168427467346,
-0.15448294579982758,
0.1763029247522354,
-0.08115579187870026,
-0.5513518452644348,
-0.12396590411663055,
0.48236072063446045,
-0.1980147510766983,
-0.630961000919342,
0.4843967854976654,
0.20031537115573883,
-0.013903310522437096,
-0.23754137754440308,
-0.06861650198698044,
0.06952270120382309,
0.1757402867078781,
0.9453921914100647,
0.5719655156135559,
-0.6169567108154297,
-0.23763735592365265,
-0.4878090023994446,
-0.05330587178468704,
0.20408542454242706,
0.9711440205574036,
-1.0530097484588623,
0.05289717763662338,
0.2756633162498474,
0.44392094016075134,
0.5867477655410767,
0.388870507478714,
0.005981958005577326,
-0.6697279214859009,
0.45945248007774353,
0.19947990775108337,
0.20529747009277344,
0.20754416286945343,
-0.10242274403572083,
0.33477383852005005,
0.057552799582481384,
-0.2761300504207611,
-0.9021216034889221,
0.4219132959842682,
-1.493811011314392,
-0.14986568689346313,
0.8275424838066101,
-0.0842016339302063,
-0.5442276000976562,
0.10759805887937546,
-0.14726214110851288,
-0.06952641904354095,
-0.47359755635261536,
0.733574628829956,
0.1840006411075592,
-0.12304820120334625,
0.15844328701496124,
-0.3270777463912964,
0.6016222238540649,
0.23980706930160522,
-0.9712181091308594,
0.30715376138687134,
0.3217657804489136,
0.2350413054227829,
0.15199661254882812,
0.4661101698875427,
0.04133927449584007,
0.44792479276657104,
-0.4382687211036682,
-0.2073362171649933,
0.19202430546283722,
-0.4367202818393707,
-0.7958133220672607,
0.1837112456560135,
0.4945201277732849,
0.05645027384161949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01490v1 | LLM See, LLM Do: Guiding Data Generation to Target Non-Differentiable Objectives | 2024-07-01T17:26:21 | 2024-07-01T17:26:21 | Luísa Shimabucoro, Sebastian Ruder, Julia Kreutzer, Marzieh Fadaee, Sara Hooker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The widespread adoption of synthetic data raises new questions about how
models generating the data can influence other large language models (LLMs) via
distilled data. To start, our work exhaustively characterizes the impact of
passive inheritance of model properties by systematically studying the
consequences of synthetic data integration. We provide one of the most
comprehensive studies to-date of how the source of synthetic data shapes
models' internal biases, calibration and generations' textual attributes and
preferences. We find that models are surprisingly sensitive towards certain
attributes even when the synthetic data prompts appear "neutral". which invites
the question whether this sensitivity can be exploited for good.
Our findings invite the question can we explicitly steer the models towards
the properties we want at test time by exploiting the data generation process?
This would have historically been considered infeasible due to the cost of
collecting data with a specific characteristic or objective in mind. However,
improvement in the quality of synthetic data, as well as a shift towards
general-purpose models designed to follow a diverse way of instructions, means
this question is timely. We propose active inheritance as a term to describe
intentionally constraining synthetic data according to a non-differentiable
objective. We demonstrate how active inheritance can steer the generation
profiles of models towards desirable non-differentiable attributes, e.g. high
lexical diversity or low toxicity. | [
-0.09739582240581512,
-0.712636411190033,
0.42396634817123413,
0.12807680666446686,
-0.007236948702484369,
0.07986725121736526,
-0.08632411062717438,
-0.5094313621520996,
-0.14815093576908112,
0.5849985480308533,
-0.5965240597724915,
-0.14742043614387512,
-0.5971769690513611,
0.05627545714378357,
-0.45199066400527954,
0.9469630718231201,
-0.22801540791988373,
0.06330127269029617,
-0.1098695769906044,
-0.08086052536964417,
0.018930833786725998,
-0.5686480402946472,
-0.15306007862091064,
-0.28187018632888794,
0.6890693306922913,
0.3431335389614105,
0.9383261799812317,
0.8216686844825745,
0.07690836489200592,
0.18980272114276886,
-0.2957994043827057,
0.19350281357765198,
-0.8054018020629883,
0.4446642994880676,
-0.3491400480270386,
-0.7550104856491089,
-0.5393223166465759,
0.42948150634765625,
0.5711942315101624,
1.0480672121047974,
0.199824720621109,
0.040683187544345856,
0.029145734384655952,
0.6082944869995117,
-0.7388963103294373,
-0.03618074953556061,
-0.7638684511184692,
-0.04963945597410202,
-0.15328629314899445,
-0.06144975125789642,
-0.4095529019832611,
-0.19411663711071014,
0.05001569539308548,
-0.2762759327888489,
0.5519648194313049,
-0.07101628929376602,
0.6228388547897339,
0.2678983509540558,
-0.8955894112586975,
-0.26324906945228577,
-1.0802602767944336,
1.0576069355010986,
-0.6943729519844055,
0.3347771465778351,
0.3375658094882965,
-0.06207367405295372,
-0.33262449502944946,
-0.6279276609420776,
-0.7324044108390808,
-0.4574328660964966,
0.14663757383823395,
0.1687990128993988,
-0.2834845185279846,
0.03176434338092804,
0.2637234330177307,
0.601505696773529,
-0.10351692140102386,
0.022866200655698776,
-0.6537935137748718,
0.027388831600546837,
0.8501886129379272,
0.029533565044403076,
0.3436841666698456,
0.08132044225931168,
-0.1748894304037094,
0.0424361489713192,
-1.0988749265670776,
-0.22602123022079468,
0.8938419818878174,
0.6250045895576477,
-0.07171101123094559,
1.0479687452316284,
-0.3110063374042511,
0.4574756324291229,
0.1913592368364334,
0.17948168516159058,
0.23238347470760345,
-0.6701931357383728,
0.08587443083524704,
0.2826174199581146,
0.3423057794570923,
0.018567368388175964,
0.2594974935054779,
-0.15534751117229462,
-0.42167648673057556,
0.27376997470855713,
0.28961822390556335,
-0.5668666958808899,
-0.20660488307476044,
0.12610946595668793,
-0.2519632577896118,
-0.5801783800125122,
0.0716439038515091,
-0.5432879328727722,
-0.15052464604377747,
-0.8027045130729675,
0.27120354771614075,
-0.03392394259572029,
-0.3718307316303253,
0.09120871871709824,
-0.1255532205104828,
0.2731601893901825,
0.1579696238040924,
-0.9845390319824219,
0.22754326462745667,
0.46732622385025024,
0.533840000629425,
-0.4168054461479187,
0.005851276684552431,
-0.46447837352752686,
0.3638451397418976,
-0.342936247587204,
0.6237798929214478,
-0.849135160446167,
-0.7292806506156921,
-0.27351897954940796,
0.21268808841705322,
0.11342136561870575,
-0.6480589509010315,
0.3850648105144501,
-0.33793288469314575,
0.3588894307613373,
-0.14911283552646637,
-0.08519890159368515,
-0.04224620759487152,
-0.11462274193763733,
-0.77338707447052,
0.9805585145950317,
0.29207777976989746,
-0.4995395243167877,
0.5490186810493469,
-0.4948749244213104,
-0.6820169687271118,
-0.19542096555233002,
-0.03876757621765137,
-0.42199254035949707,
0.5034614205360413,
-0.08444710820913315,
0.19240520894527435,
-0.42662402987480164,
0.17139320075511932,
-0.4975958466529846,
0.07266274839639664,
0.24929368495941162,
-0.6096015572547913,
0.7273262143135071,
0.27619659900665283,
-0.5963241457939148,
0.08317490667104721,
-0.8788812160491943,
0.03706252947449684,
0.042101629078388214,
-0.23631899058818817,
-0.4526923596858978,
0.20606842637062073,
-0.03648946061730385,
0.2567487359046936,
0.3040977120399475,
-0.43107330799102783,
0.4053768515586853,
-0.12204021215438843,
0.20187251269817352,
0.8274609446525574,
0.24986371397972107,
0.7474881410598755,
-0.5224087238311768,
0.5319070816040039,
0.2295343279838562,
0.330494225025177,
0.3247159719467163,
-0.47946083545684814,
-0.718969464302063,
-0.07874739170074463,
0.35175856947898865,
0.21540957689285278,
-0.4289984703063965,
0.25959303975105286,
0.13574104011058807,
-0.5349138379096985,
-0.6094456315040588,
0.38949206471443176,
0.29477551579475403,
0.33972805738449097,
0.22580669820308685,
-0.1412404179573059,
-0.5027649402618408,
-1.191616177558899,
0.12828785181045532,
-0.2424733191728592,
0.08454962074756622,
0.3710062801837921,
0.31417930126190186,
-0.4392106831073761,
0.660987138748169,
-0.4429287612438202,
0.2487764209508896,
-0.6193352341651917,
0.04526596888899803,
0.05552482604980469,
0.42951151728630066,
0.3717566132545471,
-1.0278517007827759,
-0.4386661648750305,
-0.05142734944820404,
-0.6430255770683289,
-0.5928722620010376,
-0.03885122388601303,
-0.362632155418396,
-0.12983295321464539,
-0.0015010557835921645,
-0.47546640038490295,
0.28094854950904846,
0.6247547268867493,
-0.27128785848617554,
0.3691850006580353,
-0.13294535875320435,
-0.07432349026203156,
-0.9028817415237427,
0.027942443266510963,
0.019076194614171982,
0.08938600867986679,
-0.926412045955658,
-0.1352158933877945,
-0.019013499841094017,
0.059146616607904434,
-0.6543562412261963,
0.7151776552200317,
-0.6514216661453247,
0.0753873884677887,
-0.31528589129447937,
-0.1394210159778595,
0.15326131880283356,
0.15541388094425201,
0.09904607385396957,
0.6922661066055298,
0.5946258902549744,
-0.8669400811195374,
0.3087986409664154,
0.1613849699497223,
0.0666552260518074,
0.48612359166145325,
-0.4935620427131653,
0.1283027082681656,
-0.2911251485347748,
-0.0014924508286640048,
-0.6005702614784241,
-0.21134591102600098,
0.0794878825545311,
-0.2625199854373932,
0.4601128399372101,
-0.15127570927143097,
-0.35655707120895386,
0.22177599370479584,
-0.19901342689990997,
0.30692407488822937,
0.5347323417663574,
-0.40966343879699707,
0.5064688324928284,
0.3811531364917755,
-0.11275728791952133,
-0.28038954734802246,
-0.7621164917945862,
-0.01968420296907425,
-0.2912083864212036,
-0.7152182459831238,
0.4898671805858612,
-0.03808034956455231,
-0.7606722116470337,
0.23477719724178314,
-0.2687591314315796,
0.023517770692706108,
0.11535871773958206,
0.25146862864494324,
0.37020647525787354,
-0.26486846804618835,
-0.07595483213663101,
0.2738788425922394,
-0.05707997828722,
-0.16119980812072754,
-0.08643047511577606,
0.14815972745418549,
0.4433731734752655,
-0.31517013907432556,
-0.19491079449653625,
0.34276247024536133,
0.6309119462966919,
-0.11200868338346481,
0.8366775512695312,
-0.20066754519939423,
-0.09425805509090424,
-0.8986634612083435,
-0.05592665448784828,
-0.29088568687438965,
-0.4709268808364868,
0.15181243419647217,
-0.18452446162700653,
-0.32308024168014526,
0.31712087988853455,
-0.0817507803440094,
0.2413371056318283,
0.5588394403457642,
0.7801663875579834,
0.03724360093474388,
1.1946271657943726,
0.6728527545928955,
0.30096566677093506,
0.5776570439338684,
-0.3295258581638336,
0.1516902893781662,
-0.7976763248443604,
-0.23032960295677185,
-0.3170177638530731,
-0.6358075737953186,
-0.7055008411407471,
-0.36878228187561035,
0.0607333742082119,
0.1578907072544098,
0.09374900162220001,
0.16903984546661377,
-0.5238869786262512,
0.20722824335098267,
0.4055652618408203,
0.02580951526761055,
0.31170913577079773,
-0.186112642288208,
0.18495354056358337,
0.05563583970069885,
-0.5072490572929382,
-0.7805101871490479,
1.3929029703140259,
0.18786807358264923,
1.171760082244873,
0.20323827862739563,
0.5640246272087097,
0.3724885880947113,
0.5110284686088562,
-0.5735234022140503,
0.49232572317123413,
-0.2779568135738373,
-0.9176743626594543,
0.029165105894207954,
-0.44346722960472107,
-0.9379374980926514,
-0.0032292581163346767,
0.027009176090359688,
-0.21749697625637054,
0.5679382681846619,
0.17753776907920837,
0.15678490698337555,
0.21404637396335602,
-0.9690262079238892,
0.5541270971298218,
-0.7439422011375427,
-0.8035928010940552,
0.03369836509227753,
-0.3720441460609436,
0.487545907497406,
-0.370650976896286,
-0.10988162457942963,
-0.3808346688747406,
-0.24836745858192444,
0.4645293354988098,
-0.24858233332633972,
1.0349068641662598,
-0.3705679476261139,
-0.14481504261493683,
0.42281854152679443,
0.14794142544269562,
0.6629377007484436,
-0.22967080771923065,
-0.48833170533180237,
0.06613703817129135,
0.03505191206932068,
-0.47804591059684753,
-0.4628656506538391,
0.72383713722229,
-0.8754754066467285,
-0.7357701063156128,
-0.3339199721813202,
-0.42389482259750366,
-0.3506546914577484,
0.0915689691901207,
-0.04358203336596489,
0.13575197756290436,
-0.10639964789152145,
0.39099451899528503,
0.590924084186554,
-0.23359914124011993,
-0.052042923867702484,
0.6611432433128357,
-0.023043638095259666,
0.1429188847541809,
0.9339377284049988,
0.270805686712265,
0.8801167011260986,
0.1325628161430359,
0.35013213753700256,
-0.43093058466911316,
-0.8257057070732117,
-0.24204936623573303,
0.1960994303226471,
-0.5831688046455383,
0.11761458963155746,
-0.3853108286857605,
-0.2731040418148041,
-0.26221075654029846,
-0.0925707295536995,
-0.35649922490119934,
-0.5892600417137146,
-0.6172880530357361,
-0.4193134307861328,
0.337319552898407,
0.9363741874694824,
-0.0704006478190422,
0.11929305642843246,
-0.43698713183403015,
0.5054332613945007,
0.18250109255313873,
0.00640486553311348,
-0.33220699429512024,
-0.596724808216095,
0.23704172670841217,
0.3115600347518921,
-0.5032603144645691,
-0.8684002757072449,
0.3746762275695801,
0.3217323422431946,
1.0611375570297241,
0.30194908380508423,
0.29097145795822144,
0.19406796991825104,
-0.1273442953824997,
0.5411387085914612,
-0.2610683739185333,
-0.6908215284347534,
0.5399606227874756,
-0.4799886643886566,
0.1253393441438675,
0.5657124519348145,
0.36750566959381104,
-0.20913681387901306,
-0.5827875733375549,
-0.6756592988967896,
-0.9113191366195679,
0.67806077003479,
0.33237767219543457,
0.547619640827179,
0.12644806504249573,
0.4667608141899109,
0.48528045415878296,
0.24091938138008118,
-0.8822746872901917,
-0.1527366191148758,
-0.15382742881774902,
-0.27627936005592346,
0.16976076364517212,
-0.0992094874382019,
-0.10117120295763016,
-0.012756535783410072,
0.6614766120910645,
0.045412562787532806,
-0.005913325119763613,
-0.04961475357413292,
-0.08554012328386307,
-0.16177666187286377,
0.41382458806037903,
0.3972162902355194,
0.48787856101989746,
-0.01492565218359232,
0.4105421304702759,
0.0032452624291181564,
-0.4042704701423645,
0.336342453956604,
-0.09569642692804337,
-0.48143118619918823,
-0.19384950399398804,
0.27743375301361084,
0.6987872123718262,
0.005760170053690672,
-0.5418993830680847,
0.21486899256706238,
0.2588021755218506,
-0.43451955914497375,
0.022571856155991554,
0.5185862183570862,
-0.0872083231806755,
0.10371308773756027,
0.3058728277683258,
-0.08710934221744537,
-0.23686693608760834,
-1.013662338256836,
0.3308577537536621,
0.41594529151916504,
-0.20817089080810547,
-0.7835354208946228,
0.7075591683387756,
0.25904715061187744,
-0.12074536830186844,
0.5369842648506165,
-0.14314226806163788,
-0.27289363741874695,
0.5377597212791443,
0.6383432745933533,
0.9036955833435059,
-0.3421363830566406,
0.042477529495954514,
-0.0019831997342407703,
0.2416805624961853,
-0.07569576799869537,
0.49656060338020325,
0.03676703944802284,
-0.807666003704071,
-0.12450151890516281,
-0.6948502659797668,
-0.46175873279571533,
0.1064215824007988,
-0.36544865369796753,
0.45098966360092163,
-0.5198787450790405,
-0.14387208223342896,
0.15081322193145752,
-0.35798272490501404,
-0.38503527641296387,
0.16635841131210327,
0.16252285242080688,
0.35910528898239136,
-0.8429478406906128,
0.8627047538757324,
0.43567579984664917,
-0.40252214670181274,
-0.4533635377883911,
0.1322033554315567,
0.11109184473752975,
-0.7550957202911377,
1.0081015825271606,
-0.14030514657497406,
-0.06867793202400208,
-0.0015312230680137873,
-0.5553299784660339,
-0.7116451263427734,
0.7899938225746155,
0.43948623538017273,
-0.4463437795639038,
-0.19066356122493744,
0.1611955314874649,
0.6043439507484436,
-0.28848862648010254,
-0.21118931472301483,
0.38104358315467834,
0.6487060189247131,
0.44877469539642334,
-0.5455722808837891,
-0.07620470225811005,
-0.2914450466632843,
-0.5117935538291931,
0.4303252696990967,
-0.551845133304596,
0.8651776909828186,
-0.32381168007850647,
-0.404638409614563,
-0.30120378732681274,
0.23183055222034454,
0.14824172854423523,
0.3437976837158203,
0.33813104033470154,
0.22661730647087097,
0.3884509801864624,
-0.08973536640405655,
1.0862680673599243,
-0.37898385524749756,
-0.18029208481311798,
0.8352277874946594,
-0.6791768074035645,
0.6118954420089722,
0.6460416316986084,
-0.3117600679397583,
0.2204192876815796,
0.6334776282310486,
-0.2126748263835907,
0.7044845223426819,
0.5040619969367981,
-0.6301923394203186,
0.024961838498711586,
-0.3229132890701294,
-0.04311510547995567,
0.49287647008895874,
0.2661328613758087,
-0.5308545231819153,
-0.12601415812969208,
-0.21434666216373444,
-0.1855425089597702,
-0.05814610794186592,
-0.062453802675008774,
0.7202162742614746,
0.07036273926496506,
-0.6093101501464844,
0.38521885871887207,
0.043586064130067825,
0.4564720690250397,
-0.8889934420585632,
0.031249968335032463,
-0.3179932236671448,
0.21755754947662354,
-0.35959362983703613,
-0.5858287811279297,
0.4525516629219055,
0.11282797902822495,
-0.41694900393486023,
-0.6067819595336914,
0.4839296340942383,
-0.2918807566165924,
-0.7445977926254272,
0.27244919538497925,
0.6695091128349304,
0.009781786240637302,
0.2414679229259491,
-0.5523896217346191,
-0.10278759896755219,
0.2615921199321747,
-0.4766567647457123,
0.31918278336524963,
0.4776557385921478,
-0.3422224223613739,
0.4110826253890991,
0.9686345458030701,
0.5204049944877625,
0.3088347315788269,
-0.027441401034593582,
0.9410923719406128,
-0.7150428295135498,
-0.08665121346712112,
-0.6617493629455566,
0.6332193613052368,
0.20197941362857819,
-0.32907554507255554,
0.8538739085197449,
0.7158269286155701,
0.764726459980011,
0.2678682208061218,
0.9912829995155334,
-0.120939239859581,
0.26191142201423645,
-0.4761587679386139,
0.4635592997074127,
-0.6879884600639343,
0.4175693690776825,
-0.008989074267446995,
-1.2964107990264893,
-0.1471376270055771,
0.29017874598503113,
-0.5747132301330566,
0.33643922209739685,
0.46356573700904846,
0.9623589515686035,
-0.23364384472370148,
-0.21151961386203766,
0.31060853600502014,
0.16240355372428894,
0.42711931467056274,
0.26538294553756714,
1.1700881719589233,
0.1079990491271019,
0.1255684345960617,
-0.28149187564849854,
-0.2935255765914917,
0.09517243504524231,
-0.7604891061782837,
-0.5569676756858826,
-0.4438616633415222,
-0.3500632047653198,
-0.1631869673728943,
-0.07478343695402145,
0.6177254319190979,
0.5640649199485779,
-0.8323954343795776,
-0.0991600751876831,
-0.36653175950050354,
0.06373152136802673,
0.06932735443115234,
-0.1986495554447174,
0.12851619720458984,
-0.12492384761571884,
-1.0400865077972412,
0.5611023902893066,
0.34021827578544617,
0.5119588971138,
-0.6156796813011169,
-0.13211967051029205,
-0.17987579107284546,
0.4005182385444641,
0.402591347694397,
0.30690059065818787,
-0.49092137813568115,
0.09237196296453476,
0.13038446009159088,
-0.18450334668159485,
-0.034364260733127594,
0.9632732272148132,
-0.4194164276123047,
0.6148459911346436,
0.57403963804245,
0.33938172459602356,
0.5221219658851624,
0.04824131727218628,
0.9480200409889221,
-0.6518552303314209,
0.2021005004644394,
0.4643864929676056,
0.17588923871517181,
0.31774571537971497,
-0.477816104888916,
0.4401595890522003,
0.34707751870155334,
-0.32327893376350403,
-1.1724522113800049,
0.3427637219429016,
-0.8168011903762817,
-0.4112820625305176,
1.5167236328125,
0.3014906346797943,
-0.2372637391090393,
-0.25865375995635986,
-0.2440824657678604,
0.2335483580827713,
-0.21548445522785187,
0.917630136013031,
0.4845837950706482,
-0.38928040862083435,
-0.1452370584011078,
-0.7826344966888428,
0.3334202468395233,
0.3717130422592163,
-0.9587182402610779,
0.4703119099140167,
0.6156076192855835,
0.21403126418590546,
-0.26681917905807495,
0.033327966928482056,
-0.36808833479881287,
-0.05225864052772522,
0.15127789974212646,
-0.06370849162340164,
-0.17418654263019562,
-0.17455005645751953,
-0.16494141519069672,
0.013142436742782593,
0.24117013812065125,
0.10934336483478546
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01489v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01489v1 | Agentless: Demystifying LLM-based Software Engineering Agents | 2024-07-01T17:24:45 | 2024-07-01T17:24:45 | Chunqiu Steven Xia, Yinlin Deng, Soren Dunn, Lingming Zhang | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have significantly
advanced the automation of software development tasks, including code
synthesis, program repair, and test generation. More recently, researchers and
industry practitioners have developed various autonomous LLM agents to perform
end-to-end software development tasks. These agents are equipped with the
ability to use tools, run commands, observe feedback from the environment, and
plan for future actions. However, the complexity of these agent-based
approaches, together with the limited abilities of current LLMs, raises the
following question: Do we really have to employ complex autonomous software
agents? To attempt to answer this question, we build Agentless -- an agentless
approach to automatically solve software development problems. Compared to the
verbose and complex setup of agent-based approaches, Agentless employs a
simplistic two-phase process of localization followed by repair, without
letting the LLM decide future actions or operate with complex tools. Our
results on the popular SWE-bench Lite benchmark show that surprisingly the
simplistic Agentless is able to achieve both the highest performance (27.33%)
and lowest cost (\$0.34) compared with all existing open-source software
agents! Furthermore, we manually classified the problems in SWE-bench Lite and
found problems with exact ground truth patch or insufficient/misleading issue
descriptions. As such, we construct SWE-bench Lite-S by excluding such
problematic issues to perform more rigorous evaluation and comparison. Our work
highlights the current overlooked potential of a simple, interpretable
technique in autonomous software development. We hope Agentless will help reset
the baseline, starting point, and horizon for autonomous software agents, and
inspire future work along this crucial direction. | [
-0.47787240147590637,
-0.5416420698165894,
0.764806866645813,
0.19610659778118134,
0.1559293270111084,
0.36530742049217224,
0.027666183188557625,
-0.7106325030326843,
0.2227066308259964,
0.5750022530555725,
-0.6759665012359619,
-0.43491828441619873,
-0.16731730103492737,
-0.026929887011647224,
-0.44356203079223633,
0.8248605132102966,
-0.29798072576522827,
-0.11382611095905304,
-0.23909775912761688,
-0.2442621886730194,
-0.30413544178009033,
0.09045243263244629,
-0.3510300815105438,
-0.4016996920108795,
0.3431881070137024,
0.3960561752319336,
0.7239612936973572,
0.890070915222168,
0.10959117114543915,
0.3983847498893738,
0.33466777205467224,
0.047572847455739975,
-0.1278623640537262,
0.35017386078834534,
-0.02098141238093376,
-0.5672125816345215,
-0.7632451057434082,
0.06772202998399734,
-0.07051260769367218,
0.7461191415786743,
0.12215011566877365,
0.3439478278160095,
-0.22663114964962006,
0.7830976247787476,
-0.4964349567890167,
0.29057955741882324,
-0.6075403094291687,
0.13353951275348663,
0.1487724334001541,
-0.17200268805027008,
-0.41347238421440125,
-0.22926968336105347,
-0.30632928013801575,
-0.6109951734542847,
0.396696001291275,
-0.1638997495174408,
0.43123143911361694,
0.7035863399505615,
-0.64741450548172,
-0.2020091712474823,
-1.112503170967102,
0.5792921781539917,
-0.48523715138435364,
0.11306677758693695,
-0.018115639686584473,
0.4154449999332428,
-0.4438444674015045,
-0.2731679379940033,
-0.3622529208660126,
-0.4368390738964081,
0.26489901542663574,
0.17567776143550873,
0.03639255836606026,
0.4234537184238434,
0.18921993672847748,
0.20648711919784546,
-0.7515754699707031,
0.18776598572731018,
-0.12596936523914337,
-0.17400161921977997,
0.893395721912384,
0.04728470742702484,
0.38226383924484253,
0.32419803738594055,
-0.4511595070362091,
0.1742212027311325,
-0.7697656154632568,
-0.017807401716709137,
0.04887324199080467,
0.19138139486312866,
0.023637233301997185,
0.6045838594436646,
-0.26510322093963623,
0.22440941631793976,
-0.08031225204467773,
-0.07116463035345078,
0.06620816141366959,
0.15637044608592987,
-0.27155670523643494,
-0.05630485713481903,
0.4471524953842163,
0.024623792618513107,
0.14650662243366241,
-0.5518203377723694,
-0.7671656012535095,
0.26115623116493225,
0.23947127163410187,
-0.39961615204811096,
0.1813325434923172,
0.8828997611999512,
-0.08606589585542679,
-0.42275843024253845,
-0.19905319809913635,
-0.12230382114648819,
-0.8047114014625549,
-0.4280433654785156,
0.5451681613922119,
0.023261627182364464,
-0.30159804224967957,
-0.21554036438465118,
-0.06435801088809967,
0.6237137317657471,
0.49970921874046326,
-0.3311142921447754,
0.19297820329666138,
0.6968240737915039,
0.5443956255912781,
-0.006430431269109249,
-0.45239681005477905,
-0.48113611340522766,
0.2737922966480255,
-0.9254044890403748,
0.8771283626556396,
-0.04756082966923714,
-0.38643160462379456,
-0.15426234900951385,
0.08704083412885666,
0.39690592885017395,
-0.6442522406578064,
0.01036923285573721,
-0.2236912101507187,
-0.26740071177482605,
-0.1366041600704193,
-0.5582325458526611,
-0.03627895936369896,
0.24551525712013245,
-0.622315526008606,
0.867124617099762,
0.18978452682495117,
-0.004796172026544809,
0.1898289918899536,
-0.7585307955741882,
-0.2594996690750122,
0.3701542615890503,
-0.3045080900192261,
-0.11662963777780533,
0.20566238462924957,
-0.28291940689086914,
0.17574889957904816,
-0.29790353775024414,
0.20773792266845703,
-0.25904425978660583,
-0.5332366228103638,
-0.02366161346435547,
-0.23638282716274261,
0.6351280808448792,
0.14975792169570923,
-0.8733705878257751,
0.3541830778121948,
-0.768743634223938,
0.18822038173675537,
0.04661707952618599,
0.07270534336566925,
0.0031874331180006266,
-0.031670279800891876,
-0.2017989307641983,
0.18234938383102417,
0.45117995142936707,
-0.5862005949020386,
0.24948261678218842,
-0.5191925764083862,
-0.0024755040649324656,
0.9736869931221008,
-0.12422414124011993,
0.8294057250022888,
-0.4961918592453003,
0.7681805491447449,
-0.3049195110797882,
0.5177444815635681,
-0.10917038470506668,
-0.24572297930717468,
-0.7650513648986816,
-0.3400914967060089,
-0.001132603851146996,
0.7103333473205566,
-0.7310202121734619,
0.15313929319381714,
0.08604947477579117,
-0.7014757990837097,
-0.5641874074935913,
0.3324245512485504,
0.22732657194137573,
0.14980386197566986,
0.22172951698303223,
-0.15791502594947815,
-0.30193477869033813,
-0.7898629903793335,
-0.10349094867706299,
-0.17866633832454681,
-0.03504547104239464,
0.14549678564071655,
0.4121931493282318,
-0.4227769076824188,
1.012902855873108,
-0.25064194202423096,
-0.32624074816703796,
-0.4231681823730469,
0.11320310831069946,
-0.041229795664548874,
0.2785690426826477,
0.4101645350456238,
-0.5485872626304626,
-0.49469467997550964,
0.19084550440311432,
-1.0868356227874756,
-0.25293615460395813,
-0.30238035321235657,
0.09598767012357712,
0.5741118788719177,
0.5326490998268127,
-0.9497921466827393,
0.414917916059494,
0.19529764354228973,
-0.261944442987442,
0.47166186571121216,
-0.471876323223114,
-0.2966274619102478,
-0.5212699174880981,
0.07322842627763748,
-0.17075921595096588,
-0.22235728800296783,
-0.6943403482437134,
0.4901924133300781,
-0.028021715581417084,
-0.3181324303150177,
-0.4638260006904602,
0.9080916047096252,
-0.8777504563331604,
-0.45633918046951294,
-0.6500733494758606,
0.22463127970695496,
-0.07992640137672424,
0.38936641812324524,
-0.288119375705719,
0.807504415512085,
0.5262622833251953,
-0.47190728783607483,
0.5230336785316467,
-0.250169962644577,
0.2604180872440338,
0.19381770491600037,
-0.6857108473777771,
0.09459925442934036,
-0.4005231559276581,
0.2074124962091446,
-0.6886835098266602,
-0.08712977916002274,
0.11478883773088455,
-0.3650774359703064,
0.1084122359752655,
-0.019490834325551987,
-0.43323785066604614,
-0.170303612947464,
-0.5292171239852905,
0.2310556024312973,
0.41733700037002563,
-0.18011637032032013,
0.8044344186782837,
0.3023572862148285,
-0.18199753761291504,
-0.5928620100021362,
-0.48511335253715515,
0.09671595692634583,
0.2754089832305908,
-0.592502772808075,
0.049620699137449265,
-0.19929161667823792,
-0.5304713249206543,
0.057068243622779846,
-0.5871804356575012,
-0.21622468531131744,
0.3887406587600708,
0.5067778825759888,
0.2411111742258072,
-0.2724451422691345,
0.24905425310134888,
-0.005473298020660877,
-0.48249149322509766,
0.03155158832669258,
-0.031040333211421967,
0.21064162254333496,
-0.2180689126253128,
-0.5823349952697754,
-0.08088284730911255,
0.3970211148262024,
0.9920894503593445,
-0.35736584663391113,
0.30691099166870117,
0.2967850863933563,
-0.31752267479896545,
-0.7406534552574158,
-0.4620361328125,
-0.10214072465896606,
-0.4917197823524475,
0.17562857270240784,
-0.2836866080760956,
-0.5302287936210632,
0.5885972380638123,
-0.2947820723056793,
0.34329742193222046,
0.1562523990869522,
0.1990746110677719,
0.016123110428452492,
0.9482684135437012,
0.9102907180786133,
0.058686383068561554,
0.12022368609905243,
-0.20359356701374054,
0.3899335563182831,
-0.21243441104888916,
-0.1200869083404541,
-0.29088881611824036,
-0.16801975667476654,
-0.5489351749420166,
-0.37858033180236816,
0.4000963568687439,
-0.06495759636163712,
-0.3214420676231384,
0.23845089972019196,
-0.5927536487579346,
0.7212451696395874,
0.21714746952056885,
-0.3504723012447357,
0.36062219738960266,
-0.5299304127693176,
0.17419806122779846,
0.38229435682296753,
-0.4086490273475647,
-0.44603991508483887,
0.9646064639091492,
0.2200755923986435,
0.6616919636726379,
-0.08240538090467453,
0.9254978895187378,
0.5816692113876343,
0.41691818833351135,
-0.8609644174575806,
0.8213357329368591,
0.3960024118423462,
-0.48960059881210327,
-0.6297109127044678,
-0.20135748386383057,
-1.0671635866165161,
0.3286817967891693,
-0.06564577668905258,
-0.2288278043270111,
-0.03566485270857811,
-0.14760832488536835,
-0.23093968629837036,
0.1129445731639862,
-0.850310206413269,
0.825546145439148,
-0.4811455011367798,
-0.13005249202251434,
-0.06863913685083389,
-0.5398286581039429,
0.13419535756111145,
-0.193097785115242,
0.5234416127204895,
-0.3534817099571228,
-0.3748181164264679,
0.1330484300851822,
-0.7500455379486084,
0.7123377919197083,
-0.35885515809059143,
-0.3598777949810028,
0.2870769500732422,
0.4509095847606659,
0.7686209678649902,
-0.11654709279537201,
0.05038836598396301,
-0.4185165762901306,
0.1026688739657402,
-0.7236246466636658,
-0.8318098783493042,
0.6760561466217041,
-0.7798547148704529,
-0.7264496088027954,
-0.5949570536613464,
-0.6485702991485596,
-0.23333154618740082,
0.3040306270122528,
-0.2740195393562317,
0.4103489816188812,
-0.1631588339805603,
-0.22724993526935577,
0.5549240112304688,
-0.20114214718341827,
0.7510784268379211,
0.9819396138191223,
-0.3088921010494232,
-0.06962375342845917,
1.072286605834961,
0.23301127552986145,
0.08884496986865997,
0.1469142735004425,
-0.24552252888679504,
0.028013819828629494,
-0.49820026755332947,
-0.4363582134246826,
0.26750674843788147,
-0.5847458243370056,
-0.2103354036808014,
-0.33624061942100525,
-0.2067336142063141,
-0.11658114939928055,
-0.5727136731147766,
-0.8193228244781494,
-0.31489118933677673,
0.07722488790750504,
-0.2016809731721878,
0.1616959124803543,
1.0930241346359253,
0.009124873206019402,
-0.13294026255607605,
-0.5919880270957947,
0.4859268069267273,
-0.004805212840437889,
0.24945172667503357,
-0.06147067993879318,
0.24999065697193146,
-0.2196730524301529,
0.017185673117637634,
-0.23334850370883942,
-0.7777161598205566,
0.20418459177017212,
-0.04894590377807617,
0.7204813957214355,
0.11253798007965088,
0.5910754203796387,
0.3540085554122925,
-0.12016507238149643,
0.6545867323875427,
-0.21949297189712524,
-1.0119575262069702,
0.5971068739891052,
-0.30693191289901733,
0.21176782250404358,
0.3920704424381256,
0.02786632999777794,
-0.30501922965049744,
-0.869709849357605,
-0.5403573513031006,
-1.1013672351837158,
0.34937313199043274,
0.1760263592004776,
-0.1626308262348175,
0.3100246489048004,
0.3655122220516205,
0.15501777827739716,
0.32371681928634644,
-0.7710679769515991,
-0.593480110168457,
0.07420859485864639,
-0.013215807266533375,
-0.058979809284210205,
0.11998366564512253,
-0.09296788275241852,
-0.12226934731006622,
0.7245471477508545,
-0.3007766902446747,
0.2444571703672409,
0.2605435252189636,
-0.4245332181453705,
-0.1947963386774063,
0.42109760642051697,
0.5642088055610657,
0.6252992153167725,
-0.1294846534729004,
0.14135201275348663,
0.0821470320224762,
-0.11873237788677216,
0.6085948944091797,
-0.014929434284567833,
-0.3417327105998993,
-0.009473185054957867,
0.3789420425891876,
0.2906476557254791,
-0.13250020146369934,
-0.8886340856552124,
0.6725562810897827,
0.2912822663784027,
-0.23464913666248322,
-0.5808756947517395,
0.11868727207183838,
-0.0646534189581871,
0.49953871965408325,
0.5600374937057495,
0.20369698107242584,
0.11703769117593765,
-0.7194984555244446,
0.18292979896068573,
0.5607064366340637,
-0.535062849521637,
-0.29235297441482544,
0.6175176501274109,
0.415103554725647,
-0.33672013878822327,
0.05742964893579483,
-0.4838583469390869,
-0.1011514961719513,
1.121801733970642,
0.38431689143180847,
1.3157808780670166,
-0.028291044756770134,
0.6457729339599609,
-0.2851991355419159,
0.5638781189918518,
0.018674222752451897,
0.3158459961414337,
-0.08779582381248474,
-0.34276482462882996,
-0.5953527688980103,
-0.2616322636604309,
-0.5956819653511047,
0.002004725392907858,
-0.1720401495695114,
0.10358725488185883,
-0.6153340339660645,
0.3284546732902527,
-0.2329263538122177,
0.299413800239563,
-0.10910667479038239,
0.28329718112945557,
-0.009164211340248585,
0.8315273523330688,
-0.6996572017669678,
0.7317584156990051,
0.8416849374771118,
-0.45889943838119507,
-0.7638981938362122,
-0.010139149613678455,
0.05702611804008484,
-0.5765804052352905,
0.1438695788383484,
0.12868532538414001,
-0.3977546989917755,
-0.06771639734506607,
-0.6469408273696899,
-0.6249598860740662,
1.4500936269760132,
0.6707236766815186,
-0.09260358661413193,
0.05746040865778923,
0.31960389018058777,
0.7482823133468628,
-0.3079676926136017,
0.5011336803436279,
0.044959913939237595,
0.5047021508216858,
0.06635173410177231,
-0.9244482517242432,
0.2538336217403412,
-0.37569570541381836,
-0.0351472944021225,
0.33173808455467224,
-0.665416419506073,
0.7230498194694519,
-0.3601889908313751,
-0.11888805776834488,
0.10470490157604218,
0.21836309134960175,
0.07101941853761673,
0.6300873160362244,
0.2897234857082367,
0.0058647748082876205,
0.7272862195968628,
0.13909503817558289,
0.8729380965232849,
-0.7116385102272034,
0.2679343521595001,
0.8520967960357666,
-0.6190140247344971,
0.4894757866859436,
0.27707305550575256,
0.020824924111366272,
0.2648843824863434,
0.4142189621925354,
0.06042010709643364,
0.11415071785449982,
0.027355629950761795,
-0.5054994225502014,
-0.33448725938796997,
-0.05545470863580704,
-0.42563655972480774,
0.29641059041023254,
-0.3130730092525482,
0.22207370400428772,
-0.5216904878616333,
0.026081537827849388,
-0.05056477338075638,
-0.018535379320383072,
-0.34464749693870544,
0.7050973773002625,
0.10917504876852036,
-0.3908277451992035,
0.48465898633003235,
-0.025926103815436363,
0.26256340742111206,
-0.5986679196357727,
0.056501999497413635,
-0.6381555795669556,
0.2889479994773865,
-0.39317697286605835,
-0.5354722142219543,
0.45020249485969543,
-0.062473271042108536,
-0.2183600813150406,
-0.3886878490447998,
0.7634026408195496,
-0.14331351220607758,
-0.12820184230804443,
0.5047153234481812,
1.012510895729065,
0.19426675140857697,
-0.34402817487716675,
-0.46957191824913025,
-0.20380672812461853,
-0.1491566002368927,
-0.25296568870544434,
0.4851858615875244,
0.6611166000366211,
-0.14801961183547974,
1.2609941959381104,
0.3869740962982178,
0.06882365792989731,
-0.12556716799736023,
-0.23712538182735443,
0.6099616885185242,
-0.8763821721076965,
-0.22168172895908356,
-0.5890889167785645,
0.46364453434944153,
0.29776880145072937,
0.15441426634788513,
0.7944392561912537,
0.6654247641563416,
0.5490962862968445,
-0.07061288505792618,
0.8845742344856262,
0.03673090413212776,
0.28437474370002747,
-0.0720311775803566,
0.923039436340332,
-0.7937900424003601,
0.5228708982467651,
-0.21847398579120636,
-0.839455783367157,
-0.27748510241508484,
0.20910747349262238,
0.0917801707983017,
-0.04698074609041214,
0.5674400925636292,
1.0224409103393555,
0.28137198090553284,
-0.2450193613767624,
0.4679681956768036,
0.3244856595993042,
0.2655865252017975,
0.3995351195335388,
0.6200531721115112,
-0.3552302122116089,
0.6759926080703735,
-0.02546093240380287,
-0.303295761346817,
0.08512108027935028,
-0.5523284673690796,
-0.5364649891853333,
-0.3417712450027466,
-0.3913353383541107,
-0.22222481667995453,
0.011386930011212826,
1.1467335224151611,
0.407340943813324,
-0.5976765155792236,
-0.4250231683254242,
-0.48647934198379517,
0.522205114364624,
-0.3635604679584503,
-0.15787917375564575,
-0.2036985605955124,
-0.5198867917060852,
-0.3774082064628601,
0.7541480660438538,
0.5443010926246643,
0.1494971662759781,
-0.4508274793624878,
-0.3661348819732666,
0.2929096817970276,
0.25281086564064026,
0.5765561461448669,
0.6079305410385132,
-0.5793417096138,
-0.07191925495862961,
0.14579342305660248,
-0.4580443799495697,
0.06585090607404709,
0.5184756517410278,
-0.82439124584198,
0.17328406870365143,
0.141165629029274,
0.5033850073814392,
0.26848629117012024,
-0.1918015331029892,
0.6885553598403931,
-0.5460248589515686,
0.24265077710151672,
0.23140907287597656,
-0.061503127217292786,
-0.06081807240843773,
-0.3567568361759186,
0.6233999729156494,
0.20644016563892365,
-0.6256762146949768,
-1.0034410953521729,
0.3465351164340973,
-0.9991336464881897,
-0.4662157893180847,
0.9677631258964539,
0.1357840597629547,
-0.24590076506137848,
-0.41118356585502625,
-0.2178218513727188,
0.10757213085889816,
-0.26170673966407776,
0.6502348780632019,
0.17684395611286163,
-0.44382140040397644,
-0.20744872093200684,
-0.6102656126022339,
0.3942594826221466,
0.2918398380279541,
-0.9516893625259399,
-0.023769477382302284,
0.4440065026283264,
0.3586641550064087,
0.00898931734263897,
0.9216200113296509,
0.268894225358963,
0.3364332318305969,
0.3350220024585724,
0.6373751759529114,
-0.315206378698349,
-0.4382304251194,
-0.2625170946121216,
0.35148993134498596,
0.481932133436203,
-0.03417443484067917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01476v1 | Tree Search for Language Model Agents | 2024-07-01T17:07:55 | 2024-07-01T17:07:55 | Jing Yu Koh, Stephen McAleer, Daniel Fried, Ruslan Salakhutdinov | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Autonomous agents powered by language models (LMs) have demonstrated promise
in their ability to perform decision-making tasks such as web automation.
However, a key limitation remains: LMs, primarily optimized for natural
language understanding and generation, struggle with multi-step reasoning,
planning, and using environmental feedback when attempting to solve realistic
computer tasks. Towards addressing this, we propose an inference-time search
algorithm for LM agents to explicitly perform exploration and multi-step
planning in interactive web environments. Our approach is a form of best-first
tree search that operates within the actual environment space, and is
complementary with most existing state-of-the-art agents. It is the first tree
search algorithm for LM agents that shows effectiveness on realistic web tasks.
On the challenging VisualWebArena benchmark, applying our search algorithm on
top of a GPT-4o agent yields a 39.7% relative increase in success rate compared
to the same baseline without search, setting a state-of-the-art success rate of
26.4%. On WebArena, search also yields a 28.0% relative improvement over a
baseline agent, setting a competitive success rate of 19.2%. Our experiments
highlight the effectiveness of search for web agents, and we demonstrate that
performance scales with increased test-time compute. We conduct a thorough
analysis of our results to highlight improvements from search, limitations, and
promising directions for future work. Our code and models are publicly released
at https://jykoh.com/search-agents. | [
-0.5319473147392273,
-0.7240755558013916,
0.8950980305671692,
0.19903618097305298,
0.037122998386621475,
0.3056612014770508,
-0.02131996490061283,
-0.6503625512123108,
-0.004418291617184877,
0.027845965698361397,
-0.8570379614830017,
-0.5811651349067688,
-0.3744001090526581,
0.1628093421459198,
-0.25481218099594116,
0.14164407551288605,
-0.05914594978094101,
-0.4047422707080841,
-0.017191767692565918,
0.05199821665883064,
-0.06752366572618484,
-0.130655899643898,
-0.8021546602249146,
-0.2505848705768585,
0.750545084476471,
0.13912296295166016,
1.0174529552459717,
0.7642364501953125,
0.23799723386764526,
0.42434564232826233,
-0.28668609261512756,
0.3360966444015503,
-0.18937288224697113,
0.29149430990219116,
-0.3942420184612274,
-0.22920659184455872,
-0.341656357049942,
0.019544025883078575,
0.3290866017341614,
0.28662800788879395,
-0.37003326416015625,
-0.0625409185886383,
-0.2646287679672241,
0.46623244881629944,
-0.7071592807769775,
0.5044164061546326,
-0.7607395052909851,
0.19579936563968658,
-0.07601024210453033,
-0.5620648860931396,
-0.5314434766769409,
-0.35225623846054077,
0.32659849524497986,
-0.9881938099861145,
0.22789186239242554,
0.10257427394390106,
0.7883229851722717,
0.22948208451271057,
-0.5018677711486816,
-0.32542330026626587,
-0.6432749629020691,
0.653007984161377,
-0.7123774290084839,
0.5507118701934814,
0.43441474437713623,
0.4435439109802246,
-0.4259226322174072,
-0.6683961153030396,
-0.5551652312278748,
-0.3586816191673279,
0.018209759145975113,
-0.05301198735833168,
-0.5760142207145691,
0.2804575264453888,
0.20887330174446106,
-0.1157619059085846,
-0.8561562895774841,
0.22545847296714783,
0.14938481152057648,
-0.19783422350883484,
0.5617749691009521,
0.09744146466255188,
0.282298743724823,
0.013422251679003239,
0.10591467469930649,
-0.5002535581588745,
-0.21918822824954987,
0.3261297047138214,
0.16662155091762543,
0.5100499987602234,
0.38622862100601196,
0.35460594296455383,
-0.6207727193832397,
0.6923409104347229,
-0.3950303792953491,
-0.18519161641597748,
-0.07603844255208969,
-0.4683748483657837,
-0.0881478562951088,
-0.2887085974216461,
0.5065813064575195,
0.2560955882072449,
0.33070263266563416,
-0.12915098667144775,
-0.523910403251648,
0.27346453070640564,
0.2527883052825928,
-0.8819760680198669,
-0.1826891154050827,
0.3471428155899048,
-0.3595234155654907,
-0.16858190298080444,
-0.22844751179218292,
-0.5638716816902161,
-0.2717234194278717,
-0.10543058812618256,
0.31166455149650574,
-0.4444454610347748,
-0.3075357973575592,
-0.13768650591373444,
-0.22845558822155,
0.19965124130249023,
0.504243016242981,
-0.3754076063632965,
0.5193282961845398,
0.3333422839641571,
0.9026523232460022,
-0.024171873927116394,
-0.32331353425979614,
-0.7348760962486267,
-0.0575253926217556,
-0.7143046259880066,
0.746080219745636,
-0.6426824927330017,
-0.27389025688171387,
0.1258673369884491,
-0.19472791254520416,
-0.019446246325969696,
-0.3048463761806488,
0.4205250144004822,
-0.9549705982208252,
0.011346327140927315,
0.09201516211032867,
-0.4142979085445404,
-0.3803822994232178,
0.37127232551574707,
-0.8833975791931152,
0.9750281572341919,
-0.025331346318125725,
-0.3896822929382324,
0.38847437500953674,
-0.9685956239700317,
-0.361215740442276,
0.017652301117777824,
0.018834467977285385,
-0.3147498369216919,
-0.2160741090774536,
0.6062597632408142,
0.29301753640174866,
-0.1665804386138916,
0.007289131637662649,
-0.36464592814445496,
-0.40087780356407166,
-0.03421515226364136,
-0.20947740972042084,
0.7207887172698975,
0.14655806124210358,
-0.5634250640869141,
0.2878817319869995,
-0.5037244558334351,
0.5438949465751648,
0.6106096506118774,
-0.40909507870674133,
-0.40028589963912964,
0.5521637201309204,
-0.005319051444530487,
0.13230666518211365,
0.2632131576538086,
-0.44130223989486694,
0.5337053537368774,
-0.2906666696071625,
0.15150514245033264,
0.8307664394378662,
-0.1640782356262207,
0.3024512231349945,
-0.13586977124214172,
0.7904532551765442,
-0.34328219294548035,
0.422273725271225,
-0.16271063685417175,
-0.3374561071395874,
-0.6533026695251465,
0.08893152326345444,
0.13945463299751282,
0.48733407258987427,
-0.7699324488639832,
0.29896798729896545,
-0.19581755995750427,
-0.6476378440856934,
-0.36922577023506165,
-0.028003152459859848,
0.3899630606174469,
-0.09075752645730972,
0.5141422152519226,
-0.18228058516979218,
-0.4987197816371918,
-0.8281111121177673,
-0.2049504518508911,
-0.28441479802131653,
0.19573019444942474,
0.33131951093673706,
0.3454398214817047,
-0.599011242389679,
1.2051199674606323,
-0.3099443316459656,
-0.23357440531253815,
-0.2443978190422058,
0.25886401534080505,
0.1752472072839737,
0.05334579199552536,
0.4429272413253784,
-0.9882660508155823,
-0.5367934107780457,
0.25878697633743286,
-0.5311090350151062,
-0.07942177355289459,
0.08866771310567856,
0.17507542669773102,
0.346855491399765,
0.21404299139976501,
-0.7398905754089355,
0.5625705718994141,
0.5674263834953308,
-0.17085708677768707,
0.19953951239585876,
-0.18352919816970825,
-0.1458319127559662,
-0.6409602761268616,
0.10609502345323563,
0.105527862906456,
-0.4459571838378906,
-0.4454084634780884,
0.5274593830108643,
0.10880730301141739,
0.11771174520254135,
-0.32171928882598877,
0.6893194317817688,
-0.8449506163597107,
-0.30620077252388,
-0.2961949110031128,
0.43456849455833435,
-0.21130967140197754,
0.7431273460388184,
-0.03824806213378906,
0.8848691582679749,
0.5586142539978027,
-0.9347089529037476,
-0.0036694149021059275,
0.01752617582678795,
-0.11676081269979477,
-0.03394482284784317,
-0.2734580338001251,
0.47387751936912537,
0.00468308012932539,
0.42462655901908875,
-0.6376855969429016,
-0.03319532051682472,
-0.16801533102989197,
-0.3717211186885834,
-0.04819198697805405,
-0.13882270455360413,
-0.6055077314376831,
-0.49723687767982483,
-0.3953106999397278,
0.20351094007492065,
0.29081088304519653,
-0.5958584547042847,
0.7864202857017517,
0.2816680073738098,
-0.14862407743930817,
-0.5523440837860107,
-0.07136634737253189,
0.15278851985931396,
0.2043284773826599,
-0.5138305425643921,
0.39381465315818787,
-0.22215594351291656,
-0.2041635662317276,
0.09345261007547379,
-0.3882046937942505,
-0.14784936606884003,
0.3560401201248169,
-0.13913168013095856,
-0.15167202055454254,
-0.08882877975702286,
-0.1973818689584732,
-0.07719895988702774,
-0.05893377959728241,
0.004645799286663532,
-0.2791205048561096,
0.7610999345779419,
-0.18393762409687042,
-0.5162544846534729,
-0.5256203413009644,
0.2715283930301666,
0.46729332208633423,
-0.5583829879760742,
0.2275332659482956,
0.24219577014446259,
-0.47638481855392456,
-0.4949474334716797,
-0.36167338490486145,
-0.15853121876716614,
-0.5047770142555237,
0.3647351562976837,
-0.4932675063610077,
-0.600612461566925,
0.2812509834766388,
-0.19081446528434753,
0.2966190576553345,
0.32276836037635803,
0.11264701187610626,
-0.09022032469511032,
1.7214899063110352,
0.7437469363212585,
0.04002511501312256,
0.6413565874099731,
-0.42904049158096313,
0.06314264237880707,
-0.43179044127464294,
-0.12254460901021957,
-0.5915181040763855,
-0.2711544334888458,
-0.8331471085548401,
-0.4528329372406006,
0.5209490060806274,
-0.0351179838180542,
-0.07563857734203339,
0.3504616916179657,
-0.4774884283542633,
0.4987424612045288,
0.907486081123352,
0.021319882944226265,
0.42770928144454956,
-0.12535054981708527,
-0.3741970360279083,
0.18843968212604523,
-0.7818107008934021,
-0.37958651781082153,
0.8311489820480347,
0.13841235637664795,
0.6523563861846924,
0.32399678230285645,
0.7031651735305786,
0.3222450613975525,
0.14729364216327667,
-0.7613533735275269,
0.7211058735847473,
0.33773699402809143,
-0.5062127113342285,
-0.8685015439987183,
-0.35702723264694214,
-1.4639233350753784,
0.4951644837856293,
0.25297749042510986,
-0.833468496799469,
-0.021959327161312103,
0.16981936991214752,
-0.008544976823031902,
0.23763519525527954,
-0.44417887926101685,
0.8020367622375488,
-0.5408681035041809,
-0.3532533645629883,
-0.502751886844635,
-0.558708906173706,
0.022052636370062828,
0.019285032525658607,
0.27749955654144287,
-0.12942901253700256,
-0.15268978476524353,
0.2894774079322815,
-0.4479357898235321,
0.5200209617614746,
-0.4270733594894409,
0.13913612067699432,
0.2436697632074356,
0.6302505135536194,
1.1324318647384644,
-0.4346785545349121,
0.04321550950407982,
-0.24755360186100006,
0.06289311498403549,
-0.39685291051864624,
-0.6362395882606506,
0.25874656438827515,
-0.5568403005599976,
-0.6365117430686951,
-0.7572691440582275,
-0.26065218448638916,
-0.20826518535614014,
0.45277756452560425,
-0.26840201020240784,
0.060073282569646835,
-0.38665005564689636,
0.04657400771975517,
0.28115326166152954,
-0.16224440932273865,
0.878931999206543,
0.8791272044181824,
-0.834080696105957,
0.12321538478136063,
0.7357317209243774,
-0.029907315969467163,
0.05456411838531494,
0.6147511005401611,
0.40463685989379883,
-0.48374173045158386,
-0.7469722628593445,
-0.5336345434188843,
-0.12820643186569214,
-0.62228924036026,
-0.16504396498203278,
-0.6313121318817139,
-0.1625029593706131,
-0.1756010353565216,
0.17138756811618805,
-0.34449392557144165,
-0.06471739709377289,
0.06824193894863129,
-0.018321074545383453,
0.2872976064682007,
0.8867676258087158,
0.11060582846403122,
0.22357185184955597,
-0.5783443450927734,
0.13645729422569275,
0.38406941294670105,
0.2611461281776428,
0.10986124724149704,
0.1509329229593277,
-0.23737290501594543,
-0.08349207788705826,
-0.42526188492774963,
-1.006514072418213,
0.4647258520126343,
0.11404456943273544,
0.807633638381958,
0.2773859202861786,
-0.10373469442129135,
0.8227837681770325,
-0.32169783115386963,
0.3593710660934448,
-0.30666306614875793,
-0.8427602052688599,
0.719443142414093,
-0.41313061118125916,
0.5288397669792175,
0.42633646726608276,
0.37060075998306274,
-0.5831172466278076,
-0.25751104950904846,
-0.47136619687080383,
-0.7854007482528687,
0.9088844656944275,
0.6134904026985168,
-0.43834203481674194,
0.2848252058029175,
-0.18427076935768127,
-0.18103446066379547,
0.06472894549369812,
-0.7719907760620117,
-0.1278860867023468,
0.12827569246292114,
0.3119581937789917,
-0.012416978366672993,
0.13753493130207062,
0.17400027811527252,
-0.2346150279045105,
0.7353763580322266,
-0.5424067974090576,
0.2341676503419876,
0.3658812344074249,
-0.23654738068580627,
-0.41345542669296265,
0.21599794924259186,
0.27865123748779297,
0.8508754372596741,
-0.17316800355911255,
0.16805438697338104,
0.1471085101366043,
-0.020179150626063347,
0.10110452026128769,
0.5688984394073486,
-0.159628763794899,
0.0546640008687973,
0.4363887310028076,
0.621695339679718,
0.06494516134262085,
-0.8813709616661072,
0.39605966210365295,
-0.30121079087257385,
0.17274004220962524,
-0.45025405287742615,
0.20004123449325562,
0.18526668846607208,
0.3835427165031433,
0.5380712151527405,
-0.15629051625728607,
0.48437339067459106,
-0.6326238512992859,
0.1921374648809433,
0.7129250764846802,
-0.00438074953854084,
-0.12130725383758545,
0.46221452951431274,
0.12794555723667145,
-0.7981830835342407,
0.5609490871429443,
-0.5863653421401978,
-0.6628738641738892,
0.8314806222915649,
0.3383862376213074,
0.9742599725723267,
-0.5192288160324097,
0.3033391833305359,
0.11047448962926865,
0.41359665989875793,
-0.01989847607910633,
0.3791995644569397,
-0.1496429592370987,
-0.6252794861793518,
-0.36441534757614136,
-0.6691945195198059,
-0.5682226419448853,
0.0489046573638916,
-0.08334658294916153,
0.1514504998922348,
-0.28427278995513916,
-0.1263793706893921,
-0.2699909508228302,
0.1886959820985794,
-0.9515673518180847,
0.18764105439186096,
0.00034345188760198653,
1.104217290878296,
-0.21020099520683289,
0.8204571008682251,
0.5486326813697815,
-0.37211671471595764,
-0.9319376349449158,
0.12350250035524368,
0.16610150039196014,
-0.7388075590133667,
0.2598654329776764,
0.39488136768341064,
-0.5057324767112732,
0.17602670192718506,
-0.3864397704601288,
-1.226253867149353,
1.4080536365509033,
0.23500972986221313,
-0.802622377872467,
-0.3382800817489624,
-0.03552139177918434,
0.6795439720153809,
-0.19370609521865845,
0.7215445041656494,
0.42492762207984924,
0.6841542720794678,
-0.14870472252368927,
-1.1814382076263428,
-0.06754906475543976,
-0.40613695979118347,
0.1912713348865509,
0.2338234931230545,
-0.5784321427345276,
0.795608639717102,
-0.07030191272497177,
-0.49749433994293213,
0.08202709257602692,
0.362878680229187,
0.4062570333480835,
0.49780353903770447,
0.9285283088684082,
0.38796156644821167,
0.8400158286094666,
0.16320385038852692,
1.2702651023864746,
-0.3475832939147949,
0.3323777914047241,
0.9873106479644775,
-0.33015596866607666,
0.7917436361312866,
0.16329741477966309,
-0.3361474573612213,
0.501685380935669,
1.0947773456573486,
0.5166852474212646,
0.5007436275482178,
0.23724320530891418,
-0.16922323405742645,
-0.348966121673584,
-0.14039959013462067,
0.05633492022752762,
0.3494228422641754,
0.04182703420519829,
-0.14050285518169403,
-0.3427915573120117,
-0.40605586767196655,
0.001678544096648693,
0.1478167027235031,
-0.15702229738235474,
0.7318434119224548,
-0.21490362286567688,
-0.974137544631958,
0.3022758364677429,
0.20090681314468384,
0.31677040457725525,
-0.8125717639923096,
-0.28149524331092834,
-0.2636891305446625,
0.10974480211734772,
-0.03306025639176369,
-0.4838036298751831,
-0.1836882084608078,
-0.08406783640384674,
0.19172652065753937,
-0.4386637210845947,
0.6279632449150085,
-0.10170736163854599,
-0.28509098291397095,
0.9648236632347107,
0.8987125158309937,
0.10722270607948303,
-0.42273253202438354,
-0.7056597471237183,
0.10406120121479034,
-0.015066931024193764,
-0.6479869484901428,
0.10464132577180862,
0.2651982307434082,
-0.4061051607131958,
1.0997406244277954,
0.7945466041564941,
-0.02705296501517296,
0.25760889053344727,
-0.10548435151576996,
0.87485271692276,
-0.7342458367347717,
-0.6833443641662598,
-0.7317306995391846,
0.21476605534553528,
-0.06573516875505447,
-0.04840962961316109,
0.34084394574165344,
0.8789927363395691,
0.8802657723426819,
0.29636716842651367,
0.8753654360771179,
-0.03978566825389862,
0.401934951543808,
-0.6523145437240601,
0.4458705186843872,
-0.7899090051651001,
0.030863648280501366,
-0.2355218082666397,
-1.2409242391586304,
-0.008362042717635632,
0.6371220350265503,
0.11992549896240234,
0.2380661517381668,
0.8615236878395081,
0.8989153504371643,
-0.26757171750068665,
-0.05235295370221138,
0.29734259843826294,
0.19515210390090942,
0.7066985368728638,
0.48275718092918396,
0.7879698276519775,
0.0023845303803682327,
0.8096880912780762,
-0.35386762022972107,
-0.16857251524925232,
-0.2891143262386322,
-0.9083898663520813,
-0.6656420230865479,
-0.5560228824615479,
0.15716448426246643,
0.09335093200206757,
0.22153228521347046,
1.092140793800354,
0.959402322769165,
-0.4814111292362213,
-0.3192412257194519,
-0.4754478335380554,
0.19058473408222198,
-0.48873957991600037,
-0.20459255576133728,
0.0004026689275633544,
-0.3530769646167755,
-0.8586254715919495,
1.1038888692855835,
0.1061057448387146,
-0.10759863257408142,
-0.6062914729118347,
-0.3825114965438843,
-0.5403826236724854,
0.09182429313659668,
0.42000558972358704,
0.2629629373550415,
-1.0319488048553467,
-0.31509605050086975,
0.21022561192512512,
-0.1868031769990921,
0.14219516515731812,
0.7622504234313965,
-0.906309962272644,
0.7513604760169983,
0.2583276331424713,
0.6883161067962646,
1.0097932815551758,
-0.13623502850532532,
0.5175604820251465,
-0.5451944470405579,
-0.13442492485046387,
0.5776110291481018,
0.3394513726234436,
0.08177967369556427,
-0.11302074790000916,
0.9290164709091187,
0.01723339781165123,
-0.4195495843887329,
-0.5591956377029419,
0.25655168294906616,
-0.8994143605232239,
-0.4202331304550171,
0.9362748265266418,
0.14010898768901825,
-0.17486439645290375,
0.12403080612421036,
-0.3296692371368408,
0.36610469222068787,
-0.7453709840774536,
0.5665137767791748,
0.615230143070221,
-0.5616410970687866,
-0.21412226557731628,
-0.5371835231781006,
0.45834192633628845,
0.3246578872203827,
-0.8841874003410339,
-0.07996775954961777,
0.531460702419281,
-0.06621766090393066,
0.35358163714408875,
0.7428416013717651,
0.46196049451828003,
0.2679513692855835,
-0.11537782102823257,
0.2800208628177643,
-0.06793632358312607,
-0.5875296592712402,
-0.10263123363256454,
0.15070036053657532,
0.39911070466041565,
-0.02391587384045124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01470v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01470v1 | DogeRM: Equipping Reward Models with Domain Knowledge through Model Merging | 2024-07-01T17:01:54 | 2024-07-01T17:01:54 | Tzu-Han Lin, Chen-An Li, Hung-yi Lee, Yun-Nung Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is a popular strategy for
aligning large language models (LLMs) with desired behaviors. Reward modeling
is a crucial step in RLHF. However, collecting paired preference data for
training reward models is often costly and time-consuming, especially for
domain-specific preferences requiring expert annotation. To address this
challenge, we propose the \textbf{Do}main knowled\textbf{ge} merged
\textbf{R}eward \textbf{M}odel (DogeRM), a novel framework that integrates
domain-specific knowledge into a general reward model by model merging. The
experiments demonstrate that DogeRM enhances performance across different
benchmarks and provide a detailed analysis showcasing the effects of model
merging, showing the great potential of facilitating model alignment. | [
-0.6971460580825806,
-0.3942166566848755,
0.39997974038124084,
-0.16248846054077148,
-0.02994922548532486,
0.007728002034127712,
-0.3458930253982544,
-0.5789994597434998,
-0.011660999618470669,
0.6221413612365723,
-0.5625326633453369,
-0.40158435702323914,
-0.7051072716712952,
-0.504517674446106,
-0.0030838497914373875,
1.244799017906189,
-0.24391056597232819,
0.11320982873439789,
-0.6584264039993286,
-0.30318474769592285,
-0.263649582862854,
-0.867003321647644,
-0.6541959047317505,
-0.934700608253479,
0.754570722579956,
0.3404527008533478,
0.5079914331436157,
0.49490785598754883,
0.5298827290534973,
0.19988678395748138,
0.22915662825107574,
0.4810357987880707,
-0.4026232063770294,
0.12342267483472824,
-0.46979713439941406,
-0.4142500162124634,
-0.7424724698066711,
0.3778725266456604,
0.18232478201389313,
0.6897756457328796,
-0.5160372853279114,
-0.15322864055633545,
0.08782525360584259,
0.5868073105812073,
-0.6898906230926514,
0.174636572599411,
-0.06393589824438095,
0.09261055290699005,
0.206318661570549,
-0.31647467613220215,
-0.3391832113265991,
-0.4098847508430481,
0.34257930517196655,
-0.4407425820827484,
0.10527988523244858,
0.2105109989643097,
1.0185500383377075,
0.44917091727256775,
-0.4483042061328888,
-0.05982689559459686,
-0.917222261428833,
0.9296208024024963,
-0.6198760271072388,
0.25718140602111816,
0.32681524753570557,
0.36770516633987427,
-0.29561588168144226,
-0.552691638469696,
-0.5046301484107971,
-0.1759149730205536,
-0.2700405418872833,
0.08763889223337173,
-0.10304959863424301,
0.08754678070545197,
-0.05518690124154091,
0.31709519028663635,
-0.39940258860588074,
0.13675963878631592,
-0.22714684903621674,
0.043212562799453735,
0.9611430764198303,
0.3035953938961029,
0.3863585889339447,
0.2739852964878082,
-0.7453793883323669,
-0.6890891790390015,
-0.6488529443740845,
0.2750067114830017,
0.25664928555488586,
0.23583419620990753,
-0.0928085595369339,
0.408172607421875,
-0.04758385568857193,
0.8653765320777893,
0.17711493372917175,
-0.013701047748327255,
0.13572324812412262,
0.14199873805046082,
-0.33635127544403076,
0.05719057843089104,
0.747198760509491,
0.5455878376960754,
0.22055788338184357,
-0.3720155358314514,
-0.3363363742828369,
0.10402180999517441,
0.45099154114723206,
-0.6776783466339111,
-0.3380805552005768,
0.40583422780036926,
-0.3628632426261902,
-0.5263382196426392,
0.23243814706802368,
-0.4471195638179779,
-0.37685465812683105,
-0.5707247853279114,
0.5208115577697754,
-0.21971744298934937,
-0.48439154028892517,
0.5190898776054382,
-0.3210442066192627,
0.544015645980835,
0.4596826732158661,
-0.9945875406265259,
0.3541843593120575,
1.0360229015350342,
0.33573654294013977,
-0.4259759485721588,
-0.6459379196166992,
-0.8395674824714661,
0.32157883048057556,
-0.1881946623325348,
0.8088142275810242,
-0.5044841766357422,
-0.5049479603767395,
-0.030136985704302788,
0.029881123453378677,
-0.13105888664722443,
-0.7526372075080872,
0.4479016959667206,
-0.9240787029266357,
0.5190622806549072,
-0.12571148574352264,
-0.8361467719078064,
-0.364745557308197,
0.2845819890499115,
-0.5991318821907043,
0.9635526537895203,
0.1522471159696579,
-0.5887904763221741,
0.4905305504798889,
-0.6666404008865356,
-0.40749940276145935,
0.17561322450637817,
-0.17678546905517578,
-0.21209771931171417,
-0.016344839707016945,
0.18138965964317322,
0.5592895746231079,
-0.3773484528064728,
0.5580071210861206,
-0.43281373381614685,
-0.26398664712905884,
0.2731977105140686,
0.10571397095918655,
0.1294127106666565,
0.17027483880519867,
-0.2965373992919922,
0.40640631318092346,
-0.3453108072280884,
0.06413574516773224,
0.12639348208904266,
-0.4635280966758728,
-0.660876989364624,
-0.08185700327157974,
0.2789400517940521,
0.34028545022010803,
0.3304997682571411,
-0.021709702908992767,
0.5384336709976196,
-0.08443975448608398,
0.18244506418704987,
0.6306268572807312,
-0.13485534489154816,
0.6150690317153931,
-0.7134429812431335,
0.6281424760818481,
0.052595414221286774,
-0.038477420806884766,
0.24264109134674072,
-0.2543688714504242,
-0.8042251467704773,
-0.26901936531066895,
0.6385922431945801,
0.4683842658996582,
-0.06282851845026016,
0.5598350167274475,
-0.16190746426582336,
-0.38931819796562195,
-0.6318081617355347,
-0.09976520389318466,
0.3910403847694397,
0.29321080446243286,
0.4275003671646118,
-0.3855116367340088,
-0.35929930210113525,
-1.004762053489685,
-0.2707102596759796,
-0.15909820795059204,
-0.03879861906170845,
0.5678677558898926,
0.25410258769989014,
-0.3653006851673126,
0.9995959997177124,
-0.5938057899475098,
-0.07692737877368927,
-0.2238258272409439,
0.5232737064361572,
-0.027860820293426514,
0.5920185446739197,
0.2131050080060959,
-0.7362313866615295,
-0.36595267057418823,
0.08378981798887253,
-0.7710574269294739,
0.005557188298553228,
0.23708629608154297,
-0.3672541379928589,
-0.1521761417388916,
0.32640472054481506,
-0.47627177834510803,
0.1142628863453865,
0.5132433772087097,
-0.09099914133548737,
0.3164439797401428,
-0.4333575665950775,
0.7118892073631287,
-0.9018041491508484,
0.00916165392845869,
0.13336287438869476,
-0.3946097195148468,
-0.5527958273887634,
0.04656524211168289,
0.15333089232444763,
0.019396435469388962,
-0.3995242118835449,
0.8251606822013855,
-0.33666467666625977,
0.022734662517905235,
-0.6881290078163147,
0.16248837113380432,
-0.24778291583061218,
0.6357581615447998,
0.4592718780040741,
0.5463014841079712,
0.2073584645986557,
-0.8508098125457764,
0.3552280068397522,
0.2568959891796112,
0.09186097979545593,
0.7991356253623962,
-0.5639500617980957,
0.23114202916622162,
0.04329506680369377,
0.048698313534259796,
-0.7612652778625488,
-0.5636430382728577,
0.23102229833602905,
-0.40678003430366516,
0.5101878046989441,
-0.3382366895675659,
0.040176551789045334,
-0.0842827707529068,
-0.15683341026306152,
0.3780375123023987,
0.6448763608932495,
-0.9440464973449707,
0.725273847579956,
0.5462430715560913,
-0.22347751259803772,
-0.6283252835273743,
-0.27543944120407104,
-0.07850626111030579,
-0.3512238562107086,
-0.7618376612663269,
0.8876309394836426,
0.06273947656154633,
-0.08302637934684753,
0.36477524042129517,
0.08221467584371567,
0.20467644929885864,
-0.0836171880364418,
0.22433346509933472,
0.5730631351470947,
-0.01758413389325142,
0.11458372324705124,
-0.11725504696369171,
-0.2369166612625122,
-0.06512659788131714,
-0.2767910361289978,
0.441697895526886,
-0.12691830098628998,
-0.4480937123298645,
-0.10896363854408264,
0.38000285625457764,
0.6021521091461182,
-0.2739690840244293,
0.6258184313774109,
0.38961371779441833,
-0.34047549962997437,
-0.41816240549087524,
-0.5793246626853943,
-0.3441355526447296,
-0.33579620718955994,
0.1784536987543106,
-0.32575899362564087,
-1.151526689529419,
0.21075758337974548,
-0.4404817223548889,
-0.05208546295762062,
0.2138833999633789,
0.4313304126262665,
-0.09166974574327469,
1.172918438911438,
0.8625157475471497,
-0.3225614130496979,
0.30966320633888245,
-0.059092335402965546,
0.10363072901964188,
-0.8186734318733215,
-0.4772372841835022,
-0.31350386142730713,
-0.49796685576438904,
-0.30258041620254517,
-0.41109317541122437,
-0.05369684472680092,
0.382374107837677,
-0.33564215898513794,
0.14292503893375397,
-0.3191491365432739,
0.3463710844516754,
0.6771023273468018,
0.0508519671857357,
0.2801065146923065,
-0.008210054598748684,
-0.1493995636701584,
-0.05333220213651657,
-0.7856055498123169,
-0.5070328712463379,
1.0664334297180176,
0.20163477957248688,
1.074763536453247,
-0.035974156111478806,
0.9258888959884644,
0.43532121181488037,
0.35755613446235657,
-0.9513124227523804,
0.42744070291519165,
-0.027733691036701202,
-0.0667782872915268,
-0.1741403192281723,
-0.17712470889091492,
-0.8508955240249634,
0.3372070789337158,
-0.15512077510356903,
-0.5573301911354065,
0.19854459166526794,
0.3076116144657135,
-0.35686177015304565,
0.13426576554775238,
-0.44454512000083923,
0.8398595452308655,
-0.45199063420295715,
-0.5040600299835205,
-0.44853368401527405,
-0.4818148612976074,
0.6029690504074097,
0.21477581560611725,
0.07569777220487595,
-0.023923225700855255,
0.060367826372385025,
0.8546066880226135,
-0.5844539999961853,
0.5243402123451233,
-0.10948815941810608,
-0.13357490301132202,
-0.21130341291427612,
-0.04553228244185448,
0.7722996473312378,
-0.3239598870277405,
0.5170043110847473,
-0.1217215284705162,
-0.22030328214168549,
-0.2591227889060974,
-0.7470340728759766,
0.7857460975646973,
-0.8786317706108093,
-0.6980939507484436,
-0.547265350818634,
-0.6025443077087402,
-0.5938698053359985,
-0.23471564054489136,
-0.2071516215801239,
0.19441206753253937,
-0.16906651854515076,
-0.10819040238857269,
0.8133330345153809,
-0.044958144426345825,
0.014033748768270016,
0.714646577835083,
-0.428972989320755,
-0.6654286980628967,
0.6744096875190735,
-0.5378589034080505,
0.04548812657594681,
0.2982763350009918,
0.015393057838082314,
-0.5307311415672302,
0.028557373210787773,
-0.26693055033683777,
0.3827790319919586,
-0.6199455857276917,
0.02549997717142105,
-0.6087486743927002,
-0.2654557228088379,
-0.09909562021493912,
-0.3289032280445099,
-0.3607798218727112,
-0.17839042842388153,
0.15411803126335144,
-0.04384363442659378,
0.4574776291847229,
0.9062975645065308,
-0.25821027159690857,
0.29890361428260803,
-0.9694649577140808,
0.019642777740955353,
0.5399335026741028,
0.2798142731189728,
0.21635442972183228,
-0.34044918417930603,
-0.44108355045318604,
-0.15317869186401367,
-0.021731851622462273,
-0.836739182472229,
0.4105536639690399,
-0.3136123716831207,
0.9529617428779602,
0.22249558568000793,
-0.01652933843433857,
0.604580819606781,
-0.1446029245853424,
0.6070652008056641,
0.46212533116340637,
-0.7110106348991394,
0.5329374074935913,
-0.2601308524608612,
-0.13051196932792664,
0.19032564759254456,
0.6702567338943481,
-0.8706501722335815,
-0.14492566883563995,
-0.7038881778717041,
-0.8935202360153198,
1.0759220123291016,
-0.46070942282676697,
-0.30853569507598877,
0.23896412551403046,
0.14292562007904053,
0.010128705762326717,
0.3219553828239441,
-0.4608854651451111,
-0.29936015605926514,
0.1685793697834015,
-0.3282412886619568,
-0.12658248841762543,
-0.12343864142894745,
-0.7126339673995972,
-0.25155308842658997,
0.8439763188362122,
0.07946521043777466,
0.17218855023384094,
-0.07921840250492096,
-0.21746119856834412,
-0.21928167343139648,
0.3367445766925812,
0.41504520177841187,
0.3315850794315338,
-0.36955878138542175,
0.27338194847106934,
-0.2155304104089737,
0.0431867390871048,
0.4606880247592926,
0.05012059956789017,
0.15294674038887024,
-0.5716444253921509,
0.05000985786318779,
0.9268335700035095,
0.34533417224884033,
-0.6039089560508728,
0.39673489332199097,
-0.09264737367630005,
-0.61837238073349,
0.2425231784582138,
0.47743409872055054,
0.3937508761882782,
0.5127544403076172,
0.12046553939580917,
0.0025674691423773766,
-0.09266002476215363,
-0.314812034368515,
0.4805132746696472,
0.49095600843429565,
-0.45979517698287964,
-0.08897553384304047,
0.7828425765037537,
0.22786802053451538,
-0.20374852418899536,
0.596149742603302,
-0.011242575943470001,
-0.7886565923690796,
0.41823363304138184,
0.5195462703704834,
0.9739245176315308,
-0.2098490446805954,
0.16792529821395874,
0.35237038135528564,
-0.20153166353702545,
-0.34221115708351135,
0.006221993360668421,
-0.21215790510177612,
-0.8327196836471558,
-0.39710620045661926,
-0.42802783846855164,
-0.589557945728302,
0.27496078610420227,
-0.877173125743866,
0.4087393879890442,
-0.06523289531469345,
-0.23651109635829926,
-0.0761088952422142,
-0.1849316954612732,
-0.7493718862533569,
0.20752312242984772,
0.071312315762043,
0.5016282796859741,
-0.9518103003501892,
0.8435736894607544,
1.1243449449539185,
-0.6507117748260498,
-0.9941539168357849,
-0.07721219211816788,
-0.17814607918262482,
-0.7372352480888367,
1.0589076280593872,
-0.13098695874214172,
-0.28397491574287415,
0.02027834579348564,
-0.4714617133140564,
-0.4306655526161194,
1.1033248901367188,
0.006786477752029896,
-0.4947727620601654,
0.10744555294513702,
-0.0835428461432457,
0.19802013039588928,
-0.8389725685119629,
0.13845650851726532,
0.685852587223053,
0.5208157896995544,
0.31298068165779114,
-0.7330197691917419,
0.10610280930995941,
-0.31446588039398193,
0.00706110056489706,
0.4737350344657898,
-0.5992006063461304,
0.7194366455078125,
-0.14553584158420563,
-0.054345253854990005,
-0.34317827224731445,
0.530358076095581,
0.4956241548061371,
0.12874136865139008,
0.5303797125816345,
0.9124332666397095,
0.9265924096107483,
-0.006614818703383207,
0.761604905128479,
-0.4816025495529175,
0.6131656169891357,
1.1656087636947632,
-0.4676140546798706,
0.971688985824585,
0.5294513702392578,
-0.31667855381965637,
0.38090261816978455,
0.8869338035583496,
0.08372608572244644,
0.8610154390335083,
0.16641728579998016,
-0.32755720615386963,
-0.7696805000305176,
-0.002843673573806882,
-0.6302634477615356,
0.08164847642183304,
-0.013323496095836163,
-0.20859494805335999,
-0.17232868075370789,
-0.08228122442960739,
-0.05649163946509361,
-0.04307634383440018,
-0.1142667606472969,
0.8783428072929382,
0.001660152687691152,
-1.1723806858062744,
0.45589154958724976,
0.1922384351491928,
0.9570176005363464,
-0.5996317267417908,
-0.13797396421432495,
-0.35402318835258484,
0.3161804676055908,
-0.15989653766155243,
-0.586094856262207,
0.0477435439825058,
-0.21459271013736725,
-0.5057486295700073,
-0.055727243423461914,
0.9052654504776001,
-0.9159860014915466,
0.19154544174671173,
0.6382231116294861,
0.6976425051689148,
0.05391495302319527,
0.07663091272115707,
-0.655517041683197,
-0.24189957976341248,
-0.0559304840862751,
-0.044437650591135025,
0.666569173336029,
-0.12554128468036652,
-0.002421300858259201,
0.5772040486335754,
0.6455138921737671,
0.09742660820484161,
-0.20957498252391815,
0.10538389533758163,
0.6931281685829163,
-0.7841642498970032,
-0.5121526122093201,
-0.741736650466919,
0.5771860480308533,
-0.06202321872115135,
0.14263615012168884,
0.4447263777256012,
0.4438498318195343,
0.9047773480415344,
-0.2684183716773987,
1.173295497894287,
0.12009155750274658,
0.3159184455871582,
-0.4377000331878662,
0.5558282136917114,
-0.9476423859596252,
0.16371825337409973,
0.148579403758049,
-0.7666719555854797,
0.12422548234462738,
0.4478504955768585,
-0.4916088879108429,
0.1214740201830864,
0.5938307046890259,
0.8181232810020447,
-0.2843432128429413,
-0.05487603321671486,
0.3718453049659729,
-0.45533835887908936,
0.2035474181175232,
0.8450031876564026,
1.1559802293777466,
-0.16535186767578125,
0.17843641340732574,
-0.11309726536273956,
-0.3192700445652008,
-0.4899384081363678,
-0.8603749871253967,
-0.7097936272621155,
-0.49324706196784973,
-0.49998739361763,
-0.29996296763420105,
0.09814219176769257,
1.239808201789856,
0.8856081962585449,
-0.7739497423171997,
-0.44306033849716187,
0.019614500924944878,
-0.004825653973966837,
-0.43001866340637207,
-0.2149185836315155,
0.3886561393737793,
-0.5833220481872559,
-0.8523105978965759,
0.2700246274471283,
0.40637028217315674,
0.12857908010482788,
-0.17426279187202454,
-0.7640748023986816,
0.02114124223589897,
0.2611011266708374,
0.27454838156700134,
0.3197603225708008,
-0.7278151512145996,
-0.03454657644033432,
-0.08239169418811798,
-0.36052507162094116,
0.015413259156048298,
1.019000768661499,
-0.6892918348312378,
0.37845462560653687,
0.43526268005371094,
0.9165143966674805,
0.6661757826805115,
0.26891905069351196,
1.1709949970245361,
-0.4385755956172943,
-0.06038988381624222,
-0.15727004408836365,
0.4490172266960144,
0.2655281722545624,
-0.24827535450458527,
0.6129931807518005,
0.16114532947540283,
-0.715809166431427,
-0.6590089201927185,
0.2135164588689804,
-1.0238139629364014,
-0.20477694272994995,
1.0268241167068481,
-0.16969098150730133,
-0.07119687646627426,
0.24405670166015625,
-0.1531120389699936,
0.32481348514556885,
-0.3159776031970978,
0.6000229716300964,
1.0010132789611816,
-0.38388070464134216,
-0.10020159184932709,
-0.2486657202243805,
0.7609155774116516,
0.48496416211128235,
-0.9330161809921265,
-0.00512713473290205,
0.4290926456451416,
0.4233303964138031,
-0.2191658467054367,
0.61722731590271,
-0.03236553072929382,
0.3765704929828644,
-0.23649761080741882,
0.5840707421302795,
-0.30900469422340393,
-0.2783988416194916,
-0.4772563576698303,
0.19876599311828613,
0.5789506435394287,
-0.2988598048686981
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01463v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01463v1 | Retrieval-augmented generation in multilingual settings | 2024-07-01T16:56:50 | 2024-07-01T16:56:50 | Nadezhda Chirkova, David Rau, Hervé Déjean, Thibault Formal, Stéphane Clinchant, Vassilina Nikoulina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) has recently emerged as a promising
solution for incorporating up-to-date or domain-specific knowledge into large
language models (LLMs) and improving LLM factuality, but is predominantly
studied in English-only settings. In this work, we consider RAG in the
multilingual setting (mRAG), i.e. with user queries and the datastore in 13
languages, and investigate which components and with which adjustments are
needed to build a well-performing mRAG pipeline, that can be used as a strong
baseline in future works. Our findings highlight that despite the availability
of high-quality off-the-shelf multilingual retrievers and generators,
task-specific prompt engineering is needed to enable generation in user
languages. Moreover, current evaluation metrics need adjustments for
multilingual setting, to account for variations in spelling named entities. The
main limitations to be addressed in future works include frequent
code-switching in non-Latin alphabet languages, occasional fluency errors,
wrong reading of the provided documents, or irrelevant retrieval. We release
the code for the resulting mRAG baseline pipeline at
https://github.com/naver/bergen. | [
-0.45577892661094666,
-0.36205849051475525,
0.23452994227409363,
0.21991318464279175,
0.12960976362228394,
0.4119105935096741,
-0.1767813116312027,
-0.44791117310523987,
0.21537408232688904,
0.3854685425758362,
-0.4573131799697876,
-0.321094274520874,
-0.2960412800312042,
0.5178946256637573,
0.07149872928857803,
1.0957257747650146,
-0.12382812052965164,
-0.08277259021997452,
-0.23182514309883118,
-0.3112390339374542,
-0.8755650520324707,
-0.6334818005561829,
-0.4656250774860382,
-0.2611737549304962,
0.8076069355010986,
0.6596300601959229,
0.3958163261413574,
0.2915859520435333,
0.10687582194805145,
0.17881980538368225,
-0.15759651362895966,
0.6609414219856262,
-0.5096582770347595,
0.6106411218643188,
-0.33310380578041077,
-0.25093597173690796,
-0.26228806376457214,
-0.31435948610305786,
0.7660724520683289,
0.5492451786994934,
-0.1306159794330597,
0.4026329815387726,
0.13954845070838928,
0.6599127650260925,
-0.9410589933395386,
-0.07689226418733597,
-0.6836634874343872,
-0.08337802439928055,
-0.34663477540016174,
-0.24956779181957245,
-0.62847900390625,
0.19097690284252167,
-0.2454025149345398,
-0.5624097585678101,
0.39573901891708374,
0.3621266782283783,
0.9259358644485474,
0.04287195950746536,
-0.5951611995697021,
-0.40990155935287476,
-0.4076266586780548,
0.862666130065918,
-0.3470919728279114,
0.7180988788604736,
0.4685543179512024,
0.27041104435920715,
-0.20523042976856232,
-0.7033680081367493,
-0.41366687417030334,
-0.16493229568004608,
-0.39087846875190735,
0.19652462005615234,
0.20454975962638855,
-0.40079647302627563,
0.32134610414505005,
0.16778449714183807,
-0.6823362112045288,
-0.014069327153265476,
-0.24194541573524475,
-0.31796687841415405,
0.4439578652381897,
0.07238585501909256,
0.037733469158411026,
-0.6669954061508179,
-0.3868218958377838,
0.04049209877848625,
-0.855330765247345,
-0.07751373946666718,
0.5738928914070129,
0.7641576528549194,
0.00045834522461518645,
0.4771198630332947,
-0.10919678211212158,
0.7483007311820984,
0.07282719016075134,
-0.1678159385919571,
0.3848515748977661,
-0.540148913860321,
0.15555314719676971,
-0.20273028314113617,
0.5102810263633728,
-0.04756263643503189,
-0.05566778406500816,
-0.062289975583553314,
-0.47925084829330444,
-0.35413965582847595,
0.26626381278038025,
-0.5833092927932739,
-0.041865576058626175,
0.1304861307144165,
-0.1730360984802246,
0.04190460592508316,
-0.257081001996994,
-0.8057764172554016,
-0.5812316536903381,
-0.3642726540565491,
0.19195939600467682,
-0.2530165910720825,
-0.36923953890800476,
-0.30748918652534485,
-0.13865552842617035,
0.1005324050784111,
0.014108676463365555,
-0.7035624384880066,
-0.35117480158805847,
0.3617216944694519,
0.5514326691627502,
-0.18429574370384216,
-0.5595481395721436,
-0.6789101362228394,
0.185215026140213,
-0.4662231206893921,
0.9254535436630249,
-0.4324735105037689,
-0.698424220085144,
0.2574514150619507,
-0.003286073449999094,
-0.2080645114183426,
-0.5099138021469116,
0.7672919034957886,
-0.7246348857879639,
0.6305736303329468,
-0.5886457562446594,
-0.17754685878753662,
0.16092649102210999,
0.42012274265289307,
-0.5251491069793701,
1.129969596862793,
0.14570534229278564,
-0.7450477480888367,
0.5871434807777405,
-0.46938785910606384,
-0.5157721638679504,
0.2564775049686432,
-0.2565499544143677,
-0.12659168243408203,
0.1390881985425949,
0.31950899958610535,
0.18595273792743683,
-0.30919384956359863,
0.3308897316455841,
0.3203105926513672,
-0.162413090467453,
-0.04885393753647804,
-0.43382149934768677,
0.6946167945861816,
0.6205906867980957,
0.07997876405715942,
-0.2212064564228058,
-0.8905150294303894,
0.027099134400486946,
-0.047605570405721664,
-0.5807591080665588,
-0.2841458320617676,
-0.014810063876211643,
0.1863342970609665,
0.3079319894313812,
0.40963155031204224,
-0.3258979320526123,
0.21003518998622894,
-0.12728966772556305,
-0.20497161149978638,
0.6631567478179932,
0.05212324857711792,
0.21152591705322266,
-0.2733953893184662,
0.9224281907081604,
-0.03179843723773956,
-0.23323777318000793,
-0.6133712530136108,
-0.3581675589084625,
-0.6133533716201782,
-0.5291414856910706,
0.45224785804748535,
0.7137895822525024,
-1.335401177406311,
-0.09569600224494934,
-0.1579321324825287,
-0.12423128634691238,
-0.6266518235206604,
0.23173531889915466,
0.6781046390533447,
0.8524171113967896,
0.29606908559799194,
0.04906503111124039,
-0.6260016560554504,
-0.8319588899612427,
-0.4159168004989624,
-0.25834569334983826,
-0.002004799200221896,
0.5938829779624939,
0.12704691290855408,
-0.3465716242790222,
0.9154888391494751,
-0.33906421065330505,
-0.1820010095834732,
-0.3506813943386078,
0.22230958938598633,
0.46021586656570435,
0.21424071490764618,
0.5414881706237793,
-0.9012618660926819,
-0.5772406458854675,
0.23577558994293213,
-0.8323900699615479,
-0.40314584970474243,
-0.1561523675918579,
-0.2246255725622177,
0.5995936989784241,
0.3664218485355377,
-0.5055534243583679,
-0.011654958128929138,
0.6613815426826477,
-0.4948790669441223,
0.889831006526947,
-0.3199644088745117,
0.6581476330757141,
-1.2965983152389526,
0.3824147880077362,
-0.10101164877414703,
-0.22006694972515106,
-0.6839032173156738,
0.39631107449531555,
0.241225928068161,
-0.36146947741508484,
-0.5480351448059082,
0.9702836871147156,
-0.7484232187271118,
-0.0014203343307599425,
-0.16426686942577362,
0.1660405546426773,
0.38753408193588257,
0.20310929417610168,
-0.212794229388237,
1.4400990009307861,
0.31889545917510986,
-0.6929976940155029,
-0.011732436716556549,
0.3353269696235657,
-0.2355250120162964,
0.8841986060142517,
-0.3190246522426605,
0.09289392083883286,
-0.24010753631591797,
0.023738892748951912,
-0.7832927703857422,
-0.4514058232307434,
-0.060721855610609055,
-0.6258793473243713,
0.7698865532875061,
-0.26941585540771484,
-0.5982288122177124,
-0.17305947840213776,
-0.10221204906702042,
0.2667354941368103,
0.29958850145339966,
-0.8094829320907593,
0.6864333748817444,
0.3037945628166199,
-0.2466152161359787,
-0.9540619850158691,
-0.44252198934555054,
0.3713648319244385,
-0.2777346670627594,
-0.7437033653259277,
0.15778127312660217,
0.056876715272665024,
-0.20065923035144806,
-0.406183660030365,
0.05648037791252136,
-0.12366881221532822,
-0.055327486246824265,
-0.27297598123550415,
0.310273140668869,
-0.058740854263305664,
0.34394434094429016,
0.15184615552425385,
-0.04993877187371254,
-0.22286885976791382,
-0.028822055086493492,
0.36799731850624084,
0.09171485155820847,
-0.21863681077957153,
0.23866717517375946,
0.5948836207389832,
0.2664327025413513,
-0.48283758759498596,
0.8009585738182068,
0.6694900393486023,
-0.14228495955467224,
-0.29663851857185364,
-0.5442982316017151,
0.059903934597969055,
-0.4919678270816803,
0.24429550766944885,
-0.9036361575126648,
-0.8688100576400757,
0.7697193622589111,
0.03910115361213684,
0.31382906436920166,
0.49294188618659973,
0.6429323554039001,
-0.1383114904165268,
0.8795893788337708,
0.5431112051010132,
0.3517799973487854,
0.2841672897338867,
0.10539664328098297,
0.1224406436085701,
-0.9584804773330688,
-0.16745474934577942,
-0.7662093639373779,
-0.010045638307929039,
-0.6773289442062378,
-0.3900226950645447,
0.63511723279953,
0.219047412276268,
-0.015892941504716873,
0.2819175124168396,
-0.2948019802570343,
0.40406960248947144,
0.4020826816558838,
-0.2590402066707611,
0.33649009466171265,
0.190604567527771,
-0.33675089478492737,
-0.24416226148605347,
-1.021288514137268,
-0.5419338345527649,
0.8938661813735962,
-0.06980942189693451,
0.5626237988471985,
0.29728934168815613,
0.7050692439079285,
0.3664243519306183,
0.2268245667219162,
-0.45232653617858887,
0.30856600403785706,
-0.16133959591388702,
-0.8708767890930176,
-0.020220709964632988,
-0.5183374881744385,
-1.2592158317565918,
0.5813615322113037,
-0.13229814171791077,
-0.3623811900615692,
0.28516438603401184,
0.34289881587028503,
-0.028088843449950218,
-0.08217082917690277,
-0.8979834914207458,
0.8305045366287231,
-0.12928928434848785,
-0.4043703079223633,
-0.01886974461376667,
-0.5514211654663086,
0.28087687492370605,
-0.28277429938316345,
0.5006771683692932,
0.12142582982778549,
-0.030541369691491127,
0.2768324315547943,
-0.0733482614159584,
0.46707212924957275,
-0.35480058193206787,
-0.34328290820121765,
0.2970784604549408,
0.05674506351351738,
0.6237614154815674,
0.2010832577943802,
-0.27117666602134705,
0.028154319152235985,
-0.10725106298923492,
-0.4500671625137329,
-0.3528234362602234,
0.7843207120895386,
-0.4363328516483307,
-0.6185880899429321,
-0.4663624167442322,
-0.8107522130012512,
-0.5057163834571838,
0.15765410661697388,
0.343011736869812,
0.5155020356178284,
-0.05537858605384827,
-0.08716132491827011,
0.629658579826355,
-0.5374213457107544,
0.26138144731521606,
0.5714371800422668,
-0.38828757405281067,
-0.43356508016586304,
1.144178032875061,
0.24681255221366882,
0.2096392810344696,
0.23899628221988678,
0.0020727624651044607,
-0.31453534960746765,
-0.2871720790863037,
-0.9714886546134949,
0.41886720061302185,
-0.7659370303153992,
-0.31975463032722473,
-0.49733954668045044,
0.25209540128707886,
-0.5588955879211426,
-0.08748234063386917,
-0.15334588289260864,
-0.43662029504776,
-0.4094201624393463,
0.061710841953754425,
0.28280505537986755,
0.41496720910072327,
-0.145069882273674,
-0.045303527265787125,
-0.9063712954521179,
0.4892553687095642,
0.04192718118429184,
0.29147884249687195,
-0.3092256486415863,
-0.7795513272285461,
-0.5955432057380676,
-0.13107097148895264,
-0.19504235684871674,
-0.7576547861099243,
0.33675870299339294,
0.41565704345703125,
0.6816672682762146,
-0.21091938018798828,
0.0443568117916584,
0.7915962338447571,
-0.8189750909805298,
0.9259822368621826,
-0.11660734564065933,
-0.5668962597846985,
0.440398633480072,
-0.47933265566825867,
0.5376338362693787,
0.6216824650764465,
0.32097867131233215,
-0.7928028702735901,
-0.3002420961856842,
-0.3390999436378479,
-1.0217747688293457,
0.5895829796791077,
-0.08876680582761765,
0.2684706151485443,
-0.32718604803085327,
0.28306522965431213,
0.1947987824678421,
0.357905775308609,
-0.30120307207107544,
-0.3641902506351471,
-0.028830740600824356,
-0.008119801990687847,
-0.0659051313996315,
-0.4130532443523407,
-0.1440795511007309,
0.29942432045936584,
0.90191650390625,
-0.27352121472358704,
0.03270374983549118,
0.10288682579994202,
-0.306286484003067,
0.032108038663864136,
0.49501121044158936,
0.4859474301338196,
1.0688140392303467,
0.08574840426445007,
-0.09505606442689896,
0.2367285043001175,
-0.310496062040329,
0.21908675134181976,
0.2547543942928314,
-0.365622878074646,
0.32482197880744934,
0.2652343213558197,
0.7572295665740967,
-0.02707054279744625,
-0.8020934462547302,
0.08966676145792007,
0.0009817668469622731,
0.1317116767168045,
-0.12191656976938248,
-0.22886061668395996,
-0.24560941755771637,
0.08300089836120605,
0.6829156279563904,
-0.11800140887498856,
0.13554775714874268,
-0.3627929389476776,
0.24739372730255127,
0.398512065410614,
0.029762348160147667,
-0.1946161687374115,
0.556422770023346,
0.22542543709278107,
-0.24738511443138123,
0.48737195134162903,
-0.5319204926490784,
-0.22388221323490143,
0.19059419631958008,
0.5185410380363464,
0.7272843718528748,
-0.24035683274269104,
0.18010245263576508,
0.34845709800720215,
0.30364689230918884,
0.07508012652397156,
0.38393622636795044,
0.1301218420267105,
-0.6075025200843811,
-0.8459497690200806,
-0.6895824670791626,
-0.35783645510673523,
-0.30833351612091064,
-0.6784026026725769,
0.4030936062335968,
0.07881035655736923,
-0.2091868668794632,
-0.30073782801628113,
-0.10383516550064087,
-0.6337152719497681,
0.08331383019685745,
0.07238694280385971,
0.8261792063713074,
-0.5298296809196472,
0.5728503465652466,
1.0089949369430542,
-0.21247194707393646,
-0.5717445611953735,
-0.1457531750202179,
-0.02315937727689743,
-0.6105484962463379,
0.5994675159454346,
-0.05524083226919174,
-0.17085514962673187,
0.019677074626088142,
-0.1864621639251709,
-0.8274458646774292,
0.9325992465019226,
0.5542516708374023,
-0.25447186827659607,
0.019377252086997032,
-0.16437643766403198,
0.6044850945472717,
-0.1870025098323822,
0.09939920902252197,
0.37762829661369324,
0.401719868183136,
0.06536649167537689,
-1.0609217882156372,
-0.3543829023838043,
-0.18599112331867218,
0.13512201607227325,
0.4268184304237366,
-0.5277804732322693,
0.7382532358169556,
-0.09898418933153152,
-0.4463365077972412,
-0.03323488309979439,
0.7005031108856201,
0.6854555606842041,
0.255424439907074,
0.25910744071006775,
0.6087063550949097,
0.834822952747345,
-0.020325230434536934,
1.309540867805481,
-0.517821729183197,
0.23687219619750977,
1.1767643690109253,
-0.48056137561798096,
0.6710232496261597,
0.6654512286186218,
-0.04348529502749443,
0.36833444237709045,
0.4363984763622284,
0.3944113552570343,
0.2946688234806061,
-0.18175357580184937,
-0.44811689853668213,
-0.03205646574497223,
-0.5904039740562439,
-0.4131802022457123,
0.2868131995201111,
0.3256337344646454,
-0.20590190589427948,
-0.19651314616203308,
0.22899861633777618,
0.17294317483901978,
0.28060707449913025,
-0.17754098773002625,
0.614791989326477,
-0.13951115310192108,
-0.872938871383667,
0.8464199304580688,
0.018590377643704414,
0.6557730436325073,
-0.5188742876052856,
-0.12246693670749664,
-0.5432344079017639,
-0.13231319189071655,
-0.1878175139427185,
-0.729342520236969,
0.33849605917930603,
0.4630089998245239,
-0.4736378788948059,
-0.5820558071136475,
0.7106241583824158,
-0.5124273300170898,
-0.5737552642822266,
0.09871285408735275,
0.8907362222671509,
0.16877850890159607,
0.2504420578479767,
-0.6208850741386414,
0.13150957226753235,
0.05524604022502899,
-0.49420034885406494,
0.47342658042907715,
0.6731299757957458,
-0.09400585293769836,
0.47307300567626953,
0.6168912649154663,
0.2129410356283188,
0.292898029088974,
0.4049051105976105,
0.6914669871330261,
-0.40099579095840454,
-0.20479433238506317,
-0.3662777543067932,
0.849658191204071,
0.11987467110157013,
-0.3732640743255615,
1.0114704370498657,
0.5664145946502686,
0.7737743854522705,
-0.09777291864156723,
0.7201234102249146,
-0.35526716709136963,
0.9525224566459656,
-0.43038448691368103,
0.5331804156303406,
-0.7149938941001892,
0.18978197872638702,
-0.09601777791976929,
-0.9626968502998352,
-0.22228848934173584,
0.23749150335788727,
0.22615280747413635,
-0.0007739450666122139,
0.5488603115081787,
0.8603805899620056,
0.13998936116695404,
-0.5878976583480835,
0.44220247864723206,
-0.10971002280712128,
0.44184643030166626,
0.1472962200641632,
0.6237544417381287,
-0.36676904559135437,
0.5525261759757996,
0.1778392493724823,
-0.0914091095328331,
0.23299694061279297,
-0.8783044219017029,
-0.6282207369804382,
-0.5508856177330017,
-0.09266030788421631,
-0.36250850558280945,
0.16963601112365723,
0.8088846206665039,
0.32839295268058777,
-0.7100957632064819,
-0.3859216868877411,
0.3817560076713562,
0.22045594453811646,
0.07623764872550964,
-0.19222010672092438,
0.016200879588723183,
-0.986199140548706,
-0.8311609029769897,
0.7045824527740479,
0.054017115384340286,
-0.33242008090019226,
-0.36376091837882996,
-0.13570868968963623,
-0.5189016461372375,
-0.09883306175470352,
0.7470877170562744,
0.44813570380210876,
-0.5805502533912659,
-0.31782540678977966,
0.20365746319293976,
-0.10129713267087936,
0.045051634311676025,
0.6520861387252808,
-0.914239764213562,
0.8241525292396545,
0.6961772441864014,
0.7753109931945801,
0.19792944192886353,
0.21788272261619568,
0.5904757380485535,
-1.4231460094451904,
0.24581998586654663,
0.17473842203617096,
0.407177209854126,
0.5562716722488403,
-0.3268565535545349,
0.5422717332839966,
0.16210898756980896,
-0.8478725552558899,
-0.9920827746391296,
0.40754204988479614,
-0.30652812123298645,
-0.11053518205881119,
1.2136403322219849,
-0.02596500888466835,
0.16916339099407196,
-0.18074136972427368,
-0.2956539988517761,
0.0883370041847229,
-0.44647568464279175,
0.5687606930732727,
0.8576253056526184,
-0.09785016626119614,
-0.24004164338111877,
-0.7699804902076721,
0.43759000301361084,
0.4428107440471649,
-0.7416836619377136,
0.13063769042491913,
0.9051664471626282,
-0.19936835765838623,
0.5122714042663574,
0.49024975299835205,
0.037117473781108856,
0.2253067046403885,
-0.13967467844486237,
0.19182029366493225,
-0.037201281636953354,
-0.6196040511131287,
-0.3416381776332855,
0.11374492943286896,
0.3130749762058258,
0.1718851923942566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01461v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01461v1 | Enhancing the Capability and Robustness of Large Language Models through Reinforcement Learning-Driven Query Refinement | 2024-07-01T16:55:28 | 2024-07-01T16:55:28 | Zisu Huang, Xiaohua Wang, Feiran Zhang, Zhibo Xu, Cenyuan Zhang, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The capacity of large language models (LLMs) to generate honest, harmless,
and helpful responses heavily relies on the quality of user prompts. However,
these prompts often tend to be brief and vague, thereby significantly limiting
the full potential of LLMs. Moreover, harmful prompts can be meticulously
crafted and manipulated by adversaries to jailbreak LLMs, inducing them to
produce potentially toxic content. To enhance the capabilities of LLMs while
maintaining strong robustness against harmful jailbreak inputs, this study
proposes a transferable and pluggable framework that refines user prompts
before they are input into LLMs. This strategy improves the quality of the
queries, empowering LLMs to generate more truthful, benign and useful
responses. Specifically, a lightweight query refinement model is introduced and
trained using a specially designed reinforcement learning approach that
incorporates multiple objectives to enhance particular capabilities of LLMs.
Extensive experiments demonstrate that the refinement model not only improves
the quality of responses but also strengthens their robustness against
jailbreak attacks. Code is available at:
https://github.com/Huangzisu/query-refinement . | [
-0.32366669178009033,
-0.9280035495758057,
0.5825441479682922,
0.02580794133245945,
-0.1516442596912384,
0.26189562678337097,
-0.5241534113883972,
-0.2619458734989166,
0.06150564178824425,
0.7232453227043152,
-0.5930832624435425,
-0.4722506105899811,
-0.28013861179351807,
0.14872369170188904,
-0.1653842031955719,
1.053577184677124,
0.14859876036643982,
-0.2770293056964874,
-0.05355367809534073,
-0.14829908311367035,
-0.6091064214706421,
-0.26302093267440796,
-0.8619071245193481,
0.02203924022614956,
0.6228229403495789,
0.5045298933982849,
0.6072900891304016,
0.21509775519371033,
0.15614528954029083,
0.3536732792854309,
-0.08557091653347015,
0.41179656982421875,
-0.768132209777832,
0.6667233109474182,
-0.5217775702476501,
-0.5548360347747803,
-0.08841344714164734,
-0.34935832023620605,
0.3879002332687378,
0.42848360538482666,
-0.2596244513988495,
-0.07065743952989578,
0.05516090989112854,
0.5691966414451599,
-0.58348149061203,
0.05994013324379921,
-1.0115785598754883,
-0.2841275632381439,
0.020147860050201416,
-0.2367440015077591,
-0.654223620891571,
-0.4397890865802765,
-0.006645823363214731,
-0.5420644879341125,
0.013730037026107311,
0.22545337677001953,
0.7121113538742065,
0.20043034851551056,
-0.3255707323551178,
-0.1456228643655777,
-0.48934075236320496,
0.6117117404937744,
-0.9152536988258362,
0.2381352037191391,
0.3711409866809845,
0.43678170442581177,
-0.7365500926971436,
-0.6748438477516174,
-0.33266884088516235,
-0.7135054469108582,
-0.046726856380701065,
-0.36234742403030396,
-0.1310841292142868,
0.07563552260398865,
0.4489820897579193,
0.05874933302402496,
-0.6028257608413696,
0.43750327825546265,
-0.29976144433021545,
-0.30231955647468567,
0.6512864828109741,
0.29404380917549133,
0.3241592347621918,
-0.10322237014770508,
-0.20540757477283478,
0.031722284853458405,
-0.9046888947486877,
0.28673115372657776,
0.46416059136390686,
0.5671383142471313,
0.19452369213104248,
0.36751994490623474,
-0.4935266673564911,
0.7648631930351257,
0.2879347503185272,
-0.2056073248386383,
0.033895816653966904,
-0.24624843895435333,
0.09961242228746414,
-0.18713776767253876,
0.9965735077857971,
0.10558652877807617,
0.129217728972435,
-0.26559561491012573,
-0.43850210309028625,
-0.4259997010231018,
0.5663281679153442,
-1.0163267850875854,
-0.11443613469600677,
0.3503713011741638,
-0.30490854382514954,
-0.5359989404678345,
0.06813175231218338,
-0.6379762291908264,
-0.6106985211372375,
-0.04581156000494957,
0.14386066794395447,
-0.552290678024292,
-0.1514904648065567,
0.1414666473865509,
0.26332026720046997,
-0.008566094562411308,
0.4187075197696686,
-1.0833582878112793,
0.21144872903823853,
0.5110928416252136,
0.4351678192615509,
-0.12213706970214844,
-0.010636603459715843,
-0.8020156025886536,
0.07439691573381424,
-0.25088974833488464,
0.5741418600082397,
-0.5598108172416687,
-0.5344294905662537,
0.015210955403745174,
0.11835794150829315,
0.17038841545581818,
-0.6881445646286011,
0.5741572380065918,
-1.0375275611877441,
0.07306915521621704,
-0.2734792232513428,
-0.3092802166938782,
-0.16320066154003143,
0.46351945400238037,
-0.739096999168396,
0.8138543963432312,
0.07847829908132553,
-0.5908970832824707,
0.21646720170974731,
-0.35445457696914673,
-0.6284011006355286,
0.058023907244205475,
-0.030785230919718742,
-0.3671196699142456,
0.09726723283529282,
0.4589902460575104,
0.261706680059433,
-0.17143499851226807,
0.39028361439704895,
-0.5490217208862305,
-0.37041157484054565,
0.4404790997505188,
-0.246634379029274,
0.5490278601646423,
0.3119543790817261,
-0.2034294307231903,
0.5123749375343323,
-0.8001070022583008,
0.18807168304920197,
0.19399942457675934,
-0.5860878825187683,
-0.27973082661628723,
0.11305595934391022,
-0.27315419912338257,
0.22234100103378296,
0.22865022718906403,
-0.39953896403312683,
0.3608793616294861,
-0.6766932010650635,
0.549521803855896,
0.8163069486618042,
0.07771598547697067,
0.3004276752471924,
-0.1883065551519394,
0.6256484389305115,
-0.13080745935440063,
0.10090171545743942,
-0.29718393087387085,
-0.18769022822380066,
-0.3216525614261627,
-0.10378897190093994,
0.23772364854812622,
0.627397894859314,
-1.036277413368225,
0.4094594419002533,
-0.00042727438267320395,
-0.5173124670982361,
-0.33942538499832153,
0.36841121315956116,
0.1992466151714325,
0.6738165020942688,
0.33903348445892334,
-0.2322341650724411,
-0.5951074957847595,
-0.578854501247406,
-0.4119459390640259,
-0.5105305910110474,
-0.03600793704390526,
0.4940439760684967,
0.3519059717655182,
-0.15542267262935638,
0.7313674688339233,
-0.4399026930332184,
0.13033154606819153,
-0.42363351583480835,
-0.06154899671673775,
0.21316325664520264,
0.4736746847629547,
0.40909701585769653,
-0.617103099822998,
-0.2299535721540451,
-0.18878237903118134,
-0.5100892186164856,
-0.30009642243385315,
-0.21126969158649445,
-0.012846068479120731,
-0.041123244911432266,
0.8092139959335327,
-0.4919740557670593,
0.14461344480514526,
0.248208686709404,
-0.4404175281524658,
1.0555764436721802,
-0.13615481555461884,
0.16178996860980988,
-0.967607855796814,
-0.018001871183514595,
-0.08865249902009964,
-0.46142974495887756,
-0.41411876678466797,
0.34519773721694946,
0.0721517875790596,
-0.1698043942451477,
-0.4756031036376953,
0.635672390460968,
-0.19127383828163147,
0.10600196570158005,
-0.4151170253753662,
0.13591594994068146,
0.06870559602975845,
0.32965266704559326,
-0.22790691256523132,
0.9452747702598572,
0.42801767587661743,
-0.6216230988502502,
0.6569416522979736,
0.04785840958356857,
-0.32633668184280396,
0.3942594826221466,
-0.8958774209022522,
-0.08836925774812698,
-0.02482146956026554,
0.21072961390018463,
-1.0818450450897217,
-0.14774110913276672,
0.20578663051128387,
-0.46174880862236023,
0.3303447663784027,
-0.30212780833244324,
-0.547092854976654,
-0.17683832347393036,
-0.35972175002098083,
0.30715858936309814,
0.47200679779052734,
-0.6499580144882202,
0.4062129259109497,
0.04007016867399216,
-0.3355049192905426,
-0.43058866262435913,
-0.354073166847229,
-0.0030269070994108915,
-0.2612680494785309,
-0.6212385296821594,
0.3496945798397064,
-0.10162000358104706,
-0.1085178479552269,
-0.13774113357067108,
-0.016233393922448158,
0.09928278625011444,
0.3498123586177826,
0.13762453198432922,
0.3526974022388458,
-0.13205432891845703,
0.2032262086868286,
0.10602555423974991,
0.0025109746493399143,
0.20384842157363892,
-0.3648287057876587,
0.5287883281707764,
-0.10036679357290268,
-0.4143177270889282,
-0.32170602679252625,
-0.028343744575977325,
0.4915791153907776,
-0.49083414673805237,
0.7693428993225098,
0.5914286971092224,
0.026307325810194016,
-0.4590485394001007,
-0.5335149168968201,
-0.5424804091453552,
-0.5712953805923462,
0.35522782802581787,
-0.3629961609840393,
-1.4860080480575562,
0.5243311524391174,
-0.3735290765762329,
-0.03991815820336342,
0.08745276927947998,
0.5083953738212585,
0.07294443994760513,
1.108458399772644,
0.5599285364151001,
-0.17146271467208862,
0.7116656303405762,
0.18311060965061188,
0.016648689284920692,
-0.7685877084732056,
-0.299468994140625,
-0.5685431957244873,
-0.11491041630506516,
-0.7528178691864014,
-0.24581004679203033,
0.07344315946102142,
0.13642823696136475,
-0.3697822690010071,
0.2317182868719101,
-0.27531230449676514,
0.5278155207633972,
0.3282094895839691,
0.260764479637146,
0.13416269421577454,
-0.03313041478395462,
-0.3957129716873169,
-0.06095598265528679,
-0.45548200607299805,
-0.4313915967941284,
1.047864556312561,
0.28823813796043396,
1.1041626930236816,
0.375846803188324,
0.6157885193824768,
0.16784176230430603,
0.09406457096338272,
-0.671398401260376,
0.5813239216804504,
0.24215221405029297,
-0.4467189311981201,
-0.25389695167541504,
-0.7591437101364136,
-0.9218384623527527,
0.36903923749923706,
-0.23822356760501862,
-0.9324353337287903,
-0.049091074615716934,
-0.012861521914601326,
-0.49028971791267395,
0.3072206377983093,
-0.5338646173477173,
0.7416300773620605,
-0.4048393666744232,
-0.7190949320793152,
-0.1736239343881607,
-0.43095868825912476,
0.5736996531486511,
-0.026389190927147865,
0.08623208105564117,
-0.12743119895458221,
-0.0920247733592987,
0.48410671949386597,
-0.5766860246658325,
0.9011977314949036,
-0.2651117444038391,
-0.11548229306936264,
0.2402247041463852,
0.3500957787036896,
0.7676575779914856,
0.5343080163002014,
-0.17007087171077728,
-0.5375056862831116,
-0.21978968381881714,
-0.3966042101383209,
-0.8535408973693848,
0.7808329463005066,
-0.4724893271923065,
-1.0114113092422485,
-0.03950730338692665,
-0.43289655447006226,
-0.47883856296539307,
0.41553252935409546,
-0.11955436319112778,
0.25998806953430176,
-0.16928371787071228,
0.12394389510154724,
1.0431493520736694,
-0.632908284664154,
0.18498845398426056,
0.8345854878425598,
-0.5744966864585876,
-0.2701605558395386,
0.7481940388679504,
-0.3282431662082672,
0.21168705821037292,
0.1571679711341858,
0.13171647489070892,
-0.4096054136753082,
-0.8136395812034607,
-0.32850468158721924,
0.15545201301574707,
-0.535696268081665,
-0.2833554744720459,
-0.24627016484737396,
-0.06494049727916718,
-0.4865244925022125,
0.038461215794086456,
-0.21737052500247955,
-0.21140342950820923,
-0.274105042219162,
-0.32447105646133423,
0.5321992039680481,
0.32798323035240173,
0.13203898072242737,
0.27074989676475525,
-0.7592687010765076,
0.2884659171104431,
0.39370134472846985,
0.3909556269645691,
0.001612114254385233,
-0.7994967103004456,
-0.09581439197063446,
-0.19798390567302704,
-0.33179375529289246,
-0.878205418586731,
0.4051932692527771,
-0.009050726890563965,
0.6068562269210815,
0.5277151465415955,
0.35705462098121643,
0.46273037791252136,
-0.40974342823028564,
0.7526565194129944,
0.05889730527997017,
-0.6563092470169067,
0.8709434866905212,
-0.4208321273326874,
0.2870485186576843,
0.925102174282074,
0.28189054131507874,
-0.2860349714756012,
-0.4222185015678406,
-0.4887811839580536,
-0.9990370273590088,
0.5850865840911865,
-0.20852942764759064,
0.3786637485027313,
-0.023431668058037758,
0.5365895628929138,
0.11170092225074768,
0.16441485285758972,
-0.600782573223114,
-0.024934878572821617,
-0.04144441336393356,
0.05993090942502022,
0.2575608193874359,
-0.3434409499168396,
-0.034094274044036865,
-0.22455143928527832,
0.7600662112236023,
-0.17973525822162628,
-0.26231202483177185,
-0.19163517653942108,
-0.167215958237648,
0.08065148442983627,
0.5981245636940002,
0.4247763156890869,
0.554111897945404,
-0.11916426569223404,
-0.008660131134092808,
0.2403039187192917,
-0.28695401549339294,
0.23731094598770142,
0.21015360951423645,
-0.27111542224884033,
-0.3206914961338043,
0.1944343000650406,
0.9435274600982666,
0.245550274848938,
-1.0988905429840088,
0.4018402695655823,
-0.396676242351532,
0.11252366006374359,
0.06829372048377991,
0.39733874797821045,
-0.04472964257001877,
0.3362361788749695,
0.12349409610033035,
-0.16264691948890686,
0.15294596552848816,
-0.47137853503227234,
0.28694581985473633,
0.4354877471923828,
-0.3150438368320465,
-0.17797094583511353,
0.7059550285339355,
0.16681015491485596,
-0.06155142933130264,
0.8355639576911926,
-0.3120056986808777,
-0.48583200573921204,
0.2852329611778259,
0.8120249509811401,
0.5290104150772095,
-0.2703583836555481,
0.2550104260444641,
0.559105634689331,
0.3378516733646393,
0.03600776195526123,
0.2686101496219635,
-0.14282427728176117,
-0.6108061075210571,
-0.4927576780319214,
-0.48642829060554504,
-0.32263681292533875,
0.28117766976356506,
-0.6820177435874939,
0.17023329436779022,
-0.8247247338294983,
-0.17367660999298096,
-0.4274466335773468,
0.10377653688192368,
-0.33227285742759705,
0.13936156034469604,
-0.024372657760977745,
0.9675837159156799,
-0.46567708253860474,
0.8076355457305908,
0.6091978549957275,
-0.6284348368644714,
-0.9633704423904419,
-0.11173389106988907,
0.0053285942412912846,
-0.7338079214096069,
0.5526381731033325,
0.10104601830244064,
-0.05724990367889404,
-0.19817394018173218,
-0.7730152606964111,
-0.7582640647888184,
0.8612476587295532,
0.44735291600227356,
-0.6618972420692444,
0.006137934047728777,
-0.05102114751935005,
0.4486640393733978,
-0.1640079915523529,
0.30230283737182617,
0.6463844776153564,
0.2578115463256836,
0.1487622708082199,
-0.7001679539680481,
0.47217294573783875,
-0.15567593276500702,
0.18426698446273804,
0.093535877764225,
-0.3399392366409302,
0.5958455204963684,
-0.5702471137046814,
-0.06322775781154633,
0.2220677137374878,
0.7888631224632263,
0.6752628087997437,
-0.13019631803035736,
0.42683908343315125,
0.5604798793792725,
0.912861704826355,
-0.07803204655647278,
1.0457566976547241,
-0.2222365140914917,
0.008844947442412376,
1.2632352113723755,
-0.3232896625995636,
0.9055290222167969,
0.4188561737537384,
-0.048059094697237015,
0.7586812376976013,
0.5289262533187866,
-0.07374587655067444,
0.6173405647277832,
0.5937004685401917,
-0.4695529639720917,
-0.28850871324539185,
-0.03201482445001602,
-0.21809321641921997,
0.1735820472240448,
0.541594386100769,
-0.36782121658325195,
-0.22674532234668732,
0.08533930778503418,
0.21656599640846252,
0.2892525792121887,
-0.3369981646537781,
0.893512487411499,
0.016690146178007126,
-0.7062070965766907,
0.685003936290741,
0.30909350514411926,
0.8345488905906677,
-0.7377244234085083,
0.09452062845230103,
-0.31367602944374084,
-0.0904344692826271,
-0.37064239382743835,
-0.6959306597709656,
0.02809077315032482,
0.17364969849586487,
-0.13226662576198578,
0.03013400174677372,
0.977263867855072,
-0.31691327691078186,
-0.1073540598154068,
0.28051936626434326,
0.35671094059944153,
-0.07508336752653122,
-0.08516420423984528,
-0.9100258350372314,
0.27267757058143616,
0.12947753071784973,
-0.3417319655418396,
0.5177659392356873,
0.4708419740200043,
-0.05483254790306091,
0.869308590888977,
0.8808767199516296,
0.34623777866363525,
-0.017758339643478394,
0.23461498320102692,
1.1268996000289917,
-0.5918888449668884,
-0.5752540826797485,
-0.8640197515487671,
0.517548143863678,
-0.06860983371734619,
0.09697846323251724,
0.7573588490486145,
0.32494887709617615,
0.8433610796928406,
0.10515616834163666,
0.8587920069694519,
0.011516719125211239,
0.36012089252471924,
-0.6101280450820923,
0.7305628657341003,
-0.43879279494285583,
0.7703481316566467,
-0.04104633256793022,
-0.6135412454605103,
-0.15921267867088318,
0.4820096492767334,
-0.6663625836372375,
0.317889004945755,
0.30688467621803284,
1.0707859992980957,
0.1101459339261055,
-0.229299858212471,
0.2797915041446686,
0.18622340261936188,
0.612327516078949,
0.5541332364082336,
0.9188224077224731,
-0.1038951426744461,
0.7024150490760803,
-0.036243148148059845,
-0.0667114332318306,
-0.34389978647232056,
-0.7345542907714844,
-0.8348482847213745,
-0.27168941497802734,
-0.15491123497486115,
-0.5959117412567139,
0.25670039653778076,
0.8848991394042969,
0.6599496006965637,
-0.8234544992446899,
-0.12886065244674683,
-0.013741159811615944,
0.32437825202941895,
0.019781405106186867,
-0.29546019434928894,
0.11747202277183533,
-0.8086645007133484,
-0.24597829580307007,
0.761481523513794,
0.09471890330314636,
-0.23674805462360382,
-0.2748548686504364,
-0.13427792489528656,
0.04152582213282585,
0.11683598905801773,
0.5911034345626831,
0.6489881873130798,
-0.6992253065109253,
-0.2633763253688812,
-0.1810520589351654,
-0.22632832825183868,
-0.07198872417211533,
0.7455304861068726,
-1.0992003679275513,
0.5265102386474609,
0.4247570037841797,
0.8587504029273987,
0.2388802468776703,
0.14125296473503113,
0.5591892600059509,
-0.9537216424942017,
0.058129094541072845,
0.292178213596344,
0.4075320363044739,
0.35502564907073975,
-0.44514399766921997,
0.07017810642719269,
-0.0823565348982811,
-0.5295941233634949,
-0.7736244201660156,
0.5313080549240112,
-0.7609707713127136,
-0.6046417951583862,
1.141839861869812,
-0.31451183557510376,
-0.2725813388824463,
-0.12242972105741501,
-0.47703129053115845,
-0.02030351012945175,
-0.6381886601448059,
0.7881696820259094,
0.42208704352378845,
-0.060302965342998505,
-0.4090321660041809,
-0.38659560680389404,
0.6437073945999146,
0.31766068935394287,
-0.9463309645652771,
0.2653607726097107,
0.6764413714408875,
0.6118337512016296,
-0.23660098016262054,
0.4181100130081177,
-0.345712810754776,
0.33528220653533936,
-0.30159035325050354,
-0.2210269421339035,
-0.3652898669242859,
-0.20574091374874115,
-0.3889232873916626,
0.3658920228481293,
0.6164581775665283,
0.23535823822021484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01455v1 | TimeToM: Temporal Space is the Key to Unlocking the Door of Large Language Models' Theory-of-Mind | 2024-07-01T16:50:49 | 2024-07-01T16:50:49 | Guiyang Hou, Wenqi Zhang, Yongliang Shen, Linjuan Wu, Weiming Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Theory of Mind (ToM)-the cognitive ability to reason about mental states of
ourselves and others, is the foundation of social interaction. Although ToM
comes naturally to humans, it poses a significant challenge to even the most
advanced Large Language Models (LLMs). Due to the complex logical chains in ToM
reasoning, especially in higher-order ToM questions, simply utilizing reasoning
methods like Chain of Thought (CoT) will not improve the ToM capabilities of
LLMs. We present TimeToM, which constructs a temporal space and uses it as the
foundation to improve the ToM capabilities of LLMs in multiple scenarios.
Specifically, within the temporal space, we construct Temporal Belief State
Chain (TBSC) for each character and inspired by the cognition perspective of
the social world model, we divide TBSC into self-world beliefs and social world
beliefs, aligning with first-order ToM (first-order beliefs) and higher-order
ToM (higher-order beliefs) questions, respectively. Moreover, we design a novel
tool-belief solver that, by considering belief communication between characters
in temporal space, can transform a character's higher-order beliefs into
another character's first-order beliefs under belief communication period.
Experimental results indicate that TimeToM can dramatically improve the
reasoning performance of LLMs on ToM questions while taking a big step towards
coherent and robust ToM reasoning. | [
-0.3465942144393921,
-0.922764003276825,
1.130235195159912,
0.1301463544368744,
-0.2846291661262512,
0.4268327057361603,
-0.1809462159872055,
-0.5162225365638733,
0.17684154212474823,
0.00594451604411006,
-0.6863124966621399,
-0.3387024700641632,
-0.4351089894771576,
-0.14466993510723114,
0.10636404901742935,
0.48170626163482666,
-0.0954534113407135,
-0.019802451133728027,
0.2653396427631378,
-0.09937459230422974,
-0.2073708027601242,
-0.6350181698799133,
-0.7786528468132019,
-0.47250664234161377,
0.7058590650558472,
-0.15431268513202667,
0.7654178738594055,
0.457221657037735,
0.3550138473510742,
0.247983917593956,
-0.16960738599300385,
0.30797240138053894,
-0.23822781443595886,
0.30330976843833923,
-0.6900656819343567,
-0.7262217998504639,
-0.8606487512588501,
-0.06543449312448502,
0.46220099925994873,
0.5338255763053894,
-0.2543483078479767,
-0.10577871650457382,
-0.12585999071598053,
0.26048943400382996,
-0.4822115898132324,
0.23763211071491241,
-0.7160544395446777,
0.18725138902664185,
-0.18492580950260162,
-0.5699692964553833,
-0.29588666558265686,
-0.4173923432826996,
0.17586159706115723,
-0.7870140671730042,
0.15723325312137604,
0.5419905185699463,
0.7573619484901428,
0.28802335262298584,
-0.45868465304374695,
0.011788388714194298,
-0.9008083343505859,
0.9167125821113586,
-0.6758333444595337,
0.46403127908706665,
0.18622414767742157,
0.6459190845489502,
-0.3789723217487335,
-0.15558357536792755,
-0.9713786244392395,
0.11703606694936752,
0.31674161553382874,
-0.09307795017957687,
0.12312169373035431,
0.10766538977622986,
0.2917969524860382,
0.31717565655708313,
-0.462100625038147,
-0.22189000248908997,
-0.038745298981666565,
-0.021695945411920547,
0.36443841457366943,
0.43990015983581543,
0.23250505328178406,
0.03897103667259216,
-0.13917143642902374,
-0.31732651591300964,
-0.5318402051925659,
-0.32012853026390076,
-0.28999602794647217,
0.04789188504219055,
0.08091361075639725,
0.38568615913391113,
0.005421140696853399,
0.4602764844894409,
-0.0882374569773674,
-0.3471621572971344,
-0.04720206931233406,
-0.13937869668006897,
-0.24391649663448334,
-0.0803331583738327,
0.3353854715824127,
0.3282656669616699,
0.2747863233089447,
-0.047765351831912994,
-0.04337524622678757,
0.5680448412895203,
0.21705734729766846,
-0.4636853039264679,
0.15208765864372253,
0.3674851357936859,
-0.31301164627075195,
-0.18493209779262543,
-0.17602302134037018,
-0.7487895488739014,
-0.5396311283111572,
-0.1263073980808258,
0.300408273935318,
-0.7690883874893188,
-0.5026512145996094,
0.24998895823955536,
-0.04045308381319046,
0.2933061420917511,
0.6668229103088379,
-0.6024345755577087,
0.24391479790210724,
0.6795483827590942,
0.9032096266746521,
0.010174616239964962,
-0.47654539346694946,
0.022565742954611778,
0.8594376444816589,
-0.5529534816741943,
0.6504222750663757,
-0.785870373249054,
-0.34681686758995056,
-0.24520114064216614,
-0.0601409450173378,
0.037602074444293976,
-0.005243275780230761,
-0.003691689344123006,
-0.4809073507785797,
0.4661678671836853,
-0.4167296588420868,
-0.6283866167068481,
-0.019234711304306984,
0.35554778575897217,
-0.3361942768096924,
0.5076513290405273,
0.07155348360538483,
-0.350215345621109,
0.4868572950363159,
-0.9895914793014526,
-0.43776991963386536,
0.11915678530931473,
-0.40793561935424805,
0.06455531716346741,
0.2654883861541748,
0.37505921721458435,
0.48225700855255127,
-0.5148533582687378,
0.6223154664039612,
-0.8140647411346436,
-0.09658072143793106,
0.4596964418888092,
-0.3129502236843109,
0.7048432230949402,
0.5935356020927429,
-0.3765751123428345,
-0.1773747205734253,
-0.4406534731388092,
0.19922126829624176,
0.4775034487247467,
-0.21151773631572723,
-0.6452802419662476,
0.3615768849849701,
-0.3755704164505005,
0.3153812289237976,
0.26953208446502686,
-0.6969272494316101,
0.4618905186653137,
-0.3801678717136383,
0.7400082945823669,
0.8427285552024841,
0.2702398896217346,
0.4138752520084381,
-0.4578779935836792,
0.3534342050552368,
0.14296801388263702,
0.30466797947883606,
-0.00009410710481461138,
-0.3630167841911316,
-0.7712208032608032,
0.12249372154474258,
-0.25462403893470764,
0.3381778299808502,
-0.8652995228767395,
0.49430930614471436,
-0.2953644096851349,
-0.5064122080802917,
-0.37250325083732605,
-0.2528892159461975,
0.4850831627845764,
0.0921182855963707,
0.28709542751312256,
0.08227404952049255,
-0.3750491142272949,
-0.5801553130149841,
-0.2530701458454132,
-0.564005434513092,
-0.11213714629411697,
0.11046841740608215,
0.5043814182281494,
-0.23599907755851746,
0.8603007197380066,
-0.9124924540519714,
-0.14871565997600555,
-0.1916961520910263,
-0.20786264538764954,
0.2195625752210617,
0.4465625286102295,
0.42033159732818604,
-0.5655624866485596,
0.2183075249195099,
0.003137205494567752,
-0.8313446640968323,
0.2737218737602234,
-0.14392004907131195,
-0.22028765082359314,
0.3294026553630829,
0.26781538128852844,
-0.6926308274269104,
0.5432694554328918,
0.27630606293678284,
-0.6129870414733887,
0.0878555029630661,
-0.23667237162590027,
0.3541790544986725,
-1.523797869682312,
-0.21380850672721863,
-0.06481078267097473,
0.04913676157593727,
-0.26721927523612976,
0.3380148410797119,
-0.09693469852209091,
-0.3475213050842285,
-0.021315760910511017,
0.9166387915611267,
-0.31716233491897583,
0.05043572559952736,
0.09028483182191849,
0.38442984223365784,
0.06066885590553284,
0.9044280052185059,
0.13041961193084717,
0.5914823412895203,
0.12402629107236862,
-0.8072367310523987,
0.08057907223701477,
0.2089082896709442,
-0.3606589436531067,
0.7026390433311462,
-0.5535610914230347,
0.35689646005630493,
0.020435180515050888,
0.3739459216594696,
-1.0790927410125732,
-0.2960030138492584,
0.0813959613442421,
-0.46688205003738403,
0.1875184327363968,
0.16372716426849365,
-0.6693843007087708,
-0.3765105605125427,
0.18059121072292328,
0.44736406207084656,
0.48569610714912415,
-0.503746747970581,
0.712049663066864,
0.5802099704742432,
0.016159409657120705,
-0.2206975519657135,
-0.6951003670692444,
0.015612724237143993,
-0.1467972993850708,
-0.6211070418357849,
0.41352447867393494,
-0.25497591495513916,
-0.6474321484565735,
-0.042707059532403946,
-0.36506152153015137,
-0.19683825969696045,
0.07701113075017929,
-0.014039129950106144,
0.2626034915447235,
-0.10090959072113037,
0.47141778469085693,
0.3815682530403137,
-0.0877327173948288,
-0.0007239158730953932,
-0.7560164928436279,
0.7133562564849854,
-0.2699417471885681,
-0.41715991497039795,
-0.11112760007381439,
0.24773892760276794,
0.8314959406852722,
-0.047130655497312546,
0.7107996344566345,
0.07216379046440125,
-0.6338987946510315,
-0.409527450799942,
-0.735181450843811,
-0.04955214634537697,
-0.4668487012386322,
0.2683488130569458,
-0.5668647289276123,
-0.9945334196090698,
0.2916661500930786,
-0.0643981546163559,
0.29257458448410034,
0.08399663865566254,
0.48334962129592896,
-0.2916519343852997,
0.9490220546722412,
0.5313937664031982,
-0.12901194393634796,
0.42022624611854553,
-0.02819773554801941,
0.3808201551437378,
-0.7053641080856323,
-0.27140432596206665,
-0.1782955676317215,
-0.36543670296669006,
-0.1934082955121994,
-0.7086255550384521,
0.5557427406311035,
-0.15845057368278503,
-0.2903710603713989,
0.429130882024765,
-0.38410845398902893,
0.33932504057884216,
0.18300363421440125,
0.16644108295440674,
0.2817329168319702,
-0.021134700626134872,
-0.4842706620693207,
-0.010037768632173538,
-0.6037530899047852,
-0.5378789305686951,
0.7471784353256226,
0.4682450592517853,
0.80150306224823,
0.43813207745552063,
0.5035699009895325,
0.20985491573810577,
-0.14788417518138885,
-0.599967360496521,
0.8920236825942993,
0.0954211875796318,
-1.0786811113357544,
-0.46684789657592773,
-0.2398601472377777,
-0.7646257281303406,
0.3363998234272003,
-0.08334285765886307,
-0.8898293972015381,
0.16160136461257935,
0.18182934820652008,
-0.4891357421875,
0.5936200618743896,
-0.5655198097229004,
0.39540717005729675,
-0.32671356201171875,
-0.27913394570350647,
-0.7684568762779236,
-0.5752257108688354,
0.07961573451757431,
0.07531344145536423,
0.04944451153278351,
-0.13858744502067566,
-0.027128737419843674,
0.699188768863678,
-0.49581682682037354,
0.7666142582893372,
-0.20387910306453705,
-0.45048367977142334,
0.1939316689968109,
0.6095322370529175,
0.31410425901412964,
0.14002157747745514,
0.1718776524066925,
0.13135561347007751,
0.37111392617225647,
-0.36335545778274536,
-1.0013993978500366,
0.41580986976623535,
-0.7443943023681641,
-0.8339546918869019,
-0.4768826365470886,
-0.7470870018005371,
-0.556712806224823,
0.13860271871089935,
-0.04104171320796013,
0.5791052579879761,
-0.18396903574466705,
0.028965936973690987,
0.8454720377922058,
-0.3676978349685669,
0.36648058891296387,
0.5363149046897888,
-0.46766769886016846,
-0.4467165172100067,
0.6152776479721069,
-0.07602716237306595,
0.26376107335090637,
0.8820445537567139,
0.25571301579475403,
-0.2487500160932541,
-0.11240598559379578,
0.3213036060333252,
0.4135158956050873,
-0.7114907503128052,
0.06785468012094498,
-0.594977617263794,
-0.20283809304237366,
-0.35729193687438965,
-0.3007729649543762,
-0.3150004744529724,
-0.6339505910873413,
0.26571372151374817,
-0.014906576834619045,
0.15199457108974457,
0.6507489681243896,
0.204074889421463,
0.37061354517936707,
-0.6427582502365112,
0.31992459297180176,
0.3539215326309204,
0.35119199752807617,
0.09465382993221283,
-0.16165146231651306,
0.065045066177845,
0.04444435238838196,
-0.2355816811323166,
-0.7352245450019836,
0.2699447572231293,
-0.3162703514099121,
0.4434170722961426,
0.47480541467666626,
-0.15227864682674408,
1.1285593509674072,
-0.5094826817512512,
0.5865011811256409,
0.14295800030231476,
-1.10347318649292,
0.8115478157997131,
-0.614871621131897,
0.423518568277359,
0.0650474950671196,
0.059330325573682785,
-0.7975865006446838,
-0.5780450105667114,
-0.7620172500610352,
-0.3884781301021576,
0.44156238436698914,
0.29664501547813416,
-0.4407496154308319,
-0.06481163203716278,
0.35575759410858154,
0.027266360819339752,
0.2882893979549408,
-0.5344096422195435,
0.09210255742073059,
-0.11524485796689987,
-0.15627801418304443,
-0.20814312994480133,
-0.14064069092273712,
-0.21533648669719696,
-0.33760616183280945,
0.4683874249458313,
-0.1344010829925537,
0.653617262840271,
0.3631901144981384,
0.038122933357954025,
-0.3770206868648529,
0.6628242135047913,
0.5123376846313477,
1.1152141094207764,
-0.2693016231060028,
0.14260199666023254,
0.24218519032001495,
-0.2669455409049988,
0.28673243522644043,
-0.32765188813209534,
0.1779547482728958,
-0.356954425573349,
0.5287676453590393,
0.5948353409767151,
0.20663364231586456,
-0.14785385131835938,
0.1573740392923355,
-0.09490864723920822,
-0.05536564439535141,
-0.5917596220970154,
0.3027801513671875,
-0.04021184518933296,
0.7212544679641724,
0.4770818054676056,
0.05294479802250862,
-0.46636509895324707,
-0.7429858446121216,
0.04702167212963104,
0.24364358186721802,
-0.08856050670146942,
-0.463149756193161,
0.814789354801178,
0.2573625445365906,
-0.4643533229827881,
0.3198481500148773,
-0.1345209926366806,
-0.5441861748695374,
0.42636504769325256,
0.6277048587799072,
1.0039130449295044,
-0.2831410765647888,
0.12614545226097107,
0.148295596241951,
0.49318578839302063,
0.06144805625081062,
0.5841180682182312,
-0.10364335775375366,
-1.1077208518981934,
-0.4433780908584595,
-0.5624186396598816,
-0.33562231063842773,
0.24123911559581757,
-0.48378631472587585,
-0.07872238755226135,
-1.0653332471847534,
-0.35640856623649597,
-0.25799494981765747,
0.26882204413414,
-0.5428041219711304,
0.18852177262306213,
0.1489238440990448,
0.9610865116119385,
-0.35976696014404297,
1.2146140336990356,
0.6124128103256226,
-0.09650813043117523,
-0.762305498123169,
0.36101189255714417,
0.28726062178611755,
-0.9173856377601624,
0.5912522673606873,
-0.08742869645357132,
-0.4555397033691406,
-0.15250703692436218,
-0.7233957052230835,
-0.9610733389854431,
1.4150700569152832,
0.18201115727424622,
-0.8683238625526428,
-0.4732271432876587,
-0.34845882654190063,
0.6844474077224731,
-0.5384523868560791,
-0.22514577209949493,
0.32950660586357117,
0.31115758419036865,
0.046921923756599426,
-0.7458211183547974,
0.30970636010169983,
-0.3331899344921112,
0.30825453996658325,
0.46821773052215576,
-0.8624457716941833,
0.7428317070007324,
-0.35943305492401123,
-0.4637490212917328,
0.07510059326887131,
0.7285755276679993,
0.730674684047699,
0.2664186656475067,
0.6814695000648499,
0.4479573667049408,
0.9098977446556091,
-0.1813385784626007,
1.0130292177200317,
-0.3004511594772339,
0.2640342712402344,
1.04208505153656,
-0.5120874047279358,
0.5164808034896851,
0.5745770931243896,
-0.3176732063293457,
0.550177812576294,
0.46906524896621704,
0.15905329585075378,
0.39543581008911133,
-0.10268627107143402,
0.0340312123298645,
-0.5641161203384399,
0.04335248842835426,
-0.40070363879203796,
0.17288579046726227,
0.7805906534194946,
0.15245498716831207,
0.03963268920779228,
-0.16106703877449036,
0.2459658980369568,
-0.033425189554691315,
-0.08473477512598038,
0.35790494084358215,
0.22776687145233154,
-0.6155237555503845,
0.2824581563472748,
-0.1725207269191742,
0.3257438540458679,
-0.8407723307609558,
-0.10417052358388901,
-0.12116812914609909,
0.5629551410675049,
0.2831301987171173,
-0.8223921060562134,
0.037800196558237076,
-0.26165851950645447,
0.059242408722639084,
-0.1782742589712143,
0.5519536733627319,
-0.34443655610084534,
-0.29681596159935,
0.4930446147918701,
0.5341395139694214,
0.003576330142095685,
0.2849198281764984,
-0.6349611282348633,
-0.009753190912306309,
-0.19545307755470276,
-0.17599910497665405,
-0.003004138357937336,
0.7743856310844421,
-0.01243828609585762,
1.1101523637771606,
0.3643703758716583,
0.377734512090683,
-0.27785202860832214,
-0.024492910131812096,
0.7541555762290955,
-1.1949471235275269,
-0.7604178786277771,
-0.954581081867218,
0.006898228079080582,
-0.2322423905134201,
-0.3649446368217468,
0.5769007802009583,
-0.048622556030750275,
0.8681921362876892,
0.08229836821556091,
0.8085796236991882,
-0.3471117615699768,
0.5250144600868225,
-0.8002937436103821,
0.7078660130500793,
-0.813230574131012,
0.29107892513275146,
-0.6534594893455505,
-0.9347971677780151,
-0.1191231831908226,
0.7059223651885986,
-0.3833777606487274,
0.07363881170749664,
1.3511158227920532,
0.5399394035339355,
0.17615805566310883,
0.1815168708562851,
0.49757882952690125,
0.48236843943595886,
0.6445584893226624,
1.1542198657989502,
1.0245009660720825,
-0.12033595889806747,
0.4290989935398102,
-0.09650985151529312,
-0.22550234198570251,
0.16082075238227844,
-0.6856390833854675,
-1.3173352479934692,
-0.8850044012069702,
-0.04291990399360657,
-0.4059368968009949,
0.11916793137788773,
1.3016124963760376,
0.581032395362854,
-0.5637098550796509,
-0.416094034910202,
0.07351072132587433,
0.11351937800645828,
-0.2020571529865265,
-0.24972125887870789,
0.00807681493461132,
-0.16779829561710358,
-0.5267166495323181,
0.46542033553123474,
0.6538647413253784,
0.1887146532535553,
-0.40839883685112,
-0.08283108472824097,
-0.29427728056907654,
0.22445553541183472,
0.7244361042976379,
0.014819331467151642,
-1.0678759813308716,
-0.6802034974098206,
0.06467120349407196,
0.1040683165192604,
-0.05102495849132538,
1.193899393081665,
-0.5422232747077942,
0.32900115847587585,
0.27184638381004333,
0.45171570777893066,
0.3850157856941223,
-0.33451399207115173,
0.9723286628723145,
-0.5746840834617615,
0.1953926682472229,
0.16926835477352142,
0.6280762553215027,
-0.03892753645777702,
-0.44447264075279236,
0.7496431469917297,
0.4740864038467407,
-0.36113137006759644,
-0.6918588280677795,
0.6775861382484436,
-0.8897910714149475,
-0.8134974837303162,
0.999670147895813,
0.12299435585737228,
-0.5116356611251831,
-0.1496836394071579,
-0.046136658638715744,
0.4243113398551941,
-0.564728319644928,
1.0093456506729126,
0.9473584294319153,
-0.037624865770339966,
-0.00017459946684539318,
-0.15434864163398743,
0.3012533485889435,
0.47223392128944397,
-0.9109886288642883,
0.09621960669755936,
0.38141191005706787,
0.192085400223732,
0.5726446509361267,
0.7658801674842834,
-0.331530898809433,
-0.015695111826062202,
-0.05338228493928909,
-0.21916982531547546,
-0.020116224884986877,
-0.6847299933433533,
-0.10145310312509537,
0.15568336844444275,
-0.18205121159553528,
0.04215603321790695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01437v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01437v1 | Needle in the Haystack for Memory Based Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T16:32:16 | 2024-07-01T16:32:16 | Subhajit Chaudhury, Soham Dan, Payel Das, Georgios Kollias, Elliot Nelson | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this paper, we demonstrate the benefits of using memory augmented Large
Language Model (LLM) architecture in improving the recall abilities of facts
from a potentially long context. As a case study we test LARIMAR, a recently
proposed LLM architecture which augments a LLM decoder with an external
associative memory, on several long-context recall tasks, including passkey and
needle-in-the-haystack tests. We demonstrate that the external memory can be
adapted at test time to handle contexts much longer than those seen during
training, while keeping readouts from the memory recognizable to the trained
decoder and without increasing GPU memory footprint. Compared to alternative
architectures for long-context recall tasks with models of a comparable
parameter count, LARIMAR is able to maintain strong performance without any
task-specific training. | [
-0.03297700732946396,
-0.7350555658340454,
0.7707379460334778,
-0.18350620567798615,
-0.2044103443622589,
-0.11097704619169235,
-0.3390059769153595,
-0.787250816822052,
0.2644641399383545,
0.4374839961528778,
0.12770991027355194,
-0.14392291009426117,
-0.37781912088394165,
-0.10167902708053589,
-0.6406108140945435,
0.7670639753341675,
-0.30246275663375854,
-0.09946585446596146,
-0.2058412879705429,
-0.3224012553691864,
-0.5628650188446045,
-0.9398916959762573,
-0.8385264277458191,
-0.18139417469501495,
0.522045910358429,
0.06840882450342178,
0.2276887148618698,
0.6604803800582886,
0.33203330636024475,
0.28547340631484985,
-0.3433045446872711,
0.2999182343482971,
-0.4776035249233246,
0.024792272597551346,
-0.22425539791584015,
-0.5051748752593994,
-0.4858608841896057,
-0.38869184255599976,
0.882451057434082,
0.47812676429748535,
-0.37046942114830017,
0.017985118553042412,
-0.08239332586526871,
0.5670440196990967,
-0.741729736328125,
0.13253635168075562,
-0.7772608399391174,
-0.2651761472225189,
-0.12312531471252441,
-0.2211950719356537,
-0.5661486387252808,
-0.013754365034401417,
-0.029274053871631622,
-0.23733903467655182,
-0.009348399937152863,
0.13071687519550323,
0.4684259295463562,
0.14278748631477356,
-0.3766011595726013,
-0.47002682089805603,
-0.6929500699043274,
0.6571894288063049,
-0.6981183886528015,
0.44519901275634766,
0.47560152411460876,
0.25015443563461304,
-0.186356782913208,
-0.5173322558403015,
-0.46265116333961487,
-0.19968104362487793,
-0.11729644984006882,
-0.09556378424167633,
0.11314209550619125,
-0.04064467176795006,
0.2687786817550659,
0.41232940554618835,
-0.16111259162425995,
-0.016223320737481117,
-0.3992752730846405,
-0.16396403312683105,
0.27262428402900696,
0.28791534900665283,
0.1823589950799942,
0.12145601212978363,
-0.34246817231178284,
0.16698653995990753,
-0.9384351372718811,
0.17705942690372467,
-0.108368419110775,
0.3667692542076111,
0.05233345553278923,
0.5857924818992615,
-0.04887695610523224,
0.7999148368835449,
0.07153471559286118,
-0.1442870944738388,
0.18242698907852173,
-0.2835935950279236,
-0.18496939539909363,
0.4650123417377472,
0.19289083778858185,
-0.07730672508478165,
-0.001887079793959856,
-0.2259022444486618,
-0.444892555475235,
-0.03789948672056198,
0.25857728719711304,
-0.9141095280647278,
-0.036215268075466156,
0.12188404053449631,
-0.31436800956726074,
0.4203746020793915,
-0.17468659579753876,
-0.3846815228462219,
-0.41838765144348145,
-0.06412745267152786,
0.6327415704727173,
-0.585154116153717,
0.08476173132658005,
0.35294395685195923,
0.004068868700414896,
0.3119233548641205,
0.47422873973846436,
-0.8417233228683472,
0.3419840931892395,
0.8749099373817444,
0.9850142002105713,
-0.311281681060791,
-0.25660577416419983,
-0.9358863234519958,
0.46617797017097473,
-0.40241149067878723,
0.9202220439910889,
-0.6211042404174805,
-0.25806528329849243,
0.13243412971496582,
0.16464342176914215,
-0.03395738825201988,
-0.7326927781105042,
0.26501917839050293,
-0.8815094232559204,
0.03152129799127579,
-0.37457525730133057,
-0.7454146146774292,
-0.4223290979862213,
0.2794918715953827,
-0.8636215925216675,
1.0115165710449219,
0.12957511842250824,
-0.5837680697441101,
0.21450161933898926,
-0.5465611219406128,
-0.6014851927757263,
-0.10096382349729538,
-0.13505861163139343,
-0.18826597929000854,
0.3337121903896332,
0.1690659075975418,
0.4835640788078308,
-0.13764245808124542,
0.06487814337015152,
-0.15581218898296356,
-1.0375877618789673,
0.2777560353279114,
-0.28771910071372986,
0.49671295285224915,
-0.16518504917621613,
-0.1474500298500061,
0.046090658754110336,
-0.7577617764472961,
-0.3483095169067383,
0.03198845311999321,
-0.9398788809776306,
-0.659138023853302,
0.03840611129999161,
-0.14156749844551086,
-0.02674475871026516,
0.47601890563964844,
-0.4891092777252197,
0.17360855638980865,
-0.42235007882118225,
0.18333564698696136,
0.8433035612106323,
-0.09866710007190704,
0.334602415561676,
-0.37734225392341614,
0.13858230412006378,
0.17664095759391785,
-0.42736315727233887,
-0.5594265460968018,
-0.027660584077239037,
-1.0788580179214478,
-0.5464519262313843,
0.07160639762878418,
0.5451592803001404,
-0.5987758040428162,
0.1814173310995102,
-0.20921732485294342,
0.01699526235461235,
-0.32754382491111755,
0.254874587059021,
0.23661810159683228,
0.46694663166999817,
0.2115873396396637,
-0.23772890865802765,
-0.6909005045890808,
-0.7037867307662964,
-0.049120496958494186,
-0.19598858058452606,
0.013298442587256432,
0.4601835608482361,
0.4644835293292999,
-0.25020477175712585,
0.539595901966095,
-0.359139621257782,
-0.33548858761787415,
-0.21443495154380798,
-0.30537524819374084,
0.5709040760993958,
0.038504794239997864,
0.2965783178806305,
-0.47789064049720764,
-0.2239563912153244,
0.0052408636547625065,
-0.617292582988739,
0.32632365822792053,
-0.17961673438549042,
0.09910213202238083,
0.683469831943512,
0.70948725938797,
-0.9118223190307617,
0.22523199021816254,
0.42266127467155457,
-0.5552905797958374,
0.2962569296360016,
-0.520502507686615,
0.23819926381111145,
-0.9620123505592346,
0.27259913086891174,
-0.44686388969421387,
-0.2581801414489746,
-0.5609666109085083,
0.1185629665851593,
0.33964985609054565,
0.23950818181037903,
-0.6969581246376038,
0.9490043520927429,
-0.5533994436264038,
-0.22877420485019684,
-0.451433390378952,
-0.11313088238239288,
-0.09677497297525406,
0.34766143560409546,
0.22565220296382904,
1.354935884475708,
0.41915538907051086,
-0.7765412330627441,
0.3218275308609009,
0.1466628611087799,
-0.7429473400115967,
0.4274689853191376,
-0.4011543095111847,
0.2772981822490692,
-0.26745012402534485,
0.33394938707351685,
-0.8001996874809265,
-0.19296269118785858,
-0.12143057584762573,
-0.08025702834129333,
0.4213787019252777,
0.1579626053571701,
-0.5013012886047363,
-0.13596412539482117,
-0.22614507377147675,
0.5923638939857483,
0.6226620078086853,
-1.0824517011642456,
0.7564952373504639,
0.3384954631328583,
0.018750658258795738,
-0.44296368956565857,
-0.5479291081428528,
0.12982840836048126,
-0.5428035855293274,
-0.2537314295768738,
0.1924811750650406,
-0.1609361320734024,
-0.3016960620880127,
-0.26388418674468994,
0.1196630522608757,
-0.13648244738578796,
0.010784180834889412,
0.22277982532978058,
0.2729854881763458,
-0.4326680898666382,
0.5945551991462708,
-0.5161788463592529,
0.09357337653636932,
-0.08109454065561295,
0.10629049688577652,
0.6549562215805054,
-0.3555585443973541,
-0.2318415343761444,
-0.09653697162866592,
0.4129340648651123,
0.4503609836101532,
-0.07413147389888763,
0.9908056259155273,
0.20414546132087708,
-0.326292484998703,
-0.12811122834682465,
-0.7705692648887634,
-0.028855063021183014,
-0.4858727753162384,
0.7504916191101074,
-0.40447792410850525,
-1.0667554140090942,
0.7563232183456421,
0.005032205022871494,
-0.1301717758178711,
0.1524326503276825,
0.6814589500427246,
-0.019173303619027138,
0.6273818016052246,
0.4279593527317047,
-0.398693323135376,
0.5177930593490601,
0.04454875737428665,
0.08420321345329285,
-1.207869291305542,
0.02590378001332283,
-0.023376889526844025,
-0.1380394548177719,
-0.006744162179529667,
-0.7450621724128723,
0.354024201631546,
0.15673202276229858,
-0.4327622354030609,
0.13851423561573029,
-0.14906354248523712,
0.5566468834877014,
0.46031084656715393,
0.1551956683397293,
0.3873230516910553,
-0.09037662297487259,
0.02617688477039337,
0.2835313677787781,
-0.6885982155799866,
-0.1848451793193817,
1.0050792694091797,
0.4402633011341095,
0.8018227815628052,
0.10468345135450363,
0.5644087791442871,
-0.0021605927031487226,
0.25792643427848816,
-0.9414006471633911,
0.744515061378479,
-0.24342556297779083,
-0.5136573314666748,
-0.19250868260860443,
-0.10309401899576187,
-0.8045204877853394,
0.24222825467586517,
0.03193369507789612,
-0.713417112827301,
-0.041305817663669586,
0.25393855571746826,
-0.5503247976303101,
0.5262661576271057,
-0.4749409854412079,
0.3297235369682312,
-0.4422626197338104,
-0.5078498721122742,
-0.3105872869491577,
0.00563610065728426,
0.5335230827331543,
-0.3081842362880707,
0.07540822774171829,
0.16118496656417847,
-0.3393939137458801,
0.6838555335998535,
-0.14982935786247253,
0.871222972869873,
-0.05908166244626045,
-0.2383510172367096,
0.4225192964076996,
0.07032840698957443,
0.9339927434921265,
-0.18762367963790894,
-0.38759300112724304,
0.16383925080299377,
0.04896752908825874,
-0.17508678138256073,
-0.43884027004241943,
0.8170304298400879,
-0.45008036494255066,
-0.7978894114494324,
-0.4773150682449341,
-0.8702669143676758,
-0.2669923007488251,
-0.06197360157966614,
-0.36277011036872864,
0.43547430634498596,
-0.13302618265151978,
0.3843793272972107,
0.759236752986908,
-0.36930719017982483,
0.557744026184082,
0.49468109011650085,
-0.15160250663757324,
-0.234251007437706,
0.6700296401977539,
-0.06645338982343674,
0.20636241137981415,
0.4584415555000305,
0.16196416318416595,
-0.17356161773204803,
-0.7415714859962463,
-0.22884121537208557,
0.20859988033771515,
-0.9034281373023987,
-0.24173620343208313,
-0.619530200958252,
-0.40946629643440247,
-0.0208396315574646,
-0.07374338805675507,
-0.3835389316082001,
-0.15663132071495056,
-0.32424500584602356,
0.01994924061000347,
0.84124755859375,
0.632209300994873,
0.06758230924606323,
0.4079205393791199,
-0.7280958890914917,
0.3512040972709656,
0.2861206531524658,
0.5541771054267883,
0.21771502494812012,
-0.6957959532737732,
-0.5433657169342041,
-0.15393713116645813,
0.35273051261901855,
-0.2942447066307068,
0.2594035565853119,
0.21173596382141113,
0.3782726228237152,
0.2740331292152405,
-0.27153122425079346,
0.9861059188842773,
-0.9074320197105408,
0.5860987901687622,
-0.019037626683712006,
-0.6552493572235107,
0.19078214466571808,
-0.357845664024353,
0.6641364693641663,
0.43229302763938904,
0.004809712991118431,
-0.47622358798980713,
-0.13906334340572357,
-0.05124477669596672,
-0.7863284349441528,
0.4915573000907898,
-0.4604799151420593,
0.3028697371482849,
-0.2990618944168091,
0.6174864768981934,
0.10717392712831497,
-0.06948567181825638,
-0.5135450959205627,
0.23312905430793762,
0.20775346457958221,
-0.22688087821006775,
-0.32063809037208557,
-0.6545226573944092,
-0.03481854870915413,
-0.30704161524772644,
0.5202888250350952,
-0.06334991008043289,
0.33475345373153687,
0.02287204936146736,
-0.21178829669952393,
0.1261974424123764,
0.3756796419620514,
0.7099452614784241,
0.7489415407180786,
-0.4239586889743805,
0.4134020507335663,
0.6387544870376587,
-0.48815205693244934,
-0.009590311907231808,
-0.14810428023338318,
-0.06050536781549454,
-0.20053425431251526,
0.48043105006217957,
0.7855454683303833,
0.5356670618057251,
-1.089375615119934,
0.33802369236946106,
0.11226735264062881,
0.07719039171934128,
-0.5496023893356323,
0.2754118740558624,
0.47036129236221313,
0.5330318808555603,
0.3763747811317444,
-0.44422006607055664,
0.09530531615018845,
-0.8035300970077515,
0.3482908308506012,
0.7730029225349426,
-0.2934608459472656,
-0.176099494099617,
0.27275019884109497,
-0.04893835633993149,
-0.26254481077194214,
0.5027219653129578,
0.0883275642991066,
-0.4336857199668884,
0.421081006526947,
0.9640398621559143,
0.3683827221393585,
-0.2593134939670563,
-0.3655654788017273,
0.3580181896686554,
0.08676494657993317,
-0.4401756227016449,
0.22229664027690887,
-0.06504594534635544,
-0.5865498185157776,
-0.5154043436050415,
-0.7690865993499756,
-0.08082420378923416,
0.3318157196044922,
-0.31231454014778137,
0.03771631419658661,
-0.4282653033733368,
0.1204732358455658,
-0.5253312587738037,
-0.006332069169729948,
-0.5368325710296631,
0.07545623183250427,
0.004651954863220453,
1.0313748121261597,
-0.3755688965320587,
1.2162643671035767,
0.3359610438346863,
0.045852188020944595,
-0.46224111318588257,
-0.209453746676445,
-0.24724222719669342,
-1.1156589984893799,
0.8626260161399841,
0.27219146490097046,
-0.29564031958580017,
-0.34580376744270325,
-0.09984613955020905,
-1.204842209815979,
1.1400740146636963,
0.23178909718990326,
-0.6874576807022095,
-0.11784360557794571,
-0.13900651037693024,
0.5085933804512024,
-0.47125473618507385,
0.05369040369987488,
0.585630476474762,
0.16264823079109192,
0.4216274321079254,
-0.8896449208259583,
0.23634281754493713,
-0.035209767520427704,
-0.08164448291063309,
0.3868781328201294,
-0.5676459074020386,
0.9958029389381409,
-0.3689901530742645,
-0.3062327802181244,
0.39568713307380676,
0.7762060761451721,
0.5332074761390686,
0.10469003766775131,
0.4305979013442993,
0.4658506512641907,
0.6986077427864075,
0.40339910984039307,
1.207027792930603,
-0.15407459437847137,
-0.09318600594997406,
1.5365601778030396,
-0.45412829518318176,
1.5269094705581665,
0.7799387574195862,
-0.03418269380927086,
0.45689892768859863,
0.38609975576400757,
0.22791677713394165,
0.5909398198127747,
0.06683851778507233,
-0.45313939452171326,
-0.36425215005874634,
-0.12106728553771973,
-0.33054113388061523,
0.6880801916122437,
0.42745447158813477,
-0.46285146474838257,
-0.13317832350730896,
-0.05849020183086395,
-0.11272156983613968,
0.005971280392259359,
-0.5573320984840393,
0.7385224103927612,
0.22086432576179504,
-0.5258051753044128,
0.739576518535614,
-0.1383858174085617,
0.8696438074111938,
-0.5842253565788269,
-0.2668040692806244,
-0.060181159526109695,
0.7719799876213074,
0.18519285321235657,
-0.5969672799110413,
0.41534528136253357,
-0.29588067531585693,
-0.18464137613773346,
0.009492850862443447,
0.7364242672920227,
-0.6367886066436768,
-0.6836403608322144,
0.4232006072998047,
0.21230952441692352,
0.06444470584392548,
0.02076319418847561,
-0.21933355927467346,
0.2927650213241577,
-0.3652660548686981,
-0.33388447761535645,
0.4578779935836792,
0.1489858776330948,
-0.12556929886341095,
0.6110475659370422,
0.5363528728485107,
0.28020960092544556,
-0.06906217336654663,
-0.18603336811065674,
0.7284637689590454,
-1.0020835399627686,
-0.42426496744155884,
-1.0781238079071045,
0.1461922973394394,
0.15703029930591583,
0.1840549260377884,
0.7759257555007935,
0.7848934531211853,
0.5776746869087219,
-0.05927435681223869,
0.44426536560058594,
0.32523033022880554,
0.7985162138938904,
-0.8548703789710999,
0.6679048538208008,
-0.47585251927375793,
0.3264979124069214,
0.22678546607494354,
-0.6750625967979431,
-0.2170172929763794,
0.5871809124946594,
-0.24136096239089966,
0.07405092567205429,
0.7420282959938049,
0.7158641815185547,
-0.23825986683368683,
-0.34025147557258606,
0.41230645775794983,
0.4640271067619324,
0.17636117339134216,
1.154451608657837,
0.9007700085639954,
-0.3938118815422058,
0.2627292573451996,
0.22762909531593323,
-0.01418492291122675,
-0.3464123606681824,
-0.8508400917053223,
-1.2943663597106934,
-0.5451377630233765,
0.1374787539243698,
-0.3418131470680237,
0.2065431922674179,
0.7027683854103088,
0.5022246837615967,
-0.7390726208686829,
-0.4820297658443451,
0.2718522846698761,
0.012399764731526375,
0.049341846257448196,
-0.15670771896839142,
0.7138811349868774,
-0.11862300336360931,
-0.42106160521507263,
0.5560132265090942,
0.5339980721473694,
0.0018767529400065541,
-0.19601775705814362,
-0.16956213116645813,
-0.44265368580818176,
0.28193190693855286,
0.9218555688858032,
0.2954357862472534,
-0.7382329106330872,
-0.7627326846122742,
0.04610297828912735,
0.05380532890558243,
0.28591445088386536,
0.7123854756355286,
-1.174014687538147,
0.31755346059799194,
0.36214935779571533,
0.9098498821258545,
0.5737739205360413,
-0.0700325071811676,
0.49583423137664795,
-0.2990177869796753,
0.42457666993141174,
-0.0319509282708168,
0.5242424607276917,
0.47531214356422424,
-0.5659641623497009,
0.27693653106689453,
-0.33913418650627136,
-0.2836645841598511,
-0.80914705991745,
0.025621596723794937,
-0.8570439219474792,
-0.46221891045570374,
1.2978441715240479,
0.0277099609375,
-0.6049681901931763,
-0.08990617841482162,
-0.20611639320850372,
-0.016277890652418137,
-0.2403605878353119,
0.9562274813652039,
0.7257752418518066,
-0.18418817222118378,
-0.2775808572769165,
-0.6419881582260132,
0.4749833047389984,
0.28171810507774353,
-0.9706857204437256,
0.27028658986091614,
0.5647653341293335,
0.342019259929657,
0.06888850778341293,
0.7897157669067383,
0.03522396460175514,
0.3644665479660034,
-0.14980120956897736,
-0.1849144846200943,
-0.16099010407924652,
-0.3864087462425232,
-0.43845871090888977,
0.122672900557518,
0.08539927005767822,
-0.10628215968608856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01424v1 | A Global-Local Attention Mechanism for Relation Classification | 2024-07-01T16:14:25 | 2024-07-01T16:14:25 | Yiping Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Relation classification, a crucial component of relation extraction, involves
identifying connections between two entities. Previous studies have
predominantly focused on integrating the attention mechanism into relation
classification at a global scale, overlooking the importance of the local
context. To address this gap, this paper introduces a novel global-local
attention mechanism for relation classification, which enhances global
attention with a localized focus. Additionally, we propose innovative hard and
soft localization mechanisms to identify potential keywords for local
attention. By incorporating both hard and soft localization strategies, our
approach offers a more nuanced and comprehensive understanding of the
contextual cues that contribute to effective relation classification. Our
experimental results on the SemEval-2010 Task 8 dataset highlight the superior
performance of our method compared to previous attention-based approaches in
relation classification. | [
-0.42467138171195984,
-0.6327869296073914,
0.5221914649009705,
-0.06454114615917206,
-0.2666911482810974,
-0.3768158555030823,
-0.33943191170692444,
-0.5918784737586975,
0.08903780579566956,
0.44127488136291504,
-0.6538873910903931,
-0.21951937675476074,
-0.14152057468891144,
0.07508311420679092,
0.23560240864753723,
1.3374727964401245,
-0.15514063835144043,
-0.24109207093715668,
-0.4337298572063446,
-0.32934466004371643,
-0.2614600360393524,
-0.8714258074760437,
-0.6449880599975586,
-0.2475961595773697,
1.0291494131088257,
0.26009494066238403,
0.6831120848655701,
0.536239743232727,
0.8496482968330383,
0.25052955746650696,
-0.2568393647670746,
0.21445444226264954,
-0.3940337896347046,
0.2655389606952667,
-0.4379003345966339,
-0.6389440298080444,
-0.6506316065788269,
-0.0685846209526062,
0.4386448562145233,
0.8141228556632996,
0.07714468240737915,
0.37656593322753906,
0.06797902286052704,
0.4999445080757141,
-0.902645468711853,
0.4341770112514496,
-0.6088244915008545,
0.04689338058233261,
-0.39659348130226135,
-0.1650627851486206,
-0.16078588366508484,
-0.03204750269651413,
0.2615683674812317,
-0.31244322657585144,
0.8319814205169678,
-0.3561840057373047,
1.0157744884490967,
0.034627869725227356,
-0.8855859637260437,
0.05362097546458244,
-0.8381471633911133,
0.3985442519187927,
-0.02472754567861557,
0.4265434145927429,
0.11379799246788025,
0.29058656096458435,
0.0729086846113205,
-0.5205497145652771,
-0.09809292107820511,
0.12326692044734955,
-0.2390839159488678,
0.10231099277734756,
0.25778916478157043,
0.06591297686100006,
0.24885335564613342,
0.6620733737945557,
-0.08779924362897873,
-0.4568977653980255,
-0.35015690326690674,
-0.10866884142160416,
0.2995835840702057,
-0.0662078857421875,
0.3259584903717041,
-0.21081489324569702,
-0.46825066208839417,
0.5837938189506531,
-0.7952473759651184,
0.1518014818429947,
-0.2336217612028122,
0.7590498924255371,
-0.286105215549469,
0.07125861942768097,
-0.255201131105423,
0.43621817231178284,
0.11516319215297699,
-0.13297343254089355,
0.28684911131858826,
-0.3632315695285797,
-0.12427017092704773,
0.31340599060058594,
0.6690763235092163,
0.20768983662128448,
0.3199250400066376,
-0.555977463722229,
0.12378162145614624,
0.374199241399765,
0.0428265780210495,
-0.5137014389038086,
0.15432626008987427,
-0.0401405431330204,
-0.2932824194431305,
-0.467516154050827,
0.07120651751756668,
-0.4434312880039215,
-0.08883433789014816,
-0.33372119069099426,
0.1542103886604309,
0.13046786189079285,
-0.6008630394935608,
-0.398960143327713,
0.263843297958374,
0.3833109438419342,
0.16668947041034698,
-1.01813542842865,
0.4389130175113678,
0.8022597432136536,
0.8847694993019104,
-0.14569930732250214,
0.007433540187776089,
-0.8579920530319214,
0.5055903196334839,
-0.05499465763568878,
1.044571876525879,
-0.4498165547847748,
0.1119038313627243,
0.04909104108810425,
0.23054328560829163,
-0.029622051864862442,
-0.4767185151576996,
0.5626093745231628,
-0.7119907736778259,
0.28418466448783875,
-0.3136332929134369,
-0.04932017996907234,
-0.3110195994377136,
0.21221064031124115,
-0.8202998638153076,
0.8305486440658569,
0.2561040222644806,
-1.0177844762802124,
0.353971004486084,
-0.5073202252388,
-0.7610975503921509,
0.10078583657741547,
-0.2150947004556656,
-0.42494791746139526,
0.1172628253698349,
0.460766077041626,
0.751221239566803,
-0.40198376774787903,
0.22521276772022247,
-0.5887529253959656,
-0.2104281634092331,
0.14563092589378357,
-0.12539809942245483,
0.5398430228233337,
0.17371761798858643,
-0.32401877641677856,
0.08481564372777939,
-0.5439358949661255,
-0.4817647933959961,
0.1300319880247116,
-0.019513756036758423,
-0.7150368094444275,
-0.23236645758152008,
-0.30445531010627747,
0.3759245276451111,
0.2508537173271179,
-0.22419914603233337,
0.39365026354789734,
-1.0305092334747314,
0.4209977686405182,
0.25543859601020813,
0.5205813050270081,
1.09859299659729,
0.22381794452667236,
0.44043371081352234,
0.2007211595773697,
0.14014509320259094,
-0.27494117617607117,
-0.28938838839530945,
-0.6500438451766968,
-0.030852023512125015,
0.5518820881843567,
0.4951229691505432,
-0.336050808429718,
0.11865013092756271,
-0.5537101626396179,
-0.20451557636260986,
-0.24057528376579285,
0.4620870053768158,
0.41504114866256714,
0.5359851717948914,
-0.12732471525669098,
-0.3178274929523468,
-0.22293981909751892,
-0.8994826674461365,
-0.15166069567203522,
0.1943952590227127,
-0.12895852327346802,
0.5384376049041748,
0.15566162765026093,
-0.13102398812770844,
0.8193193078041077,
-0.5564808249473572,
-0.8484613299369812,
-0.17232848703861237,
0.07990965992212296,
0.3914334774017334,
-0.0074373758397996426,
0.47956398129463196,
-1.148733139038086,
-0.4073140621185303,
0.3801431655883789,
-0.8824719190597534,
0.20739412307739258,
-0.1455201804637909,
-0.4583265781402588,
-0.07356803119182587,
0.6166154146194458,
-0.8664577603340149,
0.3524499237537384,
-0.31538140773773193,
-0.11431983858346939,
-0.06888606399297714,
0.05097435042262077,
-0.042563021183013916,
-0.8900315165519714,
-0.07373318821191788,
0.1361197829246521,
-0.23000264167785645,
-0.6418802738189697,
0.40039756894111633,
0.2904559373855591,
-0.1705792397260666,
-0.6559499502182007,
0.594633162021637,
-0.9175007939338684,
-0.1013479083776474,
0.0869380533695221,
0.39159947633743286,
-0.025071680545806885,
0.9161568284034729,
0.10782796889543533,
0.3527787923812866,
0.5573619604110718,
-0.566840410232544,
0.5270605683326721,
0.22066856920719147,
0.12595975399017334,
0.6857792735099792,
-0.10781921446323395,
0.42026403546333313,
-0.22476188838481903,
0.025713060051202774,
-0.9720090627670288,
-0.32423242926597595,
0.39921629428863525,
-0.4393443763256073,
0.6771700978279114,
-0.5654397010803223,
-0.2746192514896393,
-0.24054336547851562,
-0.4427556097507477,
0.4684687554836273,
-0.017901238054037094,
-0.5635048747062683,
0.7874473929405212,
0.48369157314300537,
-0.281479150056839,
-0.17456693947315216,
-0.24372556805610657,
-0.228239506483078,
-0.4729086458683014,
-0.6008426547050476,
0.40836843848228455,
0.6324207186698914,
-0.2243550568819046,
0.1276361346244812,
-0.5305072069168091,
-0.32620078325271606,
0.06979377567768097,
0.31628113985061646,
0.09909450262784958,
-0.20836535096168518,
0.3917849063873291,
-0.19564972817897797,
-0.4577085077762604,
0.23109419643878937,
0.12944886088371277,
0.031989745795726776,
-0.03231692314147949,
0.2719810903072357,
-0.14491377770900726,
0.4434625804424286,
0.7719386219978333,
-0.7190836668014526,
0.4631401002407074,
0.6981762647628784,
-0.55129075050354,
-0.02507026121020317,
-0.6181272864341736,
-0.3180900812149048,
-0.4949454665184021,
0.28376689553260803,
-0.5878269076347351,
-0.7044273614883423,
0.5713205933570862,
-0.3401056230068207,
-0.38084498047828674,
0.1451479196548462,
0.22027219831943512,
0.1177394688129425,
1.1137685775756836,
0.6140235066413879,
-0.5246394872665405,
0.3202669024467468,
-0.18562406301498413,
0.4902888536453247,
-1.203338384628296,
-0.24315331876277924,
-0.5776565670967102,
-0.26606595516204834,
-0.43886375427246094,
-0.2737048864364624,
0.2836175858974457,
0.4831390380859375,
-0.04573017731308937,
0.17829400300979614,
-0.8736134171485901,
0.5639969706535339,
0.4050690829753876,
0.09258528798818588,
0.18045516312122345,
0.22932174801826477,
0.006346056237816811,
-0.47914615273475647,
-0.550520122051239,
-0.08968670666217804,
0.6778874397277832,
0.25984326004981995,
0.5981948375701904,
0.06713132560253143,
0.7204812169075012,
-0.06790590286254883,
0.7525418996810913,
-0.8626092076301575,
0.5135108828544617,
0.06380187720060349,
-0.5861279368400574,
-0.011837881989777088,
-0.524969220161438,
-1.2276266813278198,
0.28888189792633057,
0.14373049139976501,
-0.9993466734886169,
0.2381874918937683,
0.033544186502695084,
-0.3889630138874054,
0.004882267210632563,
-0.9254069924354553,
1.0870839357376099,
-0.22700504958629608,
-0.5327843427658081,
0.16100862622261047,
-0.6895285248756409,
0.3392618000507355,
0.12720337510108948,
0.629320502281189,
-0.2817188799381256,
-0.1774739772081375,
0.4928494989871979,
-0.06133011728525162,
0.6307839751243591,
-0.33527931571006775,
-0.21131978929042816,
0.15635190904140472,
0.05637601017951965,
0.5137438178062439,
0.2219552993774414,
0.34540873765945435,
0.008873362094163895,
-0.6872897744178772,
0.09156724810600281,
-0.9296876788139343,
0.8414467573165894,
-0.41338276863098145,
-0.5538835525512695,
-0.41998881101608276,
-0.2763485610485077,
-0.3697216212749481,
0.2010420858860016,
0.14010028541088104,
0.6600095629692078,
0.1383279263973236,
0.04971321299672127,
0.5460007190704346,
0.31535762548446655,
0.16831918060779572,
0.413455992937088,
-0.17160089313983917,
-0.5247086882591248,
0.9804626107215881,
0.20122139155864716,
-0.10300514101982117,
0.6554628014564514,
0.0009952635737136006,
-0.4527035355567932,
0.029965423047542572,
0.1579512357711792,
0.5908558964729309,
-0.6742478609085083,
-0.5076826214790344,
-0.4770740866661072,
-0.27109280228614807,
-0.6315381526947021,
-0.04432645067572594,
-0.03055226244032383,
-0.10096826404333115,
-0.17999811470508575,
-0.058870576322078705,
0.2422337681055069,
0.3696747422218323,
0.08258870989084244,
-0.025212116539478302,
-0.8012839555740356,
0.6693177819252014,
0.5357730388641357,
0.2802294194698334,
0.10336830466985703,
-0.31778478622436523,
-0.06053159385919571,
-0.6080427169799805,
-0.29065224528312683,
-1.2928029298782349,
0.17009729146957397,
0.3211406469345093,
0.4403582215309143,
0.7625715136528015,
0.1910172402858734,
0.5774304866790771,
-0.565567135810852,
0.21959027647972107,
0.12261568009853363,
-0.6775543689727783,
1.22726309299469,
-0.6007998585700989,
0.596976637840271,
0.5250548124313354,
0.6414886116981506,
-0.3890641927719116,
-0.4048011302947998,
-0.8006000518798828,
-1.2180860042572021,
0.948011577129364,
0.21442857384681702,
0.19261860847473145,
-0.059403564780950546,
0.9002608060836792,
-0.3899916708469391,
0.09693118929862976,
-0.8749075531959534,
-0.2677297294139862,
0.7076243758201599,
-0.021054070442914963,
0.3173375427722931,
-0.3291356563568115,
-0.008647667244076729,
-0.36091095209121704,
0.4510897099971771,
-0.07126297801733017,
0.3517536520957947,
0.6239453554153442,
-0.1456584632396698,
-0.2745969593524933,
0.19707730412483215,
0.1411532759666443,
0.46282535791397095,
-0.27949947118759155,
0.2242727279663086,
0.3140510320663452,
-0.3047081232070923,
0.08532727509737015,
0.10789544880390167,
-0.3447650671005249,
0.026044383645057678,
0.4444724917411804,
0.5535578727722168,
0.6950111389160156,
0.2576310336589813,
0.6178293824195862,
-0.09035086631774902,
-0.09291303902864456,
0.03609498590230942,
0.07939597219228745,
0.3283570408821106,
0.11740903556346893,
0.2510170042514801,
0.10155162960290909,
0.4711166024208069,
-0.6280216574668884,
0.24623218178749084,
0.29550862312316895,
-0.6936267018318176,
-0.34780821204185486,
0.7057070732116699,
0.5186276435852051,
-0.50356125831604,
0.283292293548584,
-0.43243998289108276,
-0.795716404914856,
0.4553493857383728,
0.24965760111808777,
0.7744050621986389,
-0.5491816401481628,
0.030662719160318375,
0.5388176441192627,
0.0032490380108356476,
0.3151707351207733,
0.03756938874721527,
-0.7387897372245789,
-0.63045734167099,
-0.5782925486564636,
-0.4017525017261505,
-0.34469082951545715,
0.4107906222343445,
-0.9946241974830627,
0.3202376663684845,
-0.23735786974430084,
-0.23313628137111664,
0.17349687218666077,
0.03475632891058922,
-0.6621020436286926,
0.1967855989933014,
0.49336275458335876,
0.42986157536506653,
-0.6403632760047913,
0.649505078792572,
1.0417951345443726,
-0.2033936083316803,
-0.6549716591835022,
0.00226651132106781,
-0.12970684468746185,
-0.18131166696548462,
0.7483336925506592,
0.8674044609069824,
-0.18046627938747406,
-0.36144599318504333,
-0.4397105276584625,
-0.8466532230377197,
0.5558658838272095,
0.4920419454574585,
-0.5264148712158203,
-0.1530393362045288,
-0.050155363976955414,
0.2152939736843109,
-0.2228439450263977,
0.07628820836544037,
0.6078978776931763,
0.04148995131254196,
-0.16473090648651123,
-0.7305058240890503,
0.28762227296829224,
-0.40177398920059204,
0.09196638315916061,
0.6470091938972473,
-0.8257312774658203,
0.30485427379608154,
-0.2649490237236023,
-0.47758281230926514,
-0.6231982111930847,
0.8911644816398621,
-0.09803511202335358,
0.21331198513507843,
0.5714642405509949,
0.3530549705028534,
0.5844051241874695,
-0.3090616464614868,
0.7783187031745911,
-0.10101384669542313,
0.4554235637187958,
1.4078831672668457,
-0.6328823566436768,
0.8461719155311584,
0.3731198310852051,
-0.34074220061302185,
0.44956836104393005,
0.6344528198242188,
0.09592238813638687,
0.8989924788475037,
-0.16153736412525177,
-0.595600426197052,
-0.37904077768325806,
-0.1466829478740692,
-0.3240998089313507,
0.22325773537158966,
0.32126760482788086,
-0.10702620446681976,
-0.3292851448059082,
0.13476131856441498,
0.0028624662663787603,
0.023244863376021385,
-0.547455906867981,
0.9252970218658447,
0.2281149923801422,
-0.7506755590438843,
0.251446396112442,
-0.37432432174682617,
0.5469598770141602,
-0.41223976016044617,
-0.03421759977936745,
-0.2635308504104614,
0.5515397191047668,
-0.19057022035121918,
-0.3264967203140259,
0.2240280956029892,
-0.15568998456001282,
-0.34600892663002014,
0.05909904092550278,
1.209207534790039,
-0.5114315748214722,
-0.256269633769989,
0.550256073474884,
0.10076244175434113,
-0.1468099057674408,
-0.5690618753433228,
-0.5321743488311768,
-0.15664158761501312,
-0.1035875752568245,
-0.3402678668498993,
0.33219829201698303,
1.0736240148544312,
-0.09061452001333237,
0.4412641227245331,
0.5585603713989258,
0.029701149091124535,
-0.3768191635608673,
0.22336389124393463,
0.6207888126373291,
-0.7823453545570374,
-0.7475277781486511,
-0.8425740003585815,
0.32773929834365845,
-0.25728318095207214,
-0.38588252663612366,
0.667817234992981,
0.3313392996788025,
0.7165998220443726,
0.048178113996982574,
0.3912797272205353,
0.3179127275943756,
0.4321335554122925,
-0.012942601926624775,
0.3761911392211914,
-0.45916512608528137,
0.0070710196159780025,
-0.2250533401966095,
-1.0525141954421997,
-0.6923742294311523,
0.7905664443969727,
-0.6715232133865356,
0.02444528602063656,
0.8399447798728943,
0.5196247100830078,
-0.24735943973064423,
-0.2951987087726593,
-0.01924951747059822,
0.16772329807281494,
0.025779252871870995,
0.820364236831665,
0.6465553641319275,
-0.5159167051315308,
1.0721768140792847,
-0.38522419333457947,
-0.20771749317646027,
-0.05975852906703949,
-0.7022465467453003,
-1.0470662117004395,
-0.4599898159503937,
-0.6151886582374573,
-0.18570612370967865,
-0.08423871546983719,
0.5663868188858032,
0.765620768070221,
-0.717107355594635,
0.11927034705877304,
-0.08331918716430664,
0.22758843004703522,
-0.07927490770816803,
-0.37999847531318665,
0.4751972556114197,
-0.6667436957359314,
-0.35546189546585083,
-0.020371096208691597,
0.7146797180175781,
-0.2184256762266159,
0.005267744418233633,
0.1730843484401703,
-0.09282664954662323,
-0.5335294604301453,
0.48571839928627014,
0.16565349698066711,
-0.6029651165008545,
0.06454740464687347,
-0.22528764605522156,
-0.16456188261508942,
0.36326074600219727,
0.9249811172485352,
-0.7099236249923706,
0.2506498694419861,
0.36920809745788574,
0.27594515681266785,
0.7579624652862549,
-0.04169496148824692,
0.6786260604858398,
-1.1611322164535522,
0.3651479184627533,
0.12252987176179886,
0.28046196699142456,
0.5405693650245667,
-0.8524490594863892,
0.8803924918174744,
0.2760961949825287,
-0.5965257287025452,
-0.9482227563858032,
0.045279182493686676,
-0.8787615299224854,
0.1701592057943344,
1.0512205362319946,
-0.10976456105709076,
-0.7122499942779541,
-0.300564706325531,
-0.4266555607318878,
0.42778241634368896,
-0.2993575930595398,
0.5381706953048706,
0.46229463815689087,
-0.10353533178567886,
-0.24492308497428894,
-0.47815564274787903,
0.5243711471557617,
0.23454517126083374,
-0.8986539840698242,
0.26961323618888855,
0.12263594567775726,
0.14889512956142426,
0.6936542391777039,
0.7655913233757019,
-0.13917577266693115,
0.579054594039917,
-0.3567851185798645,
-0.15580493211746216,
0.44757550954818726,
-0.4181717336177826,
-0.4070940315723419,
0.5470702648162842,
-0.18596312403678894,
-0.0436682291328907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01411v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01411v2 | HyperLoader: Integrating Hypernetwork-Based LoRA and Adapter Layers into Multi-Task Transformers for Sequence Labelling | 2024-07-01T16:00:53 | 2024-07-02T06:21:41 | Jesus-German Ortiz-Barajas, Helena Gomez-Adorno, Thamar Solorio | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present HyperLoader, a simple approach that combines different
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods in a multi-task setting. To achieve
this goal, our model uses a hypernetwork to generate the weights of these
modules based on the task, the transformer layer, and its position within this
layer. Our method combines the benefits of multi-task learning by capturing the
structure of all tasks while reducing the task interference problem by
encapsulating the task-specific knowledge in the generated weights and the
benefits of combining different parameter-efficient methods to outperform
full-fine tuning. We provide empirical evidence that HyperLoader outperforms
previous approaches in most datasets and obtains the best average performance
across tasks in high-resource and low-resource scenarios. | [
-0.4653911590576172,
-0.5342531204223633,
0.10761140286922455,
0.20528970658779144,
-0.22921527922153473,
-0.41464492678642273,
-0.0935814157128334,
-0.5426831841468811,
0.16210971772670746,
0.6648022532463074,
-0.4513343572616577,
-0.2098432183265686,
-0.7422493100166321,
-0.008600303903222084,
-0.4933634400367737,
1.1722354888916016,
0.10950704663991928,
-0.3872276246547699,
-0.14755934476852417,
-0.3288349211215973,
-0.4605786204338074,
-0.37100750207901,
-0.524736762046814,
-0.8302220702171326,
1.0226715803146362,
0.6420303583145142,
0.7089065909385681,
1.1295499801635742,
0.6717436909675598,
0.3809119760990143,
-0.11163585633039474,
0.4915209114551544,
-0.3562901020050049,
0.17788423597812653,
-0.2784862816333771,
-0.4274819493293762,
-0.5321080684661865,
-0.11211834847927094,
0.45345965027809143,
0.5370292663574219,
0.009513271041214466,
0.8136996030807495,
0.25422096252441406,
0.8119395971298218,
-1.1119530200958252,
0.1769140511751175,
-0.30724862217903137,
0.28440457582473755,
-0.34294089674949646,
-0.27187010645866394,
-0.5769320130348206,
0.018231555819511414,
0.11179301887750626,
-0.8577339053153992,
0.20459899306297302,
0.24198821187019348,
0.6958197355270386,
0.7704249024391174,
-0.4455181062221527,
0.23120416700839996,
-1.098233699798584,
0.9061837792396545,
-0.4586457908153534,
0.1800699681043625,
0.2989547848701477,
0.4088493287563324,
0.19485096633434296,
-0.7858213186264038,
-0.4139796495437622,
0.4945496916770935,
-0.1616847813129425,
0.19961045682430267,
-0.2107088267803192,
0.03493081033229828,
0.4722549319267273,
0.32265371084213257,
-0.3244708180427551,
0.3096338212490082,
-0.31183522939682007,
-0.05264490842819214,
0.3351130783557892,
0.16861070692539215,
-0.09408644586801529,
-0.06081117317080498,
-0.5280091166496277,
-0.05287545546889305,
-0.39323532581329346,
-0.12878116965293884,
0.2590925395488739,
0.4228368401527405,
0.1285650134086609,
0.4797230362892151,
-0.23050764203071594,
1.1480785608291626,
0.3606468141078949,
-0.19006897509098053,
0.4431253969669342,
0.014646529220044613,
-0.5908260941505432,
0.15296080708503723,
0.6743230223655701,
0.15795764327049255,
-0.20482081174850464,
-0.13280698657035828,
-0.1307242065668106,
-0.135561004281044,
0.5077807903289795,
-0.8409260511398315,
0.06300286948680878,
0.18981729447841644,
-0.4373422861099243,
-0.24809369444847107,
-0.054383307695388794,
-0.6056566834449768,
-0.3997100293636322,
-0.5563040375709534,
0.7806598544120789,
-0.1591920107603073,
0.18159452080726624,
0.07381757348775864,
-0.37080466747283936,
0.13548347353935242,
0.1773902326822281,
-0.7234657406806946,
0.17225094139575958,
0.5467485189437866,
0.6563429832458496,
-0.30821889638900757,
-0.4742145538330078,
-0.9436208009719849,
0.5542352199554443,
0.14630553126335144,
0.8199664950370789,
-0.20544740557670593,
-0.10563280433416367,
-0.11693000793457031,
0.3253093361854553,
-0.140908345580101,
-0.7936092019081116,
0.5327422618865967,
-0.5944722890853882,
-0.10335084050893784,
-0.30298861861228943,
-0.4043218791484833,
-0.39486536383628845,
0.18054722249507904,
-1.0364351272583008,
1.1459022760391235,
0.13626861572265625,
-0.6268786787986755,
0.24327966570854187,
-0.736824095249176,
-0.6532506346702576,
0.2670382857322693,
0.2896096408367157,
-0.6706929802894592,
0.02175937406718731,
0.0023837911430746317,
0.6642870306968689,
-0.616628110408783,
0.14576324820518494,
0.1586609035730362,
-0.48467543721199036,
0.06773177534341812,
-0.1993948519229889,
0.33502545952796936,
0.17674709856510162,
-0.5675257444381714,
0.3570880889892578,
-0.879520833492279,
0.11220306903123856,
-0.19632892310619354,
-0.7360594868659973,
-0.22087745368480682,
0.003505065804347396,
0.5250300168991089,
0.35376083850860596,
0.2624329924583435,
-0.5498964190483093,
0.0762140154838562,
-0.06635431200265884,
0.3966268002986908,
0.4381658136844635,
-0.29947036504745483,
0.08569221198558807,
-0.6241060495376587,
0.25642600655555725,
0.46361371874809265,
0.26567190885543823,
-0.012858251109719276,
-0.5377138257026672,
-0.8235310912132263,
-0.13786941766738892,
0.2023923695087433,
0.6831866502761841,
-0.7562904357910156,
0.5708784461021423,
-0.07688569277524948,
-0.700602114200592,
-0.4814845323562622,
0.45280036330223083,
0.7803553938865662,
0.5650110244750977,
0.9352582097053528,
-0.34154894948005676,
-0.5782144069671631,
-1.0242878198623657,
-0.21034936606884003,
0.39938539266586304,
0.28450390696525574,
0.15516002476215363,
0.3560347557067871,
-0.354909747838974,
0.6166371703147888,
-0.6834805011749268,
-0.5588432550430298,
-0.29221203923225403,
0.33527547121047974,
0.503582239151001,
0.8795573115348816,
0.2703644931316376,
-0.8105514645576477,
-0.46366336941719055,
0.2963758707046509,
-0.5705954432487488,
0.24847716093063354,
0.014989747665822506,
-0.25524112582206726,
-0.16082905232906342,
0.41348955035209656,
-0.4874251186847687,
0.2937150001525879,
0.6108246445655823,
-0.09493491053581238,
0.556352436542511,
-0.3256067931652069,
0.028187008574604988,
-1.2140122652053833,
0.24828718602657318,
0.38504913449287415,
-0.19743335247039795,
-0.9403544664382935,
0.054334599524736404,
0.07455186545848846,
-0.14644399285316467,
-0.7185683846473694,
0.22472579777240753,
-0.27629488706588745,
0.015034502372145653,
-0.5246759653091431,
-0.33009326457977295,
0.11356789618730545,
0.666102945804596,
-0.4157851040363312,
0.5895383954048157,
0.6109328269958496,
-0.6794599890708923,
0.5510613918304443,
0.33082646131515503,
-0.45180460810661316,
0.5541391968727112,
-0.8089670538902283,
0.2733864188194275,
-0.24923226237297058,
0.2323504239320755,
-0.7711637020111084,
-0.322359561920166,
0.14757615327835083,
0.15911252796649933,
0.1438857913017273,
-0.458125501871109,
-0.5035189986228943,
-0.628151535987854,
0.1084531769156456,
0.7070634961128235,
0.43642887473106384,
-0.5491781234741211,
0.8522871136665344,
0.22030606865882874,
0.4425506293773651,
-0.8198564648628235,
-0.9289935231208801,
-0.3127841651439667,
-0.43568116426467896,
-0.2549861669540405,
0.7151435613632202,
-0.019671589136123657,
0.3525552749633789,
-0.08326458185911179,
-0.3425459861755371,
-0.3597869873046875,
-0.045515645295381546,
0.6333531737327576,
0.15373215079307556,
-0.47120726108551025,
0.02752012014389038,
0.11657331138849258,
-0.36853882670402527,
-0.22396425902843475,
-0.7346251606941223,
0.35147035121917725,
0.19091850519180298,
-0.47367653250694275,
-0.7626033425331116,
0.385296106338501,
0.7215498089790344,
-0.4328455328941345,
0.7821227312088013,
1.024524450302124,
-0.34350094199180603,
-0.27699214220046997,
-0.5808347463607788,
0.24235033988952637,
-0.5373165011405945,
0.4064117968082428,
-0.3990819454193115,
-0.7236141562461853,
0.29933711886405945,
-0.43332162499427795,
0.15320894122123718,
0.4377276301383972,
0.49519261717796326,
-0.17229799926280975,
0.8630991578102112,
0.662268340587616,
-0.3238396644592285,
0.5690171122550964,
-0.5040321946144104,
0.0846245065331459,
-0.9659306406974792,
-0.044974587857723236,
-0.588616132736206,
-1.0344023704528809,
-0.3403341472148895,
-0.5274299383163452,
0.569258987903595,
-0.03158918395638466,
-0.42569395899772644,
0.761232316493988,
-0.736530601978302,
0.6607890129089355,
0.9305641055107117,
0.5373861789703369,
0.24817486107349396,
-0.27435097098350525,
0.38045191764831543,
0.39915478229522705,
-0.783534824848175,
-0.1204829066991806,
0.8908448219299316,
-0.2196546494960785,
0.4777052104473114,
0.0493660643696785,
0.6872729659080505,
0.388467013835907,
-0.05325145274400711,
-1.0158531665802002,
0.2995353937149048,
-0.5326031446456909,
-0.6535699963569641,
-0.560835063457489,
-0.1524650603532791,
-1.2773600816726685,
0.304243803024292,
-0.3226639926433563,
-0.733380913734436,
0.41237789392471313,
0.637370228767395,
-0.6588248610496521,
0.3887510597705841,
-0.6317074298858643,
0.9039291739463806,
0.15188364684581757,
-0.48969417810440063,
-0.32267874479293823,
-0.7451154589653015,
0.14778462052345276,
-0.045194949954748154,
0.11476900428533554,
-0.12039715051651001,
0.17968837916851044,
0.9661270976066589,
-0.18101099133491516,
1.0206397771835327,
-0.2691679000854492,
-0.07793328911066055,
0.3923036456108093,
-0.1805558055639267,
0.5357429385185242,
-0.34465914964675903,
-0.3133693337440491,
-0.259867787361145,
-0.07530543208122253,
-0.6358378529548645,
-0.5814163684844971,
0.7192152738571167,
-0.8736198544502258,
-0.5037639737129211,
0.12845994532108307,
-1.1108075380325317,
-0.22872495651245117,
0.4086392819881439,
0.17413286864757538,
0.8175278902053833,
0.11305751651525497,
0.2590245008468628,
0.8669925332069397,
-0.0680566355586052,
0.49607378244400024,
0.22024624049663544,
0.3268815875053406,
-0.21254388988018036,
1.1999741792678833,
0.10528472810983658,
0.17120946943759918,
0.700484037399292,
0.2806580066680908,
0.2238815873861313,
-0.3255898654460907,
-0.4402550160884857,
-0.07277277857065201,
-0.6754043698310852,
-0.5669876933097839,
-0.46964702010154724,
-0.1586461365222931,
0.09988852590322495,
-0.02063831128180027,
-0.4761051833629608,
-0.29682913422584534,
-0.18184740841388702,
0.18864446878433228,
0.35367855429649353,
0.8474521040916443,
0.10427744686603546,
0.9373946785926819,
-0.9767258167266846,
0.6008512377738953,
0.47761428356170654,
0.34507980942726135,
0.040666837245225906,
-0.3100767731666565,
-0.9271845817565918,
-0.2628585994243622,
-0.6843966841697693,
-0.768037736415863,
0.02803323045372963,
0.28060683608055115,
0.4443284273147583,
0.42280012369155884,
-0.14800888299942017,
0.7257452607154846,
-0.5473755598068237,
0.46764907240867615,
0.24567778408527374,
-0.9902763962745667,
0.49773597717285156,
-0.15220627188682556,
0.5854266881942749,
0.32150334119796753,
0.6285732388496399,
-0.2865895628929138,
0.140923872590065,
-0.19867049157619476,
-1.0437883138656616,
0.729582667350769,
-0.06243586912751198,
-0.21459950506687164,
0.2665337026119232,
0.28606611490249634,
0.11600271612405777,
-0.01039885450154543,
-0.30949798226356506,
-0.6225268244743347,
-0.12308616936206818,
-0.31318631768226624,
-0.2938811779022217,
0.06237795203924179,
-0.3666176199913025,
-0.42429956793785095,
0.5599862337112427,
-0.5150859355926514,
0.3107960522174835,
0.09818920493125916,
-0.41129282116889954,
-0.26954764127731323,
0.2931756377220154,
0.42513298988342285,
0.5224143862724304,
0.06239032372832298,
0.22637678682804108,
0.2406739592552185,
-0.45779067277908325,
0.3231150209903717,
0.2525242269039154,
0.07861769199371338,
-0.2127477079629898,
0.30601075291633606,
1.070774793624878,
0.4094763994216919,
-0.2389012575149536,
0.21339145302772522,
0.4828624725341797,
-0.21465180814266205,
0.35213059186935425,
0.3208860754966736,
0.24451372027397156,
0.4460935890674591,
0.29828381538391113,
0.5012992024421692,
0.29335904121398926,
-0.281951367855072,
0.18822483718395233,
-0.013486793264746666,
-0.6215309500694275,
-0.31135794520378113,
0.724292516708374,
0.22013317048549652,
-0.22002197802066803,
0.27310827374458313,
0.15472494065761566,
-0.19576799869537354,
0.8634124994277954,
0.7923426628112793,
0.7065383195877075,
-0.26441705226898193,
0.0568971112370491,
0.2490484118461609,
-0.015460413880646229,
-0.30702295899391174,
0.34893128275871277,
-0.16692204773426056,
-0.5983453989028931,
-0.9008172154426575,
-0.5428613424301147,
-0.337289035320282,
0.0511108823120594,
-1.017763614654541,
0.10869191586971283,
-0.2571342885494232,
-0.470523864030838,
0.5807600021362305,
-0.38916245102882385,
-0.9482575058937073,
0.265604168176651,
0.1848052740097046,
0.8185708522796631,
-0.7946664094924927,
0.946303129196167,
1.0154807567596436,
-0.12821200489997864,
-0.5744748711585999,
-0.15777860581874847,
0.08120473474264145,
-0.6579601764678955,
0.7909418940544128,
0.1766921728849411,
-0.24668875336647034,
0.37397727370262146,
-0.17949213087558746,
-1.0841866731643677,
1.2339459657669067,
0.10293728858232498,
-0.7103152275085449,
-0.1909446269273758,
0.21504022181034088,
0.2401290088891983,
-0.04423747956752777,
0.1409764140844345,
0.5310645699501038,
0.7024281024932861,
-0.07641191780567169,
-1.0159473419189453,
0.16486385464668274,
-0.14689458906650543,
0.01858828030526638,
0.4817385673522949,
-0.7658450603485107,
0.5719579458236694,
-0.11773310601711273,
0.10429861396551132,
-0.014286949299275875,
0.7937829494476318,
-0.0734030231833458,
0.1239883229136467,
0.67701655626297,
0.6705839037895203,
0.6376786828041077,
-0.03464698791503906,
0.7552005648612976,
-0.5296952724456787,
0.2877238988876343,
1.2131545543670654,
-0.10978155583143234,
0.5642444491386414,
0.5022132992744446,
-0.008175301365554333,
0.4310317635536194,
0.010763095691800117,
-0.09025047719478607,
0.3116225302219391,
0.43478330969810486,
0.02810206264257431,
-0.30557265877723694,
-0.35855382680892944,
-0.2248440682888031,
0.46773776412010193,
0.19851244986057281,
-0.21128438413143158,
-0.08922234177589417,
0.1995375156402588,
-0.3183121681213379,
-0.35495421290397644,
-0.3429394066333771,
0.731542706489563,
-0.1580887734889984,
-0.6842091679573059,
0.640385091304779,
-0.06503605097532272,
0.8351814150810242,
-0.427302747964859,
0.08751526474952698,
0.11998408287763596,
0.4761863648891449,
-0.524344265460968,
-0.7059788107872009,
0.3312072455883026,
-0.25471198558807373,
-0.5245397686958313,
-0.1969149261713028,
0.6353120803833008,
-0.2652471661567688,
-0.21561184525489807,
0.20946596562862396,
0.7402843236923218,
-0.24282966554164886,
-0.052234143018722534,
-0.4759288728237152,
-0.010846084915101528,
-0.35752809047698975,
-0.3342553973197937,
0.4746677875518799,
0.4323023855686188,
0.07365655899047852,
0.6825254559516907,
0.5931116938591003,
-0.13233867287635803,
0.1636843979358673,
0.17118869721889496,
0.8569689393043518,
-0.8667992949485779,
-0.24513985216617584,
-0.5732043385505676,
0.6081295609474182,
0.15585793554782867,
-0.5557165741920471,
0.5107503533363342,
0.7383976578712463,
0.7003353834152222,
-0.308694988489151,
0.616616427898407,
-0.11774875968694687,
0.08994776010513306,
-0.2192208617925644,
0.47491055727005005,
-0.5601351261138916,
-0.23749014735221863,
-0.3405780792236328,
-0.9719058275222778,
-0.2609502673149109,
0.003943420480936766,
0.1875878870487213,
-0.3500215411186218,
0.7123674750328064,
0.5686253309249878,
-0.4861893057823181,
-0.004806526470929384,
0.32486721873283386,
-0.04961207136511803,
-0.08969340473413467,
0.7153629064559937,
0.6258232593536377,
-0.7565147280693054,
0.5008198022842407,
-0.45716074109077454,
-0.18191072344779968,
-0.07141947001218796,
-0.7082650661468506,
-0.8073646426200867,
-0.7749200463294983,
-0.531215250492096,
-0.06356275081634521,
0.17860931158065796,
0.9861520528793335,
1.2104017734527588,
-0.8712360858917236,
-0.544020414352417,
0.33902478218078613,
-0.02128903940320015,
-0.9592557549476624,
-0.16878356039524078,
0.21037031710147858,
-0.403628945350647,
-0.8221765160560608,
0.47606968879699707,
0.09731387346982956,
-0.14026983082294464,
0.058078326284885406,
0.15206444263458252,
-0.16987091302871704,
-0.09010476619005203,
0.8777527809143066,
0.22487038373947144,
-0.4970870614051819,
-0.052782099694013596,
-0.29926297068595886,
0.03692898154258728,
0.176286980509758,
1.0134153366088867,
-0.808803141117096,
0.06446464359760284,
0.5808151960372925,
0.8907732367515564,
0.7130129337310791,
0.11015693098306656,
0.3967263996601105,
-0.7654762268066406,
0.12287437170743942,
-0.18346431851387024,
0.4142426550388336,
-0.03791384771466255,
-0.5169517397880554,
0.30847930908203125,
0.07153832912445068,
-0.653701901435852,
-0.5311903953552246,
0.21018414199352264,
-1.261933445930481,
-0.1337442398071289,
0.8465218544006348,
-0.034892406314611435,
-0.31660088896751404,
-0.21976955235004425,
-0.011219587177038193,
0.5217393636703491,
-0.1392931342124939,
0.5744257569313049,
0.23740045726299286,
-0.2560079097747803,
0.20885451138019562,
-0.5831083655357361,
0.34674498438835144,
0.47897037863731384,
-0.9481025338172913,
-0.10084719955921173,
0.17847399413585663,
0.030032308772206306,
0.4531196355819702,
-0.1303768754005432,
0.3111829459667206,
0.21307478845119476,
-0.543729841709137,
0.17707030475139618,
-0.33052703738212585,
-0.548720121383667,
-0.007541283033788204,
0.3633005917072296,
-0.16869927942752838,
-0.4174187183380127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01409v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01409v1 | Dynamic Few-Shot Learning for Knowledge Graph Question Answering | 2024-07-01T15:59:17 | 2024-07-01T15:59:17 | Jacopo D'Abramo, Andrea Zugarini, Paolo Torroni | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models present opportunities for innovative Question Answering
over Knowledge Graphs (KGQA). However, they are not inherently designed for
query generation. To bridge this gap, solutions have been proposed that rely on
fine-tuning or ad-hoc architectures, achieving good results but limited
out-of-domain distribution generalization. In this study, we introduce a novel
approach called Dynamic Few-Shot Learning (DFSL). DFSL integrates the
efficiency of in-context learning and semantic similarity and provides a
generally applicable solution for KGQA with state-of-the-art performance. We
run an extensive evaluation across multiple benchmark datasets and architecture
configurations. | [
-0.414493590593338,
-1.137446403503418,
0.6136292815208435,
-0.5309669375419617,
-0.2539016306400299,
0.5016863942146301,
0.24290473759174347,
-0.263651967048645,
-0.1393696665763855,
0.16105636954307556,
-0.995549201965332,
-0.660049319267273,
-0.42833632230758667,
0.07914874702692032,
-0.08373656123876572,
0.5514005422592163,
-0.16730265319347382,
-0.30099400877952576,
-0.30236899852752686,
-0.34544655680656433,
-0.20100632309913635,
0.05860525742173195,
-0.74440598487854,
-0.3095143139362335,
0.5927610397338867,
0.4551781713962555,
0.5560191869735718,
0.37426596879959106,
0.25816431641578674,
0.2685825824737549,
-0.22199836373329163,
0.6303399205207825,
-0.9093759655952454,
0.18640664219856262,
0.05200423300266266,
-0.3761628270149231,
-0.034896109253168106,
-0.267545610666275,
0.9238269925117493,
0.9133357405662537,
0.11576426774263382,
0.19854311645030975,
-0.0117000387981534,
0.824981153011322,
-0.68785160779953,
0.36023420095443726,
-0.8760808706283569,
0.13523375988006592,
-0.08857142925262451,
-0.08591874688863754,
-0.2935720980167389,
-0.45913323760032654,
0.2897793650627136,
-0.875540554523468,
-0.22487959265708923,
0.12914608418941498,
0.6252328753471375,
0.36081355810165405,
-0.8133540749549866,
-0.2608720064163208,
-0.37472453713417053,
0.5679601430892944,
-0.5326341986656189,
0.41751623153686523,
0.24089238047599792,
0.920756459236145,
-0.48196345567703247,
-0.9160070419311523,
-0.7064611315727234,
0.19265073537826538,
-0.04803220182657242,
0.05049067735671997,
-0.17778313159942627,
-0.04599794000387192,
0.23281638324260712,
-0.14090926945209503,
-0.5686295628547668,
-0.03004440665245056,
-0.2093050181865692,
0.016217060387134552,
0.5252522826194763,
0.5397666692733765,
-0.17929129302501678,
-0.15082602202892303,
-0.3664180040359497,
-0.2042074352502823,
-0.6478068828582764,
0.21661129593849182,
0.30242282152175903,
0.4187702238559723,
0.1043773666024208,
0.18996858596801758,
-0.7363214492797852,
1.058260440826416,
0.03706278279423714,
-0.34176573157310486,
0.2162008285522461,
-0.02372949942946434,
-0.19657489657402039,
-0.21732361614704132,
0.5500054955482483,
0.05014338344335556,
0.1700362265110016,
-0.2638052999973297,
0.05733935907483101,
-0.5889226198196411,
-0.03427327796816826,
-0.8175371289253235,
-0.3140198588371277,
0.17330308258533478,
-0.12565019726753235,
-0.4223245680332184,
-0.1637069135904312,
-0.6794600486755371,
-0.38766831159591675,
0.08816680312156677,
0.6724103689193726,
-0.5517146587371826,
-0.07807085663080215,
-0.0776204913854599,
-0.14477315545082092,
0.19636106491088867,
0.3313697278499603,
-0.6236184239387512,
0.21188436448574066,
0.45047590136528015,
0.50552898645401,
-0.21799804270267487,
-0.3047230541706085,
-0.6727065443992615,
0.28843554854393005,
-0.3873545825481415,
0.7686052918434143,
-0.5140509009361267,
-0.13737817108631134,
-0.04211362823843956,
-0.2758771777153015,
-0.15845170617103577,
-0.5283506512641907,
-0.21387213468551636,
-1.3711724281311035,
-0.08222585916519165,
-0.4517136216163635,
-0.7075110673904419,
-0.3784911036491394,
0.616605818271637,
-0.2583741843700409,
1.0685052871704102,
0.43539589643478394,
-0.8982758522033691,
0.517493724822998,
-0.5364679098129272,
-0.29705893993377686,
0.3556435704231262,
-0.2790735363960266,
-0.31225189566612244,
-0.34884002804756165,
0.06953107565641403,
0.3169936239719391,
0.00825642328709364,
-0.02203010581433773,
-0.3886035978794098,
-0.4533599615097046,
0.22725532948970795,
-0.2079707533121109,
0.4558117985725403,
0.29975494742393494,
-0.002677317475900054,
-0.13097234070301056,
-0.8174607753753662,
0.31794488430023193,
0.2501632571220398,
-0.42354387044906616,
-0.29365357756614685,
-0.15563149750232697,
-0.6375478506088257,
0.2756159007549286,
0.050629086792469025,
-0.519717276096344,
0.35789456963539124,
-0.7139184474945068,
0.2958674430847168,
0.4014051556587219,
0.37479913234710693,
0.4381767511367798,
-0.11779062449932098,
0.6828900575637817,
0.2058420479297638,
-0.012749784626066685,
0.03427021950483322,
-0.3218998312950134,
-0.3558124005794525,
-0.22846801578998566,
0.26351290941238403,
0.4447466731071472,
-1.34735107421875,
-0.2571358382701874,
-0.2995893955230713,
-0.4856953024864197,
-0.21980249881744385,
0.376374214887619,
0.39180630445480347,
0.9084800481796265,
0.36479058861732483,
0.06129938364028931,
-0.08551890403032303,
-0.59279465675354,
-0.11754083633422852,
-0.2768513560295105,
0.13698366284370422,
0.7904372215270996,
0.5184332132339478,
0.09110869467258453,
1.2700610160827637,
-1.169290542602539,
-0.21873855590820312,
-0.3438517451286316,
0.16564202308654785,
0.13021251559257507,
-0.06183133274316788,
0.8150936961174011,
-0.7402629256248474,
-0.8072137832641602,
-0.09214766323566437,
-0.7498295903205872,
0.3298177421092987,
0.46707484126091003,
-0.32449477910995483,
-0.04154498875141144,
0.5202139019966125,
-0.6027863621711731,
0.09504289925098419,
0.21874423325061798,
-0.09652842581272125,
0.11619304865598679,
0.1395786702632904,
0.08811118453741074,
-1.061663269996643,
-0.10272137075662613,
-0.4994446933269501,
-0.3412930369377136,
-0.502004861831665,
0.07099573314189911,
-0.025228386744856834,
-0.2846503257751465,
-0.9487215876579285,
0.8298181891441345,
-0.02161007560789585,
-0.03682119399309158,
-0.2658771574497223,
0.36517998576164246,
0.04810575768351555,
0.530777633190155,
-0.24085338413715363,
0.48609593510627747,
0.6310663223266602,
-0.6591958403587341,
0.6565449237823486,
0.592678964138031,
-0.434734046459198,
0.2207091748714447,
-0.37644121050834656,
0.31870153546333313,
-0.5692633986473083,
0.47245490550994873,
-1.3016901016235352,
-0.5115163922309875,
0.13810089230537415,
-0.3780529499053955,
0.356610506772995,
-0.4440748393535614,
-0.48218196630477905,
-0.6070126295089722,
-0.29494068026542664,
0.5256538391113281,
0.46438854932785034,
-0.5112886428833008,
0.3691895604133606,
0.11237594485282898,
0.13523997366428375,
-0.7607192993164062,
-0.5479680299758911,
-0.49259963631629944,
-0.22593608498573303,
-0.611565113067627,
0.16062474250793457,
0.08568594604730606,
-0.04561792314052582,
0.12303732335567474,
-0.14991813898086548,
-0.35349297523498535,
0.2359626144170761,
-0.15639595687389374,
-0.18077488243579865,
-0.35716512799263,
0.542041540145874,
0.2757609486579895,
0.017253290861845016,
-0.3168140649795532,
-0.493443101644516,
0.4652557373046875,
0.03664693236351013,
-0.3167526423931122,
-0.21405740082263947,
0.2901645004749298,
0.42288511991500854,
-0.10117242485284805,
0.8148826956748962,
0.4524819552898407,
-0.24481940269470215,
-0.4445951282978058,
-0.14248518645763397,
-0.3232537508010864,
-0.5382623672485352,
0.421048641204834,
-0.6457147002220154,
-1.0769596099853516,
0.498485267162323,
-0.3549715578556061,
-0.15606184303760529,
0.1963019073009491,
0.40510469675064087,
-0.45280909538269043,
0.8251673579216003,
0.5060869455337524,
0.21301932632923126,
0.35201042890548706,
-0.43730688095092773,
0.15685728192329407,
-0.2928115129470825,
-0.20368732511997223,
-0.04663388803601265,
-0.4850934147834778,
-0.5266649127006531,
-0.16918587684631348,
0.8491106033325195,
0.2373856008052826,
-0.3946003317832947,
0.1683616191148758,
-0.038099754601716995,
0.7401173710823059,
0.5087373852729797,
0.21736034750938416,
0.2686532139778137,
-0.08147065341472626,
-0.5516595840454102,
0.30721867084503174,
-1.1560924053192139,
-0.138345405459404,
0.9488160610198975,
0.03568695858120918,
0.6830697059631348,
0.35801857709884644,
0.8306785821914673,
-0.1328265517950058,
-0.07118791341781616,
-0.8088452219963074,
0.5961785316467285,
-0.18572986125946045,
-0.6132352948188782,
-0.7429501414299011,
-0.5718404650688171,
-0.9107085466384888,
0.2575763761997223,
-0.2910771667957306,
-0.644143283367157,
-0.047287244349718094,
0.3204841911792755,
-0.7497321963310242,
0.2313375025987625,
-0.48424792289733887,
0.868440568447113,
0.03577079251408577,
-0.4256812632083893,
-0.0465017668902874,
-0.8176103830337524,
0.3996063470840454,
-0.21942389011383057,
-0.11673491448163986,
-0.23287749290466309,
0.14330872893333435,
0.5880197286605835,
-0.23914439976215363,
0.8505125641822815,
-0.45109114050865173,
0.24207863211631775,
0.6753085255622864,
0.16365036368370056,
0.5941680669784546,
0.13001543283462524,
-0.2663384675979614,
-0.40388748049736023,
0.2681775987148285,
-0.45566093921661377,
-0.9831571578979492,
0.6214789748191833,
-0.6593860983848572,
-0.4954872131347656,
-0.0873778760433197,
-0.7149592638015747,
-0.7205687761306763,
0.3963768780231476,
0.08180584013462067,
0.6145082116127014,
-0.08099744468927383,
0.056826282292604446,
0.5612120032310486,
-0.22422242164611816,
0.46211695671081543,
0.7352638840675354,
-0.012340150773525238,
-0.21233157813549042,
0.6323444843292236,
0.31304505467414856,
0.3619964122772217,
0.6003068685531616,
0.3441956639289856,
-0.5384591817855835,
-0.5345296263694763,
-0.6458718180656433,
0.193621426820755,
-1.0735160112380981,
-0.467387318611145,
-0.7222196459770203,
-0.11873268336057663,
-0.4978381395339966,
-0.08559729903936386,
-0.26973533630371094,
-0.3211672902107239,
-0.1663549244403839,
-0.07918176800012589,
0.637690544128418,
0.5535887479782104,
0.45663705468177795,
0.34063655138015747,
-0.8991182446479797,
0.3574714958667755,
0.8002321720123291,
0.34995418787002563,
0.15462622046470642,
-0.4235837459564209,
-0.11236671358346939,
-0.05493573844432831,
-0.5341379642486572,
-0.7972290515899658,
0.07686746120452881,
0.46989017724990845,
0.6469278335571289,
0.33072930574417114,
0.6182405948638916,
0.6462967991828918,
-0.5586158633232117,
0.6728757619857788,
-0.07749014347791672,
-0.4739830493927002,
0.5867869257926941,
-0.3929101824760437,
0.6690364480018616,
1.0074901580810547,
0.7876157164573669,
-0.23908086121082306,
-0.1204238161444664,
-0.4441509246826172,
-0.6582869291305542,
0.6782494187355042,
-0.03526507318019867,
0.2996843457221985,
-0.22126388549804688,
0.5689181685447693,
0.12298984825611115,
0.24504965543746948,
-0.16086474061012268,
-0.2389523983001709,
0.03438698872923851,
-0.37038177251815796,
0.28855982422828674,
-0.054994240403175354,
-0.1919069141149521,
-0.29084259271621704,
0.4949299991130829,
-0.7153123617172241,
0.11297740042209625,
-0.13811857998371124,
-0.11554233729839325,
-0.14197954535484314,
0.0853680744767189,
0.27026745676994324,
0.7750635147094727,
-0.0987866148352623,
0.16075259447097778,
0.6267294883728027,
-0.11794226616621017,
0.13617777824401855,
0.09164929389953613,
-0.22653250396251678,
-0.3368743360042572,
0.2602767050266266,
0.8219887018203735,
0.25710272789001465,
-0.6981643438339233,
0.7230483293533325,
0.2704588770866394,
-0.34985870122909546,
0.019553225487470627,
0.20116771757602692,
0.15512387454509735,
0.6378167867660522,
0.42379528284072876,
-0.4210253059864044,
-0.0696483924984932,
-0.5501886606216431,
0.42132648825645447,
0.6160656213760376,
-0.40665048360824585,
-0.1486692875623703,
0.6148646473884583,
0.19409231841564178,
0.07572486251592636,
0.8772854208946228,
-0.5211971402168274,
-0.5494211316108704,
0.5152208209037781,
0.37366098165512085,
0.5349521636962891,
0.1300836056470871,
0.3918110132217407,
0.2631269693374634,
-0.223724827170372,
0.30115193128585815,
0.34773358702659607,
-0.4249681532382965,
-0.8382813334465027,
-0.2613760828971863,
-0.6827868223190308,
-0.4215315878391266,
-0.12174607813358307,
-0.24498189985752106,
0.46126535534858704,
-0.2200665920972824,
0.0794064849615097,
-0.06827530264854431,
0.19326511025428772,
-0.5637140870094299,
0.19498029351234436,
0.04072492942214012,
0.9545409679412842,
-0.8279945254325867,
1.1383193731307983,
0.829801619052887,
-0.3139614760875702,
-0.7830461263656616,
0.0972728356719017,
0.17062512040138245,
-0.8107103109359741,
0.9632684588432312,
-0.18931131064891815,
-0.2864346504211426,
0.5162609815597534,
-0.3778466284275055,
-0.8889961242675781,
1.6347870826721191,
0.3601859211921692,
-0.07991699129343033,
-0.07648158818483353,
0.2875811457633972,
0.4791843295097351,
-0.21565774083137512,
0.049521367996931076,
0.48380938172340393,
0.17776598036289215,
0.7414629459381104,
-0.5622743964195251,
-0.270510733127594,
0.2728867530822754,
-0.3515695333480835,
0.19391150772571564,
-0.9628037214279175,
0.3961855471134186,
-0.2803787887096405,
-0.11176130920648575,
-0.18220333755016327,
0.6216441988945007,
0.28747645020484924,
0.509619951248169,
0.4831660985946655,
0.34064483642578125,
0.8894073963165283,
0.09331034868955612,
0.9419692754745483,
-0.19238433241844177,
0.5054537057876587,
1.0956131219863892,
-0.3632846474647522,
0.8622502088546753,
0.25676023960113525,
-0.25177887082099915,
0.26484745740890503,
0.590833842754364,
0.3045889437198639,
0.8969444036483765,
0.16270728409290314,
-0.35689762234687805,
-0.45838630199432373,
0.03514678403735161,
-0.012699786573648453,
0.627040684223175,
0.14665855467319489,
-0.1771237701177597,
-0.6842179894447327,
0.032802384346723557,
-0.2232847660779953,
-0.017833339050412178,
-0.07809717953205109,
0.9989987015724182,
0.08697062730789185,
-0.44186607003211975,
0.7279466986656189,
-0.30193817615509033,
0.27654099464416504,
-0.847232460975647,
-0.0707087367773056,
-0.34374645352363586,
0.04341669753193855,
-0.053770944476127625,
-0.8581605553627014,
0.34998539090156555,
-0.17567044496536255,
-0.028258997946977615,
0.020770909264683723,
0.6932186484336853,
-0.3356013596057892,
-0.2439410537481308,
0.12219610810279846,
0.6805315017700195,
0.006269307341426611,
0.21923871338367462,
-0.6471657156944275,
-0.37837353348731995,
-0.2820735275745392,
-0.3481582999229431,
0.5121534466743469,
0.5223169326782227,
-0.03077520802617073,
0.9172934293746948,
0.12157183885574341,
-0.404395192861557,
0.2757715582847595,
-0.07828426361083984,
1.0130077600479126,
-0.35041099786758423,
-0.44327419996261597,
-0.5670180320739746,
0.3170018196105957,
0.11530695855617523,
-0.3094988763332367,
0.6025988459587097,
0.4253796339035034,
0.8156812787055969,
-0.003383158938959241,
0.5591357350349426,
0.07734107971191406,
0.5337230563163757,
-0.5335206985473633,
0.6379088163375854,
-0.7451819181442261,
-0.008958970196545124,
-0.2850392460823059,
-0.6648761630058289,
-0.448344886302948,
0.18981477618217468,
-0.38328078389167786,
-0.07006850093603134,
0.6654614806175232,
0.8188152313232422,
-0.2189665138721466,
-0.21174201369285583,
0.632725715637207,
0.13027796149253845,
0.12570469081401825,
0.7074626684188843,
0.9048382639884949,
-0.3723805546760559,
0.8602997660636902,
-0.2603941857814789,
-0.05767734721302986,
-0.11182709038257599,
-0.8071250319480896,
-0.7771708965301514,
-0.44694817066192627,
-0.4475467801094055,
-0.15232814848423004,
0.2503353953361511,
0.8224965929985046,
0.645481526851654,
-0.647453784942627,
0.29449915885925293,
0.10107990354299545,
0.2372654378414154,
-0.19007159769535065,
-0.1925368309020996,
0.6707333326339722,
-0.43110474944114685,
-0.6094481945037842,
0.547694981098175,
0.17789871990680695,
-0.021002260968089104,
-0.0239585991948843,
0.14177291095256805,
-0.2587943375110626,
0.10365018993616104,
0.778653085231781,
0.24872761964797974,
-0.4376147389411926,
-0.5737949013710022,
0.14156174659729004,
0.03907690942287445,
-0.045716725289821625,
0.571385383605957,
-1.1336606740951538,
0.46263495087623596,
0.8898499011993408,
0.9417432546615601,
0.8314832448959351,
0.15481950342655182,
0.10541412979364395,
-1.2003164291381836,
0.10404311120510101,
0.2154286503791809,
-0.16241449117660522,
0.046720393002033234,
-0.21656057238578796,
0.212189182639122,
0.3526706397533417,
-0.2597358226776123,
-0.547804594039917,
0.6387288570404053,
-0.7778348922729492,
-0.38417792320251465,
1.2586085796356201,
-0.23808881640434265,
-0.149688720703125,
-0.31339776515960693,
0.0805697962641716,
0.24465955793857574,
-0.09452775120735168,
0.4988929033279419,
0.523076057434082,
-0.574275016784668,
-0.06852240860462189,
-0.452486127614975,
0.5079280734062195,
0.07707881927490234,
-0.5706661343574524,
-0.09656848013401031,
0.36915266513824463,
0.5586084127426147,
-0.2964482009410858,
0.7132078409194946,
0.01226701308041811,
0.18352098762989044,
-0.002060471335425973,
-0.5623227953910828,
-0.23355364799499512,
-0.28354647755622864,
-0.04938657209277153,
0.6111892461776733,
0.29160183668136597,
-0.2911255955696106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01406v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01406v1 | Adapting Multilingual LLMs to Low-Resource Languages with Knowledge Graphs via Adapters | 2024-07-01T15:56:24 | 2024-07-01T15:56:24 | Daniil Gurgurov, Mareike Hartmann, Simon Ostermann | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper explores the integration of graph knowledge from linguistic
ontologies into multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) using adapters to
improve performance for low-resource languages (LRLs) in sentiment analysis
(SA) and named entity recognition (NER). Building upon successful
parameter-efficient fine-tuning techniques, such as K-ADAPTER and MAD-X, we
propose a similar approach for incorporating knowledge from multilingual
graphs, connecting concepts in various languages with each other through
linguistic relationships, into multilingual LLMs for LRLs. Specifically, we
focus on eight LRLs -- Maltese, Bulgarian, Indonesian, Nepali, Javanese,
Uyghur, Tibetan, and Sinhala -- and employ language-specific adapters
fine-tuned on data extracted from the language-specific section of ConceptNet,
aiming to enable knowledge transfer across the languages covered by the
knowledge graph. We compare various fine-tuning objectives, including standard
Masked Language Modeling (MLM), MLM with full-word masking, and MLM with
targeted masking, to analyse their effectiveness in learning and integrating
the extracted graph data. Through empirical evaluation on language-specific
tasks, we assess how structured graph knowledge affects the performance of
multilingual LLMs for LRLs in SA and NER, providing insights into the potential
benefits of adapting language models for low-resource scenarios. | [
-0.39596039056777954,
-0.4570170044898987,
0.3867287337779999,
0.10564956068992615,
-0.2228865772485733,
0.4056077301502228,
-0.520037055015564,
-0.43269023299217224,
0.29146069288253784,
0.701837420463562,
-0.32958024740219116,
-0.5610864162445068,
-0.5381476283073425,
0.2951846718788147,
0.22100253403186798,
1.0232408046722412,
-0.25776392221450806,
0.011703548021614552,
0.10759496688842773,
-0.3533199429512024,
-0.2721274197101593,
-0.511056661605835,
-0.8524172902107239,
-0.31066763401031494,
0.7248567342758179,
0.39066269993782043,
0.4324452877044678,
0.3416871130466461,
0.366850882768631,
0.28684762120246887,
-0.18861477077007294,
0.5394913554191589,
-0.5548226833343506,
-0.23047441244125366,
-0.4427056312561035,
-0.5159893035888672,
-0.47458720207214355,
-0.32366812229156494,
0.7287877202033997,
0.783615231513977,
0.05197985842823982,
0.30056461691856384,
0.2774267792701721,
0.7396363019943237,
-0.5265665650367737,
0.5528372526168823,
-0.704988420009613,
0.08677788078784943,
-0.0309284720569849,
-0.13183963298797607,
-0.30079764127731323,
-0.2860884368419647,
-0.09618881344795227,
-0.6463792324066162,
-0.21705587208271027,
0.16409672796726227,
0.5974763035774231,
0.3943222463130951,
-0.16420269012451172,
-0.3745661973953247,
-0.48961684107780457,
0.7342315316200256,
-0.6183981895446777,
0.4547347128391266,
0.18494553864002228,
0.2637927234172821,
-0.09095213562250137,
-0.5389219522476196,
-0.5695644021034241,
0.1412036269903183,
-0.31174203753471375,
0.06588420271873474,
-0.23787610232830048,
0.12666063010692596,
0.08040137588977814,
0.10436204820871353,
-0.21141156554222107,
0.39834874868392944,
-0.1990763396024704,
-0.19223634898662567,
0.5258799195289612,
0.06630801409482956,
0.2731241285800934,
-0.32561036944389343,
-0.08778207749128342,
0.05972585082054138,
-0.5915758013725281,
0.14148768782615662,
0.3400527834892273,
0.9516791701316833,
-0.293881893157959,
0.5327568054199219,
-0.2482573390007019,
0.9594034552574158,
0.02224309742450714,
-0.4204378128051758,
0.2185364067554474,
-0.5378867387771606,
-0.020792188122868538,
0.1524447202682495,
0.7331717014312744,
0.1978592872619629,
0.5885142683982849,
-0.29943305253982544,
-0.16828812658786774,
-0.0075916689820587635,
-0.21589064598083496,
-0.7562935948371887,
-0.22502605617046356,
-0.25734251737594604,
-0.4040769040584564,
-0.14217646420001984,
-0.490583598613739,
-0.7616908550262451,
-0.546200156211853,
-0.18953509628772736,
0.1727416068315506,
-0.3572181761264801,
-0.3647398054599762,
0.14527635276317596,
-0.11739463359117508,
0.1389417052268982,
0.28733882308006287,
-0.6395601034164429,
0.30497270822525024,
0.49951601028442383,
1.0174047946929932,
-0.11325865238904953,
-0.25100553035736084,
-0.3983066976070404,
0.26322758197784424,
-0.21158644556999207,
0.7924832701683044,
-0.5566275119781494,
-0.2565264105796814,
0.06277214735746384,
0.31975677609443665,
-0.34742271900177,
-0.4716126024723053,
0.3277769386768341,
-0.7120165824890137,
0.013316255994141102,
-0.3580378592014313,
-0.430169016122818,
-0.36016228795051575,
0.6370294690132141,
-0.6336603164672852,
0.8414518237113953,
0.16544686257839203,
-0.7711260318756104,
0.16336257755756378,
-0.9610743522644043,
-0.5544072389602661,
-0.019744038581848145,
0.005125558935105801,
0.013488687574863434,
-0.0017458547372370958,
0.12192964553833008,
0.5213281512260437,
-0.1869852989912033,
-0.25376492738723755,
-0.2545701265335083,
-0.016410373151302338,
0.21212758123874664,
-0.1882346123456955,
0.7001752257347107,
0.15387924015522003,
0.11308855563402176,
0.13868162035942078,
-0.8776066303253174,
0.10869614779949188,
0.1327221542596817,
-0.5163329243659973,
-0.42415326833724976,
-0.05797714740037918,
0.09855243563652039,
0.5554972887039185,
0.22659048438072205,
-0.41885635256767273,
0.03222500905394554,
-0.6036163568496704,
0.5862728953361511,
0.5863238573074341,
-0.0777926817536354,
0.4233732521533966,
-0.05192805826663971,
0.6346055865287781,
0.27250775694847107,
-0.23358993232250214,
0.12747597694396973,
-0.37454307079315186,
-1.002833366394043,
-0.11174651980400085,
0.4951174855232239,
0.6793974041938782,
-1.1622589826583862,
0.18039000034332275,
-0.5336361527442932,
-0.34448543190956116,
-0.7557505369186401,
0.581901490688324,
0.3579176962375641,
0.46635961532592773,
0.28188133239746094,
-0.40089476108551025,
-0.46176576614379883,
-0.689081072807312,
-0.25803467631340027,
-0.21231405436992645,
0.2809976637363434,
0.5232368111610413,
0.28151020407676697,
-0.22167301177978516,
0.6073688864707947,
-0.5453888773918152,
-0.5160012245178223,
-0.5444532632827759,
-0.35478559136390686,
0.32021579146385193,
0.022186903282999992,
0.6900390386581421,
-0.5070199370384216,
-0.7658863067626953,
0.4277401864528656,
-0.6384655237197876,
0.11453763395547867,
0.3149392902851105,
-0.10708872228860855,
0.37536367774009705,
0.4808678925037384,
-0.2912333309650421,
-0.17400506138801575,
0.7563270330429077,
-0.273403525352478,
0.36088621616363525,
-0.19444328546524048,
-0.14305786788463593,
-1.330186367034912,
-0.086346335709095,
0.10037700831890106,
-0.4102712869644165,
-0.7105971574783325,
-0.006718273274600506,
-0.22805285453796387,
-0.07081633061170578,
-0.6079381704330444,
0.8201591968536377,
-0.44510984420776367,
-0.028590289875864983,
-0.25198689103126526,
0.5829727053642273,
0.019470468163490295,
0.5622461438179016,
0.023844778537750244,
0.688957691192627,
0.3693302571773529,
-0.5359880328178406,
0.26749932765960693,
0.1754617989063263,
-0.5241090655326843,
0.6356024146080017,
-0.29824817180633545,
0.15899251401424408,
-0.19134072959423065,
-0.10877510905265808,
-0.7486956119537354,
-0.00016207450244110078,
0.4253033399581909,
-0.12013570219278336,
0.2989305257797241,
-0.5987864136695862,
-0.4039932191371918,
-0.08819951117038727,
-0.12980620563030243,
0.2990536093711853,
0.2517401874065399,
-0.465679794549942,
0.7863920331001282,
0.5397440195083618,
-0.28041112422943115,
-0.5900588631629944,
-0.7641454935073853,
0.10471980273723602,
-0.3599981963634491,
-0.43757396936416626,
0.05341145768761635,
0.08168084174394608,
-0.26566267013549805,
0.2077419012784958,
0.2576659917831421,
-0.037230439484119415,
0.1145462766289711,
-0.013187171891331673,
-0.037042275071144104,
-0.43116387724876404,
0.13721640408039093,
0.02412101998925209,
-0.20314015448093414,
-0.20570877194404602,
-0.563094437122345,
0.6423135995864868,
-0.2243315875530243,
-0.1786583960056305,
-0.12009653449058533,
0.024096276611089706,
0.36684754490852356,
-0.13152605295181274,
0.8989304304122925,
0.7828835248947144,
-0.3883376717567444,
-0.169651597738266,
-0.4058058261871338,
0.12657831609249115,
-0.42775624990463257,
0.5728709697723389,
-0.6783285737037659,
-1.133175015449524,
0.6836215257644653,
-0.4717790186405182,
-0.20379236340522766,
0.3511098623275757,
0.641116738319397,
-0.04255946725606918,
0.8126606941223145,
0.8752214312553406,
-0.4797813892364502,
0.5119512677192688,
-0.2202673852443695,
0.45231547951698303,
-0.9559387564659119,
0.09165571630001068,
-0.3939271867275238,
-0.3653116822242737,
-1.0758607387542725,
-0.4925641119480133,
0.2095060646533966,
0.2646822929382324,
-0.09597834944725037,
0.19001434743404388,
-0.11665945500135422,
0.4497182369232178,
0.2574590742588043,
-0.014860326424241066,
0.4522460103034973,
0.1951272189617157,
-0.09209316223859787,
0.0939171239733696,
-1.0983220338821411,
-0.4883367717266083,
0.8435187339782715,
0.10862234234809875,
0.6529926657676697,
0.25394901633262634,
0.576321005821228,
0.06499230116605759,
0.20090998709201813,
-0.9180459380149841,
0.36677005887031555,
-0.61391282081604,
-0.20904864370822906,
-0.30505621433258057,
-0.37076327204704285,
-0.8107370734214783,
0.3119623064994812,
-0.15747593343257904,
-0.7482118010520935,
0.26761388778686523,
0.0923447236418724,
-0.21548967063426971,
0.37827780842781067,
-0.618696391582489,
0.7970442771911621,
-0.2503458857536316,
-0.020611146464943886,
-0.24727053940296173,
-0.2691836357116699,
0.09637745469808578,
-0.35519933700561523,
0.7025734186172485,
-0.2509193420410156,
-0.038949403911828995,
0.8271128535270691,
-0.06464897841215134,
1.1245943307876587,
-0.21416215598583221,
-0.25154954195022583,
0.27850499749183655,
-0.07190321385860443,
0.6570959091186523,
-0.018544059246778488,
-0.36182811856269836,
0.4250718653202057,
0.047773558646440506,
-0.3606778085231781,
-0.6417222619056702,
0.8047273755073547,
-0.9900898933410645,
-0.44213706254959106,
0.052713315933942795,
-0.7840280532836914,
-0.3321356475353241,
0.4917311370372772,
-0.06568022817373276,
-0.06557947397232056,
-0.14297793805599213,
-0.2099209427833557,
0.37710511684417725,
-0.31362929940223694,
0.25500842928886414,
0.7139609456062317,
-0.4123687148094177,
-0.4106222689151764,
1.2672655582427979,
0.5019146800041199,
0.2896904945373535,
0.41793033480644226,
0.2840597629547119,
-0.1022343635559082,
-0.43814724683761597,
-0.6408975720405579,
0.3414499759674072,
-0.9245951175689697,
-0.28745150566101074,
-0.6249836087226868,
-0.1955660730600357,
-0.2545623779296875,
0.019984012469649315,
-0.31948667764663696,
-0.5831268429756165,
-0.22464489936828613,
-0.006433859467506409,
0.6628581881523132,
0.5146212577819824,
0.09102234989404678,
0.3741661608219147,
-0.6878048181533813,
0.14844460785388947,
0.025227630510926247,
0.5616198182106018,
-0.019694488495588303,
-0.5121259093284607,
-0.5237018465995789,
0.06899259984493256,
0.032079339027404785,
-0.6293210387229919,
0.18965037167072296,
0.5565589666366577,
0.4827362596988678,
0.2559584081172943,
-0.021863102912902832,
0.801823079586029,
-0.49834397435188293,
0.48279476165771484,
0.10891512781381607,
-0.8531786203384399,
0.36081090569496155,
-0.13774053752422333,
0.05874716490507126,
0.471439391374588,
0.3929924964904785,
-0.7664758563041687,
-0.1878596395254135,
-0.07889791578054428,
-0.6324923038482666,
0.8422057628631592,
-0.18818846344947815,
0.2748382091522217,
0.10614033788442612,
0.600700855255127,
-0.09114405512809753,
0.2303754985332489,
-0.7402595281600952,
-0.3140855133533478,
-0.19343328475952148,
-0.4074229896068573,
-0.3829338252544403,
-0.23135504126548767,
-0.19957689940929413,
-0.17317083477973938,
0.5953393578529358,
-0.7173104286193848,
-0.051124610006809235,
-0.19717010855674744,
-0.43645280599594116,
-0.020578721538186073,
0.38957056403160095,
0.2767093777656555,
0.45047998428344727,
0.1684538871049881,
0.24930979311466217,
0.6601780652999878,
-0.15259046852588654,
0.05713455379009247,
0.1592959761619568,
-0.261662095785141,
-0.1441981941461563,
0.34646233916282654,
1.088362693786621,
0.3234536349773407,
-0.46957921981811523,
0.02851146087050438,
0.03166365996003151,
0.11890533566474915,
0.1097465306520462,
0.1990462839603424,
0.36844155192375183,
0.4413244128227234,
-0.2317427545785904,
-0.11846891045570374,
-0.07640775293111801,
-0.438163697719574,
-0.30034831166267395,
0.5335527062416077,
-0.6054564714431763,
-0.4539509415626526,
0.18422986567020416,
0.032291773706674576,
-0.29209181666374207,
0.36833205819129944,
-0.18462243676185608,
-0.58998703956604,
0.28044435381889343,
0.7024314999580383,
0.5115135908126831,
-0.2048856019973755,
0.17203162610530853,
0.23675191402435303,
0.41749143600463867,
0.13173523545265198,
0.4741083085536957,
0.05966449901461601,
-1.1888437271118164,
-0.5719819664955139,
-0.8030608892440796,
-0.2980843484401703,
-0.20751559734344482,
-0.5630936026573181,
0.2980894148349762,
-0.4410167336463928,
-0.2080368846654892,
0.13580459356307983,
0.16188600659370422,
-1.0449732542037964,
0.02789114974439144,
0.11024343967437744,
0.9866572618484497,
-0.9108410477638245,
0.9159554839134216,
1.0484237670898438,
-0.35902878642082214,
-0.8252145051956177,
-0.20572835206985474,
-0.2613125443458557,
-1.2794934511184692,
0.7270703911781311,
-0.24182887375354767,
-0.28523874282836914,
0.3507693409919739,
0.02400011010468006,
-0.9839712977409363,
0.8104357719421387,
0.5114091038703918,
-0.5591714382171631,
0.1338375359773636,
0.5543221831321716,
0.7191117405891418,
-0.3616813123226166,
0.037293124943971634,
0.6034850478172302,
0.5970965027809143,
-0.11838354915380478,
-0.8319387435913086,
0.039810020476579666,
-0.1598406732082367,
0.13135462999343872,
0.25760316848754883,
-0.8406655192375183,
0.4655438959598541,
-0.1823364496231079,
-0.07832980901002884,
-0.22840166091918945,
0.5655052661895752,
0.04551936686038971,
0.11254512518644333,
0.4925220310688019,
0.5071572065353394,
0.9262768030166626,
-0.04803851991891861,
0.8459842801094055,
-0.8422565460205078,
0.2890021502971649,
1.0240288972854614,
-0.44213584065437317,
0.8211423754692078,
0.5662581324577332,
-0.3366243541240692,
0.7101254463195801,
0.48136115074157715,
0.1323702186346054,
0.5273258090019226,
0.24371464550495148,
-0.023365439847111702,
-0.2488226443529129,
-0.5871225595474243,
-0.22118476033210754,
0.5551314353942871,
0.5907886028289795,
-0.22851325571537018,
-0.2239295244216919,
-0.009451989084482193,
0.1455851048231125,
-0.18014702200889587,
-0.5185363292694092,
1.1308645009994507,
0.23045599460601807,
-0.32400721311569214,
0.5638133883476257,
0.20027539134025574,
0.6589546799659729,
-0.45019349455833435,
0.23412783443927765,
-0.2089284360408783,
0.25284552574157715,
-0.3575120270252228,
-0.8158666491508484,
0.3551640212535858,
0.03961819410324097,
-0.43825989961624146,
0.0013702685246244073,
0.9852146506309509,
-0.5311951041221619,
-0.9211844205856323,
0.6887163519859314,
0.8549309372901917,
0.1401439905166626,
0.2054336965084076,
-0.7102746367454529,
0.012749632820487022,
-0.1645023077726364,
-0.10939260572195053,
0.5793567895889282,
0.6883403062820435,
-0.11406941711902618,
0.634639322757721,
0.6042553186416626,
0.3847385048866272,
-0.03194338455796242,
0.33531463146209717,
0.9220495223999023,
-0.5362799167633057,
-0.4697312116622925,
-0.8678006529808044,
0.23324185609817505,
0.12159519642591476,
-0.05063844099640846,
0.8745042681694031,
0.4114520251750946,
1.0434907674789429,
0.052181098610162735,
0.9462037682533264,
0.20960618555545807,
0.28338882327079773,
-0.5459722876548767,
0.8119114637374878,
-0.6442530155181885,
0.045655831694602966,
-0.3242529630661011,
-0.8245247602462769,
-0.3155827820301056,
0.46482959389686584,
-0.4043445587158203,
-0.0729036033153534,
0.24312490224838257,
0.7066154479980469,
-0.020262645557522774,
-0.3542546033859253,
0.33558350801467896,
0.42105984687805176,
0.18438206613063812,
0.40725207328796387,
0.6171809434890747,
-0.31002146005630493,
0.4757233262062073,
-0.3028036952018738,
-0.07212987542152405,
-0.029031645506620407,
-0.9536789655685425,
-0.9429833889007568,
-0.3383043110370636,
-0.37604695558547974,
-0.38027647137641907,
0.0450640432536602,
0.8090233206748962,
0.48986852169036865,
-0.9866747260093689,
-0.33560654520988464,
0.26864516735076904,
0.5750703811645508,
-0.08455497771501541,
-0.20428332686424255,
0.453472375869751,
-0.4895338714122772,
-0.6094053983688354,
0.3834093511104584,
0.4001641571521759,
-0.18723005056381226,
-0.23376302421092987,
-0.205022931098938,
-0.014812128618359566,
-0.020899144932627678,
0.9707627296447754,
0.18398207426071167,
-0.6556106209754944,
-0.3960290253162384,
-0.06473850458860397,
0.18206395208835602,
0.08809953927993774,
0.7425923347473145,
-0.7254155874252319,
0.4643958806991577,
0.28975921869277954,
0.6178555488586426,
0.22526761889457703,
-0.3949175179004669,
0.22698290646076202,
-0.7759273052215576,
0.30858826637268066,
-0.14251139760017395,
0.5712732076644897,
0.4974710941314697,
-0.1767445057630539,
0.3923696279525757,
0.20064309239387512,
-0.19400499761104584,
-0.9195619225502014,
0.3221193253993988,
-0.6993524432182312,
-0.11420758813619614,
1.2520581483840942,
-0.28977397084236145,
-0.21476894617080688,
-0.3047463297843933,
-0.05636351555585861,
0.4493984282016754,
-0.03387075290083885,
0.7116279602050781,
0.5988537073135376,
-0.13279038667678833,
-0.252749502658844,
-0.2975054383277893,
0.4911578893661499,
0.029132425785064697,
-0.7304267287254333,
0.048037782311439514,
0.06947740912437439,
0.5079095363616943,
0.31392180919647217,
0.62120521068573,
0.11670111119747162,
-0.17354801297187805,
-0.37393224239349365,
0.04317894205451012,
-0.0004482869408093393,
0.004997050855308771,
-0.3586980700492859,
0.04802925884723663,
0.38644179701805115,
0.13501416146755219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01403v1 | Optimization of Retrieval-Augmented Generation Context with Outlier Detection | 2024-07-01T15:53:29 | 2024-07-01T15:53:29 | Vitaly Bulgakov | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we focus on methods to reduce the size and improve the quality
of the prompt context required for question-answering systems. Attempts to
increase the number of retrieved chunked documents and thereby enlarge the
context related to the query can significantly complicate the processing and
decrease the performance of a Large Language Model (LLM) when generating
responses to queries. It is well known that a large set of documents retrieved
from a database in response to a query may contain irrelevant information,
which often leads to hallucinations in the resulting answers. Our goal is to
select the most semantically relevant documents, treating the discarded ones as
outliers. We propose and evaluate several methods for identifying outliers by
creating features that utilize the distances of embedding vectors, retrieved
from the vector database, to both the centroid and the query vectors. The
methods were evaluated by comparing the similarities of the retrieved LLM
responses to ground-truth answers obtained using the OpenAI GPT-4o model. It
was found that the greatest improvements were achieved with increasing
complexity of the questions and answers. | [
-0.7797973155975342,
-1.0936311483383179,
0.7274568676948547,
-0.11022613197565079,
-0.3567999601364136,
-0.32271307706832886,
-0.03242126479744911,
-0.13821916282176971,
0.1198987141251564,
0.6105574369430542,
-0.5085176229476929,
-0.33225879073143005,
-0.29525959491729736,
0.14655257761478424,
-0.44844189286231995,
0.7236967086791992,
0.15074650943279266,
-0.11657688766717911,
-0.6795337200164795,
-0.11896327137947083,
-0.7258608937263489,
-0.32050228118896484,
-0.6244667768478394,
0.026892859488725662,
0.02816956676542759,
0.5973098278045654,
0.4285790026187897,
0.619140088558197,
0.38326555490493774,
0.26361405849456787,
-0.19186751544475555,
0.45488351583480835,
-0.46271052956581116,
0.49346646666526794,
-0.043628644198179245,
-0.33005639910697937,
0.06832744181156158,
-0.3482339084148407,
0.7670671343803406,
0.4679206609725952,
0.0812055692076683,
0.16500505805015564,
0.20110052824020386,
0.42762574553489685,
-0.5025061964988708,
-0.13351225852966309,
-0.618732213973999,
-0.10060984641313553,
-0.19226515293121338,
-0.6608355641365051,
-0.3164444863796234,
-0.610931932926178,
0.056492023169994354,
-0.6449201107025146,
0.5662820935249329,
0.3023216724395752,
0.7221543192863464,
0.2527467906475067,
-0.30078306794166565,
-0.6354190707206726,
-0.4016527235507965,
0.8730602264404297,
-0.49948713183403015,
0.18981702625751495,
0.24406661093235016,
0.372163325548172,
-0.5229955315589905,
-0.35065901279449463,
-0.6546730399131775,
0.01989285834133625,
-0.05487227812409401,
-0.003348845522850752,
0.035040050745010376,
-0.14539632201194763,
0.3477368652820587,
0.17113156616687775,
-0.7962986826896667,
-0.04248814284801483,
-0.12490566074848175,
-0.2309163510799408,
0.49902814626693726,
0.1823389083147049,
0.3115459084510803,
-0.42814886569976807,
-0.18065661191940308,
-0.2784993648529053,
-0.8450488448143005,
0.0207991823554039,
0.5075933933258057,
0.20761381089687347,
0.42918628454208374,
0.5870447754859924,
-0.14679844677448273,
0.7515106797218323,
0.028096698224544525,
0.09597813338041306,
0.16858559846878052,
-0.660682201385498,
-0.042207859456539154,
-0.12115249037742615,
0.361405611038208,
0.46538424491882324,
-0.008579421788454056,
-0.03119163028895855,
-0.19763323664665222,
-0.4341757893562317,
0.23028986155986786,
-0.9934770464897156,
0.2581281065940857,
0.39777934551239014,
-0.5093919634819031,
-0.02998289093375206,
-0.023000411689281464,
-0.8586362600326538,
-0.3320755362510681,
-0.29385682940483093,
0.44699057936668396,
-0.6430108547210693,
-0.06662409007549286,
-0.35460397601127625,
-0.413123220205307,
0.39472416043281555,
0.36092445254325867,
-0.7126678228378296,
-0.06986794620752335,
0.5498721599578857,
0.7040169835090637,
0.014659218490123749,
0.1282036304473877,
-0.8364598155021667,
0.05043903738260269,
-0.40450021624565125,
0.8833507299423218,
-0.7264883518218994,
-0.7707385420799255,
0.11296438425779343,
-0.10992661118507385,
-0.020095989108085632,
-0.8461816906929016,
0.7225223183631897,
-0.7988438606262207,
0.47927126288414,
-0.9004480838775635,
-0.7475525736808777,
-0.1482224017381668,
0.4338136613368988,
-0.406904399394989,
1.2456027269363403,
0.47198280692100525,
-0.7360703945159912,
0.26229116320610046,
-0.6226319074630737,
-0.19496025145053864,
0.27828559279441833,
-0.32396695017814636,
-0.20934028923511505,
0.18542788922786713,
0.506593644618988,
0.25927144289016724,
-0.5540224313735962,
0.09134301543235779,
0.11915390938520432,
-0.5710941553115845,
0.22750037908554077,
-0.0429251566529274,
0.6428156495094299,
0.34800398349761963,
-0.015410611405968666,
0.09872595965862274,
-0.7060112953186035,
0.29052087664604187,
0.03321867063641548,
-0.4350510239601135,
-0.5976229310035706,
-0.12359045445919037,
-0.20600084960460663,
0.19685666263103485,
0.1916636824607849,
-0.7954660058021545,
-0.10568294674158096,
-0.505285918712616,
0.2769601345062256,
0.5854741930961609,
0.5404905676841736,
0.39218670129776,
-0.2857908606529236,
0.5749971270561218,
0.3833341598510742,
0.1472143679857254,
-0.34308922290802,
-0.5450105667114258,
-0.5242874026298523,
-0.05033576488494873,
0.014640934765338898,
0.4234744906425476,
-1.2243274450302124,
0.6268079876899719,
-0.27677178382873535,
-0.12023817747831345,
-0.34221234917640686,
0.22894354164600372,
0.3760424256324768,
1.2071824073791504,
0.5220596790313721,
0.024374954402446747,
-0.4216773211956024,
-0.8369249105453491,
-0.33881717920303345,
-0.03741397336125374,
-0.18735601007938385,
0.5203226208686829,
0.4779295325279236,
-0.1715284138917923,
1.233924388885498,
-0.4562820792198181,
-0.12353025376796722,
0.0176028273999691,
-0.12745581567287445,
0.14577484130859375,
0.4442541003227234,
0.7059730291366577,
-0.8886459469795227,
-0.31323617696762085,
-0.10845199972391129,
-0.8080499172210693,
-0.12347973883152008,
0.2240586280822754,
-0.24969317018985748,
0.1695268154144287,
0.6459832787513733,
-0.3955324590206146,
0.37858906388282776,
-0.00034490088000893593,
-0.22200137376785278,
0.1897178292274475,
-0.22442877292633057,
0.27017492055892944,
-1.252875566482544,
-0.10343574732542038,
-0.12667767703533173,
0.08267106860876083,
-0.5738523006439209,
0.0656188577413559,
0.1828693300485611,
-0.1820461004972458,
-0.2504595220088959,
0.49327725172042847,
-0.4365082383155823,
-0.14638379216194153,
-0.10529548674821854,
0.49850720167160034,
0.08636002242565155,
0.3121173679828644,
-0.33507025241851807,
1.0800328254699707,
0.20601098239421844,
-0.6568799614906311,
0.3311583697795868,
0.5128980875015259,
-0.312631219625473,
0.7329329252243042,
-0.5586887001991272,
0.22040104866027832,
-0.7498224973678589,
-0.011575723066926003,
-1.2196016311645508,
-0.312355101108551,
0.09504157304763794,
-0.6191608905792236,
0.2171565294265747,
0.017091425135731697,
-0.4068557322025299,
-0.30454885959625244,
-0.6854429244995117,
0.4949502646923065,
0.402357816696167,
-0.7182855010032654,
0.4911710321903229,
0.19063803553581238,
-0.22138668596744537,
-0.5190497040748596,
-0.4676818549633026,
-0.21949942409992218,
-0.3929939866065979,
-0.8577698469161987,
0.18360082805156708,
-0.10286670923233032,
-0.037380971014499664,
0.09593048691749573,
0.1855212152004242,
0.2507951557636261,
-0.06417107582092285,
-0.01746535487473011,
-0.006615168415009975,
-0.23945821821689606,
0.5423336029052734,
0.3961240351200104,
0.14553755521774292,
0.003828621469438076,
-0.13542824983596802,
0.5220642685890198,
0.009835459291934967,
-0.27080392837524414,
0.1355750411748886,
0.7089625000953674,
0.2961258292198181,
-0.22153306007385254,
0.6903752088546753,
0.4060235619544983,
-0.3973919451236725,
-0.16476355493068695,
-0.5395045876502991,
-0.2181592583656311,
-0.4585805833339691,
0.3381640315055847,
-0.41503867506980896,
-1.0212594270706177,
0.7792786955833435,
0.12645412981510162,
-0.10797333717346191,
0.5094327926635742,
0.3779032230377197,
0.23375080525875092,
1.0902258157730103,
0.22537115216255188,
0.24279771745204926,
0.58064866065979,
-0.2712302803993225,
0.17485803365707397,
-1.2956598997116089,
-0.3832765519618988,
-0.8311179876327515,
0.06766762584447861,
-0.5960665345191956,
-0.4751552939414978,
0.7041594982147217,
0.1519693285226822,
-0.31390246748924255,
0.02860741689801216,
-0.7740697264671326,
0.3285929560661316,
0.6779637932777405,
0.03793732821941376,
0.04165225848555565,
0.22668547928333282,
-0.18656285107135773,
0.1008230447769165,
-0.7059803009033203,
-0.4319533407688141,
1.1118406057357788,
-0.022468682378530502,
0.2685513496398926,
0.4154914915561676,
0.6788598895072937,
0.11437857151031494,
0.13963419198989868,
-0.4902181029319763,
0.5547170639038086,
0.21887138485908508,
-0.45727211236953735,
-0.6541404128074646,
-0.6252177357673645,
-1.0051063299179077,
0.39138174057006836,
-0.07962008565664291,
-0.6793802380561829,
0.3593052327632904,
-0.08921279013156891,
-0.4989585280418396,
-0.060021042823791504,
-0.7293938994407654,
0.6739467978477478,
0.08699487149715424,
-0.22002044320106506,
0.17214220762252808,
-0.5652535557746887,
0.22082944214344025,
-0.109132781624794,
0.17334449291229248,
0.09928286820650101,
-0.065273717045784,
0.5727024078369141,
-0.660957932472229,
0.15493568778038025,
-0.421024352312088,
-0.014755920507013798,
0.6986730098724365,
-0.09619839489459991,
0.5835641026496887,
0.16350749135017395,
-0.2363848239183426,
-0.335835725069046,
0.10944820940494537,
-0.4464138150215149,
-0.8110566735267639,
0.9246037006378174,
-0.7533223628997803,
-0.6986660361289978,
-0.0968199074268341,
-0.3685949742794037,
-0.29072317481040955,
0.19602587819099426,
0.7357128262519836,
0.749884307384491,
-0.1484716236591339,
0.37513163685798645,
0.9106099009513855,
-0.5676994323730469,
0.5776416659355164,
0.18728962540626526,
-0.065142922103405,
-0.24398082494735718,
0.7668370604515076,
0.38767802715301514,
-0.09401494264602661,
0.36031126976013184,
0.07303594797849655,
-0.6952692270278931,
-0.7231045365333557,
-0.5474633574485779,
0.15056388080120087,
-0.9559609889984131,
-0.37519168853759766,
-0.6066251993179321,
-0.10984073579311371,
-0.6916356086730957,
0.08073165267705917,
0.24293437600135803,
-0.0821090042591095,
-0.47985562682151794,
0.11048179864883423,
0.37012383341789246,
0.37843653559684753,
0.2876621186733246,
0.33543530106544495,
-0.7927708625793457,
0.06766216456890106,
0.3750293552875519,
0.046918537467718124,
0.07594366371631622,
-0.6750562191009521,
-0.10894646495580673,
0.018776126205921173,
-0.33273613452911377,
-0.8679195046424866,
0.37891215085983276,
0.25742870569229126,
0.6578691601753235,
0.20000429451465607,
0.19002537429332733,
0.549513578414917,
-0.27837127447128296,
0.8066173195838928,
-0.18189936876296997,
-0.6085960268974304,
0.913244903087616,
-0.3983427882194519,
0.28210189938545227,
0.4328937232494354,
0.2118149846792221,
-0.3482111692428589,
-0.06838355958461761,
-0.5205816626548767,
-0.9524679780006409,
0.479988694190979,
0.17303664982318878,
0.12286330759525299,
-0.5093098878860474,
0.7552098035812378,
-0.06495999544858932,
0.31268009543418884,
0.14828340709209442,
0.06564509868621826,
-0.14633288979530334,
-0.20799706876277924,
0.08220802247524261,
-0.5200490355491638,
-0.05022996664047241,
-0.001648931298404932,
0.6965630054473877,
-0.5028159618377686,
0.3532674014568329,
0.4097553789615631,
-0.14588721096515656,
-0.23666693270206451,
0.28013259172439575,
0.7623863816261292,
0.7424428462982178,
-0.26835525035858154,
-0.10151985287666321,
0.2756424844264984,
-0.43816885352134705,
-0.04140486195683479,
0.07208499312400818,
-0.42420172691345215,
-0.01856248266994953,
0.11084049940109253,
0.5152549743652344,
-0.21647173166275024,
-0.7477566599845886,
0.6258620023727417,
-0.21565474569797516,
0.09206662327051163,
-0.40947380661964417,
-0.010912273079156876,
-0.23334568738937378,
0.19376377761363983,
0.5680806636810303,
-0.23406362533569336,
0.4346697926521301,
-0.5378415584564209,
-0.058754537254571915,
0.636752724647522,
-0.20190992951393127,
0.042295292019844055,
0.4688480794429779,
0.13054291903972626,
-0.23615320026874542,
0.8923163414001465,
-0.19129733741283417,
-0.387986421585083,
0.5905985236167908,
0.37702733278274536,
0.681384801864624,
-0.13938377797603607,
0.10941953212022781,
0.39977988600730896,
0.13869410753250122,
0.0027600477915257215,
0.40491801500320435,
-0.08953313529491425,
-0.8360251188278198,
-0.3112609088420868,
-0.6086783409118652,
-0.18878647685050964,
0.15582561492919922,
-0.7400525808334351,
0.047063589096069336,
-0.3086993992328644,
-0.08820738643407822,
-0.19251243770122528,
0.14050202071666718,
-0.6134120225906372,
0.28096362948417664,
-0.4562801420688629,
0.7296323180198669,
-0.5895612835884094,
0.5359455943107605,
0.6776837110519409,
-0.5810464024543762,
-0.6253899931907654,
-0.03047482669353485,
-0.21516691148281097,
-0.5950334668159485,
0.4837820827960968,
0.14832136034965515,
-0.008091024123132229,
0.1327732801437378,
-0.47034168243408203,
-0.9421068429946899,
1.1234291791915894,
0.30924221873283386,
-0.25350630283355713,
0.09581414610147476,
-0.03349148482084274,
0.5258258581161499,
-0.40189439058303833,
0.3719642162322998,
0.7089947462081909,
0.19574031233787537,
0.27919167280197144,
-0.44815173745155334,
0.27673402428627014,
-0.16488628089427948,
0.5159628391265869,
0.38314515352249146,
-0.5034454464912415,
0.919645369052887,
0.06565776467323303,
-0.19159212708473206,
0.262488454580307,
0.5009742975234985,
0.38315823674201965,
0.273831307888031,
0.36530962586402893,
0.5343498587608337,
0.9801213145256042,
-0.25036314129829407,
1.1738557815551758,
-0.11881670355796814,
0.16280615329742432,
0.7193275690078735,
-0.146678626537323,
0.6572092175483704,
0.5596545934677124,
0.20878121256828308,
0.35315635800361633,
0.7689896821975708,
0.3079119026660919,
0.4699830710887909,
0.272875040769577,
-0.25008732080459595,
-0.13589386641979218,
-0.19793999195098877,
-0.5598927736282349,
0.10876436531543732,
0.5266383290290833,
-0.3572167456150055,
-0.3381546437740326,
0.24209965765476227,
-0.12156294286251068,
0.23230965435504913,
-0.3382098972797394,
0.750996470451355,
-0.23816856741905212,
-0.8523009419441223,
0.5359858274459839,
-0.054300110787153244,
0.49028754234313965,
-0.15666791796684265,
-0.10984550416469574,
-0.6042008996009827,
-0.041926585137844086,
-0.17637136578559875,
-0.6510382294654846,
0.29627084732055664,
-0.21811972558498383,
-0.22778403759002686,
-0.020545117557048798,
0.7905672788619995,
-0.3396865129470825,
-0.19545821845531464,
0.02098015509545803,
0.6120861172676086,
0.27765631675720215,
-0.2663033902645111,
-0.41909563541412354,
-0.09380164742469788,
-0.11525390297174454,
-0.2964475452899933,
0.41995298862457275,
0.7725308537483215,
-0.4254261553287506,
0.4231526851654053,
0.7336695790290833,
-0.1643349826335907,
0.07012950628995895,
-0.02059541828930378,
1.0655626058578491,
-0.5529550313949585,
-0.6666256785392761,
-0.5453404784202576,
0.09076252579689026,
-0.3666987121105194,
-0.3701370060443878,
0.8621411323547363,
0.6732061505317688,
0.6982646584510803,
0.06370608508586884,
0.7399246096611023,
-0.0344277024269104,
0.8860925436019897,
-0.5673696398735046,
0.3015435039997101,
-0.5336697697639465,
0.5293409824371338,
-0.17860344052314758,
-1.200024127960205,
-0.12511643767356873,
0.322505921125412,
-0.28377461433410645,
0.2626229226589203,
0.4999074339866638,
1.064972996711731,
0.2925247251987457,
-0.002213245490565896,
0.4128359258174896,
-0.09496255964040756,
0.45308318734169006,
0.4137537479400635,
0.9356078505516052,
-0.5474756956100464,
0.6353328824043274,
0.25420647859573364,
-0.23151229321956635,
-0.47774678468704224,
-0.6970669627189636,
-0.7789461612701416,
-0.704221248626709,
-0.09567242860794067,
-0.43801191449165344,
-0.047092266380786896,
0.7615727186203003,
0.3848887085914612,
-0.8411455154418945,
0.1732776165008545,
-0.07157835364341736,
0.3253338932991028,
0.14879420399665833,
-0.30011671781539917,
0.5181883573532104,
-0.5794463753700256,
-0.5711265802383423,
0.43350210785865784,
0.26603156328201294,
0.12060444056987762,
-0.08143661916255951,
0.045681219547986984,
-0.181852325797081,
0.22755184769630432,
0.7161591053009033,
0.2844654619693756,
-0.5501273274421692,
-0.8001682758331299,
0.24759235978126526,
0.18511371314525604,
0.09393980354070663,
0.74751216173172,
-0.7893350720405579,
0.5895253419876099,
0.7931382060050964,
0.7147917151451111,
0.46396419405937195,
0.5046181082725525,
0.34741485118865967,
-1.2084859609603882,
0.11739997565746307,
0.18006445467472076,
0.17448130249977112,
0.5617172122001648,
-0.6448799967765808,
0.40980517864227295,
0.09951147437095642,
-0.636469841003418,
-0.7986779808998108,
0.20347249507904053,
-0.5691471099853516,
-0.3767234981060028,
1.1495954990386963,
0.0979401096701622,
-0.24187134206295013,
-0.28564170002937317,
-0.2984701097011566,
0.08784186840057373,
-0.4154820442199707,
0.44582080841064453,
0.6320293545722961,
-0.4705207943916321,
-0.2179446965456009,
-0.5347772836685181,
0.6857374906539917,
0.2955407202243805,
-0.6847906112670898,
-0.2831277549266815,
0.6387543082237244,
0.23372559249401093,
0.3731176555156708,
0.4681723713874817,
-0.2514913082122803,
0.23182280361652374,
-0.10793046653270721,
-0.2628610134124756,
-0.03803257644176483,
-0.06069996953010559,
-0.41894376277923584,
0.41696566343307495,
0.13972096145153046,
-0.39612606167793274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01394v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01394v1 | Gloss2Text: Sign Language Gloss translation using LLMs and Semantically Aware Label Smoothing | 2024-07-01T15:46:45 | 2024-07-01T15:46:45 | Pooya Fayyazsanavi, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Jana Košecká | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | Sign language translation from video to spoken text presents unique
challenges owing to the distinct grammar, expression nuances, and high
variation of visual appearance across different speakers and contexts. The
intermediate gloss annotations of videos aim to guide the translation process.
In our work, we focus on {\em Gloss2Text} translation stage and propose several
advances by leveraging pre-trained large language models (LLMs), data
augmentation, and novel label-smoothing loss function exploiting gloss
translation ambiguities improving significantly the performance of
state-of-the-art approaches. Through extensive experiments and ablation studies
on the PHOENIX Weather 2014T dataset, our approach surpasses state-of-the-art
performance in {\em Gloss2Text} translation, indicating its efficacy in
addressing sign language translation and suggesting promising avenues for
future research and development. | [
-0.19276900589466095,
-0.667280375957489,
0.600115180015564,
0.3017943203449249,
-0.48996055126190186,
0.026942819356918335,
-0.07572843879461288,
-0.7422251105308533,
0.0582067109644413,
0.7608228325843811,
-0.6617175936698914,
-0.6448099613189697,
-1.1904875040054321,
-0.03582540899515152,
-0.6306007504463196,
0.966059148311615,
-0.3101179003715515,
0.04570450633764267,
0.023278241977095604,
0.16418394446372986,
0.07494322210550308,
-0.30275580286979675,
-0.9044177532196045,
-0.39661720395088196,
0.16773338615894318,
0.5185590386390686,
1.1226922273635864,
0.47922855615615845,
0.7541738748550415,
0.21140602231025696,
0.01867864467203617,
0.30154475569725037,
-0.355772465467453,
0.1850767731666565,
0.1789751797914505,
-0.09482671320438385,
-0.7186190485954285,
-0.17690172791481018,
0.6675384044647217,
0.48826056718826294,
0.10888855904340744,
0.06089843437075615,
-0.30335041880607605,
0.395694762468338,
-0.38175925612449646,
0.18422172963619232,
-0.42144301533699036,
-0.00043335973168723285,
-0.45040228962898254,
0.001891745487228036,
-0.22844570875167847,
-0.07312343269586563,
-0.07639718800783157,
-0.8641645908355713,
-0.01966448687016964,
0.20357517898082733,
0.8103320002555847,
0.7112526297569275,
-0.8640109896659851,
-0.17996276915073395,
-0.9034102559089661,
0.4552849233150482,
-0.8928758502006531,
0.5920538902282715,
0.6008954644203186,
0.35818904638290405,
-0.22317306697368622,
-1.0156229734420776,
-0.6162831783294678,
0.14328797161579132,
0.116620734333992,
0.3664608597755432,
0.2017485499382019,
0.24612513184547424,
0.11710844933986664,
0.48217740654945374,
-0.42519640922546387,
0.3244047164916992,
-0.19974711537361145,
-0.38697463274002075,
0.6801955699920654,
-0.09661772102117538,
0.39896297454833984,
0.13130493462085724,
-0.44863662123680115,
-0.2598021626472473,
-0.434280127286911,
-0.25903773307800293,
0.033863067626953125,
0.3250289559364319,
-0.3851335644721985,
0.5637969374656677,
-0.12793678045272827,
0.6720348000526428,
-0.468657523393631,
-0.31514883041381836,
0.2890801429748535,
-0.3313765823841095,
-0.2415652871131897,
-0.07780197262763977,
0.7236565351486206,
0.5824083089828491,
0.24867701530456543,
-0.022728851065039635,
-0.40665045380592346,
-0.2634775638580322,
-0.3387214243412018,
-0.7123180031776428,
-0.19081811606884003,
0.14082787930965424,
-0.04244798794388771,
0.09447658061981201,
-0.17945173382759094,
-0.5154305696487427,
-0.723106324672699,
-0.34261664748191833,
0.38386404514312744,
-0.18022488057613373,
-0.29805687069892883,
0.2413409948348999,
-0.03887752816081047,
0.19986627995967865,
0.5932807922363281,
-0.9706246852874756,
0.4754059910774231,
0.665042519569397,
0.7756327986717224,
-0.17219489812850952,
0.02355443313717842,
-0.34219634532928467,
0.4098970592021942,
-0.29999393224716187,
0.4928290545940399,
-0.3843744397163391,
-0.21927450597286224,
0.21096226572990417,
-0.1749924123287201,
0.13223320245742798,
-0.30682846903800964,
0.5480560064315796,
-0.5643624067306519,
0.14725413918495178,
0.07931474596261978,
-0.43372538685798645,
-0.1709764301776886,
-0.01339735183864832,
-0.41145262122154236,
1.2773768901824951,
0.1597880870103836,
-0.09763595461845398,
0.4175102412700653,
-0.4430133104324341,
-0.508814811706543,
-0.0015176761662587523,
0.15572446584701538,
-0.576030969619751,
0.011943189427256584,
0.1390964686870575,
0.15354526042938232,
-0.3520415425300598,
-0.05154719203710556,
0.1196974515914917,
0.02537255547940731,
0.3916229009628296,
-0.14903554320335388,
0.11636625230312347,
0.20652088522911072,
-0.3918362855911255,
0.12667334079742432,
-0.5183320045471191,
-0.10007376223802567,
-0.11204677075147629,
-0.03561631962656975,
-0.346707284450531,
-0.12000256776809692,
0.3798576295375824,
0.4914819896221161,
0.46447956562042236,
-0.33334410190582275,
0.081709124147892,
-0.4865349233150482,
0.09150514006614685,
0.4536062180995941,
-0.027451107278466225,
0.46741846203804016,
0.3258005380630493,
0.35315611958503723,
0.03598729521036148,
0.527934730052948,
0.08021388202905655,
-0.9657444357872009,
-0.8992854952812195,
0.014599372632801533,
0.005042691715061665,
0.6497845649719238,
-0.6982255578041077,
0.030112631618976593,
-0.1777653843164444,
-0.1705361157655716,
-0.514266848564148,
0.5270707011222839,
0.6763114929199219,
0.48508334159851074,
0.7408847808837891,
-0.45341283082962036,
-0.45529454946517944,
-0.7739712595939636,
0.02065885439515114,
-0.177090123295784,
-0.030061542987823486,
0.04907803237438202,
0.3261706829071045,
-0.2364678829908371,
0.5117800831794739,
-0.4478510022163391,
-0.5906941294670105,
0.05999520793557167,
0.06470376253128052,
0.14226427674293518,
0.15533609688282013,
0.2996988296508789,
-1.2078816890716553,
-0.6791400909423828,
0.0766381099820137,
-0.49868446588516235,
-0.34235596656799316,
-0.12662017345428467,
-0.06684646010398865,
0.2984883785247803,
0.8302028775215149,
-0.15075358748435974,
0.42672568559646606,
0.9703022241592407,
-0.6587736010551453,
0.16948071122169495,
-0.16334247589111328,
0.25865769386291504,
-0.9492802023887634,
-0.29715657234191895,
-0.08792831003665924,
-0.4431903064250946,
-0.8365193009376526,
-0.2385440468788147,
-0.05029124766588211,
0.14971238374710083,
-0.5627356171607971,
0.6730855107307434,
-0.5774478316307068,
-0.28086617588996887,
-0.6127299666404724,
0.5683236122131348,
-0.14938321709632874,
0.021877191960811615,
0.20144374668598175,
0.8789217472076416,
0.6538358330726624,
-0.8390577435493469,
0.3916308879852295,
0.568856418132782,
-0.13440309464931488,
0.3022197484970093,
-0.30700182914733887,
-0.006944552529603243,
0.004412555601447821,
0.09083956480026245,
-1.215145230293274,
-0.35760581493377686,
0.6994818449020386,
-0.38303688168525696,
0.5906148552894592,
0.00007123858813429251,
-0.48766401410102844,
-0.25389012694358826,
0.09215178340673447,
0.30340367555618286,
0.7838979959487915,
-0.35082072019577026,
0.36238303780555725,
0.5066649913787842,
-0.28257936239242554,
-0.2846294343471527,
-0.9239498972892761,
0.5864228010177612,
-0.07668262720108032,
-0.648905873298645,
0.5399879217147827,
0.038507238030433655,
-0.28322833776474,
-0.2700689136981964,
-0.19154804944992065,
-0.0716123953461647,
0.059421688318252563,
0.29325640201568604,
-0.07562354952096939,
0.045826081186532974,
0.1398521214723587,
0.08049602806568146,
-0.3410508632659912,
0.0216100811958313,
-0.35234472155570984,
0.22679638862609863,
0.09207481145858765,
-0.16599492728710175,
-0.34806016087532043,
0.20552250742912292,
0.31719905138015747,
0.07690421491861343,
0.7349107265472412,
0.6917547583580017,
-0.23182830214500427,
-0.04247039183974266,
-0.3085522949695587,
-0.2686714231967926,
-0.49367308616638184,
0.4039931893348694,
-0.4131782352924347,
-0.7648559212684631,
0.4402930736541748,
-0.35152262449264526,
0.017520897090435028,
0.3395363688468933,
0.43298858404159546,
-0.15956230461597443,
0.9436149597167969,
0.6345551609992981,
0.4670225977897644,
0.6412384510040283,
0.07224991917610168,
0.21483522653579712,
-0.8310360312461853,
-0.5211696624755859,
-0.1683088093996048,
-0.17573700845241547,
-0.369032084941864,
-0.7486702799797058,
0.4392879605293274,
0.21393276751041412,
-0.03409528359770775,
0.4757063090801239,
-0.3568890392780304,
0.093663290143013,
0.2797251343727112,
-0.04235057532787323,
0.4590746760368347,
0.13171444833278656,
0.21129333972930908,
-0.26910051703453064,
-0.1617783159017563,
-0.5367695093154907,
0.8900151252746582,
0.5029004216194153,
0.48132482171058655,
0.6145279407501221,
0.32793673872947693,
0.3960300087928772,
0.3965851366519928,
-0.7422141432762146,
0.6818609833717346,
-0.39139899611473083,
-0.5870788097381592,
-0.5326332449913025,
-0.1508985012769699,
-0.6323835253715515,
0.1821870505809784,
-0.3329946994781494,
-0.6106707453727722,
-0.21316154301166534,
0.33820298314094543,
0.3577142059803009,
0.041065700352191925,
-0.5456798076629639,
0.7448948621749878,
-0.5281668305397034,
-0.29561540484428406,
0.05902256816625595,
-0.9265461564064026,
0.2960589528083801,
-0.19369809329509735,
0.5925893187522888,
-0.3197639286518097,
-0.6086500287055969,
0.7159236669540405,
-0.5702950954437256,
0.8678101897239685,
-0.1284438669681549,
-0.6546534299850464,
0.15805229544639587,
-0.10672643035650253,
0.5639680027961731,
-0.09410300105810165,
0.09042007476091385,
0.08276772499084473,
-0.3068723976612091,
-0.3494681715965271,
-0.6305485963821411,
0.36512187123298645,
-0.6333303451538086,
-0.5037640929222107,
-0.39024123549461365,
-0.46987470984458923,
-0.4307066798210144,
0.22973966598510742,
0.20390890538692474,
0.08780506998300552,
-0.08563181012868881,
-0.6095442771911621,
0.6083744168281555,
0.05980764329433441,
0.3790751099586487,
0.6262733936309814,
-0.5678595304489136,
-0.6360178589820862,
0.8328752517700195,
-0.12369938939809799,
0.5357027649879456,
0.4420730471611023,
-0.10420136153697968,
-0.5824680328369141,
-0.8742425441741943,
-0.42189085483551025,
0.4825705885887146,
-0.860845148563385,
-0.06336550414562225,
-0.2596459686756134,
0.011875110678374767,
-0.8825446367263794,
-0.08279649913311005,
-0.4332112669944763,
-0.7654913663864136,
-0.07891418039798737,
-0.1742924153804779,
0.7088809609413147,
0.7052430510520935,
-0.1290588527917862,
0.8938083648681641,
-0.48096123337745667,
0.5083916783332825,
0.10803195089101791,
0.33321961760520935,
-0.5879607200622559,
-0.8541634678840637,
-0.391268253326416,
0.016052795574069023,
-0.11717554926872253,
-0.8366966247558594,
0.28440061211586,
0.5859191417694092,
0.30644410848617554,
0.388373464345932,
-0.08395016193389893,
0.572435200214386,
-0.32226890325546265,
0.865279495716095,
0.4525831937789917,
-0.9052633047103882,
0.5670527815818787,
-0.27279606461524963,
0.4052501916885376,
0.4556352198123932,
0.2543773055076599,
-0.8489254713058472,
-0.4910632073879242,
-0.3394327759742737,
-1.318604588508606,
0.5833610892295837,
0.44153621792793274,
-0.05679519101977348,
0.22527047991752625,
0.48810893297195435,
-0.15222838521003723,
0.12758849561214447,
-0.6044356226921082,
-0.6256552338600159,
-0.26055777072906494,
-0.19448430836200714,
-0.5036084651947021,
-0.2774619162082672,
-0.15680871903896332,
-0.05915253236889839,
0.9807896614074707,
-0.03198869153857231,
-0.0538153238594532,
0.10759037733078003,
-0.19348160922527313,
-0.06687072664499283,
0.1768082082271576,
0.8884789943695068,
0.12791426479816437,
-0.14040280878543854,
0.30766773223876953,
0.18569189310073853,
-0.7837631702423096,
0.13008898496627808,
0.07948898524045944,
-0.5012588500976562,
0.06637226045131683,
0.2916371524333954,
1.0110552310943604,
0.30986183881759644,
-0.46045103669166565,
0.41375452280044556,
0.21188519895076752,
-0.1693529188632965,
-0.6279529929161072,
-0.14439484477043152,
-0.05207660049200058,
-0.015002535656094551,
0.28133609890937805,
-0.08931713551282883,
0.3665129840373993,
-0.40974223613739014,
0.276832640171051,
0.11607146263122559,
-0.6309998631477356,
-0.25960683822631836,
0.9990302324295044,
0.3460639715194702,
-0.2527157664299011,
0.3989674150943756,
0.08024632930755615,
-0.5014144778251648,
0.4438912272453308,
0.6544555425643921,
0.7920199632644653,
-0.45197921991348267,
0.25903555750846863,
0.32509198784828186,
0.34456077218055725,
-0.15546025335788727,
0.24164609611034393,
-0.05081562697887421,
-0.45534002780914307,
-0.49918439984321594,
-0.6463615298271179,
-0.6589034199714661,
-0.16155876219272614,
-0.4251401126384735,
0.3057069778442383,
-0.1537484973669052,
-0.46451523900032043,
-0.2975423038005829,
-0.2813461124897003,
-0.2970253527164459,
0.7170724272727966,
0.8230270743370056,
0.9460875988006592,
-1.1807366609573364,
0.7198506593704224,
0.7704126834869385,
-0.32046979665756226,
-0.35584577918052673,
-0.18338248133659363,
0.2320290207862854,
-0.7665761709213257,
0.5955076217651367,
-0.0730641558766365,
-0.4505152404308319,
0.3235397934913635,
-0.3886699080467224,
-1.1382217407226562,
0.8272221088409424,
0.05177777633070946,
-0.3612392544746399,
0.04468346759676933,
0.6348980665206909,
0.5445372462272644,
-0.27185168862342834,
0.2521163523197174,
0.728801965713501,
0.9825177788734436,
0.600414514541626,
-1.0358765125274658,
0.09050339460372925,
-0.21435952186584473,
0.1252998411655426,
0.3700418472290039,
-0.5016483664512634,
0.2576291263103485,
-0.21983125805854797,
-0.33832141757011414,
0.13131198287010193,
1.047145128250122,
-0.17809882760047913,
0.6450814008712769,
0.18057291209697723,
0.3976616859436035,
0.6207772493362427,
-0.4558277428150177,
0.9630311727523804,
-0.1386496126651764,
0.08428549021482468,
1.1168456077575684,
0.0032996409572660923,
0.7486850619316101,
0.7644413113594055,
-0.13420839607715607,
0.34219855070114136,
0.7153651714324951,
0.11456995457410812,
0.6304963827133179,
0.18455146253108978,
-0.4680531620979309,
-0.5093680620193481,
-0.34584346413612366,
-0.31352296471595764,
0.23646260797977448,
0.8308904767036438,
-0.26260167360305786,
-0.16481420397758484,
0.2819303870201111,
0.26697131991386414,
0.4807727336883545,
-0.4192478656768799,
0.8316864371299744,
0.4523741602897644,
-0.5572287440299988,
0.549219012260437,
0.1095818504691124,
0.6153439283370972,
-0.7952190637588501,
0.013317720964550972,
-0.0977875292301178,
0.11043854057788849,
-0.43867936730384827,
-0.9324584603309631,
0.268250048160553,
-0.3395170271396637,
0.19346937537193298,
-0.557251513004303,
0.2952052056789398,
-0.6840415596961975,
-0.32082661986351013,
0.470783531665802,
0.10409752279520035,
0.6480434536933899,
0.1620635688304901,
-0.6634390354156494,
0.24459686875343323,
-0.1063481941819191,
-0.3261139690876007,
0.10959240049123764,
0.21919649839401245,
-0.22455474734306335,
0.6786471605300903,
0.4312005043029785,
0.10860822349786758,
0.27777624130249023,
0.37983283400535583,
0.5520690083503723,
-0.5280784368515015,
-0.1741495430469513,
-0.5367695093154907,
0.6165754199028015,
-0.16354520618915558,
-0.4899630844593048,
1.0395623445510864,
0.7895869016647339,
0.5760993361473083,
-0.09498732537031174,
0.7558586597442627,
-0.04087124392390251,
0.20983903110027313,
-0.8843512535095215,
0.3000315725803375,
-0.5223108530044556,
0.11698266118764877,
-0.36825671792030334,
-0.8791218400001526,
-0.75001060962677,
0.20333518087863922,
-0.38756030797958374,
-0.017189662903547287,
0.6759347319602966,
0.7618948221206665,
0.1570785641670227,
-0.3211326003074646,
0.5126343369483948,
0.2678772509098053,
0.38587358593940735,
0.5400702357292175,
0.34485042095184326,
-1.0897603034973145,
0.6351826190948486,
-0.03821326792240143,
-0.28779277205467224,
-0.36447474360466003,
-0.8233623504638672,
-0.5858023166656494,
-0.9203171133995056,
-0.8151211738586426,
-0.5145499110221863,
0.11611165851354599,
0.29309770464897156,
0.6330522298812866,
-0.8030624985694885,
-0.22636492550373077,
-0.12862342596054077,
-0.05799983814358711,
-0.2648082673549652,
-0.14898906648159027,
0.35997575521469116,
-0.1388453096151352,
-0.9169043302536011,
0.6144738793373108,
0.2440485954284668,
0.6841390132904053,
-0.03047795593738556,
-0.4589609205722809,
-0.025914425030350685,
0.13705606758594513,
0.5629832744598389,
0.4727133810520172,
-0.750299334526062,
-0.22102031111717224,
-0.1898050606250763,
-0.3422172963619232,
-0.09234646707773209,
0.5265587568283081,
-0.43010708689689636,
0.41204023361206055,
0.36208575963974,
0.047624167054891586,
1.0312570333480835,
0.21210730075836182,
0.5440683364868164,
-0.7829339504241943,
0.2682052254676819,
-0.08263092488050461,
0.03947657719254494,
0.7064974904060364,
-0.21147051453590393,
0.6723734736442566,
0.1265539675951004,
-0.3491077721118927,
-0.5282784104347229,
0.5497505068778992,
-1.3014661073684692,
-0.13128121197223663,
1.3344082832336426,
0.2574860453605652,
-0.1735297441482544,
-0.2960391938686371,
-0.11826364696025848,
0.38619181513786316,
-0.2677728831768036,
0.44678112864494324,
0.5436432957649231,
-0.25788185000419617,
-0.5202861428260803,
-0.6677020192146301,
0.9515997767448425,
0.31690627336502075,
-0.5976952910423279,
0.014835773035883904,
0.4732562005519867,
0.09215015172958374,
0.15097855031490326,
0.7730851769447327,
-0.13485826551914215,
0.22351540625095367,
-0.01806521601974964,
0.2576395869255066,
-0.23239050805568695,
-0.28273969888687134,
-0.15408723056316376,
-0.25141218304634094,
0.3733571767807007,
0.030476469546556473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01393v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01393v1 | POLygraph: Polish Fake News Dataset | 2024-07-01T15:45:21 | 2024-07-01T15:45:21 | Daniel Dzienisiewicz, Filip Graliński, Piotr Jabłoński, Marek Kubis, Paweł Skórzewski, Piotr Wierzchoń | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents the POLygraph dataset, a unique resource for fake news
detection in Polish. The dataset, created by an interdisciplinary team, is
composed of two parts: the "fake-or-not" dataset with 11,360 pairs of news
articles (identified by their URLs) and corresponding labels, and the
"fake-they-say" dataset with 5,082 news articles (identified by their URLs) and
tweets commenting on them. Unlike existing datasets, POLygraph encompasses a
variety of approaches from source literature, providing a comprehensive
resource for fake news detection. The data was collected through manual
annotation by expert and non-expert annotators. The project also developed a
software tool that uses advanced machine learning techniques to analyze the
data and determine content authenticity. The tool and dataset are expected to
benefit various entities, from public sector institutions to publishers and
fact-checking organizations. Further dataset exploration will foster fake news
detection and potentially stimulate the implementation of similar models in
other languages. The paper focuses on the creation and composition of the
dataset, so it does not include a detailed evaluation of the software tool for
content authenticity analysis, which is planned at a later stage of the
project. | [
-0.2598390579223633,
-0.9843027591705322,
0.7033450603485107,
0.3081495761871338,
-0.4788781404495239,
0.45421940088272095,
0.03240549564361572,
-0.5240340828895569,
0.5774463415145874,
0.6341708898544312,
-0.48080140352249146,
-0.7373672723770142,
-0.6027026176452637,
0.13821659982204437,
-0.7084664106369019,
0.9524182081222534,
-0.040220290422439575,
0.29202961921691895,
-0.17181040346622467,
0.028079818934202194,
-0.01950296200811863,
-0.40793952345848083,
-0.012263108976185322,
-0.1516040861606598,
0.19569511711597443,
0.3218490183353424,
0.5901656150817871,
0.41222885251045227,
0.2723104655742645,
0.1635926216840744,
0.26931554079055786,
0.5397013425827026,
-0.548302173614502,
-0.4092997908592224,
-0.27527207136154175,
-0.14018145203590393,
-0.2898176908493042,
0.19245333969593048,
0.5863606333732605,
0.40620678663253784,
0.102834053337574,
0.5602179765701294,
-0.36720922589302063,
0.7649377584457397,
-0.47016698122024536,
0.35445961356163025,
-0.5187029242515564,
0.1171906590461731,
-0.8087639808654785,
0.18307094275951385,
-0.5940494537353516,
-0.5453878045082092,
-0.44837555289268494,
-0.7608248591423035,
0.23040233552455902,
0.18995364010334015,
0.9603691697120667,
-0.2694684565067291,
-0.39309456944465637,
-0.2763358950614929,
-0.7614757418632507,
0.5440570712089539,
-0.43267643451690674,
0.16049131751060486,
0.25713998079299927,
0.364660382270813,
-0.20137855410575867,
-0.7450525760650635,
-0.8936281800270081,
0.22485777735710144,
0.05401851236820221,
0.21386457979679108,
-0.16545075178146362,
-0.555320680141449,
0.1073487401008606,
0.5300337672233582,
-0.7480778098106384,
-0.20054936408996582,
-0.6278907060623169,
-0.6067076921463013,
0.7798299193382263,
0.11610431224107742,
0.625766932964325,
-0.23354555666446686,
-0.30193620920181274,
0.026239950209856033,
-0.597343921661377,
-0.20931164920330048,
1.0318816900253296,
0.35437533259391785,
-0.21118348836898804,
0.5788774490356445,
-0.5615986585617065,
0.8285898566246033,
-0.31247350573539734,
-0.2903611361980438,
0.9276171326637268,
-0.5015851855278015,
0.0001785197964636609,
0.25013187527656555,
1.033707618713379,
0.21500436961650848,
0.4522080719470978,
-0.0012160069309175014,
-0.13169479370117188,
0.29574039578437805,
0.24559146165847778,
-0.1256486475467682,
-0.3237011730670929,
0.13312815129756927,
-0.6897897124290466,
-0.7839120626449585,
0.8833397030830383,
-0.5684075355529785,
-0.38659361004829407,
-0.2676926255226135,
0.3819989860057831,
-0.30393093824386597,
-0.5563007593154907,
0.3718162477016449,
-0.31689193844795227,
-0.1658380776643753,
0.2411140650510788,
-0.1324862390756607,
0.4042752981185913,
0.5578057765960693,
0.6286939978599548,
-0.07833277434110641,
-0.17139817774295807,
-0.3019402325153351,
-0.04757677763700485,
-0.6097533702850342,
0.8863067626953125,
-0.36637258529663086,
0.1320803016424179,
-0.05158231034874916,
0.27776944637298584,
0.2851718068122864,
-0.29831817746162415,
0.733344554901123,
-0.5658712387084961,
0.5439522862434387,
-0.31686046719551086,
-0.5904093384742737,
-0.35396283864974976,
0.14510837197303772,
-1.0758470296859741,
1.2571799755096436,
0.2964504361152649,
-0.9836515784263611,
0.42447710037231445,
-0.3943862020969391,
-0.530624508857727,
0.2965540289878845,
0.07754583656787872,
-0.5030399560928345,
0.10462751984596252,
0.21412520110607147,
-0.1094413697719574,
0.051073864102363586,
0.17607425153255463,
-0.2628055214881897,
-0.2847476303577423,
0.17590422928333282,
-0.2412302941083908,
1.276082992553711,
-0.03196195513010025,
-0.19185124337673187,
-0.2325081080198288,
-0.8638401627540588,
-0.109334796667099,
0.4220622777938843,
-0.07231946289539337,
-0.2694300413131714,
-0.0006148716784082353,
0.2837204933166504,
0.5355519652366638,
0.46988192200660706,
-1.2016475200653076,
0.15436741709709167,
-0.10405302047729492,
-0.15397591888904572,
0.29926639795303345,
0.13247160613536835,
-0.12222861498594284,
-0.40334415435791016,
0.383179634809494,
0.09537045657634735,
0.5491555333137512,
-0.013619652949273586,
-0.6646263599395752,
-0.45188140869140625,
0.029754074290394783,
0.5451583862304688,
0.728320837020874,
-0.8857387900352478,
0.4017232358455658,
-0.2832726538181305,
-0.628622829914093,
-0.5167100429534912,
0.023730799555778503,
0.27584490180015564,
0.6661216616630554,
0.22811034321784973,
-0.02418353594839573,
-0.7501827478408813,
-1.036916971206665,
-0.3896764814853668,
-0.16792894899845123,
0.18895287811756134,
0.04396199807524681,
0.5865824818611145,
0.5477096438407898,
0.9190219640731812,
-0.17648914456367493,
-0.485861599445343,
-0.24239715933799744,
0.1786457747220993,
0.5980451107025146,
0.08257737755775452,
0.6955764889717102,
-1.1991132497787476,
-0.9555391073226929,
-0.4239404499530792,
-1.020721673965454,
-0.15992215275764465,
-0.028524553403258324,
0.17391151189804077,
0.4209241271018982,
0.24666817486286163,
-0.3278815448284149,
0.4262404441833496,
0.812878429889679,
-0.5356125235557556,
0.9229459166526794,
-0.0018612344283610582,
0.2909276783466339,
-0.7794021368026733,
-0.07196325063705444,
-0.1456087976694107,
-0.6220112442970276,
-0.6023550629615784,
-0.12491870671510696,
0.043819114565849304,
-0.13599681854248047,
-0.8216939568519592,
0.4021743834018707,
-0.26992300152778625,
-0.24716581404209137,
-0.1059722900390625,
0.01396619901061058,
0.18755695223808289,
-0.03939118608832359,
-0.01587146334350109,
0.69229656457901,
0.7016800045967102,
0.07633781433105469,
0.90641188621521,
0.30121326446533203,
-0.7692107558250427,
0.2539340555667877,
-0.4651139974594116,
0.21761196851730347,
-0.1436896175146103,
0.40372902154922485,
-0.7698521614074707,
-0.34098199009895325,
0.6768862009048462,
-0.7148330807685852,
-0.4483684301376343,
-0.17455023527145386,
-1.230912685394287,
-0.605833113193512,
-0.2848227918148041,
-0.05592663213610649,
0.4091564118862152,
-0.37673529982566833,
0.3740614652633667,
0.5494053363800049,
0.05976198613643646,
-0.4413210153579712,
-0.6054803729057312,
0.3149908185005188,
0.2437189221382141,
-0.7704579830169678,
0.240544393658638,
0.1469581574201584,
-0.30868062376976013,
0.5684983730316162,
0.12880028784275055,
-0.23647606372833252,
-0.24923276901245117,
0.1996188908815384,
0.3104190528392792,
-0.22679665684700012,
0.03771352395415306,
-0.17422790825366974,
0.04374237358570099,
-0.09014124423265457,
-0.23396354913711548,
0.6233673691749573,
-0.1816605031490326,
-0.34872326254844666,
-0.6971114873886108,
0.2650093734264374,
0.7861191034317017,
-0.12113039195537567,
1.0842176675796509,
0.7806979417800903,
-0.30981966853141785,
-0.20156078040599823,
-0.39573943614959717,
0.21046729385852814,
-0.35287582874298096,
-0.10784710943698883,
-0.11090245097875595,
-0.1266978681087494,
0.5576146841049194,
0.18592871725559235,
-0.33188825845718384,
0.556738555431366,
0.6957312822341919,
-0.03554379940032959,
0.8844063878059387,
0.39236757159233093,
-0.35060152411460876,
0.2770971655845642,
-0.11705353111028671,
0.21205750107765198,
-0.1034269854426384,
-0.5191251635551453,
-0.12160065025091171,
-0.15971185266971588,
-0.3879014253616333,
-0.3119780123233795,
0.28352072834968567,
-0.3379124402999878,
0.1641126573085785,
0.19750924408435822,
-0.4145483076572418,
0.7219417691230774,
0.6134275794029236,
0.4338819086551666,
0.6262329816818237,
0.32548823952674866,
0.1342950016260147,
0.030039697885513306,
-0.5841366052627563,
-0.5943244695663452,
1.1210908889770508,
0.04927917569875717,
0.3307892084121704,
0.057152677327394485,
0.37656351923942566,
0.8309182524681091,
-0.010241542011499405,
-0.5122725367546082,
0.4638803005218506,
-0.46946197748184204,
-0.8473039269447327,
-0.3699723184108734,
-0.303032249212265,
-0.45231643319129944,
-0.06600624322891235,
-0.4412732720375061,
-0.27815142273902893,
0.12560848891735077,
0.04730002582073212,
0.07515400648117065,
0.673743724822998,
-0.411277174949646,
0.6439374089241028,
-0.12237238883972168,
-0.05823620781302452,
-0.2615763247013092,
-0.40200385451316833,
0.290920227766037,
-0.3553647994995117,
0.5805202126502991,
-0.4418674111366272,
0.006372304167598486,
0.3699823319911957,
-0.3176104724407196,
0.7386548519134521,
-0.27773886919021606,
0.2812005281448364,
0.3271947503089905,
0.1707531213760376,
0.48263391852378845,
-0.03634776175022125,
-0.2699440121650696,
0.4052234888076782,
-0.31978023052215576,
-0.6487767100334167,
-0.10153641551733017,
0.31411001086235046,
-0.49323806166648865,
-0.05375371873378754,
-0.5263790488243103,
-0.5921290516853333,
0.0036468880716711283,
0.6303518414497375,
0.4600676894187927,
0.6073541641235352,
-0.3251575529575348,
0.19913546741008759,
0.541183352470398,
-0.16534295678138733,
0.19908642768859863,
0.771598219871521,
-0.2622293531894684,
-0.28092315793037415,
1.0245205163955688,
0.28066906332969666,
-0.09658355265855789,
-0.08115092664957047,
0.06210947409272194,
-0.10868943482637405,
-0.38431939482688904,
-0.5058653950691223,
0.40325823426246643,
-0.3173693120479584,
-0.07563421875238419,
-0.2524583637714386,
-0.3395516276359558,
-0.42724594473838806,
0.26152533292770386,
-0.6436569094657898,
-0.5565820336341858,
-0.04045756906270981,
-0.03589845076203346,
0.23231366276741028,
0.881740927696228,
-0.17685763537883759,
0.020495068281888962,
-0.5149734616279602,
0.7286627888679504,
-0.07239614427089691,
0.44511231780052185,
-0.5968122482299805,
-0.17408037185668945,
-0.23543992638587952,
0.20701681077480316,
0.001659627421759069,
-1.0192997455596924,
0.39884597063064575,
0.007433746010065079,
0.5033778548240662,
0.2124439924955368,
0.5056176781654358,
-0.1532212495803833,
-0.36505964398384094,
0.8885829448699951,
-0.130466490983963,
-0.9120102524757385,
0.6604506969451904,
-0.791552722454071,
-0.13178905844688416,
0.4823329448699951,
0.651245653629303,
-0.2979971170425415,
-0.6344214677810669,
-0.9184300899505615,
-0.5393357276916504,
0.6128889918327332,
0.3423365652561188,
0.305935800075531,
0.00309775467030704,
0.062414251267910004,
0.20206138491630554,
0.31277644634246826,
-0.9391278028488159,
-0.30014699697494507,
-0.29690298438072205,
-0.3800863027572632,
0.4520086944103241,
-0.41984209418296814,
-0.28931373357772827,
-0.17117317020893097,
0.9210558533668518,
0.0854053869843483,
-0.02216484025120735,
0.2013658881187439,
-0.3605383336544037,
-0.060634154826402664,
-0.3175926208496094,
0.5878320336341858,
1.2900923490524292,
-0.16466939449310303,
-0.026116006076335907,
-0.24295225739479065,
-0.5293455719947815,
-0.049668021500110626,
-0.3558238744735718,
-0.4023726284503937,
0.63286954164505,
0.47792309522628784,
0.5925535559654236,
-0.29926353693008423,
-0.6114705204963684,
1.0450499057769775,
0.03319615498185158,
-0.38171228766441345,
-1.0575134754180908,
-0.24997982382774353,
-0.17535652220249176,
-0.09619370847940445,
0.5425935387611389,
-0.28963983058929443,
0.16933053731918335,
-0.5360156893730164,
0.4890395402908325,
-0.029392732307314873,
-0.44292017817497253,
-0.3824309706687927,
0.28886735439300537,
0.08437598496675491,
-0.30837225914001465,
0.9090282917022705,
-0.27086254954338074,
-0.6848800778388977,
0.6331267356872559,
0.5576555728912354,
0.08390653878450394,
-0.020515678450465202,
0.8362219929695129,
0.2115333378314972,
0.5579280853271484,
-0.2538122832775116,
0.41554024815559387,
0.4289749264717102,
-1.1116092205047607,
-0.4584420919418335,
-0.3228644132614136,
-0.22329135239124298,
0.4084243178367615,
-0.6835834383964539,
0.4745177626609802,
-0.3751389682292938,
0.0003136873710900545,
0.02718903310596943,
0.10770270228385925,
-0.11597990989685059,
0.06848883628845215,
0.4537986218929291,
1.2206053733825684,
-1.6794568300247192,
0.9190082550048828,
0.6471129655838013,
-0.3536324203014374,
-0.37412187457084656,
-0.1472988724708557,
0.4419640600681305,
-0.7854538559913635,
0.5175530910491943,
-0.1588064432144165,
0.054893966764211655,
-0.2444697469472885,
-0.6367071866989136,
-0.6083022952079773,
0.5491562485694885,
0.5434743165969849,
-0.4095683991909027,
0.11203451454639435,
0.4875335693359375,
0.4144635498523712,
-0.31157851219177246,
-0.4685709476470947,
0.25576117634773254,
0.7178258299827576,
-0.32218554615974426,
-0.7308077812194824,
-0.15987636148929596,
-0.3359849750995636,
-0.46148744225502014,
0.24356162548065186,
-0.8330115675926208,
0.9058751463890076,
0.38300320506095886,
-0.056638091802597046,
-0.20219218730926514,
0.3502030074596405,
0.05924108251929283,
0.4225383698940277,
0.585022509098053,
0.6366081237792969,
0.6071053147315979,
-0.16193580627441406,
1.1326957941055298,
-0.40113359689712524,
0.6631820797920227,
1.0498138666152954,
0.06964550912380219,
0.32144230604171753,
0.21237389743328094,
0.0449080616235733,
1.0257258415222168,
0.5507925152778625,
-0.7012754082679749,
0.4355790615081787,
-0.2268751710653305,
-0.22701425850391388,
-0.46014052629470825,
-0.3426937162876129,
-0.09013046324253082,
0.5651495456695557,
0.33716562390327454,
-0.47638025879859924,
-0.398654043674469,
0.18406035006046295,
0.12403887510299683,
0.2693774402141571,
-0.26703038811683655,
0.5280566811561584,
-0.3283109962940216,
0.11865279823541641,
-0.1024707555770874,
-0.13047903776168823,
0.04766184464097023,
-0.41142991185188293,
-0.07904188334941864,
-0.043738462030887604,
-0.19830197095870972,
-0.39646008610725403,
-1.145277738571167,
0.44792306423187256,
-0.05362690985202789,
-0.5048500299453735,
-0.3501754701137543,
0.9581418037414551,
-0.29767996072769165,
-0.8461740016937256,
0.18401716649532318,
0.5710878372192383,
0.3368089199066162,
-0.26280272006988525,
-0.8147015571594238,
0.20288687944412231,
-0.1264706403017044,
-0.13319242000579834,
-0.026998260989785194,
0.3872241675853729,
-0.1789938062429428,
0.4247129261493683,
0.8023398518562317,
0.7314375638961792,
-0.029846394434571266,
0.07737043499946594,
0.558232843875885,
-0.18710002303123474,
-0.7116124629974365,
-0.6151387095451355,
0.3457609713077545,
-0.6980431079864502,
-0.11007580161094666,
1.0278352499008179,
1.039472222328186,
0.8995095491409302,
-0.15241949260234833,
0.8194634318351746,
-0.30811458826065063,
0.876380980014801,
-0.4188061058521271,
0.8255868554115295,
-0.26896435022354126,
-0.08701035380363464,
-0.09824328124523163,
-0.7879437208175659,
-0.29452353715896606,
0.22335873544216156,
-0.1757684350013733,
-0.44215622544288635,
0.46113651990890503,
0.6113713979721069,
-0.38360705971717834,
-0.12207240611314774,
0.27814963459968567,
0.26912614703178406,
-0.09271330386400223,
0.11876793950796127,
0.7257712483406067,
-0.5346054434776306,
0.455022394657135,
-0.5075088739395142,
-0.014287549071013927,
-0.27438801527023315,
-0.8425266742706299,
-0.5996090173721313,
-0.5662895441055298,
-0.3540172576904297,
-0.561917245388031,
0.15892662107944489,
0.4405973255634308,
0.9131306409835815,
-0.9025064706802368,
0.046997908502817154,
0.04748544469475746,
0.3448486924171448,
-0.04212740436196327,
-0.3301810920238495,
0.38179507851600647,
-0.03450952470302582,
-0.5308536291122437,
0.29436352849006653,
0.13824039697647095,
-0.041740335524082184,
-0.18617726862430573,
0.4305359423160553,
-0.12912258505821228,
0.11188849061727524,
0.3965153992176056,
0.2793477773666382,
-0.42128729820251465,
-0.4034830331802368,
-0.19243136048316956,
0.021683407947421074,
0.13479730486869812,
0.788535475730896,
-0.8840484023094177,
0.5606398582458496,
0.6569675803184509,
-0.0444645993411541,
0.6529121994972229,
0.2008632868528366,
0.4558178782463074,
-1.0424803495407104,
0.6461316347122192,
0.10295085608959198,
0.2056073248386383,
0.2719275951385498,
-0.5416091084480286,
0.4846937358379364,
0.7212117910385132,
-0.0777500793337822,
-0.986169695854187,
0.09981627017259598,
-0.9020946025848389,
-0.43429821729660034,
0.8242064714431763,
-0.03476067632436752,
-0.49797946214675903,
-0.6315801739692688,
0.14436966180801392,
0.13057368993759155,
-0.27227330207824707,
0.8713209629058838,
1.0160555839538574,
-0.23765765130519867,
0.09197163581848145,
-0.6983655095100403,
0.38803231716156006,
-0.25939202308654785,
-0.8885543942451477,
-0.09084555506706238,
0.4857112169265747,
0.6784271001815796,
0.2817833423614502,
0.5611945390701294,
-0.6647588014602661,
0.482837051153183,
0.16751666367053986,
0.09358448535203934,
-0.5431689620018005,
-0.6647297143936157,
0.04482310637831688,
0.26660972833633423,
-0.6010370254516602,
-0.14547109603881836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01384v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01384v1 | Free-text Rationale Generation under Readability Level Control | 2024-07-01T15:34:17 | 2024-07-01T15:34:17 | Yi-Sheng Hsu, Nils Feldhus, Sherzod Hakimov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Free-text rationales justify model decisions in natural language and thus
become likable and accessible among approaches to explanation across many
tasks. However, their effectiveness can be hindered by misinterpretation and
hallucination. As a perturbation test, we investigate how large language models
(LLMs) perform the task of natural language explanation (NLE) under the effects
of readability level control, i.e., being prompted for a rationale targeting a
specific expertise level, such as sixth grade or college. We find that
explanations are adaptable to such instruction, but the requested readability
is often misaligned with the measured text complexity according to traditional
readability metrics. Furthermore, the quality assessment shows that LLMs'
ratings of rationales across text complexity exhibit a similar pattern of
preference as observed in natural language generation (NLG). Finally, our human
evaluation suggests a generally satisfactory impression on rationales at all
readability levels, with high-school-level readability being most commonly
perceived and favored. | [
-0.2897709310054779,
-0.8443558812141418,
0.7955361008644104,
0.36551433801651,
-0.3170766234397888,
-0.3778846263885498,
-0.194454625248909,
-0.32037562131881714,
-0.1937488615512848,
0.42411744594573975,
-0.5778788328170776,
-0.41942712664604187,
-0.43317559361457825,
0.41779229044914246,
-0.4461488127708435,
0.9164835214614868,
-0.263824462890625,
-0.25524476170539856,
-0.4626319110393524,
0.1652299463748932,
-0.46128150820732117,
-0.49682193994522095,
-0.519929051399231,
-0.5437710881233215,
0.9187211394309998,
0.34512218832969666,
0.9738847613334656,
0.8320508599281311,
0.2435801923274994,
0.2427462637424469,
-0.22501936554908752,
-0.05097394436597824,
-0.4701247215270996,
0.2643190026283264,
-0.38348421454429626,
-0.5721706748008728,
-0.44387033581733704,
0.16568344831466675,
0.49037429690361023,
0.7589945197105408,
0.14138063788414001,
-0.26345404982566833,
0.0672011598944664,
0.7399996519088745,
-0.5823714733123779,
-0.12807230651378632,
-0.6613893508911133,
-0.1471986323595047,
0.18871378898620605,
-0.29095083475112915,
-0.8150449395179749,
-0.26451992988586426,
0.4347119629383087,
-0.7887535095214844,
0.27012407779693604,
0.17164158821105957,
0.8575975298881531,
0.3553536832332611,
-0.5135674476623535,
-0.5552592277526855,
-0.7442445755004883,
0.9054007530212402,
-0.850219190120697,
0.39210793375968933,
0.4887898862361908,
0.0782076045870781,
-0.2895556092262268,
-0.3221060037612915,
-0.7981192469596863,
-0.4935038685798645,
-0.16900072991847992,
-0.047014784067869186,
-0.26080435514450073,
0.20081137120723724,
0.4985859990119934,
0.3893028497695923,
-0.5422664284706116,
0.13248948752880096,
-0.06975797563791275,
-0.08228572458028793,
0.5486997961997986,
0.03259870782494545,
0.41332870721817017,
-0.4207518696784973,
-0.3117615878582001,
-0.012836266309022903,
-0.44996190071105957,
0.2032751739025116,
0.44739946722984314,
0.23785988986492157,
0.08524727076292038,
0.7853253483772278,
-0.2804190218448639,
0.5130249857902527,
0.11118913441896439,
-0.05670538172125816,
-0.1485862284898758,
-0.37900570034980774,
-0.4276621639728546,
-0.054527755826711655,
0.5800146460533142,
0.44852033257484436,
0.44876426458358765,
-0.21988345682621002,
-0.45508137345314026,
0.09420748054981232,
0.34554505348205566,
-0.8572779893875122,
0.061707206070423126,
0.3869000971317291,
-0.43951547145843506,
-0.38747379183769226,
-0.1295212358236313,
-0.6907615661621094,
-0.5206034779548645,
-0.7134063839912415,
0.45694851875305176,
-0.5150750875473022,
-0.05920372158288956,
0.39851146936416626,
-0.01689237728714943,
0.20596151053905487,
0.49663418531417847,
-1.1385575532913208,
0.011566673405468464,
0.5186272859573364,
0.6398739218711853,
-0.26123759150505066,
-0.1518828272819519,
-0.29159337282180786,
0.1404854953289032,
-0.36414822936058044,
0.8468716740608215,
-0.6008356213569641,
-0.22188150882720947,
-0.13237811625003815,
-0.14897875487804413,
-0.34163567423820496,
-0.4020824432373047,
0.5728645920753479,
-0.4075547754764557,
0.44656693935394287,
-0.15039925277233124,
-0.651448667049408,
-0.30421191453933716,
0.12417799234390259,
-0.5733782649040222,
0.5951557159423828,
-0.02176407352089882,
-0.8455518484115601,
0.6390177011489868,
-0.6015830039978027,
-0.2522728145122528,
-0.14417679607868195,
0.07931996136903763,
-0.033247917890548706,
0.279552161693573,
0.31614062190055847,
0.36164143681526184,
-0.21638311445713043,
0.19719336926937103,
-0.17007920145988464,
-0.1739751696586609,
0.48562800884246826,
-0.7603549957275391,
0.6791685819625854,
0.07664624601602554,
-0.48061931133270264,
0.6013607382774353,
-0.8731181621551514,
0.0406607910990715,
0.014519954100251198,
-0.4641247093677521,
-0.46971091628074646,
0.24518416821956635,
-0.2928076386451721,
0.15092915296554565,
0.14597827196121216,
-0.2763334810733795,
0.0878216102719307,
-0.5314199924468994,
0.3398419916629791,
0.6232572793960571,
0.1808663159608841,
0.6827333569526672,
-0.4466301202774048,
0.5770017504692078,
0.007603247184306383,
0.06868289411067963,
-0.08243728429079056,
-0.281529039144516,
-0.8090923428535461,
-0.15678392350673676,
-0.03670930117368698,
0.6238052845001221,
-0.4719817042350769,
0.3086540997028351,
0.17480900883674622,
-0.3947850465774536,
-0.31085294485092163,
0.12189479917287827,
0.29611074924468994,
0.552794873714447,
0.4201463758945465,
0.3327266275882721,
-0.22255706787109375,
-0.8834359645843506,
-0.5463237762451172,
-0.08248215913772583,
-0.3130839467048645,
0.09533680975437164,
0.4842837452888489,
-0.39142554998397827,
0.7912554740905762,
-0.14735370874404907,
0.2094116508960724,
-0.391914039850235,
0.11018161475658417,
0.20869064331054688,
0.39049121737480164,
0.3049963116645813,
-0.5487896203994751,
-0.09683310240507126,
-0.1914493441581726,
-0.5361555218696594,
-0.3617384135723114,
-0.358175128698349,
-0.3011052906513214,
0.4601547122001648,
0.45037004351615906,
-0.4588548243045807,
0.6018332839012146,
0.29100143909454346,
-0.5816131234169006,
0.6318005323410034,
-0.36854276061058044,
0.013904999941587448,
-0.7762952446937561,
-0.05790451541543007,
0.13233056664466858,
0.0013971136650070548,
-0.7137414813041687,
0.05277244374155998,
0.021550819277763367,
0.14276878535747528,
-0.034640390425920486,
0.48392853140830994,
-0.2833956182003021,
0.1353788524866104,
-0.19841153919696808,
0.4182555675506592,
0.14878711104393005,
0.16516147553920746,
-0.12324614822864532,
0.669679582118988,
0.2187810242176056,
-0.6542132496833801,
-0.03448706120252609,
0.00865991786122322,
-0.2661980986595154,
0.3119879364967346,
-0.8012180924415588,
-0.04759008437395096,
-0.4358076751232147,
0.22883504629135132,
-1.0381830930709839,
-0.5801165699958801,
-0.0010649410542100668,
-0.3244926929473877,
-0.17898929119110107,
0.2678166627883911,
-0.23021486401557922,
-0.12366131693124771,
-0.17021691799163818,
0.19995683431625366,
0.17055465281009674,
-0.5728734731674194,
0.6061868071556091,
-0.17249314486980438,
-0.0011117805261164904,
-0.507709264755249,
-0.5180065631866455,
-0.2639719247817993,
-0.15966497361660004,
-0.7084951400756836,
-0.08668427169322968,
-0.4091060757637024,
-0.5789975523948669,
-0.36044421792030334,
-0.30721384286880493,
-0.15196172893047333,
0.18387900292873383,
0.23758798837661743,
0.41375312209129333,
-0.30857667326927185,
0.10520049184560776,
0.39261671900749207,
0.02463994361460209,
0.24726082384586334,
-0.07708542793989182,
0.4887985289096832,
0.026139896363019943,
-0.06342673301696777,
-0.6186494827270508,
0.27379482984542847,
0.69181889295578,
-0.03330453857779503,
0.698318362236023,
0.07302065938711166,
-0.49011048674583435,
-0.4349760413169861,
-0.3214915990829468,
-0.26195257902145386,
-0.45505839586257935,
0.07961155474185944,
-0.4493609368801117,
-0.9062680602073669,
0.44270727038383484,
0.3926035165786743,
0.35596880316734314,
0.6641308069229126,
0.5498669743537903,
0.08479136228561401,
1.3123477697372437,
0.3165232837200165,
0.5480207800865173,
0.35419532656669617,
0.16697445511817932,
0.3802794814109802,
-0.3440225422382355,
-0.2581695318222046,
-0.7442272901535034,
-0.2310556322336197,
-0.5640014410018921,
-0.23003605008125305,
-0.2540114223957062,
0.7263533473014832,
-0.2490261197090149,
-0.009609963744878769,
-0.5357472896575928,
0.8885214924812317,
0.24236582219600677,
-0.22347627580165863,
0.5514365434646606,
0.06441027671098709,
-0.35882675647735596,
-0.2119189202785492,
-0.4886721968650818,
-0.9074967503547668,
0.7135133743286133,
0.5105856657028198,
0.5532540678977966,
0.1175115555524826,
0.6377766728401184,
-0.08702470362186432,
0.4993123412132263,
-1.0358712673187256,
0.5335525870323181,
-0.276389479637146,
-0.6824052929878235,
-0.55753493309021,
-0.5082259178161621,
-0.872605562210083,
0.35798928141593933,
-0.3974792957305908,
-0.774138867855072,
0.2540868818759918,
0.2811935544013977,
-0.20131172239780426,
0.18958058953285217,
-0.8351240158081055,
0.797444760799408,
-0.027182389050722122,
-0.2561438977718353,
-0.28134897351264954,
-0.3747958242893219,
0.4396958649158478,
-0.11480145901441574,
0.3474634289741516,
-0.11982332915067673,
-0.11100860685110092,
0.526271641254425,
-0.2969408929347992,
0.6328412294387817,
-0.04436183720827103,
-0.4776354432106018,
0.135055810213089,
0.4260506331920624,
0.2532878816127777,
0.27959489822387695,
-0.2756367325782776,
-0.23054377734661102,
-0.060954779386520386,
-0.4806348383426666,
-0.7502469420433044,
0.6667227149009705,
-0.7966920137405396,
-0.7983615398406982,
-0.2461479753255844,
-0.9161205887794495,
-0.2543088495731354,
0.47951698303222656,
0.275287389755249,
0.4417019784450531,
0.09926838427782059,
0.31828755140304565,
0.8454465270042419,
-0.3557421565055847,
0.25667038559913635,
0.3383994996547699,
-0.4993378221988678,
-0.3938611149787903,
0.7795239686965942,
0.1117740049958229,
0.5194768905639648,
0.3171992301940918,
0.5544998645782471,
-0.428943932056427,
-0.6857521533966064,
-0.38036808371543884,
0.20960967242717743,
-0.5908935070037842,
0.3122005760669708,
-0.4643014073371887,
-0.15127681195735931,
-0.2850097119808197,
-0.530521810054779,
0.2429133504629135,
-0.5160529613494873,
-0.6147701740264893,
-0.2909972071647644,
0.09773001074790955,
1.0805466175079346,
0.12444581836462021,
0.38851726055145264,
-0.5102315545082092,
0.2839812636375427,
0.2955086827278137,
0.43290194869041443,
0.11050086468458176,
-0.641822874546051,
0.12637080252170563,
-0.030926240608096123,
-0.30401611328125,
-0.9345318675041199,
0.17520172894001007,
-0.23872089385986328,
0.35460034012794495,
0.5685052871704102,
0.09138846397399902,
0.23401565849781036,
-0.2251463085412979,
0.7217533588409424,
0.1917911171913147,
-1.1459784507751465,
0.3678341209888458,
-0.6162033677101135,
0.4733530879020691,
0.4450264275074005,
0.49281564354896545,
-0.38772720098495483,
-0.6588848829269409,
-0.48308441042900085,
-0.8368874192237854,
0.4832649528980255,
0.12707500159740448,
0.16735944151878357,
-0.09576624631881714,
0.7157495617866516,
0.22318218648433685,
0.0010160972597077489,
-0.8524318933486938,
0.1268986463546753,
-0.4318641126155853,
-0.13851098716259003,
-0.030230697244405746,
-0.48237743973731995,
0.04624852538108826,
-0.04723985120654106,
0.48888760805130005,
-0.02116556465625763,
-0.054944127798080444,
0.47003570199012756,
-0.04763675108551979,
-0.36731016635894775,
0.7577205896377563,
1.0054007768630981,
0.9468874931335449,
-0.23814775049686432,
0.2034417688846588,
-0.029507145285606384,
-0.32319873571395874,
0.13113872706890106,
-0.10447598993778229,
-0.5131060481071472,
-0.09688341617584229,
0.5361283421516418,
0.9335570335388184,
-0.04747416824102402,
-0.5289683938026428,
0.31778213381767273,
-0.09566493332386017,
-0.7984678745269775,
0.0786919891834259,
0.3855822682380676,
0.09927568584680557,
0.17012174427509308,
0.2792198359966278,
-0.1020524650812149,
-0.1765495240688324,
-0.25376805663108826,
0.03710611164569855,
0.254387229681015,
-0.2742549777030945,
-0.18438605964183807,
0.8547090888023376,
0.09792923182249069,
-0.35892587900161743,
0.4474445581436157,
-0.06360567361116409,
-0.24658767879009247,
0.5274680256843567,
0.7922251224517822,
0.7021938562393188,
-0.059519339352846146,
0.2107168585062027,
0.53534996509552,
0.5919077396392822,
-0.11685964465141296,
0.3489514887332916,
0.22975286841392517,
-0.7693108916282654,
-0.7506714463233948,
-0.637351930141449,
-0.46775442361831665,
0.35131537914276123,
-0.45260000228881836,
0.000646477856207639,
-0.777474582195282,
0.008855477906763554,
0.2570587694644928,
-0.1735878884792328,
-0.1844545155763626,
0.5193700194358826,
-0.17371556162834167,
1.0601650476455688,
-0.564441978931427,
0.5104584693908691,
0.41078343987464905,
-0.54292893409729,
-1.0873562097549438,
0.2719845175743103,
-0.11415186524391174,
-0.3892476260662079,
0.5275502800941467,
0.34963351488113403,
-0.11468061059713364,
-0.03721276670694351,
-0.6120232343673706,
-0.6322962045669556,
0.8144477009773254,
0.32601791620254517,
-0.7446644902229309,
-0.38137680292129517,
0.03282664716243744,
0.6868689656257629,
-0.24381105601787567,
0.13779562711715698,
0.7265808582305908,
0.7644284963607788,
0.05237190052866936,
-0.6340809464454651,
0.16834349930286407,
0.017521630972623825,
-0.08883168548345566,
0.2941168546676636,
-0.17040811479091644,
0.6775392293930054,
-0.39375510811805725,
-0.1361967921257019,
0.007854076102375984,
0.767539381980896,
0.18105073273181915,
0.39353397488594055,
0.8648054599761963,
0.43162795901298523,
0.879322350025177,
-0.05003151297569275,
1.1822060346603394,
-0.008679970167577267,
0.00873681902885437,
0.7825315594673157,
0.0030412545893341303,
0.9049763083457947,
0.5816881060600281,
0.11764496564865112,
0.6093459129333496,
0.444170206785202,
0.32418715953826904,
0.011217419058084488,
0.4517131745815277,
-0.26293814182281494,
-0.43412911891937256,
-0.05238329991698265,
0.03184768930077553,
0.19729843735694885,
0.24833840131759644,
-0.420695424079895,
-0.10641668736934662,
-0.09203758090734482,
0.09013362973928452,
0.29947134852409363,
-0.48517608642578125,
0.6638501286506653,
-0.014581115916371346,
-0.8130689263343811,
0.8284782767295837,
-0.007573546841740608,
0.4469168186187744,
-0.46239572763442993,
0.21933577954769135,
-0.27152907848358154,
0.09804749488830566,
-0.4309995472431183,
-0.7647109627723694,
0.3834565579891205,
0.21029941737651825,
-0.7277693748474121,
-0.27892711758613586,
0.7127670049667358,
-0.40079376101493835,
-0.16512203216552734,
0.31127405166625977,
0.45796525478363037,
0.10031920671463013,
0.09840593487024307,
-0.3551238179206848,
-0.1936444789171219,
0.2927825450897217,
-0.6049051284790039,
0.29399293661117554,
0.6581127643585205,
-0.23709125816822052,
0.5914214253425598,
0.8361155390739441,
-0.032500606030225754,
0.1865621954202652,
0.26991531252861023,
0.5730117559432983,
-0.5980583429336548,
-0.2059774547815323,
-0.765104353427887,
0.4941447377204895,
0.05775163695216179,
-0.5067475438117981,
0.6245917081832886,
0.34733155369758606,
0.7505371570587158,
0.0294417142868042,
0.7378795742988586,
0.30189764499664307,
0.5104442238807678,
-0.5893017649650574,
0.6569401621818542,
-0.6885449290275574,
0.18689650297164917,
-0.19695758819580078,
-1.000519871711731,
-0.5779951810836792,
0.68159419298172,
-0.6298689842224121,
-0.09188701957464218,
0.9634326100349426,
0.611987292766571,
0.18930929899215698,
0.388144314289093,
0.353773832321167,
0.30806708335876465,
0.3108743131160736,
0.26812830567359924,
0.8288506269454956,
0.1853991448879242,
0.529891312122345,
-0.06893112510442734,
-0.4083745777606964,
-0.004087099805474281,
-1.0197585821151733,
-1.1005314588546753,
-0.20824699103832245,
0.0027189820539206266,
-0.6525938510894775,
-0.22280701994895935,
0.9449434876441956,
0.035722095519304276,
-0.774042010307312,
-0.19099439680576324,
-0.44104158878326416,
0.3249562084674835,
0.10905739665031433,
-0.29069337248802185,
0.093068927526474,
-0.537969708442688,
-0.6961619257926941,
0.3974665105342865,
0.15399044752120972,
0.1975441873073578,
-0.25571104884147644,
0.016183478757739067,
-0.038435954600572586,
0.6666732430458069,
0.6686787009239197,
0.05779159441590309,
-0.8274115324020386,
-0.40965723991394043,
0.24977777898311615,
-0.397804856300354,
-0.10798782110214233,
1.1400026082992554,
-0.3313649296760559,
0.3295060694217682,
0.8788244128227234,
0.579398512840271,
-0.13255071640014648,
0.10998016595840454,
0.5633742809295654,
-0.2718798816204071,
-0.06349062919616699,
0.15779612958431244,
0.1581176072359085,
0.03884901478886604,
-0.2825435698032379,
0.18505293130874634,
0.17033936083316803,
-0.8359200358390808,
-0.7528136372566223,
0.19028693437576294,
-0.9993112087249756,
-0.4454087018966675,
1.2728967666625977,
0.03124309331178665,
-0.16426798701286316,
-0.12197650223970413,
-0.42552030086517334,
0.24036529660224915,
-0.5201038122177124,
0.8072524070739746,
1.0326344966888428,
-0.08530952036380768,
-0.15586301684379578,
-0.5628306865692139,
0.5689390301704407,
0.6431547403335571,
-1.0051127672195435,
0.5054634213447571,
0.761268675327301,
0.13664136826992035,
0.034545205533504486,
0.34524327516555786,
0.004718491807579994,
0.18338125944137573,
-0.29186639189720154,
-0.18199113011360168,
0.13624107837677002,
-0.39384254813194275,
-0.32524749636650085,
0.09841997921466827,
0.31177282333374023,
0.5275875926017761
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01376v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01376v1 | Badllama 3: removing safety finetuning from Llama 3 in minutes | 2024-07-01T15:29:45 | 2024-07-01T15:29:45 | Dmitrii Volkov | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR | We show that extensive LLM safety fine-tuning is easily subverted when an
attacker has access to model weights. We evaluate three state-of-the-art
fine-tuning methods-QLoRA, ReFT, and Ortho-and show how algorithmic advances
enable constant jailbreaking performance with cuts in FLOPs and optimisation
power. We strip safety fine-tuning from Llama 3 8B in one minute and Llama 3
70B in 30 minutes on a single GPU, and sketch ways to reduce this further. | [
-0.5028182864189148,
-1.0662553310394287,
0.49771735072135925,
0.276467502117157,
-0.9217205047607422,
0.07172402739524841,
0.2090248167514801,
-0.9518253207206726,
-0.12568746507167816,
0.7544649839401245,
-0.3905523717403412,
-0.33084455132484436,
-0.5200106501579285,
-0.2159958928823471,
-0.3869019150733948,
1.1272845268249512,
-0.2593449354171753,
-0.12807266414165497,
0.5630336403846741,
0.0037436834536492825,
-0.770389974117279,
-0.3729986250400543,
-0.8801003098487854,
-0.43904706835746765,
0.35517454147338867,
0.8036073446273804,
0.953571617603302,
0.878922164440155,
0.7303182482719421,
0.18699994683265686,
-0.3101443648338318,
0.12279363721609116,
-0.8335267901420593,
-0.17749254405498505,
-0.10326457023620605,
-0.6310662627220154,
-0.645710289478302,
0.006865017116069794,
0.09286501258611679,
-0.1445479393005371,
-0.22127076983451843,
0.3271242082118988,
-0.2547527849674225,
0.8544281125068665,
-1.1213315725326538,
-0.018179552629590034,
-0.7558830976486206,
0.02401350438594818,
-0.6562454700469971,
-0.28782767057418823,
-0.2137458175420761,
-0.7782271504402161,
-0.47775691747665405,
-0.7724912166595459,
0.14207011461257935,
0.18623819947242737,
0.9436895251274109,
0.6968418955802917,
-0.006021017674356699,
-0.09828998148441315,
-0.6815594434738159,
0.6656681299209595,
-0.5605292916297913,
-0.2680227756500244,
0.7996833324432373,
0.2791009843349457,
-0.20236997306346893,
-0.3586817681789398,
-0.4504942297935486,
0.1257535070180893,
0.23933397233486176,
-0.18706770241260529,
-0.412638396024704,
0.3139803409576416,
0.44833552837371826,
0.35472869873046875,
-0.15727856755256653,
0.6583107113838196,
-1.0329139232635498,
-0.16630005836486816,
0.8495747447013855,
0.27418333292007446,
0.19751055538654327,
-0.039142269641160965,
-0.2853410840034485,
0.09631539136171341,
-1.5329478979110718,
-0.12394534051418304,
0.6198251843452454,
-0.010288787074387074,
-0.17087505757808685,
0.4557565450668335,
0.025821905583143234,
0.7064329981803894,
0.018207920715212822,
-0.41829314827919006,
0.07264971733093262,
-0.07998144626617432,
-0.466074675321579,
0.145594522356987,
0.5696887969970703,
0.8679154515266418,
0.29341673851013184,
-0.14385519921779633,
-0.04973380267620087,
0.1620229333639145,
0.4463837146759033,
-0.9207943677902222,
-0.3614274263381958,
0.2608494758605957,
-0.4197837710380554,
-0.6088301539421082,
-0.15109917521476746,
-0.7148940563201904,
-0.5639994740486145,
0.03459182009100914,
0.5011084675788879,
-0.4181630611419678,
0.08354675024747849,
0.4458915591239929,
-0.006545346695929766,
0.4672016501426697,
0.28871065378189087,
-0.9328573346138,
0.3858308792114258,
0.9031248092651367,
0.8137551546096802,
-0.008187510073184967,
-0.15019157528877258,
-0.6742538809776306,
0.2699262499809265,
-0.5285122990608215,
0.4680604636669159,
-0.0034164281096309423,
-0.5813724398612976,
-0.43326568603515625,
-0.21571485698223114,
0.2987573742866516,
-0.831648051738739,
0.38847559690475464,
-0.7569257020950317,
-0.5368442535400391,
-0.21264712512493134,
-0.14989298582077026,
-0.6145870685577393,
0.009725035168230534,
-0.7705014944076538,
0.5333893895149231,
-0.12063788622617722,
-0.4004720151424408,
0.45644712448120117,
-0.6334017515182495,
-0.741323709487915,
-0.1782328486442566,
0.4499495029449463,
-0.7963755130767822,
0.2304750382900238,
0.38328179717063904,
0.5453131794929504,
-0.35649558901786804,
-0.015085411258041859,
-0.5099591016769409,
-1.0259590148925781,
-0.062413290143013,
-0.1308700144290924,
0.7589672803878784,
0.7455695271492004,
-0.4127998948097229,
-0.1792082041501999,
-0.7522247433662415,
-0.1995367854833603,
0.051925938576459885,
-0.18906612694263458,
-0.18949207663536072,
0.10086560249328613,
-0.009578284807503223,
0.13552196323871613,
0.21390371024608612,
-0.6463759541511536,
0.18265850841999054,
-0.6514377593994141,
0.8411564230918884,
0.9798992276191711,
0.14263072609901428,
0.08835675567388535,
-0.3922930955886841,
0.22044548392295837,
-0.06386902928352356,
0.5931990742683411,
0.4411579370498657,
-0.3590736389160156,
-0.8202273845672607,
-0.20313142240047455,
-0.11751893907785416,
0.48239025473594666,
-0.47504696249961853,
-0.08763179183006287,
0.3564547896385193,
-0.7145109176635742,
-0.5739799737930298,
0.7225679159164429,
0.7531490325927734,
0.18829186260700226,
0.7330033779144287,
-0.21353459358215332,
-0.49207422137260437,
-1.0973796844482422,
-0.2956385910511017,
-0.22303608059883118,
0.21484363079071045,
-0.11949163675308228,
0.3625492453575134,
-0.05963078513741493,
0.2578926980495453,
-0.5087786316871643,
-0.321279376745224,
-0.16054847836494446,
-0.09501700848340988,
0.16930405795574188,
0.9122670292854309,
0.6820734739303589,
-0.38782012462615967,
0.10026000440120697,
-0.12679558992385864,
-0.7737416625022888,
0.052168913185596466,
0.06237855926156044,
0.21099625527858734,
0.1395094394683838,
0.829820454120636,
-0.5484542846679688,
0.6426342129707336,
0.19942137598991394,
-0.15989387035369873,
0.43910282850265503,
-0.26843738555908203,
0.12220951169729233,
-0.6289497017860413,
-0.1917109340429306,
-0.04366033524274826,
-0.1729738712310791,
-0.5910739898681641,
0.8180147409439087,
0.2601436674594879,
-0.0831570252776146,
-1.0188840627670288,
0.36394381523132324,
-0.2263321876525879,
0.06054428964853287,
-0.34227901697158813,
0.06160600483417511,
-0.2118036299943924,
0.344221830368042,
-0.5054860711097717,
0.9318106174468994,
0.2796406149864197,
-0.6968293190002441,
0.062229640781879425,
-0.016193201765418053,
-0.43751901388168335,
0.137235626578331,
-0.8351017832756042,
0.30939963459968567,
0.10485641658306122,
0.04723875969648361,
-0.7183969616889954,
-0.3827666640281677,
0.37128716707229614,
0.24188219010829926,
0.08567862212657928,
-0.2033492624759674,
-0.6339149475097656,
-0.36776840686798096,
-0.563808262348175,
0.7084400653839111,
0.4878504276275635,
-0.7393783926963806,
0.06749951839447021,
0.5152016282081604,
0.2696067988872528,
-0.47523170709609985,
-0.6794378161430359,
0.027918849140405655,
-0.7046995759010315,
-0.38097307085990906,
0.5168371200561523,
0.06956552714109421,
-0.5638226270675659,
-0.5482231378555298,
-0.25557616353034973,
-0.12151861190795898,
0.8092467784881592,
0.6429157257080078,
0.2437845915555954,
0.20782606303691864,
-0.22258198261260986,
0.15355034172534943,
-0.3117826581001282,
0.01643277332186699,
0.43465539813041687,
0.43190905451774597,
-0.5227652788162231,
-0.3142662048339844,
-0.9371522068977356,
-0.10080205649137497,
0.6176477670669556,
0.0258060023188591,
0.31493043899536133,
0.3260246515274048,
-0.4871307611465454,
0.24920475482940674,
-0.7070059776306152,
0.16484782099723816,
-0.5440137982368469,
-0.07768182456493378,
-0.3945101499557495,
-0.8424898386001587,
0.6205893754959106,
0.12152380496263504,
0.2167956531047821,
0.4558439254760742,
0.4582999050617218,
-0.1368187963962555,
0.7755781412124634,
0.760353684425354,
-0.3488949239253998,
0.4180220663547516,
-0.24721987545490265,
0.20223578810691833,
-0.4843280017375946,
-0.21264530718326569,
-0.5110820531845093,
-0.5187846422195435,
-0.5650575757026672,
-0.21642662584781647,
0.17957350611686707,
0.6839550733566284,
-0.5264132618904114,
0.5506997108459473,
-0.3359377980232239,
1.1172810792922974,
0.26447975635528564,
0.6168777942657471,
0.18788284063339233,
-0.518711507320404,
0.4084070026874542,
0.2537996172904968,
-0.29962587356567383,
-0.4311371147632599,
1.2787364721298218,
0.44586610794067383,
1.0904561281204224,
0.22917774319648743,
0.8461325168609619,
0.14106738567352295,
0.3899821639060974,
-0.45726361870765686,
0.5457091331481934,
-0.0403701588511467,
-0.6830008029937744,
0.06026970222592354,
0.017112769186496735,
-0.5143508911132812,
-0.03402746096253395,
-0.034086182713508606,
-0.8790459632873535,
-0.031764447689056396,
0.3293422758579254,
-0.9923081398010254,
0.6273510456085205,
-0.9772632718086243,
0.458813339471817,
-0.03330045938491821,
-0.5562788248062134,
-0.7942190766334534,
-0.5449342727661133,
0.841431736946106,
-0.235049769282341,
0.1598166972398758,
-0.5156553983688354,
0.1762896478176117,
0.885408878326416,
-0.7076134085655212,
0.7442466616630554,
-0.35382673144340515,
-0.28504326939582825,
0.35497742891311646,
0.39743074774742126,
0.4539523124694824,
0.43729791045188904,
0.02383137308061123,
0.30279070138931274,
0.06607766449451447,
-0.5450941920280457,
-0.2754342555999756,
0.7388257384300232,
-0.9281455874443054,
-0.7922983169555664,
-0.2104198932647705,
-0.3265739381313324,
-0.11110066622495651,
-0.16155563294887543,
0.2661619782447815,
0.08536209166049957,
0.03360367566347122,
-0.018407126888632774,
0.5084389448165894,
-0.08798021823167801,
0.8580611944198608,
0.3507213592529297,
-0.07165995240211487,
-0.1934596747159958,
0.9174290895462036,
0.08059704303741455,
0.02063596062362194,
0.003251682734116912,
0.011018376797437668,
0.045921023935079575,
-1.0567632913589478,
-0.2077745646238327,
0.07589627057313919,
-0.3855290710926056,
-0.5583351850509644,
0.08999578654766083,
-0.1323646754026413,
0.23572136461734772,
-0.5289908647537231,
-0.6090574860572815,
-0.6804017424583435,
-0.6158748269081116,
-0.3293028175830841,
0.5025092363357544,
1.0541391372680664,
-0.43579423427581787,
0.9602705240249634,
-0.46267056465148926,
0.6246395111083984,
0.31538188457489014,
0.550345242023468,
-0.1323470175266266,
-0.3421905040740967,
-0.22045159339904785,
-0.23227347433567047,
-0.7711019515991211,
-0.6364456415176392,
0.09813276678323746,
-0.1396080106496811,
0.20160134136676788,
0.8424108028411865,
-0.21699567139148712,
1.0798941850662231,
-0.1680009812116623,
0.7608777284622192,
0.397408127784729,
-0.9550561308860779,
0.7967395782470703,
-0.2827960252761841,
0.02778448909521103,
0.7358493208885193,
0.1289786696434021,
0.1932205706834793,
-0.2882927656173706,
-0.4654015004634857,
-0.7345281839370728,
0.5527135133743286,
0.2198449969291687,
-0.20254550874233246,
-0.02339726686477661,
0.6681525707244873,
0.24891290068626404,
-0.18389561772346497,
-0.6147043704986572,
-0.29403769969940186,
-0.20176251232624054,
0.41180840134620667,
-0.42616134881973267,
-0.41165393590927124,
-0.36640506982803345,
-0.4471399486064911,
0.6861412525177002,
0.18342293798923492,
-0.08527987450361252,
-0.15903784334659576,
-0.4562942087650299,
-0.18779803812503815,
0.36166703701019287,
1.0014365911483765,
0.8905990123748779,
-0.6415376663208008,
-0.03914487734436989,
0.5327909588813782,
-0.6916763782501221,
0.5111390948295593,
-0.047722674906253815,
0.05259941145777702,
-0.6819621324539185,
-0.025708582252264023,
0.4982154369354248,
0.32668569684028625,
-0.4498039186000824,
0.10685323178768158,
-0.14111891388893127,
-0.2409891039133072,
0.18032756447792053,
0.7289837598800659,
-0.3166760206222534,
0.271881639957428,
0.28171297907829285,
0.32021254301071167,
0.014534357003867626,
-0.3593516945838928,
0.043680641800165176,
0.1532360017299652,
-0.24678760766983032,
-0.22379013895988464,
0.9242348074913025,
0.09855260699987411,
-0.23363137245178223,
0.29452022910118103,
0.12069274485111237,
-0.0797356441617012,
0.7236456274986267,
0.5215157270431519,
0.7160730957984924,
-0.09596429020166397,
-0.17412781715393066,
0.32690271735191345,
0.7662476301193237,
-0.2482294887304306,
0.1943838745355606,
0.11844605952501297,
-0.43632808327674866,
-0.3241172730922699,
-0.4706042408943176,
-0.5222263932228088,
0.5221691131591797,
-0.8432387113571167,
0.19701184332370758,
-1.2092560529708862,
-0.08429144322872162,
-0.08169370889663696,
0.03266417980194092,
-0.5867947936058044,
0.1871834397315979,
0.09859967231750488,
1.0856153964996338,
-0.5301192402839661,
0.7380188703536987,
0.17059557139873505,
-0.20641756057739258,
-0.8035934567451477,
-0.3374483585357666,
0.24822483956813812,
-0.8580334782600403,
0.34322333335876465,
0.27309471368789673,
-0.17066529393196106,
-0.26000964641571045,
-0.823856770992279,
-0.7316375970840454,
1.0304994583129883,
0.6341221928596497,
-0.9951191544532776,
-0.008584477007389069,
-0.2968928813934326,
0.28138092160224915,
0.2692737579345703,
-0.1860959529876709,
1.3513271808624268,
0.43497133255004883,
-0.5158197283744812,
-0.8090055584907532,
0.02724453993141651,
-0.21218426525592804,
-0.1896708756685257,
0.3494642674922943,
-0.9070297479629517,
0.8224380016326904,
-0.5928144454956055,
-0.07658522576093674,
0.22718431055545807,
0.48640701174736023,
0.44464945793151855,
0.055145323276519775,
0.44767147302627563,
0.9430166482925415,
0.9165315628051758,
-0.20314744114875793,
0.8907214999198914,
-0.4024698734283447,
0.17343290150165558,
0.9772977828979492,
-0.09808505326509476,
0.7635522484779358,
0.8549174666404724,
-0.06276404857635498,
0.11750432848930359,
0.9425154328346252,
0.13647575676441193,
0.8502124547958374,
0.32542720437049866,
-0.14529207348823547,
-0.30328917503356934,
0.5576519966125488,
-0.518744707107544,
0.7017003893852234,
0.4035980999469757,
0.12791122496128082,
-0.49673789739608765,
0.10705845803022385,
0.5236803889274597,
-0.3820333182811737,
-0.7547059059143066,
0.6773464679718018,
0.12181723862886429,
-0.6430829763412476,
1.0002562999725342,
0.4156920611858368,
0.6268787384033203,
-0.32605186104774475,
0.0731685608625412,
-0.40172046422958374,
0.25765445828437805,
-0.2759258449077606,
-0.6759164333343506,
0.2803337275981903,
0.1656399369239807,
0.12466276437044144,
-0.08500678837299347,
0.6600416898727417,
0.47074487805366516,
-0.05821633338928223,
0.3029782474040985,
0.09537031501531601,
0.07195257395505905,
0.02297697216272354,
-0.4570133090019226,
0.2772502303123474,
-0.09556671231985092,
-0.22452892363071442,
0.42159348726272583,
-0.2635906934738159,
-0.09548159688711166,
1.0748624801635742,
0.653116762638092,
-0.05718272179365158,
-0.00466929143294692,
-0.23398275673389435,
1.156334638595581,
-0.8570238947868347,
-0.3712151348590851,
-1.308122158050537,
-0.036818645894527435,
0.30561116337776184,
-0.5750516057014465,
0.6016831994056702,
0.621671736240387,
0.9317057728767395,
0.13423247635364532,
0.49732112884521484,
0.056729841977357864,
-0.060480207204818726,
-0.9683632254600525,
1.0689115524291992,
-0.4330556392669678,
0.5421897172927856,
-0.46293994784355164,
-0.5468970537185669,
-0.47701072692871094,
0.5776189565658569,
-0.34051594138145447,
-0.5830440521240234,
0.3858379125595093,
0.9814891815185547,
-0.04794186353683472,
0.2784709930419922,
0.189604252576828,
0.21664494276046753,
0.4675985276699066,
0.8737275004386902,
0.7551741003990173,
-0.7032395601272583,
0.514022707939148,
-0.41943371295928955,
-0.056667640805244446,
-0.3801589608192444,
-0.8648231625556946,
-0.8483700156211853,
0.01695411093533039,
-0.10526899248361588,
-0.29903337359428406,
0.4996415972709656,
0.5836966633796692,
0.6035245060920715,
-0.8025932908058167,
-0.2049982249736786,
-0.05496680736541748,
0.47029435634613037,
-0.2222762405872345,
-0.06795261055231094,
0.20073942840099335,
-0.1284233033657074,
-0.15638084709644318,
0.7278974056243896,
0.4444568157196045,
0.0663139820098877,
-0.10196787118911743,
-0.08985022455453873,
-0.02484750561416149,
0.03422977775335312,
0.5277925729751587,
0.5701920390129089,
-0.7450265884399414,
-0.6248483061790466,
-0.8882429599761963,
-0.06788472086191177,
0.23558500409126282,
0.6220998764038086,
-0.5550949573516846,
0.20332005620002747,
0.026309611275792122,
0.26770684123039246,
0.826453685760498,
0.03814181685447693,
0.48517045378685,
-0.30218350887298584,
0.4982323944568634,
-0.034568846225738525,
0.3687354326248169,
-0.17105640470981598,
-0.2714194655418396,
0.6643125414848328,
-0.08958055824041367,
-0.5038900375366211,
-0.9616928100585938,
0.0542389452457428,
-0.8206523656845093,
-0.3882557451725006,
0.8244128823280334,
-0.021152332425117493,
-0.45444154739379883,
-0.2978658378124237,
-0.2529708743095398,
-0.030118167400360107,
-0.2089235484600067,
1.0374246835708618,
0.4572388529777527,
-0.16022992134094238,
0.06387928128242493,
-0.6777632832527161,
0.8307090997695923,
0.1351402997970581,
-0.9720958471298218,
-0.0070329150184988976,
0.3280896842479706,
0.4677230715751648,
-0.05018329992890358,
0.6487763524055481,
-0.3359276056289673,
0.8610977530479431,
-0.1884741187095642,
-0.2315572053194046,
-0.3175085186958313,
-0.6190500855445862,
-0.36659306287765503,
0.4971884489059448,
0.12079080194234848,
-0.08372040838003159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01374v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01374v1 | Bridging the Gap: Transfer Learning from English PLMs to Malaysian English | 2024-07-01T15:26:03 | 2024-07-01T15:26:03 | Mohan Raj Chanthran, Lay-Ki Soon, Huey Fang Ong, Bhawani Selvaretnam | cs.CL | cs.CL | Malaysian English is a low resource creole language, where it carries the
elements of Malay, Chinese, and Tamil languages, in addition to Standard
English. Named Entity Recognition (NER) models underperform when capturing
entities from Malaysian English text due to its distinctive morphosyntactic
adaptations, semantic features and code-switching (mixing English and Malay).
Considering these gaps, we introduce MENmBERT and MENBERT, a pre-trained
language model with contextual understanding, specifically tailored for
Malaysian English. We have fine-tuned MENmBERT and MENBERT using manually
annotated entities and relations from the Malaysian English News Article (MEN)
Dataset. This fine-tuning process allows the PLM to learn representations that
capture the nuances of Malaysian English relevant for NER and RE tasks.
MENmBERT achieved a 1.52\% and 26.27\% improvement on NER and RE tasks
respectively compared to the bert-base-multilingual-cased model. Although the
overall performance of NER does not have a significant improvement, our further
analysis shows that there is a significant improvement when evaluated by the 12
entity labels. These findings suggest that pre-training language models on
language-specific and geographically-focused corpora can be a promising
approach for improving NER performance in low-resource settings. The dataset
and code published in this paper provide valuable resources for NLP research
work focusing on Malaysian English. | [
-0.5578401684761047,
-0.1962967962026596,
0.29591453075408936,
0.4325767755508423,
-0.2321205586194992,
0.30638736486434937,
-0.2852459251880646,
-0.5361506938934326,
0.18361887335777283,
0.538756251335144,
-0.38967421650886536,
-0.31699955463409424,
-0.6934168934822083,
0.5315871238708496,
-0.10472570359706879,
0.5784188508987427,
-0.32942986488342285,
-0.11099420487880707,
-0.05176788568496704,
-0.3454219400882721,
-0.7105986475944519,
-0.6319867372512817,
-0.8648502826690674,
-0.2607269585132599,
0.2984755337238312,
0.41086074709892273,
0.4208621680736542,
0.279769629240036,
0.7146003246307373,
0.2009139209985733,
0.026867011561989784,
0.10472643375396729,
-0.0779549852013588,
-0.11417753994464874,
-0.519321084022522,
-0.3662559986114502,
-0.34732407331466675,
-0.06758437305688858,
0.46513938903808594,
0.9665993452072144,
-0.26418671011924744,
0.12194156646728516,
0.3498311936855316,
0.7181463837623596,
-0.5986747741699219,
0.303766131401062,
-0.5776042938232422,
0.053179752081632614,
-0.204318568110466,
-0.24285735189914703,
-0.47771868109703064,
0.023572225123643875,
0.5178669095039368,
-0.6471741795539856,
-0.00881775002926588,
-0.023589588701725006,
1.2308785915374756,
0.3464212119579315,
-0.6343217492103577,
-0.46446892619132996,
-0.6462592482566833,
0.9090890288352966,
-0.5708975791931152,
0.7227746844291687,
0.6059592962265015,
0.2727038264274597,
0.10940226167440414,
-0.6131997108459473,
-0.282828152179718,
-0.21465609967708588,
-0.2638985216617584,
0.159941166639328,
-0.09063763916492462,
-0.08879527449607849,
-0.011558893136680126,
0.24708755314350128,
-0.27714279294013977,
0.02537587843835354,
-0.4893818795681,
-0.21234726905822754,
0.621050238609314,
-0.02998335286974907,
0.21260471642017365,
-0.48025429248809814,
-0.2908523678779602,
0.09053786844015121,
-0.8423104286193848,
0.1805475354194641,
-0.03885563090443611,
0.36095425486564636,
-0.23553143441677094,
0.4443310797214508,
0.17992591857910156,
0.7222921848297119,
0.08581061661243439,
-0.35239940881729126,
0.11171138286590576,
-0.3545701503753662,
-0.2681521773338318,
0.16701942682266235,
0.4051363170146942,
0.0837407186627388,
0.2732136845588684,
-0.05500134825706482,
-0.3363620340824127,
-0.03162730112671852,
-0.06361237913370132,
-0.7725825309753418,
-0.4817495048046112,
-0.2090541571378708,
-0.5844162106513977,
0.20847682654857635,
0.24547146260738373,
-0.4442940950393677,
-0.05441631004214287,
-0.6292521357536316,
0.3037847578525543,
-0.44428321719169617,
-0.547776460647583,
0.3095027208328247,
0.28066346049308777,
0.32737186551094055,
0.25570106506347656,
-0.7593685388565063,
0.26413634419441223,
0.3610360324382782,
0.8133249878883362,
-0.1714506298303604,
-0.27852699160575867,
-0.24475730955600739,
0.3334119915962219,
-0.14470282196998596,
0.6519138216972351,
-0.6845609545707703,
-0.3729315996170044,
-0.05474267154932022,
0.3698635399341583,
-0.361088365316391,
-0.7957773804664612,
0.39832043647766113,
-0.4799891710281372,
0.6563005447387695,
-0.17424476146697998,
-0.6574203968048096,
-0.3270871937274933,
-0.05637458339333534,
-0.8208667039871216,
0.7157846093177795,
0.309823602437973,
-0.7911573052406311,
0.3285379111766815,
-0.8281433582305908,
-0.7698447704315186,
-0.07798460125923157,
-0.09686340391635895,
-0.3255652189254761,
0.052021875977516174,
0.3774896562099457,
0.6649748682975769,
-0.056487713009119034,
0.12481473386287689,
0.2361590415239334,
-0.1666785627603531,
-0.053367458283901215,
-0.23595979809761047,
0.7734400629997253,
0.28598523139953613,
-0.18332500755786896,
-0.18760930001735687,
-0.8076631426811218,
-0.3931264579296112,
0.08303437381982803,
-0.7804560661315918,
-0.6558598279953003,
-0.21136265993118286,
-0.0037045152857899666,
0.2676609456539154,
0.12500177323818207,
-0.1650030016899109,
0.006325732450932264,
-0.18508289754390717,
0.5757643580436707,
0.41172653436660767,
-0.0054938895627856255,
0.9324465990066528,
-0.1952480673789978,
0.7868124842643738,
0.2666221261024475,
-0.34856995940208435,
-0.3399454653263092,
-0.35885530710220337,
-0.868714451789856,
-0.14527229964733124,
0.7823576331138611,
0.6481379866600037,
-0.9684369564056396,
0.32024478912353516,
-0.10460727661848068,
-0.16222210228443146,
-0.9703707098960876,
0.0647667944431305,
0.01268733199685812,
0.5174648761749268,
0.6134540438652039,
-0.5141854882240295,
-0.9842079877853394,
-0.8586356043815613,
-0.03980346396565437,
-0.0747515931725502,
-0.1234738826751709,
0.4981461763381958,
0.28429344296455383,
-0.3719436526298523,
0.9138768315315247,
-0.10159633308649063,
-0.5790180563926697,
-0.5502228140830994,
0.15671835839748383,
0.20759542286396027,
0.4093998670578003,
0.4186493754386902,
-0.6868125796318054,
-0.7022239565849304,
-0.020517323166131973,
-0.49191248416900635,
-0.3949333429336548,
-0.2804570496082306,
-0.025207925587892532,
0.4483875632286072,
0.7899652123451233,
-0.5063638687133789,
0.1414521336555481,
0.7144894599914551,
-0.29948046803474426,
0.5404371619224548,
-0.03220566734671593,
0.1170419305562973,
-1.5203537940979004,
-0.03415268287062645,
-0.14714734256267548,
-0.36988669633865356,
-0.3419565260410309,
-0.1840985268354416,
0.0988830178976059,
-0.03201517462730408,
-0.5674639940261841,
0.6335474252700806,
-0.9245197176933289,
-0.020538505166769028,
-0.29024311900138855,
0.0869799554347992,
0.043463096022605896,
0.12432863563299179,
0.37102964520454407,
0.8912419080734253,
0.36280515789985657,
-0.833534836769104,
-0.09415411204099655,
0.2470448613166809,
-0.40771013498306274,
0.7641295194625854,
-0.2972656190395355,
0.010522335767745972,
-0.18850217759609222,
0.0549176000058651,
-0.5301365852355957,
-0.04271199554204941,
0.12300463765859604,
-0.24597874283790588,
0.5381549596786499,
-0.18870480358600616,
0.008128603920340538,
-0.15836215019226074,
0.10628589987754822,
0.3155501186847687,
0.4069308936595917,
-0.38198432326316833,
0.8066129088401794,
0.4710610806941986,
-0.33558565378189087,
-0.8327392935752869,
-0.6162243485450745,
0.13990238308906555,
-0.3242030441761017,
-0.3753383457660675,
0.6035347580909729,
0.38724634051322937,
-0.29220250248908997,
0.31959211826324463,
-0.16652698814868927,
-0.3365177512168884,
0.21969515085220337,
0.1348894089460373,
0.10210151225328445,
-0.6214016675949097,
0.022215569391846657,
0.06835481524467468,
-0.2915118634700775,
0.0007101704832166433,
-0.22258178889751434,
0.5752398371696472,
-0.09195646643638611,
-0.19651910662651062,
-0.43125399947166443,
0.1874992549419403,
0.25982701778411865,
-0.4662978947162628,
0.8140669465065002,
0.7117841243743896,
-0.5869754552841187,
0.06943270564079285,
-0.34742656350135803,
-0.38194340467453003,
-0.4097799062728882,
0.4742136299610138,
-0.8829898238182068,
-1.1209570169448853,
0.33676648139953613,
-0.2085205465555191,
0.059325288981199265,
0.5622607469558716,
0.31537699699401855,
-0.21528208255767822,
0.5014093518257141,
1.0400464534759521,
-0.3652329742908478,
0.3435306251049042,
-0.12051575630903244,
0.3169086277484894,
-0.6482231616973877,
-0.1337835043668747,
-0.28600946068763733,
-0.3276708722114563,
-0.5626554489135742,
-0.3733378052711487,
-0.16556060314178467,
0.47631582617759705,
0.07468148320913315,
0.8701926469802856,
-0.02127057872712612,
0.6903641819953918,
0.39587968587875366,
-0.24209117889404297,
0.4494503140449524,
-0.0014709277311339974,
-0.14019590616226196,
-0.49966391921043396,
-0.7514098882675171,
-0.7192942500114441,
0.8872278928756714,
0.379849910736084,
0.6462873816490173,
0.3284565210342407,
0.7489804625511169,
0.268108069896698,
0.4907134473323822,
-0.39267438650131226,
0.5369551181793213,
-0.24128320813179016,
-0.23639309406280518,
-0.019573699682950974,
-0.379448264837265,
-1.3504433631896973,
0.3143724203109741,
-0.17904973030090332,
-0.28453925251960754,
0.08172459900379181,
-0.2152578979730606,
-0.42405304312705994,
0.287086546421051,
-0.7830223441123962,
0.5444650053977966,
-0.09333371371030807,
-0.1600334644317627,
-0.256293386220932,
-0.5094728469848633,
0.34383854269981384,
-0.15438321232795715,
0.1004585400223732,
-0.14791087806224823,
-0.05747972056269646,
0.9367153644561768,
-0.018256863579154015,
0.5073809027671814,
-0.1449953019618988,
-0.14178772270679474,
0.2602466642856598,
0.18879546225070953,
0.15783479809761047,
0.02210228517651558,
0.22427970170974731,
0.32526475191116333,
-0.15964274108409882,
-0.5573168992996216,
-0.17867276072502136,
0.38567492365837097,
-0.7178992033004761,
-0.4631717801094055,
-0.3300071358680725,
-0.47482919692993164,
-0.06512746959924698,
0.007869167253375053,
0.169193834066391,
-0.06231752783060074,
0.005302552133798599,
0.0636347308754921,
0.44206833839416504,
-0.46389690041542053,
0.5851176977157593,
0.7990024089813232,
-0.34656697511672974,
-0.11569137871265411,
0.8099600672721863,
0.15118664503097534,
0.1772267073392868,
0.6854575276374817,
-0.31293603777885437,
-0.35702213644981384,
-0.25993406772613525,
-0.27728721499443054,
0.45424893498420715,
-0.49527016282081604,
-0.24382919073104858,
-0.7132077217102051,
-0.4730629324913025,
-0.24401989579200745,
-0.2589835524559021,
-0.4470483660697937,
-0.39650365710258484,
-0.47308939695358276,
-0.16825556755065918,
-0.12647153437137604,
0.7283227443695068,
-0.21598117053508759,
0.47046977281570435,
-0.8628346920013428,
-0.04965495690703392,
0.19888299703598022,
0.05875226482748985,
-0.08629614114761353,
-0.7795570492744446,
-0.2754623591899872,
-0.2844431400299072,
-0.1132282167673111,
-1.0747928619384766,
0.536302387714386,
0.2502649426460266,
0.4802992641925812,
0.4399056136608124,
-0.22633041441440582,
0.6889433860778809,
-0.43178993463516235,
0.5124426484107971,
-0.06520892679691315,
-1.073081374168396,
0.44864916801452637,
0.03951016813516617,
0.06119370087981224,
0.5846580266952515,
0.7948970198631287,
-0.7602857947349548,
-0.022286998108029366,
-0.6467122435569763,
-0.9793744087219238,
0.5675552487373352,
0.11296427249908447,
-0.07955983281135559,
0.20395860075950623,
0.3150078058242798,
0.24041539430618286,
0.2939930856227875,
-0.8268188238143921,
-0.17988574504852295,
0.12552125751972198,
-0.15721584856510162,
-0.061913374811410904,
-0.3464109003543854,
0.5204553008079529,
-0.31535980105400085,
0.7409104108810425,
0.13727951049804688,
0.18523865938186646,
0.16650556027889252,
-0.8227924704551697,
0.14259746670722961,
0.47814077138900757,
0.5517587661743164,
0.7715162634849548,
-0.3070267140865326,
0.3891482353210449,
0.28084737062454224,
-0.4249536395072937,
0.33281946182250977,
0.32040637731552124,
0.05015217512845993,
0.2448575347661972,
0.4001607596874237,
0.6093577742576599,
0.27317094802856445,
-0.5803360342979431,
0.36958929896354675,
-0.08855384588241577,
-0.06457266211509705,
-0.17932486534118652,
-0.2542940676212311,
0.4490428566932678,
0.16624264419078827,
0.30340585112571716,
0.09086320549249649,
-0.206743985414505,
-0.20288066565990448,
0.5421112775802612,
0.07118730992078781,
-0.27095597982406616,
-0.5661537647247314,
0.7768092155456543,
0.5560768246650696,
-0.3385152816772461,
0.6064594984054565,
-0.5437788367271423,
-0.6153709292411804,
0.3258956968784332,
0.7149612307548523,
0.5077880024909973,
-0.6794453263282776,
0.29113155603408813,
0.5038357973098755,
0.6931676864624023,
-0.0034865897614508867,
0.31706395745277405,
0.005898360628634691,
-0.8401132225990295,
-0.7056283950805664,
-0.6010156869888306,
-0.442937433719635,
0.5158625245094299,
-0.6035109758377075,
0.412887305021286,
-0.37325578927993774,
0.06392700970172882,
-0.24198251962661743,
0.03921232372522354,
-0.8969448208808899,
-0.15200670063495636,
0.3324111998081207,
1.0145665407180786,
-1.0612125396728516,
0.7870233654975891,
0.9978170394897461,
-0.5183480978012085,
-0.8401020169258118,
-0.07604167610406876,
-0.3307279348373413,
-0.7813410758972168,
0.718305230140686,
0.3496610224246979,
0.2073441743850708,
0.29396170377731323,
-0.011548318900167942,
-0.9653089642524719,
1.1458269357681274,
0.4695538580417633,
-0.8786707520484924,
0.18263188004493713,
0.28416791558265686,
0.2934328317642212,
-0.6153129935264587,
0.28443437814712524,
0.7807153463363647,
0.3972969949245453,
-0.5203601717948914,
-1.2364882230758667,
-0.17647205293178558,
0.054963190108537674,
-0.09085655957460403,
0.20642909407615662,
-0.38662058115005493,
1.031118631362915,
-0.337145060300827,
-0.5938281416893005,
-0.12152501195669174,
0.941806435585022,
0.24260373413562775,
0.26013490557670593,
0.45164281129837036,
0.6931511163711548,
0.9975013136863708,
0.00751419086009264,
0.6808722019195557,
-0.38271477818489075,
0.23765335977077484,
1.1882596015930176,
-0.531472384929657,
1.0433380603790283,
0.5667417645454407,
-0.47104203701019287,
0.7393496632575989,
0.8240014314651489,
0.2630276679992676,
0.6516236662864685,
0.08429870009422302,
-0.3757878541946411,
0.01937960274517536,
-0.3840424120426178,
-0.4247007668018341,
0.42634209990501404,
0.4109663665294647,
-0.41411706805229187,
-0.3468448519706726,
0.24057483673095703,
0.17440475523471832,
0.0032838478218764067,
-0.374886691570282,
0.693539023399353,
0.3667032718658447,
-0.4640054702758789,
0.3822583258152008,
0.284685343503952,
1.0544991493225098,
-0.3137882947921753,
-0.0049813250079751015,
-0.387175053358078,
0.13905569911003113,
-0.28084829449653625,
-0.5863038897514343,
0.41356804966926575,
-0.2620369791984558,
-0.1465490162372589,
-0.24750131368637085,
1.059937834739685,
-0.8013096451759338,
-0.3001208007335663,
0.3996427357196808,
1.0450822114944458,
0.33559808135032654,
-0.13896538317203522,
-0.7238901853561401,
-0.4503880739212036,
0.16953887045383453,
0.03120221383869648,
0.2959017753601074,
0.28768059611320496,
-0.12519648671150208,
0.4450100064277649,
0.5332732200622559,
0.2100052684545517,
0.09296927601099014,
0.19319286942481995,
0.26497766375541687,
-0.7929998636245728,
-0.48206818103790283,
-0.9425626397132874,
0.2678515911102295,
0.11365596950054169,
-0.1114707961678505,
0.5566158890724182,
0.5716049075126648,
1.2681739330291748,
-0.2579449415206909,
0.7966727614402771,
0.03699822723865509,
0.5923783779144287,
-0.5332861542701721,
0.7691044807434082,
-0.29830753803253174,
0.28653067350387573,
-0.00979355163872242,
-1.209619402885437,
-0.15867112576961517,
0.8947895765304565,
-0.21191231906414032,
-0.12991534173488617,
0.7867475152015686,
0.6242608428001404,
-0.3187868893146515,
-0.19727671146392822,
0.26755020022392273,
0.16924341022968292,
0.24443203210830688,
0.8201777935028076,
1.0507698059082031,
-0.4129394292831421,
0.4588587284088135,
-0.2903943955898285,
0.009134787134826183,
-0.11788691580295563,
-0.8879826664924622,
-0.8587713837623596,
-0.7830455303192139,
-0.3502119183540344,
-0.3099384009838104,
0.00731617771089077,
1.154288411140442,
0.7030810713768005,
-0.990871250629425,
-0.30612748861312866,
0.0324879065155983,
0.09554857015609741,
-0.026039185002446175,
-0.29765522480010986,
0.46862733364105225,
-0.2815829813480377,
-0.619744062423706,
0.3891907334327698,
0.37005728483200073,
0.30564290285110474,
-0.2344186156988144,
-0.3106139302253723,
-0.2994399666786194,
-0.10676475614309311,
0.8099988698959351,
0.24633930623531342,
-0.6223629713058472,
0.10715807974338531,
0.05784284323453903,
-0.16105230152606964,
0.12817756831645966,
0.9030038118362427,
-0.9949222803115845,
-0.07312221080064774,
0.1881926953792572,
1.2220816612243652,
0.12374057620763779,
-0.12813690304756165,
0.48813432455062866,
-1.0083222389221191,
0.2280757576227188,
0.12603148818016052,
0.6332342028617859,
0.7220206260681152,
-0.0035494857002049685,
0.8063247203826904,
0.4239114820957184,
-0.3480904996395111,
-0.6668474078178406,
0.07662001252174377,
-0.6774337291717529,
-0.2093159407377243,
1.0635597705841064,
-0.11184640228748322,
-0.021617330610752106,
-0.485694020986557,
-0.2945312559604645,
0.14338062703609467,
-0.34781602025032043,
0.6790189743041992,
0.8629269599914551,
-0.06612962484359741,
-0.4888053238391876,
-0.5836582779884338,
0.4736314117908478,
0.7744677662849426,
-0.8867768049240112,
-0.3042752146720886,
0.059763334691524506,
0.28367847204208374,
0.11631014198064804,
0.8608489036560059,
0.12347880750894547,
0.16495682299137115,
-0.4058370888233185,
0.07722678035497665,
0.1812029927968979,
-0.38496309518814087,
-0.3688091039657593,
0.045849572867155075,
0.17559027671813965,
-0.27546966075897217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01370v1 | Summary of a Haystack: A Challenge to Long-Context LLMs and RAG Systems | 2024-07-01T15:23:42 | 2024-07-01T15:23:42 | Philippe Laban, Alexander R. Fabbri, Caiming Xiong, Chien-Sheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs and RAG systems are now capable of handling millions of input tokens or
more. However, evaluating the output quality of such systems on long-context
tasks remains challenging, as tasks like Needle-in-a-Haystack lack complexity.
In this work, we argue that summarization can play a central role in such
evaluation. We design a procedure to synthesize Haystacks of documents,
ensuring that specific \textit{insights} repeat across documents. The "Summary
of a Haystack" (SummHay) task then requires a system to process the Haystack
and generate, given a query, a summary that identifies the relevant insights
and precisely cites the source documents. Since we have precise knowledge of
what insights should appear in a haystack summary and what documents should be
cited, we implement a highly reproducible automatic evaluation that can score
summaries on two aspects - Coverage and Citation. We generate Haystacks in two
domains (conversation, news), and perform a large-scale evaluation of 10 LLMs
and corresponding 50 RAG systems. Our findings indicate that SummHay is an open
challenge for current systems, as even systems provided with an Oracle signal
of document relevance lag our estimate of human performance (56\%) by 10+
points on a Joint Score. Without a retriever, long-context LLMs like GPT-4o and
Claude 3 Opus score below 20% on SummHay. We show SummHay can also be used to
study enterprise RAG systems and position bias in long-context models. We hope
future systems can equal and surpass human performance on SummHay. | [
-0.19392959773540497,
-0.1423071175813675,
0.651984453201294,
0.20343701541423798,
-0.39970287680625916,
0.20667101442813873,
-0.0020581271965056658,
-0.5289374589920044,
0.9382827281951904,
0.5283137559890747,
-0.5082815885543823,
-0.3933807909488678,
-0.4509236812591553,
0.4189227819442749,
-0.6968570351600647,
1.29043710231781,
-0.05741267651319504,
-0.31107091903686523,
-0.33886560797691345,
-0.21287061274051666,
-0.47281941771507263,
-0.5038430690765381,
-0.28681644797325134,
-0.3000214099884033,
0.3228130638599396,
0.3369922339916229,
0.3503778874874115,
0.18460917472839355,
0.6534566283226013,
0.34559550881385803,
-0.26820868253707886,
0.4528295397758484,
-0.7661323547363281,
0.6568936109542847,
-0.33010441064834595,
-0.3088008463382721,
-0.6055571436882019,
-0.08987343311309814,
0.6779912710189819,
0.6664537787437439,
-0.1894432157278061,
0.40255895256996155,
0.31065672636032104,
0.8892964720726013,
-0.7272710800170898,
-0.21486148238182068,
-0.5005226731300354,
-0.25018346309661865,
-0.17860500514507294,
-0.2489725649356842,
-0.3066369295120239,
-0.2467324435710907,
-0.0498625785112381,
-0.5907425284385681,
0.09607133269309998,
0.019786538556218147,
0.7863301634788513,
0.24704542756080627,
-0.47101372480392456,
-0.44436880946159363,
-0.4688425064086914,
0.9150618314743042,
-0.5000625252723694,
-0.14415906369686127,
0.36686307191848755,
0.4432145953178406,
-0.08260121196508408,
-0.5962602496147156,
-0.0864068865776062,
0.1807357519865036,
-0.42123740911483765,
0.6323634386062622,
0.00041133182821795344,
-0.35458025336265564,
-0.08715959638357162,
0.3779451549053192,
-0.3681309223175049,
-0.1283053606748581,
-0.6237761378288269,
-0.18500369787216187,
0.6410375833511353,
0.5933646559715271,
-0.2796884775161743,
-0.452427476644516,
-0.28800150752067566,
-0.008604311384260654,
-0.4683273136615753,
-0.014504053629934788,
0.14197547733783722,
0.03609313443303108,
0.14509296417236328,
0.6250054240226746,
-0.3527866005897522,
0.4913257360458374,
0.05553794279694557,
-0.18719297647476196,
0.06841984391212463,
-0.5360329747200012,
-0.2422228306531906,
-0.0974753350019455,
0.4873982071876526,
0.6660987734794617,
-0.2764645516872406,
-0.19802021980285645,
-0.6340337991714478,
-0.09882976114749908,
0.3827712833881378,
-0.7447832822799683,
0.2876943051815033,
0.3644639551639557,
-0.4128156304359436,
-0.4266573488712311,
0.17823661863803864,
-0.5883193612098694,
-0.39060524106025696,
-0.1454366147518158,
0.5455214977264404,
-0.1984003633260727,
0.005043221637606621,
-0.10416103154420853,
-0.5038912296295166,
0.41493022441864014,
0.5626981258392334,
-0.7739036083221436,
0.4661352038383484,
0.8936549425125122,
1.1843422651290894,
-0.3573598563671112,
-0.3756119906902313,
-0.6143197417259216,
0.46630823612213135,
-0.5617983937263489,
1.0195425748825073,
-0.2451247125864029,
-0.7235832214355469,
-0.3074951767921448,
0.03950953856110573,
0.14444276690483093,
-0.675772488117218,
0.31930699944496155,
-0.4822641611099243,
0.3073931336402893,
-0.380411297082901,
-0.6145050525665283,
0.058997735381126404,
0.17522430419921875,
-0.6661686301231384,
0.7986829876899719,
0.3746618628501892,
-0.8019862174987793,
0.25078415870666504,
-0.6379017233848572,
-0.5771684646606445,
0.024199655279517174,
-0.05028628557920456,
-0.15905551612377167,
0.3019905984401703,
0.09695443511009216,
0.4318181574344635,
-0.30883359909057617,
0.11704875528812408,
0.0757012814283371,
-0.8573175072669983,
0.22447320818901062,
0.16521163284778595,
0.7853646874427795,
0.08201351016759872,
-0.29348552227020264,
0.21173779666423798,
-0.5830246806144714,
-0.051864612847566605,
-0.13501004874706268,
-0.45660868287086487,
-0.48414263129234314,
-0.08736938238143921,
-0.06195962429046631,
-0.3095557689666748,
0.42437854409217834,
-0.20975232124328613,
-0.08671566098928452,
-0.4478817284107208,
0.2389022409915924,
0.83823162317276,
0.04425985738635063,
0.36641958355903625,
-0.6461092829704285,
0.4924384355545044,
-0.23950250446796417,
-0.1521414965391159,
-0.7233789563179016,
0.010594024322926998,
-0.6908074021339417,
-0.31370899081230164,
0.1741199493408203,
0.5129390358924866,
-0.38820680975914,
0.46695780754089355,
-0.4005700647830963,
-0.35925859212875366,
-0.240334615111351,
0.05324726551771164,
0.37450096011161804,
0.4411836564540863,
0.2728904187679291,
-0.3681488335132599,
-0.5974855422973633,
-1.094446063041687,
-0.41162800788879395,
-0.007164767012000084,
-0.5634816288948059,
0.17437264323234558,
0.6548658013343811,
-0.09905140846967697,
0.8438736200332642,
-0.43675464391708374,
-0.513556182384491,
0.0016134772449731827,
0.1419522613286972,
0.5228471755981445,
0.1549672931432724,
0.2694559097290039,
-0.5845627188682556,
-0.17244993150234222,
-0.08454174548387527,
-0.9205513000488281,
-0.16654454171657562,
0.00397071847692132,
-0.20973394811153412,
0.37967392802238464,
0.5587884187698364,
-0.44550395011901855,
0.21746499836444855,
0.33477818965911865,
-0.39077135920524597,
0.7560874223709106,
-0.03417999669909477,
0.33747678995132446,
-1.1770720481872559,
0.5137528777122498,
-0.4799822270870209,
-0.41051343083381653,
-0.14893463253974915,
0.21988725662231445,
0.06950998306274414,
-0.09658373147249222,
-0.11139674484729767,
0.45648157596588135,
-0.47062042355537415,
-0.42914748191833496,
-0.3166911005973816,
0.3101886212825775,
0.350475937128067,
0.24160422384738922,
-0.3232012093067169,
0.9549505710601807,
0.013133510947227478,
-0.6619398593902588,
0.3576388359069824,
0.08167208731174469,
-0.4466351866722107,
0.7868914604187012,
-0.9151793718338013,
-0.10427810996770859,
-0.18690267205238342,
0.5500966906547546,
-0.9316576719284058,
-0.5135121941566467,
-0.2692420780658722,
-0.5887611508369446,
0.21640868484973907,
0.22612205147743225,
-0.3052270710468292,
0.05920405313372612,
-0.7662602663040161,
0.12659567594528198,
0.562632143497467,
-0.22235116362571716,
0.6610888242721558,
0.6417909264564514,
-0.1422891914844513,
-0.6169127821922302,
-0.6109809279441833,
0.3024173676967621,
-0.3277937173843384,
-0.5619091391563416,
0.3139961063861847,
0.26873981952667236,
-0.3910408616065979,
0.11159566044807434,
-0.34604018926620483,
0.19199779629707336,
0.23344923555850983,
0.22333435714244843,
0.13308697938919067,
-0.0462910458445549,
0.29110243916511536,
0.14222297072410583,
-0.28635817766189575,
0.15734592080116272,
-0.3291034400463104,
0.0116839949041605,
-0.3217841386795044,
-0.27800074219703674,
0.10351419448852539,
0.7487487196922302,
0.5986530780792236,
-0.06472525745630264,
0.35356590151786804,
0.31288236379623413,
-0.322218656539917,
-0.06541825085878372,
-0.4991954565048218,
-0.21166282892227173,
-0.4252799153327942,
0.39818403124809265,
-0.24320705235004425,
-0.7873906493186951,
0.5443602800369263,
-0.17420309782028198,
0.4573100209236145,
0.8201976418495178,
0.624196469783783,
-0.5303404331207275,
0.5263253450393677,
0.6602517366409302,
0.03387321159243584,
0.18043193221092224,
-0.25736746191978455,
-0.29059112071990967,
-1.0570874214172363,
-0.018409356474876404,
-0.41624191403388977,
-0.35386142134666443,
-0.31901440024375916,
-0.2996159493923187,
0.8215870261192322,
0.10448204725980759,
0.07636450976133347,
0.1329982876777649,
-0.42991843819618225,
0.7525327801704407,
0.5701191425323486,
0.031455229967832565,
0.43607985973358154,
-0.14075401425361633,
-0.021274074912071228,
0.2250043898820877,
-0.373311311006546,
-0.7321953773498535,
0.9031084775924683,
-0.03309280052781105,
0.7659453749656677,
0.38676509261131287,
1.1639925241470337,
0.4058200418949127,
0.3864460289478302,
-0.8616299629211426,
0.49812161922454834,
-0.14458014070987701,
-0.41815468668937683,
-0.6837508678436279,
-0.2737048864364624,
-1.0546295642852783,
0.44886672496795654,
0.0038815727457404137,
-0.6170748472213745,
-0.11019807308912277,
0.0452520027756691,
-0.3587179183959961,
-0.06996685266494751,
-0.525139331817627,
0.36557579040527344,
0.15687987208366394,
-0.46900513768196106,
-0.39384889602661133,
-0.7262524962425232,
0.6471152901649475,
-0.2403821498155594,
0.4598355293273926,
0.037715110927820206,
-0.2989720106124878,
1.0206449031829834,
-0.5568927526473999,
0.705531895160675,
0.14486858248710632,
-0.08554935455322266,
0.3633827865123749,
0.225706547498703,
0.4840191900730133,
-0.06993768364191055,
-0.08978088200092316,
-0.0320638082921505,
0.39525431394577026,
-0.40630966424942017,
-0.550527036190033,
0.5886918902397156,
-0.37932875752449036,
-0.696722686290741,
-0.46254801750183105,
-0.3110625445842743,
-0.10070165991783142,
0.3325877785682678,
0.2654222548007965,
0.45956072211265564,
-0.2396114319562912,
0.33023691177368164,
0.36634883284568787,
0.035373933613300323,
0.3297697603702545,
0.2726348340511322,
-0.3208254277706146,
-0.465688556432724,
0.8905036449432373,
0.10441064834594727,
0.07733875513076782,
0.5198614001274109,
0.3096638023853302,
-0.17422863841056824,
-0.09862710535526276,
-0.43024224042892456,
0.2581223249435425,
-0.9273038506507874,
-0.506751537322998,
-0.461402952671051,
-0.08586134016513824,
-0.2105899453163147,
-0.27797171473503113,
-0.21793495118618011,
-0.5717552900314331,
-0.16001208126544952,
0.188992440700531,
0.14072610437870026,
1.0886098146438599,
-0.1170327439904213,
0.07462668418884277,
-0.8945733904838562,
0.28253695368766785,
0.36086246371269226,
0.3924785852432251,
0.13436126708984375,
-0.5356429815292358,
-0.6688176393508911,
-0.12657871842384338,
-0.33046647906303406,
-0.9678529500961304,
0.06657981127500534,
0.03304194286465645,
0.3760339319705963,
0.022584786638617516,
0.04757596552371979,
0.6585486531257629,
-0.42331594228744507,
0.772037148475647,
0.05054892972111702,
-0.9669733643531799,
0.550417423248291,
-0.4399421811103821,
0.571025013923645,
0.6620126366615295,
0.08538692444562912,
-0.5268288850784302,
-0.6300678849220276,
-0.3791451156139374,
-1.0942171812057495,
0.529693067073822,
0.26186224818229675,
-0.20647649466991425,
0.026937369257211685,
0.10057488083839417,
0.0887228474020958,
0.11566106230020523,
-0.1491878628730774,
0.15709786117076874,
-0.16835692524909973,
-0.1116042211651802,
-0.0012895168038085103,
-0.4069162607192993,
-0.21900570392608643,
0.2060641050338745,
0.6067394614219666,
-0.04720138758420944,
-0.10320445150136948,
0.421174556016922,
-0.3270183503627777,
0.11183387041091919,
0.23115713894367218,
0.7946302890777588,
1.175145149230957,
-0.4222930073738098,
0.15249496698379517,
0.18003688752651215,
-0.41132959723472595,
0.045704592019319534,
-0.39276960492134094,
-0.18647035956382751,
0.30297812819480896,
0.6693871021270752,
0.2623846232891083,
0.5505666136741638,
-0.7551206946372986,
0.47104406356811523,
-0.10981422662734985,
-0.17662020027637482,
-0.40537402033805847,
-0.020053133368492126,
0.3025769293308258,
0.24490216374397278,
0.8561500310897827,
-0.2522889971733093,
0.41602611541748047,
-0.3747568428516388,
0.16921073198318481,
0.4029155969619751,
0.10426259785890579,
-0.10071063786745071,
0.3554999828338623,
0.35714393854141235,
-0.2098560333251953,
0.15277624130249023,
-0.1349894106388092,
-0.4200899004936218,
0.6531784534454346,
0.33709654211997986,
0.7981109023094177,
-0.10100594907999039,
-0.1849897801876068,
0.4243334233760834,
0.3146136999130249,
-0.06361420452594757,
-0.006335642654448748,
-0.33720648288726807,
-0.03341140225529671,
-0.587554395198822,
-0.7638477683067322,
-0.6738654971122742,
-0.0867467150092125,
-0.7777373194694519,
0.3691018521785736,
-0.09641923755407333,
-0.02895258739590645,
-0.08311481773853302,
-0.024219738319516182,
-0.3249431252479553,
-0.10371598601341248,
-0.45824700593948364,
0.666541576385498,
-0.536648154258728,
0.19978594779968262,
0.5926666855812073,
-0.04024500772356987,
-0.35809290409088135,
-0.16831514239311218,
-0.028754794970154762,
-0.5654975771903992,
0.5401538014411926,
0.2310691773891449,
-0.6260349154472351,
-0.26336750388145447,
-0.2838006317615509,
-0.9873777627944946,
1.3791825771331787,
0.0319766029715538,
-0.46561622619628906,
-0.021261340007185936,
-0.5627639889717102,
0.42383629083633423,
-0.1575479954481125,
0.28603029251098633,
0.4696780741214752,
0.31405386328697205,
0.17602047324180603,
-1.1385769844055176,
0.10081987828016281,
-0.16391505300998688,
-0.22805961966514587,
0.37068456411361694,
-0.6715071797370911,
0.8629356622695923,
-0.36066314578056335,
-0.6953040957450867,
0.044159285724163055,
0.6278958320617676,
0.40595874190330505,
0.44391658902168274,
0.37433746457099915,
0.28064560890197754,
0.8056697249412537,
0.32806092500686646,
0.9027702808380127,
-0.07472527027130127,
0.387533038854599,
1.329506516456604,
-0.1259949654340744,
0.9358823299407959,
0.5977916717529297,
-0.4265594780445099,
0.33714559674263,
0.520049512386322,
0.18789871037006378,
0.30763325095176697,
0.3560316562652588,
-0.0466683954000473,
-0.046226903796195984,
0.053778935223817825,
-0.3746654987335205,
0.5477095246315002,
0.3707871437072754,
-0.10978178679943085,
-0.5943358540534973,
-0.38740459084510803,
-0.16903550922870636,
0.11009623855352402,
-0.24824932217597961,
0.9810754656791687,
0.16209286451339722,
-0.7465248703956604,
0.6736415028572083,
0.10865429788827896,
0.7714044451713562,
-0.5813937783241272,
-0.1767105907201767,
-0.563176691532135,
-0.09589072316884995,
-0.2980189323425293,
-0.695098340511322,
0.8015521168708801,
0.05841705948114395,
-0.3512195348739624,
-0.08428659290075302,
0.6901271343231201,
-0.051144152879714966,
-0.5589038133621216,
-0.020482899621129036,
0.5608135461807251,
0.541320264339447,
0.06890750676393509,
0.1163923591375351,
0.004710259381681681,
-0.3062739670276642,
-0.417229026556015,
0.45645880699157715,
0.5327677130699158,
-0.30400192737579346,
0.46279528737068176,
0.5347208976745605,
0.07226613163948059,
-0.34429579973220825,
-0.1545739471912384,
0.8464654684066772,
-0.9244658946990967,
-0.7914899587631226,
-0.9886664748191833,
0.2758248448371887,
-0.29868483543395996,
-0.20790985226631165,
0.6694126129150391,
0.6586586833000183,
0.5304736495018005,
0.15663500130176544,
0.7241755127906799,
0.09160654991865158,
0.8489362597465515,
-0.5578702092170715,
0.839130163192749,
-0.7142619490623474,
0.30913347005844116,
-0.11555604636669159,
-0.679256021976471,
0.1288357377052307,
0.4734653830528259,
0.35860955715179443,
-0.13307662308216095,
0.8463029861450195,
0.3607020378112793,
-0.02695847675204277,
-0.1094532385468483,
0.28578853607177734,
0.06089862063527107,
0.2868495285511017,
0.6171910762786865,
0.7184193134307861,
-0.38113394379615784,
0.5497572422027588,
-0.007159319240599871,
-0.43009135127067566,
-0.529400110244751,
-1.0294251441955566,
-0.6844595074653625,
-0.8218539953231812,
0.22076880931854248,
-0.36397477984428406,
0.005034478846937418,
0.4056759774684906,
0.5127550363540649,
-0.5367220640182495,
-0.5983006358146667,
0.39424052834510803,
0.4023479223251343,
-0.1677781343460083,
-0.26871731877326965,
0.536540150642395,
-0.5858988761901855,
-0.39593419432640076,
0.2515789270401001,
0.56386798620224,
-0.10427941381931305,
-0.3698272407054901,
0.12206299602985382,
0.18148142099380493,
-0.06457279622554779,
0.8427273631095886,
0.01143086887896061,
-0.7521432042121887,
-0.10748854279518127,
0.15989378094673157,
-0.17073558270931244,
-0.319416344165802,
0.9583167433738708,
-0.9568862318992615,
0.16887345910072327,
0.39202290773391724,
0.7143405079841614,
0.641078770160675,
0.2734687030315399,
0.47455739974975586,
-0.7574414610862732,
-0.16489900648593903,
0.4240904152393341,
0.2446494698524475,
0.2803151607513428,
-0.4026641547679901,
0.6982852816581726,
-0.09465719014406204,
-0.5388367772102356,
-0.9841683506965637,
0.12875059247016907,
-0.8256101608276367,
-0.43125197291374207,
0.9191600680351257,
0.002371616195887327,
-0.4925226867198944,
0.023522837087512016,
-0.09806672483682632,
-0.016163868829607964,
-0.30653825402259827,
0.9123607277870178,
0.8726637959480286,
-0.20998528599739075,
0.3269062936306,
-0.4464156925678253,
0.2526445984840393,
0.3596663475036621,
-0.77961665391922,
0.1307331621646881,
0.5582802295684814,
0.18668344616889954,
0.3189186155796051,
0.9775874614715576,
-0.1093674749135971,
0.44760775566101074,
0.0074235377833247185,
-0.2691665291786194,
-0.1641978621482849,
-0.1754050850868225,
-0.3285832405090332,
0.04566580057144165,
-0.1398959457874298,
-0.20475268363952637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01360v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01360v1 | Nullpointer at ArAIEval Shared Task: Arabic Propagandist Technique Detection with Token-to-Word Mapping in Sequence Tagging | 2024-07-01T15:15:24 | 2024-07-01T15:15:24 | Abrar Abir, Kemal Oflazer | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper investigates the optimization of propaganda technique detection in
Arabic text, including tweets \& news paragraphs, from ArAIEval shared task 1.
Our approach involves fine-tuning the AraBERT v2 model with a neural network
classifier for sequence tagging. Experimental results show relying on the first
token of the word for technique prediction produces the best performance. In
addition, incorporating genre information as a feature further enhances the
model's performance. Our system achieved a score of 25.41, placing us 4$^{th}$
on the leaderboard. Subsequent post-submission improvements further raised our
score to 26.68. | [
-0.46723872423171997,
-0.7403637766838074,
0.1277894675731659,
0.34461653232574463,
-0.6734787225723267,
0.20521731674671173,
-0.06609585136175156,
-0.4747641980648041,
0.32304272055625916,
0.4215264916419983,
-0.08733843266963959,
-0.9938379526138306,
-1.2082926034927368,
-0.028302621096372604,
-0.7179001569747925,
1.1969940662384033,
-0.13531902432441711,
-0.21481077373027802,
0.3536612391471863,
-0.3615616261959076,
-0.441997230052948,
-0.3768937587738037,
-0.8606826663017273,
-0.03866686671972275,
0.5982561111450195,
0.779335618019104,
0.8939317464828491,
0.6438323259353638,
0.4442873001098633,
0.2763674259185791,
0.03227890282869339,
0.31388503313064575,
-0.18173760175704956,
0.19434601068496704,
-0.23685164749622345,
-0.30619239807128906,
-0.07996229827404022,
-0.021470192819833755,
0.6115298271179199,
0.24506644904613495,
0.06296507269144058,
0.5006107091903687,
-0.08247533440589905,
0.33472877740859985,
-0.7140097618103027,
-0.14853283762931824,
-0.49901241064071655,
-0.17140606045722961,
-0.3809203505516052,
-0.3501940965652466,
-0.29606544971466064,
-0.5218151807785034,
-0.1902831345796585,
-0.4278237819671631,
0.24013955891132355,
0.34257110953330994,
0.7936846017837524,
0.39358073472976685,
-0.6837621331214905,
-0.34886276721954346,
-0.7390721440315247,
0.7978480458259583,
-0.41402822732925415,
-0.06429632008075714,
0.3867769241333008,
0.10191299766302109,
-0.038353368639945984,
-0.6587322354316711,
-0.657699704170227,
-0.07294993102550507,
0.14524047076702118,
-0.015225487761199474,
-0.3139461576938629,
-0.06822763383388519,
-0.011436385102570057,
0.08999726176261902,
-0.6393822431564331,
0.0368620827794075,
-0.43579667806625366,
-0.4558829367160797,
0.6725780963897705,
-0.33870917558670044,
0.23898541927337646,
-0.34198951721191406,
-0.45224207639694214,
-0.019367191940546036,
-0.5044697523117065,
-0.2623516321182251,
0.3983882963657379,
-0.028812428936362267,
0.0369657464325428,
0.644154965877533,
-0.10262732207775116,
0.6734075546264648,
-0.10223764181137085,
-0.3760860860347748,
0.13592053949832916,
-0.1480257362127304,
0.162166029214859,
0.3810116946697235,
0.5669531226158142,
0.4499567449092865,
0.24767298996448517,
0.02122703194618225,
-0.24725839495658875,
0.5672977566719055,
0.3531816005706787,
-0.6767141819000244,
-0.05213557556271553,
-0.014093291945755482,
-0.4068732261657715,
-0.5467069745063782,
-0.013117508962750435,
-0.45795226097106934,
-0.2862725853919983,
0.0907452255487442,
0.7351938486099243,
-0.5050947070121765,
-0.25622305274009705,
-0.026378553360700607,
-0.355449378490448,
0.1456480622291565,
0.3955908715724945,
-0.3716103136539459,
0.19534295797348022,
0.7542952299118042,
1.1969776153564453,
-0.26257947087287903,
-0.09298031032085419,
-0.5449197888374329,
0.018682684749364853,
-0.6246212720870972,
1.1480638980865479,
-0.5238873958587646,
-0.5107169151306152,
0.26919496059417725,
-0.388558954000473,
0.0426432229578495,
-0.44889456033706665,
1.2154982089996338,
-0.8803192377090454,
-0.05672307685017586,
-0.15064123272895813,
-0.7562295198440552,
-0.5158212780952454,
0.2081291228532791,
-0.7058171629905701,
1.1643502712249756,
0.1652010828256607,
-0.8202404975891113,
0.49480852484703064,
-0.7504324913024902,
-0.5188957452774048,
0.1060733050107956,
-0.04627493396401405,
-0.4867243766784668,
-0.06946076452732086,
0.06244249269366264,
0.29275843501091003,
-0.029111186042428017,
0.10286124050617218,
0.24922049045562744,
-0.879925549030304,
0.18386945128440857,
-0.32732734084129333,
0.3039877116680145,
0.28779491782188416,
-0.5814582705497742,
0.24459055066108704,
-0.8333914875984192,
-0.07273650169372559,
-0.16051355004310608,
-0.257403701543808,
-0.5064908266067505,
-0.023059671744704247,
0.26569050550460815,
0.28366369009017944,
-0.07821457087993622,
-0.4427807927131653,
0.3365213871002197,
-0.4981520175933838,
-0.07300221174955368,
0.5744872093200684,
0.41434383392333984,
0.2626788914203644,
-0.6408771276473999,
0.671233057975769,
0.15059173107147217,
-0.1271626353263855,
0.09749004989862442,
-0.7247220277786255,
-0.8941637873649597,
-0.10507726669311523,
0.4624084532260895,
0.7055968642234802,
-0.919175922870636,
0.20550677180290222,
-0.1893462836742401,
-0.6782826781272888,
-0.5576013326644897,
-0.07856251299381256,
0.5542178153991699,
0.2747757136821747,
0.3173976540565491,
-0.31551393866539,
-0.5699926614761353,
-0.9682523012161255,
-0.5946539044380188,
-0.11849216371774673,
0.2599339485168457,
-0.24825522303581238,
0.9190940856933594,
0.0994156152009964,
0.5057488679885864,
-0.3157047629356384,
-0.36585232615470886,
-0.12249962985515594,
0.8073016405105591,
0.1498875617980957,
0.5637490153312683,
0.5205694437026978,
-1.1853097677230835,
-0.6152411699295044,
-0.1984642595052719,
-0.3745481073856354,
-0.11136392503976822,
0.20616646111011505,
-0.07359037548303604,
0.5748721361160278,
0.45033732056617737,
-0.36560767889022827,
0.9080295562744141,
0.4400671124458313,
-0.5510948300361633,
0.536616861820221,
0.3028567433357239,
0.5410401225090027,
-1.3496183156967163,
0.08423219621181488,
0.2119816541671753,
-0.29545876383781433,
-0.7809591889381409,
0.06598451733589172,
-0.2002830058336258,
0.12107249349355698,
-0.5860977172851562,
0.49895182251930237,
-0.3433739244937897,
0.07573043555021286,
-0.7268967032432556,
0.015643617138266563,
-0.2201525866985321,
0.23880548775196075,
-0.10678861290216446,
1.172614336013794,
0.366018146276474,
-0.5044050812721252,
0.10882564634084702,
0.2856050133705139,
-0.4620636999607086,
0.25936853885650635,
-0.600646436214447,
0.2759060263633728,
-0.1755848079919815,
0.07810419797897339,
-1.2306227684020996,
-0.05648389458656311,
0.7239943146705627,
-0.7014152407646179,
0.1700991690158844,
-0.2721719741821289,
-0.6417409181594849,
-0.041176121681928635,
-0.34667855501174927,
0.6330799460411072,
0.5862092971801758,
-0.21068695187568665,
0.24503381550312042,
0.31111112236976624,
0.0814444050192833,
-0.8360381126403809,
-0.3130650520324707,
0.16745801270008087,
-0.3637121915817261,
-0.6353070139884949,
0.5653691291809082,
0.2596062421798706,
-0.22170594334602356,
-0.03361649066209793,
-0.26576128602027893,
0.05740685015916824,
0.0799388438463211,
0.36628586053848267,
0.0789412185549736,
-0.23848411440849304,
0.14227013289928436,
0.0708589032292366,
-0.2839757800102234,
0.03466571122407913,
-0.4347303509712219,
0.6136349439620972,
0.07634173333644867,
-0.3655450940132141,
-0.38841724395751953,
0.7710984945297241,
0.29985061287879944,
-0.20532500743865967,
1.2127629518508911,
0.9725216627120972,
-0.3793140947818756,
-0.08978178352117538,
-0.589982807636261,
0.053482867777347565,
-0.4778129458427429,
0.26555541157722473,
-0.1844717264175415,
-0.908926784992218,
0.3630612790584564,
-0.3314245045185089,
-0.19846990704536438,
0.7194555997848511,
0.47283968329429626,
0.2278817892074585,
1.1239254474639893,
0.7722697257995605,
-0.2662751078605652,
0.18394561111927032,
-0.34956175088882446,
0.33191245794296265,
-0.47806310653686523,
-0.08145840466022491,
-0.7497052550315857,
-0.45539623498916626,
-0.8166772127151489,
-0.6957471966743469,
0.5573467016220093,
0.27055037021636963,
-0.19048736989498138,
0.013088610954582691,
-0.6694518327713013,
0.3572646379470825,
0.7414816617965698,
-0.14453576505184174,
0.3121446669101715,
0.20244407653808594,
0.08698876947164536,
0.031601548194885254,
-0.567225456237793,
-0.7084890604019165,
0.9027802348136902,
0.059498272836208344,
0.32441699504852295,
0.29089194536209106,
0.7579609751701355,
0.7941707372665405,
0.4772129952907562,
-0.850178062915802,
0.6239235997200012,
0.04179145395755768,
-0.4735282063484192,
-0.11111108213663101,
0.21775665879249573,
-0.8209881782531738,
0.19749246537685394,
0.03452088683843613,
-0.794984757900238,
0.10037313401699066,
0.10263492166996002,
-0.18399330973625183,
0.06987173855304718,
-0.38128238916397095,
0.6932504177093506,
0.3967110216617584,
-0.2006518840789795,
-0.40992456674575806,
-0.720619797706604,
0.2140878438949585,
-0.04926363751292229,
0.28890833258628845,
-0.14807036519050598,
-0.4565075933933258,
1.1603327989578247,
-0.23227627575397491,
0.7348347306251526,
-0.13582023978233337,
0.004084301181137562,
0.3583396375179291,
0.09583832323551178,
0.471257746219635,
-0.09794647991657257,
-0.11384572088718414,
0.220872163772583,
-0.2539515793323517,
-0.5978889465332031,
-0.3296925127506256,
0.6549506187438965,
-0.8972355127334595,
-0.7072002291679382,
-0.9520694613456726,
-0.2908945679664612,
0.11399233341217041,
0.08481083810329437,
0.5785267949104309,
0.42818570137023926,
-0.13971592485904694,
-0.028035026043653488,
0.416623055934906,
0.12287652492523193,
0.4834413528442383,
0.4032314717769623,
-0.009418316185474396,
-0.2686494290828705,
0.8883172273635864,
0.1178356185555458,
-0.04886054992675781,
0.24014773964881897,
-0.13531115651130676,
-0.14592404663562775,
-0.7923333048820496,
-0.424849271774292,
0.18852798640727997,
-0.9670332074165344,
-0.40931838750839233,
-0.3659103512763977,
-0.43234023451805115,
-0.3068081736564636,
-0.16325262188911438,
-0.16695480048656464,
-0.46122750639915466,
-0.37329792976379395,
-0.026409048587083817,
0.40327128767967224,
0.6445770263671875,
-0.08756124973297119,
0.6921532154083252,
-0.7813800573348999,
0.2098640501499176,
-0.33377406001091003,
-0.0535283200442791,
-0.3733389675617218,
-0.8410736322402954,
-0.41533225774765015,
-0.052421439439058304,
-0.5383759140968323,
-1.2966350317001343,
0.539889931678772,
0.21121783554553986,
0.25444501638412476,
0.5828081369400024,
0.0263817198574543,
0.5418754816055298,
-0.40436530113220215,
0.9217734336853027,
-0.2020864188671112,
-1.0025975704193115,
0.7883499264717102,
-0.20581786334514618,
0.30113720893859863,
0.3774762451648712,
0.9898329973220825,
-0.7024974822998047,
-0.49878740310668945,
-0.573760449886322,
-0.7998719811439514,
0.4982324540615082,
0.5205446481704712,
-0.048931658267974854,
-0.19741906225681305,
0.37223169207572937,
0.043568551540374756,
0.3415004312992096,
-0.4088018536567688,
-0.6631680130958557,
-0.17393921315670013,
-0.13593024015426636,
-0.07846008241176605,
-0.6326407194137573,
-0.11833260208368301,
-0.2829609811306,
0.9256722331047058,
-0.10348683595657349,
0.36576637625694275,
0.3498077094554901,
-0.29379940032958984,
-0.2840048670768738,
0.2739441990852356,
0.980887770652771,
0.823684811592102,
0.11730273067951202,
0.17135466635227203,
-0.15433943271636963,
-0.6299258470535278,
0.36378127336502075,
0.24578699469566345,
-0.27874577045440674,
0.4810611605644226,
0.5503048896789551,
0.7602322697639465,
0.15249305963516235,
-0.32568269968032837,
0.622620701789856,
0.25323963165283203,
-0.29566624760627747,
-0.7063291668891907,
0.09787249565124512,
-0.2497730702161789,
0.3843041956424713,
0.6872115731239319,
0.44668203592300415,
0.4863329827785492,
-0.2738519012928009,
0.2874677777290344,
0.2207144945859909,
-0.1164388656616211,
-0.2284466028213501,
0.6114014387130737,
-0.06538083404302597,
-0.7042719721794128,
0.2565251290798187,
-0.46873682737350464,
-1.0116478204727173,
0.5240108370780945,
0.5550471544265747,
0.5393433570861816,
-0.6684210896492004,
0.486524760723114,
0.4024048447608948,
0.20497091114521027,
0.01276085339486599,
0.5552541017532349,
-0.031461913138628006,
-0.8008462190628052,
-0.5531882643699646,
-0.5243207216262817,
-0.034898437559604645,
0.05070697143673897,
-0.4622143805027008,
0.29832735657691956,
-0.08404334634542465,
-0.1838017702102661,
0.2828346788883209,
0.23702338337898254,
-0.4428061842918396,
0.17249281704425812,
0.0826646238565445,
0.9560871124267578,
-0.97777259349823,
0.8440133929252625,
0.8159936666488647,
-0.3642924427986145,
-0.9183254241943359,
0.1556050330400467,
0.15649236738681793,
-0.9010568857192993,
0.7630184292793274,
0.3021914064884186,
-0.23011700809001923,
0.2756721079349518,
-0.541122555732727,
-1.1464693546295166,
0.8295949697494507,
-0.005950853228569031,
-0.20746903121471405,
0.15131494402885437,
0.12135238945484161,
0.28487032651901245,
-0.18845465779304504,
0.23116807639598846,
0.5513606071472168,
0.4828990399837494,
0.28565412759780884,
-0.9062566757202148,
0.037157051265239716,
-0.46221867203712463,
0.0018499562283977866,
0.5095191597938538,
-0.6679157614707947,
0.6201452016830444,
0.25400975346565247,
-0.25914400815963745,
0.24406930804252625,
0.8964350819587708,
0.07824312150478363,
0.4640592634677887,
0.5060040354728699,
0.499610960483551,
0.303996741771698,
0.03281686455011368,
0.8019760847091675,
-0.2863619923591614,
0.15340489149093628,
0.7086905241012573,
0.0836118683218956,
0.8215300440788269,
0.5779088735580444,
0.2254272699356079,
0.8012322187423706,
0.5184406042098999,
0.0432533398270607,
0.6756383776664734,
0.29156678915023804,
-0.6154373288154602,
0.022803300991654396,
-0.5764549970626831,
-0.3318083584308624,
0.7749419808387756,
0.4085226058959961,
-0.35149168968200684,
-0.20915469527244568,
0.26360028982162476,
0.39876604080200195,
0.23797202110290527,
-0.368228018283844,
0.7570735216140747,
-0.024168964475393295,
-0.937928318977356,
0.7111665606498718,
0.5448609590530396,
0.5960694551467896,
-0.36142081022262573,
-0.4687827229499817,
0.0331222340464592,
0.08331698924303055,
0.028060048818588257,
-0.5017989873886108,
0.4504922032356262,
-0.17070133984088898,
0.0520392544567585,
0.050308387726545334,
1.1704660654067993,
-0.37544718384742737,
-0.508533239364624,
-0.0020886510610580444,
0.48260316252708435,
0.21263042092323303,
-0.22348639369010925,
-0.41357946395874023,
0.3455050587654114,
-0.241370290517807,
-0.2605658769607544,
0.03477899357676506,
0.36333152651786804,
-0.37295767664909363,
0.48171982169151306,
0.557098925113678,
0.10721494257450104,
-0.04983854666352272,
-0.009181862697005272,
0.7892665266990662,
-0.5958293676376343,
-0.5089706182479858,
-0.9920096397399902,
0.2692292332649231,
-0.2961137890815735,
-0.4892643988132477,
0.9808914065361023,
0.6305977702140808,
0.8216670751571655,
0.028388887643814087,
0.6368772387504578,
0.10061043500900269,
0.6238475441932678,
-0.2563496232032776,
0.6952393054962158,
-0.4195074141025543,
-0.026067504659295082,
-0.22958166897296906,
-0.8264924883842468,
-0.30892935395240784,
0.6943230032920837,
-0.23447969555854797,
-0.11125141382217407,
0.8948246836662292,
0.9297780990600586,
0.12212033569812775,
0.09824654459953308,
0.25617071986198425,
-0.060210008174180984,
0.03488924354314804,
0.2701285779476166,
0.8875210881233215,
-0.6517585515975952,
0.3986471891403198,
-0.2714863419532776,
-0.13937421143054962,
-0.39031046628952026,
-0.8634198904037476,
-0.8889277577400208,
-0.8028514981269836,
-0.415446937084198,
-0.4534769058227539,
0.42027145624160767,
0.9651428461074829,
0.6030828952789307,
-0.656582236289978,
-0.0984482616186142,
0.03596033900976181,
0.21095426380634308,
-0.18859906494617462,
-0.20180264115333557,
0.5546873807907104,
-0.06685987859964371,
-0.5946077108383179,
0.016062263399362564,
0.169908806681633,
-0.1458853781223297,
-0.09726378321647644,
0.11608092486858368,
-0.5904971361160278,
0.11795683950185776,
0.33454376459121704,
0.0490184985101223,
-0.6987839341163635,
-0.6938849091529846,
-0.3020666241645813,
0.05527190491557121,
0.04578474164009094,
0.779525876045227,
-0.8177415728569031,
-0.0988105982542038,
0.13141506910324097,
0.4667357802391052,
0.412625253200531,
0.23520898818969727,
0.20551535487174988,
-1.0077712535858154,
0.5455581545829773,
0.5826564431190491,
-0.016331935301423073,
0.2408646047115326,
-0.4652738571166992,
0.3547511696815491,
0.32859551906585693,
-0.76125168800354,
-0.6769506335258484,
0.0867668017745018,
-0.85533607006073,
-0.1462486982345581,
1.1953191757202148,
0.05224183201789856,
-0.46078768372535706,
-0.32530948519706726,
-0.45939335227012634,
0.7159832715988159,
-0.5447413325309753,
0.8699809312820435,
0.7840811014175415,
0.32403773069381714,
-0.13638830184936523,
-0.5640133023262024,
0.6898931860923767,
0.5367117524147034,
-0.44214290380477905,
-1.0003020763397217,
0.3328182101249695,
0.1847052127122879,
0.33428454399108887,
0.7726007699966431,
0.35196974873542786,
0.5413998961448669,
0.012572732754051685,
-0.20203657448291779,
0.07582293450832367,
-0.45160919427871704,
-0.10654624551534653,
0.32977205514907837,
0.2744995355606079,
-0.5461991429328918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01358v1 | Evaluating Knowledge-based Cross-lingual Inconsistency in Large Language Models | 2024-07-01T15:11:37 | 2024-07-01T15:11:37 | Xiaolin Xing, Zhiwei He, Haoyu Xu, Xing Wang, Rui Wang, Yu Hong | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper investigates the cross-lingual inconsistencies observed in Large
Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, Llama, and Baichuan, which have shown
exceptional performance in various Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks.
Despite their successes, these models often exhibit significant inconsistencies
when processing the same concepts across different languages. This study
focuses on three primary questions: the existence of cross-lingual
inconsistencies in LLMs, the specific aspects in which these inconsistencies
manifest, and the correlation between cross-lingual consistency and
multilingual capabilities of LLMs.To address these questions, we propose an
innovative evaluation method for Cross-lingual Semantic Consistency (xSC) using
the LaBSE model. We further introduce metrics for Cross-lingual Accuracy
Consistency (xAC) and Cross-lingual Timeliness Consistency (xTC) to
comprehensively assess the models' performance regarding semantic, accuracy,
and timeliness inconsistencies. By harmonizing these metrics, we provide a
holistic measurement of LLMs' cross-lingual consistency. Our findings aim to
enhance the understanding and improvement of multilingual capabilities and
interpretability in LLMs, contributing to the development of more robust and
reliable multilingual language models. | [
-0.11455424875020981,
-0.7611598968505859,
0.4686140716075897,
0.47630879282951355,
0.07348192483186722,
0.3260442912578583,
-0.37492528557777405,
-0.6455176472663879,
0.15739421546459198,
0.19578680396080017,
-0.42331624031066895,
-0.46003034710884094,
-0.7283097505569458,
0.15079514682292938,
-0.33018186688423157,
0.5609069466590881,
-0.32796579599380493,
0.2901563048362732,
-0.0897037461400032,
-0.4279612600803375,
-0.6589285135269165,
-0.39638590812683105,
-0.6461350321769714,
-0.3550051748752594,
0.30521583557128906,
0.22934553027153015,
0.8530585169792175,
0.3870733976364136,
0.306835412979126,
0.2507655620574951,
-0.16584515571594238,
0.37187445163726807,
-0.4160553812980652,
-0.20570382475852966,
-0.3763262629508972,
-0.4041692912578583,
-0.4731912910938263,
-0.23466269671916962,
0.8309317231178284,
0.8712586760520935,
-0.01990300975739956,
-0.13496211171150208,
0.13857907056808472,
0.30810561776161194,
-0.39713212847709656,
0.2837153375148773,
-0.6790422201156616,
0.21939672529697418,
-0.19624747335910797,
-0.0863979309797287,
-0.3329251706600189,
-0.21154893934726715,
0.28335142135620117,
-0.5946335196495056,
0.05387309566140175,
0.21095016598701477,
0.9781507253646851,
-0.07958854734897614,
-0.41622069478034973,
-0.3679323196411133,
-0.5108360648155212,
0.8601388335227966,
-1.0697907209396362,
0.9380936622619629,
0.11392384767532349,
0.0779053121805191,
-0.15240144729614258,
-0.45505112409591675,
-0.6132665872573853,
-0.4431438148021698,
-0.1361025720834732,
0.030583929270505905,
-0.10650435835123062,
-0.36016812920570374,
0.10504009574651718,
0.24271230399608612,
-0.7389753460884094,
0.4000811278820038,
0.17189829051494598,
-0.2967880368232727,
0.538998544216156,
0.14177808165550232,
0.48661911487579346,
-0.2716972827911377,
-0.5513731241226196,
-0.02955160103738308,
-0.8582727313041687,
0.09496297687292099,
0.2775810956954956,
0.14936351776123047,
-0.3153981864452362,
0.6729139089584351,
-0.15220090746879578,
0.3981008231639862,
-0.06299103051424026,
-0.277951717376709,
0.26886293292045593,
-0.5326011180877686,
-0.2412811666727066,
0.05405222624540329,
0.7426308393478394,
0.16865214705467224,
0.21198898553848267,
-0.48644235730171204,
-0.040544845163822174,
-0.07028878480195999,
-0.24997594952583313,
-0.2713610529899597,
0.005667568184435368,
0.20805391669273376,
-0.16705483198165894,
0.036524008959531784,
-0.14392276108264923,
-0.4018104672431946,
-0.3500436544418335,
-0.3851557672023773,
0.4179950952529907,
-0.5420775413513184,
-0.4420156478881836,
0.08380351215600967,
0.18750718235969543,
0.15279491245746613,
0.283113956451416,
-0.8058152198791504,
0.1491064876317978,
0.7138956189155579,
0.6544898152351379,
-0.31040385365486145,
-0.8167982697486877,
-0.3232458531856537,
0.159894660115242,
-0.5111873149871826,
0.5761299133300781,
-0.21778886020183563,
-0.17449648678302765,
-0.038140617311000824,
0.2357640415430069,
-0.329547643661499,
-0.5261883735656738,
0.3679831624031067,
-0.5862294435501099,
-0.10694774240255356,
-0.4387166500091553,
-0.8802255392074585,
-0.1719760298728943,
0.6540305018424988,
-0.5930140018463135,
1.1075190305709839,
0.08242897689342499,
-0.9133984446525574,
0.5567439198493958,
-0.4006809890270233,
-0.23976072669029236,
0.06058841571211815,
-0.33305397629737854,
-0.1600954532623291,
-0.06096963584423065,
0.10066404193639755,
0.3585945963859558,
-0.39948007464408875,
0.6174700260162354,
-0.19094794988632202,
-0.26024335622787476,
0.415455162525177,
-0.504810094833374,
0.9487523436546326,
-0.26755836606025696,
-0.4118238389492035,
0.23494888842105865,
-0.8743155598640442,
0.21122810244560242,
0.1518879234790802,
-0.2598569393157959,
-0.42489615082740784,
-0.16091758012771606,
-0.10270945727825165,
0.38907837867736816,
0.4587554335594177,
-0.6578558683395386,
-0.09187836945056915,
-0.2637304663658142,
0.3083140552043915,
0.6922716498374939,
-0.4087369441986084,
0.17548207938671112,
-0.3473958373069763,
0.3006780445575714,
0.17847667634487152,
0.14252963662147522,
0.06509167701005936,
-0.5529230833053589,
-0.716813862323761,
0.04337397217750549,
0.41389089822769165,
0.6685735583305359,
-0.8199505805969238,
0.21402312815189362,
-0.5922556519508362,
-0.553378701210022,
-0.26612910628318787,
0.3706474304199219,
0.4065428078174591,
0.45171937346458435,
0.26343339681625366,
-0.14365966618061066,
-0.5822374224662781,
-0.8207049369812012,
-0.3038051128387451,
-0.33790528774261475,
0.163870707154274,
0.06761333346366882,
0.5368778705596924,
-0.4035150110721588,
0.8158035278320312,
-0.018541522324085236,
0.09533124417066574,
-0.27246493101119995,
0.24265313148498535,
-0.2611066997051239,
0.3363563120365143,
0.3950064778327942,
-0.5988934636116028,
-0.5366435647010803,
0.4501955807209015,
-0.8319719433784485,
-0.11087089031934738,
0.1531316041946411,
0.049015503376722336,
0.6654208898544312,
0.4513304829597473,
-0.45021408796310425,
0.23134121298789978,
0.9787402749061584,
-0.23308676481246948,
0.8390064835548401,
-0.2609686851501465,
0.32518136501312256,
-0.605635941028595,
0.008866947144269943,
0.057671837508678436,
-0.12188629060983658,
-0.5638269782066345,
0.05763651803135872,
0.4059763252735138,
0.4011085331439972,
-0.6465396881103516,
0.8958343863487244,
-0.42115387320518494,
-0.18611784279346466,
0.09158905595541,
0.5647436380386353,
0.19869719445705414,
0.48999229073524475,
0.20920151472091675,
0.6323312520980835,
0.4566211998462677,
-0.43229132890701294,
0.45359474420547485,
0.11968043446540833,
-0.5807233452796936,
0.6631781458854675,
-0.6115220785140991,
-0.15086768567562103,
0.22233182191848755,
0.03194302320480347,
-0.9595224261283875,
-0.037954505532979965,
0.09399959444999695,
-0.28006553649902344,
0.24496552348136902,
0.04789154231548309,
-0.766247570514679,
0.02628851868212223,
-0.0895446240901947,
0.5952793955802917,
0.148420050740242,
-0.6124795079231262,
0.49735936522483826,
0.2191343903541565,
-0.1998671144247055,
-0.7761960029602051,
-0.6131086945533752,
0.1373877376317978,
0.04323282837867737,
-1.1513607501983643,
0.09412506967782974,
0.04091785103082657,
-0.33020827174186707,
0.04732714593410492,
-0.09356218576431274,
0.021645566448569298,
-0.12399421632289886,
-0.07567501813173294,
0.3697715699672699,
-0.39260542392730713,
0.11925982683897018,
-0.08833303302526474,
0.21268965303897858,
0.04761160910129547,
-0.17214266955852509,
0.5354881286621094,
-0.23019005358219147,
-0.6554386019706726,
-0.11232009530067444,
0.17830997705459595,
0.44643938541412354,
-0.008674856275320053,
0.7740924954414368,
0.5656397342681885,
-0.3601108491420746,
-0.04277056083083153,
-0.7981670498847961,
0.23157358169555664,
-0.3360898196697235,
0.5011138319969177,
-0.3807462751865387,
-1.0100690126419067,
0.9565011858940125,
0.17623735964298248,
0.10547467321157455,
0.4175598621368408,
0.49499672651290894,
0.21228453516960144,
0.9911491274833679,
0.7644298076629639,
0.212830051779747,
0.13640162348747253,
-0.026215411722660065,
0.2521180808544159,
-0.9596362709999084,
-0.49557018280029297,
-0.36261266469955444,
0.10031162202358246,
-0.6701780557632446,
-0.4611876904964447,
0.25541481375694275,
-0.08099840581417084,
-0.41476649045944214,
0.3635413944721222,
0.38184693455696106,
0.10869200527667999,
0.2319643348455429,
-0.33970895409584045,
0.7072680592536926,
-0.061853159219026566,
-0.515393078327179,
-0.12387597560882568,
-1.0221617221832275,
-0.501814067363739,
0.745521605014801,
0.448623925447464,
0.7503921389579773,
0.15887309610843658,
0.16277194023132324,
0.03578987717628479,
0.2157154381275177,
-0.5498260855674744,
0.47056567668914795,
-0.21555167436599731,
-0.6311987042427063,
-0.558621346950531,
-0.6353651285171509,
-0.8694692254066467,
0.4351590871810913,
-0.19391147792339325,
-0.9153640270233154,
0.1788317710161209,
-0.22977806627750397,
-0.06126167252659798,
0.5347982048988342,
-0.561126708984375,
1.112548589706421,
-0.5346774458885193,
-0.41925325989723206,
-0.07947389781475067,
-0.6435492634773254,
0.6544792056083679,
-0.3044026494026184,
0.3573416769504547,
-0.20924441516399384,
-0.016219278797507286,
0.6990470886230469,
-0.39512258768081665,
0.7324523329734802,
0.27016738057136536,
-0.7004144787788391,
0.03433569148182869,
0.061033446341753006,
0.46180248260498047,
0.0716315358877182,
-0.06070578843355179,
0.7103191018104553,
0.2590390741825104,
-0.3740164339542389,
-0.7016093134880066,
0.7566325664520264,
-0.9398148059844971,
-0.5559407472610474,
-0.23066292703151703,
-0.9779056906700134,
-0.575025737285614,
0.1601998507976532,
0.23494143784046173,
0.35520538687705994,
-0.41198572516441345,
-0.14784075319766998,
0.6602962017059326,
-0.4511985778808594,
0.20323219895362854,
0.816216766834259,
-0.49016597867012024,
-0.16616031527519226,
0.7642782330513,
0.3950949013233185,
0.6933211088180542,
0.4864887297153473,
0.0682150200009346,
-0.4041394889354706,
-0.3337966799736023,
-0.6819677948951721,
0.4170466959476471,
-0.9351516366004944,
0.08942718058824539,
-0.6288524866104126,
-0.365186482667923,
-0.6257736682891846,
0.03675203025341034,
-0.5327656865119934,
-0.2887762188911438,
0.08722331374883652,
0.20435458421707153,
0.10700837522745132,
0.6705892086029053,
-0.1520029902458191,
0.18826594948768616,
-1.0277329683303833,
0.15224206447601318,
-0.032981209456920624,
0.39321839809417725,
0.21431401371955872,
-0.6758580803871155,
-0.4629145860671997,
0.3132326304912567,
0.010523022152483463,
-0.6094066500663757,
0.18969455361366272,
-0.22999118268489838,
0.7930222749710083,
0.17550793290138245,
-0.2597273886203766,
0.6595731973648071,
-0.33005157113075256,
0.7132284641265869,
0.238744854927063,
-1.3376023769378662,
0.17464466392993927,
-0.11681440472602844,
0.24311645328998566,
0.09990871697664261,
0.25710204243659973,
-0.9242597818374634,
-0.528236985206604,
-0.6088503003120422,
-0.7300091981887817,
0.5377256274223328,
0.12858831882476807,
-0.28842416405677795,
0.013749662786722183,
-0.06917185336351395,
0.24305987358093262,
-0.023644236847758293,
-0.7681090831756592,
-0.12635096907615662,
-0.024198897182941437,
0.1954774707555771,
0.007660889532417059,
-0.23599594831466675,
-0.08905722200870514,
0.018001407384872437,
0.9504998326301575,
-0.10696259140968323,
-0.3698684275150299,
0.0754660815000534,
-0.28096315264701843,
-0.09644065797328949,
0.4710942208766937,
0.5453104376792908,
1.0490577220916748,
-0.011538109742105007,
0.11061651259660721,
0.6204783320426941,
-0.27381306886672974,
0.23348067700862885,
-0.10999056696891785,
-0.03205931931734085,
0.12062331289052963,
0.5772020816802979,
0.7815108299255371,
0.49927785992622375,
-0.8662810921669006,
0.45226460695266724,
-0.22328035533428192,
0.12783542275428772,
-0.19670520722866058,
-0.15549755096435547,
0.2899857759475708,
0.2017693817615509,
-0.0003453324025031179,
-0.04554342105984688,
-0.29138433933258057,
-0.7330642938613892,
-0.14111042022705078,
0.4899601638317108,
-0.1964160054922104,
-0.11329413205385208,
0.410957396030426,
-0.17457331717014313,
0.10999166965484619,
0.5356524586677551,
-0.14015868306159973,
-0.5018507838249207,
0.6212828159332275,
0.4766899347305298,
0.5576045513153076,
-0.2224375307559967,
0.15858712792396545,
0.03679859638214111,
0.600509524345398,
-0.25970375537872314,
0.12481759488582611,
0.21649110317230225,
-1.0443307161331177,
-0.7112994194030762,
-0.33705806732177734,
-0.6560595631599426,
-0.03478740155696869,
-0.5199687480926514,
0.4291418492794037,
-0.16379711031913757,
0.01083108875900507,
-0.1767919808626175,
0.13118456304073334,
-0.6393366456031799,
0.28808608651161194,
0.046414103358983994,
1.0849872827529907,
-0.8831319212913513,
0.8968725800514221,
0.613854169845581,
-0.21663574874401093,
-1.1268240213394165,
-0.12153023481369019,
-0.06620632857084274,
-0.9323170185089111,
0.9002758860588074,
-0.2676312029361725,
-0.3026731014251709,
-0.3939577043056488,
-0.14694646000862122,
-0.9776931405067444,
1.1040070056915283,
0.435150682926178,
-0.7542985677719116,
0.009183142334222794,
0.48229435086250305,
0.6010437607765198,
-0.25355371832847595,
0.2144496738910675,
0.709321916103363,
0.6043803095817566,
0.11228141188621521,
-1.3783034086227417,
0.10567889362573624,
-0.2228619009256363,
0.14803040027618408,
0.024803537875413895,
-0.7353962063789368,
0.8360874056816101,
-0.10135816037654877,
-0.28044062852859497,
0.06274140626192093,
0.5626882314682007,
0.5667275786399841,
0.3144318163394928,
0.40217113494873047,
0.6066394448280334,
0.8896285891532898,
-0.1500198394060135,
0.9635239243507385,
-0.3147995173931122,
0.32181406021118164,
1.2165956497192383,
-0.7266393899917603,
0.7629046440124512,
0.4558693766593933,
-0.1993420422077179,
0.383231520652771,
0.42957979440689087,
0.05047132447361946,
0.11317886412143707,
0.017027873545885086,
-0.08533406257629395,
-0.23616167902946472,
-0.028624767437577248,
-0.48599058389663696,
0.3987222909927368,
0.30139970779418945,
-0.006027240306138992,
-0.39130276441574097,
-0.014049419201910496,
0.16420942544937134,
-0.2490217536687851,
-0.13543879985809326,
0.4315904378890991,
0.09741532802581787,
-0.6837624907493591,
0.6411066651344299,
0.274077445268631,
0.6850643754005432,
-0.6937099099159241,
0.18220928311347961,
-0.2626517415046692,
0.2544824481010437,
-0.3458215892314911,
-0.8911820650100708,
0.39382845163345337,
0.010943046770989895,
-0.09914346039295197,
0.17237363755702972,
0.45848116278648376,
-0.5432084798812866,
-0.5484063625335693,
0.6936153173446655,
0.8422855138778687,
0.16843846440315247,
0.2936202883720398,
-0.6370189785957336,
0.46573686599731445,
-0.11476118862628937,
0.09664929658174515,
0.3617805242538452,
0.8403735160827637,
-0.3068394660949707,
0.7858805060386658,
0.4850143492221832,
0.19906440377235413,
0.3094429671764374,
0.2826169729232788,
0.3921406865119934,
-0.4951731264591217,
-0.2660432755947113,
-0.8449814915657043,
0.3057920038700104,
0.12734748423099518,
-0.34082677960395813,
1.184067726135254,
0.4586431086063385,
1.2044230699539185,
0.15008631348609924,
0.8410671353340149,
-0.008692595176398754,
0.45931383967399597,
-0.6342735290527344,
0.6216955780982971,
-0.6680120229721069,
0.6331723928451538,
-0.33829382061958313,
-0.7439740300178528,
-0.20767022669315338,
0.427243173122406,
-0.4515898823738098,
0.051762230694293976,
0.9146419167518616,
0.7859300971031189,
-0.05352767929434776,
0.3580147624015808,
0.5904254913330078,
0.36488449573516846,
0.2429790049791336,
0.6293563842773438,
1.088361144065857,
-0.544998824596405,
0.47333982586860657,
-0.2443419098854065,
-0.09263048321008682,
-0.09217824786901474,
-0.996873140335083,
-0.7099637389183044,
-0.44084426760673523,
-0.5650402903556824,
-0.32859304547309875,
0.14412006735801697,
0.6942337155342102,
0.5447863340377808,
-0.8554748892784119,
-0.5648917555809021,
0.12960989773273468,
0.4052000343799591,
-0.2512568533420563,
-0.23471122980117798,
0.3935360908508301,
-0.38461288809776306,
-0.6556733250617981,
0.26326391100883484,
0.3806222975254059,
-0.01959063857793808,
-0.602835476398468,
-0.22000494599342346,
-0.3478461802005768,
0.19670799374580383,
0.7625337839126587,
0.21783384680747986,
-0.9603239297866821,
-0.2855287194252014,
0.2462698519229889,
-0.308959424495697,
0.14853189885616302,
0.5859753489494324,
-0.4521051049232483,
0.18719150125980377,
0.5358699560165405,
0.6395940184593201,
0.22112064063549042,
-0.3883199095726013,
0.42627018690109253,
-0.5500426292419434,
-0.18001441657543182,
-0.15036968886852264,
0.811337411403656,
0.6860842704772949,
-0.17305327951908112,
0.528516411781311,
0.14591708779335022,
-0.590709388256073,
-0.6671760678291321,
0.15699048340320587,
-0.9614052176475525,
-0.20350223779678345,
1.083655834197998,
-0.5586261749267578,
-0.06959251314401627,
-0.229182630777359,
-0.05639893561601639,
0.3468637764453888,
0.09675168991088867,
0.6681345701217651,
1.1023272275924683,
-0.1606953740119934,
-0.05413822829723358,
-0.6336761116981506,
0.050384849309921265,
0.6130218505859375,
-0.761898398399353,
0.1783149689435959,
0.3770654797554016,
0.651465892791748,
0.37730810046195984,
0.34336137771606445,
-0.35586416721343994,
0.2343652844429016,
0.050211917608976364,
-0.06504768133163452,
0.3601958155632019,
-0.22910873591899872,
-0.10693483799695969,
0.002151121385395527,
0.014792831614613533,
0.3632029891014099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01334v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01334v2 | Protecting Privacy in Classifiers by Token Manipulation | 2024-07-01T14:41:59 | 2024-07-03T16:31:52 | Re'em Harel, Yair Elboher, Yuval Pinter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Using language models as a remote service entails sending private information
to an untrusted provider. In addition, potential eavesdroppers can intercept
the messages, thereby exposing the information. In this work, we explore the
prospects of avoiding such data exposure at the level of text manipulation. We
focus on text classification models, examining various token mapping and
contextualized manipulation functions in order to see whether classifier
accuracy may be maintained while keeping the original text unrecoverable. We
find that although some token mapping functions are easy and straightforward to
implement, they heavily influence performance on the downstream task, and via a
sophisticated attacker can be reconstructed. In comparison, the contextualized
manipulation provides an improvement in performance. | [
0.06571542471647263,
-0.6534523963928223,
0.3000991642475128,
-0.21159321069717407,
-0.10083924233913422,
0.11252192407846451,
-0.1151258572936058,
-0.8995336294174194,
-0.2987403869628906,
1.0661439895629883,
-0.019857987761497498,
-0.6362559199333191,
-0.9071773290634155,
-0.26226621866226196,
-0.7731519341468811,
1.1714940071105957,
0.13515235483646393,
-0.1702185422182083,
0.11086218804121017,
-0.09234989434480667,
-0.2774088978767395,
-1.1677625179290771,
-0.5563571453094482,
0.005802254192531109,
0.5038465857505798,
0.21036997437477112,
0.8938984870910645,
0.9298149943351746,
0.8271875977516174,
0.41042932868003845,
-0.11805878579616547,
-0.05869646742939949,
-0.31004080176353455,
0.2416197508573532,
-0.32317492365837097,
-0.8649702072143555,
-0.3568306267261505,
-0.028971867635846138,
0.5471888184547424,
0.7296813130378723,
0.15918771922588348,
0.15212145447731018,
0.03049519844353199,
0.4985770583152771,
-0.8712571263313293,
0.21661324799060822,
-0.83250892162323,
0.09394411742687225,
-0.31870028376579285,
-0.32487696409225464,
-0.8535322546958923,
-0.10632211714982986,
0.1763865053653717,
-0.4373134672641754,
0.39615753293037415,
0.31879833340644836,
0.8161676526069641,
0.26014643907546997,
-0.49511000514030457,
0.07410251349210739,
-0.8114641308784485,
0.6407678127288818,
-0.2991606593132019,
0.19461137056350708,
0.8086704611778259,
0.3360675871372223,
-0.08330696821212769,
-0.8401892781257629,
-0.19161736965179443,
-0.02339841239154339,
-0.6280670166015625,
-0.1709156334400177,
-0.2717211842536926,
0.4713338315486908,
0.4185994565486908,
0.2753359079360962,
-0.14167042076587677,
0.18765607476234436,
-0.4855547845363617,
-0.46824944019317627,
0.5745449066162109,
0.05713355168700218,
0.5115794539451599,
-0.20381475985050201,
-0.4954107105731964,
-0.03380696848034859,
-0.5670616030693054,
0.359801709651947,
0.3644065856933594,
0.4842177629470825,
0.22018977999687195,
0.7758060097694397,
0.06877466291189194,
0.7609524130821228,
-0.044175248593091965,
-0.05020464211702347,
-0.09845360368490219,
-0.2826427221298218,
-0.547845184803009,
0.2112797647714615,
0.5008451342582703,
0.24252364039421082,
-0.001505269668996334,
-0.563674807548523,
-0.2770672142505646,
0.006815189495682716,
0.36984679102897644,
-0.6888160109519958,
-0.09888190031051636,
0.28315266966819763,
-0.800118625164032,
-0.7289262413978577,
0.44538888335227966,
-0.6366934180259705,
-0.2729305326938629,
-0.19787873327732086,
0.43135663866996765,
-0.2908715605735779,
-0.03945855796337128,
0.02431546524167061,
-0.29581573605537415,
-0.14164996147155762,
0.08206278085708618,
-0.9890711307525635,
0.6713445782661438,
1.0762009620666504,
0.8592528104782104,
-0.25061407685279846,
-0.29429298639297485,
-0.760280191898346,
0.5414829254150391,
-0.302807092666626,
0.23084917664527893,
-0.6584368348121643,
-0.5338157415390015,
0.07548275589942932,
0.1755625456571579,
-0.02213282324373722,
-0.38895562291145325,
0.1977664679288864,
-0.8084145784378052,
0.3935350477695465,
-0.008112194016575813,
-0.6523683071136475,
-0.1514754593372345,
0.15003564953804016,
-0.7531908750534058,
0.7168983817100525,
0.1079755648970604,
-1.0548354387283325,
0.30152028799057007,
-0.8624675869941711,
-0.5286396741867065,
-0.07870716601610184,
0.15501494705677032,
-0.3013669550418854,
0.16890659928321838,
0.05323890596628189,
0.4994601011276245,
0.3396569788455963,
0.21195277571678162,
0.176433727145195,
-0.6789872050285339,
0.45544230937957764,
-0.4246307611465454,
0.7984402179718018,
0.26744017004966736,
-0.5354915857315063,
0.2738268971443176,
-0.7608231902122498,
-0.3234104812145233,
-0.29502567648887634,
-0.33864590525627136,
-0.878638505935669,
-0.13053260743618011,
0.1690305918455124,
-0.0009112149127759039,
0.21506710350513458,
-0.5059499144554138,
0.16245850920677185,
-0.5862606167793274,
0.30933520197868347,
0.956386923789978,
-0.10692349821329117,
1.0339303016662598,
-0.2877737879753113,
0.6029040813446045,
0.29749277234077454,
0.2905896008014679,
-0.407219797372818,
-0.35549622774124146,
-0.47861915826797485,
-0.6408186554908752,
0.7923394441604614,
0.5261776447296143,
-0.6722148060798645,
0.4129593074321747,
-0.47753092646598816,
-0.5644909739494324,
-0.40286266803741455,
-0.09245630353689194,
0.35841989517211914,
0.5445030927658081,
0.1777123361825943,
-0.10882993042469025,
-0.30102649331092834,
-0.6577880382537842,
-0.7512471675872803,
-0.14206543564796448,
-0.05832203850150108,
0.180457204580307,
0.0439581535756588,
-0.2859841585159302,
0.9828905463218689,
-0.5004217028617859,
-0.3781585097312927,
0.06861135363578796,
0.12454622238874435,
-0.3487106263637543,
0.8237805962562561,
0.5761725306510925,
-1.0797232389450073,
-0.13343419134616852,
0.17652910947799683,
-0.5233104228973389,
0.057807233184576035,
-0.24426116049289703,
-0.2608044743537903,
0.2804069519042969,
0.6486114859580994,
-0.3813084065914154,
0.9753615856170654,
0.3163164556026459,
-0.5811455249786377,
-0.00644517270848155,
-0.19819776713848114,
0.12242380529642105,
-0.890836238861084,
0.20939549803733826,
-0.3366708755493164,
-0.7264789938926697,
-1.0482310056686401,
0.4831666946411133,
0.209347665309906,
-0.29574552178382874,
-0.6174702644348145,
0.5557047128677368,
-0.4361359775066376,
0.014557620510458946,
-0.34388431906700134,
-0.09111808240413666,
-0.2783986032009125,
0.13477526605129242,
0.11187414824962616,
0.7393863797187805,
0.5837580561637878,
-0.5146475434303284,
-0.061201635748147964,
0.24036115407943726,
-0.10617164522409439,
0.09026926755905151,
-0.3198713958263397,
0.21524770557880402,
-0.25069212913513184,
-0.02244717814028263,
-0.8112503886222839,
-0.13437189161777496,
0.4789363443851471,
-0.5120362043380737,
0.44869276881217957,
-0.3098793029785156,
-0.5504478812217712,
0.31589072942733765,
-0.324805349111557,
0.35251107811927795,
0.45735788345336914,
-0.7692626118659973,
0.7672165632247925,
0.41923433542251587,
0.15279391407966614,
-0.8070539236068726,
-1.0073539018630981,
0.18055382370948792,
-0.3931964337825775,
-0.18564356863498688,
0.551397979259491,
0.31226620078086853,
-0.26442134380340576,
0.1695142686367035,
0.007123440969735384,
-0.10141714662313461,
0.5401536226272583,
0.6953757405281067,
0.4374404549598694,
0.37304195761680603,
0.1429990977048874,
0.19365869462490082,
-0.29154157638549805,
0.12235232442617416,
-0.09100794792175293,
0.44393014907836914,
0.39306461811065674,
-0.4123935103416443,
-0.631824254989624,
0.45761364698410034,
0.4210638701915741,
-0.3391296863555908,
0.9382689595222473,
0.27336201071739197,
-0.5931693911552429,
0.08634072542190552,
-0.1985820233821869,
-0.24840429425239563,
-0.5526458621025085,
0.15419651567935944,
-0.46160221099853516,
-1.0177326202392578,
0.4887179732322693,
-0.007150718010962009,
0.06609045714139938,
-0.022928250953555107,
0.15948298573493958,
0.36632412672042847,
1.0553582906723022,
0.9953594207763672,
-0.29818224906921387,
0.7130364179611206,
0.06514044851064682,
0.4696368873119354,
-0.5686600804328918,
-0.29087740182876587,
-0.7577314972877502,
-0.23235739767551422,
-1.0918653011322021,
-0.2549292743206024,
0.19126586616039276,
-0.02163986675441265,
0.052826955914497375,
0.41767793893814087,
-0.7409512400627136,
0.5972740054130554,
0.5628589391708374,
0.15890543162822723,
0.28508853912353516,
0.23019222915172577,
0.18267232179641724,
0.022230694070458412,
-0.44145622849464417,
-0.7433710098266602,
1.2615176439285278,
0.4882045090198517,
0.6275386214256287,
0.08377773314714432,
0.842111349105835,
0.1209942176938057,
0.5083631277084351,
-0.5989296436309814,
0.6050215363502502,
-0.10492295026779175,
-0.7818774580955505,
-0.3824755549430847,
-0.47962239384651184,
-1.0612729787826538,
0.40777793526649475,
0.07905479520559311,
-1.0572181940078735,
0.17579440772533417,
0.11537639796733856,
-0.03695156052708626,
0.5823063254356384,
-0.7706737518310547,
0.40831080079078674,
0.04262267425656319,
-0.29916855692863464,
0.03790460154414177,
-0.8275024890899658,
0.20563924312591553,
-0.24737365543842316,
0.43515387177467346,
0.2569742500782013,
-0.1522119641304016,
0.6282863616943359,
-0.6213136315345764,
1.0159249305725098,
-0.35188859701156616,
0.05568496882915497,
-0.042926814407110214,
0.4938896596431732,
0.3192955255508423,
-0.044569648802280426,
0.031069330871105194,
0.29172658920288086,
0.3179776966571808,
-0.576675534248352,
-0.7019960880279541,
0.696763277053833,
-0.5859041213989258,
-0.8149213194847107,
-0.6149817109107971,
-0.3871738910675049,
-0.05860251188278198,
0.32066768407821655,
0.11480486392974854,
0.252092570066452,
0.11864664405584335,
0.1405756026506424,
0.36821886897087097,
-0.05727064609527588,
0.7643168568611145,
0.16332629323005676,
-0.37157878279685974,
-0.09977811574935913,
0.7953588962554932,
0.14148373901844025,
0.38554394245147705,
0.6857887506484985,
0.2957940101623535,
-0.2252466082572937,
-0.38768184185028076,
-0.2656036615371704,
-0.26923203468322754,
-0.878466010093689,
-0.26718318462371826,
-0.7226065397262573,
-0.13459983468055725,
-0.49839019775390625,
-0.17492027580738068,
0.020974332466721535,
-0.8679434061050415,
-0.4638015031814575,
-0.4381558895111084,
0.27015915513038635,
0.41262295842170715,
-0.11060454696416855,
0.5098330974578857,
-0.8034928441047668,
0.039789654314517975,
0.11893904209136963,
0.2078956812620163,
-0.07503858208656311,
-0.3692135214805603,
-0.0012677876511588693,
-0.13280734419822693,
-0.004234446212649345,
-0.9224419593811035,
0.3723272681236267,
-0.08714454621076584,
0.2409854233264923,
0.4509555399417877,
0.10747569054365158,
0.6003501415252686,
-0.5303703546524048,
1.0331618785858154,
-0.058319054543972015,
-1.5171154737472534,
0.5685627460479736,
0.027037670835852623,
-0.036219898611307144,
0.4618729054927826,
0.3509484529495239,
-0.5795688629150391,
-0.5657438039779663,
-0.5801206231117249,
-0.7590809464454651,
0.7628639340400696,
0.24180516600608826,
0.499698281288147,
0.1919066607952118,
0.6256921887397766,
0.19041666388511658,
0.43813347816467285,
-0.6687252521514893,
-0.4061223566532135,
-0.2963593304157257,
-0.3147026300430298,
-0.06230827420949936,
-0.2511139512062073,
-0.20246046781539917,
-0.2741577625274658,
0.2633270025253296,
0.07386361807584763,
0.25068140029907227,
0.0758928507566452,
0.0030287783592939377,
0.017424726858735085,
0.06003042310476303,
0.4164220094680786,
0.44061803817749023,
0.15985465049743652,
0.5248716473579407,
-0.06520937383174896,
-0.673689067363739,
0.1541552096605301,
0.016715414822101593,
-0.5773839354515076,
0.14787086844444275,
0.49610474705696106,
0.4876784682273865,
0.28202691674232483,
-0.6023780703544617,
0.7697838544845581,
-0.13394246995449066,
0.05862847715616226,
-0.05192352831363678,
0.2568666636943817,
-0.4741472601890564,
-0.22290004789829254,
0.25520455837249756,
0.3573271334171295,
0.4429451525211334,
-0.4532022774219513,
0.08614277094602585,
0.3485031723976135,
-0.34295037388801575,
-0.3260895013809204,
0.8935533165931702,
-0.1586439460515976,
-0.7784079313278198,
0.19260582327842712,
0.17499028146266937,
-0.7287842035293579,
0.31698864698410034,
0.6895381808280945,
0.5365244746208191,
-0.5258045792579651,
0.19090507924556732,
-0.043284956365823746,
0.35980224609375,
-0.04464857280254364,
0.05622949078679085,
-0.36249881982803345,
-0.5804851055145264,
-0.1981179118156433,
-0.08246384561061859,
-0.3665757477283478,
-0.17037136852741241,
-1.0495023727416992,
0.1964622288942337,
-0.5898219347000122,
-0.1747848093509674,
0.18521305918693542,
-0.45941707491874695,
-0.7049644589424133,
0.3586174249649048,
-0.3302123248577118,
0.8837103843688965,
-0.5670761466026306,
0.8559620976448059,
0.6537735462188721,
-0.16009147465229034,
-0.5787171721458435,
0.07576623558998108,
-0.2586824893951416,
-0.5807726383209229,
0.7826289534568787,
0.28243935108184814,
-0.18001635372638702,
-0.24100011587142944,
-0.7261698246002197,
-0.5753495693206787,
0.6730877161026001,
0.15852969884872437,
-0.525378406047821,
-0.08549261838197708,
0.4194297194480896,
0.5951863527297974,
0.13334974646568298,
-0.13737036287784576,
0.543251097202301,
0.4172489047050476,
-0.36967357993125916,
-0.8471454977989197,
0.2508693039417267,
0.020593784749507904,
0.15934999287128448,
0.13768203556537628,
-0.5746998190879822,
0.5123427510261536,
0.23744836449623108,
-0.29792582988739014,
-0.08952203392982483,
0.33461490273475647,
-0.23193968832492828,
0.3333258628845215,
0.5053102374076843,
-0.002746444195508957,
0.9608479142189026,
-0.127033531665802,
1.1067090034484863,
-0.37570711970329285,
0.26546671986579895,
0.892369270324707,
-0.228156179189682,
0.841116189956665,
0.7862687110900879,
0.20149579644203186,
0.18945832550525665,
0.29903361201286316,
0.20697583258152008,
0.8837240934371948,
0.19432851672172546,
-0.36105743050575256,
0.09573792666196823,
-0.0036693254951387644,
-0.1117173582315445,
0.812770426273346,
0.07737374305725098,
-0.6290997266769409,
0.18645840883255005,
0.40556803345680237,
0.2989054322242737,
0.3712101876735687,
-0.17288434505462646,
0.8873279094696045,
-0.18516330420970917,
-0.4622674882411957,
0.15254923701286316,
0.6370337009429932,
0.6310982704162598,
-0.16811873018741608,
0.18625394999980927,
0.1679592728614807,
0.1649237424135208,
-0.2588389813899994,
-0.32472267746925354,
0.602263867855072,
0.00665987329557538,
0.017417391762137413,
-0.49128732085227966,
1.0385829210281372,
-0.26777365803718567,
-0.4078071117401123,
0.19819241762161255,
0.15680360794067383,
0.0260681863874197,
0.055396322160959244,
-0.34798285365104675,
0.1357431709766388,
-0.10177401453256607,
-0.12419289350509644,
0.4944586753845215,
0.40495842695236206,
0.021729495376348495,
0.6089282035827637,
0.8816328048706055,
0.28847143054008484,
0.15584690868854523,
-0.26006433367729187,
0.8594359159469604,
-0.7187744975090027,
-0.7667971253395081,
-1.0319206714630127,
0.29499414563179016,
-0.2684854567050934,
-0.0711219310760498,
0.8936784267425537,
0.7270145416259766,
1.0541017055511475,
-0.028504064306616783,
0.8445460200309753,
0.3921360969543457,
0.5625447034835815,
-0.5423822402954102,
0.9173449277877808,
-0.17058353126049042,
0.3303256034851074,
-0.2599663734436035,
-0.3842439651489258,
-0.787321925163269,
0.5147244334220886,
-0.4354311525821686,
-0.26038816571235657,
0.4845241606235504,
0.7025056481361389,
0.03862330690026283,
0.3013518750667572,
0.4787231683731079,
-0.24926432967185974,
0.745559573173523,
0.026295194402337074,
0.7450844645500183,
-0.6167052984237671,
0.1883508563041687,
-0.5564635396003723,
-0.26928651332855225,
-0.09026136994361877,
-0.8787277936935425,
-1.2205774784088135,
-0.524608850479126,
-0.3166620433330536,
-0.4036777913570404,
-0.05752774700522423,
0.5926045775413513,
0.9150415658950806,
-0.7829574942588806,
0.106437548995018,
-0.0330565981566906,
0.18983802199363708,
-0.19002462923526764,
-0.23198509216308594,
0.5171966552734375,
-0.15358243882656097,
-0.9298588037490845,
0.18961794674396515,
0.29804834723472595,
0.3831897974014282,
-0.29406049847602844,
0.4996758997440338,
0.3790501654148102,
0.08017703890800476,
0.4552426040172577,
-0.023713048547506332,
-0.640536904335022,
-0.6280571222305298,
0.08895513415336609,
-0.11107831448316574,
-0.045206520706415176,
1.174440860748291,
-0.644892156124115,
0.46878740191459656,
0.25325846672058105,
0.9198105931282043,
0.3305678963661194,
0.35905128717422485,
0.21008117496967316,
-0.9543238282203674,
0.5469925999641418,
0.1496308594942093,
0.10642372816801071,
0.37703007459640503,
-1.04020357131958,
0.24375563859939575,
0.05183032527565956,
-0.4562762379646301,
-1.2434805631637573,
0.0557667501270771,
-0.7131502032279968,
-0.5315743684768677,
0.9508536458015442,
-0.3073078691959381,
-0.4973224401473999,
-0.21632875502109528,
-0.44024211168289185,
0.11276641488075256,
-0.048941273242235184,
0.9467880725860596,
0.6775334477424622,
0.14289440214633942,
-0.016421934589743614,
-0.2632381021976471,
0.5914064645767212,
0.3725617527961731,
-0.750848650932312,
0.057141516357660294,
0.17220288515090942,
0.414550244808197,
0.1624390035867691,
0.5452307462692261,
-0.5064151883125305,
-0.07208169251680374,
-0.2912275791168213,
-0.33093592524528503,
-0.05649577081203461,
-0.40023526549339294,
-0.6460636854171753,
0.4996647536754608,
-0.018204856663942337,
-0.6730104684829712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01320v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01320v1 | Increasing Model Capacity for Free: A Simple Strategy for Parameter Efficient Fine-tuning | 2024-07-01T14:26:48 | 2024-07-01T14:26:48 | Haobo Song, Hao Zhao, Soumajit Majumder, Tao Lin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Fine-tuning large pre-trained foundation models, such as the 175B GPT-3, has
attracted more attention for downstream tasks recently. While
parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods have been proposed and proven effective
without retraining all model parameters, their performance is limited by the
capacity of incremental modules, especially under constrained parameter
budgets. \\ To overcome this challenge, we propose CapaBoost, a simple yet
effective strategy that enhances model capacity by leveraging low-rank updates
through parallel weight modules in target layers. By applying static random
masks to the shared weight matrix, CapaBoost constructs a diverse set of weight
matrices, effectively increasing the rank of incremental weights without adding
parameters. Notably, our approach can be seamlessly integrated into various
existing parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods. We extensively validate the
efficacy of CapaBoost through experiments on diverse downstream tasks,
including natural language understanding, question answering, and image
classification. Our results demonstrate significant improvements over
baselines, without incurring additional computation or storage costs. Our code
is available at \url{https://github.com/LINs-lab/CapaBoost}. | [
-0.7983383536338806,
-0.6403474807739258,
0.2533223628997803,
0.18429578840732574,
-0.45330530405044556,
0.007786820642650127,
-0.38901203870773315,
-0.2877640724182129,
-0.18327666819095612,
0.7358041405677795,
-0.5610756278038025,
-0.32741907238960266,
-0.5689781308174133,
-0.42943212389945984,
-0.08170319348573685,
1.2809120416641235,
-0.2681296765804291,
-0.025755949318408966,
-0.26447978615760803,
-0.3580780625343323,
-0.8630374670028687,
0.10932162404060364,
-0.9316707253456116,
-0.16284894943237305,
0.6433181762695312,
1.061094880104065,
0.6016477942466736,
0.6896107792854309,
0.6930916905403137,
0.13176748156547546,
0.14219336211681366,
0.41197460889816284,
-0.6162017583847046,
-0.02410152368247509,
-0.009951082058250904,
-0.21336814761161804,
-0.5148295760154724,
0.0171329565346241,
0.6612530946731567,
0.8063536286354065,
-0.26914507150650024,
0.4157574474811554,
0.3427927792072296,
0.8075276017189026,
-0.8736964464187622,
0.20124584436416626,
-0.8421481847763062,
-0.41532811522483826,
-0.18659935891628265,
0.05127124860882759,
-0.07785836607217789,
-0.09580230712890625,
-0.04653732851147652,
-0.5490676760673523,
0.5403757691383362,
0.2810618579387665,
1.182583212852478,
0.5126206874847412,
-0.17206348478794098,
0.14146201312541962,
-0.2599799931049347,
0.946811318397522,
-0.4035356044769287,
0.32285505533218384,
0.4884452223777771,
0.5939537286758423,
0.027799349278211594,
-0.6948785781860352,
-0.18240292370319366,
-0.4671933948993683,
-0.0029206108301877975,
-0.08439323306083679,
-0.019752413034439087,
0.4524126648902893,
0.45182278752326965,
0.6490600109100342,
-0.4795822501182556,
-0.1118674948811531,
-0.46962833404541016,
-0.2012353092432022,
0.38633471727371216,
0.005643115378916264,
0.14884403347969055,
0.11959824711084366,
-0.3275803327560425,
-0.25013768672943115,
-0.597175121307373,
0.07502509653568268,
0.3870392441749573,
0.3717660903930664,
-0.06254203617572784,
0.39464354515075684,
-0.714238166809082,
0.882203996181488,
0.09084424376487732,
0.3995569944381714,
-0.08791554719209671,
-0.18322716653347015,
-0.4081023037433624,
-0.2678357660770416,
0.3065539598464966,
0.14061573147773743,
0.16855372488498688,
-0.13323551416397095,
-0.2339768409729004,
-0.18890777230262756,
0.4686839282512665,
-1.183529257774353,
-0.4735475480556488,
0.1892526000738144,
-0.36746910214424133,
-0.24532602727413177,
-0.08222570270299911,
-0.42543676495552063,
-0.09227297455072403,
-0.4348788857460022,
0.7018247246742249,
-0.5246372222900391,
0.0791892260313034,
0.3677324056625366,
-0.2124730497598648,
-0.04876287654042244,
0.5558448433876038,
-1.015062928199768,
0.5913504958152771,
0.6429353356361389,
1.0307120084762573,
-0.038832563906908035,
-0.14559166133403778,
-0.7807410955429077,
0.27148890495300293,
-0.34328174591064453,
0.7146263718605042,
-0.27652639150619507,
0.11990237236022949,
-0.41123563051223755,
0.016833802685141563,
0.09341593086719513,
-0.5095677375793457,
0.2857459485530853,
-0.4689957797527313,
-0.32668450474739075,
-0.5169035792350769,
-0.28909289836883545,
-0.2563925087451935,
0.2895720303058624,
-0.7286413311958313,
0.8846463561058044,
0.2879968583583832,
-0.48937588930130005,
0.427250474691391,
-0.9294725656509399,
-0.3242160379886627,
0.009584593586623669,
-0.005705612245947123,
-0.6041868925094604,
0.15246394276618958,
0.5784568190574646,
0.637520432472229,
-0.5565131306648254,
0.12699487805366516,
-0.27914831042289734,
-0.523439884185791,
-0.35459789633750916,
-0.15337267518043518,
0.5614975094795227,
0.43042922019958496,
-0.1402636468410492,
0.2503789961338043,
-0.7122008204460144,
0.028959082439541817,
-0.09447840601205826,
-0.12818124890327454,
-0.1402725875377655,
-0.3119308054447174,
-0.08491840958595276,
-0.36788177490234375,
0.27813994884490967,
-0.5505903959274292,
0.4846225380897522,
-0.12566633522510529,
0.4064734876155853,
0.7317126393318176,
0.08030223846435547,
0.5565996766090393,
-0.7179816961288452,
0.4153405725955963,
-0.30770638585090637,
0.32088080048561096,
-0.1705687940120697,
-0.40953537821769714,
-0.9032108187675476,
-0.9591098427772522,
0.4554500877857208,
0.2421473115682602,
-0.33466383814811707,
-0.022041145712137222,
-0.12635885179042816,
-0.6329996585845947,
-0.4279921352863312,
0.4584667384624481,
0.22491587698459625,
0.4512045681476593,
0.6589515209197998,
-0.36194849014282227,
-0.4289945662021637,
-1.2831896543502808,
-0.2805202901363373,
0.2715528607368469,
-0.2530119717121124,
0.5475337505340576,
0.43019914627075195,
0.049881141632795334,
0.8372501134872437,
-0.9046491980552673,
-0.38549402356147766,
-0.09865909814834595,
0.39564308524131775,
0.31938475370407104,
0.8772985339164734,
0.6807332038879395,
-0.5224599242210388,
-0.5182397365570068,
0.03216700628399849,
-0.32630297541618347,
-0.11699488759040833,
0.0537254698574543,
-0.2796664237976074,
-0.3605833351612091,
0.5356512665748596,
-0.8050836324691772,
0.10504359751939774,
0.4371355473995209,
0.21885064244270325,
0.2800101339817047,
-0.26868364214897156,
0.28095686435699463,
-0.783424973487854,
0.08137787878513336,
-0.4884856343269348,
-0.3587735593318939,
-0.32289940118789673,
0.45168691873550415,
0.21891441941261292,
-0.43040749430656433,
-0.24199482798576355,
0.6885548233985901,
-0.7441623210906982,
0.1268148124217987,
-0.32195836305618286,
-0.27661246061325073,
-0.15811613202095032,
0.5125768184661865,
-0.4064543545246124,
0.8086432814598083,
0.5386644005775452,
-0.698935329914093,
0.17148134112358093,
-0.05276716873049736,
-0.45317038893699646,
0.36006060242652893,
-0.5900796055793762,
0.1366361379623413,
-0.11177267134189606,
0.23236587643623352,
-1.1897038221359253,
-0.6555816531181335,
0.13828043639659882,
-0.14940407872200012,
0.41155701875686646,
-0.39181774854660034,
-0.46503180265426636,
-0.4491574466228485,
-0.4098498821258545,
0.5773121118545532,
0.5531114339828491,
-0.6316028237342834,
0.5178441405296326,
0.2487359642982483,
0.0538879856467247,
-0.4601821303367615,
-0.7047571539878845,
-0.17518411576747894,
-0.09402354061603546,
-0.7657877802848816,
0.29720205068588257,
-0.16563104093074799,
0.24301762878894806,
-0.12461304664611816,
-0.2939949333667755,
-0.2326297014951706,
0.25609341263771057,
0.18392272293567657,
-0.018582379445433617,
-0.11357185989618301,
0.28729701042175293,
0.5227565169334412,
-0.025294935330748558,
-0.4601132869720459,
-0.5256892442703247,
0.6785203218460083,
-0.4194062054157257,
-0.19168490171432495,
-0.34258997440338135,
0.20939451456069946,
0.441941499710083,
-0.17253246903419495,
0.758529782295227,
0.7317433953285217,
-0.5275962352752686,
-0.40020817518234253,
-0.9157564043998718,
-0.4546268880367279,
-0.49984458088874817,
0.3210528790950775,
-0.4839480519294739,
-1.1870917081832886,
0.6150642037391663,
-0.16058333218097687,
-0.02690102532505989,
0.2661285400390625,
0.32595592737197876,
-0.029189079999923706,
0.8995688557624817,
0.6792238354682922,
0.009535910561680794,
0.5322697758674622,
-0.43760284781455994,
-0.019148632884025574,
-0.8828160762786865,
0.26041916012763977,
-0.4280475080013275,
-0.5140480995178223,
-0.41919341683387756,
-0.6077365875244141,
0.1962321400642395,
0.5477504730224609,
-0.5775253176689148,
0.6976467370986938,
-0.6780097484588623,
0.6797563433647156,
0.6354256272315979,
0.36905646324157715,
0.17594169080257416,
0.24787648022174835,
0.05949636548757553,
0.13613399863243103,
-0.733898937702179,
-0.1941291093826294,
1.1287510395050049,
0.10560206323862076,
0.6039872765541077,
-0.03464118018746376,
0.6813874244689941,
0.24152784049510956,
0.558452844619751,
-0.552180826663971,
0.5419599413871765,
-0.32089945673942566,
-0.798027515411377,
-0.4165821373462677,
-0.33021774888038635,
-0.7948751449584961,
0.1531669795513153,
0.0676669180393219,
-0.7947949171066284,
0.17489595711231232,
0.5381606221199036,
-0.5510297417640686,
0.4088916778564453,
-0.6925495266914368,
0.835626482963562,
0.22896045446395874,
-0.4882488250732422,
-0.7368194460868835,
-0.3502296209335327,
0.4282384514808655,
-0.06139890104532242,
-0.19891488552093506,
-0.4294070899486542,
-0.3269530236721039,
0.6896887421607971,
-0.7545421123504639,
0.6534819006919861,
-0.3807554244995117,
0.2074851393699646,
0.46545204520225525,
-0.047324225306510925,
0.6004300713539124,
0.3973967134952545,
-0.08985015004873276,
0.3952305316925049,
-0.15382824838161469,
-0.9720506072044373,
-0.5896874666213989,
0.8927463889122009,
-0.7711139917373657,
-0.6862006783485413,
-0.11761291325092316,
-1.0800973176956177,
-0.477083683013916,
0.33707278966903687,
0.021046217530965805,
0.16191785037517548,
0.051183588802814484,
0.6434097290039062,
0.5222360491752625,
-0.08273440599441528,
0.30613216757774353,
0.374030739068985,
0.20642973482608795,
-0.6231765151023865,
0.869788408279419,
0.26858049631118774,
0.4074041545391083,
0.44604021310806274,
0.35017129778862,
0.2060476541519165,
-0.6780538558959961,
-0.4882856607437134,
0.1561785787343979,
-0.3387770354747772,
-0.5599669814109802,
-0.6789842844009399,
-0.1065906435251236,
-0.2335280478000641,
-0.3868131935596466,
-0.5215328931808472,
-0.6024933457374573,
0.0011802857043221593,
0.13639140129089355,
0.6192519068717957,
0.16479654610157013,
-0.2922804653644562,
0.8757723569869995,
-0.6097754240036011,
0.5632036328315735,
0.5532435774803162,
0.5540958642959595,
0.12077286094427109,
-0.3405393660068512,
-0.40123146772384644,
0.18214990198612213,
-0.4172080159187317,
-0.3956036865711212,
-0.06802371144294739,
0.21996237337589264,
0.3668367564678192,
0.2533549964427948,
0.046613022685050964,
1.0447953939437866,
-0.25911208987236023,
0.47340571880340576,
-0.002358851721510291,
-0.9446778893470764,
0.5925447344779968,
-0.809675931930542,
0.4289020001888275,
0.9199804663658142,
0.3131481111049652,
-0.051364701241254807,
-0.3373720049858093,
-0.5339193344116211,
-0.7845304608345032,
0.7497701644897461,
0.17236681282520294,
0.25340691208839417,
0.2536167800426483,
0.6725581884384155,
0.18895576894283295,
0.40572887659072876,
-0.33952629566192627,
0.33991119265556335,
-0.1243588849902153,
-0.19903795421123505,
0.1344897300004959,
-0.17231830954551697,
-0.11585889011621475,
-0.48646676540374756,
0.7234757542610168,
-0.36000996828079224,
0.07956770807504654,
0.0295354463160038,
-0.1598479449748993,
-0.07895782589912415,
-0.04080670699477196,
0.5156688690185547,
0.6071829199790955,
-0.701967179775238,
-0.16049690544605255,
0.5060775279998779,
-0.6451361775398254,
-0.09574894607067108,
0.18939349055290222,
-0.18389441072940826,
-0.4753655791282654,
0.061511311680078506,
0.949633002281189,
0.39308714866638184,
-0.3996811807155609,
0.4478215277194977,
0.0757007971405983,
-0.28132888674736023,
0.18579405546188354,
0.264103502035141,
-0.045112304389476776,
0.2311939299106598,
0.3250282406806946,
0.3713340759277344,
0.11181144416332245,
-0.23712611198425293,
0.3705640137195587,
0.5714895725250244,
-0.396448016166687,
0.16743025183677673,
0.7529833912849426,
0.0239254143089056,
0.15286874771118164,
0.549937903881073,
-0.07878219336271286,
0.07245830446481705,
0.6711037158966064,
0.1257130354642868,
0.8540506958961487,
-0.23217356204986572,
0.06390830129384995,
0.5914531946182251,
0.49012842774391174,
-0.4150897264480591,
0.1544792652130127,
-0.3825289309024811,
-0.6334145665168762,
-0.4236691892147064,
-0.7519106268882751,
-0.4217093288898468,
0.397256463766098,
-0.6343939900398254,
0.6693858504295349,
-0.9551405310630798,
0.006010576616972685,
-0.26879212260246277,
0.12822559475898743,
-0.6784957647323608,
0.30305927991867065,
-0.3018028438091278,
0.9278663992881775,
-0.4671623408794403,
0.7631919980049133,
0.5916149616241455,
-0.5931922197341919,
-0.8222988843917847,
0.012052610516548157,
-0.36705681681632996,
-0.8769550323486328,
0.4111083149909973,
0.411262184381485,
-0.05101875960826874,
0.2937294840812683,
-0.7757778167724609,
-1.0823171138763428,
1.141970157623291,
0.6578980684280396,
-0.6408427357673645,
0.08541320264339447,
0.06653328984975815,
0.2307678461074829,
-0.3828868865966797,
0.31709402799606323,
0.13543449342250824,
0.49664852023124695,
-0.010979410260915756,
-0.7291365265846252,
0.29949286580085754,
0.08685304969549179,
0.12411373108625412,
0.1947290152311325,
-1.000832438468933,
1.0971007347106934,
-0.2791159451007843,
-0.09047666937112808,
0.4736940860748291,
0.658932626247406,
0.2587176561355591,
0.015666533261537552,
0.7929984331130981,
0.6790353655815125,
0.8568838238716125,
-0.06414700299501419,
1.1801947355270386,
-0.2464842051267624,
0.4961620271205902,
1.1715772151947021,
0.042456917464733124,
0.6970176696777344,
0.23729248344898224,
0.13149796426296234,
0.34599143266677856,
0.6878449320793152,
-0.3606022894382477,
0.7141492366790771,
0.4103979766368866,
-0.13610292971134186,
-0.5393583178520203,
-0.07436489313840866,
-0.38855549693107605,
0.33696267008781433,
0.02762688137590885,
0.10000166296958923,
-0.24559012055397034,
0.30150797963142395,
0.01831788197159767,
-0.3399370312690735,
-0.4608865976333618,
0.2937091886997223,
0.07220897823572159,
-0.7294805645942688,
0.846132218837738,
-0.0520830899477005,
0.39780715107917786,
-0.6570309400558472,
-0.03707384690642357,
-0.2617312967777252,
0.5247724652290344,
-0.011589078232645988,
-0.3423793911933899,
0.20437602698802948,
-0.2876492738723755,
-0.22955292463302612,
-0.11438453197479248,
0.7352306246757507,
-0.33408164978027344,
-0.4070907533168793,
0.24447347223758698,
0.21588639914989471,
-0.04705437645316124,
-0.5230737328529358,
-0.5477558374404907,
0.08469913899898529,
-0.25413307547569275,
-0.1469716727733612,
0.3701445460319519,
-0.014027824625372887,
-0.3956252932548523,
0.7251375317573547,
0.9380294680595398,
0.024349162355065346,
-0.22736802697181702,
0.0798347070813179,
1.0655183792114258,
-0.3757670223712921,
-0.4889560639858246,
-0.5564272403717041,
0.5032429695129395,
-0.24005712568759918,
-0.2440597116947174,
0.5223181247711182,
0.6920278072357178,
1.0051311254501343,
-0.2564195394515991,
0.5283936858177185,
-0.031186670064926147,
0.40797528624534607,
-0.4118522107601166,
0.9491303563117981,
-0.884992778301239,
0.09613639116287231,
-0.3179025650024414,
-0.9984183311462402,
-0.4416263699531555,
0.505713164806366,
-0.235188290476799,
0.04422295466065407,
0.7154039740562439,
0.9346237182617188,
-0.4600377678871155,
0.018256887793540955,
0.20721767842769623,
0.2059045135974884,
0.2569439709186554,
0.3949875831604004,
0.43037593364715576,
-0.7350047826766968,
0.7057561278343201,
-0.2668624520301819,
-0.5502843260765076,
-0.2630766034126282,
-0.809207558631897,
-0.9325109124183655,
-0.347364604473114,
-0.3888240158557892,
-0.045663464814424515,
0.44341349601745605,
0.5092931985855103,
1.2192065715789795,
-0.9437544941902161,
-0.3213902413845062,
-0.5183327794075012,
-0.08989543467760086,
-0.49582821130752563,
-0.20156694948673248,
0.2879699766635895,
-0.6954261660575867,
-0.565966010093689,
0.20105662941932678,
0.13855740427970886,
-0.3563799560070038,
0.15799343585968018,
-0.007666685618460178,
-0.22225774824619293,
0.2357936054468155,
0.33533206582069397,
0.20343294739723206,
-0.534305214881897,
-0.599188506603241,
-0.2704407572746277,
0.22608667612075806,
-0.05740034207701683,
0.907767117023468,
-0.748344361782074,
0.23182325065135956,
0.5658324956893921,
0.8411051034927368,
0.9691827893257141,
0.05497380718588829,
0.4728025794029236,
-0.7852039933204651,
0.3529372811317444,
-0.018395407125353813,
0.29959145188331604,
0.2629926800727844,
-0.2758168876171112,
0.7445635199546814,
0.22464102506637573,
-0.5588188171386719,
-0.8638192415237427,
0.17580556869506836,
-1.2866394519805908,
-0.2878541052341461,
0.6697140336036682,
0.20063698291778564,
-0.018620310351252556,
0.18452367186546326,
-0.47470569610595703,
0.33332324028015137,
-0.5311007499694824,
0.645486056804657,
0.7089491486549377,
-0.10764773190021515,
-0.3155965209007263,
-0.8289697766304016,
0.5660496950149536,
0.703874409198761,
-0.7281507849693298,
0.1275450587272644,
0.20579956471920013,
0.4532495439052582,
0.007082827854901552,
0.48046132922172546,
0.056155674159526825,
0.3957075774669647,
-0.10596577823162079,
-0.03648979961872101,
-0.3803698420524597,
-0.3165077865123749,
0.15610715746879578,
0.3163512051105499,
-0.030185729265213013,
-0.4825196862220764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.01315v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.01315v1 | Language Portability Strategies for Open-domain Dialogue with Pre-trained Language Models from High to Low Resource Languages | 2024-07-01T14:20:54 | 2024-07-01T14:20:54 | Ahmed Njifenjou, Virgile Sucal, Bassam Jabaian, Fabrice Lefèvre | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper we propose a study of linguistic portability strategies of
large pre-trained language models (PLMs) used for open-domain dialogue systems
in a high-resource language for this task. In particular the target
low-resource language (L_T) will be simulated with French, as it lacks of
task-specific resources and allows our human evaluation, when the source
language (L_S) is English. For obvious reasons, recent works using such models
for open-domain dialogue are mostly developed in English. Yet building specific
PLMs for each possible target language supposes collecting new datasets and is
costly. For this reason, trying to leverage all existing resources (PLMs and
data) in both L_S and L_T , we wish to assess the performance achievable in L_T
with different approaches. The first two approaches evaluate the usage of
Neural Machine Translation (NMT) at different levels: TrainOnTarget where a L_S
dataset is translated before fine-tuning in L_T and TestOnSource where a L_S
model is coupled with NMT modules during inference. Then, the advent of BLOOM
[2], the world first open-access multilingual large PLM, allow researchers to
develop new approaches aiming to leverage not only the model's full
accessibility but also its multilingualism and translation abilities. In this
context the task is learned in L_S first and adapted to L_T using the MAD-X
Adapter architecture [16]. In the two sets of experiments models are evaluated
in spoken dialogue conditions with human and the strategies can be compared in
terms of perceived interaction quality. | [
-0.574804425239563,
-0.6541761755943298,
0.5100009441375732,
0.24494650959968567,
-0.18880443274974823,
-0.003412043210119009,
-0.7222022414207458,
-0.24112051725387573,
0.009402171708643436,
0.646151602268219,
-0.4913707673549652,
-0.34313181042671204,
-0.4790952503681183,
0.2099020928144455,
-0.04409485310316086,
0.6503041386604309,
-0.2657395601272583,
0.042729154229164124,
-0.16339915990829468,
-0.2571517825126648,
-0.45495593547821045,
-0.8422749638557434,
-0.6103668808937073,
-0.0331619568169117,
0.2897692620754242,
0.3883668780326843,
0.7736811637878418,
0.3797686994075775,
0.3926730453968048,
0.30625101923942566,
-0.230990469455719,
-0.08858082443475723,
-0.6246217489242554,
-0.05254872143268585,
-0.4358035922050476,
-0.47223523259162903,
-0.488831102848053,
-0.10617442429065704,
0.7480723261833191,
0.6476073265075684,
0.05897149816155434,
-0.017693234607577324,
0.31561970710754395,
0.41288453340530396,
-0.5087758302688599,
0.40536946058273315,
-0.5549291372299194,
0.011569750495254993,
-0.21160969138145447,
-0.26008984446525574,
-0.5526000261306763,
-0.0954011008143425,
0.4148561656475067,
-0.5190046429634094,
0.08384355157613754,
-0.0402253232896328,
0.6649263501167297,
0.00455875089392066,
-0.2087407410144806,
0.011418174020946026,
-1.0970035791397095,
0.9675133228302002,
-0.8950340151786804,
0.35526877641677856,
0.38010373711586,
0.4713487923145294,
-0.01545233465731144,
-0.44894206523895264,
-0.5522394776344299,
-0.36918652057647705,
-0.06823097169399261,
0.014880976639688015,
-0.2139662206172943,
0.22301754355430603,
0.3126348555088043,
0.36314985156059265,
-0.486943781375885,
0.18559207022190094,
-0.24240276217460632,
-0.16026803851127625,
0.4310915172100067,
-0.09405896812677383,
0.21108318865299225,
0.047668781131505966,
-0.2670048475265503,
0.010327829048037529,
-0.6889944076538086,
0.006446139421314001,
0.20942389965057373,
0.761508584022522,
-0.1631794571876526,
0.5981736779212952,
-0.23942267894744873,
0.6165892481803894,
-0.2891395390033722,
-0.001462114043533802,
0.1278010755777359,
-0.7468762993812561,
-0.04597984999418259,
-0.2280537188053131,
0.9349129796028137,
0.2372138500213623,
0.3814498782157898,
-0.06716781854629517,
-0.41194623708724976,
-0.37690478563308716,
0.3039259910583496,
-0.7564203143119812,
0.1445951908826828,
0.04362795501947403,
-0.6766923666000366,
-0.12856553494930267,
-0.3869239091873169,
-0.9226531386375427,
-0.04574652388691902,
-0.1109105572104454,
0.843090295791626,
-0.40259677171707153,
-0.5035818815231323,
0.13963016867637634,
0.45118293166160583,
0.0017856251215562224,
0.4494006931781769,
-0.575867772102356,
0.3750748336315155,
0.26523450016975403,
1.1143320798873901,
-0.36858314275741577,
-0.277528315782547,
-0.5152139067649841,
-0.10801418125629425,
-0.03551327809691429,
0.43770816922187805,
-0.2362395077943802,
-0.6696280837059021,
0.2380734235048294,
0.0013604912674054503,
-0.4395082890987396,
-0.582617461681366,
0.5971108675003052,
-0.46655163168907166,
0.22343327105045319,
-0.10711352527141571,
-0.17162275314331055,
-0.25463926792144775,
0.30567026138305664,
-0.7666151523590088,
0.45628803968429565,
0.23951715230941772,
-0.5966277122497559,
-0.24943900108337402,
-0.9222279191017151,
-0.5240000486373901,
-0.028598632663488388,
0.057538215070962906,
-0.12322427332401276,
-0.07776492089033127,
-0.09035944193601608,
0.2628803849220276,
-0.45544883608818054,
0.09558169543743134,
-0.1414642184972763,
-0.22581952810287476,
0.20479974150657654,
-0.6640592813491821,
0.5774530172348022,
0.39505332708358765,
-0.45143792033195496,
0.12952527403831482,
-0.5800050497055054,
0.014055457897484303,
0.2545112073421478,
-0.3603958189487457,
-0.3137744665145874,
0.13805723190307617,
0.009937446564435959,
0.37701907753944397,
0.15565457940101624,
-0.5553247928619385,
0.07472533732652664,
-0.6130468845367432,
0.5607283115386963,
0.44579020142555237,
-0.16265158355236053,
0.5367664694786072,
-0.24828386306762695,
0.751934826374054,
0.2542087435722351,
0.14635016024112701,
-0.23357734084129333,
-0.41153135895729065,
-0.7630352973937988,
-0.024094436317682266,
0.3218570053577423,
0.8080796003341675,
-0.8465098738670349,
0.20638629794120789,
-0.22079412639141083,
-0.26321354508399963,
-0.4591096341609955,
-0.09469783306121826,
0.5988470315933228,
0.17826153337955475,
0.3587823510169983,
-0.5955033898353577,
-0.38654935359954834,
-0.8149973750114441,
-0.15113890171051025,
-0.1844322234392166,
0.2564541697502136,
0.5232939124107361,
0.22225576639175415,
-0.0079188859090209,
0.7517384886741638,
-0.30013835430145264,
-0.14495830237865448,
-0.6476171612739563,
0.04256552457809448,
0.2044060230255127,
0.5844538807868958,
0.5745891332626343,
-0.6346820592880249,
-0.46215295791625977,
0.15391956269741058,
-0.46259617805480957,
0.047661006450653076,
0.09155276417732239,
-0.21704238653182983,
0.3139708638191223,
0.36367160081863403,
-0.7925167679786682,
0.7411611676216125,
0.5209037661552429,
0.03947007283568382,
0.5966532230377197,
-0.322570264339447,
0.29022216796875,
-1.2140346765518188,
0.040438637137413025,
-0.06038399785757065,
-0.17263436317443848,
-0.9761839509010315,
-0.022537672892212868,
-0.3039659559726715,
-0.35770225524902344,
-0.8398507833480835,
0.6745097041130066,
-0.4292507469654083,
-0.034650593996047974,
-0.18952833116054535,
0.22858628630638123,
-0.22286204993724823,
0.6127792000770569,
0.2944340407848358,
1.0371471643447876,
0.47227901220321655,
-0.7396814227104187,
-0.034339141100645065,
0.3980308473110199,
-0.3509698510169983,
0.36249905824661255,
-0.645962655544281,
-0.04129250720143318,
0.03475020453333855,
0.11225220561027527,
-0.9780293703079224,
0.2322096824645996,
0.23737508058547974,
-0.3678191602230072,
0.17659713327884674,
-0.18826799094676971,
-0.40156659483909607,
-0.2394954115152359,
0.1574847400188446,
0.7798322439193726,
0.4831773042678833,
-0.34230637550354004,
0.5571801662445068,
0.14874638617038727,
-0.4331577718257904,
-0.4278906285762787,
-0.4232608675956726,
-0.08485015481710434,
-0.15930452942848206,
-0.7713000774383545,
0.19430050253868103,
-0.23210032284259796,
-0.22657422721385956,
-0.23702372610569,
0.1002514660358429,
-0.2995828688144684,
0.02743360586464405,
0.07598359137773514,
0.23417600989341736,
-0.5790477395057678,
-0.1418575793504715,
-0.21674787998199463,
-0.029566021636128426,
-0.16049112379550934,
-0.36885520815849304,
0.7513163685798645,
-0.16473126411437988,
-0.4430572986602783,
-0.38487306237220764,
0.4803318977355957,
0.6823185086250305,
-0.5162873864173889,
0.9811594486236572,
0.46522068977355957,
-0.21059741079807281,
-0.08605200797319412,
-0.41824400424957275,
-0.12241727858781815,
-0.4131990671157837,
0.30377617478370667,
-0.6526074409484863,
-0.9213351607322693,
0.5495872497558594,
-0.19455216825008392,
0.11400248110294342,
0.23341621458530426,
0.6831115484237671,
0.13434143364429474,
0.9649873971939087,
0.6194724440574646,
0.0013596084900200367,
0.4157533347606659,
-0.28542008996009827,
0.48980745673179626,
-0.5092750787734985,
0.21753904223442078,
-0.7410174012184143,
-0.23150433599948883,
-0.6437608599662781,
-0.7068896889686584,
0.3219470679759979,
0.25819242000579834,
-0.06786563992500305,
0.6236131191253662,
-0.006894404534250498,
0.33388280868530273,
0.81429523229599,
-0.10818824917078018,
0.42741724848747253,
0.00007083461969159544,
-0.2514362335205078,
-0.06068159267306328,
-0.8908919095993042,
-0.5408398509025574,
0.9201734066009521,
0.40957775712013245,
0.5748918652534485,
0.3103438913822174,
0.5731149911880493,
-0.09803597629070282,
0.16486595571041107,
-0.8681970238685608,
0.7635594010353088,
-0.25303125381469727,
-0.4825296103954315,
-0.3143676817417145,
-0.5575621128082275,
-1.0081970691680908,
0.35650140047073364,
-0.15297062695026398,
-0.8252659440040588,
0.09314151853322983,
0.10053906589746475,
-0.3837592601776123,
0.5662707090377808,
-0.7837281227111816,
1.1738232374191284,
-0.20672447979450226,
-0.3995296061038971,
-0.3585945665836334,
-0.6727771759033203,
0.2577146887779236,
-0.1400754153728485,
0.32810690999031067,
0.17887206375598907,
0.185000941157341,
0.5838989615440369,
-0.33191075921058655,
0.7572212219238281,
-0.20854544639587402,
-0.16326455771923065,
0.33937156200408936,
0.3592642843723297,
0.378306120634079,
-0.27841150760650635,
-0.015188939869403839,
0.2931465804576874,
0.18681329488754272,
-0.3561374843120575,
-0.5759009122848511,
0.49291789531707764,
-0.8831072449684143,
-0.6866536736488342,
-0.29289811849594116,
-0.7864512801170349,
-0.4957221448421478,
0.36135318875312805,
0.24852687120437622,
0.4720979928970337,
-0.40475884079933167,
0.0485127754509449,
0.6772216558456421,
-0.580748438835144,
0.4823451638221741,
0.8904834389686584,
-0.3267119824886322,
-0.28498369455337524,
1.0239548683166504,
0.2058202177286148,
0.6707432866096497,
0.4722946286201477,
0.058297306299209595,
-0.23631097376346588,
-0.7999943494796753,
-0.4029839038848877,
0.3589128255844116,
-0.3605257272720337,
0.10565809905529022,
-0.44987818598747253,
-0.4484189748764038,
-0.35122203826904297,
0.15640592575073242,
-0.5409446954727173,
-0.4000524878501892,
-0.18857601284980774,
0.25945335626602173,
0.07077732682228088,
0.6379479765892029,
-0.05562533810734749,
0.46954143047332764,
-1.121625542640686,
0.05014502629637718,
-0.12104251235723495,
0.5882052779197693,
-0.0035529634915292263,
-0.658265233039856,
-0.4605239927768707,
0.18107613921165466,
-0.29533323645591736,
-0.7524844408035278,
0.40048420429229736,
-0.010457913391292095,
0.6261745691299438,
0.22796942293643951,
0.22236575186252594,
0.3196379542350769,
-0.5962936282157898,
0.7938154935836792,
0.023091059178113937,
-0.762365996837616,
0.5372101068496704,
-0.5257787108421326,
0.2514095604419708,
0.6371716856956482,
0.5035037398338318,
-0.44060981273651123,
-0.22072313725948334,
-0.5038133263587952,
-0.6806071400642395,
0.957468569278717,
0.3195517063140869,
0.13791051506996155,
0.09072539955377579,
0.049292560666799545,
0.1308836042881012,
0.3649556338787079,
-0.5155022740364075,
-0.08825304359197617,
0.032115090638399124,
-0.02104286290705204,
-0.4814313054084778,
-0.15396541357040405,
-0.19519171118736267,
-0.052981629967689514,
0.7086273431777954,
-0.029369816184043884,
0.4876624345779419,
0.05598703399300575,
-0.2014651596546173,
-0.05800052732229233,
0.5332740545272827,
0.7771584391593933,
0.5553066730499268,
-0.33061718940734863,
-0.019162585958838463,
-0.09096836298704147,
-0.37894055247306824,
0.3016881048679352,
0.22872479259967804,
-0.3231351971626282,
0.1834726631641388,
-0.07962293177843094,
1.1175744533538818,
0.1599743664264679,
-0.8559572100639343,
0.7322190999984741,
-0.10899922251701355,
-0.20229370892047882,
-0.07217200845479965,
-0.27001330256462097,
-0.12574362754821777,
0.3415725827217102,
-0.20767787098884583,
0.25882115960121155,
-0.2110365331172943,
-0.46717944741249084,
0.14665018022060394,
0.4759204685688019,
-0.3022227883338928,
-0.3750220537185669,
0.5585362315177917,
0.40994536876678467,
-0.4296930134296417,
0.3859105408191681,
-0.2250371277332306,
-0.4569587707519531,
0.15614953637123108,
0.5520516633987427,
0.9999211430549622,
-0.3701888918876648,
0.2454124242067337,
0.43027767539024353,
0.38852617144584656,
-0.20254258811473846,
0.16041763126850128,
-0.10508815944194794,
-0.8573242425918579,
-0.7760423421859741,
-0.5442323088645935,
-0.5445923209190369,
0.27613019943237305,
-0.6140037775039673,
0.11238909512758255,
-0.21187551319599152,
-0.25403115153312683,
-0.48615825176239014,
-0.2778454124927521,
-0.6354498863220215,
-0.10812478512525558,
-0.02548828534781933,
1.2580616474151611,
-0.6468203067779541,
0.8575107455253601,
0.5175701379776001,
-0.47939005494117737,
-0.7785263061523438,
0.12564483284950256,
-0.08917005360126495,
-0.6862546801567078,
0.6599542498588562,
-0.11747657507658005,
-0.05292467027902603,
0.0928485319018364,
0.01289453823119402,
-0.8850142359733582,
0.8104223012924194,
0.46631506085395813,
-0.5276581645011902,
-0.22625583410263062,
0.2588246166706085,
0.41630634665489197,
-0.2779614329338074,
0.32848238945007324,
0.5616150498390198,
0.3431992530822754,
0.0690808892250061,
-1.5633244514465332,
-0.21627959609031677,
-0.22330430150032043,
0.11727684736251831,
0.18780209124088287,
-0.6336794495582581,
0.7598414421081543,
-0.19670003652572632,
-0.17502130568027496,
0.4327912926673889,
0.6742468476295471,
-0.03181609511375427,
0.17050953209400177,
0.6664154529571533,
0.4684308171272278,
0.3076085150241852,
-0.19139313697814941,
1.0400488376617432,
-0.4594833254814148,
0.3723607659339905,
1.0322436094284058,
-0.34821817278862,
1.123514175415039,
0.4002854824066162,
-0.25776541233062744,
0.14798492193222046,
0.32480713725090027,
0.5048372745513916,
0.538372814655304,
0.33229780197143555,
-0.5812525749206543,
-0.044422294944524765,
-0.24779640138149261,
-0.3166291117668152,
0.30922994017601013,
0.1685965657234192,
-0.20334480702877045,
-0.24221843481063843,
0.40160149335861206,
-0.033660877496004105,
0.1248016282916069,
-0.37979114055633545,
0.796069324016571,
0.03136413171887398,
-0.8599191904067993,
0.8398340940475464,
0.011694616638123989,
0.6721702814102173,
-0.6484000086784363,
0.16113880276679993,
-0.17555904388427734,
0.16425591707229614,
0.009421059861779213,
-0.737955629825592,
0.22595180571079254,
-0.03294670581817627,
-0.19857458770275116,
-0.3664945363998413,
0.6281390190124512,
-0.7712227702140808,
-0.1396421641111374,
0.4087631106376648,
0.9652308225631714,
0.43259915709495544,
-0.052757058292627335,
-0.5024304986000061,
0.1542891561985016,
-0.005795993842184544,
-0.20967930555343628,
0.6170353889465332,
0.2840205729007721,
0.031285446137189865,
0.5842648148536682,
0.3662891089916229,
0.33814892172813416,
0.11456353217363358,
0.0905412808060646,
0.7104437351226807,
-0.39101937413215637,
-0.4562615752220154,
-0.5289353728294373,
0.44109728932380676,
0.2849481403827667,
-0.013265296816825867,
0.6280584931373596,
0.4140840172767639,
0.9612281918525696,
-0.21545693278312683,
0.9811640381813049,
0.038323309272527695,
0.7092424631118774,
-0.5131028294563293,
0.5369856357574463,
-0.383514404296875,
0.2272721230983734,
-0.26380595564842224,
-1.1123721599578857,
0.009102476760745049,
0.6228230595588684,
-0.5558944940567017,
0.10440705716609955,
0.7706320881843567,
0.8536630868911743,
-0.18759964406490326,
0.15850840508937836,
0.5160738229751587,
0.4311692416667938,
0.22804126143455505,
0.7953392267227173,
0.7372903823852539,
-0.22669146955013275,
0.7722006440162659,
-0.2762776017189026,
-0.3698618710041046,
-0.16917486488819122,
-0.6818392872810364,
-0.7394464612007141,
-0.6390166282653809,
-0.3197896182537079,
-0.7272789478302002,
0.008902644738554955,
0.9465532898902893,
0.6303256750106812,
-0.8985038995742798,
-0.6114000678062439,
0.06876245886087418,
-0.10300604999065399,
-0.22423721849918365,
-0.22407233715057373,
0.022903960198163986,
-0.38421228528022766,
-0.8027229309082031,
0.6227676868438721,
0.19112540781497955,
0.23380683362483978,
-0.306025892496109,
-0.29122433066368103,
-0.17010104656219482,
0.08085215836763382,
0.7834771871566772,
0.5343058109283447,
-0.5581761598587036,
-0.2913587689399719,
0.012576289474964142,
-0.015403584577143192,
0.1042059138417244,
1.0145646333694458,
-0.4975726306438446,
0.6362143754959106,
0.5466881394386292,
0.8206215500831604,
0.23213103413581848,
-0.09666681289672852,
0.9762937426567078,
-0.6401365995407104,
0.26425597071647644,
0.21688972413539886,
0.3422728478908539,
0.07208285480737686,
0.06514590978622437,
0.4002358615398407,
0.24861043691635132,
-0.6288096308708191,
-0.8229008316993713,
0.40773627161979675,
-1.1215094327926636,
0.021844420582056046,
1.1727744340896606,
-0.38031551241874695,
-0.038445789366960526,
-0.09383592009544373,
-0.4894734025001526,
0.20372997224330902,
-0.1908491849899292,
0.27199867367744446,
0.8166977167129517,
0.030547844246029854,
-0.24936887621879578,
-0.9398240447044373,
0.4223799407482147,
0.424215704202652,
-0.6322488784790039,
0.13953179121017456,
0.18318018317222595,
0.10835278034210205,
0.35093799233436584,
0.8353895545005798,
-0.17866413295269012,
0.1574769914150238,
-0.35219666361808777,
0.030912866815924644,
0.1583937555551529,
-0.14268456399440765,
-0.3048911690711975,
0.09706448763608932,
0.32846158742904663,
-0.30142223834991455
] |